Manual On The Formulation of CBJIP
Manual On The Formulation of CBJIP
Manual On The Formulation of CBJIP
FOREWORD vii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS viii
INTRODUCTION 1
Planning Stages 2
Making the Most of the Manual 3
RATIONALE/CONTEXT 4
ANNEX 1 93
ANNEX 2 98
REFERENCES 103
i
ACRONYMS
BCPC Barangay Council for the Protection of Children
CAR Children at Risk
CICL Child in Conflict with the Law
CBJIP Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program
CFLGA Child-Friendly Local Governance Audit
CLJIP Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention Program
CNJIP Comprehensive National Juvenile Intervention Program
CRC Convention on the Rights of the Child
CWC Council for the Welfare of Children
C4D Communication for Development
DepEd Department of Education
DR Documents Review
DILG Department of the Interior and Local Government
DOJ Department of Justice
ERPAT Empowerment and Reaffirmation of Paternal Abilities
IRA Internal Revenue Allotment
JJWA Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act
JJWC Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council
BDIP Barangay Development and Investment Plan
LCPC Local Council for the Protection of Children
LGOO Local Government Operations Officer
LGU Local Government Unit
LSWDO Local Social Welfare Development Office
M/C SWDO Municipal/City Social Welfare and Development Office
M/CHO Municipal/City Health Office
M/CLGOO Municipal/City Local Government Operations Officer
M/CPDC Municipal City Planning and Development Coordinator
NGO Nongovernmental Organizations
PES Parents Effectiveness Service
PNP Philippine National Police
PNP-WCPC PNP - Women and Children Protection Center
PNP-WCPD PNP - Women and Children Protection Desk
ACRONYMS
RA Republic Act
i
RBM Results-Based Management
RJJWC Regional Juvenile Justice and Welfare Committee
TOC Theory of Change
UN United Nations
UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund
WFP Work and Financial Plan
i
i
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Advocacy – Refers to a strategy that aims to influence decisions within political, economic,
and social systems and institutions of the government at different levels or any other
institution. Usually done by a group of “advocates,” it includes many activities, such as
conducting research, issuing press releases, organizing press conferences, holding
media campaigns, speaking in public, or lobbying with legislators or policymakers.
Capacity Building – Refers to the process of equipping individuals or groups with the
knowledge, information, skills, and attitudes that enable them to perform specific tasks
effectively and efficiently toward the attainment of specific objectives or desired results.
Much more than training, capacity building can be done through coaching, mentoring,
onthe-job training, apprenticeship, field exposure, exchange visits, reading, online
studies, etc.
Caregiver – Refers to a paid or unpaid person who provides care and protection to a child and
is expected to pay attention to the needs of the child in the house. The caregiver may be
the mother, father, older sibling, grandmother, house helper, housemaid, or any relative.
Under Republic Act (RA) No. 7610 or the Special Protection of Children Against Abuse,
Exploitation and Discrimination Act, child abuse is defined as “the maltreatment,
whether habitual or not, of the child which includes any of the following:
i
i
1. Psychological and physical abuse, neglect, cruelty, sexual abuse and emotional
maltreatment;
i
v
DEFINITION OF TERMS
2. Any act by deeds or words which debases, degrades or demeans the intrinsic worth
and dignity of a child as a human being;
3. Unreasonable deprivation of his basic needs for survival, such as food and shelter;
or
4. Failure to immediately give medical treatment to an injured child resulting in serious
impairment of his growth and development or in his permanent incapacity or death.”
Children at Risk – Refers to children who are vulnerable or at risk of behaving in a way that
can harm themselves or others or of being pushed and exploited to come into conflict
with the law because of personal, family, and social circumstances, such as, but not
limited to, the following:
Child in Conflict with the Law – Refers to a child who is alleged as, accused of, or adjudged
as having committed an offense under Philippine laws
Child Protection – Refers to the protection of children from abuse, exploitation, and violence
based mainly on the special protection provisions of the Convention on the Rights of the
Child, particularly Articles 19–23 and 32–40
v
DEFINITION OF TERMS
children. It helps create a safe and positive environment for children and shows that the
organization is taking its duty and responsibility of care seriously.
Child Participation – Refers to children taking part or playing a role in a process at their level
in accordance with their evolving capacities, such as children thinking for themselves,
expressing their views effectively, and acting positively with other people, among others.
It also refers to involving children in decision-making on matters that affect their lives, the
lives of the community, and the larger society in which they live.
Intervention – Refers to a series of activities designed to address issues that cause children
to commit an offense. It may take the form of individualized treatment such as
counseling, skills training, alternative learning, education, rehabilitation, or reintegration
into the family.
Juvenile Justice and Welfare System – Refers to a system of dealing with CICL that
provides child-appropriate proceedings, including programs and services for prevention,
diversion, rehabilitation, and reintegration into the family and aftercare services to ensure
their normal growth and development.
Life Skills Education – Refers to a method used for children and young people to promote
personal and social development, build their decision-making capacity in daily life,
prevent health or social problems from occurring, and protect themselves from possible
abuse, violence, or injury
Legislation – Refers to laws that have been passed and enacted by Congress. Laws in the
Philippines take effect after 15 days following the completion of their publication either in
the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation in the country. Local
legislations include city or municipal resolutions, or ordinances adopted or enacted by
the city of municipal councils.
v
i
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Local Council for the Protection of Children – Refers to an interagency and multi-sectoral
institutional mechanism in all levels of local government units (LGUs) that serve as
children’s rights advocates and oversee the planning, monitoring, and implementation of
local development plans for children designed to ensure their protection and safety in the
locality
Local Development Plan – Refers to a document that contains the deliberate, rational, and
continuous effort of LGUs, with the active participation of the community, to accelerate
the process of development and growth by optimizing the use of local resources; it is
directed toward making public services, public spaces, and infrastructures available to
the constituency.
Offense – Refers to any act punishable under special laws or the Revised Penal Code, as
amended
Parenting – Refers to the process of promoting the physical, emotional, social, financial, and
intellectual development of a child from infancy to adulthood. Also referred to as
childrearing, parenting refers to the aspects of raising a child and all the responsibilities
and activities involved.
Policy – A course or principle of action on juvenile justice and welfare in the form of national
and regional guidelines, protocols, manuals, standards, rules and regulations, and
recommendations to government agencies aiming to ensure the full implementation of
RA No. 9344, as amended, and address gaps in its enactment; these policies are
developed, adopted, and approved by the Council, Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council
(JJWC) member and coordinating agencies, and Regional Juvenile Justice and Welfare
Committees (RJJWCs)
v
i
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Rehabilitation – Refers to the process of rectifying or modifying a child’s negative attitude and
behavior. It enables the child to change negative behavior into something positive and
acceptable to the community.
Reintegration – The process that promotes or facilitates the acceptance of the child back into
the community; it is the healing of the victim’s and the community’s wounds that were
inflicted on them by the offense
v
i
FOREWORD
The enhanced Manual on the Formulation of “Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention
Program” (CBJIP) Using Results-Based Management (RBM) and Theory of Change (ToC), an
initiative of the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council (JJWC), aims to guide the Barangay
Council for the Protection of Children (BCPC), partner agencies, duty bearers, and other
stakeholders in planning, developing, budgeting, and implementing primary, secondary, and
tertiary interventions that will protect the rights of children in conflict with the law (CICL) and
prevent children from violating laws and offenses.
The Manual integrated the Public Finance Manual to further support the development and/or
implementation of the CBJIP / Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention Program (CLJIP) by
strengthening the planning, costing, and budgeting or allocating of financial resources for the
local juvenile intervention plans. This is also timely, as the implementation of the Mandanas
Ruling will commence this year.
The Manual was developed in response to issues regarding barangay-level officials having
difficulty translating the ToC and RBME Framework for the Comprehensive Plan for children at
risk (CAR) and CICL. The guidelines issued by the Department of the Interior and Local
Government (DILG) on the development of CLJIP are found to be too technical and need
simplification for a better appreciation of the duty bearers at the local level. Likewise, it aims to
increase the number of local government units (LGUs) with CBJIP/CLJIP integrated into their
Local Development Plans (LDPs), as mandated by Republic Act (RA) No. 9344, as amended.
The enhanced Manual was simplified, more instructional, and simpler in language, with step-
bystep procedures, relevant examples, and, most especially, templates that will guide the
barangays in developing their respective CBJIP and highlighting and strengthening the
accountability of stakeholders, specifically the barangay, in the process.
ix
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council Member Agencies:
• Department of Social Welfare and Development
• Department of Justice
• Department of Education
• Department of the Interior and Local Government
• Department of Health
• Commission on Human Rights
• National Youth Commission
• Council for the Welfare of Children
• League of Provinces of the Philippines
• League of Cities of the Philippines
• League of Municipalities of the Philippines
• Liga ng Mga Barangay sa Pilipinas
• People’s Recovery, Empowerment and Development Assistance (PREDA) Foundation
• Center for the Prevention and Treatment of Child Sexual Abuse (CPTCSA)
x
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Local Government Units
• City Social Welfare and Development Office and Local Government Operations Officer,
Cagayan de Oro City
• City Social Welfare and Development Office, Valenzuela City
• City Social Welfare and Development Office and Local Government Operations Officer,
Angeles City
• Municipal Social Welfare and Development Office and Local Government Operations
Officer, Paranas Samar
• Brgy. Kauswagan, Cagayan de Oro City
• Brgy. Cugmas, Cagayan de Oro City
• Brgy. Veinte Reales, Valenzuela City
• Brgy. Gen. T. de Leon, Valenzuela City
• Barangay Balibago, Angeles City
• Barangay Pulung Maragul, Angeles City
• Brgy. Ternani, Paranas Samar
• Brgy. Zone 5 Poblacion, Paranas Samar
Drafted for JJWC by: Dr. Henry Ruiz, Consultant and Writer
Participants of the Training of Trainers (TOT) on the Formulation of the CBJIP Using Theory of
Change and Results-Based Management Framework from Angeles City, Cagayan de Oro City,
Valenzuela City, and Samar Province
ix
xii
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
This Manual was developed to serve as a practical guide for the barangays (villages) in the
Philippines in developing a Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program (CBJIP)
for children in conflict with the law (CICL) and children at risk (CAR) of becoming law
offenders. The Manual is specifically designed to aid the facilitators in formulating the CBJIP
with the CBJIP Team of the Barangay Council for the Protection of Children (BCPC). Moreover,
the Manual provides concrete steps in preparing for and conducting a series of activities
toward the development of this Plan (CBJIP) based on the directives of the Department of the
Interior and Local Government (DILG) in the Revised Implementing Rules and Regulations of
Republic Act (RA) No. 9344, as amended by RA No. 10630.
The Manual is divided into three planning stages with easily manageable sessions that seek to
allow the members of the CBJIP Team to walk through the stages sequentially, leading toward
the completion of a CBJIP. Each stage is divided into sessions with specific objectives,
methodologies, estimated timelines, resource materials/equipment, and step-by-step activities
in terms of content and process. Before Stage 1, some preparations must be undertaken, and
this will be referred to as Stage 0.
The workshop sessions are flexible enough to allow users to creatively fit the specific needs
and requirements of the local participants in the Barangay. The sessions are complete and
ready for delivery but may be modified as necessary and appropriate. The entire process can
take around three weeks to one month, depending on the size of the Barangay, as well as on
available resources and capacities.
Furthermore, the Manual comes with a set of PowerPoint slides for each session to aid trainers
and facilitators in delivering them. Some slides have notes in English and Tagalog that can
serve as guides in explaining and discussing the topics. These notes are visible in the
Presenter’s View of the PowerPoint program.
This Manual underwent a series of pilot testing in 2021 in 10 barangays across the country. In
2020, four regions and four United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)–supported local
government units (LGUs) in two separate batches went through a “Training of Trainers in the
Formulation of the CBJIP.” In the process, more suggestions and revisions were made to
improve the Manual further.
This Manual has also been informed by the Module on Public Finance Management (PFM) on
Investment in Children and Costing of Priority Interventions for CICL/CAR, developed by Social
Watch Philippines in 2022.
1
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
Planning Stages
This stage triggers the whole process of developing a CBJIP. Upon receipt of a
Memorandum Circular (MC) from the DILG mandating LGUs 1 to formulate a CBJIP, the
0F
Barangay Council is expected to issue a Barangay Resolution creating the CBJIP Team
who will be tasked to develop a Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Plan and
oversee its implementation, monitoring, and evaluation. The CBJIP Team should be headed
by the Council Member in charge of the Child and Youth Committee and operate in
coordination with the BCPC.
Stage 1: Pre-Workshop
This is the stage where the members of the CBJIP Team are oriented on their roles and
responsibilities enumerated above and the process of developing the CBJIP. The team is
expected to fill up a worksheet on the situation of CICL and CAR as a requirement for the
workshop proper (Stage 1). This will take about one to two weeks, depending on the size of
the Barangay in terms of population, its geographic location, and technical capacity of the
CBJIP Team members.
2
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
1 The local government in the Philippines is divided into three levels: provinces and independent cities, component cities and
municipalities, and barangays, all of which are collectively known as local government units (LGUs).
Stage 2: Workshop
This is where the members of the CBJIP Team gather to develop the CBJIP. At this stage,
the participants will discuss and analyze the worksheet that should have been
accomplished in Stage 1. This will be the basis for completing the parts of the CBJIP from
the preparation of the causality analysis, development of the theory of change, change
strategies, and results framework. The workshop proper will take three full days, where the
participants are expected to come up with a CBJIP draft.
At this stage, the draft output of the workshop is fleshed out by an assigned team. Some
parts of the results framework may need to be filled up, such as the indicators, baseline,
and budget. The whole Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention Program (CLJIP) is
then put together, finalized, and photocopied. A Barangay Resolution should be prepared
for the presentation to the BCPC and, consequently, for the adoption and integration into
the Barangay Development Plan. This might take 1–2 months to finish.
3
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
The designated head of the CBJIP Team will serve as the facilitator and leader of the three
planning stages in developing a CBJIP. The workshop participants are the members of the
CBJIP Team who are expected to be present and active in all three planning stages.
Furthermore, the manual was designed so that the CBJIP Team could run the planning
stages and sessions on their own at their level with support from the municipal or city
government.
To make the most of this manual, it is important for the two leaders to carefully study the
planning stages and the sessions in advance. Although the manual is user-friendly, it
demands a lot of time and effort from the facilitators to internalize the concepts and
processes. They are expected to manage the sessions in chronological order, making sure
that the expected outputs are produced before moving on to the next session. The
facilitators are expected to come to the workshops well-prepared and ready to allot time to
complete the CBJIP. Moreover, the participants are enjoined to provide focused attention
on the workshops and help each other understand and undertake the sessions as
instructed in the manual, especially in the absence of a facilitator from the LGU or the
region.
Ideally, the workshop works best if conducted in a face-to-face assembly around a wide
table with a clear blank wall or board and workshop materials, such as metacards, markers,
masking tapes, Manila papers, and pairs of scissors. This is recommended because the
process will involve brainstorming, writing on metacards, and organizing them to produce
the expected outputs. The key is to navigate the stages and sessions step-by-step, and the
manual provides clear instructions, templates, and relevant examples for each of the outputs
that the Barangay Project Management Team (BPMT) will be asked to develop.
Given the nature of the workshop, it would be a bit challenging to conduct the required
activities in a pandemic. As such, the CBJIP Team is challenged to employ its creativity and
resourcefulness in undertaking the tasks while observing the minimum health standards set
by the government.
The manual is written in English. It would be best if the manual could be translated into the
vernacular so that everybody could clearly understand the instructions. Some of the terms in
the manual may sound a bit technical and new to the participants, but in the process, these
terms are clearly and thoroughly explained with relevant examples.
The instructions are intended to help the facilitators navigate through the sessions step-
bystep. The facilitators should be further guided by the objectives, resource materials,
methodologies, and duration of each session. Furthermore, the facilitators are encouraged
to use their creativity and employ methodologies they are familiar with.
4
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
The duration is merely a guide. Some barangays may take more time to complete the
CBJIP, while others may take lesser time to do it. The restrictions on travel and gatherings
due to the pandemic may cause delays in the development of the CBJIP, and the availability
of resources and capacity of the CBJIP Team members should be considered.
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
In 2017, JJWC developed the Comprehensive National Juvenile Intervention Program (CNJIP)
2018–2022 as a concrete translation of the provisions of the JJWA or RA No. 9344. The law
envisions a society that promotes and protects the rights of CAR and CICL under a restorative
justice and welfare system. It is part of the government’s overall commitment to building an
enabling environment that respects, protects, and fulfills the rights of all children, as enshrined
in the CRC.
5
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
The CNJIP is a multi-sectoral, interagency response plan of the Philippine government, its
partner agencies, and civil society toward the goal of reducing the number of new cases of
CICL and rehabilitating and reintegrating them with their families and communities. JJWC is
mandated to coordinate, oversee, and monitor the implementation of the law with its member
agencies.
Establishing a Restorative Justice and Welfare System for CAR and CICL with the law
resonates strategically well with Goal 16 of the Sustainable Development Goals, which
commits UN member states to the promotion of peaceful and inclusive societies for
sustainable development, the provision of access to justice for all, and the building of effective,
accountable institutions at all levels.
provision of the law requires that a CLJIP be instituted in LGUs, from the barangay to the
provincial level. At the barangay level, the CLJIP is called the CBJIP. The law provides that
such comprehensive juvenile intervention programs at the LGU level shall be implemented
consistent with the national program formulated and designed by JJWC 3. In line with these
2F
As a JJWC member agency, the DILG issued MC No. 2016-68 on Guidelines for Local
Government Units on the Development of the Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention
Program, which shows the systematic and scientific procedures for developing a
comprehensive juvenile program (primary, secondary, and tertiary) that is responsive to the
needs of CAR and
CICL in their area/region and fulfills their rights under the law.
2 Sec. 9 (d) of RA No. 9344, as amended
3 Sec. 18 of RA No. 9344, as amended
4 Sec. 9-A (d) of RA No. 9344, as amended
The guidelines were developed after the pilot implementation of the JJWC project
“Localization of the CNJIP” in seven pilot LGUs. To encourage LGUs to draft their respective
CLJIPs, the DILG is considering the inclusion of the CLJIP as one of the sub-indicators of the
Child-Friendly Local Governance Audit. Likewise, the Council for the Welfare of Children
included CLJIP as one of its requirements in qualifying for the Presidential Award for Child-
Friendly Municipalities and Cities.
However, there was feedback from RJJWC Secretariats that barangay-level officials have
experienced difficulties translating the Theory of Change (ToC) and the Results-Based
Management (RBM) Framework into the Comprehensive Intervention Plan for CAR and CICL.
The current guidelines on the development of CLJIP were found to be a bit too technical and
needed simplification for a better appreciation of the duty bearers at the local level. This
Manual serves to contribute to addressing these gaps.
This Manual went through a series of validation sessions. The first draft was revised based on
comments and suggestions from the Regional Coordinators of the RJJWCs, who collectively
remarked that it was a bit too technical and needed simplification. The second draft was
reviewed through online validation sessions with the Barangay Council and stakeholders from
two Barangays. The first session was with Barangay Kauswagan of Cagayan de Oro City, a
firstclass Barangay, and the other was with Barangay Sta. Rita, Minalin, Pampanga, a fifth-
class Municipality. These two Barangays were represented by Barangay Council members,
BCPC members, pastors, social workers, daycare workers, rural health nurses, Barangay
health workers, and school officials.
The validation sessions were also participated in by 9 National Staff of the JJWC Secretariat
and 17 RJJWC Regional Coordinators. There were also observers from Valenzuela City,
Angeles City in Pampanga, Province of Maguindanao, and the Department of Social Welfare
and Development (DSWD)–Maguindanao Province.
During the online validation session, the Manual was presented stage by stage, session by
session. After each session, a Google Forms questionnaire was distributed to the participants
online to review the clarity of the objectives, the appropriateness of the methodologies and
applicability in the Barangay, the chronological order of activities, the language used, and the
achievement of the session objectives. The final version of the Manual was completed based
on these validation sessions.
RATIONALE/CONTEXT
Step 1
This stage should involve the Barangay Council for the Protection of Children (BCPC) as the
coordinating body for children’s rights and welfare in the Barangay. If the Council has not yet
been organized or has been inactive, this is the time to revive it because the BCPC serves as
the primary mechanism for developing the CBIJP. The Barangay Resolution contains the
creation of the CBJIP Team, its roles and responsibilities, membership, and designated head.
In particular, the CBJIP Team will assume the following duties and responsibilities.
1. Conduct data gathering for the situational analysis (SitAn) on children in conflict
with the law (CICL) and children at risk (CAR).
2. Develop and design the Comprehensive Barangay Local Intervention Plan.
3. Ensure the integration of the CBJIP into the Barangay Development Plan (BDP)
and the Barangay Investment Plan (BIP) with a specific budget for the
implementation of the Plan.
4. Lead and oversee the implementation and monitoring of the CBJIP.
5. Report on the status of the implementation of the CBJIP to the Barangay Council
every six months.
5 DILG MC No. 2016-068 Guidelines for LGUs on the Development of CLJIP
1
PREPARATORY STAGE
The Council Resolution designates the person who will serve as the leader of the CBJIP Team
and identifies the members coming from the BCPC. These members could be the following.
PRESENT:
Hon. Punong Barangay
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
Hon. Barangay Kagawad
ABSENT:
NONE
1
PREPARATORY STAGE
RESOLUTION NO.
SERIES OF (YEAR)
RESOLUTION CREATING THE CBJIP TEAM WHO WILL BE TASKED TO DEVELOP THE
COMPREHENSIVE BARANGAY JUVENILE INTERVENTION PROGRAM (CBJIP) OF
BARANGAY , MUNICIPALITY/CITY OF AND OVERSEE ITS IMPLEMENTATION,
MONITORING, AND EVALUATION.
WHEREAS, there were several documented cases of children in conflict with the law in the
Philippines basically due to factors emanating from unfavorable conditions in the family,
community and the bigger society. There was also an increasing number of reported cases of
violation of their rights as enshrined in the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
WHEREAS, Republic Act (RA) 9344 or the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act (JJWA) of 2006, was
enacted to ensure the protection of their rights and welfare of the JJWA was enacted. To oversee
the full implementation of the law, the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council (JJWC) was
institutionalized.
WHEREAS, JJWA mandates all Local Government Units from the Barangay up to the provincial
level to institute a Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention program to address the issue of
children in conflict with the law. The CLJIP shall cover a period of 3-5 years in which the LGUs
must set aside a necessary amount in their annual budget to implement their respective juvenile
intervention program.
WHEREAS, DILG issued Memorandum Circular 2016-68 to guide LGUs on the development of
the CLJIP, and that Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council issued a simpler manual, in support of
this Memo Circular, on developing a Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program.
WHEREAS, Barangay has its own share of children in conflict with the law and that they
are not properly managed. There are also a number of children who may be considered at risk
but the Barangay, currently, has no preventive programs for keeping them from becoming law
offenders or violators.
2
PREPARATORY STAGE
WHEREAS, the CBJIP Team is tasked to take on the following roles and responsibilities:
1. Conduct data gathering for the situation analysis on CICL and CAR;
2. Develop and design the Comprehensive Barangay Local Intervention Plan;
3. Ensure the integration of the CBJIP into the Barangay Development Plan and in the Barangay
Investment Plan with specific budget for the implementation of the Plan;
4. Lead and oversee the implementation and monitoring of the CBJIP;
5. Report on the status of the implementation of BJIP to the Barangay Council every 6 months.
WHEREAS, Mr./Ms./ is being designated as Head of the CBJIP Team with the
following members:
Mr./Ms. Mr./Ms.
Mr./Ms. Mr./Ms.
Mr./Ms. Mr./Ms. Mr./Ms.
Mr./Ms.
Hon. Hon.
Hon. Hon.
Hon. Hon.
Sec.
Hon. ________________________
BARANGAY CHAIRMAN
3
PREPARATORY STAGE
Step 2
At this stage, the Barangay Chairperson gathers the BCPC and other stakeholders for a
meeting to discuss the Executive Order (EO) and the process of developing a CBJIP. In this
meeting, the Barangay Captain may or may not invite the Local Government Operations Office
or the Regional Coordinator of the Regional Juvenile Justice and Welfare Office for guidance.
Be guided by the following.
Invitees:
BCPC Members
Other Stakeholders outside the Barangay
Background
• Even before 2000, there have been several reports of children violating the law or
becoming victims of crimes. These crimes ranged from theft, robbery, homicide, rape,
drug abuse, physical assault, and murder to a whole lot more. The cases of children
in conflict with the law (CICL) in the Philippines, according to reports, were basically
due to different reasons arising from unfavorable conditions in the family; poverty;
influence of the community and mass media; inadequate preventive, rehabilitative,
and protective care programs; and the lack of enabling laws and policies. In most
cases, the rights of children provided in the Convention on the Rights of the Child
4
PREPARATORY STAGE
(CRC) were violated. For example, while in the hands of the arresting officers,
children who were caught violating the law, physically abused, hurt, humiliated,
abused, maltreated,
and manhandled. Many were placed in detention centers and jails, along with adults
considered hardened criminals. Meanwhile, cases involving children were tried in
courts that were not sensitive to the special needs of children, which led to several
violations of children’s rights. Meanwhile, various social services of different agencies
for CICL and children, in general, were fragmented and not coordinated.
• To ensure the protection of the rights and welfare of CICL, whether as the
perpetrator or the victim, the President of the Philippines then signed in 2006
a law that came to be known as the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act (JJWA)
or Republic Act (RA) No. 9344, amended by RA No. 10630. To oversee the
full implementation of the law, the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council
(JJWC) was institutionalized. In other words, everything we will do about the
CBJIP centers around the law called JJWA, and JJWC was a creation of that
law. To make this happen, the Department of the Interior and Local
Government (DILG) issued Memorandum Circular 2016-68 to guide local
government units (LGUs) on the development of the Comprehensive Local
Juvenile Intervention Plan (CLJIP), and JJWC issued a simpler manual, in
support of this Memorandum Circular, on developing a Comprehensive
Barangay Juvenile
Intervention Program (CBJIP). This is exactly why this meeting is being called.
Step 3. Read the Barangay Resolution creating the CBJIP Team. See the above sample
Barangay Resolution. Highlight the following rules and responsibilities of the CBJIP
Team:
• Conduct data gathering for the situational analysis on CICL and CAR;
• Develop and design the Comprehensive Barangay and Local Intervention
Plan.
• Ensure the integration of the CBJIP into the Barangay Development Plan
(BDP) and in the Barangay Investment Plan (BIP) with a specific budget for
the implementation of the Plan;
• Lead and oversee the implementation and monitoring of the CBJIP;
• Report on the status of the implementation of the CBJIP to the Barangay
Council every six months.
Step 4. Announce the selected members of the CBJIP Team and the lead person.
5
PREPARATORY STAGE
Step 5. The Barangay Chairman will turn over the floor to the lead person, who will ask the
CBJIP Team to agree on a date to meet for the Pre-Workshop Meeting, which is
Stage 1, described below.
6
Description
This is the first meeting of the CBJIP Team members, where they will be oriented on national
policies and programs relevant to the situation of CICL and CAR, the Barangay’s responsibility
to develop a CLJIP, and their roles and responsibilities as members of the CBJIP Team. They
will also discuss the assignment they must accomplish before the workshop proper.
Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
1. Present the context, background, and purpose of the development of the CBJIP;
2. Describe the different stages of the Development Cycle;
3. Explain the planning process for the development of the CLJIP; and
4. Develop a plan to accomplish their assignment before the workshop proper.
Duration
Two hours
Process
Step 1. Welcome the participants. Introduce the meeting’s objectives (see above).
Step 2. Explain the background/context of the development of the CBJIP. Read the following
text in the boxes below with the aid of the corresponding PowerPoint presentation.
Some of these are reiterations or repetitions of the background discussed during the
first meeting of the BCPC, where the Barangay Resolution was read.
PRE-WORKSHOP MEETING/ASSIGNMENT
1
Even before 2000, there have been several reports of children violating the law or becoming
victims of crimes. These crimes ranged from theft, robbery, homicide, rape, drug abuse,
physical assault, and murder to a whole lot more. The cases of children in conflict with the
law (CICL) in the Philippines, according to reports, were basically due to different reasons
arising from unfavorable conditions in the family; poverty; influence of the community and
mass media; and inadequate preventive, rehabilitative, and protective care programs; and
the lack of enabling laws and policies.
The Juvenile and Justice Welfare Act (JJWA) or Republic Act (RA) No. 9344, as amended by
RA No. 10630, is a law that promotes the creation of a child-friendly justice system focused
on rehabilitation and restoration rather than punishment. It upholds the basic principle that a
child must not be treated as an adult, as enshrined in the United Nations Convention on the
Rights of the Child (UNCRC), signed and ratified by the Philippines.
JJWA envisions a society that promotes and protects the rights of children at risk (CAR) and
CICL under a “Juvenile Justice and Welfare System.” This is a system of dealing with CAR
and CICL, which provides child-appropriate proceedings, including programs and services for
prevention, diversion, rehabilitation, reintegration, and aftercare, to ensure their normal
growth and development.
JJWA also mandates all Local Government Units from the Barangay up to the provincial
level to institute a Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention Program (CLJIP). The CLJIP
shall cover a period of 3-5 years in which the LGUs must set aside a necessary amount in
their annual budget to implement their respective juvenile intervention program. JJWC is
mandated to coordinate, oversee, and monitor the implementation of the Act with its
member agencies. At the barangay level, the CLJIP is translated into Comprehensive
Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program (CBJIP).
The Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) issued Memorandum Circular
2016-68 to guide LGUs in developing their respective CLJIP. This Manual was developed to
support the implementation of this Memorandum Circular.
1
PRE-WORKSHOP MEETING/ASSIGNMENT
The Regional Juvenile Justice and Welfare Committees (RJJWCs) are required under RA No.
9344, as amended, to assist in the development of the comprehensive three- to five-year LJIP,
with the participation of concerned LGUs, NGOs, and youth organizations within the region;
monitor its implementation6; and coordinate the implementation of the juvenile intervention
programs and activities by national government agencies and other activities within the
region7.
Process
Step 3. Explain the roles and responsibilities of the CBJIP Team by reading the relevant
provisions in the Barangay Resolution creating the CBJIP Team. It would be more
effective and stronger if the reading of the Resolution is done by its sponsor in the
Council.
Explain that this meeting is in preparation for the workshop proper. It will highlight the
assignment that must be done before the workshop proper.
Step 4. Explain the planning process in developing the CBJIP and what happens in each
stage. Present the following procedure.
This is the stage where the members of the CBJIP Team are oriented on their roles and
responsibilities enumerated above and the process of developing the CBJIP. The team is
expected to fill out a worksheet on the situation of CICL and CAR as a requirement for the
workshop proper (Stage 1). This will take about one to two weeks, depending on the size of
the Barangay in terms of population, its geographic location, and the technical capacity of the
CBJIP Team members.
This is where the members of the CBJIP Team gather to develop the CBJIP. In this stage, the
participants will discuss and analyze the Worksheet that should have been accomplished in
Stage 1. This will be the basis for completing the parts of the CBJIP, from the preparation of
the causality analysis, development of the theory of change, change strategies, and results
framework. The workshop proper will take three full days, during which the participants are
expected to come up with a draft CBJIP.
2
PRE-WORKSHOP MEETING/ASSIGNMENT
Process
At this stage, the draft output of the workshop is fleshed out by an assigned team. Some
parts of the results framework may need to be filled out, such as the indicators, baseline, and
budget. The whole CLJIP is then put together, finalized, and photocopied. A Barangay
Resolution should be prepared for the presentation to the BCPC and, consequently, for the
adoption and integration into the BDP. This might take 1–2 months to finish.
Illustration:
Step 5. Present Worksheet 1, which must be accomplished before the workshop proper.
Worksheet 1 is about the situation of CICL and CAR in the Barangay. Assign
members who will conduct data gathering, which mainly involves filling out and
completing the Worksheet below. Take some time to study it. Data for the
worksheet may come from the Barangay itself, City/Municipal Planning and
Development Office, City/Municipal Social Welfare Office, Municipal/City PNP -
Women and Children Protection Center (PNP-WCPC), local DILG, and
City/Municipal Council for the Welfare and Protection of Children.
Step 6. Develop a Work Plan for the accomplishment of the Worksheet and the completion
of the CBJIP itself. Use the following matrix as your guide in developing that Plan.
3
PRE-WORKSHOP MEETING/ASSIGNMENT
4
BARANGAY WORKSHEET ON THE
SITUATION OF CHILDREN IN CONFLICT WITH THE LAW AND CHILDREN AT RISK
INTRODUCTION
This WORKSHEET aims to collect data on children and the existing programs, projects and activities for the protection and welfare of children,
particularly those in conflict with the law, at risk, and those who are victims of abuse, violence, exploitation, and neglect. This is the main
assignment of the CBJIP Team that needs to be accomplished before the workshop proper.
The WORKSHEET is divided into 4 main sections, namely: (1) Basic Information which focuses on governance structures and mechanism on
child protection in the LGU; (2) Social Welfare System for Children and Families; (3) Legal System and Justice for Children; and (4) Other
related information.
The data for the questionnaire can be sourced from the Barangay itself, the Barangay Secretary and from the City/Municipal Planning and
Development Office, City/Municipal Social Welfare Office, Municipal/City PNP-WCPC, local Department of the Interior and Local Government
and the City/Municipal Council for the Welfare and Protection of Children.
INSTRUCTIONS: Please fill-out this worksheet as a requirement for the Workshop on the Formulation of the Comprehensive Barangay
Juvenile Intervention Program in your Barangay.
Barangay Municipal/City
Province Region
5
TOTAL
3. Check below the level of functionality of your BCPC. CHECK ONLY ONE.
Levels Description of the Levels Check appropriate answer. Check one only.
6
The BCPC has developed a Barangay Action Plan for
Children with specific budget, ordinances for children, is
Ideal
able to submit Accomplishment Reports regularly, and has
indicators demonstrating concrete results for children.
4. How much is the budget allocated for the activities of the BCPC?
Budget Allocation for Amount Actually Spent Percentage Spent over
Year BCPC Percentage of the IRA (%) for Children (PhP) budget allocation (%)*
2018
2019
2020
*The percentage spent over budget allocation can be obtained by dividing the ‘amount actually spent’ over the ‘budget allocation for BCPC’,
and multiplying the result by 100.
5. List down below resolutions/ordinances adopted by the Barangay for the welfare and protection of children.
Policy Reference Number Year Title/Description
7
6. What types of crime have been committed against children in the past 2 years?
Year Year Total
Crimes Against Children Number of Victims Number of Victims Number of Victims
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Rape
Incestuous Rape
Attempted/Frustrated Rape
Acts of Lasciviousness
Physical Injuries
Kidnapping, Illegal Detention
RA 9208 amended by RA 10634 (Trafficking in
persons)
Drugs/Substance Abuse
Others, specify
TOTAL
7. What types of crime have been committed by children in conflict with the law (CICL) in the past 2 years? (Data may also be
generated from the Municipal/City CSWDO or Municipal/City PNP or the Children and Women’s Protection Desk.)
Year Year Total
Crimes Against Children Number of Victims Number of Victims Number of Victims
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Rape
Incestuous Rape
Attempted/Frustrated Rape
8
Acts of Lasciviousness
Physical Injuries
8. Summary: Number of Children in Conflict with the Law (CICL) and their status. (In case a child is covered by more than one
category, choose the last category. Avoid double counting.)
Year Year Total
Categories of CICL
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Number of CICL undergoing Diversion Program
Number of CICL in Jail/Detention Center
Number of CICL in Bahay Pag-asa
Number of CICL under Intensive Juvenile
Intervention and Support for Center (IJISC)
Number of CICL in RRCY
Number of CICL undergoing After-Care Program
Number of CICL that have re-offended
Number of CICL that have been fully integrated
Number of CICL undergoing community-based
intervention
9
Year Year Total
Categories of CICL
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Number of CICL undergoing Community-Based
Rehabilitation Program (CBDR)
Others, please specify:
Total
9. Number of Children at Risk as defined in RA 9344 as amended (Choose only one category for the child. Avoid double
counting.)
Year Year Total
Categories of CAR
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Number of children violating local ordinances
Curfew Hour
Truancy
Parental Disobedience
Anti-Smoking
Anti-Drinking
Number of children committing light offenses and misdemeanors against public order or safety
Disorderly conduct
Public scandal
Harassment
1
0
Public intoxication
Criminal nuisance
Vandalism
Gambling
Mendicancy (Presidential Decree No. 1563)
Year Year Total
Categories of CAR
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
Littering
Public urination
Trespassing
Prostitution (Section 202 of the Revised Penal Code)
Sniffing Rugby (Presidential Decree 1619)
Number of children out of school
Number of street children
Number of children who are members of gangs
Number of living in a community with a high level of
criminality or drug abuse; and
TOTAL
10. What OTHER type of child protection cases have been reported and assisted in the Barangay? (In addition, you may get
answers from the LSWDO, C/MHO, or the PNP/WCPD.)
Type of child protection cases Number of Reported Cases
1
1
Year Year Year
11. Make a list of NGOs, CSOs, FBOs, POs, Children /Youth Organizations that work on child protection in your Barangay.
Name of NGOs, CSOs, FBOs, POs, Responsible Person and Phone Number (Landlines &
Designation Email Address
Youth/Children’s Organizations Mobile)
Sources of Data:
Barangay Secretary
Municipal/City PNP-WCPC
City/Municipal Planning and Development Office
LGOO, Department of Interior and Local Government
City/Municipal Social Welfare Office
City/Municipal Council for the Welfare and Protection of Children
1
2
1
3
Description
At this stage, the members of the CBJIP Team gather in a workshop to initiate the process of
developing the CBJIP document with the designated head of the Team and his/her assistant
serving as co-facilitator. Here, the participants will go through a simple discussion of the
planning framework and tools that will be used to develop the CBJIP. This will include the
project development cycle, the process of developing a SitAn and causality analysis, ToC, and
the results framework, which is the main content of the CBJIP.
As discussed earlier, the participants will first discuss and analyze the results of Worksheet 1
as a prerequisite for the workshop proper. Worksheet 1, which is about the SitAn of children in
the Barangay, will be the basis for completing the different parts of the CBJIP, starting from the
formulation of the vision of change the Barangay wants to see in the next three years. Moving
forward, the participants will develop a design or a strategic plan that will provide details
toward attaining this vision using a tool called the “Theory of Change” and the principles of
“ResultsBased Management.” All these words will be explained well in the succeeding
narratives.
The workshop is divided into five sessions. Using an interactive, participatory methodology, it
may take about two to four days, depending on the schedule of the participants and their
capacity to process results. The pandemic and its corresponding community quarantine
protocols will be major factors in scheduling.
Session Objectives
14
WORKSHOP PROPER
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
1. Explain the concept of the Program Development Cycle; and
2. Describe the different stages of the Development Cycle.
Duration
Two hours
Process
Step 1. Welcome the participants. Introduce the session objectives (see above objectives).
Step 2. Begin by explaining what a “project” is and what the types of projects are so that the
participants will have an idea of the project you are talking about.
PROJECT
By duration: By sponsorship:
• Long term • Government
• Medium term • Private (NGO, INGO, civic)
• Short term • UN / international organizations /
bilateral
By geographic scope: • Religious
• National
15
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Regional By cost:
• District • Large scale
• Provincial • Medium scale
• Municipal/city • Small scale
• Barangay
Just like any other similar endeavors above, the CBJIP is a project that has “a set of activities
that utilize resources undertaken to achieve a specific desired goal or result within a given
budget and time frame.”
It is being developed to address a specific problem, i.e., the growing number of CICL and CAR.
The desired goal is a dramatic reduction in the number of CICL and CAR.
16
WORKSHOP PROPER
• How do projects begin?
• What are the stages in developing and implementing a program/project?
• How do they end?
• How do you know if you have been successful or not?
Show the following diagram presented through PowerPoint on the screen or posted on the wall.
Situational
Analysis
Vision/Pro
Evaluation gram
Design
Target
Population
Monitoring Planning
Implementation
17
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Governments, UN agencies, international organizations, and NGOs go through the
same project development cycle.
• It is important for us to understand this diagram because our CBJIP will follow the same
pattern.
Referring to the diagram and guided by the PowerPoint slides, answer the questions you raised
earlier by explaining the following.
Step 4. Explain the six stages in the development cycle fully by discussing the following.
18
WORKSHOP PROPER
• The CBJIP will be developed using RBM and ToC as planning tools. These terms will
be explained in the succeeding sessions.
Stage 3: Planning
• Planning is the process of translating the program design into a workplan usually
referred to as “Annual Work Plan.” It identifies the activities that will be undertaken to
produce specific outputs that will lead toward the achievement of relevant outcomes.
Together, the outcomes are expected to lead toward the attainment of the desired
project impact goals.
• Apart from activities, work plans also specify the targets, indicators, responsible
persons, budget, and budget sources.
Stage 4: Implementation
• Implementation is the process of carrying out the activities in the work plan usually in a
sequential manner or as specified in the work plan.
• The success or failure of implementation is usually determined by the quality of
supervision, teamwork, dedication, and individual attitudes of the staff.
Stage 5: Monitoring
• Monitoring keeps track of the progress and quality of the program implementation. It
assesses whether the program objectives are being met or not and determines why.
• It identifies problems or gaps and provides evidence to inform possible adjustments
while the implementation is ongoing to improve program effectiveness and efficiency.
Stage 6: Evaluation
• Evaluation involves a systematic and impartial exercise that determines the relevance,
coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact, and/or sustainability of a program.
• It determines whether the intended program results or changes are achieved or not and
explains the factors that affected program performance.
• It provides recommendations, lessons learned, and good/best practices.
• It can be conducted in the beginning of the program, in the middle of program
implementation, or at the end.
19
WORKSHOP PROPER
Step 5. End the session with the participants if they have questions about the concept and the
six stages of the program development cycle.
Duration
Two hours
Process
Step 1. Welcome the participants. Introduce the session objectives (see above objectives).
“In the development world, there has been a strong emphasis on ‘RESULTS.’”
It is no longer enough to describe what we have done and how many activities we have
undertaken. They want to see “RESULTS.”
Activities are important, but they do not really show whether the programs make a difference in
the lives of the people. Reports are meaningless when they do not show the RESULTS of
activities being supported by donor agencies, UN organizations, and governments.
20
WORKSHOP PROPER
Step 3 At this point, explain what is meant by “RESULTS.”
Process
Activities are what we put in our work plan and what we undertake, while results are effects
brought about by the conduct of activities.
Activities Results
21
WORKSHOP PROPER
• •
The Barangay Council, Barangay
Training of the Barangay Council, tanods, daycare workers, and
Barangay tanods, daycare workers, Barangay health workers are aware of
Barangay health workers, and others and demonstrate skills in handling CICL
on handling CICL and CAR (Training is and CAR. (The increase in knowledge
an activity.) and skills by the mentioned service
providers is a result.)
Ask the participants to take time to take a second look and reflect on the difference between
activities and results. Then, allot time to answer questions from the participants.
Step 5. Begin this step by highlighting the fact that the CBJIP will be developed using RBM as
the main framework and tool for planning and management of the Plan from
implementation and monitoring to evaluation.
It is, therefore, important for the members of the CBJIP Team to understand and
appreciate the concept and basic principles of RBM before the actual planning starts.
RBM implies a shift in focus from “ACTIVITIES” to “RESULTS.” The CBJIP will be
developed using RBM as a planning tool.
22
WORKSHOP PROPER
RBM is about ensuring that our work in the Barangay, through the CBJIP, makes a
difference in the lives of CICL and CAR. All our activities should produce results that
will benefit them and not just for our reporting.
Step 6. In this step, raise the level of discussion by introducing the basic principles of RBM.
To solve a social problem fully and effectively, there is a need to address all factors
that caused that problem.
The diagram below depicts the situation: “if a problem has three root problems.”
Please take note how each of the three diagrams below changes with the
disappearance of the three causes in the second box and the disappearance of the
same and the social problem itself in the third box.
23
WORKSHOP PROPER
Social
Problem
Social
Problem
24
WORKSHOP PROPER
To solve the problem of CICL and CAR, all the factors that cause children to become CICL and
CAR must be eliminated.
EXPLAIN the RBM diagram further by saying that IF the factors that cause children from
becoming CICL are the following:
Cause No. 1 – Parents use physical and emotional abuse when disciplining their children;
Cause No. 2 – CICL are forced to steal money to buy food for the family table; and
Cause No. 3 – There are no opportunities for children to use their time in a proper way,
… all these causes must be addressed to prevent children from becoming CICL or reduce the
number of CICL in the Barangay.
1. To be successful in the work we will do for CICL and CAR, we have to first understand
the problem and the seriousness of the social issue we are solving. The way to do it is
by using a tool called SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS (SitAn).
2. It is also important to identify and analyze the root causes of a social problem. The
way to do it is by using another tool called CAUSALITY ANALYSIS.
SitAn and Causality Analysis are the topics in the next session.
Session Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
1. Come up with a SitAn of CICL and CAR in the Barangay using the assignment given
before the workshop; and
25
WORKSHOP PROPER
Duration
Three hours
Process
Step 1. Introduce the session objectives as in the above. Present the diagram below to show
the road toward the workshop objectives. Note the arrow below indicating what
chapter is being discussed and where the workshop is leading toward.
SITUATION RESULTS -
CAUSALITY THEORY OF CHANGE
ANALYSIS CHANGE STRATEGIES BASED
ANALYSIS
OF CICL/CAR FRAMEWORK
Step 2. Begin the discussion by bringing the participants’ attention back to the Project
Development Cycle to get them to recall “Situational Analysis” as the first step in the
cycle. Review its definition below.
26
WORKSHOP PROPER
Situational
Analysis
Vision/P
Evaluation rogram
Design
Target
Population
Monitoring Planning
Implementation
Situation Analysis:
It is an assessment of the condition of the target population (CICL).
It identifies and prioritizes the issues affecting the target population.
It serves as a basis for formulating the goals and strategies of the program.
Step 3. Invite the participants to come together as a CBJIP Team to work on the following tasks.
Ask them to choose a moderator and documenter.
Make sure each group has completed the Worksheet correctly and completely.
Present the following template for the write-up on the situation of CICL and CAR.
Barangay , Municipality/City of
Region
1. Description of the Barangay: (Please get this information from your Barangay Profile.
This is only a sample. Do not make it too long. Write only the most important
information. This should not be more than half a page. This instruction should not be
shown in the final write-up.)
27
WORKSHOP PROPER
2. Demographic Profile:
Table 1
Barangay Population
Age Group Male Female Total
Under 18
18 and above
TOTAL
28
WORKSHOP PROPER
Table 2
Barangay Population of Indigenous Peoples
Name of Indigenous Peoples or Estimated Total Estimated Number of
Tribal Groups Population Children
The BCPC has developed a Barangay Action Plan for Children with a specific budget, has
developed ordinances for children, is able to submit Accomplishment Reports regularly, and
has indicators demonstrating concrete results for children. (Note: This is only an example.
Describe the BCPC based on the choices in the Worksheet.)
Table 3
Barangay Budget for the Barangay Council for the Protection of Children (BCPC)
29
WORKSHOP PROPER
5. Barangay Resolutions/Ordinances for the Protection of Children
Table 4
Barangay Resolutions/Ordinances for Children
The table below shows that the total number of crimes committed against children in 2019 was
and in 2020. It seems like the total number of child victims in 2019 increased in 2020. There
were also more male child victims in 2019 and more female child victims in 2020. Most of the
types of crimes committed against children were .
Table 5
Number and Types of Crimes against Children
(Year) (Year)
Number of Victims Number of Victims
Crimes against Children
Male Female Total Male Female Total
Rape
Incestuous Rape
Attempted/Frustrated Rape
Acts of Lasciviousness
Physical Injuries
30
WORKSHOP PROPER
Kidnapping, Illegal Detention
The Table below shows that the number of children who committed crimes in was
higher in than in . More boys committed crimes in than in
.
Table 6
Number and Types of Crimes Committed by Children
(Year) (Year)
Number of Victims Number of Victims
Crimes against Children
Male Female Total Male Female Total
Rape
Incestuous Rape
Attempted/Frustrated Rape
Acts of Lasciviousness
Physical Injuries
(Year) (Year)
Number of Victims Number of Victims
Crimes against Children
Male Female Total Male Female Total
Kidnapping / Serious Illegal
Detention
Drug/Substance Abuse
Others, Please Specify:
TOTAL
31
WORKSHOP PROPER
8. Number of Children in Conflict with the Law (CICL) and Their Status
Table 7
Number and Categories of Children in Conflict with the Law (CICL) and Their Status
32
WORKSHOP PROPER
Number of CICL Undergoing
Community-Based Rehabilitation
Program (CBDR)
Others, Please Specify:
TOTAL
The number of CAR was progressively increasing from 2019 to 2020. Most of them were street
children, child gang members, and out-of-school children.
Table 8
Number and Categories of Children at Risk (CAR)
33
WORKSHOP PROPER
Mendicancy (Presidential
Decree No. 1563)
Littering
Public Urination
Trespassing
Prostitution (Section 202 of the
Revised Penal Code)
Sniffing Rugby (Presidential
Decree No. 1619)
Number of Out-of-Schol Children
Number of Street Children
Number of Children Who Are
Gang Members
Number of Children Living in a
Community with a High Level of
Criminality or Drug Abuse
Number of Children in
Situations of Armed Conflict
TOTAL
Step 4. Request the participants to now reflect on the Worksheet what they have done by
focusing on item numbers 8 and 9. Counting the total and analyzing the numbers,
come up with a statement of findings on the situation of CICL and CAR in your
Barangay.
34
WORKSHOP PROPER
Sample 2. The number of CICL in Barangay increased from Year to Year. Many of
them are boys ages 14–17.
Sample 3. There is an alarming number of CAR in Barangay , even
if there were no recorded cases of CICL. Many of them are into different
vices.
As presented in the above examples, the SUMMARY STATEMENT should capture the general
situation of CICL and CAR. Now, invite them to develop their own Summary Statement using
the template below.
Step 5. Ask the groups to present their write-ups on CICL and CAR in their respective
Barangays along with the summary statement. Give each group 10 minutes for the
presentation. Invite other participants to share their feedback, comments, and
suggestions.
Give the participants an hour to revise their write-ups based on feedback, comments,
and suggestions.
Session Objectives
35
WORKSHOP PROPER
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
2. Come up with a SitAn of CICL in the Barangay using the assignment given before the
workshop, including summary statements and a general summary statement of the
problem; and
3. Develop a causality analysis of the identified problem/s on CICL based on the general
summary statement of the problem.
Duration
Three hours
Process
Step 1. Introduce the session objectives (see the above objectives). Flash the diagram below
on the projection screen to indicate the current chapter being discussed and where
the workshop is leading toward.
SITUATION RESULTS -
CAUSALITY THEORY OF CHANGE
ANALYSIS BASED
ANALYSIS CHANGE STRATEGIES
OF CICL/CAR FRAMEWORK
Step 2. Begin the discussion in this session by explaining that you will now analyze the SitAn
of CICL/CAR, and determine the causes through a tool called CAUSALITY
ANALYSIS. Explain the concept of causality analysis using the following texts.
36
WORKSHOP PROPER
Causality Analysis seeks to better understand why crimes are committed against children and
children commit crimes. It is important to identify and understand these reasons or root causes
because these are what you need to address to solve the problem of CICL and CAR later on.
In Causality Analysis, we identify and analyze the reasons or root causes that push children to
become CICL from the (1) family, (2) community, and (3) Barangay sides.
Step 3. Continue the discussion by explaining the difference between SitAn and causality
analysis.
Step 4. Point out that causality analysis may be conducted on three levels, namely, the family,
community, and Barangay. The following table shows the three levels of analysis in
the first column and the guide questions in the second column that will help the
37
WORKSHOP PROPER
group analyze the root causes of CICL at each level. In the third column are the
possible
answers to the questions or the root causes of the CICL. Discuss and review the
SAMPLE causality analysis in the table below.
1. Family Side • What are the factors in families • Parents physically abuse
that push children to become their children, driving
CICL? them away from their
• What are the practices and beliefs houses.
that may push children to become • Parents are not aware of
CICL? children’s rights.
• Are parents aware of children’s • Children steal money to
rights? help their poor parents. •
• Do children have the knowledge Children’s basic needs
and skills to resist the temptation are not met at home.
to become CICL?
• Are the children’s basic needs
adequately met?
2. Community Side • Are there adequate services for • Children are influenced by
CICL and CAR? bad peers in the
• Are there available Barangay.
facilities catering to CICL and • There is no protocol in the
CAR? management of CICL and
• Is there a protocol/system for the CAR.
management of CICL? • There are limited
• Are the service providers properly opportunities in the
trained? community for play and
• Is there coordination and recreation.
networking among agencies? • Services for children are
insufficient.
3. Barangay Side • Are there adequate laws • The Barangay has no
promoting and protecting children’s ordinance protecting
rights? children.
• Are relevant laws on children (e.g., • Laws on children are not
RA No. 9344) effectively enforced? implemented in the
• Is there enough local budget for Barangay.
CICL? • There are no facilities for
• Are the relevant structures on children in the Barangay.
38
WORKSHOP PROPER
children functional? L/BCPC? • The 1% mandatory
• How supportive are the local allocation for children is
leaders (local chief executives; not being used properly.
LCEs) of the CICL program? • The Barangay has no
• Is the 1% mandatory allocation for Development Plan for
LCPC being used properly? children.
Step 5. Now, develop your own causality analysis based on the summary statement of the
problem. Please use the template below.
CAUSALITY ANALYSIS
Family Side
39
WORKSHOP PROPER
Community Side
Barangay Side
Step 6. After filling out the Causality Analysis template above, EXPLAIN that the same output
may be presented as a “problem tree.” Show the example below.
Parents are unaware of There is no protocol for Laws on children are not
children’s rights handling CICL/CAR implemented
Children steal money to There are limited opportunities The 1% allocation for
help parents for lay/recreation
children is unused
Step 7. Now, convert your causality analysis into a problem tree similar to the above. Fill out the
Template below.
40
WORKSHOP PROPER
Problem Statement
Session Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
1. Develop a ToC for the CBJIP based on the SitAn and causality analysis.
Duration
Resource Requirements
• Manila Papers
• Pentel Pens
• Masking Tapes
• Metacards (Colored Cartolina)
• Scissors
Process
41
WORKSHOP PROPER
Step 1. Introduce the session objectives (see the above objective). Flash the diagram below
on the projection screen to indicate the current chapter being discussed and where
the workshop is leading to.
SITUATION RESULTS -
ANALYSIS CAUSALITY THEORY OF CHANGE BASED
OF CICL/CAR ANALYSIS CHANGE STRATEGIES FRAMEWORK
Step 2. Begin the discussion by comparing the development of ToC with house construction.
Before constructing a house, an architect must have a house plan or a design to
guide the construction process. In architecture, the plan is usually called a blueprint.
In the same manner, before implementing a program like the CBJIP, you must have a program
plan or a design to guide the implementation process. In social development, the plan or
blueprint is called a ToC.
42
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Theory of Change (ToC) is the process of developing a plan or a design to solve a social
problem and achieve a desired end result.
• The ToC is a tool used to help identify the current and the ideal desired situation and what
must be done to move from one situation to another.
• The ToC diagram is similar to telling a story of how the problem of CICL could be
solved by setting up certain conditions to reach the long-term goal for them.
• The ToC gives you an idea of what must be done from the current situation of CICL in
the Barangay toward an ideal situation where there will be no more CICL.
Theory of Change
A formula or a guide toward your
desired direction:
ensuring your desired
CHANGE
Flash on the screen the diagram below, and ask if they understand it and if they have questions.
43
WORKSHOP PROPER
Desired
CHANGE
Dream:
No CICL
Problem on
CICL/CAR
A complete ToC diagram looks similar to the one below. It is akin to a story you read but starting
from the end (the bottom).
44
WORKSHOP PROPER
Long-Term Goal: “By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in
Barangay Pag-asa has been reduced by 100%.”
Parents are aware of children’s Barangay leaders are trained on Laws on children are fully
rights the proper handling of CICL/CAR implemented
Children engage in legal jobs to There are activities and spaces for The 1% mandatory allocation for
help their parents children to play and enjoy recreation children is planned and used
Children’s basic needs are There are available services A Development Plan for children
fully met at home for children in the community is planned and implemented
Looking at the ToC diagram above, note that the long-term goal statement is placed at the top of
the diagram, while the problem statement is located below.
In the middle, notice the direction of the three arrows that go up from the statement of the
problem in a dark blue box to the first level of results in light blue boxes; to another level of
boxes in sky blue at the family, community, and Barangay sides; and toward the long-term goal
in the dark blue box. These are referred to as “pathways to change.” This is what the “ToC”
means.
45
WORKSHOP PROPER
Note:
• Like the process of building a house, the process of developing a ToC is done
stepby-step.
• Developing a ToC is done by a discussion group and not by an individual. It normally
takes time to do it.
• In the process of developing the ToC, statements are written on metacards with
permanent markers and posted on a brown paper using masking tapes.
Step 3. Develop the ToC for the CBJIP by following the steps outlined below. Note that in
contrast with the traditional programming process, the ToC works inversely, which
means that the process begins with the end in mind, that is, formulating the long-
term goal first and then going down to identify the different levels of conditions.
Please study the steps below.
46
WORKSHOP PROPER
A ToC begins with a good SitAn, and this involves identifying the problem the program seeks
to address, the causes and consequences of this problem, and the existing resources and
opportunities that can be used. You have already done all of the above.
Step 0. Write the statement of the problem on a long metacard using a permanent marker,
and post it at the bottom of a regular-sized brown paper where you will make your
ToC similar to the diagram below.
Statement of the Problem: “The number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa increased from
40 in 2019 to 75 in 2020.”
Step 1. Formulate the CBJIP’s long-term goal, which is what your program desires to achieve
by the end of the three- to five-year period. Sometimes, it is referred to as the
IMPACT RESULT or the end result of your CBJIP. The long-term goal is usually the
opposite of your summary statement of the problem.
For example:
47
WORKSHOP PROPER
Now, formulate your long-term goal for your Barangay based on the summary statement you
defined in Output 4 and as in the above diagram.
Long-Term Goal: “The number of CICL in Barangay Pag -asa increased from 40 in
2019 to 75 in 2020.”
Step 2. Identify the preconditions that are necessary to achieve your long-term goal. In this
exercise, you will call these preconditions “outcomes.” What are outcomes?
If long-term goals are referred to as the impact results or end results, pre-conditions are
referred to as outcome results or intermediate results.
OUTCOME RESULTS are intermediate results describing the ideal conditions in the family,
community, and barangay sides that you need to set up.
48
WORKSHOP PROPER
OUTCOME RESULTS are not yet the final results as they are only the intermediate or
inbetween results. Remember that outcome results are results statements, not activities.
Note that the desired OUTCOME RESULTS correspond to the causality analysis table. Please
take a look at the sample causality analysis, which is copied and carried forward below. The
key is to analyze and convert them into something positive. You must examine the reasons
and causes of the problem you have identified to determine what might be your desired
outcome statement.
In the three levels of analysis, you must think about what should be the condition of the family,
community, and Barangay to achieve your long-term goal or desired impact result for CICL.
Conversely, think about the resulting conditions that can be achieved at the family, community,
and Barangay LGU level once the reasons or causes of the main problem are addressed.
Look at the example below. The reasons or causes of the problem that have been identified
from the causality analysis are copied and carried forward below in a table. The first column
presents the levels of analysis, and the second column shows the root causes behind children
committing offenses or crimes. For each side, review the root causes, and think about what
should be an ideal family, community, or Barangay, and these will be referred to as Outcome
Statements. Please see the samples below.
49
WORKSHOP PROPER
1. Family Side • Parents physically
children, driving them away from
their houses. Outcome Statement 2:
• Parents are not aware Theofcommunity
children’s has
rights. preventive and protective
services for children and
• Children steal money to help their
provides opportunities for
poor parents.
play and recreation.
• Children’s basic needs are not met
at home.
2. Community • Children are influenced by bad
Side peers in the Barangay.
• There is no protocol in CICL and
CAR management.
• There are limited opportunities in
the community for play and
recreation.
• Services for children are insufficient.
Now, go back to the ToC diagram written on your brown paper (see below) with the problem
statement and Long-Term Goal. Write the above outcome statements (written in blue boxes
50
WORKSHOP PROPER
above) on the cards, and post them just below the long-term goal, as in the diagram. Then,
connect the cards to the Long-Term Goal, and note the red arrows.
Outcome Statement 2:
Outcome Statement 3:
Outcome Statement 1: The community has preventive
The Barangay has funded the
The family is caring and and protective services for
CBJIP integrated into the
protective of children and children and provides
Barangay Development Plan, and
provides for their needs. opportunities for play and
that is implemented and
recreation.
Statement of the Problem: “The number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa increased from
40 in 2019 to 75 in 2020.”
Now, create your own ToC up to the OUTCOME level using the template above. This is part of
OUTPUT 5.
Check the logic of this first level of the ToC using the IF and THEN statement as follows.
• IF the family is caring and protective of children and provides for their needs,
• IF the community has preventive and protective services for children and provides
opportunities for play and recreation,
• IF the barangay has funded the CBJIP integrated into the Barangay Development Plan and
that is implemented and monitored,
• THEN “the number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa will decrease by 50%, that is, from 75
CICL in 2020 to 38 CICL in 2023.”
51
WORKSHOP PROPER
Step 3. IDENTIFY another set of preconditions that are necessary to achieve the Outcome
Statements. This next set of preconditions is referred to as OUTPUTS.
OUTPUTS are a set of preconditions that will make the OUTCOMES happen. OUTPUTS are
also defined as the direct result of INPUTS, which are direct interventions or activities you
conduct to produce results called OUTPUTS. The conduct of training sessions, for example,
are inputs through activities that directly result in an output, which is the increased awareness
or improved skills of target stakeholders. This output, along with other outputs, contributes to
outcomes such as improved decision-making or improved behaviors and actions. Note that the
outcome (change in behavior) will not be achieved directly through training without its vital
expected output, which is the increased understanding of the target stakeholder.
OUTPUTS are the necessary preconditions needed to make the expected OUTCOMES
happen at the family, community, and Barangay sides. Remember, outputs are results
statements and not activities.
The outputs can be identified by looking at the reasons or causes of the problem in the
causality analysis and transforming them into positive statements or solutions that correspond
to the causes of the problem. In this process, ensure that outputs are the results of activities or
inputs and not the activity or input itself.
52
WORKSHOP PROPER
Outcome Statement 2: • Playgrounds and play spaces are
constructed for children and youth.
The community has preventive • Barangay Health Centers/Stations have
Community and protective services for complete health services for children.
children and provides • There are daycare centers catering to
opportunities for play and children in remote areas.
recreation.
Outcome Statement 3: • The BCPC is fully functional.
• The CBJIP is developed by the CBJIP
The Barangay has funded the Team.
Barangay CBJIP integrated into the • The Barangay Ordinance approving the
Barangay Development Plan, CBJIP is passed.
and that is implemented and • Barangay Ordinances protecting children
monitored. are passed.
Recheck the logic using the IF and THEN statements below. Let us take Outcome Statement 1
as an example.
• THEN the family will become caring and protective of children and provide for their needs.
Continue the development of your ToC using the following diagram with the Output Statements.
53
WORKSHOP PROPER
Long-Term Goal: “By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in Barangay Impact
Pag-asa has been reduced by 100%.”
Statement of the Problem: “The number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa increased from
40 in 2019 to 75 in 2020.”
Step 4. Identify the assumptions and risks that can positively/negatively affect the ToC.
Assumptions are conditions or factors that must be in place or present to achieve the goal of
your CBJIP. They are stated in positive tone.
Examples of Assumptions:
• The BCPC is active and functional.
54
WORKSHOP PROPER
• The Barangay Chairman is supportive.
• Adequate funding is available.
• Political commitment exists.
Risks – Events or occurrences that can potentially affect the achievement of results
Examples of Risks:
• Lack of coordination between Barangay and NGOs
• Uncooperative community residents
• Political influences/war
• Typhoon
Step 5. Organize the summary statement, long-term goal, outcome, and outputs, as well as
the assumptions and risks, following the diagram below. This will be WORKSHOP
OUTPUT 6 (see Figure 5 for better readability).
WORKSHOP OUTPUT 6
Long-Term Goal: “By the end of 2023, the number of CICL Barangay
in Impact
Pag-asa has been reduced by 100%. ”
55
WORKSHOP PROPER
Assumptions and Risks: _______________________________________________________
Note: You may copy here the examples above.
Session Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to agree on the list of
“change strategies” for the operationalization of the ToC or the CBJIP and for keeping the CBJIP
Team active and alive.
Duration
Process
Step 1. Introduce the Session Objectives as above. Flash the diagram below on the
projection screen to indicate the current chapter being discussed and where the
workshop is leading to.
SITUATION RESULTS -
ANALYSIS CAUSALITY THEORY OF CHANGE BASED
OF CICL/CAR ANALYSIS CHANGE STRATEGIES FRAMEWORK
Step 2. Discuss what change strategies are by discussing the texts below.
56
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Because we need strategies and to exert proactive efforts to achieve the change we
desire
• The words “change” and “strategies” are coined to refer to approaches that are meant to
effect change.
are concrete action steps undertaken to achieve specific outputs that will
lead to desirable changes.
Activities
• The Conduct of Parents Effectiveness Service (PES) and FDS on
children’s rights is an activity.
• Training of social workers, police officers, health workers, teachers, and Barangay
officials in proper handling of CICL
• Peer group sessions with children on life skills and personal safety lessons
• Lobbing with the barangay council to increase the budget allocation for children’s projects
57
WORKSHOP PROPER
Highlight the difference between strategies and activities with the following examples.
58
WORKSHOP PROPER
2. Scholarship programs for CAR
3. Counseling for parents and CICL
4. Implementation of diversion programs for CICL in the Barangay
5. Provision of livelihood loans for parents of CAR
Service Delivery involves the service providers’ direct engagement with partners or
beneficiaries to deliver specific services, amenities, material aid, technical assistance,
psychosocial support, or any type of help that will benefit them.
Capability building refers to the process of developing or enhancing the skills and
knowledge of program managers, supervisors, service providers, or beneficiaries required
to perform a particular task or an important life skill through formal training, online
instruction, coaching, or apprenticeship.
59
WORKSHOP PROPER
Policy advocacy refers to activities that seek to influence decision-makers such as the
members of the Barangay Development Council or the BCPC.
Step 3. Invite the participants to form groups to discuss the questions below, and give them
one hour to finish the task. After the group discussion, give each group 10 minutes
for the presentation.
1. What strategies will you use to address the key factors that cause children to
become CICL or delay the efforts to decrease their number? Choose from the list of
sample strategies shown earlier. Then, flash the slide with the sample strategies, or
refer to the list of “change strategies” posted on the wall. The poster must be done
ahead of time.
2. What are you going to do to keep the CBJIP Team active and alive?
• The CBJIP Team will use the awareness-raising strategy to ensure that parents will
know about and become conversant of “Children’s Rights.” The team will use the existing
assemblies or meetings of parents, mothers, and fathers to discuss children’s rights.
Some of these are the Family Development Sessions (FDSs) for beneficiaries of the
DSWD’s Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (4Ps), Parents Effectiveness Service
(PES), Empowerment and Reaffirmation of Paternal Abilities (ERPAT) program, Mothers’
Classes in health centers, or the Parents-Teachers-Children’s Association in schools.
• The CBJIP Team will use the behavior change communication strategy to change how
parents discipline their children using physical punishment. Through this strategy, the
CBJIP will promote “Positive Disciple.” The CBJIP team will seek the technical expertise
and support of the Local Social Welfare and Development Officer (LSWDO) in providing
manuals, leaflets, radio plugs, and other communication materials on Positive Discipline.
60
WORKSHOP PROPER
• The same behavior change communication strategy will be used by the CBJIP Team
for children to adopt desirable behavioral practices that will allow them to resist
temptations to indulge in vices and commit crimes. The CBJIP will encourage the
organization of a children’s association so that they can meet as peers and invite
speakers where they could learn about life skills and positive values that will keep them
away from vices and crimes.
• Through the policy advocacy strategy, the CBJIP will actively engage the Barangay
officials in passing ordinances protecting children’s rights and welfare and increase
budget allocation for projects focusing on children.
• The CBJIP team will initiate activities that will strengthen the delivery of direct services
to CICL and CAR, such as legal assistance, medical attention when needed, coordination
with residential care when necessary, educational support, counseling, diversion and
aftercare services, etc.
• The CBJIP Team, in coordination with the LSWDO and DILG, will use the capability
building strategy to improve the quality of services of Barangay officials, community
development workers, parent leaders, daycare workers, health workers, and community
volunteers.
• The CBJIP Team will use the monitoring and evaluation strategy to track the
implementation of the CBJIP, monitor the situation of CICL and CAR, evaluate the
effectiveness and efficiency of the program, and determine the results and impact of
CBJIP activities to children’s lives.
61
WORKSHOP PROPER
Session Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to develop a Results
Framework for your CBJIP.
Duration
Process
Step 1. Introduce the Session Objectives as above. Flash the diagram below on the
projection screen to indicate the current chapter being discussed and where the
workshop is leading to.
62
WORKSHOP PROPER
SITUATION RESULTS -
ANALYSIS CAUSALITY THEORY OF CHANGE BASED
OF CICL/CAR ANALYSIS CHANGE STRATEGIES FRAMEWORK
Step 2. Discuss the concept of the “Results Framework” by reading the texts below.
The Results Framework is a tool for project planning, monitoring, evaluation, and
reporting that provides a snapshot of the project that will help achieve major desired
results at different levels. This is your CBJIP and the translation of your ToC into a matrix.
The Results Framework provides the programming details that includes the three levels
of results—impact, outcome, and output—and their corresponding indicators, targets,
indicative budget, and budget source.
The Results Framework is usually designed for three to five years. This is your guide for
developing your “Annual Work and Financial Plan” to be submitted to the Barangay for
approval. Agencies simply look at the outputs and activities in this framework scheduled for
a particular year and then identify other related planning details, such as the indicators,
targets, and budget.
A Results Framework may look like the table below. Notice the placement of the Long-Term
Goal, Outcomes, and Outputs, as well as the titles of the columns: Results, Activities/Inputs,
Indicators/Definition, Target (2023), Indicative Budget, and Potential Source of Budget. These
will be explained in the succeeding narratives.
63
WORKSHOP PROPER
Long-Term Impact Goal: By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa has
been reduced by 100%.
Outcome 1: Families are caring and protective of children and provide for their needs.
Step 3. After explaining the concept of a “Results Framework” and showing a good example,
invite the participants to walk through the process of developing a “results
framework.” Bring the participants’ attention to the nine columns properly marked
with numbers. Go through these columns one by one by following the tasks below,
and explain them slowly to make sure there is a clear understanding of what to put in
the columns.
64
WORKSHOP PROPER
Invite the participants to sit around a table with metacards, markers, masking tapes, and
scissors. Ask them to copy the Results Framework template below on a Manila paper, and fill it
out as they go through the process. Remind them that the references are the “ToC” and
“Change Strategies” they have just developed.
Task 1 – Copy and paste the long-term goal and outcomes on top of the template, as shown
below. The team will work on the Results Framework per outcome. Because there
are three outcomes (at the family, community, and barangay sides), they should be
working on three templates. The CBJIP team can decide to group themselves into
three so that each group will work on one outcome. They can also work on the three
outcomes together at the same time. However, this may result in taking longer to
finish the Results Framework. Under Column 1, copy and paste all the outputs for
each outcome.
Outcome 1:
Task 2 – Under Column 2, discuss and agree on a list of relevant activities necessary to
achieve the individual outputs written in Column 2. Continue doing this for each output.
The following are examples of activities that may be initiated at the Barangay level.
You may refer to the change strategies discussed in the previous chapters. Pick the
65
WORKSHOP PROPER
examples that are relevant to each of the listed outputs in the results framework.
Some of these are:
• Service Delivery
• Family therapy with the family of CAR
• Provision of livelihood support to parents of CAR
• Counseling for parents of CICL
• Counseling for CICL and CAR
• Enrollment of CICL in Alternative Learning Systems
• Provision of legal support to CICL
• Engagement of CICL in diversion programs
• Construction/management of daycare centers
• Support for Barangay Health Centers
• Goat/swine dispersal for parents of CAR
• Provision of aftercare services for CICL
• Preparation of families to welcome the return of
rehabilitated CICL
66
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Capacity Building • Training of BHWs, BNSs, CDWs, and DCWs on
children’s rights
• Training of Barangay Officials/Tanods on children’s
rights
• Training of Barangay Officials on the management of
diversion programs
• Training of Barangay-based service providers on
handling CICL and CAR
• Training of parents of CAR on the management of small
businesses
• Orientation of CICL on adopting life skills
• Orientation of Sangguniang Kabataan (SK), Pag-asa
Youth Associations (PYAs), and children’s church-based
organizations on life skills
• Training of children and youth leaders on handling peer
counseling
• Training of children’s association officers on the
leadership and management of
• Partnership/Networking • Dialogue with NGOs, FBOs, and Professional Groups
based in the Barangay on the development of a referral
system for CICL
• Orientation of stakeholders in the Barangay on the
CBJIP
• Regular meetings with NGOs, FBOs, and Professional
Groups on the updated situation of CICL
• Solicitation of various technical services for CICL and
CAR
• Promotion of children’s rights, positive parenting, and
positive discipline with Barangay partners
67
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Policy Advocacy
• Lobbying with the Barangay Council to increase budget
allocation for CICL
• Dialogue with the Barangay Council to adopt resolutions
for the care and protection of CICL and CAR
• Presentation of the CBJIP to the Barangay Council for
endorsement and adoption
• CBJIP’s dialogue with the Barangay Council
• Passing of ordinance protecting CICL and CAR
• Advocacy with the Barangay Council to allot additional
financial assistance to support services for children
• Advocacy with the Barangay Council to adopt diversion
programs, as indicated in RA No. 9344
68
WORKSHOP PROPER
• Community
• Mobilization of volunteers for the CBJIP activities
Organization/Mobilization
• Organization of neighborhood watch groups
• Development of foster families for CICL and CAR
• Fundraising to support children-initiated activities
69
WORKSHOP PROPER
Task 3 Column 3, identify the indicators needed to measure the achievement of the identified
activities required to fulfill the corresponding outputs. For example, if you are
conducting a parents’ meeting on children’s rights, you would want to know how
many parents attended the meeting and how many have gained knowledge on
children’s rights.
Before asking the participants to proceed with the group work, explain the concept of
indicators, and cite examples.
Ask the participants to review the three statements below, and determine which is an
indicator. Ask them to raise their hands as you call the three statements. Most
participants will choose A and B, but the correct answer is C.
A. Increase in the number of mothers using positive discipline in raising their children
B. About 70% of mothers consistently use positive discipline in raising their children
What is an indicator?
Used as a benchmark (sukatan) for measuring program or project outputs
Are valueless and do not specify targets, which are separate items
Are signposts of change along the path to development
Can be quantitative or qualitative
70
WORKSHOP PROPER
– Under
Task 4 – Under Column 4, determine your total target for each of the indicators for three
years, and break it down annually (under Columns 5, 6, and 7), as shown in the
template below.
The total target refers to the variables mentioned in the indicators lumped over three
years. The total number of targets is then divided into three for 2022, 2023, and
2024 in Columns 5, 6, and 7. The variables could be the number of parents targeted
to be attending the FDS or PES. It could be the number of leaflets produced and
distributed or the number of CAR mothers targeted to be engaged in livelihood
activities.
Task 5 Column 8, determine the indicative budget needed to implement the identified activities
considering its total target for three years. The key to estimating the indicative
71
WORKSHOP PROPER
budget is identifying all the foreseeable expenditure items needed to carry out an
activity or launch an event. Get the total amount for the activity, multiply it by the
number of times it will be done for the year, and then multiply it again by three years,
which is the duration of the CBJIP.
• Snacks
• Meals
• Overnight accommodation
• Venue rental
• Rentals of equipment, such as projectors or computers
• Fare for participants
• T-shirts for participants
• Production of flyers, brochures
• Supplies such as ball pens, papers, metacards, markers, Manila papers
• Professional fees for trainers, facilitators, resource persons, artists, or documenters
• Workshop folders or bags
• Printing of certificates
• Token for resource persons
• Gasoline expenses or plane tickets for resource persons
• Support for children’s chaperones
Below are some samples for determining the indicative budget for certain activities.
72
WORKSHOP PROPER
– Under
Costing for conducting a meeting:
Assumptions:
• Activity: Conducting of FDS or PES among mothers on children’s rights
• Total Target (2022–2024): 360 mothers, 120 mothers per year
• Snacks worth PHP 50 per mother will be served
• One session covers 20 mothers with 2 facilitators
• Supplies are estimated at PHP 100 per participant
• Participants will receive PHP 40 as tricycle fare no matter where they are coming from
With the above assumptions, budgeting should appear like the computation below.
• Conducting of FDS/PES on children’s rights with 20 mothers:
- Snacks: PHP 50 × 20 mothers + 2 facilitators × 6 meetings/year: PHP 6,600
- Transportation Fare: PHP 40 × 20 mothers × 6 meetings/year: 4,800
- Supplies: PHP 100 × 20 mothers × 6 meetings/year: 12,000
- Indicative budget for one year: PHP 23,400
- Indicative budget for three years: PHP 23,400 × 3 years PHP
70,200
With the above assumptions, budgeting should appear like the computation below:
• Flyers on children’s rights for 2,000 residents
Task 6 Column 9, identify the potential sources of budget for each of the activities. Some of
these potential sources of budget are:
73
WORKSHOP PROPER
• DRRM funds: 5% of income
• PS 1st and 3rd class: 45% of annual Y; 4th and 6th class: 55%
• Discretionary: 2% of RPT receipts
• Intelligence: 30% of P&O provision, or 3% of appropriation, whichever is lower
• GAD budget: 5% of total appropriations
• Children: 1% of IRA
• Development fund: 20% IRA
• SK: 10% of Barangay appropriations
74
Description
At this stage, the draft output of the workshop is fleshed out or further improved by an
assigned team. Some parts of the results framework may need to be filled out, such as the
indicators, baseline, and budget. The whole CBJIP is then put together, finalized, and
photocopied. Next, a work and financial plan (WFP) is prepared for integration into the BIP. A
Barangay Resolution should also be prepared and presented to the BCPC for the adoption
and integration of the CBJIP into the BDP and BIP. The overall process might take one to two
months to finish.
Objectives
By the end of the pre-workshop meeting, the participants will be able to:
1. Fill out, complete, and finalize the Results Framework and the WFP; and
2. Prepare a Barangay Resolution for the adoption of the CBJIP and integration into the
BDP and BIP.
Duration
Process
Step 1. Review the draft Results Framework you developed during the workshop, and
complete it by filling in all the blank items.
Step 2. Put together the SitAn (Workshop Outputs 1, 2, and 3), Causality Analysis (Workshop
4 and 5), ToC (Workshop 5 continuation), and Results Framework (Workshop 6 and
7). This will constitute your CBJIP. Organize them according to the following outline.
75
POST-WORKSHOP
23 December 2021
FOREWORD
I congratulate the Barangay Project Management Team for working hard and putting a lot of
efforts, time, and dedication in developing this document. I would like to thank the
Barangay Council for the Protection of Children for their support to the CBJIP Team
particularly in providing data and information to complete the CBJIP.
I would like to enjoin all the Barangay Officials, all the service providers, NGOs and FBOs
based in this Barangay, as well as the children and youth groups to be guided by this
document in planning your programs targeting children in this Barangay.
Let us all work together to ensure that all CICL will fulfill their rights as children.
Congratulations!!!
ACRONYMS
76
POST-WORKSHOP
AO Administrative Order
BCPC Barangay Council for the Protection of Children
CAR Children at Risk
CICL Child in Conflict with the Law
CBJIP Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program
CFLGA Child-Friendly Local Governance Audit
CLJIP Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention Program
CNJIP Comprehensive National Juvenile Intervention Program
CRC Convention on the Rights of the Child
CWC Council for the Welfare of Children
C4D Communication for Development
DepEd Department of Education
DR Documents Review
DILG Department of the Interior and Local Government
DOJ Department of Justice
ERPAT Empowerment and Reaffirmation of Paternal Abilities
IRA Internal Revenue Allotment
JJWA Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act
JJWC Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council
BDIP Barangay Development and Investment Plan
LCPC Local Council for the Protection of Children
LGOO Local Government Operations Officers
LGU Local Government Unit
LSWDO Local Social Welfare Development Office
M/CSWDO Municipal/City Social Welfare and Development Office
M/CHO Municipal/City Health Office
M/CLGOO Municipal/City Local Government Operations Officer
NGO Non-Government Organizations
PES Parents Effectiveness Service
PNP Philippine National Police
PNP – WCPC PNP - Women and Children Protection Center
PNP-WCPD PNP - Women and Children Protection Desk
Table of Contents
Acronyms 1
Foreword 2
Introduction 3
Situation Analysis/Causality Analysis of CICL 4
Theory of Change on the CBJIP 9
Results Framework on the CBJIP 2021-2023 13
Work and Financial Plan 2021-2023 16
Barangay Resolution Endorsing the CBJIP 22
77
POST-WORKSHOP
Introduction
The CBJIP is part of the Barangay’s commitment to build an enabling environment that
respects, protects and fulfils the rights of all children. The Barangay envisions a community
that promotes and protects the rights of children at risk and children in conflict with the law
under a restorative justice and welfare system.
This document is a product of the collective efforts of the Barangay Project Management
Team and the Barangay Council for the Protection of Children in coordination with the
Regional Steering Committee for the Welfare of Children and the Regional DILG Office.
This will serve as the Barangay’s guide in initiating implementing and monitoring activities
for children in general and for children in conflict with the law.
6. SitAn / Causality Analysis of CICL and CAR in the Barangay – See the example below.
Data show that there were CICL in the Barangay in 2019 and half of 2020.
Children ages ___ to ___ were more inclined to break the laws.
There were more CICL who were boys than girls.
The most common types of offenses committed against children were: _____; _____.
The most common types of offenses committed by children were: _____; _____.
The number of CICL in the Barangay appear to be increasing (or decreasing).
There were _____ children at risk in the Barangay made up of _____ children of families
registered as 4Ps beneficiary; _____ children of indigenous peoples; _____ children affected by
natural disaster; _____ children affected by armed conflict.
78
POST-WORKSHOP
79
POST-WORKSHOP
Long-Term Impact Goal: By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa has
been reduced by 100%.
Outcome 1: Families are caring and protective of children and provide for their needs.
Long-Term Impact Goal: By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa has
been reduced by 100%.
Outcome 2:
80
POST-WORKSHOP
Long-Term Impact Goal: By the end of 2023, the number of CICL in Barangay Pag-asa has
been reduced by 100%.
Outcome 3:
Total Annual Targets
Indicative Potential
Output Activities/ Indicator/ Target
Budget Source of
Results Inputs Definition (2022– 2022 2023 2024
(PHP) Budget
2024)
Output 1:
Output 2:
Output 3:
81
POST-WORKSHOP
ABSENT:
NONE
WHEREAS, there were several documented cases of children in conflict with the law in the
Philippines basically due to factors emanating from unfavorable conditions in the family, community
and the bigger society. There were also an increasing number of reported situation of violation of
their rights enshrined in the Convention on the rights of the Child.
WHEREAS, Republic Act (RA) 9344 or the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act (JJWA) of 2006, was
enacted to ensure the protection of their rights and welfare of the JJWA was enacted. To oversee the
full implementation of the law, the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council (JJWC) was
institutionalized.
WHEREAS, JJWA mandates all Local Government Units from the Barangay up to the provincial
level to institute a Comprehensive Local Juvenile Intervention program to address the issue of
children in conflict with the law. The CLJIP shall cover a period of 3-5 years in which the LGUs
must set aside a necessary amount in their annual budget to implement their respective juvenile
intervention program.
WHEREAS, DILG issued Memorandum Circular 2016-68 to guide LGUs on the development of the
CLJIP and that Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council issued a simpler manual, in support of this
Memo Circular, on developing a Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Program.
WHEREAS, Barangay __________ has its own share of children in conflict with the law and that
they are not properly managed. There are also a number of children who may be considered at risk
but the Barangay, currently, has no preventive programs for keeping them from becoming law
offenders or violators.
WHEREAS, a Barangay Project Management Team from the Barangay Council for the Protection of
Children has been organized for Barangay __________ to develop a Comprehensive Barangay
Juvenile Intervention Program (CBJIP) for 3 years.
82
POST-WORKSHOP
WHEREAS, the Comprehensive Barangay Juvenile Intervention Plan (CBJIP) needs to be endorsed
by the Barangay Council and integrated in the Barangay Development Plan with corresponding
budget for its implementation in compliance to the law, to ensure an effective response to the issue of
CICL.
Hon. ___________________________
Barangay Chairman
Step 4. Prepare a WFP on the CBJIP for 2021–2023, and use the sample as your template.
Ensure that the WFP is linked with the activities identified through the SitAn and
Results Framework. Linking them means that all activities to be funded must be
based on the situation and needs of the Barangay, available resources, and the
BCPC’s capacity to conduct and monitor the activities. For additional reference, the
levels of intervention (family-, community-, barangay-based) and the corresponding
examples of interventions that can be adopted by the Barangay for CICL and CAR
are also provided in Annex A.
83
POST-WORKSHOP
84
POST-WORKSHOP
No. of new
2. Construction of 3 new DCCs PHP MSWDO/B
daycare centers Engr. Galvez
new day centers erected 2,000,000 arangay
erected
Outcome 3. The Barangay has funded the CBJIP integrated into the Barangay Development Plan, and that is
implemented and monitored.
1.
Output 1. The The BCPC is
Reorganization/str Chairman 1% of IRA
BCPC is fully reorganized and DONE PHP 2,000
engthening of the Santos for BCPC
functional functional
BCPC
1. Workshop on
Copy of the Dr. Mata and 1% of IRA
the development DONE PHP 8,000
Output 2. The CBJIP CBJIP Team for BCPC
of CBJIP
CBJIP is developed
by the CBJIP Team 2. Formulation of Copy of the Dr. Mata and 1% of IRA
WFP for the DONE PHP 2,000
WFP CBJIP Team for BCPC
CBJIP
The CBJIP is
Output 3. The
adopted,
Barangay 1. Presentation of Chairman
approved, and 1% of IRA
Ordinance the CBJIP to the DONE Santos and PHP 3,000
funded by the for BCPC
approving the Barangay Council Dr. Mata
Barangay
CBJIP is passed
Council
Note:
The source of funds may be taken from the following.
1. Debt Servicing: 20% of income
2. Aid to Barangays: PHP 1,000/Barangay
3. DRRM fund: 5% of income
4. PS 1st and 3rd class: 45% of annual Y; 4th and 6th class: 55%
5. Discretionary: 2% of RPT receipts
6. Intelligence: 30% of P&O provision, or 3% of appropriation, whichever is lower
7. GAD budget: 5% of total appropriations
8. Children: 1% of IRA
9. Development fund: 20% IRA
10. SK: 10% of barangay appropriations
Please see Annex 2 for the guidelines for costing and budgeting for the CBJIP.
85
POST-WORKSHOP
Step 5. Present the CBJIP and WFP to the Barangay Council together with the draft Barangay
Resolution.
CONGRATULATIONS!
You may now start working on the implementation and monitoring of the CBJIP for the
Barangay. Best of luck!
86
ANNEX 1
As a guide for the formulation of the results framework, here is the list of strategies and
interventions for children in conflict with the law at the local level, which is derived from
existing initiatives of some local government units.
Advocacy - is a strategy which aims to influence decisions within political, economic, and
social systems and institutions of government at different levels or of any institution for that
matter.
Done usually by a group of “advocates”, it includes many activities such as conducting
research, issuing press releases, organizing press conferences, media campaigns, and public
speaking, or lobbying with legislators or policy makers.
Capacity Building - is the process of equipping individuals or groups with the knowledge,
information, skills, and attitudes that enable them to perform specific tasks effectively and
efficiently towards the attainment of specific objectives or desired results. Much more than
training, capacity building can be done through coaching, mentoring, on the job training,
apprenticeship, field exposure, exchange visits, reading, online studies, etc.
87
ANNEX 1
Juvenile Justice and Welfare System - refers to a system of dealing with children in conflict
with the law which provides child-appropriate proceedings, including programs and services
for prevention, diversion, rehabilitation and reintegration to family and after care services to
ensure their normal growth and development.
Strengthening the Local Council for the Protection of Children – is a set of interventions
that aims to establish and strengthen Local Council for the Protection of Children (LCPCs), or
inter-agency and multi-sectoral institutional mechanisms in all levels of local government units
(LGUs) that serve as child rights advocates and take charge of planning, implementing, and
monitoring local development plans designed to ensure the protection and safety of the
children in the locality.
88
ANNEX 1
Life Skills Education - is a method used for children and young people to promote personal
and social development, to build their capacity to make decisions in a day to day life, to
prevent health or social problems from occurring, and to protect themselves from possible
abuse, violence or injury.
Integration in the Local Development Plan – LDP is a document that contains the
deliberate, rational and continuous effort of the local government unit, with active participation
of the community, to accelerate its process of development and growth by optimizing use of
local resources. It is directed towards making public services, public spaces, and
infrastructures available to the constituency.
Integration in the Local Investment Program – LIP is a planning tool used in implementing
the comprehensive local development plan. It is a multi-layer listing of programs and projects
with cost estimates and sources of funds.
Parenting - is the process of promoting and supporting the physical, emotional, social,
financial, and intellectual development of a child from infancy to adulthood. Also referred to as
child rearing, parenting refers to the aspects of raising a child, and all the responsibilities and
activities involved in it.
Reintegration - the process that promotes or facilitates the acceptance of the child back to the
community. It is the healing of the victim’s and the community’s wounds that were inflicted on
them by the offense.
Restorative Justice - a process through parties with a stake in an offence jointly resolve the
aftermath and implications of an offense. It is a criminal justice system that focuses on the
rehabilitation of offenders through reconciliation with victims and the community at large.
89
ANNEX 1
LGU Social Worker - refers to a professional who is duly licensed/registered to practice social
work in the Philippines in accordance with RA 4373.
The following are considered primary, secondary, and tertiary interventions for CICL based
on CNJIP Framework.
General measures to promote social justice Creation of Youth Resource Centers in every
and equal opportunity, which tackle root municipality
causes of offending; therefore, developing
potential and sustaining strengths of the child, Institutionalization of activities for children and
family, and community to prevent youth, e.g., congress, camps, summits, fora
circumstances of the child being at risk of
offending Health services/education
Access of children to child and youth
organizations, such as SK, PYA, churchbased
organizations, Barangay Children
Associations, and Children Federations,
including the National Coalition of Children
Association of the Philippines (NACCAP) and
the National Anti-Poverty Commission –
Children and Youth Sector
90
ANNEX 1
91
ANNEX 2
Several studies on local programs and investments for children in the Philippines seem to
concur that financing program interventions, particularly for children in conflict with the law
(CICL), remain a huge challenge.
A study commissioned by the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Council (JJWC) entitled Local
Interventions and Public Investments for CICL in the Philippines revealed that “after more than
10 years since the enactment of RA 9344, it appears that a lot of work still needs to be done”
at the local level. For one, the study noted that local government units (LGUs) need to be
reminded of their accountability to use the 1% allocation of the Internal Revenue Allotment
(IRA) for the Local Council for the Protection of Children (LCPC), as provided for in Section 15
of Republic Act (RA) No. 9344 or the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act (JJWA) and of DILG
Memorandum Circular (MC) 2012-120 on the same subject.
The study urged the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) to develop and
implement a national strategy to revitalize Municipal/City and Barangay CPCs with an appeal
to reissue DILG MCs 2002-121 and 2005-7 and DILG MC 2012-120 to guide LCPCs in using
the “Allocation of One Per Cent IRA for the strengthening and implementation of the
Programs,
Projects, and Activities of the LCPC per Section 15 of RA 9344.”
LGUs are encouraged to increase allocation for LCPCs beyond the 1% requirement of the law
to ensure that all plans for children are provided with funds and implemented.
The study recommended an active engagement of and advocacy with local chief executives
and the members of the Local Development Councils (LDCs) who are mandated to formulate
the medium-term and annual investment programs (LDIP and AIP) and appraise and prioritize
socioeconomic development programs and projects.
In one workshop with United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)–supported LGUs in the
Development of Situational Analysis and Formulation of Comprehensive Local Juvenile
Intervention Program, Social Watch Philippines asserted that it was essential to emphasize the
need to discuss public financial management for children because their rights are not being
fully addressed. One of the main reasons cited was the existence of thematic laws mandating
the allocation of a certain percentage of LGUs’ Internal Revenue Allotment for their respective
implementation of intervention programs. JJWA requires only 1% of the local IRA compared
with other mandatory provisions requiring 5%–20%.
92
ANNEX 2
Meanwhile, some of the LCPC activities may also be charged against the 20% development
fund of the LGUs, as provided for in Section 287 of the Local Government Code, particularly in
the realization of the goals for the social development of the community.
Here are some of the possible sources of funding for CICL work and finance according
to Social Watch Philippines.
93
ANNEX 2
EXTERNAL SOURCES
1. Share from Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations (GOCCs), e.g., Philippine
Amusement and Gaming Corporation (PAGCOR) and Philippine Charity Sweepstakes
Office (PCSO)
3. Extraordinary receipts
94
ANNEX 2
4. Interlocal transfers
a. Subsidy from LGUs
b. Subsidy from other funds
5. Capital/investment receipts
a. Gain on sale of assets
b. Gain on investments
Here are some helpful tips from Social Watch Philippines for the formulation of work and
financial plans for CICL.
Annual total (if quarterly) PHP 276,000.00 LGU CAPABILITY BUILDING / ONE-
DAY TRAINING
95
ANNEX 2
On average, this can target a total of 1,000 persons/year per municipality or city, with the cost
of snacks at PHP 50 per person, equivalent to PHP 50,000. The cost can range from as low as
a few thousand in fifth- to sixth-class municipalities to 50,000 or a few million for large and
highly urbanized municipalities and cities.
Average Cost: 1,000 persons × PHP 50/snack = PHP 50,000 / Municipality or City
Why PHP 1,000? –> This can be the minimum target of 25 participants each in 10 barangays
or clusters of barangays done every quarter or 4 times a year: 25 × 10 × 4 = PHP 1,000.
96
REFERENCES
Cruz-Sta. Rita, M., Magno, C., Galvez, L., & Reyes-Cantos, J. (2013, May 21). Towards an
Informed Citizens’ Participation in Local Governance: Sourcebook on Local Public
Finance. United Nations Development Programme. https://www.undp.org/
philippines/publications/towards-informed-citizens%E2%80%99-participation-
localgovernance-sourcebook-local-public-finance
Department of Budget and Management (DBM). (2008). Updated Budget Operations Manual
(UBOM) for Local Government Units (Update of the 2005 UBOM).
DILG DBM, DOF, NEDA, HLURB. (n.d.). Volume V, Budget and Expenditure Management
Tools and Approaches. GTZ-Decentralization Program.
DILG DBM, DOF, NEDA, HLURB. (n.d.). Volume 2: Planning Tools and Approaches, GTZ-
Decentralization Program.
Galvez, L. L. (2013, December). 20% Component of the IRA Utilization Report [PowerPoint
Presentation].
Republic Act No. 7160 | GOVPH. (1991, October 10). Official Gazette of the Republic of the
Philippines. https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/1991/10/10/republic-act-no-7160/
Reyes, D., Tapales, P. D., Domingo, M. Z., & Villamejor-Mendoza, M. (2015). Introduction to
Public Administration in the Philippines: A reader (3rd ed.). UP NCPAG.
97
This page is intentionally left blank.
We value your input to further improve this document/publication.
Send us your comments/inputs at [email protected]
JJWC-IEC-005-2022
Knowledge Product No. 4
Revision No. 0
As of October 2022
Website : www.jjwc.gov.p h
Email: [email protected]
Tel. Nos. : (02) 8921-9065 / (02) 8921-0565