Chapter 3 Multicomponent Distillation - Shortcut Methods
Chapter 3 Multicomponent Distillation - Shortcut Methods
Chapter Three
Multicomponent Distillation
A) Flash or Equilibrium Distillation
Flash distillation consists of vaporizing a definite fraction of liquid in such a way that the
evolved vapour is in equilibrium with the residue liquid, separating the vapour from the liquid
and condensing the vapour if desired as a product.
Vapor
V, yi
Heater
Feed
F, zi Valve
reduce P
Q
Liquid
L, xi
when we fed the feed in the flash drum should be two phases saturated liquid and saturated
vapor. we have to check feed are two phases by using bubble point calculation and dew point
calculation.
OR at constant T
Material balance
Component balance
But ,
[ ]
∑ ∑
[ ] [ ]
D, yD
Feed
F, xF
Liquid
W, xW
Feed
F = 1 mole
Liquid
(1-f)
Slope is
Intercept of equation is
The equation a straight line with a slope of and can be plotted on the equilibrium
diagram, the coordinates the inter section of the line and the equilibrium curve are at
and .
Equilibrium curve
yD
y Slope = - [(1-f)/f]
xW xF
x
The intersection of the material balance line and the diagonal can be used as a point on
the line.
2) If the system is vapor ideal & liquid non ideal (modified Roualt’s law)
3) If the system is vapor non ideal & liquid non ideal (Real system)
Distribution coefficient
⁄
⁄
is a base component chosen usually as the least volatile component in the system
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
Equation (3.22) can be solved for
[ ]
∑{ }
[ ]
∑{ }
[ ]
B) Differential Distillation
In this process the vapour formed on boiling the liquid is removed at once from the system.
Since this vapour is richer in the more volatile component than the liquid it follows that the
liquid remaining becomes steady weaker in the more volatile component (m.v.c.) with the
result that the composition of the product is progressively alters. while the vapour formed
over a short period is in equilibrium with the liquid the total vapour produced is not in
equilibrium with the residue liquid. At the end of the process the liquid which has not been
vaporized is removed as a bottom product
Let:
moles of the material in the still.
mole fraction of the component (mole volatile component) m.v.c.
Suppose an amount containing a mole fraction y of be vaporized.
Amount left in the liquid .
Still Q (heat)
Neglect
Integrate:
∫ ∫
1/(y-x)
1/(y-x)
x2 x1
x
( ) [ ]
You have to choose a base component and you apply the above Equation (3.29) for any two
components
( ) [ ]
Example 3.1
A mixture of 33% n-haxane 33% n-heptane, and 34% n-Octane is to be subjected to a flash
distillation at 1 atm 60% of the feed is vaporized find the temperature of the flash and the
composition of the products
في البداية يجب معرفة درجتان الحرارة التي يكون فيها الخليط في حالة تشبع طورين وعليه يجب حساب درجة التشبع لطور السائل
ودرجة التشبع لطور البخاري حتى نقترب من الحل الصحيح
a) Bubble point temperature calculation (saturated liquid)
b) Dew point temperature calculation (saturated vapor)
باستخدام قانون رولتز لحساب التراكيب ومعرفة درجة الحرارة التي تم فيها الفصل حسب معطيات المساله سنحتاج حساب الضغط
البخاري للمركبات باستخدام معادلة انطوني
A B C
n-hexane 13.8193 2696.04 224.317
n-heptane 13.8622 2910.26 216.432
n-octane 13.9346 3123.13 209.635
∑ ∑
∑ ∑
}
Using the flash Equation
Assume
, ,
∑
[ ] [ ]
[ ]
This trial is not correct
Example 3.2
A liquid containing 50% benzene, 25% toluene, and 25% o-xylene is differentially distilled at 1 atm
32.5% by mole of the total feed is distilled compute the distillate and residue composition.
Basis: 100 of feed
( ) [ ]
Bubble point Temperature calculation: By using Roualt’s law and Antoine’s Equation
A B C
BENZENE 15.9008 2788.51 -52.36
TOLUENE 16.0137 3096.52 -53.67
O-XYLENE 16.1156 3395.57 -59.46
∑ ∑
zi Ki P*i αib
BENZENE 0.5 1.77686 1350.4136 2.42744994
TOLUENE 0.25 0.73199 556.30955 1
O-XYLENE 0.25 0.26124 198.54109 0.3568896
Apply Equation
( ) [ ]
( ) [ ]
Solving simultaneously the Equations (3.30), (3.31), and (3.32) by assuming values if computing
and checking the sum until it equals unity by using solver software in Excel.
From component balance you can get
zi xi yi
BENZENE 0.5 0.382035 0.745
TOLUENE 0.25 0.281951 0.18364
O-XYLENE 0.25 0.336014 0.07135
While we can graphically solve a binary component distillation system using the McCabe-
Thiele method or Ponchon Savarit Method, it is also possible to do a complete analytical
solution using mass and energy balances with the equilibrium relationship.
However, for multi-component systems, C > 2, one would find that the number of equations
obtained from mass and energy balances with the equilibrium relationship will always be one
less than the number of unknowns.
قد تجد أن عدد المعادالت التي تم الحصول عليها، 2 بالنسبة لألنظمة متعددة المكونات اي عدد المركبات أكثر من، ومع ذلك
.من موازين الكتلة والطاقة مع عالقة التوازن سيكون دائ ًما أقل من عدد المجاهيل
Consequently, one cannot do a complete analytical solution for multi-component distillation –
it requires a trial-and-error solution with the additional unknown assumed to be known, as
well as special considerations as to enhancing convergence of the solution.
فهو يتطلب حالً بستخدام محاوالت الصح والخطأ- ال يمكن أن يقوم بحل تحليلي كامل للتقطير متعدد المكونات، وبالتالي
باإلضافة إلى اعتبارات خاصة لتعزيز تقارب الحل، مع افتراض أن المجهول اإلضافي معروف
Fortunately, numerical design packages, such as Aspen Plus, and Aspen Hysys have been
developed to perform the rigorous solution of multi-component distillation systems.
However, as a design engineer, one always needs to know the underlying theory and methods
of calculation to enable one to make decisions about the validity of these “off–the– shelf”
packages and to verify the results.
Introducing some new terminology in addition to the terms used in binary distillation:
Fractional recoveries
Key components
Non-key components
Splits – distributing and non-distributing systems
Note that binary systems can be handled in the same terms.
A fractional recovery, FRi, is the amount or flow rate of component i in the distillate or
bottoms stream with respect to the amount or flow rate of component i in the feed stream:
It is the simple relationships expressed by the right-hand-side equations that make the use of
fractional recoveries useful.
These are also often specified simply as % recovery.
The components that have their distillate and bottoms composition specified are known as the
key components.
The most volatile of the key components is termed the light key (LK).
The least volatile of the key components is termed the heavy key (HK).
All other components not specified in the distillate or bottoms are termed non-key components
(NK’s).
It is the heaviest component appearing in the distillate in any appreciable quantity. It should have
enough information to be specifying its recovery in the bottom product.
The main purpose of the fractionation is the separation of the light key from the heavy key.
Relative volatility:
It is always computed with expect to the heavy key
, for components lighter than the heavy key and for heavier than the heavy
key .
Gilliland correlation
Underwood – determining
– Rmin number of stages at
Fenske – finite reflux
calculate Nmin
Estimating the
composition and product
flow rates
𝑵 – Fenske Equations
⁄
( )
⁄
̅
̅ √
̅ √
Example 3.3
A distillation column with a total condenser is being used to separate a mixture of benzene, toluene,
and 1,2,3-trimethylbenzene. The feed, 40 mol% benzene, 30 mol% toluene, and 30 mol% 1,2,3-
trimethylbenzene enters the column as saturated vapor. We desire to 95% recovery of the toluene in
the distillate and 95% recovery of 1,2,3-trimethylbenzene in the bottom. The reflux is returned as a
saturated liquid, and constant molar overflow can be assumed. The column operates at a pressure of 1
atm. Find the number of equilibrium stages required at total reflux, and the recovery fraction of
benzene in the distillate. Solutions of benzene, toluene, and 1,2,3-trimethylbenzene are ideal
D
D×xB = ?
D×xT = √
D×xTMB = √
xB = 0.4 F
xT = 0.3
xTMB = 0.3
W W×xB = ?
W×xT = √
W×xTMB = √
Component mass balance to obtain the product compositions and flow rates
Benzene: B F= 100
Toluene: T D= 70
1,2,3trimethylbenzene: TMB W= 30
̅ √ √
̅ √ √
⁄ ⁄
( ) ( )
⁄ ⁄
̅
ز
Nmin فأن القيم الجديدة يتم أستخدامها يف إعادة حساب، تغيت
رbubble point in top or bottom إذا كان أي من درجات
𝑹 – Underwood Equations
∑ ∑
𝚽 𝚽
This equation is referred to as the second Underwood equation and it is used to calculate and
once is known, is calculated from the mass balance :
∑[ ]
𝚽
This is known as the first Underwood equation. It can be used to calculate appropriate values for .
∑[ ]
𝚽
Note: in the first Underwood equation has more than one solution (number of solutions equals the
number of components in the system).
How to determine 𝑽
∑ ∑ ∑[ ]
Case I Case II
Distributions of all Distributions of Nonkey
components are known components can be predicted
Number of unknowns are one (only ) and number of equations is one (using one solution of )
𝑽 ∑ ∑ ∑[ ]
𝚽
Case III
Distributions of Nonkey
components are not known
In this case we have to use a number of solutions of that is required to set up a number of equations
that equals to the number of unknowns.
For example, there is one nonkey component for which we don’t know its distribution (i.e. we don’t
know its amount in the distillate ?). Thus we have two unknowns( ),
and therefore we need to use two solutions of , in the second Underwood equation.
Where
Solution procedure: For example if there is C (number of components) whose their distributions are
unknown then an exact solution without further assumptions is needed. Solving the first Underwood
equation and find the roots of (equals C+1). Then solving the second Underwood equation
simultaneously for all values of to obtain and the amount of each unknown nonkeys in the
distillate.
The original Gilliland correlation was graphical. Molkanov et al (1972) fit the Gilliland correlation to
the equation
𝑋 𝑋
[ ( )]
𝑋 𝑋
𝑋 𝑋
[( )( )]
𝑋 𝑋
A reasonably good approximation of optimum feed stage location can be made by employing the
empirical equation of Kirkbride (1944)
[ ( ) ]
Example 3.4
For the distillation problem described in Example (3.3), find the minimum reflux ratio. Use a basis of
100 kmol/h of feed.
∑[ ]
i Dx i ,D
V min
i i
By trial and error the value of Φ should be determined or using solver software in
Excel.
Calculation of Φ
q= 0 Feed is saturated vapor Φ = 3.2613
component classifications xF αi-TMB xF × αi-TMB [xF ×αi-TMB]/[αi-TMB-Φ]
B LNK 0.4 13.4515 5.38 0.528
T LK 0.3 6.47 1.94 0.605
TMB HK 0.3 1 0.30 -0.133
0.999999822
1.77693E-07
Calculation of Vmin
component classifications xF αi-TMB xD × D [xDD×αi-TMB]/[αi-TMB-Φ]
B LNK 0.4 13.4515 39.80 52.538
T LK 0.3 6.47 28.50 57.441
TMB HK 0.3 1 1.50 -0.663
Vmin = 109.32
Lmin = 39.52
Rmin = 0.566
Example 3.5
The feed to a depropanizer is 66% vaporized at the column inlet. The feed composition and average
relative volatilities are given in the table below. It is required that 98% of the propane in the feed is
recovered in the distillate, and 99% of the pentane is to be recovered in the bottoms product.
Calculate the minimum reflux ratio for this case using Underwood’s method.
FR (LK),D 0.98
FR (HK),D 0.01
By trial and error the value of Φ1 should be determined and the value Φ2 should be
determined or using solver software in Excel.
Component Class. zF αi-HK xF × αi-HK [xF × αi-HK]/[ αi-HK - Φ1 ] [xF × αi-HK]/[ αi-HK - Φ2 ]
𝑽 ∑ 𝑫𝒙 𝑫
𝑽 ∑ 𝑫𝒙 𝑫
نحصل على معادلتين في مجهولين وبتالي تستطيع و وبالتعويض في معادلة اندروود باستخدام الجذور االثنين
وأصغر التدفق حلهما والحصول على كمية هذه المادة في أعلى البرج
Component Class. ai-HK D×xD [ αi-HK×D×xi,D ]/[αi - Φ1] [ αi-HK×D×xi,D ]/[αi - Φ2]