Detection of Depression in Social Media Via Twitter Using Machine Learning Approach
Detection of Depression in Social Media Via Twitter Using Machine Learning Approach
.H>C<&68=>C:A:6GC>C<EEGD68=
' %( % )GD8::9I=6II=:8DC8:EID;HNCI68I>86AB6G@:GHEG:H:CI>C
! ! % # % EDHI:9 IL::IH >H LDCI ID 9:K:ADE:9 6EEA>:9 B6I= BD9:AH
! !( L=>8=B6NH><=I6C9:K:CEG:9>8I9:EG:HH>DCHNBEIDBH>C
# %% %! 6 L6NH 86C 8DBE:I:CI 6C9 :MI:C9 6C8>:CI B:I=D9H ID
!
9:H><C6I>DC -D 7J>A9 6HHD8>6I: 9:<G:: 6A<DG>I=B>8 GJA:
# #%!
" "# L=>8=L>AA6C6ANO:-L::IHG:;A:8I
% " " ,:A; 6HH:HH:99:EG:HH>K:DEI>DCH86CB6@:>I9D67A:;DG
% %! ! " E:DEA: ID >CK:HI><6I: HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHIH ;DG HNCI68I>86A
#% %& %
! % %
>9:CI>;>86I>DC I=6I HNBEIDBH 9:I:G>DG6I>C< EHN8=DAD<>86A
! % " # HI6I: L6N 7:;DG: 6C8>:CI B:I=D9H EG:H:CIAN JH: 45
" ! ! "9:CI>;N HNCI68I>86A B6G@:GH >C HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHIHE:GB>IH
% ! # ;DG667>96C8:I=6IB6N7A6C9>H=6C8>:CIB:I=D9H6C9<>K:
! & ## "% ;6G :6GA>:G EG:K>H>DC D; 9:EG:HH>K: B6G@:GH 0=>A: H:K:G6A
!#% :M>HI>C< HIJ9>:H D; 9:EG:HH>DC G:A6I:9 HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHIH
$ JH:9 68:7DD@ HDB: 8:CI:G:9DC-L>II:G96I6 !DL:K:G
I=:G: 6G: 8:GI6>C 9>;;:G:C8:H 7:IL::C I=: EA6I;DGBH I=6I
86JH: JC6B7><JDJHAN 8DBEA:I:AN 8DCIG6GN 8DCI:CI 6C9
-L>II:G 96I6 >H JC6B7><JDJHAN LDGI=N 45 =DL:K:G
" "'-+(.-"(' 68:7DD@ JH:GH D;I:C EDHI 7:ADL I=:>G G:6A C6B:H ID
;G>:C9H 6C9 B:B7:GH D; I=: ;6B>AN -L>II:G JH:GH JHJ6AAN
"I>HEDHH>7A:ID8DCHIGJ8I69::EA:6GC>C<BD9:AL=>8=
JH: G:6A C6B: 6C9 6G: 699>I>DC6A 9DJ7IA:HH ID 7: A>C@:9
86C <>K: DK:GK>:L D; E:GHDCH B:CI6A =:6AI= ;6G :6GAN >C
L>I= JH:GH I=:N C::9 C::G B:I -=>H E:GB>IH ;DG 6C
I>B:6H8DBE6G:IDI=:IG69>I>DC6A6EEGD68=:H7N6C6ANO>C<
699>I>DC6A 6CDCNBDJH B:6CH I=6I D; 8DBBJC>86I>DC
HI6I>HI>86A B6G@:GH >C HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHI %DIH D; E:DEA:
L=>8=86CD;;:G6A:HH;6@:688DJCID;HHD8>6I:>C'JGH>C<
C:6GAN 67DJI B>AA>DCH 6G: I68@A>C< L>I= I=: EGD7A:B D;
>C9>K>9J6AVH I=DJ<=IH 6C9 :ME:G>:C8:H -L>II:G 8DC?D>CIAN
9:EG:HH>DC 6C9 DCAN HDB: D; I=:B G:8:>K: 6C 8DBE:I:CI
=6K:67GD69EDEJA6I>DCD;JH:GH6<:C8NB><=I7:JHJ6AAN
IG:6IB:CI :EG:HH>DC >H 6 EG::B>C:CI :MEA6C6I>DC ;DG
9DJ7IA:HH ID =DA9 D;; >C B:CI6A =:6AI= 8DCC:8I:9 6C6ANH>H
>C86E68>IN 68GDHH I=: LDGA9 6C9 6EEGDM>B6I:AN
699>I>DC6AAN 6H 6 JCHJ7IA: 8DCIG6HI D; EJ7A>86AAN DJI I=:G:
>C9>K>9J6AH>C6N:6G8DBB>II:9HJ>8>9:L=>8=>HDC:D;I=:
>C;D EGDK>9>C< I=: H>BEA:HI L6N ID 7:6I 6 CJB7:G D; I=:
B6?DGG:6HDCH;DG9:6I=6BDC< N:6GDA9H +:HJAI6CI
8DCHIG6>CIHD;6C8>:CIHIG6I:<>:HD;>C;DGB6I>DC6HHDGIB:CI
IG:6IB:CI ;DG 9:EG:HH>DC HFJ6G: B:6HJG: JHJ6AAN 9:A6N:9
=6C<:H >C A6C<J6<: 6C9 68I>K>IN 6G: HNHI:B6I>86AAN
>BEG:8>H: DG ADHI :CI>G:AN 45 ,D8>6A B:9>6 EGDK>9: C:L
8DGG:A6I: ID I=: 9>;;:G:C8: >C 7:=6K>DG DC HD8>6A B:9>6
8=6C8: ID G:BD9:A :6GAN 9:EG:HH>DC >CI:G8:HH>DC H:GK>8:H
BDI>DC6A A6C<J6<: 6C9 HNCI68I>86A DEI>DCH JI>A>O:9 >C
BDHIAN >C N:6G DA9H 69JAI :K:GN H:8DC9 8DJCIA:HH
HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHIH 6G: L:AA IG>:9 ID >BEG:HH>DC I=6I
CJB7:G D; IL::IH 6G: EDHI:9 DC IL>II:G L=>8=
8=6G68I:G>O:9 B6?DG 9:EG:HH>DC .H:GH BDHIAN JH: HD8>6A
6EEGDM>B6I:AN8GDHHDK:G IL::IHH:CIE:GB>CJI:
C:ILDG@>C< ED9>JBH HJ8= 6H -L>II:G :MEG:HH ID I=:>G
C:6GAN 67DJI ILD =JC9G:9H 7>AA>DC D; IL::IH EDHI:9
;::A>C<H 6C9 K>:LH >C LG>II:C @>C9 6I6 8DCI:CI D; EDHIH
6CCJ6AAN6C96EEGDM;>K:=JC9G:9B>AA>DCHE:G96N4 5
DCIL>II:GHFJ6G:B:6HJG:H><C>;>86CIAN=:AE;JA;DG6C6ANH>H
D; EDEJA6I>DC JH:H 6CN D; I=: K6G>:IN D; I=: HD8>6A
6H6G:HJAID;I=:>GBDHIINE>86AAN8G:6I:9L>I=>CI=:8DJGH:
C:ILDG@>C< 6EEH A>@: 68:7DD@ 6C9 IL>II:G 7:86JH:
D; 96>AN A>;: 68I>K>I>:H 6C9 HE:8>6A :K:CIH -=>H <>K:H 6C
9:EG:HH>DC >H 6HHD8>6I: 9:<G:: =:6AI= EGD7A:B I=:G:;DG:
:ME:CH>K:6C98D=:G:CIHJ<<:HI>DCI=6I;DG<:II>C<68I>K>IN
INE>86AAN C::9H I=: 6L6G:C:HH 67DJI HNBEIDBH ,D8>6A
ID >C9>K>9J6AH I=>C@>C< BDD9 HD8>6A>O6I>DC
B:9>6 EDHI 8DCI:CI <>K: 6C :ME:CH>K: HJEEAN D;
8DBBJC>86I>DC68I>K>I>:H
>C;DGB6I>DC 6C9 96I6 I=6I B6N 7: 688JHIDB:9 IG6>C
6HHD8>6I:9:<G:::8DCDB>86AHNHI:B
!!
-=: 6>B >H ID 9:K:ADE 6 EGD?:8I >C L=>8= HNHI:B >H 6
67A: ID 86EIJG>C< 6C9 6C6ANO: I=: HNCI68I>86A B6G@:GH
G:A6I:9IDDCH:I6C9E:GE:IJ6AHNBEIDBHD;9:EG:HH>DC 45
122
"" %"-+-.+)+(,)- $ !!
-=:G:AJ8I6C8:D;HNCI68I>86A6C6ANH>H L>I=>CI=:D7HIGJ8I>DC
&>HH>C< K6AJ: :M8AJH>K:AN =6C9A: 7N I=: G6C9DB
D; B:CI6A HI6I: 86CVI 7: >BBD9:G6I: N G:H:6G8=>C< 6
;DG:HI6A<DG>I=B
E:GHDCVHLDG9H>IH=DLH6IG6CHE6G:CI6C9K6AJ67A:L>C9DL
AHD 67A: ID 8DCHIGJ8I I=: G6C9DB ;DG:HI 8A6HH>;>:G
>CID E:GHDC HI6IJH 45 K:C I=: 7:HI G:H:6G8= D; HD8>6A
;DG86I:<DG>86AK6AJ:H6AHD
C:ILDG@>C< L>AA <>K: 'DGI= B:G>86C C6I>DC L>I= B6?DG
+6C9DB ;DG:HI 6A<DG>I=B G:9J8:H I=: EGD7A:B D;
688:HH>CIDE:DEA:K>:LH6C9;::A>C<H6C986JH:8DCH>9:G67AN
DK:G;>II>C<
A6G<:GJC9:GHI6C9>C<6C9IG:6IB:CID;B:CI6AHI6I:
A6HH>;>86I>DC6C9G:<G:HH>DCI6H@7DI=86C7:HDAK:
"C4 5 &JCBJC : =DJ9=JGN :I 6A I:C9H ID JH: 7NJH>C<H6B:G6C9DB;DG:HI6A<DG>I=B
HD8>6AC:ILDG@>C<H>I:H6H686A8JA6I>K:IDDAD;9:EG:HH>DC>C :6IJG: :C<>C::G>C< B6>CAN JH:9 G6C9DB ;DG:HI
CJB7:G D; E:DEA: ;DG B:6HJG>C< 9:EG:HH>DC 7N JH>C< ,/& 6A<DG>I=B
8A6HH>;>:G B:I=D9 "C4 5 &JCBJC : =DJ9=JGN :I DG >9:CI>;>86I>DC D; I=: BDHI >BEDGI6CI ;:6IJG:H
6A I:C9HID=6G68I:G>O>C<6C9)G:9>8I>C<)DHIE6GIJB ;GDB6K6>A67A:;:6IJG:HD;I=:IG6>C>C<96I6H:I
:EG:HH>DC ;GDB ,=6G:9 68:7DD@ 6I6 ;DG :I:8I
=6G68I:G>O: 6C9 )G:9>8I )DHIE6GIJB :EG:HH>DC 7N JH>C<
E6I>:CI =:6AI= FJ:HI>DCC6>G: "C4 5):I:G JGB6E :I
6A I:C9H ID &68=>C: A6HH>;>86I>DC 6C9 C6ANH>H D;
,J>8>9: +:A6I:9 DBBJC>86I>DC DC -L>II:G 7N JH>C<
EG>C8>E6A 8DBEDC:CI 6C6ANH>H "C4 5AK>H ,6G6K>6
:I 6A I:C9HID9:I:8I>DCD;&:CI6A>AAC:HH6C96C6ANH>H
K>6 HD8>6A B:9>6 ID )G:9>8I>C< :EG:HH>DC 7N JH>C< G6C9DB
;DG:HI 8A6HH>;>86I>DC "C4 5$:JB=:: :I 6A I:C9H ID
"9:CI>;N>C< :EG:HH>K: JH:GH >C -L>II:G JH>C< &JAI>BD96A
6C6ANH>H L=>8= MIG68IH -L::IH ;GDB -L>II:G I=6I >C9>86I:
:EG:HH>DC N JH>C< $ B:6CH 8AJHI:G>C< A6I:CI ;JH>DC N
JH>C< '6PK: 6N:VH 8A6HH>;>:GH "C459G>6C :CIDC
:I6A I:C9H ID JH: &JAI>I6H@ %:6GC>C< ;DG &:CI6A
!:6AI= DC9>I>DCH L>I= %>B>I:9 ,D8>6A &:9>6 96I6 ;DG
)G:9>8I>C<:EG:HH>DC7NJH>C<&JAI>I6H@%:6GC>C<6EEGD68=
>< G8=>I:8IJG:D;)GDEDH:9&D9:A
#$% !
"I >H 6 8A6HH>;N>C< I:8=C>FJ: 76H:9 DC 6N:VH -=:DG:B
>< :MEA>86I:HI=:6G8=>I:8IJG:D;EGDEDH:9BD9:A
8DCH>HI6C6HHJBEI>DCD;>C9:E:C9:C8:6BDC<EG:9>8IDGH "C
H>BEA:I:GBH6'6>K:6N:VH8A6HH>;>:GHI6I:HI=6II=:I=:G: "C EGDEDH:9 BD9:A L: <6I=:G 96I6 G:A6I:9 ID
>HCD>CI:G8DCC:8I>DC7:IL::CILD9>;;:G:CI;:6IJG:H 9:EG:HH>DC A:K:A 7N JH>C< IL>II:G JH:GH HD8>6A
68I>K>IN
-DI=>HL:6C6ANO:I=:DCA>C:68I>K>IND;I=:IL>II:G
JH:GL=:CE:GHDCB6@:IL::IHDCIL>II:G
""" )+()(,,2,-& 6I6 8DAA:8I:9 ;GDB JH:GVH DCA>C: HD8>6A 68I>K>IN
0: 7J>A9 I=: BD9:A ;DG 9:I:8I>C< 9:EG:HH>DC K>6 IL>II:G 6C9HIDG:>C6I:HI96I6HIDG:L=:G:96I6>HHIDG:;DG
7N JH>C< B68=>C: A:6GC>C< 6EEGD68= "C L=>8= HI6I>HI>86A I=:;JGI=:GEGD8:HH>C<
BD9:A >H IG6>C ID :M:8JI: I=: E6GI>8JA6G 8DJGH:LDG@ L>I=DJI ;I:GHIDG>C<I=:96I6C:MIHI:E>HIDI:HII=:96I6>C
JH>C< 9:;>C>I: >CHIGJ8I>DCH >CHI:69 JH: I=: E6II:GCH 6C9 L=>8=EGD8:HHD;;:6IJG::MIG68I>DC>HE:G;DGB:9
>CI:G;:G:C8: H>B>A6G ID I=: GI>;>8>6A "CI:AA><:C8: &68=>C: :6IJG::MIG68I>DC:;;>868>DJHANIJGC9DLCI=:96I6
A:6GC>C< 8DCI6>CH K6G>DJH 6A<DG>I=BH L=>8= >H JH:9 ID L=>8=BJHI7:EGD8:HH:9L=>A:DG><>C6A96I6H:I>H
9:K:ADE6B6I=:B6I>86ABD9:AL=>8=>HLDG@DCI=:H6BEA: HI>AA688JG6I:AN6C98DBEA:I:AN9:H8G>7:
96I6EGDK>9:86AA:96HIG6>C>C<96I6L=>8=JH:9ID9:8>H>DCH
)GDE:GAN DEI>B>O:H ;:6IJG: :MIG68I>DC >H I=: @:N ID
L>I=DJI:MEA>8>IAN:M:8JI:I=:8DJGH:LDG@ -=:G:6G:K6G>DJH
:;;:8I>K:BD9:A8DCHIGJ8I>DC
6EEA>86I>DCH >C L=>8= B68=>C: A:6GC>C< 6A<DG>I=B >H JH:9
HJ8=6HH:GK>8:E:GHDC6A>O6I>DC'6IJG6AA6C<J6<:EGD8:HH>C< ;I:G ;:6IJG: :MIG68I>DC H6G86HB 9:I:8I>DC >H
H:CI>B:CI6C6ANH>H8DBEJI:GK>H>DCHE::8=G:8D<C>I>DC6C9 E:G;DGB:96C9;>C6AANG:HJAI>HHIDG:9
B6CN BDG: "C I=: EGDEDH:9 BD9:A L: JH:9 B68=>C:
A:6GC>C< 6A<DG>I=B > : +6C9DB DG:HI 6A<DG>I=B ;DG I=: :ADL ;>< :MEA>86I: I=: LDG@>C< D; I=: EGDEDH:9
9:I:8I>DC D; 9:EG:HH>DC ;GDB IL>II:G 96I6 +6C9DB DG:HI BD9:A >C L=>8= K6G>DJH DE:G6I>DCH 6G: E:G;DGB:9
6A<DG>I=B>H6HJE:GK>H:9B68=>C:A:6GC>C<6A<DG>I=B6HI=: HJ8= 6H 96I6 8DAA:8I>DC 96I6 EG:EGD8:HH>C< 6C9
C6B: >C9>86I:H >I 7J>A9H I=: ;DG:HI D; CJB7:G D; IG::H H H:CI>B:CI6C6ANH>H
BJ8= I=: B6M>BJB CJB7:G D; IG:HH >C I=: ;DG:HI <>K:H I=:
B6M>BJB688JG68NG:HJAI
Authorized licensed use limited to: Cardiff University. Downloaded on October 01,2023 at 19:16:07 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
123
-:HI688JG68N>HB:6HJG:7NI=: H8DG: (JGBD9:A<>K:H
I=: 7:II:G G:HJAI L=:C I=: H8DG: >H B6M>BJB
&6I=:B6I>86AAN>I86C7::MEG:HH:96H
ͳ
ͳܨൌ ʹ כ ଵ ଵ ሺͳሻ
௦
&:6HJG: 86A8JA6I:H I=: G:A6I>K>IN 7:IL::C G:86AA 6C9
EG:8>H>DC
86A8JA6I: 7N 9>K>9>C< CJB7:G D; 68IJ6A EDH>I>K:
G:HJAIH7NI=:CJB7:GD;EDH>I>K:IL::IH L=>8=>H8A6HH>;>:G
86A8JA6I:9
86A8JA6I: 7N 9>K>9>C< CJB7:G D; 68IJ6A EDH>I>K:
IL::IH7NI=:CJB7:GD;6AAG:A6I:9H6BEA:H6AAH6BEA:HI=6I
H=DJA9=6K:7::C>9:CI>;>:96HEDH>I>K:
>< 0DG@>C<D;I=:)GDEDH:9&D9:A
.-.+,()
DAADL>C< I67A: 8DCI6>CH HDB: :M6BEA:H D; EDH>I>K: IL::IH "C I=>H E6E:G 6H L: 6G: LDG@>C< DC EG:9>8I>C< IL::IH
6C99:EG:HH>K:IL::IH H:CI>B:CIH 7JI >I 86C 7: BDG: 688JG6I: 6C9 7:II:G L>I= I=:
A6G<: 96I6 -=: 7>I =6G9 E6GI L6H H:6G8=>C< I=: 6CCDI6I:9
-%" 1&)%()(,"-"/')+,,"/-0-, 96I6H:I6C98A:6C>C<>I;DGI=:6C6ANH>H
" # " #
"C ;JIJG: " L6CI JH: 9::E A:6GC>C< I:8=C>FJ:H ;DG I=:
AL6NH 7G>C< NDJG DLC :EG:HH>DCHJ8@H "B>C
BDG: 688JG6I: G:HJAI " 6AHD L6CI ID 6C6ANO: I=: 9:EG:HH>DC
HJCH=>C: I=:B>99A:D;>I
A:K:AD;I=:>C9>K>9J6A7NEG:9>8I>C<I=:9:EG:HH>K:6HL:AA6H
I=: EDH>I>K: DG C:JIG6A IL::IH D; I=: JH:G " L6CI ID JH:
,=6G>C<=6EE>C:HH96>AN "=6I:BNH:A;IDD
BJAI>EA: ;68IDGH ID 6C6ANO: >C DG9:G ID B6@: BDG: 688JG6I:
G:HJAIH
:<>C:68=96NL>I=6HB>A: "IL6HBN;6JAI"A:INDJ
6C96<G6I:;JA=:6GI 8DCIGDAB: ('%.,"(',
-=: HD8>6A B:9>6 76H:9 B:CI6A 8DC9>I>DC D; 6C >C9>K>9J6A
!6K:67A:HH:996N "IVHHDADJ9>CBN=:69 86C 7: 6C6ANO:H 7N I:HI>C< I=: G:A6I>DC 7:IL::C 9:EG:HH>DC
6C9 HE:8>;>8 HNCI68I>86A B6G@:GH I=GDJ<= 6C 6A<DG>I=B>8
"6BCDI9:EG:HH:9
EGD<G6B 0=>8= 86C =:AE ID @CDL I=: H><C D; 9:EG:HH>DC
>C9 E:DEA: L=D L>AA B6@: :K:GNDC:?JHIEG:I:C9>C<
NDJ7:II:G ID7:=6EEN
I6@>C< EA68: L>I= >C9>K>9J6A -=: 9:EG:HH>K: 7:=6K>DG DG
8DC9>I>DC 86C 7: 9>6<CDH:9 DG ;>C9 DJI I=GDJ<= I=: JH: D;
HNCI68I>86A B6G@:GH 6H 6 IDDA 7N L=>8= I=: 9:EG:HH>K:
8=6G68I:G 86C 7: :6H>AN EG:9>8I 7N I=: IL::IH :K:C L>I=DJI
I=:JH:D;69K6C8:9BD9:A -=>H86C7:;>C9>C<DJI?JHI7N
"! HDB: 8DAA:8I>K: 8A:6G 6C9 K>HJ6A 6C6ANH>H D; IL::IH -=>H
EGD?:8I :ME6C9H I=: H8DE: D; 9>6<CDH>H D; 9:EG:HH>DC ;GDB
ME:G>B:CI6ADJI8DB: HD8>6AB:9>6
-%"" (&)+",('(1)+"&'-%(.-(&( " =:6GI>AN I=6C@H ID I=: EJ7A>H=:G G:H:6G8=:G 6C9
1",-"' ')+()(,,2,-&
EGD;:HHDG ;DG <J>9>C< B: ;DG I=: EGD?:8I -=: 8DAA:<:
6JI=DG>IN 6AHD =:AE:9 B: 7N EGDK>9>C< B: 6 <G:6I HJEEDGI
6C9I=::CI>G:C::9:9>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:L=>8=L6HG:FJ>G:9;DG
M>HI>C<HNHI:B )GDEDH:9HNHI:B I=: <J>96C8: ;DG I=: EGD?:8I AHD 6 <G:6I I=6C@H ID BN
ADK>C< ;6B>AN 6C9 ;G>:C9H ;DG HJEEDGI>C< 6C9 7:A>:K>C< >C
A<DG>I=BJH:9 '6>K:7N:VH +6C9DB;DG:HI B:
6A<DG>I=B 6A<DG>I=B
,8DG: 4 5 &DL:GN GN6C DCL6N & :6IJG: U ,IJ9>:H ID "C;DGB I=:
88JG68N A6HH>;>86I>DC D; :EG:HH>K: ,NBEIDBH ;GDB -L>II:G 6I6 ;DG
)DEJA6I>DC!:6AI= U 6G1>K
45 G:9O: & !6GB6CVV *J6CI>;N>C< B:CI6A =:6AI= H><C6AH >C
-L>II:G 0DG@H=DE DC DBEJI6I>DC6A %>C<J>HI>8H 6C9 A>C>86A
)HN8=DAD<N U%
Authorized licensed use limited to: Cardiff University. Downloaded on October 01,2023 at 19:16:07 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
124
45 3><BDC9 , ,C6>I= +)U -=: =DHE>I6A 6CM>IN 6C9 9:EG:HH>DC
H86A: 8I6)HN8=>6IGH86C9 U
45 3=JC< 0 0 $ U H:A; G6I>C< 9:EG:HH>DC H86A: G8=>K:H D;
:C:G6A)HN8=>6IGN U S
45 &D=G 3=6C< & ,8=J:AA:G ,U ):GHDC6A H:CH>C< JC9:GHI6C9>C<
B:CI6A =:6AI= JH>C< J7>FJ>IDJH H:CHDGH 6C9 B68=>C: A:6GC>C< U CC
+:KA>C)HN8=DA
45 -HJ<6L6 , &D<> 2 $>@J8=> 2 $>H=>CD J?>I6$ "ID= 2
6C9 (=H6@> !U(C :HI>B6I>C< 9:EG:HH>K:I:C9:C8N D; IL>II:G JH:GH
;GDB I=:>G IL::I 96I6 U "C)GD8::9>C<H D; I=: C9 "CI:GC6I>DC6A
0DG@H=DE DCB7>:CI "C;DGB6I>DC -:8=CDAD<>:H &"-V
&6G S
45 2DH=>=>@D ,J=6G6 2>CO=6C1J A:M ,6C9N ):CIA6C9U ::E &DD9
DG86HI>C< 9:EG:HH:9 BDD9 76H:9 DC H:A;G:EDGI:9 =>HIDG>:H K>6
+:8JGG:CI ':JG6A ':ILDG@HU "CI:GC6I>DC6A 0DGA9 0>9: 0:7
DBB>II::EG>A
45 9G>6C :CIDC &6G<6G:I &>I8=:AA >G@ !DKNU &JAI>I6H@ %:6GC>C<
;DGB:CI6A=:6AI=8DC9>I>DCL>I=A>B>I:9HD8>6AB:9>6U)GD8::9>C<HD;
I=: I= DC;:G:C8: D; I=: JGDE:6C =6EI:G D; I=: HHD8>6I>DC ;DG
DBEJI6I>DC6A%>C<J>HI>8H/DA )) EG>A
45 &6GN6B &D=6BB:9 A96GL>H= !6;>O6GDDF =B:9U )G:9>8I>C<
9:EG:HH>DC A:K:AH JH>C< HD8>6A B:9>6 EDHIHU I= "CI:GC6I>DC6A
,NBEDH>JBDCJIDCDBDJH:8:CIG6A>O:9,NHI:BH
4 5 $:JB=:: $6C< =6C=:: 2DDC JC 2> $>B T"9:CI>;N>C<
:EG:HH>K:.H:GH>C-L>II:G.H>C<&JAI>BD96AC6ANH>HU><DBE
4 5 AK>H,6G6K>6=JC!6D=6C<+:C6J9#DAA:I:%DG:COD2> ,=>C
=:CU&", &:CI6A "AAC:HH :I:8I>DC 6C9 C6ANH>H K>6 ,D8>6A
&:9>6U "CI:GC6I>DC6A DC;:G:C8: DC 9K6C8:H >C ,D8>6A ':ILDG@H
C6ANH>H6C9&>C>C</DAJ<JHI
4 5 ):I:G JGB6E J6AI>:GD DADB7D #DC6I=6C ,8DJG;>:A9 T&68=>C:
A6HH>;>86I>DC 6C9 C6ANH>H D; ,J>8>9: +:A6I:9 DBBJC>86I>DC DC
-L>II:GU
4 5 &JCBJC:=DJ9=JGN,8DIIDJCIHG>8# !DGK>IO6GDC!D;;U
=6G68I:G>O>C< 6C9 EG:9>8I>C< EDHIE6GIJB 9:EG:HH>DC ;GDB H=6G:9
68:7DD@96I6U,D8>6A-:8=CDAD<>:H6C90:AA :>C<:7
4 5 &JCBJC : =DJ9=JGN ,8DII DJCIH G>8 !DGK>IO T,D8>6A &:9>6
6H6&:6HJG:B:CI-DDAD;:EG:HH>DC>C)DEJA6I>DCHU0:7,8>&6N
Authorized licensed use limited to: Cardiff University. Downloaded on October 01,2023 at 19:16:07 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
125