A Comparative Exploration

CULTURAL HARMONIES
of Vocal Traditions

By Matthew Auditor

Tuvan Throat Singing of Mongolia | Yodeling of North America | Inuit Throat Singing of Canada
 Tuvan Throat Singing
Origins

Tuvan throat singing, also known as Khoomei,

originates from Tuva in southern Siberia. This
ancient vocal technique involves producing
multiple tones simultaneously using the voice. It
developed as a way to imitate natural sounds
and was used in rituals and ceremonies. In the
modern era, Tuvan throat singing gained global
recognition and has become a unique and
captivating form of artistic expression.
 Key Features and Techniques

Kargyraa: A deep, buzzing sound that is often used to imitate the

sounds of nature, such as the wind or the waves.

Sygyt: A high, piercing sound that is often used to express emotions,

such as joy or sadness.

Pharyngeal compression: A technique used to create the buzzing

sound of kargyraa. This involves contracting the muscles in the throat.

Vocal fry: A technique used to create the high, piercing sound of sygyt.
This involves vibrating the vocal cords at a very low frequency.
 Cultural Significance and
Context
Throat singing is an important part of Tuvan culture. It is often used to accompany
traditional dances and rituals, and it is also used to tell stories and pass on cultural
knowledge.

Throat singing is believed to have originated in the Altai mountains of southern Siberia. It is
thought to have been brought to Tuva by the ancestors of the Tuvan people.

Throat singing is a very expressive form of music. It can be used to express a wide range of
emotions, such as joy, sadness, anger, and love.

Throat singing is a challenging skill to learn. It takes many years of practice to master the
techniques involved.
 Adaptations Over Time

Tuvan throat singing, rooted in spiritual and cultural traditions in Tuva, has experienced
adaptations as it enters the global music scene. The practice involves producing multiple
pitches simultaneously through vocal manipulations. As it spreads worldwide, it faces
challenges in preserving its authenticity and spiritual depth. Tuvan throat singing has
influenced Western music, leading to sub-genres like Tuvan Pop that fuse traditional
techniques with modern styles. Performance contexts have shifted from pastoral settings to
formal stages, requiring emotional control and connection with unfamiliar audiences. The
spiritual significance, tied to shamanistic practices, has led to healing systems like the "Un-Hun
System." The globalization process raises concerns about misinterpretation due to cultural
differences. Despite adaptations, maintaining the practice's essence and cultural context
remains crucial for its appreciation and understanding.
Yodelling of North America
Origins

American yodeling originated in the early 1800s

as a fusion of Alpine yodeling and field hollers.
Alpine yodeling is a vocal technique that
originated in the Swiss Alps and is characterized
by its rapid alternation between high-pitched and
low-pitched notes. Field hollers are a type of
vocal music that originated in the African
American community and is characterized by its
loud, expressive calls.
 Styles of Yodelling
Alpine yodeling: This is the oldest and most traditional style of yodeling. It
originated in the Swiss Alps and is characterized by its rapid alternation
between high-pitched and low-pitched notes. Alpine yodeling is often used in
folk music and mountain songs.

Western yodeling: This style of yodeling originated in the American West as a

fusion of Alpine yodeling and field hollers. Western yodeling is characterized by
its rapid alternation between high-pitched and low-pitched notes, its
expressiveness, and its use of both Alpine yodeling and field holler techniques.
Western yodeling is often used in country music, folk music, and bluegrass
music.

Blue yodel: This is a style of yodeling that was created by Jimmie Rodgers in the
early 1900s. Blue yodel is a blend of Alpine yodeling and field hollers, and it is
characterized by its use of blue notes and its emotional expressiveness. Blue
yodel is often used in country music.
 Cultural Significance and
Context

American yodeling is often associated with the American West and country music.
It is seen as a symbol of rural culture and American folk music. It is sometimes
used to express emotions such as joy, sadness, and longing. It can be used to
accompany traditional dances and rituals. It can be used to tell stories and pass
on cultural knowledge.
 Adaptations Over Time
In the early 1900s, American yodeling was adopted by country music artists, such as
Jimmie Rodgers and Hank Williams. These artists helped to popularize yodeling in
country music, and they helped to develop a unique style of yodeling that is
associated with country music.

In the 1960s, American yodeling was featured in popular music by artists such as The
Beach Boys and The Beatles. These artists helped to make yodeling more
mainstream, and they helped to introduce yodeling to a new generation of listeners.

In recent years, American yodeling has been adapted to a variety of genres, such as
folk music, bluegrass music, and pop music. This is due in part to the popularity of
artists such as Dolly Parton, who have incorporated yodeling into their music.
Inuit Throat Singing of Canada
Origins

Canadian Inuit throat singing originated in the

Arctic regions of Canada. It is a vocal technique
that is used to create two or more simultaneous
vocal parts. The two parts are usually a high-
pitched falsetto and a low-pitched chest voice.
The singers use their voices to create a variety
of sounds, including trills, hums, and clicks.
 Key Features And Techniques
Face-to-Face Interaction: Inuit throat singing is typically performed
by two women who face each other closely. This physical closeness
enables them to exchange rhythmic patterns and sounds in a
competitive and entertaining manner.

Rhythmic Exchange: The essence of Inuit throat singing lies in the

rhythmic exchange of vocal sounds between the two participants.
The singers create rhythmic motifs using various vocal techniques.

Voiced and Unvoiced Sounds: Throat singers produce a

combination of voiced and unvoiced sounds. These sounds can vary
from deep, breathy tones to more percussive and staccato-like
sounds. The contrast between these different vocal qualities adds to
the complexity of the performance.
 Key Features And Techniques
Breathing Techniques: Inuit throat singing requires advanced
breathing techniques. Singers need to carefully manage their breath to
maintain the rhythm while engaging in rapid vocal exchanges. Effective
breathing is crucial for sustaining the performance.

Resonance and Vocalization: The singers utilize their vocal tracts and
throat to create resonances that enhance the textures and timbres of
the sounds they produce. The manipulation of the throat and vocal
tract results in the distinct and captivating vocal effects of throat
singing.

Competitive Play: Throat singing is often described as a competitive

vocal game. The two participants engage in a playful vocal contest,
each trying to outdo the other in maintaining the rhythm and vocal
patterns. The first person to laugh or stop loses the game.
 Cultural Significance and
Context
Canadian Inuit throat singing holds cultural significance within the Inuit community, serving as a form
of art, social interaction, and identity expression. It is deeply rooted in Inuit traditions and reflects
their unique way of life in the Arctic region. Throat singing acts as a means of entertainment, often
practiced by Inuit women when the men are away on hunting trips. It fosters a sense of camaraderie
and connection among participants and provides a way for women to bond and enjoy themselves
during long winter nights.

This tradition carries historical and spiritual weight, as it has been passed down through generations
orally, contributing to the preservation of Inuit heritage. Throat singing is a vital part of Inuit identity,
serving as a powerful reminder of their cultural roots and resilience in the face of external changes
and pressures. The revival of throat singing among younger generations signals a yearning to
reconnect with their traditions and strengthen their sense of self amidst the challenges posed by
Westernization and its impacts on Inuit ways of life.
 Adaptations Over Time

The Use of Instruments: In the past, Inuit throat singing was traditionally performed a cappella.
However, in recent years, more and more throat singers have begun to incorporate instruments
into their performances. This has helped to broaden the range of sounds that can be created, and
it has also made throat singing more accessible to a wider audience.

The Use of Electronics: Some throat singers have begun to use electronic effects to enhance
their sound. This can be used to create a variety of different sounds, and it can also be used to
amplify the throat singer's voice.

The Use of New Vocal Techniques: Throat singers have also been experimenting with new vocal
techniques. This has led to the development of new sounds and styles of throat singing.

The Collaboration with Other Musicians: Throat singers have also begun to collaborate with
other musicians, such as singers, instrumentalists, and DJs. This has helped to create new and
exciting sounds, and it has also helped to introduce throat singing to a wider audience.
 Sources Images

The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. (2023, February 15). Throat-singing. Throat Singing Picture - retrieved from:
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc. Retrieved from https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Batzorig_Vaanchig_-
https://www.britannica.com/art/throat-singing _Mongolian_Throat_Singing_-_Steppe_-_No_Signature.jpg
Bove, K. (2023, March 8). World throat singing. Kaitlin Bove Music. Retrieved
from https://kaitlinbove.com/world-throat-singing Man Throat Singing - retrieved from: https://www.britannica.com/art/throat-
O'Toole, C. (2013). Tuvan throat singing: The globalization of the Tuvan spirit. singing/images-videos
Georgia State University ScholarWorks. Retrieved from
https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi? Yodeling Men - retrieved from: https://manandculture.com/2022/01/what-
article=1549&context=gsurc you-didnt-know-about-the-history-of-yodeling/
Yodeling. (2023, August 13). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved
from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yodeling Inuit Singing- retrieved from:
National Today. (2023, August 13). Yodel for Your Neighbors Day. Retrieved https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inuit_throat_singing#/media/File:Throat_singing
from https://nationaltoday.com/yodel-for-your-neighbors-day/ _1995-06-18.jpg
Quark Expeditions. (2023, August 13). Inuit throat singing: A mesmerizing
Canadian High Arctic experience. Retrieved from
https://www.quarkexpeditions.com/blog/inuit-throat-singing-a-mesmerizing-
experience
Flanagan, T. (2008). First Nations? Second thoughts (2nd ed.). Montreal,
Québec: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Guilbault, J.-M. (2000). Inuit throat-singing. Musical Traditions, MT091. Retrieved
from http://www.mustrad.org.uk/articles/inuit.htm
Klaus, C. A. (2017). Throat singing: The history, culture, and technique of an
ancient Arctic art. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Tuvan Throat Singing of Mongolia | Yodeling of North America | Inuit Throat Singing of Canada