A Review of AM in Aerospace Application
A Review of AM in Aerospace Application
A Review of AM in Aerospace Application
Department of Mechanical Engineering, National Institute of Technology Delhi, Delhi 110 040, India
https://doi.org/10.18280/rcma.310206 ABSTRACT
Received: 3 September 2020 In the era of Digital Manufacturing and supporting state-of-the-art, i.e. Additive
Accepted: 17 December 2020 manufacturing (AM) technology is getting more popular known as 3D printing, AM has
created its own space in the fastest growing industry. 3D printing has evolved in previous
Keywords: years, and now, it is being used in several social life domains. The main application of
additive manufacturing, aerospace industry, this process has found in prototyping, aerospace industry, biomedical and dental
lightweight component implants. Additive manufacturing prints a part in a layer by layer or line by line pattern.
It opposes the basic concept of traditional manufacturing. Advances in composite and
multi-material manufacturing provide new opportunities for the convenient manufacture
of lightweight parts and modern products, such as flapping wings, satellite brackets, and
lightweight components for the aviation industry. It is a particular technology that varies
from conventional and subtractive development in terms of lightweight, enhanced
features, lower fuel consumption, and optimized machine performance, so on. This paper
addressed the progress of AM in the aerospace field and addressed the issues of AM
linked to a specific aerospace component.
1. INTRODUCTION and ceramics. All metal and non-metal parts produced using
AM technology have potential applications in the aerospace
Direct digital manufacturing is a production methodology industry. Direct metal laser sintering, selective laser melting,
that essentially consists of creating net practical parts from the laser curing, and laser metal deposition are the most used
product design to be produced. Since additive manufacturing technologies for aerospace applications. A suitable selection
processes (AM) require a limited source of energy. It can print of process parameters is essential for a product that depends
complex parts so; this technique is suitable for automobile, on the requirements and end-use criteria [9]. The main
aerospace, biomedical, and other industrial application [1]. applications of AM in the manufacturing industry include
AM is a material joining process in which material either in rapid prototyping, direct component development, rapid
powder, sheet, and wire/filament form used to stack the layer tooling, and reconstruction of metal component [10, 11]. The
together to produce three dimensional (3D) component which evolution of AM minimizes the issue of inventory and shortens
opposes the subtractive manufacturing process. Direct the supply chain. The aerospace industry required high-quality
transformation of raw materials into complicated 3D shapes components which are often complex and time-consuming.
focused on digital data produced by slicing and rasterizing Although, the conventional manufacturing process is
computer-aided design (CAD) file enables substantial time insufficient for small-scale production because there is a lot of
and expense savings, where technology is appropriate for wastage of material during the machining process and making
manufacturing end-use parts [2]. American society of testing complex structures for the aerospace application takes several
and materials (ASTM) F-42 committee [3] has classified the months. The definition has changed after the restructuring of
AM process into seven categories (shown in Table 1) which the manufacturing sector.
are as follows: extrusion-based, photopolymerization based, Various industries adopted AM technology for making
direct energy deposition (laser cladding), powder bed fusion, prototypes. In 2017, nineteen percent of the AM market
material jetting (polyjet), sheet lamination (sheet forming) and compromised by aerospace industry. Research and Markets
binder jetting. Different AM technology covers a range of recently published a study in terms of AM is a disruptive
main parameters related to output response. The role of these technology for the aerospace industry and they announce the
parameters is essential for the final assessment of quality parts. possible growth rate of 23.01% between 2017 and 2021 [12].
Common metal AM types are direct energy deposition [4], In the aerospace industry, lightweight and fuel consumption
which includes laser engineering net shape (LENS) and free are the basic parameters which are the concern of the industry.
form electron beam manufacturing [5], and powder bed fusion The aerospace components are directly exposed to high-
include selective laser melting and electron beam melting [6, temperature environments, AM has the ability to handle higher
7]. The popular available AM technologies are stereo- temperatures materials that are hard to cast, such as nickel
lithography, multijet modeling, fused filament fabrication alloys and inter-metallic materials through conventional
(FFF) [8], and three-dimensional printing (3DP) for non- manufacturing.
metallic components such as plastics, and composite materials,
109
Table 1. Seven categories of additive manufacturing process [13]
Staring phase of
Techniques Strength of work Weaknesses Companies
material
Changing the resin is 3D Systems (US),
Stereolithography Photo polymerization Quick printing speed difficult to handle Envision Tec
(SLA) (liquid-based system) High resolution Machine set up larger than (Germany)
resin needed. Object
Powder based system 3D systems, EOS,
High strength Surface quality is porous
Powder bed fusion uses plastic, ceramic Blueprint, SLM
moderate stiffness nature
(PBF) and composites metal solutions
Good chemical resistance High costs, slow process
in the powder form Renishaw
Poor surface finishing
Fused filament Easy to handle Stratasys
Solid based system, Difficult to handle
fabrication (FFF) User friendly, Prototyping Voxel jet
extruder part
Reduce manufacturing lead Mcor technology,
Solid based adhesive Constraint to complex
Laminated object time SD 300 printer,
bonding between structure
manufacturing (LOM) Good process for larger Fabrisonic (US),
materials Poor surface quality
structure Mcor (Ireland)
3D systems Ex
Applicable for complex Poor adhesion between
One (US),
ceramic structure layers
Binder jetting Liquid based process Voxeljet
Fast and flexible method for Fine resolution difficult to
(Germany)
complex structure achieve
Stratasys
Minimize manufacturing cost
Require a dense support
Direct energy Metal and its element and time, Optomec (US),
structure
deposition (DED) used in powder form Useful for printing of large POM (US
Low surface quality
component
High porosities in finished
Multi jet printing Multi jet fusion Full-color objects printing 3D systems
part
110
the conventional process so that these companies using AM titanium component with a diameter of 1.5 m and a thickness
technique to manufacture the part for aircraft applications. One of 0.5 m, carrying 48 aerofoils, were fabricated using the AM
of the most interesting facts of this technology is that it can be Electron Beam Melting technique. Using this technology,
designed virtually on the modeling software, manufactured at Rolls-Royce saved production time about 30 percent
the site, and tested within fewer periods. Now Airbus made compared to traditional methods of production.
small-scaled pilotless aircraft using this technology named The Agnikul COSMOS [25] Company incubated at IIT
THOR [16]. They installed the first 3D printed part in the Madras started using 3D printing technology to build a small-
commercial aircraft. Airbus engineers in its division of sized semi-cryogenic rocket of a range of 20 kilos Newton that
Defence and Space faced two major obstacles concerning to can hurl satellites of weight up to 100 kg in earth lower orbit.
bracket construction. The first challenge is that brackets must They designed it and planned to make with additive
securely connect the part and second is that it can withstand at manufacturing. As per the demand from customers for small-
a high temperature outside the earth’s atmosphere. This sized satellites, they are going to 3D print the engine and send
difficulty is overcome by fabricating the bracket through the them to space. The Team INDUS, they are looking to send a
3D printing process [17]. rover to the moon. It has 3D printed wheels bringing down the
General Electric (GE) Aviation uses the Powder Bed Fusion cost of the time to build it and also lowering down the cost.
system to manufacture the next level of complex jet engine This technology is proving itself very much promising in
parts using an EOS 3D metal printer. Jet engine nozzle aerospace applications [26]. Indian Space Research
manufactured by Direct Laser melting process. They said that Organization (ISRO) already started using 3D printing
this part is up to 25 percent lighter and more complex than its technology for 3D printed components for its spacecraft. The
predecessors and incorporates many assembled components in feed cluster component is 3D printed for GSAT-19 by its client
the past into one part [18, 19]. GE's executive team had seen to send it into space three years ago. Wipro 3D is a client of
the ability of AM and fundamentally changed how GE aviation ISRO who gives them 3D printed components for aircraft [27].
operates. Huge investments were made in GE's aviation They are printed the specific parts by 3D printing. These
business unit to improve 3D printing technology. GE specific parts include the thrusters for the satellite engine. As
Company improves the total capability of industry and has understanding the importance of AM in part consolidation
expressed a desire to print more than 100k pieces by 2020. 3D they started using 3D printing. It needs 7-8 years to mature this
printing technology has gone from producing a small technology to use in fully printed for aircraft application.
prototype to large industrial parts for industries, such as the ISRO has built its 3D printing manufacturing system to
titanium is used to 3D print the domes in onboard orbital produce small aircraft parts. Hindustan Aeronautics Limited
satellites by Lockheed Martin [20]. It is an aerospace and (HAL) has started using 3D printing to make a part for 25 kg
defence corporation, highlighted its 5Ps (a proposal, small engine as its component. They are also working on the
production support, prototype, procurement& production) AM unmanned aerial vehicle to produce its parts with 3D printing
model to show the promise of a traditional U.S. lifecycle. technology. Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. (HAL) is India's only
Airbus, with multinational safety and aerospace corporation manufacturer of armed military aircraft. They are making
Lockheed Martin, has signed an AM deal. To increase decisive steps in making "Made in India" a globe-class name
production with such emerging technology and to minimize by entering into additive manufacturing [28]. They used AM
overall costs, the partners will collaborate to find parts of the technology to set a reference model of an aircraft engine that
F-35 Lightning II aircraft. The part count was minimized by wages around 25 kN. The first 3D printed model was on show
making assemblies directly. This company is using this at Aero India expo-2015 as an operating platform.
technology to design 3D printed door handles, cup handles,
dome prototypes for aircraft, and toilet seats in military aircraft.
It is giving innovative solutions for complex manufacturing 3. APPLICATION OF AM IN AEROSPACE
processes with ease [21]. They also manufacture a 3D printed
fuel tank with the use of AM. They are also developing the AM has a wide scope in the aerospace application. It is a
giant 3D printed titanium parts for aircraft. Boeing makes a technology that differs from traditional and subtractive
choice using 3D Printing technologies. 300 Manufacturing manufacturing in terms of lightweight, improved performance,
parts for aircraft application made using 3D printing increased fuel economy, increased system efficiency, etc. The
technology, with 10 separate aircraft manufacturing programs. keyword additive denotes the making style of a printer that is
At current, more than 20,000 produced pieces with non- a layer over a layer rather than removing it from raw material.
metallic additives, it is expected to be enhanced more parts for The weight, fuel economy, and system efficiency matter a lot
the aircraft application [22]. for aerospace applications. Aerospace AM is on the verge of
Pratt and Whitney [23] create Aero Engine components taking off (Figure 3), with market dynamics and growing
using 3D printing technology. Pratt and Whitney have technical sophistication allowing AM to be taken up further
supplied their first engine for the C-Series passenger aircraft [29].
to the world’s largest aircraft maker, Bombardier. Using this In terms of fuel consumption, if we consider at the expense
technology significantly reduced manufacturing time and of holding an entity airborne or sending a rocket into orbit, the
complexity. From concept designs to prototype and then lighter parts make more difference. Undoubtedly, if the
convert into the final product using 3D printing technology component is light, it will have better fuel consumption, or
reduces wastage and raw material usage. It also helps in the improve system performance. The ultimate goal of this is to
precise production of components with intricate geometry with reduce the weight of parts by AM. For geostationary orbit, the
decreased tooling and enables the manufacture of different payload on it runs over thousands of kilograms. In such cases,
parts from an assembly in an integrated unit. Rolls-Royce [24] this light-weighting of components can help to reduce the fuel
aims to examine the more amount of the front bearing housing economy. In civil aviation, every kilogram carried cost
for engines. The complex shape and wide front bearing hundreds of dollars per year, per aircraft, an airline, or a rocket.
111
If we add the weight and cost through the aircraft fleet, the
overall expanse is immense. There are unknown possibilities
for light weighting in the airplane region. In an aircraft cabin,
think about all non-structural, non-light essential metal
elements. Instead of solid, these components can be made
hollow to lighten the part by rendering its internal lattice
structure to minimize weight without compromising its
usability. Metal 3D printing provides hundreds of possibilities
to extract mass and save fuel economy.
112
agencies like NASA have invested in designing and creating
new 3D-printed alloys to withstand high-speed, high-heat
conditions while improving the engine's power-to-weight
ratio.AM can minimize scrap metal by up to 90 percent
compared to conventional manufacturing methods to improve
material costs.
113
size distribution, surface area, flowability, observable • Part quality can be enhanced by using post-
density, humidity, and product porosity are the processing steps like hot isostatic process, heat
common factors. For several cases, these details are treatments.
appropriate needed by the end consumer [34]. • Certification and qualification of AM parts and
• The printed part's intrinsic anisotropic property is processes are paramount and needs to be accelerated.
another AM disadvantage. The presence of this
defect changes the microstructure tends to be
expanding in some direction. It affects the 6. CONCLUSIONS
mechanical properties. The manufacturing staircase
perspective leads to induced porosity in the Additive manufacturing methods have attracted their
manufactured component of improper densification interest in aerospace components manufacturing. AM gives
[35]. engineers versatility in manufacturing complex patterns that
• Inadequate information on the properties of AM are difficult to produce using traditional techniques.
materials can lead to incorrect assessment of strength
and material application. • Molding and tooling are not required for AM
• 3D printing is applicable for small components techniques, therefore saving time, cost, and energy.
whereas, aircraft application required large This study explores the advancement of AM
components which slow down the progress of this techniques used by various parts of the economy.
technology. • Addresses in detail how AM methods in different
• Certification of quality products and their assurance industries can increase structural and aerodynamic
is an essential step before promoting the final AM performance. For all of AM's benefits, it still
manufactured part into the market. struggles from the constraints which need addressing.
• AM materials production costs are higher than the • Lack of quality-strength materials, lack of diagnostic
conventional methods because it needs the required methods, anisotropic properties, and low build
processes to turn the content of material into the volumes identify the potential of AM to become a
correct forms for AM operations. viable business solution.
• Additionally, ongoing advancement and
development in additive manufacturing would be a
5. DISCUSSION remarkable place in the future of aerospace
production.
AM is revolutionizing the manufacturing process through
the ability to print complex geometries, reduce lead time, and
flexibility. Generally, traditional manufacturing like casting, REFERENCES
welding, and forging processes are applied to make the
aerospace components results in a lot of wastages and time [1] Kobryn, P.A., Ontko, N.R., Perkins, L.P., Tiley, J.S.
consuming. Although, the mechanical strength of these (2006). Additive manufacturing of aerospace alloys for
fabricated components is higher than the AM manufactured aircraft structures. Air Force Research Lab Wright-
parts. AM has become the most researched area for the Patterson AFB OH Materials and Manufacturing
aerospace industry due to making complicated, high Directorate.
temperature, and consolidates components. Many researchers [2] Chen, L., He, Y., Yang, Y., Niu, S., Ren, H. (2017). The
are working on the challenges part associated with the AM research status and development trend of additive
process. There is a need for proper quality assurance and manufacturing technology. The International Journal of
standardization of AM fabricated components before Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 89(9-12): 3651-
considered for application. ASTM F-42 community, SAE, and 3660. https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs00170-016-9335-4
the ISO TC 261 are working on the qualification and [3] Monzón, M.D., Ortega, Z., Martí nez, A., Ortega, F.
certification methods, design guidelines, test methods for (2015). Standardization in additive manufacturing:
characteristics of raw materials, material recycling guidelines, activities carried out by international organizations and
etc. More study is needed between the pre-processing, in-situ projects. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol., 76: 1111-1121.
control and the post-processing phase to analyze the shape https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs00170-014-6334-1
deviation, the physical phenomenon of the melt pool, and [4] Liu, R., Wang, Z., Sparks, T., Liou, F., Newkirk, J.
optimize the process parameters. More systematic work is (2017). Aerospace applications of laser additive
needed to achieve a broader use of the technology. Before this, manufacturing. In Laser additive manufacturing.
the following important aspects need specific research Woodhead Publishing, 351-371.
attention: https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100433-3.00013-0
• Closer assessment of AM processes physics and [5] Shu, X., Chen, G., Liu, J., Zhang, B., Feng, J. (2018).
evaluation of powder characterization. Microstructure evolution of copper/steel gradient
• Proper understanding of failure mechanism and deposition prepared using electron beam freeform
material irregularities. fabrication. Materials Letters, 213: 374-377.
• Need to develop a correlation between the material https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2017.11.016
property and manufactured part. [6] Sutton, A.T., Kriewall, C.S., Leu, M.C., Newkirk, J.W.
• AM component design guidelines and rulemaking. (2017). Powder characterization techniques and effects
• Assess the real-time behavior of melt pool and of powder characteristics on part properties in powder-
products to analyze the mechanical properties. bed fusion processes. Virtual Phys Prototyp, 12: 3-29.
• Proper monitoring and testing of AM parts. https://doi.org/10.1080/17452759.2016.1250605
114
[7] Seabra, M., Azevedo, J., Araújo, A., Reis, L., Pinto, E., accessed on 2020/5/2.
Alves, N., Mortágua, J.P. (2016). Selective laser melting [22] https://www.machinedesign.com/3d-printing-
(SLM) and topology optimization for lighter aerospace cad/media-gallery/21835191/metal-3d-printing-to-
componentes. Procedia Structural Integrity, 1: 289-296. shape-the-aerospace-industry, accessed on 2020/5/2.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prostr.2016.02.039 [23] https://www.eos.info/en/3d-printing-examples-
[8] Brenken, B., Barocio, E., Favaloro, A., Kunc, V., Pipes, applications/aerospace-3d-printing/space-propulsion-
R.B. (2018). Fused filament fabrication of fiber- satellites, accessed on 2020/5/2.
reinforced polymers: A review. Additive Manufacturing, [24] Anderson, S. (2015). Rolls-Royce to get largest 3D
21: 1-16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.addma.2018.01.002 printed component off the ground, flight-testing engine
[9] Živanović, S.T., Popović, M.D., Vorkapić, N.M., Pjević, later Year, Feb (2015).
M.D., Slavković, N.R. (2020). An overview of rapid [25] https://digital.hbs.edu/platformrctom/submission/additiv
prototyping technologies using subtractive, additive and e-manufacturing-revolutionizes-aerospace/, accessed on
formative processes. FME Transactions, 48(1): 246-253. 2020/5/3.
[10] Pavlović, A., Šljivić, M., Kraisnik, M., Ilić, J., Anić, J. [26] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/science/indi
(2017). Polymers in additive manufacturing: The case of a-is-slowly-catching-up-with-the-world-to-use-3d-
a water pump impeller. FME Transactions, 45(3): 354- printing-in-building-products/articleshow/67085613,
359. accessed on 2020/5/3.
[11] Wohlers, T. (2010). Additive Manufacturing State of the [27] https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/accreate-labs-to-
Industry, Wohlers report, Wohlers Associates, Inc. 3d-print-user-interface-panels-for-the-isro-space-
[12] https://www.3dnatives.com/en/additive-manufacturing- project-149874/, accessed on 2020/5/2.
aerospace-growing-061220184/. [28] RAPITECH Solutions Inc., Project Engine Prototype
[13] ISO/ASTM 52900: 2015 (E). (2016). Standard Model. RAPITECH Solutions Inc., India.
Terminology for Additive Manufacturing–General [29] https://www.rolandberger.com/en/Publications/Aerospa
Principles–Terminology. ce-suppliers-brace-for-headwinds.html, accessed on
[14] Wohlers, T. (2018). Wohlers Report 2018. Wohlers 2020/5/1.
Associates, Inc. [30] Easter S., Turman J., Sheffler D., Balazs M. (2013).
[15] Concept Laser. Laser melting with metals in aircraft Using advanced manufacturing to produce unmanned
manufacturing 3D printing enables “bionic” aircraft aerial vehicles: a feasibility study. SPIE Defense,
designs. Available from: Security, and Sensing: 874204-874216.
http://www.conceptlaserinc.com/portfolioitems/laser- [31] https://www.3dsystems.com/sites/default/files/2019-
melting-metals-aircraft-manufacturing-2/#prettyPhoto 06/3DSystems-eBook-Metal-
last accessed 2020/4/30. Lightweighting_NewStyle_AW%20%283%29.pdf, E-
[16] https://www.airbus.com/public-affairs/brussels/our- book for metal additive manufacturing last accessed
topics/innovation/3d-printing.html, accessed on 2020/5/2.
2020/4/30. [32] https://www.machinedesign.com/3d-printing-
[17] https://www.3dhubs.com/knowledge-base/aerospace- cad/media-gallery/21835191/metal-3d-printing-to-
3d-printing-applications/, accessed on 2020/4/30. shape-the-aerospace-industry, last accessed 2020/5/1.
[18] Kellner, T. (2014). Fit to print: new plant will assemble [33] https://www.eos.info/en/3d-printing-examples-
world’s first passenger jet engine with 3D printed fuel applications/aerospace-3d-printing/space-propulsion-
nozzles, next-gen materials. General Electric, Boston, satellites, last accessed 2020/5/1.
MA, accessed on Nov, 29, 2016. [34] Vrancken, B., Thijs, L., Kruth, J.P., Van Humbeeck, J.
[19] Kellner, T. (2015). The FAA cleared the first 3D printed (2012). Heat treatment of Ti6Al4V produced by
part to fly in a commercial jet engine from GE. 2015. Selective Laser Melting: Microstructure and mechanical
[20] https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/premium-aerotec- properties. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 541: 177-
partners-with-lockheed-martin-to-integrate-additive- 185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2012.07.022
manufacturing-into-f-35-aircraft-157977/, accessed on [35] ASTM Standard F3003-14(2014). Standard
2020/5/1. Specification for Quality Assurance of a Small
[21] https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/lockheed-martin- Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS), ed. West
shares-its-5-ps-for-industrial-3d-printing-136902/, Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International.
115