An Analysis of Non Performing Assets (NPA) On Punjab National Bank
An Analysis of Non Performing Assets (NPA) On Punjab National Bank
ABSTRACT
The banking industry plays a very efficient role in the Indian economy. Handling and
measuring the quality of assets in banks is very important for the growth and
development of the banking sector. Nowadays it has been seen that the asset quality in
the banks, specially the public sector banks is deteriorating constantly and thus causing
stress to the banking sector. NPAs are the loans which are given by the Indian banks and
the financial institutions where interests remain overdue for a relatively long time. The
main aim and objective of this research is to analyze the sources and deployment of funds
of Punjab National Bank and to examine the trend of NPAs in Punjab National Bank with
the help of secondary data collected from the Annual Reports and the Financial
Statements of Punjab National Bank for the last five years.
KEYWORDS: Gross NPA, Net NPA, Net Profit
1. INTRODUCTION:
Punjab National Bank, also called as PNB, is an nationalized bank of India ,
headquartered at New Delhi, India. It was founded in May 1894 and is the second largest
government-owned bank in India. Punjab National Bank has commenced its operations
from April 12, 1895 from Lahore with an authorized capital of Rs. 2 lakhs and working
capital of Rs 20,000. PNB is covered under the ownership of the Ministry of
Finance, government of India. Punjab National Bank is an Indian multinational banking
organization and provides financial services to the country which is also a state-owned
sector based in New Delhi, India.
The bank is sufficiently capitalized having capital adequacy ratio of 14.14 percent at the
end of March 2020. PNB merged Oriental Bank of Commerce and United Bank of India
with itself effective from 1st April this year. With the merger, the bank now has about
more than 13,000 ATMs,11000 branches , one lakhs of employees and a business mix of
over Rs 18 lakhs crore. At the end of March 2020 total domestic business of PNB rises
to Rs 11.81 lakh crore.PNB is planning to raise some money by selling some of its
properties including its earlier headquarter building. The bank has decides to increase its
loan growth target to 6 per cent for the current fiscal policy due to the COVID-19 crisis.
8404
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
8405
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
8406
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
in banking, the study may help understanding this concept better and banks may adopt
remedial measures so as to maintain NPA at the minimum level. He concluded that the
occurrence of NPA affects the profitability and financial health of a Bank adversely.
Asha Singh (2013) examined that the Public Sector Banks are facing a problem on the
growing level of Non-Performing Assets. Repeatedly year by year the non-performing
asset of the public sector banks has stood increased.
Dr. Sonia Narula and Monika Singla (2014)8attempt to evaluate the non-performing
assets of Punjab National Bank and its effect on viability and to realize the relation among
total loans, Net Incomes, Gross and Net NPA. The study customs the yearly report of
Punjab National Bank, the vital opinion to be renowned is that the waning of NPA is
important to recover productivity of banks. The effect of NPA level on PNB, resulting the
assumption that there is an optimistic relationship amongst Net Profits and NPA of PNB.
Debasish Biswas (2014) talks about improving the effectiveness and productivity of the
banks the NPA is to be condensed and measured. Else it is hard for banking segment to
hold in the market for longer period.The analysis in detail is made on NPA of schedule
commercial bank in India through past years.
Tiwari Chandan (2015) analyzed the causes of NPA in selected co-operative banks in
Pune. It studies the causes of NPA at the micro level for co-operative banks and brings
out the major causes responsible for assets turning into non-performing. He concluded
that identifying the causes of loans turning bad during several stages of disbursement of
credit facilities are therefore significant for a banker.
Singh, V. and Bahadur, R. (Mar 2016) discussed the status and trend of NPAs in Indian
Scheduled commercial banks, the factors contributing to NPAs, reasons for high impact
of NPAs on Scheduled commercial banks in India and recovery of NPAs through various
channels during the period of 14 years i.e. from 2000 to 2014. The result shows that
extent of NPA is comparatively very high in public sectors banks. Although various steps
have been taken by government to reduce the NPAs but still a lot needs to be done to curb
this problem. The NPAs level of Schedule commercial banks is still high as compared to
the foreign banks.
8407
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
V. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:
Research methodology for the proposed research is -
• Type of Research: - The study is both analytical and descriptive in nature. It describes
the causes impact and management of NPA as well as analyzes about NPA in Punjab
National Bank. The study is largely analytical in the sense that it analyzes various financial
variables and comparison and relationship among them based on secondary data. It also
implements descriptive research methodology in order to determine the views of
bankers and customers to know their perception on the management of NPAs.
• Sample Size:
Though Non-Performing assets bind to all the types of bank but in this research we select
PNB bank which holds third highest capitalization in public sector banks.
• Sources of Data:-
The data is based on secondary data and collected from the annual report of Punjab
National Bank. The study has covered a period of five financial year from 2016-2017 to
2020-2021..
• Tools and Techniques: - The data has been analyzed by using tables, average(mean),
standard deviation, coefficient of variance and coefficient of correlation
• Hypothesis
H01: There is no relationship between Net Profit and Net NPA.
H11: There is a relationship between Net Profit and Net NPA.
• Reference Period: This study will cover a period of five financial year of Punjab National
Bank from 2016-2017 to 2020-2021.
• Limitations :
• The basis for identification of Non-performing assets is taken from the Reserve bank of
India publications.
• NPAs change with time. The study is done in the present environment and prevailing
situation.
• The study of data and its result is concerned with Punjab National bank only. It will not
represent the financial position and analysis of any other banks.
• Since the data is based on secondary data it will not reflect the direct relationship
between the customer and the bank.
8408
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
Rs % Rs % Rs % Rs % Rs % %
2016 425. 0.0 4142 5.8 621704 88.2 4076 5.7 704314 1 100
-17 59 6 1.39 8 .02 7 3.34 9 .34 0
0
2017 552. 0.0 4052 5.4 642226 86.3 6085 8.1 744151 1 105.6
-18 11 7 2.19 4 .19 0 0.75 7 .24 0 5
0
2018 920. 0.1 4386 5.7 676030 88.9 3932 5.1 760143 1 107.9
-19 81 2 6.32 7 .14 3 5.91 7 .18 0 2
0
2019 1347 0.1 6100 7.4 703846 86.2 5022 6.1 816429 1 115.9
-20 .51 6 9.97 7 .32 1 5.43 5 .23 0 1
0
2020 2095 0.1 8884 7.1 110633 89.2 4284 3.4 124011 1 176.0
-21 .54 6 1.77 6 2.47 1 0.31 5 0.09 0 7
0
Aver 0.1 6.3 87.7 5.7
age 14 44 84 46
INTERPRETATION:
Table 1 shows that share of share capital used in the table is increasing but the actual size
of the share capital in comparison to trend on working fund is also increasing from 2016-
2017 to 2020-2021 in ratio perspective. Reserves and surplus has gone up from 41421.31
crores to 88841.77 and the percentage also increases here in comparison to total working
funds. Similarly deposit increases from 621704.02 crores to 1106332.47 crores. The
percentage to total working funds initially decreases and later increases again. This is
because of increase of its working funds in middle and later on it increases. Borrowing
has shown two sides’ first increases and eventually decreases and later on it has
increased a bit and its percentage to total working funds shows fluctuation.
8409
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
INTERPRETATION:
The table 2 shows that share of cash balance with RBI increases from 25210.00 crore to
43958.83 crore. Investment also increases from 2016-17 to 2020-21 and its percentage
to total assets also increases. Share of fixed assets also increase from 2016-17 to 2020-
21. It stands 0.846 on an average during study period. The percentage of other assets is
increasing from 2.70 % to 5.63%. Thus it can be concluded that Punjab National Bank has
been managing its working funds very effectively.
8410
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
INTERPRETATION:
It is observed from the table that Gross NPA ratio increases in 2017-18 and again
decreases and it becomes 14.12% in 2020-21. Though it has shown a increasing trend the
average of Gross NPA ratio is 14.948 %. Net NPA increases to 11.24 % in 2017-18 but
eventually decreases to 5.73% in 2020-21. The average Net NPA ratio is 7.424 %,
standard deviation is 1.95 and coefficient of variance of Net NPA ratio is 27.61%. Like
that Standard Deviation of Gross NPA ratio is 1.95, and coefficient of variance is 13.045
%.
8411
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
INTERPRETATION:
It is observed from the table that correlation is -0.46. It means that there is a high degree
of negative correlation between net profit and net NPA. Thus null hypothesis is rejected
upto 2019-20. It means that while NPA is increasing The Net Profit is decreasing. It is a
weak position of bank. But in 2020-21 Net NPA is increasing and also the Net Profit is
increasing. There are two types of customers. Good customers one lead to increase in
profit by paying interest and principal amount timely while bad customers lead to
increase in NPA by not paying interest and installment amount timely. The main reason
of increasing NPA is the mismanagement of Bank. Initially Net Profit decreases, but later
on it increases upto 2020-21. But in the mean, Net profit decreases during the five year
and Net NPA increases so it accepts alternate hypothesis.
Net profit increases from 2018-19. The reason of this increasing is the low amount of
NPA. It leads to adverse effect on profitability of bank and bank is unable to give loans to
the new customers.
8412
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
INTERPRETATION-
Trend percentage is the ratio between current year NPA and Base year NPA. It increases
as the year passes. From the above table we can see that initially the Trend percentage
was 100 but later on it increases gradually. And in the last financial year 2020-21 the
Trend percentage has become 188.59.So we can conclude that as the year passes Trend
percentage of NPA also increases.
X. FINDINGS:
Findings of the Financial Year 2016-17
• In Mar, 2017, the issued capital has increased to 425.59 cr. Reserves and Surplus has
increases to 37670.53 Cr, Deposit was 621704.02 and Borrowing was 40763.34 cr. Here
in comparison to Mar, 2016 Deposit has increased and Borrowing has decreased so it is
a positive sign of performance of Punjab National Bank.
• In Mar, 2017, Cash Balances with Reserve Bank of India was 25210.00 Cr, Investment was
186725.44cr, Loan and Advances were 419493.15 Cr, and Total Assets were 720330.55
cr. Thus except cash balances with RBI the other three components had increased in
2017.
• In Mar 2017 ,the Gross NPA ratio was 13.00 and Net NPA ratio was 8.00.The Gross NPA
Ratio remains constant in the financial year 2017 but Net NPA has decreased so it was a
good financial performance for Punjab National Bank
• The Net Profit was 1324.00 Cr in March, 2017.In 2016, March Net Profit was -3974.40 Cr.
It shows good financial performance of the Bank.
8413
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
• In Mar, 2018, Cash Balances with Reserve Bank of India was 28789.03 Cr, Investment was
200305.98 Cr, Loan and Advances were 433734.72 Cr, and Total Assets were 765830.10
cr. Hence we can say that the performance of Punjab National Bank was good during 2018
since asset quality has increased in that year.
• In March 2018, the Gross NPA ratio was 18.00 and Net NPA ratio was 11.00.The Gross
NPA Ratio increases in the financial year 2018 as well as Net NPA Ratio has also increased
so it was a poor financial performance for Punjab National Bank in the Financial Year
2017-18.
• The Net Profit was 1324.00 Cr in March, 2017. In 2018, March Net Profit was -12282 Cr.
It shows poor financial performance of the Bank.
8414
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
• In Mar, 2021, Cash Balances with Reserve Bank of India is 43958.83 Cr, Investment is
392983.25 Cr, Loan and Advances are 674230.08 Cr, and Total Assets are 1260632.62 cr.
Hence we can say that the performance of Punjab National Bank is good during 2021
since asset quality and investment has increased in the year.
• In Mar 2021 ,the Gross NPA ratio is 14.00 and Net NPA ratio is 5.73.The Gross NPA Ratio
becomes constant in the financial year 2021 as well as Net NPA Ratio has also decreased
so it is a good financial performance for Punjab National Bank in the Financial Year 2020-
21.
• The Net Profit was 336.00 Cr in March, 2020. In March 2021 Net Profit was 2022 Cr. It
shows good financial performance of the Bank.
XI: SUGGESTIONS:
• Bank should provide proper awareness and training programs to avail the
products and facilities provided by them. The training program should cover rural areas
to urban areas to educate the people about various products and to give knowledge about
the benefit and future prospects of that product. Loans, insurance and various term
policies and savings should go in a proper way when the knowledge of these facilities
should be placed in the mind of the common people.
• Terms and Conditions are also a important factor about which people should be
aware of. Without awareness about these conditions a bank cannot get profits in the long
run.
• Bank should conduct Loan Recovery campaign to let people know their
installments and about the time period.
• The average Gross NPA Ratio of 5 financial years is 14.948 and the average Net
NPA Ratio of 5 financial years is 7.424. So it is quite high. It is therefore recommended for
the bank to reduce its Gross NPA, Net NPA in order to meet its requirements.
• The Punjab national Bank should control its provision towards NPA by taking
some precautions for the recovery of the loans.
• Bank should have proper choice of borrowers and should keep proper
administration which is favour to the borrowers.
• Bank should highlight the potential NPAs under special category.
• Bank need to take precautions regarding the credit assessment’s and should take
measures in pre and post sanction of the loans to avoid slippages and standard assets of
NPA. Recognition of NPA in starting stage is very important and certain steps have to be
taken up to recover the loans and to minimize the amount of NPA.
• Bank should audit regularly so that it can ensure the fringe which don’t slip to the
NPA category. Punjab National Bank has to look after before issuing any advance to the
customers or proposal has to be thoroughly examined.
XII: CONCLUSION:-
The Government has made an attempt to provide a skeleton through framework of code
and expects the judiciary to infuse flesh and blood in the skeleton to energize the code.
IBC (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code) aims at early identification of financial failure and
8415
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
maximizing the asset value of insolvent firms. The code also has provisions to address
cross border insolvency through bilateral agreements and reciprocal arrangements with
other countries. The present study confines on study of Non Performing Assets with
special reference to Punjab National Bank for the last five financial years from 2016-17
to 2020-21.It was analyzed with respect to its sources , deployment funds ,Gross NPA ,Net
NPA and its trend percentage ,Profitability ratios and its impacts etc. The issue regarding
Non Performing Assets has become a major factor for banking sector. The Reserve Bank
of India has given the guidelines and norms to Punjab National Bank to regulate the
decline of NPA because it destroys the financial position of the bank. The customers and
public would not keep trust on the banks any more if the banks have higher rates of NPAs.
The study also reveals that there is a negative correlation between Net Profit and NPA of
Punjab National Bank. This is because mismanagement and wrong choice of customers.
So, NPA should be handled and managed in such a manner that it should not affect the
financial position of the bank as well as public image of the Bank.
REFERENCES:
BOOKS:
1. Pathak, V. Bharati. (2013). Indian Financial System. Pearson Publication.
2. Gupta, Ambuj. (2010).Non Performing Assets in Indian Banks : Issue, perspectives and
future directions. LAP Lambert Academy Publication.
3. Kothari, C.R.(2009).Research methodology methods and techniques. Second edition,
New age International Publication.
8416
SPECIALUSIS UGDYMAS / SPECIAL EDUCATION 2022 1 (43)
REPORTS:
1. Annual reports of Punjab National Bank for the last five years.
2. Press Release by Punjab National Bank for five financial years.
3. Analyst ppt of Punjab National Bank for last five financial years.
WEBSITES:
1. https://www.pnbindia.in/downloadprocess.aspx?fid=lwS2UC0Bvme58fKJBnQ9ew=
=#:~:text=CAPITAL%20ADEQUACY%20RATIO,%25%20as%20at%20September'21
2. https://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/punjabnationalbank/ratiosVI/pnb05
3. https://www.ceicdata.com/en/india/nationalised-banks-selected-financial-ratios-
punjab-national-bank/punjab-national-bank-financial-ratio-capital-adequacy-ratio-
tier-ii
4. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1070980/india-punjab-national-bank-credit-
to-deposit-ratio/
5. https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/banking-finance/punjab-national-
bank-plans-to-hit-capital-market-in-q4/1998658/
6. https://m.economictimes.com/industry/banking/finance/pnbs-capital-adequacy-
falls-below-regulatory-requirement-due-to-nirav-scam/articleshow/64573303.cms
7. http://www.bankingawareness.com
8417