SoM Chapter 6
SoM Chapter 6
CHAPTER 6
6. DEFLECTION OF STRUCTURES
6.1 Introduction
Structures, like all other physical bodies, deform and change shape when subjected to forces.
Other common causes of deformations of structures include temperature changes and support
settlements. If the deformations disappear and the structure regains its original shape when
the actions causing the deformations are removed, the deformations are termed elastic
deformations. The permanent deformations of structures are referred to as inelastic, or
plastic, deformations. In this chapter, we will focus our attention on linear elastic
deformations. Such deformations vary linearly with applied loads (for instance, if the
magnitudes of the loads acting on the structure are doubled, its deformations are also
doubled, and so forth). The principle of superposition is valid for such structures.
For most structures, excessive deformations are undesirable, as they may impair the
structure’s ability to serve its intended purpose. Structures are usually designed so that their
deflections under normal service conditions will not exceed the allowable values specified in
building codes.
The methods that have been developed for computing deflections can be broadly classified
into two categories, (1) geometric methods and (2) work-energy methods. As these names
imply, geometric methods are based on a consideration of the geometry of the deflected
shapes of structures, whereas the work-energy methods are based on the basic principles of
work and energy.
Deflection of beams and frames is the deviation of the configuration of beams and frames
from their un-displaced state to the displaced state, measured from the neutral axis of a beam
or a frame member. It is the cumulative effect of deformation of the infinitesimal elements of
a beam or frame member. As shown in the figure below, an infinitesimal element of width dx
can be subjected to all three actions, thrust, T, shear, V, and moment, M. Each of these actions
has a different effect on the deformation of the element.
Fig. 6.1: Beam element deformation and the resulting curvature of the neutral axis (n.a).
From Fig.6.1, it is clear that the rotation of a section is equal to the rotation of the neutral
axis. The rate of change of angle of the neutral axis is defined as the curvature. The reciprocal
of the curvature is called the radius of curvature, denoted by ρ.
The strain in arc 𝑑𝑠, located at a position y from the neutral axis is:
(𝑑𝑠 − 𝑑𝑠 ′ )
𝜀=
𝑑𝑠
However,
𝑑𝑠 = 𝑑𝑥 = 𝜌 𝑑𝜃 and 𝑑𝑠 ′ = (𝜌 − 𝑦)𝑑𝜃
𝜌𝑑𝜃 − (𝜌 − 𝑦)𝑑𝜃 1 𝜀
𝜀= 𝑜𝑟 =
𝜌𝑑𝜃 𝜌 𝑦
For a beam made of linearly elastic materials, 𝜀 = 𝜎/𝐸. Also flexure formula 𝜎 = 𝑀𝑦/𝐼
applies. Combining these equations and substituting into the above equations:
1 𝑀
=
𝜌 𝐸𝐼
This equation is applicable to all beams made of linearly elastic materials and is independent
of any coordinate system. In order to compute any beam deflection, measured by the
deflection of its neutral axis, however, we need to define a coordinate system as shown in
Fig.6.3: Arc length, its x- and y-component, and the angle of rotation
The small deflection assumption of the classical beam theory allows us to write
𝑑𝜃 1 𝑑𝜃
= = = 𝜃 ′ = 𝑣 ′′
𝑑𝑠 𝜌 𝑑𝑥
This in turn leads to:
This last equation is the basis for the solution of the deflection curve.
By direct Integration:
Slope (Rotation) is Deflection:
Note that the term (M/EI) dx represents an infinitesimal area under the M/EI diagram, as
shown in Fig. below. To determine the change in slope between two arbitrary points A and B
on the beam, we integrate Eq. below from A to B to obtain
Or
The mathematical expression of the first moment-area theorem can be stated as follows:
The change in slope between the tangents to the elastic curve at any two points is equal to the
area under the M/EI diagram between the two points, provided that the elastic curve is
continuous between the two points.
This theorem applies only to those portions of the elastic curve in which there are no
discontinuities due to the presence of internal hinges. In applying the first moment-area
theorem, if the area of the M/EI diagram between any two points is positive, then the angle
Note that the term on the right-hand side of Eq. above represents the moment of the
infinitesimal area corresponding to dx about B. Integrating Eq. between any two arbitrary
points A and B on the beam, we obtain
The mathematical expression of the second moment-area theorem can be stated as follows:
The tangential deviation in the direction perpendicular to the undeformed axis of the beam of
a point on the elastic curve from the tangent to the elastic curve at another point is equal to
the moment of the area under the M/EI diagram between the two points about the point at
which the deviation is desired, provided that the elastic curve is continuous between the two
points.
It is important to note the order of the subscripts used for ∆ in Eq. above. The first subscript
denotes the point where the deviation is determined and about which the moments are
evaluated, whereas the second subscript denotes the point where the tangent to the elastic
curve is drawn. Also, since the distance in Eq. above is always taken as positive, the sign of
∆BA is the same as that of the area of the M/EI diagram between A and B. If the area of the
M/EI diagram between A and B is positive, then ∆BA is also positive, and point B lies above
(in the positive y direction) the tangent to the elastic curve at point A and vice versa.
Procedure for Analysis
In order to apply the moment-area theorems to compute the slopes and deflections of a beam,
it is necessary to draw a qualitative deflected shape of the beam using its bending moment
diagram. In this regard, a positive bending moment bends the beam concave upward, whereas
a negative bending moment bends it concave downward. Also, at a fixed support, both the
slope and the deflection of the beam must be zero; therefore, the tangent to the elastic curve
at this point is in the direction of the undeformed axis, whereas at a hinged or a roller support,
the deflection is zero, but the slope may not be zero. Instead of adopting a formal sign
Sign Convention
If the positive ordinates of the M/EI diagram are applied to the conjugate beam as upward
loads (in the positive y direction) and vice versa, then a positive shear in the conjugate beam
denotes a positive (counterclockwise) slope of the real beam with respect to the undeformed
axis of the real beam; also, a positive bending moment in the conjugate beam denotes a
positive (upward or in the positive y direction) deflection of the real beam with respect to the
undeformed axis of the real beam and vice versa.
Procedure for Analysis
The following step-by-step procedure can be used for determining the slopes and deflections
of beams by the conjugate-beam method.
The work is equal to the area under the force-displacement diagram as shown in Fig. (b). In
this topic, we are focusing our attention on the analysis of linear elastic structures, so an
expression for work of special interest is for the case when the force varies linearly with
displacement from zero to its final value, as shown in Fig. (c). The work for such a case is
given by the triangular area under the force-displacement diagram and is expressed as
Another special case of interest is depicted in Fig. (d). In this case, the force remains constant
at P while its point of application undergoes a displacement ∆ caused by some other action
independent of P. The work done by the force P in this case is equal to the rectangular area
under the force-displacement diagram and is expressed as
It is important to distinguish between the two expressions for work. Note that the expression
for work for the case when the force varies linearly with displacement contains a factor of
1/2, whereas the expression for work for the case of a constant force does not contain this
factor.
The expressions for the work of couples are similar in form to those for the work of forces.
The work done by a couple acting on a structure is defined as the moment of the couple times
the angle through which the couple rotates. The work dW that a couple of moment M
performs through an infinitesimal rotation dθ is given by:
Therefore, the total work W of a couple with variable moment M over the entire rotation θ
can be expressed as:
When the moment of the couple varies linearly with rotation from zero to its final value, the
work can be expressed as
and, if M remains constant during a rotation θ, then the work is given by:
in which the terms forces and displacements are used in a general sense and include moments
and rotations, respectively. Note that because the virtual forces are independent of the actions
causing the real deformation and remain constant during the real deformation, the expressions
of the external and internal virtual work in Eq. above do not contain the factor 1/2.
DEFLECTIONS OF TRUSSES BY THE VIRTUAL WORK METHOD
To develop the expression of the virtual work method that can be used to determine the
deflections of trusses, consider an arbitrary statically determinate truss as shown in Fig.
below.
Let us assume that we want to determine the vertical deflection, ∆, at joint B of the truss due
to the given external loads P1 and P2. The truss is statically determinate, so the axial forces in
its members can be determined from the method of joints. If F represents the axial force in an
arbitrary member j (e.g., member CD in Fig. (a) above) of the truss, then (from mechanics of
materials) the axial deformation, δ, of this member is given by:
in which L, A, and E denote, respectively, the length, cross-sectional area, and modulus of
elasticity of member j.
To determine the vertical deflection, ∆, at joint B of the truss, we select a virtual system
consisting of a unit load acting at the joint and in the direction of the desired deflection, as
To determine the virtual internal work, let us focus our attention on member j (member CD in
Fig. above). The total virtual internal work done on all the members of the truss can be
written as:
By equating the virtual external work to the virtual internal work in accordance with the
principle of virtual forces for deformable bodies, we obtain the following expression for the
method of virtual work for truss deflections:
Note that because the virtual moment M v remains constant during the real rotation dθ, does
not contain a factor of 1/2. Recall that the change of slope dθ over the differential length dx
can be expressed as:
in which M = bending moment due to the real loading causing the rotation dθ. By
substituting:
The total virtual internal work done on the entire beam can now be determined by integrating
Eq. over the length L of the beam as:
By equating the virtual external work, Wve = 1(∆), to the virtual internal work, we obtain the
following expression for the method of virtual work for beam deflections:
If we want the slope θ at a point of the beam we use a virtual system consisting of a unit
couple acting at the point. When the beam with the virtual unit couple is subjected to the
deformations due to the real loading, the virtual external work performed by the virtual unit
couple, as it undergoes the real rotation θ, is Wve = 1(θ). The expression for the internal
virtual work remains the same as given in Eq. above, except that Mv now denotes the
bending moment due to the virtual unit couple. The expression for the method of virtual work
for beam slopes:
In the derivation of Eq. for virtual internal work, we have neglected the internal work
performed by the virtual shear forces acting through the real shear deformations. Therefore,
the expressions of the virtual work method as given by Eqs. above do not account for the
shear deformations of beams. However, for most beams (except for very deep beams), shear
deformations are so small as compared to the bending deformations that their effect can be
neglected in the analysis.
Procedure for Analysis
The following step-by-step procedure can be used to determine the slopes and deflections of
beams by the virtual work method.
1. Real System: Draw a diagram of the beam showing all the real (given) loads acting on it.
2. Virtual System: Draw a diagram of the beam without the real loads. If deflection is to be
determined, then apply a unit load at the point and in the direction of the desired deflection. If
the slope is to be calculated, then apply a unit couple at the point on the beam where the slope
is desired.
3. By examining the real and virtual systems and the variation of the flexural rigidity EI
specified along the length of the beam, divide the beam into segments so that the real and
virtual loadings as well as EI are continuous in each segment.
4. For each segment of the beam, determine an equation expressing the variation of the
bending moment due to real loading (M) along the length of the segment in terms of a
position coordinate x. The origin for x may be located anywhere on the beam and should be
chosen so that the number of terms in the equation for M is minimum. It is usually convenient
to consider the bending moments as positive or negative in accordance with the beam sign
convention.
5. For each segment of the beam, determine the equation for the bending moment due to
virtual load or couple (Mv) using the same x coordinate that was used for this segment in step
4 to establish the expression for the real bending moment, M. The sign convention for the
The virtual internal work due to axial deformations for the entire frame can be expressed as:
The total internal virtual work for the frame due to both bending and axial deformations as:
By equating the virtual external work to the virtual internal work, we obtain the expressions
for the method of virtual work for deflections and rotations of frames, respectively, as:
in which U = strain energy; ∆i = deflection of the point of application of the force Pi in the
direction of Pi; and θi = rotation of the point of application of the couple in the direction of
couple.
The energy of a structure can be simply defined as its capacity for doing work. The term
strain energy is attributed to the energy that a structure has because of its deformation. The
relationship between the work and strain energy of a structure is based on the principle of
conservation of energy, which can be stated as follows:
The work performed on an elastic structure in equilibrium by statically (gradually)
applied external forces is equal to the work done by internal forces, or the strain
energy stored in the structure.
This principle can be mathematically expressed as:
We = U
The explicit expression for the strain energy of a structure depends on the types of internal
forces that can develop in the members of the structure. Such expressions for the strain
energy of trusses, beams, and frames are derived in the following.
The strain energy of the entire truss is simply equal to the sum of the strain energies of all of
its members and can be expressed as
The change in slope, dθ, can be expressed in terms of the bending moment, M, by the
relationship dθ = (M/EI)dx
Thus,
The expression for the strain energy of the entire beam can now be obtained by integrating
Eq. above over the length L of the beam:
The strain energy due to axial forces for the entire frame can be expressed as
The strain energy due to bending for the entire frame is equal to the sum of strain energies of
bending of all the segments of the frame and can be expressed as
We obtain the following expression for the strain energy of frames due to both the axial
forces and bending:
The axial deformations of frames are generally much smaller than the bending deformations
and are usually neglected in the analysis. The strain energy of frames due only to bending is
expressed as:
Application to Trusses
Application to Beams
Application to Frames
When the effect of axial deformations of the members of frames is neglected in the analysis: