The Crystal Building Sustainable Performance and T
The Crystal Building Sustainable Performance and T
The Crystal Building Sustainable Performance and T
ABSTRACT
Over the past few decades, the concern for sustainability as a crucial component in construction has grown, as
has the discussion surrounding its integration into the sector, with the purpose of achieving higher qualitative
and beneficial efficiency and user experience. In the architectural field, there is a great interest in improving
studies of ecological solutions that reinvent building techniques, materiality and the application of energy
sources. In this research, the primary methodology employed is the case study approach, centered around the
building known as The Crystal, located in London, United Kingdom. Presently, the building serves as the City
Hall. In this context, the research objective is to analyze the connection between the local climate and the
primary sustainable and technological strategies applied to the project. This analysis is carried out through
digital simulations, physical models, and critical analyses. The building was designed by Siemens as a part of
the “London Sustainable Cities” program and has received recognition for its energy efficiency measures and
the application of bioclimatic architecture from the beginning of its construction. This building embodies a
number of sustainable development principles, including the use of geothermal heat pumps for its bioclimatic
systems, renewable energy sources, the effective application of natural ventilation and highly effective
materials for thermal and acoustic comfort, which, in short, convert this project into a reference within the
theme of sustainability and will be studied and detailed within this research.
1
Occupation: Student of Architecture and Urbanism at Mackenzie Presbyterian University.
Highest education level: High School
Academic institution: Colégio Cidade de Itu – Anglo.
E-mail: [email protected]
2
Highest degree of training: Professor
Academic institution: Mackenzie Presbyterian University
E-mail: [email protected]
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
The concept of sustainable development was created in 1987 in the Brundtland Report
presented by the UN, with the concern of preserving natural reserves due to the extractive mode of
production. Thus, sustainable development should meet "the needs of the present, without
compromising the needs of future generations." This definition portrays how sustainability, at its
core, is the concern of keeping the environment in which one resides healthy and comfortable, with
attention to maintaining the integrity of the place without causing a lack of resources in the future.
(BRUNDTLAND, 1991, p.1)
According to Gauzin-Müller (2002), based on his studies, he observes that a good part of the
world's energy matrix still uses too many non-renewable sources and that, consequently, there will
not be enough sources for future generations. In addition, according to the 2017 Global Status
Report, the construction sector was responsible for 40% of CO₂ emissions, and the energy spent on
these buildings is maximized when there is no integration with bioclimatic strategies, considered a
preferable solution in order to minimize energy costs, in addition to promoting comfort and
increasing the useful life of buildings. These strategies are defined as those designed based on the
local climate and, at the same time, intend to promote thermal comfort (CRES, 2017), in addition to
being considered from the beginning of the project, associated with the climate study. (FLEET, 1979)
(GIVONI, 1992)
In addition to this thought, Schmid (2005) cites in his book his perception in the course of
scientific and technological discoveries over the centuries. In addition, the author also highlights the
carelessness and forgetfulness within civil construction regarding the pre-established and determining
characteristics of a certain site: "there have been effective contributions to energy performance, since
knowledge in thermal insulation and ventilation has also advanced. However, traditional knowledge
of adaptation to the local climate has been forgotten." In addition, Schmid also positions himself on
the way that buildings are planned "the elegance of the forms did not always correspond to the
elegance of the technical solutions.", in addition to emphasizing the lack of planning of sustainable
strategies when he points out the following thought "the so-called machines of living and working
depended on portentous air conditioning systems".
Thus, environmental comfort in Architecture and Urbanism has as one of its main objectives
the viability of human settlements, in association with the basic and necessary conditions of
habitability, which are adapted to the conditions of the natural environment, as well as the social,
economic and cultural (SCHMID, 2005). In addition, the quality of life in a house is intrinsically
Source: photographs produced by the author (SHINODA,TABATA), taken during the technical visit to the site (July,2022)
The building has an area of 6,300 square meters, and was designed in 2011 by the office of
Wilkinson Eyre Architects, primarily a large center for exhibitions, research and conferences of the
Siemens company, with the aim of fostering new discoveries and debates on innovation, quality of
life and "sustainable urban development". However, in mid-2022, the City of London set up shop on
the site.
Source: photo produced by the author (SHINODA,TABATA), made during the technical visit (July, 2022)
Currently, the building has few places for public visitation, due to the preservation of security
for the city hall. In Figure 3, we find the current central courtyard, where some meeting rooms were
built for the London government, and in Figure 4, the same place can be seen, but with its old
purpose, intended for the old one Siemens' Center for Sustainable Urban Development. The
building's former facilities held interactive exhibitions related to art, urbanism and technology, a wide
variety of audiovisual shows, which took place on the building's façade, as well as conferences such
as the UN Habitat program in 2012 and the conference “Digital Life Design Cities” (SIEMENS AG,
2012), as well as launch events focused on technology and sustainability. (WILKINSON EYRE
ARCHITECTS, 2022)
The development of the dynamic mapping of natural light, through the Andrew Marsh
software, aims to analyze the periods of insolation and its obstructions, which directly impact the
facades of the building, during three times of the year: winter solstice, summer solstice and
equinoxes. From the georeferencing of the project in London and the insertion of the 3D model of the
roof, in the "Dynamic Overshadowing" application, it was possible to infer the periods of light
incidence on the facades (Table 1), since the degree of shading at the point chosen in the application
is quantified based on the percentage of the sky that is occluded in the period and on the date chosen.
(ANDREW MARSH, 2016)
Figure 6: periods of insolation on the south façade, which is most critical, at 6 a.m., 12 p.m., and 6 p.m., respectively
Source: by the author (SHINODA, TABATA), images taken from the digital simulation - Andrew Marsh (2023)
Source: Prepared by the author (SHINODA, TABATA) based on the results obtained in the Andrew Marsh software
(2023)
When observing Figure 7, we observe that the building receives a uniform amount of solar
incidence and, in addition, in the immediate surroundings, there are no buildings that obstruct this
data, since around the construction there is an extensive flat area, with gardens and areas for walks
and public walks. The north façade is the coldest. On the other hand, the south façade faces the high
solar gain due to the angle of the sun. This information was confirmed by the authors of this work,
through the data presented in spreadsheet 1, by the digital simulation in the Andrew Marsh software,
as well as confirmed by Qiu et al. (2022), shown in the diagrams in Figure 7.
The solution adopted to minimize the effects of the glass facades not becoming critical was
the best use of the solar incidence, from its envelope, as a high-performance solar glass was
applied. These, "are double glazing with three different types of panels, which allow an average of
70% of the entry of visible light, and the insulating argon gas in the void between the panels
minimizes the passage of heat". In the project, therefore, only "30% of the solar energy passes
through the glass and the building is not overheated, in addition to obtaining optimal thermal
comfort". (WILKINSON EYRE ARCHITECTS, 2022) (SIEMENS, 2013)
Another resource used to promote the entry of natural light was the insertion of skylights,
which also provide an increase in internal heating after exposure to the sun during the day. The
insertion position of these skylights is strategic and efficient, as they are located at the points where
the sun exposure is more incident by the roof. (GLA,2022)
For the design of the building, the inspiring element was nature, perceived in its crystal-
shaped geometry, with two parallelogram shapes that have multiple triangular facets. However, "in
addition to the aesthetic effect, the angles of the entire building, both on its roof and on its facades,
are strategies to minimize the direct incidence of the sun and to reduce the overheating of the
building", as highlighted by the authors QIU et al.,2022.
The structure of the building uses steel, from the use of a prefabricated minimum weight cut
in CNC, the glass panels, which allow maximizing the use of natural light, and reinforced concrete,
which is used in the 160 helix-shaped foundation piles that supported the building (the floors are also
made of concrete). (ABTEC BUILDING TECHNOLOGIES, 2022)
Another strategy applied to reduce the effect of overheating and the high incidence of solar
glare was the insertion of skylight glass, made from reflective glass windows, which significantly
reduce heat gain due to their properties. In view of this, it is possible to perceive the effect of self-
shading on the elevations below, in Figures 9 and 10, because, in order to minimize the "direct
penetration of the sun's rays through the glass panels, reflective glass is used on the surfaces, which
are facing the sun, while transparent glass is used on the faces away from the sun. towards the
ground." (GLA, 2022)
Source: Wilkinson Eyre Architects (2022) adapted by the author (SHINODA, TABATA) - Archdaily
Source: Wilkinson Eyre Architects (2022) - adapted by the author (SHINODA, TABATA) - Archdaily
At the angle of the roof, 1,580 m² of photovoltaic solar panels are "arranged", which cover
two-thirds of the roof, with 20% of the building's energy generated by the solar panels. All energy use
used in the building is constantly monitored, and every kilowatt of electricity used can be
measured. (WILKINSON EYRE ARCHITECTS, 2022)
Therefore, the sustainable strategies adopted throughout the project, such as the solar panels,
the skylights on the roof and their geometry, are directly influenced by local climatic conditions (such
as the positions of the sun on the building throughout the day) and, at the same time, seek to promote
thermal comfort to users.
Then, for the study of the ventilation strategies applied inside the building, two physical
models were made on reduced scales, to understand the relationship between the openings and the air
flows inside the building, through experimentation in the environmental comfort laboratory of the
Mackenzie Presbyterian University. Both models were adapted and reproduced from the ground floor
plan, with its openings, shown below (Figure 13).
Source: Wilkinson Eyre Architects (2022 b), adapted by the author (SHINODA, TABATA) - Archdaily
For the first experiment (Figure 14), a larger-scale model was made, with the main objective
of analyzing the ventilation and the perception of the airflow paths in the openings in the facades,
considered totally open for this first study. It is possible to observe this flow through the use of
incense, positioned at the bottom, and the exit of the smoke directed to the zenith opening of the roof
and in the upper windows.
For the second experiment (Figure 15), an adaptation was carried out, and a smaller-scale
model was considered, with only the zenith opening of the roof (with its reduced angulation), because
its purpose was to understand the air vortex and wind tunnels inside the building, in an area that has a
large flow of people. On this scale, it is also possible to observe the directed smoke through the use
of incense, however, the smoke output above the zenith opening (which represents hot air) is denser
and more concentrated. The air vortex forms due to physical barriers (such as building walls and
existing constructions, such as new meeting rooms).
These two models prove the efficiency of natural ventilation in architectural projects when
they are thought together, this strategy seeks to save on air conditioning and promotes air renewal,
improving the quality of the air inside the environments. And therefore, this is one of the items in this
project that adds to the rest of the sustainable strategies.
Source: Wilkinson Eyre Architects (2022 b), adapted by the author (SHINODA, TABATA) - Archdaily
The solution adopted for the spaces that have a large flow of people, such as the cafeteria and
the old exhibition center (now transformed into meeting rooms and a religious space), is to ensure
natural ventilation, due to the openings in the facades of the building, as shown in Figure 17, and
shown in the experiments with the physical models (Figures 14 and 15). On the other hand, for
strictly closed spaces, such as administrative offices, mechanical ventilation is used.
For the building's heating and cooling system (Figure 18), there are geothermal heat pumps,
which pump water through pipes that penetrate the ground up to 150 meters deep. The two
geothermal heat pumps provide hot and cold water, and pump it into pipes under the floor for heating
Energy is recovered from thermal wheels. The outgoing air passes through a heat-absorbing
disc which then rotates in the incoming airstream, warming the fresh air. About 60% of the heat
output or cooling energy is recovered. By using 100% natural heat sources, the building does not
need external sources. (GLA, 2022)
Figure 19. Infographic on the system of bioclimatic strategies applied to the building
Source: Wilkinson Eyre Architects, rereading and translation by the author, 2022 (SHINODA, TABATA)
In the system above (Figure 19), several types of sustainable and technological systems can
be perceived, such as water planning. For rainwater, which is collected by the angles of the building's
roof, there is a 30m³ underground storage tank, since, after collection, this water will be treated
through ultraviolet filtration and disinfection. As for the black water, which needs more attention,
there is a biological tank, as it will be recycled in two treatment areas and two filters. After the
Figure 20. Digital analysis in the Envi-Met software of wind speed and temperature during the winter and summer
solstice)
Source: by the author (SHINODA, TABATA), images taken from the digital simulation - ENVI-MET(2023)
Figure 22. London compass rose inserted in the ground floor plan
Source: Archdaily (2023) and World-Weather (2023), adapted by the author (SHINODA, TABATA)
In the simulations analyzed by Envi-met (Figure 20), the average wind speeds around the
building, both in winter and summer, occur between 7 km/h (in summer) and 16 km/h (in winter),
and the authors QIU et al. (2022), find an average speed of 14 km/h. averaged 2 to 5 °C on the
winter solstice and 15.5 °C on the summer solstice. The data taken from the software's simulation, in
relation to the average temperature and wind speed, are compatible with the averages of the city of
London in the year 2022, as situated in the climate base of WEATHERSPARK (2023)
Therefore, from the compass rose, represented in Figure 22, (WORLD WEATHER, 2023), it
can be seen that the winds are more frequent from the west, with 21.9%, and from the southwest,
with 20.4%, and the least frequent wind comes from the southeast, with 5.4%, which confirms the
data obtained by the Envi-Met simulation.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Greenhouse gas emissions have had a drastic impact on climate change, especially in large
urban centers. Therefore, it is up to the buildings to contribute to the minimization of this effect.
However, unfortunately, the solution found by many companies in large-scale works is excessive
spending on air conditioning in cold places. Abroad, however, the evolution of this sustainable arm of
2. AG, SIEMENS. (2012, 19 de setembro). Siemens opens urban development center – The Crystal in
London. Recuperado de https://press.siemens.com/global/en/pressrelease/siemens-opens-urban-
development-center-crystal-london-worlds-largest-exhibition
3. AKBAR, F. (2021, 1 de setembro). The Crystal by Wilkinson Eyre. Building study & report - iukl.
Recuperado de https://issuu.com/farahimakbar/docs/assignment_4_-_group_2
5. BRUNDTLAND, G. (1992). Nosso Futuro Comum 1987. Rio de Janeiro: Editora da Fundação
Getúlio Vargas. Recuperado de
https://edisciplinas.usp.br/pluginfile.php/4245128/mod_resource/content/3/Nosso%20Futuro%
20Comum.pdf
8. DARSAN, B. (2021, 29 de maio). The Crystal by Wilkinson Eyre Architects: A pavilion in a park -
RTF: Rethinking the future. Recuperado de https://www.re-thinkingthefuture.com/case-
studies/a4224-the-crystal-by-wilkinson-eyre-architects-a-pavilion-in-a-park/
9. DE DEAR, R. (2020). Ventilação natural, proteção solar e as melhores práticas projetuais para
combater o calor. Recuperado de https://www.caurj.gov.br/ventilacao-natural-protecao-solar-e-
as-melhores-praticas-projetuais-para-combater-o-calor/
12. GIVONI, B. (1992). Comfort, Climate Analysis and Building Design Guidelines. Energy and
Buildings, 18(1), 11-23.
13. GLA-GREATER LONDON. (2022). THE CRYSTAL: One of the World's Most Sustainable
Buildings. Recuperado de https://www.thecrystal.org/about/
14. GURGEL, M. (2021). Design passivo: guia para conhecer, entender e aplicar conforto ambiental
com baixo consumo energético. Editora Senac: São Paulo.
15. KEELER, M., & BURKE, B. (2010). Fundamentos de projeto de edificações sustentáveis. Porto
Alegre: Bookman Editora.
16. KÖPPEN, W., GEIGER, R. (1928). Klimate der Erde. Gotha: Verlag Justus Perthes.
20. QIU, J. C., et al. (2022). Passive Green Building Case Studies Poster & Booklet G3. Recuperado
de https://issuu.com/joanna1025/docs/gsbd_g3
21. SCHMID, A. L. (2005). A ideia de conforto: reflexões sobre o ambiente construído. Curitiba: Pacto
Ambiental.
22. SIEMENS. (2015). The Crystal: one of the most sustainable buildings in the world. Recuperado de
https://www.thecrystal.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/The-Crystal-Sustainability-
Features.pdf
23. SIEMENS. (2013, 15 de julho). The Crystal sets the benchmark for sustainable building.
Recuperado de https://news.siemens.co.uk/news/the-crystal-sets-the-benchmark-for-
sustainable-building
24. TORCELLINI, P., et al. (2006). Zero energy buildings: a critical look at the definition. National
Renewable Energy Lab. (NREL), Golden, CO (United States).
25. UNEP. (2016). Towards zero-emission efficient and resilient buildings – Global Status Report 2016.
United Nations Environment Programme (UN Environnement).
26. WEATHERSPARK. (2023). Clima e condições meteorológicas médias em Londres no ano todo.
Recuperado de https://pt.weatherspark.com/y/45062/Clima-caracter%C3%ADstico-em-
Londres-Reino-Unido-durante-o-ano#Figures-WindDirection