Tech Law Reviewer 17
Tech Law Reviewer 17
APRIL 17 Prepare for recitation: Topic-Virtual Assets and National Payments System
BSP circular 1108 and bitcoin mining
Access Devices Registration Act, Republic Act No. 8484
Access Devices Regulation Act, officially known as Republic Act No. 8484, is a law
in the Philippines that aims to regulate access to and use of devices such as credit
cards, debit cards, and other similar instruments. Here are some key sections of the
Act:
6.1 Access Devices (Section 3)
• Definition: The Act defines "access devices" as any card, plate, code, account
number, electronic serial number, personal identification number (PIN), or other
telecommunications service, equipment, or instrumentalities that can be used to
obtain money, goods, services, or any other thing of value.
6.2 Prohibited Acts (Section 9)
• Unauthorized Use: It is prohibited for any person to use an access device with
intent to defraud or to obtain anything of value without the consent of the
cardholder or account holder.
• Possession of Access Devices: Possession of an access device without the
consent of the cardholder or issuer is also considered a prohibited act.
• Production of Access Devices: Creating, making, or producing any access
device, whether it is real or counterfeit, without the cardholder's consent or the
issuer's authority is prohibited.
• Selling or Transferring Access Devices: Selling or transferring an access
device with knowledge that it is stolen or forged is against the law.
• Tampering with Access Devices: Altering, modifying, or tampering with the
components of an access device with intent to defraud is also a prohibited act.
6.3 Frustrated and Attempted Access Device Fraud (Section 12)
1
• Frustrated Crimes: The Act also covers "frustrated" access device fraud, which
means attempting but failing to commit any act defined under the Act due to
causes independent of the perpetrator's will.
• Attempted Crimes: Attempting to commit any act defined in the Act as an
offense is also covered, even if the attempt does not result in the actual use of
the access device or the completion of the fraud.
In summary, the Access Devices Regulation Act (Republic Act No. 8484) in the
Philippines aims to prevent unauthorized use, possession, production, sale, and
tampering of access devices such as credit cards, debit cards, and related instruments.
It establishes clear prohibitions and penalties for those who engage in fraudulent
activities involving these devices.
2
• During the trial, the prosecution presented the counterfeit credit card as
evidence.
• Cruz objected, arguing that it was not pre-marked during pre-trial.
• The trial court allowed its presentation, stating that it was part of an exhibit that
had already been presented and marked during pre-trial.
Issue:
• Whether the prosecution was able to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Cruz
was guilty of violating Section 9 (a) and (e) of the Access Device Regulation Act.
• Whether Cruz was deprived of due process due to the alleged negligence of his
former counsel.
Ruling:
• The prosecution was able to establish that Cruz had in his possession a
counterfeit access device, and therefore, he was guilty of the offense.
• Cruz was not deprived of due process and his counsel was able to adequately
defend his cause.
Ratio:
• The Supreme Court ruled that the trial court had the discretion to allow the
presentation of the counterfeit credit card as evidence.
• The alleged inconsistencies in the testimonies of the witnesses were minor and
did not affect the overall credibility of the prosecution's case.
• The court found that Cruz's former counsel's alleged negligence did not result in
a violation of his right to due process.
• The court emphasized that the right to counsel does not mean that the counsel
must be error-free or always successful in defending the accused.
• The court also noted that Cruz's counsel was able to cross-examine the
prosecution's witnesses and present evidence on his behalf.
• Therefore, the court upheld Cruz's conviction for possession and use of a
counterfeit credit card.
3
Title: Soledad y Cristobal vs. People
Case: G.R. No. 184274
Mark Soledad is found guilty of Violation of Section 9 (e), Republic Act No. 8484, for
possessing a counterfeit access device or access device fraudulently applied for, after
he was caught using a credit card fraudulently obtained from the complainant.
Facts:
• Mark Soledad y Cristobal was found guilty of Violation of Section 9 (e), Republic
Act No. 8484, for possessing a counterfeit access device or access device
fraudulently applied for.
• The incident occurred in June 2004 when the private complainant, Henry C. Yu,
received a call from a credit card agent offering a loan assistance.
• Yu invited the agent, Rochelle Bagaporo, to his office where she introduced him
to her boss, Mark Soledad.
• Yu submitted various documents for the loan application but later discovered that
his credit card information was altered and additional mobile phone numbers
were registered under his name without his knowledge.
• Yu filed a complaint with the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) and an
entrapment operation was conducted.
• During the operation, the NBI apprehended Soledad who presented identification
cards bearing Yu's name and signature.
• Soledad was charged with Violation of Section 9 (e), and after trial, he was found
guilty by the Regional Trial Court (RTC) and the Court of Appeals (CA).
Issue:
1. Whether or not the Information is valid.
2. Whether or not the Information charges an offense, or the offense petitioner was
found guilty of.
3. Whether or not petitioner was sufficiently informed of the nature of the
accusations against him.
4. Whether or not petitioner was legally in "possession" of the credit card subject of
the case.
4
Ruling:
• The Information filed against Soledad was valid and sufficient.
• Soledad was sufficiently informed of the accusations against him.
• Soledad was in possession of the credit card fraudulently applied for.
• Soledad's conviction and the penalty imposed by the lower court were affirmed.
Ratio:
• The opening paragraph of the Information, which stated the name of the accused
and the offense charged, complemented the accusatory portion and fulfilled the
constitutional requirement of notice.
• Soledad was sufficiently informed of the accusations against him as the acts
constituting the offense were clearly described in the Information.
• Soledad actively participated in obtaining possession of the credit card by
presenting identification cards with his picture but bearing Yu's name and forged
signature.
• Soledad's signature on the acknowledgment receipt indicated that he received
and possessed the credit card.
• Soledad had the intent to possess the credit card and actively participated in
acquiring it.
5
This Act shall govern the supervision and oversight of payment systems in the
Philippines. This Act shall apply to all payment systems, both large-value payment
systems (LVPS) and retail payment systems (RPS), operating in the country.
SECTION 4. Definition of Terms
For purposes of this Act, the following terms shall mean:
1. "Bangko Sentral" refers to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP).
2. "Clearing" means the process of transmitting, reconciling, and confirming
payment orders or funds transfer instructions prior to the settlement.
3. "Interoperability" means the ability of different retail payment systems and
instruments to work together seamlessly.
4. "Large-Value Payment System (LVPS)" means a payment system that processes
large-value and time-critical payments, including but not limited to interbank
transfers, large-value retail payments, and other systemically important payment
transactions.
5. "National Payment Systems" means the entire structure, organization, and
processes established for the handling, clearing, and settlement of payments in
the Philippines.
6. "Payment System" means a system that enables payments to be made between
a payer and a beneficiary, involving the transfer of funds, the clearing, or the
settlement of payments.
7. "Payment System Operator" means any person or entity that operates a payment
system.
8. "Retail Payment System (RPS)" means a payment system that processes retail
payments, including but not limited to transactions involving individuals or
businesses for goods and services.
9. "Settlement" means the process of discharging obligations between two or more
participants in a payment system.
10. "Systemic Risk" means the risk that an event will significantly disrupt the
functioning of a payment system and the broader financial system.
11. "Systemically Important Payment System (SIPS)" means a large-value payment
system that could trigger systemic risk if it fails to operate smoothly.
12. "Participant" means any person or entity that is a direct or indirect user of a
payment system.
13. "Regulation" means the rules and regulations issued by the Bangko Sentral
pursuant to this Act.
6
SECTION 5. Role of the Bangko Sentral
1. The Bangko Sentral shall have the primary responsibility for the supervision and
oversight of payment systems in the Philippines.
2. The Bangko Sentral shall establish the necessary rules, standards, and
procedures for the supervision and oversight of payment systems.
3. The Bangko Sentral shall promote the safety, integrity, efficiency, reliability,
accessibility, and governance of payment systems.
4. The Bangko Sentral may issue guidelines, circulars, or regulations to implement
the provisions of this Act.
SECTION 6. Licensing of Payment System Operators
1. No person or entity shall operate a payment system without first obtaining a
license from the Bangko Sentral.
2. The Bangko Sentral shall issue rules and regulations governing the licensing of
payment system operators.
3. The Bangko Sentral may revoke or suspend the license of a payment system
operator for violation of this Act or its implementing rules.
SECTION 7. Powers and Functions of the Bangko Sentral
The Bangko Sentral shall have the following powers and functions:
1. To supervise and regulate payment systems in accordance with this Act.
2. To establish and enforce rules and regulations governing payment systems.
3. To issue guidelines, circulars, and regulations for the implementation of this Act.
4. To conduct examinations, audits, and inspections of payment system operators.
5. To impose penalties and sanctions for violations of this Act or its implementing
rules.
6. To promote cooperation and coordination among payment system operators.
7. To maintain an updated registry of payment system operators.
8. To monitor and analyze payment system developments and trends.
9. To collaborate with other regulatory authorities on matters relating to payment
systems.
10. To perform such other functions as may be necessary to carry out the purposes
of this Act.
SECTION 8. Consumer Protection
7
1. Participants and users of payment systems shall have the right to fair and
transparent access to payment services.
2. The Bangko Sentral shall establish mechanisms to protect the rights of
consumers of payment services.
3. The Bangko Sentral may require payment system operators to disclose
information and terms and conditions related to payment services.
SECTION 9. Risk Management
1. Payment system operators shall implement risk management policies and
procedures to manage and mitigate risks.
2. The Bangko Sentral may issue guidelines on risk management for payment
systems.
3. Payment system operators shall have mechanisms in place to ensure the
security and confidentiality of payment transactions.
SECTION 10. Interoperability
The Bangko Sentral shall promote interoperability among payment systems to facilitate
efficient and accessible payment services.
SECTION 11. Regulatory Fees
The Bangko Sentral may impose fees and charges for the regulation and supervision of
payment systems.
SECTION 12. Penal Provisions
1. Any person or entity found violating this Act or its implementing rules shall be
subject to administrative fines.
2. Serious violations of this Act may be subject to criminal penalties, including
imprisonment.
3. The Bangko Sentral may impose fines and penalties for non-compliance with this
Act.
SECTION 13. Implementing Rules and Regulations
The Bangko Sentral shall issue the necessary rules and regulations to implement the
provisions of this Act.
SECTION 14. Separability Clause
If any provision of this Act is declared invalid or unconstitutional, the remaining
provisions shall remain in full force and effect.
SECTION 15. Repealing Clause
8
All laws, decrees, orders, rules, and regulations, or parts thereof, inconsistent with this
Act are hereby repealed or modified accordingly.
SECTION 16. Effectivity
This Act shall take effect fifteen (15) days after its publication in the Official Gazette or in
a newspaper of general circulation.
SECTION 17. Transitory Provision
For a period of one (1) year from the effectivity of this Act, existing payment system
operators shall be allowed to continue their operations without a license from the
Bangko Sentral, provided that they comply with the rules and regulations issued by the
Bangko Sentral. Existing payment system operators shall apply for a license within the
said one-year period.
SECTION 18. Review and Amendments
The Bangko Sentral shall conduct a periodic review of this Act and its implementing
rules and regulations to ensure their relevance and effectiveness. The Bangko Sentral
may recommend amendments to this Act as necessary.
SECTION 19. Appropriations
The necessary funds for the implementation of this Act shall be sourced from the budget
of the Bangko Sentral. The Bangko Sentral may also impose fees and charges for the
regulation and supervision of payment systems.
SECTION 20. Separation from Employment
Any officer or employee of the Bangko Sentral who is found to have committed an
offense under this Act or its implementing rules and regulations shall be subject to
administrative sanctions, including suspension or dismissal from office.
SECTION 21. Rules and Regulations
The Bangko Sentral shall issue the necessary rules and regulations to implement the
provisions of this Act. Such rules and regulations shall take effect fifteen (15) days after
publication in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation.
SECTION 22. Implementing Rules and Regulations
Within ninety (90) days from the effectivity of this Act, the Bangko Sentral shall
promulgate the necessary rules and regulations to implement the provisions of this Act.
SECTION 23. Effectivity
This Act shall take effect fifteen (15) days after its publication in the Official Gazette or in
a newspaper of general circulation.
SECTION 24. Repealing Clause
9
All laws, decrees, orders, rules, and regulations, or parts thereof, inconsistent with this
Act are hereby repealed or modified accordingly.
SECTION 25. Separability Clause
If any provision of this Act is declared invalid or unconstitutional, the remaining
provisions shall remain in full force and effect.
Scope:
These guidelines shall cover VASPs, as defined in this Section, that offer their services
or engage in VASP activities in the Philippines. These guidelines do not cover
10
businesses involved in the participation and provision of financial services related to an
issuer's offer and/or sale of a VA, which fall within the jurisdiction of Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC), and entities solely acting on their own behalf (i.e., not
engaged in the business of actively facilitating VA-related activities for the account of
others).
The guidelines outlined in this Section are based on leading standards such as the
Financial Action Task Force (FATF) Recommendations on anti-money laundering and
counter-terrorist financing standards, as well as other recognized risk management
principles, and shall serve as the Bangko Sentral's baseline requirement for all VASPs.
Definitions:
a. Virtual Asset (VA):
• Definition: Refers to any type of digital unit that can be digitally traded or
transferred, used for payment or investment purposes.
• Characteristics: It can be considered as "property", "proceeds", "funds", "funds
or other assets", or "corresponding value".
• Medium of Exchange: Used as a medium of exchange or a digitally stored
value within the community of VA users.
• Scope: Includes digital units of exchange:
• (i) with a centralized repository or administrator,
• (ii) decentralized with no centralized repository or administrator,
• (iii) created or obtained through computing or manufacturing effort.
• Legal Status: VAs are not issued nor guaranteed by any jurisdiction and do not
have legal tender status.
• Exclusions: Digital units used for:
• (i) payment of goods and services solely provided by the issuer or limited
set of merchants (e.g., gift checks),
• (ii) payment of virtual goods and services within an online game (e.g.,
gaming tokens), are not considered VAs.
• Previous Terminology: Virtual currencies, as previously defined in Bangko
Sentral Circular No. 944, are now referred to as VAs.
b. Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP):
11
• Definition: Any entity offering services or engaging in activities facilitating the
transfer or exchange of VAs.
• Activities Involved:
• (1) Exchange between VAs,
• (2) Exchange between one or more forms of VAs,
• (3) Transfer of VAs, and
• (4) Safekeeping and/or administration of VAs or control over VAs.
• Previous Terminology: Virtual Currency Exchanges, previously defined in
Bangko Sentral Circular No. 944, are now referred to as VASPs.
c. VA Custodian:
• Definition: A VASP performing the act of safekeeping and/or administration of
VAs, as described in point (4) above.
d. Fiat Currency:
• Definition: Government-issued currency designated as legal tender in its country
of issuance through government decree, regulation, or law.
e. Money Service Business (MSB):
• Definition: Financial services involving the acceptance of cash, checks, other
monetary instruments, or other stores of value, and the payment of a
corresponding sum to a beneficiary through a communication, message, transfer,
or clearings network to which the service provider belongs.
12
• Application for Registration
• Notarized Deeds of Undertaking (Appendices N-8 and N-9)
5. Compliance with Bangko Sentral Rules and Regulations:
• Outsourcing (Section 702-N)
• Liquidity Risk Management (Section 724-N)
• Operational Risk Management (Section 725-N)
• IT Risk Management including the area of IT Outsourcing/Vendor
Management Program (Section 726-N)
• Business Continuity Management (Section 727-N)
• Internal Control (Section 737-N)
• Anti-Money Laundering (Sections 607-N and 502-N)
• Financial Consumer Protection (Sections 707-N, 702-N, and 703-N)
• Sound corporate governance principles, among others.
13
Wallet Security for VASPs:
Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs) offering wallet services for holding and storing
Virtual Assets (VAs) are required to establish a robust cybersecurity framework. This
framework should include appropriate security measures and controls within their VA
platform. The goal is to ensure:
1. Confidentiality: Protection of sensitive data and information uploaded, stored,
processed, and transmitted within the system. This includes user information and
transaction details.
2. Integrity: Ensuring that data and information remain accurate, complete, and
unaltered throughout their lifecycle within the VA platform.
3. Availability: The system should be available and accessible to users when
needed, without unauthorized disruptions or downtime.
14
• Regular security audits and assessments are necessary to ensure the
effectiveness of the cybersecurity framework.
• Compliance with industry standards and best practices in cybersecurity, as well
as adherence to regulatory requirements, is essential.
Technology Outsourcing:
• Risk Management: VASPs must implement a robust risk management system to
mitigate risks associated with outsourcing. This includes ensuring confidentiality,
data privacy, data management, contract management, security, and
performance monitoring.
• Responsibility: VASPs are responsible for the performance of outsourced
services as if they were directly performing the activity themselves.
Internal Control:
• System Requirement: VASPs must maintain an internal control system
appropriate to the size and complexity of their operations.
• Critical Functions: Key functions such as risk management, audit, compliance,
anti-money laundering, and information security must be performed by
competent officers.
• Corporate Governance: The board of directors and management must undergo
suitability assessments according to sound corporate governance procedures.
15
Risk Disclosure:
• Material Risks: VASPs must disclose all material risks associated with acquiring,
possessing, and trading VAs. This includes risks related to custody of VAs and
whether customers have full control over safeguarding their assets.
• Clarity: Disclosures should be clear, fair, and not misleading, ensuring
customers have a comprehensive understanding of associated risks.
Additional Requirements:
• Engagement with Others: VASPs can only engage with duly authorized VASPs,
financial institutions, remittance companies, and transfer companies.
• Accreditation: VASPs must have a robust due diligence and accreditation
process for listing or trading VAs on their platform.
• Fraud Risk Management: Adopt a fraud risk management system
commensurate with the risks associated with specific VA types or activities.
16
• Liquidity Requirement: VASPs with fiat wallets for conversions must maintain
sufficient liquid assets to meet VA redemptions promptly.
• VA Custodians: Those responsible for customer VA custody must have
measures to ensure adequate reserves and proper recording and segregation of
customers' VAs.
17
• Account number of the beneficiary (e.g., VA wallet if used for the
transaction).
This information must be transmitted immediately and securely. VASPs must maintain
the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of this data for recordkeeping and use by
receiving VASPs or other covered entities, preventing unauthorized disclosure.
Entities should submit this required information simultaneously or concurrently with the
transfer itself.
18
3. List of Operating Offices and Websites:
• Frequency: Quarterly
• Due Date: Ten (10) business days from the end of the reference quarter.
• Certification: Duty certified by the Proprietor/Managing Partner/President
or any officer of equivalent rank.
Record Maintenance
A VASP must ensure that transaction and due diligence records are maintained for a
minimum period of five (5) years. Additionally, the VASP must adhere to other
guidelines issued by the Bangko Sentral regarding the maintenance of records.
Sanctions
In case of violations, appropriate monetary penalties, sanctions, and other enforcement
actions specified under Section 901-N will be imposed on the VASP, its directors,
and/or officers. These sanctions are designed to enforce compliance and ensure
accountability within the framework of the guidelines.
19
Appendix Existing Phrase New Phrase
20
currency. These guidelines are outlined in Circular No. 944 (Guidelines for Virtual
Currency Exchanges).
• Virtual currency exchanges must register with the BSP and comply with anti-
money laundering (AML) and counter-terrorism financing (CTF) regulations.
Mining Specifics
• Mining, the process by which new Bitcoins are created and transactions are
verified on the blockchain, is not specifically addressed in Philippine law.
• There are no explicit regulations or laws that prohibit or regulate Bitcoin mining in
the Philippines as of the last update.
Electricity Costs
• One consideration for Bitcoin miners is the cost of electricity, which can vary in
different regions of the Philippines.
• Miners need to assess the profitability of mining based on electricity costs,
mining equipment expenses, and the current price of Bitcoin.
Taxation
• Income generated from Bitcoin mining is subject to taxation in the Philippines. It
falls under the category of "other income" in the tax code.
• The Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) has issued guidelines on the taxation of
cryptocurrencies, including mining income. This includes the requirement to
register as a taxpayer and declare mining income for tax purposes.
Risk and Volatility
• Bitcoin mining, like any investment or business venture, carries risks. These
include the volatility of cryptocurrency prices, changes in mining difficulty, and
hardware and maintenance costs.
Seeking Legal Advice
• Individuals or companies interested in Bitcoin mining in the Philippines should
consider seeking legal advice from experts familiar with cryptocurrency
regulations in the country.
• It's essential to stay updated with any changes in regulations or guidelines issued
by the BSP or other relevant authorities.
21