A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare
A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare
net/publication/318986903
Article in Sukkur IBA Journal of Computing and Mathematical Sciences · June 2017
DOI: 10.30537/sjcms.v1i1.9
CITATION READS
1 1,312
5 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ahmad Waqas on 08 August 2017.
Adnan Nadeem
Department of Computer Science and IT, Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science
and Technology, Pakistan & Faculty of Computer Science and Information System,
Islamic University of Madinah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
[email protected]
Kashif Rizwan
Department of Computer Science and IT, Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science
and Technology, Pakistan & Department of Computer Science, University of Karachi,
Pakistan
[email protected]
Nadeem Mahmood
Department of Computer Science, University of Karachi, Pakistan
[email protected]
Ahmad Waqas
Department of Computer Science, Sukkur IBA, Sindh, Pakistan
[email protected]
Abstract:
In today’s world the rapid advancements in Micro-Electromechanical Systems
(MEMS) and Nano technology have improved almost all the aspects of daily life routine with
the help of different smart devices such as smart phones, compact electronic devices etc. The
prime example of these emerging developments is the development of wireless sensors for
healthcare procedures. One kind of these sensors is wearable bio-sensors. In this paper, the
technologies of two types of bio-sensors (ECG, EMG) are investigated and also compared with
traditional ECG, EMG equipment. We have taken SHIMMERTM wireless sensor platform as
an example of wearable biosensors technology. We have investigated the systems developed for
SJCMS | P-ISSN: 2520-0755 | Vol. 1 | No. 1 | © 2017 Sukkur IBA 67
A. Mehmood et al. A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare (pp.67 - 77)
analysis techniques with SHIMMERTM ECG and EMG wearable bio-sensors and these bio-
sensors are used in continuous remote monitoring. For example, applications in continuous
health monitoring of elderly people, critical chronic patients and Fitness & Fatigue observations.
Nevertheless, early fall detection in older adults and weak patients, treatment efficacy
assessment. This study not only provides the basic concepts of wearable wireless bio-sensors
networks (WBSN), but also provides basic knowledge of different sensor platforms available
for patient’s remote monitoring. Also various healthcare applications by using bio-sensors are
discussed and in last comparison with traditional ECG and EMG is presented.
Keywords: Wireless Bio-sensors platforms, ECG, EMG, WBSN & its Applications,
SHIMMERTM
1. Introduction
Technological advancements in wearable electrocardiography (ECG),
microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) electromyography (EMG),
and very large scale integration (VLSI) electroencephalogram (EEG), blood pressure
elevate the field of sensors into more (BP), Saturation of Peripheral Oxygen
prominent field for research. Therefore the (SPO2), temperature monitoring sensors, these
field of wireless sensors is attracting more and are the example of physiological sensors or
more attention from researchers because of its bio-sensors. There are some other types of
wide range of applications. It has applications sensors also used in WBSN, which are inertial
in battlefield, sports, agriculture, fitness, based sensors such as accelerometer, gyro
structural monitoring, traffic control, meter, magnetometer etc.
underground mining and healthcare. Actually
sensors are devices which not only gather the
information about the physical property of an
object but also gather the changes that occur
in the state of that object. These wireless
sensors play a key role in healthcare. The
sensors used in healthcare have wide range of
applications like, remote patient monitoring,
rehabilitation process, ambient assistive living
and for biofeedback. Most of the sensors used
in healthcare are either implanted inside or
placed on the human body. The network of
these sensors is called Wireless Body area
Sensor Network (WBSN). The WBSN
comprises of the sensor nodes (wearable or
implanted inside the human body), the sink Figure. 1: ECG Electrode Placement Positions [1]
node (also called coordinator) refers to a
mobile phone or PDA (Personal Digital Here in this study, the basic introduction of
Assistant) or relay node and the base station. two bio-sensors (ECG, EMG) is presented.
The examples of sensors used in The main reason behind the selection of ECG
WBSN are, implanted cardioverter and EMG is the applications of these two
defibrillators (ICDs), swallowed camera pills, devices in healthcare. The idea behind this
study is to investigate different ECG and
SJCMS | P-ISSN: 2520-0755 | Vol. 1 | No. 1 | © 2017 Sukkur IBA 68
A. Mehmood et al. A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare (pp.67 - 77)
EMG wireless platforms and how it will affect ECG, the term lead refers to the signal of the
the field of healthcare. ECG and EMG are voltage difference between two electrodes.
used to identify the causes behind chronicle Figure 3 is also shown the limb leads
diseases such as heart attacks, muscle positions. For ECG in bipolar limb lead
dysfunction etc. configuration, electrodes are normally placed
Electrocardiography (ECG) is the on arms or legs as according to their place
process of capturing the tiny electrical activity mentioned in their names but these electrodes
of a heart detected through electrodes for a can also be placed as shown in Figure 1. V1,
defined time period. These electrodes are V2, V3, V4, V5 and V6 are the unipolar leads
placed on the surface of body. ECG is used to used for Wilson’s Central Terminal (WCT)
detect the disruption in pattern of electrical voltage measurement.
activity.
A graph comprises of the peak (refers
to voltage) versus time is called
electrocardiogram. An example of the ECG
pulse graph is shown in Figure 2. In each ECG
graph all the pulses, duration of these pulses
and time interval can be predicted denoted by
P, Q, R, S, T and U as depicting in Figure 2.
The P wave is the atrial depolarization with
time period of 80ms to 100ms; QRS complex
is the depolarization of both right and left
ventricles with time period of 80ms to 120ms
(atria repolarization simultaneously), while T
and U waves are ventricular repolarization.
The positions of the placement of ECG
electrode is shown in figure 1, where LA (Left
Arm), LL (Left Leg), RA (Right Arm) and RL
(Right Leg) refer to the bipolar limb leads. In
2. Background
There have been several sensor
platforms proposed and some are discussed
here but before the discussion about sensor
platforms, one should know about the issues
and challenges associated with the designing
and developments of the sensor platforms.
forwarding. A biosensor node should have the sensor node platform, authors used three
ability to forward the sensed data to different types of transceivers which are,
coordinator. European 868 MHz band (radio module
4) Multi-Hop: In some critical CC1101), the 2.4 GHz band (radio module
scenarios when patients are not allowed to CC2500). The last one contained ZigBee 2.4
carry their PDA or mobile phones, then the GHz (radio module CC2520). These sensor
wireless sensor attached to patients should be nodes have two 16 Mbit large flash module
able to communicate in multi-hop manner. It and a SD card slot with the support of 2 GB
means the sensor node not only sense and send SD card. In this proposed platform authors
its own data but also send the data of a node considered the monitoring of firefighting
which is connected only to it or that node is scenario. Different types of bio-sensors,
selected for forwarding the data. In some cases inertial sensors, and pressure and temperature
the relay node is used for forwarding the sensors are placed on each fire fighter
sensor node’s data. according to their work responsibility. The
5) Latency: As discussed types of parameter chosen for prototyping are
earlier these wireless biosensors are used for heart rate, blood oxygen saturation,
remote monitoring. Therefore some sensors temperature in the fire fighter jacket, air
like ECG, EMG, and BP are most important in temperature, air humidity, methane
the process of treatment. The data acquired concentration, carbon monoxide
from these types of sensors is so critical and concentration, air cylinder pressure, orange
needs continuous monitoring. Therefore smoke above, temperature above etc. authors
latency in data should not be tolerated. One claims the prototype is working fine and ready
has to keep in mind this while designing a for use in such other applications.
sensor platform. Chen et al. [9] proposed a low-cost,
There are some other considerations tiny, lightweight (wearable), ultra-low-power
regarding the designing of a wireless sensor (long lasting), flexible (for research purpose)
node to develop a WBSN that one needs to sensor platform for Wireless Body Area
keep in mind before designing such platforms. Sensor Network (WBSN). In this architecture,
Some of these considerations are Quality of authors used microcontroller (MSP430F1611)
Services QoS, reliability and self- for processing and ChipCon CC2420 radio for
organization. A class based QoS Model [5] communication. They developed an
which prioritized the data according to sensor electrocardiography (ECG) prototype for
types, Reliable Proactive Routing Protocol [6] initial assessment, and the signal acquired
which ensures the reliability of data sending from ECG prototype is transmitted to a PC
and receiving, and the study [7], in which through a Telos mote, so real time ECG signal
authors present the provisioning of the will be displayed on PC.
introduction of self-organization in WBSN. Yamaguchi et al. [10] proposed a low
power field programming gate array (FPGA)
2.2. Wireless Bio-Sensor Platforms: based sensor node working on 950 MHz
There are several wireless biosensors frequency. In this microcontroller (MSP430)
platforms proposed in past 10 to 15 years. and FPGA based architecture, authors
Piotrowski et. al [8] proposed a introduce sensors like, temperature sensor,
microcontroller (MSP430F5438A) based infrared sensor, sound sensor, light sensor and
ultra-low power wireless sensor node platform 3D acceleration based sensor. The main theme
called IHPNode platform. In this proposed of using FPGA is co-processing of the
SJCMS | P-ISSN: 2520-0755 | Vol. 1 | No. 1 | © 2017 Sukkur IBA 71
A. Mehmood et al. A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare (pp.67 - 77)
ambient sensors such as humidity and There are some other works have
temperature sensors, light sensor, barometric been done so far using Shimmer physiological
pressure sensors and 2D-accelerometer. The sensors. For example an ECG based real time
ECG experiment is done through placement of allergy detection [19], an EMG based
four ECG leads on left arm (LA), left leg (LL), analytical study on BB (bicep brachii) muscles
right arm (RA) and right leg (RL) with the rate [20], a real time joint angle measurement
of sampling frequency set to 512 Hz. Authors using EMG [21], an ECG based patient
used a peak detection algorithm to detect QRS monitoring system [22], athlete ECG
complex and identify the R peaks correctly monitoring system [23] and activity aware
with threshold mechanism and finding local ECG based patient authentication for remote
maxima in time series, they find out the heart health monitoring [2]. Adnan et. Al [24]
rate of the patient using through identifying highlighted different area in which WBSN can
the correct R peak and sampling rate. help and also proposed new application areas
In[18] authors present a wearable for WBSN also presented a brief comparison
Shimmer biosensors (ECG and surface EMG) of different sensor applications.
with an Android smartphone based solution
for continuous monitoring of patients in daily 3. Comparative Analysis
life. The activity they selected in this study is In this section a comparison between
biking. In this study, standard limb lead II of traditional EMG and ECG with wearable
Einthoven’s triangle as shown in figure 3 is wireless biosensor is presented. In some cases
selected for ECG data. The electrodes for RA the wearable biosensor outperformed their
and LL are positioned as given in figure 1. A counterparts as shown in table 1.
QRS detection algorithm is used which has
different digital signal processing steps 3.1. Advantages
processed on raw data of 10 seconds. The first There are some advantages of
step is band pass filter (comprises of the wearable wireless biosensors discussed here.
cascading of low pass and high pass filter) for 1) Flexibility: Compared with
attenuation of noise, following by 5 steps traditional ECG and EMG machines, the
differentiation, then squaring method and in wireless biosensor are lightweight and easily
last moving window integration. With this wearable. A battery is used for power and in
method author’s claim 94.76% heart beat most sensors platforms it can be recharged,
detection rate for 60 seconds (or 6 samples). while traditional ECG, EMG machines require
In this study EMG is used for treadle electrical sockets where these machines can be
detection. The EMG electrodes are placed on plugged-in.
the Vastus lateralis and the Vastus medialis 2) Size: Normally a wearable wireless
muscles as shown in figure 3. Authors claims biosensor is small in size while traditional
that the placement of EMG electrodes on these ECG and EMG are hand handled machines,
muscles produced satisfactory results. The require some space where they can be placed
raw data is processed firstly with squaring for on especially designed tables or frames.
computing the energy of the signals and then 3) Mobility: The wireless biosensors
moving window process is used for treadle are lightweight and tiny devices, therefore
detection. In total of 60 seconds (6 samples these can be worn by a patient or person and
with each of the samples comprises of 10 patient or person can move with ease, while
seconds), authors claim 91.25% detection rate traditional machines are hand-handled, and
for treadles. therefore these are quite difficult to move
SJCMS | P-ISSN: 2520-0755 | Vol. 1 | No. 1 | © 2017 Sukkur IBA 74
A. Mehmood et al. A Study of Wearable Bio-Sensor Technologies and Applications in Healthcare (pp.67 - 77)
from one place to another while connected identifies it and suggest the patient to take
with patients. some proactive measures through notification
4) Availability: A person or patient can (text message or alarm). This facility can be
wear these biosensors at any time and any used in remote monitoring where a message
place without any difficulty, while traditional sent to care giver or doctor through smart
devices are fixed at one place while connected phone to take some necessary actions.
to patients.
A. Limitations
5) Freedom of natural behavior: If a
person wants to acquire ECG or EMG through There are some limitation of using these bio-
traditional devices, which means he/she sensors.
should perform some simulated activities. It 1) Accuracy: Accuracy is one of the
means that person should be ready for unease biggest factor, sometimes false alarm could be
environment where he/she cannot feel or generated. Although some sensor platforms
implementation of Wireless Biomedical Sensor of right arm biceps brachii muscle activity with
Networks for ECG home health monitoring. varying the electrode placement on three male age
In Electronic Design, 2008. ICED 2008. groups during isometric contractions using a
International Conference on (pp. 1-4). IEEE. wireless EMG sensor. Procedia Engineering, 41,
61-67.
[12] Scholl, P. M., Van Laerhoven, K., Gordon,
D., Scholz, M., & Berning, M. (2012, June). Jnode: [21] O'Donovan, K., & Ayer, S. (2011,
a sensor network platform that supports distributed November). Real-time joint angle measurement
inertial kinematic monitoring. In Networked using the shimmer wireless sensor platform.
Sensing Systems (INSS), 2012 Ninth International In Proceedings of the First ACM Workshop on
Conference on (pp. 1-4). IEEE. Mobile Systems, Applications, and Services for
Healthcare (p. 7). ACM.
[13] https://glneurotech.com/bioradio/wireless-
physiological-monitor/ [22] Chen, B., Varkey, J. P., Pompili, D., Li, J.
K., & Marsic, I. (2010, March). Patient vital signs
[14] https://www.getqardio.com/qardiocore- monitoring using wireless body area networks.
wearable-ecg-ekg-monitor-iphone/ In Bioengineering Conference, Proceedings of the
2010 IEEE 36th Annual Northeast (pp. 1-2).
[15] http://www.btsbioengineering.com/produc
ts/surface-emg/bts-freeemg/ [23] Imaiyan.C.R., Ragavi.S.R, and Dr.
Suganthi ,L. (2015, January) “Athlete’s ECG
[16] Rajan, D., Spanias, A., Ranganath, S., Monitoring System using Wireless Sensor
Banavar, M. K., & Spanias, P. (2013, October). Networks”, International Journal on Applications
Health monitoring laboratories by interfacing in Medical Science and Research Volume 1: Issue
physiological sensors to mobile android devices. 1:, pp 1-3.
In 2013 IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference
(FIE) (pp. 1049-1055). IEEE. [24] Nadeem, A., Hussain, M. A., Owais, O.,
Salam, A., Iqbal, S., & Ahsan, K. (2015).
[17] Maciuca, A., Stamatescu, G., Popescu, D., Application specific study, analysis and
& Struţu, M. (2013, August). Integrating wireless classification of body area wireless sensor network
body and ambient sensors into a hybrid femtocell applications. Computer Networks, 83, 363-380.
network for home monitoring. In Systems and
Computer Science (ICSCS), 2013 2nd International
Conference on (pp. 32-37). IEEE.