Molluscicidal and Ovicidal Activities of Plant Extracts 2011
Molluscicidal and Ovicidal Activities of Plant Extracts 2011
Molluscicidal and Ovicidal Activities of Plant Extracts 2011
2011
Downloaded from: Biblioteca Digital da Produção Intelectual - BDPI, Universidade de São Paulo
Journal of Helminthology (2011) 85, 66–72 doi:10.1017/S0022149X10000258
q Cambridge University Press 2010
Abstract
Introduction that 200 million people are infected and 600 million people
are at risk of infection (WHO, 1993; Chitsulo et al., 2000).
Schistosomiasis remains one of the most prevalent Three main schistosome species infect humans:
parasitic infections in the world and has significant Schistosoma mansoni, present mainly in Africa and South
economic and public health consequences. It is estimated America; S. haematobium, found in Africa and the Middle
East; and S. japonicum, which is endemic in Asia.
Freshwater snails of the genus Biomphalaria play a major
*E-mail: [email protected] role as intermediate hosts in the transmission of
Piperaceae effect on Biomphalaria glabrata 67
S. mansoni. An intense multiplication of parasites occurs from P. aduncum (Orjala et al., 1993a, b) and extracts from
in these snails, making strategies to control snail P. cubeba (Pandey & Singh, 2009).
populations a high priority for reduction of schistoso- In spite of the variety of secondary compounds
miasis transmission in endemic regions (WHO, 1984; described, no systematic evaluation of molluscicidal
Rey, 2008). activity of Piperaceae extracts has been carried out.
At present, niclosamide (Bayluscidew, Bayer, Leverku- Thus, in this work, several crude extracts were assessed
sen, Germany) is the only commercially available regarding molluscicidal and ovicidal properties.
molluscicide recommended by the World Health
Organization (WHO) for large-scale use in schistosomia-
sis control programmes (WHO, 1993). Niclosamide is not Materials and methods
toxic to humans, domestic animals or crops, although it is Molluscicidal and ovicidal assays were performed
costly and ictiotoxic (WHO, 1973; McCullough & Mott, according to the methodology recommended by World
1983). Moreover, it is rapidly decomposed by sunlight Health Organization (WHO, 1965, 1983) and experimen-
and its application does not prevent recolonization of tal procedures were employed according to accepted
sites by surviving snails, which could lead to selection of principles of animal welfare in experimental science.
molluscicide-resistant populations. Thus, novel natural Adults and egg masses were obtained from the
molluscicidal compounds from plants should be inves- population of Biomphalaria glabrata (Say, 1818) originally
tigated as possible alternatives to synthetic products from Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil and reared under
(Luna et al., 2005). laboratory conditions for several years, fed with fresh
Members of the Piperaceae family are among a wide lettuce ad libitum and a balanced ration.
variety of species under study. The family comprises 14
genera and 1950 species (Mabberley, 1997); Piper and
Peperomia are the most abundant genera, with approxi- Plant material
mately 700 and 600 species, respectively ( Joly, 1993).
Plants from the genus Piper are widely distributed Fresh material of each species (table 1) was collected by
throughout tropical and subtropical regions. Brazil has Dr Massuo Jorge Kato and identified by Dr Elsie
several species and promising studies on biological F. Guimarães from Instituto de Pesquisas Jardim Botânico
properties of plants of the Piperaceae family have been do Rio de Janeiro and vouchers were deposited in the
published (Navickiene et al., 2000; Danelutte et al., 2003, Herbarium of Jardim Botânico do Rio de Janeiro.
2005; Cysne et al., 2005; Yamaguchi et al., 2006).
Phytochemical investigations on Piper species have
Preparation of plant extracts
revealed many bioactive compounds such as amides,
alkaloids, lignans, benzoic acids and chromenes (Parmar Selected parts (table 1) of freshly collected plant
et al., 1997; Alécio et al., 1998; Navickiene et al., 2000; Silva material were separated, immediately air dried and
et al., 2002). Chromenes and benzoic acid derivatives are finally dried in an oven at 458C. Material was ground and
frequently isolated from Piper species showing antimi- powdered materials were extracted with dichlorometha-
crobial, antitumoral, germination inhibition, fungicidal ne:methanol (2:1) at room temperature (25– 278C) three
(Nair & Burke, 1990), insecticidal (Miranda et al., 2002) times and filtered. Extracts were evaporated to dryness
and anti-leishmania activities (Torres-Santos et al., 1999). under vacuum in a rotoevaporator and stored at 2 208C.
In the case of molluscicidal activity, only a few reports A stock solution containing 1000 ppm of each extract
have addressed Piper species, including essential oil from was prepared by suspending 10 mg of extract in 0.1 ml
P. marginatum (Rouquayrol et al., 1980) and P. tuberculatum of 99.9% dimethylsulphoxide (DMSO; Aldrich,
(Sousa & Rouquayrol, 1974), chromenes and benzoic acid Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA) and making up to 10 ml
Selected part for all species, leaves; * stem, leaves and roots.
S, São Paulo; RJ, Rio de Janeiro, AM, Amazonas.
68 L.N. Rapado et al.
with dechlorinated water. Stock solutions were diluted containing 1% DMSO under the same experimental
with dechlorinated water in order to provide assay conditions.
solutions.
Data analysis
Assays for molluscicidal/ovicidal activities of plant extracts LC90 was obtained from the logistic regression
Molluscicidal activities of extracts against adults of adjustment using a log-dose transformation. This corre-
B. glabrata were determined according to previously sponds to a maximum likelihood estimated for the
described procedures (WHO, 1965, 1983). Snails with logodds in a multinomial probability model.
10 – 18 mm shell diameter were exposed to test com-
pounds for 24 h. After exposure, snails were washed and
Results
observed daily for 10 days to record the death rate.
A negative control group was maintained in dechlori- All extracts were 100% lethal to B. glabrata at 500 ppm
nated tap water containing 1% DMSO under the same but at 100 ppm, only leaf extracts of P. aduncum,
experimental conditions. Bayluscide WP70w was used as P. crassinervium, P. cuyabanum, P. diospyrifolium and
a positive control. Extracts were tested first at concen- P. hostmannianum showed 100% lethality during 24 h
trations of 500 and 100 ppm and those inactive were not of exposure, so the LC90 (table 2, figs 1 – 3) and
investigated further. LC90 was determined for all selected ovicidal activity (table 3 and fig. 4) of these extracts
extracts with ten animals per dose group, and exper- were determined. Leaf extracts of Pep. macrostachya,
iments were repeated three times. P. hoffmanseggianum, P. macedoi and P. solmsianum did not
Based on values of LC90 for adults, egg masses with show molluscicidal activity at 100 ppm; but mortality
embryos at blastula stage (Camey & Verdonk, 1970) were obtained with extracts of P. corcovadensis (stem, leaf and
exposed to lethal concentrations of extracts for 24 h. At the root), P. amplum (leaf), P. callosum (leaf) and P. tuberculatum
end of exposure, egg masses were washed and observed (stem) reached a maximum of 90% at 100 ppm (table 2).
for mortality daily for 7 days. Assays were repeated three The percentage of dead snails in the control group over
times with about 100 embryos for each concentration. 10 days of observation was 3.3% while dead embryos in
A control group was maintained in dechlorinated water control groups over 7 days were 1.6%.
(a) 30 (a) 30
Number of dead snails
18 18
12
12
6
6
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 0
Concentration (ppm) 0 5 10 15 20
Concentration (ppm)
(b) 30 (b) 30
Number of dead snails
12 12
6 6
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 6 12 18 24 30
Concentration (ppm) Concentration (ppm)
Fig. 1. Estimated mortality of B. glabrata exposed to (a) P. aduncum Fig. 2. Estimated mortality of B. glabrata exposed to (a) P.
leaf extract; (b) P. crassinervium leaf extract; logistic tendency cuyabanum leaf extract; (b) P. diospyrifolium leaf extract; logistic
function. tendency function.
Table 3. Effect of leaf extracts from P. aduncum, P. cuyabanum, P. crassinervium, P. diospyrifolium and P. hostmannianum on
B. glabrata embryos.
Plant species Stage Concentration (ppm) Number of embryos Dead embryos (%)
cell proliferation activity at early stages; previous In a comprehensive screening, the highest proportions
studies also showed a differential sensitivity accor- of molluscicidal species were detected in Euphorbiaceae,
ding to developmental stages (Kawano et al., 1979; Asteraceae, Leguminosae, Phytolaccaceae, Polygonaceae,
Kawano & Simões, 1987; Kawano et al., 1991; Yamamoto Rubiaceae and Rutaceae species (WHO, 1983; Kloos
et al., 1996). & McCullough, 1987). Jurberg et al. (1989) describe
Piper aduncum was more active in adults than active extracts from two species of Euphorbiaceae. In our
in embryos. A similar profile was observed with study, five out of 13 Piperaceae species fulfilled the
crude extracts and steroidal glycoalkaloid fraction of practical criterion for activity against B. glabrata. Based
Lycopersicon esculentum, which showed high activity in on results obtained with Piper extracts, further studies
adults and low effect in embryos (Leyton et al., 2005). with P. aduncum, P. crassinervium, P. cuyabanum,
Similar results were obtained in B. glabrata, B. alexandrina P. diospyrifolium and P. hostmannianum should be carried
and Bulinus truncatus in a study of the molluscicidal out, looking at the isolation of bioactive compounds.
effect of Phytolacca dodecandra (Lemma et al., 1972). At present, molluscicidal activity of P. aduncum and
Pereira et al. (1978) evaluated a leaf extract of Euphorbia P. diospyrifolium fractions are being assessed. Concomi-
cotinifolia and observed an effect in B. glabrata embryos tantly, we are perfoming bioassays with Daphnia similis
with 48 ppm, a concentration about 20 times higher and Ceridaphnia dubia to evaluate acute and chronic
than the 2.4 ppm observed to have an effect on adult toxicity of bioactive compounds isolated from the
specimens. selected Piper extracts. Cladoceran species have been
Piper diospyrifolium did not show molluscicidal activity used extensively; they have several advantages, such as
in embryos at concentrations evaluated in adults. On the high sensitivity and short reproductive cycles (Farre &
other hand, P. amplum was highly effective in embryos Barcelo, 2003). Inclusion of safety testing will ascertain
(LC90 of 8.8 ppm) despite its low activiy in adults whether toxic effects on non-target organisms are at
(Teixeira, 2004). acceptable levels.
Piperaceae effect on Biomphalaria glabrata 71
and molluscicidal activity from Piper aduncum leaves. Teixeira, E. (2004) Estudo do efeito moluscicida de
Planta Medica 59, 546– 551. extratos de Piperaceae em Biomphalaria glabrata
Pandey, J.K. & Singh, D. (2009) Molluscicidal activity (Say, 1818). Dissertação de mestrado. Coordenadoria
of Piper cubeba Linn., Piper longum Linn. and dos Institutos de Pesquisa da Secretaria de Estado da
Tribulus terrestris Linn. and their combinations against Saúde de São Paulo.
snail Indoplanorbis exustus Desh. Indian Journal of Torres-Santos, E.C., Moreira, D.L., Kaplan, M.A.C.,
Experimental Biology 47, 643– 648. Meirelles, M.N. & Rossi-Bergmann, B. (1999)
Parmar, V.S., Jain, S.C., Bisht, K.S., Jain, R., Taneja, P., Selective effect of 20 ,60 -dihydroxy-40 -methoxychalcone
Jha, A., Tyagi, O.D., Prasad, A.K., Wengel, J., isolated from Piper aduncum on Leishmania amazonensis.
Olsen, C.E. & Boll, P.M. (1997) Phytochemistry of Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 5, 1234– 1241.
the genus Piper. Phytochemistry 46, 597– 673. WHO (1965) Molluscicide screening and evaluation.
Pereira, J.P., Souza, C.P. & Mendes, N.M. (1978) Bulletin of the World Health Organization 33, 567– 581.
Propriedades moluscicidas da Euphorbia cotinifolia L. Geneva, WHO.
Revista Brasileira de Pesquisas Medicas e Biológicas 11, WHO (1973) Schistosomiasis control. pp. 1–47. Geneva, WHO.
345– 351. WHO (1983) Report of the scientific working group on plant
Rey, L. (2008) Parasitologia. 3rd edn. 930 pp. Rio de molluscicides, vol. 12, pp. 1 – 11. Geneva, WHO.
Janeiro, Guanabara Koogan S.A. WHO (1984) Report of informal consultation on research on
Rouquayrol, M.Z., Fonteles, M.C., Alencar, J.E., Matos, the biological control of snail intermediated hosts. pp. 1 – 41.
J.A. & Craveiro, A.A. (1980) Molluscicidal activity of Geneva, WHO.
essential oils from Northeastern Brazilian plants. WHO (1993) The control of Schistosomiasis: second report of
Revista Brasileira de Pesquisas Medicas e Biológicas 13, the WHO Expert Committee. 86 pp. Geneva, WHO.
135– 143. Yamaguchi, L.F., Lago, H.J.G., Tanizaki, T.M., Masuo, P.
Silva, R.V., Navickiene, H.M.D., Kato, M.J., Bolzani, & Kato, M.J. (2006) Antioxidant activity of prenylated
V.S., Meda, C.I., Young, M.C. & Furlan, M. (2002) hydroquinone and benzoic derivates from Piper
Antifungal amides from Piper arboreum and Piper crassinervium Kunt. Phytochemistry 67, 1838– 1843.
tuberculatum. Phytochemistry 59, 521– 527. Yamamoto, M.M., Kawano, T., Young, M.C.M.,
Sousa, M.P. & Rouquayrol, M.Z. (1974) Atividade Haraguchi, M. & Hiroki, K. (1996) Molluscicidal
moluscicida de plantas do Nordeste brasileiro. Revista activity of three Brazilian plant species. Fitoterapia 57,
Brasileira de Pesquisas Medicas e Biológicas 7, 388– 393. 59 – 62.