Tips - Bear Proof Investing
Tips - Bear Proof Investing
Tips - Bear Proof Investing
Investing
Protecting Your Financial Future in
a Bear Market and Taking Advantage
of an Emerging Bull Market
Kenneth E. Little
All rights reserved. No part of this book shall be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or trans-
mitted by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without writ-
ten permission from the publisher. No patent liability is assumed with respect to the use of the
information contained herein. Although every precaution has been taken in the preparation of this
book, the publisher and author assume no responsibility for errors or omissions. Neither is any lia-
bility assumed for damages resulting from the use of information contained herein. For informa-
tion, address Alpha Books, 201 West 103rd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46290.
04 03 02 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Interpretation of the printing code: The rightmost number of the first series of numbers is the year
of the book’s printing; the rightmost number of the second series of numbers is the number of the
book’s printing. For example, a printing code of 02-1 shows that the first printing occurred in
2002.
For marketing, promotion, or publicity, contact Dawn Van De Keere, marketing manager,
at 317-581-3722.
Trademarks
All terms mentioned in this book that are known to be or are suspected of being trademarks or
service marks have been appropriately capitalized. Alpha Books and Pearson Education cannot at-
test to the accuracy of this information. Use of a term in this book should not be regarded as affect-
ing the validity of any trademark or service mark.
CONTENTS
Part 1: Bear Signs 1
Chapter 1: Bear Markets 3
Defining a Bear Market 3
Market Corrections 4
The Psychology of Bears 4
The Receding Bear 5
Bear History 6
A Bear Lesson 7
Slaying Bear Myths 8
Bear-Proofing Your Portfolio 10
Risk and Investing 10
Looking for Bear Signs 11
Avoiding Traps 11
Bear Your Assets 12
Bear Tracks 12
Bear Den 13
Bearskin Rug 13
Conclusion 13
Chapter 2: Investing as a Contact Sport 15
Risk and Reward 16
A Matter of Perception 16
Age and Risk 17
Types of Risk 17
Market Risk 18
Economic Risk 20
Inflation Risk 21
Where to Hide 22
Inflation’s Evil Twin 22
Conclusion 23
Chapter 3: Types of Bear Markets 25
Bear Market Types 25
Political/Financial-Instability Bear Markets 26
Market-Liquidity Bear Markets 28
Recession Bear Markets 28
Inflation/Interest-Rate Bear Markets 29
Looking Backward 30
What Does This Mean to You? 31
iv BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Donate to Charity 93
For Some Fun 93
Conclusion 93
Conclusion 251
Appendixes
A Glossary 253
B Resources 263
Index 269
INTRODUCTION
“What happened?!”
“For years, it was hard not to make money in the stock market—
all of a sudden, everything is dropping like a lead balloon. Now what do
I do?”
That’s the question every typical investor is asking after watching
dot.coms vaporize, IPOs become DOA, high-tech stocks fizzle, and util-
ities and blue-chip leaders fall to embarrassing lows.
Over half of all American households have some sort of stake in the
stock market, whether through an employer-sponsored retirement plan,
employee stock options, or cash in a mutual fund or stock portfolio.
Investing, even in boom times, is never as easy as it may have
seemed in the past few years. A bear market makes investment decisions
even more complicated. The slide in stock market values began in the sec-
ond quarter of 2000 and soon became an avalanche. Investors watched re-
tirement dreams change as accounts reversed double-digit growth rates.
Younger investors couldn’t believe stocks actually went down instead of
always up.
The choices facing investors aren’t so clear-cut anymore:
■ Convert everything to cash?
■ Mutual funds?
■ Value stocks?
■ Real estate?
■ Bonds?
Add the voices of the daily business news, which sound like the end of the
world is near (“live update at 10”), and it’s no wonder investors are con-
fused.
BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
What this book offers you is a set of strategies to make rational decisions
about investments in an unstable or down market. These are tried-and-
true methods of protecting your portfolio from the worst in falling mar-
ket conditions.
Your goal in a bear market is to hold your own and position your-
self to take advantage of an emerging bull market. In Bear-Proof Investing,
you will learn …
■ The two most important words in investing.
■ The two most dangerous words in investing.
■ Economic and market indicators you should watch.
■ How to handle short-term financial goals.
■ Age-appropriate strategies for retirement planning.
■ Safe vehicles for short-term cash reserves.
■ How to decide what to hold and what to fold.
■ How to fatten your portfolio in a bear market.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank to Renee Wilmeth, Phil Kitchel, Christy Wagner,
and all the other folks at Alpha Books for their hard work in making this
book possible. In addition, thanks to my family for letting me shut the
door to my office for weeks on end so I could finish this book.
PA R T 1
BEAR SIGNS
It’s easy to spot a bear market, and any other market phenomena,
in the rearview mirror. In retrospect, it’s easy to see all the warning
signs and wonder why it wasn’t obvious at the time. Stock market
participants are great at pondering the “what if ” questions:
■ What if I had bought XYZ at $25 instead of $45?
BEAR MARKETS
At the most basic level, stock prices rise when there are more buy-
ers than sellers and fall when there are more sellers than buyers. So
what changes buyers to sellers? How can the history of bear markets
help us today and warn of future downturns?
Tip
There are always pundits, usually with a service to sell, who warn of dire
circumstances ahead. When the respected media, like The Wall Street
Journal and Morningstar.com, start sounding warnings, that’s when you
should listen.
MARKET CORRECTIONS
You have to understand the definition of a bear market in order to un-
derstand the underlying causes. Bear markets and “market corrections”
are not the same. Market corrections are declines of short duration, al-
though they can be severe.
The Standard & Poor’s 500 Index (S&P 500) lost some 10 percent
of its value in just a few days in October 1997. Investors in that month
had to decide if this was a market correction or the beginning of a bear
market. Investors who panicked and dumped stocks for “safer” havens
like bonds and cash instruments watched the market roar back, which put
them in the unenviable position of selling low, then buying high to get
back in the market. Investors who rode it out saw continued increases
until things began to unravel in the spring of 2000. Of course, they then
faced the same question again. This time it was a bear market.
It usually takes time and sustained good news for a bear market to reverse
itself. As we said, this is one difference between a bear market and a mar-
ket correction.
Plain English
A recession is a decline in the gross national product for two consecu-
tive quarters. The gross national product is the sum of all goods and
services produced in the United States during a single year and is ex-
pressed in dollars.
BEAR HISTORY
Bear markets are part of the history of the stock market. They occur often
enough for many observers to include them in an ongoing cycle of boom
and bust.
The biggest bear market occurred in the 1929 to 1931 market crash,
when the market lost almost 90 percent of its value. This devastating loss
of wealth and the accompanying depression shaped our history for
decades. It took the deficit spending of World War II to get the market
back on a sustained track. However, even that didn’t last long. The mid-
1950s saw the first modern bear market, the first of nine, not counting
the one that began in 2000.
Tip
Deficit spending spurred the economy by making the U.S. government
an active buyer of goods and services to support the war effort. Deficit
spending, however, can have the opposite effect when taxes are raised to
pay the increasing debt.
The sustained bull market of the 1990s convinced many of the 50 mil-
lion Americans who own stock that they were on a one-way ride to a com-
fortable retirement. The 10-year run also convinced many people who
had never invested in the stock market before to give it a try. Many were
totally unprepared for what happened.
The stock market, led by Internet and technology stocks, was highly
overpriced. When investors failed to see the profits they expected from
these rising stars, they panicked and began a sell-off that drove prices down
dramatically. Uncertainty spread to other parts of the market, and the bear
was loose.
Unfortunately, history has a way of repeating itself at the most awk-
ward times. If they had looked at the following chart of bear markets since
the 1950s, they might have been better prepared for what was coming.
This chart shows the nine bear markets leading up to the bull market of
the 1990s. Many investors might remember the beginnings of a devastat-
ing bear market of 1987 and Black Monday, when the market plunged
hundreds of points, as the worst in modern history. The chart clearly
shows, however, that it was only the third worst, and its recovery was
much quicker than previous bears.
BEAR MARKETS 7
Many observers called the bear market that began in 1973 a “super” bear,
in part because it occurred during a period of high inflation and because
of the lengthy recovery. Pity the poor soul who had planned to retire dur-
ing this period. After investing for many years, a long, painful bear mar-
ket takes almost one half of her portfolio’s value, and inflation takes a big
bite out of the remainder.
Losing one half of your retirement nest egg would be devastating.
Could it happen again? It most certainly could.
Caution
Don’t believe the popular notion that “things are different” now and
bear markets will not be long-lived or too severe. No one knows that for
sure.
A BEAR LESSON
The previous chart makes it all too clear that investing involves risk.
(We’ll look at this in more detail in Chapter 2, “Investing as a Contact
Sport.”) If you look at those nine modern bear markets beginning in 1956
and ending in 1990, you will notice that during this 34-year period, in-
vestors have struggled with bear markets about 25 percent of the time.
Contrast that with the 10-year uninterrupted run of the last bull market,
and it’s easy to see how investors became overconfident.
8 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Plain English
The S&P 500 Index represents 500 of the largest companies in Amer-
ica. It is the most widely used proxy for the whole stock market and is
the most widely used index in measuring performance of investments.
■ You can see it coming. You can’t. Bear markets are notorious for
disguising themselves. Market corrections, which we discussed ear-
lier, are great decoys for bear markets: You never know when a mar-
ket correction is going to escalate into a full bear market. In our
BEAR MARKETS 9
about to reverse course and head up. A bear trap occurs when a
stock drops sharply and panicked investors sell near the bottom,
only to watch the stock rebound. The broad market can execute
bear traps also. A straight-line drop in prices seldom marks a bear
market. Most often, prices will fall, then rebound to a level near
the original point, and repeat the pattern over and over. However,
the long-term trend is that the rebound never quite regains all the
lost ground.
Casinos use a version of the bear trap on their slot machines.
You put in three coins and pull the lever. A ringing sound means
you won. However, when you look in the tray, the machine has
only returned two coins. This incremental loss doesn’t seem as bad
as not getting anything back, so you’re encouraged to try again. In
the stock market, this type of incremental decline is a perfect dis-
guise for a bear market.
■ Bear markets can be averted. It’s preposterous to think we can
Caution
The U.S. markets can be affected by more events abroad than just po-
litical and military unrest. As globalization continues, we will be more
vulnerable to problems in foreign markets.
■ The Fed is responsible for the stock market. The Fed is not re-
sponsible for the stock market, although it watches the market
closely. Fed pronouncements about the economy and interest rates
are widely followed by investors. The Fed views its primary re-
sponsibility as controlling inflation. As we will learn in Chapter 3,
inflation is a primary cause of bear markets, but the Fed is more
concerned with the whole economy. Inflation is deadly to any
economy and benefits virtually no sector. The Fed of course knows
that raising interest rates could eventually hurt the stock market,
but inflation hurts everyone.
Tip
When you read about the overpriced “market,” understand that it
doesn’t apply to every stock. Even during the super-heated markets of
the late 1990s, there were stocks trading at very low valuations. Some
were sound companies that simply didn’t excite the investing commu-
nity like the dot.com wonders of the day.
When markets become overpriced, watch out. At least, that’s the conven-
tional wisdom. Market observers repeatedly sounded the warning during
the 1990s bull market, but if you had heeded the early warnings and re-
treated to safer investments, you would have missed most of the strongest
bull market in history. When the bubble finally burst, pundits were shak-
ing their heads with an “I told you so” attitude. Like the boy who cried
wolf too often in the fairy tale, eventually they were bound to be right.
In Chapters 3 through 5, we will look at different types of bear mar-
kets and some of the economic and market indicators that may help you
spot them coming.
AVOIDING TRAPS
Part 2, “Bear Traps,” deals with three difficult issues for investors:
■ Market timing, or trying to buy at the absolute low and sell at the
absolute peak
12 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Plain English
Your portfolio is simply your basket of investments. It can include
stocks, mutual funds, bonds, and cash instruments.
BEAR TRACKS
Part 4, “Bear Tracking,” takes a look at some strategies from two perspec-
tives: age and time horizon. Our poor soul at the beginning of this chap-
ter who lost one half of her retirement portfolio the year she planned to
BEAR MARKETS 13
retire would have benefited from reading these chapters. We will look at
short-term strategies in particular, since almost everyone has financial
goals that are less than 20 years down the road.
Are bear markets a time to pick up some bargains on decimated
stocks? This strategy walks very close to market timing; however, with the
proper research, you may find some roses among the thorns.
BEAR DEN
Investors nearing retirement are the most vulnerable to bear markets be-
cause they have less time to ride out the storm. What strategies should
you use and when? Part 5 discusses the concerns of pre-retirees and fol-
lows them through retirement. You worked hard and invested wisely so
you could enjoy a comfortable retirement. Don’t let a bear market rob you
of that goal.
Are there “safe havens” in a bear market? Although there are no
completely safe places to hide, you can protect yourself from the worst the
bear has to offer.
BEARSKIN RUG
Part 6, “Bearskin Rug,” discusses the three major considerations in sur-
viving a bear market and gives some examples of why they are so impor-
tant. These tools and techniques will help you avoid the worst the bear
has to offer. However, there are no “silver bullets” that are guaranteed to
kill the bear.
Investing is about risk, and nothing will change that. You can arm
yourself with information and education so you can make investment de-
cisions with a reasonable knowledge of their outcome.
CONCLUSION
Bear markets are as much a part of investing as bull markets. Indeed, we
may not be able to have bull markets without bear markets. Unless you
like ugly surprises, you should be able to identify bear markets and know
what they can do to your portfolio. Forewarned is forearmed.
CHAPTER 2
INVESTING AS A
C O N TA C T S P O R T
Caution
Structuring your portfolio for maximum safety makes sense late
in life when you can’t afford losses. However, while you are still
accumulating wealth, a very conservative portfolio may be very
expensive in lost opportunities.
16 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Plain English
An initial public offering (IPO) is the first issue of stock sold to the
public by a company. The company retains the proceeds to finance
growth. Once the company sells its stock to the public, subsequent sales
are between investors, and the company doesn’t receive any of the
money.
At the height of the Internet stock “bubble,” I was producing a Web site
for beginning investors. The questions I received by e-mail showed a dan-
gerous lack of understanding on the part of novice investors: “I’ve been
reading about how much money you can make with IPOs, so I thought
I’d get in on the action. How much does 10 shares of IPO cost?”
Money poured into the market in unprecedented amounts, and the
bubble got larger and larger. Individual investors were encouraged to
dump their low-performing investments and hop on the express train to
wealth. Those investors who did well were smart enough to get in at a rea-
sonable price and take a profit in the short run (but this is more like spec-
ulation than long-term investing). Ironically, the investors who lost the
most got into the market, often near the top, thinking they could ride out
falling prices by holding on or even buying more as the stock dropped.
A MATTER OF PERCEPTION
Only you can decide what level of risk you can handle without losing
sleep. What may seem risky for one investor may not appear that way at
all to another investor. Some investors find individual stocks too risky and
I N V E S T I N G A S A C O N TA C T S P O R T 17
Tip
Hot tips are for suckers. The Internet is a breeding ground for “pump
and dump” scams where a person will disclose the name of the next Mi-
crosoft with the intention of driving up the price so they can sell at a big
profit. Many times the company mentioned has no knowledge of the
swindle.
TYPES OF RISK
There are three basic types of investment risk, and any one or a combi-
nation can cause a bear market. However, your investments are subject to
these risks even if they don’t precipitate a bear market. The types of in-
vestment risk are the following:
18 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
■ Economic risk
■ Market risk
■ Inflation risk
Tip
When you see a market going crazy over a particular sector (such
as technology stocks), a red flag should warn you that eventually this
frenzy will end and the sector will collapse.
MARKET RISK
Internet and technology stocks fueled the 1990s bull market, especially
toward the end. The market was definitely behind companies that rushed
to the Internet and new technology. It was fairly simple to follow the
money and see what was hot. Billions of dollars poured into the high-
tech/Internet companies. If you had a two-page business plan and a com-
pany name that ended in “.com,” no matter how outrageous the plan or
inexperienced the managers, there seemed to be no end to the line of peo-
ple wanting to give you money.
However, many of these “new economy” wonders were really only
good at doing one thing: eating money. Toward the end, phrases like
“burn rate,” which refers to how fast a company is going through its cash,
began to be part of the dialogue.
The amount of cash the companies consumed was alarming. Even
more alarming was the fact that many of the companies would never make
a profit. Investors, particularly big institutions and mutual funds, began to
see things more clearly. When the market turned on the Internet and tech-
nology stocks, it did so with a vengeance. Stock prices plunged and com-
panies ran for cover by looking for a merger with a strong company. You
could say that investors woke up toward the end, rubbed their eyes, and
said to themselves, “I’ll never drink that hype again.”
I N V E S T I N G A S A C O N TA C T S P O R T 19
Caution
When the Nasdaq passed 5,000, some people were saying the 10,000
mark would soon fall. Even after the index plunged 50 percent, some
people were predicting it would hit 5,000 again and soon. All these pre-
dictions are idle speculation. No one knows where the index will be in
six months.
Tip
Speculating and investing are two different things. If you want to spec-
ulate in short-term trading, do so with the understanding that in the
end you will lose more often than you will win.
A theory called the “Bigger Fool Theory” describes how a market reacts
when it’s overheated. In the past, it described oil and gas booms and
20 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
real-estate runs. The Bigger Fool Theory states that it doesn’t matter
what you pay for the item because a bigger fool will come along and pay
you more for it.
If you want to speculate in an overheated market, do it with
money you can afford to lose. You should have a plan for entry and exit
and stick with it. Be satisfied with merely obscene profits. Remember
the golden rule of Wall Street: Bulls profit and bears profit, but pigs get
slaughtered.
ECONOMIC RISK
Economic risk is when the economy turns against an investment. Perhaps
interest rates go up or consumer demand goes down—either way your in-
vestment could be at risk.
For example, energy prices affect a wide range of industries; how-
ever, transportation companies and certain manufacturing concerns are
particularly vulnerable. Automobile manufacturers and homebuilders suf-
fer when interest rates rise sharply. A drop in consumer spending hurts
discount stores and clothing manufacturers.
■ Recession. Many of the preceding factors contribute to or mani-
Plain English
Money supply is the cash circulating in the economy. The Fed controls
the amount of cash and uses that control in its fight against inflation.
I N V E S T I N G A S A C O N TA C T S P O R T 21
though this process has many benefits, there are also some dangers.
As economies become interdependent, the chances of a foreign cri-
sis affecting U.S. markets increases. Political and economic unrest
with key trading partners like Japan and Europe can affect U.S.
markets.
■ Falling profits. Another economic risk is falling profits from key
Tip
The investing community watches earnings (profits) reports with great
anticipation. When companies fail to make their earnings projections,
the market batters the company’s stock.
INFLATION RISK
One of the greatest economic risks to every sector of the economy is in-
flation. Inflation is when prices rise rapidly and the currency loses value.
Simply stated, inflation is when too much money is chasing too few
goods and services.
Inflation is the most feared of all economic maladies because it
bleeds the value from investments and from workers’ payroll checks. The
Fed’s primary job is to keep inflation under control. It uses interest rates
and money supply to do this. If the Fed sees economic indicators point-
ing toward rising inflation, it will increase interest rates to cool off the
economy. It did this six times during the last bull market.
22 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Caution
Many economists consider inflation the most dangerous of economic
problems. The Fed is willing to take extraordinary steps to keep it in
check. Some of these steps, like rising interest rates, can hurt the stock
market.
WHERE TO HIDE
Investors traditionally look to hard assets like gold and real estate to pro-
tect themselves from the ravages of inflation. So-called hard assets have an
intrinsic value that historically has done well in times of inflation—that
is, until the 1980s, when gold, especially, took a beating.
Real-estate funds and inflation-indexed bonds are the most popular
defenses against inflation today. I hope that the Fed will keep inflation
under control. Those of us who lived through the hyperinflation of the
1970s and 1980s remember the pain and frustration of inflation.
CONCLUSION
Investing is a contact sport. You can, and probably will, get hurt at some
point. Whether it is a full bear market or a severe market correction, you
need to be aware of the factors that lead to falling prices.
Information and education will help you structure your portfolio
for the amount of protection you need at a particular point in your life.
Market risk, economic risk, and inflation risk are with you con-
stantly, even if there is not a bear market in progress. In a bear market,
these risks can become amplified and even more dangerous. You can’t
hope to achieve even modest returns without some risk. The trick is to
keep the risk at a level you can tolerate and to be aware of the risk you
have no control over.
CHAPTER 3
TYPES OF BEAR
MARKETS
Remember my caution from earlier: The closer you are to your financial
goal (retirement, in particular), the more concerned you should be about
bear markets and the more carefully you should watch the markets and
the economy. A good financial advisor will help you watch for warning
signs.
POLITICAL/FINANCIAL-INSTABILITY
BEAR MARKETS
As economies of the world become more intertwined and dependent on
each other, the potential for foreign instability to disrupt the stock mar-
ket increases. The invasion of Kuwait in 1990 precipitated the bear mar-
ket that set the stage for the 10-year bull market that ended with the 2000
disaster for Internet and tech stocks.
Wars and political instability are part of modern life. At any given
time, there may be 30 to 40 wars in progress around the world. All wars
are terrible, but the stock market is more concerned with some wars than
others. The Gulf War that made Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf a hero was
significant because instability in that part of the world threatened Mid-
dle Eastern oil supplies, which the United States depends heavily on to
fuel our economy. Instability always leads to higher prices, and higher
TYPES OF BEAR MARKETS 27
Caution
Energy prices are critical to our economy. Rising energy costs always
have a negative affect on the economy and stock market.
Although we won the war, the stock market and economy suffered exten-
sive damage. A bear market and a recession may have led to the defeat of
President George Bush in the 1992 presidential election. The stock mar-
ket’s real concern with the Gulf War was the disruption of oil supplies
from the region.
In Chapter 4, “Economic Indicators,” we will look at some of the
economic indicators that signal changes in the economy. When energy
prices increase, you can be sure things are going to get worse, not better.
As this is being written, California is experiencing rolling blackouts be-
cause of mismanagement by the state’s utilities; crude oil is over $30 a bar-
rel; and my natural gas bill is double what it was last year.
Plain English
A soft landing is economist-speak for a recession that doesn’t quite ma-
ture, but still has a negative affect on the economy.
The current debate is whether the economy will sink into a recession or
have a “soft landing” with only short-term consequences. Even the experts
don’t know what will happen in the short run, but an unstable energy
price scenario does not sound encouraging. Foreign oil problems are not
the only threat to our financial well-being. A protracted recession in Japan
and credit problems in Southeast Asia are sticky concerns for many U.S.
companies looking to these areas for new markets. A severe recession with
other major trading partners could have negative effects on our economy
and the stock market.
28 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
The most recent dramatic example of market liquidity occurred on
Black Monday in October 1987, when the Dow Jones Industrial Aver-
age dropped over 500 points in one day. Sellers flooded the market; how-
ever, there were few buyers. The result was a huge drop in the market.
In the first scenario, there was no liquidity because John could not find
any buyers for his shares. We assume that we can sell our stocks at any
time. When there is a serious bear market, buyers will be hard to find.
Stocks are not like bonds or certificates of deposit that have a fixed, and
in the case of most CDs guaranteed, principle. Stocks are only worth what
someone is willing to pay for them.
market is looking forward to see how it will do. These different perspec-
tives account for why the economy may view one statistic as positive while
the stock market may view the same statistic as negative.
I have used the example of unemployment figures before, but it’s
worth repeating. The economy views low unemployment figures as good
because more people are working and contributing to the economy. For
some companies, this may be a double-edged sword. It’s good that con-
sumers have more money to spend, but low unemployment means
stronger competition for labor, which means high salaries and ultimately
lower profits if the extra costs can’t be passed on to customers. The com-
pany may lower future earnings estimates, which is sure to disappoint the
market.
The intertwining of the economy and the stock market make them
siblings, even though they may look in different directions. If the econo-
my goes south, it can’t be good for the market. A bear market spreads
gloom and distrust, which erodes consumer confidence.
INFLATION/INTEREST-RATE
BEAR MARKETS
The inflation/interest-rate bear market can be the most damaging to in-
vestors and the economy in general. The 1973–1974 bear market was
especially devastating. (See the table in Chapter 1, “Bear Markets.”)
Economists believe that inflation is the most dangerous threat to our
economy. The Fed’s Chairman Alan Greenspan agrees. His best tool to
fight inflation is interest rate adjustments. During the recent bull market,
he raised interest rates six times in an attempt to cool off the white-hot
economy. These interest rates, along with other factors, finally took hold
in 2000 and the economy began to slow. Unfortunately, it looked like it
was slowing too fast and headed for a recession. In an effort to prevent the
recession or at least soften its blow, the Fed lowered interest rates in early
2000.
The falling stock market reacted predictably to the interest-rate
hikes and slammed on the brakes. Higher interest rates mean money for
expansion and growth is more expensive. Increased borrowing costs cut
into future earnings. Investors began to worry about the double whammy
of a bear market and a recession. The super hot Internet and technology
30 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
stocks began to crumble in the spring of 2000. With a bear market and
recession looming in the near future, investors dumped the former dar-
lings of Wall Street for more secure issues.
As I noted earlier, one of the reasons the economy and the stock
market don’t always move in concert is they are influenced by the same
factors, but from different perspectives.
Caution
Investors once assumed that there would always be “secure” issues to buy
in times of turmoil. Don’t assume past safe havens will remain so in the
future.
LOOKING BACKWARD
The Fed must adjust interest rates based on information from the recent
past, knowing that its actions may take some time to be effective. The
stock market looks at information from the present and attempts to guess
what impact it will have on future earnings and stock prices.
The stock market is so concerned about the future that it won’t wait
for official information. Investors anticipate the information before its re-
lease and act on it. The Fed normally meets on a quarterly basis and de-
cides what to do about interest rates. The stock market makes an educated
guess and moves before the meeting.
Tip
Analysts pore over every clue they can find to guess what the Fed will
do to interest rates. Fed officials must be extremely cautious in public
statements to not send unintended messages.
Normally, the market guesses right; but the Fed can surprise the market.
When this happens, the market may react strongly. The Fed doesn’t have
to wait until its meeting to act. It can act whenever it feels the need. The
stock market always greets these surprises with fevered activity.
TYPES OF BEAR MARKETS 31
Caution
A booming economy may not be great for the stock market. Rapid
growth is a known cause of inflation, and the Fed watches growth num-
bers very carefully.
Tip
When the market was roaring between 1998 and 2000, day traders at-
tracted lots of media attention with their huge daily profits. After the
bubble burst, they all but disappeared from the radar.
Younger investors may not remember that at one time you had to physi-
cally go to a stock brokerage to open an account to buy and sell stocks.
The brokers fixed commissions at what would now seem criminally high
rates. When these commissions were deregulated, a new type of stock bro-
kerage emerged—the discount broker. The discount broker charged dra-
matically lower commissions, but investors received no research or help
making investment decisions. Still, the lower commissions and the ease of
dealing with the broker over the phone drew more investors into the stock
market.
The next revolution occurred when the Internet gave birth to online
stock brokerages. Their rates were even lower than discount brokers, and
investors could do all their business online. Coupled with a booming
TYPES OF BEAR MARKETS 33
economy and the hysteria associated with Internet/tech stocks, online in-
vesting exploded. Problems with broker Web sites crashing during heavy
volume dulled some enthusiasm, but it didn’t blunt the desire to trade.
With full-service brokers considered by many investors a thing of
the past, investors who opted to trade with discount brokers (both on-
and offline) had to do their own research, which is where the Internet re-
ally changed the playing field. Literally hundreds of Web sites offering
information, research, and advice compete for investors’ attention. You
have access to more information today than at any time in history.
Caution
Not all Web sites are equal. There are a number of great resources on-
line, but there are also a number of thinly disguised sales pitches posing
as “information.”
CONCLUSION
Bear markets come in many flavors. Investors armed with information
and education can prepare themselves in advance.
Interest rate increases in response to higher inflation is the cause of
the most dangerous of all bear markets. Investors must prepare in advance
for these problems because once they are upon the market, it may be too
late.
CHAPTER 4
ECONOMIC
I N D I C AT O R S
Economics is known as the “dismal science.” I’m not sure who gave
it this label, but I suspect it was someone like me who’s more com-
fortable with words than numbers. Unfortunately, you can’t be very
effective as an investor without getting familiar with the numbers.
Economic indicators are a selection of measurements used to
understand the relative strength or weakness of the economy. Many
of these numbers directly affect the stock market, so they are im-
portant to investors.
Most of these numbers are indexes, which means they repre-
sent the change from a base year. For example, the Employment
Cost Index represents the change in the cost of labor. Economists
use the numbers from 1989 as the base (1989 = 100). As labor costs
change from quarter to quarter, the number relative to the base year
changes. The number for the last quarter of 2000 was 150.6. How-
ever, the number most investors follow is the percent change. In this
reporting period, that change was a 4.1 percent increase over the
last quarter of 1999.
Plain English
An index is a statistical composite that measures the increase or
decrease of an economic indicator as measured against a base year.
36 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
We’ll look at the Employment Cost Index in more detail later; however,
economists report and measure many of the indicators we will look at in
this section the same way. It’s not particularly important that you under-
stand how economists put the numbers together. (If you really want to
know, many Internet sites and books report this information.) What is
important is that you understand what these indicators mean in terms of
your investments and understand how the stock market views them.
The market is always looking to the future. Rather than wait for the
actual numbers, Wall Street economists make their own estimates of what
the numbers will report. Investors, especially big institutional investors
and mutual funds, make decisions based on these estimates. When the ac-
tual numbers differ substantially from estimates, the market will often
react dramatically. A number of Web sites report the estimates and com-
pare them to the actual numbers.
Tip
A number of Web sites, including TheStreet.com, publish a calendar of
report dates for a variety of economic indicators. If you are interested in
a particular indicator, the calendar will let you know when to look for
the information.
Not every economic indicator has an important affect on the stock mar-
ket, so we will stick with those that do.
INFLATION INDICATORS
As noted earlier, inflation is the most feared economic condition short of
a depression. It robs value from just about every sector of the economy.
Economists call inflation the evil tax because it takes value not only from
your earnings but also from your principal. The Fed has demonstrated a
willingness to go to great lengths to keep inflation in check. During the
last leg of the recent bull market, the Fed raised interest rates six times in
response to signs of impending inflation.
The following indicators represent the most important tools econo-
mists use to gauge the relative strength of inflation.
E C O N O M I C I N D I C AT O R S 37
This news justified the Fed’s decision to lower interest rates, and further
rate reductions may be possible. The market could feel good about the fu-
ture of further rate reductions.
Of course, this is just one component of many that market econo-
mists consider along with the Fed in forecasting higher or lower inflation.
Assuming no other indicators pointed in a different direction, you might
consider investments that do well in an environment of lower or steady
interest rates. Admittedly, long-term investors should probably not adjust
their portfolios on just one quarter’s information. However, a steady in-
crease in the ECI suggests the Fed may raise interest rates.
38 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
The ECI began a fairly dramatic rise in the first quarter of 1999 and
did not retreat until the fourth quarter of 2000. It isn’t surprising that the
Fed increased interest rates during this period.
Caution
Economists forecast indicators to factor them into investment decisions
before they happen. However, some indicators are so volatile that in-
vestors are reluctant to place too much value on estimates.
inflation because it contains more components than the PPI, which does
not include services.
The December 2000 number, reported in mid-January 2001, came
in just where the economists estimated, with the core number slightly
under estimates. This was good news for the market because it confirmed
that inflation was under control.
Now we have three numbers for inflation during the month of Jan-
uary 2001. The Fed’s regularly scheduled meeting at the end of the month
would consider interest rates. What would they do? A CPI moving up
over several months is a cause for concern. The Fed is likely to either raise
interest rates or leave them the same. In a bear market, raising interest
rates to combat inflation would prolong the bear’s visit. Good news on
the inflation front likely means lower interest rates, which are good for
stocks and bonds.
Tip
The Fed funds rate is a base rate that banks use when they lend to each
other overnight. It is the short-term rate upon which other rates (mort-
gages, consumer loans, and so on) are set.
EMPLOYMENT REPORT
The Employment Report is one of the best measures of the economy’s
health. There are actually four numbers: the unemployment rate, new
jobs created, length of workweek, and average hourly wages. The Labor
Department issues this report monthly, and market observers watch it
with anticipation.
40 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
The unemployment rate stayed at record low levels for much of the lat-
ter 1990s. As the economy began to slow, the rate began to creep up-
ward.
A healthy economy has a low unemployment rate, creates new jobs, in-
creases the workweek, and raises hourly wages. An economy growing too
fast in these categories creates inflation. On the other hand, a slowing
economy has rising unemployment, fewer new jobs created, short work-
weeks, and falling hourly wages. The stock market may not view numbers
that look good for the economy in a positive manner. Low unemploy-
ment is a sign of a healthy economy; however, it can mean higher labor
costs for employers, which can cut into profits.
The Fed must do an incredible balancing act between keeping in-
flation under control and keeping the economy moving at a positive pace.
Raising interest rates to slow inflation may have the effect of slamming
the brakes on the economy. The Employment Report is critical to their
deliberations. The stock market wants lower interest rates, but not at the
expense of inflation.
Caution
Changing the direction of the economy is like steering a large ship; it
usually takes some time before any changes are apparent.
The fear in the stock market as 2000 became 2001 was that the economy
was decelerating too rapidly. A bear gripped the stock market and in-
vestors were afraid a recession would only make things worse. Inflation
was clearly in check, so the Fed cut interest rates twice in January 2001
for a 1 percent decrease. However, even this was not enough to lift the
market and economy in a substantial way—at least not yet. Interest rate
E C O N O M I C I N D I C AT O R S 41
moves take some time to filter through the economy. It may be several
months after a change in interest rates before the effect spreads through-
out the economy.
It is important to remember that bad numbers in the Employment
Report can lead to higher or static interest rates. The market may react
swiftly to an interest rate decision, but it will take some time for the rate
changes to affect earnings.
Caution
A slowdown in manufacturing can ripple through the whole economy.
Whole towns have suffered terribly when factories closed because of the
wages—and expendable income—those workers have lost.
Caution
Interest rates grease the wheels of the economy, but rate adjustments
aren’t a “silver bullet” that solve all economic problems.
E C O N O M I C I N D I C AT O R S 43
Caution
You can always find market commentators on the Internet and else-
where who want to paint a picture of the economy to suit their own par-
ticular prejudices. Unfortunately, numbers are stronger than words. You
can’t wish away bad news.
RETAIL SALES
The Retail Sales Report totals sales at retail stores, but it does not include
services. The Census Bureau issues this report monthly, usually within
two weeks of the previous month’s end.
Consumer spending is a strong force in our economy, so market ob-
servers closely watch this report, which has significance for the market in
the short-term and contributes to the larger picture of economic health.
Strong retail sales signal a healthy economy. Slowing retail sales may in-
dicate consumers are contemplating tighter times ahead and are putting
off nonessential spending. (You would expect to see low unemployment
44 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
correlate with a good retail sales report.) A dramatic slowing of retail sales
can hasten an economic slowdown and a strong increase in retail sales can
help pull the economy out of a downturn.
The December 2000 Retail Sales Report showed a small 0.1 percent
increase. The two previous reports showed declines, combining for a
shaky prognosis for 2001. This fits into the picture we have drawn using
December 2000 numbers for the major economic indicators.
Caution
Investors expect companies to keep growing and increasing the value of
their investment. During slowing economies, many companies have
trouble maintaining growth rates. This can spell trouble if the company
has spent heavily building an infrastructure to support growth. If
growth slows, the revenues to pay for the infrastructure may drop and
cause profits to suffer.
E C O N O M I C I N D I C AT O R S 45
CONCLUSION
Is your head swimming? This was probably a lot more about economic in-
dicators than you wanted to know, but the relationship between the econ-
omy and the stock market is important to your investment decisions.
Understanding what’s happening in the economy can suggest sound in-
vestment strategies.
CHAPTER 5
MARKET
I N D I C AT O R S
You would think with all the economic indicators we just plowed
through in Chapter 4 and all the numbers that spew forth from the
Internet, that only an idiot couldn’t see a bear market coming.
But if it were that easy, you wouldn’t need this book! Unfor-
tunately, bears are hard to spot. Sometimes they come in the front
door, and sometimes the back. We have also learned in earlier chap-
ters that certain influences completely outside the market, such as
war, can invoke a bear. Nevertheless, it’s important to keep an eye
on market indicators for warning signs. The stock market gives off
all kinds of signs; interpreting which ones are real bears and which
are bear traps is as much an art as a science. The prudent investor
hopes for the best and prepares for the worst.
In this chapter, we will look at some of the market indicators
that can help us spot a bear market. We’ll look at some of the more
common indicators as well as some that aren’t so well known. Like
the economic indicators from the previous chapter, no single sign
clearly foretells an approaching bear. Like pieces of a puzzle, these
indicators construct a picture that previously was a jumble of ran-
dom signs.
48 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Warning signs are of no importance if you are not prepared to act. Every
investor should have a plan for every asset you own, whether it is an in-
dividual stock or a mutual fund.
Caution
You can buy futures contracts on most of the major indexes. Some in-
vestors use these to protect themselves against market swings. Futures
contracts, options, and other derivatives are valid investment tools, but
only in the hands of the most experienced investors.
Watching indexes can lead to a short-term mindset. Investors are still di-
gesting the emergence of more than one “market.” Although this situation
has been around for some time, the recent skyrocketing and subsequent
crash of the Nasdaq has focused more attention on understanding the dif-
ferences between multiple markets.
In many ways, you get a clearer picture of what is happening from
the economic indicators we discussed in the last chapter. Nevertheless,
what follows is a quick overview of the major indexes and some sense of
how they fit into the overall picture. Some of the tools listed below will
M A R K E T I N D I C AT O R S 49
help you understand what the market is doing over time, and more tools
are available if you’re interested in pursuing technical analysis further.
Plain English
A “blue-chip” stock is a premium investment. These are well-established
and respected companies with lengthy histories of good returns. The
term “blue chip” comes from poker, where the blue chips are worth the
most.
The Dow also plays an important role in registering the “mood” of the
market. You cannot take emotion out of any market observation; the mar-
ket (Dow) reflects the optimism or pessimism of the investing commu-
nity. A 20 percent decline in the Dow over a sustained period qualifies as
a bear market.
smaller companies. Small, startup companies led the late-1990s bull mar-
ket. For this reason, the NYSE probably didn’t represent the heart of the
bull market.
This index will track the Dow, although its broader coverage re-
duces some of its volatility. This makes the NYSE a widely used proxy for
“the market.” It takes more than a few bad reports on individual stocks to
move the NYSE index.
Tip
Mutual-funds managers in particular use the S&P 500 as a benchmark
for their funds performance. When they beat the S&P 500, managers
proudly display the fact in the annual report. If they don’t beat the mark,
look for many excuses.
Caution
What goes up must come down. That may not always be true; how-
ever, when a market overheats as the Nasdaq did in the final years of the
last bull market, a severe bear is almost inevitable.
VOLUME SIGNS
Watching the market volume (the number of shares traded) can give you
additional confirmation as to the “lower lows and lower highs” approach.
As the market hits these marks, take note if volume is increasing or de-
creasing. If volume is increasing from one lower low to the next (within a
couple of days), you may be looking at a bear. What you are seeing is
downward momentum, and it can be a powerful force in the market.
Unsupported lows may be a bear trap. On the other hand, when the
market hits new lower lows and lower highs on increasing volume, you
are looking at a dangerous trend downward.
The opposite works for emerging bull markets. Higher highs and
higher lows mark the way out of a bear market if volume is increasing
along the way.
Tip
Rising volume indicates more people and more issues are participating
in the market. This positive signal reflects the fact that once the market
moves strongly in one direction, it takes extreme measures to reverse its
course.
ADVANCE-DECLINE SIGNS
The advance-decline line is another tool that investors use to gain some
sense of where the market’s heading. The A/D line is a way to measure the
market’s breadth: a graphical representation of the market’s strength of
movement relative to the number of stocks advancing and the number de-
clining.
M A R K E T I N D I C AT O R S 53
15000
10000
5000
DJINDUSTRIAL IDX
2500
2000
1500
When the A/D line and the index are moving in opposite directions, it’s
called a divergence. Divergences usually indicate a change. The index usu-
ally follows the A/D line. Looking at this chart would send chills down
the back of investors who followed the A/D charts.
54 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
The problem with following the A/D line is that it doesn’t look for-
ward. You can’t know what it is going to look like next week by looking
at it this week.
Several other indicators are built around the advancing and declin-
ing issues, including one that measures not the number of issues but the
volume. Market watchers calculate the volume of advancing issues and
the volume of declining issues and chart this line. I suggest you visit Equis
(www.equis.com) for more information on these indicators and how you
can use them.
EARNINGS FORECASTS
Investors are concerned primarily with the future. One of the strongest
positive signs for investors is a market leader reporting positive earnings
estimates. This is welcome news to investors even if they don’t own those
M A R K E T I N D I C AT O R S 55
individual stocks; good news in the earnings estimate report means com-
panies are optimistic about the near-term health of their company.
One company reporting bad earnings estimates may not move the
market, but when other market leaders start warning that they may not
hit earlier estimates or release new estimates that show a decline in earn-
ings, the market takes notice.
Tip
When companies begin making or revising earnings estimates lower
than the market anticipated, you can bet the stock will fall. If several
stocks that are leaders drop, the whole market may retreat.
Tip
Bonds may do well in a bear market if the Fed is dropping interest rates
to soften the landing.
Bond yields reflect the current price of the bond and its coupon interest
rate. You would expect long-term bonds to have a higher yield than a
short-term bond. (Long-term bonds are at a higher risk from inflation
and other economic problems than short-term bonds.) When the yield of
short-term bonds exceeds those of long-term bonds, a recession and bear
market are definite possibilities. This “inverted” yield curve expresses pes-
simism about the future.
CONCLUSION
This brief introduction to market indicators is meant to show you that in-
vestors need to keep their eyes open to changing conditions. As you’ll see
in later chapters, this will help you prepare for bear markets or severe cor-
rections.
No set of magic indicators will tell you what the market will look
like next month, much less next year, but you can lower the odds that a
bear will blindside you at the worst possible time—when you’re
unprepared.
PA R T 2
BEAR TRAPS
I’m a big advocate of the “buy low, sell high” theory of investing. It
has been my experience that you can make money doing this. Un-
fortunately, the theory has one small problem: It doesn’t always
work. It doesn’t work because it relies on correctly buying at the
bottom and selling at the top, and no one can call the turns with
consistent accuracy.
Investors, even professionals, find market timing too tempt-
ing to resist at times. On the other hand, it takes nerves of steel to
sit on your “buy-and-hold” strategy while watching your invest-
ments sink like a brick in an extended bear market.
Sometimes bad things happen to good investments, but, most
often, bad things happen to bad investments. Either way, you need
an exit plan when you see a bear market coming or when you find
yourself in the middle of an unstable market that is throwing off
confusing signals.
You need a plan to deal with falling prices before they start
falling. This part of the book looks at market timing and how to
avoid this particularly nasty bear trap. We will also spend some time
on developing a strategy for selling a stock and a mutual fund. The
strategies for selling stocks and mutual funds differ in some respects
because of the difference in the two investments, but there are also
many similarities.
CHAPTER 6
MARKET TIMING:
THE TWO MOST
DANGEROUS
WORDS IN
INVESTING
Two hikers are on their way up a mountain trail when a large bear
spots them and charges. One hiker immediately drops to the
ground, pulls her running shoes out of the backpack, and begins
taking off her hiking boots.
“Are you crazy?” her companion shouts. “You can’t outrun
a bear!”
She looks up at him and says, “I don’t have to outrun the bear.
I just have to outrun you.”
You can’t outrun a bear market either. It’s tempting to think
you can, by timing your entry and exit in an unstable market, but
the overwhelming evidence is that market timing doesn’t work con-
sistently, and leaving may be more harmful than doing nothing.
There are two forms of market timing: intentional and unin-
tentional. Both are deadly to your portfolio.
60 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
MARKET TIMERS
Market timing has its proponents. You don’t have to look very far or hard
to find folks who will gladly call the market turns for you if you subscribe
to their service. Some of these market timers are very sincere about their
approach and believe they can provide a real service.
Others, however, are just short of frauds. One of their tools is trot-
ting out “historical” data that shows how their system called the market
correctly for the past 10 years, or whatever. They base many of their sys-
tems on back testing, which takes a trading system and applies it against
historical market data. Done objectively, there is nothing wrong with this
approach. However, if you manipulate the system to produce the best re-
sults based on the historical data, you have crossed the line between test-
ing and moved into the realm of shell games: You can’t duplicate their
results because they tweaked the system to work with a market that won’t
exist again.
Caution
Save your money and don’t invest in expensive newsletters that offer to
predict market turns. There is no credible evidence that they work.
Wall Street. You couldn’t open an investing publication or cruise the In-
ternet without reading about a former cab driver making $50,000 a week
day trading at his kitchen table in his underwear. When the dot.coms be-
came dot.bombs, the day traders disappeared from the media. The untold
story, even during their peak, was that very few day traders were making
money even when the market was red-hot.
Another form of market timing that ran rampant during this pe-
riod was the IPO craze. Just about any new Internet or tech company that
went public experienced huge run-ups of its stock almost overnight. This
was the origin of the dot.com billionaires who became so famous. Most
of their wealth was in the stock and stock options they held. Investors
tried to cash in on the huge gains, and some managed to do so by buying
early and getting out quickly with a reasonable profit, but the market
wasn’t very kind to those who got in late and didn’t get out quickly. The
super-high prices for most of these stocks didn’t hold, and people lost
much of their investment.
Caution
The IPO craze drove people to pay incredible prices for young compa-
nies with no track record. In fact, many of the companies had no prof-
its and no working products.
For example, I am aware of a company that went public around $20 per
share. Within a short period, the stock was selling for over $100 per share.
It didn’t stay there long and fell to $14 per share. All of this happened in
less than 12 months. (As I write this, the stock is trading for $23 per share
less than two years after it went public.)
The sad truth is that many of the hot IPOs were trading at or below
their offering price within six months to one year. After the Nasdaq melt-
down that began in the spring of 2000, many of these former high-flyers
have disappeared altogether.
they’re losing it. They jump in impulsively and bail out without much
more consideration.
The late-1990s bull market made making money look so easy, and
attracted many investors with little or no experience in the market. In-
vestors and potential investors watched the Internet/tech stocks go crazy
along with the Nasdaq index. Typically, they waited until the market was
way up before investing; then, deciding the bull market was going to be
around for a while, they charged into the market. With no real knowledge
of market dynamics, they bought overpriced stocks that ultimately proved
to have only one way to go with any momentum—and that was down.
When the market turned and their stocks began to fall, they watch
helplessly as their money evaporated. Some cut their losses quickly or
even took a small profit. Others froze like deer in the headlights. Perhaps
they convinced themselves that a “buy and hold” strategy would see them
through. When prices didn’t bounce back, they sold in frustration and left
the market in disgust. But not just the novices suffered. A number of sea-
soned professionals also took big hits because they put aside their disci-
plined approach to investing and ran with the excitement.
Caution
The heady days of the Internet/tech bull market were full of optimism
and a sense that anyone could make a fortune in the market. Unfortu-
nately, when the bubble broke, many watched the market fall, sure it
would bounce back any minute. Markets do fall, and they can fall much
farther than you think.
next year.
■ Unless index funds make up your portfolio, there is no guarantee
■ In most cases, you are probably better off invested than not: Buy
and hold.
■ Timing the market takes a lot of time.
Tip
It is hard not to be impressed with some of the Internet pundits writing
and making predictions about the market, but if you check the site
archives, you may find that their track record is not so great.
Anyone who tells you what the market is going to do next month is guess-
ing. When you guess, sometimes you are right, and sometimes you are
wrong.
Plain English
Index funds are mutual funds that attempt to mimic a particular mar-
ket index. An index fund based on the S&P 500 buys representative
shares of the index, so the fund rises and falls with the index.
Some advisors suggest that you put your money in a good stock index
fund and forget about it. An S&P 500 index fund is going to rise and fall
with the market. If you have a long time horizon before you need your
money, this is an easy way to ride out down markets. That is not always
the best strategy, however, especially if you’re approaching a financial goal
such as retirement.
What can you do? First, don’t panic. Now is the time for some very
careful decisions. Too many investors react in an emotional manner and
take themselves out of the market. You cannot afford to abandon the mar-
ket completely. Remember, you may have 20-plus years of retirement to
support. The market has historically returned close to 12 percent, and you
will need some significant returns to make your remaining assets stretch.
Don’t make the gambler’s mistake of “doubling up to catch up.” In
other words, high-risk investments may have gotten you into this mess,
but they won’t get you out. Consider moving into lower-risk products like
bonds, real estate investment trusts, and income-producing (dividend)
stocks.
The hardest decision of all may be to go back to work or not retire
immediately. Delaying retirement or going back to work will give you
much-needed cash and give your investments a chance to recover. The
longer you delay withdrawals from your investments, the longer they will
earn a return for you.
You will do yourself a big favor by contacting an investment profes-
sional to review your situation before making any big steps. The right
course of action depends on the assets you’re holding and many other fac-
tors unique to each investor. Make this move quickly to minimize the
damage.
Tip
Technical analysis is an important tool in deciding when to buy and sell
an investment; however, you should use it in connection with a funda-
mental analysis of the investment for maximum effectiveness.
Caution
Investing can involve a considerable amount of emotion. Try to keep
your decisions based on information, not hunches.
Tip
Buying or selling an investment on price alone is often too narrow a cri-
terion for long-term successful investing.
68 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
The hard lesson is: Don’t invest on price alone. If the investment doesn’t
make sense based on its fundamentals or, most importantly, on how it fits
into your plan, don’t risk your money.
CONCLUSION
Market timing doesn’t work. Research shows you are better off invested
in the market than jumping in and out in an attempt to improve your
return.
Always buy and sell within an overall investing plan. You will do
better and will avoid impulsive buying and selling.
CHAPTER 7
The best time to sell a stock is when you have made the maximum
possible return on your investment, and before it crashes. That’s not
so hard, is it?
Unfortunately, the market doesn’t like glib answers any more
than you do. Deciding when to sell is often more difficult than fig-
uring out when to buy, but you’ll hear a lot more advice on when
to buy a stock than on when to sell one. Establishing a bear defense
means shedding stocks that no longer fit your financial plan or
move you closer to your goals. In later chapters, we will look at the
process of asset allocation. Asset allocation depends on getting the
correct mix of investments. Learning to sell stocks correctly is as im-
portant as learning to buy them correctly. This chapter and the next
provide an introduction to the tools you need.
There is no definitive system, no “best way” to arrive at the
sell decision. Investors should develop their own exit plan for get-
ting out of a position. Without a plan, you may make snap deci-
sions, as we discussed in the last chapter.
What follows in this chapter are summaries of some of the
many strategies used by professional investors. Some of the strate-
gies contradict others; some investors sell quickly, while others say
if you buy correctly, you should almost never have to sell.
70 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Find one that makes sense to you, or combine a few for your own
plan. Either way, never buy a stock without some clear idea of when you
need to get out of it. Hunches, instincts, and planetary alignments are not
strategies. The key to making your strategy work is to work your strategy.
That is, decide on your exit criteria and when a stock meets those points,
sell and don’t look back.
SELLING ON PRICE
Many successful investors have absolute rules about selling a stock whose
price has fallen, and they don’t vary from these rules for any reason. The
rationale is that you have a better chance of long-term success if you keep
your losses to a minimum.
It’s hard to argue with the math: If you lose $5,000 on a stock, you
have to make $5,000 plus (to account for commissions, taxes, and so on)
on another stock to break even. If you had cut your loss at $1,000, then
your $5,000 gain works out to be a net of $4,000 in round numbers.
What is the magic number for selling? For some investors, an 8 per-
cent drop from the purchase price is reason to sell. Others put it at 10 per-
cent. Either way, they don’t let losses get out of hand.
Caution
Investors use selling strategies to counteract the emotional aspect of sell-
ing. It’s too easy to convince yourself that if you hold on a little while
longer, the stock will surely bounce back.
The danger in this strategy is that unstable markets and volatile stocks
may force you to sell in a correction just before the stock takes off. Of
course, proponents point out that you don’t know the stock is going to
take off after a drop. It could just keep dropping, which is probably the
case more often than not.
That is why this approach requires discipline. Keeping your losses
to a minimum undoubtedly helps your portfolio stay profitable. If you
miss a couple of big scores on stocks that turn around, that’s better than
watching losers sink below the horizon.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A STOCK 71
This defensive strategy keeps bears from eating your profits. It re-
quires investors to keep a close eye on the market. If you don’t get greedy,
it can protect your profits from a bear’s bite. If a bear forces you to sell
some or all of the investment to protect your profit, be very careful how
and when you reinvest the cash.
Of course, the contrary point of view suggests you let your winners
run as long as they can.
Plain English
The price/earnings ratio is computed by taking a company’s stock
price and dividing it by the earnings per share. The resulting number
tells you roughly what investors think of the expected growth in earn-
ings. A higher number says investors are willing to pay more for the
stock because they expect higher earnings.
your screen. A selling plan that kicks in when a stock’s P/E ratio hits a tar-
get number can help you move on to better values.
This is the value of having a plan for disposal when you buy a stock.
You know exactly why you are investing, and when that reason no longer
exists, you move on to another stock that meets your plan. This strategy
will exit you from a stock before it reaches its top, but it will also keep you
on plan, not worrying about whether the stock is going to keep rising.
You don’t care because you’re focused on your total investing plan.
Of course, you can hedge your bets somewhat by putting in a stop-
loss order on the stock. This lets the stock rise some more if there is any
price increase left. However, when the stock retreats to your price, your
broker or trading system executes a sell order.
Plain English
Investors use a stop-loss order to trigger a sell order, usually to protect
a profit or avoid a loss. The investor places the order below the current
stock price. If the stock stays the same or rises, nothing happens. If the
price falls to the stop-loss order price, it becomes a market sell order and
the stock is sold without any instructions from the investor.
You should look at other valuation markers in connection with the P/E to
get a better picture of the stock’s situation.
Caution
If one or two stocks heavily weight your portfolio, you are in real dan-
ger if the stocks tumble. You are particularly vulnerable during a bear
market because your asset allocation is out of whack.
There are some obvious drawbacks to this rule. First, you reduce the po-
tential for gain if the investment is still climbing. Second, you introduce
some tax considerations. However, there is ample evidence that a balanced
portfolio has a better chance of surviving unstable markets than one that
is too dependent on a single investment. You trade some potential for
growth for some protection on the downside.
Caution
Be aware that some companies play games to keep their earnings up
when the core business is suffering. A quick look at the income state-
ment shows where the company’s income is originating, and will tell you
if it’s the business or the accounting department that’s making money.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A STOCK 75
Tip
Changes in markets, competition, and economic environments can
cause problems with profits. Great companies don’t just adapt to
change, they lead it.
The reason you bought the stock should form the basis for measuring the
investment’s role in your portfolio. This is not to say you can’t be pleas-
antly surprised when a stock seems to slip out of the role you assigned it
and into one of great potential.
However, that’s usually the exception. Companies go through bad
times and do stupid things. Don’t hesitate to cut a stock if it no longer
meets your needs. When the bear comes knocking, these are among the
first stocks you should consider selling and moving the cash into some-
thing more appropriate. Don’t lose money on a stock you didn’t want
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A STOCK 77
anyway. Put the money to better use, either for sitting on the sidelines
waiting for the dust to clear or for picking up a stock you do want at a
bargain price.
Caution
Profit margins drop when products become commodities. Companies
that can control costs and gain market share will survive. Those that
can’t compete in a high-volume, low-margin arena will fail.
MANAGEMENT IS INCOMPETENT
OR CORRUPT
A company’s management is often its most important asset. A great com-
pany has great management. Great management doesn’t make many mis-
takes and they quickly reverse it when they do make a mistake. Leadership
78 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
with vision and drive can make an average company a winner. Unfortu-
nately, some CEOs lack the skill and vision to help a company succeed.
Executive ego is often at the root of business blunders. The media is usu-
ally quick to point out problems in management. Too many questions
about management decisions and directions may be a sign that trouble is
on the horizon.
Tip
Remember the great New Coke fiasco? The company redid the formula
for the most popular soft drink in the world, only to find that everyone
still wanted the “old” Coke. New is not necessarily better. The company
quickly brought back the old formula—except now it was “Classic”—
and moved forward.
TECHNICAL COLLAPSE
Technical analysis of stock is an exercise in identifying buying and selling
points and is another whole book by itself. However, even the casual chart
user can look for warning signs that a stock may be in trouble.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A STOCK 79
Tip
When a stock’s price begins to drop on increasing daily volume, it may
be time to run for cover.
Unbridled buying may be a sign that a fall is near on the first negative
news. Watch your charts for double peaks where the stock has twice failed
to break through to a new high.
POOR FINANCIALS
The “buy-and-hold” strategy that a number of investors advocate doesn’t
mean “buy and put in a drawer and forget.” It’s important to keep track
of what’s going on with your investments on at least a quarterly basis.
Great companies become also-rans, and industry leaders fall from leader-
ship roles. For a variety of reasons, balance sheets and income statements
deteriorate. Understanding the reasons for declining financial strength
may mean the difference between holding and selling.
For example, currency-conversion problems can hurt companies
with significant international operations if a foreign country suffers prob-
lems. That can cause a company to miss earnings estimates. Understand-
ing that the missed estimate had nothing to do with the day-to-day
operations of the business can ease your mind about holding on to the
stock.
Signs of weakness that raise red flags for investors are slowing sales
and declines in margins. Slowing sales may mean competition is eating
into the company’s customer base or its products are losing market ac-
ceptance. Companies in a weakened financial condition may not be able
to keep up in the technology necessary to remain competitive.
Check the financials for problems on a regular basis. More than
likely you worked through the financials before you decided to invest in
the company. Are the ratios still strong? Is debt rising, and, if so, why? Are
profit margins evaporating?
Tip
You should always have a standard for comparison when you invest.
Whether it is a market index or other companies in the same industry,
a rule to gauge performance is important.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A STOCK 81
DONATE TO CHARITY
Sometimes, you have the opportunity to help yourself and others at the
same time. Although not an investment discipline, donating stock to
charities can accomplish several goals at once.
You may be able to take a tax deduction for the value of the stock
(consult with your tax advisor). At the same time, a worthy cause can use
the stock for a greater good. That’s not a bad deal all the way around.
Tip
You will find numerous trading strategies in my book Alpha Teach Your-
self Investing in 24 Hours. (Shameless plug!)
82 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
CONCLUSION
There are many reasons for selling an investment. You should know why
you bought the stock and what has to happen that will trigger your sell
order.
Many investing professionals counsel caution in buying to prevent
panic in selling. That’s good advice—unfortunately, not every investment
turns out the way we planned, and bear markets can undo your best
plans.
When that happens, a selling discipline will take some of the emo-
tion out of letting go of a stock you liked but that didn’t perform as ex-
pected. Find a selling strategy that makes sense to you and stick with it.
CHAPTER 8
that managers can’t or won’t overcome that signal it’s time to move on to
another investment. Even market professionals running mutual funds
have trouble in bear markets. Don’t assume that they have all the answers.
A well-thought-out selling strategy is an important tool in your in-
vesting arsenal. Your selling strategy will tell you when it’s time to sell and
will take some of the emotion out of the situation. In this chapter, we’ll
look at some strategies, and at those situations when it is appropriate to
sell a fund and move on to something else. You will find many of the con-
ditions similar to the ones outlined in the previous chapter. However,
some conditions are unique to mutual funds. (Note: When I refer to
stocks, bonds, or cash in this chapter, I mean stock mutual funds, bond
funds, or money-market funds.)
However, you buy mutual funds, like individual stocks, to fill a particu-
lar niche in your investment plan. A fund that is at or near the top of its
sector but still losing ground may not be a candidate for selling.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A MUTUAL FUND 85
Tip
The best defense against a bear market is a well-diversified portfolio ap-
propriate to your age and financial goals. Part 3, “Bear Assets,” will help
you design a portfolio that meets these qualifications.
The problem with this situation is that your asset allocation could be all
out of alignment because the fund you thought was covering one area
is actually overlapping somewhere else. This may leave your portfolio
86 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
UNDERPERFORMING FUNDS
Not all managers are equal. Some managers can look at the same indus-
try segment and carve out a profitable mutual fund while other managers
can’t seem to find the handle.
Fund managers are extremely important; a later section of this chap-
ter is devoted to mutual fund managers. If your fund is consistently in the
bottom half of its peer group, that may be a sell signal.
Underperforming is not the same as losing too much money, which
we discussed earlier. An underperforming fund may actually be making
money. However, if it is consistently in the bottom half of its peer group,
that isn’t good enough. You shouldn’t settle for an underperforming fund
when there are usually many others to take its place.
I wouldn’t be too concerned about slips in performance over one or
two quarters. Any manager can have some slippage from time to time.
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A MUTUAL FUND 87
Caution
Jumping from one fund to another for a few one hundredths of a point
is a losing game. Fees and taxes will consume any additional gain in re-
turn.
Tip
There is no magic formula for asset allocation. There are some sugges-
tions, but as with any investment advice you should temper them with
your own tolerance for risk and investment goals.
A large run-up in one of these areas could throw your portfolio out of bal-
ance. If you had owned a fund focused on Internet/tech stocks in the late
1990s, you might have experienced a big increase. This increase could re-
sult in your portfolio looking like this:
80 percent stocks
15 percent bonds
5 percent cash
You can get your portfolio back in sync by selling off some stock funds
(laggards would be a good choice) or by putting more money into bond
funds and money market funds.
Bear markets are prime candidates for throwing your portfolio out of
balance. Take the time to reexamine your position or you may find your
diversified portfolio shield has some holes. It is important to watch your
tax situation when selling funds. Unfortunately, the tax liabilities funds
generate have to do with how often the manager buys and sells within the
fund. Funds distribute capital-gains taxes to shareholders, usually toward
the end of the year. Selling before the distribution may make sense from a
tax point of view, but, as always, consult your tax professional for advice.
AVOIDING OVERLAP
This selling strategy follows rebalancing your portfolio to return the assets
to the proper proportions. Mutual funds come in many flavors and with
names that don’t necessarily reflect their composition.
Caution
One of the major strengths of diversification is that parts of your port-
folio will react differently under the same market conditions. If your
funds overlap, you may not have the diversification you thought.
If you’re not careful, you may find that you own several funds that are
investing in the same types of companies and possibly even the same
companies. This defeats the purpose of diversification. You can use free
tools on Morningstar.com to analyze individual mutual funds and com-
pare several funds for overlap. Morningstar categorizes funds by what
stocks they actually buy, as opposed to how the fund might categorize
WHEN IT’S TIME TO SELL A MUTUAL FUND 89
itself. This way you get an objective view of a fund and can decide if it
still fits your portfolio.
Another service from Morningstar called, appropriately, X-Ray can
look at several funds and compare holdings. A premium service shows
you where two or more funds overlap in holdings. A quick comparison of
two funds, Oppenheimer Main Street Growth and Income A Fund, and
the Domini Social Equity Fund, reveals that both funds have significant
holdings in some major large growth stocks. Owning these two funds
would not satisfy your diversification needs; the overlap between them in-
dicates that they would probably move in the same direction in response
to market conditions. This would be a time to sell one of the funds and
move on to another sector in your portfolio. This can be a rude awaken-
ing during a bear market. Overlapping funds move in the same direction
at just the time you need diversification the most.
Tip
It’s not a bad idea to keep an eye on a hot manager who leaves one fund
for another. If he or she is taking over a similar fund, it might be worth
it to consider following the manager with your money.
Tip
Mutual funds that focus in “hot” sectors, like the Internet/tech funds,
may not perform as well as the market. When the underlying stocks
move, it is usually all in the same direction.
your profits run see no reason to cut short a profitable investment. Folks
on the other side feel they could reinvest some or all of the profits else-
where to better use.
Tip
If you can protect a profit in a bear market by selling some or all of a
winner, you can put that money to use by picking up a fund that is cur-
rently depressed but has great potential.
POOR MANAGEMENT
Poor management is one of the best reasons to sell a mutual fund. There
is no reason to stick with a fund that has poor management. A poorly
managed fund is not going to get any better except by luck, and that’s not
very comforting for investors.
A poorly managed fund will exhibit some or all of the following
characteristics:
■ A history of underperforming similar types of funds or indexes
MISTAKE AT PURCHASE
The Securities and Exchange Commission has expressed concern over
the way management companies name mutual funds. They feel that
some of the names are misleading investors to believe they are buying
92 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
one type of fund, when that is not the case. You wouldn’t be the first in-
vestor who thought they were buying a value fund, only to discover most
of the investments were in growth stocks. You also wouldn’t be the only
investor who bought a fund only to realize that a fund they already
owned covered the same type of stocks.
It is never a mistake to correct a mistake. If you picked the wrong
fund for your asset-allocation plan, you are vulnerable until you correct
the mistake.
Tip
There are too many good funds for you to be stuck with one that churns
your stomach with its wild swings. If you are losing sleep over a fund,
lose the fund.
DONATE TO CHARITY
Are you sitting on a mutual fund that is not really going anywhere? Why
not consider donating it to a charitable cause? There are some good “win-
win” reasons for making donations. More than likely, you can take a de-
duction for the appreciated value of the fund, and the charity gets an asset
they can let grow or cash in for current needs.
CONCLUSION
You’re clearly better off in the market than out of it, even in a bear mar-
ket. That doesn’t mean you should be stuck with funds that aren’t pulling
their weight.
Careful planning and research when you purchase a fund eliminates
many problems down the road. However, life and the markets have a way
of not following your most careful plan. When that happens, you need an
exit strategy. This plan should be in place when you buy the fund and not
made up as you go.
94 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
BEAR ASSETS
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N :
THE TWO MOST
I M P O R TA N T W O R D S
IN INVESTING
was to not lose as much as the rest of the market; even converting every-
thing to cash wasn’t the answer because inflation was eating away at the
value of everything.
In this chapter, we are going to look at asset allocation in a general
context. As we move deeper into the book, the focus will become more
and more specific. In this discussion, the terms “stocks,” “bonds,” and
“cash” refer to the class alone: When I use the term stocks, unless other-
wise noted, I mean both individual stocks and stock funds. Same with
bonds—I am referring to individual bonds or bond funds. Cash can be
any form of savings, from money market funds to money market ac-
counts. This is not the cash you should have on-hand for emergencies,
usually enough to cover three to six months’ expenses. (When it’s impor-
tant to make distinctions, I will do so.)
Tip
If you have substantial assets, or find this all too overwhelming, you may
want to engage a financial planner to help you with your asset alloca-
tion. If you finish this book, you’ll be ready to ask the important ques-
tions an advisor should answer.
investments over different assets. Asset allocation takes that a step further
and suggests how much of your portfolio to put in each asset class and
how to split it up within each class.
For example, diversification might suggest you have 75 percent of
your assets in stocks. Asset allocation takes that total investment in
stocks and structures the percentage of domestic, foreign, growth, value,
and so on.
Some market professionals don’t make a distinction between diver-
sification and asset allocation. You may read information about diversifi-
cation that sounds just like what this book says about asset allocation. The
specific terms are less important than the strategy behind them.
INVESTING IN HISTORY
There is no shortage of market soothsayers quick to tell you how you
should have profited in the latest market move. Clearly, it’s easy to know
where to invest in the historical market: When the Nasdaq was up 87-plus
percent in one year, where should you have invested your money?
Of course, that’s not the whole picture. Imagine that the 87-plus
percent increase occurred in one 12-month period and had a straight-line
growth rate from the beginning to the end. A graph would show the line
originating at the bottom left and going straight across to the top right,
as shown here. Almost any point along that line would have been an okay
place to buy because the market was always going up.
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
100 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
The following graph shows the same final result: The market ended up 87
for the year. However, there was only a brief period at the beginning of
the year when you could get in for less than 87. Any other entry point
and you would have broken even, at best, unless you sold before the year
was out.
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
Looking back, it’s easy to see where you should have entered the market.
The same strategy would not have worked for both markets represented
by the two charts. Unfortunately, you can’t invest in history, and neither
chart tells us anything about how the next year is going to look.
Although these charts are obviously for illustration, they make a
point: The market doesn’t move in a straight line like the first chart. The
following chart is very real. It shows the closing of the Nasdaq Compos-
ite Index on the first day of trading of each year. Of course, with just three
data points, we do get straight lines. The point is that your entry and exit
points determine how much you make or lose.
This looks so simple—and that’s the danger of dealing with historical
numbers. The market almost doubles in one year, then loses all its gains
in the next year. Actually, it was even worse than that. On March 10,
2000, the Nasdaq closed at 5048. In the last nine months of 2000, the
Nasdaq Composite lost 2757 points, almost 55 percent. This chart should
be a sobering reminder to those who thought the market could go no-
where but up forever.
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N 101
Nasdaq Composite
4500
4131
4000
3500
3000
2500
1500
(Source: Nasdaq)
1000
500
0
1999 2000 2001
If you had the time, patience, and data, you could construct a bear-proof
marketing plan for this time frame—but we aren’t going to see this mar-
ket again. And in the unlikely event that we did see this market again, you
wouldn’t know it until it was already over. Looking at historical data can
help you understand how different asset classes perform under different
circumstances, but it’s impossible to know when those circumstances will
appear again.
days, so he knew what he was doing. We worked on our hitting for sev-
eral weeks, and his instruction took hold.
My batting average that year was a league-leading .797. For you non-
baseball fans, a .300 batting average is good for professionals. Another way
to look at it is for every 10 times I came to bat, I got a hit eight times.
The professional had taught me to focus on just making contact
with the ball. That season I never hit a home run, and I had only one
triple. In fact, most of my hits were singles. The point is that my “un-
spectacular” year was the best in the league, because I focused on small
gains rather than large ones.
The analogy isn’t perfect, but the lesson is right on: Aim for better-
than-average gains, and over the long term you have a much better chance
for success than trying to hit a home run every time. Market timers swing
for home runs. Investors focus on their long-term success.
Tip
Your financial goals will require different asset-allocation models. Don’t
be concerned if one model is radically different from the others because
of the time involved.
Many investors have more than one financial goal (I assume retirement is
a common goal). College for the kids, a vacation home, or other goals will
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N 103
need their own asset allocation because of the time frame and definable
financial needs. Let’s look at these variables individually.
RISK TOLERANCE
Risk tolerance describes an investor’s willingness to take risks with invest-
ments. Higher-risk investments should offer higher potential returns than
low-risk products, and with the higher potential return comes the possi-
bility of a larger loss if things go badly. There’s nothing wrong with hav-
ing a small percentage of your portfolio in higher-risk products, but
there’s no rule that says you have to.
The meltdown of the Nasdaq and Internet/tech stocks that began in
the spring of 2000 illustrates an important point about risk tolerance: A
super-heated bull market masks high-risk investments. The market al-
lowed investors who normally would avoid stocks with huge P/E ratios to
convince themselves the stocks were really not that risky. When the mar-
ket started crumbling, investors couldn’t believe the bull run was over and
ignored normal sell indicators, hoping the market would reverse course
and return to previous heights and beyond. Investors with large positions
in this sector saw their holdings vaporize and were tempted to take even
greater risks to get back their lost wealth.
Of course, the market didn’t force investors to do any of these
things. That is why in Chapters 7, “When It’s Time to Sell a Stock,” and
8, “When It’s Time to Sell a Mutual Fund,” we discussed the importance
of planning your exit and sticking to your plan. A well-thought-out asset-
allocation plan places you in investments that meet your risk-tolerance
levels. Plan your exit strategy in advance, and avoid the emotional traps
of dealing with a loss.
TIME HORIZON
Another critical factor in your asset-allocation plan is the time horizon
you have to meet your financial goal. Your time horizon and risk toler-
ance work together to give you an indication of which investments are ap-
propriate and which are not. As we saw in Chapter 1, bear markets can
last months if not years. It may take the market years to recover ground
lost in a bear market.
104 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Caution
Time can be your best friend in investing because it compounds its
power. However, it can work against you if a rapidly approaching fi-
nancial goal is threatened.
Tip
The increased life span modern medicine is giving us has radically
changed and will continue to change many of the social and financial
structures of our society. For example, longevity is a major reason Social
Security is threatened.
Yes, you might miss some of the big rallies, but you’ll stay above the deep
valleys—at least that’s the goal. As you approach some financial goal,
think about how to protect those funds. Chapter 13, “Age-Appropriate
Strategies,” focuses more on the issue of using asset allocation later in life.
Caution
It is not unheard of for market professionals to suggest that asset alloca-
tion is unnecessary. What they mean is if you do nothing else but watch
the market all day, and have been doing it for 30 years, you probably can
get by without asset allocation. For the rest of us, it’s extremely important.
Another approach to finding the right mix is more concerned with the re-
lationship between aggressive investments and conservative investments.
This makes a lot of sense when some bond types act more aggressively
than stocks at times. The general rule is that individual stocks are more
risky than bonds, which are more risky than cash, but there’s less truth to
that statement than some want to admit.
It may be easier for you to think in terms of more or less aggressive,
or you may find the percentages work better. Either way, your asset-
allocation plan needs to reflect a degree of risk that is comfortable for you
and appropriate for your financial goals.
For example, if you were carrying 75 percent stocks before the Nas-
daq collapsed, you may find that your stock percentage is 60 percent or
less. When this happens, it’s time to rebalance your portfolio. You can do
this one of several ways:
■ Add money to stocks. This is easy if you have the extra cash avail-
able to bring up the percentage by buying more stocks.
■ Sell some bonds to reduce its percentage, and use the cash to raise
the percentage of stocks.
■ If you include cash in your mix, use some of it to purchase stocks.
If you sell some bonds and use the money to buy stocks, be careful of the
tax implications. Taxes aren’t an issue if you’re trading in a retirement ac-
count, but if not, look for bonds or bond funds with a loss or the small-
est gain to reduce your tax hit.
If mutual funds are part of your portfolio (and they should be),
make sure you don’t defeat yourself by buying funds that buy the same
stocks. Two different funds with “growth” in their names may have very
different investment styles; even worse, two funds may sound completely
different but are investing in the same stocks. Your goal of diversification
is defeated when this happens. Morningstar.com assigns mutual funds to
specific categories based on what the fund actually buys, rather than its
name, so that’s a good place to check. You can go even deeper and look at
the major holdings of each fund to see if there is any overlap.
CONCLUSION
The right asset allocation for you is a combination of your tolerance for
risk and your time horizon to reach a financial goal.
Asset allocation will not guarantee you a profit or prevent a loss, but
it will help you achieve reasonable goals in unstable markets and is your
best protection against a bear market.
CHAPTER 10
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N
IN A RECESSION
BEAR MARKET
RECESSIONS
A recession is negative economic growth for two consecutive quar-
ters. The economic indicators we looked at in Chapter 4, “Eco-
nomic Indicators,” can point to signs of a slowdown in economic
110 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
growth that will affect future earnings. To the stock market, however,
those indicators are just a record of the past—it’s more concerned with
how bad news from economic indicators is going to shape the future.
When economists officially proclaim a recession, it’s like closing the
barn door after the cows get out. Whether a slowdown technically quali-
fies as a recession doesn’t really matter to investors, except that use of the
“R” word tends to further erode consumer confidence.
Caution
There’s an old saying in the stock market that the majority is wrong
most of the time. You might also say that when the herd starts moving
in one direction, it’s hard to change course. No one wants to be a party
pooper when things are going well, despite signs that the party is about
to end—then suddenly, everyone leaves at once.
SLOWING GROWTH
The gross national product is the sum of all goods and services produced
by the country. When this measure declines for two consecutive quarters,
economists announce that we are in a recession.
When the market for goods and services is contracting, businesses
don’t grow as fast (if at all) as in an expanding economy. Investors are always
buying either future growth or earnings. A company that has been growing
at 20 percent per year might only achieve 10 percent growth thanks to a
contracting economy. This slowing growth rate will usually lower stock
prices.
Companies that produce discretionary (nonessential) consumer
items are among the first hit. Other casualties include companies that pro-
vide goods and services to other companies and the more risky, smaller
companies. Generally, companies involved in staples, like food, hold up
better than the market. People don’t stop buying toilet paper during a
recession.
INFLATION CONCERNS
Inflation may or may not accompany a recession. In fact, as we’ll see later
in the chapter, inflation can lead the economy into a recession. Neither
inflation nor its cure (higher interest rates) are good for the stock market.
Inflation concerns mean interest-rate hikes are likely, which isn’t good for
business or the stock market. Increased borrowing expense directly affects
earnings and growth.
Bonds also tend to do poorly in periods of rising interest rates.
Other interest-rate sensitive sectors include financial services, construc-
tion, and manufacturing concerns. Mutual funds that focus on hard as-
sets like real estate may do better than the rest of the market during
periods of rising inflation.
RISING UNEMPLOYMENT
As businesses slow down in response to the economy, companies lay off
workers and create fewer new jobs. Rising unemployment isn’t always a
bad thing from the employer’s point of view. It means there may be more
potential employees for those companies still expanding, and wages are
driven down by the demand for jobs.
112 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Companies like computer makers rely on business expansion to create
demand for their product. When things begin to slow, this business
model suffers almost immediately.
Tip
Investors used to consider utilities to be stable, conservative investments
that paid dividends, but were otherwise boring. Don’t make that as-
sumption anymore. Deregulation and other market forces have changed
the face of some utilities dramatically. Bad business decisions make some
utilities risky investments at best.
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N I N A R E C E S S I O N B E A R M A R K E T 113
Tip
Active investors love to trade. However, for most of us we simply don’t
have the time or expertise to be active traders, so it’s better to buy and
hold or leave the trading to mutual fund managers.
You set sell points at some level above your purchase price and the mar-
ket price. If you are optimistic about the market and economy, set the sell
points fairly high. Once you see the economy heading south, move your
sell points just under the market price to protect any profits in the in-
vestment.
This may sound easy, but it’s not. Most investors who try this strat-
egy will be worse off at the end of the bear market than when they started.
You’ll either bail out too early and miss more growth or stay too late and
find others looking for safety have already bid up the defensive stocks you
wanted.
As you can tell, I’m not a big fan of this strategy. It’s too reliant on
you correctly predicting a bear market recession. What if the recession de-
velops, but the bear market doesn’t? You also have to consider the possi-
bility that a bear market will precede a recession.
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N I N A R E C E S S I O N B E A R M A R K E T 115
A DEFENSIVE STRATEGY
There are always analysts who are sure a bear market is around every cor-
ner, and with signs of a recession on the horizon, they will run for cover.
They suggest you adopt a permanent “prepare for the worst” portfolio an-
ticipating a recession bear market.
A defensive strategy would focus on traditionally more stable
income-producing investments such as utilities, bonds, and preferred
stock. Growth investments would only occupy a small portion of the total
portfolio.
Tip
The object of investing is to make your money work for you. You are
generally better off in the end staying in the market than jumping in
and out of investments.
Caution
Timing is always a critical consideration in asset allocation. Two people
may approach the same problem with entirely different solutions based
solely on the difference in time horizons.
A REASONABLE APPROACH
Asset allocation is about planning your participation in the market. That
plan needs to include contingencies for dealing with a weakening econ-
omy and a bear market to accompany it.
Throughout the rest of this book, we will discuss specific recom-
mendations and ideas about asset allocation for a number of different cir-
cumstances. For now, let’s stay with the philosophical for a short time
more.
Earlier, I said that you could visualize asset allocation as a knob,
which you could turn from more to less aggressive (or the other way). It’s
the same visualization for dealing with a bear market and a recession. You
will want to move from a more aggressive stance to a less aggressive stance.
If you can do that before the market gets ugly, you will go a long way to-
ward protecting your position.
Tip
Actively trading in a nonqualified account may generate more costs in
commissions and taxes than it saves. Be careful that you don’t give all of
your profits to the government.
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N I N A R E C E S S I O N B E A R M A R K E T 117
CONCLUSION
Finding what works in a recession bear market is not easy. An aggressive
strategy might hurt more than it helps, and a conservative strategy may
not help enough.
Common sense may suggest the best strategy is to do nothing.
However, given the length of some bear markets that may not be as safe
as it may sounds.
CHAPTER 11
A S S E T A L L O C AT I O N
I N I N F L AT I O N A N D
D E F L AT I O N B E A R
MARKETS
DEFINING INFLATION
When we think of inflation, we see rising prices and interest rates. You
often hear inflation discussed in terms of the rising prices of goods. In
truth, the value of goods does not rise, but the value of money declines
because it takes more money to buy the same item. We talk about inter-
est rates and rising prices, but you don’t hear much about the root cause
of inflation: too much money chasing too few goods.
Here’s a recent example. Before the dot.coms became dot.bombs,
housing in Silicon Valley was at a premium. The tremendous growth of
Internet/tech companies in the area caused a dramatic rise in housing
prices. Houses weren’t for sale, they were up for bid—sellers were in the
enviable position of having buyers try to outbid one another. It wasn’t un-
common for a modest house to sell for several hundred thousand dollars
over the asking price.
That’s inflation. Too much money chasing too few houses caused a
tremendous increase in prices. The house’s value continues to skyrocket,
and it takes more money to buy it. Inflation causes things, especially hard
assets like real estate and gold, to become more valuable than money.
Inflation is great if you are selling real estate, but it’s not so great for
everyone else. Consider the bank lending money to a customer for a new
car. If inflation continues, the money the customer pays back to the bank
is worth less than when the bank lent it. The bank attempts to compen-
sate by charging higher interest rates on its loans. That may discourage
some buyers from borrowing.
Caution
Whether it is real estate, stocks, or Beanie Babies, any item bid up in
price beyond a sustainable level is bound to fall eventually.
This is what the Fed does when it raises interest rates to cool rising infla-
tion. Higher rates mean fewer people are borrowing and there is less
money chasing goods. Higher interest rates effectively take money out of
the market.
ASSET ALLOCATION IN INFLATION AND DEFLATION MARKETS 121
DEFINING DEFLATION
If inflation causes the value of money to fall, then deflation should cause
the value of money to rise. That doesn’t seem like a bad thing, but the re-
sult is dramatically falling prices. When there is too little money chasing
too many goods, prices drop. Deflation officially occurs when prices fall
enough to cause a sustained decline in the Consumer Price Index (CPI)—
although some observers believe the CPI is hopelessly flawed and isn’t
valid as a measure to predict the immediate future. Companies slash
prices to move goods, which squeezes profit margins. The more goods a
company produces, the worse the situation becomes.
Caution
When our money becomes more valuable, the prices of foreign goods
drop dramatically. If they flood the market, domestic competitors may
face dramatic reversals.
Tip
Pundits are fond of saying a market crash like the one that preceded the
Great Depression can’t happen again. However, we have seen several in-
stances where prices have declined dramatically in a short period.
122 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
RECENT INFLATION
Earlier I noted that the Fed is not responsible for the stock market. That’s
true, but it doesn’t mean the Fed is unconcerned with the market. Dur-
ing the height of the late-1990s bull market, the Fed raised interest rates
six times in order to cool off the economy. The Fed attempted to take
money out of the economy by discouraging borrowing.
One factor the Fed considered before raising interest rates was the
incredible “wealth effect” created by the exploding Internet/tech stocks.
During the last few years of the bull market, companies were issuing IPOs
like there was no tomorrow. Companies that a few months earlier had
been an idea on a bar napkin suddenly had market caps in the hundreds
of millions of dollars. Some soared into the billions of dollars as their
stock went from, for example, $25 per share to $125 per share almost
overnight. Employees, directors, and investors held options for tens of
thousands of shares at pennies per share.
Caution
Although there has been a tremendous shakeout in the Internet/tech
sector stocks, don’t dismiss the survivors out of hand. Some of them
could be the leaders in the next bull market.
Imagine that one day you’re sleeping in your clothes because you’ve been
working around the clock to launch a new Internet product or service,
and the next day you’re worth $300 million dollars. The company you
started has a market cap in the billions of dollars, and it has never gener-
ated a nickel of revenue. That’s the wealth effect, and it’s very inflation-
ary. The people who bid for houses have the wealth effect.
ASSET ALLOCATION IN INFLATION AND DEFLATION MARKETS 123
RECENT DEFLATION
Can you see what’s coming? When the Nasdaq cratered beginning in
March 2000, the Internet “bubble” burst in a rather dramatic fashion.
The market lost over 57 percent of its value in one year. For many of the
dot.coms it was even worse. Many lost up to 90 percent of their value,
and some just disappeared.
When the Nasdaq loses 57 percent of its value, it’s a huge sum of
money. Where did it go? It vaporized. To get an idea of how much value
vaporized, consider the Nasdaq 100 Index, which is 100 of the top Nas-
daq stocks. In a one-year period beginning in early 2000, the companies
represented in the index lost $2.2 trillion in value (market capitalization).
You could argue that that wasn’t “real” money but paper profits that
were unrealized. That’s not really material to this discussion. The stock
had value, and stockholders expressed that value in dollars. When in-
vestors challenged that value, they began a panicked retreat from stock to
cash. The turn from boom to bust represents a turn from acquiring stock
at almost any cost (inflation) to selling stock at any price (deflation).
Tip
The huge amount of wealth created in the Internet/tech boom was
much more than paper profits. If you sold before the bust, you got real
money; some employees who held certain classes of options had to pay
taxes on them even if they were unexercised.
The Fed lowered interest rates twice in January 2001 with more cuts
hinted in the near future. If raising interest rates keeps inflation under
124 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Whether the government declares the official beginning of inflation or
deflation is of little importance. Investors can feel the bad effects of the
two conditions without any official declaration.
Unfortunately, even the large cap stocks may not keep up with inflation,
which was the case in the late 1970s. The rate of inflation and how
quickly it appears also contribute to the success or failure of your strat-
egy. Plan for a long-term return, because in the short-run, few common
stocks are going to outperform inflation.
ASSET ALLOCATION IN INFLATION AND DEFLATION MARKETS 125
Bonds are particularly at risk in inflation, mainly for the high inter-
est rates and reduced earnings power. The interest rate a bond pays will
soon be uncompetitive if newer bonds boast a higher rate.
For example, say you bought a $10,000 bond paying six percent in-
terest at maturity. At maturity, the issuer pays you $10,600. However, in-
flation was 4 percent for the year; so instead of getting back $10,600, you
actually receive $10,176 in purchasing power.
Bond price: $10,000
Interest: $600
Due at maturity: $10,600
Less 4% inflation: ($424)
Value of cash return: $10,176
Buyer’s return: 1.76%
Now, suppose you wanted to sell the bond after one year on the open
market. Inflation has driven up interest rates and eaten into the return. To
sell this bond, you will have to discount it so the buyer’s return takes into
account the higher interest rates and diminished purchasing power. In-
stead of selling the bond for $10,000, you can only get $9,000.
Bond price: $9,000
Interest: $600
Due at maturity: $10,600
Less 4% inflation: ($424)
Value of cash return: $10,176
Buyer’s return: 11.95%
Discounting the bond’s price from $10,000 to $9,000 raises the actual re-
turn to 11.95 percent. The amount of loss to inflation is the same for
both because it is on the bond’s face value and interest. The “value of cash
return” is what you receive at the bond’s maturity from the issuer, so it re-
mains the same. The buyer’s return is what the holder receives less the lost
purchasing power from inflation.
126 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Gold has been a traditional safe haven from inflation. In the 1970s and
1980s, many people bought actual gold bullion or coins. However, don’t
assume that a hard asset like gold or real estate will hold its value when
inflation subsides—in most cases it won’t.
In Chapter 12, “Bear-Proof Assets,” we will look at specific tips and tools
for investing during an inflation bear market.
Caution
Avoid borrowing during a deflationary period if possible. You will be re-
paying the debt with money that is worth more than when you bor-
rowed it.
you receive at maturity are worth more over time. Let’s look at our bond
example from the inflation section.
In the deflation scenario, the value of the bond increases, thanks to
money buying more than in the past and interest rates falling if you hold
it to maturity.
Bond price: $10,000
Interest: $600
Due at maturity: $10,600
Less 4% inflation: ($424)
Value of cash return: $11,024
Buyer’s return: 10.24%
Your actual return in terms of buying power is boosted by the 4.24 per-
cent deflation factor (6% + 4.24% = 10.24%). This is a dramatic illus-
tration of the effect deflation would have on the market. Anyone with
cash to lend could command the best deals. Obviously, the interest rate
on new bonds would drop to something less than 6 percent.
Let’s continue our example and look at selling the bond during de-
flation. The assumption is that you bought this bond in a “normal” mar-
ket and six percent was a reasonable return. Falling interest rates to
combat the deflation raise the value of this bond by increasing its sale
price in the secondary market.
Bond price: $10,500
Interest: $600
Due at maturity: $10,600
Less 4% inflation: ($424)
Value of cash return: $11,024
Buyer’s return: 4.99%
In this case, the buyer on the secondary market might settle for this in-
terest rate knowing that deflation was adding 4 percent per year to the
value of her cash return.
128 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
CONCLUSION
Bear markets brought on by either inflation or deflation are devastating
to the economy and the stock market. Both represent a weakness in our
monetary system. In other countries that have faced these two challenges,
economies have crumbled under the distrust this weakness generates.
Distrust in the money system is dangerous. Investors face the
quandary of where to put their money so that it is safe. Hoard money
during inflation and it will lose its value. Invest your money during de-
flation and what you buy will be worth less tomorrow than it is today.
In Chapter 12, we are going to look at a number of financial sce-
narios and examine what products work best in those circumstances.
CHAPTER 12
BEAR-PROOF
ASSETS
Investing is about uncertainty. You don’t know for sure what the
stock market is going to do next year, next month, next week, or
even tomorrow. Unless you are 100 percent invested in U.S. Trea-
sury Bonds, there are virtually no guarantees on the future value of
your holdings.
Your goal as an investor is to put together a portfolio that of-
fers the best possible return for today’s market and tomorrow’s
uncertainty. This means you need to understand how certain in-
vestments normally fare in different market conditions. For exam-
ple, how will stocks, bonds, and cash react to an expanding market?
What can you expect if the market is contracting?
In the interest of full disclosure, the title of this chapter is
more marketing than factual. There is no way to completely protect
your portfolio from the ravages of a bear market and still stay in-
vested. Hiding places may be hard to find in the midst of a reces-
sion marked by high inflation and interest rates. Investors in the
“super bear” market of 1973 and 1974 couldn’t find a rock big
enough to hide under for protection. The best they could hope for
was damage control.
This chapter looks at all varieties of investments and how they
might fare in a bear market, to help you decide which tools work
130 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
best for your asset-allocation model. We have seen that bear markets come
in several shapes, so what might work in one bear market won’t do well
in another. A well-diversified portfolio is your best defense.
Caution
No company is immune from the ravages of bear markets and eco-
nomic instability. Some get back on their feet quickly, while others
never seem to recover completely.
When growth stocks don’t grow as fast as the market thinks they
should, stock prices fall. Will Microsoft, Intel, and Cisco Systems be
around after the bear market disappears? Almost certainly; however, they
may not reclaim their place as absolute market leaders.
Plain English
You compute the market capitalization by taking a stock’s price and
multiplying it by the number of outstanding shares. For example, a
company has 1,000,000 shares outstanding and its market price is $100
per share. The market cap is $100 million.
Not all large cap stocks are equal. As we will see in the later discussion of
industry sectors, being large is not always a shield against determined
bears.
132 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
GROWTH STOCKS
Growth stocks are particularly vulnerable during a recession/bear market.
The usual reason for investing in a growth stock is to participate in its fu-
ture growth. When a growth stock quits growing or even slows down, in-
vestors may jump ship for other opportunities. A recession or slowing
economic growth can hurt most growth companies.
The PC industry was facing this problem even before the
Internet/tech bubble burst in the spring of 2000. The computer industry
experienced tremendous early growth; however, once the middle- to
upper-income market was saturated, growth began to slow. Although
prices have dropped dramatically, computers are still a stretch for many
households with modest incomes. There is still good volume in replacing
older computers, but new growth is getting harder and more expensive
(lower prices and margins).
A recession or slowing economic growth gives bears all the incentive
they need to look for safer ground. Just as growth stocks may be the first
hit in a bear market, they often lead the way out. For this reason, investors
must carefully weigh the value of owning the stock through difficult
times. When the bulls return, is this stock going to lead the charge? If you
believe the company is fundamentally sound, you may want to buy more
at a bear market discount. You will learn more about this in Chapter 15,
“Fatten Up on Bear.”
DIVIDEND-PAYING STOCKS
Companies pay dividends based on the performance of the company, not
the stock. Many established large cap stocks pay regular dividends. This
income-producing benefit may make them attractive in bear markets.
Even if the stock has fallen into a bear-market slump, the company will
often continue paying dividends; as a rule, these stocks are less volatile in
good times and in bad.
Inflation is not kind to companies paying dividends, since rising
prices erode the value of the dividend. On the other hand, deflation
makes these stocks especially attractive since the value of money rises in
deflation.
BEAR-PROOF ASSETS 133
VALUE STOCKS
A value stock trades close to its true market value. For example, when
some growth stocks are sporting P/E ratios of 35 and above, a value stock
might come in with a P/E in the low teens.
By definition, value stocks don’t have much of an inflated price and
may not move as much as growth stocks in a bear market. Bear markets,
however, often create value stocks out of growth stocks. It is likely that in
a bear market, you may find some good bargains on stocks that the mar-
ket has treated badly.
Despite their bad reputation, some of the surviving Internet/
tech stocks have moved into the value category from their once lofty and
wildly inflated P/E ratios. Some market watchers were saying in early
2001 that these beaten-up companies deserved a look at their more rea-
sonable valuations.
Tip
Value is in the eye of the beholder. Just because a stock is off by 60 per-
cent doesn’t mean it’s a bargain. You determine valuation by the com-
pany’s fundamentals, not by how far it has fallen.
Tip
Mid cap stocks represent a moderately aggressive investment and should
occupy that spot in your asset-allocation strategy.
Investors looking for safety and stability often dump mid cap stocks in
favor of more secure investments in larger cap stocks or other vehicles,
like bonds. However, investors face the same question as holders of large
cap growth stocks. Will the underlying causes of the bear market perma-
nently injure the company, or does it have the resources to catch an up-
turn?
Your personal investment situation and asset-allocation model will
help you decide on the risk of riding out a bear market. If you are con-
cerned about an approaching bear market or conditions that suggest a
slowdown in the economy, you may want to think carefully about how
much of your portfolio is in mid cap stocks.
Caution
Mid cap companies are vulnerable to a takeover during a bear market or
if the business is threatened by a sour economy.
Tip
Small cap stocks offer the possibility of significant growth along with
the corresponding danger of significant loss.
Small cap stocks are highly speculative under almost any circumstance.
You should carefully evaluate their place in your portfolio relative to your
tolerance for risk and time horizon.
FOREIGN STOCKS
It is easier to invest in foreign companies now because more information
is available, and most investment professionals believe foreign stocks have
a place in every well-diversified portfolio after core investments are in
place.
BEAR-PROOF ASSETS 137
BONDS
Bonds are traditional core investments used to add stability to the volatil-
ity of stocks in portfolio. Bonds are more conservative than stocks because
of their fixed return and guaranteed principal in some cases. U.S. Treasury
issues are the most secure investment because they are backed by the “full
faith and credit” of the U.S. government. Later in the book, when we dis-
cuss specific asset-allocation strategies, you will see the key role bonds play
in the process.
Tip
Bonds appear boring to many investors because they lack the sense of ur-
gency stocks have based on how the media reacts. Interestingly enough,
there is more money in the bond market than the stock market.
Caution
Bonds are not as easy to research and trade as stocks. If you are going to
actively trade bonds, you may want to seek the help of a professional.
The longer term the bond has, the higher the coupon or interest rate will
be. This is because, over time, interest rates are likely to rise and force the
bondholder to sell at a discount to be competitive. In Chapter 5, “Mar-
ket Indicators,” we discussed the problems with selling bonds in a period
of rising interest rates.
You can approach bonds from two directions. First, you can be an
active trader, buying and selling them on the open market. In this sce-
nario, the bond’s price relates to its coupon interest rate and the prevail-
ing market interest rates for the same type of bond.
Second, you can buy bonds with the notion of holding them until
maturity. This takes the fluctuation out of the picture because you are
more concerned with receiving your full principal at maturity on a spe-
cific date. This strategy is common when investors need a certain sum of
money at a specific time (for college tuition, say). When you employ this
strategy, you are not concerned with the market fluctuation. Your concern
is having money available when you need it.
You are better off establishing a minimum bond presence in your
portfolio and adding to it if economic and market conditions call for
more protection. When we look at specific strategies later, you will see
how timing bonds’ maturities can add a new dimension to your portfolio.
MUTUAL FUNDS
Mutual funds, except for sector and other specialized funds, tend to be
more stable than individual stocks because of their diversification. The
operative word here is diversification, because you can’t always assume
you are buying a diversified portfolio in a particular mutual fund.
A large cap stock fund loaded with technology stock is not going to
perform the same way as a large cap stock fund that truly spreads invest-
ments across several industry segments. We have already noted that you
can’t always judge mutual funds by their names. You should look into
Morningstar.com for information about what the fund actually holds, in-
stead of what the name implies.
BEAR-PROOF ASSETS 139
Index funds, especially those targeting major indexes like the S&P
500, are down in a bear market and back up when the tide turns. They
are a way through bear markets with some assurance they will follow the
market up.
Bear markets offer an attractive dollar cost–averaging opportunity to
the committed index fund investor. If individual stocks post peaks and val-
leys of performance, diversified stock mutual funds tend to be rolling hills.
BOND FUNDS
Bond funds are popular with investors for many of the same reasons eq-
uity funds are popular. They offer professional management and diversi-
fication. In the case of bonds, mutual funds are much easier to buy and
sell than individual bonds. Bond funds may be an attractive safe haven in
bear markets, but if you need a specific sum of money at a specific time,
you should consider individual bonds.
Because bond funds buy issues with different maturities, you cannot
count on them to return your principal intact on the date you need it.
Tip
Mutual funds come in many varieties and attempt to address many dif-
ferent investment needs. There is a danger in trying to micro-manage
your portfolio by loading up with very specialized funds. Most invest-
ment professionals caution that owning too many funds is overkill.
HYBRID FUNDS
Hybrid or balanced funds invest in both stocks and bonds, as well as cash
instruments. They spread money across all three areas and move it around
as market conditions suggest.
For example, if technology stocks are hot, the fund will move money
out of bonds and cash and into hot stocks. Likewise, they may take a more
conservative stance if stocks are weak and the market uncertain.
Hybrid funds have differing approaches, so make sure you know
what the fund manager’s strategy is before you invest. One of the negatives
about investing in hybrid funds is they can run up some significant fees
and taxes.
140 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
BEAR FUNDS
It might not surprise you to know there are mutual funds designed to
deal with bear markets. These funds employ a variety of strategies to
move in the opposite direction of a bear market. The fund managers use
tools like shorting stocks that they believe will decline in a bear market.
They may also short index futures and other derivatives. The downside
with these funds is they have a bad habit of missing the boat when the
market turns upward.
Caution
There are no magic funds that are going to protect you completely from
a bear market. Common sense and a well-diversified portfolio are always
your best defense.
BEAR-PROOF ASSETS 141
SECTORS
I’m from Texas, so believe me when I say size matters. However, it is not
the only consideration. Industry segment is also important. A company
in the “wrong” industry segment or sector is also likely to fall during a
bear attack on other members of the segment.
Industry segments such as technology, durable goods, real estate,
and so on behave differently in a bear market. The proper mix in your
asset-allocation plan is a big step toward bear-proofing your portfolio.
Caution
Predicting a sector’s performance during a bear market is not a sure
thing. Underlying economic factors can change predicable behavior.
Investors traditionally look to some sectors for shelter during bear mar-
kets and unstable economies. These are general guidelines only; bear at-
tacks can take many forms, and a sector may not always respond the way
you think it should. There are many segments, but most market observers
cluster them into just a handful for convenience. These include …
■ Consumer durable goods. This sector includes major appliances
and items with an expected life of more than three years. It will
suffer in a prolonged recession marked by high interest rates.
■ Nondurable goods (staples). This sector includes food, clothing,
and other items necessary for daily life, which are consumed im-
mediately or have only a short period of usefulness. This has been
a favorite hideout because it seldom suffers dramatically in a re-
cession.
■ Energy. Energy is a very volatile sector, in part because foreign in-
cause they flow with the economy. When the economy is down,
they will be among the first to fall.
■ Services. Services have become a huge part of our economy. It’s
investors. For the most part, they are stable, solid companies that
pay handsome dividends. Today, some of these same conservative
utilities are venturing into a variety of other businesses (telecom-
munications, for example). Others are facing deregulation and a
variety of new competitors that didn’t exist before. If you include
the telecoms in this sector (as opposed to technology), you’re look-
ing at a group of highly leveraged companies that have expanded
at breakneck speed, primarily on debt. Not the safest place to be.
■ Healthcare. Healthcare firms have ridden the market up and
down, but if you’re looking for stability, look elsewhere. Rising
costs that are outpacing payments put healthcare providers in
tough circumstances.
■ Retail sales. Retail sales are not the place to avoid bad economic
news. Even though people still buy items, recessions tend to take
the confidence out of buyers.
Caution
Investing in sectors, whether through mutual funds or individual stocks,
can be dangerous. That strategy defeats the purpose of diversification.
Sector investing is a high-risk maneuver.
BEAR-PROOF ASSETS 143
BEAR ATTACKS
Although bears sometimes attack the whole market, they are often more
selective, picking out a particular sector to ravage. The bears attacked the
Internet/tech sector in the spring of 2000, which led to a widespread bear
attack on most of the market.
Morningstar.com has an interactive chart on the lead page of their
stock research. This chart tracks several indicators and one of them is 10
sectors they follow. In March 2001, I set the time frame on the chart for
one year and looked at their sectors. Each of them was up, except for tech-
nology, which was down 50-plus percent for the 12-month period. This
shows how the broad market remained up even though it was declining
toward the end of 2000, while technology was in a nosedive.
When I change the time frame to “year-to-date,” all of the sectors
are down except consumer durables. This indicates a general decline in
the market consistent with a broad-based bear attack.
CONCLUSION
Stocks and bonds react differently to a variety of economic and market
uncertainties. There is not always a clear strategy that will work every
time. It is important to understand the basis for the bear market. Infla-
tion often draws interest rate hikes while deflation and a general eco-
nomic downturn usually indicate interest-rate cuts are coming.
Certain sectors are safer havens than others are. Your best defense is
always a well-diversified portfolio.
PA R T 4
BEAR TRACKING
Part 4 looks at how investors can devise strategies for making age-
appropriate decisions about bear market protection. People are liv-
ing longer, and some of the old rules about asset allocation haven’t
kept up with the times.
We will also look at how to deal with the need to park cash or
meet short-term goals. A short-time horizon is the riskiest of all in-
vestment problems. If you’re too conservative, you may not meet
your goal; however, if you’re too aggressive, the bears may make you
sorry.
Bear markets can also be an opportunity to pick up some bar-
gains when the bears hammer basically sound stocks along with
everything else. This gets dangerously close to market timing, so
beware.
CHAPTER 13
A G E - A P P R O P R I AT E
S T R AT E G I E S
The second rule suggests that a person approaching retirement should re-
treat into very conservative investments. Although it’s appropriate to back
off some aggressive investing patterns as retirement approaches, it’s possi-
ble to be too conservative and risk outliving your money. A person retir-
ing at age 65 could easily live another 15 to 20 years or more. That could
be a long retirement to fund, especially considering that the cost of living
will continue to rise.
We have seen how bear markets can be vicious and prolonged. Pro-
tecting against such an attack becomes more important as we approach
major financial goals.
thing, but it also poses serious investment problems. The biggest problem
is how to protect your portfolio from bear markets and economic uncer-
tainty and not run out of money before your hourglass runs out of sand.
Bears love old people because they are so vulnerable. Older people don’t
have the time: the weapon that bears can’t defeat.
Some people address this issue by working after retirement. They
may take a part-time job or do consulting work to keep some cash com-
ing in. This extra income supplements retirement benefits and may mean
they don’t have to reach into the principal as quickly. A second group of
retirees has moved past the age when work is an option. They are living
exclusively on retirement benefits, such as a pension and Social Security.
Both groups have concerns about their retirement portfolio, however they
address them.
On the other end of the spectrum are young people just getting
started in their careers. They may be married or will be shortly. Retire-
ment is many years away. They’re more concerned with building a fam-
ily, buying a house, and all the other trappings of adulthood.
Bears love young people because they can be too aggressive on short-
term goals and step in a bear trap just before they need the money for a
down payment.
■ Each age group has four models: three for your investment port-
folio and the other for your retirement portfolio, which will be
conservative by definition.
■ The assets are heavily weighted toward mutual funds because I be-
lieve most people don’t have the time, patience, or interest to buy
individual stocks. If you would rather buy individual stocks, use
the fund definitions to guide you toward the correct equities.
■ I include a cash component, which can be a money market ac-
count, money market mutual fund, bank certificate of deposit, or
other instrument.
You can “tune” the plans to be more or less aggressive to your own tastes.
The age groupings are arbitrary; feel free to judge whether you belong in
a higher or lower group depending on your own situation. As we work
through the age groups, I will include any additional information that is
particular to that group but may not apply to all age groups.
This is not an exact science and is subject to much interpretation.
Any two financial advisers might suggest two different plans. Some ad-
visers don’t include a cash component, but I believe people tend to ignore
the need for emergency cash unless you build it into an overall plan.
These decisions will build habits that, if you stick to them, will almost
guarantee you a nice retirement nest egg and an embarrassingly high net
worth before you reach age 50.
If your employer offers a 401(k) or other similar retirement program,
commit to participating at the maximum or as close to it as possible. If
your employer has a matching program, absolutely participate in the plan
A G E - A P P R O P R I AT E S T R AT E G I E S 151
to the limit of the matching dollars. This is the best investment deal you
will ever find that doesn’t involve the risk of jail time.
At the same time, begin an investment program that automatically
deducts a specific amount from your checking account every month and
invests it in a mutual fund. Put $50 a month into a mutual fund and in
30 years you will have over $140,000 (before taxes and assuming the 11
percent historical rate of return by the market). The best part of this is if
you start now, you will never miss the money out of your budget. Every
time you get a raise, bonus, tax refund, or other income boost, put all or
part of it in your investment account.
At this age, you really don’t have to worry too much about bear mar-
kets. You have plenty of time to recover from any downturns. However,
you may want to consider some protection if market or economic condi-
tions look threatening.
Here are some models to fit different investors. Obviously, if you’re
just getting started, it will take a while to put this mix together. How-
ever, if you start early, you could have a large investment and consider-
ably more in your retirement fund. If your employer does not offer a
401(k) or similar program, start an IRA fund and put some extra in your
investment account. Remember, these are just to get you started and are
not written in stone.
The four models suggest a way to allocate your assets based on how
conservative or aggressive (risk-tolerant) you are in investing.
The Regular model shows your assets spread over several instruments with
varying degrees of aggressiveness. The idea is to balance your portfolio
with holdings in different asset classes. This is a modestly aggressive
model, appropriate for a young adult with many years of investing to
come.
The Conservative model drops the two most aggressive assets, the
aggressive growth fund and individual stocks, in favor of more money in
cash and a significant investment in short-term bonds. This is a very con-
servative model for a young person, but if it helps you sleep at night, it’s
worth it. The downside is that if inflation returns with higher interest
rates, the bonds will suffer.
The Aggressive model puts 65 percent of its assets into the aggres-
sive growth fund and individual stocks. You could argue that this model
doesn’t go far enough in its aggressiveness. The downside is obvious: A
bear market will eat this portfolio alive.
The Retirement model splits between growth (the aggressive growth
fund and growth fund) and a market-following index fund. Some would
consider this model too conservative for a young person. It is also unlikely
a person in this age range invests just for retirement, but I included it to
give you an idea of how a retirement account might be allocated separate
from other investments.
The Regular model for this age group spreads out the portfolio over more
assets and is more conservative than the 20 to 30 Regular model. I added
a growth fund and reduced the aggressive growth fund percentage. Stocks
remain the same, but I reduced the cash to reflect a more appropriate per-
centage of the overall portfolio, which should be quite a bit larger than
the previous age group’s total. I have added medium-term bonds, which
are moderately aggressive and may take advantage of falling or stable in-
terest rates.
The Conservative model remains unchanged from the previous age
group. It still reflects the position that a bear market will damage your
growth fund more than the market as a whole. Leaving the growth fund
in the portfolio gives you some upside over the index fund in the event
the bear is weak or doesn’t appear at all.
The Aggressive model reflects a slightly less robust stance by in-
creasing the participation in the index fund and adding long-term bonds
to the mix. The long-term bonds are fairly aggressive—and volatile—in
an environment of changing interest rates. I have eliminated cash from
the portfolio on the theory that you can put it to better use in an aggres-
sive portfolio.
The Retirement model remains conservative; however, I have
dropped the percentage in the aggressive growth fund and added medium-
term bonds for some diversification.
154 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Our Regular model shows a modest shift toward a more conservative pos-
ture. The aggressive growth fund drops and the growth and index funds
increase. I have also increased the medium-term bond percentage. This
portfolio still represents a diversified look at the market but is moving
away from the most aggressive assets and toward those more associated
with the center.
This Conservative model shifts money out of cash and into short-
term bonds. It retains the percentages in the growth and index funds. To
make this model even more conservative, shift more out of the growth
fund and into short-term bonds.
This Aggressive model reflects the need to back off slightly as you
get older. Some might argue that it is still too soon for conservative meas-
ures, but use your own judgment based on your tolerance for risk. This
model differs from the previous age group in that the index fund partici-
pation increases slightly, the aggressive growth fund decreases slightly, and
it moves from the long-term bonds to medium-term bonds.
A G E - A P P R O P R I AT E S T R AT E G I E S 155
which may seem high to some; make an adjustment if you feel this is too
aggressive for your risk-tolerance level.
This Conservative model shows a strong move away from equities
and into bonds. With 40 percent invested in equities, the portfolio still
has some room for growth, but it’s taking root in bonds for stability and
principal protection.
This Aggressive model keeps you in 70 percent aggressive equities
(contrast with the Regular model where the equity investments are much
more conservative). A 30 percent stake in medium-term bonds provides
some stability, although bonds in this maturity range can be volatile.
This mix for a Retirement fund may surprise some of you who ques-
tion 60 percent in equities. However, if you have a normal life span, you’ll
have another 20 to 30 years of living to finance. The bond investments
should provide some stability and, along with the stock income fund,
some current income for reinvestment. The idea here is to build a posi-
tion in income-producing assets to help with post-retirement expenses.
This Regular investment model takes a defensive stance as you enter the
years just preceding your retirement. You have reduced your exposure to
60 percent equities. Your position in bonds is now 35 percent. If you are
nervous about this model’s aggressiveness, reduce your equities and add
the percentage into bonds.
Your Conservative model continues a shift out of equities and into
bonds. Bonds provide a stability that may be reassuring at this point in
life and probably offer the best protection against a bear market.
This Aggressive model takes you out of the aggressive growth fund
and moves you into a regular growth fund. Even though you still may
want to be in the market, it’s time to take your foot off the gas. You’re still
70 percent invested in equities, but they’re more conservative than previ-
ous age groups.
How you configure your Retirement fund will depend on when and
how much you withdraw. This is one suggestion that keeps you in the
stock market.
This is such a complicated area. You will do yourself a great favor by
hiring a professional to construct a plan for withdrawing money from
your various accounts. I suggest a fee-based financial planner who spe-
cializes in retirement, or a CPA.
158 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
AGE SEVENTY-PLUS
From this age on, generalized plans are meaningless. If you haven’t sought
professional counsel before now, please do so soon. There’s no room for
error at this point. A bear market could mean the difference between the
retirement you dreamed of and the retirement from hell.
You worked hard all your life and deserve the best in retirement.
Don’t let a last-minute bear spoil your “golden years.”
CONCLUSION
Constructing model investment and retirement portfolios is an exercise in
suggestions. Temper these suggestions by your tolerance for risk and will-
ingness to monitor your assets.
Five financial professionals can look at the same individual and con-
struct five different plans to protect his or her portfolio from bear mar-
kets. None of them will be necessarily right or wrong, and none of them
can guarantee how they will do in a real bear market. However, if you
don’t make some plans, the bears will eat you alive.
CHAPTER 14
S H O R T- T E R M A N D
MID-TERM
S T R AT E G I E S
The first situation is the easiest since you don’t need to earn any more to
reach your goal. You need a safe place to put the money for a short time.
The second poses a more serious problem: How do you keep building to-
ward your goal and still have some assurance that a bear market isn’t going
to eat your earnings and then some?
Protecting a short-term position is very important. There are nu-
merous examples, including the one at the beginning of this chapter, of
why you can’t afford to take chances with a short-term goal. Never take
for granted that past performance is any indicator of future returns.
Things change and you have to stay informed. You can better meet a pre-
cise financial goal in a short period with a fixed-return instrument.
There is nothing worse than finding out the $20,000 you put into
the market for your daughter’s college tuition is now $16,000. Unfortu-
nately, if you were in the market around the middle of March 2001, that
fund might be even less. You need $20,000 in one year. Where do you
park your money so that you know the full $20,000 will be there? There
are some fairly obvious answers, any of which will work for the short
term:
■ Bank CDs
Tip
Safety and a high rate of return are mutually exclusive. If you want a
high degree of safety, you must settle for lower returns.
Reaching a short-term goal (fewer than five years) is often more an exer-
cise in saving than investing. In any given short period, you face a real
danger of a bear market or major correction.
A number of sites on the Internet offer calculators to help you de-
termine the best path to reach your goal. For example, if you want to save
$6,000 in two years, a calculator at Bankrate.com shows you that at 5 per-
cent interest, you need to deposit $242.96 a month. If you can find a safe
savings instrument that pays more than 5 percent, the calculator will re-
calculate your needed deposit.
162 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
In our situation, we can’t alter the amount of time in the problem; in fact,
time will be working against us. The amount of money for investment
usually has some practical limits based on the priority of the problem.
The rate of return is what we can get from various instruments and is sub-
ject to change beyond our control. Your tolerance for risk and common
sense will prevent you from attempting an exotic solution.
There are three basic ways to accomplish this goal. (The following
examples ignore taxes, fees, and inflation. Obviously, in real life you can’t
ignore them, but for this exercise let’s put them aside for the sake of sim-
plicity. We will also ignore solutions such as home equity loans or other
types of borrowing.)
■ Use a savings account that pays 5 percent interest and make
monthly deposits. This method has the most chance for success.
S H O R T- T E R M A N D M I D - T E R M S T R A T E G I E S 163
Tip
Putting money in a savings account may run counter to all you know
about investing, but some place a higher value on the certainty of sav-
ings accounts than on the need to achieve the maximum return. There’s
nothing wrong with using a savings account when you do so as a con-
scious choice.
stocks. There are also all types of exotic options/futures trading plans.
None of these is suitable for the average investor, and most of them lose
money anyway.
So, a savings account will get us there, but it will cost the most. In-
vesting for 10 years is the least expensive way to reach our goal, but mak-
ing it without a downturn seems improbable. Here are the parameters of
the problem:
Tip
Even in bear markets, the Internet overflows with get-rich-quick
schemes. Some are complicated hedging plans that the vast majority of
investors should avoid. Others are outright frauds. Don’t let a bear mar-
ket frighten you into trying one of these quick fixes to recoup losses.
Nothing hard about this solution (if you have the money), and it still keeps
the bears off your back.
3,000 points in one year. At every mark along the way, some pundit called
it the bottom. If anyone says, “It just can’t fall any lower,” you know dif-
ferently. Wait until you feel sure the market is on solid ground before
transferring out of savings and into a mutual fund.
Use the Bankrate.com calculator to recalculate your monthly de-
posits after transferring your earnings from savings. At a constant interest
rate, the calculator will give you a new monthly deposit number. Unless
there is a major change in market conditions, I would monitor the fund
weekly and make adjustments quarterly. This is a lot of work, but you
can’t leave the success of this investment to chance. Ten years from now,
you’ll have to write a tuition check, and you need to be sure the money is
there.
Tip
Bonds can be a great spot for bear-shy investors if you are avoiding the
right kind of bear. However, understanding the bond market is not easy,
and you should consider using a professional.
Bond mutual funds are not good choices for short-term investing any
more than stock funds are. Once the market turns in your favor, you may
S H O R T- T E R M A N D M I D - T E R M S T R A T E G I E S 167
want to consider putting the money in over several periods, rather than
dumping it in all at once. This takes advantage of the power of dollar cost
averaging and may give you a better overall yield.
CONCLUSION
Financial goals that fall into the under-10-year range are particularly per-
ilous for investors. History suggests you can expect at least one bear mar-
ket in this period, plus several major corrections.
If you need a specific amount of money by a certain date, you have
to protect it from bear markets. As we saw in Chapter 1, bear markets can
last for months, even years. The recovery usually takes even longer.
Important financial goals demand that you focus on safety as well as
growth.
CHAPTER 15
F AT T E N U P
ON BEAR
Bear markets don’t mean that you can’t look for profits in the mar-
ket. They simply mean that you have to look in different places.
Bears are indiscriminate in their attacks—they take down
healthy stocks along with weak or obese ones, although the healthy
ones will bounce back eventually. If you’re interested in adding to
your portfolio, there just might be some bargains.
However, you need to be very clear on one thing: Just because
a stock is down 75 percent doesn’t mean it’s a bargain—or that it
isn’t going to fall another 15 percent.
Caution
A stock that has fallen by 75 percent is not necessarily a bargain. Some
stocks do fall to virtually zero in value. If you don’t believe this can hap-
pen, ask some of the folks holding stock in the “dot.bombs.”
Caution
You can be your own worst advisor. You convince yourself a stock is
going nowhere but up, so you buy at any price. When it starts to fall,
you tell yourself it will surely rebound. When it doesn’t rebound, you
sell at the bottom. Don’t feel bad—professionals do the same thing
sometimes.
The mistake many investors make is to buy the stock on the way up and
sell when it has lost most of its value. If you stick to your analysis, the
FA T T E N U P O N B E A R 171
stock isn’t a buy candidate until it reaches the approximate dollar figure it
is worth. Don’t be dismayed if the stock falls even past the price you set
as reasonable. There’s nothing reasonable about a bear market.
TROUBLE BY ASSOCIATION
Sometimes the only thing wrong with a stock is the company it keeps.
This is especially true when bears are ravaging a market sector. If it even
smells like the sector, the stock may come under attack.
A sound company that has its stock beaten up because it is in the
wrong sector is an excellent candidate for bargain hunters. When the mar-
ket begins its upturn, this company is likely to draw much attention from
investors looking for a solid buy.
STAYING POWER
The bursting Internet/tech stock bubble taught many investors that just
because a company can raise hundreds of millions of dollars doesn’t guar-
antee it will be around in three months. However, there are many
companies—some old, some new—that dominate their markets in a way
that assures continuance for at least the immediate future.
Microsoft, whether you love it or hate it, isn’t going anywhere soon.
Microsoft software is in 95 percent of the personal computers in the
world, and it will stay there until something cataclysmic happens. Will
Microsoft stock return to its previous levels during the raging bull mar-
ket? What is a reasonable price for the stock? After the 2000–2001 melt-
down, the market may have fairly priced the stock for the first time in
years.
172 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
The Internet has done wonders to level the playing field for small indi-
vidual investors, but it’s just a matter of following the money to realize
that big institutional investors and wealthy individual investors still get
the best information first.
If more analysts are rating a stock a “buy” than one month ago, you can
also expect a price increase. Likewise, if more analysts are downgrading
from a “buy” to a “hold,” expect further price drops.
DEAD-CAT BOUNCE
A “dead-cat bounce” is one of the false signals bears leave. (Please, no
angry letters from cat lovers—I don’t write the news, I just report it.) This
indelicately phrased phenomenon occurs when a stock has fallen from a
dizzying height, hits bottom, and briefly rallies.
True believers in the stock will see this as a sign of a return to new
heights. Unfortunately, what happens next is not a rally but a continued
slide into the dumps. “Dead-cat” stock doesn’t rebound or stage a sus-
tained rally. If you’re in love with one of these unfortunate stocks, your
hopes for a life together are shattered.
174 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
A company’s stock price may or may not be an accurate reflection of the
company’s value. Stock prices move based on expectations of future
events and whether more investors are positive or negative in those ex-
pectations.
PROTECTING YOURSELF
As noted earlier, bears are notorious for sending out false signals. Stocks
may rally in what appears to be the end of a bear market, only to fall back
even further.
FA T T E N U P O N B E A R 175
If you think you’ve found a real bargain, keep the bears from turn-
ing around and biting you by using limit sell orders. These orders become
market orders if the stock’s price falls back to a certain price.
This way of protecting yourself from a stock retreating after a rally
works best for stocks you’re not interested in holding for a long time,
since a volatile stock may drop back far enough to trip the limit sell order.
SHORT-TERM PROFITS
While this borders on speculation, there’s no reason not to take advantage
of a relatively quick profit when you see one.
The stock market is self-correcting which is why there are bull
markets and bear markets. Bears often overcorrect the market, espe-
cially for stocks not particularly overpriced in the beginning. These are
times for profits.
Just because the market has underpriced a stock doesn’t mean you
should buy and hold it in your portfolio. As I emphasized in our previous
discussions on asset allocation, any asset you buy should fulfill a purpose
in your portfolio.
Reaching for quick profits can be risky, so don’t use your retire-
ment money for this purpose. You should also be aware of the tax con-
sequences of quick profits. However, when framed the right way, a
quick profit is a way to raise more cash for those securities you want to
hold.
you get your money out before the carnage, you may be better off doing
nothing, assuming your time horizon permits a wait for the market’s
return.
Caution
Finding bargains in the mutual fund area can be difficult. Other factors
(fees, expenses, taxes, and so on) besides the underlying value of the
fund’s holdings can affect the price per share.
VALUE FUNDS
Value funds are just what the name implies: funds that look for under-
valued stocks. The strategy is to buy cheap and sell expensive as the stocks
move up to a more realistic value.
Value funds do what I suggested investors do with individual stocks.
They will undoubtedly be more efficient, but you always give up some
gain due to mutual fund fees and so on.
Value funds may not perform all that well in the depths of a bear
market, but when the market begins its upturn, expect some handsome
gains.
Tip
If you just can’t decide what to do, you are probably better off doing
nothing. If you can’t stand to watch your funds fall, sell your losers and
put the money in a money-market fund, bond, or other cash instru-
ment.
SECTOR FUNDS
Sector funds invest heavily in particular industries. They should never be
a solo investment, but used in connection with a well-balanced portfolio.
However, during a bear market, sector funds that focus on indus-
tries that aren’t at the top of the bear’s menu may be an appealing buy for
a small portion of your portfolio.
FA T T E N U P O N B E A R 179
CONCLUSION
Bear markets can be times of great concern for investors. However, there
are always opportunities for profits in any market. Investors need to adjust
their thinking and expectations to deal with bear markets. Most folks
would be happy to come out of a bear market close to even. If you can pick
up some bargains and convert them into profits, you may offset losses in
other areas.
PA R T 5
BEAR DEN
The period beginning when you realize that retirement is not very
far away and continuing into retirement is a dangerous time for in-
vestors. Just when the thought of retreating from the front lines of
employment starts sounding better every day, a bear jumps out of
the woods and takes a bite out of your future income.
Bear markets can strike at any time, and the closer you are to
needing money from your investments, the more your portfolio is
at risk.
As we discussed earlier, pulling out of the market too soon can
also be costly. In this part of the book, we will be looking at spe-
cific strategies for pre-retirement and post-retirement. We will also
discuss some of the “safe” places you can sock away some money.
CHAPTER 16
PRE-RETIREMENT
S T R AT E G I E S
Our parents called retirement the “golden years,” but now we know
them as the “anxiety years.” The reason is that so many retirement
plans tie ultimate benefits to investing decisions made by individual
workers.
As you approach retirement, be aware that you probably need
to make some fundamental changes in your portfolio. With any
luck, you will be able to make these changes in normal market sit-
uations.
DANGEROUS TIMES
Earlier in this book, we talked about the length and recovery of bear
markets reaching back 70-plus years. Those numbers should chill
you to the bone if you are beginning your pre-retirement planning.
A major reversal at the wrong time (assuming there ever is a right
time) can mean the difference between a retirement of fun and re-
laxation and one spent worrying about outliving your money.
Caution
If you have a 20-plus year retirement, it’s almost a certainty that
one or more bear markets will attack your portfolio.
184 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Bear markets do happen, and there’s no way to predict whether they will
be close together or spread out with periods of bull markets in between.
Preparation is your best defense, especially if you start during a normal
market.
PRE-RETIREMENT CHECKLIST
When you start your preparations for retirement is a personal choice, but
I would start within 7 to 10 years of retirement, depending on the cur-
rent market and what the future looks like. This gives you time to slowly
rebalance your portfolio to more accurately reflect your retirement pos-
ture and fill in any holes that may exist.
Here are some points to consider during pre-retirement:
■ If you have an investment portfolio and a retirement portfolio
(and I hope you do), consider them together but with different
roles.
■ Make sure you understand your retirement plan and its with-
drawal rules. Generally, the IRS requires you to begin withdrawals
at a certain age. Since this age is subject to change, your tax pro-
fessional can tell you the rules that apply in your situation. You
also need to understand the distribution options, especially for
pension plans.
■ You may have more than one retirement plan. If you had a 401(k)
your benefits and any rules that may apply to working after retire-
ment.
■ Consider hiring a financial professional if you don’t already have
professional help.
These are some of the major investment and planning steps you need to
consider. Of course, there are other concerns, such as paying off all or a
substantial portion of any debt, preparing or updating your will, polish-
ing your golf clubs, and so on. Let’s expand on some of those points.
P R E - R E T I R E M E N T S T R AT E G I E S 185
Tip
Roth IRAs are a special type of retirement account that lets you put
after-tax dollars in an account that builds tax-free. When you begin
withdrawals, they are also tax-free.
retirement. This asset has to last you for the rest of your life, which, pre-
sumably, you hope is a long time. How you manage it before your actual
retirement will determine how well you will enjoy your “golden years.”
(Manage it poorly and you may find yourself saying, “You want fries with
that burger?”)
Your first step is getting a firm handle on what your particular plan
offers in terms of a payout. Can you roll it into an IRA? What about
dumping a lump sum into an annuity?
Tip
Estimating your income and expenses during retirement is complicated.
Bear markets can throw your estimates off on the income side. Inflation
can play havoc with expense estimates.
The worst thing that can happen is you have to make an uninformed de-
cision at retirement and it costs you a chunk of your nest egg. You should
have an estimated payout a few years before retirement and a well-
designed plan to deal with the proceeds. Your decision should consider all
your assets and how “bear exposed” you are.
There are rules regarding withdrawals that could come into play in
the middle of a bear market if you’re not careful. Tax laws change fre-
quently, so please consult a professional before making any decisions on
your own.
Caution
A retirement-planning professional can help you put together a plan
that considers all the variables and outlines a course of action to achieve
your retirement goals.
Ideally, this plan will be in place before you retire so there are no decisions
about pension plan payouts and rollovers. This professional should spe-
cialize in retirement planning and work on a fee-only basis. Many com-
panies that provide investment products will help you with retirement
planning, but I’m not convinced their recommendations always have your
best interests in mind.
188 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
DANGEROUS TIMING
You can use your pre-retirement years to get your financial life organized,
so by the time you’re ready for a well-earned permanent vacation, you
won’t have to spend extra time worrying about how to pay for it.
No one plans for a stock market disaster just before retirement, but
it happens. My experience is that planning is very important if you hope
to accomplish a goal, but you need to be flexible enough to adapt to sud-
den and unexpected changes.
Bear markets can play havoc with your pre-retirement planning,
and they almost always come at the worst time. In Chapter 13, we dis-
cussed the process of gradually moving your portfolio from a growth pos-
ture to a more secure posture. This helps you move out of volatile assets
over time and can eliminate some of the concern that you may need to
cash in a mutual fund at the bottom of a bear market.
Think of it as dollar cost averaging in reverse. Dollar cost averaging
directs you to invest a fixed amount every month or so into the market.
You invest regardless of the market’s behavior. You buy more when it is
down and less when it is up. I’m not suggesting you take out a fixed
amount each month and move the proceeds to a more appropriate pre-
retirement asset. I’m suggesting that realigning your portfolio and its pri-
orities should be a gradual process.
On a practical note, cashing out all at once also generates some sig-
nificant tax considerations. Spreading out the redemptions over several
tax years can ease the load.
P R E - R E T I R E M E N T S T R AT E G I E S 189
LOCK IN RETURNS
One benefit of realigning your portfolio in your pre-retirement years is to
lock in returns on part of your assets. These fixed returns will give you a
solid base. Bonds, CDs, money market accounts, and money market
funds can help you do this. Money market accounts and funds are highly
liquid, but their interest rates do fluctuate. Bonds and CDs are not as liq-
uid, but you can lock in a return and feel confident about the security of
your principal.
Bankrate.com is an excellent source for information on interest rates
for various cash instruments. Your CD is as safe in an insured bank across
the country as it is in the bank across town.
Caution
Trading bonds removes the stabilizing influence they can have on your
portfolio and puts them in the same category as stocks, subject to mar-
ket variances.
Tip
Don’t go overboard and put everything in cash. Inflation reduces the
value of cash by raising prices.
Cash gives you the option of avoiding selling assets in a bear market un-
less you absolutely have to cover an unexpected expense.
CONCLUSION
The planning and preparation you do in your pre-retirement years will
determine the quality of your retirement. If you take only one thing away
from this chapter, I hope it is that hiring a retirement-planning profes-
sional is the smartest, and ultimately cheapest, move you can make.
CHAPTER 17
RETIREMENT
PROTECTION
I live where bears (real bears, not market ones) can be a problem.
Most of the incidents occur farther north, but bear sightings and
problems can happen anywhere. I’ve never had a problem with the
bears, but every year, bears ravage campsites, destroy trashcans, and,
occasionally, chew up hikers and hunters. This has given me a
healthy respect for what bears can do.
This is a roundabout way of warning you that investors must
also respect bears—market bears and real ones. Market bears de-
mand the most respect just before and during retirement. The pre-
vious chapter detailed some of the precautions and planning
necessary to prepare your bear defense.
I don’t mean to be an alarmist or to frighten you about bear
markets during your retirement. I do want to help you prepare for
the bear market(s) that will surely come sometime during your re-
tirement. There is no guaranteed bear repellent, and some bears and
accompanying recessions can be so bad that no one will escape un-
harmed. With proper planning, however, you can hope to prevent
serious damage. This section and the rest of the book will help you
formulate your plan.
194 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
The proper balance between a portfolio that is too conservative and one
that is too aggressive is the heart of a retirement plan that takes advan-
tage of continued appreciation with sufficient safeguards.
RETIREMENT PROTECTION 195
TOO CONSERVATIVE
In the previous chapter, I talked about the importance of moving some of
your assets into bonds and/or cash instruments to cover living expenses
during a bear market so you wouldn’t have to sell off assets at depressed
prices. You might be tempted to convert everything to bonds and cash, so
you don’t have to worry about bear markets.
Tempting as this sounds, it has problems of its own. Even if infla-
tion stays at its recent low of about 3 percent a year, that’s enough to erode
your cash stash much quicker than you think. For example, say you con-
vert your assets to cash and invest $500,000 in a fixed-return instrument
like a CD or bond that pays 6 percent per year. You estimate the $30,000
of income each year will be enough to cover expenses.
This seems like a simple plan—except inflation will rob you of 3
percent each year. Instead of $30,000 per year for expenses, you have less
each year in purchasing power. After 10 years, your $30,000 per year will
now only buy just over $22,000 per year in goods and services. Subtract
income taxes and the figure would even be lower.
I chose to use a 6 percent return in this simple example on purpose.
It’s twice the 3 percent inflation rate of the recent past, and it illustrates
that earning even twice the inflation rate isn’t enough to hold off the drain
on your retirement cash.
This is why the Fed and everyone else fears inflation. People on
fixed incomes suffer the most during inflation, and adopting a too-
conservative posture can be devastating. Inflation will eat away at your
earnings, and the only way you can compensate is to reduce spending.
Caution
Inflation, even at a modest rate, can destroy a fixed-income budget over
time. Protection against its effect means leaving at least part of your
portfolio invested as a hedge.
The point is that to stay even, your investments must earn the rate of in-
flation and then some—but protecting yourself from inflation can leave
you open to other problems, not the least of which are bear attacks. In the
past, large cap stocks have proven that they can grow faster than the rate
196 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
of inflation. They are also targets of bear markets. During a few days of
wild bear trading in March 2001, the Dow (all large cap stocks) lost over
1,000 points.
AN UNLIKELY FRIEND
Although unlikely, deflation can be your friend in retirement. You’ll re-
member from earlier discussions that deflation occurs when too many
goods are chasing too few dollars. Cash becomes more valuable than
goods and prices fall. People on fixed incomes can do very well in defla-
tion because their fixed income increases in value over time.
Deflation is probably the least likely reason we will have a bear mar-
ket, but events in Japan for the 10 years leading up to early 2001 indicate
it is possible. As I write this, their equivalent of the U.S. Fed is providing
Japan’s banks with zero-interest loans to keep the entire system from col-
lapsing.
Could that happen here? Probably not, but as the world’s economies
grow more entwined through globalization, the possibility exists for mas-
sive economic disruptions.
NO PAIN, NO GAIN
The asset-allocation models we looked at earlier in Chapter 13, “Age-
Appropriate Strategies,” provided for some participation in the stock mar-
ket even after retirement except in the most conservative models.
Unless you have a very large retirement nest egg and very modest
plans after retirement, most of you will still need the growth stocks pro-
vide to see you through. That extra post-retirement growth may make a
big difference in how long your money lasts and how you can spend it.
Without that growth, you may need to work some after retirement
whether you planned to or not.
Those folks with a high aversion to risk might find this necessity
painful. That’s perfectly understandable, but you need to find a way that
is as comfortable as possible to accomplish the goal of continued growth
after retirement.
RETIREMENT PROTECTION 197
Tip
Many investors find mutual funds a convenient and safe way to invest
in stocks. Professional managers take on the burden of evaluating indi-
vidual companies as investments.
Mutual funds are the safest way to stay invested in equities. They offer
professional management and most provide a level of diversification indi-
vidual investors can’t achieve. Mutual fund managers should also be bet-
ter prepared in the event of a bear market. Hybrid funds that invest in
stocks and bonds may be a good choice for low-risk investors.
TOO AGGRESSIVE
Investors who are too aggressive after retirement expose themselves to
more risk than is prudent by most standards. These folks often fall into
two groups:
■ Those like our lady friend in Chapter 1, “Bear Markets,” who just
didn’t pay any attention to her portfolio before retirement and lost
a big piece of it in a bear market.
■ Those investors who believe they can jump out of the way (just in
Their portfolios suffer the same result: They rob themselves of a better life
in retirement.
Tip
Financial planners usually carry a professional designation such as CFP
(Certified Financial Planner) or ChFC (Chartered Financial Consul-
tant). These designations mean the planner has fulfilled specialized ed-
ucation requirements and met ethical and professional standards. The
designations don’t necessarily mean they are fee-only.
Some brokerage houses still offer investment services. Check to see if any
of them have offices nearby; they’ll be glad to put together an investment
program that meets your needs and is appropriate for your age group.
You’ll pay fees and/or commissions for these services, but you may sleep
better with someone else making the decisions and keeping an eye on the
progress of the plan.
Investors who don’t pay attention to the market or economy are too
aggressive by default because they set up an investment pattern years ago
and never changed it. Asset allocation and diversification are foreign
terms to these investors. They sail into retirement with their assets in one
or two instruments and with a big “Bite Me” sign on their back. Guess
whom the bear is going after first?
The bear market that ate the Nasdaq in 2000 and 2001 feasted on
investors who put all they had into tech stocks during the late 1990s. For
a while, they looked like market geniuses, until the bear ate them for
lunch. Don’t let your portfolio suffer from lack of attention.
hysteria that created the Internet/tech bubble in the late 1990s. This same
microanalysis helped fan the panic selling, which began with the tech-rich
Nasdaq in April of 2000 and spread to the rest of the market in early
2001.
Tip
Changing technology and information sources may have long-term in-
fluences on the stock market we haven’t even begun to understand.
Micromanaging your portfolio is no guarantee of success. People who
actively trade run up commission charges and tax bills, often for little
gain.
Tip
Plan for the possibility that a bear market can be defeated or at least se-
verely wounded by cutting back on expenses to put off cashing in in-
vestments at depressed prices.
With some careful planning and a little luck, you might be able to get
through all but the lengthiest bear markets without cashing in depressed
RETIREMENT PROTECTION 201
CONCLUSION
You are most vulnerable to bear markets during your retirement years
when you are relying on investment income to pay the bills. Retirees often
live 20-plus years past retirement, which means they will almost cer-
tainly face one or more bear markets. A well-planned retirement that
takes special care to provide adequate cash is your best defense against a
bear market.
CHAPTER 18
S A F E H AV E N S
Tip
Safety always has a price in the market. Lower returns and growth are
the usual outcome when your primary motivation is safety. There is
nothing wrong with this since the market rewards (and punishes) risk.
This chapter looks at some of the “safe havens” available to investors. You
can use them for a variety of reasons. The most common reason is to
avoid the clutches of a bear market.
BONDS
Bonds are a traditional part of virtually every asset-allocation model. A
bond is simply an I.O.U. or debt from an organization. Various govern-
mental units and corporations issue bonds. They are as safe as the organ-
ization issuing the bond. They provide a measure of stability for your
portfolio’s equities.
One of the safest moves you can make is increasing the bond com-
ponent of your portfolio. We have discussed this in the asset-allocation
discussions. Bonds provide a fixed rate of return and an assurance of prin-
cipal if you hold them to maturity. Along with cash, bonds add a stabi-
lizing influence to your stock portfolio.
Several independent services rate bonds against the possibility of de-
fault. The greater the possibility of default, the higher interest rate the is-
suer must pay.
Lost opportunity costs are the profits you miss because your money
is tied up in a safe but low-return investment. Quality investments will
score significant increases when the market leaves bear country, but you
will miss those gains if your money is tied up elsewhere. That is the “cost”
you pay for safety.
Tip
Treasury bonds are absolutely safe if held to maturity. You will get your
principal back plus interest. This feature is often more important than
high rates of return.
There is some upside to Treasury bonds. If interest rates fall while you are
holding a bond, you may be able to sell it at a premium. This comes in
handy when the danger has passed and you’re ready to move the money
back into the equity market. Of course, the opposite is also true. If inter-
est rates rise while you’re holding the bond, you may have to discount it
on the open market. As you can see, the minute you trade Treasury bonds,
the absolute guarantee disappears. Market conditions may dictate that
you discount the bond to sell it.
If you only need a holding place for a short time, consider one of
the very short (one year and under) maturity Treasury issues. These pay
the lowest interest rate, but you only have to hold them a short time until
maturity to get your full principal back.
Tip
There are special municipal bonds that are tax-free including federal,
state, and local taxes. There are mutual funds that specialize in these
issues.
MUNI’S
State, county, city, and other local agencies issue municipal bonds or
muni’s. Independent services rate the issuers for creditworthiness. Tax rev-
enues and other income sources back these bonds. Municipalities issue
the bonds in large denominations ($5,000 and up).
They are less secure than U.S. Treasury or agency issues, but highly
rated muni’s seldom default. They are exempt from federal income tax.
CORPORATE BONDS
Companies issue bonds to finance business growth, especially new plants
and equipment. Companies sometimes use bonds to finance acquisitions.
Companies may prefer bonds to commercial loans because the company
can structure longer pay-offs and better interest rates.
Independent services rank corporate bond issues also, and the inter-
est rate is determined from the credit rating. Corporate bonds are more
risky than U.S. Treasury bonds because bad economic times can affect the
company’s ability to repay.
If you’re using bonds to cushion your portfolio during bear markets,
corporate bonds may not be the answer. Bear markets in connection with
a recession could put a strain on the company to repay the bonds.
Caution
Corporate bonds that are poorly rated by independent services are not
appropriate when safety is a primary concern.
REAL ESTATE
Real estate is one of those “hard” assets investors flock to when inflation
threatens. In an inflationary environment, real estate will usually keep
pace.
Investing in real estate is complicated and requires huge amounts of
capital and time. Once you own real estate, it’s hard to get rid of. In the
words of a banker, real estate is an “illiquid” asset, meaning you can’t eas-
ily convert it to cash.
Fortunately, you don’t have to go through all this to own the bene-
fits of real estate. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) and real estate mu-
tual funds are the answer to all the difficulties of owning real estate.
REITS
REITs are a special breed of investment. They are more closely related to
closed-end mutual funds, but they trade like equities on the stock ex-
change.
REITs invest in income-producing properties, such as shopping
centers, apartments, and other commercial real estate. They receive in-
come in the form of rent. Despite their specialized nature, REITs trade on
major stock exchanges. This gives their shares liquidity or the ability of
the owner to convert them to cash easily. Not all REITs trade as freely as
others do. Some may be “thinly traded,” meaning there isn’t much of a
market for the shares. If you want to sell these shares, you might find it
difficult to get a good price—or any price.
REITs are popular during unstable markets when investors are look-
ing for something of value. They did very well in 2000 when every major
index closed down for the year: Periods of uncertainty in the stock mar-
ket drive investors to look for alternative investments, and investors div-
ing for cover from the Internet/tech sector found not only a safe place but
a profitable one. However, real estate is not immune from the problems
of recession and will drop in value like everything else.
REITs often act differently than equities during a turbulent market
and may move in opposite directions. Their income derives from rents
paid by tenants in the properties they own. Regular companies, on the
other hand, sell products and services for their income. REITs must pay
S A F E H AV E N S 209
Tip
REITs that specialize in particular types of investments give you the op-
portunity to pick the type of property that seems poised for the greatest
growth.
Deflation will be bad news for REITs, as will a rapidly rising market. De-
flation causes prices to drop as money becomes scarce. A rapidly rising
market presents too many other good opportunities, so investors dump
REITs in favor of growth stocks.
Caution
Many financial advisors suggest you put a small portion of your port-
folio in foreign stocks, since they may not follow U.S. markets into the
teeth of a bear. Buying individual foreign stocks is getting easier, but I
recommend beginning investors stick with mutual funds that invest in
foreign economies.
210 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
INTERNATIONAL FUNDS
Although it may strike some as odd that investors would look overseas for
protection against a bear market in the U.S., that is exactly what some ad-
visors do recommend.
Globalization is blurring the economic lines between national
economies. However, overseas markets are rapidly developing markets
with much room for future growth. You may be better off with a fund
that targets medium to small foreign firms. Large multinational compa-
nies tend to move together.
International funds may provide some relief during turbulent do-
mestic markets. I would not classify them as “safe havens” per se, just
alternatives during down U.S. markets. Even then, I would not let inter-
national funds exceed 5 to 10 percent of your portfolio. While individu-
als can buy shares of stock in foreign companies, I believe most investors
are better off turning those decisions over to professional managers of mu-
tual funds.
INVESTING IN SECTORS
As we saw earlier, some sectors do better than others in a bear market.
These sectors may not have the glamour of the Internet/tech arena, but
they turn in steady performances in almost any market or economic con-
ditions.
The following sectors offer some protection from bears in certain
circumstances. You should consider mutual funds that follow these sectors
volatile and probably not long-term investments but rather brief retreats.
Individual stocks in these sectors require careful analysis to make sure they
will follow sector trends.
Caution
Investing in economic sectors can be risky since you are not taking ad-
vantage of diversification. However, for a small part of your portfolio,
they can provide a hedge against losses in the broad market for a lim-
ited time.
S A F E H AV E N S 211
FINANCE
Falling interest rates usually help the finance sector by stimulating activ-
ity in home building and other credit-intensive activities.
Banks and other institutions that lend money do better in an envi-
ronment of lowering interest rates, which might occur when the Fed tries
to head off a recession. However, the financial sector may not benefit
from falling interest rates if consumers are concerned about an economic
slowdown.
UTILITIES
Utilities are favorite hiding places for many investors. They are tradition-
ally very conservative investments that find their way into many retire-
ment portfolios. Investors like them for their higher than average
dividends, which have more value in a falling market with falling interest
rates.
Not all utilities are equal—or managed well, for that matter. Dereg-
ulation and heavy debts from replacing aging facilities have strained some
utilities. Utilities in California suffered disastrous consequences of a mis-
guided deregulation that they themselves pushed for in early 2001.
The lesson is to pick wisely. A mutual fund that specializes in utili-
ties may be a good bet, although the dividend issue is a problem.
CONSUMER STAPLES
Consumer staples include items like food and basic necessities. This sec-
tor is one of the most unglamorous, yet it keeps moving forward even in
the midst of a bear market. Economic downturns have little effect on this
sector since people still need to eat and wear clothes. Earnings may not
grow at a fast rate, but this sector is a favorite safe haven for many bear-
market veterans.
Tip
Consumer staples are the bread and butter (pardon the pun) of many
conservative asset-allocation models. Companies in this sector don’t
show rapid growth or super increases in earnings.
212 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
This is not a sector to stay with for the long term. When the economy
picks up, these stocks are not going to grow much faster than during a re-
cession. (People probably don’t eat a lot more in an expanding economy).
Investors often dump these funds in favor of growth-oriented invest-
ments.
HEALTHCARE
Healthcare is another favorite of investors during bear markets and reces-
sion. HMOs and drug companies are among the companies represented
in this sector. Even in a down economy, people still get sick and buy drugs
or go to the hospital.
This sector has a little more upside than consumer staples, thanks to
increases in elective procedures (laser eye surgery and hair transplants, for
example).
PRECIOUS METALS
Precious metals are a traditional hiding place from inflation. Along with
real estate, precious metals were the weapon of choice in the 1970s and
1980s when inflation was high.
These stocks and funds have long been out of favor, thanks to an ef-
fective lid on inflation. You can be sure, however, that if inflation mounts
a serious threat, investors will run to gold.
Caution
Some bear market funds use shorting as their primary investment
model. When the market is sliding into a bottomless pit, these funds do
very well. However, when the market turns they may find themselves
scrambling to stay alive. Approach with caution.
basically bet against the market by shorting growth stocks and stock in-
dexes that will probably decline in a bear market.
Most of these funds are only a few years old and have no real track
record to analyze. Most did well in 2000 and the beginning of 2001. You
don’t want to hold these funds when the market turns. They suffered mas-
sive losses during the bull market of the late 1990s.
These funds, especially those that try to achieve an inverse return of
major indexes, are for short-term buys at best. When the market turns up,
you’ll want out of these funds fast. Unfortunately, you won’t know when
the market is truly turning up or just blipping before falling some more.
BALANCED FUNDS
Balanced or hybrid funds help you address the ratio of stocks to bonds in
a single fund. These funds vary the ratio of stocks to bonds, so you can
find one that is more conservative than another one.
One way to judge balanced funds is to look at some of the older
ones and see how they fared in unstable markets of the past.
CONCLUSION
You can look at a number of alternatives when faced with a bear market
that might help you weather the downturn. If you’re young and have a
214 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
long time horizon, you may be better off just riding it out. On the other
hand, you may not want to sit passively when there are investment vehi-
cles that might ease the pain.
Whatever measures you decide on, don’t get completely out of the
market. When the market turns up, you won’t know it right away and will
miss the early gains, which can be substantial.
PA R T 6
BEARSKIN RUG
Bears are dangerous because they are cunning and can move quickly.
Your best defense against a bear market is preparing your portfolio in
advance. This means you diversify your assets across stocks, bonds,
and cash. This multi-pronged defense works on the theory that dif-
ferent assets move in opposite directions in certain market condi-
tions.
Asset allocation addresses the proportions of each asset rela-
tive to your risk tolerance, time horizon, and financial goal.
Dollar cost averaging is a way to counterattack the bear market.
It’s the most effective tool the average investor can use.
CHAPTER 19
BUY-AND-HOLD
The buy-and-hold strategy is almost carved in stone by some in-
vestors. It certainly has its strengths, but it has some flaws that you
need to know about.
218 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
BUY-AND-HOLD: PRO
The buy-and-hold strategy is one that many, if not most, investment pro-
fessionals believe best suits the average investor. Some Wall Street tycoons
have built their fortunes on this strategy.
The underlying reasoning of buy-and-hold is that over time you are
better off invested in the stock market than not. This means you will do
better if you put your money in and leave it because, over time, the stock
market has been the most consistent investment you could make.
Two key elements make buy-and-hold work for you: a long-term
view and quality investments. Actually, there is a third key element: the
resolve to stick with the strategy when the market heads south. These el-
ements work with the market’s strengths to make your money work hard
for you. Let’s look at each one.
LONG-TERM VIEW
Although it went out of style during the 1990’s bull market, the stock
market has always been about long-term investing. The market works the
most consistently over the long term.
Plenty of statistics reflect this positive aspect. One of my favorites is
the fact that you can pick any 20-year period in the market’s history, in-
cluding the Great Depression, and “the market” has never lost a dime.
(This statistic is through 1998.) It didn’t matter where you got into the
market as long as you stayed for 20 years. This points out the great
Y O U R B E S T B E A R S T R AT E G I E S 219
strength the market has as a long-term investment. (I’m sure you can see
some holes in this argument; however, I’ll discuss those when I look at the
weaknesses of buy-and-hold.)
Investors almost worship Warren Buffett as an investing guru.
He identifies hidden jewels and buys them before the market discovers
the stock and bids up the price. An interviewer asked the legendary in-
vestor how long was the proper holding period for an investment. Mr.
Buffett answered, “Forever.” Mr. Buffett made his fortune buying dia-
monds in the rough: companies that showed signs of future greatness
and that the market undervalued. They became industry leaders and
made Mr. Buffett a very wealthy man. (Of course, Mr. Buffett didn’t
hold every stock he bought forever, and this points out the other weak-
ness of the buy-and-hold strategy. I’ll talk about that more later, too.)
When you buy and hold a good stock for an extended period, you
allow the company to grow at a natural pace. If you pick industry leaders
as Mr. Buffett did, the effect of compounding growth is what makes buy
and hold so potent. Great companies re-invest all or a substantial part of
their earnings back into the company in the early years to finance growth.
The market favors large companies. Over time, the large companies dom-
inate their markets. This domination allows the company to make even
more profits. A long period allows companies to grow and acquire mar-
ket share. It lets them open new markets. Coca-Cola, one of Mr. Buffett’s
early successes, has huge operations outside the United States. According
to Morningstar.com, 62 percent of the company’s revenues come from
operations outside North America.
GREAT COMPANIES
Investing in great companies is a key part of the buy-and-hold strategy.
Great companies may stumble, but they do not fall. They lead markets
out of bear territory. They continue to grow and innovate. They take ad-
vantage of market opportunities for new revenue sources. They forge
alliances with strategic partners and swallow up competitors. Great com-
panies open new markets overseas and domestically. They discontinue or
sell off unprofitable ventures.
220 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Great companies are not as easy to spot as you might think. Sometimes
they are in very unglamorous industries and are overlooked by active in-
vestors.
If you buy and hold great companies, you will profit from their continu-
ing success. Even when they fall on hard times, they eventually work their
way out of trouble.
BRANDING
Another benefit time buys companies is branding. Branding is the process
of establishing a company’s presence in the market. Branding makes Mc-
Donald’s, IBM, and Coca-Cola household words not just in the United
States, but around the world.
The dot.coms of the 1990s spent billions of dollars trying to build
“brands.” Some of them, like Amazon.com and Yahoo!, were successful,
but the vast majority were not. Many of the New Economy order dis-
missed old brand identities as passé and not of great value. After the
Internet/tech market flamed out, companies with a pre-Internet brand
have done much better than the pure dot.coms.
What is a brand worth during a bear market? There’s no easy an-
swer, but we do know that investors are likely to stick close to companies
they know.
MARKET TIMING
I have discussed in some detail the dangers of trying to time the market,
which is impossible to repeat with any consistency. Another way to “time
the market” is by staying invested. This keeps you in the market and
means you will catch the first up-ticks of recovery.
Many recoveries make their biggest moves in the first 5 to 10 days.
If you miss these days, you will miss the first burst of moves upward and
reduce your overall gain. Investors who try to catch the first part of a re-
covery often miss it completely or mistake a “dead-cat bounce” for the
recovery.
Y O U R B E S T B E A R S T R AT E G I E S 221
BUY-AND-HOLD: CON
The buy-and-hold strategy is widely accepted and praised as the best tool
for individuals to accumulate wealth in the stock market. Investing in
great companies for the long term is a sound strategy. However, there are
some potentially dangerous flaws in the buy-and-hold strategy:
■ The first and foremost potential flaw is the notion that individu-
bear market and not selling in a panic to save something from the
investment.
Caution
It is difficult to make a profit buying a stock at or near its historic high,
even if you hold it for a long time.
One of the “great” companies of the 1990s bull market had a P/E of over
100 for several years and over 180 for one year. If you invested in this
company at that level, you faced a rude awakening when the stock fell
222 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
from a high of 82 to a low of 18. Even then, it still had a P/E of 46. How
long is it going to take this “great” company to recover what it lost for in-
vestors? Is this stock a good buy now with a P/E of only 46?
There are only two ways a P/E can go down: The price of the stock
has to fall, and/or the earnings have to increase. If this stock continues to
fall and it manages to get earnings up, what is a good P/E to trigger a buy
signal?
These are not fair questions because you need to know so much
more about the company before you consider buying. Value investors
never buy on just low P/E alone. Sometimes, a low P/E means the mar-
ket is fairly valuing the stock.
Caution
Don’t assume that a “great” company today will be a “great” company
tomorrow. Things change and companies that don’t change with the
times are lost.
U.S. Steel still dominates the domestic steel industry, but there’s not
much left to dominate. Foreign competitors with significantly lower costs
have eaten into the steel industry. It could barely muster $6 billion in sales
in the 2000–2001 trailing 12-month period, compared to almost $24 bil-
lion for Microsoft in the same period.
Montgomery Ward, once a powerful retailer, filed for bankruptcy in
2000. The list goes on and on of once mighty companies reduced to sec-
ondary roles at best.
Things change and companies that can’t change and profit from the
change won’t remain “great” companies for long.
Y O U R B E S T B E A R S T R AT E G I E S 223
Plain English
Opportunity costs are those profits you lost because your money was
in a nonproductive asset instead of one making you money.
This doesn’t mean you have to become a day trader or a speculator. You
can set price targets for your investments that they may reach in a short
period or over a longer time span.
I discussed this strategy earlier. Some professionals suggest you have
a price you want to sell at when you buy the stock. This strategy also has
its flaws; for example, hitting your target may mean selling just as the
stock was preparing to rise sharply.
COURAGE TO HANG ON
The buy-and-hold strategy requires a lot of courage: to sit tight through
a tough bear market and watch your stock drop like a rock.
This may be the weakest link in the strategy. Investors without the
necessary resolve often hold on as long as they can, then give up just when
the investment has hit the bottom.
The unfortunate consequence is the investor has sold low and will
probably have to pay more to get back in the market later.
224 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
PRICE FOLLOWERS
A strategy that might be called the opposite, although not an exact oppo-
site, of the buy-and-hold adherents is focused on hitting certain stock
prices to drive buy and sell actions.
Caution
Don’t fall into the trap of buying on price alone. Just because a stock is
down significantly doesn’t mean it’s a bargain.
These folks study a stock and arrive at a price they believe is a fair market
value for the stock. They don’t buy until they get that price. At the same
time, they set a selling goal. Once the stock hits this mark, they either sell
or put in escalating sell limit orders to protect the price.
This strategy has two premises: The first is that the way to build
a portfolio is to never take a big loss. The second is that once a stock
reaches a certain price, the market has overvalued it and you should sell
before the market corrects the price (the price falls).
There is no arbitrary hold time on the stock. You act when the stock
hits the appropriate price. This tends to take some of the emotion out of
the process.
Y O U R B E S T B E A R S T R AT E G I E S 225
Tip
Be sure you know how to use stops, stop limit orders, and other price-
sensitive controls on your trading account before you make a mistake.
You could take a 10 percent loss on a stock, only to watch it turn around
to take off without you. Practitioners of this strategy point out that it is
also possible that 10 percent dip may turn into a 25 percent or more drop,
which could take years to recover.
Another significant negative is the taxes and commissions you
might incur with active trading. Any stock sold for a profit in less than
one year faces ordinary income tax rates for your tax bracket.
226 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Many mutual funds will dramatically lower the initial deposit if you
agree to let them debit your bank account by a fixed amount each
month.
TIME STRATEGY
Time is your investment’s best friend. Time is why buy-and-hold works.
Time will cover many investing mistakes.
The best thing you can do for yourself is start now, today, if you’re
not already an investor. If you start early enough (and there’s no such
thing as too early), you can make several mistakes along the way and still
end up with a sizable nest egg at retirement.
Time defeats bear markets, too. Even though in the middle of one
it may not seem like it, bear markets will pass. You want to be there when
it happens and enjoy the upturn.
Y O U R B E S T B E A R S T R AT E G I E S 227
CONCLUSION
No single strategy is perfect or works for everyone. As you gain experience
as an investor, adopt a strategy or devise one of your own. Whatever you
decide, it needs to make sense to you and meet some basic investing
guidelines. This strategy will carry you through bear markets with much
less anxiety.
CHAPTER 20
DIVERSIFY OR DIE
Caution
Many investors who made money early in the 1990s bull market
confuse luck with success. When the market began to unravel,
luck was not enough to keep their heads above water.
230 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
Classifying stocks by a single system makes it easier to compare similar
issues when looking for an investment.
DIVERSIFY OR DIE 231
Tip
If you haven’t taken the plunge into the Internet, I strongly encourage
you to. It’s not as expensive or complicated as you might think. You
don’t have to trade online, and the access to free information is un-
believable. I can’t imagine today’s investor buying and selling without
access to Internet research.
GROWTH STOCKS
Much lower numbers in revenue growth distinguish growth stocks from
aggressive growth. However, growth stocks can be cash machines with
earnings that are rising at a good clip. These companies are established
and confident in their place in the economy. They pay out more of their
earnings in the form of dividends (or stock buy-backs) than aggressive
growth firms do.
Tip
You can’t afford to not have some part of your portfolio in growth as-
sets. You have little opportunity to participate in an upward movement
in the market without growth stocks or mutual funds.
Growth stocks are a key part of any diversification strategy with the ex-
ception of the radically conservative. They still have growth potential, but
are less likely to exhibit wild swings in price.
As growth firms mature, they show slower and slower growth, but
they may pay out increasingly high dividends. Folks who can use current
income (retirees, for example) and some stability of price favor these
stocks. Their steady dividends help offset a decline in price during a bear
market. The company isn’t likely to grow significantly, but it’s steadiness
is ideal for investors who want some security of principal and income.
DIVERSIFY OR DIE 233
■ Real estate
■ Timber
VALUE STOCKS
Value stocks represent potential bargains in the market. They represent
companies that are, for some reason, out of favor with the market.
The companies may be distressed or just in industries that don’t have
the growth potential of other sectors. Distressed companies may be
turnaround possibilities or just poorly run firms that are going nowhere
fast.
Caution
Some stocks are values because the company is a loser. Buying cheap
doesn’t mean the stock will automatically rise at some point. More cheap
stocks stay that way than rise to new highs.
The market undervalues value stocks. A low P/E relative to the rest of the
market or industry peers is one sign of a value stock. Value stocks can oc-
cupy a small part of the aggressive side of your asset-allocation model.
They are aggressive because there is a chance the stock will not move up
during a bull market, and you will lose the opportunity for growth.
Value stocks don’t do much for your diversification goal. You want
components of your portfolio to move when other parts are not. Value
stocks seldom react strongly to the market.
234 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
In the interest of complete disclosure, I have no financial interest in
Morningstar.com, and they in no way compensate me for my opinions.
Tip
Mutual funds offer many investors the best way to participate in the
market because they can turn most of the decision-making over to pro-
fessionals.
Another great piece of information on mutual funds is how much they have
invested in various economic sectors and a rating on how well they might
hold up in a bear market. If you don’t have access to Morningstar.com or
some other free Internet-based service that classifies mutual funds, I would
suggest you use a broker that can get this information for you. Without this
information, you may or may not accomplish the goal of diversification—
you won’t know for sure until it is too late and the market punishes you.
Tip
If you feel yourself being caught up in the buying frenzy of a bear mar-
ket, cut yourself off from the media hype for 48 hours. Don’t watch tel-
evision or listen to radio reports about the market. Stay off the Internet
and avoid magazines with raging bulls on the cover. Out of the hype-
storm, you may feel differently about that stock you just couldn’t live
without two days ago.
236 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Caution
Built into the collective consciousness of our society is a fascination with
getting something for nothing or making a financial killing with no ef-
fort. That’s not investing—that’s the lottery.
wealth. That wealth is gone, and it won’t come back. The surviving com-
panies may rebuild some of that wealth, but it will take much longer than
in the bull market preceding the fall. A well-diversified portfolio main-
tained a significantly higher value than the Internet/tech stock domi-
nated accounts.
Of course, the story of the bear that ate the Nasdaq isn’t just about
out-of-whack portfolios. It’s a larger tragedy of investors who only in-
vested in the Internet/tech-stock boom. While the media (both Internet
and traditional) have to take some blame for the superhype surrounding
the market, no one pointed a gun at investors and made them buy tech.
Tip
Focusing on a diversified portfolio is the best way to keep common
sense in your investing. You will thank yourself in 20 years when your
portfolio has continued to grow year after year.
CONCLUSION
Diversification means you may not profit to the fullest in certain bull
markets. It also means you may not lose to the fullest in bear markets.
Maintaining a well-diversified market takes some effort, since major
market moves can unbalance your portfolio. It takes courage to stay di-
versified when jumping into a hot sector seems like such easy money.
However, in the end, you’ll come out ahead with a steady return.
CHAPTER 21
YOUR WEAPON
OF CHOICE
I hope by now I have convinced you that there are only two real
weapons you can use to defend your portfolio from a bear attack:
diversification and asset allocation.
Asset allocation is a way to target the precise defense you need.
However, no matter how hard we try, some bears are just too pow-
erful. Bears reinforced by recession, deflation, or inflation can be
formidable enemies. When faced with this much strength, the best
we can hope for is to keep damage to a minimum. It may not be
much consolation to know that your portfolio is only down 20 per-
cent while the market is off 40 percent. However, you have cut your
potential loss in half, and that’s worth celebrating.
Using diversification, you spread your assets over the market
spectrum of conservative to aggressive. Asset allocation defines the
specific amount of each asset as percentage of your total portfolio.
MONITORING ALLOCATION
It doesn’t do much good to set up your asset-allocation model to
protect your portfolio from bears if it becomes out of balance
thanks to a large movement in the market.
240 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
Tip
It is important to stay on top of your asset-allocation model. If it be-
comes unbalanced, you have defeated the purpose.
Many folks during the bull market of the late 1990s may have had 10 per-
cent of their portfolio in Internet/tech stocks before the explosion. When
the dust settled, the tech sector of their asset-allocation model had in-
creased to 30-plus percent. The huge run-up in tech stocks increased the
total portfolio. However, when combined with taking money out of some
other assets and putting more into tech, those stocks dominated the port-
folio.
Here is what the model looked like originally, during the bull mar-
ket, and after the crash.
As you can see, the choice to take money out of other assets proved
to be very unwise. When the bottom fell out of tech stocks, the port-
folio was devastated. What should the investor have done to prevent this
disaster?
The choices weren’t popular during the middle of the tech-stock
boom. To bring the asset-allocation model back into balance, the investor
must sell off tech stocks and redistribute the cash to other assets or add
more money to other assets so the percentages got back in line. This
would undoubtedly create some significant tax bills, and you may not
have extra cash lying around to add funds to the other assets.
YOUR WEAPON OF CHOICE 241
Tip
You should always be mindful of the tax consequences in selling invest-
ments. However, don’t let tax concerns stop you from taking actions to
protect your portfolio.
Some investors who knew they were violating their asset-allocation model
told themselves they would ride the Internet/tech stock boom until it re-
versed itself. They would sell for a fat profit, then wait until the tech
stocks bottomed out and use some of the profits to pick up bargains
among the devastated tech stocks.
A nice plan, however, investors in the middle of a boom might not
give up so easily. They might convince themselves that every dip was
merely a correction, and the stock would soon begin soaring to previous
heights and more.
HARD CHOICES
Rebalancing your portfolio can be painful when one part is on a hot
streak. Our natural tendency is to let profits run, but if you’re truly con-
cerned about protecting your portfolio, you will make the hard decisions.
Another solution for our hypothetical portfolio above is to follow a sim-
ple rule: Never reduce a position in one asset to increase a position in an-
other asset just to take advantage of a hot market.
Caution
Selling assets to put the proceeds in a hot sector is gambling at best and
dangerous at worst. Should a bear attack that sector, you will likely suf-
fer major losses.
Obviously, as your goals and time horizon change, you will change as-
sets and percentages of other assets. Just don’t engage in this activity to
put more money in a hot sector. These have a tendency to cool off—
sometimes quite rapidly. Let’s look at the portfolio after the bull market
run-up.
242 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
This looks better, but the tech stocks are still dominating the portfolio. In
an almost perfect world, the investor would continue making the hard
choices, reduce his tech stocks back to 10 percent of the portfolio, and re-
distribute the proceeds to the other assets.
Now, when the bear attacks (and note that all assets are hit by the bear)
the results are not nearly so bad.
The portfolio is still out of balance, but no single asset dominates it.
When I applied the same percentage reductions in all assets, the loss in
tech stocks did not have the dollar impact as when it dominated the port-
folio. This maneuver saved the investor over $9,000 in losses, and all the
assets except tech stocks are close to their original allocations.
Obviously, this is just an example of one strategy you could em-
ploy. Unfortunately, it requires the courage to sell off the tech stocks just
when they’re booming. This proved the correct strategy, but if the bull
had continued for another six months, the investor would have missed
even higher gains.
This bear launched an across-the-board attack and the portfolio
didn’t have a cash component, which would have offered another strategy.
Tip
It is not wise to hide all your assets in cash accounts, because there will
be nothing to take advantage of the market when it begins to rise out of
a bear.
The investor could have sold off the tech stock like before, but instead of
putting the money back into the other assets, he could have kept it in
cash. In this bear market, that would have been the best solution. Every-
one is a great investor when looking backward. The trick is to protect
yourself going forward.
244 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
ANOTHER SOLUTION
If you simply can’t stand to cash in a winning investment like the tech
stocks in the previous section, there is another alternative. It also requires
discipline and some attention to the market.
The first task is to sell off some tech stocks and return the other as-
sets to their full funding. The next step is one you take in your head. Take
all the gains out of the tech-stock sector of your asset-allocation plan.
Mentally, you have rebalanced your portfolio, and you have a sum of
money tied up in tech stocks that sits outside your portfolio.
If these are individual stocks, consider trading tools to protect your
profit. You can use a “stop limit order” to set a price below the current
price. If the stock falls to this point, the order becomes a market order,
and the system automatically sells the stock.
Tip
Protecting profits is not the same as market timing when done with a
commitment to sell upon a specific retreat in price. This is letting the
market time itself.
Should the stock(s) keep rising, you can raise your stop limit order ac-
cordingly. One way to visualize this process is to think of a ladder with
rungs going up and down. As the stocks rise, you follow up the ladder
with new stop limit orders.
That ladder might look like this:
In this example, you will notice that there is an increasing spread between
the stop limit order and the price of the stock. There are two reasons for
this:
■ First, at the lower price, the stock doesn’t have to move much to
more volatile on daily trading. A lower stop limit order keeps you
in the stock through corrections and still protects your profit.
This system requires you to keep a close eye on the market and move your
stop limit orders up as necessary. However, you should never lower the
stop limit order. When you do this, you are trying to time the market and
could easily watch your profit disappear. Some investors use a percentage
to figure their stop limit order. Either way, you are using logic and reason
to set the price as opposed to hope and emotion.
Using stop limit orders is a way to let the market time itself. You are
not attempting to call a market turn. You are setting a price and letting
the market come to that price or move away from it. When the market
backs up and you’re cashed out of the tech stocks, take the cash and ei-
ther reinvest per your asset-allocation model or put it in a cash instrument
if you believe a bear market is lurking.
Tip
Mutual funds are slightly harder to work with because you only get fresh
pricing once a day. Usually, this is not a problem because mutual funds
don’t often move in big steps one way or the other.
Unfortunately, this system relies on your attention to the share price, un-
like the strategy for stocks that use orders that execute automatically when
the stock hits your stop limit order price. I suggest you write the price on
a piece of paper and keep it where it will remind you to check the NAV.
If you are riding a bull market up, you can change your sell price as often
as necessary.
REBALANCING SCHEDULE
How often should you rebalance your portfolio? I would check it every
month or so during a normal market and more frequently when the mar-
ket is moving strongly in one direction or the other. It’s probably not nec-
essary to rebalance if one or more assets are only a few points off target.
However, watch for bracket creep if one sector is growing faster than the
rest of the market.
If there are signs of economic slowdowns or bear markets in the
near future, reevaluate your portfolio to see if you want to take a more
conservative stance until the uncertainty is over. In Chapter 13, “Age-
Appropriate Strategies,” I discussed the components of conservative asset-
allocation models. Your two most important conservative or defensive
tools are cash and bonds. Inflation on the horizon signals interest rate in-
creases, which aren’t going to be good to bonds. Cash will be a better
choice. A looming recession means interest rates are likely to drop, which
will help bonds and not cash.
YOUR WEAPON OF CHOICE 247
Caution
Keep an eye on the Fed through the media for hints of whether interest
rates are likely to go up, stay the same, or go down.
USE OF CASH
I believe cash should be a part of your asset-allocation model, although
you will undoubtedly see articles on asset allocation that don’t mention
cash. There are reasons for eliminating cash from the model, one of the
most common being that cash instruments (CDs, money market ac-
counts, money market mutual funds, and so on) are savings vehicles, not
investments. Rather than quibble, I would simply point out that cash in
a money market mutual fund earning 5 percent looked pretty good in the
bear-ravaged early months of 2001.
Opponents might argue that bonds and bond mutual funds can ac-
complish many of the same tasks as cash. I would beg to differ. Bonds
may not sell at par (face) value on the open market if interest rates have
risen. Bond mutual funds can actually lose part of your principal.
Neither of these is true of cash. Cash is always quickly convertible
to other assets, while the same isn’t necessarily true.
In the previous section, we looked at what happens when a major
market move unbalances your asset-allocation model. A possible solution
was to sell off the inflated tech stock sector and put the proceeds into cash
instruments. Hiding in cash is not always the best answer. The biggest
downside is that when the market turns, you are not in a position to take
advantage of the earliest moves.
IRRATIONAL EXPECTATIONS
One of the biggest obstacles to accepting the structured approach to in-
vesting that asset allocation imposes is the irrational expectation still
smoldering after the Internet/tech-stock bull market. The frenzy built up
248 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
around the Nasdaq was just short of a riot. Unbelievable gains became be-
lievable and even expected. If the Nasdaq Composite didn’t post a triple
digit gain, pundits considered it a down market.
These expectations have long lives, even after the bull became ham-
burger. Investors are always looking to the unknown future. Could we see
a return of the wild bull market in tech stocks? No one knows for sure,
but that won’t stop the true believers from loading up on downtrodden
tech stocks in anticipation of a renewed buying frenzy.
Biotech stocks were once the objects of these same irrational
expectations. Investors bid the stocks up, then when products and prof-
its appeared to be years away, the market cooled and the sector col-
lapsed. I am sure there are some folks who loaded up on these stocks
hoping for a return to the center ring. One day, the market may prove
them right.
Tip
Investors should not write off the Internet/tech stocks because of the
2000–2001 bear market. Survivors may be good buys now that the bear
has punctured the hype.
The Internet/tech companies that survived the shakeout are not going
away. They will continue to play a major role in our economy for years to
come. Will they ever return to the boom days of the 1990s? No one
knows for sure. However, I wouldn’t dismiss the industry leaders. They
will likely lead the way out of bear markets for several years to come.
ASSET-ALLOCATION TOOLS
As I noted earlier, I find the information and tools on Morningstar.com
to be top rate for free services. In this final section, I want to introduce
you to two tools that can be extremely helpful in guarding your portfo-
lio from a bear attack, help you decide which mutual funds fit your asset-
allocation model, and help you judge the likelihood of a portfolio’s
success.
YOUR WEAPON OF CHOICE 249
PORTFOLIO ALLOCATOR
Morningstar’s Portfolio Allocator is a tool that helps you decide which
stocks and funds should go into your asset-allocation model. You set up
the criteria for your model and the Portfolio Allocator suggest different
mutual funds that might fit your model. These are funds selected from
small groups of funds that Morningstar’s analysts have studied in detail.
If you want the Portfolio Allocator to include individual stocks, you
must manually enter them yourself. The Allocator looks at all the possi-
bilities and reports the best combinations. The Allocator isn’t giving ad-
vice, it is simply recommending a mix based on your input. The ultimate
responsibility is yours.
Tip
The Internet has many good tools to help you with your investing ques-
tions and problems; however, always consider the source of the infor-
mation before acting on it.
This tool is a very helpful starting place if you are a beginner in asset al-
location. Don’t use it as a recommendation service. It works by giving you
a starting place, which is sometimes the hardest part.
CONCLUSION
Asset allocation is your weapon of choice in defending your portfolio
against bear attacks. Monitoring your allocation can force you into some
hard choices when your portfolio needs rebalancing. Selling winners is
often painful; however, leaving your portfolio out of balance is extremely
dangerous. Bears love to attack undefended portfolios.
Rebalancing your portfolio after a strong market movement is nec-
essary for it own protection. Check your portfolio once a month or more
if the market is unstable. There are numerous tools on the Internet to help
you establish an asset-allocation model and maintain its balance.
CONCLUSION
Now that you’ve worked your way through this book, I’m sure
you’re feeling supremely confident about handling any market
emergency. Right?
Of course you’re not. Wrestling with bear markets and a tum-
bling economy is unnerving at best and terrifying at worse.
However, there are steps—and now you know them—you can
take to prevent the market from washing your portfolio wherever
the bear wants to take it. The two words to keep repeating are: asset
allocation.
This strategy prepares your portfolio to deal with the curve
balls bear markets can throw. Will it guarantee you won’t lose
money? No, but it will give you a fighting chance to ride out a bear
market with much less damage than a randomly constructed basket
of investments. Ask anyone who had 40 percent of their portfolio
in Internet/tech stocks what a bear market can do in a short period.
(Maybe you were one of the victims.)
Asset allocation aims for the best return in today’s market with
reasonable protection against bear attacks. The key features you
need to remember about bear-proofing your investments are …
■ You must diversify your portfolio across stocks, bonds, and
cash.
■ How you determine the proportions for each asset depends
on your time horizon, risk tolerance, and financial goal.
■ In most cases, it doesn’t make much difference if you use
individual instruments or mutual funds to fill your asset-
allocation model.
252 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
These points will help you face bear markets with a greater confidence in
your ability to make good decisions. You may not avoid a loss, but when
the dust clears, your portfolio will look a lot healthier than if you acted
like the good times would last forever.
APPENDIX A
GLOSSARY
loaded fund A fund that charges a sales fee or commission. The load
may be up front or deferred.
lost opportunity costs When you cannot act on an opportunity be-
cause your money is locked in another investment or you pass up a chance
for profits because fear or the lack of information holds you back.
management fee Also called the investment advisory fee, charged by
the mutual fund company and used to pay the fund’s manager, who is re-
sponsible for making sure the fund meets its objectives.
market capitalization A way of measuring the size of a company. You
calculate it by multiplying the current stock price by the number of out-
standing shares. A stock trading at $55 with 10,000,000 outstanding
shares would have a market cap of $550 million.
market cycles Periods of market ups and downs.
market indicators A collective name for a number of indexes and other
measurements of market activity.
market order An order to buy or sell placed with your broker request-
ing the best price at that moment.
market value risk The danger that your investment will fall out of
favor with the market.
mid cap stock Any company with a market capitalization of $1 to
$5 billion.
money market accounts Special savings accounts usually offered by fi-
nancial institutions that pay a higher interest rate than regular savings but
require a higher minimum balance. They are not the same as money mar-
ket mutual funds.
money market mutual funds Funds that invest in short-term money
market instruments. You can often withdraw money on short notice
without penalty. Some offer check-writing privileges.
mutual funds Funds representing a group of individuals who have
pooled their money and hired a professional management company to in-
vest it for them. Each mutual fund has specific goals and objectives that
drive its buy and sell decisions. Mutual funds may invest in stocks, bonds,
or both.
Nasdaq Also known as the over-the-counter market, it is the new kid
on the block. Many of the companies listed here are fairly young, and this
is the home of many of today’s high-tech stars and former stars.
GLOSSARY 259
RESOURCES
In this appendix, you will find a list of Web and published resources to
assist you in planning and implementing your investment program.
INVESTMENT PUBLICATIONS
Alpha Teach Yourself Investing in 24 Hours, Ken Little—This book is a
comprehensive overview of investing techniques and strategies. It covers
all the information you need to get started or to review the basics.
The Intelligent Investor: A Book of Practical Counsel, Benjamin Graham—
Benjamin Graham is one of the best-known value investors of all time.
Graham advocates a simple portfolio and stock selection methods.
The Only Investment Guide You’ll Ever Need, Andrew Tobias—Andrew To-
bias is a well-respected financial counselor and stresses no-load mutual
funds.
The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Making Money with Mutual Funds, Alan
Lavine and Gail Liberman—This guide is a great primer for getting you
on track with mutual funds. It is easy to follow and full of information,
including definitions and tips.
Beating the Street, Peter Lynch—Peter Lynch is a name that inspires awe
on Wall Street for his successful investing strategies.
The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Managing Your Money, Robert Heady and
Christy Heady—A great consumer guide to managing your money, this
book is easy to read and full of practical tips.
Motley Fool’s You Have More Than You Think: The Foolish Guide to Investing
What You Have, David and Tom Gardener—These guys are no fools when
it comes to investing advice. This book shows you how to get started with
a small amount.
Technical Analysis of Stock Trends, Robert D. Edwards and John Magee—
The authors offer a comprehensive look at a technical analysis of stock
movement.
MARKET INDICATORS
The following is a list of key market indicators:
Dow Jones Industrial Average (www.dowjones.wsj.com)—The oldest
and best known of all market indicators, the Dow consists of 30 stocks
representing the leading companies in their industries. Here is a list of the
stocks that make up the Dow Jones Industrial Average as of April 2001:
Alcoa, Inc. Intel Corp.
American Express Co. International Business Machines Corp.
RESOURCES 265
ONLINE BROKERS
The authoritative source on online brokers is Gomez.com
(www.gomez.com). They use fees, ease of use, and a number of other fac-
tors to rank online brokers. Here are some of the top-rated online brokers:
1. Charles Schwab (www.schwab.com)
2. E*Trade (www.etrade.com)
3. DLJdirect (www.djdirect.com)
4. Fidelity Investments (www.fidelity.com)
5. NDB (www.ndb.com)
6. A.B. Watley (www.abwatley.com)
7. My Discount Broker (www.mydiscountbroker.com)
266 BEAR-PROOF INVESTING
RETIREMENT CALCULATORS
www.quicken.com—The financial software giant has a great site with
plenty of aids, including this comprehensive retirement planning calcula-
tor at www.quicken.com/retirement/planner/js/.
www.retireplan.about.com—A complete site devoted to retirement
planning.
www.interest.com—This calculator helps you figure the future value of
money before and after retirement.
www.firstar.com/persfin/—FirstStar bank’s calculator includes inputs
for a second income in the household.
www.moneycentral.msn.com/articles/retire—MSN.com shows how
much you can spend after you retire.
www.principal.com/—The Principal Financial Group discusses ex-
penses after retirement.
RISK TOLERANCE
www.better-investing.org—An article discussing risk tolerance and how
yours should affect your investment decisions.
www.cigna.com/retirement—A short risk-tolerance quiz will help you
sleep better at night with your investment decisions.
www.scudder-u.working4u.com—Another quiz on risk tolerance and
the role it plays in investing.
ROTH IRA
www.university.smartmoney.com—Online SmartMoney magazine
(from The Wall Street Journal ) has complete Roth IRA information.
www.fool.com/retirement.htm—The Internet wits from Motley Fool
have sound advice for IRA shoppers.
RESOURCES 267
STOCK EXCHANGES
American Stock Exchange—www.amex.com
Chicago Board of Trade—www.cbot.com
Chicago Board Options Exchange—www.cboe.com
Chicago Mercantile Exchange—www.cme.com
Kansas City Board of Trade—www.kcbt.com
Nasdaq—www.nasdaq.com
New York Cotton Exchange—www.nyce.com
New York Mercantile Exchange—www.nymex.com
New York Stock Exchange—www.nyse.com
Philadelphia Stock Exchange—www.phlx.com
STOCK SCREENING
Stock screening services make finding the right stock or mutual fund
much easier. Here are three that are worth getting to know:
■ Microsoft’s site is comprehensive and easy to customize at
moneycentral.msn.com.
■ Marketguide’s StockQuest is a powerful screening tool, but it takes