Best Practice Guide 5 Issue 2
Best Practice Guide 5 Issue 2
Electrical
installations
and their
impact on the
fire performance
of domestic
premises used as
single family
houses
Page 1
This is one of a series of Best Practice Guides produced by Electrical
Safety First* in association with leading industry bodies for the benefit
Best Practice Guide of electrical contractors and installers, and their customers.
Electrical Safety First is indebted to the following
organisations for their contribution and/or Consultants to Electrical Safety First:
support to the development of this Guide:
International Fire Consultants Ltd
Association of Building Engineers www.intfire.com
www.abe.org.uk
In electronic format, this Guide is intended to be made available free
BEAMA
of charge to all interested parties. Further copies may be downloaded
www.beama.org.uk from the websites of some of the contributing organisations.
British Gypsum The version of this Guide on the Electrical Safety First website
www.british-gypsum.com (www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk) will always be the latest. Feedback
on any of the Best Practice Guides is always welcome – email
BSI Product Services [email protected]
www.bsigroup.com Electrical Safety First is supported by all sectors of the electrical
industry, approvals and research bodies, consumer interest
CEDIA UK organisations, the electrical distribution industry, professional institutes
www.cedia.co.uk and institutions, regulatory bodies, trade and industry associations and
federations, trade unions, and local and central government.
Certsure
www.certsure.com *Electrical Safety First (formerly the National Inspection Council for
Electrical Installation Contracting) is a charitable non-profit making
Chief Fire Officers’ Association organisation set up in 1956 to protect users of electricity against the
www.cfoa.org.uk hazards of unsafe and unsound electrical installations.
1. Aim
1.1 The aim of this Guide is to promote best practice 1.2 The guidance, which is intended to apply to
by providing practical advice and guidance for electrical installations designed after July 2008, may
designers, installers, verifiers and inspectors also be of benefit to specifiers, builders, building
of domestic electrical installations where, as is control bodies and other interested parties.
often the case, the electrical work requires, or has
required, the penetration of linings forming ceilings 1.3 By following the guidance, it is considered that
and walls. electrical installation work will not compromise the
fire performance provisions that are mandatorily
required to be incorporated into domestic premises
under the relevant building regulations.
Page 3
2. Introduction
2.1 This Guide has been produced by Electrical Safety 2.7 Amongst these forms of construction are narrow
First in association with the bodies indicated on section solid, stress graded timber joists, plywood/
page 2. Orientated Strand Board (OSB) webbed ‘I’ joists
(‘timber I beams’), tooth or nail-plated trusses and
2.2 It addresses the impact that electrical installations joists, composite timber studs and lightweight metal
in domestic premises have on the fire performance studs. Illustrations of these vulnerable forms of
of loadbearing and non-loadbearing walls and floors construction are to be found in Annex A.
(and sometimes ceiling membranes) that have a
fire containment function, or are required to carry a 2.8 The fire resistance of these elements can easily
load for a prescribed period. be compromised by inadequate fire sealing
and ‘making good’ after any penetration to
2.3 Fire safety in buildings generally requires that in the accommodate electrical equipment and associated
event of a fire sufficient time is available for people wiring.
to escape from a building:
2.9 Electrical equipment that has been identified as
• certain walls, floors and ceilings provide having a direct and significant influence on the fire
fire resistance for the purposes of performance of buildings includes:
constructing fire compartments and/
or protected escape routes, and • flush-mounted consumer units
• the structure resists collapse. • concealed and recessed luminaires,
including downlighters
2.4 The advice given in this Guide is aimed largely at
preserving the structural stability of the premises • flush-mounted electrical socket-outlets,
as much as the fire separation between areas. flex outlet plates and data points
For example, in most domestic premises, it is
the loadbearing capacity of the floors that is • flush-mounted switches, detection
threatened by early failure of ceiling linings, not and control devices
the fire separating function.
• recessed wall luminaires
2.5 Many modern forms of engineered construction
• concealed speakers.
have an inherently lower level of fire resistance
when compared to more traditional forms of 2.10 The above items all require the removal of a part
construction, and are heavily reliant on the of the ceiling or wall lining, and replacement
plasterboard or similar linings for achieving the with glass, thin metal or plastic that does not
requisite level of fire separation. provide the same level of fire protection to the
structural members, causing a reduction in the fire
2.6 Much of the guidance is related to the effect that performance of the element. These are known as
the installation of electrical equipment will have partial penetrations.
on the performance of the protective linings that
are used to provide fire protection to lightweight 2.11 In addition to the influence that these partial
joisted or studded constructions. In the case of the penetrations have on the fire performance, some
associated wiring, the need to prevent fire from installations can penetrate both linings, such as:
passing through holes in all elements, whether solid
or lightweight, is also addressed. • associated wiring and conduits
• ventilation fans and related ductwork.
2.12 These installations have a potential to compromise
the fire containment capability, and guidance is
included for these situations. These are known as
full penetrations.
Page 4
2.13 In addition to the above items that all have a direct of a fire, for example due to heat generated by
influence on the fire performance of floors or loose connections.
walls, the following items can also have an indirect
influence if the lining provides some or all of their 2.15 When involved in a fire, thermoplastic materials
support: used in the construction of electrical fittings can
release significant quantities of dense smoke and
• heavy ceiling-hung luminaires, lighting toxic products. They can also create flaming molten
tracks and overhead projectors droplets which have been known to cause fire
spread to carpets and furnishing below them.
• wall-mounted brackets for televisions, heavy
speakers and flat screen installations. 2.16 The fire separating capability of an element of
construction is generally measured by the duration
If the room is involved in fire, the weight of such for which the element will satisfy the criteria of a
items may lead to the premature failure of the lining fire resistance test. Historically, these criteria have
material. been determined by exposure to the BS 476: Part
2.14 In addition to the risk of the electrical installation 20: 1987 heating and pressure conditions, but more
reducing the fire separation capabilities of those recently by the new European testing regime as
elements that need to resist fire spread or to embodied in BS EN 1363-1. More information on
remain structurally sound in a fire, a poorly the relevant test methods and criteria can be found
constructed installation can potentially be the cause in Annex B.
Result of an eight minute fire on lightweight joists (Courtesy of Manchester City Council - Building Control)
Page 5
3. Scope
3.1 This Guide gives practical advice and guidance for 3.5 The Guide gives recommendations as to what is
the installation, and the making good following considered to be best practice, taking into account
the installation, of electrical equipment and wiring that electrical installers may not have adequate
in self-contained domestic premises (including knowledge of the construction of the elements that
bungalows, multi-storey houses, individual flats and are potentially being compromised by their work.
maisonettes) that are designed to accommodate a
single family unit. The advice and guidance applies 3.6 Where an installer wishes to differentiate between
to both new and existing premises. new and traditional forms of construction, the
guidance given in Annex C may assist. Some
3.2 The Guide does not apply directly to Houses in investigations may require the services of another
Multiple Occupation, hostels, caravans or boats, professional, such as a surveyor or fire specialist.
or to the communal parts of blocks of flats or the
communal parts of maisonettes, nor does it apply
to any premises used for purposes other than a
Note: This Guide does not necessarily
dwelling (such as small shops, factories or similar
apply to all innovative or unusual forms of
premises used solely as places of work).
construction or electrical equipment. If in
3.3 The Guide gives advice on what needs to be done doubt, specialist advice should be sought.
to maintain the fire resistance of walls and ceilings
in domestic premises that have been penetrated
or partially penetrated in the process of installing
electrical equipment and wiring.
Page 6
4. General electrical installation requirements
4.1 This Guide takes into account the publication 4.4 Regulation 510.3 requires manufacturers’
of BS 7671: 2008 (Requirements for Electrical instructions to be taken into account. It is
Installations, IET Wiring Regulations 17th Edition), important to do this in order, for example, to
which is the latest version of the national standard prevent luminaires becoming a source of ignition.
for the safety of electrical installations, first Any installation instructions that are considered
published in 1882. to be inappropriate should be queried with the
manufacturer concerned, and amended installation
4.2 BS 7671 requires, in Section 421 (Protection instructions requested.
against fire caused by electrical equipment),
that equipment must not present a fire hazard 4.5 All terminations and joints, whether for low voltage
to adjacent materials, and that manufacturers’ (LV) or extra-low voltage (ELV) circuits, should be
instructions must be taken into account. Section enclosed in accordance with Regulation 526.5 to
421 also requires that fixed equipment causing prevent fire spread should a loose connection occur.
a concentration and focusing of heat (such as
spot lamps) shall be at a sufficient distance from 4.6 As part of the initial verification process, the
any fixed object or building element so that the electrical installer has a duty to ensure that all
object or element is not subjected to a dangerous the necessary fire precautions have been taken,
temperature in normal conditions. irrespective of which party was responsible for
that element of the electrical work(Regulation
4.3 In Section 527 (Selection and erection of wiring 611.3(vii)).
systems to minimise the spread of fire) of that
standard, it is required that wiring systems are
selected and erected to minimise the spread of fire,
including:
Page 7
5. Legal
5.1 Building regulations for each part of the UK Note: In England & Wales, Part P of the Building
define fire performance objectives for the various Regulations and, in Scotland, Building Standard
elements that make up domestic premises, and 4.5, make this a requirement, putting the
give recommended performance levels in guidance responsibility on the installer if self-certifying the
supporting those regulations. The objectives work as compliant with building regulations.
are taken into account in this Guide. For further
information, see Annex D. Currently, electrical safety in Northern Ireland
is not controlled under building regulations.
5.2 It is vital that the fire performance of critical
walls and floors is maintained to at least the level
recommended in the guidance supporting the
regulations, after the installation of electrical
equipment and associated wiring.
Page 8
RECOMMENDATIONS
6. Flush-mounted consumer units
Photo courtesy of MK
Page 9
7. Downlighters (recessed luminaires)
7.1 When exposed to a fire from below, downlighters 7.6 Such separate forms of protection must be
may provide far less protection to a cavity and the fit for purpose and not be easily dislodged or
structural elements within it than the plasterboard compromised after installation by subsequent work.
they are replacing, unless suitable precautions are Any such protection must conform to the guidance
taken. given in Annex E.
7.2 Electrical Safety First recommends that, wherever 7.7 Electrical Safety First recommends that
possible, downlighters having integral fire downlighters installed in a ceiling beneath a roof
protection are selected for use in all ceilings where space have integral fire protection, or are provided
the lining that is to be penetrated is the sole means with some other suitable form of fire protection,
of keeping fire and heat out of the cavity. in order to safeguard escape from the premises,
restrict the spread of fire, and reduce the risk of
premature failure of the roof structure.
7.3 There are a number of types of downlighter A number of studies have shown that the use of
available, and it is important that the type selected “unprotected” downlighters which penetrate into
for a particular application has test evidence to a loft space account causes significant energy loss.
support its fire performance when incorporated in a The use of approved downlight loft covers allows
ceiling of the type into which it is to be installed. the insulation to be continuous and uninterupted
thus meeting current Building Regulations fully. Any
such downlighter loft covers should be dust tight to
IP6X and meet the requirements of BS EN 60598-1
and BS EN 60598-2.2.
Page 10
Table 1: Recommendaons for recessed luminaires/downlighters in floors and ceilings
Building Locaon Construcon Fire Resistance Required Recommended
Bungalow Roof ceiling All N/A A
Two-storey house Roof ceiling All N/A A (assuming adequate compartmentaon between
adjacent dwellings)
First Floor Robust Modified 30 mins** B, C, but A can be jusfied if tradional construcon
confirmed (Annex C)
Lightweight Modified 30 mins** B, C
Below room over garage All 30 mins B ,C
Over basement All 30 mins B, C
Three-storey house Roof ceiling All N/A A (assuming adequate compartmentaon between
adjacent dwellings)
First and Second Floor All 30mins B, C
Ceiling of garage under room All 30 mins B ,C
Over basement All 30 mins B, C
Robust Modified 30 mins** B, C, but A can be jusfied if tradional construcon
Lo conversion
First floor (when lo converted) confirmed (Annex C)
(2-storeys to 3)
Lightweight Modified 30 mins** B, C
Four-storey (or more) Roof ceiling All N/A A (Assuming adequate compartmentaon between
house adjacent dwellings)
All Floors, including garage and
basement ceilings/ floors All 60 mins B, C
Flats
Top floor <5m Compartment floor All 30 min D, B ,C
Top floor <18m Compartment floor All 60 min D, B ,C
Top floor <30m Compartment floor All 90 min D, B ,C
Top floor >30m Compartment floor All 120 min D, B ,C
Duplex flats Intermediate floor All 30 min B, C
KEY:
A = Unprotected downlighter permied, but = Ensure that thermal insulaon will not prejudiceluminaire
suitable fire protecon recommended for safety reasons = Should only be installed if it can be verifed that the penetraon
B = Downlighter with integral protecon will not have an adverse impact on accousc performance
C = Downlighter with hood complying with Annex E = Robust construcon is defined in Annex C
D = Downlighter inserted in false (secondary) ceiling = Lightweight engineered construcon is defined inAnnex A
** = See Annex F
Page 11
8. Flush-mounted accessories
(including switches, sockets, flex outlet plates, data and telephone points etc.)
8.1 Numerous flush-mounted accessories are common 8.3 The risks associated with fire penetrating through
in modern homes. These generally comprise two flush-mounted accessories are significant when they
components: penetrate a 30 minute fire-resisting loadbearing
stud wall, ‘back-to-back’ with other accessories in
• a recessed housing, or back box the same cavity (or interlinked cavities).
• a face plate with integral socket,
switch mechanism, flex outlet etc,
and associated wiring terminals.
Plan view
!
Example of accessories being back-to back in the
The effect of fire on a socket-outlet same cavity space (can be at different heights)
(Photo courtesy of Greater Manchester
Fire & Rescue Service)
Plan view
!
Example of accessories not being back-to-back in the
same cavity
Page 12
8.5 Such back boxes or protective pads must have
evidence of performance to demonstrate that they
have the ability to maintain the fire separation
capability of a wall for 30 minutes, were they to
be tested to BS 476: Part 21: 1987 (loadbearing) Plan view
or BS 476: Part 22 (non-loadbearing), or the EN !
equivalent as appropriate (see Annex B), with plastic The box depth must be selected so that with the
accessories fitted in both linings. pad in place, the required clearance is maintained
between the pad and the accessory, and the wiring
is not unduly distorted.
Plan view
!
Fire protection pad fitted externally
Page 13
Table 2: Recommendaons for flush-mounted accessories in mber and metal stud walls
Page 14
Building Locaon Installa on Fire Resistance Required Recommended
All DwellingTypes Internal walls within a dwelling that do not One lining only or back-to-back N/A A
have a fire separa ng func on
Page 15
10. Cables, conduit and trunking penetrating
internal fire separating walls and floors
10.1 This section provides guidance as to what should 10.4 Sealing the cable ingress point has to take into
be done to preserve the fire resistance of elements account that the insulation of non-fire performance
that are required to provide fire resistance, when cables will probably melt or char away, leaving an
cables have to pass through them. The guidance unfilled gap between the conductors and the lining.
is applicable to situations where insulated and Depending upon the nature of the cable insulation,
sheathed cables, or cables in plastic conduit or this may even have the potential to carry the flames
plastic trunking, pass through floors and walls. on its surface into the void. On a single cable this is
unlikely to be a serious risk, but the ability to make
10.2 The fire risk associated with non-fire performance an adequate fire seal becomes increasingly difficult
cables and plastic conduits and trunking passing as the number of cables increase.
through building elements is twofold. Initially there
is a risk of a loss of integrity due to the heat and/ 10.5 It is common and accepted practice to make good
or flames passing through any unsealed holes that any hole around a cable by using inert filler such
have been made to allow the cable to pass through, as plaster or grout, but this does not compensate
resulting in flaming on the unexposed side. for melting/flaming insulation, and will also be
ineffective in voids between cables.
Secondly, the hole in a plasterboard lining will allow
fire to get into the ceiling or wall void prematurely, 10.6 It is recommended, therefore, that the sealant used
cause ignition of the structure which can lead to a to make good holes through which cables pass has
loss of loadbearing capacity. intumescent properties: that is, it has the ability to
expand and fill any voids that are developing due
10.3 With respect to the first of these, it is important to movement and/or melting of cables, in order to
that fire is not allowed to exploit either the initial maintain the fire resistance of the element.
penetration of the first lining (which could permit
fire to get into the cavity), or subsequently to 10.7 The risk of fire gaining premature access to any void
penetrate the second lining (which would allow the is increased if the cables are run through a plastic
fire to effectively bypass the protective barrier). conduit or trunking system, or are bunched. Any
cosmetic sealing of the gap between the lining and
the plastic conduit or trunking will certainly not be
able to seal any voids between the cables and the
outer plastic casing following the melting of the
conduit or trunking.
Page 16
11. Ventilation fans and related ductwork
11.1 In older properties, ventilation fans were normally 11.3 If fire were to enter the cavity of a stud wall
fitted on an external wall rather than on an internal or the cavity between the inner wall and any
wall and, as a consequence, there was not generally outer ‘sheathing’, the building can suffer both
a fire safety issue regarding the influence on the undue structural damage if modern engineered
integrity and insulation rating of the wall due to construction is used, and/or disproportionate
such systems when installed in a cavity blockwork or fire spread in the cavity in more conventional
masonry wall. properties. This cavity spread can result in an
indirect loss of fire integrity between adjacent
11.2 However with ever increasing air tightness internal enclosures, and therefore fire should be
requirements, controlled ventilation and, often prevented from gaining access to any of the cavities.
heat recovery is the standard for new builds, this
means combustible PVC ducting runs are installed 11.4 When installing a ventilation fan directly into a
all around the building, often with both return and loadbearing external stud construction wall, the
supplies in each room, which can result in rapid hole cut into the inner and outer lining should be
spread of fire and smoke, both horizontally and lined out across the thickness of the wall with a
vertically through the premises. Where such ducting continuous non-combustible material, preferably
penetrates a fire-rated ceiling, intumescent fan and with some insulating properties, through which the
vent sleeves or fire-rated air valves should be fitted. extract duct passes. This liner should be fixed in
place so that it does not fall away over time.
Page 17
11.6 Any void between two joists that contain such 11.7 Where the duct runs transverse to the joists,
a duct which is running parallel with the joists the amount of joist to be cut away is likely to be
should be lined on the face of both joists with fire structurally significant and expert guidance should
protection board that duplicates the fire protection be sought, in respect of both the effect on the
provided by the ceiling lining. The void beyond the structure and the fire separation measures.
duct should be separated by a transverse barrier of
the same rating. Similarly, the flooring above may
need to be underdrawn with fire protection board if
it is butt-jointed.
Figure 11a: Joist/wall protection when installing vent into conventional masonry wall construction
Figure 11b: Joist/wall protection when installing vent into a timber frame wall construction
Page 18
12. Wall or ceiling-mounted electrical equipment
Page 19
ANNEX A
Floor Joists
Studs
Page 20
ANNEX B
Under regulatory guidance there are a number In respect of these tests, the criteria of failure are
of fire tests called up against which the elements, loadbearing capacity (BS 476 Part 21 and
together with installed components as they will be BS EN 1365 only), integrity and insulation, which are
in practice, have to be verified. The ability of the defined as follows:
element to satisfy the structural fire requirements
Loadbearing capacity is the ability to carry the
and fire separating objectives is adjudged by a
design loads for the specified period without
series of established British and European test
collapse or exceeding pre-determined deflection
procedures.
limits.
The relevant standards are:
Integrity is the ability to resist the passage of
• Non-loadbearing walls and ceiling membranes: flames, or the passage of critically hot gases
BS 476: Part 22: 1987, or (measured by means of an oven dry cotton pad).
BS EN 1364: Parts 1 and 2.
Insulation is the ability to restrict temperature rise
• Loadbearing elements: on the unexposed face to a mean temperature rise
BS 476: Part 21: 1987, or of 140 °C and a maximum temperature rise of
BS EN 1365: Parts 1 and 2. 180 °C.
*The use of a suspended ceiling provided for the purpose of protecting steel beams in lieu of cladding, or
spraying them, is a very restricted application and will rarely be found in the domestic sector. Unfortunately,
a number of proprietary products available for protecting downlighters will have erroneously been tested
to this standard, but these will not be suitable for ‘making good’ fixed ceilings or suspended ceilings
used to provide protection to ‘timber’ joisted floors or other ‘domestic’ forms of construction.
Page 21
ANNEX C
Guidance on what constitutes robust construction c) One hour fire resisting floors between flats:
which identifies where unprotected4 downlighters
may be fitted
• the joists are solid timber not less than 43 mm
thick and at no more than 450 mm centres, and
When the installer wishes to fit unprotected
• the floorboards above are either tongue
downlighters, it is necessary to establish the and grooved softwood boards greater
construction in detail and ensure that the floor is of than 18 mm thick and free from dead
one of the following constructions; knots, or is ‘timber’ based jointed flooring
of a similar minimum thickness
a) First floor of two-storey house:
• the ceiling consists of two layers of
• the joists are solid timber not less than 43 mm plasterboard, not less than 30 mm* thick
thick and at no more than 450 mm centres, and for non-fire rated board or not less than
25 mm thick of fire rated** board.
• the floorboards above are either tongue and
grooved softwood greater than 18 mm thick or
are tight fitting butt jointed softwood boards
free from dead knots, or is ‘timber’ based
jointed flooring not less than 18 mm thick, and
Protected means downlighters that incorporate integral fire protection or which are fitted
4
with fire hoods that comply with the guidance given in Annex E of this Guide.
* Excluding any textured surface which should be removed locally prior to fitting the luminaire
** Type 5 to BS 1230 or Type F to BS EN 520
Page 22
ANNEX D
Northern Ireland
The Building Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000,
as amended
Page 23
ANNEX E
Test procedure to evaluate the robustness of The base of the test construction consists of a single
downlighter fire hoods sheet of 12.5 mm type plasterboard nailed to the
underside of the timber framework. Two further
1. INTRODUCTION sheets of 12.5 mm plasterboard 1500 mm x
This Annex provides requirements5 that need 300 mm are screwed to the inner face of the two
to be satisfied by a downlighter fire hood major timber sections in a vertical position.
that is considered to be ‘robust’ in both its
Midway down the length of the frame, a hole
construction and fitting, and thereby meets the
is cut in the centre of the plasterboard on the
recommendations given in this Guide.
underside of the test frame. The size of the hole so
During installation, in order not to compromise the cut should be equal to that formed in the ceiling to
performance of the downlighter, it is essential that accommodate the downlighter that the fire hood is
the area immediately above the downlighter and designed to protect.
the fire hood remains free from thermal insulation
A 1400 mm length of 400 mm wide mineral wool
(see 7.9). Subsequent to its installation, however,
(24 kg/m3) is cut sufficient to provide an overall
the fire hood needs to demonstrate its ability to
insulation depth of 270 mm within the test frame.
remain in place and resist crushing, that is to be
‘robust’ in the event of any application of thermal The test assembly is held in position 2 m above
insulation or other material by others. ground level by the use of appropriate scaffolding.
Page 24
Once the above distances have been ascertained,
the insulation should be removed and the
‘dislodgement test’ should be undertaken on the
same test specimen
6. PERFORMANCE CRITERIA
5
These test requirements have been developed by IFSA, the Intumescent Fire Seals Association.
IFSA is a recognized trade association for manufacturers of intumescent materials and intumescent-
based systems, membership of which requires all product claims to be substantiated.
Page 25
ANNEX F
Glossary of terms
Luminaire: equipment which distributes, filters or ‘Separating floor and wall’: In Scotland, a floor
transforms the light transmitted by one or more or wall constructed to prevent the spread of fire
lamps, and which includes all the parts necessary between buildings or parts of buildings of separate
for supporting, fixing and protecting the lamps, but habitation, such as flats and maisonettes.
not the lamps themselves and, where necessary,
circuit auxiliaries together with the means for
Three-storey house: A house in single occupation
connecting them to the supply.
with two floors above ground floor levels, often
referred to as a town house.
Critical application: An application where the
consequences of a failure to provide the fire
House of four storeys, or more: A house that has
resistance requirements for an element will have
three or more floors above ground floor where the
a direct impact on the life safety of the occupants,
height of the uppermost floor does not exceed
e.g. between adjacent dwellings.
18 m.
Page 26
Page 27
Best Prac Best Prac (Issue 2) Best Prac (Issue 2) Best Pracce Guide 5 (Issue 2)
Page 28