Biological Treatment Methods
Biological Treatment Methods
METHODS
DEFINITIONS
• BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT is the degradation of organic waste by the action of
microorganisms.
• Degradation alters the molecular structure of organic compounds, and the degree of
alteration determines whether biotransformation or mineralization has occurred.
• Biotransformation refers to the simplification of an organic compound to a daughter
compound.
• Mineralization is the complete breakdown of organic molecules into cellular mass,
carbon dioxide, water, and inert inorganic residuals.
• Biotransformation is partial degradation and mineralization is complete degradation.
BASIC MICROBIOLOGY
• Several microbiological factors affecting biological treatment include:
• Any form of living matter requires energy and carbon for growth and maintenance
• A cell operates two critical types of metabolic processes, known as anabolic (cell building)
and catabolic (energy releasing) processes. The oxidation-reduction reactions which
release energy involves a transfer of electrons from organic carbon as it is oxidized to a
higher state. To complete the reaction, electron acceptors are needed which can be
oxygen, nitrate, sulfate. The energy released by catabolic processes is captured and
transformed by adenosine triphosphate and adenosine diphosphate (ATP-ADP) energy
coupling cycle to support cell maintenance and cell building activities.
• The anabolic processes produce protoplasm as an end product which is composed of 75-
80% water. The remaining solid material is 90% organic and 10% inorganic. The organic
portion is represented by formula 𝐶5 𝐻7 𝑂2 𝑁. The inorganic cellular material contains P, Na,
Ca, Mg, S, K, Fe, and various trace metals.
SUBSTRATE BIODEGRADABILITY
• Most synthetic organics are biodegradable, but some specific compounds may resist
biodegradation (such compounds are called recalcitrant or refractory) or their
degradation occurs so slowly as to make biological treatment inefficient.
• The inherent biodegradability of a chemical depends to a large extent upon its molecular
structure. Small changes in the configuration of a biodegradable molecule may result in
persistence.
• Many organic and inorganic waste materials move through a progression of effects as the
concentration increases, similar to that of a dose-effect relationship.
• At even higher concentrations, the substance can become toxic to the culture. These
effects derive presumably from the degree to which the substance overwhelms the
enzymatic systems which normally degrade it.
• Many of the inorganic nutrients necessary for the synthesis of cellular mass are toxic to
the same organisms at higher concentrations.
MICROBIAL COMMUNITY
• Biological treatment involves complex interaction of mixed biological populations. Growth
rates and utilization of substrate is frequently higher in mixed enrichment cultures than in
pure cultures isolated from the mixture.
• In mixed microbial communities, not only are organisms that can initiate catabolism
important, but so are secondary utilizers (i.e., organisms that utilize intermediates derived
from transformation of the original substrate).
1. Electron acceptor
2. Moisture
3. Temperature
4. pH
5. Total dissolved solids
6. Nutrient availability
7. Reactor design
8. Alternative carbon source
ELECTRON ACCEPTOR
• The catabolic reactions involve transfer of electrons from the waste to an electron
acceptor, and the biological process by which this occurs is called respiration.
• In aerobic respiration, bacteria utilize oxygen as the terminal acceptor of electrons
removed from oxidized organic compounds. Typically, in the case of biotransformation,
oxygen is added to the organic molecule and hydrogen removed. Upon complete
mineralization, oxygen is reduced to water and organic carbon is oxidized to carbon
dioxide.
• The mass of oxygen required by aerobic systems can be calculated based on stoichiometry
or lab determinations.
𝐶7 𝐻12 + 10𝑂2 → 7𝐶𝑂2 + 6𝐻2 𝑂 (Catabolic metabolism)
➢ Because the solubility of oxygen in surface water is in the range of 8 mg/L, even small
concentrations of organic waste necessitate that oxygen be supplied to aerobic treatment
operations. For providing factor of safety, a minimum DO of 2 mg/L is maintained
continuously.
• Anaerobic processes are the treatments that occur in the absence of oxygen. Here, the
organics are degraded to acetic acid, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide which are metabolized
by methanogens, thereby producing methane.
• The electron acceptor in anaerobic respiration include several inorganic oxygen bearing
compounds such as:
a) Nitrates – reduced to nitrogen (sometimes called anoxic rather than anaerobic
condition)
b) Sulfates – reduced to hydrogen sulfide
c) Carbon dioxide – reduced to methane
• The rate of anaerobic degradation is usually lower than aerobic degradation but it offers
advantages when degrading high-strength wastes. The expense of aeration is eliminated.
Less biomass is produced since the organic substrate is eventually converted to methane.
• Several wastes undergo anaerobic degradation more efficiently than aerobic process. Of
particular interest with hazardous waste is the highly specialized ability of anaerobic
process to transform halogenated compounds.
MOISTURE
b) As a medium for movement of the microorganisms to the substrate, or vice versa, for
non-motile species
• Biodegradation in soil systems can occur at moisture levels well below saturation. It is
generally accepted that the minimum moisture content necessary for treatment of wastes
such as contaminated soil is 40% of saturation.
TEMPERATURE
• Temperature has a major influence on growth rate. Cellular activity, particularly enzyme
systems, responds to heat so that the cell growth increase sharply with increasing
temperature until the optimum is reached.
• Increase in temperature by just few degrees can slow the cell growth by inactivating
enzymes and continued exposure to high temperatures can result in cell death.
• Unlike high temperature, low temperature is usually not lethal. Instead, the cells
eventually become dormant. A sudden decrease to a low temperature produces a much
greater reduction in cell activity than gradual decreases to the same temperature. Gradual
decreases enable the microorganisms to acclimate.
• The effect of temperature on cellular activity, and thus the rate of biological degradation,
can be expressed as:
𝑟𝑇
= 𝜃 (𝑇−20)
𝑟20
where,
𝑟𝑇 = activity rate at TC
𝑟20 = activity rate at 20C
= temperature activity coefficient
T = temperature in C
• Most bacteria grow best in a relatively narrow pH range around neutrality. Die-off occurs
below a pH of 4-5 and above 9-9.5.
• Microbial activity can alter the external pH. Examples include anaearobic fermentation
which converts organic waste to organic acids, depressing pH. Nitrification also lowers pH
as does the carbon dioxide produced by aerobic degradation. If any of these effects are
not buffered, the altered pH can inhibit/kill the microbial population.
TOTAL DISSOLVED SOLIDS
• The concentration of dissolved solids can affect liquid-based biological treatment. If the
TDS varies widely, the activity of the microbial population can decline.
• The physical design of reactor within which biodegradation occurs has a major effect on
treatment efficiency and economics.
• Acclimation takes time and shock loads can upset the biomass. High concentrations of
waste are even toxic to microbial population and have inhibitory effects.
• For liquid waste with a highly variable flow rate, equalization consists of passing the
influent into a tank where the depth of water is permitted to vary. The waste is then
pumped at a constant rate from this tank.
MIXING REGIME
• Another factor is that the reactor must provide sufficient mixing for the waste to come
into contact with the biomass.
SOLIDS RETENTION TIME
• Greater the SRT, greater is the concentration of biomass, and thus higher removal
efficiency.
• Another advantage of recycling is that it serves to retain the specific “degraders” that have
acclimated to the particular organic chemicals being treated.
HYDRAULIC RETENTION TIME
• The HRT of a reactor is equal to the volume of the reactor divided by the flow rate.
Obviously, cost of treatment decreases as HRT decreases but it is constrained by the fact
that as it reduces, the ability to handle shock loads decreases.
• Also, as the HRT is decreased, the biomass must increase to achieve effective
biodegradation.
• Extremely high biomass levels are unacceptable in liquid treatment systems because of
potential problems with overloading of the clarifier, and the inability to transfer adequate
oxygen in a limited volume.
ALTERNATE CARBON SOURCE
Binary Fission
Generation Time : 20 min to
less than a day Exponential Growth
Condition: unlimited supply of food, unlimited supply of nutrients and abundance of dissolved
oxygen in water
MICROBIAL GROWTH PATTERN
• Cells have abundant food and grow without limit during this phase
X = X 0e t
where,
rg =
dX
= X
dt
Is it a constant?
• Specific growth rate is a function of environmental conditions for the organism, including
substrate concentration. There is a maximum rate at which organisms can grow even with
plenty of nutrients available (μmax). As substrate becomes limited, growth slows down. A
simple equation describing this behavior is called the Monod model.
m
dX
rg = = X
dt
Monod model for growth
m/2
dX m XS = m
s
= Ks + s
dt Ks + S
K s is half - velocity constant (mg/L)
s is substrate concentration (mg/L)
Ks S
CELL GROWTH AND SUBSTRATE UTILIZATION
New Cells
Food
Inorganic and organic
end products
• For a given substrate (food) the quantity of new cells produced can be defined with a
mathematical relationship
rg = −Yrsu
rg= rate of bacterial growth, mg/(L. sec)
Y= maximum yield coefficient, mass of cells formed per unit mass of BOD consumed,
mg/mg
rsu = Substrate utilization rate, mg/(L. sec)
m XS
rg = −Yrsu and rg =
Ks + S
m XS
or, rsu = −
Y (Ks + S )
kXS m
or, rsu = − where, k=
(Ks + S ) Y
k is defined to be the maximum rate of substrate utilization per unit mass of
microorganism
➢ In a mixed system, not all the cells are in log growth phase. Death rate are not
considered in the above expression.
GROWTH IN MIXED CULTURES
• Growth curves for different species of microorganisms are different from each other.
• For a mixed population, the position and shape of a particular growth pattern shall depend
on the relative abundance of the different species, food and nutrients available and also on
environmental factors such as temperature, pH, availability of oxygen, etc.
➢ Assumption: The decrease in cell mass caused by death is proportional to the concentration
of the microorganism present. The decrease in the number of microorganism is considered
to be endogenous decay.
rd = −k d X
kd = endogenous decay coefficient, time-1
X = concentration of cells (microorganisms), mg/L
r = rg − rd
'
g
where,
rg’ = net rate of bacterial growth
m XS
r =
'
− kd X
(K s + S )
g
rg' m S
Net specific bacterial growth rate = = = − kd
'
(Ks + S )
g
X
rg'
Observed Yield YObs = −
rsu
Important kinetic parameters which can be determined only through
treatability tests
𝒌𝒅
SOLIDS RETENTION TIME
• SRT is a key factor in designing biological reactors. SRT is also known as mean cell
residence time or 𝜃𝑐 .
• A longer SRT can result in more efficient degradation, smaller reactor size, and lower cost.
If the SRT drops below the cell regeneration time, biomass will wash out faster than it
forms new cells.
• As a thumb rule, an SRT of about 20-30 days with biomass concentration not exceeding
5000 mg/L is used for ASP. A higher value of biomass will result in clarifier failing.
𝑋𝑉
𝜃𝑐 =
𝑅𝑎𝑡𝑒 𝑜𝑓 𝑏𝑖𝑜𝑚𝑎𝑠𝑠 𝑤𝑎𝑠𝑡𝑒𝑑
where,
X = biomass concentration
V = volume of the reactor
TOXIC INHIBITION
• Many hazardous wastes can inhibit their own degradation at increased concentrations.
𝑑𝑆 𝑆𝑋
=𝑘
𝑑𝑡 𝑆2
𝐾𝑠 + 𝑆 +
𝐾𝑖
where,
𝐾𝑖 = inhibition coefficient (mass/unit volume)
• From this expression, the biokinetics for various treatment reactors can be derived.
MINIMUM SUBSTRATE CONCENTRATION
• In contrast, for the specific conditions of many contaminated sites, some toxic organics are
considered to pose an unsafe carcinogenic risk at concentrations as low as 0.01 mg/L.
• When concentrations of toxic organics do not exceed their 𝑆𝑚𝑖𝑛 , it is necessary to include
co-metabolism or add a primary substrate. Otherwise, effective biodegradation may not
occur.
MATHEMATICAL APPROXIMATION FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES
• In the field of hazardous waste, a simple first order approximation has been used to
describe the degradation of organic waste. This approximation stems from the following
equation,
dS kXS
=− (1)
dt (Ks + S )
• The approximation is based on two key assumptions concerning the concentrations of
substrate and biomass.
1) For the typical hazardous waste application, where the target organic chemical is at a very
low concentration, the numerical value of S is much smaller than 𝐾𝑠 . Thus, equation 1
becomes:
dS kXS
=− (2)
dt Ks
2) If the biomass concentration changes little with time, it can be considered a constant.
Thus, equation 2 becomes: 𝑘′
𝑆 𝑘
ln =− 𝑋𝑡 (3)
𝑆𝑜 𝐾𝑠
where,
t = duration of treatment (time)
𝑆𝑜 = initial substrate concentration (mass/unit volume)
𝑘 ′ = first order degradation rate constant (𝑡𝑖𝑚𝑒 −1 )
• Solving for S, equation 3 yields:
′𝑡
𝑆 = 𝑆𝑜 𝑒 −𝑘
• Hazardous waste degradation rate constant can also be related to the half-life (𝑡1/2 ) as:
0.633
𝑘′ =
𝑡1/2
TREATMENT SYSTEMS
Classification of biological treatment systems
A key technical factor in selecting the appropriate system is the capability to provide proper contact between the organic
constituents of the hazardous waste and the microbial population. This capacity primarily depends on the state of the waste
and its concentration.
Appropriate treatment
system as a function of
concentration and form of
waste
CONVENTIONAL TREATMENT
• The typical hazardous wastes treated by this method include wastewaters from industrial
processes containing toxic organic substances.
• The method consists of passing aqueous hazardous waste through a reactor containing
either suspended or attached biomass of highly active and acclimated microorganisms.
Flow can be continuous or batch, and the reactor can be operated under aerobic or
anaerobic conditions. Oxygen is added in aerobic systems by diffused or surface aeration.
• The liquid waste receives treatment both before and after biological treatment.
• Pretreatment could consist of several steps depending upon the type of waste:
a) Equalization – to dampen hydraulic surges and variable organic loading in continuous flow
systems
b) Chemical treatment – typically to precipitate toxic metals, if present
c) Physical separation – sedimentation of metallic precipitates, removal of floating material
d) Conditioning – typically to supply nutrients and adjust pH to optimum range
• After pretreatment, the liquid waste flows into the bioreactor where the dissolved organics
are metabolized by the biomass with a resulting growth of cellular mass. This can only be
achieved by biodegradation.
• The removal of a portion of organic waste occurs by methods other than biological, i.e.,
abiotic losses. Volatilization can result in significant removal of organics, especially in
aerated systems. Some organics may not be metabolized but adsorbed with colloidal
contaminants onto the biomass.
• Abiotic losses can account for significant amount of organic waste removed with no
reduction of the toxic nature of the waste. The chemical constituents have merely
transferred to other media which may require their own particular treatment.
Conventional liquid-phase treatment
SUSPENDED GROWTH SYSTEMS
• Such systems include a bioreactor which is mixed continuously, thereby facilitating contact
between the substrate (i.e., organics in the liquid) and the suspended biomass. The
effluent washes the suspended biomass out of the bioreactor to a separation step where
the biomass is separated from the treated effluent, typically by sedimentation.
• A major portion of the settled biomass is returned to the bioreactor to maintain a proper
SRT and proper ratio between substrate and acclimated microorganisms (food:biomass).
Recycling increases the SRT beyond simple HRT. This speeds up the degradation and
reduces the reactor size.
• Typical SRT is in the range of 20-30 days. Lower SRT will result in washout and higher SRT
will interfere with the settling of sludge. Biomass should exceed 1000 mg/L to promote
proper flocculation.
• These systems are best suited for wastes containing moderate to high concentrations of
organics, as high as 5000 mg/L TOC. Low concentrations of organics do not yield enough
biomass growth.
Completely mixed, suspended growth treatment system
Treated
water
ATTACHED GROWTH SYSTEMS