Gravitational Field Strength
Gravitational Field Strength
Gravitational Field Strength
What is the distance between the surfaces of the spheres after they have been separated?
A 2R
B 4R
C 8R
D 12R
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational field associated with a planet is radial, as shown in Figure 1, but near the
2. surface it is effectively uniform, as shown in Figure 2.
Alongside each figure, sketch a graph to show how the gravitational potential V associated with
the planet varies with distance r (measured outwards from the surface of the planet) in each of
these cases.
Figure 1
Figure 2
(Total 4 marks)
x y
(Total 1 mark)
(a) State the factors that affect the gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet.
4.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
The density of the granite rock is 3700 kg m–3 and the mean density of the surrounding
material is 2200 kg m–3.
(i) Show that the difference between the mass of the granite rock and the mass of an
equivalent volume of the surrounding material is 5.0 × 1010 kg.
(4)
(4)
(iii) Add to the diagram above a graph to show how the variation in gravitational field
strength would change if the granite rock were buried deeper in the Earth’s crust.
(1)
(Total 11 marks)
(a) (i) Explain what is meant by the gravitational field strength at a point in a gravitational
5. field.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Planet P has mass M and radius R. Planet Q has a radius 3R. The values of the
gravitational field strengths at the surfaces of P and Q are the same.
(6)
(Total 8 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Some of the earliest attempts to determine the gravitational constant, G, were regarded as
experiments to “weigh” the Earth. By considering the gravitational force acting on a mass at
the surface of the Earth, regarded as a sphere of radius R, show that the mass of the Earth
is given by
where g is the value of the gravitational field strength at the Earth’s surface.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Calculate the mass of the Moon and express its mass as a percentage of the mass of the
Earth.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 7 marks)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) Calculate the minimum amount of energy required to lift a 9.0 kg rock a vertical
distance of 10 m from the surface of X.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(iii) State whether the minimum amount of energy you have found in part (ii) would be
different if the 9.0 kg mass were lifted a vertical distance of 10 m from a point near
the top of the highest mountain of planet X. Explain your answer.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(3)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 5 marks)
Both gravitational and electric field strengths can be described by similar equations written in the
8. form
(a) Complete the following table by writing down the names of the corresponding quantities,
together with their SI units, for the two types of field.
a gravitational
field strength
b m F–1
(4)
(b) Two isolated charged objects, A and B, are arranged so that the gravitational force
between them is equal and opposite to the electric force between them.
(i) The separation of A and B is doubled without changing their charges or masses.
State and explain the effect, if any, that this will have on the resultant force between
them.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 7 marks)
The gravitational field strength at the surface of P is 13.4 N kg−1. What is the gravitational field
strength at the surface of Q?
A 3.4 N kg−1
B 13.4 N kg−1
C 53.6 N kg−1
D 80.4 N kg−1
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational potential difference between the surface of a planet and a point P, 10 m above
10.
the surface, is 8.0 J kg− 1 . Assuming a uniform field, what is the value of the gravitational field
strength in the region between the planet’s surface and P?
A 0.80 N kg− 1
B 1.25 N kg− 1
C 8.0 N kg− 1
D 80 N kg− 1
(Total 1 mark)
(a) Calculate
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(5)
(b) Draw an arrow on the above diagram to show the direction of the electric field at the
point P.
(1)
(Total 6 marks)
Which one of the following has different units to the other three?
12.
A gravitational potential
A 2π
B 2π
C 2π
D 2π
(Total 1 mark)
A small mass is situated at a point on a line joining two large masses ml and m2 such that it
14. experiences no resultant gravitational force. If its distance from the mass m1 is r1 and
its distance from the mass m2 is r2, what is the value of the ratio ?
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a system of satellites that transmit radio signals which
16. can be used to locate the position of a receiver anywhere on Earth.
(a) A receiver at sea level detects a signal from a satellite in a circular orbit when it is passing
directly overhead as shown in the diagram above.
(i) The microwave signal is received 68 ms after it was transmitted from the satellite.
Calculate the height of the satellite.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(4)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(5)
(Total 9 marks)
A planet has a radius half of the Earth’s radius and a mass a quarter of the Earth’s mass. What is
18. the approximate gravitational field strength on the surface of the planet?
A 1.6 N kg–1
B 5.0 N kg–1
C 10 N kg–1
D 20 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational field strength at the surface of P is 13.4 N kg–1. What is the gravitational field
strength at the surface of Q?
A 3.4 N kg–1
B 13.4 N kg–1
C 53.6 N kg–1
D 80.4 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
gravitational potential
weight
energy
A becomes increases by
B becomes increases by
C remains W increases by U
D becomes increases by U
(Total 1 mark)
The radius of a certain planet is x times the radius of the Earth and its surface gravitational field
21. strength is y times that of the Earth.
A xy
B x2y
C xy2
D x2y2
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational potential difference between the surface of a planet and a point P, 10 m above
22.
the surface, is 8.0 J kg–1. Assuming a uniform field, what is the value of the gravitational field
strength in the region between the planet’s surface and P?
A 0.80 N kg–1
B 1.25 N kg–1
C 8.0 N kg–1
D 80 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
What is the value of the gravitational field strength at the mid-point, P, between the two masses?
D zero
(Total 1 mark)
What would the period of rotation of the Earth need to be if objects at the equator were to appear
24. weightless?
B 1.4 hours
C 24 hours
D 160 hours
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
A planet has a radius half the Earth’s radius and a mass a quarter of the Earth’s mass. What is
26. the approximate gravitational field strength on the surface of the planet?
A 1.6 N kg–1
B 5.0 N kg–1
C 10 N kg–1
D 20 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational field strength on the surface of a planet orbiting a star is 8.0 N kg–1. If the planet
27.
and star have a similar density but the diameter of the star is 100 times greater than the planet,
what would be the gravitational field strength at the surface of the star?
A 0.0008 N kg–1
B 0.08 N kg–1
C 800 N kg–1
D 8000 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
A 1.8
B 3.6
C 6.0
D 10
(Total 1 mark)
C Moving a mass perpendicularly across the field lines does not alter its potential energy.
30.
Which one of the following gives a correct unit for ?
A N m−2
B N kg−1
C Nm
D N
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational field strengths at the surfaces of the Earth and the Moon are 9.8 N kg–1 and
31.
1.7 N kg–1 respectively. If the mass of the Earth is 81 × the mass of the Moon, what is the ratio of
the radius of the Earth to the radius of the Moon?
A 3.7
B 5.8
C 14
D 22
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
The resultant gravitational field strength is zero along the line between their centres at a distance
y from the centre of the star of mass M.
(Total 1 mark)
n X a b
A 1 E charge
B 1 V mass
C 2 g G mass
D 2 V G charge
(Total 1 mark)
35. The diagram shows an isolated binary star system. The two stars have equal masses, M, and
the distance between their centres is r.
A zero
B −
C −
D −
(Total 1 mark)
A 3.4 N kg–1
B 13.4 N kg–1
C 53.6 N kg–1
D 80.4 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
37. A satellite of mass m is in a circular orbit at height R above the surface of a uniform spherical
planet of radius R and density ρ.
What is the force of gravitational attraction between the satellite and the planet?
D
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
The planet Venus may be considered to be a sphere of uniform density 5.24 × 103 kg m−3.
39.
The gravitational field strength at the surface of Venus is 8.87 N kg−1.
(a) (i) Show that the gravitational field strength gs at the surface of a planet is related to the
the density ρ and the radius R of the planet by the expression
(2)
radius = ____________________ m
(3)
(b) At a certain time, the positions of Earth and Venus are aligned so that the distance between
them is a minimum.
Sketch a graph on the axes below to show how the magnitude of the gravitational field
strength g varies with distance along the shortest straight line between their surfaces.
Consider only the contributions to the field produced by Earth and Venus.
Mark values on the vertical axis of your graph.
(3)
(Total 8 marks)
The resultant gravitational field strength is zero along the line between their centres at a distance
y from the centre of the star of mass M.
(Total 1 mark)
A planet has a radius half the Earth’s radius and a mass a quarter of the Earth’s mass. What is
41. the approximate gravitational field strength on the surface of the planet?
A 1.6 N kg–1
B 5.0 N kg–1
C 10 N kg–1
D 20 N kg–1
(Total 1 mark)
A 1.1 × 10−14
B 2.9 × 10−10
C 3.4 × 109
D 9.0 × 1013
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(c) Show that the magnitude of the gravitational potential at the Earth’s surface due to the
mass of the Earth is about 6.3 × 107 J kg−1.
(2)
1. _________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
2. _________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(e) The satellite has a mass of 1200 kg and the radius of its orbit is 4.23 × 107 m.
Calculate the gain in gravitational potential energy of the satellite when it is placed into orbit
from the Earth’s surface.
Discuss any changes this makes to the orbital motion of the satellite.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(4)
(Total 15 marks)
The distance between the Sun and Mars varies from 2.1 × 1011 m to 2.5 × 1011 m.
44.
When Mars is closest to the Sun, the force of gravitational attraction between them is F.
What is the force of gravitational attraction between them when they are furthest apart?
A 0.71F
B 0.84F
C 1.2F
D 1.4F
(Total 1 mark)
The distance between the centre of Pluto and the centre of Charon is d.
X is the point at which the resultant gravitational field due to Pluto and Charon is zero.
(Total 1 mark)
(c) A small mass released from rest just above the surface of Pluto has an acceleration of
0.617 m s–2.
Assume Pluto has no atmosphere that could provide any resistance to motion.
A meteorite hits Pluto and ejects a lump of ice from the surface that travels vertically at an
initial speed of 1400 m s–1.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 10 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
Figure 1
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(c) A ball travelling at constant speed passes position J moving towards position K in Figure 1.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Figure 2
Explain why the lines of force shown in Figure 2 cannot represent a gravitational field.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
(e) State which object L or M has a charge with the greater magnitude.
object ____________________
object ____________________
(1)
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Figure 1 shows a point charge of +46 μC placed 120 mm from a point charge Q.
Figure 1
Q = ____________________ C
(3)
(c) Explain, without calculation, whether net work must be done in moving a proton from infinity
to position P in Figure 1.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Figure 2
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 9 marks)
A zero.
(Total 1 mark)
A small object of mass m has a charge Q. The object remains stationary in an evacuated space
51.
between two horizontal plates. The plates are separated by a distance d and the potential
difference between the plates is V.
What is V?
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
What does the gradient of the graph represent at the surface of the Earth?
A potential energy
(Total 1 mark)
The figure shows a moon of mass m in a circular orbit of radius r around a planet of mass M,
55.
where m << M.
T 2 = kr3
(3)
Table 1 gives data for two of the moons of the planet Uranus.
Table 1
Umbriel 4.14 X
mass = _______________ kg
(3)
Table 2
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
Determine whether the same mechanism could project the same object vertically to a
maximum height greater than 100 m when placed on the surface of Ariel.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 14 marks)
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Annotate Figure 1 to show the field direction at X and the field direction at Y.
(1)
R = _______________ m
(1)
(d) Sketch, on Figure 2, the variation of the gravitational field strength g with distance r.
The distance r is measured from the centre of P.
Figure 2
(1)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Figure 3
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
(Total 12 marks)
A 2R 2M
B R
D 2M
(Total 1 mark)
A planet has radius R and density ρ. The gravitational field strength at the surface is g.
59.
What is the gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet of radius 2R and density 2ρ?
A 2g
B 4g
C 8g
D 16g
(Total 1 mark)
The Earth has density ρ and radius R. The gravitational field strength at the surface is g. What is
60. the gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet of density 2ρ and radius 2R?
A g
B 2g
C 4g
D 16 g
(Total 1 mark)
2.
C
3.
[1]
B1
2
B1
B1
B1
B1
4
NB
1) the fourth mark is not for 5.0 × 1010 – all working must be
shown
2) those who do not show conversion of radius from km to m
in the calculation but otherwise correct will get 3
C1
C1
C1
A1
4
B1
1
C1
C1
C1
A1
4
[11]
B1
2
C1
GMQ/(3R)2 seen
C1
mass of Q = 9M
A1
M1
M1
A1
6
[8]
(a) attractive force between two particles (or point masses) (1)
6. proportional to product of masses and inversely proportional to
square of separation [or distance] (1)
2
(= 0.0123) ∴ 1.23%
3
[7]
7.
(a) (i) 19 = (–) gives ΔV = 190 (1) J kg–1 (1)
(ii) W(= mΔV) = 9.0 × 190 = 1710J [or mgh = 9.0 × 19 × 10 = 1710J] (1)
(iii) on mountain, required energy would be less
because gravitational field strength is less (1)
max 3
∴ g′ = = 4.75(Nkg–1) (1)
2
[5]
(a)
8.
________ N kg–1 electric N C–1 (1)
field
strength or V m–1
B
9.
[1]
A
10.
[1]
A
12.
[1]
D
13.
[1]
C
14.
[1]
C
15.
[1]
[or v2 = = (1)
v= (1)
(ii) = (1)
(i) (1)
(ii) (1)
A
17.
[1]
C
18.
[1]
B
19.
[1]
B
21.
[1]
A
22.
[1]
D
23.
[1]
B
24.
[1]
B
25.
[1]
C
26.
[1]
C
27.
[1]
B
28.
[1]
D
29.
[1]
A
30.
[1]
A
31.
[1]
C
32.
[1]
B
33.
[1]
C
34.
[1]
A
35.
[1]
B
36.
[1]
A
37.
[1]
(ii) ✔
For 3rd mark accept flatter curve than the above in central region.
3
[8]
B
40.
[1]
C
41.
[1]
42. D
[1]
(Forces attractive) so work must be done (on a mass) to reach ∞ (hence negative) ✔
2
(e) V = − GM / r = 6.67 × 10−11 × 5.97 × 1024 / 4.23 × 107 = − 9.41 × 106 J kg−1 ✔
= 6.38 × 1010 J ✔
3
reference to R3 is proportional to T2 ✔
A
44.
[1]
C
45.
[1]
(a) Gravitational field lines show the direction (and relative magnitude)
47.
of force on a mass (placed in the force field) ✔
Or
The direction a stationary/placed mass would (initially) move.
1
(f) The drawn line should approximately cross the field lines at right
angles ✔
A
48.
[1]
(b) (At B) the (magnitude) of the electric field strength due to Q = the magnitude of the electric
field strength due to the 46 μC charge ✔
=) 1.4 × 108.
3
(c) Work must be done on the positive proton because P is at a positive potential
OR
Work must be done (on the positive proton) due to the repulsive forces / because like
charges repel OWTTE ✔
(d) (As the ball falls) it experiences both vertical and horizontal forces/accelerations ✔
OR
In this 2nd mark a wrong answer will gain zero marks even if accompanied by a correct
answer
‘Horizontal’ needs to be accompanied by some implication that it is
away from the wall. This may be by some reference to repulsion
from the wall.
Moves diagonally can imply straight.
“Moving away and downwards” does not imply straight.
Do not credit “horizontal straight line” or “vertical straight line.”
‘Gravity ‘ on its own is not a force whereas weight is.
2
[9]
C
50.
[1]
B
51.
[1]
B
52.
[1]
B
53.
[1]
D
54.
[1]
55. (a)
OR
OR
Middle mark may be given when seen as a substitution and can be
a stand-alone mark.
Last mark is only given if accompanied with the working and must
eventually be in the form with T 2 and r3.
3
OR
To give
M = 8.5(6) × 1025 kg ✔
Give full credit for use of Umbriel period and their answer to (b)
Alternative:
Conversion of T to seconds for Umbriel
T = 4.14 × 24 × 3600 = 3.58 × 105 s ✔
Determine k from
T2 = kr3 for Miranda (or Umbriel) ✔
k = 6.9 × 10–15
Converting to seconds mark stands alone
use of k =
OR
OR
stating the escape velocity depends on M/d ✔
g = 0.25 (m s–2) ✔
OR
(comparing
C
56.
[1]
ALTERNATIVE B
G has greater mass because the density of field lines is greater ✔1
Density of field lines depends on mass ✔2
Allow arguments based on potential maximum at null point.
2
Condone arrow heads only but if arrows are drawn in full they must
not follow a curved line.
Arrows are acceptable if drawn alongside X and Y but must not be
further away than the X or Y label.
1
(c)
(d) Sketch must pass through coordinates (R, 0.40), (2R, 0.10) and (3R, 0.044) ✔
Must be within one 1/2 small division of coordinates requested.
If plotted points differ a little from the line drawn then plotted points
take priority.
OR
(area is) energy transferred to/work done on the object per unit mass when it is
moving from R to 2R ✔1a✔2a
In each alternative, the first answer is only awarded MP1. The
second, fuller answer scores MP1 and MP2.
ALTERNATIVE B
change in gravitational potential ✔1b
OR
increase in gravitational potential when moving from R to 2R ✔1b✔2b
R may be given as 1.8 × 105
2
✔1 F(PH) =
✔2 Mark is for the use of the equation allowing for ecf from
candidate’s force calculation.
✔3 Correct answer only, no ecf this interim calculation may be
subsumed in the next mark.
Use of ✔2
D
58.
[1]
C
60.
[1]
(a) Most candidates gave at least one correct factor although vague answers such as ‘mass’
4. was not uncommon. The inadequacy of this response was evident when other candidates
referred to the mass of the object at the surface.
(b) (i) This was often very well done although the setting out of the fairly complex working
frequently left much to be desired. It was often difficult to find the sequence in which
the calculations were made. Errors made included use of the wrong formula and/or
the wrong radius and, in the case of weaker candidates, an incorrect formula for
density.
(ii) Fewer were successful in this part. The use of an incorrect distance (usually 0.2 km)
was common. Few appreciated that the use of the given value in part (i) in the
formula field strength = GM/r2 would give the required answer and most either
calculated the value of the field strength for the granite and left it at that or made
other irrelevant calculations using other distance values.
(a) (i) The clear majority of the candidates stated the definition of gravitation field strength.
5. There was occasional confusion with that of gravitational potential energy.
(ii) Most candidates gained this mark a common alternative was ms"2 - which was
penalised as not being the SI unit of gravitational field strength.
(b) (i) Candidates failing to gain a mass of 9M often used 3R2 rather than (3R)2. 1/9M was
a relatively common incorrect answer.
(ii) Few gained the full three marks for this part. Most candidates started their curve from
(3R, g) but then went through (4R, g/4) rather than the correct (6R, g/4).
Missing from most attempted statements in part (a) were the expected references to point
6. masses and to an attractive force. Many candidates simply tried to put the well-known formula
into words, whilst others referred to the sum of the masses rather than the product of them.
Answers to part (c) were frequently completely successful, making an interesting contrast with
the earlier parts of this question. The main problems here were omission of kg after the mass of
the moon, significant figure penalties, and arithmetical slips – typically forgetting to square the
denominator.
In part (b) the ability to distinguish between 2r2 and (2r)2 was beyond the mathematical skills of
the many candidates who, having realised that g ∝ (1 / r2). gave an incorrect answer of 9.5 N
kg−1.
Although part (a) was relatively novel, most candidates could handle the comparison of
8. gravitational and electric fields. The gaps in the second line of the table could be filled directly by
use of the Data Booklet, but most of the other entries required a little more thought. Derived units
were sometimes quoted (but not accepted) for the electric field strength: candidates were
expected to know that this is N C–1 or V m–1. In the fourth line, distance (or radius) squared was a
surprisingly common wrong answer.
In pan (b)(i) quite a large number of candidates did not state that the resultant force would be
unchanged, even though they had correctly considered the separate effects of a 1 / r2
relationship on both the gravitational and electric forces. The most frequent wrong response was
that the force (presumably the resultant force) would decrease by a factor of four. In part (b)(ii)
many candidates stated that the charge should be increased, without indicating that it should be
doubled – this was expected for the mark to be awarded.
There were many pitfalls en route to successful answers to part (a). Most candidates obtained
11. little reward in this question because they could not steer clear of them. Examiners were pleased
that so many of the candidates were not put off by the slightly unfamiliar way in which charge
was given in part (a)(i), or by the mass given in u in part (a)(ii). This, at least, showed that some
learning is taking place across the topic boundaries within Module 4. The really serious problems
arose with arithmetic, units and the need to take care in calculations. Typical errors in part (i)
were failing to halve the diameter and forgetting to square the denominator. The unit of electric
field strength was known by some, yet hardly any of the candidates could give a correct unit for
gravitational potential. Carelessness was apparent in the work of all those who omitted the
negative sign from the final value for gravitational potential.
The subject area tested in part (a) remains totally confusing for so many candidates, who
obviously cannot distinguish between the words gravitational and electric or field and potential.
Perhaps they did not read the wording of the question correctly. This may be more excusable
than the huge number of wrong answers to the electric field direction in part (c): an arrow
pointing inwards at P was common, a tangential arrow at P was fairly frequent, and a vague
arrow drawn some distance from P was not exceptional.
Gravitation was the subject being tested in this question, on the inverse square law, which had a
14. facility of 61% but did not discriminate as well as it had when used in a previous AS level
examination.
This question, with a facility of 66%, examined the variations of electric field strength and electric
15. potential with distance in a radial field. Distractor D was hardly ever chosen, with wrong answers
divided mainly between distractors A and B.
Most candidates scored the mark in part (a) (i) and went to use their answer correctly in part (ii).
16. A small number of candidates however, failed to add the height calculated in part (i) to the Earth’s
radius or added the radius in km to the height in m. They were usually able to gain some credit
for knowing the correct equation to use.
In part (b) (i), many candidates gave a clear and correct expression, using either the expressions
for centripetal acceleration or the speed in terms of the mass of the Earth. Weaker candidates
confused the symbols for speed and gravitational potential on the data sheet and attempted to
calculate the speed using the expression for gravitational potential. Most candidates who
completed part (i) went on to complete part (ii) successfully, although some lost the final mark as
a result of giving the answer to too many significant figures. Some candidates in part (ii)
successfully related the time period to the radius of orbit and thus gained full credit. A small
minority of candidates gained no credit as a result of misreading part (b), attempting to provide
answers based on a time period of 24 hours.
The direction of forces in gravitational, electric and magnetic fields continues to be an area of
17. misunderstanding, as illustrated by the responses in this question, which had a facility of 55%.
Despite the fact that this question was about gravitational fields, just over a quarter of the
candidates selected distractor C, where the force is supposed to be at right angles to the field.
This confusion with a magnetic field is no more understandable than that of the 11% who chose
distractor B, where the force would be in the opposite direction to the field. Perhaps this latter
group were thinking of electrons in an electric field. Such incorrect responses suggest that
candidates were not always reading the questions with sufficient care.
The gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet and its relation with radius and mass
18. was the subject tested by this question. 61% of the candidates selected the correct response, a
10% improvement over the pre-test facility. Distractor B, the most common wrong response, was
chosen by just over one in five of the candidates.
This question had been used previously in a linear A level examination, when 62% gave the
19. correct response. Several linked ideas were necessary to obtain the required value: the
dependence of g on radius and mass, and the connection between mass, density and volume.
Fewer of the 2004 cohort were able to progress through this, because only 58% responded
correctly this time. Since 21% chose distractor A, and 18% chose C, it is probable that many
resorted to guessing.
The correct algebraic rearrangement of g = GM/R2 would deliver a correct answer in this
21.
question, achieved by 62% of the candidates.
This question was a direct test of the equation connecting field strength and potential gradient, g
22. = –ΔV/Δr. The outcome from this question was very similar to when it was last used; the facility
was 72% and there were no particularly strong distractors.
This question was about the value of the gravitational field strength at the mid-point between two
23. equal masses; surprisingly, only 60% of the candidates knew that this would be zero.
This question required familiarity with the idea that a body appears to become weightless when
24. its centripetal acceleration is just equal to the local value of the acceleration due to gravity.
Hence, if this were to happen at the surface of the Earth, ω2R would have to equal 9.81 m s–2.
The question had a facility of 55%, but one in five candidates selected distractor A.
The algebra required to relate the density of a planet to its mass and gravitational field strength in
25. this question did not prove to be an obstacle to most students because 79% of them gave the
correct combination from the table.
This question, on the gravitational field strength at the surface of a planet, made similar
26. mathematical demands to the previous question but was answered more successfully. The
facility was 72%, an improvement of over 10% on the result when this question last appeared in
an examination. The question was also an effective discriminator.
This question which tested how g is connected to the diameter for two stars of similar density,
27. was the most demanding question on the test – its facility was only 39%. Equating mg with GMm
/ R2 and then substituting (4/3) π R3ρ. for M ought to have shown that g is proportional to the
product Rρ. Consequently, if ρ is taken to be the same, g ∝ R. Yet 33% of the students
suggested that g would be 100 times smaller (distractor A), and not 100 times bigger, when the
diameter was 100 times larger.
This question was more demanding algebraically and involved use of a density value to
28. determine the ratio of Earth’s radius to the Moon’s radius. Slightly under half of the candidates
chose the correct value; incorrect responses were fairly evenly spread between the other
distractors and the question discriminated poorly. This suggests that many were guessing.
This question tested knowledge and understanding of gravitational fields. 57% of the students
29. selected the required incorrect statement in this question One in five of them chose distractor A.
This may have been caused by them thinking they were supposed to choose the correct
statement, or it may have been caused by a general misunderstanding of gravitational potential
that was also evident in Section B of this paper.
In this question there were two further tests of gravitational field strength which candidates found
31. demanding, with facilities of 46% and 50% respectively. The question required candidates to find
the ratio RE : RM when gE : gM are in the ratio 9.8:1.7 and ME is 81 × MM. Forgetting to take the
square root of (RE /RM)22 when applying the equation g = GM / R2 was probably responsible for
the incorrect response of the 27% of the candidates who chose distractor C.
This question, which involved determining the position of the point between two masses at which
32. there would be no resultant gravitational force, was repeated from an earlier examination. Two
thirds of the responses were correct, the most common incorrect one being distractor D – the
inverse of the required expression.
In this question there were two further tests of gravitational field strength which candidates found
33. demanding, with facilities of 46% and 50% respectively. The question required candidates to find
the ratio RE : RM when gE : gM are in the ratio 9.8:1.7 and ME is 81 × MM. Forgetting to take the
square root of (RE / RM)2 when applying the equation g = GM / R2 was probably responsible for
the incorrect response of the 27% of the candidates who chose distractor C. This question was
concerned with the position of the point between masses of M and 4M at which there would be
no resultant field strength; distractor D was the choice of 26% of the candidates.
This question proved to be somewhat easier, despite the rather abstract phrasing of the stem.
34.
85% of the students knew that only alternative C gave a consistent expression i.e. g = GM / r2.
This question distracted only 13% of the students away from the correct answer. When the
35. question was pre-tested only 68% of the responses were correct. Yet it should not have been too
demanding for students to appreciate that the field strength would be zero at the mid-point
between two identical stars.
This question turned to gravitational field strength. This question had been used in a previous
36. examination, when slightly less than half of the responses were correct. This time 65% were
correct and the discrimination was also much improved. The basis of the calculation of g at the
surface of the second planet ultimately depended on the ratio of the relative R × ρ values (which
happened to be 1.0).
This question was an algebraic test of Newton’s law involving the use of density and the volume
37. of a sphere to determine mass. Slightly more than one half of the students succeeded with this,
although more than a quarter of them selected distractor B, where the force would be twice the
expected value.
In part (b) the graph of g against the distance between Earth and Venus was rewarding for most.
A graph of a correct general shape was usually presented, with the majority appreciating that
there would be a minimum value to the right of centre. This minimum was not always shown to
be zero, which was expected. Some answers did not heed the instruction to mark values on the
vertical axis of the graph.
(a) Most scripts showed a clear connection between the centripetal force and the force of
46.
gravity on the satellite, to arrive at the correct proportional relationship between T2 and r3.
Less able students failed to get the two starting equations and only toyed with the
centripetal equation unsuccessfully. The most common algebraic mistake was to miss that
the π term was squared when (2π)2 was expanded.
(b) Marks for this calculation were quite low because students could not cope with the quite
complicated proportional relationship. Some students avoided the proportional calculation
by using the Kepler’s equation derived earlier. Quite a number of these students then got
into difficulty because the distances were given in km and not m.
(c) This question was tackled well by most students. Equating the Universal gravitational force
to mg was a well understood task. Only the least able students failed to rearrange the
equation or made calculation errors. A significant number that were correct failed to answer
using 3 significant figures, but by the same token some making calculation errors did give
an answer to 3 significant figures, and thereby gained a mark.
(d) The students who took the very straightforward approach and calculated the escape
velocity were very successful in this question. However, a majority of students made errors.
Many did not know the escape velocity equation or could not get to it from the conservation
of energy. Other students referred to the top of the graph, Figure 8, at a potential of -1.4 ×
105 J kg-1 as being the point at which the ice escapes, which is a physics error.
(b) Many students appreciated that the gravitational field was stronger at K but then did not
give a good reason for it. They often referred to the earth not being flat, or stated that K is
up a mountain or down a hole. Other students did state that there was a mass at K or it
was an area where the Earth’s density is greater, but they did not refer to the field being
stronger. Also a few students referred to gravitational force when they were really referring
to gravitational field.
(c) Only a small number of students deduced that the field had a component horizontally near
K. Therefore very few scored 2 marks. A majority did appreciate that the ball would
accelerate, even if their reasoning was sometimes false. Several students misinterpreted
the question and thought that the ball was falling, but this would not have excluded the
student from scoring both marks. If no direction was stated, the motion was treated as
horizontal by examiners. If the students thought the ball was falling, and separated the
horizontal and vertical motion, both marks are obtainable. The vertical was ignored and
both points in the mark scheme are still true for the horizontal motion.
(d) The idea behind the question was well understood by the vast majority of students. It was
only the least able who missed out on the mark.
(f) A majority of students seemed to be unaware how equipotential lines relate to field lines.
Very few scored full marks. Common shapes drawn were a line joining L to M, a straight
vertical line, and a tight circle around M.
58.5% correct
48.
(a) As was the case in 2017, many students had not learnt definitions thoroughly. So, the
49. actual unit of charge was absent from many scripts as was a reference to a positive
charge. Weaker students mixed the definition of electric field strength with electric potential.
44.4% of students did not gain any credit here.
(b) This was a very discriminating question and just over half of the students performed well
and gained at least two marks. The hurdle to overcome was to use an inverse-square force
equation rather than an inverse equation that relates to potential. Once the correct equation
had been established, most found no difficulty in the re-arrangements involved. It is worth
pointing out that students who explained their work with a couple of words were much more
likely to obtain marks even if their calculations were wrong.
(c) Most students showed a weakness in their understanding in this topic. The fact that the
resultant electric field was zero at P, and they rightly concluded that the field was zero at
infinity, made it too tempting to conclude the line between P and infinity must be an
equipotential, which was obviously wrong. Only about a third of the students thought about
the work that must be done in moving a proton to a region close to two positive charges.
Also very few referred to the potential being zero at infinity. 60.7% of students scored zero.
The success rate on almost all the multiple-choice questions was between 25% and 55%.
52. Questions that were noticeably more straightforward than this were B7, B14, B19 and B29. Only
questions B22 and B23 proved to be accessible to less than 25% of students.
(a) About half the students were given full marks, with a large portion of them showing the
55. equations and an efficient manipulation of them. The remainder did not show such a logical
approach. A typical technique was to write down as many equations as possible, placed in
any position in the answer space. These students then hoped to find some link between
them. The weaker students sometimes picked up the second mark for converting the
equation for circular motion into one that involved time.
(b) A large number of students could not convert the equation into one showing proportionality
and then substitute data correctly. Alternatively, they calculated k but then failed to
rearrange the equation to make the radius the required subject. A few students failed to get
started on the problem. However, a majority of the students found the question to be very
straightforward and headed straight to the answer.
(c) Some students gained the three marks easily but a majority scored only one mark for
rearranging the equation to make mass the subject. An equal number made no real attempt
at answering the question.
(d) Students who initially established the escape-velocity equation either went on to gain full
marks or dropped one mark for not noticing the difference between the radius and
diameter. The main error by the less successful students was to equate a centripetal force
with a gravitational force and obtain an expression for a velocity. They then thought
(wrongly) that this velocity was the escape velocity.
(e) Half the students did calculate the gravitational field strength for Ariel but then had no real
idea how to use this information. There were some students who gained full marks, but for
many the sticking point was providing a proof that the object could not reach 100 m. Stating
that the force was 39 times weaker does not constitute proof.
There was a good spread in the performance on the multiple-choice section of this 2022 paper.
56.
(a) Only a minority of students did not realise that G had the greater mass. Where students
57. failed to gain marks, it was because they explained their answer in a vague way. ‘ G has
straighter lines’ and ‘ G has lines that push lines from H’ are statements seen that do not
explain the situation. Many did refer to a greater density of lines around G compared to H
to score one mark. Often they failed to gain the second mark because they did not explicitly
connect the density of field lines with mass. Students who chose to explain the situation in
terms of the null point often scored both marks. Their main downfall was to refer to the
equilibrium of null point as a point of zero potential.
(c) A very straightforward question in which most students were successful. A few failed by not
realising that the equation, depending on how it was presented, had a square or
square-root term. Others made numerical or re-arrangement errors.
(d) Students failed to gain marks by not searching for specific data points to follow. Many just
drew the basic shape they expected. A significant number of students did not know what
shape to expect so peaks and other shapes were seen.
(e) There was quite a spread of marks for this basic bookwork question. Students who referred
to a change in gravitational potential tended to stop there and not write about it increasing
when moving from R to 2R. Those who preferred to discuss the ‘work done’ route tended to
be more successful in gaining two marks. However, when they did not refer to a unit mass
they did not score at all.
(f) Most students could find the force on P due to H to gain the first mark, but a majority could
not add the forces from G and H on P vectorially. Many attempted a plain addition rather
than adding them in quadrature. This meant the next two marks were inaccessible for most.
An error carried forward was allowed for the last mark (for use of F = ma) – this gave the
second mark for the majority. A few students calculated the accelerations that P would
experience from G and H and then made the vector addition. This was an acceptable
approach and many of these students scored full marks.
(g) Most students failed to gain the mark for this question because they did not start by thinking
about what conditions are necessary for circular motion, i.e. the need for a centripetal
force. Many discussed the problem in general terms such as ‘ force from G pulls the path
out of circular’. This is true but it lacks the main explanation of the necessary conditions
required for circular motion. In a similar way, some students stated that the force is not at
right angles to the motion. Again, this sounds quite reasonable but the motion or path has
not been established so this really cannot be used as a reference.
There was a good spread in the performance on the multiple-choice section of this 2022 paper.
58.
The success rate on almost all the multiple-choice questions was between 25% and 55%.
59. Questions that were noticeably more straightforward than this were B7, B14, B19 and B29. Only
questions B22 and B23 proved to be accessible to less than 25% of students.
The candidates found this question, with a facility of 41%, to be the most demanding on the test.
60. The pre-test facility of this question had been rather higher. Candidates continue to have difficulty
with algebraic questions such as this, which require two separate quantities (here field strength
and density) to be combined. Practically half of the responses were divided almost equally
between incorrect distractors A and B.