TRAFFICKING OF WOMEN AND

CHILDREN: CHALLENGES AND

REMEDIES
 REPORT

TRAFFICKING OF WOMEN AND

CHILDREN: CHALLENGES AND
REMEDIES

NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION (NHRC) INDIA

New Delhi

Coordinator
Hriday Narayan Pandey

Principal Investigator
Dr. Awadhesh Kumar Singh

Co-Investigator
Dr. Ratna N. Pandey

Bharatiya Institute of Research & Development (BIRD)

4830/24, Ansari Road, Darya Ganj, New Delhi - 110002
 CONTENTS
Preface vii
Acknowledgements ix
Executive Summary xi
List of Tables & Figures xxxix
Research Team xlix
Reference Period li
1. Introduction 1
2. Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 27
3. Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 63
4. Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 85
5. Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 139
6. Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 165
7. Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 197
8. Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 229
9. Research Findings & Conclusions 251
10. Recommendations 271
Appendix-1: References 283
Appendix 2 303
Appendix 3 305
Appendix-4: List of Abbreviations Used 307
 PREFACE

H uman trafficking has evolved into a major humanitarian concern of our time. Human
trafficking is a heinous violation of human rights that takes place all over the world. Human
trafficking necessitates a multidisciplinary, coordinated national and international response due
to its complex cross-border character. After drugs and the arms trade, human trafficking is the
world’s second-largest organized crime. The literature on human trafficking asserts that it is a kind
of slavery or indentured servitude that involves abuse and lack of liberty: “Human trafficking
always results in the exploitation of a person by a third party who recruits, transports, receives,
and houses the victim in his or her home country or a foreign nation with the intent of selling
sexual services. Human trafficking can involve the sale of labourers, organs, and infants, as well
as the compulsion of individuals to work as beggars or prostitutes. The majority of women who
are victims of human trafficking are exploited in the context of organized prostitution.
Human trafficking is a multinational occurrence that transcends the North/South divide. In
1949, the United Nations enacted a convention prohibiting human trafficking and prostitution.
The United Nations has also adopted a convention against transnational organized crime, the
Palermo Protocol, which is an addendum to combat trafficking, particularly of women and
children. Human trafficking is a phenomenon that occurs in the grey area. It can be difficult
to distinguish between prostitution and trafficking, and not all foreign women who engage in
prostitution have been trafficked. It might often be difficult to distinguish between prostitution
and trafficking. In many instances, women are aware that they will be working as prostitutes,
yet they feel powerless over their life. In other instances, they were deceived into believing they
would be performing tasks such as industrial work, housekeeping, etc. A person is a victim
of human trafficking if she/he is no longer in control of where and when she/he engages in
prostitution, has no right to defend herself, or cannot quit whenever she/he desires.
Human trafficking is a covert activity, and the majority of incidents likely go unreported due
to victims’ reluctance or inability to contact authorities due to intimidation, fear of retaliation,
and lack of freedom of movement. Due to the lack of appropriate legislation in many nations,
such crimes are frequently reported under alternative headings. The cumulative effect of these
worries causes the victim to remain silent, hence reducing the number of reported occurrences.
Government of India under the Ministry of Women and Child Development has implemented
a comprehensive scheme for prevention, combating of trafficking, rescue and rehabilitation
of trafficked victims and their reintegration in the family and society. However, effective
implementation of the scheme could not be ensured due to various factors. The plan of action on
the part of various state governments, non-government organizations and donor agencies also
could not witness the desired results due to ineffective enforcement of legislation and governance
of programmes and schemes. Against this view point, this study has been conducted to examine
the issue of human trafficking and the efforts for protection of women and girl children against
 viii

trafficking for trade of human flash as well as to examine the implementation of various shelter
and Rehabilitation Homes such as Ujjawala P & R Homes & Swadhar Greh, Children Homes etc.
in selected states.
The study has been planned in ten chapters. Chapter 1st is introductory-95 percent of
trafficked people in India are pushed into prostitution, according to statistics (Divya, 2020).
According to the NCRB, there are a total of 6,616 human trafficking instances documented in
India, with sex trafficking being the most common (Munshi, 2020). The Indian government does
not yet fully meet the minimal standards for the elimination of human trafficking, although it is
working hard to do so. As a result of the government’s overall increased efforts compared to the
previous reporting period, India remained on Tier 2. Chapter 2nd deals with policy and legal
perspective of human trafficking- it examines the policy and legal aspects of human trafficking
in India and around the world. Chapter 3rd is concerned with rationale, objectives and research
methodology of the study. Chapter 4th examines the profile and problems of trafficked victims
and their exploitation- The study simply shows that victims of human trafficking are frequently
subjected to severe physical violence, weariness, and malnutrition. Broken bones, concussions,
bruising, or burns are common injuries, as well as other assault-related injuries. Some of these
major injuries can result in long-term health issues, necessitating long-term therapy. Chapter 5th
deals with perception analysis of recruiters, perpetrators and exploiters of victims. Chapter 6th is
concerned with status of law enforcement in combating human trafficking in India- The analysis
merely indicates that India’s present human trafficking laws contain numerous loopholes. There
has been a lack of conceptual clarity among law enforcement officers on the topic of human
trafficking. Chapter 7th is related with rehabilitation and re-integration of recued victims- Data
analysis reveals that current reintegration techniques in India fail to provide the basic requirements
and rights of trafficked children and their families, such as protection, decent living standards,
health care, and education. Reintegration is viewed as a fixed, short-term procedure by Indian
anti-trafficking experts. Chapter 8th is all about role and perception analysis of stakeholders-
By incorporating all stakeholders and responders, it is possible to prevent and combat human
trafficking in a comprehensive and holistic manner. Chapter 9th is about major research findings
and conclusions- Insufficient and inadequate laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties,
minimal chances of prosecution, the relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency,
poor visibility and less debate on the issue, the lack of political will of the governments to
implement policies and to provide adequate services for victims- all has played important role
in perpetuating trafficking. Chapter 10th is one which highlights the recommendations and
Suggestions- All stakeholders’ capacity building and gender sensitization are vitally needed and
should be done on a regular basis.
The present study would be of immense importance for policy implications and also for
operational view point as it will provide academic inputs for better understanding of the socio-
legal issue and a road map for protection of women and girls against trafficking and rehabilitation
of trafficked victims.

12th April, 2023 Dr. A. K. Singh

Principal Investigator
Dr. Ratna N. Pandey
Co-Investigator cum Chairperson BIRD
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

W e are grateful to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), India, New Delhi, for
entrusting the study to us and giving financial support. A Special Acknowledgement goes
to Mr. Rajiv Jain, Hon’ble Member, NHRC, Ms. Anita Sinha, IRS, Joint Secretary (TR-II), Dr. M. D.
S. Tyagi, Joint Director (Research), Shri Sudesh Kumar, Senior Research Officer, Ms. Shilpi Jain &
Ms. Tejasvini Akhawat, Junior Research Consultant and Mr. Ajeet Singh, Special Monitor of the
National Human Rights Commission for adding qualitative depth to the process of designing &
development of research tools, data collection and analysis, facilitating contacts with different
offices, commenting on the interview schedules & draft report, and granting our request for an
extension of time.
We place on record our sincere appreciation to Govt. officials especially Shri Surender Kumar
Gulia, IPS, ACP, Crime Branch, Delhi Police, AHTU, Ms. Kiran Sethi, Sub Inspector, also Known
as Lady Singham of Delhi Police, Ms. Sharmista Sharma, Deputy Director ICDS-I, Ms. Lata Negi,
Deputy Director, HOD Women Empowerment Cell, Litigation, Dept. of WCD, GNCT of Delhi,
Mr. Nabin Kumar Naik, State and Regional Director, Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan, Ministry of
Youth Affairs & Sports, Govt. of India, Kolkata, Mr. Surendra Kumar, IPS, IGP, CID Assam, Ms.
Mandira Baruah, In-charge/Assistant Research Officer, Swadhar Greh and Ujjawalla Scheme,
Department of Social Welfare, Govt. of Assam, Smt. Halima, Deputy Director, Child Welfare,
Directorate of WCD, Karnataka, Ms. H. Jayalakshmi, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Crime
against Women and Children (CWC) Wing, Chennai, Ms. Debashmita Chattopadhyay Banerjee,
Sr. Divisional Security Commissioner RPF, Bengaluru, Shri M. A. Sayeed, Member, MSHRC, Ms.
Shruti Shukla & Mr. Sarvesh Kumar Pandey, Deputy Chief Probation Officer, Dept. of Women
Welfare, Govt. of Uttar Pradesh, Shri Dhrijesh Kumar Tiwari, ISS, Statistical Adviser, Ministry
of WCD, Govt. of India and Dr. R.V. P. Singh, Deputy Advisor, NITI Aayog, New Delhi, who
played proactive role in smooth conduct of the study and support in Data Collection.
We are highly thankful to the representatives of civil society organizations especially Mr.
Naveen Joshi, Project Coordinator, KIN Nepal, Mr. Amos Tshering, Project Coordinator, World
Vision, Mr. Sanjay Mishra, Head, Jharkhand, ATSEC India /NACG-EVAC India, Ms. Prathima
M., Associate Director & Ms. Dimple D. Government Relation Officer, International Justice
Mission (IJM), Mr. Raju Nepali, Founder & Director, Duars Express Mail, Siliguri, Mr. Pinaki
Ranjan Sinha, Director, SANLAP, Kolkata, Ms. Sita Swanshi, Chairperson, Diya Sewa Sansthan,
Ranchi, Ms. Baitali Ganguly, Secretary Jabala Action Research Organization, Kolkata and Mr. A.
J. Hariharan, Founder Secretary at Indian Community Welfare Organization (ICWO). Chennai,
 x

Tamil Nadu, who provided their full support in data collection & FGDs.
We appreciate to officials from the concerned state governments for extending all kinds of
assistance and support to the research team in conducting of survey of the selected Ujjawala
Centers-Protective and Rehabilitative (P&R) Homes, Swadhar Greh, Short Stay Homes, Children
Homes, One Stop Center, CCIs/ICPS/JJ Homes, and NGOs working for the cause and concerns
of human trafficking in various districts. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to the
officials and administrative staff of the organizations/institutions for enabling the victims for
their interaction with research team. They also provided all kinds of assistance in getting the
desired information.
Shri H. N. Pandey, CEO, BIRD deserves special credit for Coordination amongst all the
team members and all the stakeholders, Field Survey, Tabulation & Data Analysis and assisting
in drafting & finalization of the report. Ms. Gayatry Singh went to great lengths to enter and
tabulate data in a short period of time. We express our heartfelt gratitude to our research team,
who worked tirelessly to gather data, review of pertinent literature, conducting a field survey,
processing of data, and analysis of research findings at a terrible time of global pandemic. Finally,
Mr. Sunil Barar typed the manuscript.

12th April, 2023 Dr. A. K. Singh

Principal Investigator
Dr. Ratna N. Pandey
Co-Investigator cum Chairperson BIRD
 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

A Research Study
On
“TRAFFICKING OF WOMEN AND CHILDREN- CHALLENGES AND
REMEDIES”

Human trafficking is defined as the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring, or reception

of persons for the purpose of profit by force, fraud, or deception. This crime, which occurs in every
corner of the world, can affect men, women, and children of all ages and backgrounds. To fool
and coerce their victims, traffickers frequently use violence, phoney employment agencies, and
false promises of education and work possibilities. Human trafficking has developed as a severe
social concern, particularly among women and children, and is one of the most egregious affronts
to their dignity and human rights. It is a heinous commercialization and commodification of the
lives of innocent people. Despite the fact that trafficking is a transnational crime, India, like many
other South Asian countries, is increasingly being used as a source, transit point, and destination
for traffickers. It’s not just about human rights violations; it’s about human rights defeats. Human
rights are not the only ones that are failing; society and institutions are also to fault. The duties of
traffickers get easier in the face of rising violence and deep-seated patriarchal norms. As a result,
human trafficking of women and children, the most vulnerable group, is a heinous crime that
violates human rights and dignity. Human trafficking of women and children is one of the most
heinous types of human rights abuse. Because it is such a complicated problem, it has received
little attention from academia, the legal profession, and civil society. It is frequently associated
with prostitution, although this is only half of the story.
For labour and sex trafficking, India is a source, destination, and transit country. 90% of
trafficking in India takes place within the country (intra-state or inter-state), while 10% takes
place across national borders. The country is a transit country for people being trafficked
to the Middle East and other parts of the world, as well as a destination for those trafficked
from neighbouring countries such as Nepal and Bangladesh. India is also a transit country for
people seeking asylum in Europe, the Middle East, or North America. Women and children are
trafficked for the goal of exploitation, which can be classified as either sexual or non-sexual in
 xii

nature. The first category includes prostitution trafficking, commercial sexual abuse, pedophilia,
pornography, cyber-sex, and various forms of disguised sexual exploitation that occur in massage
parlours, beauty parlours, bars, residential flats, and other manifestations such as call girl racket,
friends clubs, and so on. Domestic labour, industrial labour, adoption, organ transplant, camel
racing, marriage, and other sorts of servitude could all be included in non-sex-based trafficking.
However, the increased trafficking of women and children is mostly for sexual exploitation.
While common techniques of trafficking are identified, such as coercion, duping, luring, false
marriage, abducting, kidnapping, and so on, the victims are especially vulnerable due to their
social and economic circumstances.
Human trafficking, like drug and arms trafficking, is a market-driven criminal enterprise
based on supply and demand factors. Human trafficking is made possible by a variety of reasons
that render children and people vulnerable. Human trafficking, on the other hand, does not
occur only because numerous people are at risk of being exploited. Instead, the desire for cheap
labour, services, and commercial sex fuels human trafficking. Human traffickers are people who
use force, deception, or compulsion to exploit others in order to benefit from an existing need.
It is critical to address these demand-driven variables, as well as to change the broader market
incentives of high-profit and low-risk that traffickers now exploit, in order to solve the problem
of human trafficking.
The study is divided into ten chapters. The first chapter is an introduction. 95 percent of
trafficked people in India are pushed into prostitution, according to statistics (Divya, 2020).
According to the NCRB, there are a total of 6,616 human trafficking instances documented in
India, with sex trafficking being the most common (Munshi, 2020). India has been identified as
a source, destination, and transit country for CSE and forced labour of women and minor girls
(USDOS, 2012). It was ranked seventh out of 196 nations in the Trafficking Index in terms of
danger of human trafficking in 2011, when it was grouped with countries recognized as being at
high risk of human trafficking (Warhurst et al., 2011). The Indian government does not yet fully
meet the minimal standards for the elimination of human trafficking, although it is working
hard to do so. As a result of the government’s overall increased efforts compared to the previous
reporting period, India remained on Tier 2.
The second chapter examines the policy and legal aspects of human trafficking in India and
around the world. Human trafficking has been a problem in our country since the dawn of
time, particularly since India’s globalization and industrialization. Our engagement with the
worldwide community has grown, allowing us to become a member of the global economy,
which has boosted our economic growth. On the other side, it has led to the victimization of our
society’s most vulnerable members, namely women and children. Human trafficking is not only
a result of globalization, but it is also a part of it. Sexual trafficking or the immoral flesh trade is
the most widespread kind of human trafficking that is ubiquitous and has been acknowledged by
our legal organizations. Human trafficking is a type of modern-day slavery in which criminals’
profit from exploiting trafficking victims. It is a crime against humanity since it violates the
victims’ dignity, rights, and liberty. It is a type of organized crime syndicate that works in a chain,
making it difficult to eradicate from society. India’s Constitution addresses human trafficking
both directly and indirectly. Part III, Fundamental Rights, and Part IV, Directive Principles of
State Policy, each contain three articles that address trafficking-related issues. The Constitution
notably emphasizes human trafficking and forced labour, as well as the special protection that
must be offered to society’s most vulnerable populations.
Executive Summary xiii

The study’s rationale, objectives, and methodology are discussed in Chapter 3. The assembled
bibliography on human trafficking reveals that the prevailing anti-trafficking discourse is not
evidence-based, but rather built on the creation of a particular trafficking mythology. Despite
the rising interest in human trafficking, there has been relatively little systematic, empirically
grounded, and theoretically sound research on the subject. Activists participating in anti-
prostitution campaigns have performed much of the research on human trafficking for sexual
exploitation. Human trafficking for labour exploitation research is also detached from theory.
Within existing international migration theories, there have been limited attempts to evaluate
concerns of cross-border trafficking for labour exploitation. There is also no attempt to build a
new theoretical framework within which to evaluate the phenomenon completely. Poverty and
the desire for a better life are by far the most prominent ‘push factors’ and primary explanations
for why women and children, in particular, are vulnerable to human trafficking. It is necessary
to emphasize the constraints of small samples for generalizations and extrapolations, while also
emphasizing the importance of ethnographic investigations for creating hypotheses for future
studies, including survey questionnaire development. In light of this, the National Human
Rights Commission (NHRC) entrusted Bharatiya Institute of Research and Development
(BIRD) with undertaking this study. This research study has focused on the status of victims
and their exploitation, law enforcement, rehabilitation, reintegration, and repatriation schemes
and programmes, and will provide a forum for in-depth discussions and deliberations on the
pertinent issues, dimensions, and emerging perspectives on Human Trafficking in India, as well
as the development of an action plan to combat it.
The main objectives of the present study are as follows:
• To review the legal and policy perspective of human trafficking and role of various
stakeholders in prevention, combating, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and
their reintegration in family and society;
• To study the magnitude, nature, dimensions, causes and modus operandi of trafficking of
women and children in India;
• To assess the functioning and performance of Ujjawala Centres in terms of prevention
and combating of trafficking, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their
reintegration in society and family;
• To examine the background of trafficked victims and their rehabilitation and reintegration
in society and family;
• To appraise the government, private and civil society initiatives, interventions and
efforts in prevention, combating, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their
reintegration in family and society;
• To suggest policy measures for prevention and combating of trafficking, rescue and
rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their reintegration in society and family.
In order to fulfill the objectives, the study used a mixed methodological approach that
included quantitative and qualitative methodologies. It’s an exploratory research project that
combines primary and secondary data. The current research is empirical in nature and relies
heavily on original data gathered through a field survey. In addition to conducting a survey and
analyzing primary data, secondary data and relevant material were gathered from published and
documented sources to get insight into the research issue. The field survey was limited to Assam,
 xiv

West Bengal, Jharkhand, and Uttar Pradesh as sources of trafficking and Delhi, Maharashtra,
Tamil Nadu, and Karnataka as destinations of trafficking. Purposive and convenience sampling
have been used due to the illicit nature of human trafficking. Purposive sampling was used
to interview Law Enforcement Agencies/police personnel from the IGP/ACP to the Sub
Inspector Level, Chairperson and Members of CWCs, DCPOs, Public Prosecuting Officers/
APOs, Officials of NGOs/CBOs/Service Providers, Officials of the Department of Women and
Child Development, Social Welfare and Labour Department, Officials of SCWs/SHRC/SCPCR,
and Shelter Homes. Respondent-driven sampling (RDS), which combines “snowball sampling”
and “respondent-driven sampling,” was used to identify the Sex Workers Victims (getting
individuals to refer those they know, these individuals in turn refer those they know and so
on). Randomness has been preserved to the greatest extent possible. As a result, a statistically
representative sample of an unrepresentative portion of the target population has been drawn,
allowing valid conclusions to be drawn about the full target population.
Sample size of the study is fairly large. Total 815 Rescued Victims, 340 Commercial sex Workers,
411 Parents of Rescued Victims, 93 Law enforcement officials, 255 Programs Administrators such
as member of CWCs and DCPOs, 24 NGOs, 29 Prosecuting Officers, 49 Traffickers, 47 Brothel
Keepers/operators, 63 Clients of CSWs, 123 Shelter Homes such as Ujjawala P& R Homes and
Swadhar Grehs etc. 25 ICPS Officials were interviewed and 56 Focused Group Discussions
(FGDs) with different stakeholders across the selected states were conducted. Primary data has
been obtained through canvassing interview schedules, focus group discussions, case studies
and non-participant observation. A total 8 different pre-structured format (Interview Schedules)
was designed for different stakeholders in consultation with NHRC namely Interview Schedule
for Victims, Service Providers, Law Enforcement Agencies, Prosecuting Agencies, Traffickers/
Brothel Operators, Programs Administrators, Parents of Victims and one for Clients of CSWs.
The filled in interview schedules was thoroughly checked, edited and processed in computer on
SPSS 22.0 package for the analysis. Inferences, results and conclusions has been drawn out from
the analysis of data. The data in tabular form has been analyzed, interpreted and discussed in
the respective chapters.
The fourth chapter is about trafficked victims and their exploitation. The study simply shows
that victims of human trafficking are frequently subjected to severe physical violence, weariness,
and malnutrition. Broken bones, concussions, bruising, or burns are common injuries, as well as
other assault-related injuries. Some of these major injuries can result in long-term health issues,
necessitating long-term therapy. Because women who have been trafficked have been subjected
to many abuses over a lengthy period of time, they may experience health problems similar to
those experienced by torture victims.
Recruiters, Perpetrators, and Victims’ Exploiters are all discussed in Chapter 5. Human
traffickers are criminals who gain money by exploiting others. The sole purpose of human
trafficking is to make money. The various ‘links’ in the human trafficking network are
human traffickers. They may engage in one or more of the following activities: recruitment,
transportation, sheltering, and receiving trafficked individuals. Human traffickers entice their
victims with promises of a better life and financial opportunities using charm, lies, and deception.
These assurances are not genuine. Human trafficking victims quickly learn that the promises of
a “better life” or “good wages” made by the traffickers were false. A victim’s “lover” or legal
spouse can be a human trafficker. This is based on a fictitious reality as well. The goal is to make
money, not to be romantic. The victim could be sold or used for sexual exploitation or labour.
Executive Summary xv

The sixth chapter looks at the role of law enforcement in the fight against human trafficking.
The analysis merely indicates that India’s present human trafficking laws contain numerous
loopholes. There has been a lack of conceptual clarity among law enforcement officers on the
topic of human trafficking. The vulnerabilities of human trafficking are not given the attention
they deserve, and they are not successfully addressed. Many officials in charge of enforcing anti-
human-trafficking laws and regulations have not received training. Due to a lack of knowledge
and information, even those officials who have undergone training are unable to effectively
deal with the complex concerns of human trafficking. Between law enforcement authorities and
service providers, there is a lack of collaboration.
Rehabilitation and Reintegration of Recued Victims is the subject of Chapter 7. Data analysis
reveals that current reintegration techniques in India fail to provide the basic requirements and
rights of trafficked children and their families, such as protection, decent living standards, health
care, and education. Reintegration is viewed as a fixed, short-term procedure by Indian anti-
trafficking experts. Individual children’s cases are closed within four months of rescue, according
to 96% of those polled, with no following follow-up or monitoring of the implications of return.
Reintegration plans for rescued children and their families, both short- and long-term, are rarely
established or implemented. Instead, current reintegration efforts consist of just identifying
and returning rescued children to their families, leaving them vulnerable to the same structural
vulnerabilities that led to their being trafficked in the first place.
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders is the subject of Chapter 8. By incorporating
all stakeholders and responders, it is possible to prevent and combat human trafficking in a
comprehensive and holistic manner. The police should form strong alliances with non-
governmental organizations (NGOs) that work in this field. The Police Nodal Officer (PNO)
should take steps to ensure that government notifications are made for the purpose of forming
the “advisory committee” described in Section 13 (3) (b) of the ITPA. In the meantime, the cops
can partner with any NGO they like. Because this is such a complex and challenging subject, the
involvement and active participation of other stakeholders in the prevention and battle of human
trafficking, as well as the rehabilitation of trafficked victims, is crucial. Interventions against
human trafficking come in a variety of forms.
The ninth chapter summarizes the research findings and conclusions. Insufficient and
inadequate laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties, minimal chances of prosecution, the
relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency, poor visibility and less debate on
the issue, the lack of political will of the governments to implement policies and to provide
adequate services for victims- all has played important role in perpetuating trafficking. It has
been also expressed by all stakeholders that people who takes up the cudgels against trafficking
are in miniscule. It becomes difficult to combat because everyone (trafficking camp) is unified.
The profiting families are also reluctant to talk. There has been a complete failure in identifying
and mapping human trafficking vulnerabilities. According to our research, the state, central, and
local governments have not done any vulnerability surveys in the majority of India.
The tenth chapter is the final one, and it deals with the Recommendations and Suggestions.
To combat human trafficking and so defend the human rights of vulnerable people, governments
must have a strong political will to carry out their anti-trafficking responsibilities. Rehabilitation
and Re-integration policies should be family centric rather than victim centric otherwise there are
chances of re-trafficking. Safety and security of victims must be the center of multi-agency work.
Appropriate safety of victims and a conducive environment is the prerequisite of a shelter home
 xvi

and this should not be compromised in any way. Gender Sensitization, Training & Capacity
Building for Police Officials, and Strict Action Against Police Officials Found Guilty of Corrupt
Practices, Harassment of Victims, Especially Minor Girls, are all necessary.

MAJOR FINDINGS OF THE STUDY:

Preventive Measures, Profile of Victims & Their Exploitation
1. NCRB Data shows that during 2019, about 3.80 Lakh persons were traced missing and out
of them, about 2/3rd were females. Out of total missing persons, a significant number of
persons could not be traced out and remained missing. This shows that a large proportion
of missing persons particularly women were forced into sexual exploitation trade. The
Supreme Court while hearing a case in 2013 directed police that cases of missing children
should be treated as abduction or trafficking until proven otherwise, it is yet to become a
reality.
2. Most of the trafficked respondents (80.7%) were from economically weaker sections i.e.,
BPL families (50.3%), AAY-Antodaya Anna Yojana (30.4%) (Poorest of Poor) hailing from
Rural & Semi-urban areas.
3. Friends/lovers/brokers/middlemen, strangers and migrant workers recruiters /
placement agents were the main persons who initiated victims in trafficking; about 12%
victims admitted that their family members are already trafficked.
4. About 11% victim respondents were found minor at the time of trafficking and thus, they
were accompanied by family members during the course of trafficking. As per NCRB
Data for 2019 this comes to 44.04% (2914 victims were minor out of total 6616 trafficked
victims). Promise for paid work, to pay back or support parents were the main reasons for
trafficking in case of minor at the time of trafficking.
5. Sexual exploitation, violence, beating, over work and deprivation of sleep and food were
some of the types of physical and sexual abuse/violence experience by trafficking victims
and sex workers. About 58% victims also experience injuries during their trafficking.
6. Victim re-trafficking is a common occurrence, especially in socially and economically
disadvantaged areas. As per Report of International Organisation For Migration (IOM),
one study found rates of re-trafficking in India to be 25.8 per cent among women trafficked
for sexual exploitation; of this figure, 8.4 per cent had been trafficked on three or more
occasions.
7. There is an increase in the recruitment of vulnerable people for online sexual exploitation
by traffickers, as well as a growing market for child sexual abuse material and technology-
facilitated child sex trafficking.
8. Many trafficked people (8%) are still unable to access governmental help due to
administrative hurdles especially victims hailing from Bangladesh, Nepal & Myanmar.
One of the most difficult parts is determining legal status/Identity. Trafficked people
are frequently refused state services (e.g., medical, employment, social assistance,
kindergarten, etc.) as well as other advantages to which they should be entitled and which
are critical in the reintegration process.
9. A negligible proportion (10.8%) of Law Enforcement Agency respondents & 7.6%
Executive Summary xvii

Programme Administrators admitted that there has been some kind of vulnerabilities
survey in their States, it was reported from Tamil Nadu followed by Assam and Karnataka.
10. It is reported that Domestic Work is offered to the majority of trafficked victims or migrant
workers, particularly females, by traffickers/placement agencies/migrant worker
recruiters, etc.
11. Domestic workers, caretakers, and those employed in the sex and entertainment industries
are largely unprotected by labour laws. Female migrants may be coerced into prostitution
or the sale of sexual favours in order to survive or provide for their family, especially
if they are forced to migrate or are displaced. Sexual exploitation is a threat to migrant
women.
12. The types of physical and psychological abuse human trafficking victims experience have
led to serious mental or emotional health consequences, including feelings of severe guilt,
posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, substance abuse (alcohol or narcotics),
and eating disorders. Victims of trafficking were in need of psychological care as part of
comprehensive medical treatment. Stress, depression, sleeplessness, desperation, negative
thinking, sort temper and violence and lack of obedience were some of the psychological
impacts of human trafficking.
13. Violent exploitation has resulted in survivors developing a mistrust of care-giving
individuals and systems, which has severely hindered the service delivery.
14. Prolonged physical and mental abuse has affected victim’s behaviour in negative ways,
having an impact on both physical and emotional responses. Because trafficked persons
experienced extreme forms of trauma over long periods of time, their capacities both to
understand what has happened to them and to describe their experiences are directly
impaired as a result of such abuse. Victims found that it is difficult to make personal
sense of the abuse they have experienced, much less tried to explain it to the authorities
of shelter home or counsellors.
15. Social withdrawal, poor communication skills, inability to express feelings, difficulty with
adjustment, lack of motivation and aggression, sexual activeness, nightmares, inability to
make friendship and frightened of adults and strangers were some of the behavioural
impacts reported by victims of human trafficking.
16. The level of awareness about schemes and programmes among the trafficked victim
respondents was reported very low as negligible proportion of respondents were found
aware about a few schemes such as Beti Bachao, Beti Padao, Swadhar Greh, Ujjawala,
child line and children’s homes. A negligible proportion of respondents further reported
that they get benefits under Ujjawala, Swadhar, compensation for sexual exploitation and
children homes scheme.
17. Only 3.6% victim respondents were aware about Compensation Scheme for Women
Victims/Survivor of Sexual Assault/other crime-2018 and only 2.6% respondents got
benefitted from the Scheme. The Victim Compensation Scheme established under 357-
A Cr.Pc. by National Legal Services Authorities are not reaching the trafficked victims.
In the last seven years, between 2012 and 2019, across India, not even 100 victims of
human trafficking have been awarded compensation. Out of total 100 applications, only
30 survivors received compensation amount. In 19 States, out of the total fund allocation
xviii

of Rs 544.53 crore for victim compensation, only 128.27 crore has been utilized and 75 per
cent of the funds remain unutilized.
18. About 1/3rd victim respondents reported that their family is unwilling to accept them
back. However, about 2/3rd victims were willing to join mains steam after exit of the
trafficking. Slightly less than 1/3rd victims further reported that they try to escape from
destination of trafficking.
19. Less than 1/3rd sex workers reported that their families are willing to accept them
back in their families. Similarly, majority of rescued victims were found willing to join
mainstream as against 1/3rd of sex workers who were willing to join mainstream at the
exit of trafficking. More than 2/5th rescued victims attempted to escape from destination
of trafficking as against 6% of sex workers who try to escape from the trafficking.
20. There are still a lot of social customs/practices that inducts young girls into prostitution.
21. Majority of the sex workers were from the age group of 16 years and above at the time of
entry in sex profession. However, more than 1/4th respondents were less than 16 years of
age.
22. There is no sound programme and scheme to prevent second generation of prostitutions.
23. Psychological manipulation, threat of physical violence and pleasure are some of the
main habituation factors in sex profession.
24. About 60% sex workers are willing to exit from the profession. Most of the respondents
reported that they do not want that their children follow their mother’s profession.
However, majority of them require the support such as livelihood and accommodation,
alternative livelihood and safe and secure place to live in order to exit from the current
profession.
25. A new form of organized Prostitution has emerged in recent years. Gangs involved in
organized prostitution are luring customers through internet, text messages and mobile-
based applications, taking advantage of a loophole in the law which is silent on regulating
the proliferation, promotion and advertisement of prostitution on digital platforms
and even though leaflets /pamphlets. In the name of Cross Gender Massage Services,
Organized Sexual Services are being provided at Night Clubs, Massage Parlours, Spas,
Luxury Hotels & Resorts, Motels, Dance Bars, Private Residences, huts and even vehicles
etc.
26. Poverty and illiteracy have been identified as two primary causes of trafficking and
Primary data simply supports this theory as most of the parents of trafficked victims are
illiterate and were living in object poverty.
27. About 60% parents of victim respondents said that family members are the facilitators
followed by friends/relatives (11.8%), contractors/agents (5.9%) and placement agencies
(2.9%). Surprisingly 23.5% respondents reported that their children run away from home.
28. Most of the (about 37%) parents reported that their children were working as forced
labour-domestic works.
29. About 31% parents reported that their children were working in hazardous industries-
metallurgical industries, coal, fertilizers, mining, chemical & petrochemicals, cement and
Executive Summary xix

firecracker workshops. As per census of 2011, this figure is 20.7%.

30. There is a lack of National Level Campaign against Human Trafficking and Media is
silent.
31. About 2/5th Law Enforcement Agency respondents reported that the problem of human
trafficking is serious and this has been taken as priority in their agency. Even less than
1/3rd respondents viewed that human trafficking is very serious problem. It was found
more pronouncing in Tamil Nadu followed by Karnataka and West Bengal.
32. A negligible proportion of Law Enforcement Agency respondents (7.5%) admitted that
placement agencies that facilitate migration are registered with law enforcement agency.
It was found more pronouncing in Tamil Nadu followed by Karnataka and Maharashtra.
Thus, most of the respondents revealed that placement agencies are not registered with
them. Thus, there is possibility of exploitation of girls during their migration.
33. The main reasons for non-stoppable trafficking as per law enforcement agencies were
recorded mainly poor economic conditions, social customs, gender inequality, negligible
penalties, domestic violence and poor law enforcement. However, prosecuting officers
reported that poor economic conditions, poor law enforcement, negligible penalties,
corruption, social customs, gender inequalities and inadequate laws are important reasons
responsible for human trafficking.
34. Majority of stakeholders during FGDs informed that it is necessary to identify appropriate
points of intervention so that migrants and future migrants are warned about the dangers
and repercussions of human trafficking and get information that allows them to seek help
if necessary.
35. Poverty, lack of means of livelihood, many girl children, lack of education, child marriages,
and domestic violence are some of the major trafficking vulnerabilities. However,
trafficking vulnerabilities vary across the stakeholders such as victims, law enforcement
agencies and traffickers.
36. Poverty along with gender discrimination, domestic abuse/ violence, organized crime/
poor law enforcement, social inequities and cultural practices are some of the supply side
factors of human trafficking and Cheap labour force, cheap domestic servants / maids,
demand for women‘s sexual services and derived demand-profit and revenue generated
by third parties including recruiters are some of the demand side factors responsible for
human trafficking identified in this research.
37. Abuse of vulnerability/promise and offering money / jobs, allurement/ be funding
/ enticing with attractive offers, deception, fraud making, false promises of marriage,
physical force / use of force and threats were some of the modus operandi of traffickers.
38. A negligible proportion of victims (5.3%), traffickers (0.0%), parents (0.7%) and client’s
(4.8%) respondent were found aware of National Human Rights Commission. The
awareness level was found slightly significant among women and children victims
followed by clients. The main sources of information about NHRC were reported to be
NGOs followed by print media and electronic media
39. About 56% of respondents, who were aware about NHRC, were partially aware of role
and functions of NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among the parents followed by
 xx

women and children victims, law enforcement agencies and clients. Slightly more than
1/3rd respondents were found fully aware of role and functions of NHRC. It was found
more pronouncing among the public prosecutors followed by programme administrators.
About 1/3rd clients and more than 1/4th service providers were not aware at all about the
roles and functions of NHRC.
40. Insufficient and inadequate laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties, minimal
chances of prosecution, the relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency,
poor visibility and less debate on the issue, the lack of political will of the governments to
implement policies and to provide adequate services for victims- all has played important
role in perpetuating trafficking.
41. It has been also expressed by all stakeholders that people who takes up the cudgels against
trafficking are in miniscule. It becomes difficult to combat because everyone (trafficking
camp) is unified. The profiting families are also reluctant to talk.

Law Enforcement, Traffickers & Exploiters

1. AHTUs in India are special police units, devoted to tackle human trafficking. Following
MHA advisory (July 2020), a recent report of 16 states and UTs suggest that 225 AHTUs
existed only on paper, and only 27 percent of the AHTUs were operational. Most of the
AHTUs are designated AHTUs burdened with a lot of other law enforcement activities.
The Anti Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) are not fully operative & Dedicated to
Human Trafficking and in many districts of India, AHTUs have not been established so
far.
2. Anti-Human Trafficking units (AHTUs) are currently under-resourced as well as
undertrained. AHTUs are not fully aware about various legislations and sections dealing
with human Trafficking.
3. According to the Protocol, rescue teams should include: an official from the Department of
Labour, representatives of the CWCs, a local non-profit, a doctor, and a female police officer
or volunteer. These individuals must receive training on relevant laws, their individual
responsibilities, and trauma prevention strategies. However, research participants
reported that, in reality, teams are often too small to cope with the numbers of children
needing rescue. Police officers, doctors, and female witnesses only sporadically take part.
Key informant data suggests this overreliance leads to ad hoc and under-resourced raids
directed by inexperienced or poorly supported workers, a situation that can and does
inflict additional trauma on vulnerable children.
4. The Rescue Protocol states that details of the rescue and the identities of rescued children
must remain strictly confidential, and should not be disclosed to outside parties, including
the media. Yet privacy breaches concerning occurrences and information leaks before,
during and after raids are frequent.
5. Service Provider Respondents stated that employers are often alerted to impending raids,
and that unsuccessful rescue operations can increase the risk of employers retaliating
against children.
6. Most of the Government official stated that rescue team members directly solicit
media involvement so ‘the public could understand that this type of activity is a
Executive Summary xxi

crime and punishable offence’. Publicity generates risks of retaliation against rescued
children, increased social stigma and difficulty in reintegration. Moreover, widespread
sensationalized media coverage of raids plays an important role in simplifying the
complex underlying social and economic problems that perpetuate this problem.
7. Key informant interviews held with police officers, Government Railway Police (GRP)
and Railway Protection Force (RPF) and other stakeholders-Child Welfare Committee
members, NGO representatives, and vendors in railway stations, reveals that most cases
of trafficking are not registered or reported which is the major reason for the declining
trend in reported cases of trafficking. It is reported that Memo/GD entry is made by
GRB/RPF and children are handed over to Child Welfare Committee in most cases. Some
of them are left without any enquiry/record.
8. The terms “human trafficking” and “migration” are being used interchangeably,
resulting in the denial of labour rights. It’s crucial to understand the difference between
“trafficking,” “sex work,” and “migration.”
9. Human Trafficking incidents are underreported as a result, the complainant is compelled
to file a complaint through court order, while the offending police officers walk free.
There are cases of refusal by police to file a complaint on the basis of jurisdiction/area,
despite the fact that any police station can file a complaint and the investigation can be
moved to the appropriate police station
10. There are several reasons for non-registration of cases. It varies from case to case. The police
officials are not much aware of IPC section 370. It is clearly provided in explanation-2 of
the Act that the consent of the victim is immaterial in determination of the offence of
trafficking, most of the police officers don’t accept it. In the case of Bhagubhai Patel v State
of Gujarat, the High Court held that a customer at a brothel comes within the purview of
sec 370 of the IPC because trafficking also includes prostitution, the reason being that it is
one type of exploitation.
11. The police are burdened with so many responsibilities as there are vacancies in police
stations. Hence, they are reluctant as they cannot investigate the entire chain which
crosses over three to four states. No coordination mechanism is available between source
and destination states. Even if victims are rescued and sent back to their home, there is no
rehabilitation package under IPC which would result in leaving the victims unprotected.
There will be also problem in filing charge sheet, trail and other proceedings for which the
victims will not either coordinate or turn hostile. Corruption, pressure from superiors/
politicians and lack of review mechanism force the officers in non-reporting of incidents.
Moreover, the child protection mechanisms are very weak and they are not properly
enquiring the victims and following the procedures. They don’t have any power or
authority to influence the police officers.
12. The major challenges being faced by agency in encountering with investigation of cases
frequently reported of lack of victim cooperation/victim distressed, community ignorance
and lack of identity as Victims do not identify themselves as a Victim. However, other
important challenges were reported to be language /cultural barriers, lack of adequate
resources, victims do not identify themselves as victims, lack of support with victim
support providers, lack of adequate training and knowledge as well as lack of procedures
and clear jurisdiction.
xxii

13. NGOs and Service Providers reported that most of the AHTU or police relied on NGOs
to report victims to the police for action. In some cases, poor inter-state coordination
impeded victims’ ability to obtain services and participate in civil and criminal cases upon
return to their home states. The Odisha Labour Department took steps to improve inter-
state coordination on labour trafficking cases by establishing help desks, located in the
capital cities of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, as well as in Delhi, to identify trafficking
victims from Odisha.
14. International Justice Mission (IJM) and other NGOs reported that some officials in Uttar
Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Telangana and Karnataka treated bonded labour cases as labour
exploitation, which meant victims were not identified as bonded labour victims, did
not receive “release certificates,” and were not eligible for government compensation or
services. In the Bonded Labour Abolition Act, the definition of accused restricted to the
principal employer and leaves traffickers out of the ambit of prosecution.
15. Labour department officials do not register FIR in most of the cases as mandated under
law as there is confusion & disagreement about who has this responsibility. The resulting
consensus is that employers are ‘rarely’ or ‘never’ arrested & unlikely to be convicted.
Official figures for 2015 show that nationwide only 55 cases of child trafficking for any
purpose 1.09% resulted in convictions out of 5,026 under investigation.
16. Most of the traffickers during interaction told that they are also involved in drug
peddling but they were always arrested on grounds of human trafficking rather than for
drug peddling as they get bail easily in trafficking cases. Justice S K Panigrahi of Odisha
High Court. Justice Panigrahi has heavily commented on this issue as reported in TOI:
02.07.2020. Drug trafficking is linked to many forms of trafficking including diverse forms
of labour trafficking in agriculture, begging and diverse forms of hard physical labour.
17. Associations with traffickers with Pan India Network of Traffickers & smugglers is
the basic reason for about half of the respondents for getting involved in flesh trade,
whereas more than one third (37%) respondents have reported that earlier they were Sex
Workers/Broker/Pimps, about 8% have reported that earlier they were brothel owners.
2% respondents were practicing their inherited business.
18. Most of the traffickers (79.6%) reported that they traffic the victims on promise of money/
jobs and they directly contact to the family/victims through their placement agencies.
Placement agencies are playing a major role in trafficking minor girls as well as children
for the purpose of labour, sex slavery and forced marriages.
19. The traffickers have changed their modus operandi with the changes in law and society.
In most of the cases the trafficker is known to the victim who convinces the victim and
her/his family and further sell them over to placement agent.
20. For objecting the work given by placement agencies, the victims are tortured, thrashed
and beaten up badly, many times these victim girls report sexual violence and assault
by the placement agents and even by their employers. The girls are kept confined in the
placement agencies till the time they are sold further. These placement agencies keep on
changing their addresses, name and contact details to escape from law.
21. Most of the Traffickers (98%) reported that Relatives /family members, neighbour /
friends and other middle men are playing critical role in making women and children
Executive Summary xxiii

more vulnerable to join trafficking.

22. Big profit and lack of alternative livelihood for trafficker are the main reasons for continuity
act of human trafficking.
23. Witness turning hostile, protection of victims and witness, court adjournment and victims
pleading guilty were some of the major difficulties being faced by Law Enforcement
Agencies in working with cases of human trafficking.
24. The phenomenon of flying sex workers is increasing day by day and has been attributed
the reason behind flourishing of brothels.
25. More than 2/5th brothel keepers reported that police raids thrice and above in a month
in the brothels. The main reasons for police raids were reported to be checking of minor
girls, law and order problems and for official figures. More than 1/4th brothel keepers
reported that Police Raids the brothel when monthly quota is not given to them. About
1/4th respondents reported that they are often involved in contact with police. About 30%
respondents reported that police are also involved in racket of trafficking.
26. Only 7.9% clients reported that they were ever harassed by Police and those who were
harassed 4.8% clients reported that they were harassed occasionally where as 3.2%
reported that were rarely harassed. Clients those who were harassed by Police were asked
what was the action taken by Police when encountered. 6.3% Clients reported that Police
extracted money from them and 1.6% reported that they were verbally abused.
27. Easy bail for traffickers, intimidation and humiliation of victims, and baseless segregation
of survivors/accused following rescue operation from brothels during complaint filing
are the major gaps in the enforcement mechanism to combat human trafficking.
28. Most of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents admitted that the officials of their
units/department have received training on the issues of human trafficking. However, a
large proportion of respondents in Karnataka, Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu revealed
that officers have not received such training.
29. Most (84.4%) of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents reported that less than half of
the officers in their departments have received training on the issues of human trafficking.
In-service, induction, orientation and refresher training were organized on the issues of
human trafficking.
30. Most of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents (91.4%) revealed that they learn the
subject of human trafficking as regular law enforcement activities while about half of
the respondents admitted that they learn such knowledge from training, conference
and workshops. Thus, about 2/3rd respondents revealed that their knowledge about
legislations on human trafficking is at average level.
31. Majority of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents (64.5%) reported that section-7
and 8 are most commonly used sections of ITPA. However, about 58.1% respondents
revealed that section-3 and 4 are most commonly used sections of ITPA.
32. There is a lack of integrated information system about the trafficked person and the
traffickers/brothel owners/operators.
33. Police involvement in perpetuating the practice of trafficking is reported by traffickers,
xxiv

NGOs as well as brothel keepers. Raid and rescue efforts have often resulted in police
harassment, detention and abuse of women and minor girls as reported by victims rescued
from the brothels of Pune and Mumbai. Although rescue efforts provide an important
means of escape for women and minor girls in CS and a pathway to support services,
when implemented poorly without sufficient police training and adequate insight about
the commercial sex network, it has become traumatising for women and minor girls.
34. It is reported that Law enforcement authorities, for example, the police force themselves,
have a limited understanding of the prevalence of trafficking of women and minor girls
for CSE and tend to be uninformed about their responsibilities under the ITPA towards
trafficking. This constitutes yet another challenge in the prevention of trafficking of
women and minor girls.
35. The clause u/s 18 ITPA, which allows for the closure of brothels and the eviction of
offenders, has been applied sparingly. We have discovered a slew of brothels operating
beneath the radar of local cops in Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Nasik, Kolkata, and others.

Prosecution of Offenders
1. Conviction rate in crimes against women and children for the past three years has been
low. The conviction rate in cases of crimes like rape, cruelty by husband or his relatives,
violation of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, human trafficking,
violation of Cyber Crimes/Information Technology Act and Protection of Children from
Sexual offenses Act, have been amongst the lowest. It has been informed by the State
Government of Uttar Pradesh that they are conducting prosecution drives to improve the
conviction rate in crimes against women and children.
2. According to NCRB data, conviction rate under human trafficking was recorded 42.4 per
cent in 2017 which declined to 31.9 per cent in 2018 and further reduced to 20 per cent in
2019. BIRD’ Primary Data indicates that 20.8% prosecuted persons were convicted. The
main reasons for low conviction rate as per public prosecutors were recorded witnessed
turning hostile (44.8%), poor evidence (20.7%), lengthy court procedure (13.8%),
inappropriate charge sheet (10.3%) and easy bail to traffickers (10.3%). However, reasons
for low conviction rate vary across the selected states.
3. Material evidence, medical examination of victims, suspects and documents and witness
evidence are some of the major techniques being used in investigation of crimes related
to trafficking. However, techniques of investigation of crimes vary across the states.
The State Law Enforcement Agencies Reported that forensics plays a critical role in the
successful investigation, prosecution and conviction.
4. NGOs have reported that police rarely make the informant NGO witness of the recovery
memo or charge sheet, therefore most traffickers and brothel owners are able to evade
legal capture.
5. Most of the rescued victims (56%) have reported that the statement of the complainant/
victims is changed or ignored during the investigation, and it is not video-graphed as
required by law. Even it is videotaped, they are not sent to the court with the charge sheet.
6. Inappropriate charge sheet, witness turn hostile, poor evidences and lack of victim or
witness protection are some of the loopholes in law enforcement mechanism for low-rate
Executive Summary xxv

of prosecution.
7. Service Providers, NGOs, Parents, Programme Administrators and Public Prosecutors
have reported that at different levels of government, a lack of comprehensive responsibility
for wrongdoing and corruption persisted, contributing to widespread impunity.
8. During FGDs with the Service Providers, NGOs, Parents, Programme Administrators and
Public Prosecutors it was deliberated that the survivors/families are forced to become
hostile and refuse to testify in the trial court due to social pressure, threats, intimidation,
bribes, police collaboration, protracted trials, cross-cases, and a lack of faith in the criminal
justice system, among other things.
9. About 1/4th Public Prosecuting Officers reported that present laws are able to address the
issues of human trafficking adequately. It has been noted that law enforcement officials do
not take any action against accused persons who provide falsified documents in order to
obtain bail. Protection of victims and wetness, adequate rehabilitation facilities for victim,
victim’s access to legal aid, long term crime control policy and victim’s rights are some of
the ignored areas in existing laws.
10. Most of the Public Prosecuting Officers (79.3%) admitted that existing laws permit them to
use of specialized evidence-gathering techniques in course. It was found more pronouncing
in Jharkhand, Karnataka, West Bengal, Maharashtra, Assam and Uttar Pradesh. Witness
turning hostile, protection of victim and witness and victim pleading guilty are some of
the major difficulties being faced in working with cases of human trafficking.
11. It has been noted that law enforcement officials do not take any action against accused
persons who provide falsified documents in order to obtain bail.
12. Majority of the Public Prosecuting Officers (69.6%) reported that less than 25% officers
have received training on the issues of human trafficking. Trainings were mainly
organized by department of justice, service providers and independent trainers. About
79% respondents reported that officers have received training on the issues of human
trafficking. It was found more pronouncing in Karnataka followed by West Bengal, Uttar
Pradesh and Jharkhand. However, about half of the respondents in Tamil Nadu and
1/3rd respondents in Assam ad Maharashtra revealed that officers have not received such
training.
13. Approximate only half of the Prosecuting Officers has received Training on the Issues of
Trafficking & prosecution of offenders and those who received the training majority of
the respondents (82.6%) revealed that training on the issues of human trafficking has not
been effective.
14. There are major coordination gaps/lacks among NGOs inside states, across states, and
across borders, as well as other stakeholders.

Rehabilitation, Re-integration and Repatriation

1. It is reported that at every level, there is a resource shortage, particularly in terms of funds
to combat human trafficking, such as underfunded shelter homes, which impedes the
rehabilitation process.
2. It is reported that the CWC serves as ‘guardian of the rescued child…empowered to
xxvi

plan the rehabilitation plan’. Immediate care and support are also of critical importance
as a prelude to more sustained rehabilitation and reintegration into a rights-respecting
childhood. In practice, while basic food and shelter are generally provided immediately
following rescue, care is found to be insufficient. Several NGO participants reported
that rescued children are sometimes transferred to a police station, an inappropriate and
potentially re-traumatising environment.
3. When the victim speaks a different language, investigators and trial courts are handicapped
in trans-border and inter-state trafficking cases. The lack of an interpreter who is fluent
in the relevant local languages makes it difficult to care for women & children who have
been trafficked from different states. This egregious failure has far-reaching repercussions
for service delivery performance and the risk of criminal prosecution.
4. It is reported that both government and NGO run shelters faced serious shortages of
financial resources and trained personnel, particularly counsellors and medical staff as
funds are not released on time. The disbursal of government funding to NGOs was most
of the time delayed for multiple years.
5. About 60% Service Providers reported that service providers received training on subject
matter of human trafficking. It was found more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by
Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.
6. Only 38.1% Service Providers reported that there is reporting mechanism within their
agencies to track trafficking cases. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand followed
by Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka and Assam.
7. Most of the Service Providers (98.4%) reported that there is specific menu of food for
beneficiaries. About 3/4th respondents further reported that they follow such menu, but
Research Team did not find a single cook in most of the shelter homes run by NGOs and
victims reported that they them self-cook the food and perform other activities.
8. Most of the Service Providers reported that they have admission register (87.8%),
attendance register (83.7%), separate case file (82.1%) and detailed case histories of
beneficiaries (74%). However, less than 1/4th respondents (23.6%) reported that files are
being given specific codes for maintaining confidentiality. The files are being updated
mainly weekly and quarterly.
9. It is reported that only 16 out of 123 (13%) service providers are maintaining the
Rehabilitation Plan, Psychological Counselling Reports, Home Verification Reports and
follow up Reports. Research Team did not find a single Psychological Counsellor in most
of the NGOs run shelter homes. It is a serious lacuna and the main reason behind failure
of rehabilitation of victims, when there is no proper rehabilitation plan and no proper
Psychological Counselling of victims then how can they be treated or rehabilitated. Follow
up report after reunion in the family is also missing on part of service providers, so it
cannot be ascertained as what happened to the victims after their reunion in the families.
Home Verification Report is also missing from the files, it raises a serious question that
when home of victims is not verified, how they are reintegrated to families. This is a
fundamental flaw in the rehabilitation and reintegration process that must be addressed.
10. In most of the cases and in most of the shelter homes psychological counselling is done
only on paper, we have not found a single psychological counselor in any of the visited
Executive Summary xxvii

shelter homes during the interaction with service providers.

11. The mode of follow up of victims restored to their families or reintegrated is being ensured
through telephone, other organizations and direct visit to the place where beneficiaries
are resided but was limited to a handful of victims (26.83%).
12. Funding, social stigma, service coordination, long term commitments and lack of
sensitivity and understanding on sex trade were some of the obstacles in rehabilitation
and reintegration programmes as reported by Victims.
13. It is reported that in most of the shelter homes (82.1%) run by NGOs there is a lot of
deficiency on part of the services provided by them. Most of the shelter homes run by
NGOs do not have the proper infrastructure as well as qualified and skilled manpower as
envisaged in the guideline of Ujjawala, Swadhar Greh or other children’s homes. The care
system is completely missing in these homes. Almost every stakeholder argues that most
of these shelters are run on poor budgets. The reasons for not investing in a care system
that does not become custodial is a neglect and blindness to the oppression being inflicted
upon the ones that one claims to protect and empower.
14. Ujjawala and Swadhar are schemes devised by the MOWCD to reach out to women and
minor girls in CS and women in difficult circumstances, respectively. Their implementation,
however, has been far from satisfactory. Rehabilitation centers and shelter homes under
these schemes are not universally available across states. This creates barriers to rescue
operations by the police, because of the lack of designated places to which the police can
send the rescued women and minor girls. Moreover, the quality of services provided to
victims in shelter homes was found to be poor.
15. Many shelter homes were also found to be unsafe for victims, and the environment in these
homes was such that rescued women and minor girls were at risk of being criminalized
and re-victimized. 78% girls/women residing in shelter facilities reported that they
were subjected to invasive medical examinations and had to face traumatizing queries
from investigators checking details of their backgrounds. Finally, the Ujjawala scheme
has not been successful in reintegrating survivors with their families and communities
and in coordinating interstate activities between government and NGOs for rescue and
rehabilitation of victims.
16. In several cases, government-funded shelter homes continued to operate despite
significant gaps in mandatory reporting and allegations of abuse, at times due to alleged
political connections. Due to unsafe conditions and forcible detention in government run
and funded shelters, some sex trafficking victims including children ran away, and at
least one attempted suicide in the shelter during the reporting period especially in Delhi,
Maharashtra and Assam.
17. It is reported that the staffs hired in shelter homes are poorly paid and it is a challenge to
find, recruit and retain good therapists, educators or trainers in shelters. Therefore, the
survivors must rely on mainstream service providers, in hospitals and chambers. The
chances of getting employment based on the vocational trainings taught to survivors in
shelter homes are near zero.
18. Rehabilitating sex workers is a serious issue. The Indian Supreme Court has declared that
sex workers’ rehabilitation program should not be contingent on their being forced to
xxviii

stay in corrective homes, and that sex workers cannot be imprisoned in corrective homes
“which they see as a virtual prison.” Regardless of these facts, forced rehabilitation is still
the norm in India.
19. The Protocol requires a home verification report to determine whether it is safe for the
child to be sent back home to his or her family. If not, the CWC can recommend family-
based alternative care, or residential hostels provided by the government or non-profits.
In practice, children are always returned to their families except in cases where the family
cannot be located. Respondents agreed that thorough family assessments, exploring the
original drivers of the child’s trafficking and measures that could alleviate risks of re-
trafficking, never happen.
20. This serious protection failure is due in part to the logistical difficulties of home assessment.
Approximately, four-fifths of child workers in India are from low-caste families in remote
and hard-to-reach rural areas, and trafficked children sometimes come from families that
are themselves migratory, struggling to survive. In most of the cases once home is traced,
the family is told to come and collect the child from the regional hub.
21. Resources to strengthen a child’s integration back into the family, to support parents’
mentorship and acceptance of returned children are also lacking. As a result, reintegration
is generally reduced to simple return to the status quo preceding the child’s trafficking.
It is not surprising, given this reality, that reports of assault, neglect and re-trafficking in
these environments are not uncommon.
22. Rescued children are not consistently enrolled in bridge school programmes (NCLP
School) after their return home.
23. The Rescued Children who are successfully enrolled in bridge schools, returned children
face difficulties integrating into formal schools because the coordination between the two
systems is extremely poor. This serious problem is partly exacerbated by the fact that
bridge school programmes are run by the Ministry of Labour and Employment, while the
Ministry of Education organises formal schooling. The failure to invest in robust teaching
facilities in bridge schools and to ensure smooth transition opportunities into mainstream
formal education is a critical issue in the reintegration context.
24. NGOs representatives during FGDs reported that ‘There is no chance of financial help or
compensation to victims.
25. Responses of Programs Administrators (76%) clearly show that most of them are not
aware about various components of National Plan of Action (NPA) to combat Human
Trafficking. If the Programs Administrators are not fully aware about various components
of NPA, we were not able to understand how they are administering the various schemes
and programme to combat human trafficking in their respective areas.
26. About one third Programs Administrators are not aware about the main/nodal Agency/
Ministry/Actor for implementation of specific activities under NPA.
27. As per NPA, Central Advisory Committee is responsible for Monitoring and Evaluating
the Strategy and Activities under NPA. But only 9% Programs Administrators are aware
about this fact.
28. As per Direction of MHA & MoWCD State Nodal officers (Police) are responsible for
Executive Summary xxix

Coordination and holding periodical meetings to review and monitor the efforts taken
to prevent and combat the crime of trafficking at State Level. Only about 1/5th (19.6%)
Programs Administrators are aware about this fact.
29. Most of the Programs Administrators reported that they perceive menace of sex trafficking
for CSE as mild (48.2%) and moderate (41.4%). However, a significant proportion of
respondents (10.4%) in Jharkhand and Maharashtra reported it as severe.
30. The main reasons for people in the district being trafficked out according to Programs
Administrators include poverty, poor schooling, poor law enforcement, family conflicts,
lack of awareness, poor social support, lack of severe punishment to perpetrators and
search for better quality of life.
31. According to Programs Administrators Community awareness; prosecution and conviction
of offenders; rehabilitation of victims; establishment of helpline; and prevention against
vulnerabilities of trafficking are some of the existing measures that address the issues of
prevention of trafficking of women and children.
32. Most of Programs Administrators admitted that state initiatives to counter human
trafficking are moderate (53.9%) and significant (379%). The flaws in the existing laws
include mainly lack of severe penalty for repeat offenders; lack of continuous training of
investigators, judicial officers and public prosecutors; lack of provision for special court;
lack of protection for victims and witnesses; and non-existence of special investigating
agency.
33. Majority of the Programs Administrators (67.5%) reported that there is lack of capacity
building for care givers, law enforcement and judiciary while more than half of the
respondents (51.07%) revealed that there is lack of specialized investigative agencies.
Other lacunas included poor police infrastructure (38.21%), inadequate funds (38.21%),
adequate police officials (36.42%) and lack of political will (33.21%).
34. Community awareness, empowerment of women and girls, prone to trafficking, proactive
community policing, help line for women and children, penalties to perpetrators and
clients of victims and sensitization programme for SSHs were some of the most effective
programmes in combating human trafficking according to Programs Administrators.
35. CWCs have not been constituted in a number of districts (20) and jurisdictional aberrations
create confusion resulting in a large number of vulnerable children not being able to access
their right to protection.
36. Majority of CWCs reviewed have a complete five-member composition in terms of official
appointment by Selection Committees. Poor attendance is however a concern. Overall,
more men than women are appointed into CWCs. A majority of CWC members and
Chairpersons across the different States largely meet the minimum eligibility criteria.
However, an ideal CWC composition in terms of a diverse and multidisciplinary profile
is missing.
37. CWCs appear to be dominated by those from the social work and education sector, while
people from law, medicine and psychology sectors are relatively under-represented.
CWC recruitments that could lead to potential conflict of interest such as those who are
associated with a residential child care facility being appointed as CWC members within
the same district have also been noted.
 xxx

38. Nearly all the CWCs are found to be functioning in incomplete settings and some in
severely insufficient settings. The concept of child-friendliness has not yet been defined
within the JJ System. Its implementation has been largely ignored in both the CWC set-
up as well as during CWC proceedings. A single fixed CWC sitting venue has been
insufficient to reach out to all children in need of care and protection within the district.
39. Currently, there are no prescribed procedures in the Act or the Rules for management of
cases during proceedings. While a few CWCs effectively manage proceedings and case
flow, others are seen to flounder and use inefficient/ inappropriate practices.

POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS:
In light of the critical examination of the existing legislation and its gaps to tackle different forms
of human trafficking and punish the perpetrators, Prevention, Protection and Rehabilitations
measures taken by Government of India and the State Governments and the Challenges being
faced by various stakeholders in combating Trafficking of Women and Children in India, we
recommend following Remedies:

Prevention:
1. To combat economic distress, states should map all vulnerable families, particularly
migrants and children at risk, and link them to 37 government schemes, including those
for skill development, income generation, housing, right to education, and livelihood
schemes, such as those under the Atmanirbhar Yojana. The government’s many policies,
programmes, and initiatives involve different departments must be intertwined in such
a way that they must include an anti-trafficking component that is integrated into the
larger plan of action by the concerned government department. Self-Help Groups (SHGs)
and PRIs can be useful in this regard.
2. It is necessary to identify appropriate points of intervention so that migrants and future
migrants are warned about the dangers and repercussions of human trafficking and get
information that allows them to seek help if necessary. Effective patrolling and vigilance
at trafficking hotspots such as highways, dhabas, railway stations, and bus stations
for suspicious movement of traffickers and victims, as well as monitoring suspicious/
unnecessary movements of strangers in villages with the help of the village community.
Truckers Against Trafficking (TAT) and Bus Operators Against Trafficking (BOAT)
initiative could play a major role.
3. To guarantee domestic workers’ rights to compensation, reasonable working hours, good
health, and other benefits, it is important to regulate domestic employment and create a
legislative organisation to do so. Residents Welfare Associations (RWAs) should be given
the responsibility of keeping a database of domestic workers, servants, and maids in their
colonies and societies, as well as making sure that there is no child labour there.
4. The second prerequisite is for a regulatory body to oversee migrations, like the Migrant
Worker’s Commission, to guarantee safety and security of movement. Third, there has to
be a dedicated web portal for keeping a database of every single migrant worker so that
their present status can be evaluated or tracked and they can benefit from various social
security programmes. Finally, we think that governments should accredit recruitment
agencies and actively monitor, control, and oversee them.
Executive Summary xxxi

5. Recruitment agencies should be required to require contracts for migrant workers, and
each state should have a law to regulate them, like the Chhattisgarh Private Placement
Agencies (Regulation) Act, 2013, or the Jharkhand Private Employment Agency and
Domestic Employee Bill, 2016. It is proposed that there be a web-based single point
registration system (SPRS) for recording all placement agencies’ addresses and locations,
with the requirement that no placement agency may function without being registered on
SPRS. A Department of Labour & Employment inspector level officer may be assigned to
regularly audit the placement agencies’ field operations and data accuracy.
6. The government should make sure that all migratory workers in the informal sector,
including prostitutes, are covered by social security programmes and that their children
have access to education in all states.
7. Between NGOs within states, between states, across borders, and other stakeholders, there
exist large coordination gaps or failures. A National Integrated Grid of Anti-Trafficking
NGOs that is connected to NGO groups outside of Bangladesh and Nepal’s borders is
appropriate and essential. Partnership between NGOs and government organisations
is essential in anti-trafficking programmes and actions. The National System of Anti-
Trafficking Nodal Officers at the national level may be connected to the NGO grid.
Ministry of MHA and I&B can play a vital role in this regard.
8. There is a lack of resources at every level, especially in terms of funding to combat human
trafficking, as seen by the underfunding of shelter homes, which impedes the process
of rehabilitation. Collaboration between businesses and non-profits can be started by
either party or encouraged by the proper government agencies. The enormous sums that
corporations set aside to fulfil their social obligations (CSR) could be efficiently directed
into the fight against trafficking.
9. A comprehensive information system about both the trafficked individual and the
traffickers/brothel owners/operators is lacking. We support the establishment of a
national website on human trafficking where members of the public, law enforcement, and
non-governmental groups may exchange images and details on trafficked individuals and
traffickers. A National Database connected to a National, State, and District Dashboard is
required to continuously monitor cases and oversee rescue and rehabilitation efforts. This
will make it possible for the police, judges, concerned government officials, and non-profit
organisations to stay informed and act quickly. To facilitate effective communication, it
is important to promote regional information exchange on trafficking. To provide data
bases, situational analyses, information system management, training modules, and
documentation of best practises, a national media resource centre should be established.
Ministry of MHA can play a vital role in this regard.
10. Human trafficking is so deeply ingrained in society’s social ethos that it cannot be
addressed just through legal measures, government programmes, or initiatives. Lack of
livelihood possibilities, gender discrimination, and opportunity deprivation are the most
serious challenges. The community should guarantee human rights. Other stakeholders,
such as schools, panchayats, other democratic institutions, NGOs, CBOs, religious
teachers, media persons, and all members of the community, must play an important
part in transforming the neighborhood’s existing “culture of quiet” into “community
involvement.”
xxxii

11. The initiative of Dr. PM Nair IPS (Retd.) to Panchayat Against Human Trafficking (PAHT)
could be replicated in every Gram Panchayat in India. This will involve a public awareness
campaign and the development of an all-inclusive system to fight human trafficking at
the grass-roots level that will involve all officials at that level. Women and children must
be made aware of the tactics used by traffickers to entice them with enticing employment,
lucrative incomes, and unions that result in commercial sexual exploitation. In addition
to their proactive involvement, all stakeholders must be empowered by the community,
have their capacities increased, and get support. It is recommended that Anti Human
Trafficking Clubs (AHTCs) be established in every Indian school, college, and university
for efficient awareness building and prevention of human trafficking because students
are change agents in any society.
12. Anti-trafficking movement should begin in order to keep the subject of human trafficking
at the forefront of national debate. The media should play a beneficial role in promoting
a good outlook. Ministry of I&B can play a vital role in this regard.
13. Stringent laws should be enacted to prevent immoral social conventions that, in the name
of folk culture, traditions, and rituals, induct minor girls and children into the flesh trade.
Social initiatives for the rehabilitation of prostitutes should be carried out in partnership
with non-governmental organisations (NGOs), particularly among specific castes and
communities such as the Kolta, Nat, Bedia, Mahar, and others.
14. To prevent the threat of sex tourism, the government must act quickly. It is necessary to
institutionalize coordination between state police agencies and central law enforcement
agencies, including immigration officers, as well as other related departments such as
tourism and urban development.
15. The problem of second-generation prostitution can be reduced if the children of prostitutes
are given a fair future. Prajwala, an Andhra Pradesh-based anti-trafficking organization,
has made a start.
16. There is an increased need to raise awareness among the trafficking vulnerable population
in general, and among trafficking victims in particular, about various development
schemes and programmes being implemented by State Governments, which are either
sponsored by the Central Government or by the State Government. Ministry of I&B can
play a vital role in this regard.
17. Because the law is silent on controlling the proliferation, promotion, and advertisement
of prostitution on digital platforms and even through leaflets/pamphlets, gangs engaged
in organised prostitution are enticing clients using the internet, text messaging, and
mobile-based applications. Organized sexual services are offered in nightclubs, massage
parlours, spas, luxury hotels & resorts, motels, dance bars, private residences, huts, and
even cars, among other places, under the guise of cross-gender massage services. On the
internet and on mobile devices, these kinds of messages ought to be outlawed, and an
effective monitoring system ought to be developed to find such material there and on
other social media platforms. To counteract organised prostitution, which may be a form
of human trafficking and is illegal under the law, local police should be especially vigilant
and frequent checks and raids should be conducted at these sites.
18. The same recruiter can repeatedly traffic many vulnerable children from a village because
Executive Summary xxxiii

arrests are typically focused on the place of exploitation rather than on perpetrators
complicit in other stages of trafficking. As a result, it is suggested that widespread
knowledge of human traffickers be raised at both the source and transit points.
19. Along with a growing market for child sexual abuse materials and technology-facilitated
child sex trafficking, there is an increase in the recruitment of vulnerable individuals for
online sexual exploitation by traffickers. Social media and messaging businesses have been
urged by CEDAW to implement sufficient security measures to lower the danger of human
trafficking and sexual exploitation of women and girls. Digital platforms should use “big
data, artificial intelligence, and analytics to identify any pattern that could lead to trafficking
and identification of the relevant parties” engaging in criminal activities, according to the
request. In this regards MHA may create a cell & a dashboard under Indian Cybercrime
Coordination Centre (I4C) Scheme for combating Online Human Trafficking with a alert
system for local police. The cell may be entrusted with the responsibility to verify that social
media and messaging providers are adhering to CEDAW regulations. It is also essential to
start a significant public education effort regarding the nation’s cyber laws.

Effective Rescue, Rehabilitation, Repatriation & Re-Integration

1. Sex workers have expressed a desire to be included in social security programmes as well
as take part in larger campaigns and forums advocating for the rights of the unorganised
sector. Customized rehabilitation programmes have been found to be more successful
than shelter-based programmes, such as the Community Based Rehabilitation Package
and identity-based self-help groups. It might be possible to reproduce the Gujrat
Amul Model for Sex Workers Rehabilitation in other regions of India. We recommend
that initiatives impacting sex workers be carried out with the input, participation, and
leadership of sex workers. We urge the Indian government to adopt a comprehensive
strategy to uphold sex workers’ human rights.
2. The Bonded Labor Abolition Act limits the definition of an accused to the primary employer
and excludes traffickers from prosecution. The fact that victims were not recognised
as such, did not receive “release certificates,” and were not qualified for government
assistance was considered labour exploitation by some. It is essential that the statute be
amended so that traffickers are subject to prosecution under the Bonded Labor Laws. We
demand that those responsible for such abuses be held accountable to the fullest extent of
the law and that programme managers, including SDMs, receive training on how to do
away with the bonded labour system.
3. There is a serious lack of services provided in the majority of shelter homes managed
by NGOs. Budgetary resources must be increased to support the programme. Anti-
trafficking initiatives that are creative, multifaceted, and cross-sectoral should be given
top priority. The Indian government should push for the use of CSR cash for community-
based rehabilitation programmes and closely supervised shelter facilities in the anti-
trafficking sector.
4. Strong oversight and administration of Shelter homes’ operations, as well as the provision
of Social Audit, are also crucial. It is imperative to have an unbiased social audit authority.
These shelters should be connected to various government programmes like ICDS,
NRHM, NSDM/NSDC, and others in order to establish convergence and connect rescued
victims to the mainstream.
xxxiv

5. The Ministry of Women and Child Development, in collaboration with the Ministries of
Education and Skill Development, should implement skill development initiatives and
vocational training programmes for children rescued from beggaring, drug abuse, child
labour, bonded labour, and adolescent dropout girls.
6. Rehabilitation and Re-integration policies should be family centric rather than victim
centric otherwise there are chances of re-trafficking. Safety and security of victims must
be the center of multi-agency work. Appropriate safety of victims and a conducive
environment is the prerequisite of a shelter home and this should not be compromised in
any way.
7. Depending on the objective of the shelter and the anticipated requirements of the women
it will serve, particular positions and qualifications should be given preference. To
optimise the breadth of services that can be provided with limited resources, personnel
from Shelter Home may be hired on a case-by-case basis or staff with diverse/multiple
abilities may be recruited.
8. We suggest requiring PTSD testing of human trafficking survivors before they may be
rehabilitated and assisting NGOs in offering assistance for rights-based case management.
9. Rehabilitation frequently entails returning the child/victim to the same parents who
exploited them in the first place. “We must abandon the notion that the natal family is a
safe sanctuary for young children and develop novel rehabilitation solutions.” Stopping
child trafficking in the country should be the responsibility of the government. It should be
made mandatory and compulsory that no victim is re-integrated and repatriation until and unless
complete home verification is done.
10. In circumstances where the victim’s or child’s safe return to his or her family is either
impractical or not in the victim’s best interests, sufficient care arrangements that preserve
the victim’s rights and dignity must be created. A child who is mature enough to form
their own ideas should be given the freedom to express them in every choice that affects
them, especially those involving the possibility of returning to their family, and their
opinions should be given the weight that is appropriate given their maturity and age.
11. Mandatory repatriation of rescued survivors is not desired, as many of the girls were
averse to the prospect of reuniting with their families. Participants who were duped into
trafficking by deception were eager to return to their families, whereas those who had fled
their homes due to domestic violence and eventually ended up in a trafficking position
were hesitant to return.
12. To arrest re-trafficking and facilitate the return and reintegration tailor-made strategies
are required, which can address the factors which lead to the victimization in the first
instance. All interventions during the rehabilitation phase must address the potentially
vulnerable elements causing trafficking in the first place on the case-by-case basis.
13. Service Providers (Shelter homes) have no mechanism for follow up or monitoring of
victims after reintegration. It is recommended that periodic monitoring of the victim’s
well-being after reintegration be done through service providers on the ground before
closing the case.
14. The Ministry of Labour & Employment, Ministry of Education, and State Governments
Executive Summary xxxv

should collaborate to ensure that there are enough NCLP Schools in each district and
develop a monitoring mechanism to ensure that NCLP schools are providing the services
for which they were created. The rescued children and their families require ongoing
counselling and persuasion to enrol in NCLP Schools.
15. There is an urgent need for strengthening the systems of victim compensation for
increasing access to survivors of all forms of trafficking. An essential factor that enables
survivors to work in congruence with the justice system involves harm reparation and
compensation that is provided to the survivors in question.
16. The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) is largely unknown to victims,
traffickers, parents, and clients. We strongly suggest educating the general public, as
well as law enforcement personnel, service providers, prosecutors, and programme
administrators, about the NHRC’s duties and functions, as well as its grievance redressal
procedure.

Effective Law Enforcement & Prosecution:

1. Law enforcement officials should treat cases of missing children as abduction or trafficking
until proven otherwise as per Direction of The Supreme Court in 2013 and search for
these people in every possible location. When children disappear, Law EAs should start
the missing person’s process, look into what happened, disseminate information, and
conduct investigations, collaborating with other agencies as needed.
2. About 31 percent Parent respondents reported that their children were working in
hazardous industries- metallurgical industries, coal, fertilizers, mining, chemical &
petrochemicals, cement and firecracker workshops. We recommend that provisions of
The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection) of Children Act, 2000: and The Child Labour
(Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986: should be implemented in letter and sprits.
Violators should be punished. Regular check of hazardous industries/units must be
carried out by the Labour Inspectors.
3. The idea of community policing needs to be made more widely known in order for people
and non-governmental organisations to get involved in policing to stop and combat the
trafficking of women and children.
4. Anti-Human Trafficking units (AHTUs) are currently under-resourced as well as
undertrained. There is an urgent need for additional Capacity Building of AHTUs and
Providing them adequate funds and infrastructure because “the police lack the means to
undertake a thorough investigation if the person is trafficked from another state.”
5. To address the issue and protect the rights of victims and survivors, comprehensive
legislation is required due to the underreporting of human trafficking instances and gaps
in other laws. For law enforcement organisations, there is a need for an extensive training
and capacity-building programme on the topic of human trafficking. It should be made
mandatory for AHTU or the Police to report every case of human trafficking.
6. We advise the police to use the following strategies to win the trust of victims: Assuring
victims that they are not the subject of an inquiry Victims deserve to be treated with respect
and decency. Employ a translator if the victims speak different languages, ensuring that
the victim’s identity and privacy are protected by taking all necessary precautions; Keep
xxxvi

the accused far enough away from the victims to be safe. Check to see if Section 228
A of the IPC and Section 21 of the JJ Act are being followed; Inform the victims of the
investigation’s development; Keep in mind that the victim takes all of their belongings
with them. Do not take offence if traumatised victims behave inappropriately or refuse to
interact. Avoid, among other things, using derogatory language or making humiliating
gestures or body language. Police officers may be able to overcome these challenges using
their knowledge, skilful communication abilities, and information because it is also a
question of counselling and persuasion.
7. According to public prosecutors, the primary causes for the low conviction rate include
witnesses becoming hostile, inadequate evidence, a long court process, an improper
charge sheet, and easy bail for traffickers. The problem of insufficient evidence and
improper charge sheet could be addressed by conducting thorough investigations into
human trafficking instances. Because most witnesses and victims become hostile during
prosecution, more emphasis should be placed on gathering Material Evidence, Medical
Examination of Victims, Suspects, Digital Videography of Investigations & Statements of
Victims and Documents Supplemented by Forensic Evidences for filling a charge sheet
instead of a statement under section 161 of the Cr..Pc., as this will almost certainly increase
the chances of offenders being convicted.
8. A qualified and experienced investigative agency, such as the National Investigation
Agency (NIA), which has been mandated to look into interstate and international
trafficking crimes, is urgently required for the proper investigation of human trafficking
cases. We support the full capacity building of law enforcement and prosecuting
organisations, including providing them with state-of-the-art methods and tools for
obtaining information and forensic evidence, as well as witness and victim protection,
which may lead to a more severe conviction.
9. Recruitment agencies, document forgers, brokers, brothel owners, debt collectors,
managers and owners of employment agencies, corrupt immigration officials, consular
staff, embassy staff, law enforcement officers, border guards who accept bribes in
exchange for passports, visas, and safe transit, and all others who are involved by their
acts of omission and commission that result in exploitation should be dealt harshly under
law.
10. In order to safeguard some victims of human trafficking, prosecutors should set up child-
friendly courts, as is done in Telangana and West Bengal. Most of the time, courts should
employ video conferencing to hear testimony from victims who have been reintegrated
or repatriated. Since it is essential for convicting traffickers and criminals, victim and
witness protection should be carefully considered. Because of poor witness protection
and the drawn-out legal process, many victims were reluctant to take part in trials against
their traffickers. As a result, it should be ensured that cases are routinely reviewed by
superior authorities.
11. To combat human trafficking, all states and territories should establish an Anti-Human
Trafficking Bureau at the state capital level, as well as independent, non-designated Anti-
Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) at every district level, and use of Women Help Desks to
monitor investigations at every police station by a Senior Officer at State Level. Dedicated
AHTUs are urgently needed because some AHTUs lacked defined mandates, were not
Executive Summary xxxvii

completely focused on human trafficking, and often received requests for assistance
months later, limiting the effectiveness of investigations. In a few cases, police allegedly
freed alleged sex traffickers on bond right away, allowing them to focus on other crimes.
Trafficking investigations are lengthy and complex, and we believe that having full-time
resources devoted to these investigations are essential for success. These officials also
underscore the need to provide and use undercover assets and to establish and nurture
informants and witnesses.
12. Ministry of Home Affairs should collaborate with the Ministry of Railways. The Railway
Board should be asked to enlist the help of the Railway Protection Force (RPF) and the
Government Railway Police (GRP) to combat human trafficking at railway stations. They
should instruct GRP and RPF officials to remain watchful and alert when dealing with
such instances and mandatorily report each and every case of Human trafficking.
13. Brothels ought to be shut down right away. A thorough action plan needs to be created
for this project. Prostitutes and commercial sex workers need to be rehabilitated into other
fields in order to improve their livelihoods. The relationship between police and owners
of brothels makes things worse. This nexus has to be broken up as soon as feasible.
14. It is advised that rescue teams strictly follow rescue protocols and include a representative
from the Department of Labor, representatives from the CWCs, a local non-profit, a doctor,
and a female police officer or volunteer. Almost every stakeholder reported that police do
not follow standard rescue protocol.
15. Enforcing the law in relation to applicable Acts like CLPRA, BLSA, IPTA, JJA, and IPC
involves not only police but also many other authorities involved in the Criminal Justice
System, such as executive magistrates, labour officials, CWC members, and in-charges of
Homes. In order to strengthen the state’s investigation and prosecution apparatus in this
area, the State government should create a time-bound action plan.
16. The development of all stakeholders’ capacities and a regular programme of gender
sensitization are absolutely necessary.
17. A First Information Report should be filed in every instance of child labour, the case should
be thoroughly investigated, and the offenders should be punished. As a result, there is
an urgent need to train and sensitise labour department workers on the aforementioned
issue.
18. The lack of an interpreter who is fluent in the relevant local languages makes it difficult to
care for children who have been trafficked from different states. As a result, professional
interpreters are required in such situations. At the district level, a database of competent
language interpreters should be kept and shared with law enforcement agencies, service
providers, and the courts.
19. CWCs must be established in each district as soon as possible, according to available
guidelines, and multiple appointment practices should be strictly prohibited to eliminate
potential conflicts of interest. CWCs should include those who work in the fields of law,
medicine, and psychology.
20. It is found that almost all CWCs are working in inadequate sittings, some of which are
seriously inadequate. To deal with this, three different sorts of sitting venue styles are
utilised by several CWCs across the nation. There are further unique sittings available,
 xxxviii

including rotating and parallel sittings. Each, however, offers a unique set of benefits and
drawbacks. A mixed sitting configuration of CWC is advised as needed.
21. The Act and the Rules do not currently provide any procedures for case management
during hearings. While some CWCs successfully handle proceedings and financial
flow, others seem to be struggling and using ineffective/inappropriate approaches. The
necessary authorities must create a flawless attendance system, such as Aadhar Enabled
Biometric Attendance, to prevent prolonged absenteeism from CWC meetings because it
interferes with the evaluation of children’s rights.
22. Strong action against human traffickers should be taken, including criminal penalties and
the freezing of their bank accounts. The unlawful assets amassed by traffickers and other
parties as a result of exploiting trafficked victims should be seized and forfeited.
Human trafficking, particularly of minors, is a kind of modern-day slavery that necessitates
a holistic, multi-sectoral strategy to address the problem’s complicated dimensions. Law cannot
be the exclusive device for dealing with challenging social and economic issues. Given the
infancy of services to trafficked people, monitoring and evaluation studies should be a part of
any assistance programme, both governmental and private. Anti-trafficking legislation must be
enforced properly, which necessitates educating individuals about the laws in place so that these
rights are respected and upheld in practice. There are provisions for victim confidentiality, in-
camera trial (Section 327 CrPC), and compensation (Section 357 CrPC) in the existing laws. These
provisions should be applied in relevant circumstances to protect victims’ rights. In dealing with
instances, the National Human Rights Commission has a larger role to play, and it must make
recommendations and adopt remedial actions.
 LIST OF TABLES & FIGURES
Table: 1.1 Trafficking in Persons” as defined in terms of 3
the UNTOC and the Protocols
Figure: 1.1 Exploitative Purpose of Human Trafficking 5
Figure: 1.2 Process of Human Trafficking 7
Figure: 1.3 Interplay between exploitation, trafficking, migration, 16
smuggling, labour and consent
Table: 2.1 The Indian Penal Codes (IPC) 1860-Relevant 33
to Human Trafficking
Table: 2.2 Special Provisions of IPC Relating to Pornography 34
and Trafficking
Table: 2.3 State-wise (highly affected) legislation and 64
programmes to mitigate trafficking
Table: 3.1 Geographical Coverage of the Research Study 77
Table: 3.2 Details of Stakeholders 78
Table: 3.3 State Wise Vs Stakeholders Wise Sample Covered 79
Table: 3.4 State wise Details of Focused Group Discussions (FGDs) 79
Table: 4.1 States/UT-wise Children and Women Victims of Trafficking 87
Table: 4.2 States/UT-wise Children and Women Victims Rescued 88
Table: 4.3 Victims Trafficked & Rescued 90
Table: 4.4 Purpose of Human Trafficking 90
Table: 4.5 Nationality-wise profile of Victim Rescued 91
under Human Trafficking
Table: 4.6 States/UT-wise Missing Children (Below 18 years) 91
Table: 4.7 Total No. of Missing and Traced Persons 92
Table: 4.8 Total No. of Missing and Traced Children 93
 xl

Table: 4.9 Place of Interview of Trafficked Victims/Respondents 93

Table: 4.10A Gender of Trafficked Victims 94
Table: 4.10B Gender, Ecological Background & Age of 94
Respondents (Victims)
Table: 4.11 Social Class & Religion of Respondents (Victims) 94
Table: 4.12 Marital Status & Educational Level of Respondents (Victims) 95
Table: 4.13 Category of Respondents wise Educational Level of 95
Trafficked Victims
Table 4.14 Level of Supply side reasons of trafficking Vs Type 95
of Family you belong
Table: 4.15 Family Occupation, Annual family Income & 96
Economic Class of Respondents (Victims)
Table: 4.16 Instrumental Person/Institutions of Trafficking 97
and Name of Other Family member Already
Trafficked
Table 4.17 Correlation between socio-economic parameters and 97
Instrumental Person/Institutions in Trafficking
Table: 4.18 Minors Accompanied by Family Members during 98
Trafficking and Reasons for Trafficking
Table: 4.19 Kind of Threats and Violence Experienced During 98
Trafficking
Table 4.20 Place of Physical and Sexual Abuse/Violence 99
Experienced
Table 4.21 Types of Physical and Sexual Abuse/Violence Experienced 100
Table 4.22 Have You Experienced Injuries During Trafficking? 100
Table 4.23 Ecological Background wise Level of physical and 100
Sexual abuse/violence experienced by Trafficked
Victims
Table 4.24 Age of victims wise Level of physical and Sexual 101
abuse/violence experienced by victims
Table 4.25 Living Conditions, Drug Abuse & Other Restrictions 102
During Trafficking
Table 4.26 Whether You Are a Rescued Victim of Trafficking 102
Table 4.27 Name of Agency who Rescued the Trafficked Victims 102
Table 4.28 Intension of Trafficking other than Sexual Exploitation 103
Table 4.29 Physical Impact/ Physical Health Symptoms of 104
Human Trafficking on Victims
List of Tables & Figures xli

Table 4.30 Ecological Background wise Level of Physical Impact 105

of Human Trafficking on Victims
Table 4.31 Age of victims wise Level of Physical Impact of 105
Human Trafficking on Victims
Table 4.32 STD, Hygienic Condition & Other Health Problems 106
Table 4.33 Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking 107
Table 4.34 Ecological Background wise Level of Psychological 107
(Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking
Table 4.35 Age of victims wise Level of Psychological 108
(Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking
on victims
Table: 4.36 Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking 110
Table 4.37 Ecological Background wise Level of Emotional 110
Impact of Human Trafficking
Table 4.38 Age of Victims wise Level of Emotional Impact 110
of Human Trafficking on Victims
Table 4.39 Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking 111
Table 4.40 Ecological Background wise Level of Behavioral 112
Impact of Human Trafficking
Table 4.41 Age of Victims wise Level of Behavioral Impact 112
of Human Trafficking on Victims
Table 4.42 Awareness and Benefits availed in different 113
Schemes & Programme
Table 4.43 Correlation Between Level of Education of Victims 115
Vs Awareness about various developmental
schemes and the whether they benefitted
from the scheme
Table 4.44 Correlation Between Ecological Background of 115
Victims Vs Awareness about various developmental
schemes and the whether they benefitted from
the scheme
Table 4.45 Feedback on Employment Options Pursued by 116
Rescued Victims
Table 4.46 Aspirations of Respondents 116
Table 4.47 Have you ever escaped or tried to escape 116
from Trafficking Destinations?
Table 4.48 Entry age of CSWs in Sex Trade and their Tenure in 119
Sex Trade
 xlii

Table 4.49 Reasons for Being in Sex Profession for A Long Tenure 120
Table 4.50 Have you ever been lured/ pressurized to engage In 120
Sex during Childhood?
Table 4.51 Type of Clients and Frequency of Their Visits to Brothels 121
Table 4.52 Refusal of Client to Serve 121
Table 4.53 Earnings of CSWs and their Financial Inclusions 122
Table 4.54 Instances of Harassment of CSWs by Police 122
Table 4.55 Use of Alcohol/Drugs by CSWs 123
Table 4.56 Preference of Safe or Unsafe Sex by CSWs 123
Table 4.57 Awareness of HIV/AIDS and STD amongst the CSWs 123
Table 4.58 Feedback on Medical Tests 124
Table 4.59 How Do You Take Habituation Factors in Sex Profession? 124
Table 4.60 Possessing of Mobile Handset and Use of Social 125
Networking Sites
Table 4.61 Aspirations of CSWs 125
Table 4.62 Who takes Decision about Movement of Child for Migration? 133
Table 4.63 How Did Child Go Out of Village/Town? 134
Table 4.64 Nature of Work in Which Child was involved at 134
The Destination
Table 4.65 Suggestions to Reduce the Possibility of Migration of 136
Children to Work
Table 4.66 Ecological background wise Awareness about National 136
Human Rights Commission (NHRC) amongst the
Victims
Table 4.67 Educational Level wise Awareness about National 137
Human Rights Commission (NHRC) amongst the
Victims
Table: 5.1 Gender of Trafficker 140
Table: 5.2 Previous Occupation of Traffickers 141
Table: 5.3 Types of Drugs You Use 142
Table: 5.4 Instrumental Factors for involving in Trafficking Trade 142
Table: 5.5 Tenure in Trafficking Trade 143
Table: 5.6 What Role Did You Play Initially in Trafficking? 143
Table: 5.7 Methods Normally adopted in Recruitment 143
Table: 5.8 Involvement of Other Persons in Trafficking 145
List of Tables & Figures xliii

Table: 5.9 Modus Operandi of the Traffickers 145

Table 5.10 Kind of Work Normally Promised to Victims 146
Table 5.11 Reasons for Involving other Persons in Trafficking 146
Table 5.12 Whether Victims Are Usually Known to Traffickers 146
Table 5.13 Role in Making Women & Children Vulnerable 146
to Join Trafficking
Table 5.14 How Often You Kidnapped/Abducted Victim 147
Table 5.15 How Often Victim is sold by Family 147
Table 5.16 How Do You View the Victim of Trafficking? 147
Table 5.17 Contact of Traffickers with Police & Involvement of 147
Police in Trafficking Rackets
Table 5.18 Encounter By Police During Transition & Arrest on 147
Ground of Trafficking
Table 5.19 Prosecution and Conviction for Crime Related to 148
Human Trafficking
Table 5.20 Reasoning For Continuing Act of Trafficking 148
Table 5.21 Loopholes in Law Enforcement Mechanism 148
Table 5.22 Perceived Reasons of Different Stakeholders for 150
Flourishing of Brothels
Table: 5.23 Previous Occupation of Brothel Keepers 152
Table: 5.24 Period of Brothel Keeping 152
Table: 5.25 Ownership of Brothel 152
Table: 5.26 No. of Rooms in Brothel 153
Table: 5.27 No. of CSWs in Brothel (Regular) 153
Table: 5.28 No. of CSWs in Brothel (Flying) 153
Table 5.29 Methods Normally Being Adopt in Recruitment 154
Table 5.30 No. Of Pimps in Brothel 154
Table 5.31 Share in Victim’s Earnings 154
Table 5.32 Types of Women and Girls in Demand 154
Table 5.33 Average No. of Clients Visiting Brothel Per Day 155
Table 5.34 Reasons for Police Raids 155
Table 5.35 How You Get involved in Brothel Keeping 155
Table 5.36 Reasoning For Continuing Act of Brothel Keeping 155
Table 5.37 Whether You Are Regular Visitor of CSW 158
 xliv

Table 5.38 Type of Sexual Activity Preferred with CSW 158

Table 5.39 Describe the CSW Whom You Have Just Contacted 159
Table 5.40 Type of CSW Preferred by You 159
Table 5.41 Do You Prefer Safe Sex or Unsafe Sex? 160
Table 5.42 How Often You Carry a Condom When Visiting a CSW 160
Table 5.43 Encounter/Harassment of Clients by Police 160
Table 5.44 Addiction History 161
Table 5.45 Awareness About STD/HIV 162
Table: 6.1 State -Wise Cases Reported Under Human Trafficking 169
During 2016-2019
Table: 6.2 Number of Trafficked and Rescued Victims in India 169
Table: 6.3 Disposal of Persons Arrested under Human Trafficking 172
Table 6.4 Disposal of Cases of Human Trafficking by Police 173
Table 6.5 Reasons for Low Conviction Rate as Per Public Prosecutors 174
Table 6.6 Disposal of Cases of Human Trafficking by Court 175
Table 6.7 Type of Agency Interviewed 176
Table: 6.8 Role and Responsibility of Respondents 176
Table 6.9 Kinds of Things Covered in Protocol 177
Table 6.10 Protocols during Rescue Operations 177
Table 6.11 Any Survey has been conducted in areas 178
Vulnerable to Trafficking
Table 6.12 Whether Trafficking is viewed as serious problem 178
and priority in your Agency
Table 6.13 Whether Placement Agencies Who Facilitate 178
Migration Are Registered with Law Enforcement
Agencies
Table 6.14 Prevalence of Different Types of Human Trafficking 179
Within Your Jurisdiction
Table 6.15 Possible signs of potential victim of human trafficking 180
& Modern Slavery
Table 6.16 How Cases Come to Attention of Law Enforcement 180
Table 6.17 Primary Role of Law Enforcement Agencies while 181
working on Cases of Human Trafficking
Table 6.18 Average Time Spend in Investigating a Human 182
Trafficking Case
List of Tables & Figures xlv

Table 6.19 How Often Do Human Trafficking Cases Result 182

in Following Outcomes
Table 6.20 Frequency of Agency Encounter with Challenges 183
While Investigating Cases of Trafficking
Table 6.21 Type of Crimes Associated with Human Trafficking 184
Table 6.22 Frequency of Investigative Responses to Build 184
Human Trafficking Cases in Community
Table 6.23 Most Likely Locations in Which Police Might 185
Encounter Sex Trafficking Activities
Table 6.24 Techniques Being Used in Investigating Crimes 185
Related to Trafficking
Table 6.25 Availability of Law Enforcement Officials as 186
Designated Under AHTU
Table 6.26 Level of Relationship of AHTU/District Law 186
Enforcement Agencies with Other Stakeholders
Table 6.27 Difficulties of Department in Working with Cases 187
of Trafficking
Table 6.28A Have Officers in Your Unit/Department Has 187
Received Training on the Issues of Trafficking
Table 6.28B Proportion of Officers in your unit received Training 188
on the issues of Trafficking
Table 6.29 Reasons for Non-Stoppable Trafficking 189
Table 6.30 Measures to Prevent Trafficking 189
Table 6.31 Most Commonly Used Sections of ITPA 190
Table 6.32 Chances of Conviction in an ITPA Case 190
Table 6.33 Additional Resources You Need to Better Address Trafficking 190
Table 6.34 Type of Prosecuting Agency Interviewed 192
Table 6.35 Role and Responsibility of Prosecuting Agency 192
Table 6.36 Kinds of Things Are Covered in the Protocol/Guidelines 192
Table 6.37 Ignored Areas in Laws 193
Table 6.38 Critical Evidence Leading to Conviction/Acquittal of a Case 193
Table 6.39 Difficulties Being Faced in Working with Cases of Trafficking 194
Table 6.40A Whether Prosecuting Officers Received Training 194
on Issues of Trafficking
Table 6.40B Approximate Percentage of Prosecting Officers 195
who have received Training on the Issues of Trafficking
 xlvi

Table 6.41 Effectiveness of Training on Prosecution of Trafficking 195

Cases
Table: 7.1 Budget Estimates and Expenditure on Ujjawala 200
Scheme in India (Rs. Crore)
Table: 7.2 State/UT-wise Number of Projects and Beneficiaries 200
Covered under Ujjawala Scheme
Table: 7.3 Budget Estimates and Expenditure on Swadhar Greh 201
Scheme in India (Rs. Crore)
Table: 7.4 State- Wise Swadhar Homes and Beneficiaries in India 201
Table: 7.5 State/UTs Wise-Child Care Institutions Along with 203
The Children Residing Therein Under Child
Protection Service Scheme
Table: 7.6 Category of Organizations visited 204
Table: 7.7 Type of Services being provided by Organizations 205
Table: 7.8 How Victims Are Normally Referred to You 206
Table: 7.9 Challenges being faced while helping Victims 207
of Human Trafficking
Table: 7.10 Do You Agree That Task Force Has Been Effective 207
in Addressing Issues of Sex Trafficking?
Table: 7.11 Do Service Providers Receive Training on Subject 208
Matter of Human Trafficking
Table: 7.12 Whether There is Reporting Mechanism within 208
Your Agency to Track Trafficking Cases
Table: 7.13 Case management: Maintenance of Various Kinds 209
of Registers/ Documents by P & R Homes as
Per Guidelines
Table: 7.14 Documents Found in Files Verified 210
Table: 7.15 Mode of Follow Up of Victims Restored to 210
their Families or Reintegrated
Table: 7.16 Rescue, Rehabilitation and Reintegration Programs 211
Sought by Victims
Table: 7.17 Feedback on Forms of Counseling Provided in 211
P & R Homes
Table: 7.18 Obstacles in Rehabilitation and Reintegration Programs 212
Table: 7.19 Obstacles in Rehabilitation and Reintegration Process 212
Table: 7.20 Satisfaction on Availability and Adequacy of Services 213
Provided by Service Providers Such as Ujjawala
Centers, Swadhar Greh Etc.
List of Tables & Figures xlvii

Table: 7.21 Satisfaction on Quality of Services Provided by 213

Service Providers Such as Ujjawala Centers,
Swadhar Greh Etc.
Table: 7.22 Provisions included in National Plan of Action (NPA) 218
Table: 7.23 What Priority Actions are identified to Address under NPA 218
Table: 7.24 Identified Actors for implementation of Specific Activities 219
Table: 7.25 Whether Strategy and National Plan of Action are 219
Monitored and Evaluated on a Regular Basis
Table: 7.26 Which body Monitors and Evaluates the Strategy 219
& National Action Plan
Table: 7.27 Existing Mechanism for Coordinating and Monitoring 220
overall Anti- Trafficking Strategy at State Level
Table: 7.28 Perceive of Menace of Sex Trafficking For CSE 220
Table: 7.29 Reasons for People Being Trafficked Out in the 220
District/State
Table: 7.30 Modus Operandi of Women and Children Trafficking 221
Table: 7.31 Trend of Trafficking in State 221
Table: 7.32 Existing Measures for Prevention of Trafficking of 222
Women and Children
Table: 7.33 Flaws Exist in the Law 222
Table: 7.34 Lacunas in Implementation of Existing Laws and Procedures 223
Table: 7.35 Whether Provisions in Legislation for Rehabilitation 223
of the Victims are Adequate
Table: 7.36 Whether Law Provide for Using Confiscated Proceeds 224
of Crime to Compensate Victims
Table: 7.37 Availability of Trained Professionals to Assist in 224
Recovery and Reintegration of Victims of CSE
Table: 7.38 Most Effective Programs in Combating Trafficking 225
Table: 7.39 Impact of State Activities on Community 225
Understanding of the Issues of Trafficking
Table 8.1 Trafficking Vulnerabilities 238
Table 8.2 Supply Side Reasons of Trafficking 238
Table 8.3 Demand Side Reasons of Trafficking 239
Table 8.4 Modes of Transports used For Human Trafficking 239
Table 8.5 Routes of Transports used For Human Trafficking 240
Table 8.6 Type of Functioning Place for Human Trafficking 241
 xlviii

Table 8.7 Trafficking Process Activities 241

Table 8.8 Modus Operandi of Traffickers- Mean & Methods 242
Adopted for Trafficking
Table 8.9 Where Are from Trafficking Location and Logistics 242
Table: 8.10 Purpose and Intention of Trafficking 243
Table 8.11 Type of Organization and Groups Involved 243
in Human Trafficking
Table 8.12 Reasons For Non-Stoppable Trafficking 243
Table 8.13 Stakeholders Wise Awareness about National 244
Human Rights Commission (NHRC)
Table 8.14 Stakeholders Wise Source of Information About NHRC 244
Table 8.15 Stakeholders wise level of awareness about Role & 245
Functions of NHRC
Table 8.16 Whether a Complaint Regarding Human Trafficking 245
Can Be Directly Filed With NHRC
Table 8.17 Mode of Filling of a Complaint with NHRC 246
Table 8.18 Who Can File a Complaint with NHRC? 246
Table 8.19 Have You Ever Filed a Complaint with NHRC? 247
Table 8.20 Level of Satisfaction Regarding Grievance Redressed 247
by NHRC
Table 8.21 Limitations/Shortcomings of NHRC in Dealing 248
with a Complaint
Table 8.22 Problems Faced by a Person While Filing a 248
Complaint with NHRC
 RESEARCH TEAM

S.
Name of Members Designation
No.
Principal
1 Dr. Awadesh Kumar Singh, Vice President, BIRD
Investigator
Co-
2 Dr. Ratna N. Pandey, Chairperson, M/s Bharatiya Institute of Research & Development (BIRD)
Investigator
3 Mr. Hriday Narayan Pandey, CEO, M/s Bharatiya Institute of Research & Development (BIRD) Coordinator
4 Dr. S. P. Sharma, (ISS-Retired) Statistician
5 Dr. Manoj Kumar Sharma Data Analyst
Dr. Jayant Choudhary, Associate Professor, National Institute of Rural Development and
6 State
Panchayati Raj (NIRD & PR)-NERC, Guwahati
Coordinator,
Dr. Sachchidanand Sharan Das, Assistant Professor (Human Rights), Centre for Juridical Assam
7
Studies, Dibrugarh University, Dibrugarh, Assam
Prof. (Dr.) Samar Kumar Biswas, Professor, Department of Anthropology, North Bengal State
8
University, Siligudi, West Bengal Coordinator,
9 Prof. Bishwajeet Ghosh, Department of Sociology, Burdman University, Burdman, West Bengal West Bengal
Dr. Atul Pratap Singh, HOD, Department of Social Work, Dr. B. R. Ambedekar College, State
10
University of Delhi, Delhi. Coordinator,
11 Dr. Ankur Tyagi, HOD, Department of Education, Lingaya’s University, Faridabad Delhi
12 Dr. I. Sundar, Associate Professor of Economics, Annamalai University, Tamil Nadu State
Dr. P. Jegan, Assistant Professor of Commerce & Co-ordinator, Entrepreneurship Development Coordinator,
13 Tamil Nadu
Cell, A.V.V.M. Shri Pushpam College (Autonomous), Poondi, Thanjavur, Tamil Nadu
14 Prof. G. R. K. Krishna Murthy, Chief Advisor, A. J. Group of Educational Institutions, Mangalore. State
Coordinator,
15 Prof. (Dr.) R. V. M. Reddy, Dean, Faculty of Commerce, Manipal University, Udupi, Karnataka Karnataka
State
Mr. Sanjay Mishra, Convenor, Action Against Trafficking & Sexual Exploitation of
16 Coordinator,
Children (ATSEC), Jharkhand Chapter, Ranchi
Jharkhand
17 Col (Dr.) MZU Siddiquie, Sena Medal, Director General, Axis Colleges & University, Kanpur
State
18 Mr. Salil Srivastava, Sr. Programm Manager (Migration), TATA Trusts, Mumbai, RO Lucknow Coordinator,
Uttar
Prof. Anjani Kumar Singh, Associate Professor, Amity Business School, Amity University, Pradesh
19
Noida, Sector 125, Noida, Uttar Pradesh- 201313
 l

20 Prof. Om Prakash Shukla, Principal, National Defence Academy, Khadakwasla, Pune State
Dr. Parth D. Shukla, Assistant Professor, Aditya Institute of Management Studies & Research Coordinator,
21 Maharashtra
- Mumbai
Mr. Hemant Yadav, Research Scholar, Sikkim Manipal University, Samdur, P. O, Tadong,
22
Gangtok, Sikkim -737102
23 Ms. Sweta Majumder, MSW Research
24 Ms. Sushmita Mondal, MSW Investigator,
West Bengal
25 Mr. Rakibul Islam M. A. M.Phil, Doctor of Philosophy
26 Ms. Basana Sutradhar, MSW
Dr. Shailendra Kumar, Post-Doctoral Fellow
27
(UGC- Dr. Radhakrishan )
28 Ms. Naheed Aqueel, M.Phill Research
Investigator,
29 Ms. Kalpana Singh, MA (Sociology) Uttar
Pradesh
Dr. Nasurruddin, Assistant Director, Regional Center For Urban & Environmental Studies
30
(RCUES), Lucknow

31 Ms. Anjali Navin Thakar, MA (Political Science) Research

Investigator,
32 Ms. Jyoti Lataprasad Pandey, MA (Political Science) Maharashtra

33 Ms. Jyoti Lataprasad Pandey, MA (Political Science)

Research
34 Mr. Shailesh Gopal Thorat, MA (Political Science) Investigator,
Karnataka
35 Mr. H. Umesha, MSW

36 Ms. Jesssica Englengpi, MA in Tourism

37 Ms. Jutika Nath, MA in English Langauage & Literature Research

Investigator,
38 Ms. Sukanya Phukan, MA in Economics Assam

39 Ms. Panna Priyom Borah, MA (Political Science)

40 Mr. Vivekanand
41 Ms. Jyoti Lataprasad Pandey, MA (Political Science) Research
Investigator,
42 MS. Puja Pandey, MA (Political Science) Tamil Nadu
43 Mr. Mohan Kumar E., Director CADRE India
44 Dr. Manisha Singh, Assistant Professor, Lingaya’s University, Faridabad Research
Investigator,
45 Dr. Ruby Farooqui, Assistant Professor, Lingaya’s University, Faridabad Delhi
46 Mrs. Sita Swanshi, MSW Research
Investigator,
47 Mr. Pawan Raj, MBA Jharkhand
Data
48 Ms. Gyatri Singh, MSW Processing
SPSS
Data entry
49 Mr. Lalit Kumar
Operator
50 Mr. sunil Barar Typist
 REFERENCE PERIOD
The Survey & Data collection of Research Study On “Trafficking of Women and Children-
Challenges and Remedies” has been conducted between 26.11.2019 to 24.07.2021 and data
scrutiny, data Processing, Tabulation and Data Analysis has been carried out between 01.06.2020
to 31.07.2021. The Draft Report has been prepared in the month of August 2021.
 Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION

H uman trafficking is a serious human rights violation that takes place all over the world. Due
to its complicated cross-border nature, human trafficking demands a coordinated, multi-
disciplinary national and international response. Human trafficking is the world’s second-largest
organized crime, after drugs and the arms trade. The causes of this global phenomenon’s rise are
various and varied, affecting both developed and developing countries. In India, this is also
true. The source areas or points of origin are typically the poorest cities, regions, or countries,
whereas the points of destination are often-but not always-urban conglomerates within or
beyond borders. The real or perceived economic disparity between the source and destination
areas is crucial for those who view human trafficking in economic terms. It would be inaccurate
to assume that human beings are constantly trafficked from undeveloped to developed areas, as
this is not always the case, because human trafficking is designed and controlled by traffickers
for their own interests, which they achie ve through a number of strategies. To a large part, this
indicates that human trafficking is primarily a human rights issue, as it violates all of the victims’
fundamental human rights. Furthermore, while economic analysis approaches are designed
to explain and evaluate issues in terms of their overall efficacy, they are not well suited for
safeguarding and promoting human rights goals.
According to the definition of the United Nations- “trafficking is any activity leading to
recruitment, transportation, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of threat or use of force
or a position of vulnerability”. Globally, 1.2 million children are trafficked every year. It is a
form of modern slavery which generates US$ 150 billion for traffickers every year. It is shocking
to note that the slaves today are cheaper than ever. In 1850, the average cost of a salve is US$
40,000 in today’s money, but now it is only US$ 90. This indicates the vulnerability of trafficked
person.
India is a source, destination, and transit country for labour and sex trafficking. In India,
90% of trafficking takes place within the country (intra-state or inter-state), whereas 10% takes
place across national borders. The country serves as a transit point for persons being trafficked
to the Middle East and other parts of the world, as well as a destination for those being trafficked
from neighbouring Nepal and Bangladesh. India is also a transit country for persons seeking
asylum in Europe, the Middle East, or North America. According to a three-year average data
of NCRB, Majority of them (63 per cent) are trafficked for Forced labour (31 per cent) and sexual
 2

exploitation related offences (32 per cent). Trafficking for domestic servitude, forced marriage,
petty crimes/begging and removal of organ constitute 8 per cent.
Although it is continuously striving to do so, the Indian government does not yet fully achieve
the minimum standards for the elimination of human trafficking. India stayed on Tier 2 as a
consequence of the government’s overall increased efforts compared to the previous reporting
period. These actions included convicting traffickers, starting a high-profile investigation into one
case involving authorities allegedly involved in sex trafficking at a government-funded shelter,
and continuing to raise awareness about trafficking. The Supreme Court examined an important
shelter abuse case and requested all states to investigate their shelter homes, citing concerns about
the overall level of control. The Trafficking in Persons (Prevention, Protection, and Rehabilitation)
Bill 2018 was passed by the lower house of Parliament, but the upper chamber did not take it up
during the reporting period. In numerous key sectors, the government, on the other hand, failed
to achieve the minimum standards. The government took some actions in response to allegations
of official involvement in forced labour and sex trafficking, but the systematic failure to handle
forced labour and sex trafficking in government-run and government-funded shelter homes
remained a serious problem. The government withholds information about human trafficking
investigations, charges and convictions, as well as trafficking victims who have been identified
and referred for rehabilitation. According to NGOs, government law enforcement and victim
identification efforts were inadequate in contrast to the extent of the problem. Victims have been
penalized by authorities in the past for the illegal actions that their traffickers coerced them to
do. The government’s efforts to address bonded labour remained inadequate in comparison to
the scope of the problem, and officials failed to comply with the law requiring the provision of
release certificates and compensation to bonded labourers removed from exploitation in the vast
majority of reported cases, preventing victims from accessing government services and, in some
cases, leading to their re-victimization.

CONCEPT OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING

Trafficking is defined in Article 3 of the UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish
Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, which supplements the UN Convention
against Transnational Organized Crime.

Article 3
(a) “Trafficking in persons” shall mean the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring
or receipt of persons, by means of threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction,
of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving
or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over
another person, for the purpose of exploitation. Exploitation shall include, at a minimum, the
exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or
services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs;
(b) The consent of a victim of trafficking in persons to the intended exploitation set forth
in sub paragraph (a) of this article shall be irrelevant where any of the means set forth in sub
paragraph (a) have been used.
On the basis of the definition given in the Trafficking in Persons Protocol, it is evident that
trafficking in persons has three constituent elements;
Introduction 3

The Act (What is done)

Recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons
The Means (How it is done)
Threat or use of force, coercion, abduction, fraud, deception, abuse of power or vulnerability,
or giving payments or benefits to a person in control of the victim
The Purpose (Why it is done)
For the purpose of exploitation, which includes exploiting the prostitution of others, sexual
exploitation, forced labour, slavery or similar practices and the removal of organs.
We should consider the definition of trafficking in persons in the Trafficking in Persons
Protocol, as well as the constituent parts of the offence as established by relevant legal provisions,
when determining whether a situation constitutes trafficking in persons.
The UNODC (2004:42-43) describes “Trafficking in Persons” as defined in terms of the UNTOC
and the Protocols thereto as (Table: 1.1).
a. The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the
threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the
abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments
or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for
the purpose of exploitation. Exploitation shall include, at a minimum, the exploitation of
the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services,
slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs.
b. The consent of a victim of trafficking in persons to the intended exploitation set forth in
subparagraph (a) of Article 3(a) of the Trafficking in Persons Protocol shall be irrelevant
where any of the means set forth in subparagraph (a) above have been used;
c. The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of a child for the purpose
of exploitation shall be considered ‘trafficking in persons’ even if this does not involve
any of the means set forth in subparagraph (a) of Article 3(a) of the Trafficking in Persons
Protocol;
d. “Child” shall mean any person under eighteen years of age.
Table: 1.1
ACTIVITIES MEANS/METHODS PURPOSE/INTENTION
(Any of these) (Any of these) (Any of these)
• Recruitment • Threat For the purpose of exploitation:
• Transportation • Force • Prostitution of others
• Transfer • Other forms of coercion • Other forms of sexual exploitation
• Harbouring • Abduction • Forced labour or services
• Receipt of persons • Fraud • Slavery or practices similar to slavery
• Deception • Servitude
• Abuse of Power & Position for • Removal of organs
vulnerability
• Giving or receiving of payments or
benefits
Source: UNODC
When any of the methods listed above are used, a victim’s ‘consent’ is immaterial. Even if
 4

none of the above methods are used, ‘consent’ is immaterial in the case of minors.
This definition should be equated to another Protocol, the UN Smuggling of Migrants Protocol
3 (a), which defines smuggling as “the procurement of the illegal entry of a person into a State
Party of which the person is not a national or a permanent resident in order to obtain, directly or
indirectly, a financial or other material benefit.” As a result, the following elements are included
in this definition:
• Obtaining unauthorised admission into a country where the person is not a citizen or a
permanent resident
• To obtain a monetary or other tangible reward
The Indian Constitution outlaws human trafficking and declares it a fundamental right of all
citizens. Furthermore, the Directive Principles of State Policy include a subject of freedom from
exploitation.

Section 370 of the Indian Penal Code 1860 defines trafficking as:
Whoever for the purpose of exploitation, (a) recruits, (b) transports, (c) harbours, (d) transfers,
or (e) receives, a person or persons, by –
First. - using threats, or
Secondly. - using force, or any other form of coercion, or
Thirdly. - by abduction, or
Fourthly. - by practicing fraud, or deception, or
Fifthly. - by abuse of power, or
Sixthly. - by inducement, including the giving or receiving of payments or benefits, in order
to achieve the consent of any person having control over the person recruited, transported,
harboured, transferred or received, commits the offence of trafficking.
• The expression “exploitation” shall include any act of physical exploitation or any form
of sexual exploitation, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude, or the forced
removal of organs.
• The consent of the victim is immaterial in determination of the offence of trafficking.

PURPOSE OF TRAFFICKING
Women and children are trafficked for the purpose of sexual and non-sexual exploitation.
Prostitution trafficking, commercial sexual abuse, paedophilia, pornography, cybersex, and
other forms of disguised sexual exploitation occur in massage parlours, beauty parlours, bars,
residential flats, and other manifestations such as call girl racket, friends clubs, and other forms
of disguised sexual exploitation are all included in the first category. Non-sex related trafficking
includes domestic labour, industrial labour, adoption, organ donation, camel racing, marriage,
and other forms of servitude. The rising trafficking of women and children, on the other hand, is
primarily for sexual exploitation. While common trafficking strategies such as coercion, duping,
seducing, fraudulent marriage, abducting, kidnapping, and so on have been recognized, it is
the victims’ social and economic constraints that place them at the greatest risk. The majority of
Introduction 5

trafficked people in India are trafficked for sexual exploitation, including women, boys and girls.
By deception, compulsion, or force, a person is illegally trafficked for the intention of utilizing
him or her for involuntary commercial sex acts, prostitution, or other forms of sexual exploitation.
Men, women, boys and girls are the second most trafficked people in India, with men, women,
boys, and girls being trafficked for the purpose of forced labour. Labor trafficking is defined as
the trafficking of a person for the purpose of exploiting him or her for forced labour or services,
slavery, or practices similar to slavery, such as involuntary servitude, peonage, or debt bondage
(Figure:1.1).
Figure: 1.1

Nearly 80% of global human trafficking is for sexual exploitation, with the rest being for
bonded labour, with India being the epicenter of the crime in Asia. According to government
statistics, a child goes missing every eight minutes in our country. Furthermore, it is estimated
that just 30% of all incidents are reported, meaning that the true figure is far higher. Estimating
the number of people trafficked for labour or sex is impossible due to the unlawful operation’s
inherent secrecy. The number of people trafficked for forced labour in India is estimated to
be between 20 and 65 million, according to the US Department of State’s 2013 Trafficking in
Persons Report. Calculating the true number of victims of labour trafficking, on the other hand,
is frequently difficult, if not impossible. The key problem is distinguishing between migrant
workers who go to or around India voluntarily in pursuit of work and those who are trafficked
into exploitative labour utilizing the UN Trafficking Protocol’s methodology. Moreover, many
migrant workers begin their journey voluntarily, but become vulnerable to human trafficking if
they are unable to locate acceptable employment or if the job for which they originally migrated
ends.
It is extremely difficult to detect the prevalence and breadth of sex trafficking. According to a
study done by India’s Ministry of Women and Child Development in 2008, the country has over
three million sex workers. Many of these sex workers could have been sex trafficking victims.
Estimating the number of people trafficked for the purpose of sexual exploitation is particularly
difficult, according to government authorities questioned, because victims may return to sex
work after escaping their traffickers owing to a lack of alternative options. Due to a lack of
education or occupational training, many recovered trafficking victims are unable to find long-
term employment in other sectors, and even work that is available in sectors such as domestic
labour may pay significantly less. Victims of sex trafficking typically have limited job options
outside of sex work due to the cultural stigma associated with having engaged in commercial sex
acts. As a result, determining whether a sex worker is currently a victim of human trafficking,
 6

was a victim of human trafficking who chose to continue working in the sex industry, or has
always worked in this business voluntarily may be difficult.
Human trafficking, especially of women and children, is a well-organized crime that breaches
the victims’ fundamental human rights. The right to life, dignity, security, privacy, health,
education, and redress of grievances are among the rights and dignity of individuals that are
violated in a number of ways. They are subjected to physical and sexual abuse, and they are
compelled to work for minimal or no pay against their will. This, combined with their obligation
to the trafficker, maintains them in a state of debt slavery and debt bondage. They are forced
to work terrible working conditions for long periods of time with no chance of rest. In terms
of physical confinement, they are imprisoned-like and have little or no control over their own
movements. They live in horrible circumstances, with poor hygiene and sanitation and limited
access to health and medical services. On a daily basis, they face social stigma and ostracism,
and as a result, they are continually humiliated. They are addicted to opiates, alcohol, and other
substances, and they are frequently forced to become addicts in order to keep their reliance on
the trafficker. In addition to the relentless assault on their physical, psychological, and emotional
health, they face health risks such as physical damage, STD, HIV/AIDS, unwanted pregnancies,
numerous abortions, gynecological disorders, TB, and other diseases. They are also harassed and
humiliated by the police and the prosecution. When they are no longer able to work, they are
abandoned, and even the families that rely on their income do not support them.
Accordingly, one or more of the following issues can also be construed as means and/or
ends to human trafficking, or human trafficking itself, for the purpose of the above definition:
1. Bonded Labour;
2. Forced Labour;
3. Child Labour;
4. Sexual Exploitation in massage parlours, etc.;
5. Prostitution;
6. Sexual Exploitation for pornography or similar purposes;
7. Trafficking for child marriage;
8. Child Soldiers.
9. Forced Removal of Organs/Organ Trafficking.
Trafficking is a continuing offence that continues from source to transit and to destination
(Figure: 1.2).
Introduction 7

Figure: 1.2

Source: The area or Destination: The

place From where a area or place where
victim is identified and Transit the victim of trafficking
recruited with the is brought to be
intention of being exploited for
exploited. economic gain

The route through

which the victim is
taken to the place of
intended exploitation

Trafficking is a basket of crimes; hence, while the victim maybe being trafficked for the end
exploitation, he / she maybe the victim of many crimes even before reaching the destination.

TRAFFICKING AND PROSTITUTION ARE NOT THE SAME

The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act is India’s major sex trafficking legislation. It does not
prohibit prostitution or prostitutes per se, but rather conduct by third parties that facilitate
prostitution, such as brothel maintaining, living off revenues, and soliciting women and girls.
The ITPA punishes acts such as brothel holding (Section 3), living off sex work revenues (Section
4), and procuring, inciting, or detaining for prostitution (Section 5 & 6). Penalties are harsher
when children (under the age of 16) and minors (under the age of 18) are involved, as well
as prostitution in areas where the police have been notified and near public places (Section 7)
and soliciting (Section 8). Section 8 penalizes a sex worker who attracts potential customers
from a prominent, conspicuous location, such as a street or a private residence. All offences
are cognizable, which means that officers do not need a warrant to arrest or search someone.
Although the exchange of money for sex is permissible, organized prostitution, which includes
pimping, brothel-keeping, and soliciting sex in public is prohibited. The Immoral Trafficking
Act makes it permissible for a woman to voluntarily use her body to earn money. She is allowed
to work secretly at her home, but she is not allowed to publicize or promote her profession or
conduct business in public. Even while it is lawful to trade sex for money on an individual basis,
it is illegal for a woman to do so within 200 yards of a public space. Houses of worship, hostels,
educational institutions, and hospitals are examples of public venues. Call girls, on the other
hand, are not allowed to reveal their phone numbers to the general public. They might face a
maximum of 6 months in prison as well as financial penalties if caught. Clients who socialize with
prostitutes or indulge in similar activities within 200 yards of a designated area face a maximum
prison sentence and penalties of three months. A person who engages in such behaviour with
a minor under the age of 18 could receive a prison sentence of 7 to 10 years. Pimps and others
who live off a prostitute’s earnings are also responsible. Sex workers are not within the ambit of
normal labour laws. They do, however, enjoy all of the same rights as citizens, including the right
to be rescued and rehabilitated if they so wish.
The ITPA does not make prostitution illegal, but it does make all behaviours linked with it
illegal. Indian law prohibits the operation of a brothel. As a result, anyone who operates a brothel
or permits one to function on his or her premises will almost probably face legal ramifications.
 8

Pimping is also prohibited under the law. As a result, anyone who solicits customers for a
prostitute as a pimp will be prosecuted. Human trafficking business owners, such as brothel
owners and landlords, may face criminal prosecution. If this is their first offence, they will be
sentenced to a maximum of three years in jail. If they detain someone in their brothel forcibly to
be used as a prostitute or exploited for sexual purposes, they face a minimum sentence of seven
years in prison. Under this legislation, prostitution is also illegal in hotels. Human traffickers and
those who attempt to recruit someone, whether forcibly or voluntarily, face a prison sentence of
three to seven years.
Decriminalizing sex work in India is thought to boost women’s status. In 2009, the Supreme
Court proposed legalizing prostitution. Prostitution regulation was promoted by the National
Commission for Women in order to prevent human trafficking, particularly of children, and to
help ameliorate the deplorable working conditions of clients and workers, as well as to reduce
the spread of HIV-AIDS. The sex workers aspired to be recognized by the law. Stopping sex
trafficking and regulating the sex business will reduce clandestine, covert, illegal, and street
prostitution, safeguard prostitution women, enhance women’s health, and recognize prostitution
as an economic activity, allowing women to receive sex worker permits. Some people were
against legalizing prostitution, believing that as the demand for sex grows, so will the amount
of trafficking.
Human trafficking is a global phenomenon that is considered a challenging issue in any
community. States employ legal and administrative processes to deal with problems, regardless
of how powerful or weak they are. Despite the fact that India has been recognized as a source,
transit, and destination countries for the trafficking of underage girls for Commercial sex
Exploitation, it is widely acknowledged that India is the source of the bulk of trafficked girls
for Commercial sex Exploitation. Only about 10% of all trafficked people of any age, trafficked
for any cause, including adolescent girls trafficked for Commercial sex Exploitation enter
India through international borders, while interstate trafficking accounts for 89 percent of
those trafficked within India. International trafficking accounts for a small percentage of total
trafficking in India, as previously indicated. According to reports, women and young girls have
been smuggled into India from Russia, Bhutan, Myanmar, Kyrgyzstan, Pakistan, Europe, Russia,
and Thailand. While evidence of trafficking into India has been established from Bangladesh and
Nepal, there is minimal evidence of trafficking from India to international destinations. Children
from Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh have been reported to be
trafficked for Commercial sex Exploitation to the Gulf States, England, Korea, and the Philippines.
International trafficking passes through Delhi and Mumbai, and Tripura has emerged as a “safe
passage” state for children being trafficked from Bangladesh to West Asia, particularly Dubai.
The fact that India finally ratified the UN agreement against human trafficking on May
5, 2011, together with treaties against transnational organised crime and corruption, is cause
for celebration. In fact, ratification of this agreement makes it mandatory for India to create
legislation that complies with the international convention’s rules. However, those who traffic in
forced labour are now covered by the country’s legal framework. Because the laws of the nation
are more skewed against prosecuting employers or pimps in cases of prostitution, criminal
groups involved in widespread kidnappings, abductions, and forced labour of children escape
punishment. The concern is that India lacked a comprehensive definition of human trafficking to
provide a common platform for the different Indian states to use in legislation and enforcement
(Sarkar 2014).
Introduction 9

TRAFFICKING DIMENSIONS
Human trafficking is a multi-faceted phenomena that covers a wide range of different
and complex economic, social, and cultural factors. Promises of jobs, better job prospects, and
marriage enticed the bulk of the victims. Some people are kidnapped against their will. Some
girls are sold by friends or relatives, and in extreme situations, even by their own parents, out of
desperation. Human trafficking and sexual exploitation of women and children are inextricably
linked to women’s and children’s positions in society. Though poverty is the most significant
factor, underlying gender-based discrimination and male dominance in society structures also
contribute to women’s dehumanization, commercialization, and exploitation. Other important
factors include the rise of sex tourism, the entertainment industry, pornography in print,
electronic, and cyber media, the breakdown of family structures, shifting social and family
settings, and shifting public perspectives on sex and morality. Lack of education, caste, ethnicity,
and social marginalization all contribute to human trafficking. Natural calamities such as floods
and draughts, as well as the impact of globalization, which has resulted in the elimination of
traditional subsistence practices, are all elements that contribute to human trafficking. Human
trafficking and Commercial sex Exploitation are both connected by a ‘demand’ and ‘supply’
nexus. Sex trafficking is a profitable but low-risk criminal activity. While poverty may serve as
a backdrop for sex trafficking, the existence of criminal networks that control the push and pull
components that lead to the recruitment and trafficking of women and minor girls is the driving
force behind it. Poverty and the pressures to work or support a family; a lack of education and
training that prevents access to economic resources; man-made conflict and natural disasters that
devastate local economies; hostile cultural attitudes toward children and girls; and inadequate
local laws and their poor enforcement are all ‘supply’ factors that encourage trafficking.
The rising demand for women and children in the sex industry could be due to ‘sex tourism’
and the desire for intercourse with young and minor females. The high profit margins of this
low-risk unlawful enterprise also play a role. Inadequate or ineffective laws, poor enforcement,
low chances of prosecution and conviction, corruption and complacency, governments’ failure to
enact strong laws, implement policies, and provide adequate rehabilitation services for victims
are all factors that contribute to the perpetuation of human trafficking.

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO WOMEN AND CHILD TRAFFICKING

Almost all research and publications on trafficking in India indicate to poverty and feminization
of poverty as major underlying causes in the trafficking of women and minor girls for Commercial
Sex Exploitations. However, as the ILO and UNICEF research points out, poverty alone does not
make people vulnerable to human trafficking. Poverty can be seen as a contextual factor that
enhances the effects of other vulnerabilities, making human trafficking more likely. There are
many risk factors that make people vulnerable to human trafficking, and a combination of these
factors and poverty is sometimes referred to as “poverty plus,” which refers to a situation in
which poverty alone does not lead to a person being trafficked, but where a “plus” factor, such
as illness, family crisis, or other stress factors, combines with poverty to increase a person’s
vulnerability to human trafficking. A number of “plus” factors, including as natural catastrophes
and civil unrest, as well as community, family, and individual-level vulnerabilities, put women
and underage girls at risk of Commercial Sex Exploitations trafficking, according to the evidence.
Poverty is the primary cause of human trafficking in India. Other issues include “poor
employment opportunities, a patriarchal culture, a low regard for women’s rights, low levels
 10

of education, women’s discrimination and marginalization, and cultural components such as

dowry troubles.” Poverty, which makes people more vulnerable to trafficking, as well as growing
demand for cheap labour and a lack of government oversight, all contribute to human trafficking.
Similar factors, such as the low female-to-male child sex ratio in northern India (specifically,
Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and Haryana) and the large number of migrant labourers in certain
regions of India, which increases demand for commercial sex workers as well as trafficked brides,
facilitate sex trafficking, which primarily affects women and girls forced into prostitution. Caste
also compounds the situation. A person who belongs to a “lower” caste is more vulnerable to
human trafficking. Due to their precarious economic condition, lower caste women face dual and
simultaneous discrimination based on their caste and gender: caste and gender both contribute
to the restriction of access to education and long-term work, making it easier to exploit and traffic
them. Furthermore, the persistence of the problem has been aided by a lack of societal awareness
of human trafficking as well as a sound legal framework.
Agents convince their parents with promises of school, a better life, and money to take their
children from their homes and sell them in different parts of India for sexual exploitation and
bonded labour. These children are not sent to school; instead, they are sold to work in brick kilns,
carpentry shops, as domestic staff, beggars, and other low-wage tasks, while girls are trafficked
for sexual exploitation. Even these girls are forced to marry in communities with an uneven
female-to-male sex ratio. Children from tribal communities are more likely to be victims of
human trafficking. Human trafficking cases have lately been reported in Manipur’s Tamenglong
area, with the Kuki tribe accounting for the majority of the youngsters. Tribal feuds were the
reason for this, which allowed human trafficking to flourish. A battle between the Kukis and
Nagas tribes in the Northeast region resulted in the displacement of many children between 1992
and 1997. These children were moved to other parts of the country via agents.

FACTORS IMPACTING INTO TRAFFICKING VULNERABILITY

In order to address the problem holistically, it is necessary to have a thorough understanding
of the factors that lead to human trafficking. At the global, regional, and local levels, these factors
must be understood as pull or push elements. In general, the following are some of these factors:

1. Economic Vulnerability
Globalization has increased price competition, resulting in a higher demand for low-cost
labour to keep production costs low. As a result, the informal labour sectors have exploded,
including street vending and unlicensed manufacturing work. Employees have grown more
vulnerable and prone to abusive working circumstances since these neglected and uncontrolled
areas of employment are not visible and hence are not subject to labour laws and regulations.
On the pull side of the equation, these elements are present. On the other side, globalization
has the impact of undermining the traditional family structure. Each member of the family has
become a “separate and independent unit of labour capable of being plugged into the modern
labour market.” Furthermore, basic economic shifts such as the rural economy’s collapse, natural
disasters, agro-climatic variability, and dwindling employment chances compel disadvantaged
communities with no economic options to leave to places where their prospects may be better. In
general, these migrants are at a greater risk of being trafficked.
Introduction 11

2. Gender Vulnerability
The UN Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women notes “The underlying causes of
migration and trafficking often coincide.” The main driving force behind both female migration
and female trafficking is a lack of rights for women. Governments foster circumstances conducive
to human trafficking by failing to protect and promote women’s civil, political, and social rights.
The feminization of poverty, in which the majority of poor women are denied access to resources,
women’s low social status, lack of education for girls, the expectation that women perform
certain roles and be solely responsible for their children, and discrimination against women in
political participation, sexuality, religion, customs, and social practices are all push factors. On
the one hand, there is the traditional sexual division of labour and on the other, there is the
increased demand for reproductive services in the globalized market, where women and girls
are increasingly being recruited as service providers. They provide a wide range of personalized
reproductive services in the entertainment and sex industries, domestic employment, and the
marriage market.

3. Vulnerability to Migration
“Fishing in the migratory stream” is a tactic used by human traffickers. As a result, all migrants,
particularly women, are at risk of being trafficked, including involuntarily resettlers, refugees,
internally displaced individuals, illegal migrants, and others. As a result of unequal societal
and household duties, women and children are becoming more conspicuous in contemporary
migration. As their duties to their families expand, women venture out to seek job opportunities.
Due to a lack of education and career options, many women are drawn into the sex business,
domestic employment, and marriage market. As a result, the phenomena of feminization of
migration emerges.

4. Restrictive Migration Policy

Despite the increased need for all sorts of migrant labour, immigration restrictions in
destination countries are still unable to keep up. As a result, there is a significant gap between
the demand for and supply of labour. As a result, unemployed migrant workers end up in the
clutches of human traffickers and migrant smugglers. In addition, the link between human
trafficking and irregular migration has led to tighter immigration restrictions and laws.

5. Development Vulnerability
Poor development practices have created a division between the developed and developing
worlds, which is replicated at the local, regional, national, and global levels. As the developing
world’s population rises, it becomes a “consumable commodity” for the developed world. The
underdeveloped area serves as a supply zone, whereas the developed area is a demand zone.
Furthermore, promoting sex tourism as a development strategy leads to prostitution-related
human trafficking. There is a connection between the influx of relatively wealthy foreigners
seeking sex with women from developing countries and the movement of women into the sex
industry to meet that demand. Therefore, trafficking in women and children is clearly both a
human rights and a developmental issue.

6. Political Vulnerability
The political and economic backdrops of the countries frequently exacerbate the vulnerability
 12

of women and children. The collapsing economic and political conditions in Myanmar encouraged
women to flee to Thailand. Thai officials who are searching for cheap labour or personal benefit
are facilitating this influx. As Eastern Europe moves from communism to capitalism, women’s
trafficking into Western Europe has increased. Women were once trafficked into Western Europe
from countries like as Colombia, the Dominican Republic, Ghana, Thailand, Zaire, and the
Philippines. Eastern Europe is becoming the primary source of female workers in the industry.
Intra-country trafficking is influenced by economic and political factors inside a country.

7. Armed Conflict Vulnerability and Insurgency

During times of armed conflict, women and children are particularly vulnerable to sexual
assault and forced domestic services by armed soldiers. Large-scale displacement and migration
are also a result of armed wars. Traffickers use these influxes of displaced people as an easy
way to seduce, abduct, or compel people to become victims of human trafficking. As proven
by the fact that the conflicts in Bosnia and Kosovo created opportunities for traffickers in the
former Yugoslavia and the Balkans. Human traffickers had targeted refugee women leaving
Kosovo. Kidnappings of children are also common during armed wars in order to recruit them
as soldiers. According to a US State Department investigation on human trafficking, the LTTE
kidnaps and retains adolescents against their will for forced labour, military conscription, and
in some cases sexual exploitation. Kenya, Angola, Sudan, and Uganda are among the African
countries that have experienced such patterns. Because their absence is unlikely to be noticed or
reported, street children in general are easy targets.

8. Religious and Cultural Vulnerability

In various countries, such as India and Nepal, religious and historic customs of the devadasi
or devki system give legitimacy to human/Sex trafficking and slavery-like practices. Such legal
and illegal violence is then considered as a routine private family matter, and society accepts it
as a norm.

9. Information Technology Vulnerability

Human traffickers have incorporated technology into their business model at every level of
the process, from recruitment to torturing victims. Many young people are targeted by human
traffickers on social media. The UNODC has identified two types of trafficking strategies:
“hunting,” in which a trafficker actively pursues a victim, usually on social media, and “fishing,”
in which criminals post job advertising and wait for possible victims to respond. Technology
can be used by traffickers to launder or transfer illegal profits. It can also aid investigations,
improve convictions, raise awareness, and provide services to victims in the fight against human
trafficking. As a pull factor, information technology, particularly the Internet, is rapidly being
used to advertise pornography, prostitution, and matrimony to women and children. Websites
for males sell detailed sex-related information on every country in the world, according to studies
undertaken by the Coalition Against Trafficking on the use of the Internet for worldwide sexual
exploitation of women and children. On the Internet, there is a world sex guide, a virtual grocery
store where men, women, and girls from over 80 countries can be selected for sex tourism. These
websites include information about sex tours, such as where to find prostitutes, hotel costs,
taxi prices and the sex acts that may be purchased. The Internet has had a huge impact on the
sexual exploitation of children and the elderly. Because there are no mediators or borders on
the Internet, unlawful or harmful behaviours are less likely to occur. Women and children are
Introduction 13

considerably more cost-effective and easier to obtain. Men can objectify and categories women
and children based on their skin colour, male cooperation and male hardness. Thanks to the
Internet, the dehumanization of women as sexual objects has reached new heights.

10. Vulnerability to Authority Complicity

The UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, Ms. Radhika Coomaraswamy,
claims that trafficked women have claimed considerable levels of government complicity and
cooperation. Officials accept bribes from drug traffickers in exchange for allowing them to pass
borders and in some cases, officials are personally participating in the operation. Both Burmese
and Thai officials have been accused of being directly involved in the trafficking of Burmese
women to Thailand. Armed police officers and in certain circumstances, police and brothel
guests have allegedly transported women into Thailand.

11. Vulnerability to Growth in Tourism

The tourist sector has grown worldwide as a result of globalization, particularly in poorer
countries. Tourists from all over the world flock to underdeveloped countries in search of easy and
inexpensive sexual fulfilment, particularly with children. American males, along with Europeans
are said to be the most prevalent sex tourists in Central America (Costa Rica, Honduras) and
Southeast Asia (India, Sri Lanka). Not only does their twisted psychology push them to treat
children as sexual objects, but the AIDS epidemic fuels a yearning for virgin females as well.

12. Vulnerability to Adoption

As birth rates fall in many industrialized countries adoption from poor countries with higher
fertility rates is becoming more common. The rising demand for children has put pressure on
sending countries to respond quickly, often without the necessary infrastructure and mechanisms
in place. As a result of this situation abuses have occurred, as well as the establishment of a
global market for adoptive children. The trafficking of children for the purpose of adoption is
on the rise, with adoption charges reaching from $5,000 to $30,000 per child in some countries,
according to intermediaries.

13. Natural Disasters and Civil Strife

Natural catastrophes and political upheaval represent a serious threat to young girls from
marginalized communities, since they exacerbate their family’s economic deprivation and limited
livelihood options, making underage girls and their families ideal targets for human traffickers. A
catastrophic cyclone in Odisha in 1999, recurrent floods in Bihar (Kosi River basin), and Naxalite
activity in Jharkhand have all been blamed for increased trafficking of women and young girls.
As a result of distress-driven and unstable migration to metropolitan areas, women and minor
girls may be at risk of being trafficked. Minor girls and women who relocate as dependents or
alone under difficult circumstances are likely to encounter severe gender discrimination. They
may be compelled to labour in the informal economy in low-wage, low-skilled jobs, or they may
be subjected to hazardous working conditions or sexual exploitation, including being duped into
Commercial Sex Exploitation.

14. Community, Family and Individual Factors

Because of a multitude of factors at the community, family, and individual levels, women
and minor girls in India are becoming increasingly exposed to trafficking for Commercial Sex
 14

Exploitation. Discriminatory social and cultural practices against women such as child marriage
and dowry play an important role in exposing minor girls to human trafficking at the community
level. There are also locations where it is a multigenerational practice to initiate adolescent girls
and women into Commercial Sex. Family and community elders decide which minor girls will
be initiated into Commercial Sex and when they will be initiated in these societies. In parts of
Karnataka, Maharashtra, and Andhra Pradesh (Blanchard et al., 2005; Orchard, 2007; Sen and
Nair, 2004; Mukherjee and Mukherjee, 2004) as well as among the Bedia community in Madhya
Pradesh, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh (Agarwal, 2008; Mukherjee and Mukherjee, 2004) this
practice is quite prevalent. Intergenerational Commercial Sex is also widespread among the
Nat group in Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh (O’Neil et al., 2004; Gupta
and Sinha, 2007; Mukherjee and Mukherjee, 2004). According to two surveys in Karnataka, the
devadasi custom brought 26 percent of women and 46 percent of minor girls into Commercial Sex
(Blanchard et al., 2005; Banandur et al., 2012). Several devadasi girls refused to call themselves
trafficked, instead defining themselves as girls who “do not always like what they do or what is
asked of them, but do so out of a sense of filial duty, economic need, and because Commercial
Sex is interwoven into their conceptions of female maturation”.
At the family level, studies have shown that a large proportion of women and minor girls-
between one-third and two-thirds-attributed their entry into CS to poverty (see McClarty et al.,
2014 for a review; Blanchard et al., 2005; Devine et al., 2010; Saggurti et al., 2011a; Banandur et
al., 2012). Domestic abuse, illness or death of family members who make a living and marriage
separation or abandonment are all key factors that put women and girls at risk of being trafficked
for Commercial Sex Exploitation. According to a study of rescued women and girls who were
trafficked into Commercial Sex Exploitation as children, family disruption, the death of income-
earning family members and marriage separation or desertion were all major factors in their
enslavement as minors. According to the study, 43% of women trafficked as teens reported
physical and/or sexual violence by their parents, natal family members and husbands before
being trafficked, compared to 26% of women trafficked as adults. Minor girls were considerably
more likely than adult females in Commercial Sex to report dispute with parents over marriage
partner choice as a factor in their Commercial Sex admission (19 percent vs. none) (19 percent
vs. none). They were, however, less likely to blame their trafficking on family illness or death (5
percent vs. 26 percent) or marriage dissolution and abandonment (5 percent vs. 26 percent) (24
percent versus 44 percent).
The family’s social position has also been linked to the likelihood of minor girls being trafficked
into Commercial Sex Exploitation. According to studies, minor girls from socially excluded caste
groups, such as scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, are more likely to be trafficked than
those from other caste groups (Sen and Nair, 2004; International Center for Research on Women
[ICRW], 2010). Children of women who work in brothels are equally vulnerable to mistreatment,
trafficking and sexual exploitation. Individually, illiteracy has been identified as a risk factor.
According to a countrywide survey conducted by the National Human Trafficking Resource
Center, 63 percent of trafficking survivors were illiterate or barely literate, with only 10% having
some secondary education (Sen and Nair, 2004). According to a study conducted in Mumbai,
49% of rescued women and underage girls indicated they had never attended school.

MIGRATION AND HUMAN TRAFFICKING

The worldwide community has pledged to address global challenges through the Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs) in order to achieve a better and more sustainable future for everybody.
Introduction 15

SDG 8.7 aims to prohibit child labour by 2025 and eliminate modern slavery, human trafficking,
forced labour, and the worst forms of child labour by 2030. Alliance 8.7 is a multi-stakeholder
group dedicated to achieving Target 8.7 by pooling resources, boosting research, and exchanging
data and knowledge. The SDGs target migration as well, most notably in SDG 10.7, which aspires
to promote orderly, safe, and responsible migration and mobility, particularly through well-
managed migration policies. In addition, the Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular
Migration wants to be the first UN-sponsored worldwide migration accord. When looking into
all sorts of human trafficking, one’s focus is pulled to migration. The main purpose of this focus
is to find more effective ways to combat human trafficking particularly in the prevention area,
while not infringing on migrants’ rights.
Radhika Coomarswamy’s study covers crucial indications for possible human trafficking
and migratory crossovers. In their two recent papers, Raymond and Blanchet used this link as
the foundation for their research. The link is believed to be significant because understanding
migration patterns and trends, as well as the factors that drive movement and the procedures
involved in migration, will help in the battle against human trafficking. In contrast to the
relationship between trafficking and other phenomena, migration and trafficking appear to
overlap at almost all levels. The exploitation of migration by traffickers appears to be the most
prominent characteristic of this relationship. They appear to collide at first at a physical movement
crossroads. Migration appears to offer the foundation and context for human trafficking on
a structural level. The fact that these places expose those who live in them to a high level of
vulnerability is self-evident. It is obvious that the nature of movement provides opportunities
and means for human trafficking to occur. Migration trends may have an impact on human
trafficking, as evidenced by the relationship between these two phenomena.
Migrant workers are also vulnerable in certain work situations that are either hidden, difficult
to access, or do not come within the purview of existing legal protections. This can include migrants
who are essentially confined to work locations by private employers or agencies who have extensive
control over their visa status, working and living circumstances, and mobility. It can also refer to
migrants who are effectively bound to work sites by private employers or agents who have a lot of
power over their visa status, working and living circumstances, and mobility. Migrant children and
adolescents are especially vulnerable to modern slavery. While there are an estimated 31 million
children who travel around the world, children are frequently denied legal migration opportunities.
Certain forms of exploitation may be acceptable to people. “However, no one can consent to human
trafficking” (UN. 2003, p.27). Even if there is manifest permission, it is merely a ‘facade of consent’
rather than ‘informed consent.’
The term “human trafficking” refers to a lot more than the systematic transportation of people
 16

for monetary gain (Recommended Guidelines of the UN High Commission for Human Rights,
2002). The use of force, coercion, and/or deceit throughout, or at some level, in the process-
such deception, force, or coercion being employed for the aim of exploitation-is a significant
additional factor that distinguishes trafficking from migrant smuggling. In this context, Figure
1.3 depicts the UN Economic and Social Commission’s (ECOSOC) model, which demonstrates
how the many connected concepts interact (UN.2003. p.27)
Figure: 1.3 Interplay between exploitation, trafficking, migration, smuggling, labour and consent

Source: ECOSOC
Maria Grazia Giammarinaro, the UN Special Rapporteur on human trafficking, has emphasized
the link between human trafficking and large-scale migration as an area that demands further
attention. Tight and discriminatory immigration regulations, insufficient pathways for regular
migration and family reunion, and irregular access to the labour market for asylum seekers,
refugees, and migrants all contribute to migrant exploitation, according to the expert. “Human
trafficking does not affect all migrants. People fleeing wars, natural catastrophes, and poverty,
on the other hand, are forced to move in perilous and vulnerable conditions “she explains.
“They could be exploited and trafficked throughout their route or at their destination because
of their social vulnerability.” The line between human trafficking and migration is quite thin.
Person trafficking is a subset of migration, although the magnitude of this subgroup is difficult
to measure.

LABOUR MIGRATION AS TRAFFICKING

In recent years, a new view on the complex relationship between human trafficking,
smuggling, and migration has emerged. A number of international development agencies and
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have begun to use an “anti-trafficking framework”
in their theory and practice when dealing with cases of labour exploitation involving “legal”
migrants in response to mounting evidence of a wide range of exploitative practices experienced
by labour migrants in destination countries. Many of these workers face restrictions on their
freedom of movement, as well as counterfeit and fake documents, bonded labour and debt
bondage, fraud, assault and abuse, deplorable working conditions, and nonpayment of wages.
Rather than treating these issues as cases of labour abuse under recipient countries’ labour laws,
migrant rights activists-and some governments-have turned to anti-trafficking legislation. They
argue that the vast majority of low-skilled migrant workers can easily be categorized as “victims
Introduction 17

of human trafficking” under the UN Trafficking Protocol’s criteria due to the prevalent nature
of these concerns and the ease with which documented migrant workers can become unlawful.
Treating ‘documented/legal’ migrants as ‘trafficking victims’ skews the classifications that
countries use to limit temporary labour migration. While the ability of individual states to regulate
labour migration varies substantially, state authorities’ attempts to manage temporary labour
migrations are rather similar. Both sending and receiving countries have developed complex
immigration and employment regimes to recruit and deploy labour migrants, with the bulk of
these regimes presuming a clear distinction between legal and illegal entry and deployment.
By addressing the fundamental assumptions that underpin most immigration and labour
policy, the ‘labour migration as trafficking’ approach reveals the model’s shortcomings. Since 2000,
international agencies and donors have made major investments in anti-trafficking programmes,
which has assisted this approach. While donor money gives the means to prosecute labour abuse
cases as “trafficking cases,” the political motive for this shift in focus is international pressure to
ratify the Trafficking Protocol and ensure compliance with fundamental conditions listed in the
annual TIP Reports. Dealing with documented labour migrants under anti-trafficking legislation
or programmes can assist states portray themselves as tough on both trafficking and smuggling,
as well as terrorism. On the other hand, the characterization of labour migration as trafficking
should not be disregarded as a cynical response to international pressure from the United States
and other donor countries. It also reflects a growing consensus among academics and activists
that labour laws are ineffectual in curbing the demand for low-wage, unprotected work. For
example, Roger Plant, the former head of the ILO’s Special Action Programme to Combat Forced
Labor, argues that trafficked people are better protected than other vulnerable migrants working
in slave-like conditions. Despite the fact that the ILO’s forced labour conventions have been
signed by the majority of its members.
Forced labour is not defined in any detail, making it difficult for law enforcement agents to
identify and prosecute the offence. Second, and in consequence of this, there have been very
few prosecutions for forced labour offences anywhere in the world. A vicious cycle is thereby
established: no clear legislation, little or no resources for prosecutions, limited awareness or
publicity, thus no pressure for clear legislation, and so on. (ILO 2005: 2).
The International Labour Organization (ILO) proposes that “legislative and judicial action
against forced labour and human trafficking can serve the same purposes and be mutually
supportive” in the face of government inaction on labour exploitation (ILO 2009: 8). This is
because, whereas the definition of forced labour emphasizes the involuntary character of the
employment, the Trafficking Protocol emphasizes the tactics used to gain initial consent (i.e.,
force, deception, coercion, etc). To address the link between forced labour and trafficking, the ILO
employs a ‘forced labour continuum,’ defining three forms of labour: trafficked victims of forced
labour, non-trafficked victims of forced labour, and successful migrants. It claims that trafficked
forced labour victims face the worst abuses because they have the least freedom of movement
and are the most vulnerable, whereas non-trafficked forced labour victims face a variety of
exploitative conditions, including non-payment of wages, retention of identity documents,
long working hours, and inhumane working conditions. The ‘forced labour continuum’ has an
advantage over the traditional distinction between ‘victims of trafficking’ and ‘illegal migrants,’
in that it allows researchers to look at the ‘varying degrees to which migrants can become victims
of exploitation, routes that lead to forced labour, and individual strategies to escape coercion and
control,’ among other things.
 18

The majority of migrant domestic workers obtain employment contracts that are purposely
dishonest, according to Jureidini and Moukarbel and “such direct and indirect deception
regarding contractual security... pushes people into the category of being trafficked.” This
classification of all forms of exploitation involving temporary labour migrants as “trafficking”
ignores the agency of migrant workers and fails to recognize that many migrants knowingly cross
borders without “legal” papers and choose to work in illegal jobs in both sending and receiving
societies. It also disregards what migrants want from the migration process. Anti-trafficking laws
and regulations govern not just the status of a victim, but also how that victim is treated. This
usually means being removed from the exploitative situation, staying in the receiving country
for a period of time while evidence and statements are obtained, and then being repatriated.
Migrant workers may not want any of these things to happen in many cases: they may prefer
to stay at their current employment (but with better pay and/or hours), leave to hunt for new
work, and/or have their immigration status regularized. These objectives will not be met just
by anti-trafficking legislation. Only nations have the last word on whether or not a certain act is
considered forced labour or human trafficking.
While some international NGOs argue for a “labour migration as trafficking” strategy,
most governments have been much less willing to include documented workers in their anti-
trafficking efforts. Only the “worst cases” of exploitation, mainly sexual exploitation of women
and children, are dealt with in this manner due to the financial, legal, and administrative
problems in identifying labour migrants as victims of trafficking (Piper 2005). This isn’t to say
that the Protocol isn’t getting traction; in fact it’s already having an impact on international,
national, regional, and local responses to regional migratory movements. The repercussions of
this transformation, on the other hand, are still unknown.

HUMAN TRAFFICKING’S CONSEQUENCES

1. Human Trafficking’s Health Consequences
Empirical research on the impact of human trafficking for Commercial Sex Exploitation on
women’s lives reveals a range of risks to their physical and mental health, which could have long-
term consequences. They are at risk of unwanted pregnancies, unsafe abortions, and sexually
transmitted infections (STIs), including HIV/AIDS. They are also more likely to experience
physical and sexual violence as well as mental health issues like depression, anxiety, guilt,
shame, and feelings of self-blame, attachment disorders, adult mistrust, and antisocial behaviour,
reduced cognitive functioning, low self-worth, suicidal ideation, alcohol or drug addiction, and
PTSD symptoms.

2. Self-Reported STIs/Symptoms of STIs and HIV Infection

The research that looked into the link between Commercial Sex experiences and HIV infection
used cross-sectional data from women in Commercial Sex at the time of the survey or women
and minor girls who had been rescued and were receiving post-trafficking care from NGOs at
the time of the survey. To assess whether or not someone was infected with HIV, all of these trials
used laboratory testing. Three of the four studies included in this review (all from India) found
no statistically significant association between HIV infection and age at first interaction with
Commercial Sex/age at first encounter with trafficking. However, a Nepalese study discovered
a significant link: those trafficked before the age of 15 had nearly four times the chance of
contracting HIV as those trafficked after the age of 18. Those between the ages of 15 and 17 who
Introduction 19

were trafficked were not at risk. Similarly, when it came to the link between HIV infection and
ever having been a victim of human trafficking, as defined by entrance into Commercial Sex by
force or deception, the results were ambiguous. Women who were trafficked were 2.3 times more
likely to be HIV positive than others, according to a study from Karnataka, however no such
link was identified in a study from West Bengal. Only two studies looked into the experiences of
women and underage girls who were trafficked for Commercial Sex and other STIs besides HIV.
There was no link between a history of human trafficking and STIs or STI symptoms in these
investigations.

3. HIV-Infection-Producing Behaviors
Several studies have looked into the relationship between human trafficking and HIV risk
variables such as client load, length of Commercial Sex involvement, violence exposure, condom
use, and alcohol consumption. Women and minor girls who were trafficked, as defined by entry as
minors with or without force or deception or as adults as a result of force or deception at the time
the studies were conducted, were more likely to serve more clients and engage in Commercial
Sex for longer periods of time than those who were not. Women who were trafficked as minors
were significantly more likely than those who were trafficked as adults to have spent greater
time in brothels (19 months versus 10 months), a factor that has been related to an elevated risk
of HIV infection.

4. Mental Health
Only a few studies have looked into the mental health consequences of being a victim of
human trafficking or Commercial Sex. One study in Nepal compared women trafficked for
sexual exploitation to those trafficked for domestic work, and the findings revealed that, while
many trafficked women reported negative symptoms in general, women trafficked for sexual
exploitation had a significantly higher risk of depression and PTSD than those trafficked for
labour. Another study of women in Commercial Sex in Goa found that 42 percent of those under
the age of 20 had attempted suicide in the three months preceding to the interview, and that
those over the age of 20 were three to six times less likely to have attempted suicide.
According to a study conducted in Kolkata, when young girls aged 13–18 years who were
trafficked for Commercial Sex Exploitation were compared to a matched sample of minor girls
who had not been sexually assaulted, those trafficked for Commercial Sex Exploitation showed
significantly higher levels of hostility (31% versus 14%). Other behavioural symptoms ranging
from social isolation to violence were discovered in a small qualitative study of 20 Commercial
Sex survivors in Nepal.
In a cross-sectional study titled “Mental Health of Female Survivors of Human Trafficking
in Nepal,” 164 female survivors of human trafficking were studied in Kathmandu, Nepal. The
researchers utilized a T-test for continuous variables and an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA)
using age as a covariate. The chi-square test was used to compare categorical data and the case
proportions of anxiety, depression, and PTSD, as determined by the measures’ cut-off values
(two-tailed). The sex workers had much more anxiety symptoms than the non-sex workers. In
terms of depression, the proportion of people in the sex workers group who are above the PTSD
cut-off (29.6%) was higher than in the non-sex workers group (7.5 percent).
According to another study, violence and mental suffering are common among women and
 20

girls trafficked for sexual exploitation. The random effects pooled prevalence of detectable HIV
was 31.9 percent in studies of women seeking post-trafficking help in India and Nepal, while the
estimate was subject to considerable fluctuation.

LIFE TRAJECTORIES OF TRAFFICKING

In this part, we summarize findings from research that depict the lives of minor girls who
were trafficked, their experiences in brothels, and their rescue and rehabilitation.

The Process of Human Trafficking

While the majority of incidents of trafficking begin with deception or coercion of women and
young girls into migrating to an area where they will be exploited, women and children who
move voluntarily can also be trafficked into Commercial Sex Exploitation after they get at their
destination. By taking advantage of vulnerable characteristics such as poverty, troubled family
conditions, or restricted access to education, Commercial Sex hooks minor women and girls into
Commercial Sex Exploitation or their families into enabling their daughters to be trafficked into
Commercial Sex. Young women and teenage girls were reportedly recruited for Commercial Sex
Exploitation through a variety of informal social networks, including friends and coworkers,
family members such as husbands, relatives, and parents, and strangers, according to studies
performed across India. In several research, stranger-induced trafficking is represented to varying
degrees. According to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) Study, only 11% of
trafficking victims in Commercial Sex at the time of the survey were trafficked by strangers,
whereas 35% were trafficked by family or relatives, and 53% were exploited by acquaintances
(Sen and Nair, 2004) whereas in some studies the percentage of trafficking by strangers vary
from 11% to 53%.

Locations for Recruitment

Some traffickers approached women and minor girls through informal social networks and
familial ties, while others approached them directly at bus stops, train stations, and markets. Cafes
and restaurants, beauty contest venues, beauty parlours, national roadways, and construction
sites were all places where traffickers approached women and minor girls (Sen and Nair, 2004).
According to a survey of trafficked victims rescued in Mumbai, the most common recruitment
sites were relatives’ or friends’ residences (27%), workplaces (21%), and public transportation
terminals and other public venues (51 percent). Females from rural areas were typically recruited
by traffickers, according to studies (Sen and Nair, 2004). As a result of greater usage of current
communication technologies, the character of the recruitment process has evolved in recent years.
Traffickers, for example, utilize newspaper adverts to recruit women and minor girls through
allegedly legal shop-front organizations, and they’ve also expanded their reach by using the
internet and mobile phones.
Lure/Promises
Offers of well-paying jobs, opportunities to live in a more developed location, the promise of
marriage, and protestations of love are just a few of the many enticements used by traffickers to
persuade victims to join them on their journey. A common inducement is the promise of a well-
paying job; studies from throughout the country suggest that offers of economic opportunity
attracted between two-fifths and two-thirds of women and minor girls trafficked into Commercial
Sex. Promises of better living conditions or lifestyles enticed minor ladies in the past. Some people
were trafficked because of false marriage offers. According to studies, human traffickers deceived
Introduction 21

parents who did not have the financial means to marry their daughters by offering false dowry-
free marriage proposals or cash offers from phoney grooms in exchange for marriage (Ghosh, 2009).
Kidnapping or abduction with or without the use of drugs or force has been documented in several
studies, with between 12% and 26% of victims reporting the use of force and drugs.

Mode of Transports
According to studies, traffickers used public transit to take their victims to their locations,
typically buses or trains. Bribes paid to local officials and transporters ensured that the traffickers
conduct were not called into question. In a Mumbai survey of trafficking survivors, 63 percent of
women and minors stated they were transported to various locations using public transportation
(Silverman et al., 2007a). According to the NHRC survey, public transit was used by more
than three-quarters of the survivors (Sen and Nair, 2004). In the second part of the trafficking
operation, the trafficked person was usually relocated to a transit site before being taken to the
final destination. Minor girls who had been trafficked became even more reliant on traffickers
or brothel owners and they had no choice but to obey them at the transit site, which was usually
the brothel owner’s or trafficker’s residence. Traffickers used a variety of methods to make girls
dependent, including starvation, imprisonment, sexual and physical abuse, threats of violence
against them and their families, and forced drug use. They also kept them in a false debt bondage
ostensibly created by their travel, living and other expenses, and used methods of harassment,
such as starvation, imprisonment, sexual and physical abuse, threats of violence against them and
their families, and forced drug use (Saggurti et al., 2011a). Minor girls who have been trafficked
may be moved to other traffickers with whom they have had no previous contact, adding to
their anxiety. We found that the movement of trafficked young females from their point of origin
to transit and final destination points was not necessarily linear, and that they were moved or
resold numerous times before reaching their final destination (Sen and Nair, 2004).

Exploitation of Victims in Brothels

A human trafficking victim is sold to a brothel and is forced to deal with clients directly.
Pricing for adolescent females was set by a “sorting and grading” method, according to one
study, with the youngest girls earning the highest fee. In the early days of Commercial Sex
Exploitation, women and minor girls may have been imprisoned in a small room for several
months in order to break them in. They were held in brothels on a debt bondage, which they
were led to believe had to be paid with their brothel work. They were also told that their families
relied on them financially. They may be offered drugs and drink, and if they are enrolled in
Commercial Sex Exploitation, they may be forced to sell themselves to 5-15 men each day, with
the “madam” earning approximately $100 per customer if sold as a virgin. According to another
study of women and girls trafficked for Commercial Sex Exploitation in Delhi, Mumbai, and
Kolkata, physical assault and imprisonment were widespread, especially in the early days of
their stay in the brothel. The victims described torture, hunger, forced use of drugs and alcohol,
being paraded naked, solitary confinement in a darkened room, and other damaging actions as
ways in which brothel owners ensured their submissiveness. These women and girls claimed
that on average, they served 4-5 customers every day at the brothels, where they were kept in
deplorable and filthy conditions. Brothel owners kept all of their earnings, including gratuities
from customers. Healthcare costs were viewed as a debt that people were expected to repay
if they were ill. Many women said that they were pressured to get pregnant because brothel
owners saw having a child as another way to retain women and young girls in the brothel.
 22

Saving money is difficult in these circumstances. According to the NHRC study, 61% of
women and underage girls in CS had no savings at the time of the survey, and nearly half said
they sent money home on a regular basis. According to the research, the majority of the girls did
not communicate with their parents while at Commercial Sex Exploitation. Accordingly, more
than two-thirds of survivors had no contact with their families, and barely half of those who did
have visited them, including some who had done so to get more young girls (Sen and Nair, 2004).
Women and underage girls who stay in brothels as they get older become less profitable, and by
the age of 35, they are no longer deemed profitable and are released. Because they lack familial
support or a means of earning money, many people believe they have no choice but to operate
as human traffickers.

Rescue
Women and girls are rescued from brothels through raids and relocation to safe locations
where they are not exploited (Pandey et al., 2013). Typically, rescue operations are broken down
into many stages. When the police or non-governmental organizations (NGOs) get information
about a trafficked minor girl in a brothel, they conduct an independent confidential investigation
to verify the accuracy of the information. After being authenticated, police officials and NGO
representatives carry with the rescue operation. Minor ladies rescued from human trafficking
are sent to a police station to make a first information report (FIR). Medical testing is arranged
by the police, with the support of NGOs, to determine the age of people rescued, if necessary.
According to surveys, brothel raids occur more frequently than in the past, and many minor girls
are spared. The majority of Commercial Sex Exploitation survivors and those in Commercial Sex
at the time of the NHRC study said that rescue efforts took place in the brothels where they were
trafficked (Sen and Nair, 2004).
However, there are a lot of faults in the rescue efforts. First, police officers regularly charge
trafficking victims with offences including soliciting or engaging in sex in or near a public venue,
as defined by Section 8 of the ITPA, during rescue operations, sometimes known as “raids”.
According to the NHRC’s study of survivors, more than half of them had been arrested at least
once, with two-fifths of those arrested being charged with solicitation. The rest of the group
appeared to be unaware of the situation, probably because the charges against them were swiftly
dropped and they were released and returned to the brothel. Second, the collaboration of human
traffickers and law enforcement officers’ thwarts rescue efforts. According to the NHRC study,
about half of the women and minor girls in CS had eluded arrest at least once, largely because
the brothel owner had received advance information from the police and had moved girls away
from the brothel (58%) or they were hidden in boxes, cupboards, and other places unlikely to
be searched (24%) or the brothel owner had bribed the raiding police party (1%) (Sen and Nair,
2004). Third, several women and minor girls in CS who had previously been subjected to police
raids and rescues said that they were able to bribe officials or solicit the help of their brothel
owner to get out of police custody.

Rehabilitation
After rescue, victims’ various needs, such as immediate and long-term physical and mental
health demands, social concerns, and meaningful integration into society, are addressed in
rehabilitation (Pandey et al., 2013). It usually means placing women and minors in government
or non-governmental organization (NGO) homes for a period of protective custody until their
cases are heard in court or they are returned to their families. NGOs play an important role in
Introduction 23

the rehabilitation process, giving legal support and supporting victims in seeking compensation.
Minors are sent to designated shelter Homes for custodial care. They are placed in protective
custody in the residence until their parents or legal guardians are located and their identities are
verified before a Magistrate in order for the minor girls to be released to their families. When
recognized non-governmental organizations (NGOs) involved in the restoration and repatriation
process return underage girls to their parents or legal guardians, the NGOs must provide a detailed
report on their follow-up actions. If the girl is from another country, the two governments work
together to repatriate her and help her through an approved non-governmental organization in
her home country. Women are relocated to Swadhar/Ujjawala homes, where they are counselled
and imparted income-generating skills in preparation for alternative jobs.

Reintegration
Reintegration is the process of assimilating a rescued victim into their “source” or home
community so that they can live a normal life and be accepted socially. According to the
information now available, stigma, insufficient skills, and a lack of livelihood opportunities make it
difficult for women and underage girls to reintegrate with their native families and communities.
Those who returned were often placed in vulnerable conditions, such as poverty and a lack
of safety, leading to re-trafficking. The vast majority of re-trafficked survivors (80%) reported
they were unable to find other sources of income or livelihood options when they returned to
their communities, according to a study (Sen and Nair 2004). Furthermore, many societies hold
significant prejudices against women and minor girls who have been trafficked for Commercial
Sex, making it impossible for returned victims to lead normal lives. Existing interventions appear
to be largely concerned with rescue and rehabilitation, with social reintegration receiving little
attention. In the limited efforts to rehabilitate rescued victims, economic reintegration frequently
takes precedence over social reintegration.

THE SUPPLY AND DEMAND SIDE OF TRAFFICKING

The most immediate cause of trafficking in women and minor girls has been thought to be
male desire for Commercial Sex. The literature on sex trafficking for Commercial Sex Exploitation
articulates three levels of demand: (a) demand from those who employ women and minor girls
in Commercial Sex (brothel owners and managers, for example); (b) demand from clients; and
(c) demand from third parties involved in the process (recruiters, agents, transporters, and others
who knowingly participate in the movement of persons for the purpose of exploitation). Men
who solicit or buy sex acts; profiteers in the sex industry (traffickers, pimps, brothel owners,
and corrupt officers who support trafficking); and, finally, the culture that indirectly creates a
demand for victims by normalizing prostitution, such as media depictions of prostitution and
other commercial sex acts.
While there is a demand for women, a variety of supply-side factors also play a role, and
the combination of demand- and supply-side factors makes it tough to pinpoint the reasons of
trafficking. As a result, poverty may be a supply-side issue, causing a large number of women
and minor girls to migrate to unregulated businesses, where they are more vulnerable to
exploitation. A plentiful supply of such women and juvenile girls stimulates demand that would
not have existed if they were not so freely available. However, some experts believe that the
commercial sex industry in India is largely demand driven, and that even when the supply of
vulnerable women and minor girls in particular source sites is depleted, traffickers and other
parties profiting from Commercial Sex procure minor girls and women from other parts of the
 24

country because there is a constant demand for Commercial Sex.

Traffickers/Recruiters
Despite women’s participation being higher than in other crimes, nearly two-thirds of
individuals convicted of human trafficking offences in 2018 were men, according to the UNODC’s
2020 Global Report on Trafficking in Persons. About 2% of the overall convictions were for
traffickers under the age of 18. Females continue to be convicted in greater numbers than males
in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, with 80 percent of convictions involving women, but in
Central America and East Asia, males and females were convicted in about equal proportions in
2018. Human trafficking impacts business owners, intimate partners, and other family members.
While many traffickers have criminal backgrounds and use human trafficking as a direct source
of cash, it also affects company owners, intimate partners, and other family members. According
to court documents, parents have been accused of supporting their children’s sexual exploitation
or pushing them to beg on the streets. In India, however, the situation is different, as more than
half of all traffickers are women, with many of them having previously been trafficked (Sen and
Nair, 2004).
Human trafficking is a well-organized crime involving multiple people, according to
studies of human traffickers in India. Accordingly, the trafficker is a critical link in a multi-
tiered chain involving many actors: (a) master trafficker/cum-kingpin; (b) primary trafficker/
cum-procurers; (c) subordinate traffickers; and (d) spotters or a grassroots chain of intelligence
gatherers. Multiple people are involved in the trafficking process, according to Commercial Sex
Exploitation survivors. They indicated at least three to four persons were there, including the
brothel owner, an initial procurer, a secondary procurer, a transporter, and an initial procurer.
It is also discovered that a variety of other stakeholders support the main trafficking structure,
including (a) financiers who finance transactions at various levels; (b) hoteliers who provide
accommodation during transit; (c) goons/goondas who provide security at various levels; (d)
transporters who provide or arrange transportation; and (e) paramedical persons or even quacks
who attend to the illnesses of trafficked victims while in transit.
According to findings from studies undertaken in India, traffickers are equally likely to be
males or girls. Strangers or individuals who are related to or familiar with the trafficked women
and minor girls can be the traffickers. Female traffickers were often victims of Commercial Sex
Exploitation themselves, accordingly, many of them are elderly women who had lost their
business in brothels. The majority of traffickers said that the police were aware of their actions
and that they were paid in cash or “free sex” to keep them from being prosecuted. As a result,
more than half of those questioned had never been arrested, and many of those who had been
arrested had never been to jail or had been released on bail. Sex trafficking is a low-risk, high-
reward criminal activity (Hodge and Lietz, 2007).

Brothel Owners
In India, the brothel owner does not have to be the owner of the property. Brothel managers
or brothel keepers are the people in charge of the brothel who work for or on behalf of the brothel
owner. According to a recent survey, just 10% of 30 “madams” from a well-known brothel
district in Nagpur owned the facility that housed their brothel. On average, they spend Rs 5,500
per month on rent. The majority of information about brothel proprietors comes from rescued
survivors or reports of women or minor girls involved in Commercial Sex. The survey reveals
Introduction 25

that almost three-quarters of brothel owners were between the ages of 31 and 50, were illiterate
or barely educated, and that the majority of brothel owners had worked in Commercial Sex in
brothels before becoming owners, based on interviews with 412 brothel owners from 12 states.

Patterns of Demand and Client Profile

Men who buy sex from women and minor girls have been the subject of a few studies. The
majority of these client studies were conducted in the aftermath of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, mainly
in Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra, and Tamil Nadu. According to existing evidence
from several studies on consumer socio-demographic variables, clients included both younger
and older males, although they were primarily men in their 30s. While some studies suggest
that married men made up the bulk of the clients, others report that the married and unmarried
clients were evenly split. According to the study, clients came from a variety of educational
and occupational backgrounds, however blue-collar workers and merchants dominated. These
figures show that demand for Commercial Sex is far broader than previously imagined, and that
it is not restricted to a single socioeconomic group. According to studies, clients were also able
to receive sex at a reasonable cost. In one study, nearly 80% of customers indicated they paid Rs
500 or less.
Customers’ first meetings with women or minor girls in CS were more frequently organized
by friends or colleagues than by the clients themselves, according to one study. As a result, a
mix of their own beliefs of masculinity’s societal norms and peer pressure to conform to those
demands influenced young men’s first encounters with approaching a lady or minor girl for sex.
Following the AIDS crisis, there appears to be a preference for younger girls, with a particular
need for HIV-free virgin girls. The belief that having sexual contact with a virgin can cure HIV/
AIDS is fueling demand for young females (Datta, 2011). Finally, research shows that the majority
of clients regard women and minor girls as commodities, and that knowing they may have been
trafficked does not bother them. Commercial Sex demand varies, with more demand during
festivals and the Christmas season. The demand for Commercial Sex varies by geography and
location, such as at train stations, movie theatres, and beaches, for example. Wherever anonymity
can be preserved, law enforcement is lenient, and clients are not at risk of being arrested, demand
is high. Connections between hotels, brothels, and human smugglers have been established
(Gupta and Sinha, 2007). It is becoming less site specific as a result of the rising use of mobile
phones to express demand, and anonymity is easier to maintain than before (Suryawanshi et al.,
2013).

Profits and costs of trafficking

According to the ILO, human trafficking (which includes sexual exploitation and other forms
of forced labour) earns roughly US$ 31.6 billion in annual revenue. The Asia-Pacific area earns
the largest profits (US$ 9.7 billion), accounting for about one-third of all profits worldwide. Data
on the profits and costs of human trafficking in India is scant, according to our review of the
literature. According to the conclusions of the Sen & Nair, 2004 report and others, trafficking and
Commercial Sex are lucrative and profitable in India for traffickers and brothel operators, but not
for the women and minor girls involved in Commercial Sex Exploitation and their families, who
earn a small percentage of the industry’s income.

Implications of Human Trafficking

Human trafficking has serious psychosocial and economic effects for victims, but it also has
 26

far-reaching consequences for society and the country. For trafficked children, isolation from
family and community, fear and psychological stress, physical and emotional abuse, as well
as the loss of childhood and education, are all regular occurrences. In the case of trafficked
minor girls, pregnancy, early motherhood, and reproductive abnormalities are all possibilities.
Furthermore, their families and communities demonize and reject them. In the worst-case
situation, it could result in his or her death or severe bodily and mental injury. In addition to the
consequences of having limited housing, sleep, and freedom of movement, trafficking victims
are frequently denied food and medical treatment. Isolation and dominance have a significant
psychological impact on the victim, which is aggravated by the victim’s relocation to a region
where she is compelled to live in silence and submission. Victims of abuse and exploitation,
especially those forced into commercial sex, may be drugged, becoming sick and dependent.
Human trafficking has a harmful impact on victims in the context of the HIV/AIDS epidemic,
which is becoming a growing concern. According to some studies, the longer victims are kept in
brothels, the more likely they are to contract HIV/AIDS as a result of multiple sex partners, sex
assault, and inadequate condom negotiation. The country will be forced to spend a significant
amount of money on health and rehabilitation.
One of the major gaps is the lack of studies on human trafficking in India based on primary
data. There are few research available, and those that do exist are inconsistent. Human
trafficking’s different dimensions and characteristics must be thoroughly investigated. There
is no community-based research on people’s awareness of human trafficking and its relevance
to human trafficking’s incidence. The demand side of trafficking is virtually non-existent, as
is information about traffickers and their networks. NGO responses to human trafficking, best
practices followed by them, and NGO networks to combat trafficking are all underrepresented in
the literature. The effectiveness of government and non-government anti-trafficking programmes
must be properly assessed.
 Chapter 2
POLICY AND LEGAL PERSPECTIVE OF
HUMAN TRAFFICKING
H uman trafficking has been an issue in our country since the beginning of time, but it has
become increasingly prevalent since India’s globalization and industrialization. Our
global engagement has increased, allowing us to participate in the global economy, which has
improved our economic growth. On the other hand, it has resulted in the victimization of the
most vulnerable elements of our society, particularly women and children. Human trafficking
is both a result and an integral aspect of globalization. Sexual trafficking, often known as the
immoral flesh trade, is the most common form of human trafficking that has been recognized
by our legal institutions. Human trafficking is a modern-day kind of slavery in which criminals
benefit from the exploitation of trafficking victims. It is a crime against humanity since it infringes
on the dignity, rights, and liberty of the victims. It’s a form of organized crime gang that operates
in a network, making it tough to eradicate from society. The global stats for sex trafficking are
worrisome, but what’s even more alarming is that it’s one of the least reported crimes on the
planet due to its organized nature. It’s a war crime that needs to be handled on both a national
and international level.
A multitude of push and pull dynamics are at work in this organized crime. By “push factors,” we
mean factors that encourage victims to leave their own nation in search of a better life. Pull factors, on
the other hand, are by-products of globalization and modernization that operate within the destination
country. Among them are better job prospects in host countries, better living conditions, political
stability, and so on. According to emerging statistics on human trafficking, the push forces have a
stronger impact on victims and offenders than the pull elements, resulting in this crime situation.
Because of these circumstances, an attempt was made in the shape of the Immoral Trafficking
Prevention Act (ITPA) amendment Bill of 2006, which recommended criminalizing clients. However,
due to a lack of agreement, the bill lapsed.

INTERNATIONAL LEGAL INSTRUMENTS TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING:

A number of international tools are now in use to prevent human trafficking. The two most
important international conventions addressing child trafficking are the Convention on the
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) of 1979 and the Protocol
to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Particularly Women and Children.
The Palermo Protocol, a supplement to the UN Convention against Transnational Organized
Crime (2000), is the most important international mechanism for combating human trafficking.
Trafficking, attempted trafficking, and any other purposeful involvement or organization in a
 28

trafficking system are all prohibited under Article 5 of the Protocol.

The following International Legal Instruments are in existence to combat trafficking in
persons, especially women and children:
1. International Agreement for Suppression of White Slave Traffic, 18th May, 1904, as
amended by the Protocol approved by General Assembly of the United Nations on 3
December 1948: The agreement was formulated with the intention of securing to women
of full age who have suffered abuse or compulsion, as also under-age girls, effective
protection against criminal traffic known as the “White Slave Traffic”.
2. International Convention for Suppression of White Slave Traffic, 4th May, 1910, as
amended by the Protocol approved by General Assembly of the United Nations on 3
December 1948: This convention criminalized procurement, enticement or leading away
of a woman or girl under the age of 21, even with her consent for immoral purposes
irrespective of the fact that the various acts constituting the offence may have been
committed in different countries.
3. International Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic of the Women and Children,
30th September, 1921, as amended by the Protocol approved by General Assembly of the
United Nations on 20th October 1947: The treaty prohibits the enticing or leading away of
a woman or girl for immoral purposes, to be carried out in another country.
4. Slavery Convention, 1926: States Parties are enjoined to discourage all forms of forced
labour. Slavery means control over another person, without full informed consent, for
the purpose of exploitation.
5. International Labour Organization Forced Labour Convention, 1930: Article 1 of this
convention calls for suppression of the use of forced or compulsory labour in all its forms
within the shortest possible period.
6. International Convention for Suppression of Traffic in Women of Full Age, 1933: This
convention imposes a duty on the signing countries to prohibit, prevent, prosecute and/
or punish those engaged in trafficking in women.
7. Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948: Article 4 of the Declaration prohibits all
forms of slavery and the slave trade. Article 13 recognizes the right of persons to freedom
of movement and residence and Article 15 recognizes the right to nationality.
8. UN Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Persons and of the Exploitation
of the Prostitution of Others, 1949: This convention is a compilation of four previous
international conventions (Conventions of 1904, 1910, 1921 and 1933). This convention
made procurement, enticement, etc. for purposes of prostitution punishable irrespective
of the age of the person involved and his/her consent to the same (Article 1). Brothel
keeping was also denounced to be illegal and punishable (Article 2). The convention
provided for repatriation (Article 19) and rehabilitation (Article 20) measures. However,
the 1949 Convention is limited to trafficking for prostitution and related activities.
9. Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery, Slave Trade and Institutions
and Practices of Slavery, 1956 (Slavery Convention): This convention condemned a
variety of slavery-like practices, including debt bondage and forced marriage. States
Parties undertook to establish suitable minimum ages of marriage and registration of
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 29

marriages.
10. Abolition of Forced Labour Convention, ILO, 1957: Under this convention, States Parties
undertook to suppress any form of forced or compulsory labour as a means of political
coercion, economic development, labour discipline, or racial, social, national or religious
discrimination.
11. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966: Forced labour and slavery
are prohibited by Article 8 of the ICCPR. Article 24 outlines the rights of children.
12. International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) 1966:
Article 10 of this convention stipulates that States are responsible for protecting children
from exploitation and must lay down the minimum age for their employment.
13. Minimum Age Convention, 1973: The aim of this convention was to prohibit and regulate
child labour and restrict engagement of children in hazardous work.
14. Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination against Women, 1979
(CEDAW): Article 6 of CEDAW requires States Parties to take all appropriate measures,
including legislation, to suppress all forms of traffic in women.
15. United Nations Convention against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading
Treatment or Punishment, 1984: The convention provides against the expulsion or return
of a person to another state if there are substantial grounds for deeming her to be in
danger of torture. Victim compensation measures are also stipulated in the convention.
16. Tourism Bill of Rights and the Tourist Code 1985: Adopted by the WTO, the Code
enjoins that the State should preclude any possibility of the use of tourism to exploit
others for purposes of prostitution.
17. Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989: Article 11 requires States Parties to take
measures to combat the illicit transfer and non-return of children abroad. Under Article
34 and 35, States Parties must take appropriate national, bilateral and multilateral steps to
protect the child from all forms of sexual exploitation and sexual abuse as also to prevent
the abduction, sale of or traffic in children.
18. Convention on Protection of Rights of Migrant Workers, 1990: This Convention seeks
to put an end to the illegal or clandestine recruitment and trafficking of migrant workers
and lays down binding international standards for their treatment, welfare and human
rights.
19. The ILO Convention on the Worst Forms of Child Labour, 1999: Article 3 of this
Convention defines the worst forms of child labour comprising all manifestations of
slavery or practices similar to slavery, such as the sale and trafficking of children, debt
bondage and servitude and forced or compulsory labour, etc.
20. Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination
against Women, 1999: The Protocol enables individuals or groups who have exhausted
national remedies to directly approach the Committee under the Protocol.
21. UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women
and Children, 2000: The UN Trafficking Protocol seeks to create a global language to
define trafficking in persons, especially women and children, assist victims of trafficking,
and prevent trafficking in persons. It supplements the United Nations Convention Against
 30

Transnational Organized Crime, 2000. Article 3(a) of the Protocol defines ‘trafficking in
persons’ as “the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons,
by means of threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud,
of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or
receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over
another person, for the purpose of exploitation”. This victim-friendly protocol provides
for preventive measures (Art. 9), victim compensation and privacy protection (Art. 6),
repatriation (Art. 8) and strengthened border control measures (Art. 11 & 12).
The Protocol, on the other hand, does not give immunity from prosecution for activities that
victims are forced to commit. As a result, victims could be charged with a crime they were
pressured into committing-such as prostitution, working without a permit, or possessing
fraudulent identification documents – and deported immediately. Furthermore, the
majority of the beneficial actions, particularly victim aid, are optional. Victims who stay
in a country to testify for the prosecution may be jailed for months without access to basic
amenities or jobs. This could lead to victims becoming hesitant to testify, which would be
damaging to the case and undercut the Protocol’s law enforcement goals. These victims
are still still in danger of being physically harmed by the traffickers. There is no discussion
of ‘reintegration’ or offering services following return to help victims reintegrate into
society. Only collaboration between States Parties is included in the Protocol in order to
facilitate the safe repatriation of victims to their home countries. The victims will almost
certainly be returned to the same conditions in which they were trafficked, putting them
at risk of re-victimization.
22. Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the Sale of Children,
Child Prostitution and Child Pornography, 2002: This process seeks to raise standards
for the protection of children from all forms of sexual exploitation and abuse
23. Recommended Principles and Guidelines on Human Rights and Human Trafficking,
2002: These standards were developed by the UN High Commission for Human Rights so
as to strengthen the human rights principles and perspective of the Trafficking Protocol.
The document sets down 17 Recommended Principles and 11 Recommended Guidelines,
which are meant to facilitate effective implementation of the key provisions
24. Second World Congress against Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children held at
Yokohama, Japan 2001 to review developments as a follow-up process to strengthen the
commitment to protect children from sexual exploitation; and abuse.

REGIONAL LEGAL INSTRUMENTS TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING:

At the regional level, there have been several initiatives by the governments of South Asia and
Asia-Pacific regions. The Bangkok Accord and Plan of Action to Combat Trafficking in Women,
1998; Asian Regional Initiative Against Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children,
(ARIAT) 2000; The ASEM (Asia Europe Meeting) Action Plan to Combat Trafficking in Persons,
especially Women and Children, 2000; The Bali Conference Co-chair’s Statement on People
Smuggling, Trafficking in Persons and Related Transnational Crime, 2002; are illustrations of
their concerted efforts.
1. SAARC Convention on Preventing and Combating Trafficking in Women and Children
for Prostitution, 2002: The primary aim of this convention is to promote cooperation among
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 31

member states in order to effectively deal with various aspects of trafficking in women
and children, including prevention, interdiction, and suppression, as well as repatriation
and rehabilitation of victims of trafficking and preventing the use of women and children
in international prostitution networks, particularly where SAARC member countries
(Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka) are involved. The
convention is the first regional anti-trafficking deal to originate from Asia, and it is legally
obligatory on its signing states. Except for Nepal and Sri Lanka, all member countries had
accepted the pact as of March 2004. Article 1 of the SAARC Convention specifies the terms
“child,” “prostitution,” “trafficking,” “traffickers,” and “persons vulnerable to trafficking.”
It allows for ‘aggravating circumstances,’ which are facts that increase the severity of the
crime (Art. 4). It also includes provisions for victim protection (Article 5), mutual legal
assistance (Article 6), training and sensitization of law enforcement authorities (Article 8),
and victim rehabilitation (Article 9). (Art. 9). Extraditable offences under the Convention
(Art. 7). Article 8(3) calls for the States Parties to form a Regional Task Force made up
of officials from the Member States to help implement the Convention’s provisions and
conduct periodic evaluations. The SAARC Convention has been criticized for its restricted
definition of trafficking, which is limited to prostitution, as well as the fact that it makes no
distinction between women and children. Human trafficking is defined as the movement,
sale, or purchase of a person, but not recruiting, labour, transfer, or reception, which are
not basically the same as buying or selling.
2. Convention on Regional Arrangement for the Promotion of Child Welfare, 2002: This
Convention seeks to create regional arrangements among SAARC countries in order
to promote understanding and awareness of the rights, duties and responsibilities of
children and to develop the full potential of the South Asian child.
3. World Conference on Human Rights, 14 – 25 June 1993, Vienna, Austria: This conference
took new steps to promote and protect the rights of women and children by supporting the
creation of new mechanisms and advocating the universal ratification of the Convention
on the Rights of the Child by the year 1995.
4. World Congress against the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children, 1996: The
aims of the World Congress were to award high priority and adequate resources for action
against the commercial sexual exploitation of children; promote stronger cooperation
among all sectors and strengthen the role of families in protecting children; ensure the
revision and enforcement of laws; and advocate the development and implementation of
gender sensitive prevention and reintegration programmes.
5. Amsterdam Conclusion and Oslo Conference, 1997: The Conference affirmed that in
order to eliminate the exploitation of children, poverty eradication and rehabilitation
programmes must be developed, along with a sound mechanism to monitor their progress
6. Second World Congress against Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children,
Yokohama, 2001: The Conference called upon the international community to promote
action towards the eradication of commercial sexual exploitation of children and address
the risk factors of poverty, inequality, discrimination, violence, armed conflict, HIV/
AIDS, dysfunctional families and criminality.
7. The Honolulu Declaration, 2002: This Declaration recognized the need to address the
structural causes of trafficking and the forms of exploitation and poverty at its roots.
 32

The mobilizing of a broad coalition was envisaged, to bring together concerned agencies,
organizations and individuals to combat trafficking at local, national, regional and
international levels.
8. Brussels Declaration on Preventing and Combating Trafficking in Human Beings,
2002: The Brussels Declaration aims at bringing about European and international
cooperation, in developing concrete measures, standards, best practices and mechanisms
for prevention, victim protection and assistance, and police and judicial cooperation to
prevent and combat the trafficking of human beings.
Despite progress, there is still impunity in many regions of the world, as indicated by the low
rates of victim detection and trafficker convictions in Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia. The majority
of governments in these regions have now signed the UN Trafficking in Persons Protocol, and
relevant legislation has been passed. The focus now must be on implementing the Protocol’s
terms in these origin regions, as well as in their important destination states. In the spirit of
shared responsibility and international collaboration, support from other countries affected by
these trafficking flows can help speed up anti-trafficking operations and battle impunity for this
crime.

INDIAN LEGAL INSTRUMENTS TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING

“The Government of India does not fully comply with the minimal standards for the elimination
of trafficking; nevertheless, it is making considerable efforts to do so,” according to the United
States Department of State’s 2013 Trafficking in Persons Report - India, published on June 19, 2013.
The government amended the penal code in April 2013, considerably improving the country’s
regulations by widening the types of acts that are deemed trafficking and imposing more severe
penalties on traffickers. Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) were established by the Ministry
of Home Affairs (MHA) to combine law enforcement and rehabilitation operations. ….. The
government’s protection services were woefully inadequate in many locations. The involvement
of some government officials in human trafficking remained a substantial and unresolved issue
that hampered efforts to combat the crime effectively. According to a number of sources, the Indian
central government tackled human trafficking in a disorganised, piecemeal manner, its prioritising
of anti-trafficking measures dropped over the year, and certain officials’ indifference and lethargy
hampered efforts. Aside from the provisions of the Constitution, which serves as the country’s
fundamental law, India has a rather extensive legal framework enacted by the Parliament and
many State legislatures.

The Constitution of India

Article 23 of the Constitution: The Constitution of India, the fundamental law of the land,
forbids trafficking in persons. Article 23 of the Constitution specifically prohibits “traffic in
human beings and beggar and other similar forms of forced labour” and any contravention of
this provision is an offence punishable in accordance with Law.
Article 24 of the Constitution: Article 24 further prohibits employment of children below 14
years of age in factories, mines or other hazardous employment.
Article 35 of the Constitution: Such a law has to be passed by the Parliament, as soon as may
be, after the commencement of the constitution.
Article 39(e) of the Constitution: Directive Principle of State Policy directed at ensuring that
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 33

health and strength of individuals are not abused and that no one is forced by economic necessity
to do work unsuited to their age or strength
Article 39 (f) of the Constitution: The Directive Principles of State Policy articulated in the
Constitution are also significant, particularly Article 39 which categorically states that men and
women should have the right to an adequate means of livelihood and equal pay for equal work;
that men, women and children should not be forced by economic necessity to enter unsuitable
vocations; and that children and youth should be protected against exploitation. Further, Article
39A directs that the legal system should ensure that opportunities for securing justice are not
denied to any citizen because of economic or other disabilities.
Article 42 of the Constitution: requires the State to enact/bring in suitable provisions for
securing just and human working conditions as well as provide for maternity benefits.
Article 43 of the Constitution: Article 43 states that all workers should have a living wage
and there should be appropriate conditions of work so as to ensure a decent standard of life.
Article 51 of the Constitution: requires the State to foster respect for international law and
treaty obligations.
Article 51-A (e) of the Constitution: ordains that it shall be the duty of every citizen of India
to renounce practices derogatory to the dignity of women.
Other fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution relevant to trafficking are Article
14 relating to equality before law, Article 15 that deals with prohibition of discrimination on
grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth, Article 21 pertaining to protection of life
and personal liberty and Article 22 concerning protection from arrest and detention except under
certain conditions.

The Indian Penal Code (IPC) 1860:

There are 25 provisions relevant to trafficking; significant among them are shown in Table:
2.1:
Table: 2.1
The Indian Penal Code (IPC) Section
Procuration of a minor girl (below 18 years of age) from one part of the country to the another is
Section 366A
punishable.
Importation of a girl below 21 years of age is punishable Section 366B
Selling of girls for prostitution Section 372
Buying of girls for prostitution Section 373
Provides punishment for compelling any person to labour against his will Section 374
Kidnapping/Abduction 359-368
Wrongful Restraint & Wrongful Confinement 339-348
Acts Done in Furtherance of Common Intention 34
Abetment 107-120
Criminal Conspiracy 120A, 120 B
Criminal Force/ Assault 349-356
Cheating 415-418
Criminal Trespass 441
 34

Criminal Intimidation 503-509

Rape 375-376
Unnatural Offences 377
Hurt 319-338
Causing Miscarriage 312-318
Attempt to Commit Offences 511
Slavery 370-371
Source: Desk Research
Human Trafficking (Section 370 and 370A IPC) after enactment of the criminal law
(amendment) Act, 2013,
Section 370 IPC - Trafficking of person
(1) Whoever, for the purpose of exploitation, (a) recruits, (b) transports, (c) harbours, (d)
transfers, or (e) receives, a person or persons, by –
First –using threats, or
Secondly- using force, or any other form of coercion, or
Thirdly- by abduction, or
Fourthly- by practicing fraud, or deception, or
Fifthly- by abuse of power, or
Sixthly- by inducement, including the giving or receiving of payment or benefits, in order
to achieve the consent of any person having control over the person commits the offence of
trafficking.
Special Provisions Relating to Pornography and Trafficking: Trafficking of women and
children may also be done for the purposes of pornography. The laws dealing with pornography
that is relevant to are shown in Table: 2.2.
Table: 2.2
The Indian Penal Code (IPC) Section
Sale of obscene books etc. 292-293
Obscene acts and songs 294
Defamation 500
Word, gesture, or act intended to insult the modesty of a woman 509
Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986 Entire Act
Information Technology Act, 2000 67
Young Persons (Harmful Publications) Act, 1956 Entire Act
Source: Desk Research

THE ACTS ENACTED BY THE INDIAN PARLIAMENT:

From time-to-time Indian Parliament has enacted various Act to combat Human Trafficking,
some most relevant are:
1. The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 in which Sections 114 A and 151 are relevant in this context.
2. The Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929 defines the terms ‘child marriage’, ‘child’,
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 35

‘contracting parties’, ‘minors’, etc. It sets down the legal age of marriage as 18 years for
girls and 21 years for boys. The Act empowers the court to issue injunctions prohibiting
child marriage.
3. The Criminal Law Amendment Ordinance, 1944 provides for attachment of property in
case of commission of a scheduled offence.
4. Suppression of Immoral Traffic in Women and Girls Act, 1956 (SITA) was enacted
under Article 35 of the Indian Constitution with the object of inhibiting or abolishing the
immoral traffic in women and girls. It was also in pursuance of the Trafficking Convention,
which India signed on 9 May 1950. The Act aimed to rescue exploited women and girls, to
prevent deterioration of public morals and to stamp out the evil of prostitution, which was
rampant in various parts of the country. In 1978, SITA was amended by the Amendment
Act 46 of 1978, which took effect from 2 October 1979. This was owing to the realisation
that the social evil needed to be curbed and that existing provisions failed to do so. The act
was further amended and changed in 1986, resulting in the Immoral Traffic Prevention
Act also known as PITA. PITA only discusses trafficking in relation to prostitution and
not in relation to other purposes of trafficking such as domestic work, child labour, organ
harvesting, etc.
5. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (ITPA) is a special legislation that deals
exclusively with trafficking. The Act defines the terms ‘brothel’, ‘child’, ‘corrective
institutions’, ‘prostitution’, ‘protective home’, ‘public place’, ‘special police officer’
and ‘trafficking officer’. The purpose of the enactment was to inhibit or to abolish
commercialized vice, namely the traffic in women and girls for the purpose of prostitution,
as an organised means of living.
The main outage of the ITPA is that it allows for the arrest of those engaging in acts of
prostitution (seducing or soliciting for the purpose of prostitution) under Sec 8. Crimes under
ITPA are cognizable, only certain police officers under Sec 13 can do this and there must be
female officers and witnesses present. The ITPA also allows for the Special Courts to be set up for
the purpose of Trafficking Cases. Presently, the Anti-Trafficking Cell (ATC) located in the Ministry of
Home Affairs is the nodal agency for the implementation of the ITPA 1956. The creation of the ATC has
led to the strengthening of the law enforcement response. The advisories issued by the MHA has
not only strengthened legal procedures and investigations of cases of human trafficking but also
pushed the State governments to build the capacity in the various law enforcement agencies. 225
Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTU) have also been created by the MHA at the district level
to combat trafficking and undertake rescue operations.

RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF THE ACT:

Sec 3. Punishment for keeping a brothel or allowing premises to be used as a
brothel.
1. Any person who keeps or manages, or acts or assists in the keeping or management of, a
brothel shall be punishable on first conviction with rigorous imprisonment for a term of not
less than two years and which may extend to three years and also with fine which may extend
to ten thousand rupees and in the event of a second or subsequent conviction, with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years and which may extend to
seven years and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to two lakh rupees
 36

2. any person who, -

a. being the tenant, lessee, occupier or person in charge of any premises, uses, or
knowingly allows any other person to use, such premises or any part thereof as a
brothel, or
b. being the owner, lessor or landlord of any premises or the agent of such owner,
lessor or landlord, lets the same or any part thereof with the knowledge that the
same or any part thereof is intended to be used as a brothel, or is willfully a party
to the use of such premises or any part thereof as a brothel, shall be punishable on
first conviction with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years and
with fine which fine which may extend to two thousand rupees and in the event of a
second or subsequent conviction, with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may
extend to five years and also with fine.

Sec 4. Punishment for living on the earnings of prostitution.

1. Any person over the age of eighteen years who knowingly lives, wholly or in part, on the
earnings of the prostitution of any other person shall be punishable with imprisonment
for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine which may extend to one thousand
rupees, or with both, and where such earnings relate to the prostitution of a child, shall
be punishable with imprisonment for a term of not less than seven years and not more
than ten years.
2. Where any person over the age of eighteen years is proved,—
a. to be living with, or to be habitually in the company of, a prostitute; or
b. to have exercised control, direction or influence over the movements of a prostitute
in such a manner as to show that such person is aiding abetting or compelling her
prostitution; or
c. to be acting as a tout or pimp on behalf of a prostitute, it shall be presumed, until
the contrary is proved, that such person is knowingly living on the earnings of
prostitution of another person within the meaning of sub-section (1).

Sec 5. Procuring, inducing or taking person for the sake of prostitution.

1. Any person who—
a. procures or attempts to procure a person whether with or without his/her consent,
for the purpose of prostitution; or
b. induces a person to go from any place, with the intent that he/she may for the purpose
of prostitution become the inmate of, or frequent, a brothel; or
c. takes or attempts to take a person or causes a person to be taken, from one place
to another with a view to his/her carrying on, or being brought up to carry on
prostitution; or
d. causes or induces a person to carry on prostitution; shall be punishable on conviction
with rigorous imprisonment for a term of not less than three years and not more
than seven years and also with fine which may extend to two thousand rupees, and
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 37

if any offence under this sub-section is committed against the will of any person, the
punishment of imprisonment for a term of seven years shall extend to imprisonment
for a term of fourteen years:
Provided that if the person in respect of whom an offence committed under this subsection, is
a child, the punishment provided under this sub-section shall extend to rigorous imprisonment
for a term of not less than seven years but may extend to life.
3. An offence under this section shall be friable, —
a. in the place from which a person is procured, induced to go, taken or caused to be
taken or from which an attempt to procure or taken such persons made; or
b. in the place to which she may have gone as a result of the inducement or to which he/
she is taken or caused to be taken or an attempt to take him/her is made.
Sec 5A. Whoever recruits, transports, transfers, harbours, or receives a person for the
purpose of prostitution by means of-
a. threat or use of force or coercion, abduction, fraud, deception; or
b. abuse of power or a position of vulnerability; or
c. giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of such person
having control over another person, commits the offence of trafficking in persons.
Sec 5B. (1) Any person who commits trafficking in persons shall be punishable on first
conviction with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than seven years and
in the event of a second or subsequent conviction with imprisonment for life.
2. Any person who attempts to commit, or abets trafficking in persons shall also be deemed to
have committed such trafficking in persons and shall be punishable with the punishment
hereinbefore described.
Sec 5C. Any person who visits or is found in a brothel for the purpose of sexual exploitation
of any victim of trafficking in persons shall on first conviction be punishable with imprisonment
for a term which may extend to three months or with fine which may extend to twenty thousand
rupees or with both and in the event of a second or subsequent conviction with imprisonment
for a term which may extend to six months and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to
fifty thousand rupees.

Sec 6. Detaining a person in premises where prostitution is carried on.

1. Any person who detains any other person, whether with or without his consent, —
a. in any brothel, or
b. in or upon any premises with intent that such person may have sexual intercourse
with a person who is not the spouse of such person, shall be punishable on conviction,
with imprisonment of either description for a term which shall not be less than seven
years but which may be for life or for a term which may extend to ten years and shall
also be liable to fine which may extend to one lakh rupees:
Provided that the court may for adequate and special reasons to be mentioned in the judgment,
impose a sentence of imprisonment for a term which may be less than seven years.
 38

2. Where any person is found with a child in a brothel, it shall be presumed, unless the
contrary is proved, that he has committed an offence under sub-section (1).
(2-A) Where a child found in a brothel, is, on medical examination, detected to have been
sexually abused, it shall be presumed unless the contrary is proved, that the child has been
detained for purposes of prostitution or, as the case may be, has been sexually exploited
for commercial purposes.
3. A person shall be presumed to detain a person in a brothel or in upon any premises for
the purpose of sexual intercourse with a man other than her lawful husband, if such
person, with intent to compel or induce her to remain there, —
a. withholds from her any jewellery, wearing apparel, money or other property
belonging to her, or
b. threatens her with legal proceedings if she takes away with her any jewellery, wearing
apparel, money or other property lent or supplied to her by or by the direction of such
person.
4. Notwithstanding any law to the contrary, no suit, prosecution or other legal proceeding
shall lie against such woman or girl at the instance of the person by whom she has been
detained, for the recovery of any jewellery, wearing apparel or other property alleged to
have been lent or supplied to or for such woman or girl or to have been pledged by such
woman or girl or for the recovery of any money alleged to be payable by such woman or
girl.

Sec 7. Prostitution in or in the vicinity of public place.

1. Any person who carries on prostitution and the person with whom such prostitution is
carried on, in any premises:
a. which are within the area or areas, notified under sub-section (3), or
b. which are within a distance of two hundred meters of any place of public religious
worship, educational institution, hotel, hospital, nursing home or such other public place
of any kind as may be notified in this behalf by the Commissioner of Police or Magistrate
in the manner prescribed, shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may
extend to three months.
Sec 7 (1-A) Where an offence committed under sub-section
1. is in respect of a child, the person committing the offence shall be punishable with
imprisonment of either description for a term which not be less than seven years but
which may be for life or for a term which may extend to ten years and shall also be liable
to fine:
Provided that the Court may, for adequate and special reasons to be mentioned in the
judgment, impose a sentence of imprisonment for a term of less than seven years.
2. Any person who:
a. being the keeper of any public place knowingly permits prostitutes for purposes of their
trade to resort to or remain in such place; or
b. being the tenant, lessee, occupier or person in charge of any premises referred to in sub-
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 39

section (1) knowingly permits the same or any part thereof to be used for prostitution; or
c. being the owner, lessor or landlord of any premises referred to in sub-section (1), or
the agent of such owner, lessor or landlord, lets the same or any part thereof with the
knowledge that the same or any part thereof may be used for prostitution, or is willfully
a party to such use shall be punishable on first conviction with imprisonment for a term
which may extend to three months, or with fine which may extend to two hundred rupees,
or with both, and in the event of a second or subsequent conviction with imprisonment
for a term which may extend to six months and also with fine, which may extend to two
hundred rupees, and if the public place or premises happen to be a hotel, the license for
carrying on the business of such hotel under any law for the time being in force shall also
be liable to be suspended for a period of not less than three months but which may extend
to one year:
Provided that if an offence committed under this sub-section is in respect of a child in a hotel,
such license shall also be liable to be cancelled.

Sec 9. Seduction of a person in custody.

Any person who having the custody, charge or care of or in a position of authority over
any person causes or aids or abets the seduction for prostitution of that shall be punishable on
conviction with imprisonment of either description for a term which shall not be less than seven
years but which may be for life or for a term which may extend to ten years and shall also be
liable to fine:

Sec 10-A. Detention in a corrective institution.

1. Where , —
a. a female offender is found guilty of an offence under Section 7, and
b. the character, state of health and mental condition of the offender and the other
circumstances of the case are such that it is expedient that she should be subject to detention
for such term and such instruction and discipline as are conducive to her correction, it
shall be lawful for the court to pass, in lieu of a sentence of imprisonment, an order for
detention in a corrective institution for such term, not being less than two years and not
being more than seven years, as the court thinks fit:

Sec 11. Notification of address of previously convicted offenders.

1. When any person having been convicted—
a. by a court in India of an offence punishable under this Act or punishable under Section
363, Section 365, Section 366, Section 366-A, Section 366-B, Section 367, Section 368, Section
370, Section 371, Section 372 or Section 373 of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), with
imprisonment for a term of two years or up wards; or
b. by a court or tribunal in any other country of an offence which would, if committed in
India, have been punishable under this Act, or under any of the aforesaid sections with
imprisonment for a like term, is within a period of five years after release from prison,
again convicted of any offence punishable under this Act or under any of those section
with, imprisonment for a term of two years or upwards by a court, such court may, if it
 40

thinks fit, at the time of passing the sentence of imprisonment on such person, also order
that his residence, and any change of, or absence from, such residence, after release, be
notified according to rules made under Section 23 for a period not exceeding five years
from the date of expiration of that sentence.
2. If such conviction is set aside on appeal or otherwise, such order shall become void.
3. An order under this section may also be made by an Appellate Court or by the High
Court when exercising its powers of revision.
4. Any person charged with a breach of any rule referred to in sub-section (1) may be tried
by a Magistrate of competent jurisdiction in the district in which the place last notified as
his residence is situated.

Sec 13. Special police officer and advisory body.

1. There shall be for each area to be specified by the State Government in this behalf a special
police officer appointed by or on behalf of that government for dealing with offences
under this Act in that area.
2. The special police officer shall not be below the rank of a sub-inspector of Police.
(2-A) The District Magistrate may, if he considers it necessary or expedient so to do, confer
upon any retired police or military officer all or any of the powers conferred by or under
this Act on a special police officer, with respect to particular cases or classes of cases or to
cases generally.
Sec 13A. (1) The Central Government may constitute an Authority for the purposes of
effectively preventing and combating the offence of trafficking in persons.
2. The members of the Authority shall be appointed by the Central Government and shall
be of such number and chosen in such manner as may be prescribed.
3. The Chairperson of the Authority shall be one of the members appointed under sub-
section (2) to be nominated by the Central Government.
4. The term of office of the members of the Authority, the manner of filling vacancies among
and the procedure to be followed in the discharge of their functions by the members shall
be such as may be prescribed.
Sec 14. Offences to be cognizable-Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), an offence punishable under this Act shall be deemed to be
a cognizable offence within the meaning of that Code.

Sec 15. Search without warrant.

1. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, whenever
the special police officer or the trafficking police officer as the case may be, has reasonable
grounds for believing that an offence punishable under this Act has been or is being
committed in respect of a person living in any premises, and that search of the premises
with warrant cannot be made without undue delay, such officer may, after recording the
grounds of his belief, enter and search such premises without a warrant.
(5-A) Any person who is produced before a Magistrate under sub-section (5), shall be
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 41

examined by a registered medical practitioner for the purposes of determination of the age of
such person, or for the detection of any injuries as a result of sexual abuse or for the presence of
any sexually transmitted diseases.

Sec 18. Closure of brothel and eviction of offenders from the premises.
1. A Magistrate may, on receipt of information from the police or otherwise, that any house,
room, place or any portion thereof within a distance of two hundred meters of any public
place referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 7 is being run or used as a brothel by any
person, or is being used by prostitutes for carrying on their trade, issue notice on the
owner, lessor or landlord or such house, room, place or portion or the agent of the owner,
lessor or landlord or on the tenant, lessee, occupier of, or any other person in charge of
such house, room, place, or portion, to show cause within seven days of the receipt of the
notice why the same should not be attached for improper use thereof, and if, after hearing
the person concerned, the Magistrate is satisfied that the house, room, place or portion
is being used as a brothel or for carrying on prostitution, then the Magistrate may pass
orders, —
a. directing eviction of the occupier within seven days of the passing of the order from the
house, room, place, or portion;
b. directing that before letting it out during the period of one year or in a case where a child
has been found in such house, room, place or portion during a search under Section 15,
during the period of three years, immediately after the passing of the order, the owner,
lessor or landlord or the agent of the owner, lessor or landlord shall obtain the previous
approval of the Magistrate
Sec 19. Application for being kept in a protective home or provided care and
protection by court.
1. A person who is carrying on, or is being made to carry on prostitution, may make an
application, to the Magistrate within the local limits of whose jurisdiction she is carrying
on, or is being made to carry on prostitution, for an order that she may be—
a. kept in a protective home, or
b. provided care and protection by the court in the manner specified in sub-section (3).
2. The Magistrate may pend inquiry under sub-section (3) direct that the person be kept in
such custody as he may consider proper, having regard to the circumstances of the case.
3. If the Magistrate after hearing the applicant and making such inquiry as he may consider
necessary, including an inquiry by a Probation Officer appointed under the Probation of
Offender Act, 1958, (20 of 1958) into the personality, conditions of home and prospects
of rehabilitation of the applicant, is satisfied that an order should be made under this
section, he shall for reasons to be recorded, make an order that the applicant to be kept:
i. in a protective home, or
ii. in a corrective institution, or
iii. under the supervision of a person appointed by the Magistrate for such period as
may be specified in the order.
 42

Sec 21. Protective homes.

1. The State Government may in its discretion establish as many protective homes and
corrective institutions under this Act as it thinks fit and such homes and institutions when
established shall be maintained in such manner as may be prescribed.

Sec 22.
(1) Trials -No Court, inferior to that of a Metropolitan Magistrate or a Judicial magistrate of
the first class, shall try any offence under Section 3, Section 4, Section 5, Section 5B, Section 5C,
Section 6 or Section 7.
Sec 22-A. Power to establish special Courts. (1) If the State Government is satisfied that it is
necessary for the purpose of providing for speedy trial of offences under this Act in any district
or metropolitan area, it may, by notification in the official Gazette and after consultation with the
High Court, establish one or more Courts of Judicial Magistrates of the first class, or, as the case
may be, Metropolitan Magistrate, in such district or metropolitan area.
Sec 22-B. Court can try the offences summarily
6. The Young Persons (Harmful Publications) Act, 1956 defines the term ‘harmful
publication’ as “any book, magazine, pamphlets, leaflet, newspapers or other like
publication which consists of stories told with the aid of pictures or wholly in pictures,
being stories portraying wholly or mainly, a) the commission of offence, b) acts of violence
or cruelty, and c) incidence of a repulsive or horrible nature”.
7. The Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 is aimed at offenders. Its important features are:
a) the Act empowers the court to release certain offenders after admonition and place
certain other offenders on probation for good conduct, and b) the Act puts a restriction
on the court, forbidding the imprisonment of any offender below the age of 21 years,
who has not committed an offence punishable with imprisonment for life, unless the
circumstances of the case or nature of the offence requires that the offender be punished.
8. Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 with Section 51(2), 53(2), 98, 160, 327(2) and 357 having
relevance in this context. Responsibility for providing compensation to trafficking
victims is fragmented between the central government and individual states. This is
largely the result of Section 357, Code of Criminal Procedure, which states that the Central
Government should be responsible for compensating victims of any crime (not limited to
trafficking) who have suffered loss or injury. However, it fails to note the form or degree
of such compensation.
The Section deals with compensation for victims of human trafficking, although it leaves
it up to the individual states to decide on compensation procedures and amounts. As
a result, there is no centralised compensation system in India for victims of human
trafficking. The Centrally Sponsored Rehabilitation Scheme for Bonded Labor requires
each bonded labourer to receive a rehabilitation grant of Rs. 20,000 (approximately $330)
as well as rehabilitation assistance. Unfortunately, regardless of how long the labourer
has supplied bonded work, this amount is fixed. According to interviews with law
enforcement authorities, India’s anti-trafficking laws and regulations are patchwork
and sporadically implemented. Dr. P.M. Nair of the Indian Police Service in New Delhi
said in an interview that the government’s rehabilitative efforts are often haphazard and
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 43

ineffective, owing to a lack of coordination among the police and government agencies
involved at every stage of the process, from rescue to rehabilitation. Many NGOs have
experienced difficulty securing timely disbursements of national government funds for
their shelters, according to the United States’ 2012 Trafficking in Persons Report.
9. The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976 defines the terms ‘advance’, ‘agreement’,
‘ascendant or descendant’, ‘bonded debt’, ‘bonded labour’, ‘bonded labour system’ and
provides for initiating appropriate action.
10. Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment Conditions) Act, 1979: In
addition to trafficking laws, the provisions of this Act can be used to fasten liability on the
principal employer and to protect the rights of the workers who may have been recruited
in one State for employment in an establishment of another State. Relevant Sections:
Sections 2(e), 61, 14 & 151.
11. The Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986 defines “indecent
representation of women” as the depiction in any manner of the figure of a woman, her
form of body or any part thereof in such a way as to have the effect of being indecent,
or derogatory to, or denigrating of women; or is likely to deprave, corrupt or injure
public morality. The Act puts a restriction on the publishing or sending by post, of
books, pamphlets, etc., containing indecent representations of women, and prohibits all
persons from getting involved directly or indirectly in the publication or exhibition of any
advertisement containing indecent representations of women in any form.
12. The Child labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986 prohibits employment of
children in the specific occupations set forth in Part A of the schedule of the Act. The Act
lays down the conditions of work of the children. As per the Act, no child shall work for
more than three hours before he or she has had an interval of rest for at least one hour.
13. Religious Institutions (Prevention of Misuse) Act, 1988: This Act can be used to combat
various social evils that are associated with religious institutions like some of the practices
mentioned earlier, Some of these activities of sexual exploitation may be conducted
within the premises of religious institutions under the pretext of rituals. This Act can
be invoked in order to prevent such misuse. The manager of the religious institution or
person connected with such contravention can be punished for contravention of the Act.
The devadasis or other trafficked women cannot be brought under the purview of this Act.
They are to be treated as ‘victims’ and not as ‘offenders’
14. The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, Many
victims are from marginalized groups because traffickers are targeting on vulnerable
people in socially and economically backward areas. This Act provides an additional tool
to safeguard women and young girls belonging SC/ST and also creates greater burden
on the trafficker to prove his lack of complicity in the crime. This can be effective if the
offender knows the status of victim. It specifically covers certain forms of trafficking,
forced or bonded labour and sexual exploitation of women. A minimum punishment of 6
months is provided that could extend up to 5 years in any offence covered under Sec 2.
15. The Transplantation of Human Organ Act, 1994. The two-fold objectives of this Act are:
(1) to provide for the regulation of removal, storage and transplantation of human organs
for therapeutic purposes, (2) to prevent commercial dealings in human organs. The Act
44

also provides for regulation and registration of hospitals engaged in removal, storage and
transplantation of human organs.
16. The Information Technology Act, 2000 extends throughout India and also has extra-
territorial jurisdiction. Section 67 penalizes the publication or transmission of any
material, in electronic form, which is lascivious; or appeals to prurient interests; or if its
effect is such as to tend to deprave and corrupt persons who are likely, having regard to
all relevant circumstances, to read, see or hear the matter contained or embodied therein.
17. The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 was passed in
consonance with the Convention on the Rights of the Child, to consolidate and amend the
law relating to juveniles in conflict with law and children in need of care and protection.
The definition specifically includes the child who is found vulnerable and is, therefore,
likely to be inducted into trafficking. The focus of the Act is to provide for proper care,
protection and treatment by catering to the child’s development needs and by adopting a
child-friendly approach in the adjudication and disposition of matters in the best interests
of children and for their ultimate rehabilitation through various institutions established
under the Act. ‘Child’ means a person, either male or female, who has not completed
his or her eighteenth year of age. Section 29 of the act empowers state governments to
constitute child welfare committees for such areas as they may deem fit. It also outlines
the powers of the committee and the procedures to be followed. Section 31 gives them
the ultimate authority to dispose of cases for the care, protection, treatment, development
and rehabilitation of the children as well as to provide for their basic needs and protection
of human rights. Under Section 34, a state government may establish and maintain
children’s homes for the care and protection of children. Under Section 39, the primary
objective of the children’s home or shelter is the restoration and protection of childhood.
This law is essentially in the form of a Code and incorporates in itself not only punitive
and rehabilitative provisions, but also spells out the detailed procedures to be followed.
The Act has been amended in 2015 as it mandates setting up Juvenile Justice Boards and
Child Welfare Committees in every district. Both must have at least one-woman member
each.
18. Immigration (Carrier’s Liability) Act, 2000 This Act can be used to prosecute those who
indulge in the illegal transport of human beings from other countries. This Act applies
only to carriers by air or by sea. Where the provisions of the Passport Act or any rules
made there under are contravened in bringing persons from other countries into India,
the carrier may be punished by the competent authority under the Passport Act, by order
imposing a penalty of rupees one lakh on such carrier1iv. For the purposes of this Act,
‘carrier’ means a person who is engaged in the business of transporting passengers by
water or air and includes any association of persons, whether incorporated or not, by
whom the aircraft or the ship is owned or chartered.
19. The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006: This Act restrains the solemnization of
child marriages. A child under this Act is defined as a male below twenty-one and a
woman below eighteen years of age. A minor is defined as a person of either sex who
is under eighteen years of age. If either the bride or groom is a child, it would amount
to a child marriage. The Act provides for punishment for a variety of crimes associated
with child marriages. It also has a direct provision dealing with trafficking holding such
marriages null and void.
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 45

20. Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act): The Protection of
Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act), was enacted to protect children
from offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography and to provide a
child friendly system for the trial of these offences. The Act provides for seven specific
sexual offences against children and stipulates child-friendly legal procedures that must
be adhered to during investigation and trial. Under the POCSO Act, the term “child” has
been defined to mean “any person below the age of eighteen years”. The Act does not
recognize sexual autonomy of children in any form. Children can also be held liable for
committing sexual offences under the Act. As a result, sexual interactions or intimacies
among or with children below the age of 18 years constitute an offence. The Act has
been amended as THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN FROM SEXUAL OFFENCES
(AMENDMENT) ACT, 2019 NO. 25 OF 2019.

Punishments for Offences covered in the Act are:

1. Penetrative Sexual Assault (Section 3)- Not less than seven years which may extend to
imprisonment for life, and fine (Section 4)
2. Aggravated Penetrative Sexual Assault (Section 5) – Not less than ten years which may
extend to imprisonment for life, and fine (Section 6)
3. Sexual Assault (Section 7) – Not less than three years which may extend to five years, and
fine (Section 8)
4. Aggravated Sexual Assault (Section 9) – Not less than five years which may extend to
seven years, and fine (Section 10)
5. Sexual Harassment of the Child (Section 11) – Three years and fine (Section 12)
6. Use of Child for Pornographic Purposes (Section 13) – Five years and fine and in the event
of subsequent conviction, seven years and fine (Section 14 (1))
The Act provides for the establishment of Special Courts for trial of offences under the Act,
keeping the best interest of the child as of paramount importance at every stage of the judicial
process. The Act incorporates child friendly procedures for reporting, recording of evidence,
investigation and trial of offences.
21. Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2019: POCSO was gender-neutral while the new law
pertains to girls specifically. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2019 enhances the
minimum sentence for offence of rape against girl children of all three age categories.
Under new law, if the victim is under 12 years of age, the culprit faces minimum sentence
of 20 years, up from 10 years previously. Accused is not entitled to anticipatory bail,
under new law, in offences of rape of child less than 16 years of age.
22. Criminal Law Amendment Act 2013: Until recently, Indian law did not contain a
comprehensive definition of human trafficking. In March 2013, India passed the Criminal
Law (Amendment) Act of 2013, which amended Section 370 of the Indian Penal Code
and included India’s first definition of human trafficking based on the UN Trafficking
Protocol: Section 370, as amended, now defines exploitation as including “any act of
physical exploitation or any form of sexual exploitation, slavery or practices similar to
slavery, servitude, or the forced removal of organs.” The new Amendment Act expanded
the types of offenses criminalized as a trafficking violation and instituted heightened
 46

sentences for perpetrators. It is a significant step towards bringing India in line with the
international law obligations it assumed on ratifying the UN Trafficking Protocol.

STATE GOVERNMENTS ACTS/LAWS:

State governments have also established their own programmes and schemes to address
trafficking that are based on the National Plan of Action to Combat Trafficking and Commercial
Sexual Exploitation of Women and Girls. These programmes focus on awareness raising, income
generation, the provision of medical and other support and the training of law enforcement
officials (Everly, 2011). Most States have also constituted anti-trafficking units and have shelter
homes for the rehabilitation of trafficked victims. Given below is a tabular analysis of state-wise
(highly affected) legislation and programmes to mitigate trafficking (Table: 2.3).
Table: 2.3
States Legislation and Programmes/Schemes

• Passed legislation for prevention of “traditional” forms of sexual exploitation (Devadasis) and
Andhra Pradesh the Prohibition of Dedication Act (1988)
• Andhra Pradesh Children Act, 1979

Assam • Assam Children Act, 1970

• Bihar Children Act, 1970

Bihar
• Human Trafficking Prevention Program (2007)
• Chhattisgarh Private Placement Agencies (Regulation) Act, 2013 - Regulatory unit set up to
grant licenses to any private placement agency, thereby ensuring no fee is charged from domestic
Chhattisgarh
workers, and prohibiting girls under 18 from being engaged by such agencies.
• Committees for Prevention of Atrocities against Women and Trafficking in 16 district (2008)
• Goa Children’s Act, 2003 – To ensure protection of children against exploitation. Explicit
prohibition of child sexual trafficking, child labour and abuse. Provides for setting up of children’s
Goa
homes. State Level Authority and Village Child Committee to be set up. Setting up of special
Children’s Court for offences under this act.
• Jharkhand Private Employment Agency and Domestic Employee Bill has been introduced in
2016 and is yet to be passed. It provides compulsory licensing for placement agencies, prohibits
Jharkhand
them from taking money from domestic workers and makes publication of employment details
mandatory
• The Karnataka Devadasis (Prohibition Of Dedication) Act, 1982 - To prevent dedication
Karnataka of women as Devadasis in the State of Karnataka, as the practice is leading to prostitution and
exploitation
• The Bombay Devadasis Protection Act, 1934 - To prevent dedication of women as devadasis in
the State of Maharashtra, as the practice is leading to prostitution andexploitation
Maharashtra • The Orphanages and other Charitable Home (Supervision and Control) Act, 1960 –To
provide for the supervision and control of orphanages, homes for neglected women and children
and other like institutions
Odisha • Orissa Children Act, 1982
• Tamil Nadu Children Act, 1920
Tamil Nadu • Tamil Nadu Hostel and Homes for Women and Children (Regulation) Act, 2014 - To provide
for regulation and registration of hostels, lodging houses, homes for women and children
West Bengal • West Bengal Children Act, 1959

• Draft Policy on Rehabilitation and Combating Trafficking of Women and Children, 2018, The
NCT of Delhi
Draft Policy yet to be finalized.
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 47

INDIA’S TRAFFICKING PREVENTION MEASURES

The Government of India has initiated several initiatives in collaboration with NGOs to combat
trafficking and has also formed a special cell in the Ministry of home Affairs, Government of
India as the Nodal Agency for the Anti Human trafficking Units. The law enforcement agencies
are also being sensitized on the issue of Trafficking and several modules for police trainings
have been formulated by United Nations office on Drugs and Crimes (UNODC), Bureau of
Police Research and Development (BPRD) and Ministry of Home Affairs. The Union of India in
collaboration with NGOs has launched Ujjwala and Swadhar Schemes which are more focused
towards trafficked children and as short stay homes.
To combat trafficking, especially in vulnerable areas and parts of society, with the aid of
local communities at the village and urban levels, as well as to enable the rescue, rehabilitation,
and reintegration of trafficked victims, a multi-sectoral approach is required. To address
the foregoing concerns and shortcomings, the Ministry of Women and Child Development
established a “Comprehensive Scheme for Prevention of Trafficking for Rescue, Rehabilitation,
and Re-Integration of Victims of Trafficking for Commercial Sexual Exploitation-Ujjawala.” On
the one hand, this strategy was designed with the primary goal of preventing human trafficking,
and on the other, it was created with the major purpose of rescuing and rehabilitating victims.
Ujjawala Scheme: The Ministry of Women and Child Development is implementing
“Ujjawala”-a Comprehensive Scheme for Prevention of Trafficking and Rescue, Rehabilitation,
Re-integration and Repatriation of Victims of Trafficking for Commercial Sexual Exploitation.
The number of beneficiaries under the scheme in the year 2017-18 and 2016-17 each is 6,175.
The Schemes provide shelter, food and clothing, counseling, medical care, legal aid and other
support, vocational training and income generation activities for the victims. The main objectives
of the scheme are:
• To prevent trafficking of women and children for commercial sexual exploitation through
social mobilization and involvement of local communities/awareness generation
programmes, generate public discourse through workshops, seminars and such events
and any other innovative activity;
• To facilitate rescue of victims from the place of exploitation and place them in safe custody;
• To provide rehabilitation services both immediate and long term to the victims by
providing basic amenities / needs such as shelter, food, clothing, medical treatment
including counseling, legal and guidance and vocational training;
• To facilitate reintegration of the victims into the family and society at large;
• To facilitate repatriation of cross-border victims to their country of origin.
One Stop Centre: Many women who face violent crimes do not know where to go for support.
For them, One Stop Centers (OSCs) have been set up across the country. Popularly known as
Sakhi Centers, the Scheme of One Stop Centre (OSC) is being implemented across the country
since 1st April, 2015 for facilitating access to an integrated range of services including police,
medical, legal, psychological support and temporary shelter to women affected by violence. The
Scheme is funded through Nirbhaya Fund.
Swadhar Greh: The Ministry is implementing the Swadhar Greh Scheme which targets
the women victims of unfortunate circumstances who are in need of institutional support for
 48

rehabilitation so that they could lead their life with dignity. The Scheme envisages providing
shelter, food, clothing and health as well as economic and social security for the women victims
of difficult circumstances which includes widows, destitute women and aged women.
Child Line: A project supported by the MOWCD to help children in distress is the Child Line
India Foundation, which provides a 24-hour toll-free telephone outreach service (MOWCD and
UNODC, 2008). It provides referral services to children in emergency situations and undertakes
activities to sensitize various stakeholders on trafficking (MOWCD and UNODC, 2008).
Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS)-2009: The Ministry of Women and Child
Development, (MWCD) extends its commitment of the XI plan to create a protective environment
for 40 per cent of India’s vulnerable children who are experiencing difficult circumstances, by
continuing the centrally sponsored Scheme - the Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS) in
the XII plan. The Scheme, since its launch in 2009, in partnership with the State Governments/UT
Administrations, has strengthened prevention of child rights violation; enhanced infrastructure
for protection services; provided financial support for implementation of the Juvenile Justice
(Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000; increased access to a wider range and better quality
of protection services; increased investment in child protection and is continuously drawing
focus on the right of all children to be safe.
The Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS) has made a substantial contribution to realizing
Government/State responsibilities for developing a system that protects children efficiently and
effectively. ICPS is achieving its objectives to contribute to improvements in the well-being of
children in difficult circumstances, as well as to the reduction of vulnerabilities to situations and
actions that lead to abuse, neglect, exploitation, abandonment, and separation of children from
their families, based on the cardinal principles of “protection of child rights” and “best interest
of the child.” ICPS is being implemented by establishing State Child Protection Societies (SCPS)
and District Child Protection Entities (DCPUs) as the essential units for implementation at the
State and District levels, respectively, in order to ensure successful service delivery. The State
Adoption Resource Agency (SARA) is a division of the SCPS. The SCPS is a registered charity
under the Societies Registration Act of 1860 that operates under the overall supervision and
control of the state/UT department responsible for child welfare and protection. The Ministry
of Women and Child Development (MWCD) has previously developed and published thorough
instructions, as well as bylaws, for establishing these institutions at the state level.
The MWCD’s Child Welfare Bureau is implementing the Integrated Child Protection
Scheme (ICPS), which has responsibilities such as formulating policies and legislation for
children, advocating for effective implementation of policies, programmes, and services for
children, ensuring the implementation of various international norms and standards related
to children, and representing the Government of India at various national and international
child-related fora. A full-fledged dedicated and professionally equipped staff working closely
with State Governments and other stakeholders is required to enable the successful and timely
implementation of a scheme as broad and comprehensive as ICPS.
National Child Protection Policy: In pursuance with the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the matter of Sampoorna Behura vs. UOI & Ors. (M.A. No.- 2069/2018 in W.P.(C)
No.473/2005 regarding drafting of the National Child Protection Policy, the first draft of the
National Child Protection Policy was prepared by the Ministry. The draft was widely circulated
in the public domain to gather the comments/suggestions of all the stakeholders. A large
number of comments have been received which are under consideration of the Ministry. The
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 49

Government has adopted a National Policy for Children (NPC, 2013 on 26th April, 2013). The
policy reaffirms the Government’s commitment to realization of the rights of all children in the
country. It recognizes every person below the age of eighteen years as a child. It acknowledges
that childhood is an integral part of life with a value of its own, and a long term, sustainable,
multi-spectral, integrated and inclusive approach is necessary for the harmonious development
and protection of children. The Policy lays down the guiding principles that must be respected
by the National, State and local Governments in their actions and initiatives affecting children.
The Policy has identified survival, health, nutrition, education, development, protection and
participation as the undeniable rights of every child, and has also declared these as key priority
areas. The National Plan of Action for children, 2016 was released on 24th January, 2017.
First meeting of the Joint Task Force in Human Trafficking between India and UAE was
held from 4th to 5th August, 2019 at Abu Dhabi, UAE to enhance cooperation to prevent human
trafficking especially the trafficking of women and children between the two countries. A
delegation of the Government of India including officers of the Ministry of Women and Child
Development, Ministry of Home Affairs, Ministry of External Affairs and Ministry of Labour and
Employment attended the First meeting of the Joint Task Force in Human Trafficking between
India and UAE.
POCSO e-Box: To facilitate reporting of offences/ complaint, the POCSO e-Box was launched
on 26th August, 2016. POCSO e-Box is an online complaint management system for easy and direct
reporting of sexual offences against children and timely action against the offenders under the
POCSO Act, 2012. In order to address newer forms of offences and for further deterrence, certain
other provisions in the Act were considered necessary. Accordingly, the Protection of Children
from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Bill, 2019 was considered and passed by the Lok Sabha on
1st August, 2019. Further, the same received the President’s assent on 5th August, 2019. It was
published in the Gazette by Ministry of Law on 6th August, 2019 and has also been notified by
this Ministry to be made effective from 16th August, 2019. Further, under amended provisions in
the Act, death penalty has also been introduced as a possible punishment in cases of aggravated
penetrative sexual assault. After the amendment, the definition of Child Pornography has now
been explicitly defined in the Act. The Amendments have provided more stringent punishments
for committing the crime related to child pornography. Section-14 of the Act has been amended
to provide enhanced punishments for the act of pornography, associated with different sexual
offences. Amendment also provides for levying fine for not destroying/or deleting/ or reporting
the pornographic material involving a child. Person can be further penalized with jail term or
fine or both for transmitting/propagating/displaying/ distributing such material in any manner
except for the purpose of reporting as may be prescribed and for use as evidence in court. More
stringent penal provisions have been provided in the Amendment for storing/possessing any
pornographic material in any form involving a child for commercial purpose.
Child Tracking System: Track Child, including Khoya-Paya, a website for missing children
and related MIS. Launched on 2nd June, 2015, it is an enabling platform for the citizens to report
on the missing and sighted children in a prompt manner, thus avoiding time delay. Reporting on
the portal can be through uploading the available information.
Open Shelter Home for Children in Need in Urban and Semi Urban Areas: In order to
provide for the growing needs of children, the ICPS facilitates for setting up of Open Shelters
particularly in urban areas. Such centers shall provide a space for children where they can play,
use their time productively and engage themselves in creative activities through music, dance,
 50

drama, yoga & meditation, computers, indoor and outdoor games, etc. These activities would
encourage meaningful peer group participation and interaction. This will ensure their overall
growth and development, and keep them away from socially deviant behaviors in addition to
fulfilling their basic requirements for food, nutrition and health. These shelters shall also have
provisions for health care, quality and flexi-time education and vocational training, including
provisions where children can safely keep their belongings and earnings. Counseling guidance
and life skill education shall also be provided for channeling these children’s energy into
productive endeavours.
National Scheme for Rehabilitation of Sex Workers: A panel constituted by the Supreme
Court of India to look into the rehabilitation of sex workers, on 08th of November, 2012 has
submitted a rehabilitation scheme to the Supreme Court. The panel has suggested to the
Apex Court that the scheme should be a national scheme. The scheme is first of its kind and
provides rehabilitation to sex workers as well as victims of commercial sexual exploitation. It
will be a national scheme. The Government of India unfortunately has till date not devised any
proper scheme for rehabilitation for women in prostitution so that they can become part of the
mainstream. This Scheme remained only a proposal.
Compensation Scheme For Women Victims/Survivors Of Sexual Assault/Other Crimes
– 2018: In response to Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in W.P. (C) No. 565/2012 titled Nipun
Saxena Vs. Union of India, National Legal Services Authority Committee has finalized the
Compensation Scheme for women Victims/Survivors of Sexual Assault/other Crimes and
submitted the same before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India on 24.04.2018.
Central Victim Compensation Fund (CVCF): Central Victim Compensation Fund (CVCF)
has been set up under Nirbhaya Funds at a total cost of the project is Rs. 200.00 crore CVCF
has been released as a one-time grant to States/UTs to support and supplement the Victim
Compensation schemes in respective States/ UTs and expenditure from this fund is allowed to
States/ UTs after consuming non-budgetary resource with them.

JUDICIAL RESPONSE TO ISSUE OF TRAFFICKING:

In the governance of a democracy, the court performs a crucial role that cannot be overstated.
In fact, the judiciary takes a large and unique importance as a result of its critical role in passing
judgement on the activities of the two other components-as well as the privilege of interpreting
constitutional provisions. The Supreme Court of India or one of the High Courts are frequently
referred to when judicial rulings or “landmark cases” on human trafficking are mentioned.
Lower courts, on the other hand, handle the majority of cases involving human trafficking. Unlike
the High Courts and the Supreme Court, these cases are not reported. However, studies have
revealed that conviction rates are abysmally low, and that victims are frequently re-victimized
as a result of the procedure. Some principles established by the High Courts and the Supreme
Court have had a favourable impact on the judiciary’s attitude to cases of human trafficking.
These judgements, in general, are concerned with three key issues: victim’s rights, issuing
suitable directions to the government, and special protection for children. In 2016, pursuant to
an order of the Supreme Court (Prajwala vs. Union of India 2016 (1) SCALE 298), the Ministry
of Women and Child Development constituted a committee to examine the feasibility of a
comprehensive legislation on trafficking.
Victim’s Rights: Many judicial decisions in India have been focused on the protection of
victims of trafficking. In Prajwala v Union of India, the implementation of a victim protocol
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 51

was demanded. There have been cases where compensation has been ordered to be paid by a
perpetrator of crimes to victims of the crime as in Bodhisattwa Gautam v Subhra Chakraborty,
where a person had promised marriage to a woman and even went through with a wedding
ceremony which turned out to be false. This has been applied to foreign nationals as well. In
cases of trafficking too, this principle has been used, as seen in PUCL Vs Union of India, where
compensation was ordered to be paid where children were trafficked/ bonded for labour.
Vishal Jeet Vs. Union of India AIR 1990 SC 1412: was a landmark decision where the
Supreme Court took it upon itself to give directions for the protection and rehabilitation of those
who had been dedicated as devadasis by their families or communities for cultural reasons and
were currently in prostitution. The problem of child prostitution was thoroughly discussed by
the Supreme Court in this case Through a Public Interest Litigation. The Supreme Court observed:
“It is highly deplorable and heart rendering to note that many poverty -stricken children and girls
in the prime youth are taken to “flesh market” and forcible pushed into flesh trade which is been
carried on utter violation of all canons of morality, decency and dignity of human mankind. There
can be two opinions -- indeed there is none-that this obnoxious and abominable crime committed
with all kinds of unthinkable vulgarity should be eradicated at all levels by drastic steps.” The
Supreme Court of India passed an order stating the Central and State Government should set up
Advisory Committees to make suggestions for:
• The measure to be taken in eradicating child prostitution
• The social welfare programmes to be implemented for the care, protection, treatment,
development and rehabilitation of the young fallen victims and mainly children and girls
rescued either from the brothel houses or from the vices of prostitution;
• To make suggestions of amendments of the existing laws or for enactment of any new law if
so warranted for the prevention of sexual exploitation of children;
• The examination of the Devadasi and Yogins traditions and give suggestions for their
welfare and rehabilitation;
• Devising suitable machinery for implementing the suggestions made by the committees.
In pursuance of the court directives, the Government of India constituted a Central Advisory
Committee on Child Prostitution. The recommendationsmade by the Central Advisory Committee
have been sent to the concerned Central Ministries/ Department and to the State Government
to notify special police officers, set up Advisory Boards of social workers and NGO’s in red light
areas, conduct regular raids and take measures for the protection and rehabilitation of rescued
persons.
The Supreme Court in the case of Vishaal Jeet Vs Union of India directed that the law
enforcement agencies should implement the law and at the same time, bring such rescued child
prostitutes to rehabilitation homes maintained by well qualified and trained social workers,
psychiatrist and doctors. In view of this, as when child prostitutes are rescued from such
premises it would be necessary to shift them to juvenile’s homes and ensure their protection
in such homes. Such homes have been set up under the Juvenile Justice Act and numbers of
such homes are established in the various states. Prior to the placement of the children in such
homes, enforcement authorities will have to coordinate with the social welfare officers of the
state government who are locally available, and seek the orders of Juvenile Welfare Board.
Bhagwati, J. in Lakshmi Kant Pandey Vs Union of India, [1984] 2 SCC 244 while emphasizing
 52

the importance of children has expressed his view thus: “It is obvious that in a civilized society
the importance of child welfare cannot be over-emphasized, because the welfare of the entire
community, its growth and development, depend on the health and well-being of its children.
Children are a ’supremely important national asset’ and the future wellbeing of the nation
depends on how its children grow and develop.”
Accordingly, we make the following directions:
1. All the State Governments and the Governments of Union Territories should direct their
concerned law enforcing authorities to take appropriate and speedy action under the
existing laws in eradicating child prostitution without giving room for any complaint of
remissness or culpable indifference.
2. The State Governments and the Governments of Union Territories should set up a separate
Advisory Committee within their respective zones consisting of the secretary of the
Social Welfare Department or Board, the Secretary of the Law Department, sociologists,
criminologists, members of the women’s organizations, members of Indian Council
of Child Welfare and Indian Council of Social Welfare as well the members of various
voluntary social organizations and associations etc., the main objects of the Advisory
Committee being to make suggestions of:
a. the measures to be taken in eradicating the child prostitution, and
b. the social welfare programmes to be implemented for the care, protection, treatment,
development and rehabilitation of the young fallen victims namely the children and
girls rescued either from the brothel houses or from the vices of prostitution.
3. All the State Governments and the Governments of Union Territories should take steps
in providing adequate and rehabilitative homes manned by well-qualified trained social
workers, psychiatrists and doctors.
4. The Union Government should set up a committee of its own in the line, we have suggested
under direction No. (2) the main object of which is to evolve welfare programmes to
be implemented on the national level for the care, protection, rehabilitation etc. etc.
of the young fallen victims namely the children and girls and to make suggestions of
amendments to the existing law or for enactment of any new law, if so warranted for the
prevention of sexual exploitation of children.
5. The Central Government and the Governments of States and Union Territories should
devise a machinery of its own for ensuring the proper implementation of the suggestions
that would be made by the respective committees.
6. The Advisory Committee can also go deep into devadasi system and Jogin tradition and
give their valuable advice and suggestions as to what best the Government could do in
that regard.
7. The copies of the affidavits and the list containing the names of 9 girls are directed to be
forwarded to the Commissioner of Police, Delhi for necessary action. We may add that
we are not giving an exhaustive list of the members for the constitution of the committee.
Therefore, it is open to the concerned Government to include any member or members in
the committee as it deems necessary.
In Gaurav Jain vs. Union of India (1997 (8) SCC 114), the court affirmed that the State had
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 53

a duty to rescue, rehabilitate and enable women to lead a life of dignity. The Supreme Court
passed an order directing, inter alia, the constitution of a committee to make a in depth study of
the problems of prostitution child prostitutes, and children of prostitutes, to help evolve suitable
schemes for their rescue and rehabilitation. Taking note of the fact that, ‘children of prostitutes’
should not be permitted to live in the inferno and undesirable surroundings of prostitute homes’,
The Apex Court issued directions to ensure the protection of human rights of such persons the
court also desired that
“... the ground realities should be tapped with a meaningful action imperative apart
from the administrative action which aims at arresting the immoral traffic of women
under the ITPA through interstate or Interpol arrangements and the Nodal Agency like
the CBI is charged to investigate and prevent such crimes.”
The central government pursuant to the directions issued by this Honorable Court in Gaurav
Jain case constituted a “Committee on the Prostitution, Child Prostitutes & Plan of Action to
Combat trafficking and commercial and Sexual Exploitation of Women and Children”.
The Supreme Court in Budhadev Karmaskar v. State of West Bengal ([2011] 10 SCR 578)
had issued notice to all states while noting down the concern on the pathetic conditions of Sex
Workers: “we strongly feel that the Central and the State Governments through Social Welfare
Boards should prepare schemes for rehabilitation all over the country for physically and sexually
abused women commonly known as prostitutes as we are of the view that the prostitutes also
have a right to live with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution of India since they are
also human beings and their problems also need to be addressed. As already observed by us, a
woman is compelled to indulge in prostitution not for pleasure but because of abject poverty. If
such a woman is granted opportunity to avail some technical or vocational training, she would
be able to earn her livelihood by such vocational training and skill instead of by selling her
body. Hence, we direct the Central and the State Governments to prepare schemes for giving
technical/vocational training to sex workers and sexually abused women in all cities in India.
The schemes should mention in detail who will give the technical/vocational training and in
what manner they can be rehabilitated and settled by offering them employment. For instance, if
a technical training is for some craft like sewing garments, etc. then some arrangements should
also be made for providing a market for such garments, otherwise they will remain unsold and
unused, and consequently the women will not be able to feed herself.”

Rehabilitation / Compensation approach

The Supreme Court in Bandhua Mukti Morcha (1984 (3) SCC 161) has elucidated the
rehabilitation of Bonded Labour and directed the Government to award compensation to Bonded
labour under the provisions of Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act 1976 after taking note
of serious violation of Fundamental & Human Rights : “The other question arising out of the
implementation of the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act 1976 is that of rehabilitation of
the released bonded labourers and that is also a question of the greatest importance, because if
the bonded labourers who are identified and freed, are not rehabilitated, their condition would
be much worse than what it was before during the period of their serfdom and they would
become more exposed to exploitation and slide back once again into serfdom even in the absence
of any coercion. The bonded labourer who is released would prefer slavery to hunger, a world
of ‘bondage and (illusory) security’ as against a world of freedom and starvation. The State
Governments must therefore concentrate on rehabilitation of bonded labour and evolve effective
 54

programmes for this purpose. Indeed, they are under an obligation to do so under the provisions
of the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act 1976. It may be pointed out that the concept of
rehabilitation has the following four main features as admirably set out in the letter dated 2nd
September 1982 addressed by the Secretary. Ministry of Labour, Government of India to the
various States Governments:
i. Psychological rehabilitation must go side by side with physical and economic rehabilitation;
ii. The physical and economic rehabilitation has 15 major components namely allotment of
house sites and agricultural land, land development, provision of low cost dwelling units,
agriculture, provision of credit, horticulture, animal husbandry, training for acquiring 134
new skills and developing existing skills, promoting traditional arts and crafts, provision
of wage employment and enforcement of minimum wages, collection and processing of
minor forest produce, health medical care and sanitation supply of essential commodities,
education of children of bonded labourers and protection civil rights;
iii. There is scope for bringing about an integration among the various central and central
sponsored schemes and the on-going schemes of the State Governments for a more
qualitative rehabilitation. The essence of such integration is to avoid duplication i.e.
pooling resources from different sources for the same purpose. It should be ensured
that while funds are not drawn from different sources for the same purpose drawn from
different sectors for different components of the rehabilitation scheme are integrated
skillfully; and
iv. While drawing up any scheme/programme of rehabilitation of freed bonded labour,
the latter must necessarily be given the choice between the various alternatives for their
rehabilitation and such programme should be finally selected for execution as would
need the total requirements of the families of freed bonded labourers to enable them to
cross the poverty line on the one hand and to prevent them from sliding back to debt
bondage on the other.
Supreme Court in MC Mehta v. State of Tamil Nadu and Others – Writ Petition (Civil)
No.465/1986 seeing the severe violation of fundamental rights in cases of child labour laid down
guidelines for compensation and rehabilitation: “It may be that the problem would be taken care
of to some extent by insisting on compulsory education. Indeed, we think that if there is at all a
blueprint for tackling the problem of child labour, it is education. Even if it were to be so, the child
of a poor parent would not receive education, if per force it has to earn to make the family meet
both the ends. Therefore, unless the family is assured of income allude, problem of child labour
would hardly get solved; and it is this vital question which has remained almost unattended. We
are, however, of the view that till an alternative income is assured to the family, the question of
abolition of child labour would really remain a will-o’-the wisp. Now, if employment of child
below that age of 14 is a constitutional indication insofar as work in any factory or mine or
engagement in other hazardous work, and if it has to be seen that all children are given education
till the age of 14 years in view of this being a fundamental right now, and if the wish embodied in
Article 39(e) that the tender age of children is not abused and citizens are not forced by economic
necessity to enter avocation unsuited to their age, and if children are to be given opportunities
and facilities to develop in a healthy manner and childhood is to be protected against exploitation
as visualized by Article 39(f), it seems to us that the least we ought to do is see to the fulfillment
of legislative intendment behind enactment of the Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation)
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 55

Act, 1986. Taking guidance therefrom, we are of the view that the offending employer must be
asked to pay compensation for every child employed in contravention of the provisions of the
Act a sum of Rs.20,000/-; and the Inspectors, whose appointment is visualized by section 17 to
secure compliance with the provisions of the Act, should do this job. The inspectors appointed
under section 17 would see that for each child employed in violation of the provisions of the
Act, the concerned employer pay Rs.20,000/- which sum could be deposited in a fund to be
known as Child Labour Rehabilitation-cum-Welfare Fund. The liability of the employer would
not cease even if he would desire to disengage the child presently employed. It would perhaps
be appropriate to have such a fund district wise or area wise. The fund so generated shall form
corpus whose income shall be used only for the concerned child. The quantum could be the
income earned on the corpus deposited qua the child. To generate greater income, fund can
be deposited in high yielding scheme of any nationalized bank or other public body. As the
aforesaid income could not be enough to dissuade the parent/guardian to seek employment of
the child, the State owes a duty to come forward to discharge its obligation in this regard. After
all, the aforementioned constitutional provisions have to be implemented by the appropriate
Government, which expression has been defined in section 2(i) of the Act to mean, in relation
to establishment under the control of the Central Government or a railway administration or
a major port of a mine or oil field, the Central Government, and in all other cases, the State
Government. Now, strictly speaking a strong case exists to invoke the end of an Article 41 of
the Constitution regarding the right to work and to give meaning to what has been provided in
Article 47 relating to raising of standard of living of the population, and Articles 39(e) and (f) as
to non-abuse of tender age of children and giving opportunities and facilities to them to develop
in healthy manner, for asking the State to see that an adult member of the family, whose child is
in employment in a factory or a mine or in other hazardous work, gets a job anywhere, in lieu of
the child. This would also see the fulfillment of the wish contained in Article 41 after about half
a century of its being in the paramount parchment, like primary education desired by Article
45, having been given the status of fundamental right by the decision in Unni Krishnan. We
are, however, not asking the State at this stage to ensure alternative employment in every case
covered by Article 24, as Article 41 speaks about right to work “within the limits of the economic
capacity and development of the State”. The very large number of child-labour in the aforesaid
occupations would require giving of job to very large number of adults, if we were to ask the
appropriate Government to assure alternative employment in every case, which would strain the
resources of the State, in case it would not have been able to secure job for an adult in a private
sector establishment or, for that matter, in a public sector organization., we are not issuing any
direction to do so presently. Instead, we leave the matter to be sorted out by the appropriate
Government. In those cases where it would not be possible to provide job as abovementioned,
the appropriate Government would, as its contribution/grant, deposit in the aforesaid Fund
a sum of Rs.5,000/- for each child employed in a factory or mine or in any other hazardous
employment. The aforesaid would either see an adult (whose name would be suggested by the
parent/guardian of the concerned child) getting a job in lieu of the child, or deposit of a sum of
Rs.25,000/- in the Child Labour Rehabilitation-cum- Welfare Fund. In case of getting employment
for an adult, the parent/guardian shall have to see that his child is spared from the requirement
to do the job, as an alternative source of income would have become available to him.”
The Supreme Court in Public Union for Civil Liberties V. State Of Tamil Nadu (2013(1)
SCC 585) directed the District Magistrates to effectively implement Section 10, 11 and 12 of the
Bonded Labour (Abolition) Act, 1976 and that they expected them to discharge their functions
 56

with due diligence, with empathy and sensitivity, taking note of the fact that the Act is a welfare
legislation.
The case of Upendra Baxi Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh shows how deeply entrenched is the
market for sex trafficking. The Agra Protective Home was constituted by and functioned under
the penal law, The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956. In a letter to the Indian Express a
member of the Board of Visitors of the Agra Protective Home described the pathetic condition of
the Home in which the girls were kept. According to this letter,’ a letter was written to the then
Justice P.N. Bhagwati who treated it as a writ petition.
The judgment transcending from 1989 to 1998 saw three phases and ultimately the Supreme
Court transferred the case to the National Human Rights Commission with certain guidelines
recorded by the Supreme Court. The guidelines were far reaching in the changes they proposed
to the existing framework while staying within the framework of the Immoral Traffic Prevention
Act and the Constitution. They required the person who is either “ removed” under Section 15(4)
or “rescued” under Section 16(1) of ITPA and produced before a Magistrate to be heard either in
person or through a lawyer (assigned by the Legal Aid Committee of the District Court concerned
) at every stage of proceedings including admission to a Protective Home, Intermediate custody
as well as discharge. The Supreme Court further lay down that in camera trial be held and that it
should be the duty of the court to ensure the presence of lawyers of both sides. If under section
15(4) and section 16(1) it was a child, the child should be placed in an institution recognized or
established under the Juvenile Justice Act, 1986. It was further suggested that the post of special
police officer shall, wherever possible, be held by a woman police officer and that there should
be in place an Advisory Board consisting of five leading social workers to be associated with the
special police officer.
Section 20 of the ITPA was challenged on several occasions. Section 20 permits the removal
of prostitutes from any area in the interests of the general public. The Magistrate is further
empowered to prohibit the prostitute women from re-entering the place from which she has
been removed.
In Shama Bai vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, Section 20 was challenged by a prostitute woman.
She argued that prostitution was hereditary trade. It was her only means of livelihood and the
members of her family were economically dependent on her. The writ was filed primarily to
prevent her landlord from using the provisions of the ITPA for evicting her from the premises
.The court held that the unfettered discretion conferred on the Magistrate ^remove any woman
believed to be a prostitute from his jurisdiction by Section20, violated Article l4.The court further
held that prostitutes were subject to a punitive form of surveillance to which other women
were not, and that this differential treatment constituted discrimination between persons
who were similarly situated.
In the State of Uttar Pradesh Vs. Kaushaliya, Section 20, ITPA was again challenged as
violating Article 14. The Supreme Court, in adopting the reasonable classification approach,
held that the difference between a prostitute and non-prostitute was a reasonable classification.
Further, the court ruled that there were real differences between a prostitute who does not
demand, in public interest, any restrictions on her movement, and a prostitute, whose action
demand restrictions.
In the case of, Prerana Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others, Mumbai High Court clearly held
that children who have been trafficked themselves should also be considered as children in need of care
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 57

and protection and not as children in conflict with the law. The Mumbai High Court looked into the
issue of violation of rights of trafficked children by various authorities who are supposed to
implement the law. Prerana, the petitioner is a registered organization which works m the red-
light areas of Mumbai and Navi Mumbai with the object of preventing the trafficking of women
and children and rehabilitating the victims of forced prostitution. This petition was filed in public
interest to protect children and minor girls rescued from the flesh trade against the pimps and
brothel keepers keen on reacquiring possession of the girls. On May 16, 2002 the social service
branch of Mumbai police raided a brothel at Santa Cruz. Four persons who were alleged to
be brothel keepers/pimps were arrested. Twenty-four females were rescued. On conducting
an ossification test, ten of them were found to be minors. In this case the Mumbai High Court
passed the following directions which are of great significance for the children rescued from the
brothels.
• No magistrate can exercise jurisdiction over any person under eighteen years of age
whether that person in a juvenile in conflict with law or a child in need of care and
protection, as defined by sections 2 (1) and 2(d) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection
of Children) Act 2000. At the first possible instance, the magistrate must take steps to
ascertain the age of a person who seems to be under eighteen years of age. When such a
person is found to be under eighteen years of age, the magistrate must transfer the case to
the Juvenile Justice Board if such a person is a juvenile in conflict with law, or to the Child
Welfare Committee of such a person is a child in need or care and protection.
• A magistrate before whom such persons rescued under, the immoral Traffic (Prevention)
Act 1956 or found soliciting in a public place are produced should, under Section 17(2) or
the said Act, have their ages ascertained the very first time when they are produced before
him. When such a person is found to be under eighteen years of age, the magistrate must
transfer the case to the Juvenile Justice Board if such person is a juvenile in conflict with
law or to the Child Welfare Committee if such a person is a juvenile in conflict with law
or to the child welfare committee if such a person is a child in need of care and protection.
• Any juvenile rescued from a brothel under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act 1956
or found soliciting in a public place should only be released after an inquiry has been
completed by the probation officer.
• The said juvenile should be released only to the care and custody of a parent/guardian
after such parents/guardian has been found fit by the child welfare committee, to have
the care and custody of the rescued juvenile.
• If the parent/guardian is found unfit to have the care and custody of the rescued juvenile,
the procedure laid down under the Juvenile Justice (care and protection of children) Act
2000 should be followed for the rehabilitation of the rescued child.
• No advocate can appear before the child welfare committee on behalf of a juvenile
produced before the child welfare committee after being rescued under the immoral Traffic
(Prevention) Act l956 or found soliciting in a public place. Only the parents/guardian
of such juvenile should be permitted to make representations before the child welfare
Committee through themselves or through an advocate appointed for such purpose.
• An advocate appearing for a pimp or brothel keeper is barred from appearing in the same
case for the victims rescued under the Immoral Traffic (prevention) Act 1956.
 58

In Khatri II Vs. State of Bihar the Supreme Court held that the provision of free legal aid by
the state to those who cannot afford legal representation is integral to a person’s fundamental
right to life.
Recently, a committee was appointed by the Mumbai High Court in relation to the case
of Jayesh Thakker and Another Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others and Internet Users
Association of India (Intervenors). The High Court laid down several restrictions on cyber-
Cafes to provide for an adequate degree of supervision and control so that minors are protected
from being exposed to pornographic sites on the Internet in the cyber cafes. The committee has
given recommendations to make a child friendly or child-safe ‘cyber zone’ where minors could
safely access and use the internet for information, education, communication and entertainment.
A public interest petition was filed in the Allahabad High Court and the Supreme Court in
the case of Munna Vs. State of when reports of sexual abuse in Kanpur Central Jail appeared
in newspaper based on a social activist’s findings. The High Court asked the session’s judge of
Kanpur to visit the jail and find out whether they are maltreated. The jail authorities meanwhile
released a large number of boys. Therefore, when the session’s judge visited the jail, there were
only some six children there. But there were eighty-four under trial who were between sixteen
and twenty-one years of age. The judge also reported that there was general ignorance about the U.P.
Children’s Act among the jail authorities. There were parallel proceedings on the same issue in the
High Court and the Supreme Court.
The Lucknow High Court in a judgment on Wednesday dated 13-10-95, not only directed the
release of a 13-year-old girl forcibly engaged in the flesh trade but also issued writ of mandamus
directing the state of Uttar Pradesh and the Barabanki District Magistrate to admit her to a
primary school and sanction Rs. 10,000 for her rehabilitation.’*^ The Court was of the view that
the child should be immediately restored to her parents, whose primary responsibility will be
the upbringing and development of the child. The judiciary have also played an important role
in protection of minor/child prostitution by saying that “no lawyer can appear on behalf of
minor girl rescued from the flesh trade market” — the Bombay High Court.
The Supreme Court in the case of, Lakshmi Kant Pandey Vs. Union of India and others,
examined the vulnerability of children being trafficked in adoption rackets due to the lack of an
effective protection mechanism. The court went on to create an appropriate mechanism to fill the
gap, especially in the context of inter country adoptions. The Court have taken the view that no
malpractices indulged in by social organizations and voluntary agencies engaged in the work
of offering Indian Children in adoption to foreign parents, must not in any manner be involved.
In a writ petition No.365 of 1997 by an NGO Savera and Others Vs State of Goa and Others,
the High Court of Bombay delivered a judgment on 21st July, 2003. The object of the petition
was primarily to seek the direction of High Court to the concerned agencies in the “readjustment
and rehabilitation” of the persons in the Red-Light area of Baina. The High Court took into
consideration the various views m the replies filed by the petitioners, respondents, etc., as well
as the report of the Kamat Committee. The High Court directions included the following:
• State government to ensure necessary action as per Kamat Committee Report.
• Ensure effective implementation of the judgment of the Apex Court in Gaurav Jain Vs
Union of India.
• Ordered that the District Collector take steps under ITPA and other relevant laws to
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 59

close down the cubicles (250 cubicles being used for sex trade in Baina beach). If the said 250
cubicles constructions are illegal, and are on government land and land belonging local
authorities, then to take steps to evict the illegal occupants and then demolish them by
following due process of law”.
• State government to take adequate steps to prevent the CSWs (Commercial Sexual
Workers) being brought into the state of Goa on contract basis, as noted by the Justice
Kamat Committee.
• Since the CSWs are being brought from outside Goa, the Government of Goa is not bound
to rehabilitate them except to the extent mentioned by specific directions in the judgments
of the Apex Court. The rescued CSW’s be deported to the state where they came from.
The Goa State Commission for Women, along with the National Commission for Women
to take steps, so that the said women are rehabilitated in the state from where they hail
with the assistance of the perspective state governments.
• The National Commission for Women to report in ninth months the action taken on the
implementation of the Kamat Committee Report.

A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF LAWS AGAINST HUMAN TRAFFICKING IN INDIA

India’s Constitution addresses human trafficking both directly and indirectly. Part III,
Fundamental Rights, and Part IV, Directive Principles of State Policy, each contain three articles
that address trafficking-related issues. The Constitution notably emphasizes human trafficking
and forced labour, as well as the special protection that must be offered to society’s most
vulnerable populations. The Indian Constitution addresses provisions on human trafficking on
two levels: first, at the level of Fundamental Rights, which are fundamental rights guaranteed to
all people regardless of caste, creed, sex, or place of origin, and second, at the level of State Policy
Directive Principles.
As a Fundamental Right in Article 23, trafficking in human beings is prohibited as are all
forms of forced labour. According to Directive Principles of State Policy in Articles 39(e) and
(f), the health and strength of workers should not be abused. It prohibits exploitation of persons
to perform work which is unsuitable for them. It also specifically protects children and youth
against exploitation of any kind. While the provisions in the Directive Principles of State Policy
do not mention trafficking, it mentions exploitation which is a key element in trafficking.
Human trafficking has become one of the most lucrative types of organised crime throughout
the years. For both forced labour and human trafficking, India continues to be a source,
destination, and transit country for men, women, and children. The ITPA 1956, on the other
hand, specifies a narrow definition of trafficking, recognising only trafficking of girls and women
for prostitution and excluding various other types of trafficking from the Act’s scope. Following
the Justice Verma Committee Report, a modification to the IPC Section 370 in 2013 provided a
broad definition of trafficking that recognised multiple manifestations of trafficking.
The ITPA Act is an abject failure & requires changes which can help to overcome the
loopholes which are prevailing in it. For better administration it should be amended and special
attention should be given on execution of the Act. It has been a normal practice to arrest and charge
sheet commercial sex workers, who often are victims of trafficking, mainly under section 8 of the ITPA for
seducing and soliciting customers. As most of the arrests are done during the rescue operations and raids
by police, nearly 90% of the arrested persons in India are found to be victims of trafficking. The persons,
 60

who are in control of the brothels (often called brothel keepers or managers or madams), a large majority
of whom were originally trafficked into commercial sexual exploitation, are hardly caught and arrested.
Prostitution is not an offence under the ITPA. It however criminalizes solicitation or engaging in
sex work in or near a public place. Often this provision of the act is used by the police to harass
and punish the sex workers who themselves are the victims of trafficking. The Government of
India has therefore recently attempted to amend the law and absolve the sex workers of the
offence of soliciting or seducing by deleting Section 8 of the act even though it complicated the
matter by suggesting exemplary punishment for the clients under a new section 5C.
Moreover, rehabilitation of victims is a critical challenge which requires adequate attention
and legal backing for proper enforcement. Hence there is a need to enact a new legislation
to expand the definition of trafficking as well as address critical gaps to deal with the newly
emergent challenges.
DRAFT BILL 2018: The Ministry of Women and Child Development (MoWCD) has drafted
Bill known as The Trafficking of Persons (Prevention, Protection and Rehabilitation) Bill,
2018, as per the direction of Hon. Supreme Court and under the guidance of the Inter-Ministerial
Committee constituted on this issue. It had been understood that there is no comprehensive
legislation for the prevention of trafficking and protection and rehabilitation of its victims. Also,
trafficking is an organized crime which includes more than one criminal activity or groups. It
has a borderless character across States and Countries as the groups or persons indulged have
close nexus with other offences. Therefore, it needs a comprehensive attention and broader
strategy to tackle the menace of this offence. The Trafficking of Persons (Prevention, Protection
and Rehabilitation) Bill, 2018 was introduced in Lok Sabha on 18, July 2018 and was passed on
26, July 2018 but it never became a law as the same was not presented in upper house. The Bill
provides for the prevention, rescue, and rehabilitation of trafficked persons.
The Trafficking In Persons (Prevention, Care And Rehabilitation) Bill, 2021: A Bill to prevent
and counter trafficking in persons, especially women and children, to provide for care, protection, and
rehabilitation to the victims, while respecting their rights, and creating a supportive legal, economic and
social environment for them, and also to ensure prosecution of offenders, and for matters connected therewith
or incidental thereto. The draft anti-trafficking Bill, 2021 is slated to be tabled in the coming session
of Parliament. Activists working in the field of child and women welfare are hopeful that the
Bill will be passed in both the Houses of Parliament, thus adding muscle to the efforts of various
organizations working to combat the threat. There are a few recommendations and additional
measures that activists have made after the ministry of women and child development sought
public feedback.

Some of the significant provisions of the Bill are listed below:

1. Cases will be probed by the fully functional and prestigious Agency- NIA. The faster
arrest of offenders (most often operating in syndicates and organised criminal groups).
2. Stricter punishment to the perpetrator if the victim of trafficking is a child. Aggravated
crime to get deservedly stricter punishment.
3. Online trafficking: Bill includes a provision that says that physical movement or
transportation of the victim is not necessary to define the crime of tracking.
4. The provision of protection homes for immediate protection of victims and
Policy and Legal Perspective of Human Trafficking 61

rehabilitation homes for long term rehabilitation will help the victims to come out of
the trauma and seamlessly assimilate in society later.
5. This Bill proposes a proposal for the provision of separate protection and rehabilitation
homes for transgenders. This is a great step to erase discriminatory behaviour that this
hitherto neglected section of the society is subject to and will cater to their different
needs.
6. This anti-trafficking bill states that the rehabilitation of victims is not dependent
on criminal proceedings and not even on its outcome. The rehabilitation is to begin
immediately once the FIR is registered.
7. The Bill also provides for immediate relief to the victim within 30 days of the filing of
FIR. This immediate relief is that it is
8. over and above the compensation that will be awarded to the victim under the State
Victim Compensation Scheme.
9. This Bill makes re-tracking an aggravated form of tracking with higher punishment of
not less than 10 years which can go
10. Up to life imprisonment and a fine which can be up to Rs 10 lakh.
11. Women, children and physically and mentally disabled persons are given extra
protection in the law by including them under the provision of “presumption of
offences”. This means that when the victims are women, children and physically and
mentally disabled persons then the trackers will be presumed to have committed the
crime and during the trial, they have to prove they are innocent.
12. To crush crime syndicates in trafficking, the Bill provides for the attachment and
forfeiture of property and bank accounts of the accused.
13. Proceeds of crime collected and accumulated by traffickers, will be used for the relief
and rehabilitation of the victim.
We still have a long way to go before we can truly address the threat of human trafficking in
India. India is now categorized as a Tier-II country in terms of dealing with human trafficking,
indicating that, while it has been committed to its promise to combat the evil of human trafficking,
it has not been able to fully address the problem.
 Chapter 3
RATIONALE, OBJECTIVES AND RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
H uman trafficking, particularly of women and children, is one of the fastest-growing
enterprises, earning unfathomable revenues every year. The causes of this worldwide
phenomenon’s rise are numerous and diverse, affecting both affluent and poor countries. This is
also true in India. The most destitute localities, regions, or countries are generally the source areas
or points of origin, whereas the points of destination are often but not necessarily metropolitan
conglomerates within or across borders. For those who view human trafficking in economic
terms, the real or perceived disparity in economic status between source and destination areas is
critical. Human people, on the other hand, may be and are transported from one destitute area
to another for reasons best known to the traffickers, as evidenced by research studies and data
from around the world. The truth is that traffickers construct and control the process for their
own interests, and they use a variety of methods to achieve their goals. As a result, the idea that
people are constantly transported from developing to industrialized countries is incorrect. It’s
difficult to gauge the magnitude of the occurrence.
Data collection on human trafficking is exceedingly difficult due to the clandestine nature
of the activities. ‘The trade is hidden, women are hushed, traffickers are violent, and only a few
agencies keep track of it. The United Nations estimates that 4 million individuals are exchanged
against their will to work in some kind of slavery each year, many of them children,’ and that
‘trafficking in women and children for sexual exploitation has harmed more than 30 million
people in Asia alone in the previous 30 years.’ The golden triangle, in which India is located,
is the most vulnerable location for the trafficking of women and children for the flesh trade.
Girls and women become a cheap commodity as a result of poverty and exploitation. Low-
yielding agriculture, a lack of alternative employment opportunities, and marginalization all
result in poverty, impoverishment, economic troubles, deprivation and resource scarcity, and
marginalization, all of which create an ideal climate for sex trade to thrive. This is especially true
in the case of human trafficking of women and children, as two-thirds of the girls and women
recruited come from impoverished areas. The sex trade is also encouraged by cultural traditions
such as Jogini, Devadasi, and Basavi in Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, Maharashtra, and Karnataka.
Sex trafficking is also encouraged by economic factors among tribes and communities such
as the Bedias, Jahats, Kanjars, Kolta, Banchra, Mahar, Matang, and Sansi. Delhi and Bombay
have grown into major flesh-trading hubs. Though there are over 1100 red light areas in India,
Sonagachchi is the biggest.
The five major metropolitan areas viz. Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai, and Bangalore
 64

account for over 80% of child prostitutes. When rural poor people migrated to cities, human
traffickers took advantage of their desperation and used promises of money and jobs to entice
their children into this business. It’s also been stated that as the working population migrates
to industrial districts, children and women seek to satisfy their sexual and financial desires by
visiting brothels, resulting in an increase in the demand for female prostitutes. Girls and women
have been trafficked as a result of tourism, particularly in coastal tourist locations. Thailand, the
Philippines, Sri Lanka, and India have all emerged into organized tourism flesh trades.
The law gives relevant authorities broad powers in terms of victim and survivor rescue
and rehabilitation, as well as harsh punishment for exploiters, including eviction of brothels,
surveillance, and externment, as well as increased punishment when crimes are perpetrated
against children. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act and the Juvenile Justice Act in India have
been updated to reflect current international instruments. The Juvenile Justice Act considers a
child who is judged to be vulnerable and at risk of being initiated into human trafficking as a kid
in need of care and protection, and it includes extensive measures for rescue and rehabilitation.
It provides non-governmental organizations (NGOs) authority and a seat on child welfare
committees and the Juvenile Justice Board. The ITPA authorizes state governments as well as the
Indian government to establish special courts. Rape laws have been scrutinized and interpreted
by the Supreme Court multiple times, with the result that the legislation is now gender and
childfriendly.
Therefore, it was imperative to conduct a National Level Research Study on Trafficking
of Women and Children in India and to find out the various challenges faced by different
stakeholders in combating Human Trafficking and suggest the remedies thereafter.

REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Human trafficking is the outcome of a complex interaction of situational, social, and personal
circumstances that make those who are trafficked susceptible. Traffickers are always on the lookout
for this vulnerable demographic, as they are simpler to persuade into risky migration, which
leads to exploitation. Several studies have been conducted, and there is a substantial literature
on the subject of human trafficking. This section analyses previous studies and literatures on the
topic in order to provide it with a solid foundation. The current overview of the literature looks
at research findings on many elements of human trafficking. The reviews are divided into two
sections based on research conducted at the international level and (ii) the national level.
Giselle Balfour , David Okech , Tamora A. Callands & Grace Kombian (2020): A Qualitative
Analysis of the Intervention Experiences of Human Trafficking Survivors and At-risk Women
in Ghana: study documents the positive and negative intervention experiences of 37 trafficked
and at-risk women from a residential care facility in Accra, Ghana. In-depth interviews were
analyzed with the Atlas T.I. software using a primarily inductive approach in thematic analysis.
Delia Deckard, Natalie (2020) -Constructing Vulnerability: The Effect of State Migration Policy
and Policing on the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children: examines the effects of the
criminalization of immigration control systems on the prevalence of the commercial sexual
exploitation of children (CSEC) in the United States. This research delineates the relationship
between increased carcerality and marginalization. The results confirm existing theory that more
intense criminalization is associated with greater marginalization and exploitation of the most
vulnerable members of the polity. Controlling for demographic and socio-economic variables
proves relevant to CSEC, and models exhibit positive correlations between the variables of
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 65

interest. It can be seen that migration, human trafficking and human smuggling have a nexus
amongst themselves. They thrive on mutual elements which are functional in these phenomena.
The ‘consent’ element is taken into account in context of trafficking and human smuggling (Kyle
& Koslowski, 2011). Victims of both phenomena are exploited. In case of migration, people who
avail the services of a smuggler outside their own conscious knowledge, often find themselves
turn into victims of trafficking. Another prime difference between people smuggled and people
trafficked is that the former have the freedom to leave their place of work or operation and the
latter are not even remotely fortunate to do the same (Väyrynen, 2003). Dinh et al. (2014) invited
a proposal comprising innovative and dynamic methodologies with an intention to develop the
base and expand it for further research in Human Trafficking in Vietnam. It is an organized crime
and is on the rise. It can also be called as the modern-day slavery. The outcomes of the pilot
study that was conducted in the rural regions (hamlets) of Vietnam have been focused upon to
find reliable and relevant statistical data which is usually not available. To overcome this issue,
the pilot study was a requisite and to find a solution to this. The revelations of this survey were
that the researchers did not find any trace or reliable information to confirm as to why rural
population saw more trafficking incidences. Traffickers make lump sum amount of money at the
cost of the lives of innocent people which consists of babies, young girls, children, women, men
(Orhant & Murphy, 2002). They are exploited and deprived of their freedom and human rights.
People who get victimized are forced to work without pay (Kangaspunta, 2011). The incidences
of human trafficking generally flourish due to the marginalized people who are frail, poverty
stricken and helpless due to the absence of livelihood options which makes them susceptible.
Gender discrimination and related exploitation is another major reason for these marginalized
people suffering and bearing the cost of exploitation. Their lives can be transformed when
better and sustainable livelihood opportunities would be created for them. In some countries
where there is a situation of war, military base camps serve as the demand driven group and are
facilitated by sex workers who have been trafficked from different regions (Getu, 2006).
The American Psychological Association (2011) established the Task Force on Trafficking
of Women and Girls and reported that there are different aspects to human trafficking apart
from legal, social and human rights. Different recommendations regarding the enhancement
of training and research in this field of human trafficking and also for changes in public policy,
advocacy set up, capacity building and preventive measures to be taken for combating the same
were suggested. Scientific approach has been used to have an insight for the psychologists to
deal with this social problem. Because if the dynamics of trafficking are not well understood, the
picture that we get is vague and lacks clarity about the real issue. In the policy recommendations
section, it has been suggested that behavioural health services and counseling services should
be given to those who have been the victims and then came out as survivors and also to be
able to generate enough funds to have further in-depth research in this field. It is important to
promote and create awareness in the sectors like education, health, legal (judiciary) and child
welfare and train their professionals about the various aspects, elements and consequences
of human trafficking. Bohl (2010) critically study about human trafficking in Nepal and India
and throws light on the structural and institutional factors which contribute to its propensity
in both the countries. Failure of developmental strategies leads to loss of jobs and also breeds
unemployment everywhere. This in turn forces people to look for livelihood opportunities in
anywhere possible. Resource mobilization is also seen to be defective. Both the countries have
seeds of patriarchy sowed deep, which have fed the culture threads to discriminate women in all
spheres. This is where they are worst affected. Relying on social networks to benefit themselves
 66

for obtaining work to feed themselves and their families proves harmful in the long run. One
major finding was that the trafficker is usually someone whom they know. Sometimes parents
unknowingly push their children into the vicious circle of trafficking. Relatives play a major role
in aggravating this problem further. In Nepal, many children are seen to have been trafficked
by their parents when they were sent to work at the Indian Circuses. Maiti Nepal is an NGO
working rigorously by formulating trafficking combat programs. They also run shelter homes
for re-establishing the rescued victims of trafficking in a new order. Trafficking in persons is
often portrayed as the world’s fastest growing criminal enterprise, with profits that rival the
illegal drugs and arms trade. Reports repeatedly quote the number of seven billion dollars in
profit to indicate the magnitude of the phenomenon (Spangenberg 2002; Denisova 2001; Scarpa
2006; Roby 2005). Reports also talk about networks of international organized crime which are
attracted to the trade in human beings because of low risk and because the criminal penalties for
human trafficking are light in most countries (Pochagina 2007; Tiefenbrun 2002; Sheldon 2007).
In transnational trafficking, it is commonly seen that those people who are taken away from
their home country in the pretext of being given good jobs, their passports are taken away from
them. And other such related personal documents are confiscated (Shelley, 2007). UNDOC’s
first endeavour towards classifying human trafficking from among the pool of other forms
of organized crime was done in April 2006 (Chawla et al., 2009). Trafficking must have some
essentials elements to be fully defined as trafficking. An ‘action’ is important which is to be done
through some ‘means’ and must be directed towards some ‘goal(s)’. The varieties and ways
in these elements vary from situation to situation. Without these elements, human trafficking
cannot be said to have taken place (Aronowitz, 2009).
Different TIP Reports produced by the US Department of State reiterate this assertion,
describing how traffickers enjoy virtually no risk of prosecution by using sophisticated modes
of transportation and communication; avoid punishment by operating in places where there is
little rule of law, lack of anti-trafficking laws, poor enforcement of such laws, and wide-spread
corruption (DOS 2003-2007). Media and international organizations also talk about the fact that
the crime of trafficking in persons offers international organized crime syndicates a low-risk
opportunity to make billions of profits by taking advantage of unlimited supply and unending
demand for trafficked persons (Claramunt 2002; Burke et al 2005; ILO, 2002; Reuters 2000). Basu
and Chau (2004) asserted that debt creates a bondage situation where people are forced to stay
as proletariats under the exploitation of the money lenders. Generally, it is seen that children
are made to offer their labour as service for such bondages. And this vicious cycle of debt and
bondage labour among children is a never-ending process. This is seen to get passed from
one generation to another which eventually contributes to labour based trafficking. Therefore,
assessment of trade permits and endorsements must be made mandatory as policy measure
to combat bonded labour. Richards (2004) analyses the mutual connection between corruption
and trafficking and how they feed each other at every level. This connection has two sides to
itself, one where it heightens the danger faced by those who get trafficked. The other side is, it
makes trafficking smooth, as a process to function without interruptions and any hurdles. This
is substantiated by the way the allocated resources are utilized for this process. Nothing but
corruption helps it to grow.
Given the lack of research findings and statistical data, it is difficult to accurately assess the
scope of organized crime’s involvement in human trafficking (Bruckert and Parent 2002: 13). The
distinction between trafficking and smuggling is not always easy to make. According to John Salt
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 67

(2000: 43) the notion that human trafficking and organized crime are closely related is widespread
despite lack of evidence-based data to support this assertion. This alleged connection is based on
the fact that people of different nationalities are part of the same group of trafficked victims; that
trip over a long distance require a well-oiled organization; those substantial amounts of money
are involved; those itineraries change quickly; those legal services are available very quickly; and
that there is a strong reaction to counter-offensives by law enforcement agencies (Bruckert and
Parent 2002). These arguments developed by Europol (Salt 2000) are also shared by others (e.g.,
Taibly 2001; Juhasz 2000). Some researchers point to a close connection between organized crime
and trafficking for sexual exploitation indicating that the magnitude and geographic scope of the
sex industry are phenomenal and organized crime is involved at various levels (Shanon 1999;
Caldwell et. al. 1997). Miko and Park (2003) investigated that how inclination, favouritism and
differential treatment towards boys and men generally seen in almost every society is a major
reason for trafficking. This is where we know that patriarchy prevails and thus aggravates the
situation for women who are adversely affected and exploited in every possible manner.
Human trafficking is a global socio legal issue of discussion and debate. A number of
studies have been conducted which highlight the various dimensions of the issue. A study by
Congressional Research Service for the US Congress cities the following estimates of trafficked
people worldwide: South-East Asia 225,000; South Asia 15,000; former Soviet Union - 100,000;
East Europe 75,000; Latin America 10,000; Africa 50 crores (CRS, 2001). Recent International
Labour Organization figures for children in the worst forms of labour worldwide are: trafficking
(1.2 million); forced and bonded labour 5.7 million); armed conflict (0.3 million); prostitution and
pornography (1.8 million); and illicit activities (0.6 million) (ILO, 2002). Calculations of trafficked
people are generally made with reference to commercial sex exploitation. In India, the stigma
attached to prostitution and the clandestine nature of operations makes it doubly difficult to
arrive at authentic numbers (Gupta, 2003). To give a sense of the total magnitude of the problem,
estimates of adult and child sex workers in India are quoted. All minors in commercial sex work are
generally classified as cases of trafficking. The figures quoted show a high degree of discrepancy,
and the possibility of ascertaining the authenticity of the quoted figures is almost nil. The original
sources, or how these figures have been arrived at, are rarely stated. Around 30 to 90 per cent of
women and girls are under 18 at the time of entry in to prostitution (Mukherjee and Das, 1996;
UNICEF 1994; YMCA 1995; Gathia 1999; Gathia 2003; Save our sisters 2001). The population of
women and children in sex work in India is stated to be between 70,000 and 1 million. Of these,
30 per cent are 20 years of age. Nearly 15 per cent began sex work when they were below 15, and
25 per cent entered between 15 and 18 years (Mukherjee and Das, 1996). A news item published
in Statesman (12 August 2002) states that roughly 2 million children are abused and forced into
prostitution every year in India. A rough estimate prepared by an NGO called End Children’s
Prostitution in Asian Tourism reveals that there are around 2 million prostitutes in India; 20 per
cent among them are minors. A study conducted in 1992 estimates that any one time, 20,000 girls
are being transported from one part of the country to another (Gupta, 2003).
NGO estimates of sex work are however much higher (UNICEF, 1994). A CEDPA report
states that in 1997, approximately 200 girls and women in India entered prostitution on a daily
basis and 80 per cent were coerced into it (Save Our Sisters, 2001). There are reportedly 300,000
to 500,000 children in prostitution in India (Patkar, Praveen and Priti, Patkar, 2001). A UNICEF
study on Maharashtra states that at any given time, approximately 40 per cent of the victims
of commercial sex exploitation and trafficking are found to be below 18 years. Trafficking of
women and children for flesh trade has emerged as one of the most profitable illegal trades next
 68

to illegal trade in arms and narcotics. All of three became the toughest forms of organized crime.
Selling of young women is one of the fastest growing organized crimes making the traffickers
richer by $ 6 billion every year (Shelley, 2010). Richards (2000) maintains that trafficking in
persons, particularly women and children is significant on nearly every continent. Trafficking-
involves gross violation of human rights. People suffer from physical and mental abuse and social
stigmatization. The alarming number of women and children being trafficked for forced labour
or slavery like practices, including commercial sex exploitation, is a concern for development
agencies and government. The complexity of trafficking, the links with visceral issues such as
commercial sex work and exploitation of children, and the politics of migration management
have meant that there is much contention over the definition of trafficking and the types of
policies and programming that would effectively combat this serious crime and effort to basic
human rights (Asian Development Bank, 2003).
Large numbers of Nepalese citizens have migrated to India to work as labourers. During
colonial times, Nepalese were recruited in the Gorkha Regiments of the Indian Army, and that
continues to this day. Nepalese migrant workers crossing the borders into India 7000 sex workers
cross over from Nepal into India every year. It is reported that 86 per cent of the prostitutes come
from Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal, Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh
(National Commission for Women, 1995-96). About 66 per cent of the girls are from families
where the annual income is about Rs.5000. While they are sold off by their parents, deceived with
promises of marriage of a lucrative range in between 1.8 million and 3 million in a year (Gurung,
2001). India and Nepal share a common open border and the nationals in both the countries do not
require a travel permit or a passport to cross the border. Women make up a large of proportion
of the Nepalese labour force in India. They end up as domestic help in rich Indian families or
sex workers in the red-light areas in Mumbai, Kolkata, Delhi and Chennai. Nepalese women
migrants are highly vulnerable to commercial and sexual exploitation (UNDP, 2004). About job,
others are children who are kidnapped and sold to brothel owners (The Week, August 4, 1996).
Fowler & UNICEF (2004) illustrated the different segments a country gets divided into, pertaining
to the ways the traffickers carry out their transactions, in context of Africa. Their role in carrying
out these transactions (involving people from the marginalized section of the community) also
characterizes the patterns and the classifications made. It is seen that those countries which
supply (involuntarily) people for the purpose of meeting the demands of traffickers and their
clients, are known as the country of source. This is more evident in the third world countries who
are deprived, poverty stricken, lack ample amount of livelihood and employment opportunities,
characterized by low levels of literacy, health and where inequality prevails. ILO (2005) studied
about the preconceived notions about the employment of those who are trafficked into different
industries. The study states that the people, who are trafficked, due to coercion, trick, bondage,
false hope and sham marriages don’t always get into prostitution. There are various other kind
of sexual enslavement. They are put into laborious factory and industry-based jobs. Mostly kids
are a part of the begging racket where they are forced to go into the streets. Young girls and even
women are sold off in the name of marriage and forced into domestic servitude also. All of these
things are studied in the context of South Asia. Recent estimates from ILO’s study shows that, of
all victims 43% are sexually exploited, 32% are victims are economically abused and exploited.
Huda (2006) claims that, apart from health ramifications, sex trafficking goes beyond the limits
of human rights violation. The outcomes of the cruel treatment of the victims, is reflected in
their status of physical, sexual and psychological health. The cost borne by these people are a
cluster of health perils which might include an obsession of drugs and increased dependence
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 69

on them. Sexual health gets impaired due to reasons like STDs (sexually transmitted diseases),
unintended pregnancy leading to abortion in most cases, health complications, and different
forms of physical and sexual abuse like rape. The mental health of an individual is adversely
affected pushing them to their limits, with an increased propensity towards mental instability and
suicide. Kilgman and Limoncelli (2005) illustrated examples of trafficking in persons, especially
that of women in various countries. They analyzed that human trafficking isn’t a new thing
for the academicians, national authorities, media persons and development professionals. This
concept is not an alien subject to them. They mentioned about the transiting nature of trafficking
patterns in the last one century. Nonetheless the stability of their organizational foundation and
structural roots remained almost similar to that of ancient times. Countries like China, Japan and
many European nations served as country of source in the past.
The prostitution is not confined to sexual abuse. It also encompasses (i) sexual harassment,
(ii) rape, (iii) battering, (iv) verbal abuse, (v) domestic violence, (vi) a racist practice, (vii) a
violence of human rights, (viii) childhood sexual abuse, (ix) a consequence of male domination
of women, (x) a means of maintaining male domination of women, (xi) all of above (Prostitution-
research.com). The commercial sex industry includes street prostitution; massage brothels, escort
out call services, strip clubs, lap-dancing, phone sex, adult and child pornography, internet
pornography, and prostitution tourism. Most women who are in prostitution than a few months
drift among these various permutations of the commercial sex. All prostitution causes harm
to women. Whether it is being sold by one’s family to whether it is being sexually abused in
ones’ family, running away from home, and pimped by one’s boyfriend, or whether one is in
college and needs to pay for next tuition and one work’s out at a strip club behind glass where
men haves actually touch forms of prostitution hurt the women in it (Melissa, 2000). It is to be
noted that about 80 per cent of women in prostitution have been the victim of a rape (Susan
and Reed, 1990). Other studies report that 68 per cent to 70 per cent of women in prostitution
being raped (Silbert, 1998). Prostitution is an act of violence against women, which is intrinsically
traumatizing. Melissa et al. (1998) reported that most women have been raped in prostitution,
and have experienced physical assault in prostitution. They are mainly homeless, and wanted to
escape from prostitution immediately. A study conducted by the Central Social Welfare Board,
1990 reported that 40 per cent of the population of commercial sex workers entering the trade is
below 18 years of age. At least 400,000 are estimated to be minor of which 20,000 are annually
brought to India from Nepal. The children of sex workers, a very vulnerable group are estimated
to be 53 lakhs (National Commission for Women, 1997).
People with personal characteristics of low self-esteem and lack of self-control are reported
to be vulnerable (United Nations Development Programme, 2002). Low levels of literacy,
awareness and information are also risk factors. Economic deprivation due to various reasons
and its associative conditions are among the most important factors that lead to vulnerability.
Greater the degree of impoverishment, higher is the risk of falling prey to trafficking (Mukherjee
and Das, 1996; Department of Women and Child Development, 1998; UNDP, 2002). People with
disabilities and ‘women who suffer from “disfigurements” are also vulnerable (Gathia, 2003).
A dysfunctional home environment - break-up of the family, marital discord, physical abuse,
sexual abuse, drug use, family pressures, large families, families facing uncertain times, children
in substitute care, gender discrimination within the family, desertion by husbands, husbands’
acquiring a second or a third wife makes people vulnerable to trafficking. Studies by Central
Social Welfare Board and others have shown that most trafficked women were unmarried,
divorced, separated or widowed (Karmakar, 2001). Environments lacking livelihood options
 70

or economic opportunities, with the accompanying pressures to work and earn, make peoples’
lives on ongoing ‘battle for survival’ (Sanghera, 1999). The quickening pace of urbanization and
heightened mobility resulting from the development of road links are contributing factors. A
culture of consumerism, materialism, commoditization of individuals and commercialization
of sex distorts family needs and individual desires (National Commission for Women, 1997;
Raymond 2002). A mindset which judges children’s worth by the amount of money they can earn,
and how soon they are able to do so, has developed (Institute of Social Sciences 2003), justifying
their exploitation by kin members. Discriminatory practices and social exclusion exacerbate the
vulnerabilities of groups like Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes, Other Backward Castes, ethnic
minorities, tribal communities, undocumented migrant workers, stateless people or people in
refugee camps.
Trafficking occurs in a wider context of increasing instances of human rights violation against
women. These include the violation of their reproductive rights and the rights of female infants
and foetuses to live; domestic violence against women, custodial violence against women,
violence against women in markets and other public places; the violation of women’s rights to
decision-making and to land assets and other resources (Sanghera, 1999; Karmakar, 2001; Asian
Development Bank, 2002; Raymond et. Al.). In ‘cases where their families or guardians push
women or girls into trafficked circumstances, many do not consider this as harmful, as they are
considered chattels of their father or guardian and further protection from their community
would be inappropriate’ (Asian Development Bank, 2002). Instances of male relatives making
periodic visits to collect a girl’s earnings have been reported (Nirmala Niketan, College of Social
Work, 2003). Thus, there is a non-recognition and non-acceptance of such practices as being
exploitative. Early marriage, lack of choice regarding marriage partner and their socialization
into women who remain servile and bear injustice silently are other factors that render them more
vulnerable (Asian Development Bank, 2002). Sanghera (1999) elaborates how the feminization
of poverty and migration increases vulnerability to traffickers. Driven by the pressing need for
gainful employment, with scarcity of jobs in their home bases, women and children are easy prey
for the designs of unscrupulous agents, offering choices and assistance with travel, particularly
across borders, for jobs.
Sex tourism has also become a problem in Kerala, which has witnessed a tourist boom since
the early ‘80s. The National Geographic has listed Kerala as one of the world’s fifty ‘Must see
destinations. Along with the growth of tourism, there has been an increasing victimization of
young children. DARSHAN, an NGO group, has made a research study of the problems of sex
tourism in Kerala. The study mentions that the Kerala Women’s Commission received numerous
letters of complaint from women tourists, about sex tourism in Kovalam. They even rescued 11
girls belonging to Lambada community of Karnataka from Kovalam in October, 1998. Brothels
also arrange package tours to tourist destinations for their customers. The research paper contains
case studies showing the exploitation of trafficked females at the hands of the tourists. In one
case, a girl was deceived by the promise of a job and forced into commercial sexual exploitation.
She perforce had to accompany local tourists to various places like Ooti, Nelliampathy and
other places and satisfy their sexual urges. The clients paid the victim well. Darshan’s study also
reveals how hoteliers in areas like Qullion, Alleppy, Ernakulam promote sex tourism, because
such services bring them extra income. Victims are often projected by the agents as college girls
in search of fun and excitement, wanting to earn an extra buck. In places like Alleppy, foreign
tourists come and stay in houseboats. This houseboat sex tourism is a new and thriving concept.
It is safe, as there are no raids on the houseboats (Patkar & Patkar, 2002). In Kerala, although
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 71

places like Kovalam and Fort Cochin have become sex tourism hot spots, police records indicate
that enforcement agencies have turned a blind eye to the problem and cases have seldom been
registered under the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act. The study mentions the case of a ‘sex
worker’ from Mangalore and Goa who shifted her operations to Varkala, a major tourist spot,
because of the growth of sex tourism. She earns well from sex work and possesses houses and
vehicles of her own. She says that there is demand for sex not only from foreign tourists but also
among the locals, including a number of political figures. With the accent on tourism promotion,
bars and pubs have proliferated in different tourist destinations. A study of trafficked bar girls
around Mumbai conducted by two NGO groups – Save our Sisters (SOS) and VEDH – reveal a
very disturbing picture. There are about 2,000 bars in Greater Mumbai, where a large number
of the girls work, averaging about 50 girls per bar. Thus, there are now approximately one
lakh bar girls in Greater Mumbai alone. Most of the bar girls come from Bangladesh, Nepal as
well as different cities in India. The ‘push’ factors are mainly economic, such as sale of family
land, debt, expenditure on marriages and lack of any other skills. A number of girls who were
interviewed said that natural disasters like flood, drought etc. force them to leave their homes.
In a majority of the cases, male family members made the decision to send them to Mumbai, and
the girls usually had no choice. 75 per cent of the bar girls are under 25 years of age. Trafficked
persons are reportedly traumatized by their experiences. Depression and suicidal thoughts are
commonly reported. The mental and emotional state of the survivors may include malevolence,
helplessness and withdrawal; disassociation; self-blame and identification with the aggressor;
distraction; a foreshortened view of time; normalization and shaping, whereby the victims
convince themselves that their experiences had to happen instead of viewing them as traumatic
(Saarthak, 2002). Some of the psychiatric disorders among survivors of trafficking are listed as
posttraumatic stress disorder, depressive disorder, dissociative disorders, psychotic disorders
and eating disorders. Girls are made to bear the responsibility of upholding the family honour
through their sexual purity/chastity (ISS, 2003). If they are trafficked into commercial sexual
exploitation, they face additional stress because of the prevalent morality.
According to ‘Report on Trafficking in Women and Children India’ by Sen and Nair, 2004 ( p.
440.), the overall major trends are:
a. Trafficking major purpose is commercial sexual exploitation
b. There is a repeated preference for younger children and inclusion of men.
c. Trafficking is becoming extremely lucrative business, sometimes exceedingly doing well
than arms and drug trafficking.
d. There is strong nexus between traffickers and public officials with the participation of
corporate, sex and tourism industry.
e. Majority of women and children are trafficked through deception and false promises
Research Study on Human Right Violation of Victims of Trafficking in Delhi Conducted by
Social Action Forum for Manvaadhikar-SAFMA (2006), sponsored by NCW studied the limitations
faced by the CSWs in accessing the legal system and found that the laws are ultimately harmful
to both the CSWs and public because they reinforce and encourage negative double standards
regarding what is or is not acceptable female behaviour. Acceptable female sexual behaviour
is much more narrowly defined than male sexual behaviour and reflects societal bias against
sexually promiscuous women as opposed to our tolerance of sexually promiscuous men. Singh
 72

and Pandey (2008) in their research study on children depending on female sex workers in Uttar
Pradesh highlighted that young child of prostitutes and erstwhile prostitutes are more vulnerable
to sexual exploitation. The traffickers lure poor and vulnerable young women for trafficking and
sexual exploitation. Ghosh, Biswajit. (2009). Trafficking in women and children in India: nature,
dimensions and strategies for prevention. The International Journal of Human Rights. 13. 716-
738. 10.1080/13642980802533109. Trafficking in women and children is one of the worst abuses
of human rights. But it is very difficult to estimate the scale of the phenomenon as trafficking is
closely related to child labour, bonded labour, child marriage, kidnapping and abduction and
prostitution even though these phenomena can exist also independent of trafficking. This paper
has attempted to analyze the nature, causes, modes and volume of trafficking in a country that
has recently become a soft target in the South Asian region for trafficking in persons. India has
failed to comply with certain international standards to combat the crime. The paper highlights
the need to develop a multidimensional approach and focuses attention on structural factors of
trafficking for recommending meaningful stratagems to counter the social evil. Sadika Hameed,
Sandile Hlatshwayo, Evan Tanner, Meltem Türker, and Jungwon Yang (2010): Report on Human
Trafficking India: Dynamics, Current Efforts, and Intervention Opportunities-indicated that
trafficking was prevalent in destination states because of high inflow of migrants, high demand
for sex workers, generic gender/caste issues, a lack of community responsibility for social
security & welfare and the absence of strong legal framework.
Gupta et al. (2011) critically analyzed the probable measures which contribute to the increasing
danger of HIV infection amongst those who have survived sex trafficking in India. 61 case studies
of those women and girls were taken for in depth analysis that were trafficked for sexual activity
and then rescued and sent back home. These women and girls were benefiting from the services
of an NGO in Mysore. Case study analysis was done to find the prime roots and causes of the
dangerous HIV infection which made their lives miserable. The women and girls who were the
respondents of this study belonged to the age group of 14-30 years. Singh and Singh (2012) in their
edited volume on trafficking of women and children also highlighted that Nepal and Bangladesh
have emerged major source point from where a large number of young women are trafficked
into India and later on are trafficked to gulf countries. Shetty (2012) studied that development
induced displacements is a major reason for the alarmingly increasing number of trafficking
cases in Odisha. When people from the tribal populace get displaced due to the execution of
developmental projects, they are forced to migrate. While migrating, some people fall prey to
the traffickers who take immense advantage of these situations. Panda (2013) opined about the
mobility that is there among the tribal populace. The two districts in concern here are Khordha
district and Sundargarh district of Odisha. Both these districts have varying migration patterns.
Therefore, the focus was on finding out the gender-based feature and course of mobility to better
explain trafficking in persons. It was found that the tribal women from Sundargarh district were
mostly employed as domestic helps in places like New Delhi. And those from Khordha district
were seen working as wage labourers in the stone crushing sites which are found along the
highway which connects Mumbai and Chennai. Singh and Pandey (2013) have also opined that
the efforts for prevention and combating of trafficking as the problem are gradually increasing.
Mishra (2013) in his edited volume on human trafficking has attempted to examine the role of
various stakeholders in prevention and combating the human trafficking in India.
Shri S. Saratkumar Sharma (2016), Chairperson Manipur Commission For Protection of Child
Rights-Child Trafficking In The Indo-Myanmar Region: A Case Study In Manipur, reported that
During the period of 2008-2016 (till June 26), 66 reported incident of child trafficking was reported
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 73

throughout Manipur and in that 44 incident are reported from the five hill districts whereas only
22 incident are reported from the four districts of Imphal valley. The reported number of child
trafficking during the period is 530 children. It was also reported that 135 children were rescued
in the year 2010, which is the highest reported case of child trafficking in Manipur. But the cases
reported from the year 2011 till 2013 is a concern and also alarming as the number of cases are all
above 100 except 2011. This is alarming because the situation has to be read with the background
that the state mechanism to combat trafficking has already put in place particularly by the
Department of Social Welfare and Department of Home, Government of Manipur. In addition,
the Child Welfare Committees (CWC) which are constituted under the JJ Act were already in
operation since 2007 in all the district of Manipur. Vimal Vidushy (2016), Human trafficking In
India: An Analysis-It argues that the focus on trafficking either as an issue of illegal migration
or prostitution still dominates the discourse of trafficking, which prioritizes state security over
human security and does not adequately address the root causes of trafficking and the insecurity
of trafficked individuals. The root causes or vulnerability factors of trafficking such as structural
inequality, culturally sanctioned practices, poverty or economic insecurity, organ trade, bonded
labor, gender violence, which are further exacerbated by corruption, have remained unrecognized
in academic and policy areas. Roy S, Chaman C. Human rights and trafficking in women and
children in India. J His Arch & Anthropol Sci. 2017;1(5):162-170. DOI: 10.15406/jhaas.2017.01.00027
reported that Human trafficking is not occasional crime but it is rampant and affecting every state
of the country. It not only crosses national and international level but has street level occurrence
also. The victim of the trafficking can be an acquaintance and trafficker can also be a familiar
person. India in a continued seventh time remained on the Tier 2 watch list and in the Trafficking
in Persons (TIP) report 2014, which is issued by the US state department annually, received
lowest rank. This paper attempted to present the trends and dimensions of trafficking from a
human rights paradigm and demystify several issues surrounding it.
Besides being stigmatized as outcasts and facing moral and legal isolation (Giri, 1999),
trafficked people are vulnerable to HIV/AIDS infection; drug addiction; and high-risk abortions
and teenage pregnancies, which may affect their reproductive health for life. A study by an NGO
in Dhaka found that ‘more than 20 per cent of street children prostitutes die before reaching
adulthood. Almost 22 per cent become physically invalid and are fit only for begging’ (Save
Our Sisters, 2001). Psychological trauma permeates all aspects of their lives. Since it usually
remains unaddressed and unresolved, ‘the abused turn into abusers’, with a high probability
of them becoming criminals. The consequences of being in ‘child labour’ and its adverse impact
on the development of children are well documented. The victims of trafficking are compelled
to lead illegal lives. Illegality taints every dimension of their lives, converting into criminals.
Their criminalization as workers and persons severely stigmatizes them. It intensifies their
victimization several folds and leaves them with no recourse for redress (Sanghera, 2002). There
is also a viewpoint which is generally not expressed in the literature on trafficking. It argues that
there are conflicting aspects to the social impacts of trafficking, as for many women, trafficking
episodes, while causing harm, also removed them from otherwise oppressive circumstances.
Thousands of women, who have returned, but remain silent about their experiences, especially
concerning commercial Sex Worker, may have brought back not only some savings, but also
more experience of the world. Some of these women have managed to turn these experiences
into personal empowerment within their communities’ (Asian Development Bank, 2002). The
crime of trafficking involves the violation of a whole gamut of laws and human rights. It becomes
a threat to society because traffickers operate across borders with impunity, with the growing
 74

involvement of organized criminals and by generally undermining the rule of law. Trafficking
‘threatens the very fabric of society’ because it involves not only criminals but also law enforcers.
It manifests and perpetuates patriarchal attitudes and behavior, which undermine the efforts
to promote gender equality and eradicate discrimination against women and children (Asian
Development Bank, 2002). This is illustrated by reports from Albania, which ‘document villages
where nine in 10 girls over 14 stay away from school because they are afraid of being trafficked’.
Thus, this fear ‘alters the choices that girls make about their futures’ (International Labour
Organization, 2002).
A study by Asian Development Bank notes that the ‘economic losses to communities and
governments are enormous if considered in terms of lost returns on human or social capital
investments. The cost of countering criminal trafficking activities puts additional strain on the
already limited government resources for law enforcement. A vast amount of potential income
from trafficked labour is lost in ‘hidden’ sectors’ (Asian Development Bank, 2002). Specific
communities may become known as potential sources for people if following each other’s
example, communities start a trend of sending their children and women out. The loss of future
productivity and earning power through low educational levels, ill health and potentially
premature death is also felt at the country and regional level. Poor nations can ill afford to lose
their young people, whose present and future productive capacity is essential to growth…. The
ravage of disease, including HIV/AIDS, is also an enormous burden on such countries and
causes further imbalances between the young and middle-aged potential workforce (most likely
to be affected) and older people dependent on them (International Labour Organization, 2002).

RESEARCH GAPS
The analysis of the compiled bibliography on trafficking in persons suggests that the
dominant anti-trafficking discourse is not evidence-based but grounded in the construction of
particular mythology of trafficking. Despite the increased interest in human trafficking, relatively
little systematic, empirically grounded, and based on solid theoretical underpinnings research
has been done on this issue. Much of the research on human trafficking for sexual exploitation
has been conducted by activists involved in anti-prostitution campaigns. Research on human
trafficking for labor exploitation is disconnected from theory as well. There are few attempts
to analyze issues of cross-border trafficking for labor exploitation within existing international
migration theories. There is also no attempt to develop a new theoretical framework in which
to comprehensively analyze the phenomenon. Poverty and the aspiration for a better way
of life are by far the most discussed ‘push factors and principal reasons for explaining why
women and, in particular, children are at risk for trafficking. Similarly, to theoretical approaches,
development of innovative methodologies to study human trafficking is also in its infancy.
Reliance on unrepresentative samples is widespread. Most studies relay on interviews with
‘key stakeholders.’ Studies that do include interviews with victims are limited to very small
samples. There is a need to emphasize the limitations of small samples for generalizations and
extrapolations, while at the same time stressing the value of ethnographic investigations for
formulating hypotheses for further studies, including preparation of survey questionnaires.
Predominant methodologies include qualitative data collection techniques, mainly interviews.
Victims’ and stakeholders’ narratives are important but need to be augmented by participant
observation. Participant observation is needed, but difficult. The main obstacle to conducting
empirical qualitative research on human trafficking is related to gaining access to trafficked
persons. There is a need to facilitate researchers’ access to victims while protecting victims who
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 75

are willing to participate in research projects. In order to acquire the broadest possible picture
of the trafficking phenomenon, several different data collection methods, including quantitative
and qualitative methods, need to be tested. There is a need for both quantitative and qualitative
research that would provide both macro-and micro-level understanding of the trafficking
phenomenon. Rigorous ethnographic and sociological studies based on in-depth interviews with
trafficking survivors would provide baseline data on trafficking victims and their characteristics.
Too often victims of trafficking remain one-dimensional figures whose stories are condensed
and simplified, which does not bode well for the development of culturally appropriate
services. In order to develop appropriate assistance and treatment programs for trafficking
survivors, increased attention needs to be paid to the expertise and practical knowledge of non-
governmental organizations (NGOs) and their experience in working with different groups of
trafficking survivors, including women, men, and children.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

The present study has been conducted keeping in view of the following main objectives:
• To review the legal and policy perspective of human trafficking and role of various
stakeholders in prevention, combating, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and
their reintegration in family and society;
• To study the magnitude, nature, dimensions, causes and modus operandi of trafficking of
women and children in India;
• To assess the functioning and performance of Ujjawala Centers in terms of prevention
and combating of trafficking, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their
reintegration in society and family;
• To examine the background of trafficked victims and their rehabilitation and reintegration
in society and family;
• To appraise the government, private and civil society initiatives, interventions and
efforts in prevention, combating, rescue and rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their
reintegration in family and society;
• To suggest policy measures for prevention and combating of trafficking, rescue and
rehabilitation of trafficked victims and their reintegration in society and family.

RESEARCH QUESTIONS
The present study has been conducted keeping in view of the following research questions:
• Whether poverty, backwardness and illiteracy are the major factors responsible for human
trafficking?
• Whether poor women and girls are more vulnerable for human trafficking in the backward
regions, international border areas and tourists’ destinations?
• Whether cultural traditions, rituals and practices among tribal communities encourage
prostitution and trafficking of young women for trade of human flash?
• Whether civil society organizations, NGOs, corporate houses and various government
organizations are making serious efforts to prevent and combat the human trafficking for
human flash?
 76

• Whether Ujjawala Scheme, government and non- government initiatives and efforts are
effective in prevention and combating as well as rescue, rehabilitation and reintegration
of trafficked victims in family and society?

SCOPE OF THE STUDY

The present study is an attempt to make an enquiry into the various facets of Trafficking
of Women and Children in India. The scope of the present study is both wide and narrow. It
is wide because it covers all the Stakeholders of Trafficking, involved in combating Trafficking
and welfare of victims. The scope of the study could also be viewed as narrow for it covers only
women and Children. This need not be a limitation of the study as an in-depth enquiry lends
itself to incisive analysis and comprehensive coverage to get better insight into the issue relating
to trafficking.

RESEARCH DESIGN & METHODOLOGY

Research Design
In order to respond to the objectives, the study has followed the combined methodological
approach of quantitative supplemented by qualitative methodology. It is an exploratory study
with the integration of Primary and Secondary Data. The present study is empirical in nature
and is based mainly on primary data collected through field survey. Besides survey and analysis
of primary data, secondary data and pertinent literature have been compiled from published and
documented sources for getting insights on the topic of the research.
The study has focused on National Perspective however; the field survey was confined to the
states of Assam, West Bengal, Jharkhand and Uttar Pradesh as Source of Trafficking AND Delhi,
Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka as Destination of Trafficking. The selection of States
is based on highest number of cases registered under Human Trafficking Laws and Number
of Victims as Reported by NCRB data. The districts were selected on the basis of reported
trafficking cases under ITPA and other relevant trafficking laws by the Anti Human Trafficking
Units in CID/Crime Branch of the respective States and on discussions with the key officials of
the State AHTU.

Universe of the Study

All the victims of Trafficking and their parents, inmates of all the Short Stay Home
running under Ujjawala, Child Line, and Swadhar Greh scheme, All the responsible officials
of organizations running Ujjawala and Swadhar Greh, All State and District Level Officers of
the Departments responsible for prevention and combating of trafficking of women and girl
children; various other stakeholders such as victim families, Women and Child rights based
NGOs; civil society activist, government official dealing with the issues of child, police officials,
member of SCWs, CWCs, JJBs and NCPCR etc. Besides, civil societies, NGOs, organizations
and other stakeholders who are not supported by Ministry of Women and Child Development,
Government of India but are active in prevention and combating human trafficking from all the
eight selected states namely Assam, West Bengal, Jharkhand, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi, Maharashtra,
Tamil Nadu and Karnataka of India have constituted the Universe of the Study. The operators
of brothels, traffickers, other persons engaged in human trafficking and other networks working
for prevention and combating of trafficking of women and children active in selected states will
also been included in the universe of the study.
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 77

RESEARCH SETTING:
Present study is mainly empirical in nature and based on primary data. Besides, collection and
analysis of primary data, secondary data and pertinent literature has been compiled, analyzed
and reviewed accordingly. Both dependent and independent variables have been identified for
the quantitative & qualitative analysis of data and information.

SAMPLE DESIGN
The trafficked victims were contacted in brothels for interview and the trafficking survivors
in Shelter Home in each selected district. In view of the criminal nature of trafficking, both
purposive and convenience sampling has been adopted. Purposive sampling has been used to
select the Law Enforcement Agencies/police personnel from IGP/ACP to Sub Inspector Level,
Chairperson and Members of CWCs, DCPOs, Public Prosecuting Officers/APOs, Officials of
NGOs/CBOs/Service Providers, Officials of Department of Women and Child Development,
Social Welfare and Labour Department, Officials of SCWs/SHRC/SCPCR and Shelter Homes
for interview.
The Sex Workers Victims have been identified through Respondent-driven sampling (RDS),
combines “snowball sampling” (getting individuals to refer those they know, these individuals
in turn refer those they know and so on). As for as possible randomness has been maintained.
Therefore, a statistically representative sample has been drawn of an unrepresentative part of the
target population, so conclusions can be validly made about the entirety of the target population.
Representative Random Sampling method has been adopted to interview the Parents of the
Victims and the victims from the Shelter Homes & their Homes. Since the traffickers were the most
elusive category, snowball sampling method has been adopted in their selection. The method
of saturation point has been used to discontinue the data collection process for the qualitative
process.

Stakeholders/Units of Inquiry Identified for the Research Study:

Various stakeholders such as victims and their parents, Traffickers & Brothel operators, Clients
of CSWs, Public Prosecutors, Child rights-based NGOs; civil society activist, government official
dealing with the issues of child, police officials, Officials and Non-Officials of organizations
running Ujjawala and Swadhar Greh and member of SCWs, CWCs and NCPCR (State CPCR)
etc. have been the part of our sample. State Level Committee to Combat Human Trafficking, Anti
Human Trafficking Units in all the districts by the state Home Department (under the guidelines
of the Ministry Home Affairs, Government of India (GoI), Anti-Trafficking Squads at the State
and District level by the Department of women and Child Welfare have also been consulted and
interviewed (Table: 3.1)
Table: 3.1
Geographical Coverage of the Research Study
Name of States Name of Districts Visited
Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, Kanpur, Ayodhya, Gorakhpur, Mahrajganj, Varanasi, Ghaziabad, Gautam Budh Nagar
Jharkhand Ranchi, Dhanbad, Khunti, Gumla, Latehar, Simdega, Lohardaga, Pakur, Hazaribagh
West Bengal Kolkata, Howrah, North 24 Parganas, South 24 Parganas, Jalpaiguri, Darjeeling, Uttar Dinajpur
Kamrup Metro, Kamrup Rural, Nagon, Dhubri, Goalpara, Lakhimpur, Tinsukia, Dhemaji, Sonitpur,
Assam
Dibrugarh, Hojai, Sivsagar
 78

Maharashtra Mumbai, Palghar, Pune, Thane, Solapur, Sangli, Nasik,

Karnataka Bengaluru Urban, Bengaluru Rural, Tumkur, Ramanagara, Chitadurga, Mandya, Bellari, Belagavi,
Chennai, Thiruvarur, Madurai, Kanyakumari, Thanjavur, Rameswaram, Ramanathapuram,
Tamil Nadu
Tiruvannamalai, Pattukkotai
Delhi New Delhi, South Delhi, North Delhi, Central Delhi, West Delhi, North West Delhi, East Delhi

Conceptual Clarity
As per National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR), a child includes those
up to the age of 18 years, however as per the Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act,
1986, a child is defined as a person who has not completed 14 years of age.

SAMPLE SIZE OF THE RESEARCH STUDY

The size of the sample varies from the state to state. The sample, although has been stratified,
but randomization was not permissible in view of the criminal nature of trafficking (Table 3.2,
Table 3.3 and Table 3.4).
Table: 3.2
Details of Stakeholders

Sample
S. No Stakeholder Subcategory
Size
Victims of Trafficking-Women & Children and their Parents
(Survivors- rescued trafficked victims of CSE, trafficked non-rescued victims of Victims 1155
1
commercial sexual exploitation and rescued trafficked child labourer,): Proposed
Sample: 1255 Parents 411
Total 1566
Law Enforcement
93
Officials and non- officials including police personnel, representatives of local Agencies
governments and civil society organizations and other stakeholders who are active Programms
in prevention and combating of human trafficking and rescue, rehabilitation, and 255
2 Administrators
reintegration of trafficked victims in family and society, member of CWCs, JJBs and
NCPCR, SHRC, State Anti-Trafficking Committee, District Anti Trafficking Committee Civil Society
24
etc., Proposed Sample: 400 Organizations
Public Prosecutors 29
Total 401

Traffickers 49
Operators of brothels, traffickers, Clientele and other persons engaged in human
3 Brothel Operators 47
trafficking; Proposed Sample: 150
Clients 63
Total 159
Ujjawala Homes 29
Swadhar Greh 26
Officials of organizations running Ujjawala and Swadhar Greh or short stay homes, Short Stay homes 16
4 Children Homes run under JJ Act/ICPS.
Proposed sample: 120 Children Homes 23
One Stop Centers 13
CCIs 16
Total 123
5 Officials of District Child Protection Unit, Child Line Service, Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS), 25
6 Focused Group Discussions (FGDs) with all Stake holders of the scheme at state level. 56
Grand Total (2000) 2324
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 79

Table: 3.3
State Wise Vs Stakeholders Wise Sample Covered

Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand

Karnataka
Pradesh

Assam

Delhi
Uttar

Total
States

Stakeholder
Victims-Rescued 180 13 151 125 100 96 98 52 815
Sex Workers 0 98 0 75 75 10 20 62 340
Parents 104 1 76 104 39 43 44 0 411
Service Providers 3 7 17 29 32 11 14 34 147
Law Enforcement Agencies 7 10 6 21 15 2 3 29 93
Programms Administrators 47 46 35 25 18 33 34 42 280
Traffickers 28 7 0 0 0 0 0 14 49
Brothel Operators 0 0 0 15 12 0 0 20 47
Clients 0 0 0 18 25 0 0 20 63
Public Prosecutors 5 6 3 4 6 2 3 0 29

Table: 3.4
State wise Details of Focused Group Discussions (FGDs)

No. of FGDs No. of Participants Per

Name of State Types of Participants/ Stakeholders
Conducted FGD
Service Providers 1 7

Law EAs 2 7

Victims 2 10
Jharkhand
Parents 2 11
Programms Administrators 1 8
Total 8
Service Providers 1 6
Law EAs 2 6
Uttar Pradesh Victims 1 12
Programms Administrators 2 8
Total 6
Service Providers 2 9
Law EAs 2 8
Victims 2 11
Assam
Parents 1 9
Programms Administrators 2 8
Total 9
 80

Service Providers 3 11
Law EAs 1 6
Victims 2 11
West Bengal
Parents 2 10
Programms Administrators 2 6
Total 10
Service Providers 2 8
Law EAs 2 8
Victims 2 11
Maharashtra
Parents 1 12
Programms Administrators 3 7
Total 10
Service Providers 2 8
Law EAs 1 8
Tamil Nadu Victims 1 11
Programms Administrators 1 8
Total 5
Service Providers 1 15
Law EAs 1 8
Karnataka Victims 1 11
Programms Administrators 1 8
Total 4
Service Providers 1 7
Law EAs 1 8
Delhi Victims 1 12
Programms Administrators 1 8
Total 4
Grand Total 56

METHODS FOR DATA COLLECTION:

Primary data has been obtained through canvassing interview schedules, focus group
discussions, case studies and non-participant observation. Interviewing, an interactive method
of data collection, has been used mostly in collecting qualitative data. The data & information
from various stakeholders has been collected through pre-structured Interview Schedules and
Questionnaires. A different pre-structured format (Interview Schedules) was designed for
different stakeholders in consultation with NHRC. Secondary Data has been collected on a pre-
structured Format. The questions related to the role, functions, challenges, problem areas as well
as suggestions for improving the existing scenario. The interview method was also used to access
information from the functionaries and residents of the state homes regarding quality of services
delivered and numbers rehabilitated, followed up etc.

TOOLS FOR DATA COLLECTION

The field survey has been conducted with the help of structured interview schedules. We
developed a set of interview schedules for the interview of following stakeholders: -
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 81

1. Victims of Trafficking-Women and Children

2. Parents of Victims
3. Programms Administrators (Officials of Members of SHRCs, SCWs, CWCs and NCPCR,
Officials of Department of Women and Child Development, Social Welfare and Labour
Department, Officials of SCWs/SHRC/SCPCR etc.)
4. Law Enforcement Agencies
5. Service Providers/CBOs/NGOs
6. Operators of brothels, traffickers and other persons engaged in human trafficking
7. Clients of CSWs
8. Public Prosecutors/APOs
9. Observations and Focused Group Discussions (FGDs) with all Stakeholders.

SOURCE OF SECONDARY DATA

The main sources of secondary data and pertinent literature included the publications and
documents of state governments, Central Government and non-government organizations.
Academic institutions such as universities, colleges, research institutes and various departments of
government and non-government were consulted for collection of secondary data and literature.
The Reports of Department/ Directorate of Home Affairs, MoWCD, CWCs, NCPCR, NCRB,
UNDP, UNODC, Asian Development Bank, World Bank, International Labour Organization,
UNICEF, ECOSOC, IOM, NHRC, UNIFEM etc. have been widely consulted.

PROCESSING & ANALYSIS OF DATA

The filled in interview schedules was thoroughly checked, edited and processed in computer
on SPSS 22.0 package for the analysis. Inferences, results and conclusions has been drawn out
from the analysis of data. The data in tabular form has been analyzed, interpreted and discussed
in the respective chapters. The interpretation of the primary data has been carried out keeping
in view the overall perspective of the study and by comparing and correlating data, wherever
possible. Efforts have been made to integrate the quantitative and qualitative data. The analysis is
based on the frequency distribution of the data obtained. After tabulating the data, the frequency
numbers and their corresponding percentages has been calculated.
Analysis of the qualitative information has involved undertaking a systematic thematic
analysis of the qualitative data using a framework approach whereby both a priori and
emerging themes were synthesized by tabulating them in a common analytic framework. For
the study, both dependent and independent variables were identified for the analysis of data
and information. Again age, education, caste, religion, geographical background, income levels,
occupation of family, ecological background, etc. have been considered for the analysis of data.
The policy recommendations are based on the analysis of research findings, observations and
critical appreciation of pertinent literature.

RECRUITMENT AND TRAINING OF FIELD STAFFS/INVESTIGATORS

Interviews have been conducted by teams, each of which consisted of two persons – with at
least one female. In view of the sensitive nature of the data to be collected from the respondents,
 82

the interviewers were given adequate orientation to facilitate their work. A background note
was prepared by BIRD and was circulated to all the field research partners/Team Members to
sensitize them about the objectives and scope of the research. This note dealt with the programme
of work, expectations of the study, the time frame and the responsibility of the various members/
partners in research. In order to familiarize the field researchers with the interview schedules
and the methods of data collection, a four days training programme was organized at in Each
State. The research methodology experts of Study Team, who prepared the interview schedules,
conducted the training of the field staff- explaining the tools and instruments, the methods of
data collection, the necessity of being sensitive towards the respondents, etc. After Pilot Testing
of Research Tools, the same was printed.
Monitoring & Reporting Mechanism: The Principal Investigator, Coordinator along with
NHRC Officials of the Study were regularly updated about the progress of the research and
feedback was taken from them regarding crucial decisions taken in connection with the project.
This was done through monthly review meetings and continuous exchanges. For Monitoring
of Field Visits and in order to ensure quality data collection exercise, eminent researchers such
as Professors/HOD, Govt. Officials and head of prominent NGOs were identified as State
Coordinators and were actively involved in the study. These researchers continuously monitored
the field staffs and ensured the quality of data.

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY:

Government of India under the Ministry of Women and Child Development has implemented
a comprehensive scheme for prevention, combating of trafficking, rescue and rehabilitation
of trafficked victims and their reintegration in the family and society. However, effective
implementation of the scheme could not be ensured due to various factors. The plan of action on
the part of various state governments, non-government organizations and donor agencies also
could not witness the desired results due to ineffective enforcement of legislation and governance
of programmes and schemes. Against this view point, this study has been conducted to examine the
issue of human trafficking and the efforts for protection of women and girl children against trafficking for
trade of human flash as well as to examine the implementation of various shelter and Rehabilitation Homes
such as Ujjawala P & R Homes & Swadhar Greh, Children Homes etc. in selected states. The present
study would be of immense importance for policy implications and also for operational view
point as it will provide academic inputs for better understanding of the socio-legal issue and a
road map for protection of women and girls against trafficking and rehabilitation of trafficked
victims.

LIMITATION OF THE STUDY:

Though fairly large number of source and destination states and districts has been covered in
the sample but due to time and resource especially budget constraints, the study had its limitation
in covering other regional states where incidence of human trafficking is high. Due to Covid-19
period from the beginning of study, the reference period of the study stretched lengthy, 2-3 times
filed work was discontinued and most of the stakeholder especially Law Enforcement Agencies,
Prosecuting Agencies and Programs Administrators preferred on line mode of interview instead
of face to face /physical interview. Due to Covid-19 restrictions we were not able to take the
views and opinions of Members of Judiciary only Public Prosecutors showed their willingness to
participate in the study that to in on-line mode. We faced a lot of problem in getting permissions
from selected State Governments for visiting the shelter homes due to Covid-19 restrictions and
Rationale, Objectives and Research Methodology 83

it consumed a lot of time and efforts of the Research Team.

CHALLENGES FACED IN THE FIELD

Being the nature of study explorative one and exploration was for a clandestine activity, it
was a great challenge to identify and locate a respondent especially traffickers, clients, CSWs
and brothel keepers/operators. In the case of rescued victims (former victims of CSE or child
labourers), some were found in rescue homes but the researchers had to search for reintegrated/
repatriated trafficked ‘survivors’ in the places they had been rehabilitated. For identification
and location of rescued victims, traffickers and brothel operators the help of some credible
NGOs and Police/Prosecuting officials was taken. Once the respondents were located, it was
a herculean task to gain their confidence and to assure them that their identities would not be
revealed. Suspicion and fear created an atmosphere which acted as a barrier to truthful response.
It required considerable ingenuity and perseverance on the part of the interviewers to coax them
to part with information relevant to the study and to assure them of anonymity. Many times,
interviews had to be rescheduled, postponed and even repeated.
Interviewing victims who were still trapped in commercial sexual exploitation was the most
difficult. Segregating the trafficked victims from the non-trafficked ones in the brothels was
certainly no simple matter. Moreover, as they were under the complete control of the exploiters,
it was not easy to get them to speak the truth. The researchers had to make repeated visits to
the brothels to interview some of the victims as they were busy with their ‘clientele’ and did
not want to be disturbed. Clients would walk in even during the ‘lean’ periods and would get
preference to anything else. The interviewers had to adjust to such breaks in the interviews
and be patient enough to wait for the interviewee’s convenience. The only positive thing was
that when respondents were told that this research is being carried out by NHRC, only then
they showed their willingness to participate in the research and agreed to share their views and
opinions/information.
 Chapter 4
TRAFFICKED VICTIMS AND THEIR
EXPLOITATION
M ore people are falling prey to human trafficking each year than ever before, particularly in
the case of women and children. Many factors contribute to the rise of this worldwide issue.
Rich and poor countries alike are affected by it. Women and children are trafficked in India for
three reasons: (a) commercial sexual exploitation, (b) exploitative labour, and (c) various forms
of exploitation such as organ sales, begging, and camel jockeying. A cursory examination of the
available records and reports on human trafficking reveals that trafficked women and children
are forced to engage in activities such as prostitution in brothels, massage parlours, or beer bars,
pornography, dancing, petty crimes, domestic help, agricultural labour, begging, camel jockeying,
organ trafficking, and drug trafficking, as well as after they have been trafficked. The surge in
trafficking of young women and girls has been attributed to the rapid growth of sex tourism
and the growing need for cheap labour in the globalized globe. Women are bartered at different
values depending on their physical beauty and virginity. Some clients in the sex industry prefer
girl children who are thought to be AIDS-free. As a result, the sex business is always looking for
young girls, sometimes as young as ten years old. Trafficking for exploitative labour occurs in a
variety of industries, including agriculture, the domestic sector, the entertainment business, and
construction work. Some boys are trafficked to West Asia or the Persian Gulf States to work as
camel jockeys. During the Hajj, some pilgrims end up as beggars in Saudi Arabia. Young girls are
trafficked to meet the demand for brides in Northern India, where the number of girl children is
lower.
According to the NCRB, girls and women are the predominant targets of immoral trafficking
in India, accounting for 76 percent of all human trafficking instances over the last decade (26
Aug, 2015, IndiaSpend.com-Chaitanya Mallapur- Minor Girls, Women Chief Targets as Human
Trafficking Surges-Human Trafficking in India Over the Past 10 Years, NCRB Report 2015, Munshi
2020). Women and girls represent 72 per cent of all trafficking victims globally, and 77 per cent of
detected female victims are trafficked for the purpose of sexual exploitation (UN Women Deputy
Executive Director, Tuesday, 8 December 2020). Women and children are increasingly being
victimised by sex trafficking in tiny motels, automobiles, and private residences, in addition to
typical red-light districts. Human trafficking for sexual exploitation is shifting away from brothels
and into non-brothels. Websites, mobile apps, and online money transfers are increasingly being
used by traffickers to arrange commercial sex. In religious pilgrimage centres and tourism areas,
children are still susceptible to sex trafficking. Poverty, unemployment, illiteracy, family financial
issues, rape, kidnapping and abduction, allured for marriage purposes, superstitions, frenzy to
 86

enter the entertainment sector such as TV serials, media, and movies are all factors that contribute
to the flesh trade. The age of women/girls entering prostitution has been steadily decreasing over
the last decade, which is extremely concerning. (2012-13 Prajwala Annual Report, Cunningham,
Fiona & Jacquin, Kristine. (2018). Age of Entry into Sex Work is a Myth, Rana, U., Sharma, D. &
Ghosh, D. Prostitution in northern Central India: an ethnographical study of Bedia community
(2020).
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the appeal matter of Buddhdev Karmasker V/S
State of West Bengal (Criminal Appeal No(s).135/2010- Judgement Date: August 02, 2011) had
directed the State government and Central government to prepare schemes for women and girls
in prostitution on following issues (1) Prevention of trafficking; (2) Rehabilitation of sex workers
who wish to give up sex work and (3) Creating conditions conducive for sex workers to live with
dignity. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India directed the state /Union Territory to carry out survey
through their agencies and assess if sex worker given an opportunity would opt for rehabilitation
or whether they would choose to continue in the profession voluntarily.
The use of the internet to spread violence and criminality has become a big problem around the
world. Women and children are the most vulnerable and targeted demographics. Blackmailing,
exploitation, harassment, stalking, voyeurism, and other types of violence against women and
children are becoming more common on digital platforms. For fear of social stigmatisation, a
considerable percentage of such occurrences go unreported. This also permits perpetrators of
such abuse to get away with it. In order to address the problem of trafficking holistically, a
comprehensive policy as well as its action plan covering various aspects such as prevention of
trafficking, victim rescue, repatriation to their native place, economic empowerment, health care,
education, housing, legal reforms, and the creation of a corpus fund is the need of the hour.

Magnitude of Human Trafficking:

According to the 2020 Global Report on Human Trafficking, 50% of victims were trafficked for
sexual exploitation in 2018, 38% for forced labour, 6% for forced criminal activity, 1% for begging,
and smaller amounts for forced marriages, organ removal, and other purposes. Detected kinds of
exploitation varies greatly amongst subregions. For more than a decade, the number of victims
identified as being trafficked for forced labour has continuously climbed. Trafficking for forced
criminal behaviour is the most commonly recognized form of trafficking, aside from trafficking
for forced labour or sexual exploitation. Around 6% of all victims found around the world are
used to commit crimes ranging from pickpocketing to drug cultivation and trafficking. In 2018,
13 countries in Europe, South Asia, Africa, and the Americas reported this type of trafficking
(trafficking for exploitation in criminal enterprises - a double victimization). Trafficking for the
purpose of exploitative begging is a less well-known form of trafficking. In 2018, 19 nations from
all corners of the globe reported occurrences of this type of trafficking, accounting for more than
1% of all detected victims. North Africa and the Middle East have the highest numbers of victims
of this type of trafficking, accounting for almost 30% of all victims discovered in the region.
Trafficking victims for the purpose of forced marriage are less common, with only nine nations
across various regions reporting cases, accounting for around 1% of the global total. Similarly,
mixed types of exploitation, in which victims of human trafficking are exploited for both forced
labour and sexual exploitation, account for around 1% of all victims identified. A few examples of
trafficking of pregnant women and/or newborns, both for the goal of illegal adoption, have also
been documented in a number of nations. (UNODC, Global Report on Human Trafficking, 2020).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 87

Victims of human trafficking might be of any age, gender, or nationality. Female victims
remain the major targets, according to the UNODC’s 2020 Global Report on Trafficking in
Persons, which is based on official data from over 148 countries. According to the report, women
made up 46 percent of the victims in 2018, while girls made up 19 percent. In the case of male
victims, the report states that 20% of those found were males and 15% were boys. Over the
last 15 years, the proportion of minors among recognized trafficking victims has tripled, while
the proportion of boys has climbed fivefold. In the world, one out of every three victims is a
youngster. Boys are primarily trafficked for forced labour, whereas girls are primarily trafficked
for sexual exploitation. The percentage of male victims found has increased from 10% in 2003
to 20% in 2018. According to the UNODC Report 2020, female victims of human trafficking
continue to be disproportionately affected. In 2018, roughly five adult women and two girls were
found for every ten victims worldwide. Children, both girls and boys, made up around a third
of the total casualties, while adult men made up 20%. 95 percent of trafficked people in India are
pushed into prostitution, according to statistics (Divya, 2020). According to the NCRB, there are
a total of 6,616 human trafficking instances documented in India, with sex trafficking being the
most common (Munshi, 2020)
The rise in human trafficking has put the country’s social fabric at jeopardy. Girls under the
age of 18 are being enticed to Indian metropolises from Nepal and Bangladesh. Girls and young
women from Assam, West Bengal, Bihar, Rajasthan, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh,
and Uttar Pradesh are also targeted by traffickers. False promises of better jobs and living
conditions drive many young ladies into prostitution. The issue is not only sensitive, but also
serious. Commercial exploitation of women’s and children’s vulnerabilities has become a multi-
million-dollar organized crime ring. A link between HIV/AIDS, human trafficking, and other
sexually transmitted illnesses has also been discovered in several research.
Between 2017 and 2019, there was a dramatic decrease in the number of trafficked children
in India. During the same time period, however, the number of trafficking women victims
climbed by 42.59 percent. During this time, the number of women trafficked victims increased
significantly in many states. Maharashtra had the highest number of victims of human trafficking
in 2019, followed by Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, and Odisha. However, Rajasthan had the
highest number of trafficked minors throughout the year, followed by Bihar, Odisha, Jharkhand,
and Kerala. According to the statistics, 3535 children and 2040 women were trafficked in 2017. In
2018, there were 2772 children and 2432 women trafficked, and in 2019, there were 2914 children
and 2907 women trafficked. (Table 4.1).
Table: 4.1
States/UT-wise Children and Women Victims of Trafficking
Year 2017 2018 2019
Sates/UTs Children Women Children Women Children Women
Andhra Pradesh 26 312 16 351 18 380
Arunachal Pradesh 0 0 3 0 4 0
Assam 187 106 238 114 80 132
Bihar 395 56 539 80 294 22
Chhattisgarh 45 26 101 74 113 94
Goa 1 74 9 93 2 88
Gujarat 2 17 1 25 2 20
 88

Haryana 9 13 26 6 6 14
Himachal Pradesh 3 12 3 13 1 14
Jammu & Kashmir 1 0 1 0 0 0
Jharkhand 331 78 218 30 172 48
Karnataka 149 89 8 178 42 112
Kerala 60 21 145 38 171 27
Madhya Pradesh 121 47 73 19 123 92
Maharashtra 134 520 73 698 95 475
Manipur 13 10 2 3 5 151
Meghalaya 3 0 22 2 30 1
Mizoram 60 2 2 1 25 27
Nagaland 0 0 0 0 2 18
Odisha 117 61 131 64 202 250
Punjab 8 2 20 7 9 8
Rajasthan 886 11 373 6 653 6
Sikkim 5 0 2 2 0 2
Tamil Nadu 37 135 8 12 43 16
Telangana 124 300 8 373 71 263
Tripura 12 2 1 0 1 1
Uttar Pradesh 38 24 41 49 32 94
Uttarakhand 15 22 18 40 16 20
West Bengal* 319 66 159 96 159 96
Total State(s) 3101 2006 2241 2374 2377 2871
A&N Islands 0 0 0 0 0 0
Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 1 1
D&N Haveli 0 0 0 0 0 0
Daman & Diu 0 3 0 0 0 0
Delhi UT 434 31 531 58 536 30
Lakshadweep 0 0 0 0 0 0
Puducherry 0 0 0 0 0 5
Total UT(s) 434 34 531 58 537 36
Total (All India) 3535 2040 2772 2432 2914 2907
Source: NCRB Data
Between 2017 and 2019, the number of women rescued increased significantly. Maharashtra,
Telangana, Odisha, and Manipur had the most number of rescued women in 2019. Rajasthan,
Bihar, Odisha, Kerala, West Bengal, and Madhya Pradesh had the highest number of rescued
children in 2019. Furthermore, in 2017, 3294 children and 2211 women were rescued, followed by
2484 children and 2466 women in 2018, and 2837 children and 2964 women in 2019. (Table 4.2).
Table: 4.2
States/UT-wise Children and Women Victims Rescued
2017 2018 2019
Sates/UTs
Children Women Children Women Children Women
Andhra Pradesh 27 371 16 437 15 410
Arunachal Pradesh 0 0 3 0 3 0
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 89

Assam 154 99 182 97 73 126

Bihar 395 56 537 73 294 22
Chhattisgarh 77 79 101 74 112 94
Goa 1 74 9 93 2 88
Gujarat 2 17 1 25 2 16
Haryana 9 14 24 5 6 14
Himachal Pradesh 2 10 0 11 1 15
Jammu & Kashmir 1 0 1 0 0 0
Jharkhand 103 44 201 19 102 39
Karnataka 149 89 8 178 42 112
Kerala 86 102 112 45 179 29
Madhya Pradesh 97 41 72 16 124 93
Maharashtra 148 482 74 693 95 917
Manipur 12 10 2 3 4 151
Meghalaya 3 0 5 2 29 0
Mizoram 0 0 2 1 25 27
Nagaland 0 0 0 0 2 18
Odisha 117 61 131 64 202 250
Punjab 7 0 15 5 18 7
Rajasthan 886 11 373 6 653 6
Sikkim 5 0 2 2 0 2
Tamil Nadu 37 135 27 22 42 16
Telangana 30 354 8 381 71 263
Tripura 12 2 1 0 2 1
Uttar Pradesh 38 28 41 45 32 98
Uttarakhand 15 22 18 40 16 20
West Bengal 450 80 154 94 154 94
Total State(s) 2863 2181 2120 2431 2300 2928
A & N Islands 0 0 0 0 0 0
Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 1 1
D & N Haveli 0 0 0 0 0 0
Daman & Diu 0 3 0 0 0 0
Delhi UT 429 27 364 35 536 30
Lakshadweep 0 0 0 0 0 0
Puducherry 2 0 0 0 0 5
Total UT(s) 431 30 364 35 537 36
Total (All India) 3294 2211 2484 2466 2837 2964
Source: NCRB Data
Total No. of Victims Trafficked and Rescued as per NCRB data during the year 2015 to 2019
has been shown in Table 4.3, Data reveals that number of persons trafficked shows a declining
trend from 2015 to 2018 but it increased during the year 2019. The reason for declining trend in
cases of human trafficking as cited by stakeholders are “Traffickers have changed their mode
of operating, discarded known routes and found new ones. In many cases, the police are not
registering cases under trafficking laws,”.
 90

Table: 4.3
Victims Trafficked & Rescued

Total No. of Victims Trafficked Total No. of Victims Rescued

Year
Below 18 Years Above 18 Years Total Below 18 Years Above 18 Years Total
2019 2914 3702 6616 2837 3734 6571
2018 2834 2954 5788 2358 2906 5264
2017 3535 2365 5900 3294 2495 5789
2016 9034 6345 15379 14183 8934 23117
2015 9127 6321 15448
Source: NCRB Reports
Note: 1. In 2016: 15 Transgender Victims Trafficked from Odisha is included and 10 Transgender Victims
Trafficked from West Bengal is included
2. Due to non-receipt of data from Assam & Jharkhand for 2018, data furnished for 2017 has been used
3. Due to non-receipt of data from West Bengal in time for 2019, data furnished for 2018 has been used.
Human trafficking is primarily used for sexual exploitation for prostitution, according to
reports (31.65 per cent). In 2019, forced labour accounted for around 17% of the overall number
of incidents. During 2016, forced labour accounted for nearly 45 percent of all human trafficking,
while sexual exploitation for prostitution accounted for 21.54 percent. However, in 2018, it was
stated that its market share was as high as 36.51 percent. Domestic servitude and post-marriage
trafficking were identified as further forms of human trafficking in 2019. (Table 4.4).
Table: 4.4
Purpose of Human Trafficking

No. of Victims Trafficked (All India)

Purpose of Human Trafficking
2019 2018 2017 2016
Forced Labour 1141 1046 1657 10509
Sexual Exploitation for Prostitution 2080 1922 1275 4980
Other forms of Sexual Exploitation 0 0 0 2590
Domestic Servitude 364 143 113 412
Forced Marriage 227 220 240 349
Petty Crimes 13 7 9 212
Child Pornography 0 154 0 162
Begging 68 21 358 71
Drug Peddling 0 0 0 8
Removal of Organs 4 6 0 2
Other reasons 2674 1745 2137 3824
Total 6571 5264 5789 23117

Source: NCRB Reports

The majority of human trafficking victims recovered were of Indian descent. However, Nepal
and Bangladesh accounted for about 5% of the rescued victims. From 0.32 percent in 2016 to 4.96
percent in 2019, this percentage has risen (Table 4.5).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 91

Table: 4.5
Nationality-wise profile of Victim Rescued under Human Trafficking

Year of Nationality
Rescue India Sri Lanka Nepal Bangladesh Other Total
2019 6198 0 228 98 47 6571
2018 5012 0 167 25 60 5264
2017 5699 0 47 17 26 5789
2016 22932 38 38 36 73 23117

Source: NCRB Reports

Note: i) 5 Transgender Victims Rescued from West Bengal is included

ii) Other includes Victims belonging to Thailand & Uzbekisthan & other Countries.
The data shows that 1,18,971, 1,15,656 and 1,19,617 children went missing in the country in
2017, 2018 and 2019 respectively, The State of West Bengal and Madhya Pradesh have reported a
maximum number of missing children from 2017-2019. The common reasons for missing children
as reported by Law Enforcement Agencies during FGDs with them are “lost the way, academic
pressure, scolding by parents, elopement, runaway, left on their own will, family circumstances,
etc.” (Table 4.6).
Table: 4.6
States/UT-wise Missing Children (Below 18 years)

S. No. States/UTs 2017 2018 2019

1. Andhra Pradesh 3616 3150 3286
2. Arunachal Pradesh 74 34 46
3. Assam 1651 2120 2067
4. Bihar 8493 12072 12404
5. Chhattisgarh 3341 4237 4460
6. Goa 45 47 62
7. Gujarat 2172 2417 1983
8. Haryana 3814 3739 3978
9. Himachal Pradesh 368 481 534
10. Jammu & Kashmir 725 800 661
11. Jharkhand 1099 993 972
12. Karnataka 3195 2864 1385
13. Kerala 1755 2153 2335
14. Madhya Pradesh 14116 15320 17058
15. Maharashtra 8581 6928 8276
16. Manipur 97 107 137
17. Meghalaya 148 163 148
18. Mizoram 1 3 0
19. Nagaland 103 97 53
20. Odisha 7446 3491 5503
21. Punjab 2724 2587 2843
22. Rajasthan 3403 3521 4697
 92

23. Sikkim 88 57 43
24. Tamil Nadu 5844 5333 5814
25. Telangana 4304 4410 4566
26. Tripura 166 198 179
27. Uttar Pradesh 5161 5704 6089
28. Uttarakhand 877 938 1103
29. West Bengal 19671 16027 16027
Total State(s) 103078 99991 106709
30. A & N Islands 43 56 55
31. Chandigarh 513 540 528
32. D & N Haveli 8 4 7
33. Daman & Diu 34 30 30
34. Delhi UT 15252 14986 12239
35. Lakshadweep 0 0 0
36. Puducherry 43 49 49
Total UT(s) 15893 15665 12908
Total (All India) 118971 115656 119617

Source: NCRB data

It is reported that Ministry of Women & Child Development has developed a national tracking
system for missing and vulnerable children which has been implemented across the country. On
June 2, 2015, the MoWCD created the ‘Khoya-Paya’ site, which allows citizens to report missing
children and sightings of their whereabouts. This website can also be used to report the details of
children who have been found. For more efficient working, the Portal has been integrated with
CCTNS. Approximately 3.80 lakh people were reported missing in 2019, with women accounting
for roughly two-thirds of the total. A considerable proportion of the total missing individuals
were unable to be located and remain unaccounted for. The Supreme Court while hearing a
case in 2013 directed police that cases of missing children should be treated as abduction
or trafficking until proven otherwise, yet to become a reality. This demonstrates that a huge
number of missing people, especially women, were coerced into the sexual exploitation trade
(Table 4.7).
Table: 4.7
Total No. of Missing and Traced Persons

Persons Missing Persons Traced

Year
Male Female Trans. Total Male Female Trans. Total
2019 132089 248397 40 380526 125558 222949 101 348608
2018 123339 223621 564 347524 122384 209852 518 332754
Back log of Previous Years 137659 161064 35 298758

Source: NCRB Reports

Note: 1. Due to non-receipt of data from West Bengal in time for 2019, Data furnished for 2018 has been used

2. Clarifications are pending from West Bengal, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya & Sikkim
Female children constituted about 71 per cent during 2019 and a significant proportion of
missing children were not traced out and it is likely to happen that these children are being
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 93

sexually exploited (Table 4.8).

Table: 4.8
Total No. of Missing and Traced Children

Children Missing Children Traced

Year
Male Female Trans. Total Male Female Trans. Total
2019 21074 52049 15 73138 21797 49436 20 71253
2018 19784 47191 159 67134 22239 48787 150 71176
Backlog of Previous Years 17759 30761 2 48522

Source: NCRB Reports

Note:
i. Due to non-receipt of data from West Bengal in time for 2019, Data furnished for 2018 has been used
ii. Clarifications are pending from West Bengal, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya & Sikkim
The BIRD study team contacted 1155 victims across eight states to learn about their status and
perceptions of rescued victims and Commercial Sex Workers (CSWs). 815 rescued victims and
340 CSWs were questioned in total. Table 4.9 shows where trafficking victims were interviewed.
Ujjawala Centres accounted for almost 20% of responders, while women victims from homes
accounted for nearly the same percentage. About 1/4th respondents were from brothels and
short stay homes.
Table: 4.9
Place of Interview of Trafficked Victims/Respondents

Particular No. of Respondents

Ujjawala Center 229 (19.8%)
Swadhar Greh 45 (3.9%)
Brothel 202 (17.5%)
Home 225 (19.5%)
Institutional Child Care Home 101 (8.7%)
Street 27 (2.3%)
Short Stay Home 82 (7.1%)
Other 116 (10.0%)
Open Shelter Home 97 (8.4%)
Transit Point 31 (2.7%)
Total 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

PROFILE OF TRAFFICKED VICTIMS

Gender of Trafficked Victims is shown in Table: 4.10A. It is crystal clear that 44.0% trafficked
victims are children and 43.94% victims are women, thus women and children constitute majority
number of persons trafficked out.
 94

Table: 4.10A
Gender of Trafficked Victims

Below 18 Years Above 18 Years Total

Gender
Male Female Total Male Female Total Male Female Total
No. of Victims 1742 1172 2914 795 2907 3702 2537 4079 6616
% 26.33 17.71 44.0 12.02 43.94 55.96 38.35 61.65% 100

Source: NCRB Report-2019

Most of victim respondents were women and children. They were mainly females (86.4 per
cent). About 2/5th respondents were from the age group of less than 18 years. About half of the
respondents were from the age group of 18 to 35 years. Majority of them were found belonging
from rural and semi-urban areas (Table 4.10B).
Table: 4.10B
Gender, Ecological Background & Age of Respondents (Victims)

Category Gender Ecological Background Age

Women and Children Male Metropolitan City <10 Years
1152 (99.7%) 154 (13.3%) 149 (12.9%) 29 (2.5%)
LGBTI People Female Rural 10-14 Years
3 (0.3%) 998 (86.4%) 714 (61.8%) 129 (11.2%)
Transgender Semi-Urban 14-16 Years
3 (0.3%) 97 (8.4%) 164 (14.2%)
Urban 16-18 Years
195 (16.9%) 175 (15.2%)
18-25 Years
260 (22.5%)
25-30 Years
148 (12.8%)
30-35 Years
141 (12.2%)
Total 35-40 Years
1155 (100%) 109 (9.4%)

Source: Field Survey

About 80 per cent respondents were from weaker section including Scheduled Caste,
Scheduled Tribes, OBCs and Minority communities. About 20 per cent respondents were from
General Caste. About 2/3rd respondents were Hindus while 20 per cent victims were Muslims
(Table 4.11).
Table: 4.11
Social Class & Religion of Respondents (Victims)

Social Class No. of Respondents Religion No. of Respondents

Schedule Castes (SC) 175 (15.2%) Hindu 759 (65.7%)
Schedule Tribes (ST) 258 (22.3%) Islam 231 (20.0%)
Other Backward Classes 275 (23.8%) Christian 22 (1.9%)
General Castes 226 (19.6%) Buddhist 12 (1.0%)
Minority 204 (17.7%) Sikh 3 (0.3%)
Others 17 (1.55) Other 128 (11.1%)
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 95

Total 1155 (100%) Total 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

About 2/3rd respondents were unmarried, divorced, widows and abandoned. However,
about 30 per cent respondents were married. About 28 per cent respondents were illiterate
while more than half of the respondents were primary and matriculation pass. Thus, a
negligible proportion of respondents were found intermediates and graduates (4 per cent)
(Table 4.12).
Table: 4.12
Marital Status & Educational Level of Respondents (Victims)

Marital Status No. of Respondents Education Level No. of Respondents

Married 350 (30.3%) Illiterate 322 (27.9%)
Separated 37 (3.2%) Primary 307 (26.6%)
Abandoned 13 (1.1%) Middle School 337 (29.2%)
Divorced 26 (2.3%) High School 142 (12.3%)
Widow 19 (1.6%) Intermediate 32 (2.8%)
Unmarried 710 (61.5%) Graduate 11 (1.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) Postgraduate 4 (0.3%)

Source: Field Survey

The educational levels were found comparatively low among the sex workers as compared
to rescued victims. However, about 20 per cent rescued victims were educated high school and
above levels (Table 4.13).
Table: 4.13
Category of Respondents wise Educational Level of Trafficked Victims
Middle High
Category of Respondent Illiterate Primary Intermediate Graduate Postgraduate Total
School School
194 234 215 130 28 11 3 815
Rescued Victims
23.8% 28.7% 26.4% 16.0% 3.4% 1.3% 0.4% 100%
128 73 122 12 4 0 1 340
Sex Workers
37.6% 21.5% 35.9% 3.5% 1.2% 0.0% 0.3% 100%
322 307 337 142 32 11 4 1155
Total
27.9% 26.6% 29.2% 12.3% 2.8% 1.0% 0.3% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Types of Family wise Level of supply side reasons/Human Trafficking has been shown in
Table 4.14. The value of chi-square indicating that the Level of Supply side reasons of trafficking
and Family type having significant relation.
Table 4.14
Level of Supply side reasons of trafficking Vs Type of Family you belong
Type of Family you belong
Level of Supply side reasons of
No One in her Total
trafficking Joint Nuclear Extended
Family
60 445 82 0 587
Low
10.2% 75.8% 14.0% 0.0% 100%
 96

36 415 39 0 490
Medium
7.3% 84.7% 8.0% 0.0% 100%
3 73 1 1 78
High
3.8% 93.6% 1.3% 1.3% 100%
99 933 122 1 1155
Total
8.6% 80.8% 10.6% 0.1% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 38.824**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

Unskilled labour, agriculture, self-employment, casual and skilled labour were some of the
family occupations of respondents. About 2/3rd respondents reported that their annual family
income at the time of trafficking was less than Rs. 20,000. However, about 1/4th respondents
revealed that their annual family income at the time of trafficking was in between Rs. 20,000 to
40,000. Thus, most of the respondents were from economically weaker sections i.e., BPL families
(Table 4.15).
Table: 4.15
Family Occupation, Annual family Income & Economic Class of Respondents (Victims)

Annual Family Income

Occupation No. of Respondents No. of Respondents
(INR)
Agriculture 248 (21.5%) Less Than 20,000 754 (65.3%)
Self Employed 145 (12.6%) 20,000-40,000 270 (23.4%)
Salaried-Govt. Job 6 (0.5%) 40,000-60,000 84 (7.3%)
Salaried-Pvt. Job 46 (4.0%) 60,000-80,000 37 (3.2%)
Skilled Labour 119 (10.3%) More Than 80,000 10 (0.9%)
Unskilled Labour 343 (29.7%) Economic Class of Family
Crop Plantation 33 (2.9%) Economic Class No. of Respondents
Animal Husbandry 20 (1.7%) APL 35 (3.0%)
Causal Labour 140 (12.1%) BPL 581 (50.3%)
AAY-Antodaya Anna
Petty Business 32 (2.8%) 351 (30.4%)
Yojana (Poorest of Poor)
Individual Service (Caste
2 (0.2%) No Card 162 (14.0%)
Occupation)
Others 21 (1.8%) Not Sure 26 (2.3%)
Total 1155 (100%) Total 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Friends / lovers, brokers / middlemen, strangers and migrant workers recruiters / placement
agents were the main persons who initiated victims in trafficking, about 12 per cent respondents
admitted that their family members are already trafficked. These family members were mainly
sisters, mothers and brothers (Table 4.16).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 97

Table: 4.16
Instrumental Person/Institutions of Trafficking and Name of Other Family member Already Trafficked

Name of Other Family

Instrumental Person/Institutions Respondents member Already Respondents
Trafficked
Family 103 (8.9%) Mother 47 (4.1%)
Parents 87 (7.5%) Sister 68 (5.9%)
Friend/Lover 290 (25.1%) Widow Mother 4 (0.3%)
Brokers/Middleman 145 (12.6%) Widow Sister 4 (0.3%)
Migrant Worker Recruiters/ Placement Agent 115 (10.0%) Brother 13 (1.1%)
Friends and Acquaintances 52 (4.5%) Daughter 1 (0.1%)
Strangers 146 (12.6%) None 1016 (87.9%)
Other Family Members
64 (5.5%) Cousins 1 (0.1%)
(Aunts, Uncles, Cousins, Sister-In-Law)
Brothel Owners/Pimps 17 (1.5%) Other 1 (0.1%)
Sex Abusers of Minors 5 (0.4%)
Prostitute Clients 5 (0.4%)
Relatives 65 (5.6%)
Self 54 (4.7%)
Beauty/Massage Parlors 4 (0.3%)
Escort Services 3 (0.3%)
Total 1155 (100%) Total 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Correlations between Instrumental Person/Institutions in trafficking and Social-economic
parameters of Family of Victims has been shown in Table 4.17. The results indicate that ecological
background has a significant and negative correlation with instrumental Person/Institutions
in Trafficking/How you Victimize of Trafficking. While other socioeconomic parameters are
found no significant correlation with Who initiated you in Trafficking/How you Victimize of
Trafficking.
Table 4.17
Correlation between socio-economic parameters and Instrumental Person/Institutions in Trafficking

Instrumental Person/ Institutions in Trafficking/ How you

Socio-economic parameters
Victimize of Trafficking
Social Class/Category 0.003NS
Ecological Background -0.161**
Economic Class of Family/Household you belong -0.049NS

** indicating correlation is significant at the 1% level of significance

About 11 per cent respondents who were minor at the time of trafficking, were accompanied
by family members during the course of trafficking. Promise for paid work, to pay back or
support parents were the main reasons for trafficking at the time of trafficking (Table 4.18).
 98

Table: 4.18
Minors Accompanied by Family Members during Trafficking and Reasons for Trafficking

Accompanied by
Respondents Reasons for Trafficking Respondents
Family Members
Yes 128 (11.1%) To Pay Back or Support Parents 318 (27.5%)
No 1027 (88.9%) Child Fostering 48 (4.2%)
Total 1155 (100%) Parents Accepted Money from Traffickers 45 (3.9%)
Promise For Paid Work 339 (29.4%)
Promise For Education/ Vocational Training 18 (1.6%)
Others 38 (3.3%)
Total 806 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

More than 2/3rd respondents faced threat to themselves and their family while about 2/5th
respondents reported that they faced physical and sexual violence (Table 4.19).
Table: 4.19
Kind of Threats and Violence Experienced During Trafficking

Kinds of Threats Respondents Kinds of Violence Respondents

Threats To Self 677 (58.6%) Physical Violence 297 (25.7%)
Threats To Family 101 (8.7%) Sexual Violence 285 (24.7%)
Both (Family & Self) 137 (11.9%) Both Type of Violence 491 (42.5%)
No Threats 239 (20.7%) No Violence 82 (7.1%)
Threats To Children 1 (0.1%) Total 1155 (100%)
Total 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Girls and women have become cheap commodity as a result of poverty and exploitation.
Low-yielding agriculture, a lack of alternative sources of employment, and marginalization
all result in poverty, impoverishment, economic troubles, deprivation and resource scarcity,
and marginalization, all of which create an ideal climate for sex trafficking to develop. This is
especially true in the case of human trafficking of women and children, as two-thirds of the girls
and women recruited come from impoverished areas. The sex trade is also encouraged by cultural
traditions such as Jogini, Devadasi, and Basavi in Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, Maharashtra, and
Karnataka. Sex trafficking is also encouraged by economic factors among tribes and communities
such as the Bedias, Jahats, Kanjars, Kolta, Banchra, Mahar, Matang, and Sansi. Delhi and Bombay
have grown into major flesh-trading hubs. Though there are over 1100 red light areas in India,
Sonagachchi is the largest. The five major metropolises of Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai, and
Bangalore account for over 80% of child prostitutes. When rural poor people moved to cities,
human traffickers took advantage of their desperation and used promises of money and jobs to
entice their children into this business. It’s also been said that working-class people frequently
migrate to industrial areas, where children and women satisfy their sexual and financial desires
by visiting brothels, hence increasing demand for girls prostitutes. Girls and women have been
trafficked as a result of tourism, particularly in coastal tourist locations. Thailand, the Philippines,
Sri Lanka, and India have all developed into organised tourism flesh trades (Singh and Singh,
2012).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 99

According to a report conducted by the National Commission for Women in 2002, the
majority of children are trafficked from areas near tourist hotspots. The majority of the children
were accompanied by an uncle from the area. Marriage or better careers were offered to them.
Tourists inquired about oral sex with the children. They are mostly drug addicts. Tourists take
advantage of youngsters sexually. Some of the variables that lead to youngsters selling their
bodies are coercive sexual encounters and compulsive sexual experiences. The pimps and
middlemen that make up the nexus come in all shapes and sizes, from van drivers to hotel
workers to tour operators. As a result, sex tourism, or travelling to a foreign nation in pursuit
of sex, has evolved into a well-developed component of commercial child sexual exploitation.
Experts believe that modern technology and low-cost travel have exacerbated the problem of
child sex tourism. Because of the anonymity it provides, technology has also proven to be a safe
location to engage in such behaviours and exchange child pornography without fear of being
found. Child sexual predators have discovered a means to reach out to young children via the
internet and messaging apps, resulting in romance tourism. When travelers meet youngsters
online and begin up a dialogue with them, without implying any sexual intentions, this is known
as romance tourism. This allows the abuser to acquire the child’s trust before abusing them.
Later, the abuser may pay a visit to the child in his country; if the abuser is a man, this is known
as sex tourism; if the abuser is a woman, this is known as romantic tourism. (Boruah, Jayanta
and Baruah, Masia, Legal Implications of Sex Tourism (April 3, 2021). Journal on Jurisprudential
Studies Vol 1 Issue 3, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3818710)
Most of the respondents reported that they faced physical and sexual abuse / violence at
destination and during trafficking (Table 4.20).
Table 4.20
Place of Physical and Sexual Abuse/ Violence Experienced

Place (Multiple Response) Frequency Percent

During Trafficking 245 21.2
At Destination 975 84.4
At P & R Homes 1 .1
Hotel 55 4.8
Home/Street 43 3.7
Other 2 .2

Source: Field Survey

Victims of human trafficking are frequently subjected to severe physical violence, weariness,
and malnutrition. Broken bones, concussions, bruising, or burns are common injuries, as well as
other assault-related injuries. Some of these major injuries can result in long-term health issues,
necessitating long-term therapy. Because women who have been trafficked have been subjected
to many abuses over a lengthy period of time, they may experience health problems similar to
those experienced by torture victims.
Sexual assault is a painful experience for the victim, with both physical and emotional
consequences. Any sexual interaction between two or more persons in which one of the people
is involved against his or her will is referred to as sexual assault. In an assault, the sexual action
might comprise a wide range of experiences. Unwanted touching, grabbing, oral sex, anal sex,
sexual penetration with an object, and/or sexual intercourse can all happen to women. Victims
of human trafficking are frequently forced to engage in sexual activities through physical or
 100

non-physical means, such as pressure from someone in a position of authority, bribery or

manipulation, or impairment from drink or drugs. A woman who has been sexually assaulted
may have a variety of physical and emotional effects, including extreme stress and sadness.
Sexual exploitation, violence, beating, over work and deprivation of sleep and food were
some of the types of physical and sexual abuse/violence experience by trafficking victims and
sex workers (Table 4.21).
Table 4.21
Types of Physical and Sexual Abuse/ Violence Experienced

Type of Abuse Respondents Type of Abuse Respondents

Deprivation of Food 393 (34.0%) Beatings 733 (63.55)
Deprivation of Sleep 537 (46.5%) Acid Attacks 5 (0.4%)
Over Work 625 (54.1%) Cutting with Knives 13 (1.1%)
Sexual Exploitation 780 (67.5%) Breaking Arms/Legs 16 (1.4%)
Frequent Abortions 54 (4.7%) Throwing Stones 12 (1.0%)
Gang Sex 114 (9.9%) Putting Chilli Powders in Eyes 1 (0.1%)
Burning Of Breasts/Genitals with Cigarettes 4 (0.3%) Hitting with Hard Objects 64 (5.5%)
Beating And Chaining with Fetters 21 (1.8%) Shaving Heads 4 (0.3%)
Violence 905 (78.4%) Beating the Soles of The Feet 39 (3.4%)

Source: Field Survey

It is reported that about 58 per cent respondents also experience injuries during their
trafficking (Table 4.22).
Table No. 4.22
Have You Experienced Injuries During Trafficking?
Particular Respondents Percent
Yes 666 57.7
No 489 42.3
Total 1155 100.0

Ecological Background wise Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence experienced by

Trafficked Victims is being Shown in Table 4.23. The value of chi-square indicates the ecological
background has significant relation with Sexual abuse/violence experienced by Trafficked
Victims is being.
Table 4.23
Ecological Background wise Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence experienced by Trafficked
Victims
Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence experienced
Ecological Background by Trafficked victims Total
Low Medium High
30 107 12 149
Metropolitan City
20.1% 71.8% 8.1% 100%
131 536 47 714
Rural
18.3% 75.1% 6.6% 100%
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 101

23 70 4 97
Semi-Urban
23.7% 72.2% 4.1% 100%
60 132 3 195
Urban
30.8% 67.7% 1.5% 100%
244 845 66 1155
Total
21.1% 73.2% 5.7% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 21.522**

** indicating the value is significant at 1% level of significance

The age of victims wise Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence experienced by victims
is shown in Table 4.24. The value of the chi-square indicates that the age of victims and levels of
physical and sexual abuse/violence experienced by victims has significant relation.
Table 4.24
Age of victims wise Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence experienced by victims

Level of physical and Sexual abuse/violence

Age of Victims experienced by Victims Total
Low Medium High
11 17 1 29
Less than 10 Years
37.9% 58.6% 3.4% 100%
19 109 1 129
10-14 Years
14.7% 84.5% 0.8% 100%
24 133 7 164
14-16 Years
14.6% 81.1% 4.3% 100%
36 129 10 175
16-18 Years
20.6% 73.7% 5.7% 100%
54 177 29 260
18-25 Years
20.8% 68.1% 11.2% 100%
34 110 4 148
25-30 Years
23.0% 74.3% 2.7% 100%
33 96 12 141
30-35 Years
23.4% 68.1% 8.5% 100%
33 74 2 109
35-40 Years
30.3% 67.9% 1.8% 100%
244 845 66 1155
Total
21.1% 73.2% 5.7% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 47.952**

** indicating values is significant at 1% level of significance

Poor hygiene, locking in room, living in overcrowded room and inadequate food were some
of the living conditions during trafficking. Extreme restriction of movement, forced to drink
alcohol and illegal drugs were the main restriction and drug abuse during trafficking. About
2/5th respondents faced terrific encounter of trafficking (Table 4.25).
 102

Table 4.25
Living Conditions, Drug Abuse & Other Restrictions During Trafficking

Living Conditions Respondents Drug Abuse & Other Restrictions Respondents

Locked in a Room 445 (38.5%) Being Made to Drink Alcohol 276 (23.9%)
Living/Sleeping in Overcrowded Room 300 (26.0%) Being Made to Take Illegal Drugs 109 (9.4%)
Sleeping in Dangerous Conditions 80 (6.9%) Being Made to Take Medications 71 (6.1%)
No Access to Passport or Identity
Poor Hygiene 827 (716.6%) 115 (10.0%)
Documents
Nowhere to Sleep/Sleeping on The Floor 169 (14.6%) Extreme Restriction of Movement 809 (70.0%)
Inadequate Food 390 (33.8%)
Inadequate Drinking Water 172 (14.9%)
No Clean Clothing 198 (17.1%)

Source: Field Survey

Majority of the respondents reported that they were rescued victims of trafficking. About
63 per cent respondents who were rescued admitted that they were rescued after exploitation
occurred (Table 4.26).
Table 4.26
Whether You Are a Rescued Victim of Trafficking

Rescued Respondents If Rescued Then Please Specify

Yes 815 (70.6%) Rescued Before Exploitation Occurred-Trafficking Preempted 84 (7.3%)
No 340 (29.4%) Rescued After Exploitation Occurred-Trafficking Not Preempted 731 (63.3%)
Total 1155 (100%) Total 815 (70.6%)

Source: Field Survey

Local law enforcement Agency, service providers, child care institutions, and good samartian
were some of the agencies who rescued the trafficked victims (Table 4.27).
Table 4.27
Name of Agency who Rescued the Trafficked Victims

Name of Agency Respondents Percent

Good Samartian 38 3.3
Health Care Providers-Hospitals 3 .3
Local Law Enforcement Agency 442 38.3
Raid (By CBI/ED) 6 .5
Self 34 2.9
Department of Labour 5 .4
SSB/BSF 2 .2
Railway Protection Force (RPF) 12 1.0
Child Care Institutions 86 7.4
Service Providers-NGOs 256 22.2
Immigration Officials 1 .1
Others 1 .1

Source: Field Survey

Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 103

Labour exploitation, slavery / servitude, criminal activities, forced marriages and illegal
adoption were some of the intensions of trafficking other than sexual exploitation as reported by
Victims. Domestic servants, hotels, bars, restaurants, markets, brick kilns and textile/garment
industry as well as begging rackets were some of the industries/establishments from where
victims were mainly rescued (Table 4.28).
Table 4.28
Intension of Trafficking other than Sexual Exploitation

Purpose and Intention Respondents In Case of Forced Labour/ Beggars, Place of rescue Respondents
Labour Exploitation 356 (30.8%) Construction Sectors 11 (1.0%)
Slavery/ Servitude 63 (5.5%) Steel Industry 2 (0.2%)
Removal of Organs 1 (0.1%) Textiles/Garment Industry 23 (2.0%)
Organized Begging 13 (1.1%) Carpet Weaving 8 (0.7%)
Criminal Activities 54 (4.7%) Biscuits Factories 6 (0.5%)
Illegal Adoptions 28 (2.4%) Pickling 5 (0.4%)
Forced Marriages 46 (4.0%) Floriculture 3 (0.3%)
Child Pornography 16 (1.4%) Fish Farms 1 (0.1%)
Others 11 (1.0%) Agricultural Workers 6 (0.5%)
Coal Mining/ Metallurgical Industries 6 (0.5%)
Cement And Glass Industry 1 (0.1%)
Paint and Dyes Industry 4 (0.3%)
Brick Kilns 34 (2.9%)
Chemical & Petrochemicals 1 (0.1%)
Firecracker Workshop 3 (0.3%)
Hotels, Bars, Restaurants, Markets 136 (11.8%)
Domestic Servants/Maid from a House 162 (14.0%)
Beggars From Street or Begging Rackets 32 (2.8%)

Source: Field Survey

IMPACT OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING ON VICTIMS:

People who have been trafficked have apparently been scarred by their experiences. Suicidal
ideation and depression are frequently mentioned. The survivors’ mental and emotional states may
include malevolence, helplessness, and withdrawal; disassociation; self-blame and identification
with the aggressor; distraction; a shortened view of time; normalization and shaping, in which
the victims convince themselves that their experiences had to happen rather than viewing
them as traumatic; and normalization and shaping, in which the victims convince themselves
that their experiences had to happen rather than viewing them as traumatic (Saarthak, 2002).
Posttraumatic stress disorder, depressive disorder, dissociative disorders, psychotic disorders,
and eating disorders are among the psychiatric problems experienced by survivors of human
trafficking. Girls are expected to carry the burden of sustaining the family honour through their
sexual purity and chastity (ISS, 2003). If they are trafficked for commercial sexual exploitation,
they will be under even more duress due to the dominant morality.
Apart from being labelled as outsiders and experiencing moral and legal isolation (Giri,
1999), trafficked people are at risk for HIV/AIDS, drug addiction, and high-risk abortions and
 104

teenage pregnancies, all of which can negatively impact their reproductive health for the rest of
their lives. According to a survey conducted by a Dhaka-based NGO, “more than 20% of street
children prostitutes die before reaching maturity.... Nearly 22% become physically invalid and
are only fit for begging” (Save Our Sisters, 2001). Psychological trauma has affected them in every
part of their life. ‘The abused turn into abusers,’ with a high possibility of becoming criminals,
because it is frequently left ignored and unresolved. The repercussions of “child labour” and its
negative impact on children’s development are well recognized. Victims of human trafficking
are forced to live in deplorable conditions. Illegality infiltrates every aspect of their existence,
turning them into criminals. Their criminality as workers and individuals has a significant
negative impact on them. It multiplies their victimization and leaves them with no recourse for
retaliation (Sanghera, 2002).
Human trafficking has a variety of effects on victims and survivors, depending on the type
of trafficking and the circumstances. However, research has revealed that victims and survivors
may face a variety of challenges. Trafficking victims are frequently subjected to extreme physical
conditions, such as forced labour or the use of force by their traffickers. Victims may also be at
risk for health issues like as HIV/AIDS, illnesses, and substance dependence. They may also
face major mental health problems, such as worry, insecurity, fear, and trauma. Survivors had
high degrees of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), according to several studies. Cognitive
impairment, memory loss, depression, and even suicide are all possible consequences of human
trafficking. Because of their age, trafficked kids are even more susceptible. Child trafficking can
have a significant impact on a child’s emotional, physical, and psychological development.
Human trafficking has physical impacts on victims in terms of deprivation of sleep, fatigue,
frequent headache, back pain etc. (Table 4.29).
Table 4.29
Physical Impact/ Physical Health Symptoms of Human Trafficking on Victims

Physical Health
Respondents Physical Health Symptoms Respondents
Symptoms
Constitutional Symptoms Neurological Symptoms
Easily Tired 495 (42.9%) Frequent Head-Aches 466 (40.3%)
Weight Loss 335 (29.0%) Dizzy Spells 161 (13.9%)
Loss Of Appetite 364 (31.5%) Memory Problems 94 (8.1%)
Inadequate Sleep 507 (43.9%) Fainting/ Fatigue 92 (8.0%)
Gastrointestinal Symptoms Cardiovascular Symptoms
Vomiting,
Upset Stomach,
83 (7.2%) Chest/ Heart Pain 165 (14.3%)
Constipation or
Diarrhea
Stomach Pain 300 (26.0%) Breathing Difficulty 101 (8.7%)
Lower Abdomen Pain 229 (19.8%) Musculoskeletal Symptoms
Dermatological
Symptoms (Rashes, 211 (18.3%) Back Pain 743 (64.3%)
Itching, Sores)
Eye, Ear and Upper Respiratory Symptoms Malnourishment /Dental Pain 82 (7.1%)
Asthma 83 (7.2%) Rheumatic Disorders 39 (3.4%)
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 105

Eye Pain/Weak Eyes 75 (6.5%)

Ear Pain/Hearing
42 (3.6%)
Problem
Tuberculosis 11 (1.0%)

Source: Field Survey

The Ecological Background Wise Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on victims
has been shown in Table 4.30. The value of chi-square indicates that the Ecological Background
has significant relation with Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on victims.
Table 4.30
Ecological Background wise Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims
Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking
Ecological Background Total
Low Medium High
30 112 7 149
Metropolitan City
20.1% 75.2% 4.7% 100%
147 523 44 714
Rural
20.6% 73.2% 6.2% 100%
28 67 2 97
Semi-Urban
28.9% 69.1% 2.1% 100%
29 127 39 195
Urban
14.9% 65.1% 20.0% 100%
234 829 92 1155
Total
20.3% 71.8% 8.0% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 52.745**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

Age of victims wise Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims has been
shown in Table: 4.31. The value of chi-square indicates that the age of victims has significant
relation with Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.31
Age of victims wise Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims
Level of Physical Impact of Human Trafficking
Age of Victims Total
Low Medium High
12 17 0 29
Less than 10 Years
41.4% 58.6% 0.0% 100%
36 89 4 129
10-14 Years
27.9% 69.0% 3.1% 100%
42 117 5 164
14-16 Years
25.6% 71.3% 3.0% 100%
59 107 9 175
16-18 Years
33.7% 61.1% 5.1% 100%
53 188 19 260
18-25 Years
20.4% 72.3% 7.3% 100%
 106

14 120 14 148
25-30 Years
9.5% 81.1% 9.5% 100%
13 109 19 141
30-35 Years
9.2% 77.3% 13.5% 100%
5 82 22 109
35-40 Years
4.6% 75.2% 20.2% 100%
234 829 92 1155
Total
20.3% 71.8% 8.0% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 103.687**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

Table 4.32 shows the STDs, hygienic conditions, and other health problems connected
with trafficked victims. Sexual and reproductive health concerns, such as sexually transmitted
infections (STDs) and other gynecological issues, are common among women who participate
in the commercial sex trade. Women who have been trafficked into the sex trade may not have
access to or be allowed to use condoms or other forms of birth control, and their gynecological
examinations may be irregular. Unwanted pregnancies and losses are a risk for such women.
Prostitutes have a higher rate of abortion, sterilization, and infertility than other women.
Table 4.32
STD, Hygienic Condition & Other Health Problems

Sexually Transmitted Diseases Hygienic Condition & Other Health Problems

Health Problems Respondents Health Problems Respondents

HIV/AIDS 111 (9.6%) Personal Hygienic 735 (63.6%)

Pelvic Pain/
Inflammatory Diseases 7 (0.6%) Sexual Services on the Same Bad 352 (30.5%)
(PID)

Chlamydia 7 (0.6%) Recurring Pregnancy 41 (3.5%)

Infertility from chronic untreated Sexually Transmitted

Gonorrhea 27 (2.3%) 5 (0.4%)
Infections or botched or unsafe Abortions

Human Papillomavirus Infections Or Mutilations Caused by Unsanitary and

7 (0.6%) 15 (1.3%)
(HPV) Infection, Dangerous Medical Procedures

Undetected Or Untreated Diseases, Such as Diabetes

Syphilis 14 (1.2%) 28 (2.4%)
or Cancer

Rectal Trauma and

127 (11%)
Urinary Difficulties

Source: Field Survey

Human trafficking victims often suffer from acute guilt, posttraumatic stress disorder,
depression, anxiety, substance abuse (alcohol or narcotics), and eating disorders as a result of
the physical and psychological violence they endure. Psychological care is frequently required
as part of complete medical treatment for victims of human trafficking. Human trafficking has
a psychological impact that includes stress, despair, insomnia, desperation, negative thinking,
irritability, aggressiveness, and a lack of obedience (Table 4.33).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 107

Table 4.33
Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking

Psychological Symptoms Respondents Psychological Symptoms Respondents

Depression 517 (44.8%) Phobias and Panic Attacks 69 (6.0%)
PTSD- Post Traumatic
186 (16.1%) Stress/ Anxiety 612 (53.0%)
Stress Disorder.
Bipolar Disorder 18 (1.6%) Self-Mutilation 86 (7.4%)
Passive Suicidal Ideation 97 (8.4%) Hopelessness Or Desperation for The Future 438 (37.9%)
Active Suicide Attempts 20 (1.7%) Humiliation 56 (4.8%)
Sleeping Difficulties 451 (39.0%) Negative Attitude 301 (26.1%)
Eating Disorder 121 (10.5%) Lack of Obedience 208 (18.0%)
Somatic Complaints 143 (12.4%) Short Temper and Violence 510 (44.2%)
Drug/Alcohol Use (In Past
193 (16.7%)
Month)

Source: Field Survey

Ecological Background wise Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human
Trafficking on Victims is being shown in Table 4.34. The value of chi-square indicates that the
Ecological Background has significant relation with Level of Psychological (Mental Health)
Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.34
Ecological Background wise Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking
Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human
Ecological Background Trafficking Total
Low Medium High
35 101 13 149
Metropolitan City
23.5% 67.8% 8.7% 100%
187 460 67 714
Rural
26.2% 64.4% 9.4% 100%
38 50 9 97
Semi-Urban
39.2% 51.5% 9.3% 100%
34 152 9 195
Urban
17.4% 77.9% 4.6% 100%
294 763 98 1155
Total
25.5% 66.1% 8.5% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 24.302**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

Age of victims wise Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking on
victims is being shown in Table 4.35. The value of chi-square indicates that the age of victims has
no relation with Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking on victims.
 108

Table 4.35
Age of victims wise Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking on victims
Level of Psychological (Mental Health) Impact of Human Trafficking
Age of Victims Total
Low Medium High
Less than 10 5 24 0 29
Years 17.2% 82.8% 0.0% 100%
24 94 11 129
10-14 Years
18.6% 72.9% 8.5% 100%
35 109 20 164
14-16 Years
21.3% 66.5% 12.2% 100%
46 111 18 175
16-18 Years
26.3% 63.4% 10.3% 100%
72 163 25 260
18-25 Years
27.7% 62.7% 9.6% 100%
47 93 8 148
25-30 Years
31.8% 62.8% 5.4% 100%
40 90 11 141
30-35 Years
28.4% 63.8% 7.8% 100%
25 79 5 109
35-40 Years
22.9% 72.5% 4.6% 100%
294 763 98 1155
Total
25.5% 66.1% 8.5% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 21.494 NS

NS- indicating value is not significant at desired level of significance

It might be difficult to provide culturally appropriate and trauma-informed mental health
therapy. Some of the most commonly stated impediments and challenges to assisting trauma
victims include:
• There is a scarcity of competent mental health services and access to them.
• Developing trustworthy relationships with survivors is difficult.
• When engaging with victims, mandated therapeutic initiatives may be detrimental. This
is especially important in places where the only way to get mental health help is to be
locked up in a treatment facility.
• Trauma, recognised mental health disorders, and substance misuse or addiction all occur
together.
• Polyvictimization has a long history among victims.
• Victims are not permitted to label their experience as abusive or to attempt to flee.
• Cultural and linguistic difficulties, as well as separation from one’s family.
Aside from the difficulties mentioned above, it’s also vital to remember that some victims
may be uncomfortable with their sexuality as a result of such trauma. Same-sex interactions may
be an option for those who have been subjected to severe exploitation. Service providers must be
informed, prepared, and at ease when assisting victims through this process, as disassociating
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 109

from one’s birth gender can be a coping technique for victims dealing with traumatic experiences.
It is critical to first guarantee basic safety and service needs in order to effectively treat the mental
health needs of survivors of human trafficking. When working with trafficking victims who have
experienced trauma, physical and psychological safety must be established. This necessitates
collaborating with individuals involved in the case to assess current client safety needs and plan
ahead of time. In order to address numerous requirements, task force members participating
in a case should be able to work across systems of care. It’s critical that professionals dealing
with victims have access to a variety of trauma-specific interventions, including well-trained
clinicians who are willing and culturally competent to engage with victims. Polyvictimization
can be treated in a variety of ways, including educational support groups that focus on skill
development, interpersonal connections, and competence and resiliency.
Many victim support providers use art and music therapy to assist survivors relate physical
symptoms to mental health, which has been shown to be effective in rehabilitation programmes.
It’s also crucial to think about the client’s cultural background and how it influences resiliency and
the experience of receiving mental health care, especially in the case of victims who are foreign
nationals. The importance of culture and community bonds in survivor reintegration and healthy
relationships may be overlooked in Western-centered psychotherapy treatment. The therapy
privilege does not apply in group settings, thus social workers should be cautious about victim
disclosure about components of the trafficking experience. A peer-support approach is a viable
alternative to clinical mental health care. Victims can benefit greatly from peer-to-peer therapy
and mentoring from survivors who are now working in victim services. Peers who understand
and have experienced comparable suffering and abuse in a nonjudgmental, empathic manner are
frequently more comfortable with victims. It’s also a means to assist survivors in reclaiming their
identity and overcoming feelings of loneliness.
Table 4.36 shows the emotional impact of human trafficking on victims. Human trafficking
can have a variety of acute and long-term psychological consequences. Maladaptive behaviours,
mental health issues, and substance abuse are all possible outcomes of these consequences.
Understanding the complexities of this crime and offering proper support requires knowing
what the individual impacts are and how they affect a victim. Human trafficking has an emotional
impact that includes depression, lack of self-compassion, suspicion of others, anxiety, impatience,
low self-esteem, emotional instability, irritation, shame, and guilt.
Survivors of violent exploitation may develop a distrust of care-giving individuals and
systems, which might obstruct service delivery. Sex trafficking wreaks havoc on caregiving by
sabotaging the victim’s sense of trust and security. Victims rely on their traffickers for food and
shelter, but in order to achieve these necessities, victims must work, which often involves sexual
violence and coercion. As a result, the hand that feeds, shelters, and promises a way to safety is also
the hand that leads to harm and persecution. This extreme disruption of attachment connections
can have a profound impact on survivors, impacting their sense of self and their ability to escape
exploitative settings, rehabilitate emotionally, and engage with resources. Survivors describe
feeling helpless and despondent after times of imposed seclusion, loss of autonomy, and forced
servitude, as well as struggle to feel competent with life skills, ashamed of their prior victimisation,
and resentful over missed schooling and job training. In their personal search for identity and
significance, many people feel lost. It might be tough to manage uncomfortable emotions and
interpersonal interactions. Overall, sex trafficking has far-reaching, profound, and often poorly
understood consequences. Signs and symptoms of psychological distress can also exist outside
 110

of diagnostic categories, manifesting themselves in distressing cultural idioms (Table 4.36).

Table: 4.36
Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking

Name of Effects Respondents Name of Effects Respondents

Very Low Self Esteem 335 (29.0%) Depression 591 (51.2%)
Impatience/Short Temper 489 (42.3%) Anxiety 549 (47.5%)
Irritability 436 (37.7%) Suicidal Ideation 154 (13.3%)
Distrust Towards Others 581 (50.3%) Feelings Of Isolation 312 (27.0%)
Lack Of Self-Confidence 614 (53.2%) Shame And Guilt 332 (28.7%)
Emotional Instability 338 (29.3%)

Source: Field Survey

Ecological Background wise Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims has
been shown in Table 4.37. The value of chi-square indicates that the Ecological Background has a
significant relation with the Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.37
Ecological Background wise Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking
Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking
Ecological Background Total
Low Medium High
36 107 6 149
Metropolitan City
24.2% 71.8% 4.0% 100%
107 572 35 714
Rural
15.0% 80.1% 4.9% 100%
33 57 7 97
Semi-Urban
34.0% 58.8% 7.2% 100%
24 162 9 195
Urban
12.3% 83.1% 4.6% 100%
200 898 57 1155
Total
17.3% 77.7% 4.9% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 32.438**
** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance
Age of Victims wise Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims is being
shown in Table 4.38. The value of the chi-square indicates that the Age of Victims has a significant
relation with Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.38
Age of Victims wise Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims
Level of Emotional Impact of Human Trafficking
Age of Victims Total
Low Medium High
2 27 0 29
Less than 10 Years
6.9% 93.1% 0.0% 100%
17 107 5 129
10-14 Years
13.2% 82.9% 3.9% 100%
21 137 6 164
14-16 Years
12.8% 83.5% 3.7% 100%
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 111

30 134 11 175
16-18 Years
17.1% 76.6% 6.3% 100%
55 188 17 260
18-25 Years
21.2% 72.3% 6.5% 100%
29 116 3 148
25-30 Years
19.6% 78.4% 2.0% 100%
33 100 8 141
30-35 Years
23.4% 70.9% 5.7% 100%
13 89 7 109
35-40 Years
11.9% 81.7% 6.4% 100%
200 898 57 1155
Total
17.3% 77.7% 4.9% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 24.095*
* Indicating value is significant at 5% level of significance
Long-term physical and mental abuse has a deleterious impact on victims’ behaviour,
affecting both physical and emotional responses. Because trafficked people are typically subjected
to significant forms of trauma over extended periods of time, their ability to comprehend what
has occurred to them and to recount their experiences is severely harmed. It can be difficult for
victims to make personal sense of the abuse they have suffered, let alone describe it to authorities.
They’re much less able to recognize what kind of assistance they could require as a result of
the abuse. They may be hesitant to reveal facts, give incorrect information, be angry, rude, and
aggressive toward others, including supporters. They could appear grumpy, uncooperative, or
ungrateful. As a result, individuals may not be identified as criminals, exacerbating the injustice
they have suffered. Failure to identify a person as a victim of human trafficking frequently leads
in expulsion from the transit or destination country, with no access to legal, medical, or social
services. Individuals’ behaviour, on the other hand, may persist for years. Victims may be too
traumatized to fully participate in programmes, make decisions, express preferences, or accept
assistance. Victims’ capacity to participate in programmes designed to help them will be harmed
if their physical health issues and chronic pain are not addressed.
Social withdrawal, poor communication skills, inability to express feelings, difficulty with
adjustment, lack of motivation and aggression, sexual activeness, nightmares, inability to make
friendship and frightened of adults and strangers were some of the behavioural impacts of
human trafficking (Table 4.39).
Table 4.39
Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking

Nature of Effects Respondents Nature of Effects Respondents

Difficulty With Sleeping /
Inability to Express Feelings 406 (35.2%) 334 (28.9%)
Nightmares
Poor Communication Skills 499 (43.2%) Difficulty with Adjustment 403 (34.9%)
Inability to Make Friendship 294 (25.5%) Tendency of Suicide 165 (14.3%)
Frightened of Adults and Strangers 210 (18.2%) Social Withdrawal 536 (46.4%)
Addiction to Drugs and Substances 139 (12.0%) Lack of Motivation and Aggression 450 (39.0%)
Sexual Activeness 328 (28.4%)

Source: Field Survey

 112

Ecological Background wise Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims has
been shown in Table 4.40. The value of chi-square indicates that the Ecological Background has
no relation with Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.40
Ecological Background wise Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking

Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking

Ecological Background Total
Low Medium High
74 71 4 149
Metropolitan City
49.7% 47.7% 2.7% 100%
264 413 37 714
Rural
37.0% 57.8% 5.2% 100%
39 54 4 97
Semi-Urban
40.2% 55.7% 4.1% 100%
69 120 6 195
Urban
35.4% 61.5% 3.1% 100%
446 658 51 1155
Total
38.6% 57.0% 4.4% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 11.680NS

NS indicating value is not significant at the desired level of significance

Age of Victims wise Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims is being
shown in Table 4.41. The value of chi-square indicates that the Age of Victims has significant
relation with Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims.
Table 4.41
Age of Victims wise Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking on Victims
Level of Behavioral Impact of Human Trafficking
Age of Victims Total
Low Medium High
12 17 0 29
Less than 10 Years
41.4% 58.6% 0.0% 100%
44 81 4 129
10-14 Years
34.1% 62.8% 3.1% 100%
45 112 7 164
14-16 Years
27.4% 68.3% 4.3% 100%
55 106 14 175
16-18 Years
31.4% 60.6% 8.0% 100%
113 139 8 260
18-25 Years
43.5% 53.5% 3.1% 100%
64 79 5 148
25-30 Years
43.2% 53.4% 3.4% 100%
66 65 10 141
30-35 Years
46.8% 46.1% 7.1% 100%
47 59 3 109
35-40 Years
43.1% 54.1% 2.8% 100%
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 113

446 658 51 1155

Total
38.6% 57.0% 4.4% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 33.926**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

To address the various components of trafficking, the central and state governments have
developed legislation and programs/schemes to combat all forms of trafficking. In all of its
efforts to construct an integrated response to prevent and combat trafficking, the government has
established strong links and partnerships with a variety of stakeholders, including civil society,
NGOs, corporate sector, international organisations, and others. The Central Government has
implemented a variety of programmes to safeguard vulnerable people, particularly women and
children, from human trafficking and to give economic and social empowerment to them. In
addition, the government has developed a number of anti-trafficking legal procedures to tackle
the problem.
We attempted to assess the level of awareness among the rescued victims (815) of the various
schemes/prohragmme being implemented by Central or State Agencies, as well as whether
or not they have benefited from these schemes. Table 4.43 shows the level of awareness and
benefits received by victims or their families. The degree of awareness regarding schemes
and programmes among trafficking victims was observed to be very poor, with only a small
percentage of respondents knowing about Beti Bachao, Beti Padao, Swadhar Greh, Ujjawala, child
line, and children homes. A small percentage of respondents also said they receive benefits from
the Ujjawala, Swadhar, compensation for sexual exploitation, and children’s homes schemes.
The rescued victims who were educated were found to be more aware of government initiatives
and programmes. Similarly, when compared to illiterate and low-educated victims, educated
respondents received a higher degree of benefits under government schemes and programmes.
Table 4.42 clearly depicts that only 3.6% respondents were aware about Compensation
Scheme for Women Victims/Survivor of Sexual Assault/other crime-2018 and only 2.6%
respondents got benefitted from the Scheme. The Victim Compensation Scheme established
under 357-A Cr.Pc. by National Legal Services Authorities are not reaching the trafficked victims.
In the last seven years, between 2012 and 2019, across India, not even 100 victims of human
trafficking have been awarded compensation. Out of total 100 applications, only 30 survivors
received compensation amount. In 19 States, out of the total fund allocation of Rs 544.53 crore for
victim compensation, only 128.27 crore has been utilized and 75 per cent of the funds remain
unutilized. Less than 1% of the survivors rescued from trafficking over 10 years (2009 to 2019)
were compensated. (Source: RTI filed by Sanjog, Kolkatta).
Table 4.42
Awareness and Benefits availed in different Schemes & Programme

Aware Benefitted
Name of Scheme/Programme
Respondents Respondents
Beti Bachao Beti Padhao Scheme 126 (10.9%) 19 (1.6%)
Women Helpline Scheme 42 (3.6%) 4 (0.3%)
One Stop Centre Scheme 37 (3.2%) 9 (0.8%)
Mahila police Volunteers 41 (3.5%) 15 (1.3%)
Working Women Hostel Scheme 25 (2.2%) 1 (0.1%)
 114

SWADHAR Greh (A Scheme for Women in Difficult Circumstances) 52 (4.5%) 37 (3.2%)

UJJAWALA: P&R Homes 48 (4.2%) 39 (3.4%)
Support to Training and Employment Programme for Women
7 (0.6%) 2 (0.2%)
(STEP)
NIRBHAYA 18 (1.6%) -
Kishori Shakti Yojana 5 (0.4%) 1 (0.1%)
Family Counseling Centre Scheme 9 (0.8%) 6 (0.5%)
Compensation Scheme for Women Victims/Survivors of Sexual
42 (3.6%) 34 (2.9%)
Assault/other Crimes – 2018
Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition
12 (1.0%) 7 (0.6%)
and Redressal) Act, 2013
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 16 (1.4%) 4 (0.3%)
Immoral Traffic Prevention Act 1956 6 (0.5%) 3 (0.3%)
Adolescent Girls Scheme 5 (0.4%) 2 (0.2%)
National Crech Scheme 4 (0.3%) -
Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012-The Protection of Children from
20 (1.7%) 13 (1.1%)
Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019
Rashtriya Bal Kosh (National Children’s Fund) 4 (0.3%) 1 (0.1%)
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act 2009 24 (2.1%) 16 (1.4%)
Education and Vocational Training in Observation Homes 16 (1.4%) 13 (1.1%)
Child Line Scheme 38 (3.3%) 19 (1.6%)
Children Homes, CCIs 38 (3.3%) 28 (2.4%)
The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 7 (0.6%) 3 (0.3%)
Child Care Institutions (CCIs under JJ Act 2015 9 (0.8%) 2 (0.2%)
Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006 8 (0.7%) -
The Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act 1986 (CLPRA) 6 (0.5%) 3 (0.3%)
Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976 3 (0.3%) -
Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS) 11 (1.0%) 2 (0.2%)

Source: Field Survey

The education-wise awareness score analysis and correlation analysis of Victims have been
presented in Table 4.43. The awareness about various developmental schemes of the victims has
been found quite low i.e., 10 per cent and below for all levels of education. However, in the case
of whether they benefitted from the scheme has also found a quite low percentage (below 5 per
cent). The quite low percentage shows that most of the victims are not educated. The correlation
coefficients have been found positive and significant between the education level of victims and
other variables under study. It can be concluded that the awareness and beneficiaries could be
increased if the education level is increased.
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 115

Table 4.43
Correlation Between Level of Education of Victims Vs Awareness about various developmental schemes
and the whether they benefitted from the scheme
Percentage of Percentage of
Awareness
Awareness obtained Awareness score Awareness score
obtained score
score about different about different about different Total possible
Educational Level about different
Schemes-Whether Schemes-Whether Schemes-Whether score
Schemes-Whether
Aware Aware from total benefited from total
benefited
possible score possible score
Illiterate 69 0.74 35 0.37 9338
Primary 177 1.99 88 0.99 8903
Middle School 160 1.64 64 0.65 9773
High School 148 3.59 48 1.17 4118
Intermediate 93 10.02 46 4.96 928
Graduate 31 9.72 2 0.63 319
Postgraduate 1 0.86 0 0.00 116
Total 679 2.03 283 0.84 33495
Correlation 0.198** 0.142**

** values are indicating significant at 1% level of significance

The Ecological Background-wise awareness score analysis and correlation analysis of Victims
have been presented in Table 4.44. The awareness about various developmental schemes of the
victims has been found quite low i.e., below 3 per cent for all ecological background. However,
in the case of whether they benefitted from the scheme has also found a quite low percentage
(below 2 per cent). The quite low percentage shows that most of the victims were found from
rural background. The correlation coefficients have been found negative and significant between
the ecological background of victims and other variables under study. It can be concluded that
the awareness amongst beneficiaries could be increased if the stakeholder will conduct awareness
programme regularly.
Table 4.44
Correlation Between Ecological Background of Victims Vs Awareness about various developmental
schemes and the whether they benefitted from the scheme
Percentage of
Percentage of
Awareness about Awareness about Awareness score
Ecological Awareness score about Total possible
different Schemes- different Schemes- about different
Background different Schemes- score
Whether Aware Whether benefited Schemes-Whether
Whether Aware
benefited
Metropolitan City 64 1.48 21 0.49 4321
Rural 516 2.49 220 1.06 20706
Semi-Urban 71 2.52 38 1.35 2813
Urban 28 0.50 4 0.07 5655
Total 679 2.03 283 0.84 33495
Correlation -0.067** -0.068**

* Values are indicating significant at 5% level of significance

About 28 per cent victims were minor and therefore, they could not opt for employment
while about 12 per cent could not persuade employment. Thus, others were persuaded in self-
employment, wage employment, domestic help, volunteers and other economic activities (Table
4.45).
 116

Table 4.45
Feedback on Employment Options Pursued by Rescued Victims

Employment Persuaded Respondents

Homes Guards 1 (0.1%)
Volunteers 33 (2.9%)
Domestic Helpers/cook 51 (4.4%)
Wage Employment 26 (2.3%)
Self-Employment 102 (8.8%)
Others 140 (12.1%)
NA as Victims was below 14 Years 323 (28%)
Not Persuaded 139 (12.1%)
Total 815 (70.6%)

Source: Field Survey

About a third of those interviewed said their families are unwilling to take them back.
However, nearly two-thirds of respondents were willing to return to mains steam after the
trafficking was over. A little more than a third of those polled also said they try to flee from a
human trafficking location. Approximately 80% of the rescued victims said their family are eager
to accept them back. However, just around a third of sex workers said their families are eager
to take them back into their homes. Similarly, the majority of rescued victims were willing to
reintegrate into society, compared to only 1/3 of sex workers who were willing to reintegrate
into society after being released from trafficking. (Table 4.46).
Table 4.46
Aspirations of Respondents

Respondents Rescued Victims Sex Workers Total

Responses Yes No Yes No Yes No
Are your families unwilling to accept you 164 651 233 107 397 758
backing in to respective homes (20.1%) (79.9%) (68.5%) (31.5%) (34.4%) (65.6%)
Are you willing to joining the main stream at 634 181 115 225 749 406
the exit of the trafficking trade (77.8%) (22.8%) (33.8%) (66.2%) (64.8%) (35.2%)
Total 815 (100%) 340 (100%) 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

More than 2/5 of rescued victims attempted to flee the trafficking destination, compared to
6% of sex workers who seek to flee the trafficking destination (Table 4.47).
Table 4.47
Have you ever escaped or tried to escape from Trafficking Destinations?

Category of Respondent Yes No Total

Rescued Victims 333 (40.9%) 482 (59.1%) 815 (100%)
Sex Workers 21 (6.2%) 319 (93.8%) 340 (100%)
Total 354 (30.6%) 801 (69.4%) 1155 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 117

PROFILE AND PERCEPTION OF THE SEX WORKERS:

A prostitute has the same right to life as everyone else under Article 21. In the case of Budhadev
Karmaskar v State of West Bengal, this was explained. It said that sex workers are human beings
who have the right to live and that no one has the right to abuse or murder them. The judgement
also highlighted the plight of sex workers, empathizing that these women are forced to engage
in prostitution not for pleasure, but because of abject poverty, and directed the federal and state
governments to open rehabilitation centres and teach technical and vocational skills such as
sewing so that they can find alternative sources of income. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act
has integrated Section 21 as a regulation for state governments to build and operate protective
houses, which should be regulated by licences issued by them, in accordance with the directive. A
competent authority should be chosen to conduct an inquiry into the application for a protection
house licence. These licences are non-transferable and only good for the time period mentioned.
By virtue of Section 23 of the Act, the government has the authority to adopt ancillary rules for
the licencing, management, and maintenance of protection houses, as well as other concerns.
Prostitutes are generally categorized according to their’ modus operandi,’ which are as follows:
• Brothel Prostitutes: Their business is conducted in a brothel operated by a former
prostitute. Prostitutes are paid a commission for their sexual services.
• Call Girl Prostitutes: These prostitutes usually operate independently of her. She may be
available to customers directly or through middlemen.
• Street Prostitutes: This type of prostitute solicits customers on the streets and takes them
to a location where they will be assigned.
• Other Types: Clandestine forms of prostitution are also found in bare, massage parlors,
amusement centers, dance clubs etc.
According to research conducted by Havocscope, there are roughly 13,828,700 people
participating in prostitution worldwide (Havocscope, 2015). In the last 150 years, several
researchers have focused their efforts on highlighting the causes of prostitution (Benjamin et
al. 1964; Bullough et al. 1978). Hughes identifies four factors that lead to women becoming
prostitutes (Hughes 2004). The first reason is because men are sexually demanding. The second
reason is that various agencies, such as brothel owners, traffickers, pimps, and organized crime
groups, recruit women. The failure of state measures and the legalization of prostitution are the
third and most critical reasons. The fourth factor for women turning to prostitution, according to
Hughes, is societal impact. He goes into great detail about the media’s involvement in promoting
prostitution as a way to get quick money.
It is important to note that while there is no particular restriction against prostitution, there
is a prohibition against trafficking in persons. In reality, in the case of Gaurav Jain v Union of
India, the Supreme Court used its extra-ordinary writ jurisdiction making powers under Article
145 and Article 142 to lay out a comprehensive plan to rescue and rehabilitate victims of sexual
exploitation (AIR 1997 SC 3021). When asked whether the profession they were performing was
legal or illegal, the majority of CSWs did not understand the implications of the issue or had any
knowledge of the law, even if it was just rudimentary. They were afraid of the law enforcement
authorities, but they also said the police aided them, and 66% of the ladies said they were
satisfied with the police’s behaviour. When asked if they wanted the profession to be legalized
or not, almost 79 percent replied yes, although it’s unclear whether they really comprehended
the implications. There is no clear and specific definition of “prostitute” under the Act. Section 2
 118

(f) defines prostitution as “the sexual exploitation or abuse of persons for commercial objectives,
and the phrase “prostitute” should be understood accordingly.” People should not be sexually
exploited or abused for commercial objectives, according to Section 2 (f) of the Act. As a result,
there must be a commercial motive, which entails a customer’s offer of money and acceptance of
the same by the person who sells her body in exchange for consideration.
Despite the fact that prostitution is illegal in India, the country still has Asia’s largest red-light
areas including Kamathipura in Mumbai and Sonaganchi in Kolkata (Menen, 2007; Karandikar
et al., 2008), as well as other red-light localities like G.B. Road in Delhi, Budhwar Peth in Pune,
Meergunj in Allahabad, and Chaturbhujsthan in Muzaffarpur, among others. Because the number
of prostitutes engaging in prostitution vary year to year, the prevalence of prostitution cannot
be precisely estimated. UNAIDS estimate there were 657,829 prostitutes in the country as of
2016. Other unofficial estimates have calculated India has roughly 3–10 million prostitutes. The
government recognized 5532 girls as trafficking victims, according to the NCRB study (Trafficking
in Persons Report: India, 2018). According to the Ministry of Women and Child Development,
nearly 40% of the country’s three million prostitutes are youngsters (Karandikar et al., 2013).
Children are trafficked through well-organized networks with the sole goal of selling them to
brothel owners. Human trafficking is becoming more common by the day, with kids accounting
for roughly 60% of all victims (Sen et al., 2004). In her studies, Pandey stated that child trafficking
for sex work is a symptom of larger socioeconomic issues (Pandey, 2018). According to another
study by Sithannan, certain communities who practice institutional prostitution, such as the
Bedia, Benchara, and Rajnat, have been actively partaking in sex work since the ancient past until
now (Sithannan, 2006). Prostitution has been highlighted as a convenient familial activity among
the Bedias (Agrawal, 2008; Agrawal,2018; Pandey, 2010; Ray,2008; Sen et al.,2004), but it deprives
them of respectability and social position. The Bedia community’s queerness comes from the fact
that they train their females to be prostitutes themselves. Prostitution is traditionally required
of the elder daughter. Institutions such as family, marriage, and kinship are governed by
community structures and guidelines. Pathariya, Mehar, Maneriya, Rahatpur, Banda, Gadakota,
Madwara, Bamuriya, Karyiya Fataka, Fatehpur, Habla, and other villages in the Sagar district
are populated by Bedia people.

Voluntarism in Prostitution in India

In India, prostitution is prohibited, but millions of unlucky girls are forced into it. Poor and
illiterate women are increasingly participating in sex labour, according to research by India’s
Population Council. It is discovered that only 1–5% of women sex workers in Andhra Pradesh
were trafficked into the industry; the rest chose it voluntarily owing to poverty and debt, which
was caused by familial or spousal death, divorce, separation, or a spouse’s chronic sickness
(Population Council, 2008).
However, an increasing number of women are voluntarily trading in their bodies just for
luxury life styles. The same has been also reported in the study conducted by K K Mukherjee
and Sutapa Mukherjee on behalf of the central government by the Gram Niyojan Kendra in
Ghaziabad. According to the article, many young guys seek sex for pleasure and fun. Group sex
is also becoming more popular. (Mukherjee, K. K. and S. S. Mukherjee. 2004. Girls/Women in
Prostitution in India. A National Study. Ghaziabad: Gram Niyojan). Yes, we’re discussing high-
end escorts/Call Girls.
Case Study-1: Meet Priya Singh (name changed), a 24-year-old student at one of Delhi’s most
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 119

prominent colleges. She has already found her ‘ideal’ career, with flexible hours and good pay,
even before she has finished her education. “I come from a middle-class family in north India,
and I can’t afford to live a nice lifestyle without working.” “I use my leisure time to get money,”
Priya explains as she proudly displays a new cell phone she recently purchased. We live in a
culture where people are judged based on their occupation. A doctor or engineer can be seen as
a highly recognized career, whereas a painter or a dancer might not be so much. A female who
stays at home all day may be thought of as a ‘ideal’ woman, but a girl who returns home late may
cause discussion and suspicion in the neighborhood. Let’s not even get into the debate over what
society would think of a girl who chooses to be a prostitute! Priya is one of those high-priced
prostitutes who chose to work in this industry and have no regrets. “You sell your brain, we sell
our bodies,” says the narrator. What’s the big deal? Our society, I believe, is still quite judgmental.
It’s fine if a boy and a girl go on a blind date and end up having sex. However, if the guy pays
the girl for sex, it is unethical, according to Priya. Priya believes that no other career would have
given her such exposure with a clientele that includes businessmen, engineers, lawyers, doctors,
architects, and others from educational backgrounds. She recently went on an all-expenses-paid
vacation to Switzerland with one of her customers, who introduced her as his girlfriend at his
college reunion there. She considers her job to be far more than simply having sex. “I should be
able to carry on a decent discourse about practically any subject.” Many men find a lady who is
well-read attractive. “Of course, I spend a large amount of money every month to stay in shape
and take care of my skin,” says Priya, adding, “And of course, I need to be proficient in English
and grasp something as fundamental as table etiquettes.” My clients usually give me clothes and
make-up.”
Majority of the respondents were from the age group of 16 years and above. However, more
than 1/4th respondents were less than 16 years. More than 2/5th respondents revealed that they
were in sex trade for more than 7 years. However, about 18 per cent sex workers were in sex
trade for less than 4 years, Tenure refers to number of years in sex industry since the entry (Table
4.48).
Table 4.48
Entry age of CSWs in Sex Trade and their Tenure in Sex Trade

Entry age of CSWs in Sex Trade Respondents Tenure of CSWs in Sex Trade Respondents
0-10 Years 9 (2.65%) Less Than 1 Year 1 (0.29%)
10-14 Years 24 (7.06%) 1 Year 2 (0.58%)
14-16 Years 54 (15.88%) 1-2 Years 16 (4.71%)
16-18 Years 96 (28.24%) 3-4 Years 43 (12.65%)
18-25 Years 110 (32.35%) 4-5 Years 37 (10.88%)
25-30 Years 41 (12.06%) 5-6 Years 40 (11.76%)
More Than 30 Years 6 (1.77%) 6-7 Years 54 (15.88%)
Total 340 (100%) 7 Years & Above 147 (43.23%)

Source: Field Survey

Lack of support, not accepting as victim, supporting families, fear of going back to home,
better living and lack of trust in the system were some of the main reasons for being in sex
profession for a long time. About 34 per cent sex workers revealed that they moved to different
locations to engage in commercial sex profession. However, majority of them accepted that their
families are not aware of their profession (Table 4.49).
 120

Table 4.49
Reasons for Being in Sex Profession for A Long Tenure

Reasons For Tenure Frequency

Fear of Going Back to Home 68 (20%)
Lack of Trust in The System 42 (12.35%)
Isolation/ No Support 123 (36.17%)
Don’t Recognize Self as a Victim 108 (31.76%)
Fear of Violence Against Self or Family 19 (5.58%)
Shame / Embarrassment 14 (4.11%)
Traditional Occupation 9 (2.64%)
To Support Family 70 (20.58%)
Better Living 64 (18.82%)
Others 2 (0.58%)

Source: Field Survey

Less than 10 per cent respondents reported that they were lured/ pressurized to engage in
sex during childhood. They were lured/pressurized mainly by relatives, neighbors and strangers
for money and relationship (Table 4.50).
Table 4.50
Have you ever been lured/ pressurized to engage In Sex during Childhood?

Responses Respondents If Yes, Then Lured/ Pressurized by Respondents

Yes 32 (9.41%) Neighbor 9 (28.12%)
No 301 (88.52%) Peer 3 (9.32%)
Refused/No
7 (2.05%) Relative 10 (31.25%)
Response
Total 340 (100%) Pimp 4 (12.5%)
For What You Were Lured/ Pressurized Stranger 5 (15.62%)
Money 11 (34.37%) Others 1 (3.12%)
Gift 6 (18.75%) Total 32 (100%)
Relationship 10 (31.25%)
Others 5 (15.62%)
Total 32 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Type of clients and frequency of their visits to brothels is shown in Table 4.51. “Prostitutes
are offering concessions to student clients,” said K K Mukherjee and Sutapa Mukherjee in
a study conducted on behalf of the central government by the Gram Niyojan Kendra in
Ghaziabad. According to the article, many young guys seek sex for pleasure and fun. Group sex
is also becoming more popular. Regular clients to brothels, according to more than half of the
respondents, are mostly from the working-class labourers, drivers, businessmen/rich people,
and criminals. Client visits were said to be frequent for doctors, teachers, lawyers, foreigners,
police / army officers, and the working class, including labourers, drivers, and others.
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 121

Table 4.51
Type of Clients and Frequency of Their Visits to Brothels

Type Regularly Occasionally Never Total

133 85 122 340
Students
39.11% 25.0% 35.88% 100%
Working Class-Labourers, Drivers 220 118 2 340
Etc. 64.70% 34.70% 0.58% 100%
95 156 89 340
Doctors, Teachers, Lawyers
27.94% 45.88% 26.17% 100%
216 68 56 340
Businessmen/Rich People
63.52% 20% 16.47% 100%
129 109 102 340
Police/Army Personnel
37.94% 32.05% 30% 100%
173 83 84 340
Criminals/Bad Characters
50.88% 24.41% 24.70% 100%
17 151 172 340
Foreigners
5% 44.41% 50.58% 100%
27 73 240 340
Tourists
7.94% 21.47% 70.58% 100%
103 78 158 340
Politicians
30.29% 22.94% 46.47% 100%
134 60 146 340
New Visitors/Strangers
39.41% 17.64% 42.94% 100%
3 57 280 340
Film Personalities
0.88% 16.76% 82.35% 100%
12 32 296 340
Others
3.52% 9.41% 87.05% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Majority of the respondents revealed that they also refused to serve to clients mainly urge for
sex without using condoms, abnormal sex and use of alcohol and drug (Table 4.52).
Table 4.52
Refusal of Client to Serve

Response Respondents Reason For Refusal

Yes 235 (69.17%) Reason Respondents
No 105 (30.88%) Alcohol/ Drug Addict 57 (24.25%)
Total 340 (100%) Sex Without Condom 205 (87.23%)
Client Fee 111 (47.23%)
Abnormal Sex 127 (54.04%)
Others 5 (2.12%)
Total 235 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

About 57 per cent respondents revealed that they get less than Rs. 500 per customer per
 122

service. However, about 20 per cent respondents reported that they get more than Rs. 1000 and
above per customer per service. More than half of them admitted that they have saving account
in bank / post office in their name. About 58 per cent respondents admitted that they remit of
their earnings to their families. However, remittance against total income was reported to be low
(Table 4.53).
Table 4.53
Earnings of CSWs and their Financial Inclusions

Earnings of CSWs Per Customer Per One Services Do You Have a Saving Account in any Bank/Post Office
Earnings Respondents Response Respondents
Below Rs. 500 193 (56.76%) Yes 178 (52.35%)
Rs. 500-1000 79 (23.23%) No 158 (46.47%)
Rs. 1000-2000 60 (17.64%) Refused/ No Response 4 (1.17%)
Rs. 2000 and above 8 (2.35%) Total 340 (100%)
Total 340 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Majority of the respondents had ID such as voter card and aadhar card. These IDs are in
their possession. Majority of the respondents reported that they have basic amenities. About 18
per cent respondents reported that they were abused a part from prostitution earlier. More than
1/4th respondents reported that they faced harassment by police. However, about 17 per cent
respondents admitted that they were arrested by police for soliciting clients. They were released
from police custody mainly through bribing money, providing sex services and on bail (Table
4.54).
Table 4.54
Instances of Harassment of CSWs by Police

Ever Encountered/ Harassed by Police Frequency of Harassment

Responses Respondents Responses Respondents
Yes 91 (26.76%) Frequently 53 (58.24%)
No 247 (72.64%) Occasionally 24 (26.37%)
Refused / No Response 2 (0.58%) Rarely 14 (15.38%)
Total 340 (100%) Total 91 (100%)
Ever Been Arrested by Police for Soliciting Clients Mode of Release from Police Custody
Yes 59 (17.35%) Mode of Release Respondents
No 281 (82.64%) Bribing Money 39 (66.10%)
Total 340 (100%) Providing Sex Services 14 (23.72%)
On Bail 14 (23.72%)
On Cash Penalty 7 (11.86%)
Others 1 (1.69%)
Total 59 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Slightly more than 1/4th respondents revealed that they take drugs/alcohol daily. The main
reasons for taking drugs / alcohol were reported to be physical relief, client’s demand and as a
way of life in brothel (Table 4.55).
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 123

Table 4.55
Use of Alcohol/Drugs by CSWs

Do You Use Drug/Alcohol Daily Frequency of Drug/Alcohol Use

Responses Respondents Responses Respondents
Yes 92 (27.05%) Rarely 30 (32.60%)
No 248 (72.94%) Sometimes 41 (44.56%)
Total 340 (100%) Most Times 17 (18.47%)
Every Time Before Sex 4 (4.34%)
Total 92 (100%)
Reason For Taking Alcohol/Drugs
Reason Respondents
Client Demand 35 (38.04%)
Physical Relief 40 (43.47%)
Thrill/ Excitement 7 (7.60%)
Brothel Way of Life 10 (10.86%)
Total 92 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents admitted that they adopt safe sex behavior. However, a significant
proportion of respondents reported that due to unwillingness on part of clients they do not use
condoms (Table 4.56).
Table 4.56
Preference of Safe or Unsafe Sex by CSWs

Preference of Safe Sex or Unsafe Sex If Safe Sex, How Often You Use Condom
Responses Respondents Responses Respondents
Safe Sex (With Condoms) 328 (96.47%) All The Times 324 (94.29%)
Unsafe Sex (Non-Use of
12 (3.52%) Most Often 16 (4.70%)
Condoms)
Total 340 (100%) Total 340 (100%)
If Not All the Times, Reasons for Not Using Condom All the Time
Not Available 1 (6.25%)
Client Unwilling 15 (93.75%)
Total 16 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents were found aware of HIV /AIDS and STD. However, a negligible
proportion of respondents were not aware of issues pertaining to protected sex, risk of HIV/
AIDS, STD infection (Table 4.57).
Table 4.57
Awareness of HIV/AIDS and STD amongst the CSWs

Have you heard about HIV/AIDS Source of Your Information About HIV/AIDS
Response Respondents Source Respondents
Yes 335 (98.52%) Mass Media 38 (11.34%)
No 5 (1.47%) Co-Workers 60 (17.91%)
 124

Total 340 (100%) NGO Workers 316 (94.32%)

A Person with STD is Prone To HIV/AIDS Others 21 (6.26%)
True 230 (68.65%) Total 335 (100%)
Condom Use Reduces the Risk of HIV/AIDS/STD
False 1 (0.29%)
Infections
Don’t’ Know 104 (31.04%) Response Respondents
Total 335 (100%) True 324 (96.71%)
HIV Mainly Spreads Through Unprotected Sex False 8 (2.38%)
True 332 (99.10%) Partially True 2 (0.59%)
Partially True 2 (0.59%) Don’t Know 1 (0.29%)
Don’t Know 1 (0.29%) Total 335 (100%)
Total 335 (100%)
Commercial Sex Workers Are Most Susceptible To HIV/AIDS
Response Respondents
True 294 (87.76%)
False 15 (4.47%)
Partially True 11 (3.28%)
Don’t Know 15 (4.47%)
Total 335 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

About 60 per cent respondents revealed that they had medical expenditure on major diseases.
However, a large proportion of respondents admitted that they do not undergo on medical test
such as STD, HIV /AIDS (Table 4.58).
Table 4.58
Feedback on Medical Tests

Period General Test HIV/AIDS Test STD Test

Less Than One Month 109 (32.05%) 3 (0.88%) 0 (0.0%)
1-2 Months 31 (9.11%) 10 (2.94%) 7 (2.05%)
2-3 Months 90 (26.47%) 70 (20.58%) 38 (11.17%)
3 Months and Above 100 (29.41%) 176 (51.76%) 131 (38.52%)
No Response 10 (2.94%) 81 (23.82%) 164 (48.23%)
Total 340 (100%) 340 (100%) 340 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Psychological manipulation, threat of physical violence and pleasure are some of the main
habituation factors in sex profession (Table 4.59).
Table 4.59
How Do You Take Habituation Factors in Sex Profession?

Habituation Factors Respondents

Due to Threat of Physical Violence 49 (14.41%)
Threat Of Torture 12 (3.52%)
Forced Drug Use 6 (1.76%)
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 125

Psychological Manipulation 267 (78.52%)

Pleasure 25 (7.35%)

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents had mobile handset and about 36 per cent respondents reported that
they possess smart phone. About 1/3rd respondents further reported that they have their account
in social networking sites such whats App, face book and Youtube. The main reasons for using
social networking sites were reported to be maintaining client relationship, finding new clients
and maintaining profile (Table 4.60).
Table 4.60
Possessing of Mobile Handset and Use of Social Networking Sites

Do you possess Mobile Handset What is Most Commonly Used Site Social Networking site by you
Response Respondents Response Respondents
Yes Basic 205 (60.29%) Facebook 55 (16.17%)
Yes Smart 123 (36.17%) What’s App 115 (33.82%)
No 12 (3.52%) Youtube 18 (5.29%)
Total 340 (100%) Instagram 3 (0.88%)
Do You Use Any Social Networking
Snapchat 3 (0.88%)
Site
Yes 117 (24.41%)
No 223 (65.58%) Total 117 (100%)
Total 340 (100%)
Reason For Using Social Networking Sites
Maintain Client Relationship 81 (69.23%)
Find New Clients 27 (23.07%)
Present Profile 15 (12.82%)
Others 29 (24.78%)
Total 117 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

About 60 per cent respondents are willing to exit from the profession. Most of the respondents
reported that they do not want that their children follow their mother’s profession. However,
majority of them require the support such as livelihood and accommodation, alternative
livelihood and safe and secure place to live in order to exit from the current profession
(Table 4.61).
Table 4.61
Aspirations of CSWs

Do You Wish to Exit from This Profession What Support Do You Need to Exit from This Profession
Response Respondents Response Respondents
Yes 200 (58.82%) Alternative Livelihood 184 (54.11%)
No 104 (30.58%) Livelihood and House to Stay 216 (63.52%)
Already Left 2 (0.58%) Safe and Secure Place to Live 83 (24.41%)
Refused/ No Response 34 (10%) Others 13 (3.82%)
Total 340 (100%)
 126

Whether You Want Your Children to your Profession

Yes 4 (1.17%)
No 336 (98.82%)
Total 340 (100%0

Source: Field Survey

Due to a lack of education and job skills, sex workers are forced to rely on the flesh trade for
a living. It is advised that the district and state governments use the National Urban Livelihood
Mission (NULM) to create basic skill-training programmes for women in areas such as data
entry, telephoning, sales, tailoring, and working with NGOs. Skills-sharing workshops for and
by sex workers is most desirable and sustainable. For sex workers’ economic empowerment,
community-based self-help groups could be formed. Under the PM Shahri Awas Yojana, all
sex workers may be provided with residential accommodations. The formal status of a person
as a worker has a significant impact on their access to credit, social security, benefits, and even
citizenship. Due to the invisibility of sex work, sex workers may be denied access to many sorts
of government assistance and financial resources that could allow them to plan their future, have
an extra income besides sex work, start other economic ventures if they wish to, and save the
money they make.
There is a need for right based economic empowerment of sex workers rather than
rehabilitation based. Financial security, social protection, individual crisis response, and
community institutional development are all important in addressing vulnerabilities and
providing organized support to Sex Workers in obtaining their social and economic entitlements,
such as ration cards, Aadhaar cards, bank accounts, gas connections, and other benefits from
social protection schemes. Unified Help Desks (UHDs) might be established in every red-light
area to help Sex Workers access various social and economic services. Self-employment may be
encouraged besides wage employment.
By default, the structural roots of prostitution and the modus operandi remains the same
across the country where mostly minor girls are trafficked and forced into sex slavery so Kolkata
is no exception. Even Global Slavery Index 2018 report also highlights that India has the highest
number of people living in modern slavery. Besides this, a Public Interest Litigation is already
pending in the Hon’ble Supreme Court for the immediate rescue of 1.2 million minor girls from
the brothels all over the country (PIL filed by Guria Swayam Sevi Sansthan represented by Mr.
Ajeet Singh, reported in Times of India on March 9, 2014).
There are several international and national organizations seeking to protect the rights of
sex workers, including those advocating for the recognition of sex work as labour. The Supreme
Court’s Seventh Report on Sex Work included recommendations such as using community-based
rehabilitation rather than sending them to state-run ‘homes,’ and revising laws like the Immoral
Trafficking in Persons Act to distinguish between those coerced into sex work and those who
engage in it voluntarily, so that interventions are tailored to those who need them (The Seventh
Report of the Panel on Sex Work, constituted by the Supreme Court in 2012).
The Global Network of Sex Work Projects (NSWP) strives to promote the rights of female,
male, and transgender sex workers globally and to unite regional networks working for their
rights. NSWP is a not-for-profit private business registered in the United Kingdom. NSWP is a
non-profit organization with a membership base. Its members are sex worker-led groups and
networks from five continents: Africa, Asia and the Pacific, Europe, Latin America, and North
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 127

and Central America, as well as the Caribbean. NSWP’s work is guided by three core values: (1)
accepting sex work as work; (2) opposing all forms of criminalization and other legal oppression
of sex workers (including sex workers, clients, third parties*, families, partners, and friends); and
(3) promoting sex workers’ self-organization and self-determination.
The All-India Network of Sex Workers (AINSW) is a member of NSWP and represents 5
million sex workers in India. AINSW is a sex workers’ membership-based organization. Each
member organization has equal voting power and rights. The organization now has 19 office
bearers (representing 16 states), and the secretariat is based in Delhi. It is a federation of sex
workers’ community-based organizations (CBOs) dedicated to promoting and safeguarding sex
workers’ rights in addition to their participation in HIV intervention programmes. The AINSW is
committed to establishing sex workers’ rights as well as individuals’ right to self-determination.
It views sex labour as any other type of work that should be decriminalized. It is dedicated to
eliminating the stigma and discrimination associated with sex and sex work. For sex workers,
AINSW facilitates access to social security and health services. For communication, participation,
and representation, AINSW uses basic democratic norms and procedures.
The National Network of Sex Workers (NNSW) is a national network of sex worker-led
groups and partners dedicated to advancing sex workers’ rights in India. NNSW is made up
of 12 CBOs, State Networks, State Federations, and Collectives, as well as eight NGOs spread
throughout seven states. It is the only national network that brings together female, transgender,
and male sex workers with NGOs and sex worker rights advocates, with a membership of 50,000.
The NNSW further urges that anti-human trafficking law not equate sex work with trafficking
and exclude adult consenting sex workers from its scope, whose rights must be protected.
“In the name of prevention, rescue, and rehabilitation, anti-trafficking laws in Asia largely
end up further criminalizing and incarcerating persons who are not trafficked, i.e., the poor, the
beggar, the sex worker, the transgender, the bonded labour, the juvenile, and the surrogate,”
says the NNSW in its statement. This, it claims, occurs because laws place a greater emphasis
on victims than on criminals. Over 1.5 lakh sex workers are members of the NNSW, which is
made up of 63 organizations spread throughout eight states. The network is very vocal in its
opposition to the 2018 Bill on Human Trafficking (Prevention, Protection, and Rehabilitation). It
was passed by the Lok Sabha in 2018, but it lapsed when the 16th Lok Sabha was disbanded prior
to the 2019 general elections.
Several sex workers’ organizations, including the Vaishya Anyay Mukti Parishad (VAMP) in
Sangli, Maharashtra, Ganika Mahila Shakti Sanghatan, Ganga-Jamuna, Red Light Area, Nagpur,
Ananya, Me and My World, Karnataka Sex Workers Union, Muskan, Vadamlar Federation,
Aneka, SIAAP, Samraksha, Sangama, Sangram, WINS According to the NNSW, such tactics have
proved that collectives are efficient first responders to trafficking occurrences at the community
level.
Durbar is a collective of sex workers (male, female, and transgender) headquartered in West
Bengal, India. Durbar (unstoppable or indomitable in Bangla) is a collective of sex workers (male,
female, and transgender) based in West Bengal, India. Durbar has been working to remove
the social, cultural, and structural challenges that sex workers face since its creation (in 1995).
We were compelled to live on the periphery of society due to a lack of self-esteem, the stigma
linked to sex work, and the mainstream culture’s negative attitude toward sex and sex workers.
Durbar is clear about its political goal: to have sex work recognized as equal to other jobs, and
 128

sex workers treated equally to other workers in our society. It is involved in campaigning for
changes to laws and policies that limit sex workers’ human rights, criminalizes sex workers, and
restricts our rights as full citizens of the country. The Durbar Mahila Samanwaya Committee
(DMSC) is a sex workers’ forum established in West Bengal, India, that represents 60,000 sex
workers’ opinions (female, male and transgender). Adult sex work should be decriminalized
in all aspects, according to the DMSC, and sex work should be socially recognized as a service
sector vocation.
DMSC has formed Function of Self-Regulatory Board to
• Prevent entry of minors and trafficked women in the trade in addition to slavery and
slavery-like practices.
• Control other exploitative practices within the sex trade.
• Arrange social security schemes (old age pension, health insurance, vocational training)
for sex workers & their children.
• Support women, children of sex workers with alternative occupations if one wishes to
leave sex work.
• Provide economic security through linking financial institutes.
• Ensure child protection mechanisms for children of sex workers and their access to
education and other career building opportunities
On January 31, 2021, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) ordered the Chief
Secretary of West Bengal to submit a thorough report on the strategy enacted to “monitor and
prevent” the sex-trade and brothels in Kolkata’s Sonagachi neighbourhood within the next 10
weeks. The NHRC also ordered the Secretary of the West Bengal Government’s Department of
Women and Child Development and Social Welfare to expedite the work of conducting a survey,
in collaboration with the Indian Institute of Science, on the social, legal, and health conditions
of sex-trade victims in Sonagachi, and to submit the report by March 11 at the latest. The NHRC
issued the order in response to a plea filed by Radhakanta Tripathy, a prominent human rights
campaigner and Supreme Court lawyer, regarding the situation of trafficked or otherwise
engaged sex workers in Sonagachi, Kolkata’s main red-light area. Tripathy said in his plea that
women, including little girls, have been subjected to sexual assault and savage rape as a result
of the state’s inaction and negligence. “The government authorities fail to maintain surveillance
and do what is required for a permanent solution to the issue that has existed in the area for
decades,” he said.
In response to the NHRC’s directives, the Commissioner of Kolkata Police stated in his report
that the police conducted an extensive search to locate the victims and that a strict vigil and close
watch is maintained throughout the year over the Sonagachi area to prevent human trafficking
and sexual exploitation. “At Sonagachi Area, the local police station and detective department of
Kolkata Police also record cases as per the provisions of the Immoral Trafficking and Prevention
Act (ITP Act),” stated Police Commissioner. The report also revealed that the Kolkata Police,
which includes a women’s helpline and a child line, have established a helpline to combat
human tracking in order to prevent crime, and that awareness programmes have been held at
various locations by the Kolkata Police to raise public awareness and combat human tracking.
The West Bengal government’s Secretary Department of Women and Child Development and
Social Welfare detailed the actions taken to address the issue of human tracking in its report.
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 129

The above analysis and discussion simply raised a valid question: “Can the Government of
India grant social recognition of sex work as a service sector occupation or can it legalise sex
work as a work?” Many National and International agencies have raised concerns about the
criminalization of Consensual Adult Sex Work.
The following is the logic behind the demand:
• Why Criminalizing adult, voluntary, and consenting sex, as well as the commercial
exchange of sexual services, violates the fundamental right to personal autonomy and
privacy. In other words, the government should not dictate consenting adults who they
can have sexual relations with and under what conditions.
• Criminalization exposes sex workers to abuse and exploitation by law enforcement
personnel, such as cops. Human Rights Watch has documented how police officers
harass sex workers, extort bribes, physically and verbally abuse sex workers, and even
rape or coerce sex from them in criminalized contexts. Many studies have revealed that
criminalizing sex workers renders them more vulnerable to violence, such as rape, assault,
and murder, by attackers who regard sex workers as easy targets since they are stigmatized
and unlikely to receive support from the authorities. Criminalization may also force sex
workers to labour in dangerous environments in order to avoid being arrested.
• Sex workers’ ability to seek justice for crimes against them is routinely harmed by
criminalization.
• The criminalization of sex work has been determined to have a negative impact on sex
workers’ right to health, according to UNAIDS, public health specialists, sex worker
organizations, and other human rights organizations.
• Criminalization has ramifications for other human rights. Sex workers are less likely to be
able to organize as workers, fight for their rights, or work together to support and protect
themselves in nations that prohibit sex work.
• Sex work is defined as the voluntary exchange of sex between two adults. Human
trafficking and child sexual exploitation are two distinct issues. Both are severe human
rights violations and crimes that should be investigated and prosecuted at all times.
• Laws that clearly separate sex work from crimes such as human trafficking and child
sexual exploitation protect both sex workers and crime victims. Sex workers may have
valuable knowledge about crimes such as human trafficking and child sexual exploitation,
but they are unlikely to feel safe revealing this information to the authorities unless the
activity they do is not considered unlawful.
• The Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women (SR-VAW) has stated that “measures
to address trafficking in persons should not overshadow the need for effective measures
to protect the human rights of sex workers” [UNHRC (2014) Report of the Special
Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, its Causes and Consequences, Mission to India].
The SR-VAW has also requested that India’s Immoral Traffic Prevention Act, 1956, which
criminalizes sex employment, be reviewed.
• UN Resolutions, international agencies, and commissions have emphasized the importance
of a rights-based approach to sex work, emphasizing the need to protect rights not just by
decriminalizing sex work, but also by ending the unjust application of non-criminal laws
and regulations against sex workers.
 130

• According to the National Commission for Women, access to health care is a serious
concern for women who work in the sex industry. While the stigma of being a “immoral
whore” makes it difficult to acquire adequate medical care, the medical establishment’s
illiteracy, ignorance, and fear leaves them vulnerable to exploitation and extortion of
money and resources.

RESCUE AND REHABILITATION OF SEX WORKERS:

The ITPA’s rescue and rehabilitation provisions are responsible for some of the most
pervasive human rights violations. Special police officers and NGO workers conduct raids on
brothels, where women are “rescued” and placed in rehabilitation centers. Police raids, which
are common in red light areas and ostensibly to save youngsters, make no distinction between
minors and consenting adults. Trafficking and migration are being conflated, resulting in the
denial of labour rights. The distinction between “trafficking,” “sex work,” and “migration” is
critical. There is a propensity to equate sex work with human trafficking, according to the Special
Rapporteur on Violence Against Women [ (SR-VAW) [UNHRC (2014) Report of the Special
Rapporteur on violence against women, its causes and consequences, Mission to India]. She saw
that when sex workers are identified as victims of human trafficking, the help they receive isn’t
tailored to their individual requirements.
Though many sex workers have been deceived or persuaded into sex work by money and
may be considered “trafficked,” there are many more who have not entered sex work owing to
any form of force or deception. They’ve relocated in pursuit of a better life and a better way of
life. Though poverty and inequality are factors that lead people to engage in sex work and show
a lack of “free will,” it is impossible to say that everyone who suffers from these conditions
is a victim of human trafficking. Human rights assistance, including social and economic
options, should be provided to them. When women’s voluntary migration (for the purpose of
employment, residence, or escape from persecution by State or non-State actors) is confused
with human trafficking, protectionist measures steeped in patriarchal control over women’s
mobility result in female migration being stifled both within and outside the country’s borders.
This restricts women’s ability to go away from their families and kinfolk in search of a better
life. Even though the lines between deceptive transportation and a person’s desire to travel are
blurred (with women encountering both situations at different times in their lives), restricting
women’s movement is not the solution.
For women who work in the sex industry, the challenges are magnified. An older sex worker
becomes destitute and disenfranchised due to a lack of support from family and unsafe, inadequate
workplaces (as well as from family members who would like the income to reach home, but
without the ‘sullied’ woman returning home), even if she may have earned a substantial income
during her working years. The consent of adult women who are “rescued” from sex work is
irrelevant, and they are detained in correctional facilities despite testifying that they were in sex
work willingly. These adult women are placed in the care of their parents or family members
on the condition that they stop working in the sex industry. Moral judgments are frequently
used to give over “custody” of an adult sex worker to a parent or family member. The (often)
involuntary rehabilitation of women in sex trade is the final stage in the rescue intervention.
Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) or government-sponsored rehabilitation programmes
are available. Sex workers are sent to rehabilitation centers, where they are confined in jail-like
conditions and subjected to recurrent sexual abuse before being freed. The health and safety
problems of women unwillingly removed from brothels have been brought to the attention of
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 131

sex worker organizations. Given the high rates of violence faced by women in rehabilitation
homes, the return of women to sex work, and the disruption of their daily lives as a result of
being held for extended periods of time, rehabilitation programmes frequently undercut the
whole goal of their existence.
According to our study, the rehabilitation of sex workers in India is a serious problem.
The Supreme Court of India has ruled that sex workers’ rehabilitation training should not be
conditional on their being forced to stay in corrective homes, and that sex workers cannot be
detained in corrective homes “which they regard as a virtual prison.” (The Seventh Report
of the Panel on Sex Work, constituted by the Supreme Court in 2012). Despite these findings,
forced rehabilitation remains the standard across the India. The demand for unorganized sector
social security nets has evolved as a right to offer social protection for India’s marginalized and
invisible workers. Unorganized workers’ concerns about sex workers’ social security must also
be considered. The Indian Parliament passed the Social Security for the Unorganized Sector 2008
legislation in December 2008. Sex workers have expressed a desire to be included in these social
protection schemes, as well as to take part in larger campaigns and forums advocating for the
rights of the unorganized workforce. At the district level, however, income generation plans
are made conditional on sex workers giving up sex work, a requirement that many sex workers
refuse.
Another factor that prevents sex workers from participating in income-generating
initiatives is that they are forced to join self-help groups in their village or neighbourhood.
Many sex workers who participate in self-help groups have complained of discrimination and
marginalization from other SHG members. As a result, the government should examine the need
for identity-based self-help groups as an unique relaxation for marginalized communities. The
Pension Parishad, a national campaign to demand a Universal Old Limit Pension, has taken
into account the concerns of old sex workers, such as lowering the eligibility age to 45 years
for especially vulnerable populations such tribal tribes, transgender people, and women in sex
work. Women’s (and trans-women’s) concerns in sex work should not be relegated to Article 6
of CEDAW, according to the overarching recommendation to the Indian government. Women
who work in the sex industry have rights in the economic, political, social, civil, and cultural
arenas. Education, political participation (including national and international representation),
citizenship, livelihood, health, equality before the law, and freedom from gender stereotyped
notions about women’s chastity and roles and responsibilities within a hetero- normative and
patriarchal family can only be fully realized if discrimination is eliminated from all aspects of
sex workers’ lives. As a result, we urge the Indian government to take a holistic approach to
realizing sex workers’ human rights, and we advocate those interventions impacting sex workers
be carried out with sex workers’ input, participation, and leadership.
To ensure that the State is held accountable for respecting, safeguarding, and fulfilling the
rights of women in sex work, the question must be asked: How will the person, department, or
mechanism responsible be held accountable? What will be the relief/remedies for the woman/
women who have been harmed as a result of the absence of implementation? What would be
the consequences of non-compliance with laws and policies, as well as non-implementation?
Addressing the state’s accountability for acts or omissions by state and non-state actors, as well as
establishing an independent monitoring system to hold the judiciary accountable for upholding
the checks and balances amongst state organs, are all critical.
 132

PERCEPTION ANALYSIS OF PARENTS OF TRAFFICKED VICTIMS:

Parents of trafficked victims are one of the most important stakeholders in combating human
trafficking, thereby we contacted 411 parents of trafficked victims across the selected states except
Delhi and a thorough interview and FGDs were conducted with them by the Research Team.
Out of 411 Parents interviewed, majority of them (71.3 percent) belongs to Rural Areas followed
by Semi-Urban areas (13.1 percent). The percentage of parents of belonging to urban areas and
metropolitan cities are same (7.8 percent). It is reported that most of the respondents were having
the age more than 30 Years, 4.9 percent were from the age group of 25-30 Years, whereas only
0.5 percent respondents were in the age group of 18-25 Years. As for as social background of
parents is concerned majority of them were from other backward classes (25.1 percent) followed
by Scheduled Tribes (23.6 percent), General Castes (19.7 percent) and Scheduled Castes (17.0
percent). About 12.4 percent parents were from minority communities and 2.2 percent parents
were from other social classes. Out of 411 Parents interviewed most of the respondents (74.7
percent) were followers of Hindu religion followed by Islam (13.4 percent, Christian (2.7 percent),
Sikhs (0.2 percent) and 9.0 percent respondents were followers of other faiths & religion. Most
of the respondents were married (89.8 percent), separated (6.6 percent), divorced (1.9 percent),
widows (1.2 percent) and 0.5 percent were abandoned.
It is reported that most of the Parents of trafficked victims were illiterate (38.2percent),
about 33.6 percent were having primary level education and 20.0 percent had completed their
middle level schooling. Only 0.7 percent were graduate and only 2.4 percent had completed their
intermediate (10+2). Most of the respondents were from nuclear family (64.7 percent) followed
by extended families (23.8 percent) and only 11.4 percent were from joint families. Family
occupation of most of the respondent is agriculture (31.1 percent) followed by un-skilled labours
(22.6 percent), skilled labours (14.6 percent), self-employed (13.9 percent) and causal labours
(6.1 percent). Equal percentages (3.9 percent) were having salaried private Jobs and engaged in
crop plantations. About 1.2 percent respondents were engaged in animal husbandry, 0.7 percent
having petty business and only 0.2 percent having the salaried government, Jobs. 1.7 percent
respondents were engaged in other profession. As for economic status is concerned 53.3 percent
of respondents reported that their annul family income is in less than Rs. 20,000/- thereby 51.8
percent respondent were belonging to BPL category and 28.2 percent were the beneficiaries of
AAY-Antodaya Anna Yojana (poorest of poor). 9.5 percent reported that they fall in BPL category
but they do not have any kind of card. Only 5.4 percent respondents were from APL category.
Poverty and illiteracy have been identified as two of the leading causes of human trafficking.
The majority of the parents of trafficked victims are illiterate and live in object poverty, which
confirms this study. As a result, it is critical to ensure that the various poverty-eradication schemes
target families with vulnerable women and children who are at high risk of being trafficked for
sexual exploitation and commercial purposes. The focus must be on preventing women and
girls from becoming victims of human trafficking. People from disadvantaged populations,
such as Dalits, tribals, and religious minorities, are particularly vulnerable to human trafficking.
Forced child labour and/or sex trafficking are common forms of trafficking for children from
underserved families. Several minors work in brick kilns, construction sites, and agricultural
areas illegally. Child trafficking can also take the form of youngsters being forced to participate
in begging rings and other similar activities. Many youngsters are sold to work in factories and
other hazardous occupations with poisonous conditions by their parents. Aside from that, awful
reports of young girls being coerced into the sex trade appear on a daily basis. Due to their terrible
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 133

socioeconomic conditions, the parents of these children are either misled or tricked into ‘sending’
or ‘selling’ their children for ‘better livelihood possibilities.’ Most traffickers take advantage of
their lack of awareness, particularly among the uneducated and impoverished who live in slums
and other backward areas of the country. Parents of young children are promised daily wages by
traffickers, who then move them to large cities, where they are frequently treated as commodities.
Families in desperate financial situations are frequently approached by traffickers who offer to
buy their children, and with no other option, parents accept.

Response on Status of Migration

In today’s environment, migration is quite important. Understanding the complexities
of gender and migration can lead to initiatives and policies that assist female migrants while
lowering their costs. Respondents were asked is anyone from your house living/working/
seasonally working outside the village in last three years, only 37 (9.0 percent) out of 411 reported
yes. Out of 37 persons migrated, 22 (59.46 percent) were female and 15 (40.54 percent) were male
members. Out of 37 migrated persons 18 (48.65 percent) were in the age group of 14-18 Years,
only 3 (5.4 percent) were above 18 years. Thus 34 (91.89 percent) were minor at the time of
migration. Those 37 persons who migrated 21 (56.76 percent) were daughters, 8 (21.62 percent)
were sons, 5 (13.51 percent) were wives and 3 (8.11 percent) were brothers of respondents. It is
crystal clear that majority of migrated persons are female (70.29 percent). Migrant women are at
a heightened risk of violence and abuse because domestic workers, caregivers, and workers in
the sex and entertainment industries are often not covered by labor protections and are hidden
from the public. Example-Dance bar girls in Maharashtra
Women migrants, particularly irregular migrants, may be particularly exposed to violence.
Emotional, psychological, physical, and sexual violence, as well as economic abuse, can occur in
the origin country/state, during transit, in the destination country/state, or even on returning
home. Respondents were asked who takes decision about movement of Child out of village/
town for work, the responses of 34 parents whose children were migrated is shown in Table:
4.62. More than half of the respondents said that decision is taken by both i.e., mother and father.
About 29.4 percent respondents replied that this kind of decision is taken only by father of child.
Table 4.62
Who takes Decision about Movement of Child for Migration?

Who Takes Both Father Guardian

Father Mother Self Total
Decision and Mother (Uncle/ Aunt/ Grandparents)

10 1 20 2 1 34
Response
29.4% 2.9% 58.8% 5.9% 2.9% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Respondents were asked that who were the facilitators for migration of their children,
responses are shown in Table: 4.63. About 60 percent respondents said that Family members
are the facilitators followed by friends/relatives (11.8 percent), contractors/agents (5.9 percent)
and placement agencies (2.9 percent). Surprisingly 23.5 percent respondents reported that their
children run away from home. NCRB data shows that 1,18,971, 1,15,656 and 1,19,617 children
went missing in the country in 2017, 2018 and 2019 respectively and run away is one of the most
important reasons for rising number of missing children in the country.
 134

Table 4.63
How Did Child Go Out of Village/Town?

Friend/ Child Contractors/Agents Paid Advance

Placement
Facilitator Family Relatives/ Run and Took the Child Away with Total
Agencies
Other Villagers Away The Permission of The Family
19 4 8 1 2 34
Responses
55.9% 11.8% 23.5% 2.9% 5.9% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Respondents were asked about the relationship with persons who accompanied child
outside the village. 32.4 percent respondents reported that it was the employer/agent followed
by parents (17.6 percent), family members (14.7 percent), and relatives (14.75 percent) and about
17.6 percent others who accompanied their children. Only 2.9 percent children were migrated
alone. When asked about duration of stay in migration, 28.2 percent respondents reported that
their child stayed for 1-3 months followed by 3-6 months (23.6 percent) and more than 6 months
51.8 percent. As for as purpose of migration is concerned about 3/4th respondents said that their
children went out for job followed by education (9.7%), marriage (8.5 percent) and for other
purposes (5.4 percent). When asked about money received in lieu of migration/ trafficked, 16.3
percent respondents said yes, they had received advance financial payments. This means 16.3
percent parents almost sold their children in the hand of traffickers or agents. This is a serious
concern. When respondents were asked that if they are aware where their children’s lives,
surprisingly 28.7 percent respondents said that they have no idea where his child lives.
Respondents were asked about nature of work in which child is involved at the destination;
the responses are shown in Table: 4.64. Most of the (about 37 percent) respondents reported that their
children were working as forced labour-domestic works. Women make up the majority of domestic
workers worldwide. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), there were
roughly 43.6 million female domestic workers worldwide in 2011. Domestic work is typically
unregulated by labour rules. Migrant domestic workers are kept concealed from the public
eye, making them more vulnerable to abuse and limiting their ability to socialise. It is more
difficult for them to become aware of their rights, or to form or join unions, as a result of their
isolation. Female migrants may also face lower salaries as a result of the scenario. When migrant
women are subjected to harassment or discrimination at work, they are frequently unaware of
their rights, especially if they are secluded from the general population. Because of their limited
mobility, fear of deportation, and concern about losing their jobs, they may be unable to use
current resources and support. Female migrants may be coerced into prostitution or the sale of
sexual favours in order to survive or support their family, particularly in circumstances of forced
migration or displacement. Sexual exploitation is a threat to migrant women. According to an
ILO report, one out of every six irregular female migrants is forced to engage in sexual activity,
generally in the entertainment or domestic sectors. Separation from spouses due to migration, as
well as forced or income-based sex activity, may raise the risk of HIV and AIDS.
Table 4.64
Nature of Work in Which Child was involved at The Destination

Nature of Works Total Response

Forced Labour-Domestic Works 98 (37.1%)

Labour In Agriculture 2 (0.8%)
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 135

Labour In Small Industries-Textiles Workshop Etc. 20 (7.6%)

Labour In Firecracker Workshop 6 (2.3%)
Labour In Construction 20 (7.6%)
Labour In Hazardous Industries- Metallurgical Industries, Coal, Fertilizers, Mining,
75 (28.4%)
Chemical & Petrochemicals, Cement,
Hotels, Bars, Restaurants, Markets 28 (10.6%)
Others 15 (5.7%)
Total 264 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

About 31 percent respondents reported that their children were working in hazardous
industries- metallurgical industries, coal, fertilizers, mining, chemical & petrochemicals, cement
and firecracker workshops. Hazardous child labour, more specifically, is work in hazardous or
unhealthy situations that could result in a child being killed, hurt, or sickened as a result of
low safety and health regulations and working conditions. It can lead to long-term disability,
illness, and psychological harm. Often, health problems induced by child labour do not manifest
themselves until the child is an adult. Hazardous child labour is the most common form of child
labour, with an estimated 73 million children aged 5 to 17 working in hazardous situations
in a variety of industries such as agriculture, mining, construction, manufacturing, as well as
hotels, bars, restaurants, markets, and domestic service. It can be found in both developed and
underdeveloped nations. Girls and boys typically begin doing dangerous work at a young
age. Every year, the ILO estimates that 22,000 children are killed at work around the world.
The number of people who have been hurt or become unwell as a result of their profession
is unknown. Children are more vulnerable to occupational dangers than adults because their
bodies and minds are still developing, and the repercussions of hazardous work are typically
more catastrophic and long-lasting for them.
The other forms of works reported by respondents are Hotels, Bars, restaurants, markets
(10.6 percent), Labour in small industries-textiles workshop etc. (7.6 percent), and labour in
construction (7.6 percent). Respondents were asked about their contact with the children during
the migration period. Only 15.1 percent respondents reported that they had regular contact with
their children and 74.9 percent respondents reported that they had irregular contact with their
children whereas 10 percent respondents reported that their children were untraceable. About 50
percent respondents reported that they had to contact their children through friends/relatives/
agent’s phone. Only 13.1 percent respondents reported that their children were provided some
kind of education along with the works Respondents were asked whether they are aware of the
law against child labour, 76.9 percent respondents said they are not aware and those were aware
only 11.4 percent said that they are aware that child labour is a punishable crime.
In a very astonishing way 83.8 percent respondents said that Child migration/trafficking for work
is not inevitable. About 98.3 percent respondents said that there is no change in living status of family
after sending child for work outside. Respondents were asked about status of child’s health after
migration/trafficking for work. About 13 percent respondents reported that health of their children
gets deteriorated after migration, especially mental health and behavior. Respondents were asked
about the instances Where their migrant child was abused. About 62.5 percent respondents reported
that their children were abused during the migration/trafficking as well as destinations. When asked
about types of abuse, 65.4 percent reported that their children faced both verbal and physical abuse,
16.6 percent reported for verbal abuse only, 12.8 percent reported for physical abuse only and 23.7
 136

percent respondents reported that their children were sexually abused. When asked about nature
of physical abuse 69.7 percent reported for beating/hitting followed by over work (48.5 percent),
deprivation of food (24.2 percent) and deprivation of sleep (15.2 percent). It was also reported by 78.8
percent respondents that their children suffered/got injured by beating and upon knowing these kind
of abuse 92.3 percent respondents felt helpless and very bad. 95 percent respondents reported that
their children complained about the misbehavior or sexual exploitation to the concerned available
authorities (contractors/agents/relatives) but got no help. Better education for children, protection
of children, employment for adult, better information and awareness for families and better law
enforcement against offenders were some of the measures suggested to reduce the possibility of
children having to migrate to work (Table 4.65).
Table 4.65
Suggestions to Reduce the Possibility of Migration of Children to Work

Suggestions Total Response

More Employment for Adults 249 (60.6%)
Better Education for Children 254 (61.8%)
More Protection for Children 286 (69.6%)
Better Information and Awareness for Families 219 (53.3%)
Better Law Enforcement Against Offenders 162 (39.4%)
Better Awareness Among Sending Communities 99 (24.1%)
Communities To Be Organized Against Trafficking of Children 80 (19.5%)
Awareness Among Children Against Child Labour and Unsafe Migration 68 (16.5%)
Others 2 (0.5%)
Source: Field Survey
The Ecological background wise distribution of Awareness about National Human Rights
Commission (NHRC) amongst the Victims is presented in Table 4.66. The awareness has been
found quite low (5 per cent) for all the ecological background. However, the relation between
ecological background and Awareness about National Human Rights Commission (NHRC)
amongst the Victims has been found significant which is validated by the value of chi-square.
Table 4.66
Ecological background wise Awareness about National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) amongst the
Victims
Ecological Awareness about National Human Right Commission (NHRC)
Total
Background Yes No
0 144 144
Metropolitan City
0.0% 100% 100%
2 697 699
Rural
0.3% 99.7% 100%
0 90 90
Semi-Urban
0.0% 100% 100%
58 137 195
Urban
29.7% 70.3% 100%
60 1068 1128
Total
5.3% 94.7% 100%
Trafficked Victims and Their Exploitation 137

Chi-Square Tests 279.287**

** indicating value is significant at 1% level of significance

The Educational Level wise distribution of Awareness about National Human Rights
Commission (NHRC) amongst the Victims is presented in Table 4.67. The awareness has been
found quite low (5 per cent) for all the ecological background. However, the relation between
Educational Level and Awareness about National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) amongst
the Victims has been found significant which is validated by the value of chi-square.
Table 4.67
Educational Level wise Awareness about National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) amongst the
Victims
Awareness about National Human Right Commission (NHRC)
Educational Level Total
Yes No
7 310 317
Illiterate
2.2% 97.8% 100%
6 284 290
Primary
2.1% 97.9% 100%
44 292 336
Middle School
13.1% 86.9% 100%
2 136 138
High School
1.4% 98.6% 100%
0 32 32
Intermediate
0.0% 100% 100%
0 11 11
Graduate
0.0% 100% 100%
1 3 4
Postgraduate
25.0% 75.0% 100%
60 1068 1128
Total
5.3% 94.7% 100%
Chi-Square Tests 62.112**

Prostitution and human trafficking are linked. Globalization, economic liberalization, and
other socio-cultural issues have all contributed to an alarming rise in both human trafficking
and prostitution. This rise can be linked to a number of factors, including illiteracy, ignorance,
poverty, cultural customs, as well as increased consumerism brought on by globalization, growth
in the tourism and hotel industries, and so on. Economic exploitation, corruption, and criminal
ties define the industry. Human trafficking has become one of the most profitable industries
on the planet. Women and children are trafficked from vulnerable and destitute homes, and
the majority of young women and girls are forced into the sex business. Trafficking isn’t just
about commercial sexual exploitation; it’s also about bonded labour, organ transplants, beggary,
and weddings, among other things. The existence of red-light areas in our towns and cities
demonstrates that society has implicitly accepted and even endorsed the prostitution industry.
Prostitution has become socially acceptable, resulting in systematic exploitation of young women
and the marketing of the flesh trade by anti-social forces. The principal victims of this institution
are the children of prostitutes, who are discriminated against, socially ostracised, and denied of
a normal existence for no fault of their own. They continue to be deprived of basic chances, as
 138

well as the atmosphere and conditions that are required for general physical and psychological
growth.
 Chapter 5
RECRUITERS, PERPETRATORS AND
EXPLOITERS OF VICTIMS
H uman trafficking is a breach of human rights that involves the practice of enslaving another
person by force, deception, or compulsion. Traffickers profit from the practice by enslaving and
exploiting their victims for labour and/or sex. Prostitution or other forms of sexual exploitation,
forced labour or services, slavery or practices comparable to slavery, servitude, or the removal of
organs are all examples of exploitation. According to the UNODC’s 2020 Global Report on Human
Trafficking in Persons, nearly two-thirds of those convicted of human trafficking offences in 2018 were
men, despite women’s participation being higher than in other crimes. Traffickers under the age of 18
accounted for about 2% of all convictions. Females continue to be convicted in significantly greater
numbers than males in Eastern Europe and Central Asia, with 80 percent of convictions involving
women, while males and females were convicted in nearly equal numbers in Central America and
East Asia in 2018. While many traffickers have criminal backgrounds and use human trafficking
as a direct source of revenue, business owners, intimate partners, and other family members are
also engaged. Court trials indicate instances of parents facilitating their children’s sexual exploitation
or pushing them to beg on the streets. Despite the fact that most nations have extensive human
trafficking legislation in place for some time, the number of convictions has only recently begun
to rise. The rise in the number of convictions coincides with the rise in the number of detected and
reported victims, indicating that the criminal justice system is responding to the detection trend.
However, certain regions continue to have an extremely low number of trafficking convictions while
detecting fewer victims. The fact that there are few recognized victims and convictions does not mean
that human traffickers are not active in these countries. Victims of human trafficking from areas
with low detection and conviction rates have been found in high numbers in other areas. According
to a report released by the International Labor Organization in May 2014, human trafficking is the
world’s second largest criminal enterprise, earning exploiters more than $150 billion every year.

THE RECRUITERS/TRAFFICKERS
Human traffickers are criminals who profit from the exploitation of others. The sole
purpose of a human trafficker is to get money by exploiting other people. Different ‘links’ in the
human trafficking network act as human traffickers. Their acts may involve one or more of the
following: recruiting, transportation, sheltering, and receiving of trafficked individuals. Human
traffickers entice their victims with promises of a better life and financial prospects, utilizing
charm, falsehoods, and deception. These assurances are false. Victims of human trafficking
quickly learn that the promises of a “better life” or “excellent wages” made by the traffickers
 140

were lies. Traffickers may become the “lover” or the legal spouse of a victim. This, too, is based
on a fabrication of reality. The goal is not to be romantic, but to make money. The victim could
be sold, employed for labour, or sexually exploited. The truth is that these victims have become
commodities to be exchanged, exploited, threatened, beaten, tortured, raped, and occasionally
killed – all in the name of profit for the human trafficker. Human traffickers have been known to
use kidnapping to obtain their “commodity.” After obtaining their victim, the trafficker maintains
control by using physical and psychological threats, humiliation, beatings, sleep deprivation,
and hunger. Despite movies and TV shows, abduction is not a method of recruitment in general.
Grooming and relentless creation of a ‘genuine friendship’ is typically used to win trust and
subsequently control.
Human traffickers may be tied to large international criminal networks, smaller domestic
networks, a ‘family business,’ or operate on a small scale, completely on their own. They could
own a bar, a nightclub, a massage parlour, a factory, an orchard, or a farm, for example. While some
companies may be legal, their earnings may be based on the exploitation of human trafficking
victims. Human traffickers might transport their victims over national borders or keep them in
the same country, city, or town. The trafficker may accompany the victim physically or create
a circumstance in which the victim is unable to “simply turn around and go back” once they
have started their journey. They are sometimes provided only the name and phone number of
the next person they will meet (the next trafficker in the trafficking chain), with no knowledge
of where they are or what route the journey will take. Because of the victims’ lack of orientation,
fear, limited understanding of the destination country, and ongoing maltreatment, traffickers
are able to keep such control over them. Victims who are trapped, demoralized, abused, and
‘camouflaged’ inside our immediate communities but under the power of the human trafficker
can only be protected via the acts of free members of civil society.

PROFILE OF TRAFFICKERS:
Table 5.1 shows the gender of traffickers (respondents). More over two-thirds of traffickers
(69.4%) are men, while significantly less than one-third (30.6%) of respondents are women.
Human traffickers can thus be both men and women. In reality, when it comes to recruiting
victims, a woman trafficker may appear more ‘trustworthy’ than a man, especially when it comes
to minors or young women for forced sexual exploitation. “Of sure, we’ll take care of her.” She’ll
be surrounded by great things and meet lovely people.” To a desperate poor parent who wants
the best for their child, these words of hope may sound so genuine. It’s also possible that their
culture “justifies” selling their child to pay off debts or provide sustenance for the family for a
limited time.
Table: 5.1
Gender of Trafficker

Gender Male Female Total

34 15 49
Responses
69.4% 30.6% 100%

Source: Field Survey

According to our research, more than half of the traffickers (57.1%) live in rural areas, while
slightly more than a third (36.7%) live in India’s metropolitan cities. Only 6.1 percent of human
traffickers live in cities or semi-urban areas. As a result, it can be established that the majority
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 141

of traffickers’ networks are concentrated in rural areas, followed by India’s metropolitan cities.
When it comes to the age of traffickers, it is reported that slightly less than half (49.0 percent)
of them are between the ages of 35 and 40, followed by 30-35 and 40-50. (Each 18.4 percent).
Only 14.4 percent of respondents stated that they are under the age of 30. More than a third
of respondents (38.8%) identified themselves as belonging to Other Backward Classes, while
slightly less than a third (32.7%) identified themselves as Schedule Tribes. Only 6.1 percent said
they belonged to Schedule Caste communities, while slightly more than a fifth (22.4 percent) said
they belonged to the general category. It can be assumed that, like the victims, the majority of
traffickers are from underprivileged backgrounds, as they have an easier time gaining the trust
of victims from their own neighbourhoods. About one-fifth (19.3%) of respondents were from
minority communities, and slightly more than two-thirds (77.6%) belonged to the Hindu faith.
Only 4.1 percent of widows were also involved in trafficking, despite the fact that the majority
of respondents (95.9%) were married. In terms of educational qualifications, more than 80%
of traffickers are educated (primary-16.3 percent, middle school-30.6 percent, high school-32.7
percent, intermediate-8.2 percent, graduate-4.1 percent), with just 8.2 percent claiming to be
illiterate. Slightly less than two third (63.3 percent) traffickers were conversant with at least two
languages, about 14 percent respondents were conversant with three languages. The majority of
respondents (81.65) were now living with their spouse and children, with roughly 8% living with
their parents and similar amounts living alone.
Previous occupation of traffickers is shown in Table: 5.2. Petty business, pimp, skilled labour,
sex workers and previous victim of Commercial Sex Exploitation were some of the previous
occupations of traffickers.
Table: 5.2
Previous Occupation of Traffickers
Previous Occupation of Traffickers Responses
Previous victim of CSE 1 (2.0%)
Sex Worker 2 (4.1%)
Pimp 5 (10.2%)
Skilled Labour 4 (8.2%)
Petty Business 19 (38.8%)
Service 2 (4.1%)
Other 3 (6.1%)
No response 1 (2.0%)
Total 49 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

It is reported that slightly less than half (49.0%) respondents had some or other types of
Criminal Antecedents. Those having Criminal Antecedents were arrested by Police in some or
other cases mainly for Cheating, Abuse of Children, Human Trafficking, rape or other heinous
crimes and those arrested about 86% reported that they have been prosecuted for their offences
but only slightly more than one fifth (20.8 percent) prosecuted persons were convicted/sentenced.
The main reason behind low conviction rate as reported by traffickers is getting bail easily and
thereby influencing the witness and the victims in their favour. Slightly more than two third
(69.4 percent) respondents reported they are used to take Drugs or Alcohol and those were used
to take drugs /alcohol half of the respondents reported that they take it often and slightly more
 142

than one fifth (20.6 percent) reported that they always take it. Types of drugs used by traffickers
are shown in Table: 5.3, Cocaine and tranquillizers are the most desired/favoured drugs used
by traffickers. Most of the traffickers during interaction told that they are also involved in drug
peddling but they were always arrested on grounds of human trafficking rather than for drug
peddling as they get bail easily in trafficking cases.
Table: 5.3
Types of Drugs You Use
Name/Types of Drugs Trafficker
Heroin 8 (23.5%)
Other Opiate 3 (8.8%)
Tranquillizers 6 (17.6%)
Crack Cocaine 4 (11.8%)
Amphetamine 2 (5.9%)
Cocaine 6 (17.6%)
Cannabis 2 (5.9%)
Others 10 (29.4%)

Source: Field Survey

Though trafficking of women and girls for commercial sexual exploitation is a more heinous
crime than peddling drugs, the law makers have missed opportunities to prescribe stringent
punishment for human trafficking, which attracts a lenient maximum three-year jail term as
against minimum 10 years for drug peddlers, says Justice S K Panigrahi of Odisha High Court.
Justice Panigrahi said, “The complex and troubling issue as emerged in the instant case, in
essence, demonstrates a conflict between collective morality of the society and markedly
skewed legislations which mismatches the culpability of the participants in question (i.e.,
service provider, facilitator) and the recipient of the services. Though it involves clandestine
and unlawful trafficking of girls but the law makers have missed the opportunity to prescribe
a stringent punishment regime, even though the present offence is far more heinous than drug
trafficking.” (As Reported by Times of India on July 2, 2020)
Instrumental factors for involving in trafficking trade are shown in Table: 5.4. Respondents
were asked how they get involved in human trafficking trade. Associations with traffickers is
the basic reason for about half of the respondents for getting involved in flesh trade, whereas
more than one third (37 percent) respondents have reported that earlier they were Sex Workers/
Broker/Pimps, about 8 percent have reported that earlier they were brothel owners. 2 percent
respondents were practicing their inherited business.
Table: 5.4
Instrumental Factors for involving in Trafficking Trade

Earlier
Earlier Association with
Association with Inherited Association With
Instrumental Factors Trafficking as Sex Worker / Others Total
Trafficking as The Business Trafficker’s
Broker/Pimp
Brothel Owner
18 4 1 24 2 49
Responses
36.7% 8.2% 2.0% 49.0% 4.1% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Respondents were asked about their tenure in human trafficking trade. About 92 percent
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 143

respondents said that they are in this profession for more than 3 years, only about 8 percent
respondents replied that they are new entrant in this trade. About slightly less than half (45
percent) of respondents were in this trade for more than 7 years (Table 5.5).
Table: 5.5
Tenure in Trafficking Trade

Tenure 1-2 Years 3-4 Years 4-5 Years 5-6 Years 6-7 Years 7 Years and Above Total
4 10 7 4 2 22 49
Total
8.2% 20.4% 14.3% 8.2% 4.1% 44.9% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Respondents were asked about their initial role they played in human trafficking trade, about
half (46.9 percent) of the respondents replied that initially they were agents, slightly more than
one fourth (26.5 percent) were spotter, 14.3 percent were transporters, less than one tenth (8.2
percent) were horborers and about 4 percent respondents played some other roles. It is very
much clear from this analysis that most of the traffickers were involved in human trafficking
trade at initial stage and played some or other roles (Table 5.6).
Table: 5.6
What Role Did You Play Initially in Trafficking?

Role Played Agent Spotter Transporters Harborer Others Total

23 13 7 4 2 49
Total
46.9% 26.5% 14.3% 8.2% 4.1% 100%
Source: Field Survey
More than 3/4th (77.6 percent) traffickers said that normally they targeted at minor girls/boys
below 18 years age and for more than 1/4th (28.6 percent) traffickers, unmarried girls above 18
years ages were at target. Young widows and young divorcees were at the target of about 6%
traffickers (Table 5.7).
Table: 5.7
Methods Normally adopted in Recruitment

Indirectly Through Agents/

Methods Direct Contact Network of Love Boys
Spotters
35 36 2
Responses
71.4% 73.5% 4.1%
Source: Field Survey
Tables 5.8 and 5.9 reveal the traffickers’ modus operandi. The majority of traffickers (79.6%)
stated that they traffic victims on the promise of money or jobs, and that they contact the victims’
families/victims directly through their placement agency. Minor girls and children are being
trafficked for the purposes of labour, sex slavery, and forced marriages via placement agencies.
The traffickers have changed their modus operandi with the changes in law and society. In the
majority of cases, the victim knows the trafficker, who persuades the victim and her/his family to
sell them to a placement agent. The placement firms usually hire someone to track down the girls
and then pick them up (by luring or kidnapping) and transport them to the state’s urban centers.
Another person is in charge of transporting the victims from the urban centers to the railway
station, where they are given over to another person and transported to Delhi. After arriving in
 144

Delhi, the victims are given over to someone else and sent to placement agencies. Some victims
are subsequently placed as domestic help in various houses for a payment ranging from Rs
20,000 to Rs 30,000, while others are sold into forced marriages or prostitution. The girls who are
placed in residences where they are paid a monthly salary of Rs 1000 or Rs 3000 are never paid.
A girl is placed in a single house for 11 months, and the placement companies withdraw their
salary every month, which never reaches the victims or their families. Once a victim has served
her 11-month sentence in one house, she is moved to another, and the exploitation continues.
The victims are tormented, whipped, and beaten up harshly for objecting to the labour assigned
by placement agencies; many times, these victim girls describe sexual violence and assault by
placement agents and even their employers. The girls are maintained in placement agencies
until they are sold to other people. To avoid the law, these placement services continuously
shifting their addresses, names, and contact information. The placement agencies operate freely
and actively, taking advantage of different loopholes in the law and government machinery.
Most wanted traffickers have been apprehended recently. The NIA confirms this tactic with
Panna Lal and Sunita from Jharkhand. Panna Lal and Sunita revealed to the research team, and
Jharkhand AHTU revealed during an investigation, that they were running more than 200 illegal
placement agencies in Delhi, where they were bringing minor girls from Jharkhand and selling
them as domestic slaves in affluent houses for an advance payment of Rs 20,000 to Rs 30,000 per
girl. Panna Lal and his wife Sunita used to prey on young girls and the poorest households in
Jharkhand’s rural and tribal districts. Once a female has been identified as a target, she is enticed
with false promises of marriage, a good job, an education, or a happy life. Families were also
assured that the girl would have a happy life and that she would receive a monthly salary. After
being transported to Delhi, the girl is detained and housed by Panna Lal’s placement agencies,
where she is forced to work from early dawn to late at night, with no breaks or vacations. The
salary of the girl is also taken by Panna Lal. Every girl is assigned to one residence for 11 months
before being transferred to another. Victims are not permitted to return home or meet with their
relatives.
The victims of human trafficking were exploited not just by these individuals, but also by their
employers. Those who are fortunate enough are rescued by law enforcement or anti-trafficking
organizations, while others remain enslaved. In the last few years, Delhi has quickly become a
center for placement firms. Tughlakabad, Ranibagh, Punjabi Bagh, Shakurpur, Shakarpur, and
other areas became hubs for these placement firms. More than 10,000 illegal placement agencies
operate in Delhi, with over 4000 of them based in Shakurpur, which is under the jurisdiction of
the Subhash Place police station. While a small number of these firms are registered with the
Labor Department, they have yet to follow the laws. Because there is currently no law to control
these agencies, they are freely trafficking minors from the states of Jharkhand, Bihar, Assam,
West Bengal, and Orissa. Even if an agency is raided and shut down, the agents get away with
it and create a new one with a different name and address, perpetuating the never-ending cycle
of exploitation of minor girls. In 2014, the Jharkhand CID handed over a list of 240 agents and
agencies operating illegally in Delhi and involved in trafficking minor girls from Jharkhand to
the Delhi Police and a Writ Petition 1555/2013 was filed in the Jharkhand High Court by an
NGOs working to combat human trafficking, namely Diya Seva Sansthan regarding the same
issue (Table 5.8).
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 145

Table: 5.8
Involvement of Other Persons in Trafficking

Family
Brokers/Pimps/Agent/Brothel Placement
Other Persons Friends Members/ Others
Owners/Sex Workers Agencies
Relatives
8 18 30 18 2
Responses
16.3% 36.7% 61.2% 36.7% 4.1%
Source: Field Survey
Due to the lack of a Placement Agency Act in Jharkhand and several other states, persons
who work for such agencies have assumed the role of traffickers, raking in millions of rupees.
From both sides, the children are entrapped. On the one hand, many domestic bosses are cruel,
and on the other, placement agencies seize their income and prevent them from returning home
or speaking with their loved ones. While it is accepted that a lack of employment prospects will
force people to migrate, governments must ensure that migration is safe (Table 5.9).
Table: 5.9
Modus Operandi of the Traffickers
Making False
Promise of Befriending/ enticing Using Coercion/ Force/
Modus Operandi Promises of
Money/ Jobs with attractive offers Threat/ Kidnapped
Marriage
39 4 25 10
Responses
79.6% 8.2% 51.0% 20.4%
Source: Field Survey
According to the ILO report Profits and Poverty: The Economics of Forced Labour (2014),
commercial sexual exploitation accounted for two-thirds of the estimated total of US$ 150 billion,
or US$ 99 billion, where women and young girls account for the majority of victims, while forced
economic exploitation, which included domestic work, agriculture, and other economic activities,
accounted for the remaining US$ 51 billion.
Table 5.10 shows the types of work that are typically promised by traffickers to victims and
their families. More than half of the respondents said they usually offer victims Domestic Jobs
and some types of office work. At a time when India’s Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, is
focusing on labour reforms and giving workers respect, the country fails to recognize one of
the most important work forces, domestic labour. Domestic Labour, also known as domestic
workers, is a large work force in India that is largely hidden behind closed doors in our homes.
It is critical to control the placement agencies that operate in each state, particularly in Delhi.
The Delhi Private Placement Agencies (Regulation) Bill 2012 was proposed to the government
with the goal of regulating placement agencies and recognizing domestic workers as workers.
However, the bill has not yet been passed. In this regard, Chhattisgarh has made a significant
step forward by being the first state to implement the Private Agencies (Regulation) Act. On
September 25, 2014, the Labour Department of the Government of the National Capital Territory
of Delhi, in accordance with the order of the Delhi High Court in writ Petition (Crl.) 82/2009,
issued an executive order directing placement agencies to register under the “Delhi Shops &
Establishment Act, 1954” or the “Inter State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and
Conditions of Service) Act, 1979” before October 25, 2014, but most placement agencies never
complied for the same.
 146

It is suggested that there should be web based single point registration system for registration
of all the placement agencies and address of all their offices and it should be made mandatory
that no placement agency will operate without the registration on SPRS. An inspector level officer
from the Department of Labour & Employment may be deputed to check the accuracy of data
and the field operations of placement agencies at regular intervals.
Table 5.10
Kind of Work Normally Promised to Victims

Kind of Work Domestic Work Office Work Firm/ Factory Work Others
29 31 13 10
Responses
59.2% 63.3% 26.5% 20.4%
Source: Field Survey
Having huge network in trafficking, being friends and involvement in commercial sexual
exploitation were main reasons for involving other persons in human trafficking (Table 5.11).
Table 5.11
Reasons for Involving other Persons in Trafficking

Were already involved Already had Were already providing

Were
Reasons In Commercial Sexual huge networks in Young/Fresh and Beautiful
Friends
Exploitation Trafficking Girls
9 10 34 5
Responses
18.4% 20.4% 69.4% 10.2%
Source: Field Survey
About 3/4th respondents reported that a few victims were known to traffickers while about
20 percent respondents reported that victims are usually unknown to traffickers (Table 5.12).
Table 5.12
Whether Victims Are Usually Known to Traffickers

Known Status Mostly Known A Few Known Unknown Total

3 36 10 49
Response
6.1% 73.5% 20.4% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Relatives /family members, neighbor /friends and other middle men are playing critical role
in making women and children more vulnerable to join trafficking (Table 5.13).
Table 5.13
Role in Making Women & Children Vulnerable to Join Trafficking

Neighbor/ Others Like

Who made Vulnerable Relative / Family Stranger
Friends Middlemen
10 38 1 7
Responses
20.4% 77.6% 2.0% 14.3%
Source: Field Survey
The respondents reported that they kidnapped / abduct victims seldom, sometimes and
often. However, about 22 per cent respondents revealed that they never kidnap / abduct victims
(Table 5.14).
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 147

Table 5.14
How Often You Kidnapped/Abducted Victim

How Often Never Seldom Sometimes Often Total

11 20 12 6 49
Responses
22.4% 40.8% 24.5% 12.2% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents reported that sometimes victims are sold to them by family members
(Table 5.15).
Table 5.15
How Often Victim is sold by Family
How Often Seldom Sometimes Often Total
5 41 3 49
Responses
10.2% 83.7% 6.1% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents view the victims of human trafficking as business value while
about 22 per cent respondents view it as benefactor. Majority of the respondents have justified
trafficking as they help needy persons. Most of traffickers felt good after first act of trafficking
(Table 5.16).
Table 5.16
How Do You View the Victim of Trafficking?
How you view the victim Benefactor Business Value Total
11 38 49
Responses
22.4% 77.6% 100%
Source: Field Survey
However, majority of the respondents (63.3%) revealed that they do not get often involved in
contact with police. Further About half of the respondents reported that police are also involved
in racket of trafficking (Table 5.17).
Table 5.17
Contact of Traffickers with Police & Involvement of Police in Trafficking Rackets

Contact with Police Involvement of Police in Trafficking

Yes No Total Yes No Total
18 31 49 26 23 49
36.7% 63.3% 100% 53.1% 46.9% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents reported that they face encounter by police during transition, more
than 4/5th respondents reported that they were also arrested by police on ground of trafficking
(Table 5.18).
Table 5.18
Encounter By Police During Transition & Arrest on Ground of Trafficking
Faced Police Encounter during Transition Ever arrested by Police on Ground of Trafficking
Yes No Total Yes No Total
 148

40 9 49 41 8 49
81.6% 18.4% 100% 83.7% 16.3% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Most of the traffickers reported that they were prosecuted for human trafficking cases,
However, a negligible proportion of traffickers were convicted (Table 5.19).
Table 5.19
Prosecution and Conviction for Crime Related to Human Trafficking

Ever been Prosecuted for Trafficking Convicted or Sentenced for Human Trafficking Crime
Yes No Total Yes No Total
37 4 41 4 37 41
90.2% 9.8% 100% 9.8% 90.2% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Big profit and lack of alternative livelihood are the main reasons for continuity act of human
trafficking (Table 5.20).
Table 5.20
Reasoning For Continuing Act of Trafficking

Reason for
Big Profit No Alternative Livelihood Others
Continuation
42 10 2
Responses
85.7% 20.4% 4.1%
Source: Field Survey
Inappropriate charge sheet, witness turn hostile, poor evidences and lack of victim or witness
protection are some of the loopholes in law enforcement mechanism (Table 5.21).
Table 5.21
Loopholes in Law Enforcement Mechanism

Inappropriate Poor Lack Of Victim or Witness Turn

Loopholes Don’t Know
Charge Sheet Evidences Witness Protection Hostile
36 18 19 34 1
Responses
73.5% 36.7% 38.8% 69.4% 2.0%

Source: Field Survey

BROTHEL OWNER/KEEPERS:
A brothel is defined by the Immoral Traffic Prevention Act of 1956 as “any house, room,
conveyance, or place, or any portion of any house, room, conveyance, or place, used for the
purpose of sexual exploitation or abuse for the gain of another person or for the mutual gain of
two or more prostitutes” (Section 2a). Prostitution is defined as “the sexual exploitation or abuse of
humans for commercial objectives,” according to the act (Section 2f). Because commercial sexual
exploitation of women and children is the primary goal of human trafficking, and brothels play
a key role in this illegal business, an effort has been made to better understand their exploitative
environment, the role of various exploiters, the factors that exacerbate victims’ vulnerability,
and the response mechanisms of the agencies involved in addressing the relevant issues. To
be classified as a brothel, a location must have been utilized for prostitution. In the lack of any
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 149

proof from the surrounding circumstances, the premises cannot be held “used for brothel” when
the prosecution showed the presence of only one female in the premises and a single instance
of prostitution (In Re Dhanalakshmi, 1974 CriLJ 61 MAD). A single incident of prostitution in
a location does not qualify it as a “brothel” (Sushila v. State of Tamil Nadu, CriL J 1982 MAD
702). Thus, if a single woman uses the premises for her own gain, she is not breaking the law, but
if two prostitutes use the same premises for mutual gain, it is considered a “brothel.” The last
sentence of the definition is crucial. It means that a single woman who practices prostitution for
a living without the presence of another prostitute or another person involved in the upkeep of
such premises will not be considered a “brothel” (In Re Ratnamala, AIR 1962 MAD 31).
The Act obviously denies Commercial Sex Workers the ability to work because, if properly
applied, the law prohibits women from working in brothels or soliciting on the street. Seducing
or soliciting for the purpose of prostitution is punishable under Section 8. It makes soliciting for
prostitutes illegal and is being used to arrest and punish women and girls who have been victims
of human trafficking. The Commercial Sex Workers are left to find clients through methods other
than solicitation. Soliciting clients is an essential part of earning a livelihood, and this clause
simply strengthens the police, who harass Commercial Sex Workers by threatening to invoke
section 8. This is predicated on the International Convention’s flawed premise that criminalizing
the commercial sex business will cause the enterprise to collapse.
According to K K Mukherjee and Sutapa Mukherjee, there are various reasons why brothels
and prostitution are on the rise, as per a study conducted on behalf of the central government by
the Gram Niyojan Kendra in Ghaziabad. Growing migration and poverty, political instability,
the degradation of traditional values, the drive to make quick money, globalization, and the
decline of job opportunities for uneducated and unskilled youths are only a few of these factors.
Urbanization, new attitudes toward sex, worry among youngsters about their sexual performance,
the expansion of the hotel industry, promiscuity, and sex myths with virgin women are all
factors to consider. “Consumerism, combined with the expansion of transportation facilities,
is contributing to the emergence of a new form of practice known as ‘commuting prostitute,’ in
which girls and women from nearby rural areas come to cities such as Delhi, Kolkata, and Mumbai
for a set number of hours under the guise of working in offices/homes,” according to the study.
According to the report, there is no way to completely eradicate prostitution. However, if the
government and others demonstrate the will, its prevalence can be minimized. The Karnataka
government formed a committee to investigate the working conditions of sex workers in the state,
with one of the sitting women members of the Karnataka Legislative Council as its head. The
study discovered that in the early stages, women are pushed into this job only for the purpose of
human trafficking or to make more money for the rest of their lives, or are sold unintentionally
to pimps by relatives or friends. When women become trapped in this vicious cycle, they have
no choice but to continue working as sex workers. Women are found to be sex workers as long
as demand or beauty reigns supreme in the market. When demand falls, they continue to work
as a supplier/agent in the field (pimps). The majority of them are trafficked from Maharashtra
and Goa to Karnataka, according to the research. Migration, drought, unemployment, early
marriage divorce, poverty, and other factors were identified as causes for seeking this job in
the study. Surprisingly, the survey found that married women are more active in this field. The
more fascinating issue is that approximately 26% of women/girls have entered this sex labour
employment in order to acquire a good phone, a good dress, pocket money, and so on.
The Research Team of BIRD visited as many as 47 Brothels across the State of West Bengal,
 150

Delhi and Maharashtra as in the State of Karnataka, Tamil Nadu brothels have been closed by
Law Enforcement agencies and research team could not found any brothel in the selected districts
of Jharkhand, Assam & Uttar Pradesh. Perceived reasons of different stakeholders for flourishing
of brothels are shown in Table 5.22. Lack of livelihood, lack of alternative profession for victim
of CSE, low level of requirement/investment to operate sex related business, high rewarding,
low risk criminal activity, loose manners and morals, prostitution as entertainment and most
lucrative illicit business and most profitable trade are some of the main reasons responsible for
flourishing of brothels.
Table 5.22
Perceived Reasons of Different Stakeholders for Flourishing of Brothels

Brothel Public
Perceived Reasons Traffickers Law EAs
Keepers Prosecutors
5 8 17 10
Luxurious Life Style Addiction
10.2% 17.0% 18.3% 100%
19 11 38 9
Loose Manners and Morals
38.8% 23.4% 40.9% 100%
6 2 3 3
Self-Indulgence Of the Wealthier Class
12.2% 4.3% 3.2% 100%
Prostitution As Entertainment- Women and Girls Are Treated as 10 14 21 10
Sexual Toys 20.4% 29.8% 22.6% 100%
3 4 54 13
Pornographic, Soft and Strong Literature and Entertainment
6.1% 8.5% 58.1% 100%
31 44 83 12
Lack Of Livelihoods/High Level of Unemployment
63.3% 93.6% 89.2% 100%
Lack Of Alternatives for A Victim Of CSE/ No Other Options for 30 36 76 12
Survival 61.2% 76.6% 81.7% 100%
8 6 20 3
Easy Spending of Quick Money Earned by Criminals and Thugs
16.3% 12.8% 21.5% 100%
1 0 3 6
Decline Of Public Order and Increase in Lawlessness
2.0% 0.0% 3.2% 100%
27 6 22 6
Most Lucrative Illicit Business and Most Profitable Trade
55.1% 12.8% 23.7% 100%
Low Level of Requirements/Investment to Operate Sex-Related 24 14 17 3
Business 49.0% 29.8% 18.3% 100%
0 3 23 3
Worldwide Phenomenon of Sex Tourism
0.0% 6.4% 24.7% 100%
Government’s Criminalization Policy Fails to Adequately Address 3 2 18 10
the Problem of Prostitution 6.1% 4.3% 19.4% 100%
7 2 17 16
Insufficient Or Inadequate Laws, Poor Enforcement
14.3% 4.3% 18.3% 100%
16 0 36 6
Difficult To Prove Offences Related to Sexual Exploitation
32.7% 0.0% 38.7% 100%
Minimal Chances of Prosecution and Conviction In The Field Of Pimping, 11 0 58 12
Exploitation And Trafficking Of Human Beings 22.4% 0.0% 62.4% 100%
21 2 35 10
High-Rewarding, Low-Risk Criminal Activity
42.9% 4.3% 37.6% 100%
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 151

11 4 4 7
Corruption And Complacency
22.4% 8.5% 4.3% 100%
Lack Of Clear-Cut Guidelines and Mechanism for Monitoring of 1 1 25 6
Brothels 2.0% 2.1% 26.9% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Growing poverty due to COVID-19 is likely to compel more women to choose sex work
and enforcement agencies must engage their collectives to “prevent, identify and redress”
perpetrators of human trafficking who force children and women into flesh trade instead of
criminalizing adult consenting workers.
It is reported that majority of brothel keepers were female (95.7 percent). More than half
(53.2 percent) of the operators of brothels were from rural background followed by Metropolitan
Cities (23.4 percent). Slightly less than one fourth (23.4 percent) operators of brothels were
from Urban/Semi Urban background. Brothel and prostitution is a phenomenon of Urban and
Metropolitan Cities but operators of brothels were found from rural background because most of
the sex workers whether by trafficked or by self belongs to rural background and after 7-8 years
they become Madam Jee/Badi Didi/ operators of brothels. It is found that women continue to
be sex workers as long as demand or beauty prevails in the market. When demand decreases,
they continue in the field as a supplier/agent (pimps). This could be confirmed from the analysis
of age group of brothel operators. Most of the brothel operators (70.2 percent) were having age
more than 40 Years. About 13 percent respondents were in the age group of 35-40 years. Most
of the brothel keepers (42.6 percent) was from Other Backward Classes community followed
by general castes (34 percent). Significant percentages of brothel operators were also from
Scheduled Caste communities (12.8 percent) and Scheduled Tribes communities (10.6 percent).
About half (48.9 percent) of the brothel operators were followers of Hinduism faith followed by
Islam (25 percent) and 10.6 percent respondents were from other minority communities. It is
reported that slightly more than one fifth (21.3 percent) brothel keepers were widows, 17 percent
were unmarried, 42.6 percent were married, Equal percentage (8.5 percent) were separated and
divorced and 2.1 percent were abandoned. Slightly more than two third (68.1 percent) brothel
keepers were illiterate, slightly more than one fourth (25.5 percent) had completed their primary
level schooling and only 6.4 percent had completed their middle level education. More than
half (57.4 percent) brothel keepers can speak at least two languages, slightly less than one fifth
(19.1 percent) brothel keepers know three or more than three languages. It is reported that about
three fourth (72.3 percent) brothel keepers were living alone and those living alone were residing
inside of the brothels. 6.4 percent brothel keepers were living with their spouse and 4.3% were
living with their spouse and children.
Previous Occupation of Brothel Keepers is shown in Table: 5.23. More than half (59.6 percent)
brothel keepers were previously sex workers and about 15 percent were previous victims of
Commercial Sex Exploitation (CSE). 12.8 percent respondents refused to disclose their previous
occupations.
 152

Table: 5.23
Previous Occupation of Brothel Keepers
Previous Occupation of Brothel Keepers Responses
Previous victim of CSE 7 (14.9%)
Sex Worker 28 (59.6%)
Pimp 0 (0.0%)
Skilled Labour 2 (4.3%)
Petty Business 0 (0.0%)
Service 0 (0.0%)
No Work 4 (8.5%)
Other 0 (0.0%)
No response 6 (12.8%)
Total 47 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
It is reported that most of the brothel keepers (95.7 percent) do not have any kind of criminal
antecedents and those having criminal antecedents were never prosecuted for their offences.
Slightly more than one third (36.2 percent) brothel keepers reported that they take alcohol/drugs
and when asked about frequency of taking drugs/alcohol from those taking alcohol/drugs more
than half of the respondents (52.9 percent) reported that they take it sometimes and only slightly
more than one third (35.3 percent) reported that they take it always. Those taking drugs less than
one fourth reported that they take other opiate, about 12 percent respondents reported that they
take cocaine and more than half (58.8 percent) reported that they take other kind of drugs.
More than half of the respondents reported that period of brothel keeping are more than 10
years while about half of the respondents reported that brothel keeping has been for less than 10
years (Table 5.24).
Table: 5.24
Period of Brothel Keeping
Period of Brothel Keeping Less Than 5 Years 5-10 Years 10-20 Years > 20 Years Total
8 15 9 15 47
Response
17.0% 31.9% 19.1% 31.9% 100%
Source: Field Survey
More than half of the respondents reported that brothels are on rent while ownership of
brothels was reported by slightly more than 1/3rd cases even significant number of brothel
keepers reported that brothels are inherited to them (Table 5.25).
Table: 5.25
Ownership of Brothel

Type of Ownership Owned Inherited On Rent Total

16 5 26 47
Response
34.0% 10.6% 55.3% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Slightly more than half of the respondents reported that there are less than 5 rooms in the
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 153

brothel. However, more than 2/5th respondents reported that there are 5 to 10 rooms in brothel
(Table 5.26).
Table: 5.26
No. of Rooms in Brothel

No. of Rooms Less Than 5 5-10 Rooms > 10 Rooms Total

24 21 2 47
Response
51.1% 44.7% 4.3% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that there are less than 10 CSWs in the brothel. However,
about 1/4th respondents reported that there are more than 10 CSWs in the brothel (Table 5.27).
Table: 5.27
No. of CSWs in Brothel (Regular)

No. of Regular CSWs > 5 CSWs 5-10 CSWs >10 CSWs Total
16 20 11 47
Response
34.0% 42.6% 23.4% 100%
Source: Filed Survey
No. of flying sex workers in brothels is shown in Table: 5.28. The phenomenon of flying
sex workers is increasing day by day and has been attributed the reason behind flourishing of
brothels. K K Mukherjee and Sutapa Mukherjee in the study undertaken by the Gram Niyojan
Kendra, Ghaziabad, on behalf of the central government find that “Consumerism combined with
growth of transport facilities is contributing to the emergence of a new form of practice called
‘commuting prostitute’ wherein girls and women from neighboring rural areas come to cities
like Delhi, Kolkata, Bengaluru and Mumbai for some specific hours on the pretext of working in
offices/homes,” This was also confirmed during a FGD with the Sex Workers at Kanpur, Uttar
Pradesh. About 3/4th respondents reported that they directly contact sex workers however; about
30 per cent respondents reported that they recruit them indirectly through pimps. Majority of the
respondents reported that they themselves supervise the brothels.
Table: 5.28
No. of CSWs in Brothel (Flying)

No. of Flying CSWs < 5 CSWs 5-10 CSWs >10 CSWs Total
25 15 7 47
Response
53.2% 31.9% 14.9% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Methods normally being adopted in recruitment of sex workers in brothels are shown in
Table 5.29. More than three fourth (76.6 percent) brothel operators reported that they directly
recruit the sex workers, so they do not want services of pimps. Slightly more than one fourth
(29.8 percent) respondents reported that they recruit through pimps. The reason behind direct
recruitment is easily availability of Flying Sex workers or part time sex workers in that city.
 154

Table 5.29
Methods Normally Being Adopt in Recruitment

Method of Direct Indirectly Through Promise Of Incited For

Others
Recruitment Contact Pimps Marriage Prostitution
36 14 1 3 2
Response
76.6% 29.8% 2.1% 6.4% 4.3%
Source: Field Survey
More than half (53.2 percent) brothels keepers reported that they do not require services of
pimps due to increasing no. of voluntarisms in sex industry and increasing number of flying sex
workers (Table 5.30).
Table 5.30
No. Of Pimps in Brothel

No. of Pimps Zero 1-2 3-5 More Than 5 Total

25 13 4 5 47
Response
53.2% 27.7% 8.5% 10.6% 100%
Source: Field Survey
About 2/3rd respondents reported that they share room rent and fixed amount per customer
in the victim’s earnings while 1/4th respondents reported that they share room rent and 50 per
cent of earnings of victims (Table 5.31).
Table 5.31
Share in Victim’s Earnings

Room Rent and Fixed Room Rent and

Type of Share Room Rent Alone Others
Amount Per Customer 50% Of Earning
31 6 12 1
Response
66.0% 12.8% 25.5% 2.1%
Source: Field Survey
Young, beautiful and virgin women and girls are more demanded in brothels (Table 5.32).
Table 5.32
Types of Women and Girls in Demand

Women and Girls in demand Virgin Young Beautiful Region Specific Others
29 39 36 17 7
Response
61.7% 83.0% 76.6% 36.2% 14.9%
Source: Field Survey
About 2/5th respondents reported that on an average more than 10 clients are visiting brothels
per day. However, about 30 per cent respondents revealed that there are less than 5 clients per
day per brothel (Table 5.33).
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 155

Table 5.33
Average No. of Clients Visiting Brothel Per Day

No. of Clients Less Than 3 3-5 6-10 > 10 Clients Total

10 4 13 20 47
Responses
21.3% 8.5% 27.7% 42.6% 100%

Source: Field Survey

More than 2/5th respondents reported that police raids thrice and above in a month
in the brothels. The main reasons for police raids were reported to be checking of minor
girls, law and order problems and for official figures. About 1/4th respondents reported
that they are often involved in contact with police. However, most of them denied that
they were arrested by police on ground of trafficking or commercial sex exploiters. About
30 per cent respondents reported that police is also involved in racket of trafficking
(Table 5.34).
Table 5.34
Reasons for Police Raids

Reason for Police To Check Minor Law & Order For Official To Collect Monthly
Others
Raids Girl Problem Figures Quota
37 19 12 10 6
Response
97.4% 50.0% 31.6% 26.3% 15.8%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that they get involved in brothel keeping as they were
sex workers / brokers, Pimp earlier. A significant proportion of respondents also reported that
they inherited the business and were associated with traffickers (Table 5.35).
Table 5.35
How You Get involved in Brothel Keeping
Reason for
Earlier Working as Sex Earlier Association with Inherited The Association
Getting
Worker/Broker/ Pimp Brothel Owner Business With Traffickers
involved
29 8 10 7
Total
61.7% 17.0% 21.3% 14.9%
Source: Field Survey
Lack of alternative livelihood and inherited profession as well as big profit are some of the
main reasons for continuing the act of brothel keeping (Table 5.36).
Table 5.36
Reasoning For Continuing Act of Brothel Keeping
Reason for No Alternative
Big Profit Inherited Profession Others
Continuation Livelihood
8 36 10 1
Responses
17.0% 76.6% 21.3% 2.1%
Source: Field Survey

THE CLIENTS:
Human trafficking exploiters comprise a diverse group of criminals and criminal entities
 156

who plan, carry out, and profit from human trafficking. In order to run their business, traffickers
frequently rely on enablers: individuals and entities – both legal and illegal – that give goods and
services to exploiters, making human trafficking conceivable and profitable. The Organization
for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) describes human trafficking as “a process rather
than a single offence, a process including several stages or nodes through which victims’ transit
and involving different persons at each level of the process.” Prostitution is frequently linked to
illegal drug markets, crime, violence, and other undesirable negative effects on neighborhoods,
as well as sexually transmitted diseases. Despite the public safety, order, and health issues
associated with prostitution, there is surprisingly little reliable empirical data on crucial aspects of
the problem, particularly male clients of prostitute women. To address some of these information
gaps, we conducted multi-stranded research.
Many researchers have looked into the attitudes, beliefs, motivations, and conduct of male
sex workers’ clients. However, few studies have looked at individual variations in significant
personality traits indicated by males who buy prostitution versus those who don’t. Although
numerous evolutionary psychologists have researched prostitution and individuals engaging
in sex work, none have explicitly considered the utility of an evolutionary personality approach
in attempting to understand why certain men pay for sex, to our knowledge. Prostitution is
described largely as a form of short-term mating sought primarily by men in the current mini-
review, following other academics. We argue that the dark tetrad’s socially aversive traits
(narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathism, and sadism) may characterize some male clients
of female sex workers, particularly those who express desires for exciting and novel sex with
women who are treated with contempt, perceiving prostitution as a business with little emotional
involvement, and seeking to dominate and control sex workers who are viewed as vulnerable.
In comparison to men who acquire sex from female sex workers in interior settings (e.g., street
prostitution), the tetrad features may be more prominent among men who purchase sex from
female sex workers in outdoor (e.g., street prostitution) settings (e.g., escort agencies).
Direct prostitution (e.g., street prostitution, escort services, and brothels) is a type of sex
work that entails an explicit exchange of material items, favours, and/or services in exchange
for sexual intimacy or erotic acts with no commitment necessary (Harcourt and Donovan, 2005).
Indirect prostitution, on the other hand, occurs when the exchange of money for sex is not the
primary source of income (e.g., massage parlour workers), purveyors do not refer to themselves
as prostitutes (e.g., “camgirls,” adult film actors/actresses, and exotic dancers), or people are
forced into sex work out of necessity (e.g., “camgirls,” adult film actors/actresses, and exotic
(e.g., survival sex). However, among academics, the word used to describe prostitution remains
a contentious issue (Benoit et al., 2018). Since ancient times, prostitution has been conducted
in sex-specific ways throughout a wide range of civilizations, with males typically being the
principal clients of sex work services provided by both women and men (Dylewski and Prokop,
2019). Estimates of the percentage of men who purchase sex cross-culturally range from 9 to
80% (discussed in Farley et al., 2011); however, several researchers have cautioned that previous
estimates are likely inflated due to methodological issues (e.g., sampling bias), and that a more
conservative estimate below 20% likely typifies men who have ever paid for sex (Månsson, 2004;
Pan et al., 2011; Jewkes et al., 2012; Monto and Milrod, 2014; Ondrášek et al., 2018).
Personality traits influence both mate choices (i.e., intersexual selection) and how people
fight for mating opportunities with rivals, according to evolutionary psychologists (i.e., intra
sexual competition; Jonason et al., 2012, 2015; Buunk et al., 2017; Buss and Schmitt, 2019). Because
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 157

personality characteristics have an impact on fitness-related outcomes and exhibit a significant

degree of inter-individual variability, heredity, and developmental stability, it’s worthwhile to
think about their possible adaptive significance (Nettle, 2006; Buss, 2009).
The dark tetrad is a four-variable personality model marked by egocentrism and grandiosity
(i.e., narcissism), manipulative and cynical tendencies (i.e., Machiavellianism), callousness
and anti-sociality (i.e., psychopath), and taking pleasure in the pain and suffering of others
(i.e., psychopath) (i.e., sadism; Buckels et al., 2013; Book et al., 2016; Meere and Egan, 2017;
Paulhus et al., 2018). Investigators have argued that the Dark Tetrad dimensions appear to
comprise an organised system of co-adapted traits that facilitate, to varying degrees, early sexual
development, short-term mating strategies, risk-taking, exploitation, and aggressive behaviour;
a so-called “fast life history strategy” (Lalumière et al., 2001; Gladden et al., 2009; Jonason et al.,
2010; McDonald et al., 2012; Davis et al., Personality traits like honesty and humility, on the other
hand, appear to be associated to a “slower life history strategy” in which resources are invested
in generating fewer offspring later in development, heightened parental care, risk aversion, and
better physical and mental health (Davis et al., 2019). Researchers have warned, however, that the
application of life history theory to human personality has deviated from its theoretical roots in
ecology and evolutionary biology (Nettle and Frankenhuis, 2019). Some have disputed the fast–
slow life history continuum, claiming that these tactics do not function on a single continuum
(Holtzman and Senne, 2014). Scholars have also argued that the evolutionary processes that lead
to differences in life history between species (Darwinian evolution) are distinct from those that
contribute to changes in psychological qualities among members of a species (e.g., developmental
plasticity; Zietsch and Sidari, 2019). Nonetheless, scholars argue that a life history framework is
important for studying personality trait diversity in humans and nonhuman animals (Wolf et al.,
2007; Vonk et al., 2017; Davis et al., 2019; Young et al., 2019; Del Giudice, 2020).
A very consistent set of reasons for why men purchase sex from women has been identified
across samples of arrested offenders and non-offenders from different cultures (McKeganey,
1994; Xantidis and McCabe, 2000; Vanwesenbeeck, 2001; Cotton et al., 2002; Mnsson, 2004, 2006;
Pitts et al., 2006; Lowman and Atchison, 2006; Monto, 2010; Milrod and Monto, 2012, 2017; Farley
et al., 2017; Ondrášek et al., 2018). When extrapolating findings from offenders to non-arrested
male clients of sex work, however, caution should be exercised because these individuals differ
in important ways (e.g., demographic characteristics; Monto and McRee, 2005; Monto and
Milrod, 2014), which may affect the degree to which they express certain motives for buying sex.
Wanting novel, exciting, and forbidden sex with a variety of female sex workers who are treated
with contempt to satisfy their sexual urges; seeking specific sexual acts that dating or romantic
partners are unwilling or unlikely to provide; perceiving sex in a business-like manner without
emotional involvement that is less complicated than dating and romantic relationships; a desire
to dominate and control female sex workers who are persecuted; and a desire to dominate and
control female sex workers who are per The findings in this section support the hypothesis
that while the majority of male clients of female sex workers have increased short-term mating
proclivities, the motivations driving a subgroup of males to purchase prostitution may actually
indicate a long-term mating endeavour (e.g., wanting companionship).
Only a few studies have looked at major personality traits in male clients of female sex workers.
Men who had previously been prostitution clients in Zimbabwe exhibited higher degrees of
impulsivity, pleasure seeking, and ego-defensiveness (Wilson et al., 1992). In comparison
to non-clients, Australian male clients of brothels who purchased services from female sex
 158

workers indicated higher levels of sensation-seeking (i.e., an eagerness to engage in unusual

and stimulating activities) (Xantidis and McCabe, 2000). Xantidis and McCabe (2000) discovered
that male clients who viewed sex as a business transaction were substantially more interested
in sensation than consumers wanting romance and connection. Hostile masculinity, which is
defined as a psychological profile characterized by animosity and cynicism toward women, as
well as views that legitimize aggressiveness and dominance over women, was found to be more
prevalent among American men who purchased prostitute services (Farley et al., 2017). Those
who held inaccurate beliefs about prostitution (e.g., “prostitutes make a lot of money”) had higher
cynicism (misanthropy and interpersonal distrust), antisocial practice (criminal behaviour and
lawlessness), and lower self-esteem than those who held accurate beliefs about prostitution (e.g.,
“prostitutes make a lot of money”) (Sawyer et al., 2001).
These data also imply that the Dark Tetrad is more common among men who express certain
goals, such as thrilling and scornful sex with a variety of sex workers, commodified and business-
like sex, and the desire to have power and control over sex workers. In contrast, the tetrad’s
characteristics may not clearly characterize males seeking sex workers for specific actions as a
result of unmet demands from their spouses. Men who buy sex for the purposes of connection,
intimacy, and love are likely to have a lower predominance of the Dark Tetrad aspects.
The respondents were mainly from urban areas including semi-urban and metropolitan cities.
They were mainly from age group of 18 to 40 years. A large proportion of respondents were from
General Caste and OBCs. They were mainly Hindus. More than 2/5th clients were found married
while less than 1/3rd respondents were unmarried. The educational level of clients was reported
to be poor as majority of them were educated up to high school. The clients were mainly self-
employed, casual labour and salaried private job holders. More than half of the clients were from
local areas.
About 46 per cent respondents reported that they are regular visitors of CSW. However,
there is no specific frequency of visit to them for more than 2/5th cases. A significant proportion
of respondents further reported that they visit to CSW once a week and once a month. Curiosity
and learning as well as greater sex urge and desire for variety in sexual life were main reasons
for visiting a CSW (Table 5.37).
Table 5.37
Whether You Are Regular Visitor of CSW

Are you a Regular Visitor Yes No Refused/ No Response Total

29 28 6 63
Response
46.0% 44.4% 9.5% 100%
Source: Field Survey
More than 3/4th respondents reported that they prefer intercourse only with CSW while about
1/4th respondents reported that they prefer both oral and intercourse with CSW (Table 5.38).
Table 5.38
Type of Sexual Activity Preferred with CSW

Types of Sexual Activity Percentage of Preference

Half and Half sex- both oral and intercourse 15 (23.8%)
Intercourse Only 48 (76.2%)
Oral Only 0 (0.0%)
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 159

Total 63 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Most of clients admitted that they were easy going, entertaining, obeying, polite and friendly
with CSW. Most of them paid less than Rs. 500 per visit to CSW (Table 5.39).
Table 5.39
Describe the CSW Whom You Have Just Contacted

Obeying Entertaining Polite Easy Going Friendly Reserved Unfriendly

24 22 16 31 15 6 1
38.1% 34.9% 25.4% 49.2% 23.8% 9.5% 1.6%
Source: Field Survey
Good looking, young and beautiful CSWs are being preferred by the clients (Table 5.40).
Table 5.40
Type of CSW Preferred by You
Percentage of Percentage of
Types of CSW Types of CSW
Preference Preference
Young 28 (44.4%) Beautiful 24 (38.1%
Good Looking 30 (47.6%) Slim 4 (6.3%)
Good Body Shape 10 (15.9%) Fair Complex 3 (4.8%)
Region Specific 1 (1.6%) Shy and submissive 6 (9.5%)
Language Specific 0 (0.0%) Agreed to sex without condom 4 (6.3%)
Total 63 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Clients of CSWs were asked if they ever been refused by CSWs.12.7 percent Clients of CSWs
reported that they were refused by CSW for sexual services and 5 percent clients refused to reply.
Clients of CSWs were asked have they had any instance of misbehavior by the CSW, 8 percent
clients reported yes and further 3 percent reported that refusal was due to under payment, 1
percent reported it was due to over exploitation, 1 percent were refused for abusive behavior and
1 percent were refused for other reasons. Clients were asked if they are aware that buying sex is
illegal, only 28.6 percent said that this is illegal, others were not aware.
Preference about safe or unsafe sex is shown in Table 5.41. Most of the Clients (81.0 percent)
reported that they prefer safe sex; only 19% clients said that they prefer unsafe sex. When asked
about frequency of use of condom, slightly less than two third (63.5 percent) those using condom
during sex reported that they use it always, 6.3 percent reported that they use it often and
another 6.3 percent reported that they use it sometimes. Only 4.8 percent reported that they use
it seldom. Those using condom all the times slightly less than half (47.6 percent) said they use
this as it prevents from HIV-AIDS, 9.5 percent reported that it prevents STD and only 6.3 percent
reported that it prevents from STD as well as HIV, meaning by very few clients were aware why
they are using protective measures. Those who were not using condom sighted the reasons such
as non-availability (6.3 percent), Don’t Like (6.3 percent), not necessary (4.8 percent) and other
reasons (1.6 percent). The first Integrated Bio-Behavioural Assessment (IBBA) survey in Andhra
Pradesh, Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu, showed that 28 percent of clients reported ‘every time’
condom use with sex workers. A quarter of the clients (27 percent) reported commercial partners
only, 47 percent reported also having a main sexual partner and 27 percent reported casual and
 160

main female partners. (Subramanian T, Gupte MD, Paranjape RS, Brahmam GN, Ramakrishnan
L et al. (2008) HIV, sexually transmitted infections and sexual behavior of male clients of female
sex workers in Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra.
Table 5.41
Do You Prefer Safe Sex or Unsafe Sex?

Unsafe Sex (Non-Use of

Preference of Sex Safe Sex (With Condoms) Total
Condoms)
51 12 63
Responses
81.0% 19.0% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents revealed that they carry condom while visiting a CSW. However,
about 16 per cent respondents revealed that they do not carry condom while visiting CSW. Thus,
they are more vulnerable and at risk of STD and HIV-AIDS (Table 5.42).
Table 5.42
How Often You Carry a Condom When Visiting a CSW

How Often Frequency Percentage

All the time 28 44.4
Most the time 9 14.3
Some Times 16 25.4
Never 10 15.9
Total 63 100.0
Source: Field Survey
Clients were asked whether they ever been encountered/ harassed by Police. Only 7.9 percent
clients reported that they were ever harassed by Police and those who were harassed 60 percent
clients reported that they were harassed occasionally where as 40 percent reported that were
rarely harassed. Clients those who were harassed by Police were asked what was the action
taken by Police when encountered. 80 percent Clients reported that Police extracted money from
them and 20 percent reported that they were verbally abused. Clients of CSWs were asked have
they ever been arrested by Police for buying sex, only 4.8 percent Clients reported that they
were arrested by Police for buying the sex and those who were arrested by Police were later on
released on bribing to Police. Only 7.9 percent clients were aware that clients can be penalized
under Section 7 of ITPA for buying the sex and surprisingly slightly more than one third (33.3
percent) clients were aware that that sexual assault on a child under 16 years age, even with
consent, amounts to rape under Indian Penal Code (Table 5.43).
Table 5.43
Encounter/Harassment of Clients by Police

Ever been encountered/ harassed by Police If harassed, Frequency of Harassment

Response Respondents Frequency Respondents
Yes 5 (7.9%) Occasionally 3 (60%)
No 53 (84.1%) Rarely 2 (40%)
Refused 5 (7.9%) Total 5 (100%)
Total 63 (100%) Have you ever been arrested by Police for buying sex
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 161

Action taken by Police when encountered Response Respondents

Action Respondents Yes 3 (4.8%)
Extracted Money 4 (80%) No 59 (93.7%)
Verbally abused 1 (20%) Refused 1 (1.6%)
Total 5 (100%) Total 63 (100%)
Are you aware that clients can be penalized under Section
How Many Times Arrested by Police for buying Sex
7 of ITPA
1 Time 1 (33.3%) Very much Aware 5 (7.9%)
15 Times 1 (33.3%) Not Aware 58 (92.1%)
2 Times 1 (33.3%) Total 63 (100%)
Total 3 (100%) Mode of Release from Police Custody
Bribing Money 3 (100%)
Are you aware that sexual assault on a child under 16 years age, even with consent, amounts to rape under Indian
Penal Code
Very much Aware 21 (33.3%)
Not Aware 42 (66.7%)
Total 63 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
More than half of the clients (57.1 percent) reported that they drink alcohol and 7.9 refused
to response on their addiction history. 36.1 percent of those were taking drinks reported that
they drink regularly, 27.7 percent occasionally, and 19.4 percent rarely where as 16.6 percent
who were taking drinks refused to response on the frequency of drinks. Clients who were taking
drinks, were asked what types of drink you take, 22.2 percent responded that they take foreign
brand, 30.5 percent reported that they take Local Brand and 47.22 percent clients reported that
they consume both Foreign and Local brands of Alcohol based on its availability and their pocket
money. Further clients were asked “Do you take drink when visit to CSW/Brothel” 25 percent
clients reported that yes, they take drink before visiting a CSW whereas same percentage (25
percent) clients refused to reveal their choices (Table 5.44).
Clients were asked if they take drugs, slightly less than half (44.4 percent) respondents
reported that yes, they take drugs, those who were taking drugs were not regular users but 75
percent clients reported that they take the drugs sometimes, only 25 percent reported that take
it often. Those who were taking drugs reported that they take Other Opiate, Heroin and some
other kinds of drugs. Clients were asked if they take drugs before visiting a CSW, only 18.7
percent clients reported that yes, they take it before visiting a CSW whereas 6.25 percent clients
refused to reveal their preferences (Table 5.44).
Table 5.44
Addiction History

Have you ever had a drink If yes, how frequently you drink
Response Respondents Frequency of Drink Respondents
Yes 36 (57.1%) Regularly 13 (36.1%)
No 22 (34.9%) Occasionally 10 (27.7%)
No Response 5 (7.9%) Rarely 7 (19.4%)
Total 63 (100%) No Response 6 (16.6%)
What type of drink you take Total 36 (100%)
 162

Foreign 8 (22.2%) Do you take drink when visit to CSW/ Brothel

Local 11 (30.5%) Response Respondents
Both 17 (47.22%) Yes 9 (25%)
Total 36 (100%) No 18 (50%)
Do you take Drugs No Response 9 (25%)
Yes 16 (44.4%) Total 36 (100%)
No 20 (55.5%) How frequently you use drugs
Total 36 (100%) Sometimes 12 (75%)
Types of Drugs you Take Often 4 (25%)
Drugs Types Respondents Total 16 (100%)
Heroin 4 (25%) Taking drugs when visit to CSW
Other Opiate 7 (43.75%) Response Respondents
Tranquilizers 0 (0.0%) Yes 3 (18.7%)
Crack Cocaine 0 (0.0%) No 12 (75%)
Amphetamine 0 (0.0%) No Response 1 (6.25%)
Cocaine 4 (25%) Total 16 (100%)
Cannabis 0 (0.0%)
Others 1 (6.25%)
Total 16 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents were found aware about STD-HIV/AIDS. They were also aware that
HIV mainly spreads through unprotected sex and condom use reduced of risk of HIV/AIDS/
STD infection. They were also aware that commercial sex workers are more susceptible to HIV/
AIDS. However, most of the respondents refused that they have ever been tested for HIV or have
faced genital ulcer / sores during last 12 months (Table 5.45).
Table 5.45
Awareness About STD/HIV

Have heard of STD-HIV/ Respondents A person with STD is prone to HIV/AIDS

AIDS
Yes 60 (95.2%) Response Respondents
No 3 (4.8%) Yes 35 (58.3%)
Total 63 (100%) No 6 (10%)
Source of your Information about HIV/AIDs Refused/ No Response 19 (31.6%)
Source Respondents Total 60 (100%)
Mass Media 31 (51.6%) HIV mainly spreads through unprotected Sex
Co-Workers 10 (16.6%) True 54 (90%)
NGO Workers 16 (26.6%) Partially true 1 (1.6%)
Others 3 (5%) Don’t Know 5 (8.3%)
Total 60 (100%) Total 60 (100%)
Condom use reduces the risk of HIV/AIDS/STD Commercial Sex Workers are most susceptible to HIV/
Infections AIDs
True 52 (86.6%) True 49 (81.6%)
Partially true 1 (1.6%) False 1 (1.6%)
Don’t Know 7 (11.6%) Partially true 1 (1.6%)
Recruiters, Perpetrators and Exploiters of Victims 163

Total 60 (100%) Don’t Know 9 (15%)

Have you any genital ulcer/ sores during last 12 Total 60 (100%)
months
No 48 (80%) Have you ever been tested for HIV
No Response 12 (20%) Yes 5 (8.3%)
Total 60 (100%) No 49 (81.6%)
What was the result of HIV Test No Response 6 (10%)
HIV Negative 5 (100%) Total 60 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Human trafficking of women and children is a worldwide concern since it violates fundamental
human rights. Although there are various individual violations of national and international
law committed during the course of trafficking, it is the combination of displacement from
the community and marketed exploitation that distinguishes trafficking from its constituent
parts. Individuals operating on their own or in small groups on an opportunistic basis to well-
structured criminal organizations operating as business entities pursuing territorial dominance.
Many more victims are trafficked when organized criminal gangs are engaged, frequently for
longer periods of time, over greater distances, and with greater brutality. However, individual
traffickers were identified in a greater number of court cases studied by UNODC than organized
crime groups. While many traffickers have criminal past and use human trafficking as a direct
source of revenue, human trafficking also affects business owners, intimate partners, and other
family members. Parents have been accused of assisting their children’s sexual exploitation or
forcing them to beg on the streets, according to court documents. In other circumstances, business
owners abuse people by forcing them to work.
Several human trafficking organizations, according to court cases and literature, are
organized as recruiting agencies, which are commonly employed by potential migrants looking
for work abroad. Workers are frequently fooled about the fees withdrawn from their earnings
to ostensibly cover job search, official paperwork, transportation, housing, and other services.
Some agencies have been accused of charging as much as 11 months’ salary. These organizations
can be found in a variety of industries, such as construction, fishing, agriculture, manufacturing,
and cleaning. In some circumstances, agencies intimidate employees, and they frequently have
the right to seize firm funds. In disadvantaged rural communities, small-scale recruiters use the
same strategies. These traffickers approach poor families, persuade them to send their children
to work, advance monies to purchase labour gear, and enslave the families in a cycle of debt with
their children stuck in exploitation. Employers are frequently charged fees by some agencies that
recruit domestic employees in Asia for wealthy families in the Middle East and other parts of
the world. Employers frequently force employees to reimburse fees, sometimes by withholding
documents and refusing to let them go until the fee is paid.
Individual or opportunistic traffickers are more likely to employ violence than traffickers
structured in governance-type organized criminal organizations. However, during the
recruitment phase, traffickers are more likely to use false or manipulative methods. The
UNODC-GLO-TiP-2020 investigation demonstrates how little victims are valued in the illegal
trafficking industry. Victims are traded as commodities by human traffickers. When victims are
bought and sold between traffickers, they are “priced.” Traffickers may offer victims as little as
a couple hundred dollars, which is comparable to a few grammes of methamphetamine. Human
trafficking is carried out by actors with varying levels of organizational structure, which can be
 164

split into two categories: organized criminal groups and opportunistic traffickers who operate
alone or in collaboration with one or more other traffickers. Human trafficking has become the
most profitable profession for many recruiters, including brothel owners and traffickers. Many
traffickers have strong ties to politicians and other high-ranking government officials, and as a
result, they are rarely arrested or prosecuted. Because human trafficking has a large network of
operations that extends beyond states and national borders, they are frequently not captured or
prosecuted. The arrest, incarceration, legal trial, and prosecution of trackers and brothel owners
is also time consuming, complicated, and laborious; as a result, many recruiters reap the rewards
and continue their operations. Existing laws include gaps, and many law enforcement agencies
and other players involved in enforcing laws and combating trafficking are under-informed.
 Chapter 6
STATUS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT IN
COMBATING HUMAN TRAFFICKING

C oncerns regarding migrant workers’ rights and conditions in India have been in the news
since the beginning of the COVID-19 outbreak, but the Indian government’s response has
been lacklustre (Janwalkar, 2020; Rukmini, 2020; Francis and Uniyal, 2021). Covid-19, according
to Subir Sinha, has exacerbated existing inequities in India, blurring the distinctions between
waged, compelled, and trafficking labour (Sinha, 2020). There have also been indications of an
increase in human trafficking incidents in India as a result of the present pandemic (News18
Networks, 2020). In response to these concerns, the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs’ Women
Safety Division has issued an advice, which has been in effect since July 2020, advising all
states and Union Territories to build new Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) and/or
enhance infrastructure in existing ones. The functions of AHTUs primarily include registering
cases of human trafficking, conducting raid and rescue operations for survivors of trafficking,
carrying out investigation on all aspects of the crime, collecting evidence, effectively prosecuting
traffickers, collecting, disseminating and utilizing intelligence on human trafficking and the
sharing of information on traffickers to concerned law enforcement agencies. Human trafficking
for the purpose of commercial sexual exploitation can invoke legal provision of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (‘IPC’), the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (‘ITPA’) and the Protection of
Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (‘POCSO’). Complaints of human trafficking can be
made before the local police, who ideally have to transfer such cases to the jurisdictional AHTU.
A study conducted by Sanjog, a technical resource organization, and Tafteesh, a coalition of
lawyers, activists, social workers and survivor leaders, on assessing the operational competence
of Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) across India revealed that only 27% of the AHTUs
are functional and only 51% being notified with all the power and resources. The study was
spearheaded by 5 lawyers who filed RTIs in 33 States and Union Territories out of which only
22 States and Union Territories responded. his study collated data between 2010-2019 with the
objective of evaluating the effectiveness of the AHTUs to find out the number of AHTUs actually
notified by State/UT Governments, the district-wise breakup of these AHTUs and various aspects
of how they functioned and trained their officials. Responses from 16 States and UTs showed
that 225 AHTUs are setup only on paper with no centralized process to notify them. Further, the
number of notified AHTUs in many states/UTs were much less than the number of AHTUs that
states/UTs claimed were operational. Most of the AHTU postings were only seen as ‘notional’
offices occupied by near-retirees or police officials taking on ‘punishment postings. (Published
in Indian Express on 1st September 2020, AHTU WATCH- A National Study on Status of Anti
Human Trafficking Units in India (2010-2019) by Sanjog-Kolkata and Tafteesh-Delhi). The study
 166

also found that only seven states/UTs (Bihar, Kerala, Nagaland, Rajasthan, West Bengal, Tamil
Nadu and Uttarakhand) have AHTUs covering all their districts. All the other states either have
AHTUs in half or less of their districts, with Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh having the lowest
coverages of AHTUs with 30% and 25%, respectively. Also, its alarming that 51% of the states
were unresponsive to the questions of establishing AHTUs. While the MHA advisory has sparked
increased interest among anti-trafficking activists, leading to calls for the rapid establishment of
AHTUs in all districts (Janyala, 2021), the report’s highlighted claim indicates that the Ministry
of Home Affairs, Government of India advisory, and demand for the establishment of AHTUs
is insufficient. The proposed intervention is warped by its failure to account for the colonial
heritage and current contestations in policies that equate human trafficking with social control
of consensual adult sex work and migration (Bhattacherya, 2018; Giammarinaro and Boola,
2018). Attempts to modify the legal definition of human trafficking and intervene have resulted
in the use of arbitrary and excessive state authority and bureaucratic control (Tandon, 2015).
These attempts indicate a misdirected emphasis on law enforcement rather than comprehensive
human-rights-based solutions that enhance workers’ and migrants’ agency.
India’s current policies on human trafficking have a colonial past, with negative consequences.
For example, as a colonial construct formed by the British Raj to promote their military, racial,
and colonial goals (Chang, 2007; Tambe, 2009), colonial regimes defined human trafficking as the
kidnapping and transportation of women for prostitution (Irwin, 1996). This definition conflates
human trafficking and prostitution, ignoring the interests and rights of consenting adult sex
workers (Tambe, 2009). Apart from the conflation with consenting adult sex work, colonial
prostitution governance established a regulatory system that gave unrestricted powers to
organizations such as the police or the regime, culminating in the prosecution and imprisonment
of sex workers. For example, the Indian Contagious Disease Act of 1868 required sex workers to
register, which included being compelled to stay at home (without work) for an indeterminate
amount of time and being imprisoned (Banerjee, 2000; Tambe, 2009). The focus of human
trafficking interventions on criminalizing sex work persisted, and Indian nationalists backed
laws reflecting a similar conflation of human trafficking and sex work and/or related professions
in the 1920s and 1930s, such as the Madras Hindu Religious Endowments (Amendment) Act
of 1929 (Sreenivas, 2011) and/or The Suppression of Immoral Traffic Acts (SITA) (Legg, 2014).
After India’s independence, SITA was reinstated and eventually replaced by the Immoral Traffic
(Prevention) Act, 1986. (ITPA). Except for a few minor differences, ITPA has a similar colonial
background and design to SITA, equating consenting adult sex employment with trafficking
(Cunha, 1987).
India has additional provisions combating human trafficking in addition to the ITPA, with an
amendment in section 370 of Indian Penal Code, which defines human trafficking as: Whoever,
for the purpose of exploitation, recruits, transports, harbors, transfers, or receives, a person or
persons, by using threats, or using force, or any other form of coercion, or by abduction, or by
practicing fraud, or deception, or by abuse of power, or by inducement, including the giving or
receiving of payments or benefits, in order to achieve the consent of any person having control
over the person recruited, transported, harbored, transferred or received, commits the offence
of trafficking. The expression “exploitation” shall include any act of physical exploitation or any
form of sexual exploitation, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude. The consent of the
victim is immaterial in determination of the offence of trafficking” (Govt. of India, 2013: 5).
The above definition in Section 370 not only perpetuates the conflation of human trafficking
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 167

and sex work, but it also introduces new complications: the broad definition encompasses many
people displaced by forced migration, denies targeted person’s agency, and gives the state
and bureaucratic regime and its institutions, including the police, unrestricted power. It also
advocates for a criminalization strategy to combat human trafficking. The National Crime Record
Bureau (NCRB) of the Indian government collects data on the current number of trafficking
cases using this definition of 370. According to data, 95 percent of trafficked persons in India are
forced into prostitution (Divya, 2020). According to the NCRB, there are a total of 6,616 human
trafficking instances documented in India, with sex trafficking being the most common (Munshi,
2020). Because these numbers are based on the description of trafficking in Section 370, which
conflates sex work with trafficking, the accuracy of this number is questioned. Because both
the ITPA and Section 370 allow it, these figures could include cases of adult sex workers who
consented but were denied consent during anti-trafficking interventions. However, these data
and laws place sex workers in a scenario where they are targeted selectively by anti-trafficking
actors and interventions (GAATW, 2007; The Telegraph, 2017; Chandra, 2018). As a response to
the Verma Committee’s proposal, the amendment to section 370 made minor but insufficient
revisions to the concept of trafficking (Khan, 2015). After ratifying the United Nations Protocol
to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children (UN
Protocol) in 2011, India’s commitment to international players prompted these modifications
(UNODC, 2004). Despite certain advances in India’s human trafficking or labourers’ tough
working circumstances, these adjustments, like colonial policies, caused more harm than good.
For example, documented narratives (Sangram, 2018), experiences (Walters, 2018) of targeted
groups, and research (GAATW, 2007; Pai, Seshu, and Murthy, 2018; Sangram, 2018; Walters and
Ramachandran, 2018) have all shown (re)production of violence and harms in targeted people’s
lives as a result of contemporary anti-trafficking interventions, of which AHTUs primarily serves
as the central implementing agency.
The purpose of settling AHTUs appears to be to maintain a law enforcement anti-crime
framework, given the ITPA and Section 370 definitions treat trafficking as a criminal offence.
In practice, however, narratives from targeted individuals at the local level indicate that
this intervention does not advance the goal of human rights and targeted person protection.
Narratives from Najar’s current ethnographic research, which gives epistemic priority to
adult migrant workers who have experienced anti-trafficking interventions or who are seen as
trafficked ‘victims’ in the law (Najar, 2020, 2021), in India’s construction and sex sectors, show
that anti-trafficking officials are viewed by such workers as corrupt and partial to the interests of
the perpetrators. Case Study-2: “Police is the culprit here,” Sanjana (name changed), a migrant
female adult sex worker, remarked while sitting inside her brothel room in Pune. She related an
incident from the day before in which two police officers harassed a customer, and the customer
responded by giving them Rs.1000/-. These customers were then allowed to enter the brothel
by the cops. She claimed that the police are a party in the red-light area. She also mentioned
that work should normally be done till midnight or 1:00 a.m. However, because the Police make
rounds till midnight, very few customers arrive before that time because they are afraid of being
harassed by the cops. According to Sanjana, the method is reversed here, as the market opens
after 12 p.m., after the cops have collected their share and left. This story shows how a system
that gives greater power and authority to institutions like the police may be abused, causing
more harm to workers’ livelihoods and rights, rather than securing and preserving their human
rights. Furthermore, state officials were seen as having unrestrained power over the targeted
person’s decisions, choices, and path. Case Study-3: “Who knows when they (Police) will start
 168

harassing you,” remarked Sultana, a non-brothel based adult migrant sex worker in Kolkata,
who introduced herself as a “flying sex worker” when describing her experiences in our research.
They occasionally come to a halt in front of me, inquire whether I have Ganja or Daaru and
exchange a few words with me before driving away. All power, however, is in their hands. They
can put me in jail if they want by claiming that I am 15 years old or that I am a Bangladeshi
(undocumented migrant). Then no one will come to my aid. They (Police) are in charge. So,
it’s best not to annoy them and pay or do the service that they require.” This story depicts the
anxiety and consequences experienced by marginalized migrant workers in India as a result of
excessive and unaccountable institutionalized authority given to agents such as cops, as well as
the conflation of rules with consenting adult sex activity.
As of February 29, 2020, the Ministry of Women and Child Development of India supported 332
Anti-Human Trafficking Units (2010-2011 to 2019-2020). Uttar Pradesh had the highest number of
AHTUs (35) followed by Madhya Pradesh (24), Bihar (20), Rajasthan (19), and Maharashtra (18).
As a result, total reliance on AHTUs has the potential to recreate harmful situations, resulting in
insufficient relief for the targeted person (Sangram, 2018; Walters, 2018; Sen, 2021). Furthermore,
giving AHTUs authority and relying on them may foster further corruption, police surveillance
and control, the replication of problematic raid-rescue methods, and the targeting of suspected
migrants, particularly sex workers, undocumented/informal labourers, and so on. Sen (2021)
that discusses a recent incident and how “Police Raid to Rescue interventions criminalized an
Entire Neighborhood.” Because the legislation conflates human trafficking with sex work and
forced migration, and places disproportionate emphasis on law enforcement techniques, this
situation is possible.
More structural efforts to engage with these intersecting challenges in a way that honours the
agency of targeted persons are hampered by the disproportionate reliance on law enforcement
measures. In her report, the UN special rapporteur on human trafficking called for a shift in focus
away from law enforcement and toward human rights and victim protection (Okyere, 2020). In
her report, the UN special rapporteur on human trafficking also stated that a new international
instrument may be required, as existing international treaties such as the Palermo Protocol may
not be sufficient or successful in addressing such human rights goals. “The Palermo agreement
is irredeemably corrupted and must be abolished, rather than modified,” Sam Okyere argues,
analyzing the Special Rapporteur’s thesis. Instead, we must strengthen existing international
institutions that focus on the rights and protections of workers and migrants. Any new instrument
devised must avoid falling into the trap of prioritizing crime prevention” (Okyere, 2020). As a
result, the present demand to combat human trafficking and protect migrant rights indicates
a movement away from law enforcement-focused intervention and toward human rights
and worker protection. Given the colonial past and the ongoing problems raised by previous
attempts at legal reform, it appears that the current intervention to combat human trafficking in
India, which consists solely of the establishment of AHTUs, is insufficient. India’s plan to combat
human trafficking and the migrant worker dilemma should not rely solely on law enforcement
institutions such as AHTUs; rather, it should include rights-based reforms that demolish the
colonial legacy of the law that conflates human trafficking, sex work, and migration. If the Indian
government fails to alter its policies and instead supports intervention by solely establishing law
enforcement mechanisms such as AHTUs, it would be a token response rather than a genuine
effort to combat trafficking and safeguard the rights of migrant workers.
The Rescue Protocol lays forth basic recommendations for planning and carrying out raids
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 169

in a “successful, child-friendly manner [that is] less stressful for the child,” as well as rapid
post-rescue procedures. According to the Harvard FXB report (2016), rescue operations in Bihar
and Rajasthan are mostly successful in physically removing a small number of children from
exploitative labour situations after workplace raids. However, operations are carried out in a
haphazard manner by poorly trained personnel who are not supported by centralized intelligence
systems, exposing youngsters to further trauma and risk. The content and implementation of
policies for organizing and executing raids are both lacking.
Rescue teams should include a representative from the Department of Labour, representatives
from the CWCs, a local non-profit, a doctor, and a female police officer or volunteer, according to
the Protocol. These individuals must be trained on applicable legislation, their personal duties,
and trauma prevention techniques. However, participants in the study stated that in actuality,
teams are frequently too small to handle the large number of youngsters in need of rescue.
Only occasionally do police officials, doctors, and female witnesses participate. The AHTUs,
whose primary mission is to coordinate rescue and post-rescue operations, are rarely involved
in the process. Rescue operations rely primarily on non-profit groups in practice because there
is no clear distribution of responsibility between the many bodies named in the Protocol. While
several organizations, including Bachpan Bachao Andolan, Rescue Foundation, International
Justice Mission, Diya Seva Sansthan, BKS, and Sanlap, have significant experience conducting
raids, key informant data suggests that this overreliance leads to ad hoc and under-resourced
raids directed by inexperienced or poorly supported workers, a situation that can and does cause
additional trauma to vulnerable children. NGOs occasionally continue with a rescue on their
own, according to one respondent: ‘Most of the time, if we don’t take prompt action, the child
could be transported somewhere else.’ As a result, no one is informed. My first goal is to save
the child, and then I’ll inform the rest of the family.’ In retribution for their acts, non-profit
participants claimed receiving threats, stone attacks, and beatings. The lack of engagement of
law enforcement in raids exacerbates the possibility of retaliation. Details of the rescue and the
identities of rescued children must be kept totally confidential, according to the Protocol, and
should not be revealed to third parties, including the media. Privacy violations and information
leaks before, during, and after raids, however, are common. Employers are frequently notified
to impending raids, according to respondents, and botched rescue operations can raise the
chance of employers retaliating against minors. Basic safeguards to protect children’s identity
are frequently overlooked. According to one government official, rescue team members actively
seek media participation so that “the public understands that this type of action is a crime and
serious offence.” Retaliation against rescued children is a possibility, as is heightened societal
stigma and reintegration problems. Furthermore, frequent sensationalized media coverage of
raids contributes to the problem’s perpetuation by simplifying the complicated underlying social
and economic issues.
The average number of reported human trafficking cases during 2016 to 2019 was reported
to be 5237. The number of such cases was recorded high in Maharashtra followed by Andhra
Pradesh, Assam, Kerala, West Bengal and Odisha which witnessed average number of 150-300
cases per year in each state (Table 6.1).
Table: 6.1
State -Wise Cases Reported Under Human Trafficking During 2016-2019
Sl. No State/UT 2016 2017 2018 2019
1 Andhra Pradesh 239 218 240 245
 170

2 Arunachal Pradesh 2 0 3 0
3 Assam 91 262 262 201
4 Bihar 43 121 127 106
5 Chhattisgarh 68 48 51 50
6 Goa 40 39 55 38
7 Gujarat 548 9 13 11
8 Haryana 51 22 34 15
9 Himachal Pradesh 8 11 6 11
10 Jammu & Kashmir 0 1 1 0
11 Jharkhand 109 373 373 177
12 Karnataka 404 31 27 32
13 Kerala 21 53 105 180
14 Madhya Pradesh 51 87 63 73
15 Maharashtra 517 310 311 282
16 Manipur 3 8 3 9
17 Meghalaya 7 8 24 22
18 Mizoram 2 2 2 7
19 Nagaland 0 0 0 3
20 Odisha 84 63 75 147
21 Punjab 13 5 17 19
22 Rajasthan 1422 316 86 141
23 Sikkim 1 3 1 0
24 Tamil Nadu 434 13 8 16
25 Telangana 229 329 242 137
26 Tripura 0 2 2 1
27 Uttar Pradesh 79 46 35 48
28 Uttarakhand 12 20 29 20
29 West Bengal 3579 357 172 172
30 A & N Islands 1 0 0 0
31 Chandigarh 1 0 0 2
32 D&N Haveli 0 0 0 0
33 Daman & Diu 7 1 0 0
34 Delhi UT 66 95 98 93
35 Lakshadweep 0 0 0 0
36 Puducherry 0 1 0 2
Total 8132 2854 2465 2260
Source: NCRB, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India
Table: 6.1 Shows that there is a declining trend in the number of reported cases whereas the
ground realities show that there is an increase in the incidences of trafficking. The traffickers
mostly use the railway stations as transit point for transporting the victims to other states, as
it is well connected, cheaper and safer for them. According to Shri Birendra Kumar, Principal
Chief Security Commissioner, Southern Railway during the interview, “The number of children
rescued, most of them trafficked, at railway stations across Tamil Nadu and Kerala under
Southern Railway, has tripled over three years. In 2016, the number of children rescued was 615.
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 171

This jumped to 905 in 2017 and to 1603 in 2018. Until the end of April this year, 683 children have
been rescued.” However, no case is registered in 2017 and 2018 by Government Railway Police
in Tamil Nadu as per NCRB data which is contrary to the reality.
Key informant interviews with police officers, Government Railway Police (GRP) and
Railway Protection Force (RPF), and other stakeholders – Child Welfare Committee members,
NGO representatives, and vendors in railway stations - were conducted to better understand the
reasons for not reporting the incidents. According to them, the majority of incidents of human
trafficking are not registered or reported, which is one of the main reasons for the decline in
recorded cases of human trafficking. More than 2000 runaway/trafficked children are rescued
every year in Tamil Nadu from major railway stations such as Chennai central, Egmore, Salem,
Erode, Tirupur, and Coimbatore, according to Service Providers and Program Administrators.
GRP/RPF makes a memo/DD entry, and in most circumstances, the children are handed over to
the Child Welfare Committee. Some of them go uninvestigated or unrecorded.
The law relating to FIR is covered in Section 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), which
is the procedural law governing crimes in our country. When a police officer receives information
on the commission of a criminal offence, he or she is required to record the information and file
a report. In 2013, Section 154 was revised, and now, if the informant is a woman who has been
the victim of an acid attack or a sexual offence, the information must be recorded by a woman
officer. Furthermore, if the woman has been physically or mentally impaired as a result of the
crime, such information must be documented at her home or any other location convenient to
her. Wherever possible, the information should be recorded in the presence of an interpreter or
special educator, and in such situations, it is also obliged by law to video graph the information
recording.
Despite the terms of the law and directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, police refuse to
register complaints in situations of human trafficking and rape, forcing the complainant to file
a complaint through court orders- while the wrongdoing police officials go unpunished. There
have been instances where police have refused to file a complaint on the basis of jurisdiction/area,
despite the fact that there are regulations that allow any police station to file a complaint and the
investigation to be transferred to the appropriate police station. Any police officer who refuses
to file a FIR in a rape case faces a minimum sentence of six months in prison and a maximum
sentence of two years in prison, as well as a fine (Section 166A(c), IPC), So the real issue in this
case is the enforcement of law, appropriate authorities are suggested for strict enforcement of
law and also there is a need of capacity building & Training of Police Personnel.
Cases are not registered for a variety of reasons. It varies depending on the circumstances.
IPC section 370 is not well known among police officers. Although it is stated explicitly in
explanation-2 of the Act that the victim’s consent is irrelevant in determining whether or not
the offence of trafficking has occurred, most police do not accept this. As there are vacancies at
police stations, the officers are overburdened with tasks. As a result, they are hesitant since they
are unable to study the complete chain, which spans three to four states. Between the source
and destination states, there is no coordination mechanism. Even if the victims are rescued and
returned to their homes, there is no rehabilitation package available under the IPC, keeping the
victims vulnerable. There will also be issues with filing charge sheets, trials, and other actions if
the victims do not cooperate or become hostile. Officers are forced to disclose incidents due to
corruption, pressure from superiors/politicians, and a lack of review mechanisms. Furthermore,
child protection processes are ineffective, with victims not being properly questioned or protocols
 172

not being followed. They don’t have the authority or power to sway police officers.
As a result of the underreporting of human trafficking cases and loopholes in other laws,
comprehensive legislation is needed to combat the problem and safeguard the rights of victims
and survivors. The bill against human trafficking is currently being revised by the Ministry of
Women and Child Development. While revising the bill, stakeholders’ recommendations should
be taken into account in order to create a complete bill that would prevent human trafficking,
protect/rehabilitate victims, prosecute offenders, and ensure efficient implementation of the Act.
This demonstrates that IPC section 370 has many gaps and cases are under-reported, which is
extremely obvious. It excludes rehabilitation, victim recompense, and access to justice in favour of
punishing the traffickers. Furthermore, the Prevention of Immoral Trafficking Act solely addresses
sex trafficking, not other forms of trafficking such as forced labour, organ transplantation,
beggary, and commercial surrogacy. The definition of an accused in the Bonded Labor Abolition
Act is limited to the major employer, which excludes traffickers from prosecution. Furthermore,
the victim’s recompense is related to their conviction, making them more vulnerable.
As per a recent report on atrocities and crimes against women and children, submitted to
Rajya Sabha on 15th March, 2021, there were 3073 average number of trafficked children and
2459 trafficked women in India during the period of 2017 to 2019. The average number of
rescued victims was reported 2872 for children and 2547 for women victims. Thus, the number
of trafficked and rescued children as compared to trafficked and rescued women victims was
recorded comparatively higher (Table 6.2).
Table: 6.2
Number of Trafficked and Rescued Victims in India

Particular 2017 2018 2019

Trafficked Victims
Children 3535 2772 2914
Male 2037 1706 1742
Female 1498 1066 1172
Women 2040 2432 2907
Victims Rescued
Children 3294 2484 2837
Women 2211 2466 2964
Source: Two Hundred Thirtieth Report on Atrocities and Crimes Against Women and Children, Rajya Sabha
On 15th March, 2021
Since human trafficking is an organized crime therefore rescue alone cannot succeed in isolation
– most of the other related activities cross-cut and supplement each other at various levels. Hence,
every rescue should be compulsorily followed by arrest of traffickers, seizure of brothels, bail rejections,
conviction and much more. 90% acquittal rate in trafficking cases (Crime in India - NCRB 2020)
should be seen as a direct result of the impunity enjoyed by the criminal nexus which also results in
increased trafficking and child prostitution. Though, number of persons arrested under human
trafficking has shown a declining trend over the period of 2016 to 2019. However, number of
persons convicted and number of persons charge sheeted against number of persons arrested
under human trafficking was recorded lower in during the corresponding period (Table 6.3).
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 173

Table: 6.3
Disposal of Persons Arrested under Human Trafficking
Persons Charge Persons Persons Acquitted/ discharged
Year Persons Arrested
sheeted Convicted by the Court
2019 5128 3638 324 1329
2018 5362 3922 432 1126
2017 5528 4209 249 1155
2016 10815 7292 159 753
Source: NCRB, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India
Though, there has been significant decline in the number of cases reported and cases charge
sheeted and final report submitted by police. However, there has been significant growth in the
rate of charge sheeted (Table 6.4).
Table 6.4
Disposal of Cases of Human Trafficking by Police

Total Number of Cases Disposal by Police

Year
Reported Cases Charge-sheeted Final Report
2019 2260 1606 312
2018 2465 1910 349
2017 2854 2060 383
2016 8132 2403 2814
Source: NCRB, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India
The conviction rate under crimes against women & Children during the period from 2017 to
2019 is given in Table 6.5. The tables depict that the conviction rate in crimes against women and
children for the past three years has been low. The conviction rate in cases of crimes like rape,
cruelty by husband or his relatives, violation of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence
Act, human trafficking, violation of Cyber Crimes/Information Technology Act and Protection
of Children from Sexual offenses Act, have been amongst the lowest. It has been informed by the
State Government of Uttar Pradesh that they are conducting prosecution drives to improve the
conviction rate in crimes against women and children. It has helped in increasing the conviction
rate as in 2019, the conviction rate was 29.28 percent under POCSO Act and in 2020, and it has
increased to 37.51 percent. In rape cases also, the rate of conviction has increased from 34.36% in
2019 to 47.45 percent in 2020. In other sexual offenses, it has increased from 34.97 percent in 2019
to 38.15 percent in 2020. They have a separate prosecution department headed by Additional
Director-General (ADG) level officer who undertakes special drives from time to time to coordinate
with the district level Monitoring Committees. The Government of West Bengal has also informed
that crime against women has been showing a decreasing trend and the charge-sheets rate in case
of crime against women is 94% in their State. It was further informed that the conviction rate
is not good and, in this regard, the interface between the Judiciary and the Executive comes to
the fore.
The conviction rate under crimes against women has shown a declining trend during the
period of 2017 to 2019. The conviction rate was recorded high for buying of minor girls (66.7 per
cent) followed by murder with rape /gang rape (63.2 per cent), acid attack (54.2 per cent) during
2019. Conviction rate under human trafficking was recorded 42.4 per cent in 2017 which declined
 174

to 31.9 per cent in 2018 and further reduced to 20 per cent in 2019. There has been significant
increase in number of persons convicted under human trafficking in India during the period of
2016-2019. During 2016, number of persons convicted under human trafficking was reported 159
which increased to 432 during 2018; however, it dropped to 324 in 2019. The number of persons
convicted under human trafficking was recorded high in Andhra Pradesh followed by Uttar
Pradesh, Jharkhand and Telangana.
The main reasons for low conviction rate as per public prosecutors were recorded witnessed
turning hostile (44.8 percent), poor evidence (20.7 per cent), lengthy court procedure (13.8 per
cent), inappropriate charge sheet (10.3 per cent) and easy bail to traffickers (10.3 per cent).
However, reasons for low conviction rate vary across the selected states (Table 6.5).
Table 6.5
Reasons for Low Conviction Rate as Per Public Prosecutors

Witness In – Easy Bail to Traffickers So They Lengthy

Poor
State Turning Appropriate Influence the Witness, Threaten Survivors Court Total
Evidences
Hostile Charge Sheet and Often Commit Crime Again Procedure
2 0 0 2 0 4
West Bengal
50.0% 0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 0.0% 100%
4 0 0 1 1 6
Maharashtra
66.7% 0.0% 0.0% 16.7% 16.7% 100%
1 1 1 0 0 3
Karnataka
33.3% 33.3% 33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 100%
2 1 1 0 1 5
Jharkhand
40.0% 20.0% 20.0% 0.0% 20.0% 100%
2 0 0 0 1 3
Assam
66.7% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 33.3% 100%
2 1 1 1 1 6
Uttar Pradesh
33.3% 16.7% 16.7% 16.7% 16.7% 100%
0 0 0 0 2 2
Tamil Nadu
0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100% 100%
13 3 3 4 6 29
Total
44.8% 10.3% 10.3% 13.8% 20.7% 100%

Source: Filed Survey

The Key informant interviews with police officers, Government Railway Police (GRP) and
Railway Protection Force (RPF), and other stakeholders – Child Welfare Committee members,
NGO representatives & Service Providers reveals that during the course of investigation, the
statement of complainant/victims is altered or ignored and not video-graphed as per law. Even
if the statement of victims/complainants is video-graphed, then the same is not forwarded to
the court with the charge-sheet. It is observed that law enforcing authorities neglect to take any
action against the accused persons furnishing forged documents to procure bail. Police hardly
makes the informant NGO witness of recovery memo/charge sheet due to which the traffickers/
brothel keepers are mostly successful in escaping the legal trap. These are some basic reasons foe
low rate of conviction in cases of Human Trafficking.
About 44.8 percent of respondent has reported that the reason for low conviction rate is
witness turning hostile followed by Poor Evidence, Lengthy Court Practices, in-appropriate
charge sheet and easy bail to offenders. A paucity of evidence against the culprit also contributed
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 175

to the poor conviction. When asked about the issues that rape victims face during the medical
examination and investigation process, the NGO ‘All India Women’s Conference (AIWC)’ stated
that the issues that rape victims face include delays in medical examination that result in the
disappearance of evidence, insensitivity of doctors, apathy and insensitivity of police, lack of
counselling, and so on. In terms of investigating and prosecuting severe crimes against women,
the NGO Action India believes that due to defective charge sheets filed in a timely manner,
it can be difficult to prove a case of rape or even a case of violence. As a result, charge sheets
must be filed correctly and within the timeframe specified. According to reports, the Delhi Police
Legal Cell has taken many steps to keep Investigation Officers (IOs) up to date on the latest
Court judgements and decrees, including producing an advance monthly calendar of all such
cases pending trial in District Courts, the High Court, and the Supreme Court. On a monthly
basis, a summary of various observations/directions made by the District Courts is created
and distributed to all Districts/Units in order to improve the skills of Investigating Officers.
These monthly booklets highlight issues/errors relating to investigation flaws caused by non-
compliance with statutory provisions, IO procedural lapses, and other factors influencing the
speed of trial and court proceedings. These orders are organized by offence and compiled. Joint
training programmes for investigating officers and police personnel are also held to develop
their skills in order to improve the conviction rate. In addition, IOs are regularly trained in
specialist courses such as scientific investigation, extradition law, key case studies, and cyber-
crime, among others, in order to conduct a proper investigation. W/IOs are also given a number
of workshops and short-term courses in order to ensure that offenders are convicted. In all of
its basic training programmes for various ranks, the Delhi Police prioritizes all parts of scientific
inquiry, forensic science, and knowledge of criminal laws and procedures. This model could be
used in other states as well.
There has been decline in conviction rate during the period of 2016 to 2019, however, disposal
cases of human trafficking by course have shown an increasing trend over the period of 2016 to
2019 (Table 6.6).
Table 6.6
Disposal of Cases of Human Trafficking by Court

Disposal By Court
Total Number of Cases Acquitted/ Cases In Which
Year Cases Convicted by Cases Conviction
Cases Reported Discharged by Trials Were
Court Rate
Court Completed
2019 2260 172 538 782 22.0%
2018 2465 202 485 687 29.4%
2017 2854 164 505 669 24.5%
2016 8132 163 424 587 27.8%

Source: NCRB

PERCEPTION OF LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES:

About 58 per cent respondents were found associated with AHTUs/SDM Vigilance
Committee. It was found more pronouncing in Delhi (89.7 percent) followed by Uttar Pradesh
(70 per cent). About 2/5th respondents in West Bengal and 1/3rd respondents in Assam were
associated with District Law Enforcement Agency while half of the respondents in Tamil Nadu,
2/5th respondents in Jharkhand and 1/3rd respondents in Karnataka and Assam were associated
with State Law Enforcement Agency (Table 6.7).
 176

Table 6.7
Type of Agency Interviewed
State Law District Law AHTU/SDM-
GRP/BSF/SSB/ CRPF/
State Enforcement Enforcement Vigilance Total
RPF- In Case of Transit
Agency Agency (Police) Committee
West Bengal 1 (4.8%) 9 (42.9%) 8 (38.1%) 3 (14.3%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 1 (6.7%) 4 (26.7%) 6 (40.0%) 4 (26.7%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 3 (42.9%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (57.1%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 2 (33.3%) 2 (33.3%) 1 (16.7%) 1 (16.7%) 6 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (70.0%) 3 (30.0%) 10 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (100%)
Delhi 0 (0.0%) 3 (10.3%) 26 (89.7%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 9 (9.7%) 18 (19.4%) 54 (58.1%) 12 (12.9%) 93 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Intelligence collection, crime investigation, undertaking rescue operations, database
maintenance and updation and prosecution of offender were main responsibilities of respondents
(Table 6.8).
Table: 6.8
Role and Responsibility of Respondents

Work With Prosecutors

Database Maintenance
Intelligence Collection

Post Prosecution Con-

And Sishu Desks/De-
Post Rescue Care and

On Law Enforcement

Keep Vigil At Transit

Liaison With Mahila

Undertake Commu-
nity/Moral Policing
Crime Investigation

Prosecution Of Of-
Undertake Rescue

viction Action
Rehabilitation
& Updation

Operations

Activities
partment

fenders

Areas
State

18 18 15 3 5 16 10 0 6 5 6
West Bengal
85.7% 85.7% 71.4% 14.3% 23.8% 76.2% 47.6% 0.0% 28.6% 23.8% 28.6%
10 8 12 3 6 15 8 6 7 7 8
Maharashtra
66.7% 53.3% 80.0% 20.0% 40.0% 100% 53.3% 40.0% 46.7% 46.7% 53.3%
3 1 2 0 0 2 1 0 2 0 0
Karnataka
100% 33.3% 66.7% 0.0% 0.0% 66.7% 33.3% 0.0% 66.7% 0.0% 0.0%
5 3 5 0 3 4 1 0 3 0 0
Jharkhand
71.4% 42.9% 71.4% 0.0% 42.9% 57.1% 14.3% 0.0% 42.9% 0.0% 0.0%
4 4 4 3 3 4 4 1 3 1 4
Assam
66.7% 66.7% 66.7% 50.0% 50.0% 66.7% 66.7% 16.7% 50.0% 16.7% 66.7%
9 9 9 0 4 6 1 1 3 4 7
Uttar Pradesh
90.0% 90.0% 90.0% 0.0% 40.0% 60.0% 10.0% 10.0% 30.0% 40.0% 70.0%
0 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0
Tamil Nadu
0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 50.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
25 17 26 0 5 26 19 2 4 2 6
Delhi
86.2% 58.6% 89.7% 0.0% 17.2% 89.7% 65.5% 6.9% 13.8% 6.9% 20.7%
74 60 74 9 26 74 45 10 28 19 31
Total
79.6% 64.5% 79.6% 9.7% 28.0% 79.6% 48.4% 10.8% 30.1% 20.4% 33.3%

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents admitted that their departments have formal protocol for conducting
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 177

raid and rescue of victims of human trafficking. However, about 17 per cent respondents in
Assam were against the view point and about 19 per cent respondents in West Bengal were
not aware about the fact. Most of the respondents reported that registering of FIR is covered
under protocol while about 3/4th respondents reported that obtaining search warrant has been
included in the protocol. A large proportion of respondents reported that wearing badges and
uniform also covered in the protocol (Table 6.9).
Table 6.9
Kinds of Things Covered in Protocol
Obtain Search Wearing Badges and
State Register FIR Others
Warrant Uniform
West Bengal 14 (82.4%) 12 (70.6%) 4 (23.5%) 1 (5.9%)
Maharashtra 14 (93.3%) 6 (40.0%) 8 (53.3%) 1 (6.7%)
Karnataka 3 (100%) 3 (100%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%)
Jharkhand 7 (100%) 5 (71.4%) 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%)
Assam 5 (100%) 2 (40.0%) 3 (60.0%) 1 (20.0%)
Uttar Pradesh 10 (100%) 9 (90.0%) 10 (100%) 0 (0.0%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Delhi 29 (100%) 29 (100%) 1 (3.4%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 83 (94.3%) 66 (75.0%) 34 (38.6%) 3 (3.4%)
Source: Field Survey
Producing of victims before magistrate, searching premises, producing victims before CWC
in case of minor, custody of belongings of victim, segregating offenders and evidence collection
were some of the protocols during rescue operations (Table 6.10).
Table 6.10
Protocols during Rescue Operations
Produce
Custody of Produce Victim
Searching Segregating Evidence
State belongings of Victim Before Before Others
Premises Offenders Collection
Victims Magistrate CWC If
Minor
17 3 15 2 15 15 0
West Bengal
100% 17.6% 88.2% 11.8% 88.2% 88.2% 0.0%
15 12 14 14 14 14 0
Maharashtra
100% 80.0% 93.3% 93.3% 93.3% 93.3% 0.0%
3 0 2 3 3 3 0
Karnataka
100% 0.0% 66.7% 100% 100% 100% 0.0%
6 4 5 5 7 6 0
Jharkhand
85.7% 57.1% 71.4% 71.4% 100% 85.7% 0.0%
3 2 4 3 4 5 1
Assam
60.0% 40.0% 80.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100% 20.0%
8 8 10 4 10 10 0
Uttar Pradesh
80.0% 80.0% 100% 40.0% 100% 100% 0.0%
1 1 1 1 2 0 0
Tamil Nadu
50.0% 50.0% 50.0% 50.0% 100% 0.0% 0.0%
29 12 29 8 29 29 0
Delhi
100% 41.4% 100% 27.6% 100% 100% 0.0%
 178

82 42 80 40 84 82 1
Total
93.2% 47.7% 90.9% 45.5% 95.5% 93.2% 1.1%

Source: Field Survey

A negligible proportion of respondents admitted that survey has been conducted in their
areas about vulnerabilities of human trafficking (Table 6.11).
Table 6.11
Any Survey has been conducted in areas Vulnerable to Trafficking
Response Yes No Not Sure Total
10 72 11 93
Respondents
10.8% 77.4% 11.8% 100%
Source: Field Survey
About 2/5th respondents reported that the problem of human trafficking is serious and this
has been taken as priority in their agency. Even less than 1/3rd respondents viewed that human
trafficking is very serious problem. It was found more pronouncing in Tamil Nadu followed by
Karnataka and West Bengal (Table 6.12).
Table 6.12
Whether Trafficking is viewed as serious problem and priority in your Agency
Somewhat Serious Very Serious
State Minor Problem Total
Problem Problem Problem
West Bengal 0 (0.0%) 5 (23.8%) 3 (14.3%) 13 (61.9%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 2 (13.3%) 1 (6.7%) 6 (40.0%) 6 (40.0%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (66.7%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 3 (42.9%) 4 (57.1%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 0 (0.0%) 2 (33.3%) 2 (33.3%) 2 (33.3%) 6 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 2 (20.0%) 6 (60.0%) 2 (20.0%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (100%) 2 (100%)
Delhi 0 (0.0%) 3 (10.3%) 22 (75.9%) 4 913.8%) 29 (100%)
Total 4 (4.3%) 21 (22.6%) 39 (41.9%) 29 (31.2%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
A negligible proportion of respondents (7.5 per cent) admitted that placement agencies that
facilitate migration are registered with law enforcement agency. It was found more pronouncing
in Tamil Nadu followed by Karnataka and Maharashtra. Thus, most of the respondents revealed
that placement agencies are not registered with them. Thus, there is possibility of exploitation of
girls during their migration (Table 6.13).
Table 6.13
Whether Placement Agencies Who Facilitate Migration Are Registered with Law Enforcement Agencies
State Yes No Not Sure Total
West Bengal 0 (0.0%) 20 (95.2%) 1 (4.8%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 5 (33.3%) 4 (26.7%) 6 (40.0%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 1 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 5 (71.4%) 2 (28.6%) 7 (100%)
Assam 0 90.0%) 5 (83.3%) 1 (16.7%) 6 (100%)
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 179

Uttar Pradesh 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%)

Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%)
Delhi 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 7 (7.5%) 74 (79.6%) 12 (12.9%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
About 29 per cent respondents reported that labour trafficking of people within India is
widespread in their jurisdiction area while about 20 per cent respondents reported that sex
trafficking is widespread in their jurisdiction area. Majority of the respondents reported that sex
trafficking of people within the area including victims of commercial sex is found to be occasional
in their jurisdiction area (Table 6.14).
Table 6.14
Prevalence of Different Types of Human Trafficking Within Your Jurisdiction

Non existent
Widespread

Occasional

Unsure

Total
Rare
Type of Human Trafficking

Labor Trafficking of People Who Come from Outside 12 26 38 15 2 93

the India, Including Victims of Forced Labor or
Domestic Servitude. 12.9% 28.0% 40.9% 16.1% 2.2% 100%
Labor Trafficking of People Within the India, 27 42 18 4 2 93
Including Victims of Forced Labor or Domestic
Servitude. 29.0% 45.2% 19.4% 4.3% 2.2% 100%

Sex Trafficking of People Who Come from Outside 13 48 17 11 4 93

the India, Including Victims of Commercial Sex Acts. 14.0% 51.6% 18.3% 11.8% 4.3% 100%
Sex Trafficking of People Within the India, Including 19 57 11 1 5 93
Victims of Commercial Sex Acts 20.4% 61.3% 11.8% 1.1% 5.4% 100%
Source: Field Survey
The Ministry of Home Affairs of the Government of India has issued frequent advisories
to the Border Security Force (BSF), the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB), and state governments to
engage and coordinate to combat the issue of border trafficking. BSF and SSB have lately received
funding from the MHA to build Anti-Human Trafficking Units (ATHUs) in border areas and
upgrade their infrastructure in order to combat human trafficking. Bilateral Memorandums
of Understanding (MoUs) with adjacent countries such as Bangladesh and Myanmar are also
thought to be beneficial in the repatriation of trafficking victims. India has also been working with
other surrounding nations to sign such Memorandums of Understanding in order to improve
collaboration and coordination in the fight against human trafficking.
Non local language speaking, being control by someone, frightened, unusual behavior,
unfamiliar with local language, holding of identity documents by someone, body language,
limited freedom of movement are some of the possible sign of potential victims of human
trafficking and modern slavery (Table 6.15).
 180

Table 6.15
Possible signs of potential victim of human trafficking & Modern Slavery

Signs/Indicators Response

Frightened/Wary/Scared 77 (82.8%)
Victims Are Non-Local Language Speaking 81 (87.1%)
Unusual Behavior/ Demeanor 63 (67.7%)
Nervous/Withdrawn/Quiet 53 (57.0%)
Beginning On the Street 18 (19.4%)
Sad/Depressed 33 (35.5%)
Being Controlled by Someone 75 (80.6%)
No Communication or Eye Contact 33 (35.5%)
Houses of Multiple Occupancy/Multiple Housing Moves/ Suspicious Activity in Premises/
Heavy Security at The Commercial Establishment or Work Site (Barred Windows, Locked 28 (30.1%)
Doors, Electronic Surveillance, Guards)
Unusually High Foot Traffic at Establishment 27 (29.0%)
Thin/Malnourished 23 (24.7%)
Limited Freedom of Movement/Isolated 58 (62.4%)
Dress 20 (21.5%)
Injured/Ill Health/Discomfort 40 (43.0%)
Limited Access to Money/Control on How or Where Money Is Spent 45 (48.4%)
Unfamiliar With Local Language /Away from Home 63 (67.7%)
Signs Of Physical or Psychological Trauma 55 (59.1%)
Long Working Hours 19 (20.4%)
Poor Hygiene 24 (25.8%)
Body Language 57 (61.3%)
Poor Living Conditions/Accommodation 30 (32.3%)
Signs Of Substance Misuse 57 (61.3%)
Passport Identity Documents held by Someone Else/ Victims do not have Control of Their own
77 (82.8%)
Identity/Travel Documents
Disclosure 27 (29.0%)
Tone/Volume of Voice 26 (28.0%)
Works In Sex Industry 28 (30.1%)
Pay Transferred to Other Accounts 12 (12.9%)
Source: Field Survey
Help lines, referrals from advocacy groups/victims service providers, missing person’s
report, tips from members of the community, tip from informant or coconspirator and railway
protection force etc. are some of the attention means for cases of human trafficking (Table 6.16).
Table 6.16
How Cases Come to Attention of Law Enforcement
Sources of Information Response
Calls For Service 27 (29.0%)
Alerts/ Referrals from Advocacy Groups/Victim Service Providers (VSPs) Or Community/
73 (78.5%)
Faith-Based Organizations (CBOs)
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 181

Tips From Members of The Community/ Citizens or Good Samaritans 63 (67.7%)

Task Forces 30 (32.3%)
Tips From Informant or Co-Conspirator 61 (65.6%)
Media Reports 13 (14.0%)
During The Course of Investigation for Other Crimes (e.g., Prostitution, Drugs, Domestic
44 (47.3%)
Violence)
Missing Persons Reports 69 (74.2%)
Information/Referrals from Inspectional Services or Other Regulatory Agencies/Law
20 (21.5%)
Enforcement Agencies
Information/Referrals from Criminal Justice Agencies That Are Non-Law Enforcement (e.g.,
14 (15.1%)
Probation)
Undercover Operations (e.g., Collaborative Investigations with National and State Law
24 (25.8%)
Enforcement)
Railway Protection Force 66 (71.0%)
Help Lines 78 (83.9%)
Transporters 13 (14.0%)
Other 4 (4.3%)
Source: Field Survey
Work with state and local law enforcement agency, surveillance, interview of victims, covert
/overt operations, follow up on the leads and, task force participation are some of primary role
of law enforcement agencies while working on cases of human trafficking (Table 6.17).
Table 6.17
Primary Role of Law Enforcement Agencies while working on Cases of Human Trafficking
Primary Role of Law Enforcement Response
Work With State/Local Law Enforcement 84 (90.3%)
Work With National Law Enforcement 19 (20.4%)
Task Force Participation 69 (74.2%)
Surveillance 75 (80.6%)
Crime Pattern Analysis 23 (24.7%)
Review Paper Trail (Bank Receipts, Tax Records) 22 (23.7%)
Look For Suspicious Activities in The Community 48 (51.6%)
Look For Evidence of Exploitation 37 (39.8%)
Look For Evidence of Criminal Enterprises 28 (30.1%)
Interview Victims 76 (81.7%)
Follow Up on The Leads 69 (74.2%)
Covert/Overt Operations/ Raids 70 (75.3%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that 3-6 months is the average time spending in
investigation of a human trafficking case. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand followed
by Delhi, West Bengal and Uttar Pradesh. However, most of the respondents in Maharashtra and
half of the respondents in Tamil Nadu admitted that average time spend in investigation of such
cases is less than 3 months (Table 6.18).
 182

Table 6.18
Average Time Spend in Investigating a Human Trafficking Case
Less Than 3
State 3 To 6 Months 6 To 12 Months Unsure Total
Months
West Bengal 2 (9.5%) 17 (81.0%) 1 (4.8%) 1 (4.8%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 12 (80.0%) 1 (6.7%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (13.3%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 1 (33.3%) 2 (66.7%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 1 (16.7%) 4 (66.7%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (16.7%) 6 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 2 (20.0%) 8 (80.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%)
Delhi 1 (3.4%) 28 (96.6%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 20 (21.5%) 67 (72.0%) 1 (1.1%) 5 (5.4%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
On the issue of non-filing of final report and charge sheet within 60 days by police, Law
Enforcement Agencies during FGDs Reported that investigation is a factor of availability of
evidence, witnesses to adequately substantiate the case theory to file a prosecution charge which
varies from case-to-case. The NGO Jagori informed the Research Team that in terrible crimes
against women, the focus should be on the certainty of conviction rather than the death penalty.
It’s also critical for law enforcement authorities (LEAs) to treat every single report of sexual
harassment seriously, because failing to do so empowers the perpetrators, allowing them to
perpetrate even more horrific crimes. According to the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2018, law
enforcement agencies have been given an analytical tool called “Online Investigation Tracking
System for Sexual Offenses (ITSSO)” to monitor and track police investigations in sexual offences
within two months. The data is updated on a regular basis by the police and is not made public.
In addition, the Supreme Court of India has ruled that victims’ identities should not be revealed
and that victims and their families should be protected.
About 61 per cent respondents reported that human trafficking cases outcomes results
occasionally of investigation, arrest and prosecution. However, about 45 per cent respondents
reported that human trafficking cases occasionally results in investigation, arrest, leading to
prosecution where defendant is acquitted (Table 6.19).
Table 6.19
How Often Do Human Trafficking Cases Result in Following Outcomes
Outcome Frequently Occasionally Seldom Never Unsure Total
2 13 50 24 4 93
Case is Investigated, but does not lead to an Arrest(s)
2.2% 14.0% 53.8% 25.8% 4.3% 100%
Case is investigated, any arrests are made, but does 3 13 44 28 5 93
not lead to a Prosecution 3.2% 14.0% 47.3% 30.1% 5.4% 100%
Case is investigated, any arrests are made, and leads 9 42 30 6 6 93
to prosecution where defendant is Acquitted 9.7% 45.2% 32.3% 6.5% 6.5% 100%
Case is investigated, any arrests are made and leads 15 57 9 2 10 93
to Prosecution where defendant is Convicted 16.1% 61.3% 9.7% 2.2% 10.8% 100%

Source: Field Survey

The major challenges being faced by agency in encountering with investigation of cases
frequently reported of lack of victim cooperation/victim distressed, community ignorance and
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 183

lack of identity as Victims do not identify themselves as a Victim. However, other important
challenges were reported to be language /cultural barriers, lack of adequate resources, victims
do not identify themselves as victims, lack of support with victim support providers, lack of
adequate training and knowledge as well as lack of procedures and clear jurisdiction. However,
such challenges are occasionally reported (Table 6.20).
Table 6.20
Frequency of Agency Encounter with Challenges While Investigating Cases of Trafficking
Level of Frequency
Challenges and Barriers in Investigations
Frequently Occasionally Seldom Never Unsure Total
61 23 4 5 0 93
Lack of Victim Cooperation/Victims Distrust
65.6% 24.7% 4.3% 5.4% 0.0% 100%
50 32 7 4 0 93
Victims do not identify themselves as a Victim
53.8% 34.4% 7.5% 4.3% 0.0% 100%

Language/Cultural Barriers/ Lack of or Inadequate 25 44 21 3 0 93

translator/ interpreters Services 26.9% 47.3% 22.6% 3.2% 0.0% 100%
7 15 12 56 3 93
Lack of Social Services for Human Trafficking Victims
7.5% 16.1% 12.9% 60.2% 3.2% 100%
14 3 13 56 7 93
Lack of Adequate Shelter Homes
15.1% 3.2% 14.0% 60.2% 7.5% 100%

Lack of coordination with State, National & International 5 3 10 72 3 93

Agencies 5.4% 3.2% 10.8% 77.4% 3.2% 100%

Lack of Support with Victim Service Providers (VSPs) / 5 10 22 49 7 93

Community Based Organizations 5.4% 10.8% 23.7% 52.7% 7.5% 100%

Resistance From National Law Enforcement to Pursue 1 4 5 79 4 93

or Assist in Case Investigations 1.1% 4.3% 5.4% 84.9% 4.3% 100%
17 33 20 23 0 93
Lack of Adequate Resources (e.g. Time, Money, Staff)
18.3% 35.5% 21.5% 24.7% 0.0% 100%

Lack of Adequate Training/ Lack of Adequate 5 30 33 25 0 93

Knowledge 5.4% 32.3% 35.5% 26.9% 0.0% 100%

Lack of Procedures /Protocols to Identify and Respond 3 13 31 46 0 93

to Human Trafficking Cases and Victims of Trafficking 3.2% 14.0% 33.3% 49.5% 0.0% 100%
3 3 23 62 2 93
Lack of Clear Jurisdictions
3.2% 3.2% 24.7% 66.7% 2.2% 100%
60 12 13 6 2 93
Community Ignorance
64.5% 12.9% 14.0% 6.5% 2.2% 100%
6 2 1 4 80 93
Other
6.5% 2.2% 1.1% 4.3% 86% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents admitted that human trafficking is associated with other crimes.
Prostitution, drug trafficking, pornography, false identification, organ trafficking, cybercrimes
and organized crimes are associated with human trafficking (Table 6.21).
 184

Table 6.21
Type of Crimes Associated with Human Trafficking
Types of Crime Total

Drug Trafficking 68 (78.2%)

Tax Evasion 2 (2.3%)
Arms Dealing 7 (8.0%)
False Identification 50 (57.5%)
Organ Trafficking 41 (47.1%)
Computer- Assisted Crimes 37 (42.5%)
Organized Crime 34 (39.1%)
Prostitution 80 (92.0%)
Terrorism 7 (8.0%)
Pornography 64 (73.6%)
Conspiracy 4 (4.6%)
Gangs 7 (8.0%)
Corruption And Bribery 2 (2.3%)
Money Laundering 26 (29.9%)
Other 2 92.3%)
Source: Field Survey
In order to build, human trafficking cases in community, surveillance, undercover operation
and raids are frequently reported while undercover operations, raids or other overt operations,
surveillance, collaboration with other law enforcement agencies were occasionally reported as
investigative response (Table 6.22).
Table 6.22
Frequency of Investigative Responses to Build Human Trafficking Cases in Community
Level of Frequency
Potential Investigative Responses
Frequently Occasionally Seldom Never Unsure Total

50 26 15 1 1 93
Surveillance
53.8% 28.0% 16.1% 1.1% 1.1% 100%
22 46 22 2 1 93
Undercover Operations
23.7% 49.5% 23.7% 2.2% 1.1% 100%
24 37 30 1 1 93
Raids or Other Overt Operations
25.8% 39.8% 32.3% 1.1% 1.1% 100%
Collaboration with other Law 14 25 52 1 1 93
Enforcement Agencies 15.1% 26.9% 55.9% 1.1% 1.1% 100%
Collaboration with Code Enforcement 10 10 37 33 3 93
& Inspectional Agencies 10.8% 10.8% 39.8% 35.5% 3.2% 100%
Pursuing Paper Trails (Bank Receipts, 10 10 36 33 4 93
Tax Records) 10.8% 10.8% 38.7% 35.5% 4.3% 100%
Wire Tapping/ Communication 7 11 54 19 2 93
Monitoring 7.5% 11.8% 58.1% 20.4% 2.2% 100%
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 185

Investigate Linkages to Other Criminal 8 10 43 32 0 93

Enterprises 8.6% 10.8% 46.2% 34.4% 0.0% 100%
14 6 18 49 6 93
Providing Victim Support Services
15.1% 6.5% 19.4% 52.7% 6.5% 100%
3 0 40 3 47 93
Other
3.2% 0.0% 43.0% 3.2% 50.5% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that massage parlors, brothels and private homes /
apartments are most likely locations in which police might encounter sex trafficking activities
(Table 6.23).
Table 6.23
Most Likely Locations in Which Police Might Encounter Sex Trafficking Activities
Locations Responses
Massage Parlors 83 (89.2%)
Brothels 77 (82.8%)
Hotels 27 (29.0%)
Street Corners 9 (9.7%)
Drug Busts 3 (3.2%)
Escort Services 28 (30.1%)
Private Homes/Apartments 65 (69.9%)
Others 2 (2.2%)
Source: Field Survey
Material evidence, medical examination of victims, suspects and documents and witness
evidence are some of the major techniques being used in investigation of crimes related to
trafficking. However, techniques of investigation of crimes vary across the states (Table 6.24).
Table 6.24
Techniques Being Used in Investigating Crimes Related to Trafficking
Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Pradesh
Assam

Delhi
Uttar

State Total

19 13 2 6 5 6 2 29 82
Material Evidence
90.5% 86.7% 66.7% 85.7% 83.3% 60.0% 100% 100% 88.2%
12 12 2 6 5 8 1 13 59
Witness Evidence
57.1% 80.0% 66.7% 85.7% 83.3% 80.0% 50.0% 44.8% 63.4%
Medical 19 14 0 6 5 9 2 28 83
Examination of
Victim 90.5% 93.3% 0.0% 85.7% 83.3% 90.0% 100% 96.6% 89.2%

Forensic 2 9 0 0 5 4 1 6 27
Examination of
Victims 9.5% 60.0% 0.0% 0.0% 83.3% 40.0% 50.0% 20.7% 29.0%

Suspects & 18 7 3 3 3 5 1 29 69
Documents 85.7% 46.7% 100% 42.9% 50.0% 50.0% 50.0% 100% 74.2%
Electronic 2 6 3 3 5 3 2 5 29
Surveillance 9.5% 40.0% 100% 42.9% 83.3% 30.0% 100% 17.2% 31.2%
 186

1 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 4
Others
4.8% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 16.7% 0.0% 50.0% 3.4% 4.3%

Source: Field Survey

According to state law enforcement agencies, forensics is crucial to a successful investigation,
prosecution, and conviction. Since December 23, 2019, the Central Forensic Science Laboratory
(CFSL) in Chandigarh has had a state-of-the-art DNA laboratory. It is projected to be a leading
research and development center in this field, with a capacity of 2000 cases. Similarly, 20 States/
UTs have approved projects to strengthen state-level forensic sciences laboratories based on
demand-gap analysis and requisition by States/UTs. Several states have begun operations after
procuring the requisite equipment and staff for DNA and Cyber Forensics. Himachal Pradesh,
Madhya Pradesh, Mizoram, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, and West Bengal are among these
states. Others are in the process of acquiring the requisite equipment at various levels. MHA
has approved projects at 16 State Forensic Science Laboratories (FSLs) at a total cost of Rs.157.98
crore, taking into account demand and gap analysis, as part of an initiative to strengthen DNA
analysis, based on requests from States/UTs, Cyber-forensics and related facilities in the States.
Guidelines for the collecting, management, and transportation of forensic evidence have been
developed to improve capabilities and strengthen skill sets of Investigation Officers, Prosecution
Officers, and Medical Officers in State/UTs who are handling forensic evidence in sexual assault
cases. BPR&D and the Lok Nayak Jayaprakash Narayan National Institute of Criminology and
Forensic Science (LNJP NIC&FS) in New Delhi have begun training programmes. A total of 9397
officers, including investigators, prosecutors, and medical officers, have been trained. States/
UTs have received 14,950 Sexual Assault Evidence Collection Kits from BPR&D.
Special police officer, nodal officer and working partnership between LEAs and service
providers were found available under Anti human trafficking unit. However, a significant
proportion of respondents were either not aware or denied the availability of such officials (Table
6.25).
Table 6.25
Availability of Law Enforcement Officials as Designated Under AHTU

Type of Officials/ Partnership Yes No Don’t Know Total

Special Police Officer 86 (92.5%) 3 (3.2%) 4 (4.3%) 93 (100%)

Nodal Officer 84 (90.3%) 1 (1.1%) 8 (8.6%) 93 (100%)
Working Partnership between LEAs and Service
81 (87.1%) 6 (6.5%) 6 (6.5%) 93 (100%)
Providers
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents reported very good and good relationship of AHTUs /District Law
Enforcement Agencies with other stakeholders. However, all the respondents admitted that
relationship with APOs/public prosecutors is not very good (Table 6.26).
Table 6.26
Level of Relationship of AHTU/District Law Enforcement Agencies with Other Stakeholders
Name of Stakeholder/Services Very Good Good Not Very Good Total
Service Providers 37 (45.7%) 41 (50.6%) 3 (3.7%) 81 (100%)
Other Law Enforcement Agencies 45 (48.4%) 45 (48.4%) 1 (1.1%) 2 (2.2%)
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 187

APOs/Public Prosecutors 41 (44.1%) 52 (55.9%) 93 (100%) 41 (44.1%)

Whether Patrol Officers, Investigators
& Prosecutors are Trained on New 15 (16.1%) 55 (59.1%) 23 (24.7%) 93 (100%)
Trafficking Trends and Legislations
Source: Field Survey
The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) routinely engages with States and UTs through various
advisories and meetings to promote inter-State coordination and advises them on how to achieve
greater inter-State cooperation mechanisms to combat human trafficking. In addition, on March
12, 2020, MHA inaugurated a national-level communication network, the Crime Multi-Agency
Centre (Cri-MAC), to meet the goal of inter-State coordination in discovering and identifying
trafficked victims, as well as in crime prevention, detection, and investigation. The Cri-MAC
provides inter-State coordination by facilitating real-time broadcast of information regarding
major crimes, such as human trafficking instances, across the country.
Witness turning hostile, protection of victims and witness, court adjournment and victims
pleading guilty were some of the major difficulties being faced in working with cases of human
trafficking (Table 6.27).
Table 6.27
Difficulties of Department in Working with Cases of Trafficking
Victim Pleading Protection of Witness Turning
State Court Adjournments Others
Guilty Victim and Witness Hostile
West Bengal 5 (23.8%) 20 (95.2%) 2 (9.5%) 17 (81.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Maharashtra 4 (26.7%) 3 (20.0%) 4 (26.7%) 13 (86.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 9100%) 0 (0.0%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 6 (85.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Assam 1 (16.7%) 4 (66.7%) 4 (66.7%) 3 (50.0%) 2 (33.3%)
Uttar Pradesh 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%) 8 (80.0%) 10 (100%) 0 (0.0%)
Tamil Nadu 0 (0.0%) 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%)
Delhi 9 (31.0%) 28 (96.6%) 27 (93.1%) 27 (93.1%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 19 (20.4%) 73 (78.5%) 46 (49.5%) 80 (86.0%) 3 (3.2%)
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents admitted that the officials of their units/department have received
training on the issues of human trafficking. However, a large proportion of respondents in
Karnataka, Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu revealed that officers have not received such training
(Table 6.28A).
Table 6.28A
Have Officers in Your Unit/Department Has Received Training on the Issues of Trafficking
State Yes No Don’t Know Total
West Bengal 19 (90.5%) 2 (9.5%) 0 (0.0%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 11 (73.3%) 3 (20.0%) 1 (6.7%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 1 (33.3%) 2 (66.7%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 5 (83.3%) 1 (16.7%) 0 (0.0%) 6 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 4 (40.0%) 6 (60.0%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%)
 188

Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (100%)

Delhi 29 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 77 (82.8%) 15 (16.1%) 1 (1.1%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
In collaboration with BPR&D, the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), the
Border Security Force (BSF), and others, State Police personnel are trained in the prevention and
detection of human trafficking. This attempts to improve law enforcement agencies’ capacity
and raise awareness among them. States have also been recommended to train police officers
stationed at bus stations, state borders, and inter-state checkpoints, among other locations, to
keep an eye out for suspicious actions involving the transportation of human trafficking victims,
particularly youngsters.
Proportion of Officers in respective unit that has received Training on the issues of Trafficking
is shown in Table: 6.28B Most of the respondents reported that less than half of the officers in their
departments have received training on the issues of human trafficking. In-service, induction,
orientation and refresher training were organized on the issues of human trafficking.
Table 6.28B
Proportion of Officers in your unit received Training on the issues of Trafficking
State > 25 % 25-50 % 50-75 % 75-100 % Total
West Bengal 13 (68.4%) 5 (26.3%) 1 (5.3%) 0 (0.0%) 19 (100%)
Maharashtra 1 (9.1%) 5 (45.5%) 3 (27.3%) 2 (18.2%) 11 (100%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 4 (57.1%) 3 (42.9%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 5 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 5 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 4 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%)
Delhi 16 (55.2%) 11 (37.9%) 2 (6.9%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 39 (50.6%) 26 (33.8%) 10 (13.0%) 2 (2.6%) 77 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The majority of those who responded said that such trainings were organized by police
training institutes. Identifying victims, victim rights, victim support, and assonance, legal
provisions of human trafficking, legal and administrative provisions for inter-state and trans-
border investigations, and distinguishing trafficking from prostitution, as well as trafficking’s
modus operandi, were among the topics covered during the training. The majority of responders
only rated the efficiency of such training on human trafficking investigation to some level. The
majority of respondents said they learn about human trafficking as part of their routine law
enforcement efforts, while about half said they learn about it from training, conferences, and
workshops. As a result, around two-thirds of respondents stated that their knowledge of human
trafficking regulations is average.
The main reasons for non-stoppable trafficking as per use of law enforcement agencies
were recorded mainly poor economic conditions, social customs, gender inequality, negligible
penalties, domestic violence and poor law enforcement. However, prosecuting officers reported
that poor economic conditions, poor law enforcement, negligible penalties, corruption, social
customs, gender inequalities and inadequate laws are important reasons responsible for human
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 189

trafficking (Table 6.29).

Table 6.29
Reasons for Non-Stoppable Trafficking
State Law Enforcement Agencies Prosecuting Agencies
Inadequate Laws 16 (17.2%) 13 (44.82%)
Poor Law Enforcement 24 (25.8%) 23 (79.31%)
Negligible Penalties 32 (34.4%) 19 (65.52%)
Corruption 13 (14.0%) 17 (58.62%)
Poor Economic Conditions 86 (92.5%) 25 (86.21%)
Gender Inequality 39 (41.9%) 13 (44.83%)
Domestic Violence 30 (32.3%) 9 (31.03%)
Social Customs/Evils 54 (58.1%) 13 (44.83%)
Other 0 (0.0%) 3 (10.35%)
Source: Field Survey
Law enforcement agencies suggested the measures such as effective patrolling and vigil
at traffic prone locations, inter-departmental cooperation, public awareness, support to
vulnerable women and sensitization programme for stakeholders for prevention of human
trafficking. However, prosecuting agencies suggested measures like sensitization programme
for stakeholders, support to vulnerable women, inter-state collaboration and inter-departmental
cooperation for prevention of human trafficking (Table 6.30).
Table 6.30
Measures to Prevent Trafficking

Prosecuting
Measures for Prevention of Human Trafficking Law EAs
Agencies
Effective Patrolling and Vigil at locations prone to trafficking 87 (93.5%) 13 (44.83%)
Inter Departmental Cooperation for spotting and Rescuing Victims 77 (82.8%) 12 (41.37%)
Periodical Checks on Transporters 70 (75.3%) 9 (31.03%)
Addressing New forms of Demand 33 (35.5%) 9 (31.03%)
Inter State Collaboration 39 (41.9%) 20 (86.96%)
Sensitization Programs for Police Officers, Railway Police Force, Prosecutors and Judges on
54 (58.1%) 29 (100%)
various legislation
Prosecution of Perpetrators 45 (48.4%) 9 (31.03%)
Public Awareness 73 (78.5%) 16 (55.17%)
Support to Women Vulnerable to trafficking 58 (62.4%) 29 (100%)
Others 2 (2.2%) 7 (24.14%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that section-7 and 8 are most commonly used sections of
ITPA. However, about 58 per cent respondents revealed that section-3 and 4 are most commonly
used sections of ITPA (Table 6.31).
 190

Table 6.31
Most Commonly Used Sections of ITPA
State Section - 7 & 8 Section - 3 & 4 Section - 5 & 6 Section- 20
West Bengal 11 (52.4%) 9 (42.9%) 3 (14.3%) 0 (0.0%)
Maharashtra 10 (66.7%) 12 (80.0%) 4 (26.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Karnataka 2 (66.7%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Jharkhand 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Assam 4 (66.7%) 3 (50.0%) 2 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%)
Uttar Pradesh 3 (30.0%) 7 (70.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%) 2 (100%) 0 (0.0%)
Delhi 22 (75.9%) 20 (69.0%) 2 (6.9%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 60 (64.5%) 54 (58.1%) 13 (14.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Source: Field Survey
Slightly less than 3/4th respondents admitted that there are low chances of conviction in
ITPA case. It was found more pronouncing in Karnataka followed by Jharkhand, Delhi and Uttar
Pradesh. Thus, hardly 8 per cent respondents reported that chances of conviction in ITPA cases
are higher (Table 6.32).
Table 6.32
Chances of Conviction in an ITPA Case
State Very Low Low High Very High Total
West Bengal 8 (38.1%) 11 (52.4%) 2 (9.5%) 0 (0.0%) 21 (100%)
Maharashtra 0 (0.0%) 10 (66.7%) 4 (26.7%) 1 (6.7%) 15 (100%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Assam 3 (50.0%) 2 (33.3%) 1 (16.7%) 0 (0.0%) 6 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 2 (20.0%) 8 (80.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (100%)
Delhi 3 (10.3%) 26 (89.7%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Total 17 (18.3%) 68 (73.1%) 7 (7.5%) 1 (1.1%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Easy bail for traffickers, harassment and humiliation of victims and adjournment in court
are main loop holes in enforcement mechanism to tackle human trafficking. Thus, reforms in
procedures, clarity of objectives of rescue and rehabilitation, introduction of new legislation
and reforms in existing laws were suggested by the respondents. In order to address effectively
human trafficking, adequate staff, infrastructure and funds are required as per use of officials
(Table 6.33).
Table 6.33
Additional Resources You Need to Better Address Trafficking
State Adequate Staff Adequate Infrastructure Adequate Funds Others
West Bengal 21 (100%) 15 (71.4%) 4 (19.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Maharashtra 12 (80.0%) 7 (46.7%) 7 (46.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Karnataka 3 (100%) 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Jharkhand 7 (100%) 7 (100%) 5 (71.4%) 0 (0.0%)
Assam 5 (83.3%) 5 (83.3%) 5 (83.3%) 1 (16.7%)
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 191

Uttar Pradesh 10 (100%) 10 (100%) 10 (100%) 0 (0.0%)

Tamil Nadu 2 (100%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Delhi 29 (100%) 24 (82.8%) 6 (20.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 89 (95.7%) 72 (77.4%) 37 (39.8%) 1 (1.1%)
Source: Field Survey
The Ministry of Home Affairs is currently implementing projects under the Nirbhaya
Fund, and has approved the release of Rs.100 crore from the fund to all States and UTs for
the establishment/strengthening of Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) with office
infrastructure, as well as the purchase of computers, mobile phone instruments, digital cameras,
four-wheelers, motorcycles, and landline phones with broadband, among other things. The
AHTUs will be staffed by State Police officers who will be aided by officers from other relevant
state departments. Because many traffickers use railways as a significant route of conveyance for
trafficking victims to other states and border areas, the MHA has also worked with the Ministry
of Railways. The Railway Board has been requested to enlist the help of the Railway Protection
Force (RPF) and the Government Railway Police (GRP) to combat human trafficking at railway
stations. They’ve been told to tell GRP and RPF officials to stay attentive and watchful in the
face of such instances. The MHA has also spoken with the Ministry of Labour and Employment,
advising them to train personnel from the Labor Department in all States and UTs to keep an eye
on unlawful placement companies that abuse youngsters under the guise of a work. The MHA
has sent a comprehensive scheme to all States and UTs to address the issue of human trafficking,
advising them to establish an Anti-Human Trafficking Bureau at the State capital level, Anti-
Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) at every District level, and Women Help Desks to monitor
investigations at each Police Station level.
The Ministry of Home Affairs is implementing Nirbhaya Fund projects such as the Emergency
Response Support System (ERSS), the Central Victim Compensation Fund (CVCF), the Cyber
Crime Prevention against Women and Children (CCPWC), Delhi Police projects on women’s
safety, Safe City projects in selected eight cities, the establishment of a state-of-the-art DNA
Lab at the Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) in Chandigarh, and the strengthening
of State/UT forensic science laboratories. These projects include capacity building through the
infusion of appropriate equipment and technology to improve women’s safety, such as better
surveillance using drones, CCTV cameras, automatic number plate recognition to track and alert
Police in crime hotspots throughout the city, and technology-enabled infrastructure such as smart
lighting systems to eliminate dark alleys, women’s toilets that can be located on maps, and so on.
These include continuing and continual tender-based procurement, therefore the money granted
to States/UTs constitute substantially committed expenditure for the project. The projects are
reviewed on a regular basis by the states/UTs and the Ministry of Home Affairs.

PROSECUTING AGENCIES:
Most of the respondents were from district prosecuting agency. However, a significant
proportion of respondents in Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra were from state
prosecuting agencies (Table 6.34).
 192

Table 6.34
Type of Prosecuting Agency Interviewed
State State Prosecuting Agency District Prosecuting Agency Total
West Bengal 0 (0.0%) 4 (100%) 4 (100%)
Maharashtra 1 (16.7%) 5 (83.3%) 6 (100%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 5 (100%) 5 (100%)
Assam 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 3 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 1 (16.7%) 5 (83.3%) 6 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%)
Total 3 (10.3%) 26 (89.7%) 29 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Providing compensation to rescued victims, coordination with police for conviction of
perpetrators, ensuring victim witness protection and legal counseling to rescued victims are the
main responsibility as per views of law enforcement agencies and public prosecuting agencies
(Table 6.35).
Table 6.35
Role and Responsibility of Prosecuting Agency
Role and Responsibility Response
Assisting Investigation Officer (I.O.) In Drafting FIR 6 (20.69%)
Legal Counseling to Rescued Victims 10 (34.48%)
Assisting IO During Investigation 3 (10.35%)
Assisting I.O To Draft Charge Sheet 3 (10.35%)
Ensure Victim-Witness Protection 19 (65.52%)
Co-Coordinate with Police for Conviction of Perpetrators 22 (75.86%)
Providing Compensation to Rescued Victims 29 (100%)
Other 48.28 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
All the respondents reported that they have protocols / guidelines for prosecuting of
trafficking cases. Witness statements, recording of victim’s statement before magistrate, medical,
forensic, material and documentary evidences are some of the things being covered in the
protocol (Table 6.36).
Table 6.36
Kinds of Things Are Covered in the Protocol/Guidelines
Things are covered in the Protocol/Guidelines Total Response
Victim’s Statement Recorded Before Magistrate 26 (89.66%)
Medical, Forensic, Material, Documentary Evidences 22 (75.86%)
Witness Statements 26 (89.66%)
Other 10 (34.48%)
Source: Field Survey
About 1/4th respondents reported that present laws are able to address the issues of human
trafficking adequately. Protection of victims and wetness, adequate rehabilitation facilities for
victim, victim’s access to legal aid, long term crime control policy and victim’s rights are some of
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 193

the ignored areas in existing laws (Table 6.37). Reforms in existing laws, reforms in procedures,
introduction of new legislation and reforms in court practices were suggested by the respondents.
Table 6.37
Ignored Areas in Laws

Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Pradesh
Assam

Uttar

Total
Ignored Areas

0 4 1 0 1 2 1 9
Victim’s Rights
0.0% 44.4% 11.1% 0.0% 11.1% 22.2% 11.1% 100%
Adequate rehabilitation Facilities for 0 3 3 3 2 4 2 17
Victim 0.0% 17.6% 17.6% 17.6% 11.8% 23.5% 11.8% 100%
2 3 1 0 1 2 0 9
Long Term Crime Control Policy
22.2% 33.3% 11.1% 0.0% 11.1% 22.2% 0.0% 100%
2 5 3 3 2 5 2 22
Protection of Victim and Witness
9.1% 22.7% 13.6% 13.6% 9.1% 22.7% 9.1% 100%
0 4 1 0 1 2 1 9
Victim’s Access To Legal Aids
0.0% 44.4% 11.1% 0.0% 11.1% 22.2% 11.1% 100%
0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1
Others
0.0% 100% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Material evidence, medical report, witness, forensic examination report, electronic surveillance
was some of the critical evidences leading to conviction of a case (Table 6.38).
Table 6.38
Critical Evidence Leading to Conviction/Acquittal of a Case Uttar Pradesh
Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Assam

Total
Critical Evidences

4 6 1 2 2 4 1 20
Material Evidence
20.0% 30.0% 5.0% 10.0% 10.0% 20.0% 5.0% 100%
2 5 1 2 2 3 1 16
Witness
12.5% 31.3% 6.3% 12.5% 12.5% 18.8% 6.3% 100%
4 4 1 2 2 3 1 17
Medical Report
23.5% 23.5% 5.9% 11.8% 11.8% 17.6% 5.9% 100%
0 1 2 3 2 3 1 12
Forensic Examination Report
0.0% 8.3% 16.7% 25.0% 16.7% 25.0% 8.3% 100%

0 1 2 3 2 3 1 12
Electronic Surveillance
0.0% 8.3% 16.7% 25.0% 16.7% 25.0% 8.3% 100%
2 1 0 2 1 1 0 7
Other
28.6% 14.3% 0.0% 28.6% 14.3% 14.3% 0.0% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Most of the respondents admitted that existing laws permit them to use of specialized evidence
 194

– gathering techniques in course. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand, Karnataka, West
Bengal, Maharashtra, Assam and Uttar Pradesh.
Witness turning hostile, protection of victim and witness and victim pleading guilty are some
of the major difficulties being faced in working with cases of human trafficking (Table 6.39).
Table 6.39
Difficulties Being Faced in Working with Cases of Trafficking

Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Pradesh
Assam

Uttar

Total
State

2 4 2 3 2 3 0 16
Victim Pleading Guilty
12.5% 25.0% 12.5% 18.8% 12.5% 18.8% 0.0% 100%
2 5 3 5 3 5 2 25
Protection Of Victim and Witness
8.0% 20.0% 12.0% 20.0% 12.0% 20.0% 8.0% 100%
0 1 0 0 1 1 0 3
Court Adjournments
0.0% 33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 33.3% 33.3% 0.0% 100%
4 5 3 5 3 5 1 26
Witness Turning Hostile
15.4% 19.2% 11.5% 19.2% 11.5% 19.2% 3.8% 100%
2 2 0 2 1 2 1 10
Other
20.0% 20.0% 0.0% 20.0% 10.0% 20.0% 10% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that less than 25 per cent officers have received
training on the issues of human trafficking. Trainings were mainly organized by department
of justice, service providers and independent trainers. About 79 per cent respondents
reported that officers have received training on the issues of human trafficking. It was
found more pronouncing in Karnataka followed by West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh and
Jharkhand. However, about half of the respondents in Tamil Nadu and 1/3rd respondents
in Assam ad Maharashtra revealed that officers have not received such training
(Table 6.40A).
Table 6.40A
Whether Prosecuting Officers Received Training on Issues of Trafficking
State Yes No Total
West Bengal 4 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (100%)
Maharashtra 4 (66.7%) 2 (33.3%) 6 (100%)
Karnataka 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 4 (80.0%) 1 (20.0%) 5 (100%)
Assam 2 (66.7%) 1 (33.3%) 3 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 5 (83.3%) 1 (16.7%) 6 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%)
Total 23 (79.3%) 6 (20.7%) 29 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Approximate Percentage of Officers who has received Training on the Issues of Trafficking is
shown in Table: 6.40B. Table: 6.40B depicts that only half of respondents have received training
Status of Law Enforcement in Combating Human Trafficking 195

on subject matter of human trafficking and prosecution of offenders.

Table 6.40B
Approximate Percentage of Prosecting Officers who have received Training on the Issues of Trafficking
State Less Than 25% 25-50 % Total
West Bengal 2 (50.0%) 2 (50.0%) 4 (100%)
Maharashtra 2 (50.0%) 2 (50.0%) 4 (100%)
Karnataka 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 4 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (100%)
Assam 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 2 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 3 (60.0%) 2 (40.0%) 5 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 1 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%)
Total 16 (69.6%) 7 (30.4%) 23 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents revealed that training on the issues of human trafficking has
not been effective on Prosecution of trafficking cases as 17 per cent respondents reported that
training has been very effective on Prosecution of trafficking cases (Table 6.41).
Table 6.41
Effectiveness of Training on Prosecution of Trafficking Cases
State Very Little Effect Some Effect Very Big Effect Total
West Bengal 2 (50.0%) 0 (0.0%) 2 (50.0%) 4 (100%)
Maharashtra 1 (25.0%) 2 (50.0%) 1 (25.0%) 4 (100%)
Karnataka 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Jharkhand 1 (25.0%) 3 (75.0%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (100%)
Assam 1 (50.0%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (100%) 2 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 2 (40.0%) 2 (40.0%) 1 (20.0%) 5 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (100%)
Total 7 (30.4%) 12 (52.2%) 4 (17.4%) 23 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The existing human trafficking laws in India has numerous flaws. There has been a lack
of conceptual clarity among law enforcement officers on the topic of human trafficking. The
vulnerabilities of human trafficking are not given the attention they deserve, and they are not
successfully addressed. Many officials in charge of enforcing anti-human-trafficking laws and
regulations have not received training. Due to a lack of knowledge and information, even those
officials who have undergone training are unable to effectively deal with the complex concerns
of human trafficking. Between law enforcement authorities and service providers, there is a lack
of collaboration. Many local police departments lack established standards for dealing with
human trafficking situations. The image of the police worked as a deterrent, and many victims
and communities believe that the police are also complicit in human trafficking, preventing law
enforcement from having a whole picture. There are many laws and legal requirements that are
complicated, and law enforcement agencies and public prosecutors frequently need to consult
with legal professionals when dealing with cases. As a result, law enforcement authorities’
capacity to deal effectively with tracking cases must be strengthened. The public perception of
cops needs to improve.
 Chapter 7
REHABILITATION AND RE-INTEGRATION
OF RECUED VICTIMS

S ince the rehabilitation, reintegration, and repatriation of victims of human trafficking is a long
process, it must be planned in advance, taking into account the individual victims’ distinct
short and long-term needs. Efforts must be non-punitive and geared at ensuring the victims’
rights are protected. Regardless of where they are trafficked from or to, rescued persons/victims
of trafficking are ‘victims of crime,’ and all efforts should be made to ensure that: (1) Jurisdictional
limitations, of any sort, do not impede rescue and post rescue activities in any way; (2) there is
no delay in rescue and post rescue activities; (3) the rescued person’s human rights are protected
and are not further violated; (4) adequate care and attention is extended to rescued persons
during and post rescue and; (5) all actions and decisions that are initiated are based on the
principle of ‘the best interest of the victim/ rescued person’.
Human trafficking can be effectively prevented and combated by integrating all stakeholders
and responders in a comprehensive and holistic approach. The police should form successful
cooperation with non-governmental organizations (NGOs) working in this field. The Police
Nodal Officer (PNO) should take steps to ensure that government notifications are made for the
purpose of forming the “advisory committee” described in Section 13(3)(b) of the ITPA. However,
until such notification is received, the police may collaborate with any non-governmental
organization (NGO) of their choice.

Post Rescue Operations:

A thorough interview with the rescued individuals is required to obtain information on their
personal characteristics such as age, place of origin, health status, family history, and so on.
Such information will be useful in determining the victim’s ‘best interests’ so that post-rescue
procedures can be tailored to their needs, as well as in comprehending the full scope of the crime.
As required by section 15 (6A) ITPA, the interview must be performed by a female police officer
or in the presence of a female representative of an NGO. The interview should be conducted by
a specifically selected team of sensitive officials from both HT and VT. During the rescue from
the ‘scene of the crime,’ the JT has the following options: • Rescued persons may be escorted,
without any public display, to the local PS where they are kept segregated from the offenders.
• If the Magistrate/ CWC is in office and the required documents (such as forwarding report,
injury report, etc.) have been prepared at the place of rescue, the rescued persons may be escorted
to the Magistrate/ CWC (u/s. 15 (5) or 16 (2) or 17 (1) ITPA). The rescued person, irrespective of
the state or country of origin, is a trafficked victim and therefore a ‘victim of crime’. Hence, all
 198

relief/ compensation to which a trafficked victim is entitled should be extended to the rescued
person. The responsibility for this lies with the Government Nodal Officer (GNO)- representing
the Departments of Women and Child/ Welfare/ Labour of the place where the rescue takes
place. The PNO concerned should liaise with the GNO and ensure expeditious action. Identify
persons less than 18 years of age so that they can be sent to the Child Welfare Committee, as they
are ‘children in need of care and protection’ under the JJ Act. The rescued adult persons are to be
sent to the Magistrate u/s. 15 (5) or 16 (2) or 17 (1) ITPA. The leader of the JT in consultation with
the NGO partner and based on the prima facie appearance of the person should take a decision
as to whether the rescued person is less than 18 years of age or an adult. If there is any doubt
regarding the age of the rescued person, it would be appropriate to leave it to the decision of the
CWC.
Children should be sent to “drop-in centers or temporary shelter houses under the auspices
of the Social Welfare Department” after being rescued until more permanent accommodations
can be found. They should be accompanied to the CWC as soon as possible after being rescued
so that they can make a statement about their ordeal. The CWC acts as the “guardian of the
rescued children” who is “empowered to develop the rehabilitation plan.” As a forerunner to
more persistent rehabilitation and reintegration into a rights-respecting childhood, immediate
care and assistance are also crucial. In actuality, while basic food and shelter are usually supplied
right after a rescue, care is frequently inadequate. Several NGO participants stated that rescued
children are occasionally taken to a police station, which is an inappropriate and potentially re-
traumatizing setting. The care of children trafficked from different states is hampered, according
to 123 of 147 Service Providers and NGOs who took part in the survey, by the simple lack of an
interpreter who is fluent in the relevant local languages. This egregious failure has far-reaching
repercussions for service delivery performance and the risk of criminal prosecution. Criminal
proceedings are also intended to be begun as soon as possible after a rescue, which is an essential
step in reducing the need for exploitative child labour. Officials from the Labor Department must
file a First Information Report (FIR) to begin an investigation and possible prosecution of a crime.
Respondents said that FIRs are not always filed in practice, and that there is misunderstanding
and disagreement over who is responsible for filing them. Employers are ‘rarely’ or ‘never’
arrested, according to the agreement, and are unlikely to be convicted. According to official
numbers from 2015, just 55 cases of child trafficking for whatever reason (1.09%) resulted in
convictions out of 5,026 cases under investigation.

Reintegration
The children confront significant hurdles in successfully reintegrating into society after
their rescue. While no common definition exists, ‘reintegration’ is widely understood in the
literature to refer to a long-term, holistic process. Surtees defines it as “a process of recovery and
economic and social inclusion...that includes settling in a stable and safe environment, access to
a reasonable standard of living, mental and physical well-being, and opportunities for personal,
social, and economic development, as well as access to social and emotional support.” In India,
the current reintegration plan prioritizes ‘educational rehabilitation for the child and economic
rehabilitation for the family.’ However, the Harvard FXB study shows that current reintegration
initiatives in Bihar and Rajasthan fail to meet the core needs and rights of trafficked children
and their families, such as protection, appropriate living standards, health care, and education.
Reintegration is viewed as a fixed, short-term procedure by Indian anti-trafficking experts.
Individual children’s cases are closed within four months of rescue, according to 96% of those
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 199

polled, with no following follow-up or monitoring of the implications of return. Reintegration

plans for rescued children and their families, both short- and long-term, are rarely established
or implemented. Instead, current reintegration efforts consist of just identifying and returning
rescued children to their families, leaving them vulnerable to the same structural vulnerabilities
that led to their being trafficked in the first place.
To reduce the danger of a child being re-trafficked for economic reasons, families require
planned and continuous support. Cash transfers, according to the research, are most effective in
reducing child labour when combined with other investments in health, schooling facilities, or
afterschool education as part of a comprehensive, long-term poverty reduction plan. Lump-sum
compensation does little to address the systemic reasons that contribute to families using child
labour as a coping mechanism. Finally, the severe mental and physical health needs of rescued
children are addressed as an afterthought, with no solid policy efforts in place to ensure that
appropriate and long-term care are provided. Although study participants stated that a counsellor
should accompany children immediately after rescue, no other tangible actions addressing the
physical, emotional, and psychological needs of these vulnerable persons or their families were
mentioned.
To address their concerns, it is critical to make systematic and coordinated efforts involving
a variety of services such as police assistance, legal aid, medical assistance, support for their
children, livelihood opportunities, shelter homes, and so on. The need for support services for
women in prostitution is now widely recognized; nonetheless, the availability and quality of
such services varies greatly. There are a variety of emergency services maintained by women’s
organizations and state governments, such as shelter homes and assistance lines, that need to be
strengthened in addition to stronger legislation provisions.
Trafficked children fall into the category of “Children in Need of Care and Protection,” and
the Integrated Child Protection Scheme (ICPS) has unique procedures for preventing trafficking,
rescuing, rehabilitating, and reintegrating victims. Ujjawala is a comprehensive anti-trafficking
scheme. The Scheme was established in 2007 with the goals of preventing women and children
from being trafficked for commercial sexual exploitation, assisting victims in being rescued and
placed in safe custody, providing rehabilitation services by providing basic amenities/needs,
assisting victims in reintegrating into their families and society, and assisting cross-border victims
in being repatriated. The Scheme is mostly executed by Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs)
(NGOs). The Ujjawala scheme’s norms have been updated as of April 1, 2016. The budgetary
provisions have been enhanced under the new regulations, and the plan is being implemented
as a sub-scheme of the Centrally Sponsored Umbrella Scheme “Protection and Empowerment
of Women” by the States/UTs. Except in the North-Eastern States and Himalayan States, where
the cost ratio is 80:10:10, the cost ratio between the Centre, States, and implementation agency is
60:30:10. The ratio between the center and the implementing agency in Union Territories is 90:10.
Prevention, rescue, rehabilitation, reintegration, and repatriation of trafficked victims for
commercial sexual exploitation are the five components of the scheme. The Ujjawala Scheme
assists eligible organizations in carrying out the aforementioned services. The total number of
homes under the Ujjawala Scheme as of today (31.12.2020) is 104. For 2020-21, a budget provision
of Rs. 30.00 crores have been set aside to implement the Ujjawala Scheme. Table 7.1 shows the
budget estimates and expenditures under the Ujjawala Scheme for the last ten years.
 200

Table: 7.1
Budget Estimates and Expenditure on Ujjawala Scheme in India
(Rs. Crore)

Year Budget Estimate (BE) Expenditure

2012-13 5.00 7.32
2013-14 13.00 13.72
2014-15 16.00 7.92
2015-16 20.00 20.67
2016-17 35.00 20.31
2017-18 50.00 24.56
2018-19 50.00 6.43
2019-20 30.00 9.35
2020-21 30.00 1.13
Source: Annual Reports of Ministry of WCD, Govt. of India
As on 31st December, 2020, there were 104 projects with 1732 beneficiaries under Ujjawala
scheme in India. The numbers of Ujjawala homes were recorded high in Assam followed by
Manipur, Karnataka, Odisha and Andhra Pradesh. The number of beneficiaries was recorded
high in Karnataka followed by Odisha, Manipur and Assam (Table 7.2).
Table: 7.2
State/UT-wise Number of Projects and Beneficiaries Covered under Ujjawala Scheme
(As on 31.12.2020)

S. No State Name Homes Beneficiaries

1 Andhra Pradesh 5 102
2 Assam 20 196
3 Chhattisgarh 3 26
4 Karnataka 13 386
5 Kerala 3 50
6 Maharashtra 5 82
7 Manipur 19 225
8 Mizoram 2 22
9 Nagaland 1 14
10 Rajasthan 1 22
11 Orissa 12 309
12 Tamil Nadu 4 120
13 Uttar Pradesh 2 24
14 Uttarakhand 2 10
15 West Bengal 2 51
16 Gujarat 2 16
17 Telangana 5 68
18 Jharkhand 2 0
19 Goa 1 9
Total 104 1732
Source: Annual Reports of Ministry of WCD, Govt. of India
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 201

SWADHAR GREH
The Swadhar Greh initiative aims to provide a supportive institutional framework for women
who have been victims of adversity, allowing them to live with dignity and conviction. The
scheme aims to provide shelter, food, clothes, and health care, as well as economic and social
security, to widows, poor women, and elderly women who are victims of difficult circumstances.
Because the Swadhar Greh Scheme is a sub-scheme of the Centrally Sponsored Umbrella Scheme
“Protection and Empowerment of Women,” funds are disbursed through the States, with a
cost-sharing ratio of 60:40 between the Centre and the States (except in the North Eastern and
Himalayan States, where it will be 90:10, and for UTs, it will be 100% with effect from January 1,
2016). As of December 31, 2020, there are 362 Swadhar Grehs operating throughout the country,
benefiting 7719 women for the 2020-21 fiscal year. Table 7.3 shows the Budget Estimates and
Spending of the Swadhar Greh Scheme for the preceding ten years and for the current year (as
of December 31, 2020).
Table: 7.3
Budget Estimates and Expenditure on Swadhar Greh Scheme in India
(Rs. Crore)

Year Budget Estimate (BE) Expenditure

2011-12 30.00 24.59
2012-13 100.00 52.23
2013-14 75.00 53.74
2014-15 115.00 28.60
2015-16 100.00 48.57
2016-17 100.00 83.78
2017-18 100.00 57.20
2018-19 95.00 24.56
2019-20 50.00 25.48
12.27
2020-21 50.00
(As on 31.12.2020)
Source: Annual Reports of Ministry of WCD, Govt. of India
As on December, 31, 2020, there were 362 Swadhar Greh with 7719 beneficiaries in India. The
number of such homes was recorded high in Odisha followed by Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, West
Bengal, Telangana, Manipur and Andhra Pradesh. The numbers of beneficiaries in these homes
were recorded high in Odisha followed by Karnataka, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana
and Uttar Pradesh (Table 7.4).
Table: 7.4
State- Wise Swadhar Homes and Beneficiaries in India
(As on 31.12.2020)
S. No State Name Homes Beneficiaries
1 Andaman and Nicobar Islands 1 9
2 Andhra Pradesh 22 467
3 Arunachal Pradesh 1 12
4 Assam 16 232
5 Bihar 0 0
 202

6 Chandigarh 1 5
7 Chhattisgarh 3 55
8 Delhi 2 38
9 Gujarat 9 106
10 Himachal Pradesh 1 9
11 Jammu & Kashmir 3 27
12 Jharkhand 5 17
13 Karnataka 52 1378
14 Kerala 7 165
15 Madhya Pradesh 16 230
16 Maharashtra 9 165
17 Manipur 23 335
18 Mizoram 11 129
19 Meghalaya 2 12
20 Nagaland 2 35
21 Odisha 55 1669
22 Punjab 2 34
23 Puducherry 1 10
24 Rajasthan 9 167
25 Sikkim 1 20
26 Tamil Nadu 35 861
27 Telangana 23 389
28 Tripura 3 64
29 Uttar Pradesh 13 295
30 Uttarakhand 1 0
31 West Bengal 33 784
Total 362 7719
Source: Annual Reports of Ministry of WCD, Govt. of India

CHILD PROTECTION SERVICES (ERSTWHILE ICPS)

Ministry of Women and Child Development is implementing a Centrally Sponsored Scheme
i.e., Child Protection Services Scheme (CPS, erstwhile ICPS) since 2009-10, through the State
Government/ UT Administrations on predefined cost sharing financial pattern. It’s part of the
Umbrella Integrated Child Development Scheme, which is funded by the central government.
The Scheme’s goal is to offer children in adverse situations with a safety net of legislation and
service delivery structures. It also aims at reduction of vulnerabilities to situation and actions,
that lead to abuse, neglect, exploitation, abandonment and separation of children from parents by
focusing on (a) improved access to quality child protection services, (b) raised public awareness
about the reality of child rights, situations and physical and social protection in India, (c) clearly
articulated responsibilities and enforced accountability for child protection, (d) established and
functional structure at all levels for delivery of statutory and support services to children in
difficult circumstances and (e) operational evidence based monitoring and evaluation. CPS
provides preventive, statutory care and rehabilitation services to children in need of care and
protection, as well as those who are in legal conflict, as defined by the Juvenile Justice (Care and
Protection of Children) Act, 2015. In the fiscal year 2020-21, the Ministry aided 1565 Homes, 366
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 203

Specialized Adoption Agencies (SAAs), and 247 Open Shelters across the country, benefiting over
75,000 people. Apart from institutional services, the State Governments/UT Administrations
have claimed that the scheme has so far aided 713 Child Welfare Committees and 711 Juvenile
Justice Boards.
The Ministry of Women and Child Development has prepared a draft National Child Protection
Policy in response to the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s direction in the Matter of Sampoorna Behrua
vs. UOI & Ors (M.A. No.-2069/2018 in W.P.(C) No.473/2005 regarding the drafting of a National
Child Protection Policy, which is expected to be finalized soon. As on Feb., 2020, there were 1541
assisted institutional care homes, 259 open shelter homes and 352 specialized adoption agencies
in India. IN these homes about 74000 children were beneficiaries while about 3600 beneficiaries
were reported in specialized adoption agencies (Table 7.5).
Table: 7.5
State/UTs Wise-Child Care Institutions Along with The Children Residing Therein Under Child
Protection Service Scheme
(As on February, 2020)

Institutional Care Homes Open Shelters Specialized Adoption Agencies

State/UTs
No.
No. Assisted Beneficiaries No. Assisted Beneficiaries Beneficiaries
Assisted
Andhra Pradesh 66 2954 9 262 14 140
Arunachal Pradesh 5 185 0 0 1 10
Assam 52 1617 7 104 21 72
Bihar 26 1286 0 0 13 132
Chhattisgarh 65 2042 10 127 12 95
Goa 20 557 2 225 2 16
Gujarat 52 1668 3 60 13 128
Haryana 24 1322 14 425 7 52
Himachal Pradesh 32 1268 4 91 1 15
Jammu and Kashmir 17 823 0 0 2 0
Jharkhand 41 1466 5 125 12 92
Karnataka 79 3124 38 1084 25 319
Kerala 30 721 4 100 11 222
Madhya Pradesh 67 2804 8 348 26 243
Maharashtra 74 2320 2 50 17 170
Manipur 42 1160 14 296 7 55
Meghalaya 44 868 4 150 4 5
Mizoram 45 1178 0 0 7 26
Nagaland 39 609 3 60 4 5
Orissa 93 7112 12 300 25 250
Punjab 19 620 0 0 6 77
Rajasthan 95 4418 20 331 21 211
Sikkim 16 496 4 64 4 20
Tamil Nadu 198 12864 11 275 20 200
Tripura 23 717 2 58 6 49
Uttar Pradesh 74 3703 20 517 25 247
Uttarakhand 20 437 2 50 2 15
 204

West Bengal 70 4156 49 1226 23 326

Telangana 40 1306 0 0 11 320
Andaman & Nicobar 10 401 - 0 2 10
Chandigarh 6 252 0 0 2 17
Dadra and Nagar
0 0 1 25 1 10
Haveli
Daman and Diu 1 25 - 0 - 0
Lakshadweep - 0 - 0 - 0
Delhi 29 1614 9 313 3 59
Puducherry 27 1043 2 42 2 16
Total 1541 67136 259 6708 352 3624

Source: LS.US.Q.NO. 3791 FOR 17.03.2020

RESPONSES OF SERVICE PROVIDERS

BIRD’s research team visited 123 P&R Homes and 24 NGOs combating trafficking of women
and children in the eight states chosen. Ujjawala Centers accounted for about 20% Swadhar
Greh (18%). Short-stay (11%) and children’s homes accounted for about 16%. A large number of
respondents came from other places, such as one-stop centers, CCIs, and NGOs dedicated to the
cause and prevention of human trafficking (Table 7.6).
Table: 7.6
Category of Organizations visited
Short Stay Homes

Children Homes

One Stop Center

Ujjawala Center
- Protective and

NGO Working
for Cause And
Swadhar Greh

CCIs/ICPS/JJ
Rehabilitative
(P&R) Homes

Concerns Of
Trafficking
Homes

Total
State

1 4 1 7 0 2 14 29
West Bengal
3.4% 13.8% 3.4% 24.1% 0.0% 6.9% 48.3% 100%
6 6 1 6 2 6 5 32
Maharashtra
18.8% 18.8% 3.1% 18.8% 6.3% 18.8% 15.6% 100%
6 2 0 3 0 0 3 14
Karnataka
42.9% 14.3% 0.0% 21.4% 0.0% 0.0% 21.4% 100%
0 0 1 1 0 0 1 3
Jharkhand
0.0% 0.0% 33.3% 33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 33.3% 100%
10 0 1 3 3 0 0 17
Assam
58.8% 0.0% 5.9% 17.6% 17.6% 0.0% 0.0% 100%
2 2 2 1 0 0 0 7
Uttar Pradesh
28.6% 28.6% 28.6% 14.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100%
3 5 0 1 0 2 0 11
Tamil Nadu
27.3% 45.5% 0.0% 9.1% 0.0% 18.2% 0.0% 100%
1 7 10 1 8 6 1 34
Delhi
2.9% 20.6% 29.4% 2.9% 23.5% 17.6% 2.9% 100%
29 26 16 23 13 16 24 147
Total
19.7% 17.7% 10.9% 15.6% 8.8% 10.9% 16.3% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 205

Most of organizations visited were categorized as non-government organizations (82.3

per cent). The overwhelming majority of respondents were females (68.7 per cent). Majority
of respondents were found from urban centers including metropolitan city and semi-urban
areas. The respondents were mainly from the middle age group i.e., 30 to 50 years. They were
mainly from the General Caste and Other Backward Caste. However, majority of them were
postgraduates while about 22 per cent respondents were graduates. Majority of respondents
reported that they are providing multiple services pertaining to prevention of human trafficking,
emergency response and rescue of victims, protection of victims and their rehabilitation,
educational, economic and income generation, reintegration, repatriation and prosecution (Table
7.7).
Table: 7.7
Type of Services being provided by Organizations
Activities Performed/ Services Provided Total
Prevention Activities
Anti-Trafficking Watch Group 50 (34.01%)
Community Vigilance Group 63 (42.86%)
Linkage Building with Other NGOs 71 (48.30%)
Media And Government 52 (35.37%)
Livelihood Support 74 (50.34%)
Helpline For Children 55 (37.45%)
Survey And Data Collection 53 (36.05%)
Awareness Generation Through Mass Media, Audio Visuals, Digital Communication and social
81 (55.10%)
media.
Advocacy And Development & Printing of Awareness Generation Material Such as Pamphlets,
74 (50.34%)
Audio Visual, Leaflets and Posters
Emergency Response and Rescue Services
Assistance In Information Gathering 69 (46.94%)
Assisting Enforcement Agencies in Rescue Operations 63 (42.86%)
Immediate Relief on Rescue - Food, Shelter, Toiletries, Clothing, Trauma Care/Counseling,
Medical Aid Etc. During The Interim Period Between Rescue and Production Before the Concerned 87 (59.18%)
Authorities
Protection and Rehabilitation
Protective And Rehabilitative (P&R) Homes 123 (83.67%)
Basic Amenities-Food, Clothes, Toiletries, Sanitary Items, Pocket Money, Insurance and Expense
123 (83.67%)
for Recreational Activities Etc.
Medical Care/ Assistance 115 (78.23%)
Legal Aid and Counseling 37 (25.17%)
Psycho-Social Support/ Counseling 117 (79.59%)
Assistance To Women in Lodging FIR And Intimation to The Concerned Enforcement Agency 78 (53.06%)
Education
Formal Education 48 (32.65%)
Informal Education 85 (57.82%)
Life Skills 91 (61.90%)
Vocational Training 89 (60.54%)
Economic Opportunities and Income Generation Activities
 206

Financial Inclusion 41 (27.89%)

Skill Development Training 83 (56.46%)
Placement Services for Wage Employment 39 (26.53%)
Economic And Marketing Support for Self-Employment 36 (24.49%)
Re- Integration
Setting Of Half-Way Home 0 (0.0%)
Monetary Support for Self-Employment, Sustainable Living and Restoration to Families 0 (0.0%)
Repatriation (Cross- Border)
Facilitate Repatriation Procedures, Communication and Documentation 59 (40.14%)
Repatriation To Country of Origin (Transport to The Victim and Escort, Includes Food and Other
15 (10.20%)
Incidentals)
Prosecution
Assist Police to Register Case Against Traffickers 26 (17.68%)
Legal Aid 20 (13.61%)
Assist Victim and Witness in Deposition 12 (8.16%)
Capacity Building
Organizing Workshops/Seminars/Conferences Etc. 34 (23.13%)
Sensitization and Training of Police, Other Law Enforcement Agencies, Judiciary, WCD Officials,
36 (24.49%)
NGOs, Communities and Others
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents admitted that law enforcement agencies are referring cases to them.
However, a large proportion of respondents reported that neighbours, concerned citizens, self
and other agencies are also referring victims to them (Table 7.8).
Table: 7.8
How Victims Are Normally Referred to You
Source of Referral Total
Self-Referral 68 (55.28%)
Law Enforcement (Local, State, National) 118 (95.93%)
Prosecuting Agency (DPO) 35 (28.46%)
Neighbors, Concerned Citizens Groups, Ethnic Community Groups 71 (57.72%)
Other Service Providers 72 (48.98%)
Source: Field Survey
Insufficient rehabilitation provisions for victims, lack of community support for rescued
victims, slow judicial process, lack of long-term funding for sustainable approach, lack of adequate
funds, lack of protection for victims, inter-departmental cooperation, corruption, insufficient law
enforcement, lack of cooperation from CSOs are major challenges being faced while helping
victims of human trafficking (Table 7.9).
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 207

Table: 7.9
Challenges being faced while helping Victims of Human Trafficking

Uttar Pradesh
Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Assam

Delhi

Total
State

21 14 8 1 11 2 3 10 70
Slow Judicial Process
30.0% 20.0% 11.4% 1.4% 15.7% 2.9% 4.3% 14.3% 100%
12 5 9 1 7 3 3 8 48
Lack of Protection for Victims
25.0% 10.4% 18.8% 2.1% 14.6% 6.3% 6.3% 16.7% 100%
Insufficient Rehabilitations Provisions for 13 16 7 3 8 4 9 17 77
Victims 16.9% 20.8% 9.1% 3.9% 10.4% 5.2% 11.7% 22.1% 100%
5 13 11 1 8 5 6 12 61
Lack of Adequate Funds
8.2% 21.3% 18.0% 1.6% 13.1% 8.2% 9.8% 19.7% 100%
1 5 4 2 7 7 4 13 43
Interdepartmental Cooperation
2.3% 11.6% 9.3% 4.7% 16.3% 16.3% 9.3% 30.2% 100%
5 7 4 1 8 2 4 11 42
Corruption
11.9% 16.7% 9.5% 2.4% 19.0% 4.8% 9.5% 26.2% 100%
6 9 7 2 1 1 4 3 33
Insufficient Law Enforcement
18.2% 27.3% 21.2% 6.1% 3.0% 3.0% 12.1% 9.1% 100%
1 5 3 0 0 1 1 7 18
Lack of Cooperation from CSOs
5.6% 27.8% 16.7% 0.0% 0.0% 5.6% 5.6% 38.9% 100%
9 15 7 2 10 2 8 20 73
Lack of Community Support for Rescued
Victims 12.3% 20.5% 9.6% 2.7% 13.7% 2.7% 11.0% 27.4% 100%

Lack of Long-Term Funding for 3 14 10 2 9 5 7 16 66

Sustainable Approach 4.5% 21.2% 15.2% 3.0% 13.6% 7.6% 10.6% 24.2% 100%
1 6 3 0 2 1 1 5 19
Others
5.3% 31.6% 15.8% 0.0% 10.5% 5.3% 5.3% 26.3% 100%

Source: Field Survey

Majority of the respondents reported that the attitude of police to the victims of trafficking
is helpful. However, more than 1/3rd respondents revealed that attitude of police towards them
have been indifferent and harassing. Most of respondents reported that their relations with law
enforcement agencies for addressing issues of human trafficking have been good. However, lack
of manpower, lack of networking and lack of infrastructure were some of the hurdles which are
being faced by police in tackling human trafficking.
Less than 2/5th respondents were found agreed on the view point that task force has been
effective in addressing issues of sex trafficking. However, about 18 per cent respondents were
against the view point while more than 2/5th respondents were found neutral on the view point
(Table 7.10).
Table: 7.10
Do You Agree That Task Force Has Been Effective in Addressing Issues of Sex Trafficking?
Strongly Strongly
State Disagree Neutral Agree Total
Disagree Agree
West Bengal 3 (10.3%) 2 (6.9%) 20 (69.0%) 4 (13.8%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
 208

Maharashtra 1 (3.1%) 5 (15.6%) 11 (34.4%) 15 (46.9%) 0 (0.0%) 32 (100%)

Karnataka 1 (7.1%) 2 (14.3%) 2 (14.3%) 9 (64.3%) 0 (0.0%) 14 (100%)
Jharkhand 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Assam 1 (5.9%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (58.8%) 6 (35.3%) 0 (0.0%) 17 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 2 (28.6%) 1 (14.3%) 1 (14.3%) 3 (42.9%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 4 (36.4%) 6 (54.5%) 1 (9.1%) 11 (100%)
Delhi 2 (5.9%) 6 (17.6%) 14 (41.2%) 12 (35.3%) 0 (0.0%) 34 (100%)
11 16 63 56 1 147
Total
7.5% 10.9% 42.9% 38.1% 0.7% 100%

Source: Field Survey

About 60 per cent respondents reported that service providers received training on subject matter
of human trafficking. It was found more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by Karnataka and
Tamil Nadu. Induction, orientation and refresher training programmes are being provided to them.
Now-a-days, online training programmes are also being organized. Service providers, police training
institutes and independent trainers are providing such trainings. Rights of victims, victim support
and assistance, counseling and care of trafficked victims, psychological state of trafficked victims,
legal tools, rescue protocols, public education, etc. are some of the important topics of such training
(Table 7.11).
Table: 7.11
Do Service Providers Receive Training on Subject Matter of Human Trafficking
State Yes No Total
West Bengal 14 (48.3%) 15 (51.7%) 29 (100%)
Maharashtra 26 (81.3%) 6 (18.8%) 32 (100%)
Karnataka 11 (78.6%) 3 (21.4%) 14 (100%)
Jharkhand 1 (33.3%) 2 (66.7%) 3 (100%)
Assam 11 (64.7%) 6 (35.3%) 17 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 3 (42.9%) 4 (57.1%) 7 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 8 (72.7%) 3 (27.3%) 11 (100%)
Delhi 15 (44.1%) 19 (55.9%) 34 (100%)
Total 89 (60.5%) 58 (39.5%) 147 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
About 38 per cent respondents reported that there is reporting mechanism within their
agencies to track trafficking cases. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand followed by
Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka and Assam (Table 7.12).
Table: 7.12
Whether There is Reporting Mechanism within Your Agency to Track Trafficking Cases
State Yes No Total
West Bengal 4 (13.8%) 25 (86.2%) 29 (100%)
Maharashtra 13 (40.6%) 19 (59.4%) 32 (100%)
Karnataka 6 (42.9%) 8 (57.1%) 14 (100%)
Jharkhand 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Assam 7 (41.2%) 10 (58.8%) 17 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 7 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100%)
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 209

Tamil Nadu 4 (36.4%) 7 (63.6%) 11 (100%)

Delhi 12 (35.3%) 22 (64.7%) 34 (100%)
Total 56 (38.1%) 91 (61.9%) 147 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents reported that there is specific menu of food for beneficiaries. About
3/4th respondents further reported that they follow such menu. They further reported that menu
is changed mainly weekly and monthly basis. Most of the respondents revealed that beneficiaries
are being provided with clothing and toilet reach (89.4 per cent). Majority of the respondents
reported that beneficiaries are being provided new cloths for more than one time in a year.
Similarly, most of the respondents reported that beneficiaries are being provided toiletries many
times in a year.
Most of the respondents reported that they have admission register, attendance register,
separate case file and detailed case histories of beneficiaries. However, less than 1/4th respondents
reported that files are being given specific codes for maintaining confidentiality. The files are
being updated mainly weekly and quarterly. The desired and relevant documents were found in
files during the time of verification of documents while visiting the centers (Table 7.13).
Table: 7.13
Case management: Maintenance of Various Kinds of Registers/ Documents by P & R Homes as Per
Guidelines
Name of Document Yes No Total
Admission Register 108 (87.8%) 15 (12.2%) 123 (100%)
Attendance Register 103 (83.7%) 20 (16.3%) 123 (100%)
Separate Case Files 101 (82.1%) 22 (17.9%) 123 (100%)
Files are being given specific Codes/Numbers to Maintain Confidentiality 29 (23.6%) 94 (76.4%) 123 (100%)
Detailed Case Histories
91 (74.0%) 32 926.0%) 123 (100%)
of Beneficiaries
Source: Field Survey
It is reported that after verification of files by team it has been found that most of the service
providers are maintaining the various kinds of documents as per guidelines but when it comes to
Rehabilitation Plan, Psychological Counseling Reports, Home Verification Reports and follow up
Reports only 16 out of 123 (13%) service providers are maintaining these documents (Table: 7.14).
It is a serious lacuna and the main reason behind failure of rehabilitation of victims, when there
is no proper rehabilitation plan and no proper Psychological Counseling of victims then how can
they be treated or rehabilitated. Follow up report after reunion in the family is also missing on
part of service providers, so it cannot be ascertained as what happened to the victims after their
reunion in the families. Home Verification Report is also missing from the files, it raises a serious
question that when home of victims is not verified, how they are reintegrated to families.
 210

Table: 7.14
Documents Found in Files Verified

Uttar Pradesh
Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Assam

Delhi

Total
State

13 27 11 2 14 7 11 31 116
Case Study
11.2% 23.3% 9.5% 1.7% 12.1% 6.0% 9.5% 26.7% 100%
6 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 16
Rehabilitation Plan
37.5% 12.5% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 18.8% 100%
12 23 10 2 11 7 11 26 102
Photograph
11.8% 22.5% 9.8% 2.0% 10.8% 6.9% 10.8% 25.5% 100%
14 21 11 2 9 6 9 23 95
Age Proof
14.7% 22.1% 11.6% 2.1% 9.5% 6.3% 9.5% 24.2% 100%
12 20 11 2 8 6 9 22 90
Address Proof
13.3% 22.2% 12.2% 2.2% 8.9% 6.7% 10.0% 24.4% 100%
10 23 10 2 15 7 9 23 99
Medical Records
10.1% 23.2% 10.1% 2.0% 15.2% 7.1% 9.1% 23.2% 100%
Legal/Court 5 20 7 2 13 7 11 20 85
Orders 5.9% 23.5% 8.2% 2.4% 15.3% 8.2% 12.9% 23.5% 100%
FIR/Complaint 10 21 7 2 16 7 7 25 95
Copy 10.5% 22.1% 7.4% 2.1% 16.8% 7.4% 7.4% 26.3% 100%
Counseling 6 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 16
Reports 37.5% 12.5% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 18.8% 100%
Social Worker’s 9 10 7 2 13 7 8 25 81
Reports 11.1% 12.3% 8.6% 2.5% 16.0% 8.6% 9.9% 30.9% 100%
Home Verification 6 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 16
Report 37.5% 12.5% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 18.8% 100%
5 0 1 1 1 1 1 6 16
Follow Up Report
31.3% 0.0% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 37.5% 100%
Source: Field Survey
The mode of follow up of victims restored to their families or reintegrated is being ensured
through telephone, other organizations and direct visit to the place where beneficiaries are
resided (Table 7.15).
Table: 7.15
Mode of Follow Up of Victims Restored to their Families or Reintegrated
Uttar Pradesh
Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Assam

Delhi

Total

State

Through Direct Visit to The Place Where 2 2 8 0 3 2 4 12 33

Beneficiary is Residing 6.1% 6.1% 24.2% 0.0% 9.1% 6.1% 12.1% 36.4% 100%
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 211

0 5 6 1 1 0 4 17 34
Through Other Organizations
0.0% 14.7% 17.6% 2.9% 2.9% 0.0% 11.8% 50.0% 100%
5 6 9 1 5 4 4 18 52
Through Telephone
9.6% 11.5% 17.3% 1.9% 9.6% 7.7% 7.7% 34.6% 100%
0 1 4 0 1 0 4 14 24
Through Other Means-such as DCPOs/ Police
0.0% 4.2% 16.7% 0.0% 4.2% 0.0% 16.7% 58.3% 100%
Source: Field Survey

RESPONSES OF VICTIMS ON THE SERVICES/PROGRAMS OF RESCUE,

REHABILITATION AND RE-INTEGRATION:
Medical care/assistance (58 percent), psycho social support/counseling (56.9 per cent),
shelter-protective and rehabilitation home (47.4 per cent) and legal aid and counseling (33.6 per
cent) and drop-in centers (31.1 per cent) were some of the rescue, rehabilitation and reintegration
programmes which were sought by victims (Table 7.16).
Table: 7.16
Rescue, Rehabilitation and Reintegration Programs Sought by Victims
Name of Programme Respondents
Rescue and Immediate Relief on Rescue 370 (32.0%)
Shelters- Protective and Rehabilitative (P&R) Homes 548 (47.4%)
Drop-in Centers 359 (31.1%)
Legal aid and counseling 388 (33.6%)
Assistance in lodging FIR and intimation to the concerned enforcement agency 304 (26.3%)
Psycho-social support/ counseling 657 (56.9%)
Medical Care/ Assistance 670 (58.0%)
Education 289 (25.0%)
Financial Inclusion 106 (9.2%)
Empowerment- Vocational Training and Income generation activities 236 (20.4)
Monetary support for self-employment, Sustainable living 73 (6.3%)
repatriation procedures, Communication and Documentation 48 (4.2%)
Compensation under Scheme for Women Victims/Survivors of Sexual Assault/other Crimes -
44 (3.8%)
2018
Total 815 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Individual counseling, group counseling, professional counseling and bare foot counseling
were some of the forms of counseling which were provided in P & R Homes (Table 7.17).
Table: 7.17
Feedback on Forms of Counseling Provided in P & R Homes
Particular Respondents
Bare-foot counseling 49 (4.2%)
Professional Counseling 64 (5.5%)
Group Counseling 112 (9.7%)
Peer Counseling 7 (0.6%)
Individual Counseling 541 (46.8%)
Source: Field Survey
 212

Funding, social stigma, service coordination, long term commitments and lack of sensitivity
and understanding on sex trade were some of the obstacles in rehabilitation and reintegration
programmes (Table 7.18).
Table: 7.18
Obstacles in Rehabilitation and Reintegration Programs
Obstacles Respondents
Lack of sensitivity and understanding on sex trade 190 (16.5%)
Social Stigma 412 (35.7%)
Funding 392 (33.9%)
Service Co-Ordination 300 (26.0%)
Long Term Commitments 340 (39.4%)
Resistance to Rehabilitate and Reintegrate 164 (14.2%)
Source: Field Survey
General mentality, lack of assistance, lack of sensitivity, family, stereotypes and shame were
some of the obstacles in rehabilitating and reintegration process of trafficked victims. The obstacles
in rehabilitation and reintegration process vary across the social categories of respondents. The
issue of lack of sensitivity was recorded high among the respondents from minority communities
while the issue of family was reported high among Scheduled Tribes. Lack of assistance and
stereotype were reported high among the respondents from other categories (Table 7.19).
Table: 7.19
Obstacles in Rehabilitation and Reintegration Process
Obstacles Frequency
Lack of Sensitivity 334 (28.9%)
General Mentality 391 (33.9%)
Stereotypes 222 (19.2%)
Lack of Assistance 366 (31.7%)
Shame 191 (16.5%)
Family 316 (27.4%)
Fear of Pimps 39 (3.4%)
Source: Field Survey
More than half of the respondents were found satisfied on availability of medical care, psycho
social support, toilets, room for counseling, separate space for recreation, room for inmates,
room for administrative work and clothing and toilet reach while majority of the respondents
were found satisfied with the availability of bathroom in Ujjawala Centres and Swadhar Greh.
However, satisfaction with the adequacy of such services was found to be quite low. About half
of the respondents were found satisfied with the availability of room for administrative work
while about 1/3rd respondents were found satisfied with medical care, psycho social support,
separate space for creation, counseling and room for inmates (Table 7.20).
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 213

Table: 7.20
Satisfaction on Availability and Adequacy of Services Provided by Service Providers Such as Ujjawala
Centers, Swadhar Greh Etc.
Availability Adequacy
Name of Services / Particulars
of Services of Services
No. of Rooms for inmates 602 (52.1%) 416 (36.0%)
No. of Beds for inmates 553 (47.9%) 371 (32.1%)
No. of Mattresses for inmates 557 (48.2%) 383 (33.2%)
Rooms used for office/ administrative work 632 (54.7%) 566 (49.0%)
Separate room for counseling 619 (53.6%) 405 (35.1%)
Number of toilets 615 (53.2%) 305 (26.4%)
Number of bathrooms 815 (70.6%) 295 (25.5%)
Beneficiaries are provided with clothing and toiletries 584 (50.6%) 306 (26.5%)
Kitchen Room 582 (50.4%) 350 (30.3%)
Specific menu for food for the Beneficiaries 567 (49.1%) 286 (24.8%)
Separate space for recreational activities/ assembly 613 (53.1%) 371 (32.1%)
Separate space for vocational training/education/etc. 515 (44.6%) 291 (25.2%)
Safety and security of the Beneficiaries 530 (45.9%) 296 (25.6%)
Separate room for visitors in the premise 529 (45.8%) 343 (29.7%)
Legal aid and counseling 491 (42.5%) 331 (28.7%)
Psycho-social support/ counseling 641 (55.5%) 402 (34.8%)
Medical Care/ Assistance 650 (56.3%) 415 (35.9%)
Education 387 (33.5%) 261 (22.6%)
Vocational Training and Income generation activities 413 (35.8%) 243 (21.0%)
Source: Field Survey
More than half of the respondents rated the quality of services being provided in Ujjawala
Centers and Swadhar Greh as good, very good and excellent. These services include mainly easily
accessibility of shelter home, cleanliness of rooms for inmates, toilets, bath rooms and kitchen,
availability of infrastructure for recreational activities, safety and security of inmates, beds and
their condition, quality of clothing and toiletries, maintenance of admission and registration
register, case management, medical care, legal aid and counseling (Table 7.21).
Table: 7.21
Satisfaction on Quality of Services Provided by Service Providers Such as Ujjawala Centers, Swadhar
Greh Etc.
Excellent

Response
Present
Good

Good

Total
Very

Very
Poor

Poor

Not

Name of Services/
No

Easily Accessibility of the shelter home 1 41 401 78 86 0 208 815

from the road 0.1% 5.0% 49.2% 9.6% 10.6% 0.0% 25.5% 100%
1 83 376 57 89 0 209 815
Cleanliness of rooms for inmates
0.1% 10.2% 46.1% 7.0% 10.9% 0.0% 25.6% 100%
10 113 339 50 93 0 210 815
Toilets and their cleanliness
1.2% 13.9% 41.6% 6.1% 11.4% 0.0% 25.8% 100%
 214

2 128 300 70 74 0 241 815

Bathrooms and their cleanliness
0.2% 15.7% 36.8% 8.6% 9.1% 0.0% 29.6% 100%
5 80 357 46 82 0 245 815
Kitchen room and its cleanliness
0.6% 9.8% 43.8% 5.6% 10.1% 0.0% 30.1% 100%
Infrastructures for recreational activities/ 13 90 377 67 75 0 193 815
assembly 1.6% 11.0% 46.3% 8.2% 9.2% 0.0% 23.7% 100%
Infrastructure for vocational training/ 19 89 301 74 79 0 253 815
education/etc. 2.3% 10.9% 36.9% 9.1% 9.7% 0.0% 31.0% 100%
Quality of vocational training/education/ 23 89 299 61 77 0 266 815
etc. 2.8% 10.9% 36.7% 7.5% 9.4% 0.0% 32.6% 100%
10 72 354 49 84 0 246 815
Safety and security of the Beneficiaries
1.2% 8.8% 43.4% 6.0% 10.3% 0.0% 30.2% 100%
4 88 313 40 86 2 282 815
Beds and their condition
0.5% 10.8% 38.4% 4.9% 10.6% 0.2% 34.6% 100%
3 97 306 36 80 2 291 815
Mattresses and their condition
0.4% 11.9% 37.5% 4.4% 9.8% 0.2% 35.7% 100%
8 99 342 38 78 0 250 815
Quality of clothing and toiletries provided
1.0% 12.1% 42.0% 4.7% 9.6% 0.0% 30.7% 100%
22 74 343 41 82 0 253 815
Specific menu for food for the Beneficiaries
2.7% 9.1% 42.1% 5.0% 10.1% 0.0% 31.0% 100%
Maintenance of Admission register of the 2 36 399 50 86 0 242 815
Beneficiaries 0.2% 4.4% 49.0% 6.1% 10.6% 0.0% 29.7% 100%
Maintenance attendance register of the 5 37 437 50 85 0 201 815
beneficiaries 0.6% 4.5% 53.6% 6.1% 10.4% 0.0% 24.7% 100%
14 22 462 46 98 0 173 815
Case Management
1.7% 2.7% 56.7% 5.6% 12.0% 0.0% 21.2% 100%
19 32 452 63 87 0 162 815
Medical Care/ Assistance
2.3% 3.9% 55.5% 7.7% 10.7% 0.0% 19.9% 100%
30 18 420 61 89 0 197 815
Legal aid and counseling
3.7% 2.2% 51.5% 7.5% 10.9% 0.0% 24.2% 100%
Quality of staffs in P&R home and their 14 25 454 62 89 0 171 815
behavior towards the Beneficiary 1.7% 3.1% 55.7% 7.6% 10.9% 0.0% 21.0% 100%
Source: Field Survey
Case Study-4: “There’s no difference between living in a brothel and staying in a shelter
home,” says Sazia, 23, who spent two years in a ‘shelter home’ run by an NGO after escaping a
brothel in Pune. “We have no control over the situation at a brothel; we can’t predict what will
happen to us next minute; the same is true for these shelter homes, which are worse than prisons
for us,” she continues. “At jails, we know when we’ll be allowed to leave; in a shelter house, we
don’t know when we’ll be able to leave.” When I inquire, I am always informed that things are in
the process, that I am being held at the shelter due to a court order, and that they cannot send me
home until the court has ‘released’ me.” Shelter Homes are essential for trafficked women and
girls who have been rescued until they may return home or seek rehabilitation assistance. When
these shelters are run like prisons, robbing survivors of all agency and independence, confining
them for long lengths of time, and failing to check consent, the unintended effect is that they
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 215

(survivors) will perceive them as nothing less than prisons.

Shelters must adhere to minimal care standards and not infringe on survivors’ fundamental
rights; they must also avoid confinement and indefinite detention. While it is true that the first
three months following a rescue are important, locking the shelter’s gates cannot be the only
solution. One could argue that the majority of these shelters are managed on a shoestring budget.
However, evidence suggests that the practice is consistent even among the 10 or 12 organizations
out of 150 that receive significant funding from the private sector or foreign governments and
foundations (The News Minute, December 7, 2018). The grounds for not investing in a non-
custodial care system include a disregard for and ignorance to the tyranny inflicted on those
whom one promises to protect and empower.
Deinstitutionalization and community-based care and protection should be the focus
of rehabilitation services. More effective than shelter-based rehabilitation are rehabilitation
programmes that provide survivors access mainstream health, education, and welfare services
while living with their families or in independent shelters. In Nepal, Bangladesh, and India,
there are a few extant community-based rehabilitation schemes. Community-based rehabilitation
programmes have not increased as much as they might because they require investment in
districts and rural areas, and it is difficult for city-based organisations to execute interventions
and services in far-flung districts. Rural NGOs, on the other hand, are effective at implementing
community-based care programmes, and once they’ve negotiated with Panchayats, police, and
block development offices to provide social, financial, and health services to trafficked survivors,
the approach is sustainable, rights-based, and strengthens the government’s response system.
It is a fallacy that shelters can provide better recovery and rehabilitation services than
community-based rehabilitation programmes. Staff recruited in shelter homes are underpaid, and
finding, recruiting, and retaining skilled therapists, educators, or trainers in shelters is difficult.
Therefore, the survivors must rely on mainstream service providers, in hospitals and chambers.
The prospects of finding work as a result of the vocational training provided to survivors in
shelter homes are nearly nil. Even specialized efforts in which a few NGOs cooperated with
hospitality sector companies to provide jobs in services were uncommon, with the majority of
them collapsing over time. On the contrary, when NGOs attempted to establish in-house training
and manufacturing units, survivors’ reliance on NGOs for survival and income increased, and
this dependence became an additional barrier to their reintegration.
The aforementioned analysis is indicative of a dysfunctional ecosystem for which various
stakeholders-NGOs, the government, and the law-are somewhat accountable. NGOs that
administer shelters must be held to a higher standard of accountability right away. The anti-
trafficking sector requires consistent and increased financial investment, and the Indian
government should recommend CSR funding for community-based rehabilitation programmes
and closely monitored shelter homes.

RESPONSES OF PROGRAMME ADMINISTRATORS

The Ministry of Women and Child Development, the Nodal Ministry in the Government of
India dealing with issues concerning women and children, drew up a National Action Plan based
on the report of the Central Advisory Committee on Child Prostitution, the recommendations of
the National Commission for Women, and the directions of the Supreme Court of India (orders
dated 2nd May 1990 and 9th July 1997), as well as the experiences of various non-governmental
organizations working in this area. In addition to combating human trafficking, the NPA
 216

prioritizes the rescue and rehabilitation of victims of human trafficking and commercial sexual
exploitation. Legal and law-enforcement systems are activated under the National Plan of Action
to strengthen the implementation of the IPTA, 1956. Under Section 21 of the Immoral Trafficking
Prevention Act (IIPA), the government has established Protective Homes exclusively for girls
and women incarcerated under the ITPA, as well as those seeking protection from being pushed
into commercial sexual exploitation. For the protection and rehabilitation of victims, the Indian
government has a vast network of around 351 short stay institutions aided by the DWCD and
juvenile homes established under the Juvenile Justice Act. The Government of India has approved
projects for the establishment of child development centers in various high-crime regions under
the Integrated Child Development Service Scheme (ICDS).
Rehabilitation centers and shelter homes under Ministry of Women and Child Development,
Govt. of India are run by Govt. and Non Govt. Organizations under the supervision, guidance
and control of State/District Advisory Committee and State/District Anti-Trafficking Committee,
GNO, State/District level Officials, WCD, Department of Labour, Human Rights Commission & State
Commission for Women, District Women and Child Development Officers/District Social Welfare
Officers, District Child Protection Officers, Child welfare Committees, JJ Boards etc. known as
Programme Administrators. Programme Administrator is one of the most important stakeholders
and has a very crucial role in rehabilitation and reintegration.
In terms of accommodation, the CWC is responsible for finding adequate housing for rescued
children. A home verification report is required by the Protocol to establish whether it is safe
for the child to return home to his or her family. If not, the CWC can suggest family-based
alternative care or government- or non-profit-run residential hostels. Except in circumstances
where the family cannot be traced, children are always returned to their relatives in reality.
Comprehensive family assessments, examining the original motivations of the child’s trafficking
and methods to reduce the risk of re-trafficking, are never conducted, according to respondents.
Part of the reason for this major breach of protection is the logistical challenges of conducting
a home verification. In India, almost four-fifths of child workers originate from low-caste
households living in remote and difficult-to-reach rural areas, and trafficked children may come
from families who are themselves nomadic and struggling to live. The constraints that CWCs have
in doing home visits are significant, and they necessitate staffing, training, and transportation
resources that are currently lacking. There is no apparent party in charge of coordinating and
funding the return of rescued children to their home state. Long-distance returns, such as from
Rajasthan to Bihar, are facilitated by sending groups of rescued children by train to significant
regional railway hubs, escorted on an ad hoc basis by either a government official or an NGO
worker. The family is notified and advised to come pick up the child from the regional hub.
There is also a dearth of resources to facilitate a child’s reintegration into the family, as well
as mentorship and acceptance of returning children by their parents. As a result, reintegration is
frequently limited to a simple return to the pre-trafficking status quo. Alternative housing choices
are similarly restricted, underfunded, and not adequately monitored and evaluated. Given this
reality, it’s not surprise that complaints of assault, neglect, and re-trafficking in these settings
are prevalent. The NCLP schools are aimed to give non-formal educational services to rescued
children in order to assist them make up for lost years. Pupils are taught a shortened curriculum
in these ‘bridge schools’ before being mainstreamed into a formal institution or returning to
some type of self-employment. NCLP schools are also the main conduit for vocational training
and sporadic health checks, which are conducted on a largely ad hoc basis.
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 217

According to the findings, when rescued children return home, they are not consistently
enrolled in bridging school programmes. According to a CWC official, “only the child’s parents
have a role in school enrolment.” The lack of suitable participating schools in the district, the failure
of schools to deliver the promised daily compensation to formerly trafficked children, and the
child’s simple refusal to attend were all mentioned as impediments to enrolling by participants.
According to research, family mentorship and support are crucial in ensuring school attendance
in India. Parents, on the other hand, are not given the financial, logistical, or emotional support
they need to fulfil this duty. According to other sources, the NCLP is underfunded, operating
in just approximately a third of India’s 676 districts, and its teaching staff is underpaid and
often underqualified. Quality education that provides useful learning skills and resources to
help students continue to higher education is essential, as it acts as a self-reinforcing mechanism
to encourage parents to enroll their children in school. Bridge schools that are inadequate have
the opposite effect. Returning children have a tough time integrating into formal schools, even
if they are successfully enrolled in bridge schools. This is due to a lack of coordination between
the two systems. The fact that bridge school programmes are run by the Ministry of Labour and
Employment, while formal schooling is organized by the Ministry of Education, exacerbates this
serious problem. A key issue in the reintegration context is the failure to invest in robust teaching
facilities in bridge schools and to guarantee easy transition opportunities into mainstream formal
education.
Through a lump sum compensation plan, India’s reintegration strategy aims to assist the
social and economic viability of children and their families. In the case of M C Mehta vs. State
of Tamil Nadu, the Supreme Court ruled that violating employers must pay INR 20,000 per
rescued child into a special benefit fund. It also stipulated that one adult member of the child’s
family be offered work or that the state contribute an additional INR 5,000 to the welfare fund
if this is not possible. The study’s participants were all aware that rescued children should be
compensated, but they also agreed that in actuality, children are rarely compensated at all. This
backs up previous reports that compensation rarely reaches its intended recipients. ‘There is no
hope of financial assistance or recompense,’ said an NGO spokesman. The freedom of a child is
thought to constitute compensation in and of itself.’ Importantly, respondents did not cite a lack
of resources as the primary cause for children’s underpayment. Employer noncompliance, as well
as technological and administrative issues, were cited. Policy frameworks do not provide clear,
uniform instructions on how cash transfers should be implemented. Neither the Protocol nor the
M C Mehta decision specify where the welfare fund to receive the funds should be established,
how interstate coordination should be accomplished, or what kind of access families will have
to the funds. After incorporating recommendations from several regional workshops on the
subject, the NPA became an Integrated Plan of Action. The Integrated Plan took a four-pronged
approach: prevention, rescue, rehabilitation, and repatriation and reintegration. This strategy
covers all areas of victim prevention, rescue, case registration, investigations, prosecution,
conviction, cross-border trafficking issues, victim rehabilitation, repatriation, and reintegration,
and so on.
A question was drafted to assess the level of awareness amongst the Programs Administrators
about the component of NPA. Responses of Programs Administrators are shown in Table: 7.22
which clearly show that most of the Programs Administrators are not aware about various
components of NPA. If the Programs Administrators are not fully aware about various
components of NPA, we were not able to understand how they are administering the various
schemes and programme to combat human trafficking in their respective areas.
 218

Table: 7.22
Provisions included in National Plan of Action (NPA)
Provisions Responses
Measures For Prevention of Trafficking 105 (37.5%)
Focus on Newly Emerging Forms of Trafficking 70 (25.0%)
Identification of Traffickers and Trafficked Victims 49 (17.5%)
Special Measures for Identification and Protection of Trafficked Child Victims 98 (35.0%)
Rescue of Trafficked Victims 93 (33.21%)
Rehabilitation, Reintegration and Repatriation of Trafficked Victims 129 (46.07%)
Cross-Border Trafficking 91 (32.5%)
Legal Framework and Law Enforcement Measures 81 (28.93%)
Witness Protection and Support to Victims 49 (17.5%)
Training, Sensitization, Education and Awareness 93 (33.21%)
Others 10 (3.57%)
Total 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Rehabilitation, reintegration and repatriation of trafficked victims; rescue of trafficked
victims; training, sensitization, education and awareness; and inter-departmental coordination
are some of the priority actions identified to address under National Plan of Action (Table 7.23).
Table: 7.23
What Priority Actions are identified to Address under NPA
Priority Actions Responses
Rescue of Trafficked Victims 144 (51.43%)
Rehabilitation, Reintegration and Repatriation of Trafficked Victims 152 (54.28%)
Prevention of Trafficking 53 (18.93%)
Additional Powers of Law Enforcement 51 (18.21%)
Training, Sensitization, Education and Awareness 119 (42.5%)
Inter Departmental Coordination 96 (34.29%)
Others 21 (7.5%)

Source: Field Survey

Majority of the respondents reported that Ministry of Women and Child Development is
the main actor identified for implementation of specific activities while National Human Rights
Commission, Ministry of Home Affairs and National Commission for Women are also identified
for implementation of specific activities (Table 7.24), whereas the truth is that Ministry of Women
and Child Development, Govt. of India is the main actor and Nodal Agency/Ministry dealing
with issues concerning to Trafficking of women and children. Table 7.24 depicts again that about
one third Programs Administrators are not aware about the main/nodal Agency/Ministry/
Actor for implementation of specific activities.
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 219

Table: 7.24
Identified Actors for implementation of Specific Activities
Actor/Agency Responses
Ministry of Women and Child Development 190 (67.85%)
National Human Rights Commission 127 (45.36%)
Ministry Of Home Affairs 99 (35.36%)
National Commission for Women 68 (24.29%)
Source: Field Survey
About 2/5th respondents reported that strategy and National Plan of Action are monitored
and evaluated on regular basis. It was found more pronouncing in Delhi followed by Tamil
Nadu, West Bengal, Assam and Karnataka. However, more than half of the respondents were
not aware about the fact (Table 7.25).
Table: 7.25
Whether Strategy and National Plan of Action are Monitored and Evaluated on a Regular Basis
State Yes No Don’t Know Total
West Bengal 12 (48.0%) 1 (4.0%) 12 (48.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 7 (38.9%) 3 (16.7%) 8 (44.4%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 15 (44.1%) 2 (5.9%) 17 (50.0%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 0 (0.0%) 10 (21.3%) 37 (78.7%) 47 (100%)
Assam 16 (45.7%) 2 (5.7%) 17 (48.6%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 15 (32.6%) 0 (0.0%) 31 (67.4%) 46 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 20 (60.6%) 2 (6.1%) 11 (33.3%) 33 (100%)
Delhi 26 (61.9%) 2 (4.8%) 14 (33.3%) 42 (100%)
Total 111 (39.6%) 22 (7.9%) 147 (52.5%) 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
As per NPA Central Advisory Committee is responsible for Monitoring and Evaluating the
Strategy and Activities under NPA. But only 9% Programs Administrators are aware about this
fact (Table 7.26).
Table: 7.26
Which body Monitors and Evaluates the Strategy & National Action Plan
Name of Body/Agency Responses
Central Advisory Committee 25 (8.93%)
Ministry of Women and Child Development 123 (43.93%)
National Human Rights Commission 119 (42.5%)
Ministry of Home Affairs 54 (19.29%)
National Commission For Women 29 (10.36%)
Others 22 (7.86%)
Source: Field Survey
As per Direction of MHA & MoWCD State Nodal officers (Police) are responsible for
Coordination and holding periodical meetings to review and monitor the efforts taken to
prevent and combat the crime of trafficking at State Level. Only about 1/5th (19.6%) Programs
Administrators are aware about this fact (Table: 7.27).
 220

Table: 7.27
Existing Mechanism for Coordinating and Monitoring overall Anti- Trafficking Strategy at State Level

Maharashtra
West Bengal

Tamil Nadu
Jharkhand
Karnataka

Pradesh
Assam

Delhi
Uttar

Total
State

State Anti- 19 6 18 22 25 35 21 20 166

Trafficking
Committee 11.4% 3.6% 10.8% 13.3% 15.1% 21.1% 12.7% 12.0% 59.3%

Govt. Nodal 2 3 5 0 8 4 3 4 29
Officer 6.9% 10.3% 17.2% 0.0% 27.6% 13.8% 10.3% 13.8% 10.4%
Police Nodal 3 7 4 25 5 4 5 2 55
Officer 5.5% 12.7% 7.3% 45.5% 9.1% 7.3% 9.1% 3.6% 19.6%
6 11 14 0 10 12 15 22 90
IAHTU
6.7% 12.2% 15.6% 0.0% 11.1% 13.3% 16.7% 24.4% 32.1%
0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
Other
0.0% 100% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.7%
Source: Field Survey
Most of the respondents reported that they perceive menace of sex trafficking for CSE as mild
and moderate. However, a significant proportion of respondents in Jharkhand and Maharashtra
reported it as severe (Table 7.28).
Table: 7.28
Perceive of Menace of Sex Trafficking For CSE
State Mild Moderate Severe Total
West Bengal 7 (28.0%) 16 (64.0%) 2 (8.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 3 (16.7%) 12 (66.7%) 3 (16.7%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 12 (35.3%) 20 (58.8%) 2 (5.9%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 25 (53.2%) 12 (25.5%) 10 (21.3%) 47 (100%)
Assam 12 (34.3%) 20 (57.1%) 3 (8.6%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 28 (60.9%) 16 (34.8%) 2 (4.3%) 46 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 22 (66.7%) 8 (24.2%) 3 (9.1%) 33 (100%)
Delhi 26 (61.9%) 12 (28.6%) 4 (9.5%) 42 (100%)
Total 135 (48.2%) 116 (41.4%) 29 910.4%) 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The main reasons for people in the district being trafficked out include poverty, poor
schooling, poor law enforcement, family conflicts, lack of awareness, poor social support, lack of
severe punishment to perpetrators and search for better quality of life (Table 7.29).
Table: 7.29
Reasons for People Being Trafficked Out in the District/State
Reason for Trafficking Responses
Poverty 230 (82.14%)
Gender Discrimination 36 (12.86%)
Poor Schooling 145 (51.79%)
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 221

No Severe Punishment to The Perpetrators 78 (27.86%)

Poor Law Enforcement 104 (37.14%)
Family Conflicts 111 (39.64%)
To Hide From Shame 32 (11.43%)
Poor Social Support 76 (27.14%)
For Better Quality of Life 72 (25.71%)
Supportive Culture 7 (2.5%)
Lack Of Awareness 118 (42.14%)
Other 7 (2.5%)
Source: Field Survey
The modus operandi of trafficking of women and children include induced by family/friends/
relatives; induced by traffickers; sold by family; promise of marriage; abduction; deception and
forced marriage (Table 7.30).
Table: 7.30
Modus Operandi of Women and Children Trafficking
Modus Operandi Responses
Sold By Family 105 (37.5%)
Abducted 68 (24.29%)
Induced By Family or Friend or Relative 145 (51.79%)
Induced By Trafficker 112 (40.0%)
On Forced Marriage 41 (14.64%)
On Promise of Marriage 91 (32.5%)
Deception 40 (14.29%)
Other 34 (12.14%)
Source: Field Survey
It is to be noted that Assam, West Bengal, Jharkhand and Uttar Pradesh are mainly
source states for human trafficking while Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Delhi are
destination states. West Bengal, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka also are categorized as source states
for human trafficking. Majority of the respondents reported that they are witnessing increasing
trend of trafficking in their states. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand followed by
Maharashtra, Delhi, Uttar Pradesh and Assam while more than 1/4th respondents in Uttar
Pradesh and Jharkhand reported that they are realizing decreasing trend of trafficking. Majority
of the respondents (62.5 per cent) admitted that trafficking methods have shifted from brothels
to private apartments, massage parlours and Escort services (Table 7.31).
Table: 7.31
Trend of Trafficking in State
State Increasing Decreasing Constant Total
West Bengal 14 (56.0%) 6 (24.0%) 5 (20.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 13 (72.2%) 2 (11.1%) 3 (16.7%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 18 (52.9%) 8 (23.5%) 8 (23.5%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 35 (74.5%) 12 (25.5%) 0 (0.0%) 47 (100%)
Assam 22 (62.9%) 6 (17.1%) 7 (20.0%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 29 (63.0%) 13 (28.3%) 4 (8.7%) 46 (100%)
 222

Tamil Nadu 17 (51.5%) 5 (15.2%) 11 (33.3%) 33 (100%)

Delhi 28 (66.7%) 6 (14.3%) 8 (19.0%) 42 (100%)
Total 176 (62.9%) 58 (20.7%) 46 (16.4%) 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Community awareness; prosecution and conviction of offenders; rehabilitation of victims;
establishment of helpline; and prevention against vulnerabilities of trafficking are some of the
existing measures that address the issues of prevention of trafficking of women and children
(Table 7.32).
Table: 7.32
Existing Measures for Prevention of Trafficking of Women and Children
Measures Responses
Prosecution and Conviction of Offenders 137 (48.93%)
Prevention against Vulnerabilities That Create Victims 85 (30.36%)
Community Awareness 216 (77.14%)
Reducing Demand by Changing Attitudes of Society and Punishing the Clients 42 (15.0%)
Enhanced Cooperation with CSOs 38 (13.57%)
Establishment of Help Lines Or Hotlines 103 (36.79%)
Rehabilitation of Victims 132 (47.14%)
Other 14 (5.0%)
Source: Field Survey
Community Awareness programmes, target group specific programme and family education
programme are being organized as public education campaigns for creating awareness and
sensitization. About half of the respondents admitted that existing legal mechanism address the
problem of trafficking of women and children. Most of respondents admitted that state initiatives
to counter human trafficking are moderate and significant. The flaws in the existing laws include
mainly lack of severe penalty for repeat offenders; lack of continuous training of investigators,
judicial officers and public prosecutors; lack of provision for special court; lack of protection for
victims and witnesses; and non-existence of special investigating agency (Table: 7.33).
Table: 7.33
Flaws Exist in the Law
Flaws Responses
No Severe Penalties for Repeat Offenders 177 (63.21%)
Lack Of Protection for Victims and Witnesses 102 (36.43%)
No Provision for Special Court 127 (45.36%)
No Victim’s Legal Right to Rehabilitation 44 (15.71%)
No Continuous Training of Investigators, Judicial Officers and Public Prosecutors 131 (46.79%)
Non-Existence of Special Investigative Agency 92 (32.86%)
Offence Not Cognizable and Non Bailable 48 (17.14%)
Other 11 (3.93%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that there is lack of capacity building for care givers,
law enforcement and judiciary while more than half of the respondents revealed that there is
lack of specialized investigative agencies. Other lacunas included poor police infrastructure,
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 223

inadequate funds, adequate police officials and lack of political will (Table 7.34).
Table: 7.34
Lacunas in Implementation of Existing Laws and Procedures
Lacunas Responses
No Political Will 93 (33.21%)
Inadequate Police Officials 102 (36.43%)
Inadequate Funds 107 (38.21%)
Poor Police Infrastructure 107 (38.21%)
Lack of Specialized Investigative Agency 143 (51.07%)
Lack of Capacity Building for Care Givers, Law Enforcement and Judiciary 189 (67.5%)
Other 1 (0.36%)
Total 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The lacuna in Section 370 of the IPC is that it does not address rehabilitation of rescued persons.
“Currently, funds for rehabilitation are provided through the Victim Compensation Fund. Not
even 100 victims have been awarded compensation from 2012 to 2019. In 19 States, out of the total
allocation of Rs 544.53 crore, only Rs 128.27 crore has been utilized. More than 2/3rd Programs
Administrators reported that Legal Framework Related to Trafficking Contain Provisions for
Rehabilitation of the Victims. Shelter, food, clothing, skill development, education, legal support,
health care services, referral support, counseling are some of the important services which
are being extended to rescued victims. In order to create alternative livelihood opportunities,
skill developments, infrastructure under special welfare scheme, victim assistance fund, job
placement, micro credit are being provided to the victims. More than 2/3rd (71.1%) respondents
reported that Victim has a Legal Right to Rehabilitation but only slightly more than half (56.1%)
of the respondents reported that victim’s willingness is presumed in rehabilitation process.
Majority of the respondents reported that provisions for rehabilitation of victims in the existing
laws are adequate and somewhat adequate. However, more than 1/3rd respondents in Assam,
Karnataka, Delhi and West Bengal admitted that such provisions are inadequate. Majority of the
respondents (71.1 per cent) reported that victims have legal right for rehabilitation. It was found
more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal and Delhi.
More than half of the respondents reported that victim’s willingness is presumed. It was found
more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by West Bengal, Karnataka and Delhi (Table 7.35).
Table: 7.35
Whether Provisions in Legislation for Rehabilitation of the Victims are Adequate
Somewhat
State Adequate Inadequate No Response Total
Adequate
West Bengal 8 (32.0%) 8 (32.0%) 8 (32.0%) 1 (4.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 3 (16.7%) 11 (61.1%) 4 (22.2%) 0 (0.0%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 14 (41.2%) 8 (23.5%) 12 (35.3%) 0 (0.0%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 12 925.5%) 25 (53.2%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (21.3%) 47 (100%)
Assam 11 (31.4%) 9 (25.7%) 13 (37.1%) 2 (5.7%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 9 (19.6%) 16 (34.8%) 13 (28.3%) 8 (17.4%) 46 9100%)
Tamil Nadu 12 (36.4%) 13 (39.4%) 8 (24.2%) 0 (0.0%) 33 (100%)
Delhi 18 (42.9%) 10 (23.8%) 14 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 42 (100%)
 224

Total 87 (31.1%) 100 (35.7%) 72 (25.7%) 21 (7.5%) 280 (100%)

Source: Field Survey
About 1/3rd respondents reported that Law Provide for using Confiscated Proceeds of Crime
to Compensate Victims. It was found more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by Karnataka
(Table 7.36).
Table: 7.36
Whether Law Provide for Using Confiscated Proceeds of Crime to Compensate Victims
State Yes No Don’t Know Total
West Bengal 6 (24.0%) 1 (4.0%) 18 (72.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 10 (55.6%) 4 (22.2%) 4 (22.2%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 17 (50.0%) 1 (2.9%) 16 (47.1%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 12 (25.5%) 10 (21.3%) 25 (53.2%) 47 (100%)
Assam 11 (31.4%) 3 (8.6%) 21 (60.0%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 8 (17.4%) 4 (8.7%) 34 (73.9%) 46 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 11 (33.3%) 3 (9.1%) 19 (57.6%) 33 (100%)
Delhi 12 (28.6%) 4 (9.5%) 26 (61.9%) 42 (100%)
Total 87 (31.1%) 30 (10.7%) 163 (58.2%) 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents reported that police officials and NGOs have been trained to
assist in recovery and reintegration of victims of CSE. A significant proportion of respondents
further reported that judiciary, health care professionals, public prosecutors, teachers and
representatives of local government were also trained. Victims support and assistance; human
rights and legal rights of victims; legal provisions of trafficking; trafficking patterns and trend;
gender sensitivity, trafficking modus operandi, distinguishing trafficking from prostitution were
some of the important topics of training (Table 7.37).
Table: 7.37
Availability of Trained Professionals to Assist in Recovery and Reintegration of Victims of CSE
Name of Professionals Responses
Police Officials 202 (72.14%)
Public Prosecutors 61 (21.79%)
Judiciary 70 (25.0%)
Service NGOs 162 (57.86%)
Other NGOs 54 (19.29%)
Health Care Professionals 72 (25.71%)
PRIs 39 (13.93%)
Teachers 48 (17.14%)
Other 33 (11.79%)
Source: Field Survey
Community awareness, empowerment of women and girls, prone to trafficking, proactive
community policing, help line for women and children, penalties to perpetrators and clients of
victims and sensitization programme for SSHs were some of the most effective programmes in
combating human trafficking (Table 7.38)
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 225

Table: 7.38
Most Effective Programs in Combating Trafficking
Name of Programme Responses
Community Awareness 204 (72.86%)
Pro-Active Community Policing 114 (40.71%)
Empowerment of Women and Girls Prone to Trafficking 174 (62.14%)
Penalties To Perpetrators and Clients of Victims 105 (37.5%)
Confiscation, Forfeiture and Attachment of Property of Perpetrators 49 (17.5%)
Sensitization Programs for SSHs 76 (27.14%)
Helpline For Women and Children 109 (38.93%)
Other 42 (15.00%)
Source: Field Survey
More than half of the respondents reported that state activities on community understanding
of the issues of human trafficking have some improvement. However, more than 1/4th respondents
rated the state activities as noticeable and significant improvement in understanding of issues of
human trafficking (Table 7.39).
Table: 7.39
Impact of State Activities on Community Understanding of the Issues of Trafficking
Some Significant Noticeable
State Don’t Know Total
Improvement Improvement Improvement
West Bengal 15 (60.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (12.0%) 7 (28.0%) 25 (100%)
Maharashtra 9 (50.0%) 3 (16.7%) 4 (22.2%) 2 (11.1%) 18 (100%)
Karnataka 16 (47.1%) 3 (8.8%) 9 (26.5%) 6 (17.6%) 34 (100%)
Jharkhand 37 (78.7%) 10 (21.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 47 (100%)
Assam 15 (42.9%) 4 911.4%) 10 (28.6%) 6 (17.1%) 35 (100%)
Uttar Pradesh 26 (56.5%) 3 (6.5%) 5 (10.9%) 12 (26.1%) 46 (100%)
Tamil Nadu 15 (45.5%) 6 (18.2%) 9 (27.3%) 3 (9.1%) 33 (100%)
Delhi 22 (52.4%) 6 (14.3%) 10 (23.8%) 4 (9.5%) 42 (100%)
Total 155 (55.4%) 35 (12.5%) 50 (17.9%) 40 (14.3%) 280 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The most important district-level bodies for ensuring proper implementation of the JJ Act
are the CWCs and DCPUs. The legislation establishes CWCs as the final authority for the care,
treatment, protection, development, and rehabilitation of children in need of care and protection,
as well as for the resolution of all complaints involving these children, while ensuring that their
basic rights and needs are met.
In a number of districts, CWCs have not been constituted, and jurisdictional inconsistencies
cause uncertainty, preventing a huge number of vulnerable children from exercising their
entitlement to protection. Due to the size of the district, tough geographical topography or
remote accessibility, case overflow due to the district’s child profile, high population density,
and long stretches of international boundaries, extra CWCs must be established inside some
districts. Many beneficial provisions of the JJ Act and Model Rules, such as District/ City
Advisory Boards, District Child Protection Units, State/ District/ City Inspection Committees,
and Special Juvenile Police Units, have either not been established or are no longer operational
in the vast majority of districts.
 226

In terms of official appointment by Selection Committees, the majority of CWCs reviewed had
a complete five-member makeup. Poor attendance, on the other hand, is a cause for concern. In
rare circumstances, this might lead to extended absences. Recruitment is indefinitely postponed
where vacant positions/prolonged absenteeism exist, possibly resulting in the inability to obtain
a quorum for final decisions. In general, men are appointed to CWCs in greater numbers than
women. The majority of CWC members and Chairpersons in various States largely meet the
minimum eligibility requirements. However, in terms of a diversified and multidisciplinary
profile, an optimum CWC composition is lacking. People in the social work and education fields
appear to be overrepresented in CWCs, whereas those in the legal, medicine, and psychology
fields appear to be underrepresented. The selection of government officials as Chairpersons,
dual appointment of CWC and JJB membership, and dual CWC membership in two different
CWCs have all been identified as serious deviations and problems in the CWC recruiting process.
Recruitment of CWC members that could lead to a potential conflict of interest, such as people
affiliated with a residential child care facility being appointed as CWC members within the same
district, has also been highlighted.
Almost all of the CWCs were discovered to be functioning in insufficient settings, with
several being significantly insufficient. Within the JJ System, the concept of child-friendliness
has yet to be defined. Its deployment has largely gone unnoticed in both the CWC’s setup and
during the CWC’s sessions. A single fixed CWC sitting location was insufficient to reach out to
all children in the district who needed care and safety. Three types of sitting venue styles used by
some CWCs across the country have been discovered to address this issue. Additional unusual
sittings, such as rotating and parallel sittings, are available. However, each has its own set of
advantages and disadvantages. CWCs conduct sittings at irregular intervals and for varying
lengths of time. While some CWCs are found to meet the statutory three weekly sittings, the
majority of CWCs in the country only meet once or twice a week. There are also CWCs that
meet every two weeks, once a month, or whenever they are needed. The majority of CWCs do
not hold sittings for the necessary four hours mandated by law. Other than low caseload, CWC
sittings are being cut short for a variety of reasons, including members’ personal obligations
and employment commitments. Irregular member attendance and long periods of absence are
common in many CWCs, with the main causes being a lack of foolproof attendance monitoring,
members’ other professional commitments, and insufficient sitting allowance. There are currently
no processes in the Act or the Rules for case management during proceedings. While a few CWCs
manage proceedings and case flow successfully, others appear to be floundering and employing
inefficient/inappropriate techniques.
The removal of victims via raid and rescue has been discovered to be ineffective as an
intercepting method. Re-trafficking among the victims is a common occurrence. Victims are re-
introduced into their families, frequently under the premise of ‘reunification within the family,’
where they are re-exposed to the same spectrum of risk factors that led to their trafficking in the
first place. The elements that initiate Sex Trafficking (economic or monetary assistance, physical,
individual and family, and institutional factors) are also responsible for re-trafficking at later
stages, implying that the determinants of Sex Trafficking are positively correlated to rehabilitation/
reintegration. Poverty has been related to increased vulnerability to human trafficking, therefore
economic rehabilitation could be a crucial step toward effective reintegration. Because many
victims were victimized due to financial desperation, characteristics that encourage re-trafficking
exist if victims return home without any vocational skill training. Economic rehabilitation may
be a matter of life and death for some of the victims. As a result, even after reintegration into
Rehabilitation and Re-integration of Recued Victims 227

their home or community, they are likely to be trafficked again. Because the majority of victims
have only worked in the sex business, they require life and job skills training in order to acquire
and maintain employment. Job and life skills training are critical for a victim’s ability to achieve
financial independence and care for himself or herself.
Therefore, we argue that Economic Rehabilitations must be preferred over reunification with
families as Economic rehabilitation is beneficial not only for the victims’ means of subsistence, but
also for their self-esteem, which has a positive impact on their rehabilitation and reintegration.
 Chapter 8
ROLE AND PERCEPTION ANALYSIS OF
STAKEHOLDERS
“Women found in flesh trade, should be viewed more as victims of adverse socioeconomic
circumstances rather than an offender in our society The commercial exploitation of sex may
be regarded as a crime but those trapped in custom oriented prostitution and gender-oriented
prostitution should be viewed as victims of gender-oriented vulnerability”
-Gaurav Jains Vs Union of India
When the gender and age components of human trafficking are taken into account, the
image that emerges is one of ongoing mistreatment of children and women, particularly
girl children. Children are the most vulnerable and disenfranchised members of our society,
and they require protection and security as they face many forms of adversity. They require
special attention in policy and rehabilitation. The girl child is more affected than the boy child.
Children are frequently physically and psychologically exploited in situations where all social
security measures and internal mechanisms have failed completely. She becomes vulnerable
to prostitution trafficking, particularly if she has no one to safeguard her. There is a strong
undercurrent of gender prejudice and the exploitation that follows. This can only be handled
if the topic of gender is integrated into all relevant schemes, programmes, and policies. Anti-
trafficking measures, particularly those connected to prevention and rehabilitation, should
be integrated into all relevant departments’ policies and programmes. In the long run, such a
strategy can provide the necessary empowerment to women and children, particularly those in
vulnerable situations, by providing them with secure livelihood options, rights awareness, and
protection from exploitation. Human rights defence is, at its core, a defence of human dignity.
This chapter gives an overview of the policies and programmes implemented by the government,
the NHRC, the NCW, the NCPCR, and nongovernmental organizations.

NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION

The Protection of Human Rights Act of 1993 was enacted in response to a directive under
Article 51 of the Constitution, international commitments, and the international community’s
evolving approach to human rights. However, there has been an increase in concern in the country
and abroad about human rights issues. With this in mind, as well as changing social realities and
emerging trends in the nature of crime and violence, the government has been reviewing existing
laws, procedures, and administrative systems, as well as their transparency, and devising more
efficient and effective ways of dealing with the situation. The Protection of Human Rights Act,
1993, was enacted by the Indian Parliament, and it provided for the establishment of a National
 230

Human Rights Commission by the Union Government. The Commission gave special attention
to the rights of the most vulnerable, such as women and children, particularly young girls who
are victims of prostitution trafficking.
The National Human Rights Commission is completely committed to the fight against human
trafficking. There have been a number of projects in this direction. In 1998, the NHRC launched a
public awareness campaign on the topic of child prostitution and sexual abuse of minors, with the
support of UNICEF and other organizations. Following that, in collaboration with Prasar Bharati
and UNICEF, the Commission sponsored four workshops on Sexual Violence Against Children
and the Role of the Media. The NHRC issued guidelines for the media to handle the subject of
child prostitution and child sexual abuse as a result of this workshop. An Information Kit on
Trafficking in Women and Children was developed by the Commission’s Focal Point in order
to inform society on the various facets of trafficking - its forms, estimates, causes, consequences,
modus operandi, and role of the Commission. The Action Research on Trafficking of Women and
Children in India, which is being performed jointly by the NHRC, UNIFEM, and the Institute of
Social Sciences in New Delhi, is one of the programmes initiated by the NHRC. The NHRC aims
to establish an authentic database through action research in order to economically and socially
strengthen vulnerable communities in supply zones. It also seeks to educate the public and law
enforcement organizations about the grave hazards of human trafficking and the importance of
preventing it. In addition, the Commission seeks to improve laws and enforcement mechanisms
to penalize human traffickers, as well as rescue and rehabilitation programmes. It also wants to
assist NGOs in utilizing the Government of India’s National Plan of Action for this goal.
Under the joint jurisdiction of the NHRC and the DWCD, a manual on trafficking in women
and children is now being prepared for the judiciary. Workshops with Judicial Magistrates and
members of NGOs have been held in Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Goa, and Madhya Pradesh,
West Bengal, Orissa, Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Rajasthan, and Delhi for this purpose. Apart from
the anti-trafficking activities, the NHRC strives to make a training module on trafficking issues
to be included in training programmes for administrators, police officers, and other government
officials. The National Human Rights Commission has been working tirelessly to combat human
trafficking and has developed a Plan of Action to prevent and combat trafficking of women and
children. After incorporating recommendations from various regional workshops on the subject,
this Plan of Action evolved into an Integrated Plan of Action. A procedure and guidelines
have been developed by the Ministry of Women and Child Development and the National
Human Rights Commission for both police and civic society to follow when undertaking rescue
operations. In light of the information gap that exists about issues related to human trafficking
and the laws that govern it, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has decided to
issue a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) to fill that gap. This SOP also serves as a checklist of
the tasks that must be completed by the various entities tasked with fighting human trafficking.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR WOMEN

The National Commission for Women was established in 1990 by an Act of Parliament known
as the National Commission for Women Act (No. 20 of 1990) . Keeping in mind that commercial
sexual exploitation of children and trafficking of persons for commercial sex abuse are the most
serious forms of human rights violations, and that the number of adolescents entering the trade
is growing. The Commission’s main focus was the sexual exploitation of women and children.
As a result, studies were commissioned in various states to examine the scope of the problem,
which revealed an extremely bleak and dreadful situation. It conducted two investigations in the
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 231

late 1990s, named “The Lost Childhood” and “Velvet Blouse — Sexual Exploitation of Children.”
It conducted another study in 2001 called ‘Trafficking – A Socio-Legal Study.’ It later conducted
research on ‘Coastal Sex Tourism’ in 2004. It has also organized a number of seminars, training
programmes, and conferences on the issue of human trafficking in addition to these research
investigations. Based on the foregoing, it proposed changes to the ITPA in order to create a
comprehensive anti-trafficking law. Through its research, the NCW has learned that the network
includes not just traffickers, but also pimps and brothel owners who work in collusion with the
police. The state governments are acting quickly and effectively on NCW’s suggestions in order
to eradicate the scourge. Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are becoming more involved.
To prevent children from becoming involved in prostitution, NCW has enlisted the help of
prostitutes themselves. The women themselves have come up to say that they will be able to
stop it, and that the admission of children into this field would be addressed.’ They were also
prepared to inform the NCW on the State Commissions rather than the police about new entries.
NCW’s mission is to eliminate all forms of child prostitution. The commission had devised a ten-
year National Plan of Action to achieve this (1997-2006 A.D.). The NCW has long been concerned
about issues involving trafficking in women and girls.

NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR PROTECTION OF CHILD RIGHTS

The National Commission for the Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) was constituted as a
statutory body in March 2007 under the Commissions for the Protection of Child Rights Act, 2005
(4 of 2006), a Parliamentary Act (December 2005). NCPCR’s major responsibility is to safeguard,
promote, and defend children’s rights throughout the country. The mandate of the Commission is
to ensure that all laws, policies, programmes, and administrative mechanisms are consistent with
the Child Rights perspective as embodied in the Indian Constitution and the UN Convention on
the Rights of the Child. A child is someone who is between the ages of 0 and 18. The Commission
envisions a rights-based approach to national policies and programmes, as well as nuanced
responses at the state, district, and block levels, taking into account the unique characteristics
and capabilities of each region. The NCPCR plays an important role in safeguarding, promoting,
and defending children’s rights in the country. The mandate of the Commission is to ensure that
all laws, policies, programmes, and administrative mechanisms are consistent with the Child
Rights perspective as embodied in the Indian Constitution and the UN Convention on the Rights
of the Child.
The Commission’s focus is on tasks such as monitoring the implementation of the Protection
of Children from Sexual Offenses (POCSO) Act, 2012; monitoring the implementation of the JJ
Act 2015; monitoring the designation of Special Courts by State Governments; monitoring the
appointment of Public Prosecutors by State Governments; and monitoring the designation of
Special Courts by State Governments in order to achieve the Commission’s mandate of ensuring
that each and every child has access to all entitlements and enjoys all of her rights. A National
Conscience must be created that grabs each citizen’s imagination and inspires them to be proud
of their country because it looks after all of its children and performs many other jobs.
The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) recently advised states
to assist local bodies in mapping “vulnerability of households” so that parents are not forced
to “sell” their children to meet economic necessities. For the first time, the NCPCR, which is
part of the women and children ministry, has developed a methodology for a “family centric
strategy to counter child trafficking.” The body has also named locations in the country that have
 232

reported the most occurrences of child trafficking, as well as measures to prevent them, in a letter
addressed by the Union home ministry to the State to enforce the measures. In a letter to states,
the NCPCR recommended that governments map all vulnerable families, notably migrants
and children at risk, and link them to 37 government schemes to combat economic distress,
including the Atmanirbhar Yojana introduced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Following two
discussions, the letter with suggestions placed local governments and community organizations
in the forefront of the struggle, requesting that they keep a close eye on families with children.

MINISTRY OF WOMEN AND CHILD DEVELOPMENT

The Ministry of Women and Child Development, the Nodal Ministry in the Government of
India dealing with issues concerning women and children, drew up a National Action Plan based
on the report of the Central Advisory Committee on Child Prostitution, the recommendations of
the National Commission for Women, and the directions of the Supreme Court of India (orders
dated 2nd May 1990 and 9th July 1997), as well as the experiences of various non-governmental
organizations working in this area.
Besides combating human trafficking, the NPA prioritizes the rescue and rehabilitation of
victims of human trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation. Legal and law-enforcement
systems are activated under the National Plan of Action to strengthen the implementation of the
IPTA, 1956. Under Section 21 of the Immoral Trafficking Prevention Act (IIPA), the government
has built Protective Homes exclusively for girls and women jailed under the ITPA, as well as those
seeking protection from being pushed into commercial sexual exploitation. For the protection
and rehabilitation of victims, the Indian government has a vast network of around 351 short
stay institutions aided by the DWCD and juvenile homes established under the Juvenile Justice
Act. The Government of India has approved projects for the establishment of child development
centers in various high-crime regions under the Integrated Child Development Service Scheme
(ICDS).
In addition, the Ministry of Women and Child Development has collaborated with UNICEF on
research on the rescue and rehabilitation of child victims of commercial sexual exploitation. The
Ministry of Women and Child Development also issued a Protocol for Pre-Rescue, Rescue, and
Post-Rescue Operations of Child Victims of Commercial Sexual Exploitation. This Protocol
includes recommendations for state governments as well as a plan for Rescue Team Members
for pre-rescue, rescue, and post-rescue operations involving minors who have been victims of
human trafficking and have been sexually exploited for commercial purposes. The Ministry of
Women and Child Development has developed three manuals: “Manual for Judicial Workers on
Combating Trafficking of Women and Children for Commercial Sexual Exploitation,” “Manual
for Medical Officers for Dealing with Child Victims of Trafficking and Commercial Sexual
Exploitation,” and “Manual for Social Workers Dealing with Child Victims of Trafficking and
Commercial Sexual Exploitation” in collaboration with UNICEF and other organizations. The
National Human Rights Commission collaborated on the development of the Judicial Workers’
Manual.
The government is also debating whether a Central Nodal Authority should be established
under the Act to monitor interstate and cross-border trafficking issues. The government has taken
a two-pronged approach to combating human trafficking: raising awareness and empowering
women economically. There are two aspects to raising awareness. The first is intended at
educating key stakeholders in the fight against human trafficking, while the second is targeted
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 233

at educating the general public. Government officers from the relevant departments, police, the
judiciary, social workers, medical officers, women’s commissions, and media representatives
have all been highlighted as important stakeholders. The DWCD has also developed a model
grant-in-aid programme to support NGOs in preventing, rescuing, and rehabilitating victims
of human trafficking in source, transit, and destination locations. In collaboration with NGOs,
the DWCD has conducted regional efforts to raise awareness of the trafficking dimension and
promote sensitivity to trafficking victims among government departments, police, and judiciary,
as well as civil society at large.

MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS

Human trafficking is a critical issue that the Ministry of Home Affairs is worried about. The
Ministry of Home Affairs established a Nodal Cell for Trafficking Prevention in August/
September 2006. The major purpose of this Cell is to coordinate, network, and provide feedback
to state governments and other relevant agencies on a regular basis in order to prevent and
combat human trafficking. This Cell has also been charged with documenting “best practices”
in the prevention and battle of human trafficking, as well as sharing data inputs with other
stakeholders. The Cell proposes holding regular meetings with all stakeholders every quarter
to examine the overall status of trafficking in the country. The majority of law enforcement
is handled by the states. The MHA, on the other hand, is responsible for all law enforcement
matters, including the provisions of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act (ITPA) and particular
provisions of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Special enforcement agencies such as the Central
Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Border Security Force (BSF), and the National Bureau for Crime
Records, which compiles crime statistics, are also under the MHA’s umbrella. The MEA is in
charge of international conventions and protocols that deal with human trafficking. The Ministry
of Labour and Employment is responsible for all aspects of labour law enforcement, as well as
the rehabilitation and repatriation of child labourers.
On the 20th of September, 2018, a National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (www.cybercrime.
gov.in) was launched, allowing users to report online content relating to Child Pornography/
Child Sexual Abuse Material or sexually graphic content such as Rape/Gang-Rape Content. On
the 30th of August, 2019, a revised portal was established in conjunction with stakeholders to allow
residents to report all forms of cyber-crimes, with a special focus on cyber-crimes against women
and children. Several initiatives have been taken to raise awareness about cyber-crime, including the
distribution of cyber-crime awareness messages via SMS, the MHA’s Twitter handle @CyberDost,
a radio campaign, and the publication of a Handbook for Adolescents/Students, among others. A
Website on Anti Human Trafficking (stophumantrafficking-mha.nic.in) was launched in February
2014. It is a vital IT tool for sharing information among stakeholders, States/UTs and civil society
organizations for effective implementation of Anti-Human trafficking measures. The MHA accepted
a plan to construct 332 Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) in various districts across the country
as part of its project “Strengthening law enforcement response in India against trafficking in persons
via training and capacity building.” The Ministry assists states in establishing AHTUs by providing
financial assistance. 264 AHTUs have been established across the country so far.

STATE MECHANISM TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING

State governments have concentrated on preventing human trafficking and have enacted
particular legislation to combat it within their borders. There are various specific laws dealing
with human trafficking of women and children, forced labour, cultural exploitation, and religious
 234

exploitation. In Chapter 2, there is a more in-depth discussion.

ROLE OF JUDICIARY
The Supreme Court, as well as the High Courts of each state, have taken a lead role in ensuring
that the state responds to human trafficking cases. In this section, we’ll look at some of the most
important cases from both courts in a nutshell. The Ministry of Women and Child Development
established a committee to study the viability of a comprehensive legislation on trafficking in
2016, in response to a Supreme Court judgement (Prajwala vs. Union of India 2016 (1) SCALE
298). Vishal Jeet Vs. Union of India AIR 1990 SC 1412: was a landmark decision where the
Supreme Court took it upon itself to give directions for the protection and rehabilitation of those
who had been dedicated as devdasis by their families or communities for cultural reasons and
were currently in prostitution. In Gaurav Jain vs. Union of India (1997 (8) SCC 114), the court
affirmed that the State had a duty to rescue, rehabilitate and enable women to lead a life of dignity.
In response to Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in W.P. (C) No. 565/2012 titled Nipun Saxena Vs.
Union of India, National Legal Services Authority Committee has finalized the Compensation
Scheme for women Victims/Survivors of Sexual Assault/other Crimes WP 75/2012, Bachpan
th
Bachao Andolan v. Union of India, On 10 May, 2013 the Supreme Court ordered the police
to file a FIR in every case of a missing child apart from other measures of strengthening the
juvenile justice mechanism. The Jharkhand Government as well as the CID have passed orders in
pursuance of this order. WP 82/2009, Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India: This petition
highlighted the plight of children from various parts of the country trafficked to Delhi, especially
through placement agencies for domestic labour. The Supreme Court ordered for the registration
and then regulation of placement agencies. In pursuance of this the Delhi Government passed
th
and order on 25 September, 2014 issuing directions for the regulation of placement agencies in
Delhi. This requires a domestic worker to be above the age of 18 years. All placement agencies
are to register with the Labour Department under the Delhi Shops and Establishment Act, 1954
and then also apply for a license to run a placement agency. An important provision under this
order is of opening bank accounts for the domestic workers where their salary will be deposited.
WP 139/2011, Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. State of Jharkhand and Ors. This petition dealt with
the paucity of shelter homes in the state of Jharkhand. The High Court directed for constitution
of Child Welfare Committees, Children’s Homes, Shelter Homes, etc. Jharkhand State Action
Plan for Elimination of Child Labour formulated in pursuance of this order.
There are several other landmark judgements which are torch bearers in combating human
trafficking, discussed in details in chapter-2.

ROLE OF NGOS IN THE AREA OF EXPLOITATION AND TRAFFICKING:

Civil society organizations have made significant contributions to the fight against human
trafficking. Many of the groups working on trafficking issues aren’t just anti-trafficking
organizations; they also address it as part of their efforts to prevent HIV, improve public health,
and protect human rights. However, there are a number of non-governmental organizations
(NGOs) and networks of NGOs that solely focus on human trafficking. The majority of these
NGOs focus on prevention, with only a few focusing on prosecution of criminals, presumably as
a result of the authorities’ lack of cooperation.
NGO interventions aimed at preventing human trafficking have focused on sites where
trafficked people originate, transit, or end up. Awareness-raising and social mobilization,
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 235

community networking and surveillance, capacity-building and training, and empowerment

through formal and informal education, income production, and job training are just a few of the
activities. NGOs have conducted rallies, lectures, street theatre performances, and preventative
camps to raise awareness and sensitize communities. They’ve started neighbourhood support
groups and peer education programmes, as well as hosting TV and radio shows. Some have
attempted to reach out to influential adults in the community, such as by establishing inter-
religious Priests Forums, which bring priests together to denounce trafficking, and forums
that raised trafficking awareness among representatives from gramme panchayats, schools,
and government-run hostels (MOWCD and UNODC, 2008). Women and minor girls have also
benefited from life skills education in trafficking-prone communities, as well as skill building and
economic empowerment efforts that provide women and minor girls with alternative sources of
income.
In terms of rescue, the ITPA mandates the presence of representatives from civil society
organizations during police rescue operations. The pan-Indian ATSEC network, Prajwala
in Hyderabad, Prerana and Rescue Foundation in Mumbai, Saarthak and STOP in Delhi,
and Sanlaap in West Bengal, DSS in Ranchi, IJM in Banglore are among the NGOs that help
authorities undertake raids and subsequent rescues of children in CSE. The majority of these set
up and use networks to find minors in brothels, then perform raids with the police to rescue the
youngsters. Raids on brothels are difficult for NGOs because of safety concerns and the potential
for information about future raids to reach brothel operators. NGOs, on the other hand, have
been successful in collaborating with police officers who have been educated on the concerns
surrounding human trafficking. NGOs also assist rescued minor girls in securing their items
from the brothel, keeping traffickers at bay, and ensuring that police procedures are followed
correctly so that they are not further disadvantaged. Several non-governmental organizations
(NGOs) provide legal assistance in cases of human trafficking.
It has also been attempted to collectivize sex workers to combat trafficking by forming
vigilance committees or self-regulatory bodies from among themselves. Because they are insiders
and can better grasp the issue, the Durbar Mahila Samanwaya Committee (DMSC), a sex workers’
organization in Kolkata, has a self-regulatory body to rescue minors or women trafficked into
brothels. The institutionalization of self-regulatory groups has contributed to a drop of nearly
90% in the number of minors in CSE in the Sonagachi area, according to one research based on
programme monitoring data (Jana et al., 2013). Despite these attempts, minor females continue
to work in brothels, according to evidence (George, Vindhya and Ray, 2010). By default, since
predominantly minor girls are trafficked and coerced into sex slavery, the structural origins of
prostitution and the modus operandi remain the same across the country. India has the biggest
number of individuals living in modern slavery, according to the Global Slavery Index 2018. A
Public Interest Litigation has also been filed in the Hon’ble Supreme Court for the immediate
rescue of 1.2 million juvenile girls from brothels across the country.
In terms of protecting rescued girls, various NGOs work with the government to create
shelter homes where rescued trafficking women and underage girls can stay. Some shelters
focus just to children, while others serve both women and underage girls. In the shelter homes,
kids are offered opportunities to build peer networks and develop self-confidence, as well as
rehabilitation and reintegration. NGOs have concentrated on identifying traffickers at transit
locations along the Nepal border as well as at interstate crossings as part of their prosecution
efforts. Volunteers engage with local police and informants to identify human traffickers, or they
 236

interview migrants who fit the victim profile. Unfortunately, there has been a lack of conventional
programme monitoring and evaluation processes and only a few NGOs have released reports
detailing their operations, successes, and challenges.

ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL AGENCIES

The United Nations system has taken a significant step forward in organizing a global
response against human trafficking. The United Nations General Assembly has approved a
package of instruments to combat various forms of transnational organized crime, including the
UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime and the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress,
and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Particularly Women and Children. Various UN organizations
and organs, such as UNIFEM, UNICEF, ILO, UNDP, and UNODC, have been active in the fight
against human trafficking.
Since 1992, the International Programme for the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) has
been working to combat child trafficking inside the ILO. IPEC aims to effectively eliminate child
trafficking by addressing its core causes, guided by the United Nations Convention on the Rights
of the Child and ILO Convention 182. The UNICEF strategy for combating child trafficking focuses
on four primary areas: (1) increasing public knowledge of the problem, (2) providing financial
assistance to families, (3) improving access to and quality of education, and (4) advocating for
children’s rights. The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) is in charge of crime
prevention, criminal justice, and criminal law reform within the United Nations. It focuses on
tackling transnational organized crime, corruption, and human trafficking in particular. The
UNODC developed the Global Programme against Human Trafficking (GPAT) in partnership
with the United Nations Inter-Regional Crime and Justice Research Institute (UNICJRI) and
launched it in March 1999. The work of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
in the area of human trafficking is guided by two fundamental principles: (1) human rights must
be at the heart of any credible anti-trafficking strategy, and (2) such strategies must be developed
and implemented from the perspective of those who need their human rights protected and
promoted the most.
UNIFEM began working on the subject of human trafficking in 1991, and for the first few
years, it focused on building an appropriate conceptual framework for dealing with the problem
in South Asia. At UNIFEM’s First Ministerial-Level Regional Biennial Review of the Beijing
PFA in South Asia, trafficking was noted as a particular source of concern (1996). NGOs and
governments agreed that UNIFEM, given its strategic position and unique cross-cutting mandate
to address gender-related challenges, should priorities the elimination of human trafficking of
women and children as a regional priority intervention. The United Nations Economic and Social
Commission for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP) conducted comprehensive research to enhance
awareness of the many legal tools available to states to combat human trafficking. On December
19, 2003, at the United Nations Conference Centre in Bangkok, it was released as a resource
guide. Because they are frequently subjected to a variety of physical and psychological health
problems, UNAIDS has identified trafficked persons as a category that is extremely vulnerable
to HIV/AIDS exposure. In more than 100 nations, the United States Agency for International
Development (USAID) provides economic and humanitarian aid. It has prioritized human
trafficking as a major source of concern. President George W. Bush formed the President’s Inter-
Agency Task Force to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons under the Trafficking Victims
Protection Act of 2000. AusAID has identified human trafficking as a major source of concern
and is launching anti-trafficking programmes as soon as possible. By lowering the incidence
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 237

of violence against women and eliminating trafficking and its harmful impacts on women and
girls in Nepal, The Asia Foundation aspires to promote women’s prospects for full involvement
in social, political, and economic life. One of the Population Council’s responses to the HIV
epidemic in South and East Asia, among other issues, has been to work on human trafficking of
women and girls.
The COVID-19 is posing new issues for migrant protection, and it is well recognized that
the pandemic has varied effects on males, women, and children, especially adolescents. All
parties must join hands and work together to tackle the evil of human trafficking.” Stakeholder
engagement in the implementation of anti-trafficking policies and service solutions has been
extensively researched.

Perception Analysis of Stakeholders:

Poverty, uneven development, social discrimination, gender-based violence, family or
marital separation or dysfunction, lack of educational or economic opportunity, poor social
infrastructure, a lack of awareness of trafficking, and cultural practices that sanction or tolerate
trafficking are all recognized as major contributors to trafficking vulnerability in India. While
much attention has been paid to the factors that influence human trafficking vulnerability, such
as poverty and uneven development, conflict, and gender inequality, the debate over what causes
these elements to exist in the first place has received less attention.
We agreed that notions of vulnerability have fed into discourses of mobility, migration, and
movement associated with trafficking as well as climate-induced migration and displacement
during Focused Group Discussions with Victims and Service Providers in West Bengal, with
implications for what kinds of responses are envisioned and carried out. Climate adaptation
plans are being called for to account for migration and displacement outcomes and manage
people flows, just as traditional anti-trafficking efforts continue to prioritize border security
and criminal law responses, despite the fact that existing frameworks are deemed inadequate
to deal with the complexity of such issues. Climate change-related vulnerability, which involves
uneven, uncertain, and complex processes that are influenced by a variety of factors, does not fit
neatly into current criminal justice-based anti-trafficking initiatives, which are based on limited
evidence and understandings of vulnerability, target individual perpetrators, and produce visible
results quickly. Despite the fact that anti-trafficking, like climate change, has been a contentious
issue, both arenas are dominated by powerful interests who are unwilling to account for and
address specific forms and dynamics of capitalism, as well as capital and state relations, that
structure conditions of insecurity and exploitation. The Sundarbans region of West Bengal has
been characterized as both particularly sensitive to climate change and vulnerable to human
trafficking.
Trafficking vulnerabilities are shown in Table 8.1. Poverty, lack of means of livelihood, many
girl children, lack of education, child marriages, and domestic violence are some of the major
trafficking vulnerabilities. However, trafficking vulnerabilities vary across the stakeholders such
as victims, law enforcement agencies and traffickers.
 238

Table 8.1
Trafficking Vulnerabilities

Trafficking Vulnerabilities Victims Law EAs Traffickers

Child Marriages 127 (11.0%) 45 (48.4%) 29 (59.2%)
Domestic Violence 244 (21.1%) 38 (40.9%) 22 (44.9%)
Lack of Education 274 (23.7%) 84 (90.3%) 34 (69.4%)
Many Girl Children 114 (9.9%) 54 (58.1%) 41 (83.7%)
Dowry Harassment 53 (4.6%) 8 (8.6%) 0 (0.0%)
Alcoholic Husband 98 (8.5%) 16 (17.2%) 8 (16.3%)
Poverty 974 (84.3%) 85 (91.39%) 39 (79.59%)
Natural Calamities 53 (4.6%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Military Operations 2 (0.2%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Male Dominance 104 (9.0%) 25 (26.9%) 2 (4.1%)
Lack of Means of Livelihood 559 (48.4%) 88 (94.6%) 41 (83.67%)
Others 3 (0.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Poverty, globalization, social behaviours, natural calamities, and government are all major
influences on the supply side of people trafficking. The demand side of trafficking, on the other
hand, is determined by factors such as labour demand in industries such as commercial sex
work (CSW), brick manufacturers, and so on. Given the interdependence of demand and supply,
addressing both types of facts has been critical in India’s fight against human trafficking. Economic
marginalization resulting in the breakdown of traditional livelihoods, low status of women and
girls in society, insufficient educational and employment opportunities due to gender disparities,
lucrative business with low investment, high monetary returns attracting crime syndicates,
economic disparities between countries and regions, migration of women into the labour market
resulting in channels of Traditions and religious practices in some communities of dedicating
girls to GOD & Goddess, Poverty, as well as gender discrimination, domestic abuse/violence,
organized crime/weak law enforcement, societal inequity, and cultural customs, are also supply
side elements in human trafficking (Table 8.2).
Table 8.2
Supply Side Reasons of Trafficking

Law Enforcement Programs

Supply Side Reasons Victims
Agencies Administrators
Poverty coupled with Gender Discrimination 425 (36.8%) 87 (93.5%) 266 995.0%)
Domestic Abuse/Violence 293 (25.4%) 31 933.3%) 111 (39.6%)
Search For a Better Life 865 (74.9%) 37 (39.7%) 72 (25.7%)
Desire To Travel 179 (15.5%) 17 (18.2%) 23 (8.21%)
Organized Crime/Poor Law Enforcement 153 (13.2%) 23 (24.7%) 104 (37.1%)
Systemic Inequalities/ Cultural Practices 88 (7.6%) 27 (29.0%) 83 (29.6%)
Military Conflict 31 (2.7%) 0 (0.0%) 0 90.0%)
Environmental Disasters 12 (1.0%) 11 (11.8%) 37 (13.2%)
Others 17 (1.5%) 9 (9.6%) 39 (13.9%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 280 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 239

The demand side of human trafficking is influenced by industrialization, rural-to-urban

migration, particularly of males, expanding commercial sex industry, demand for service of
sex workers, preferences for young and virgin girls due to fear of HIV/AIDS, cheap labour of
children and women, male-dominated value system in society, and STD removal by sex with
girl before menstrual cycle. Poverty, lack of knowledge and awareness, low socio-economic
status-inequalities, inadequacy in legislation are all push/pull factors. The lack of a strong law
enforcement apparatus, Discrimination and women’s status Modern life style, urbanization,
migration, lucrative earning desire, achieving of status in society, and other push or pull factors
for human trafficking include: commoditization of children in the market economy, growth
of tourism and unsafe migration, modern life style, urbanization, migration, lucrative earning
desire, achieving of status in society, and so on.
Some of the demand side elements responsible for human trafficking include inexpensive
labour, cheap domestic servants / maids, demand for women’s sexual activities, and derived
demand - profit and money created by third parties including recruiters (Table 8.3).
Table 8.3
Demand Side Reasons of Trafficking

Programs
Demand Side Reasons Victims Law EAs
Administrators
Demand For Women’s Sexual Services of Women, Girls and Boys 763 (66.1%) 37 (39.7%) 147 (52.5%)
Derived Demand-Profit and Revenue Generated by Third Parties involved In
233 (20.2%) 69 (74.1%) 141 (50.36%)
the Trafficking Process (Recruiters, Travel Agents, Transporters)
Cheap Labour Force 429 (37.1%) 57 (61.2%) 177 (63.2%)
Cheap Domestic Servant / Maid 394 (34.1%) 63 (67.7%) 163 (58.2%)
Organized Begging/ Other Crimes 106 (9.2%) 7 (7.5%) 17 (6.1%)
Child Pornography 23 (2.0%) 5 (5.3%) 13 (4.6%)
Others 24 (2.1%) 4 (4.3%) 11 (3.9%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 280 (100%)

Source: Field Survey

It all comes down to transportation and how traffickers’ routes work. People who have
been trafficked tend to migrate from less developed places to more developed areas. Routes
are classified into three categories: origin, transit, and destination. Routes are also mentioned in
some reports as gathering and dispersal places. Nepal and Bangladesh are two major suppliers
in India, and the ease with which traffickers traverse borders is well known. Women are detained
in West Bengal and Orissa once they arrive in India. They may be sold to pimps or sent to the
Middle East, Kolkata, Delhi, Mumbai, and Agra after being ‘sorted out or graded.’ ADB (2002)
and Shamim (2001) conducted studies that detail the trafficking pathways in these areas.
Multi-mode transport, public transport as well as private transport is some of the common
modes of transportation used for human trafficking (Table 8.4).
Table 8.4
Modes of Transports used For Human Trafficking

Mode of Transport Victims Law EAs Traffickers Parents

Public Transport 672 (58.2%) 13 (14.0%) 1 (2.0%) 167 (40.6%)
Private Transport 212 (18.4%) 12 (12.9%) 5 (10.2%) 76 (18.5%)
Personal Transport 10 (0.9%) 1 (1.1%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (0.7%)
 240

Multimode 251 (21.7%) 82 (88.2%) 43 (87.8%) 146 (35.5)

Others 10 (0.9%) 1 (1.1%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (0.2%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%) 411 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Without a doubt, sexual exploitation trafficking, like other kinds of human trafficking,
begins at the source, continues during the transit(s), and ends at the destination. It doesn’t
end until the person is rescued. There may be several changes of destination, but the offence
continues in each of them. To comprehend the difficulties and dimensions of human trafficking,
it is necessary to understand the paths involved. Human trafficking, like any other business,
relies on transit systems to function. Traffickers recruit victims at bus and railway stations, and
they use transportation networks to convey current victims to different locations where they
would be trafficked and abused. For many survivors attempting to flee their trafficking scenario,
transportation is a major barrier.
Individual sex traffickers, or pimps, hunt for opportunities to recruit whenever and wherever
they can, but bus stops and railway stations are particularly good trawling grounds, as they are
brimming with vulnerable people with spare time. The proliferation of runaway or homeless
youth who tend to congregate in these venues is of particular interest to traffickers, either because
they are looking for ways to leave their current living situation or because they have nowhere
else to go, and transit hubs often serve as a last resort shelter. Any offer that does not require a
runaway youth to return to the place they are attempting to flee is likely to be at least moderately
appealing. While participants in focus groups claimed that traffickers preferred the flexibility
and relative obscurity of ground transportation to air travel when executing their business, a
large percentage of survey respondents said they flew at some point during their exploitation.
TAT (Truckers Against Trafficking) and BOT (Bus Operators Against Trafficking) are two
initiatives that could help India combat human trafficking. During Focused Group Discussions
with Law Enforcement Agencies in Bengaluru, Karnataka, the Commissioner of Railway
Protection Force stated that the Railway Protection Force (RPF) is a critical stakeholder in the
fight against human trafficking because railway is a very cheap mode of transportation, with
widespread connectivity, a large crowd, and atomicity, making it easy for traffickers to use this
mode for trafficking. Because traffickers are fully aware that the RPF lacks the authority to deal
with trafficking cases, they can easily influence the RPF. He proposed that the RPF be given
authority over the registration and filing of trafficking cases whenever they fall under railway
jurisdiction. He also suggested linking khoya paya to an android-based application. The railway
is the only mode of transportation that connects India’s length and breadth. Giving railways
more power may result in a reduction in crime rates and a reduction in the strain on local police
stations. For example, RPF’s Operation Nanhe Farishte, run by Southern Railway, was a huge
success and should be replicated across India.
By road, multi routes and by train are common routes of transportation being used for human
trafficking (Table 8.5).
Table 8.5
Routes of Transports used For Human Trafficking
Route of Transport Victims Law EAs Traffickers
By Air 1 (0.1%) 3 (3.2%) 1 (2.04%)
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 241

By Road 660 (57.1%) 8 (8.6%) 21 (42.85%)

By Train 146 (12.6%) 12 (12.9%) 11 (22.44%)
Multi Route 348 (30.1%) 66 (70.9%) 16 (32.65%)
Sea Routes 0 (0.0%) 4 (4.3%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Hoteliers or those in control of hotels, residential homes, guest houses, and other establishments
where exploitation occurs. There has been shifting of places of human trafficking for commercial
sexual exploitation. Near bus station, brothel house/export service, Flats in apartments, private
houses, lodges and beauty/massage parlous are some of the important functioning places as per
perception of main stakeholders (Table 8.6).
Table 8.6
Type of Functioning Place for Human Trafficking

Functioning Place Victims Law EAs Parents Traffickers

Private House 603 (52.2%) 74 (79.6%) 192 (46.7%) 14 (29.2%)
Lodgers 232 (20.1%) 31 (33.3%) 115 (27.9%) 12 (25.0%)
Brothel House/Escort Service 303 (26.2%) 77 (82.8%) 0 (0.0%) 19 (39.6%)
Flats in Apartments 281 (24.3%) 46 (49.5%) 43 (10.5%) 14 (29.2%)
Near Bus Station 84 (7.3%) 17 (18.3%) 19 (4.6%) 21 (43.8%)
Near Railway Station 87 (7.5%) 31 (33.3%) 22 (5.4%) 1 (2.1%)
Beauty / Massage Parlour 39 (3.4%) 75 (80.6%) 0 (0.0%) 8 (16.7%)
Drug Busts/Others 75 (6.5%) 1 (1.1%) 1 (0.2%) 8 (16.7%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 411 (100%) 48 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Recruitment, transportation, transfer, harboring and receipt of persons are some of the
major activities involved in trafficking. However, trafficking process activities vary across the
stakeholders such as law enforcement agencies’, victims and traffickers (Table 8.7).
Table 8.7
Trafficking Process Activities

Activity Victims Law EAs Traffickers

Recruitment 1031 (89.3%) 85 (91.4%) 31 (63.2%)
Transportation 514 (44.5%) 87 (93.5%) 4 (8.2%)
Transfer 397 (34.4%) 83 (89.2%) 3 (6.1%)
Harbouring 99 (8.6%) 44 (47.3%) 8 (16.3%)
Receipt of Persons 110 (9.5%) 27 (29.0%) 3 (6.1%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Traffickers are skilled at using a variety of abilities and methods, from persuasion to
kidnapping. The victims were occasionally drugged or kidnapped, and other times they were
befriended and deceived. Fake employment and bogus marriages are the most prevalent ways
they entice people. Low-income people are given dowry-free marriages, and they fall into the trap
 242

of human trafficking. Many level players are involved in human trafficking, which reinforces the
organized crime. Police, administrative officials, railways and bus authorities or personnel, taxi/
auto rickshaw drivers or rickshaw pullers are all connected in some way. Investors or financiers,
procurers or recruiters, document forgers, protectors or corrupt public officials, brothel operators,
and tour guides are some of the roles they play. Abuse of vulnerability/promise and offering
money / jobs, allurement/ be funding / enticing with attractive offers, deception, fraud making,
false promises of marriage, physical force / use of force and threats were some of the modus
operandi of traffickers (Table 8.8).
Table 8.8
Modus Operandi of Traffickers- Mean & Methods Adopted for Trafficking
Means & Methods Victims Law EAs Parents Traffickers
Threat 372 (32.2%) 31 (33.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Physical Force/Use of Force 250 (21.6%) 46 (49.5%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Coercion 59 (5.1%) 33 (35.5%) 0 (0.0%) 10 (20.4%)
Abduction/ Kidnapping 42 (3.6%) 23 (24.7%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Fraud- Making False Promises of Marriage 110 (9.5%) 83 (89.2%) 32 (7.8%) 4 (8.2%)
Deception 382 (33.1%) 44 (47.3%) 3 (0.7%) 0 (0.0%)
Abuse of Power 130 (11.3%) 30 (32.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Abuse of Position 115 (10.0%) 28 (30.1%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Abuse of Vulnerability/ Promised and or offering
796 (68.9%) 86 (92.5%) 171 (41.6%) 39 (79.6%)
Money/Jobs
Advance Financial Payment 106 (9.2%) 72 (77.4%) 8 (1.9%) 0 (0.0%)
Allurement/ Befriending/ Enticing with Attractive
549 (47.5%) 78 (83.9%) 130 (31.6%) 25 (51.0%)
Offers
Blackmailing By Photo Editing 15 (1.3%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 411 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
People are recruited at many crowded places like railway stations or bus stops, cinema
halls with other places like cafes, beauty parlours. The construction sites and state and national
highways are also where people are recruited. Work place, home and public place area the major
locations and logistics from where trafficking is being performed (Table 8.9).
Table 8.9
Where Are from Trafficking Location and Logistics
Location Victims Traffickers Law EAs
For From Home 517 (44.8%) 15 (30.6%) 47 (50.5%)
Public Place 415 (35.9%) 6 (12.2%) 36 (38.70%)
Work Place 136 (11.8%) 23 (46.9%) 51 (54.8%)
Friends Home 54 (4.7%) 4 (8.2%) 7 (7.5%)
Other Locations 33 (2.9%) 1 (2.0%) 5 (5.3%)
Total 1155 (100%) 49 (100%) 93 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
An examination of the available records and reports on human trafficking reveals that
trafficked women and children are forced to engage in activities such as prostitution in brothels,
massage parlours, or beer bars, pornography, dancing, petty crimes, domestic help, agricultural
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 243

labour, begging organ trade, and drug trafficking. Human trafficking’s main goals include sexual
exploitation / prostitution, labour exploitation, slavery / servitude, unlawful adoption and force
marriage, and child pornography (Table 8.10).
Table: 8.10
Purpose and Intention of Trafficking

Purpose & Intention Victims Law EAs Traffickers

Sexual Exploitation/ Prostitutions 884 (76.5%) 92 (98.9%) 42 (85.7%)
Labour Exploitation 523 (45.3%) 83 (89.2%) 41 (83.7%)
Slavery/ Servitude 146 (12.6%) 21 (22.6%) 36 (73.46%)
Removal of Organs 8 (0.7%) 11 (11.8%) 0 (0.0%)
Organized Begging 35 (3.0%) 17 (18.3%) 0 (0.0%)
Criminal Activities 65 (5.6%) 12 (12.9%) 0 (0.0%)
Illegal Adoptions 34 (2.9%) 48 (51.6%) 3 (6.1%)
Forced Marriages 38 (3.3%) 52 (55.9%) 0 (0.0%)
Child Pornography 30 (2.6%) 47 (50.5%) 0 (0.0%)
Others 10 (0.9%) 3 (3.2%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Trafficking happens through organized national networks, local trafficking rings or by
occasional traffickers. They may act alone or in small groups. Organized groups, small localized
crime network, local gang and syndicates with PAN India connection are some of the type of
organizations and groups involved in human trafficking (Table 8.11).
Table 8.11
Type of Organization and Groups Involved in Human Trafficking

Groups Victims Law EAs Traffickers

Organized Group Involved 607 (52.6%) 62 (66.7%) 34 (69.4%)
Local Gangs 446 (38.6%) 26 (28.0%) 5 (10.2%)
Small Localized Crime Networks 126 (10.9%) 24 (25.8%) 14 (28.6%)
Syndicates with Pan India Connections 42 (3.6%) 25 (26.9%) 4 (8.2%)
Others 17 (1.5%) 1 (1.1%) 0 (0.0%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 49 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Poverty, poor law enforcement, negligible penalties, corruption, inadequate laws, gender
inequalities, social customs and domestic violence are the main reasons for non-stoppable
trafficking (Table 8.12).
Table 8.12
Reasons For Non-Stoppable Trafficking

Reasons Victims Law EAs Public Prosecutors

Inadequate Laws 192 (16.6%) 16 (17.2%) 13 (44.8%)
Poor Law Enforcement 283 (24.5%) 24 (25.8%) 23 (79.3%)
Negligible Penalties 80 (6.9%) 32 (34.4%) 19 (65.5%)
Corruption 177 (15.3%) 13 (14.0%) 17 (58.6%)
 244

Poverty 1009 (87.4%) 86 (92.5%) 25 (86.2%)

Gender Inequality 143 (12.4%) 39 (41.9%) 13 (44.8%)
Domestic Violence 186 (16.1%) 30 (32.3%) 9 (31.0%)
Social Customs/Evils 76 (6.6%) 54 (58.1%) 13 (44.8%)
Others 15 (1.3%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (10.3%)
Total 1155 (100%) 93 (100%) 29 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
A negligible proportion of respondents were found aware of National Human Rights
Commission. The awareness level was found slightly significant among women and children
victims followed by clients (Table 8.13).
Table 8.13
Stakeholders Wise Awareness about National Human Rights Commission (NHRC)

Category of Stakeholders Yes No Total

Women and Children Victim 61 (5.3%) 1094 (94.7%) 1155 (100%)
Recruiters/Traffickers & Brothel Keepers 0 (0.0%) 96 (100%) 96 (100%)
Parents of Victims 3 (0.7%) 408 (99.3%) 411 (100%)
Clients of CSWs 3 (4.8%) 60 (95.2%) 63 (100%)
Total 67 (3.9%) 1658 (96.1%) 1725 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
The main sources of information about NHRC were reported to be NGOs followed by print
media and electronic media (Table 8.14).
Table 8.14
Stakeholders Wise Source of Information About NHRC

Print
Electronic
Category of Govt. Media- Friends /
NGOs Media- Total
Stakeholders Offices News Relatives
Television Etc.
Papers Etc.

Women and Children 1 2 56 2 0 61

Victims 1.6% 3.3% 91.8% 3.3% 0.0% 100%
0 1 1 0 1 3
Parents
0.0% 33.3% 33.3% 0.0% 33.3% 100%
0 3 0 0 0 3
Client
0.0% 100% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100%
1 6 57 2 1 67
Total
1.5% 9.0% 85.1% 3.0% 1.5% 100%

Source: Field Survey

About 56 per cent respondents were partially aware of role and functions of NHRC. It was
found more pronouncing among the parents followed by women and children victim, law
enforcement agencies and clients. Slightly more than 1/3rd respondents were found fully aware
of role and functions of NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among the public prosecutors
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 245

followed by programme administrators. About 1/3rd clients and more than 1/4th service providers
were not aware at all about the roles and functions of NHRC (Table 8.15).
Table 8.15
Stakeholders wise level of awareness about Role & Functions of NHRC
Category Of Stakeholders Partially Aware Fully Aware Not Aware Total
Women & Children Victims 58 (95.1%) 2 (3.3%) 1 (1.6%) 61 (100%)
Parents 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Clients 2 (66.7%) 0 (0.0%) 1 (33.3%) 3 (100%)
Public Prosecutors 13 (44.8%) 16 (55.2%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Programs Administrators 138 (49.2%) 142 (50.7%) 0 (0.0%) 280 (100%)
Law Enforcement Agencies 59 (63.4%) 22 (23.7%) 12 (12.9%) 93 (100%)
Service Providers/NGOs 73 (49.7%) 33 (22.4%) 41 (27.9%) 147 (100%)
Total 346 (56.1%) 215 (34.9%) 55 (8.9%) 616 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
About 45 per cent respondents were found aware that a complaint regarding human
trafficking may be directly filed with NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among parents
followed by public prosecutors and service providers. However, all the respondents from women
and children victims followed by clients and majority of the respondents from law enforcement
agencies and service providers were not aware about the fact (Table 8.16).
Table 8.16
Whether a Complaint Regarding Human Trafficking Can Be Directly Filed With NHRC
Category of Stakeholders Aware Not Aware Total
Women and Children Victim 0 (0.0%) 61 (100%) 61 (100%)
Parents 3 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%)
Clients 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 3 (100%)
Public Prosecutors 29 (100%) 0 (0.0%) 29 (100%)
Programs Administrators 168 (60.0%) 112 (40.0%) 280 (100%)
Law Enforcement Agencies 22 (23.7%) 71 (76.3%) 93 (100%)
Service Providers/NGOs 55 (37.4%) 92 (62.6%) 147 (100%)
Total 277 (45.0%) 339 (55.0%) 616 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
About 20 per cent respondents were found aware of the mode of filling of a complaint with
NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among public prosecutors (75.9 percent) while a significant
proportion of respondents from programme administrators and law enforcement agencies were
also found aware of the mode of filling of complaint. Thus, majority of the respondents were not
aware of the mode of filling of complaint with NHRC (Table 8.17).
Table 8.17
 246

Mode of Filling of a Complaint with NHRC

Through Common

The Above Modes

Through None Of
Online On Www.

The Above Mode

Through E-Mail

Through All Of
Service Center
Through Post

By Phone On

Nhrc.Nic.In
9810298900
Mobile No.
By Fax

(CSC)

Other
Category Of Stakeholders

Women and Children 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Victim 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Parents
0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Clients
0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
6 6 6 6 6 3 22 4 0
Public Prosecutors
20.7% 20.7% 20.7% 20.7% 20.7% 10.3% 75.9% 13.8% 0.0%
56 39 74 76 103 21 62 0 0
Programs Administrators
20.0% 13.9% 26.4% 27.1% 36.8% 7.5% 22.1% 0.0% 0.0%
4 3 5 2 4 4 17 3 0
Law Enforcement Agencies
4.3% 3.2% 5.4% 2.2% 4.3% 4.3% 18.3% 3.2% 0.0%
21 13 17 15 30 5 24 1 1
Service Providers/NGOs
14.3% 8.8% 11.6% 10.2% 20.4% 3.4% 16.3% 0.7% 0.7%
87 61 102 99 143 33 125 8 1
Total
14.1% 9.9% 16.6% 16.1% 23.2% 5.4% 20.3% 1.3% 0.2%

Source: Field Survey

About 2/5th respondents were aware about the filling of a complaint with NHRC. Thus,
majority of the respondents were not aware that who can file complaint with NHRC regarding
human trafficking (Table 8.18).
Table 8.18
Who Can File a Complaint with NHRC?
Advocate Of
Only Victim

on Behalf of
Members of

Victim with
Any Person
Relatives of
Friends Or

His/ Her
Consent
Family

Victim

Victim

Victim

Category of Stakeholders Other

0 0 0 0 0 0
Women and Children Victims
0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
1 0 0 0 0 0
Parents
33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
1 0 0 0 0 1
Clients
33.3% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 33.3%
3 3 3 3 26 3
Public Prosecutors
10.3% 10.3% 10.3% 10.3% 89.7% 10.3%
18 41 32 22 151 1
Programs Administrators
6.4% 14.6% 11.4% 7.9% 53.9% 0.4%
2 4 3 4 22 0
Law Enforcement Agencies
2.2% 4.3% 3.2% 4.3% 23.7% 0.0%
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 247

9 8 6 12 52 0
Service Providers/NGOs
6.1% 5.4% 4.1% 8.2% 35.4% 0.0%
34 56 44 41 251 5
Total
5.5% 9.1% 7.1% 6.7% 40.7% 0.8%

Source: Field Survey

About 7 per cent respondents admitted that they file a complaint of human trafficking with
NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among public prosecutors (55.2 per cent). About 7 per
cent programme administrators and 6 per cent service providers also reported that they have
filed a complained with NHRC (Table 8.19).
Table 8.19
Have You Ever Filed a Complaint with NHRC?
Category of Stakeholders Yes No Total
Women and Children Victims 0 (0.0%) 61 (100%) 61 9100%)
Parents 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 3 (100%)
Clients 0 (0.0%) 3 (100%) 3 (100%)
Public Prosecutors 16 (55.2%) 13 (44.8%) 29 (100%)
Programs Administrators 19 (6.8%) 261 (93.2%) 280 (100%)
Law Enforcement Agencies 0 (0.0%) 93 (100%) 93 (100%)
Service Providers/NGOs 9 (6.1%) 138 (93.9%) 147 (100%)
Total 44 (7.1%) 572 (92.9%) 616 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
Majority of the respondents were found satisfied and fully satisfied with grievance redressal
by NHRC. Even less than 2/5th respondents were somewhat satisfied with grievance redressal
by NHRC (Table 8.20).
Table 8.20
Level of Satisfaction Regarding Grievance Redressed by NHRC
Category of Stakeholders Fully Satisfied Satisfied Somewhat Satisfied Total
Prosecutors 3 (18.8%) 7 (43.8%) 6 (37.5%) 16 (100%)
Programs Administrators 7 (36.8%) 4 (21.1%) 8 (42.1%) 19 (100%)
Service Providers/NGOs 2 (22.2%) 4 (44.4%) 3 (33.3%) 9 (100%)
Total 12 (27.3%) 15 (34.1%) 17 (38.6%) 44 (100%)
Source: Field Survey
NHRC can only recommend and does not have the power to enforce decisions as well as
its limitation to entertain a matter if it is not subjudice before a court are the main limitations
of NHRC in dealing with a complaint. There is also lack of time frame for the disposal of the
complaint on part of NHRC. NHRC also cannot enquire in any case if the complaint is made after
one year of the incident. (Table: 8.21).
 248

Table 8.21
Limitations/Shortcomings of NHRC in Dealing with a Complaint

Programme
Prosecutors

Providers
Law EAs

Service
Public

Total
Category of Stakeholders

As
16 50 1 15 82
NHRC Can only recommend and does not have the Power
to Enforce Decisions 55.2% 17.9% 1.1% 10.2% 13.3%

NHRC Cannot Inquire in any Case, If the Complaint Is Made 16 17 0 6 39

After One Year of The Incident
55.2% 6.1% 0.0% 4.1% 6.3%

Cannot Entertain a Matter If It Is Sub-Judice Before a Court 16 49 2 8 75

or a Tribunal or SHRC
55.2% 17.5% 2.2% 5.4% 12.2%

Cannot Entertain Maters Where Complaint is A Copy 13 15 2 3 33

Addressed to Some Other Authority
44.8% 5.4% 2.2% 2.0% 5.4%
7 28 0 2 37
No Timeframe for The Disposal of The Complaints,
24.1% 10.0% 0.0% 1.4% 6.0%
3 19 0 2 24
NHRC Does Not Send Timely Reminders to The Authorities
Concerned by The Officials Where No Responses Is
Forthcoming 10.3% 6.8% 0.0% 1.4% 3.9%

NHRC Merely Rely on The Reports of The State Authorities 9 32 0 4 45

Which Are Themselves Responsible for Acts of Omission 31.0% 11.4% 0.0% 2.7% 7.3%
No Action Is Taken by NHRC Against the Authorities That 0 6 0 6 12
Do Not Respond to The Call for Reports 0.0% 2.1% 0.0% 4.1% 1.9%
0 8 1 2 11
Others
0.0% 2.9% 1.1% 1.4% 1.8%
Source: Field Survey
Delay in grievance redressal, lengthy complaint form, unfriendly complain procedure, and
incurring of cost in obtaining documents are some of the problems faced by a person while filling
a complaint with NHRC (Table 8.22).
Table 8.22
Problems Faced by a Person While Filing a Complaint with NHRC
Programme
Prosecutors

Providers
Law EAs

Service

Total

Category of Stakeholders
As

0 15 1 6 22
Complaint Procedure is Not User Friendly
0.0% 5.4% 1.1% 4.1% 3.6%
0 26 0 1 27
Complaint Form is Too Lengthy
0.0% 9.3% 0.0% 0.7% 4.4%
Too Much Documentation; Face Difficulties in 0 37 1 3 41
Obtaining the Required Documents 0.0% 13.2% 1.1% 2.0% 6.7%
Role and Perception Analysis of Stakeholders 249

Cost Incurred in Obtaining Documents Such 0 17 0 0 17

as Affidavit Etc. And Filing A Complaint 0.0% 6.1% 0.0% 0.0% 2.8%
16 50 2 9 77
Delay in Grievance Redressal
55.2% 17.9% 2.2% 6.1% 12.5%
0 11 2 5 18
Others
0.0% 3.9% 2.2% 3.4% 2.9%
Source: Field Survey
Inadequate and ineffective laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties, minimal chances
of prosecution, the relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency, low visibility
and less debate on the issue, and governments’ lack of political will to implement policies and
provide adequate services for victims are all factors that contribute to the perpetuation of human
trafficking. It has also been stated that those who take up the fight against human trafficking
are in the minority. Because everyone (trafficking camp) is united, combat becomes harder. The
profiteering families are also wary of speaking up.
During Focused Group Discussions (FGDs), all stakeholders agreed that forming partnerships
across governments, the UN system, civil society, the commercial sector, faith-based groups, as well
as victims and survivors, is critical to effectively combating human trafficking. Media, educators,
research institutes, NGOs, and companies can all play a role in energizing such collaborations.
The need of utilizing technology, research, and information sharing in the development of anti-
trafficking measures was also underlined. Stakeholders agreed on the importance of increased
collaboration and coordination among all stakeholders and departments of the federal and state
governments to ensure system-wide coherence, emphasizing the importance of state governments
collaborating with civil society and the private sector in both the implementation and evaluation
of the National Plan of Action. They also agreed that humanitarian and development actors must
work together to prevent human trafficking by leveraging efforts to implement the 2030 Agenda
for Sustainable Development.
The need of political will in pursuing multiple ways to combating human trafficking was
emphasized by all the participants. A renewed request for increased resources and financing
to combat human trafficking was made, especially considering the extent and magnitude of
the problem. Stakeholders also stressed the importance of establishing mechanisms to properly
identify victims and cases of human trafficking, ensure that victims are not prosecuted, that
perpetrators are sentenced appropriately, and that prosecutors are fully aware of the factors
that lead to vulnerability and work with victims and witnesses in a way that empowers them
to come forward and increase prosecution and compensation claims. To safeguard children,
the prosecution mechanisms should be child-friendly. Stakeholders who were consulted Many
delegates underlined the need of recognizing developing difficulties and addressing unique
vulnerabilities, and that specific steps should be implemented to combat human trafficking as a
result of conflict, humanitarian crises, and natural disasters. From the beginning, the Government
of India and all actors engaged must respond in a systematic and predictable manner with
preventive and protective measures. The specific susceptibility of migrants and refugees to
human trafficking necessitates more safeguards.
Stakeholders emphasized the importance of understanding and addressing the core causes
of human trafficking, including crisis, gender, poverty, and abuse. The complicated interplay of
these aspects must be taken into account. Counter-trafficking measures should be implemented
 250

before, during, and after a crisis to prevent trafficking, according to the report. Participants agreed
that, while human trafficking can take many forms, such as sexual exploitation, forced labour, or
organ removal, all forms of trafficking, as well as their connections to other issues such as crisis
situations, migration, labour policy, public health, and child protection, should be addressed
comprehensively. It was emphasized that children, particularly those in crisis situations, must
be made aware of their vulnerability and available resources.
Throughout the discussions, a major focus was placed on pursuing a victim- and survivor-
centered strategy to combating human trafficking. The strategy should priorities victims’ and
survivors’ human rights, take into account their unique vulnerability, particularly among
women and children, promote their long-term reintegration and recovery, and eliminate the
stigma associated with human trafficking. Victims of human trafficking should be included in
the action plan, and survivors should be at the center of decision-making. In support of all efforts
to implement the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially
Women and Children (the “Palermo Protocol”)’s 3Ps” approach (“Prevention,” “Prosecution,”
and “Prosecution”), victim protection is critical to ensure effective prosecution of trafficking
perpetrators.
 Chapter 9
RESEARCH FINDINGS & CONCLUSIONS

H uman trafficking has emerged as a significant global concern of unprecedented scope in

the twenty-first century. Human trafficking is increasingly being referred to as “modern-
day slavery” due to its nature of exploitation, which has prompted the rapid proliferation of
international, regional, and national anti-trafficking laws, as well as states to devote enormous
financial and bureaucratic resources to its abolition. Over the last decade, the volume of human
trafficking has increased though the exact numbers are not known; it is one of the most lucrative
criminal trades, next to arms and drug smuggling undertaken by highly organized criminals.
The causes for its rise as worldwide phenomena are numerous and varied, affecting both affluent
and poor countries. Women and children are sexually exploited in the popular conception of
human trafficking; nevertheless, minors are trafficked for a number of reasons. Various social,
economic, and political factors combine to produce a vulnerable scenario, particularly for women
and children who have become victims of human trafficking.
Organized criminal groups involved in human trafficking varies in size and structure from
small local networks to big transnational organizations. Recruiters, document forgers, brokers,
brothel proprietors, debt collectors, and managers/owners of employment agencies are among
those who profit. Bribes are accepted by corrupt immigration authorities, consular employees,
embassy personnel, law enforcement officers, and border guards in exchange for passports, visas,
and safe passage. Human trafficking, being a large international crime, is frequently associated
with other organized criminal activities such as fraud, extortion, racketeering, money laundering,
bribery of public officials, drug use, document forgery, and gambling.
Insufficient and inadequate laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties, minimal chances of
prosecution, the relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency, poor visibility and
less debate on the issue, the lack of political will of the governments to implement policies and to
provide adequate services for victims- all has played important role in perpetuating trafficking.
It has been also expressed by all stakeholders that people who takes up the cudgels against
trafficking are in miniscule. It becomes difficult to combat because everyone (trafficking camp) is
unified. The profiting families are also reluctant to talk.

MAJOR FINDINGS OF THE STUDY

Preventive Measures, Profile of Victims & Their Exploitation
1. NCRB Data shows that during 2019, about 3.80 Lakh persons were traced missing and out
252

of them, about 2/3rd were females. Out of total missing persons, a significant number of
persons could not be traced out and remained missing. This shows that a large proportion
of missing persons particularly women were forced into sexual exploitation trade. The
Supreme Court while hearing a case in 2013 directed police that cases of missing children
should be treated as abduction or trafficking until proven otherwise, it is yet to become a
reality.
2. Most of the trafficked respondents (80.7%) were from economically weaker sections i.e.,
BPL families (50.3%), AAY-Antodaya Anna Yojana (30.4%) (Poorest of Poor) hailing from
Rural & Semi-urban areas.
3. Friends/lovers/brokers/middlemen, strangers and migrant workers recruiters /
placement agents were the main persons who initiated victims in trafficking; about 12%
victims admitted that their family members are already trafficked.
4. About 11% victim respondents were found minor at the time of trafficking and thus, they
were accompanied by family members during the course of trafficking. As per NCRB
Data for 2019 this comes to 44.04% (2914 victims were minor out of total 6616 trafficked
victims). Promise for paid work, to pay back or support parents were the main reasons for
trafficking in case of minor at the time of trafficking.
5. Sexual exploitation, violence, beating, over work and deprivation of sleep and food were
some of the types of physical and sexual abuse/violence experience by trafficking victims
and sex workers. About 58% victims also experience injuries during their trafficking.
6. Victim re-trafficking is a common occurrence, especially in socially and economically
disadvantaged areas. As per Report of International Organisation For Migration (IOM),
one study found rates of re-trafficking in India to be 25.8 per cent among women trafficked
for sexual exploitation; of this figure, 8.4 per cent had been trafficked on three or more
occasions.
7. There is an increase in the recruitment of vulnerable people for online sexual exploitation
by traffickers, as well as a growing market for child sexual abuse material and technology-
facilitated child sex trafficking.
8. Many trafficked people (8%) are still unable to access governmental help due to
administrative hurdles especially victims hailing from Bangladesh, Nepal & Myanmar.
One of the most difficult parts is determining legal status/Identity. Trafficked people
are frequently refused state services (e.g., medical, employment, social assistance,
kindergarten, etc.) as well as other advantages to which they should be entitled and which
are critical in the reintegration process.
9. There has been a complete failure in identifying and mapping human trafficking
vulnerabilities. According to our research, the state, central, and local governments have
not done any vulnerability surveys in the majority of India. A negligible proportion
(10.8%) of Law Enforcement Agency respondents & 7.6% Programme Administrators
admitted that there has been some kind of vulnerabilities survey in their States, it was
reported from Tamil Nadu followed by Assam and Karnataka.
10. It is reported that Domestic Work is offered to the majority of trafficked victims or migrant
workers, particularly females, by traffickers/placement agencies/migrant worker
recruiters, etc.
Research Findings & Conclusions 253

11. Domestic workers, caretakers, and those employed in the sex and entertainment industries
are largely unprotected by labour laws. Female migrants may be coerced into prostitution
or the sale of sexual favours in order to survive or provide for their family, especially
if they are forced to migrate or are displaced. Sexual exploitation is a threat to migrant
women.
12. The types of physical and psychological abuse human trafficking victims experience have
led to serious mental or emotional health consequences, including feelings of severe guilt,
posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, substance abuse (alcohol or narcotics),
and eating disorders. Victims of trafficking were in need of psychological care as part of
comprehensive medical treatment. Stress, depression, sleeplessness, desperation, negative
thinking, sort temper and violence and lack of obedience were some of the psychological
impacts of human trafficking.
13. Violent exploitation has resulted in survivors developing a mistrust of care-giving
individuals and systems, which has severely hindered the service delivery.
14. Prolonged physical and mental abuse has affected victim’s behaviour in negative ways,
having an impact on both physical and emotional responses. Because trafficked persons
experienced extreme forms of trauma over long periods of time, their capacities both to
understand what has happened to them and to describe their experiences are directly
impaired as a result of such abuse. Victims found that it is difficult to make personal
sense of the abuse they have experienced, much less tried to explain it to the authorities
of shelter home or counsellors.
15. Social withdrawal, poor communication skills, inability to express feelings, difficulty with
adjustment, lack of motivation and aggression, sexual activeness, nightmares, inability to
make friendship and frightened of adults and strangers were some of the behavioural
impacts reported by victims of human trafficking.
16. The level of awareness about schemes and programmes among the trafficked victim
respondents was reported very low as negligible proportion of respondents were found
aware about a few schemes such as Beti Bachao, Beti Padao, Swadhar Greh, Ujjawala,
child line and children’s homes. A negligible proportion of respondents further reported
that they get benefits under Ujjawala, Swadhar, compensation for sexual exploitation
and children homes scheme. The educated rescued victims were found more aware
of government schemes and programmes. Similarly, educated respondents availed
comparatively higher level of benefits under the government schemes and programmes
as compared to illiterate and low educated victims.
17. Only 3.6% victim respondents were aware about Compensation Scheme for Women
Victims/Survivor of Sexual Assault/other crime-2018 and only 2.6% respondents got
benefitted from the Scheme. The Victim Compensation Scheme established under 357-
A Cr.Pc. by National Legal Services Authorities are not reaching the trafficked victims.
In the last seven years, between 2012 and 2019, across India, not even 100 victims of
human trafficking have been awarded compensation. Out of total 100 applications, only
30 survivors received compensation amount. In 19 States, out of the total fund allocation
of Rs 544.53 crore for victim compensation, only 128.27 crore has been utilized and 75 per
cent of the funds remain unutilized. Less than 1% of the survivors rescued from trafficking
over 10 years (2009 to 2019) were compensated.
254

18. About 1/3rd victim respondents reported that their family is unwilling to accept them
back. However, about 2/3rd victims were willing to join mains steam after exit of the
trafficking. Slightly less than 1/3rd victims further reported that they try to escape from
destination of trafficking.
19. Less than 1/3rd sex workers reported that their families are willing to accept them
back in their families. Similarly, majority of rescued victims were found willing to join
mainstream as against 1/3rd of sex workers who were willing to join mainstream at the
exit of trafficking. More than 2/5th rescued victims attempted to escape from destination
of trafficking as against 6% of sex workers who try to escape from the trafficking.
20. There are still a lot of social customs/practices that inducts young girls into prostitution.
21. Majority of the sex workers were from the age group of 16 years and above at the time of
entry in sex profession. However, more than 1/4th respondents were less than 16 years of
age.
22. There is no sound programme and scheme to prevent second generation of prostitutions.
23. Psychological manipulation, threat of physical violence and pleasure are some of the
main habituation factors in sex profession.
24. About 60% sex workers are willing to exit from the profession. Most of the respondents
reported that they do not want that their children follow their mother’s profession.
However, majority of them require the support such as livelihood and accommodation,
alternative livelihood and safe and secure place to live in order to exit from the current
profession.
25. A new form of organized Prostitution has emerged in recent years. Gangs involved in
organized prostitution are luring customers through internet, text messages and mobile-
based applications, taking advantage of a loophole in the law which is silent on regulating
the proliferation, promotion and advertisement of prostitution on digital platforms
and even though leaflets /pamphlets. In the name of Cross Gender Massage Services,
Organized Sexual Services are being provided at Night Clubs, Massage Parlours, Spas,
Luxury Hotels & Resorts, Motels, Dance Bars, Private Residences, huts and even vehicles
etc.
26. Poverty and illiteracy have been identified as two primary causes of trafficking and
Primary data simply supports this theory as most of the parents of trafficked victims are
illiterate and were living in object poverty.
27. About 60% parents of victim respondents said that family members are the facilitators
followed by friends/relatives (11.8%), contractors/agents (5.9%) and placement agencies
(2.9%). Surprisingly 23.5% respondents reported that their children run away from home.
28. Most of the (about 37%) parents reported that their children were working as forced
labour-domestic works.
29. About 31% parents reported that their children were working in hazardous industries-
metallurgical industries, coal, fertilizers, mining, chemical & petrochemicals, cement and
firecracker workshops. As per census of 2011, this figure is 20.7%.
30. There is a lack of National Level Campaign against Human Trafficking and Media is
Research Findings & Conclusions 255

silent.
31. About 2/5th Law Enforcement Agency respondents reported that the problem of human
trafficking is serious and this has been taken as priority in their agency. Even less than
1/3rd respondents viewed that human trafficking is very serious problem. It was found
more pronouncing in Tamil Nadu followed by Karnataka and West Bengal.
32. A negligible proportion of Law Enforcement Agency respondents (7.5%) admitted that
placement agencies that facilitate migration are registered with law enforcement agency.
It was found more pronouncing in Tamil Nadu followed by Karnataka and Maharashtra.
Thus, most of the respondents revealed that placement agencies are not registered with
them. Thus, there is possibility of exploitation of girls during their migration.
33. The main reasons for non-stoppable trafficking as per law enforcement agencies were
recorded mainly poor economic conditions, social customs, gender inequality, negligible
penalties, domestic violence and poor law enforcement. However, prosecuting officers
reported that poor economic conditions, poor law enforcement, negligible penalties,
corruption, social customs, gender inequalities and inadequate laws are important reasons
responsible for human trafficking.
34. Majority of stakeholders during FGDs informed that it is necessary to identify appropriate
points of intervention so that migrants and future migrants are warned about the dangers
and repercussions of human trafficking and get information that allows them to seek help
if necessary.
35. Poverty, lack of means of livelihood, many girl children, lack of education, child marriages,
and domestic violence are some of the major trafficking vulnerabilities. However,
trafficking vulnerabilities vary across the stakeholders such as victims, law enforcement
agencies and traffickers.
36. Poverty along with gender discrimination, domestic abuse/ violence, organized crime/
poor law enforcement, social inequities and cultural practices are some of the supply side
factors of human trafficking and Cheap labour force, cheap domestic servants / maids,
demand for women‘s sexual services and derived demand – profit and revenue generated
by third parties including recruiters are some of the demand side factors responsible for
human trafficking identified in this research.
37. Abuse of vulnerability/promise and offering money / jobs, allurement/ be funding
/ enticing with attractive offers, deception, fraud making, false promises of marriage,
physical force / use of force and threats were some of the modus operandi of traffickers.
38. During Focused Group Discussions with Victims as well as Service Providers in West
Bengal, we agreed that notions of vulnerability have fed into discourses of mobility,
migration, and movement associated with trafficking as well as climate-induced migration
and displacement, with implications for what kinds of responses are envisioned and
carried out. Just as typical anti-trafficking efforts continue to prioritize border security and
criminal law responses, there are increasing calls for climate adaptation plans to account
for migration and displacement outcomes and manage flows of people, even while existing
frameworks are deemed inadequate to deal with the complexity of such issues. Climate
change-related vulnerability, which entails uneven, uncertain, and complex processes
contingent on myriad factors, does not fit neatly into dominant criminal justice-oriented
256

anti-trafficking initiatives that are informed by limited evidence and understandings of

vulnerability, target individual perpetrators, and produce immediately visible results.
39. A negligible proportion of victims (5.3%), traffickers (0.0%), parents (0.7%) and client’s
(4.8%) respondent were found aware of National Human Rights Commission. The
awareness level was found slightly significant among women and children victims
followed by clients. The main sources of information about NHRC were reported to be
NGOs followed by print media and electronic media
40. About 56% of respondents, who were aware about NHRC, were partially aware of role
and functions of NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among the parents followed by
women and children victims, law enforcement agencies and clients. Slightly more than
1/3rd respondents were found fully aware of role and functions of NHRC. It was found
more pronouncing among the public prosecutors followed by programme administrators.
About 1/3rd clients and more than 1/4th service providers were not aware at all about the
roles and functions of NHRC.
41. About 45% respondents, who were aware about NHRC, were found aware that a
complaint regarding human trafficking may be directly filed with NHRC. It was found
more pronouncing among parents followed by public prosecutors and service providers.
However, all the respondents from women and children victims followed by clients and
majority of the respondents from law enforcement agencies and service providers were
not aware about the fact.
42. About 20% aware respondents were found aware of the mode of filling of a complaint
with NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among public prosecutors (75.9%) while
a significant proportion of respondents from programme administrators and law
enforcement agencies were also found aware of the mode of filling of complaint. Thus,
majority of the respondents were not aware of the mode of filling of complaint with
NHRC.
43. About 2/5th aware respondents were aware about the filling of a complaint with NHRC.
Thus, majority of the respondents were not aware that who can file complaint with NHRC
regarding human trafficking.
44. About 7% aware respondents admitted that they file a complaint of human trafficking
with NHRC. It was found more pronouncing among public prosecutors (55.2%). About
7% programme administrators and 6% service providers also reported that they have
filed a complained with NHRC.
45. Insufficient and inadequate laws, poor enforcement, ineffective penalties, minimal
chances of prosecution, the relatively low risks involved, corruption and complacency,
poor visibility and less debate on the issue, the lack of political will of the governments to
implement policies and to provide adequate services for victims- all has played important
role in perpetuating trafficking.
46. It has been also expressed by all stakeholders that people who takes up the cudgels against
trafficking are in miniscule. It becomes difficult to combat because everyone (trafficking
camp) is unified. The profiting families are also reluctant to talk.
Research Findings & Conclusions 257

Law Enforcement, Traffickers & Exploiters

1. AHTUs in India are special police units, devoted to tackle human trafficking. Following
MHA advisory (July 2020), a recent report of 16 states and UTs suggest that 225 AHTUs
existed only on paper, and only 27 percent of the AHTUs were operational. Most of the
AHTUs are designated AHTUs burdened with a lot of other law enforcement activities.
The Anti Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) are not fully operative & Dedicated to
Human Trafficking and in many districts of India, AHTUs have not been established so
far.
2. Anti-Human Trafficking units (AHTUs) are currently under-resourced as well as
undertrained. AHTUs are not fully aware about various legislations and sections dealing
with human Trafficking.
3. According to the Protocol, rescue teams should include: an official from the Department of
Labour, representatives of the CWCs, a local non-profit, a doctor, and a female police officer
or volunteer. These individuals must receive training on relevant laws, their individual
responsibilities, and trauma prevention strategies. However, research participants
reported that, in reality, teams are often too small to cope with the numbers of children
needing rescue. Police officers, doctors, and female witnesses only sporadically take part.
Key informant data suggests this overreliance leads to ad hoc and under-resourced raids
directed by inexperienced or poorly supported workers, a situation that can and does
inflict additional trauma on vulnerable children.
4. Most of the service provider respondents noted that NGOs sometimes proceed with a
rescue on their own: ‘Most of the time, when Police don’t take immediate action, the
child could be sent somewhere else. So, they don’t inform anyone. Their first priority is
to rescue the child, and then inform others.’ Non-profit participants reported suffering
threats, stone attacks, and beatings in retaliation for their actions. These risks of reprisal
are exacerbated by the non-involvement of law enforcement in raids.
5. The Rescue Protocol states that details of the rescue and the identities of rescued children
must remain strictly confidential, and should not be disclosed to outside parties, including
the media. Yet privacy breaches concerning occurrences and information leaks before,
during and after raids are frequent.
6. Service Provider Respondents stated that employers are often alerted to impending raids,
and that unsuccessful rescue operations can increase the risk of employers retaliating
against children.
7. Most of the Government official stated that rescue team members directly solicit
media involvement so ‘the public could understand that this type of activity is a
crime and punishable offence’. Publicity generates risks of retaliation against rescued
children, increased social stigma and difficulty in reintegration. Moreover, widespread
sensationalized media coverage of raids plays an important role in simplifying the
complex underlying social and economic problems that perpetuate this problem.
8. Key informant interviews held with police officers, Government Railway Police (GRP)
and Railway Protection Force (RPF) and other stakeholders-Child Welfare Committee
members, NGO representatives, and vendors in railway stations, reveals that most cases
of trafficking are not registered or reported which is the major reason for the declining
258

trend in reported cases of trafficking. It is reported that Memo/GD entry is made by

GRB/RPF and children are handed over to Child Welfare Committee in most cases. Some
of them are left without any enquiry/record.
9. The terms “human trafficking” and “migration” are being used interchangeably,
resulting in the denial of labour rights. It’s crucial to understand the difference between
“trafficking,” “sex work,” and “migration.”
10. Human Trafficking incidents are underreported as a result, the complainant is compelled
to file a complaint through court order, while the offending police officers walk free.
There are cases of refusal by police to file a complaint on the basis of jurisdiction/area,
despite the fact that any police station can file a complaint and the investigation can be
moved to the appropriate police station
11. There are several reasons for non-registration of cases. It varies from case to case. The police
officials are not much aware of IPC section 370. It is clearly provided in explanation-2 of
the Act that the consent of the victim is immaterial in determination of the offence of
trafficking, most of the police officers don’t accept it. In the case of Bhagubhai Patel v State
of Gujarat, the High Court held that a customer at a brothel comes within the purview of
sec 370 of the IPC because trafficking also includes prostitution, the reason being that it is
one type of exploitation.
12. The police are burdened with so many responsibilities as there are vacancies in police
stations. Hence, they are reluctant as they cannot investigate the entire chain which
crosses over three to four states. No coordination mechanism is available between source
and destination states. Even if victims are rescued and sent back to their home, there is no
rehabilitation package under IPC which would result in leaving the victims unprotected.
There will be also problem in filing charge sheet, trail and other proceedings for which the
victims will not either coordinate or turn hostile. Corruption, pressure from superiors/
politicians and lack of review mechanism force the officers in non-reporting of incidents.
Moreover, the child protection mechanisms are very weak and they are not properly
enquiring the victims and following the procedures. They don’t have any power or
authority to influence the police officers.
13. The major challenges being faced by agency in encountering with investigation of cases
frequently reported of lack of victim cooperation/victim distressed, community ignorance
and lack of identity as Victims do not identify themselves as a Victim. However, other
important challenges were reported to be language /cultural barriers, lack of adequate
resources, victims do not identify themselves as victims, lack of support with victim
support providers, lack of adequate training and knowledge as well as lack of procedures
and clear jurisdiction.
14. IPC section 370 suffers with a lot of lacunae and cases are under-reported which is very
evident. It does not cover rehabilitation, compensation to victims and access to justice and
focuses on penalizing the traffickers. In addition, The Prevention of Immoral Trafficking
Act focuses only on sex trafficking and not all forms of trafficking – forced labour, organ
transplant, beggary, commercial surrogacy. In the Bonded Labour Abolition Act, the
definition of accused restricted to the principal employer and leaves traffickers out of the
ambit of prosecution. Moreover, the compensation is linked with the conviction which
makes the victim more vulnerable
Research Findings & Conclusions 259

15. NGOs and Service Providers reported that most of the AHTU or police relied on NGOs
to report victims to the police for action. In some cases, poor inter-state coordination
impeded victims’ ability to obtain services and participate in civil and criminal cases upon
return to their home states. The Odisha Labour Department took steps to improve inter-
state coordination on labour trafficking cases by establishing help desks, located in the
capital cities of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh, as well as in Delhi, to identify trafficking
victims from Odisha.
16. International Justice Mission (IJM) and other NGOs reported that some officials in Uttar
Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Telangana and Karnataka treated bonded labour cases as labour
exploitation, which meant victims were not identified as bonded labour victims, did
not receive “release certificates,” and were not eligible for government compensation
or services. IJM fought for justice of those bonded labourers and currently running
rehabilitation programme for them. In the Bonded Labour Abolition Act, the definition
of accused restricted to the principal employer and leaves traffickers out of the ambit of
prosecution.
17. Labour department officials do not register FIR in most of the cases as mandated under
law as there is confusion & disagreement about who has this responsibility. The resulting
consensus is that employers are ‘rarely’ or ‘never’ arrested & unlikely to be convicted.
Official figures for 2015 show that nationwide only 55 cases of child trafficking for any
purpose 1.09% resulted in convictions out of 5,026 under investigation.
18. Most of the traffickers during interaction told that they are also involved in drug
peddling but they were always arrested on grounds of human trafficking rather than for
drug peddling as they get bail easily in trafficking cases. Justice S K Panigrahi of Odisha
High Court. Justice Panigrahi has heavily commented on this issue as reported in TOI:
02.07.2020. Drug trafficking is linked to many forms of trafficking including diverse forms
of labour trafficking in agriculture, begging and diverse forms of hard physical labour.
19. Associations with traffickers with Pan India Network of Traffickers & smugglers is
the basic reason for about half of the respondents for getting involved in flesh trade,
whereas more than one third (37%) respondents have reported that earlier they were Sex
Workers/Broker/Pimps, about 8% have reported that earlier they were brothel owners.
2% respondents were practicing their inherited business.
20. Most of the traffickers (79.6%) reported that they traffic the victims on promise of money/
jobs and they directly contact to the family/victims through their placement agencies.
Placement agencies are playing a major role in trafficking minor girls as well as children
for the purpose of labour, sex slavery and forced marriages.
21. The traffickers have changed their modus operandi with the changes in law and society.
In most of the cases the trafficker is known to the victim who convinces the victim and
her/his family and further sell them over to placement agent.
22. For objecting the work given by placement agencies, the victims are tortured, thrashed
and beaten up badly, many times these victim girls report sexual violence and assault
by the placement agents and even by their employers. The girls are kept confined in the
placement agencies till the time they are sold further. These placement agencies keep on
changing their addresses, name and contact details to escape from law.
260

23. Most of the Traffickers (98%) reported that Relatives /family members, neighbour /
friends and other middle men are playing critical role in making women and children
more vulnerable to join trafficking..
24. Big profit and lack of alternative livelihood for trafficker are the main reasons for continuity
act of human trafficking.
25. Witness turning hostile, protection of victims and witness, court adjournment and victims
pleading guilty were some of the major difficulties being faced by Law Enforcement
Agencies in working with cases of human trafficking.
26. It is reported that majority of brothel keepers were female (95.7%). More than half (53.2%)
of the operators of brothels were from rural background followed by Metropolitan Cities
(23.4%). Slightly less than one fourth (23.4%) operators of brothels were from Urban/
Semi Urban background.
27. More than half (59.6 percent) brothel keepers were previously sex workers and about 15
percent were previous victims of Commercial Sex Exploitation (CSE).
28. The phenomenon of flying sex workers is increasing day by day and has been attributed
the reason behind flourishing of brothels.
29. More than 2/5th brothel keepers reported that police raids thrice and above in a month
in the brothels. The main reasons for police raids were reported to be checking of minor
girls, law and order problems and for official figures. More than 1/4th brothel keepers
reported that Police Raids the brothel when monthly quota is not given to them. About
1/4th respondents reported that they are often involved in contact with police. About 30%
respondents reported that police are also involved in racket of trafficking.
30. Only 7.9% clients reported that they were ever harassed by Police and those who were
harassed 4.8% clients reported that they were harassed occasionally where as 3.2%
reported that were rarely harassed. Clients those who were harassed by Police were asked
what was the action taken by Police when encountered. 6.3% Clients reported that Police
extracted money from them and 1.6% reported that they were verbally abused.
31. Only 4.8% Clients of CSWs reported that they were arrested by Police for buying the sex
and those who were arrested by Police were later on released on bribing to Police. Only
7.9% clients were aware that clients can be penalized under Section 7 of ITPA for buying
the sex and surprisingly slightly more than one third (33.3%) clients were aware that that
sexual assault on a child under 16 years age, even with consent, amounts to rape under
Indian Penal Code.
32. Easy bail for traffickers, intimidation and humiliation of victims, and baseless segregation
of survivors/accused following rescue operation from brothels during complaint filing
are the major gaps in the enforcement mechanism to combat human trafficking.
33. Most of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents admitted that the officials of their
units/department have received training on the issues of human trafficking. However, a
large proportion of respondents in Karnataka, Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu revealed
that officers have not received such training.
34. Most (84.4%) of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents reported that less than half of
the officers in their departments have received training on the issues of human trafficking.
Research Findings & Conclusions 261

In-service, induction, orientation and refresher training were organized on the issues of
human trafficking.
35. Most of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents (91.4%) revealed that they learn the
subject of human trafficking as regular law enforcement activities while about half of
the respondents admitted that they learn such knowledge from training, conference
and workshops. Thus, about 2/3rd respondents revealed that their knowledge about
legislations on human trafficking is at average level.
36. Majority of the Law Enforcement Agency respondents (64.5%) reported that section-7 and
8 are most commonly used sections of ITPA. However, about 58.1% respondents revealed
that section-3 and 4 are most commonly used sections of ITPA.
37. There is a lack of integrated information system about the trafficked person and the
traffickers/brothel owners/operators.
38. Police involvement in perpetuating the practice of trafficking is reported by traffickers,
NGOs as well as brothel keepers. This shows that the police may support brothel
owners, be complicit with traffickers and give low priority to crimes of trafficking. Police
behaviour, their procedures for age-verification of minors and lack of coordination with
other agencies, such as protective homes, have seriously compromised the quality of
rescue operations conducted by them. Raid and rescue efforts have often resulted in police
harassment, detention and abuse of women and minor girls as reported by victims rescued
from the brothels of Pune and Mumbai. Although rescue efforts provide an important
means of escape for women and minor girls in CS and a pathway to support services,
when implemented poorly without sufficient police training and adequate insight about
the commercial sex network, it has become traumatising for women and minor girls.
39. It is reported that Law enforcement authorities, for example, the police force themselves,
have a limited understanding of the prevalence of trafficking of women and minor girls
for CSE and tend to be uninformed about their responsibilities under the ITPA towards
trafficking. This constitutes yet another challenge in the prevention of trafficking of
women and minor girls.
40. The clause u/s 18 ITPA, which allows for the closure of brothels and the eviction of
offenders, has been applied sparingly. We have discovered a slew of brothels operating
beneath the radar of local cops in Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Nasik, Kolkata, and others.

Prosecution of Offenders
1. Conviction rate in crimes against women and children for the past three years has been
low. The conviction rate in cases of crimes like rape, cruelty by husband or his relatives,
violation of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, human trafficking,
violation of Cyber Crimes/Information Technology Act and Protection of Children from
Sexual offenses Act, have been amongst the lowest. It has been informed by the State
Government of Uttar Pradesh that they are conducting prosecution drives to improve the
conviction rate in crimes against women and children.
2. According to NCRB data, conviction rate under human trafficking was recorded 42.4 per
cent in 2017 which declined to 31.9 per cent in 2018 and further reduced to 20 per cent in
2019. BIRD’ Primary Data indicates that 20.8% prosecuted persons were convicted. The
262

main reasons for low conviction rate as per public prosecutors were recorded witnessed
turning hostile (44.8%), poor evidence (20.7%), lengthy court procedure (13.8%),
inappropriate charge sheet (10.3%) and easy bail to traffickers (10.3%). However, reasons
for low conviction rate vary across the selected states.
3. Material evidence, medical examination of victims, suspects and documents and witness
evidence are some of the major techniques being used in investigation of crimes related
to trafficking. However, techniques of investigation of crimes vary across the states.
The State Law Enforcement Agencies Reported that forensics plays a critical role in the
successful investigation, prosecution and conviction.
4. NGOs have reported that police rarely make the informant NGO witness of the recovery
memo or charge sheet, therefore most traffickers and brothel owners are able to evade
legal capture.
5. Most of the rescued victims (56%) have reported that the statement of the complainant/
victims is changed or ignored during the investigation, and it is not video-graphed as
required by law. Even it is videotaped, they are not sent to the court with the charge sheet.
6. Inappropriate charge sheet, witness turn hostile, poor evidences and lack of victim or
witness protection are some of the loopholes in law enforcement mechanism for low-rate
of prosecution.
7. Service Providers, NGOs, Parents, Programme Administrators and Public Prosecutors
have reported that at different levels of government, a lack of comprehensive responsibility
for wrongdoing and corruption persisted, contributing to widespread impunity.
8. During FGDs with the Service Providers, NGOs, Parents, Programme Administrators and
Public Prosecutors it was deliberated that the survivors/families are forced to become
hostile and refuse to testify in the trial court due to social pressure, threats, intimidation,
bribes, police collaboration, protracted trials, cross-cases, and a lack of faith in the criminal
justice system, among other things.
9. About 1/4th Public Prosecuting Officers reported that present laws are able to address the
issues of human trafficking adequately. It has been noted that law enforcement officials
do not take any action against accused persons who provide falsified documents in order
to obtain bail. Protection of victims and wetness, adequate rehabilitation facilities for
victim, victim’s access to legal aid, long term crime control policy and victim’s rights are
some of the ignored areas in existing laws.
10. Most of the Public Prosecuting Officers (79.3%) admitted that existing laws permit
them to use of specialized evidence-gathering techniques in course. It was found more
pronouncing in Jharkhand, Karnataka, West Bengal, Maharashtra, Assam and Uttar
Pradesh. Witness turning hostile, protection of victim and witness and victim pleading
guilty are some of the major difficulties being faced in working with cases of human
trafficking.
11. It has been noted that law enforcement officials do not take any action against accused
persons who provide falsified documents in order to obtain bail.
12. Majority of the Public Prosecuting Officers (69.6%) reported that less than 25% officers
have received training on the issues of human trafficking. Trainings were mainly
Research Findings & Conclusions 263

organized by department of justice, service providers and independent trainers. About

79% respondents reported that officers have received training on the issues of human
trafficking. It was found more pronouncing in Karnataka followed by West Bengal, Uttar
Pradesh and Jharkhand. However, about half of the respondents in Tamil Nadu and
1/3rd respondents in Assam ad Maharashtra revealed that officers have not received such
training.
13. Approximate only half of the Prosecuting Officers has received Training on the Issues of
Trafficking & prosecution of offenders and those who received the training majority of
the respondents (82.6%) revealed that training on the issues of human trafficking has not
been effective.
14. There are major coordination gaps/lacks among NGOs inside states, across states, and
across borders, as well as other stakeholders.

Rehabilitation, Re-integration and Repatriation

1. It is reported that at every level, there is a resource shortage, particularly in terms of funds
to combat human trafficking, such as underfunded shelter homes, which impedes the
rehabilitation process.
2. It is reported that the CWC serves as ‘guardian of the rescued child…empowered to
plan the rehabilitation plan’. Immediate care and support are also of critical importance
as a prelude to more sustained rehabilitation and reintegration into a rights-respecting
childhood. In practice, while basic food and shelter are generally provided immediately
following rescue, care is found to be insufficient. Several NGO participants reported
that rescued children are sometimes transferred to a police station, an inappropriate and
potentially re-traumatising environment.
3. According to 123 of 147 Service Providers and NGOs participants, the care of children
trafficked from different states is inhibited by the simple lack of an interpreter competent
in the relevant local languages. When the victim speaks a different language, investigators
and trial courts are handicapped in trans-border and inter-state trafficking cases. The lack
of an interpreter who is fluent in the relevant local languages makes it difficult to care for
women & children who have been trafficked from different states. This egregious failure
has far-reaching repercussions for service delivery performance and the risk of criminal
prosecution.
4. It is reported that both government and NGO run shelters faced serious shortages of
financial resources and trained personnel, particularly counsellors and medical staff as
funds are not released on time. The disbursal of government funding to NGOs was most
of the time delayed for multiple years.
5. About 60% Service Providers reported that service providers received training on subject
matter of human trafficking. It was found more pronouncing in Maharashtra followed by
Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.
6. Only 38.1% Service Providers reported that there is reporting mechanism within their
agencies to track trafficking cases. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand followed
by Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka and Assam.
7. Most of the Service Providers (98.4%) reported that there is specific menu of food for
264

beneficiaries. About 3/4th respondents further reported that they follow such menu, but
Research Team did not find a single cook in most of the shelter homes run by NGOs and
victims reported that they them self-cook the food and perform other activities.
8. Most of the Service Providers reported that they have admission register (87.8%),
attendance register (83.7%), separate case file (82.1%) and detailed case histories of
beneficiaries (74%). However, less than 1/4th respondents (23.6%) reported that files are
being given specific codes for maintaining confidentiality. The files are being updated
mainly weekly and quarterly.
9. It is reported that after verification of files by team it has been found that most of the service
providers are maintaining the various kinds of documents as per guidelines but when
it comes to Rehabilitation Plan, Psychological Counselling Reports, Home Verification
Reports and follow up Reports only 16 out of 123 (13%) service providers are maintaining
these documents. Research Team did not find a single Psychological Counsellor in most
of the NGOs run shelter homes. Only Social Counsellors were there that too were not
proper qualified and having skills and expertise for counselling. Team hardly found
any language interpreter in any of the shelter homes. It is a serious lacuna and the main
reason behind failure of rehabilitation of victims, when there is no proper rehabilitation
plan and no proper Psychological Counselling of victims then how can they be treated
or rehabilitated. Follow up report after reunion in the family is also missing on part of
service providers, so it cannot be ascertained as what happened to the victims after their
reunion in the families. Home Verification Report is also missing from the files, it raises
a serious question that when home of victims is not verified, how they are reintegrated
to families. This is a fundamental flaw in the rehabilitation and reintegration process that
must be addressed.
10. The urgent mental and physical health needs of rescued children are addressed as an
afterthought, with no solid policy efforts in place to ensure that appropriate and long-
term care are provided. Despite the fact that a counsellor is meant to accompany children
immediately after rescue, no further specific actions to address the physical, mental,
and psychological needs of these vulnerable persons or their families were indicated by
survey participants. In most of the cases and in most of the shelter homes psychological
counselling is done only on paper, we have not found a single psychological counselor in
any of the visited shelter homes during the interaction with service providers.
11. The mode of follow up of victims restored to their families or reintegrated is being ensured
through telephone, other organizations and direct visit to the place where beneficiaries
are resided but was limited to a handful of victims (26.83%).
12. Funding, social stigma, service coordination, long term commitments and lack of
sensitivity and understanding on sex trade were some of the obstacles in rehabilitation
and reintegration programmes as reported by Victims.
13. It is reported that in most of the shelter homes (82.1%) run by NGOs there is a lot of
deficiency on part of the services provided by them. Most of the shelter homes run by
NGOs do not have the proper infrastructure as well as qualified and skilled manpower as
envisaged in the guideline of Ujjawala, Swadhar Greh or other children’s homes. The care
system is completely missing in these homes. Almost every stakeholder argues that most
of these shelters are run on poor budgets. The reasons for not investing in a care system
Research Findings & Conclusions 265

that does not become custodial is a neglect and blindness to the oppression being inflicted
upon the ones that one claims to protect and empower.
14. Ujjawala and Swadhar are schemes devised by the MOWCD to reach out to women and
minor girls in CS and women in difficult circumstances, respectively. Their implementation,
however, has been far from satisfactory. Rehabilitation centers and shelter homes under
these schemes are not universally available across states. This creates barriers to rescue
operations by the police, because of the lack of designated places to which the police can
send the rescued women and minor girls. Moreover, the quality of services provided to
victims in shelter homes was found to be poor.
15. Many shelter homes were also found to be unsafe for victims, and the environment in these
homes was such that rescued women and minor girls were at risk of being criminalized
and re-victimized. 78% girls/women residing in shelter facilities reported that they
were subjected to invasive medical examinations and had to face traumatizing queries
from investigators checking details of their backgrounds. Finally, the Ujjawala scheme
has not been successful in reintegrating survivors with their families and communities
and in coordinating interstate activities between government and NGOs for rescue and
rehabilitation of victims.
16. In several cases, government-funded shelter homes continued to operate despite
significant gaps in mandatory reporting and allegations of abuse, at times due to alleged
political connections. Due to unsafe conditions and forcible detention in government run
and funded shelters, some sex trafficking victims including children ran away, and at
least one attempted suicide in the shelter during the reporting period especially in Delhi,
Maharashtra and Assam.
17. It is reported that the staffs hired in shelter homes are poorly paid and it is a challenge to
find, recruit and retain good therapists, educators or trainers in shelters. Therefore, the
survivors must rely on mainstream service providers, in hospitals and chambers. The
chances of getting employment based on the vocational trainings taught to survivors in
shelter homes are near zero.
18. Rehabilitating sex workers is a serious issue. The Indian Supreme Court has declared that
sex workers’ rehabilitation program should not be contingent on their being forced to
stay in corrective homes, and that sex workers cannot be imprisoned in corrective homes
“which they see as a virtual prison.” Regardless of these facts, forced rehabilitation is still
the norm in India.
19. Regarding accommodation, the CWC has an obligation to allocate appropriate housing
to rescued children. The Protocol requires a home verification report to determine
whether it is safe for the child to be sent back home to his or her family. If not, the CWC
can recommend family-based alternative care, or residential hostels provided by the
government or non-profits. In practice, children are always returned to their families
except in cases where the family cannot be located. Respondents agreed that thorough
family assessments, exploring the original drivers of the child’s trafficking and measures
that could alleviate risks of re-trafficking, never happen.
20. This serious protection failure is due in part to the logistical difficulties of home assessment.
Approximately, four-fifths of child workers in India are from low-caste families in remote
and hard-to-reach rural areas, and trafficked children sometimes come from families that
266

are themselves migratory, struggling to survive. The challenges facing CWCs seeking to
conduct home visits are therefore substantial and require staffing, training and transport
resources that are generally unavailable at present. In most of the cases once home is
traced, the family is told to come and collect the child from the regional hub.
21. Resources to strengthen a child’s integration back into the family, to support parents’
mentorship and acceptance of returned children are also lacking. As a result, reintegration
is generally reduced to simple return to the status quo preceding the child’s trafficking.
Alternative accommodation options are also limited, underfunded, and not subject to
adequate monitoring and evaluation. It is not surprising, given this reality, that reports of
assault, neglect and re-trafficking in these environments are not uncommon.
22. Rescued children are not consistently enrolled in bridge school programmes (NCLP
School) after their return home. One CWC official stated that ‘only the parents of the
child have a role in school enrolment’. Participants listed several barriers to enrolment,
most prominently the lack of available participating schools in the district, the failure
of schools to deliver the promised daily stipend to formerly trafficked children, and the
child’s simple refusal to attend.
23. The Rescued Children who are successfully enrolled in bridge schools, returned children
face difficulties integrating into formal schools because the coordination between the two
systems is extremely poor. This serious problem is partly exacerbated by the fact that
bridge school programmes are run by the Ministry of Labour and Employment, while the
Ministry of Education organises formal schooling. The failure to invest in robust teaching
facilities in bridge schools and to ensure smooth transition opportunities into mainstream
formal education is a critical issue in the reintegration context.
24. NGOs representatives during FGDs reported that ‘There is no chance of financial help
or compensation to victims. It is believed that child’s freedom is itself compensation.’
Importantly, respondents did not list the lack of resources as the principal reason why
children are not compensated. They pointed to noncompliance by employers or technical
and administrative failures.
25. Responses of Programs Administrators (76%) clearly show that most of them are not
aware about various components of National Plan of Action (NPA) to combat Human
Trafficking. If the Programs Administrators are not fully aware about various components
of NPA, we were not able to understand how they are administering the various schemes
and programme to combat human trafficking in their respective areas.
26. About one third Programs Administrators are not aware about the main/nodal Agency/
Ministry/Actor for implementation of specific activities under NPA.
27. As per NPA, Central Advisory Committee is responsible for Monitoring and Evaluating
the Strategy and Activities under NPA. But only 9% Programs Administrators are aware
about this fact.
28. As per Direction of MHA & MoWCD State Nodal officers (Police) are responsible for
Coordination and holding periodical meetings to review and monitor the efforts taken
to prevent and combat the crime of trafficking at State Level. Only about 1/5th (19.6%)
Programs Administrators are aware about this fact.
29. Most of the Programs Administrators reported that they perceive menace of sex trafficking
Research Findings & Conclusions 267

for CSE as mild (48.2%) and moderate (41.4%). However, a significant proportion of
respondents (10.4%) in Jharkhand and Maharashtra reported it as severe.
30. The main reasons for people in the district being trafficked out according to Programs
Administrators include poverty, poor schooling, poor law enforcement, family conflicts,
lack of awareness, poor social support, lack of severe punishment to perpetrators and
search for better quality of life.
31. Majority of the Programs Administrators (62.9%) reported that they are witnessing
increasing trend of trafficking in their states. It was found more pronouncing in Jharkhand
followed by Maharashtra, Delhi, Uttar Pradesh and Assam while more than 1/4th
respondents in Uttar Pradesh and Jharkhand reported that they are realizing decreasing
trend of trafficking. Majority of the respondents (62.5%) admitted that trafficking methods
have shifted from brothels to private apartments, massage parlours and Escort services.
32. According to Programs Administrators Community awareness; prosecution and conviction
of offenders; rehabilitation of victims; establishment of helpline; and prevention against
vulnerabilities of trafficking are some of the existing measures that address the issues of
prevention of trafficking of women and children.
33. Most of Programs Administrators admitted that state initiatives to counter human
trafficking are moderate (53.9%) and significant (379%). The flaws in the existing laws
include mainly lack of severe penalty for repeat offenders; lack of continuous training of
investigators, judicial officers and public prosecutors; lack of provision for special court;
lack of protection for victims and witnesses; and non-existence of special investigating
agency.
34. Majority of the Programs Administrators (67.5%) reported that there is lack of capacity
building for care givers, law enforcement and judiciary while more than half of the
respondents (51.07%) revealed that there is lack of specialized investigative agencies.
Other lacunas included poor police infrastructure (38.21%), inadequate funds (38.21%),
adequate police officials (36.42%) and lack of political will (33.21%).
35. About 1/3rd Programs Administrators reported that Law Provide for using Confiscated
Proceeds of Crime to Compensate Victims. It was found more pronouncing in Maharashtra
followed by Karnataka.
36. Community awareness, empowerment of women and girls, prone to trafficking, proactive
community policing, help line for women and children, penalties to perpetrators and
clients of victims and sensitization programme for SSHs were some of the most effective
programmes in combating human trafficking according to Programs Administrators.
37. CWCs have not been constituted in a number of districts (20) and jurisdictional aberrations
create confusion resulting in a large number of vulnerable children not being able to access
their right to protection.
38. Majority of CWCs reviewed have a complete five-member composition in terms of official
appointment by Selection Committees. Poor attendance is however a concern. This extends
to prolonged absenteeism in some cases. Where vacant positions/ prolonged absenteeism
exist, recruitment is indefinitely delayed, sometimes leading to the inability to have a
quorum for final decisions. Overall, more men than women are appointed into CWCs. A
majority of CWC members and Chairpersons across the different States largely meet the
 268

minimum eligibility criteria. However, an ideal CWC composition in terms of a diverse

and multidisciplinary profile is missing.
39. CWCs appear to be dominated by those from the social work and education sector, while
people from law, medicine and psychology sectors are relatively under-represented.
Serious deviations and concerns have been noted in the CWC recruitment process,
including the appointment of government officials as Chairpersons; dual appointment
of CWC and JJB membership and dual CWC membership in two separate CWCs.
CWC recruitments that could lead to potential conflict of interest such as those who are
associated with a residential child care facility being appointed as CWC members within
the same district have also been noted.
40. Nearly all the CWCs are found to be functioning in incomplete settings and some in
severely insufficient settings. The concept of child-friendliness has not yet been defined
within the JJ System. Its implementation has been largely ignored in both the CWC set-
up as well as during CWC proceedings. A single fixed CWC sitting venue has been
insufficient to reach out to all children in need of care and protection within the district.
41. Irregular member attendance and prolonged absenteeism is a frequent occurrence among
many CWCs, the key reasons for this being the lack of fool proof attendance monitoring,
other professional commitments of members and inadequate sitting allowance. Currently,
there are no prescribed procedures in the Act or the Rules for management of cases during
proceedings. While a few CWCs effectively manage proceedings and case flow, others are
seen to flounder and use inefficient/ inappropriate practices.
Human trafficking, particularly of minors, is a kind of modern-day slavery that necessitates
a holistic, multi-sectoral strategy to address the problem’s complicated dimensions. Law cannot
be the exclusive device for dealing with challenging social and economic issues. Given the
infancy of services to trafficked people, monitoring and evaluation studies should be a part of
any assistance programme, both governmental and private. Anti-trafficking legislation must be
enforced properly, which necessitates educating individuals about the laws in place so that these
rights are respected and upheld in practice. There are provisions for victim confidentiality, in-
camera trial (Section 327 CrPC), and compensation (Section 357 CrPC) in the existing laws. These
provisions should be applied in relevant circumstances to protect victims’ rights. In dealing with
instances, the National Human Rights Commission has a larger role to play, and it must make
recommendations and adopt remedial actions. People must also be aware of the commission,
and it is now up to them to use these existing institutions to instill human rights ideals in their
homes, communities, societies, and public spaces. Furthermore, the three pillars of government,
namely the legislative, executive, and judiciary, must now respect and promote this culture of
human rights, particularly for women and the weaker sections of society, in order to combat
human trafficking in women and children to a larger level. Even NGOs, welfare agencies, legal
experts, civil society, and social workers must play a vital role in securing the rights of women
and children by advocating for them, giving legal help, and offering legal education from the
ground up.
Given the fact that services to trafficked persons are in their infancy, monitoring and
evaluation studies should be an integral part of every assistance program, public and private.
Well-designed monitoring and evaluation studies, particularly external evaluations, can identify
effective policies and ‘best practice’ approaches as well as assess the success of different programs.
Research Findings & Conclusions 269

Particularly important are longitudinal studies of the effects of rehabilitation programs on the
ability of survivors to integrate into the new society or re-integrate into their native one. There
is also a need for effective cooperation and coordination of research within and among different
regions of the world.
 Chapter 10
RECOMMENDATIONS
H uman trafficking, as a complex manifestation of the global economy, organized crime, and
human rights violations, causes extreme hardship for the millions of people suspected of being
victims of this crime around the world, and has an impact on the financial markets, economies,
and social structures of countries where trafficking is tolerated. Human trafficking has a complex
and overlapping detrimental impact across human, social, political, and economic spheres as
a fundamental component of organized crime with great financial power. The destabilizing
and dangerous implications range from publicly recognized violence, direct economic loss, and
huge migration issues to the less easily measurable, equally important, but more complicated
effects of environmental, social, health, and safety problems, as well as human rights violations.
Human trafficking is a direct threat to the formation of stable, successful communities and
lawful economies, and it works against reconciling political goals with humanitarian and human
rights commitments. The variety of trafficking-related crimes and their vast and interconnected
consequences have altered political, social, and economic responses at both national and global
levels, posing a cumulative danger to global peace, security, and stability.
Human trafficking jeopardizes the dignity and security of those who are trafficked, as well as
their human rights. When it comes to real execution, India’s constitutions provide equal rights
for men and women, but they are sometimes just rhetoric. To combat human trafficking and so
defend the human rights of vulnerable people, governments must have a strong political will to
carry out their anti-trafficking responsibilities. Like a result, every crime that can be profited from
one day becomes a major social problem, as in the case of people trafficking. The solution to the
problem is still in our hands if thoughtful, forceful efforts are taken and policies are created and
rigidly executed. If prompt action is not done, it will be late, but too late, in a very short period.
In light of the critical examination of the existing legislation and its gaps to tackle different forms
of human trafficking and punish the perpetrators, Prevention, Protection and Rehabilitations
measures taken by Government of India and the State Governments and the Challenges being
faced by various stakeholders in combating Trafficking of Women and Children in India, we
recommend following Remedies:

Prevention:
1. To combat economic distress, states should map all vulnerable families, particularly
migrants and children at risk, and link them to 37 government schemes, including those
272

for skill development, income generation, housing, right to education, and livelihood
schemes, such as those under the Atmanirbhar Yojana. The government’s many policies,
programmes, and initiatives involve different departments must be intertwined in such
a way that they must include an anti-trafficking component that is integrated into the
larger plan of action by the concerned government department. Self-Help Groups (SHGs)
and PRIs can be useful in this regard.
2. It is necessary to identify appropriate points of intervention so that migrants and future
migrants are warned about the dangers and repercussions of human trafficking and get
information that allows them to seek help if necessary. Effective patrolling and vigilance
at trafficking hotspots such as highways, dhabas, railway stations, and bus stations
for suspicious movement of traffickers and victims, as well as monitoring suspicious/
unnecessary movements of strangers in villages with the help of the village community.
Truckers Against Trafficking (TAT) and Bus Operators Against Trafficking (BOAT)
initiative could play a major role.
3. Most migrant workers or victims of trafficking, especially females, are given domestic
labour by traffickers, placement agencies, recruiters of migrant workers, etc. The majority
of people employed in the sex and entertainment sectors, caretakers, and domestic
employees are not covered by labour regulations. To guarantee domestic workers’
rights to compensation, reasonable working hours, good health, and other benefits, it is
important to regulate domestic employment and create a legislative organisation to do so.
Residents Welfare Associations (RWAs) should be given the responsibility of keeping a
database of domestic workers, servants, and maids in their colonies and societies, as well
as making sure that there is no child labour there. In order to prevent domestic employees
from being taken advantage of, they could also be given the authority to regularly inspect
homes or apartments.
4. The second prerequisite is for a regulatory body to oversee migrations, like the Migrant
Worker’s Commission, to guarantee safety and security of movement. Third, there has to
be a dedicated web portal for keeping a database of every single migrant worker so that
their present status can be evaluated or tracked and they can benefit from various social
security programmes. Finally, we think that governments should accredit recruitment
agencies and actively monitor, control, and oversee them.
5. Recruitment agencies should be required to require contracts for migrant workers, and
each state should have a law to regulate them, like the Chhattisgarh Private Placement
Agencies (Regulation) Act, 2013, or the Jharkhand Private Employment Agency and
Domestic Employee Bill, 2016. It is proposed that there be a web-based single point
registration system (SPRS) for recording all placement agencies’ addresses and locations,
with the requirement that no placement agency may function without being registered on
SPRS. A Department of Labour & Employment inspector level officer may be assigned to
regularly audit the placement agencies’ field operations and data accuracy.
6. The government should make sure that all migratory workers in the informal sector,
including prostitutes, are covered by social security programmes and that their children
have access to education in all states.
7. Between NGOs within states, between states, across borders, and other stakeholders, there
exist large coordination gaps or failures. A National Integrated Grid of Anti-Trafficking
Recommendations 273

NGOs that is connected to NGO groups outside of Bangladesh and Nepal’s borders is
appropriate and essential. Partnership between NGOs and government organisations
is essential in anti-trafficking programmes and actions. The National System of Anti-
Trafficking Nodal Officers at the national level may be connected to the NGO grid.
Ministry of MHA and I&B can play a vital role in this regard.
8. There is a lack of resources at every level, especially in terms of funding to combat human
trafficking, as seen by the underfunding of shelter homes, which impedes the process
of rehabilitation. Collaboration between businesses and non-profits can be started by
either party or encouraged by the proper government agencies. The enormous sums that
corporations set aside to fulfil their social obligations (CSR) could be efficiently directed
into the fight against trafficking. In this regard Ministry of Corporate Affairs may put the
activities to combat human trafficking on top priority under Section 135 of the Companies
Act, 2013 (‘Act’), Schedule VII of the Act and Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014.
9. A comprehensive information system about both the trafficked individual and the
traffickers/brothel owners/operators is lacking. We support the establishment of a
national website on human trafficking where members of the public, law enforcement, and
non-governmental groups may exchange images and details on trafficked individuals and
traffickers. A National Database connected to a National, State, and District Dashboard is
required to continuously monitor cases and oversee rescue and rehabilitation efforts. This
will make it possible for the police, judges, concerned government officials, and non-profit
organisations to stay informed and act quickly. To facilitate effective communication, it
is important to promote regional information exchange on trafficking. To provide data
bases, situational analyses, information system management, training modules, and
documentation of best practises, a national media resource centre should be established.
Ministry of MHA can play a vital role in this regard.
10. Human trafficking is so deeply ingrained in society’s social ethos that it cannot be addressed
just through legal measures, government programmes, or initiatives. Lack of livelihood
possibilities, gender discrimination, and opportunity deprivation are the most serious
challenges. The community should guarantee human rights. Other stakeholders, such as
schools, panchayats, other democratic institutions, NGOs, CBOs, religious teachers, media
persons, and all members of the community, must play an important part in transforming
the neighborhood’s existing “culture of quiet” into “community involvement.”
11. The National Resource Center for Human Trafficking Chairperson and UN Anti-Human
Trafficking Nodal Officer Dr. PM Nair IPS (Retd.) provided support and direction for
the Panchayat Against Human Trafficking (PAHT) initiative, which was launched in
Vithura Grama, Thiruvananthapuram district, Kerala. This initiative could be replicated
in every Gram Panchayat in India. This will involve a public awareness campaign and the
development of an all-inclusive system to fight human trafficking at the grass-roots level
that will involve all officials at that level. Women and children must be made aware of the
tactics used by traffickers to entice them with enticing employment, lucrative incomes,
and unions that result in commercial sexual exploitation. In addition to their proactive
involvement, all stakeholders must be empowered by the community, have their
capacities increased, and get support. It is recommended that Anti Human Trafficking
Clubs (AHTCs) be established in every Indian school, college, and university for efficient
awareness building and prevention of human trafficking because students are change
274

agents in any society.

12. Anti-trafficking movement should begin in order to keep the subject of human trafficking
at the forefront of national debate. The media should play a beneficial role in promoting
a good outlook. The media can help boost public awareness and participation in anti-
human trafficking activities. It is a potent tool for social change because of its reach and
ability to influence public opinion. As a result, it is vital to communicate often with the
media. Investigative journalism on human trafficking should be encouraged. However,
media coverage should take a rights-based approach to ensure that victims’ and survivors’
rights are not violated. Ministry of I&B can play a vital role in this regard.
13. Stringent laws should be enacted to prevent immoral social conventions that, in the name
of folk culture, traditions, and rituals, induct minor girls and children into the flesh trade.
Social initiatives for the rehabilitation of prostitutes should be carried out in partnership
with non-governmental organisations (NGOs), particularly among specific castes and
communities such as the Kolta, Nat, Bedia, Mahar, and others.
14. To prevent the threat of sex tourism, the government must act quickly. It is necessary to
institutionalize coordination between state police agencies and central law enforcement
agencies, including immigration officers, as well as other related departments such as
tourism and urban development.
15. The problem of second-generation prostitution can be reduced if the children of prostitutes
are given a fair future. Prajwala, an Andhra Pradesh-based anti-trafficking organization,
has made a start.
16. The level of awareness of schemes and programmes among trafficking victims
was found to be quite low. There is an increased need to raise awareness among the
trafficking vulnerable population in general, and among trafficking victims in particular,
about various development schemes and programmes being implemented by State
Governments, which are either sponsored by the Central Government or by the State
Government. Ministry of I&B can play a vital role in this regard.
17. Cross-border collaboration is required in more than just bordering districts. Ad hoc task
groups or cross-border committees, on the other hand, are operating in a number of sites
along the border at the request of local governments or law enforcement officials manning
the border. For starters, such informal networks, which include both government officials
and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), might be institutionalized so that they can
successfully carry out anti-trafficking efforts.
18. Because the law is silent on controlling the proliferation, promotion, and advertisement
of prostitution on digital platforms and even through leaflets/pamphlets, gangs engaged
in organised prostitution are enticing clients using the internet, text messaging, and
mobile-based applications. Organized sexual services are offered in nightclubs, massage
parlours, spas, luxury hotels & resorts, motels, dance bars, private residences, huts, and
even cars, among other places, under the guise of cross-gender massage services. On the
internet and on mobile devices, these kinds of messages ought to be outlawed, and an
effective monitoring system ought to be developed to find such material there and on
other social media platforms. To counteract organised prostitution, which may be a form
of human trafficking and is illegal under the law, local police should be especially vigilant
and frequent checks and raids should be conducted at these sites.
Recommendations 275

19. The same recruiter can repeatedly traffic many vulnerable children from a village because
arrests are typically focused on the place of exploitation rather than on perpetrators
complicit in other stages of trafficking. As a result, it is suggested that widespread
knowledge of human traffickers be raised at both the source and transit points.
20. Along with a growing market for child sexual abuse materials and technology-facilitated
child sex trafficking, there is an increase in the recruitment of vulnerable individuals for
online sexual exploitation by traffickers. Social media and messaging businesses have
been urged by CEDAW to implement sufficient security measures to lower the danger of
human trafficking and sexual exploitation of women and girls. Digital platforms should
use “big data, artificial intelligence, and analytics to identify any pattern that could lead
to trafficking and identification of the relevant parties” engaging in criminal activities,
according to the request. In this regards MHA may create a cell & a dashboard under Indian
Cybercrime Coordination Centre (I4C) Scheme for combating Online Human Trafficking
with a alert system for local police. The cell may be entrusted with the responsibility to
verify that social media and messaging providers are adhering to CEDAW regulations. It
is also essential to start a significant public education effort regarding the nation’s cyber
laws.

Effective Rescue, Rehabilitation, Repatriation & Re-Integration

1. Sex workers have expressed a desire to be included in social security programmes as
well as take part in larger campaigns and forums advocating for the rights of the
unorganised sector. Customized rehabilitation programmes have been found to be more
successful than shelter-based programmes, such as the Community Based Rehabilitation
Package and identity-based self-help groups. CBR is more efficient than shelter-based
rehabilitation because it enables survivors to access mainstream health, education, and
welfare services while residing with their family or in independent shelters. It might be
possible to reproduce the Gujrat Amul Model for Sex Workers Rehabilitation in other
regions of India. We recommend that initiatives impacting sex workers be carried out with
the input, participation, and leadership of sex workers. We urge the Indian government to
adopt a comprehensive strategy to uphold sex workers’ human rights.
2. The Bonded Labor Abolition Act limits the definition of an accused to the primary employer
and excludes traffickers from prosecution. The fact that victims were not recognised
as such, did not receive “release certificates,” and were not qualified for government
assistance was considered labour exploitation by some. It is essential that the statute be
amended so that traffickers are subject to prosecution under the Bonded Labor Laws. We
demand that those responsible for such abuses be held accountable to the fullest extent of
the law and that programme managers, including SDMs, receive training on how to do
away with the bonded labour system.
3. There is a serious lack of services provided in the majority of shelter homes managed
by NGOs. Budgetary resources must be increased to support the programme. Anti-
trafficking initiatives that are creative, multifaceted, and cross-sectoral should be given
top priority. The Indian government should push for the use of CSR cash for community-
based rehabilitation programmes and closely supervised shelter facilities in the anti-
trafficking sector.
4. Strong oversight and administration of Shelter homes’ operations, as well as the provision
276

of Social Audit, are also crucial. It is imperative to have an unbiased social audit authority.
These shelters should be connected to various government programmes like ICDS,
NRHM, NSDM/NSDC, and others in order to establish convergence and connect rescued
victims to the mainstream.
5. The Ministry of Women and Child Development, in collaboration with the Ministries of
Education and Skill Development, should implement skill development initiatives and
vocational training programmes for children rescued from beggaring, drug abuse, child
labour, bonded labour, and adolescent dropout girls.
6. We recommend that the central and provincial governments develop and implement
regular monitoring mechanisms for government-run and government-funded shelters to
ensure appropriate quality of care and promptly disburse funding to shelters that meet
official care standards; and that the central and provincial governments improve the
implementation of protection and compensation schemes for human trafficking victims
to ensure that they receive benefits. Shelters must follow minimum care requirements
and not infringe on survivors’ fundamental rights, as well as avoid arrest and indefinite
incarceration.
7. Rehabilitation and Re-integration policies should be family centric rather than victim
centric otherwise there are chances of re-trafficking. Safety and security of victims must
be the center of multi-agency work. Appropriate safety of victims and a conducive
environment is the prerequisite of a shelter home and this should not be compromised in
any way.
8. Shelters for women and other organisations that serve women specifically must manage
their services from a gender perspective. All paid and volunteer staff in specialised
support services must be taught about gender perspectives. It is important to address
gender disparity in all fields of work, especially those that include working with young
children of both sexes. Any form of discrimination ought to be prohibited. General and
specialised women’s support services must adopt a victim-centered, human rights-based
approach with the fundamental tenet that “nothing about victims without victims” due
to the institutional power systems that oppress women who have been abuse victims.
In particular, victims shouldn’t be intimidated or pressured into filing a lawsuit. Any
decision regarding the victim should only be taken with the victim’s informed permission,
unless it’s an emergency.
9. Depending on the objective of the shelter and the anticipated requirements of the women
it will serve, particular positions and qualifications should be given preference. To
optimise the breadth of services that can be provided with limited resources, personnel
from Shelter Home may be hired on a case-by-case basis or staff with diverse/multiple
abilities may be recruited.
10. We have not encountered a single psychological counsellor in any of the visited shelter
homes throughout our interactions with service providers; psychological counselling is
typically only conducted on paper in most cases and shelter homes. The study found
that those who have been trafficked frequently experience depression and post-traumatic
stress disorder (PTSD). Therefore, a person with PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder)
won’t be able to fully utilise the possibilities and resources at their disposal, which will
undermine their resilience. As a result, recovery from trauma or having access to excellent
Recommendations 277

mental health care are essential elements of human trafficking survivors’ rehabilitation.
“Community-based rehabilitation is essential, where the impacted survivor obtains
financial, social, psychosocial, and legal help, as opposed to an institution-based approach
of placing them into shelter homes.” The feeling of being imprisoned in a small space
with a lot of uncertainty can lead to problems like irritability, sleeplessness, and more.
We suggest requiring PTSD testing of human trafficking survivors before they may be
rehabilitated and assisting NGOs in offering assistance for rights-based case management.
11. Rehabilitation frequently entails returning the child/victim to the same parents who
exploited them in the first place. “We must abandon the notion that the natal family is a
safe sanctuary for young children and develop novel rehabilitation solutions.” Stopping
child trafficking in the country should be the responsibility of the government. It should be
made mandatory and compulsory that no victim is re-integrated and repatriation until and unless
complete home verification is done.
12. In circumstances where the victim’s or child’s safe return to his or her family is either
impractical or not in the victim’s best interests, sufficient care arrangements that preserve
the victim’s rights and dignity must be created. A child who is mature enough to form
their own ideas should be given the freedom to express them in every choice that affects
them, especially those involving the possibility of returning to their family, and their
opinions should be given the weight that is appropriate given their maturity and age.
13. Mandatory repatriation of rescued survivors is not desired, as many of the girls were
averse to the prospect of reuniting with their families. Participants who were duped into
trafficking by deception were eager to return to their families, whereas those who had fled
their homes due to domestic violence and eventually ended up in a trafficking position
were hesitant to return.
14. To arrest re-trafficking and facilitate the return and reintegration tailor-made strategies
are required, which can address the factors which lead to the victimization in the first
instance. All interventions during the rehabilitation phase must address the potentially
vulnerable elements causing trafficking in the first place on the case-by-case basis.
15. Service Providers (Shelter homes) have no mechanism for follow up or monitoring of
victims after reintegration. It is recommended that periodic monitoring of the victim’s
well-being after reintegration be done through service providers on the ground before
closing the case.
16. The Ministry of Labour & Employment, Ministry of Education, and State Governments
should collaborate to ensure that there are enough NCLP Schools in each district and
develop a monitoring mechanism to ensure that NCLP schools are providing the services
for which they were created. The rescued children and their families require ongoing
counselling and persuasion to enrol in NCLP Schools. In the context of reintegration, it is
crucial to invest at strong teaching facilities in bridge schools and to guarantee seamless
entry possibilities into mainstream formal education. Coordination and interdepartmental
cooperation are therefore particularly desirable.
17. The Compensation Scheme for Women Victims/Survivors of Sexual Assault/Other
Crime-2018 was only known to 3.6% of victims. Information on victim compensation
schemes is even more important for victims and programme administrators. Judges
should occasionally give restitution to those who have fallen victim to any form of
 278

human trafficking through other government initiatives. There is an urgent need for
strengthening the systems of victim compensation for increasing access to survivors of
all forms of trafficking. An essential factor that enables survivors to work in congruence
with the justice system involves harm reparation and compensation that is provided to
the survivors in question.
18. The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) is largely unknown to victims,
traffickers, parents, and clients. We strongly suggest educating the general public, as
well as law enforcement personnel, service providers, prosecutors, and programme
administrators, about the NHRC’s duties and functions, as well as its grievance redressal
procedure.

Effective Law Enforcement & Prosecution:

1. Law enforcement officials should treat cases of missing children as abduction or trafficking
until proven otherwise as per Direction of The Supreme Court in 2013 and search for
these people in every possible location. When children disappear, Law EAs should start
the missing person’s process, look into what happened, disseminate information, and
conduct investigations, collaborating with other agencies as needed.
2. About 31 percent Parent respondents reported that their children were working in
hazardous industries- metallurgical industries, coal, fertilizers, mining, chemical &
petrochemicals, cement and firecracker workshops. We recommend that provisions of
The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection) of Children Act, 2000: “If any person employs
a child in any of the hazardous work or use the child as a bonded labour then that person
will be punishable under this Act.” And The Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation)
Act, 1986: “No child who is less than 14 years of age shall be employed in any hazardous
occupations that are provided in a list by law.” should be implemented in letter and
sprits. Violators should be punished. Regular check of hazardous industries/units must
be carried out by the Labour Inspectors.
3. The idea of community policing needs to be made more widely known in order for people
and non-governmental organisations to get involved in policing to stop and combat the
trafficking of women and children.
4. Anti-Human Trafficking units (AHTUs) are currently under-resourced as well as
undertrained. There is an urgent need for additional Capacity Building of AHTUs and
Providing them adequate funds and infrastructure because “the police lack the means to
undertake a thorough investigation if the person is trafficked from another state.”
5. To address the issue and protect the rights of victims and survivors, comprehensive
legislation is required due to the underreporting of human trafficking instances and gaps
in other laws. For law enforcement organisations, there is a need for an extensive training
and capacity-building programme on the topic of human trafficking. It should be made
mandatory for AHTU or the Police to report every case of human trafficking. At police
stations, courts, and other homes and institutions for victims of human trafficking, we
promote the hiring of social workers and counsellors who are certified and trained in
their fields. Law enforcement Agencies (LEAs) must also take every accusation of sexual
harassment seriously because failing to do so gives the perpetrators more power and
enables them to commit even more heinous crimes.
Recommendations 279

6. We advise the police to use the following strategies to win the trust of victims: Assuring
victims that they are not the subject of an inquiry Victims deserve to be treated with respect
and decency. Employ a translator if the victims speak different languages, ensuring that
the victim’s identity and privacy are protected by taking all necessary precautions; Keep
the accused far enough away from the victims to be safe. Check to see if Section 228
A of the IPC and Section 21 of the JJ Act are being followed; Inform the victims of the
investigation’s development; Keep in mind that the victim takes all of their belongings
with them. Do not take offence if traumatised victims behave inappropriately or refuse to
interact. Avoid, among other things, using derogatory language or making humiliating
gestures or body language. Police officers may be able to overcome these challenges using
their knowledge, skilful communication abilities, and information because it is also a
question of counselling and persuasion.
7. According to public prosecutors, the primary causes for the low conviction rate include
witnesses becoming hostile, inadequate evidence, a long court process, an improper
charge sheet, and easy bail for traffickers. The problem of insufficient evidence and
improper charge sheet could be addressed by conducting thorough investigations into
human trafficking instances. Because most witnesses and victims become hostile during
prosecution, more emphasis should be placed on gathering Material Evidence, Medical
Examination of Victims, Suspects, Digital Videography of Investigations & Statements of
Victims and Documents Supplemented by Forensic Evidences for filling a charge sheet
instead of a statement under section 161 of the Cr..Pc., as this will almost certainly increase
the chances of offenders being convicted.
8. A qualified and experienced investigative agency, such as the National Investigation
Agency (NIA), which has been mandated to look into interstate and international
trafficking crimes, is urgently required for the proper investigation of human trafficking
cases. We support the full capacity building of law enforcement and prosecuting
organisations, including providing them with state-of-the-art methods and tools for
obtaining information and forensic evidence, as well as witness and victim protection,
which may lead to a more severe conviction.
9. Recruitment agencies, document forgers, brokers, brothel owners, debt collectors,
managers and owners of employment agencies, corrupt immigration officials, consular
staff, embassy staff, law enforcement officers, border guards who accept bribes in exchange
for passports, visas, and safe transit, and all others who are involved by their acts of
omission and commission that result in exploitation should be dealt harshly under law.
10. In order to safeguard some victims of human trafficking, prosecutors should set up child-
friendly courts, as is done in Telangana and West Bengal. Most of the time, courts should
employ video conferencing to hear testimony from victims who have been reintegrated
or repatriated. Since it is essential for convicting traffickers and criminals, victim and
witness protection should be carefully considered. Because of poor witness protection
and the drawn-out legal process, many victims were reluctant to take part in trials against
their traffickers. As a result, it should be ensured that cases are routinely reviewed by
superior authorities.
11. In many parts of India only designated AHTUs have been established. To combat human
trafficking, all states and territories should establish an Anti-Human Trafficking Bureau
280

at the state capital level, as well as independent, non-designated Anti-Human Trafficking

Units (AHTUs) at every district level, and use of Women Help Desks to monitor
investigations at every police station by a Senior Officer at State Level. Dedicated AHTUs
are urgently needed because some AHTUs lacked defined mandates, were not completely
focused on human trafficking, and often received requests for assistance months later,
limiting the effectiveness of investigations. In a few cases, police allegedly freed alleged
sex traffickers on bond right away, allowing them to focus on other crimes. Trafficking
investigations are lengthy and complex, and we believe that having full-time resources
devoted to these investigations are essential for success. These officials also underscore
the need to provide and use undercover assets and to establish and nurture informants
and witnesses.
12. Many traffickers use railways as a significant route of transport for trafficking victims
to other states and border areas as Railway Police is generally reluctant in Reporting of
such cases and only GD is maintained. Ministry of Home Affairs should collaborate with
the Ministry of Railways. The Railway Board should be asked to enlist the help of the
Railway Protection Force (RPF) and the Government Railway Police (GRP) to combat
human trafficking at railway stations. They should instruct GRP and RPF officials to
remain watchful and alert when dealing with such instances and mandatorily report each
and every case of Human trafficking.
13. In Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Nasik, Kolkata, and other cities, we have found a tonne of
brothels that are operating under the radar of the local police. The provision of Section 18
of the ITPA, which permits the closure of brothels and the removal of offenders, has only
occasionally been used. Education and accountability for law enforcement officials are
crucial. Brothels ought to be shut down right away. A thorough action plan needs to be
created for this project. Prostitutes and commercial sex workers need to be rehabilitated
into other fields in order to improve their livelihoods. The relationship between police
and owners of brothels makes things worse. This nexus has to be broken up as soon as
feasible.
14. It is advised that rescue teams strictly follow rescue protocols and include a representative
from the Department of Labor, representatives from the CWCs, a local non-profit, a doctor,
and a female police officer or volunteer. Almost every stakeholder reported that police
do not follow standard rescue protocol. These people need to receive training on the
pertinent laws, their responsibilities, and trauma prevention methods. Both the specifics
of the rescue and the identities of the people who were saved must be kept completely
secret and not shared with anyone, including the media. Key informant data indicates
that this overdependence results in ad hoc and under-resourced raids that are led by
inexperienced or under-supported employees. This circumstance can and does cause
further trauma to vulnerable children and could have been avoided.
15. The incidence of women and minor girls being trafficked for CSE is not well understood
by law enforcement organisations, including police personnel, and they frequently are
not aware of their obligations under the ITPA with regard to trafficking. Enforcing the
law in relation to applicable Acts like CLPRA, BLSA, IPTA, JJA, and IPC involves not only
police but also many other authorities involved in the Criminal Justice System, such as
executive magistrates, labour officials, CWC members, and in-charges of Homes. In order
to strengthen the state’s investigation and prosecution apparatus in this area, the State
Recommendations 281

government should create a time-bound action plan.

16. The development of all stakeholders’ capacities and a regular programme of gender
sensitization are absolutely necessary. As a result, dealing with cases of human trafficking
and their rehabilitation requires a specialist team of social workers. The assistance of
the cadre might be advantageous to the police, courts, and treatment centers. All of
the following are necessary: gender sensitization; training and capacity building for
police officials; strict action against police officials found guilty of corrupt practices; and
harassment of victims, especially young girls. Police officers need to be well informed on
the commercial sex network.
17. To launch an investigation and potentially bring charges against a suspect, Labor
Department representatives must submit a First Information Report (FIR). Respondents
claimed that in practise, FIRs are not always filed and that there is confusion and
disagreement regarding who is in charge of filing them. A First Information Report should
be filed in every instance of child labour, the case should be thoroughly investigated,
and the offenders should be punished. As a result, there is an urgent need to train and
sensitise labour department workers on the aforementioned issue.
18. IPC section 370 has a number of gaps, and cases are obviously underreported. It disregards
victim compensation, rehabilitation, and access to justice in favour of prosecuting the
traffickers. We suggest that Section 370 of the Penal Code be revised to include forced
labour trafficking in its definition of trafficking and to ensure that the presence of force,
deceit, or coercion is not a necessary element of a child sex trafficking accusation. The
Act should also include provisions for victim rehabilitation and financial compensation.
The rights of human trafficking victims should be given top priority under the Act. All
forms of human trafficking should be covered, such as bonded labour, child labour,
forced labour, forced marriage, sexual exploitation, commercial surrogacy, begging, and
organ transplantation. We further demand that Section 370’s definition of “trafficking” be
changed to encompass traffickers and brothels.
19. The lack of an interpreter who is fluent in the relevant local languages makes it difficult to
care for children who have been trafficked from different states. As a result, professional
interpreters are required in such situations. At the district level, a database of competent
language interpreters should be kept and shared with law enforcement agencies, service
providers, and the courts.
20. CWCs must be established in each district as soon as possible, according to available
guidelines, and multiple appointment practices should be strictly prohibited to eliminate
potential conflicts of interest. CWCs should include those who work in the fields of law,
medicine, and psychology.
21. It is found that almost all CWCs are working in inadequate sittings, some of which are
seriously inadequate. To deal with this, three different sorts of sitting venue styles are
utilised by several CWCs across the nation. There are further unique sittings available,
including rotating and parallel sittings. Each, however, offers a unique set of benefits and
drawbacks. A mixed sitting configuration of CWC is advised as needed.
22. The Act and the Rules do not currently provide any procedures for case management
during hearings. While some CWCs successfully handle proceedings and financial
flow, others seem to be struggling and using ineffective/inappropriate approaches. The
 282

necessary authorities must create a flawless attendance system, such as Aadhar Enabled
Biometric Attendance, to prevent prolonged absenteeism from CWC meetings because it
interferes with the evaluation of children’s rights.
23. Many trafficked people are still unable to access governmental help due to administrative
hurdles. One of the most difficult parts is determining legal status. There is a need for
creating legal status and documents to access services and opportunities.
24. In the vast majority of human trafficking instances, local police do not take harsh
measures against the perpetrators. Strong action against human traffickers should be
taken, including criminal penalties and the freezing of their bank accounts. The unlawful
assets amassed by traffickers and other parties as a result of exploiting trafficked victims
should be seized and forfeited.
The development of all stakeholders’ capacities and a regular programme of gender
sensitization are absolutely necessary.
 Appendix 1
REFERENCES
A Havocscope Report (2015): Black Market Crime, Prostitution: Prices and Statistics of the Global Sex Trade
Aengst, J. 2001. Litigation Report: Girl Trafficking in Nepal. Human Rights Advocacy Clinic.
Agarwal, Anuja. 2008. Chaste Wives and Prostitute Sisters: Patriarchy and Prostitution among the Bedias of
India. New Delhi: Routledge.
Agrawal, Anuja. 2018. Situating the law on prostitution/sex work in India. E-journal of the Indian Sociological
Society 2: 3–20.
AHTU Watch- A National Study on Status of Anti Human Trafficking Units in India (2010-2019) by Sanjog-
Kolkata and Tafteesh-Delhi, Available at https://idronline.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/AHTU-
Watch-Status-of-Anti-Human-Trafficking-Units-in-India-2010-2019.pdf
American Psychological Association, Task Force on Trafficking of Women and Girls. (2014). Report of the Task
Force on Trafficking of Women and Girls. Retrieved from http://www.apa.org/pi/women/programs/
trafficking/report.aspx
Andrees, B. and M. N. J. van der Linden (2005) ‘Designing trafficking research from a labour market perspective:
The ILO experience’, International Migration, 43 (1-2): 55-73.
Anderson, B. and J. O. Davidson. 2003. Is trafficking in Human Beings Demand Driven? A Multi-Country Pilot
Study. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
Annual Report of National Commission for Women, 1995-96
Aronowitz, A. (2009-10). Understanding Trafficking in Human Beings. In M. Natarajan (Ed.), International Crime
and Justice (pp. 118-125). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511762116.021
ASI (2003) The Migration-trafficking Nexus: Combating Trafficking through the Protection of Migrants’ Human
Rights, London: Anti-Slavery International.
Asian Development Bank (2002) Combating Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: Regional
synthesis Paper for Bangladesh, India and Nepal. Manila.
Asian Development Bank. 2003a. Combating Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: Regional
Synthesis Paper for Bangladesh, India, and Nepal. Manila: Asian Development Bank.
Asian Development Bank. 2003b. Combating Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: Guide for
Integrating Trafficking Concerns into ADB Operations. Manila: Asian Development Bank
Apne Aap Women Worldwide. 2013. Annual Report 2012–2013. New Delhi: Apne Aap Women Worldwide.
Asian Development Bank. 2003a. Combating Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: Regional
Synthesis Paper for Bangladesh, India, and Nepal. Manila: ADB
Balfour, Giselle & Okech, David & Callands, Tamora & Kombian, Grace. (2020). A Qualitative Analysis of
the Intervention Experiences of Human Trafficking Survivors and At-risk Women in Ghana. Journal of
 284

Human Trafficking. 1-15. 10.1080/23322705.2020.1806186.

Banerjee, S. (2000) Under the Raj: Prostitution in Colonial Bengal. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Basu, Arnab K., and Nancy H. Chau. 2004. “Exploitation of Child Labor and the Dynamics of Debt Bondage.”
Journal of Economic Growth 9(2): 209-38.
Baumeister, R. F., and Campbell, W. K. (1999). The intrinsic appeal of evil: sadism, sensational thrills, and
threatened egotism. Pers. Soc. Psychol. Rev. 3, 210–221. doi: 10.1207/s15327957pspr0303_4
Blanchard J. F., J. O’Neil, B.M. Ramesh et al. 2005. “Understanding the social and cultural contexts of female sex
workers in Karnataka India: Implications for prevention of HIV infection”. Journal of Infectious Diseases,
191 (suppl 1): 139–46.
Bhattacherya, U. (2018) Why Is the Anti-Trafficking Bill Bothering India’s Sex Workers? The Quint. Available
at: https://www.thequint.com/voices/women/anti-trafficking-bill-india-2018-sex-workers-
problems (Accessed: 12 September 2020).
Bhatt, W. 2009. “The gender dimension of migration in India: The politics of contemporary space in Orissa and
Rajasthan”. Development in Practice, 19(1): 87–93.
Banandur, P., S. Ramanaik, L. E. Manhart et al. 2012. “Understanding out-migration among female sex workers
in South India”. Sexually Transmitted Diseases. 39(10): 776–83.
Benjamin, Harry, et al. 1964. Prostitution and morality: A definitive report on the prostitute in contemporary
society and an analysis of the causes and effects of the suppression of prostitution. New York: Julian Press.
Benoit, C., Smith, M., Jansson, M., Healey, P., & Magnuson, D. (2018). “The prostitution problem”: Claims,
evidence, and policy outcomes. Archives of Sexual Behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-018-1276-6.
Béteille, André. “M.S.A. Rao.” Contributions to Indian Sociology 20, no. 2 (July 1986): 301–2. https://doi.
org/10.1177/006996686020002010.
Beattie, T. S., P. Bhattacharjee, B. Ramesh et al. 2010. “Violence against female sex workers in Karnataka state,
south India: Impact on health, and reductions in violence following an intervention program”. BMC Public
Health, 10(1): 476.
Beyrer, C. and J. Stachowiak. 2003. “Health consequences of trafficking of women and girls in Southeast Asia”.
Brown Journal of World Affairs, 10(1): 105–17.
Bohl, K. (2010). Human trafficking as a livelihood strategy? (Doctoral dissertation, Master Thesis in Culture).
Book, A., Visser, B. A., Blais, J., Hosker-Field, A., Methot-Jones, T., Gauthier, N. Y., et al. (2016). Unpacking
“eviller”: what is at the core of the dark tetrad? Pers. Indiv. Differ. 90, 269–272. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2015.11.009
Boruah, Jayanta and Baruah, Masia, Legal Implications of Sex Tourism (April 3, 2021). Journal on Jurisprudential
Studies Vol 1 Issue 3, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3818710
Bowen, K., J. Dzuvichu, B. Rungsung et al. 2011. “Life circumstances of women entering sex work in Nagaland,
India”. Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health, 23(6): 843–51.
Brahme, R., S. Mehta, S. Sahay et al. 2006. “Correlates and trend of HIV prevalence among female sex workers
attending sexually transmitted disease clinics in Pune”. Journal of Acquired Deficiency Syndrome, 41:
107–13.
Buckels, E. E., Jones, D. N., and Paulhus, D. L. (2013). Behavioral confirmation of everyday sadism. Psychol.
Sci. 24, 2201–2209. doi: 10.1177/0956797613490749
Bullough, Vern, et al. 1978. Prostitution: An illustrated social history. New York: Crown Publishers.
Buunk, A. P., Bucksath, A. F., and Cordero, S. (2017). Intrasexual competitiveness and personality traits: a study
in Uruguay. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 108, 178–181. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2016.11.060
Burke, Alicia., Stafania Ducci and Giuseppina Maddaluno 2005 Trafficking in Minors for Commercial Sexual
Exploitation: Costa Rica. Torino. UNICRI.
Burley, N., and Symanski, R. (1981). “Women without: an evolutionary and cross-cultural perspective on
REFERENCES 285

prostitution,” in The Immoral Landscape: Female Prostitution in Western Societies, ed. R. Symanski (New York,
NY: Butterworths), 239–274.
Buss, D. M., and Schmitt, D. P. (2001). “Sexual strategies theory: an evolutionary perspective,” in Social Psychology
and Human Sexuality: Essential Readings, ed. R. Baumeister (Hove: Psychology Press), 57–94.
Buss, D. M., and Schmitt, D. P. (2019). Mate preferences and their behavioral manifestations. Annu. Rev.
Psychol. 70, 77–110. doi: 10.1146/annurev-psych-010418-103408
Buss, D. M. (2009). How can evolutionary psychology successfully explain personality and individual
differences? Perspect. Psychol. Sci. 4, 359–366. doi: 10.1111/j.1745-6924.2009. 01138.x
Bruckert, Christine, and Colette Parent 2002 Trafficking in human beings and organized crime: A literature
review Research and Evaluation Branch Community, Contract and Aboriginal Policing Services
Directorate. Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Caldwell, Gillian, Steven Galster and Nadia Steinozer. 1997. Crime and Servitude: An Expose of the Traffic in
Women for Prostitution in the Newly Independent States. NY: Global Survival Network and International
League for Human Rights.
Carter, G. L., Campbell, A. C., and Muncer, S. (2014). The Dark Triad: beyond a ‘male’ mating strategy. Pers.
Indiv. Differ. 56, 159–164. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2013.09.001
Chakraborty, Usha. 1963. Condition of Bengali women: Around the second half of the 19th century. Calcutta:
Chandra, J. (2018) Activists oppose draft anti-trafficking Bill – The Hindu, The Hindu. Available at: https://www.
thehindu.com/news/national/activists-oppose-draft-anti-trafficking-bill/article24445893.ece (Accessed:
18 January 2019).
Chang, S. (2007) A Colonial Haunting: Prostitution and the Politics of Sex Trafficking in by British India, 1917-1939.
Chaitanya Mallapur (2015) Minor Girls, Women Chief Targets As Human Trafficking Surges-Human Trafficking
In India Over The Past 10 Years
Chattopadhyay, M., S. Bandyopadhyay and C. Dutta Gupta. 1994. “Biosocial factors influencing women to
become prostitutes in India”. Social Biology, 41(3–4): 252–59.
Chawla, S., Me, A., & Pichon, T. Le (2009). Global report on trafficking in persons. Human trafficking a crime that
shames us all. United Nations Global Initiative to Fight Human Trafficking (UN. GIFT).
Claramunt, Maria Cecilia 2002 Commercial sexual Exploitation of Minors: Costa Rica. Geneva: ILO.
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) Adopted and opened
for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 34/180 of 18 December 1979 entry
into force 3 September 1981, in accordance with article 27(1)
Cotton, A., Farley, M., and Baron, R. (2002). Attitudes toward prostitution and acceptance of rape myths. J.
Appl. Soc. Psychol. 32, 1790–1796. doi: 10.1111/j.1559-1816. 2002.tb00259.x
Cunha, J. D. (1987) ‘Prostitution in a Patriarchal Society-A Critical Review of the SIT Act’, Economic and Political
Weekly, 22(45), pp. 7–8. Available at: https://www.epw.in/journal/1987/45/special-articles/prostitution-
patriarchal-society-critical-review-sit-act.html (Accessed: 16 October 2018).
Cunningham, Fiona & Jacquin, Kristine. (2018). Age of Entry into Sex Work is a Myth
Crawford, M. and M. R. Kaufman. 2008. “Sex trafficking in Nepal: Survivor characteristics and long-term
outcomes”. Violence Against Women, 14(8): 905–17.
Crime in India. New Delhi: Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India-2014. Crime in India. New Delhi:
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
Crush, J., and S. Ramachandran. 2009. “Xenophobia, International Migration and Human Development.”
Human Development Research Paper 47, United Nations Development Programme, Human Development
Report Office, New York.
Dandona, R., L. Dandona, G. Kumar et al. 2006. “Demography and sex work characteristics of female sex
workers in India”. BMC International Health and Human Rights, 6(1): 5.
 286

Danailova-Trainor, G. and F. Laczko (2010) ‘Trafficking in persons and development: Towards greater policy
coherence’, International Migration, 48 (4): 38-83.
Das, M. M. and S. K. Mishra. 2011. Stolen Childhoods: A Study of Child Trafficking in the Kosi Region of Bihar.
New Delhi: Save the Children.
Datta, P. 2011. “Trafficking and illegal female Nepali migration in India”. International Journal of Afro-Asian
Studies, 1: 34.
Davis, A. C., Visser, B., Volk, A. A., Vaillancourt, T., and Arnocky, S. (2019a). Life history strategy and the
HEXACO model of personality: a facet level examination. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 150:109471. doi: 10.1016/j.
paid.2019.06.014
Davis, A. C., Visser, B., Volk, A. A., Vaillancourt, T., and Arnocky, S. (2019b). The relations between life history
strategy and dark personality traits among young adults. Evol. Psychol. Sci. 5, 166–177. doi: 10.1007/
s40806-018-0175-3
Deane, T. 2010. “Cross-border trafficking in Nepal and India—violating women’s rights”. Human Rights
Review, 11(4): 491–513.
Deb, S., A. Mukherjee and B. Mathews. 2011. “Aggression in sexually abused trafficked girls and efficacy of
intervention”. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 26(4): 745–68.
Decker, M. R., Seage, G., Hemenway, D., Gupta, J., Raj, A., and Silverman, J. G. (2009). Intimate partner violence
perpetration, standard and gendered STI/HIV risk behaviour, and STI/HIV diagnosis among a clinic-
based sample of men. Sex. Trans. Infect. 85, 555–560. doi: 10.1136/sti.2009.036368
Decker, M.R., H. L. McCauley, D. Phuengsamran et al. 2010. “Sex trafficking, sexual risk, sexually transmitted
infection and reproductive health among female sex workers in Thailand”. Journal of Epidemiology and
Community Health, 65(4): 334–39.
Decker, M. R. 2013. “Sex trafficking, sex work, and violence: Evidence for a new era,” International Journal of
Gynecology &Obstetrics 120(2): 113–14
Del Giudice, M. (2020). Rethinking the fast-slow continuum of individual differences. Evol. Hum. Behav. doi:
10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2020.05.004
Denisova, T.A. Trafficking in women and children for purposes of sexual exploitation: The criminological
aspect. Trends Organ Crim 6, 30–36 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-001-1003-9
Devine, A., K. Bowen, B. Dzuvichu et al. 2010. “Pathways to sex-work in Nagaland, India: Implications for HIV
prevention and community mobilization”. AIDS Care, 22(2): 228–37. ii
Dharmadhikari, Ashwin & Gupta, Jhumka & Decker, Michele & Raj, Anita & Silverman, Jay. (2009). Tuberculosis
and HIV: a global menace exacerbated via sex trafficking. International journal of infectious diseases: IJID:
official publication of the International Society for Infectious Diseases. 13. 543-6. 10.1016/j.ijid.2008.11.010.
Dinh, Ngan, Conor Hughes, James W. Hughes, and Margaret Maurer-Fazio. “Human Trafficking in Southeast
Asia: Results from a Pilot Project in Vietnam.” Available at SSRN 2528778 (2014).
Divya, A. (2020) Sex workers in India on the verge of debt bondage and slavery, says a study | Lifestyle News,
The Indian Express, The Indian Express. Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/lifestyle/life-
style/sex-workers-in-india-on-the-verge-of-debt-bondage-and-slavery-says-a-study-7117938/ (Accessed:
10 January 2021).
Dubas, J. S., Baams, L., Doornwaard, S. M., and van Aken, M. A. G. (2017). Dark personality traits and impulsivity
among adolescents: differential links to problem behaviors and family relations. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 126,
877–889. doi: 10.1037/abn0000290
Dutta, M. and B. Zutshi. 2003. Rescued Trafficked Children from Commercial Sexual Exploitation—A Situation
Analysis. Geneva: United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
Duggal-Chadha, A. 2006. “Crises, challenges and response children and disasters”. Refugee Survey Quarterly,
25(4): 85.
REFERENCES 287

Dylewski, Ł., and Prokop, P. (2019). “History of prostitution,” in Encyclopedia of Evolutionary Psychological
Science, eds T. K. Shackelford and V. A. Weekes-Shackelford (Cham: Springer). doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-
16999-6_270-1
Edwards, B. G., Albertson, E., and Verona, E. (2017). Dark and vulnerable personality trait correlates of
dimensions of criminal behavior among adult offenders. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 126, 921–927. doi: 10.1037/
abn0000281
E Donger and J Bhabha, ‘Dilemmas in Rescue and Reintegration: A critical assessment of India’s policies
for children trafficked for labour exploitation’, Anti-Trafficking Review, issue 10, 2018, pp. 52–69, www.
antitraffickingreview.org.
End Child Prostitution, Child Pornography and Trafficking of Children for Sexual Purposes [ECPAT
International], 2003
Everly, Rebecca. 2011. Preventing and Combating the Trafficking of Girls in India Using Legal Empowerment
Strategies. Rome: International Development Law Organization.
Falb, K. L., H. L. McCauley, M. R. Decker et al. 2011. “Trafficking mechanisms and HIV status among sex-
trafficking survivors in Calcutta, India”. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 113(1): 86–87.
Farley, Melissa. (2003). Prostitution and the Invisibility of Harm. Women & Therapy. 26. 247-280. 10.1300/
J015v26n03_06.
Farley, M., Golding, J. M., Matthews, E. S., Malamuth, N. M., and Jarrett, L. (2017). Comparing sex buyers with
men who do not buy sex: new data on prostitution and trafficking. J. Interpers. Viol. 32, 3601–3625. doi:
10.1177/0886260515600874
Farley, M., Macleod, J., Anderson, L., and Golding, J. M. (2011). Attitudes and social characteristics of men who
buy sex in Scotland. Psychol. Trauma Theory Res. Pract. Policy 3, 369–383. doi: 10.1037/a0022645
Farley, M., Freed, W., Phal, K. S., and Golding, J. (2012). “A thorn in the heart: Cambodian men who buy
sex,” Paper Presented at the Focus on Men Who Buy Sex: Discourage Men’s Demand for Prostitution, Stop Sex
Trafficking Conference, Phnom Penh.
Fernández del Río, E., Ramos-Villagrasa, P. J., Castro, Á, and Barrada, J. R. (2019). Sociosexuality and bright and
dark personality: the prediction of behavior, attitude, and desire to engage in casual sex. Int. J. Environ.
Res. Public Health 16:2731. doi: 10.3390/ijerph16152731
Figueredo, A. J., Vásquez, G., Brumbach, B. H., and Schneider, S. M. (2007). The K-factor, covitality, and
personality. Hum. Nat. 18, 47–73. doi: 10.1007/bf02820846
Ford, M. (2006a) ‘After Nunukan: The regulation of Indonesian migration to Malaysia’, in Kaur, A. and Metcalfe,
I. (eds) Mobility, Labour Migration and Border Controls in Asia, Basingstoke & New York: Palgrave
Macmillan, pp. 228-47. (2006b) ‘Migrant labor NGOs and trade unions: A partnership in progress?’, Asian
and Pacific Migration Journal, 15 (3): 299-318.
(2007) Advocacy Responses to Irregular Labour Migration in ASEAN: The cases of Malaysia and Thailand,
March: Manila: Migrant Forum in Asia and the South East Asian Committee for Advocacy
Fowler, J., & UNICEF. (2004). Human Trafficking in Africa Fuelled by War, Economic Hardship, and Lack of
Birth Registration.”.
Francis, A. and Uniyal, M. (2021) Migrant workers have returned to India’s cities – but they are even more vulnerable
now, Scroll.in. Available at: https://scroll.in/article/981358/migrant-workers-have-returned-to-indias-
cities-but-they-are-even-more-vulnerable-now (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
FXB Center for Health and Human Rights at Harvard University, March 2016.: An Investigation into Current
Anti Trafficking Practices in Rajasthan and Bihar
GAATW (2007) ‘Collateral Damage. The Impact of Anti-Trafficking Measures on Human Rights Around the
World’. Bangkok: Global Alliance Against Traffic in Women, p. 277. doi: 10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004.
Gaffey, M. F., S. Venkatesh, N. Dhingra et al. 2011. “Male use of female sex work in India: A nationally
representative behavioural survey”. PloS one, 6(7): e22704.
 288

Gathia, Jospeh. (2003) Asia Me Deh Vyapar. New Delhi. Concept Publishing Company.
Gathia, Joseph. 1999. Child Prostitution in India. New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company.
George, A. and S. Sabarwal. 2013. “Sex trafficking, physical and sexual violence and HIV risk among young
female sex workers in Andhra Pradesh, India”. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 120(2):
119–23.
George, A., U. Vindhya and S. Ray. 2010. “Sex trafficking and sex work: Definitions, debates and dynamics—A
review of literature”. Economic and Political Weekly, 45: 24–30.
Getu, M. (2006). Human trafficking and development: The role of microfinance. Transformation, 23(3), 142-156.
Ghosh, B. 2009. “Trafficking in women and children in India: Nature, dimensions and strategies for prevention”.
International Journal of Human Rights, 13(5): 716–38.
Ghosh, J. 2009. “Migration and Gender Empowerment: Recent Trends and Emerging Issues.” Human
Development Research Paper 04, United Nations Development Programme, Human Development Report
Office, New York
Giammarinaro, M. G. and Boola, U. (2018) India must bring its new anti-trafficking Bill in line with human rights law,
urge UN experts, OHCHR. Availableat: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.
aspx?NewsID=23392&LangID=E (Accessed: 18 January 2019).
Giri, Mohini. V. 1999. Kanya: Exploitation of little angels. New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House
Gladden, P. R., Figueredo, A. J., and Jacobs, W. J. (2009). Life history strategy, psychopathic attitudes, personality,
and general intelligence. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 46, 270–275. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2008.10.010
Govt. of India (2013) The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013. New Delhi: PRS India. Available at: http://
www.prsindia.org/uploads/media/Criminal Law, 2013/Criminal Law Amendment Bill as passed by
LS.pdf (Accessed: 18 January 2019).
Government of Goa. 2003. Goa Children’s Act, 2003. Accessed on 20 September 2013 at https://www.nls.ac.in/
ccl/Acts
Gupta, J., A. Raj, M. R. Decker et al. 2009. “HIV vulnerabilities of sex-trafficked Indian women and girls”.
International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 107: 30–34
Gupta, J., E. Reed, T. Kershaw et al. 2011. “History of sex trafficking, recent experiences of violence, and HIV
vulnerability among female sex workers in coastal Andhra Pradesh, India”. International Journal of
Gynecology and Obstetrics, 114: 101–05
Gupta, G.R. (2003) Review of Literature for Action Research on Trafficking in Women and Children. New
Delhi: Institute of Social Sciences
Gupta, R. and R. Sinha. 2007. Confronting the Demand for Sex Trafficking: A Handbook for Law Enforcement.
Kolkata: Apne Aap Women Worldwide. http://issuu.com/ishtihaar/docs/confronting_demand_for_
trafficking.
Gurung G (2001) Patterns of Foreign employment and vulnerability of Migrant Workers, Nepal Country
Report, NIDS, Kathmandu, Nepal
Hameeda, S., Hlatshwayo, S., Tanner, E., Turker, M., & Yang, J. (2010). Human Trafficking in India: Dynamic,
Current Efforts, and Intervention Opportunities for the Asia Foundation. Report by Stanford University
for the Asia Foundation.
Heym, N., Firth, J., Kibowski, F., Sumich, A., Egan, V., and Bloxsom, C. A. (2019). Empathy at the heart of darkness:
empathy deficits that bind the Dark Triad and those that mediate indirect relational aggression. Front.
Psychiatry 10:95. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00095
Hodge, D. R. and C. A. Lietz. 2007. “The international sexual trafficking of women and children: A review of
the literature”. Affilia, 22: 163–73.
Harcourt, C & Donovan, Basil. (2005). The Many Faces of Sex Work. Sexually transmitted infections. 81. 201-6.
10.1136/sti.2004.012468.
REFERENCES 289

Holtzman, N. S., and Donnellan, M. B. (2015). “The roots of Narcissus: old and new models of the evolution of
narcissism,” in Evolutionary Perspectives on Social Psychology, eds V. Zeigler-Hill, L. L. Welling, and T. K.
Shackelford (Cham: Springer), 479–489. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-12697-5_36
Holtzman, N. S., and Strube, M. J. (2011). “The intertwined evolution of narcissism and short-term mating:
an emerging hypothesis,” in The Handbook of Narcissism and Narcissistic Personality Disorder: Theoretical
Approaches, Empirical Findings, and Treatments, eds W. K. Campbell and J. D. Miller (Hoboken, NJ: John
Wiley & Sons, Inc), 210–220. doi: 10.1002/9781118093108.ch19
Holtzman, N. S., and Strube, M. J. (2013). Above and beyond short-term mating, long-term mating is uniquely
tied to human personality. Evol. Psychol. 11, 1101–1129. doi: 10.1177/147470491301100514
Howitt, Dennis & Sheldon, Kerry. (2007). The role of cognitive distortions in paedophilic offending: Internet
and contact offenders compared. Psychology Crime & Law - PSYCHOL CRIME LAW. 13. 469-486.
10.1080/10683160601060564.
Huda, S. (2006). Sex trafficking in South Asia. International journal of gynaecology & obstetrics, 94(3), 374-381.
Hughes, Donna M.
2001 Role of Marriage Agencies in Trafficking of Women and Trafficking in Images of Sexual Exploitation.
Council of Europe November 2001 http://www.uri.edu/artsci/wms/hughes/agencies_and_images.pdf
2004 Myths and realities concerning child trafficking. Brussels: Fafo Institute for Applied International Studies.
2005 The demand for victims of sex trafficking. Report prepared for the US Department of State.
Human Rights Watch (2008) ‘As if I am not Human’: Abuses against Asian Domestic Workers in Saudi Arabia,
New York: Human Rights Watch.
IOM (2007) ASEAN and Trafficking in Persons: Using Data as a Tool to Combat Trafficking in Persons, Geneva:
International Organization for Migration.
Institute of Social Sciences (2003) “Review of Literature for ARTWAc: West Bengal.” Kolkata: Institute of Social
Sciences.
ILO (2005) A Global Alliance against Forced Labour, Geneva: International Labour Organization.
(2009) The Cost of Coercion: Global Report under the Follow-up to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental
Principles and Rights at Work, Geneva: International Labour Organization
ILO (2014) Profits and Poverty: The Economics of Forced Labour
International Labour Organization. (2006.) Maritime Labour Convention, 2006
International Labour Office (ILO) (2009): Decent work for domestic workers. Report IV (1), International Labour
Conference,
99th Session, 2010 (Geneva). — (2010a): Report of the Committee on Domestic Workers, Provisional Record
No. 12, International Labour Conference,
99th Session (Geneva). — (2010b): Global Wage Report 2010/11: Wage policies in times of crisis (Geneva).
(2011): Measuring the economic and social value of domestic work. Domestic Work Policy Brief, No. 3,
Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (Geneva).
ILO, A. (2005). Global Alliance against Forced Labour. ILO, Geneva.
International Labour Organization. (2002.) Every Child Counts---New Global Estimates on Child Labour.
Geneva: ILO-IPEC.
International Center for Research on Women (ICRW). 2010. Unpacking Sex Trafficking: A Survey of Sex
Trafficking and Sex Work in Three Districts of Andhra Pradesh, India. New Delhi: International Center for
Research on Women.
ILO and UNICEF. 2009. Training Manual to Fight Trafficking in Children for Labour, Sexual and Other Forms
of Exploitation: Understanding Child Trafficking. Turin: ILO.
 290

Indian Express, 01st September 2020, 225 anti-human-trafficking units in India exist only on paper
Irwin, M. A. (1996) ‘White Slavery’ As Metaphor Anatomy of a Moral Panic, Ex Post Facto: The History Journal.
Available at: https://walnet.org/csis/papers/irwin-wslavery.html (Accessed: 19 August 2018).
Idrus, N. I. (2008) ‘Makkunrai passimokolo’: Bugis migrant women workers in Malaysia’, in Ford, M. and
Parker, L. (eds) Women and Work in Indonesia, London: Routledge, pp. 155-72
Janwalkar, M. (2020) UN expert mentions Indian migrant crisis in report | India News, The Indian Express, Indian
Express. Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/india/un-expert-mentions-indian-migrant-
crisis-in-report-6601819/ (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Janyala, S. (2021) Activists seek anti-human trafficking units in Andhra | Cities News, The Indian Express, Indian
Express. Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/hyderabad/activists-demand-anti-
human-trafficking-units-in-andhra-pradesh-7139519 (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Jana, S., B. Dey, S. Reza-Paul et al. 2013. “Combating human trafficking in the sex trade: Can sex workers do it
better?”. Journal of Public Health, first published online 31 October 2013: Doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdt095.
Jewkes, R., Dunkle, K., Koss, M. P., Levin, J. B., Nduna, M., Jama, N., et al. (2006). Rape perpetration by young,
rural South African men: prevalence, patterns and risk factors. Soc. Sci. Med. 63, 2949–2961. doi: 10.1016/j.
socscimed.2006.07.027
Jewkes, R., Morrell, R., Sikweyiya, Y., Dunkle, K., and Penn-Kekana, L. (2012). Transactional relationships and
sex with a woman in prostitution: prevalence and patterns in a representative sample of South African
men. BMC Public Health 12:325. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-12-325
Jha, Vikas. 2005. “A new story of exploitation migration of Orissa’s tribal women”. Economic and Political
Weekly, 40(15)
Joffers, C., E. Mills, M. Joffers, et al. 2008. “Sexual slavery without borders: Trafficking for commercial sexual
exploitation in India”. International Journal for Equity and Health, 7:22. Accessed on 30 September 2013 at
http://www.equityhealthj.com/ content/7/1/22
Jones, D. N., and Paulhus, D. L. (2011). The role of impulsivity in the Dark Triad of personality. Pers. Indiv.
Differ. 51, 679–682. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2011.04.011
Jonason, P. K., Luevano, V. X., and Adams, H. M. (2012). How the Dark Triad traits predict relationship
choices. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 53, 180–184. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2012.03.007
Jonason, P. K., and Tost, J. (2010). I just cannot control myself: the Dark Triad and self- control. Pers. Indiv.
Differ. 49, 611–615. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2010.05.031
Jonason, P. K., Lyons, M., and Blanchard, A. (2015). Birds of a “bad” feather flock together: the Dark Triad and
mate choice. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 78, 34–38. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2015.01.018
Jonason, P. K., Girgis, M., and Milne-Home, J. (2017). The exploitive mating strategy of the Dark Triad traits:
tests of rape-enabling attitudes. Arch. Sex. Behav. 46, 697–706. doi: 10.1007/s10508-017-0937-1
Jonason, P. K., and Krause, L. (2013). The emotional deficits associated with the Dark Triad traits: cognitive
empathy, affective empathy, and alexithymia. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 55, 532–537. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2013.04.027
Juhász, J. 2000 “Migrant trafficking and human smuggling in Hungary”, in International Organization for
Migration (Ed.), Migrant Trafficking and Human Smuggling in Europe: A Review of the Evidence with
Case Studies from Hungary, Poland and Ukraine, IOM, Geneva: 167-232.
Jureidini, R. and N. Moukarbel (2004) ‘Female Sri Lankan domestic workers in Lebanon: A case of ‘contract
slavery’?’, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 30 (4): 581-607.
Karmakar, Sumati. 2001. Red light area: Social environment of sex workers. New Delhi: Dominant Publishers
and Distributors.
Karandikar, Sharvari, et al. 2008. My one-way ticket to Kamathipura. Rights of sex workers comprised. Research for
Sex Workers 10: 12–15.
Karandikar, Sharvari, et al. 2013. A qualitative examination of women involved in prostitution in Mumbai,
REFERENCES 291

India: The role of family and acquaintances. Int Soc Work 56: 496–515.
Kaur, A. and Metcalfe, I. (eds) (2006) Mobility, Labour Migration and Border Controls in Asia, Basingstoke &
New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kangaspunta, K. (2011). Trafficking in persons. Routledge Handbook of Criminology, 178.
Kelly, J. (2005) ‘Transnational NGO involvement in the new age of migration: Building a framework for the
protection of the human rights of undocumented economic migrants’, Michigan Journal of Public Affairs,
2 (Summer): 1-30
Khan, S. A. (2015) ‘Human Trafficking, Justice Verma Committee Report and Legal Reform: A Unaccomplish
Agenda’, Ssrn, 9(1). doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2614393.
Kligman, G., & Limoncelli, S. (2005). Trafficking women after socialism: From, to, and through Eastern Europe.
Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State and Society, 12(1), 118-140.
Kotiswaran, P. 2008. “Born unto brothels—toward a legal ethnography of sex work in an Indian red-light area”.
Law & social inquiry, 33(3): 579–629. . 2013. “A battle half-won”. Economic and Political Weekly, 48(17): 9
Krishnaraj, Shanti. 2005. “Gender dimensions in rural-urban migration in India: Policy imperatives”. Paper
delivered at 25th International Population Conference, Tours, France, 18–23 July. Accessed on 27 May 2008
at http://iussp2005.princeton. edu/download.aspx? submissionId¼51757.
Kyle, D., & Koslowski, R. (Eds.). (2011). Global Human Smuggling: Comparative Perspectives (2nd edition ed.).
Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Lalumière, M. L., Harris, G. T., and Rice, M. E. (2001). Psychopathy and developmental instability. Evol. Hum.
Behav. 22, 75–92. doi: 10.1016/S1090-5138(00)00064-7
Legg, S. (2014) Prostitution and the ends of empire: scale, governmentalities, and interwar India. Durham: Duke
University Press.
Lee, K., Ashton, M. C., Wiltshire, J., Bourdage, J. S., Visser, B. A., and Gallucci, A. (2013). Sex, power, and money:
prediction from the Dark Triad and Honesty–Humility. Eur. J. Pers. 27, 169–184. doi: 10.1002/per.1860
Lerche, J. (2007) ‘A global alliance against forced labour? Unfree labour, neo-liberal globalization and the
International Labour Organization’, Journal of Agrarian Change, 7 (4): 425-52.
Lowman, J., and Atchison, C. (2006). Men who buy sex: a survey in the Greater Vancouver Regional District. Can.
Rev. Sociol. 43, 281–296. doi: 10.1111/j.1755-618X.2006.tb02225.x
Månsson, S. A. (2004). Men’s Practices in Prostitution and Their Implications for Social Work. Available online
at: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.645.745 (accessed August 3, 2020).
Månsson, S. A. (2006). Men’s demand for prostitutes. Sexologies 15, 87–92. doi: 10.1016/j.sexol.2006.02.001
McClarty, L. M., P. Bhattacharjee, J. F. Blanchard et al. 2014. “Circumstances, experiences and processes
surrounding women’s entry into sex work in India”. Culture, health & sexuality, 16(2): 149–63.
McDonald, M. M., Donnellan, M. B., and Navarrete, C. D. (2012). A life history approach to understanding the
Dark Triad. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 52, 601–605. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2011.12.003
McKeganey, N. (1994). Why do men buy sex and what are their assessments of the HIV-related risks when they
do? Aids Care 6, 289–301. doi: 10.1080/09540129408258641
Megumi, M. 2009. Human Trafficking: A Brief Overview. Washington DC: World Bank. at https://
openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/11103.
Meere, M., and Egan, V. (2017). Everyday sadism, the Dark Triad, personality, and disgust sensitivity. Pers.
Indiv. Differ. 112, 157–161. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2017.02.056
Meliss, F. et al. (1998) Prostitution in Five Countries and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Feminism & Psychology.
Vol. 8 (4).
Meliss, F. Prostitution: Fact Sheet on Human Rights Violation: http://www.prostitution research.com
Menen, Rajendar. 2007. Karma sutra essays from the margin. Canada: Saga Books.
 292

Miko, F. T., & Park, G. (2003, March). Trafficking in women and children: The US and international response.
Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress
Milrod, C., and Monto, M. A. (2012). The hobbyist and the girlfriend experience: behaviors and
preferences of male customers of internet sexual service providers. Deviant Behav. 33, 792–810. doi:
10.1080/01639625.2012.707502
Milrod, C., and Monto, M. (2017). Older male clients of female sex workers in the United States. Arch. Sex.
Behav. 46, 1867–1876. doi: 10.1007/s10508-016-0733-3
Ministry of Home Affairs. 2009. Office Memorandum on Advisory on Preventing and Combating Human
Trafficking in India. New Delhi: Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India
Ministry of Human Resource Development. 2002. Swadhar: A Scheme for Women in Difficult Circumstances.
New Delhi: Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India. 2005. National Plan of
Action for Children, 2005. New Delhi: Ministry of Human Resource Development. at http://www.wcd.
nic.in/NAPAug16A.pdf.
Ministry of Law and Justice. 2007. The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006. at http://wcd. nic.in/
cma2006.pdf. 2012. Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act 2012. at http://wcd.nic.in/childact/
childprotection31072012.pdf. 2013. The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, No. 13 of 2013. The Gazette
of India. New Delhi: Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India. iv
Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs. 2000. Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children), Act,
2000. http://wcd.nic.in/childprot/jjact2000.pdf.
Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India. http://www.wcd.nic.in/ empwomen.htm.
2007. UJJAWALA: A Comprehensive Scheme for Prevention of Trafficking and Rescue, Rehabilitation
and Re-Integration of Victims of Trafficking for Commercial Sexual Exploitation. New Delhi: Ministry of
Women and Child Development, Government of India. n.d. National Tracking System for Missing and
Vulnerable Children. http://www. trackthemissingchild.gov.in/trackchild/index.php.
Min‐Harris, C. 2008. “Youth Migration and Poverty in Sub‐Saharan Africa: Empowering the Rural Youth.”
Topical Research Digest: Human Rights in Sub‐Saharan Africa. Denver: University of Denver.
Monto, M. A., and Milrod, C. (2014). Ordinary or peculiar men? Comparing the customers of prostitutes
with a nationally representative sample of men. Int. J. Offen. Ther. Comp. Criminol. 58, 802–820. doi:
10.1177/0306624X13480487
Monto, M. A. (2010). “Prostitutes’ customers: motives and misconceptions,” in Sex for Sale: Prostitution,
Pornography, and The Sex Industry, ed. R. Weitzer (Abindon: Routledge), 233–254.
Monto, M. A., and McRee, N. (2005). A comparison of the male customers of female street prostitutes with
national samples of men. Int. J. Offen. Ther. Comp. Criminol. 49, 505–529. doi: 10.1177/0306624X04272975
MOWCD and UNODC. 2008. India Country Report: To Prevent and Combat Trafficking and Commercial Sexual
Exploitation of Children and Women. Prepared for the World Congress III against Sexual Exploitation of
Children and Adolescents, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, November 2008. New Delhi: MOWCD, Government of
India and UNODC ROSA.
Mishra, Eira. 2013. “Combating human trafficking: A legal perspective with special reference to India”.
Sociology and Anthropology, 1(4): 172–79.
Munshi, S. (2020) Human Trafficking Hit Three-year High in 2019 as Maha Tops List of Cases Followed by
Delhi, Shows NCRB Data, News18 Networks. Available at: https://www.news18.com/news/india/
human-trafficking-hit-three-year-high-in-2019-as-maha-tops-list-of-cases-followed-by-delhi-shows-ncrb-
data-2944085.html (Accessed: 10 January 2021).
Mukherjee, K. K. and D. Das. 1996. Prostitution in Six Metropolitan Cities of India. New Delhi: Central Social
Welfare Board.
Mukherjee, K. K. and S. S. Mukherjee. 2004. Girls/Women in Prostitution in India. A National Study. Ghaziabad:
Gram Niyojan
REFERENCES 293

Najar, J. L. (2020) Anti-Trafficking Bill: What Meenakshi Lekhi’s Suggestions Got Wrong, The Wire. Available
at: https://thewire.in/rights/anti-trafficking-bill-meenakshi-lekhi (Accessed: 12 September 2020).
Najar, J. L. (2021) (Jaffer) JL Najar | Erasmus University Rotterdam. Available at: https://www.eur.nl/en/
people/j-l-najar (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Najar, J. L. (2021) (Jaffer) JL Najar | Erasmus University Rotterdam. Human Trafficking in India: How the
Colonial Legacy of the Anti-Human Trafficking Regime Undermines Migrant and Worker Agency,
February 11th, 2021, Available at https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/humanrights/2021/02/11/human-trafficking-
in-india-how-the-colonial-legacy-of-the-anti-human-trafficking-regime-undermines-migrant-and-
worker-agency/
Natalie Delia Deckard (2020) Constructing Vulnerability: The Effect of State Migration Policy
and Policing on the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children, Journal of Human
Trafficking, DOI: 10.1080/23322705.2020.1782656
National Commission for Women. (1997) Study Report on the Sexual Abuse of Children in Goa. New Delhi:
National Commission for Women.
National Human Rights Commission India (NHRC), Annual Report 2015-16 and Journal of NHRC, Vol. 15,
2016
National Crimes Records Bureau (NCRB).: NCRB, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. 2013 to 2019
Crime in India: Compendium. Delhi: NCRB, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
Nettle, D. (2006). The evolution of personality variation in humans and other animals. Am. Psychol. 61, 622–631.
doi: 10.1037/0003-066X.61.6.622
Nettle, D., and Frankenhuis, W. E. (2019). The evolution of life-history theory: a bibliometric analysis of an
interdisciplinary research area. Proc. R. Soc. B 286:20190040. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2019.0040
News18 Networks (2020) ‘Covid-19 Pandemic Has Created a Second Crisis in India -the Rise of Child Trafficking’.
Available at: https://www.news18.com/news/india/covid-19-pandemic-has-created-a-second-crisis-in-
india-the-rise-of-child-trafficking-3004136.html (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR). n.d. Convention on the Elimination of All
Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW). http://www.ohchr.org/en/hrbodies/cedaw/
pages/cedawindex.aspx.
Office of the Registrar General and Census Commissioner, India. 2011. Census of India, Provisional Population
Totals, Paper 2 of 2011. New Delhi: Office of the Registrar General and Census Commissioner.
O’Neil, J., T. Orchard, R. C. Swarankar et al. 2004. “Dhandha, dharma and disease: Traditional sex work and
HIV/AIDS in rural India”. Social Science & Medicine, 59(4): 851–60.
Okyere, S. (2020) The master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house: time to rethink the Palermo
protocol | open Democracy, Open Democracy. Available at: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/
beyond-trafficking-and-slavery/the-masters-tools-will-never-dismantle-the-masters-house-time-to-
rethink-the-palermo-protocol/ (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Ompad, D. C., Bell, D. L., Amesty, S., Nyitray, A. G., Papenfuss, M., Lazcano-Ponce, E., et al. (2013). Men
who purchase sex, who are they? An interurban comparison. J. Urban Health 90, 1166–1180. doi: 10.1007/
s11524-013-9809-8
Ondrášek, S., imnáèová, Z., and Kajanová, A. (2018). “It’s also a kind of adrenalin competition”–selected aspects
of the sex trade as viewed by clients. Hum. Affairs 28, 24–33. doi: 10.1515/humaff-2018-0003
Orchard, T. R. 2007. “Girl, woman, lover, mother: Towards a new understanding of child prostitution among
young Devadasis in rural Karnataka, India”. Social Science and Medicine, 64(12): 2379–90.
Orhant, M., & Murphy, E. (2002). Trafficking in Persons. Reproductive Health and Rights: Reaching the Hardly
Reached. Washington, DC: PATH.
Oram, S., H. Stöckl, J. Busza et al. 2012. “Prevalence and risk of violence and the physical, mental, and sexual
health problems associated with human trafficking: Systematic review”. PLoS Medicine, 9(5): e1001224.
 294

Ould, D. (2004) ‘Trafficking and international law’, in van den Anker, C. (ed.) The Political Economy of New
Slavery, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 55-74.
Panda, S. M. (2013). 5 Exploring mobile livelihoods among tribal communities in Odisha, India. Gender,
Mobilities and Livelihood Transformations: Comparing Indigenous People in China, India and Laos:
Comparing Indigenous People in China, India, and Laos, 93.
Pandey, Sonal. 2018. Trafficking of children for sex work in India: Prevalence, history, and vulnerability
analysis. E-journa l of the Ind ian Sociological Society 2: 21–43.
Pandey, S, H. R. Tewari and P. K. Bhowmick. 2013. “Antecedents and reintegration of sex trafficked victims in
India: A conceptual framework”. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 8(1).
Pandey, S.P. et.al. (2008), Rehabilitation of Disadvantaged Children and Women Sex Workers, Serials
Publications, New Delhi
Pandey, S.P. 2010. A study of children dependent on prostitutes in selected areas of Uttar Pradesh. Lucknow: Pt. G. B.
P. Institute of Studies in Rural Development.
Pan, S., Parish, W. L., and Huang, Y. (2011). Clients of female sex workers: a population-based survey of China. J.
Infect. Dis. 204, S1211–S1217. doi: 10.1093/infdis/jir537
Patkar P. and P. Patkar. 2001. Report of A Rapid Assessment of Situation of Trafficking and the children victims
of commercial sex exploitation and Trafficking: A study of six Districts of Maharashtra. Mumbai: UNICEF
Pai, A., Seshu, M. and Murthy, L. (2018) ‘In Its Haste to Rescue Sex Workers, “Anti-Trafficking” Is Increasing Their
Vulnerability’, Economic & Political Weekly, 53(28). Available at: https://www.epw.in/engage/article/
raid-and-rescue-how-anti-trafficking-strategies-increase-sex-workers-vulnerability-to-exploitative-
practices (Accessed: 12 September 2020).
Paulhus, D. L., Curtis, S. R., and Jones, D. N. (2018). Aggression as a trait: the Dark Tetrad alternative. Curr.
Opin. Psychol. 19, 88–92. doi: 10.1016/j.copsyc.2017.04.007
Pfattheicher, S., Keller, J., and Knezevic, G. (2019). Destroying things for pleasure: on the relation of sadism and
vandalism. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 140, 52–56. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2018.03.049
Piper, N. (2003) ‘Feminization of labor migration as violence against women: International, regional, and
local nongovernmental organization responses in Asia’, Violence Against Women, 9 (6): 723-45. -(2005)
‘A problem by a different name? A review of research on trafficking in South East Asia and Oceania’,
International Migration, 43: ½
Pitts, M. K., Smith, A. M., Grierson, J., O’Brien, M., and Misson, S. (2004). Who pays for sex and why? An
analysis of social and motivational factors associated with male clients of sex workers. Arch. Sex. Behav. 33,
353–358. doi: 10.1023/B: ASEB.0000028888.48796.4f
Phinney, A. (2001). Trafficking of women and children for sexual exploitation in the Americas. Washington D.C: Inter
American Commission of Women and World Health Organisation.
Pochagina, O. (2007). Trafficking in Women and Children in Present-Day China. Far Eastern Affairs, 35(1), 82-
101
PRAJWALA Annual Report (2012-13)
Prokop, P., Dylewski, Ł, Woźna, J. T., and Tryjanowski, P. (2018). Cues of woman’s fertility predict prices for
sex with prostitutes. Curr. Psychol. 39, 919–926. doi: 10.1007/s12144-018-9807-9
Raimo Väyrynen, 2003. “Illegal Immigration, Human Trafficking, and Organized Crime,” WIDER Working
Paper Series DP2003-72, World Institute for Development Economic Research (UNU-WIDER).
Rafferty, Y. 2008. “The impact of trafficking on children: Psychological and social policy perspectives”. Child
Development Perspectives: 2(1): 13–18. v
Rana, U., Sharma, D. & Ghosh, D. Prostitution in northern Central India: an ethnographical study of Bedia
community. Int. j. anthropol. ethnol. 4, 2 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s41257-020-0027-5
Raymond, G. Janice. 2004. “Prostitution on demand: Legalizing the buyers as sexual consumers”. Violence
REFERENCES 295

against Women, 10(10): 1156–86.

Raymond, J, et al. (2002). A comparative study of women trafficked in the migration process. New York: CATW
International.
Reuters Washington Report 2000
Report of the Central Advisory Committee on Child Prostitution, published in May 1994
Roby JL. Women and children in the global sex trade: Toward more effective policy. International Social Work.
2005;48(2):136-147. doi:10.1177/0020872805050206
Rukmini, S. (2020) Why India’s ‘migrants’ walked back home, Mint. Available at: https://www.livemint.com/
news/india/why-india-migrants-walked-back-home-11590564390171.html (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
2013. “Child trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation: A review of promising prevention policies
and programs”.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 83(4): 559–75.
Ramesh, B., T. S. Beattie, I. Shajy et al. 2010. “Changes in risk behaviours and prevalence of sexually transmitted
infections following HIV preventive interventions among female sex workers in five districts in Karnataka
state, South India”. Sexually Transmitted Infections, 86(Suppl 1): i17–i24.
Raj, A., Reed, E., Welles, S. L., Santana, M. C., and Silverman, J. G. (2008). Intimate partner violence perpetration,
risky sexual behavior, and STI/HIV diagnosis among heterosexual African American men. Am. J. Men’s
Health 2, 291–295. doi: 10.1177/1557988308320269
Ray, Nilanjana. 2008. Vulnerability to human trafficking: A qualitative study. Retrospective Theses and
Dissertations 17 https://openscholarship.wustl.edu/etd_restrict/17.
Rosenberg, R. (ed.) (2003) Trafficking of Women and Children in Indonesia, Jakarta: International Catholic
Migration Commission and the American Center for International Labor Solidarity.
Roy S, Chaman C. Human rights and trafficking in women and children in India. J His Arch & Anthropol Sci.
2017;1(5):162-170. DOI: 10.15406/jhaas.2017.01.00027
Richards, Kathy. (2004). The Trafficking of Migrant Workers: What are the Links Between Labour Trafficking
and Corruption? International Migration. 42. 147 - 168. 10.1111/j.0020-7985.2004.00305. x.
Richards, Amy O’Neill, “International Trafficking in Women to the United States: A Contemporary Manifestation
of Slavery and Organized Crime,” Hhttp://www.cia.gov/csi/monograph/women/trafficking.pdfH,
April, 2000.
Rich, R., Leventhal, A., Sheffer, R., and Mor, Z. (2018). Heterosexual men who purchase sex and attended an
STI clinic in Israel: characteristics and sexual behavior. Israel J. Health Policy Res. 7:19. doi: 10.1186/s13584-
018-0213-4
Saggurti, N., S. Sabarwal, R. K. Verma et al. 2011a. “Harsh realities: Reasons for women’s involvement in sex
work in India”. Journal of AIDS and HIV Research, 3(9): 172–79
Saggurti, N., R. K. Verma, S.S. Halli et al. 2011b. “Motivations for entry into sex work and HIV risk among
mobile female sex workers in India”. Journal of Biosocial Science, 43(5): 535–54
Saggurti, N., A. K. Jain., M. P. Sebastian et al. 2012. “Indicators of mobility, socio-economic vulnerabilities and
HIV risk behaviours among mobile female sex workers in India”. AIDS Behaviour, 16(4): 952–59.
Salmon, C. A. (2008). “The world’s oldest profession: evolutionary insights into prostitution,” in Evolutionary
Forensic Psychology: Darwinian Foundations of Crime and Law, eds J. Duntley and T. K. Shackelford (Oxford:
Oxford University Press), 121–135. doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195325188.003.0007
Salt, J. and Hogarth, J., 2000. Migrant trafficking and human smuggling in Europe: a review of the evidence.
13-163 in IOM, Migrant Trafficking and Human Smuggling in Europe. Geneva, IOM.
Samarasinghe, V. and B. Burton. 2007. “Strategizing prevention: A critical review of local initiatives to prevent
female sex trafficking”. Development in Practice, 17(1): 51–64.
Sanghera, J. 2005. “Unpacking the trafficking discourse” in Trafficking and Prostitution Reconsidered—New
Perspectives on Migration Sex Work and Human Rights, eds K. Kempandoo. Boulder, CO: Paradigm
 296

Publishers.50
Sanghera, Jyoti. 1999. Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: A review of anti-trafficking initiatives
in Nepal, Bangladesh and India. India: UNICEF Regional Office and Save the Children Alliance.
Sanghera, Jyoti. (2000) Trafficking of Women and Children in South Asia: Taking Stock and Moving Ahead:
A Review of Anti-trafficking Initiatives in Nepal, Bangladesh and India, New Delhi: UNICEF. ROSA and
Mumbai: Save the Children Alliance, South and Central Asia Region.
Sanghera, Jyoti. 2001. Towards the Construction of an Empowered Subject: A Human Rights Analysis of Anti-
Trafficking Legal interventions and Trends in South Asia. Paper presented at the Technical Consultative
Meeting on Anti-Trafficking Programs in South Asia, Kathmandu, 11–13 September 2001.
Sarkar K., B. Baishali, R. Mukherjee et al. 2008. “Sex trafficking, violence, negotiating skill and HIV infection in
brothel-based sex workers of eastern India, adjoining Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh”. Journal of Health,
Population and Nutrition, 26 (2): 223–31.
Sarkar, Siddhartha (2014). “Rethinking Human Trafficking in India: Nature, Extent and Identification of
Survivors.” The Round Table (Routledge) 103, no. 5 (2014): 483–495.
Saarthak. (2002) The Sounds of Silence: A Manual for Forming Therapeutic Relationships. New Delhi: Saarthak
and UNIFEM.
Sangram (2018) Raided: How Anti-Trafficking Strategies Increase Sex Workers’ Vulnerability to Exploitative
Practices. Available at: http://sangram.org/resources/RAIDED-E-Book.pdf (Accessed: 9 February 2019).
Shamim I. State of Trafficking in Women and Children and their Sexual Exploitation in Bangladesh. Dhaka:
Centre for Women and Children Studies (CWCS), 2010.
Sen, J. (2021) How a Nagpur Police Raid to ‘Rescue Underage Sex Workers’ Criminalised an Entire
Neighbourhood, The Wire. Available at: https://m.thewire.in/article/rights/nagpur-sex-workers-
police-raid/amp (Accessed: 20 January 2021).
Sen, S. and P. M. Nair. 2004. A Report on Trafficking in Women and Children in India 2001–2003: Volume 1.
New Delhi: Institute of Social Sciences, National Human Rights Commission and UNIFEM.
Sen, R. 2012. Learnings from a Regional Case Management Programme with Survivors of Trafficking: Sanyukt
Snapshots. Kolkata: Sanjog.
Sest, N., and March, E. (2017). Constructing the cyber-troll: psychopathy, sadism, and empathy. Pers. Indiv.
Differ. 119, 69–72. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2017.06.038
Scarpa, S. (2006), Child Trafficking: International Instruments To Protect The Most Vulnerable Victims. Family
Court Review, 44: 429-447. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-1617.2006.00098.x
Schei, B., and Stigum, H. (2010). A study of men who pay for sex, based on the Norwegian national sex
surveys. Scand. J. Public Health 38, 135–140. doi: 10.1177/1403494809352531
Shahmanesh, M., S. Wayal, F. Cowan et al. 2009. “Suicidal behavior among female sex workers in Goa, India:
The silent epidemic”. American Journal of Public Health, 99(7).
Shakti Vahini. 2004. Trafficking in India Report. New Delhi: Shakti Vahini.
Shelley Louise Human Trafficking: A Global Perspective Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University
Press, 2010, ISBN: 9780521130875, 356p.
Shannon, Sarah 1999 Prostitution and the Mafia: The Involvement of Organized crime in the Global Economy.
In Phil Williams (ED.) Illegal Migration and Commercial Sex. The New Slave Trade. London: Frank Cass
Publishers. Pp. 119-144.
Sharma S. Saratkumar (2016), Chairperson Manipur Commission For Protection of Child Rights-Child
Trafficking In The Indo-Myanmar Region: A Case Study In Manipur, reported that During the period of
2008-2016 (till June 26),
Sharma, R. 2007. “Trafficking in women and children in India: A situational analysis in Maharashtra”.
International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 2(2).-. 2011. “Gender and international migration: The
REFERENCES 297

profile of female migrants from India”. Social Scientist, 37–63. vi

Save Our Sisters. (2001) South Asian Conference to Combat the Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation of Children.
14 to 17 October in Goa. Organised by Save Our Sisters Program. Mumbai: Women’s Institute for Social
Education (WISE).
Semple, S. J., S. A. Strathdee, A. K. Srikrishnan et al. 2012. “Social and behavioral characteristics of gharwalis
who operate brothels in the Ganga-Jamuna area of Nagpur, India”. AIDS Care, 25(4): 438–42.
Shaw, S., K. Deering, S. Reza-Paul. 2011. “Prevalence of HIV and sexually transmitted infections among clients
of female sex workers in Karnataka, India: A cross-sectional study”. BMC Public Health, 11(Suppl 6): S4.
Shelley, L. (2007). Human trafficking as a form of transnational crime. Human trafficking, 116-137.
Silbert, M. (1998) Factors in the Rape of Street Prostitutes in AW: Bargess (Ed.) Rape and Sexual Aspects:
Washington: Garland Publishing
Silverman, J. G. 2011. “Adolescent female sex workers: Invisibility, violence and HIV”. Archives of disease in
childhood, 96(5): 478–81.
Silverman, J. G., M. R. Decker, J. Gupta et al. 2006. “HIV prevalence and predictors among rescued sex-trafficked
women and girls in Mumbai, India”. Journal of Acquired Deficiency Syndrome, 43: 588–93.
Silverman, J.G., M.R. Decker, J. Gupta et al. 2007a. “Experiences of sex-trafficking victims in Mumbai, India”.
International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics. 97(3): 221–26.
Silverman, J. G., M. R Decker, J Gupta et al. 2007b. “HIV prevalence and predictors of infection in sex-trafficked
Nepalese girls and women”. Journal of American Medical Association, 298: 536–42.
Silverman, J. G., A. Raj, D. M. Cheng et al. 2011. “Sex trafficking and initiation-related violence, alcohol use
and HIV risk among HIV positive female sex workers in Mumbai”. Journal of Infectious Diseases, 204:
S1229–S1234.
Silverman, J. G., N. Saggurti, D. M. Cheng et al. 2013. “Associations of sex trafficking history with recent sexual
risk among HIV Infected FSWs in India”. AIDS and Behavior, 1–7.
Simonovsky, Y., and M. Luebker. 2011. “Global and Regional Estimates on Domestic Workers.” Domestic
Work Policy Brief 4, International Labour Organization, Geneva. http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/
public/‐‐‐ed_protect/‐‐‐protrav/‐‐‐ travail/documents/publication/wcms_155951.pdf
Simpson, J. A., Griskevicius, V., Szepsenwol, O., and Young, E. (2017). “An evolutionary life history perspective
on personality and mating strategies,” in The Praeger Handbook of Personality Across Cultures: Evolutionary,
Ecological, and Cultural Contexts of Personality, ed. A. T. Church (Westport: Praeger), 1–29.
Singh, A. K. and Pandey, S. P. (2013) Women Trafficking in India: A Case Study of Women Sex Workers of
Uttar Pradesh, In Human Trafficking: The Stakeholders’ Perspective edited by Veerendra Mishra, Sage
Publication, New Delhi
Singh, A. K. and Pandey, S. P (2008) Rehabilitation Of Disadvantaged Children And Female Sex Workers,
Serials Publications, New Delhi
Singh, A. K. and Singh, A P. (Ed) (2012) Trafficking in Women and Children in India: Emerging Perspectives
Issues and Strategies, Serials Publications, New Delhi
Sinha, S. (2020) COVID has blurred the lines between waged, coerced and trafficked labour in India |
openDemocracy, Open Democracy. Available at: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/beyond-
trafficking-and-slavery/covid-has-blurred-lines-between-waged-coerced-and-trafficked-labour-
india/ (Accessed: 27 January 2021).
Sithannan, Veerappan. 2006. Immoral traffic-prostitution in India. Chennai: Jeywin: Publications.
South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC). 2002. SAARC Convention on Preventing and
Combating Trafficking in Women and Children for Prostitution. http://www.saarc-sec.org/userfiles/
conv-traffiking.pdf.
Spangenberg, Mia. (2002). International Trafficking of Children to New York City for Sexual Purposes.
 298

Subramanian, T., M. D. Gupte, R. S. Paranjape et al. 2008. “HIV, sexually transmitted infections and sexual
behaviour of male clients of female sex workers in Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra, India:
Results of a cross-sectional survey”. Aids, 22: S69–S79.
Susan, K.H. (1999), Council for Prostitution Alternative, Annual Report, Oregon.
Susan Kay Hunter and K.C. Reed, July, 1990 “Taking the side of bought and sold rape,” speech at National
Coalition against Sexual Assault, Washington, D.C.
Sugiarti, K. L., J. Davis, et al. (eds) (2006) When They were Sold, Jakarta: International Catholic Migration
Commission and American Center for International Labor Solidarity
Suryawanshi, D., T. Bhatnagar, S. Deshpande et al. 2013. “Diversity among clients of female sex workers in India:
Comparing risk profiles and intervention impact by site of solicitation. Implications for the vulnerability
of less visible female sex workers”. PloS one, 8(9): e73470. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0073470.
S. Sen and P.M Nair, NHRC - UNIFEM - ISS Project –A Report on Trafficking in Woman and Children in India
2004, Volume 1(March 02, 2012), http://nhrc.nic.in/Documents/ReportonTrafficking.pdf
Sanlaap, Tracking Our Children: A Brief Situational Analysis on the Trend of Migration, Child Marriage and
Trafficking in Eight Districts of West Bengal (March 01,2012) http://www.childtrafficking.com/Docs/
sanlaap_tracking_oct07.pdf
Sarkar K., B. Baishali, R. Mukherjee et al. 2008. “Sex trafficking, violence, negotiating skill and HIV infection in
brothel-based sex workers of eastern India, adjoining Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh”. Journal of Health,
Population and Nutrition, 26 (2): 223–31.
Sawyer, S., Metz, M. E., Hinds, J. D., and Brucker, R. A. (2001). Attitudes towards prostitution among males: a
“consumers’ report”. Curr. Psychol. 20, 363–376. doi: 10.1007/s12144-001-1018-z
Seidu, A. A., Darteh, E. K. M., Kumi-Kyereme, A., Dickson, K. S., and Ahinkorah, B. O. (2019). Paid sex among
men in sub-Saharan Africa: analysis of the demographic and health survey. SSM Popul. Health 11:100459.
doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2019.100459
Sheila Mckinnon, Project Report-Legal Empowerment of Girls in India to Prevent and Combat Human
Trafficking (Feb28,2012), http://www.idlo.int/Documents/ProjectReportLEHumanTrafficking.pdf
Shetty, J. (2012). Loss of tribal land and displacement: Impact on women. Afro Asian Journal of Anthropology
and Social Policy, 3(2), 71-79.
Srivastava, Ravi, and S. K. Sasikumar. “An overview of migration in India, its impacts and key issues.”
In Regional Conference on Migration, Development and Pro-Poor Policy Choices in Asia, pp. 22-24. 2003.
Sreenivas, M. (2011) ‘Creating Conjugal Subjects: Devadasis and the Politics of Marriage in Colonial Madras
Presidency’, Feminist Studies, 37(1), pp. 63–92.
Tailby, Rebecca (2001) A cross-analysis report into smuggling and trafficking between the Philippines and
Australia: Australian Institute of Criminology.
Tambe, A. (2009) Codes of Misconduct Regulating Prostitution in Late Colonial Bombay, Society. london: University
of Minnesota.
Tandon, T. (2015) ‘India’s Trafficking Bill 2018 is Neither Clear Nor Comprehensive’, Economic and Political
Weekly, 50(23), pp. 7–8. Available at: https://www.epw.in/engage/article/trafficking-of-persons-
prevention-protection-and-rehabilitation-bill-2018-is-neither-clear-nor-comprehensive (Accessed: 18
January 2019).
Tarachand, K.C. 1991. Devadasi custom. Rural social structure and flesh markets. New Delhi: Reliance Publishing
House.
The Hindu, December 15, 2005
The Telegraph (2017) Sex workers oppose anti-trafficking bill, The Telegraph. Available at: https://www.
telegraphindia.com/india/sex-workers-oppose-anti-trafficking-bill/cid/1518222 (Accessed: 29 May
2019).
REFERENCES 299

The Week, August 4, 1996

The Week, 2014. Childhood Lost. Accessed on 10 March 2014 at http://week.
manoramaonline.com/cgi-bin/MMOnline.dll/ portal/ep/theWeekContent.
do?contentId=16037055&programId=1073755753&tabId=6&BV_ID=@&categoryId=-21260
Tiefenbrun S. The saga of Susannah: A U. S. remedy for sex trafficking in women: The Victims of Trafficking
and Violence Protection Act of 2000. Utah Law Review. 2002;107(1):107–175.
Times of India on July 2, 2020
The News Minute, December 7, 2018
Tomei, M. and P. Belser. 2011. “New ILO Standards on Decent Work for Domestic Workers: A Summary of the
Issues and Discussions.” International Labour Review 150 (3–4): 431–38.
Trafficking of Minor Girls for Commercial Sexual Exploitation in India: A Synthesis of Available Evidence
(2014), Population Council
Terre de Hommes. 2005. Summary of Findings: A Study of Trafficked Nepalese Girls and Women in Mumbai
and Kolkata, India. Kathmandu: Terre de Hommes Foundation.
“Trafficking in Persons Report, 2019” United States Department of State-June 2019
Tsoukas, A., and March, E. (2018). Predicting short-and long-term mating orientations: the role of sex and the
dark tetrad. J. Sex Res. 55, 1206–1218. doi: 10.1080/00224499.2017.1420750
Tsutsumi, A., T. Izutsu, A. K. Poudyal et al. 2008. “Mental health of female survivors of human trafficking in
Nepal”. Social Science and Medicine, 66: 1841–47
Tumlin, K. C. 2000. Trafficking in Children in Asia: A Regional Overview. Chulaongkorn University, Bangkok:
Institute for Asian Studies.
UNAIDS Country Progress Report. (2010). http://www.unaids.org/en/dataanalysis/monitoringc
ountryprogress/progressreports4/2010 countries/india_2010. Accessed 25 May 2019.
Uncompensated victims-A National Report On Status Of Victim Compensation To Survivors Of Human
Trafficking In India by Sanjog-Kolkata and Tafteesh-Delhi, March 2020
UNICEF and College of Social Work. (1994) National Consultation on Child Prostitution, Mumbai: College of
Social Work.
United Nations. 2000. Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and
Children, Supplementing the United Nations Convention against transnational Organized Crime. New
York: United Nations. vii
United Nations Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM). n.d. Trafficking in Women and Children. UNIFEM:
Gender Fact Sheet No. 2. http://www4.worldbank.org/ afr/ssatp/ Resources/ HTML/Gender-RG/
Source%20%20
UNDP. (2002). Layers of silence: links between women’s vulnerability: trafficking and HIV/AIDS in Bangladesh,
India and Nepal. Switzerland: Author.
UNDP (2004) Layers of Silence: Links between Women Vulnerability, Trafficking and HIV/ AIDS in Bangladesh,
India, Nepal, UNRISD, Switzerland
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). 2007. Migration Gone Wrong: Linkages between Trafficking
and HIV. New Delhi: UNDP.
United Nations Inter-Agency Project on Human Trafficking (UNIAP). 2007. Targeting Endemic Vulnerability
Factors to Human Trafficking. Bangkok: UNIAP-Phase III.
U N Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (2003) : Combating Human Trafficking In Asia,
ISBN: 92-1-120357-0
UN High Commission for Human Rights, 2002, 58th session of the Commission on Human Rights - (18 March
to 26 April 2002)
 300

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), 2007. Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) on
Investigating Crimes of Trafficking for Commercial Sexual Exploitation. New Delhi: UNODC. 2008.
Training Manual for Prosecutors on Confronting Human Trafficking. New Delhi: UNODC. 2012. Global
Report on Trafficking in Persons. Vienna: UNODC. 2013. Current Status of Victim Service Providers and
Criminal Justice Actors in India on Anti-Human Trafficking: A Review Commissioned by UNODC. New
Delhi: UNODC, Global Report on Trafficking in Persons 2020, UNODC, Vienna
United States Agency for International Development (USAID). 2006. Literature Review: Trafficking in
Humanitarian Emergencies. Washington: USAID.
United States Department of State (USDOS). 2005. Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. 2016. Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. 2015. Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. - 2013, Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. - 2012, Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. - 2010, Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. - 2005, Trafficking in Persons
Report. U.S. Department of State. - 2004, Trafficking in Persons
UNODC (2004) United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime and The Protocols Thereto
United Nations. Available at: www.unodc.org (Accessed: 2 September 2018).
UNODC (2003) Coalitions against Trafficking in Human Beings in the Philippines: Research and Action Final
Report, Vienna: Anti-Human Trafficking Unit: Global Programme against Trafficking in Human Beings,
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime.
(2010) Human Trafficking FAQs, Available at http://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/humantrafficking/
faqs.html (accessed 19 August 2010).
UNODC Global Report on Trafficking in Person (2020)
Vanwesenbeeck, I. (2001). Another decade of social scientific work on sex work: a review of research 1990–
2000. Annu. Rev. Sex Res. 12, 242–289. doi: 10.1080/10532528.2001.10559799
Vimal Vidushy (2016) Human trafficking In India: An analysis. Int J Appl Res 2016;2(6):168-171.
Violence Against Women (SR – VAW) [UNHRC (2014) Report of the Special Rapporteur on violence against
women in India
Vonk, J., Weiss, A., and Kuczaj, S. A. (eds) (2017). Personality in Nonhuman Animals. New York, NY: Springer
International Publishing.
Warhurst, A., C. Strachan, Z. Yousuf et al. 2011. “Trafficking: A global phenomenon with an exploration of India
through maps”. Accessed on 30 September 2013 at maplecroft.com/docs/hr_2011_q3_in_trafficking_
report
Walters, K. (2018) Scandals in sex worker rescue shelters: is ‘awful’ distracting from ‘lawful’? |
openDemocracy, openDemocracy. Available at: https://www.opendemocracy.net/beyondslavery/
kimberly-walters/scandals-in-indias-raid-and-rescue-shelters-is-awful-distracting-from (Accessed: 17
January 2019).
Walters, K. and Ramachandran, V. (2018) A recipe for injustice: India’s new trafficking bill expands a troubled
rescue, rehabilitation, and repatriation framework, Open Democracy. Available at: https://www.
opendemocracy.net/beyondslavery/kimberly-walters-vibhuti-ramachandran/recipe-for-injustice-india-
s-new-trafficking-bil (Accessed: 18 February 2019).
Ward, H., Mercer, C. H., Wellings, K., Fenton, K., Erens, B., Copas, A., et al. (2005). Who pays for sex? An
analysis of the increasing prevalence of female commercial sex contacts among men in Britain. Sex. Trans.
Infect. 81, 467–471. doi: 10.1136/sti.2005.014985
REFERENCES 301

Williams, Suzanne and Rachel Masika 2002 Editorial. In Rachel Masika (Ed.), Gender, Trafficking and Slavery.
Oxfam Focus on Gender. Pp. 2-9.
Wilson, D., Manual, A., and Lavelle, S. (1992). Personality characteristics of Zimbabwean men who visit
prostitutes: implications for AIDS prevention programmes. Pers. Indiv. Differ. 13, 275–279. doi: 10.1016/0191-
8869(92)90102-U
Wirth, K., E. J. T. Tchetgen, J. G. Silverman et al. 2013. “How does sex trafficking increase the risk of HIV
infection? An observational study from Southern India”. American Journal of Epidemiology, 177(3): 232–
41.
Wolf, M., Van Doorn, G. S., Leimar, O., and Weissing, F. J. (2007). Life-history trade-offs favour the evolution
of animal personalities. Nature 447, 581–584. doi: 10.1038/nature05835
Xantidis, L., and McCabe, M. P. (2000). Personality characteristics of male clients of female commercial sex
workers in Australia. Arch. Sex. Behav. 29, 165–176. doi: 10.1023/A:1001907806062
YMCA, UNICEF and ECPAT. (1995) National Consultation on Child Prostitution: The Ultimate Abuse. New
Delhi: YMCA, UNICEF and ECPAT.
Young, E. S., Simpson, J. A., Griskevicius, V., Huelsnitz, C. O., and Fleck, C. (2019). Childhood attachment and
adult personality: a life history perspective. Self Ident. 18, 22–38. doi: 10.1080/15298868.2017.1353540
Zietsch, B. P., and Sidari, M. J. (2019). A critique of life history approaches to human trait covariation. Evol.
Hum. Behav. doi: 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2019.05.007
Zimmerman, C., K. Yun, I. Shvab et al. 2003. The Health Risks and Consequences of Trafficking in Women
and Adolescents. Findings from a European Study. London: Gender Violence and Health Centre, London
School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
 APPENDIX 2
DISTRICT WISE NUMBER OF AHTUS AND NOTIFICATION DETAILS

(FY: 2010-11 to FY: 2018-19)

No. of No. of AHTUs No. of AHTUs Date(s) of No. of Functional
S. No. State/UT Name
Districts set up Notified Notification AHTUs
No response to
1 Andhra Pradesh 13 4
RTI
2 Arunachal Pradesh No Information Provided under RTI
3 Assam No Information Provided under RTI
4 Bihar 38 44 0 16.06.2010 44
30.10.2010
No Information
5 Chhattisgarh 28 4 11 29.12.2011
Provided
28.03.2019
6 Goa 2 1 2 01.08.2014 1
7 Gujarat No Information Provided under RTI
No Information 17.07.2015 No Information
8 Haryana 22 6
Provided 04.08.2015 Provided
9 Himanchal 9 4 0 NA 4
14.07.2011
10 Jharkhand 26 8 8 8
23.08.2013
11 Karnataka No Information Provided under RTI
No Information
12 Kerala 14 20 3 20.12.2014
Provided
13 Madhya Pradesh No Information Provided under RTI
14 Maharashtra No Information Provided under RTI
15 Manipur No Information Provided under RTI
16 Meghalaya No Information Provided under RTI
12.07.2010
No Information
17 Mizoram 8 4 4 23.07.2010
Provided
19.01.2012
3-Notification on No Information
18 Nagaland 12 11 12
25.10.2010 Provided
19 Odisha No Information Provided under RTI
304

20 Punjab No Information Provided under RTI

Not Information Not Information No Information
21 Rajasthan 42 42
Provided Provided Provided
22 Sikkim No Information Provided under RTI
Not Information No Information
23 Tamil Nadu 34 34 04.06.2009
Provided Provided
24 Telangana No Information Provided under RTI
17 (West 07.09.2009
Tripura-1, South No Information
25 Tripura 8 5
Tripura-1, 02.11.2014 Provided
Gomati-15)
No Information No Information No Information
26 Uttar Pradesh 75 39
Provided Provided Provided
No Information No Information No Information
27 Uttarakhand 13 7
Provided Provided Provided
28 14.07.2014 No Information
West Bengal 23 34 23
18.08.2014 Provided
29 Chandigarh No Information Provided under RTI
30 Dadar & Nagar Haveli No Information Provided under RTI
31 Daman and Diu No Information Provided under RTI
32 Delhi No Information Provided under RTI
33 Jammu and Kashmir No Information Provided under RTI
 APPENDIX 3
APPLICATIONS AND COURT RECOMMENDATIONS FOR VICTIM
COMPENSATION FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING
(From the Year of Scheme to FY: 2018-19)
Court recommendation for victim
S. No. State/UT No. of Applications for victim compensation
compensation
1 Andhra Pradesh 2 2
2 Arunachal Pradesh 0 0
3 Assam 14 8
4 Bihar No Information Provided under RTI 2
5 Chandigarh No Information Provided under RTI 0
6 Chhattisgarh No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
7 Dadra & Nagar Haveli No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
8 Daman & Diu No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
9 Delhi 3(adults) and 4 (minors) 7
10 Goa No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
11 Gujarat No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
12 Haryana 2 (1 minor victim) 23
13 Himachal Pradesh 0 0
14 Jharkhand 26 (24 minor victims) 0
15 Karnataka 2 (adults) and 24 (minors) 56
570 applications; no separate data for human
16 Kerala
trafficking
17 Madhya Pradesh 0 0
18 Maharashtra No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
19 Manipur 0 0
20 Meghalaya 2 2 (kidnapping of major victims)
21 Mizoram 0 ‘Not received human trafficking case’
‘Human trafficking cases may be treated as
22 Nagaland ‘No cases of human trafficking’
NIL’
23 Odisha 0 0
24 Punjab 0 0
 306

4,531 applications; no separate data for human

25 Rajasthan
trafficking
26 Sikkim 0 0
27 Tamil Nadu No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
28 Telangana 0 0
29 Tripura No Information Provided under RTI No Information Provided under RTI
Data not available, since ‘under the scheme
30 Uttar Pradesh concerned Victim Compensation Board makes No Data Available
recommendation to UPSLSA’
31 Uttarakhand 0 0
32 West Bengal 24 (adults) and 4 (minors) 2

The data is only for human trafficking applications/recommendations from the year of institution of the
scheme, till March 2019 for most of the states/UTs, except Arunachal Pradesh and Meghalaya which provided
2019-20 data
 Appendix-4
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS USED
ACP Assistant Commissioner of Police
ADB Asian Development Bank
AHTUs Anti Human Trafficking Units
AIR All India Reporter (of judgements of Supreme Court and High Courts)
AINSW All-India Network of Sex Workers
AIWC All India Women’s Conference AIWC
ANCOVA- Analysis of covariance is used to test the main and interaction effects of categorical variables on a
continuous dependent variable
APOs Assistant Prosecution Officers
ARZ Anyaya Rahit Zindagi (an NGO based in Goa)
ASI Assistant Sub Inspector of Police
ASP Additional/Assistant Superintendent of Police
ATC Anti Trafficking Cell
ATSEC Action against Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation of Children
Aus AID Australian Agency for International Development
BIRD Bharatiya Institute of Research & Development
BPRD Bureau of Police Research and Development
BSF Border Security Force
CARA Central Adoption Resource Agency
CBI Central Bureau of Investigation, Government of India
CBM Confidence Building Measures
CBO Community Based Organisation
CCTNS Crime and Criminal Tracking Network & Systems
CCEVT Condensed Course for Education and Vocational Training
CCPWC Cyber Crime Prevention against Women and Children, Delhi Police projects
CCTV Closed-circuit television and is commonly known as video surveillance
CEDAW Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women
CEDPA Centre for Development and Population Activities
 308

CFSL Central Forensic Science Laboratory CFSL

CID Criminal Investigation Department (of the state government)
CIF Child India Foundation (an NGO network)
CIS Commonwealth of Independent States
COVID-19 Coronavirus Disease discovered in 2019
CLPRA Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act 1986
CPCL Campaign against Child Labour (an NGO network)
CPCT Campaign against Child Trafficking (an NGO network)
CPC Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000
CPO Central Police Organisation (of the Government of India)
CRC Child Rights Convention (of the UN)
CrPC Criminal Procedure Code
Cri-MAC Crime Multi-Agency Centre
CS Commercial Sex
CSEC Commercial sexual exploitation of children
CSE Commercial Sexual Exploitation
CSO Civil Society Organization
CSW Commercial Sex Worker
CSWB Central Social Welfare Board (of the Government of India)
CVCF Central Victim Compensation Fund
CWC Child Welfare Committee
DCP Deputy Commissioner of Police
DCPUs District Child Protection Units
DCPOs District Child Protection Officers
DIG Deputy Inspector General of Police
DSP Deputy Superintendent of Police
DMSC Durbar Mahila Samanwaya Committee
DNA Deoxyribonucleic acid
DPO District Prosecuting Officer
DWCD Department of Women and Child Development, Government of India
ECOSOC UN Economic and Social Commission
ECPAT End Child Prostitution and Trafficking (an international NGO)
ED Enforcement Directorate-A Law Enforcement Agency
ERSS Emergency Response Support System
FACSE Forum Against Child Sexual Exploitation (an NGO based in Mumbai)
FBI Federal Bureau of Investigation (of USA)
FGD Focus Group Discussion
FIR First Information Report (of a crime lodged in a police station)
GAATW Global Alliance Against Traffic in Women
List of Abbreviations Used 309

GB Road Garstin Bastion Road (now known as Shraddhanand Marg) in Delhi

GD General Diary (maintained in a police station)
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GLOTiP Global Report on Trafficking in Persons
GPAT Global Programme Against Trafficking
GNO Government Nodal Officer
GRP Government Railway Police
HAQ Centre An NGO based in Delhi
HIV/AIDS Human Immono-deficiency Virus/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome)
HTCA Human Trafficking (Control) Act, 1986 (of Nepal)
ICCW Indian Council for Child Welfare
ICESCR International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
ICDS Integrated Child Development Scheme
ICPS Integrated Child Protection Scheme
ICRW International Center for Research on Women
IG Inspector General of Police
IJM International Justice Mission (an NGO based in Mumbai)
ILO International Labour Organisation
IO Investigating Officer
IOM International Organisation of Migration
IPC Indian Penal Code, 1860
IPEC International Programme for the Elimination of Child Labour
IPS Indian Police Service
IRDP Integrated Rural Development Scheme
ISS Institute of Social Sciences
ITSSO Investigation Tracking System for Sexual Offenses
ITPA Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956
JJ Act Juvenile Justice Act, 2000
JWP Joint Women’s Programme (an NGO based in Delhi)
LGBTs Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender.
LTTE Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam
LEAs Law Enforcement Agencies
MHA Ministry of Home Affairs
MOU Memorandum of Understanding
MoWCD Ministry of Women and Child Development
MPB Missing Persons Bureau
NACO National AIDS Control Organisation
NCPCR National Commission for Protection of Child Rights
NCLP National Child Labour Project
 310

NCRB National Crime Records Bureau

NCT National Capital Territory of Delhi
NCW National Commission for Women
NE North-East
NSWP Global Network of Sex Work Projects
NFHS National Female Health Survey
NGO Non-Governmental Organisation
NHRC National Human Rights Commission
NIPCCD National Institute of Public Cooperation and Child Development
NPA National Plan of Action (of the Government of India to fight trafficking and commercial sexual exploitation)
NNSW National Network of Sex Workers
NSSO National Sample Survey Organisation
OHCHR Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
OSCE Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe
OSCs One Stop Centres
PIL Public Interest Litigation
POCSO Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012
PNO Police Nodal Officer
P & R Homes Protective & Rehabilitative Homes
PTSD Post-traumatic stress disorder
RDS Respondent driven sampling
RPF Railway Protection Force
SAARC South Asia Association of Regional Countries
SARA State Adoption Resource Agency
SAFAHT South Asia Forum Against Human Trafficking (a regional NGO network)
SAFMA Social Action Forum for Manvaadhikar
SAKHI An NGO based in Patna
SAPAT South Asia Professionals Against Trafficking
SC Supreme Court (of India)
SCW State Commission For Women
SCPCR State Commission for Protection of Child Rights
SDM Sub-Divisional Magistrate
SDGs Sustainable Development Goals
SEP Socio-Economic Programme
SHO Station House Officer (of a police station)
SHRC State Human Rights Commission
SI Sub Inspector of Police
SITA Suppression of Immoral Traffic Act, 1951
SLARTC Socio-legal Aid Research and Training Centre (an NGO based in Kolkata)
List of Abbreviations Used 311

SOS Save our Sisters (an NGO based in Mumbai)

SOP Standard Operating Procedure
SP Superintendent of Police
SPO Special Police Officer
SPSS Statistical Package for Social Sciences
SR-VAW Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women
SSB Sashastra Seema Bal
STD Sexually Transmitted Disease
STIs Sexually Transmitted Infections
STEP Support to Training and Employment Programme for Women
STOP Stop Trafficking and Oppression of Persons (an NGO based in Delhi)
TB Tuberculosis
TIP Trafficking In Persons
u/s Under Section
UDCR Universal Declaration of Child Rights, 1989
UN United Nations
UNDCP United Nations International Drug Control Programme
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNAIDS United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS
UNESCAP United Nations Economic and Social Council for Asia and Pacific
UNFPA United Nations Population Fund
UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund
UNIFEM United Nations Development Fund for Women
UNICJRI United Nations Inter-Regional Crime and Justice Research Institute
UNODC United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime
USAID United States Agency for International Development
UNESCAP United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific
UNTOC United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime
UT Union Territory
UTI Urinary Tract Infection
Vs Versus
VAMP Vaishya Anyay Mukti Parishad
VSPs Victim Service Providers
WHO World Health Organisation
WP Writ Petition (filed in the Supreme Court of India or the High Courts in India)
WTO World Trade Organisation
YMCA Young Men’s Christian Association