SM Chapter 2
SM Chapter 2
SM Chapter 2
2
a
CHAPTER a
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS:
EXTERNAL
ENVIRONMENT
LEARNING OUTCOMES
CHAPTER OVERVIEW
Strategic Analysis
Strategic Analysis - External
Industry
Competitive Strategy
2.1 INTRODUCTION
There are different kinds of business activities that take place in an organisational
setting, and a cursory look into their world reflects a wide variety of organisations
ranging from small local businesses to international or multinational corporations’
level. Generally, organisations are distinguished based on their size, type of
products, markets, geographical coverage, legal status, and like because of vast
organisational diversity.
Whatever their size or other distinguishing feature they do not operate in a vacuum.
They continuously act and react to what happens outside their periphery. The
factors that are outside the business operations are typically referred to as
organisational / business environment. In other words, and in the specific context
of business, environment may be defined as a set of all external factors that weigh
in the minds of the managers. Drawing an analogy with the term ‘atmosphere’ one
could envision layers of such influences. See Figure-
International Politico-legal,
Socio-cultural, Economic,
Decomgrpahic, Ecological
and Teachnological
Environment
Domestic Politico-legal,
Socio-cultural, Economic,
Decomgrpahic, Ecological
and Teachnological
Environment
Industry shaping
competitive force
Firm's
stakeholders
Firm's Internal
Environment
The process of strategic formulation begins with a strategic analysis. Its objective
is to compile information about internal and external environments in order to
assess possibilities while formulating strategic objectives and contemplating
strategic activities. In this chapter various aspects of external environment are
covered with the perspective of strategic analysis. We will also attempt to
understand how to identify, and tackle strategies to adapt within complex and
turbulent external environment.
Identify
External
Analysis Opportunity,
Evaluation Threats
Current
Vision
Analysis
Mission
Goals
Strategies Identify
Internal
Analysis Strength,
Weakness
Time
The below given broad list of analysis that a business undertakes to plan a strategy
covers both aspects of external analysis and internal analysis. An analysis helps
identify opportunities, threats, strengths and weaknesses.
Strategic Analysis
Management
Strategy Environment
Resources
To flourish, a business must be aware of, assess, and respond to the many
opportunities and threats present in its environment. In order to succeed, the business
must not only be aware of the numerous aspects of its surroundings but also be able
to handle and adapt to them. The business must continuously evaluate its
environment and modify its operations in order to thrive and expand.
♦ Macro environment
♦ Who are the firm suppliers and how are the links between the two being
developed?
♦ The local community within which the firm operates.
“The environment includes factors outside the firm which can lead to
opportunities for, or threats to the firm. Although, there are many factors, the
most important of the factors are socio-economic, technological, supplier,
competitors, and government.” Gluek and Jauch
operations of the organization. The beliefs, values and norms of a society determine
how individuals and organizations should be interrelated. The core beliefs of a
particular society tend to be persistent. It is difficult for a business to change these
core values, which becomes a determinant of its functioning. This means, that
businesses have to adjust to social norms and beliefs to operate successfully. The
social environment primarily affects the strategic management process within the
organization in the areas of mission and objective setting, and decisions related to
products and markets.
Economic Environment
Economic conditions have a direct bearing over the business strategies. The
economic environment refers to the overall economic situation around the business
and include conditions at the regional, national and global levels. It encompass es
conditions in the markets for resources that have an effect on the supply of inputs
and outputs of the business, their costs, and the dependability, quality, and
availability.
Economic environment determines the strength and size of the market. The
purchasing power in an economy depends on current income, prices, savings,
circulation of money, debt and credit availability. Income distribution pattern
determine the business possibilities. The important point to consider is to find out
the effect of economic prospect, growth and inflation on the operations of the
business.
Higher interest rates are detrimental for the businesses with high debt. In the real
estate market, they reduce the capability of the prospective buyers to avail loan and
pay instalments, thus lower the demand.
The economic conditions of a nation refer to a set of economic factors that have
great influence on business organizations and their operations. These include gross
domestic product, per capita income, markets for goods and services, availability
of capital, foreign exchange reserve, growth of foreign trade, strength of capital
market, interest rates, disposable income, unemployment, inflation, etc. All these
factors generally tell the state of the economy. Whether it is doing good or is it
performing poorly.
Political-Legal Environment
Political-legal environment takes into account elements like the general level of
political development, the degree to which business and economic issues have
been politicised, the degree of political morality, the state of law and order, political
stability, the political ideology and practises of the ruling party, the effectiveness
and purposefulness of governmental agencies, and the scope and type of
governmental intervention in the economy and industry. It is partly general to all
similar enterprises and partly specific to an individual enterprise.
Business is highly guided and controlled by government policies. Hence the type
of government running a country is a powerful influence on business. A business
has to consider the changes in the regulatory framework and their impact on the
business. Taxes and duties are other critical areas that may be levied and affect the
business.
Businesses prefer to operate in a country where there is a sound legal system.
However, in any country businesses must have a good working knowledge of the
major laws protecting consumers, competitions and organizations. Businesses must
understand the relevant laws relating to companies, competition, intellectual
property, foreign exchange, labour and so on.
Technological Environment
A highly important factor in the present times is technology. Technology has
changed the way people communicate and do things. Technology has also changed
the ways of how businesses operate now. Technology and business are linked and
are interdependent on one another. Businesses help society access the outcomes
of technological research and development, raising everyone's standard of living.
Changes in technology have an effect on how a business runs its operations. The
technological advancements might require a business to drastically alter its
operational, production and marketing strategies.
P- political
E- economic
S- socio-cultural
T- technological
L- legal
E- environmental
The PESTLE analysis is simple to understand and quick to implement. The advantage
of this tool is that it encourages management into proactive and structured
thinking in its decision making.
The Key Factors
♦ Political factors are how and to what extent the government intervenes in
the economy and the activities of business firms. Political factors may also
influence goods and services which the government wants to provide or be
provided and those that the government does not want to be provided.
Furthermore, governments have great influence on the health, education and
infrastructure of a nation.
♦ Economic factors have major impacts on how businesses operate and take
decisions. For example, interest rates affect a firm's cost of capital and
therefore to what extent a business grows and expands. Exchange rates affect
the costs of exporting goods and the supply and price of imported goods in
an economy. The money supply, inflation, credit flow, per capita income,
growth rates have a bearing on the business decisions.
♦ Social factors affect the demand for a company's products and how that
company operates.
Political Economic
♦ Political stability ♦ Economy situation and trends
♦ Political principles and ideologies ♦ Market and trade cycles
♦ Current and future taxation policy ♦ Specific industry factors
♦ Regulatory bodies and processes ♦ Customer/end-user drivers
♦ Government policies ♦ Interest and exchange rates
♦ Government term and change ♦ Inflation and unemployment
♦ Thrust areas of political leaders ♦ Strength of consumer spending
Social Technological
♦ Lifestyle trends ♦ Replacement
♦ Demographics technology/solutions
♦ Consumer attitudes and opinions ♦ Maturity of technology
♦ Brand, company, technology ♦ Manufacturing maturity and
image capacity
♦ Consumer buying patterns ♦ Innovation potential
♦ Ethnic/religious factors ♦ Technology access, licensing,
♦ Media views and perception patents, property rights and
copyrights
Legal Environmental
♦ Business and Corporate Laws ♦ Ecological/environmental issues
♦ Employment Law ♦ Environmental hazards
♦ Competition Law ♦ Environmental legislation
♦ Health & Safety Law ♦ Energy consumption
♦ International Treaty and Law ♦ Waste disposal
♦ Regional Legislation
♦ Develop distinct corporate strategies for the global business and whole
organisation.
Why do businesses go global?
Technological developments and evolving political views are two important factors
in the rapid rise of multinational organisations. Because of technological advances,
the process of internationalisation is now simpler than it was previously. Worldwide
communication makes it easier to define and implement global strategy by linking
corporate headquarters with their abroad operations. In addition, introduction of
improved transportation has increased the mobility of money, people, raw
materials, and finished items. There are several reasons why companies go global.
These are explained as follows:
♦ The first and foremost reason is the need to grow. It is basic need of every
organisation. Often finding opportunities in the other parts of the globe,
organisations extend their businesses and globalise their operations.
♦ There is rapid shrinking of time and distance across the globe, because of
faster communication, speedier transportation, growing financial flow of funds
and rapid technological changes.
♦ It is being realised that the domestic markets are no longer adequate. The
competition present domestically may not exist in some of the international
markets.
♦ There can be varied other reasons such as need for reliable or cheaper source
of raw-materials, cheap labour, etc. Many foreign businesses shift and set up
some of their operations to take advantage of availability of vast pool of talent.
♦ Companies often set up overseas plants to reduce high transportation costs.
It may be cheaper to produce near the market to reduce the time and costs
involved in transportation.
♦ When exporting organisations find foreign markets to open up or grow big,
they may naturally look at overseas manufacturing plants and sales branches
to generate higher sales and better cash flow.
♦ The rise of services to constitute the largest single sector in the world
economy; and regional economic integration, which has involved both the
world’s largest economies as well as certain developing economies.
♦ The apparent and real collapse of international trade barriers redefines the
roles of state and industry. The trend is towards increased privatization of
manufacturing and services sectors, less government interference in business
decisions and more dependence on the value-added sector to gain
marketplace competitiveness. The trade tariffs and custom barriers are getting
lowered, resulting in increased flow of business.
♦ Globalization has made companies in different countries to form strategic
alliances to ward off economic and technological threats and leverage their
respective comparative and competitive advantages.
♦ Product has a price. Businesses determine the cost of their products and
charge a price for them. The dynamics of supply and demand influence the
market price of an item or service. The market price is the price at which
quantity provided equals quantity desired. The price that may be paid is
determined by the market, the quality, the marketing, and the targeted group.
In the present competitive world price is often given by the market and
businesses have to work on costs to maintain profitability.
On account of competition, businesses are not able to fix market price by adding
profit margin on the costs. Rather, they work on reducing the costs given the
prevailing market price.
The third phase of PLC is maturity stage where there is slowdown in growth rate. In
this stage, the competition gets tough, and market gets stablised. Profit comes
down because of stiff competition. At this stage, organisations have to work for
maintaining stability.
In the fourth stage of PLC is declines with sharp downward drift in sales. The sales
and profits fall down sharply due to some new product replaces the existing
organisation has a unique set of procedures to perform its duties, and they may all
benefit from value chain analysis to evaluate and optimise their processes.
Value chain analysis has been widely used as a means of describing the activities
within and around an organization and relating them to an assessment of the
competitive strength of an organization (or its ability to provide value-for-money
products or services). Value chain analysis was originally introduced as an
accounting analysis to shed light on the ‘value added’ of separate steps in complex
manufacturing processes, in order to determine where cost improvements could
be made and/or value creation improved. The two basic steps of identifying
separate activities and assessing the value added from each were linked to an
analysis of an organization’s competitive advantage by Michael Porter.
Each of these groups of primary activities are linked to support activities. These
can be divided into four areas;
♦ Procurement: This refers to the processes for acquiring the various resource
inputs to the primary activities (not to the resources themselves). As such, it
occurs in many parts of the organization.
♦ Technology development: All value activities have a ‘technology’, even if it is
simply know-how. The key technologies may be concerned directly with the
The goal of the industry environment analysis, which is typically an important step
of strategic analysis, is to estimate the amount of competitive pressures the
business is presently facing and is expected to face in the near future.
The analysis entails seeing the firm in the context of a bigger framework. The
purpose of industrial analysis is to get insight into a wide range of elements within
and outside the business. Analysing these elements enhances knowledge of
surrounding and serves as the foundation for aligning strategy with changing
industry circumstances and realities.
industry helps to adapt strategy, boost profitability, and stay ahead of the
competition. Strategist may use a strong position to organizational advantage or
reinforce a weak one to avoid making mistakes in the future.
Michael Porter believes that the basic unit of analysis for understanding is a group
of competitors producing goods or services that compete directly with each other.
It is the industry where competitive advantage is ultimately won or lost. It is through
competitive strategy that the organisation attempts to adopt an approach to
compete in the industry.
The character, mix, and intricacies of competitive forces are never the same from
one industry to another. The model holds that the state of competition in an
industry is a composite of competitive pressures operating in five areas of the
overall market:
♦ Competitive pressures associated with the market manoeuvring and jockeying
for buyer patronage that goes on among rival sellers in the industry.
♦ Competitive pressures associated with the threat of new entrants into the
market.
♦ Competitive pressures coming from the attempts of companies in other
industries to win buyers over to their own substitute products.
♦ Competitive pressures stemming from supplier bargaining power and
supplier-seller collaboration.
♦ Competitive pressures stemming from buyer bargaining power and seller-
buyer Collaboration.
The strategists can use the five-forces model to determine what competition is like
in a given industry by undertaking the following steps:
Step 1: Identify the specific competitive pressures associated with each of the five
forces.
Step 2: Evaluate how strong the pressures comprising each of the five forces are
(fierce, strong, moderate to normal, or weak).
Step 3: Determine whether the collective strength of the five competitive forces is
conducive to earning attractive profits.
POTENTIAL
NEW Competitive pressures
ENTRANTS coming from the threat of
entry of new rivals
INDUSTRY
COMPETITORS
SUPPLIERS BUYERS
Competitive pressures Competitive pressures
stemming from RIVALRY AMONG stemming from buyer
suppliers Bargaining EXISTING FIRMS Bargaining Power
Power
firm’s profitability tends to be higher when other firms are blocked from
entering the industry.
To discourage new entrants, existing firms can try to raise barriers to entry.
Barriers to entry represent economic forces (or ‘hurdles’) that slow down or
impede entry by other firms. Common barriers to entry include, capital
requirements, economies of scale, product differentiation, switching costs,
brand identity, access to distribution channels and possibility of aggressive
retaliation by existing players. These are explained as follows:
(i) Capital Requirements: When a large amount of capital is required to
enter an industry, firms lacking funds are effectively barred from the
industry, thus enhancing the profitability of existing firms in the industry.
(ii) Economies of Scale: Many industries are characterized by economic
activities driven by economies of scale. Economies of scale refer to the
decline in the per-unit cost of production (or other activity) as volume
grows. A large firm that enjoys economies of scale can produce high
volumes of goods at successively lower costs. This tends to discourage
new entrants.
(iii) Product Differentiation: Product differentiation refers to the physical
or perceptual differences, or enhancements, that make a product special
or unique in the eyes of customers. Firms in the personal care products
and cosmetics industries actively engage in product differentiation to
enhance their products’ features. Differentiation works to reinforce entry
barriers because the cost of creating genuine product differences may
be too high for the new entrants.
(iv) Switching Costs: To succeed in an industry, new entrant must be able
to persuade existing customers of other companies to switch to its
products. To make a switch, buyers may need to test a new firm’s
product, negotiate new purchase contracts, and train personnel to use
the equipment, or modify facilities for product use. Buyers often incur
substantial financial (and psychological) costs in switching between
firms. When such switching costs are high, buyers are often reluctant to
change.
This is another force that influences the competitive condition of the industry.
This force will become heavier depending on the possibilities of the buyers
forming groups or cartels. Mostly, this is a phenomenon seen in industrial
products. Quite often, users of industrial products come together formally or
informally and exert pressure on the producer. The bargaining power of the
buyers influences not only the prices that the producer can charge but also
influences in many cases, costs and investments of the producer because
powerful buyers usually bargain for better services which involve costs and
investment on the part of the producer.
(ii) They spend a lot of money on the industry’s products i.e. they are big
buyers.
(iii) The industry’s product is not perceived as critical to the buyer’s needs
and buyers are more concentrated than firms supplying the product.
They can easily switch to the substitutes available.
III. Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Quite often suppliers, too, exercise considerable bargaining power over
companies. The more specialised the offering from the supplier, greater is his
clout. And, if the suppliers are also limited in number, they stand a still better
chance to exhibit their bargaining power. The bargaining power of suppliers
determines the cost of raw materials and other inputs of the industry and,
therefore, industry attractiveness and profitability.
Suppliers can influence the profitability of an industry in a number of ways.
Suppliers can command bargaining power over a firm when:
(i) Their products are crucial to the buyer and substitutes are not available.
The rivalry among existing players is quite obvious. This is what is normally
understood as competition. For any player, the competitors influence strategic
decisions at different strategic levels. The impact is evident more at functional
level in the prices being charged, advertising, and pressures on costs, product
and so on.
The intensity of rivalry in an industry is a significant determinant of industry
attractiveness and profitability. The intensity of rivalry can influence the costs
of suppliers, distribution, and of attracting customers and thus directly affect
the profitability. The more intensive the rivalry, the less attractive is the
industry. Rivalry among competitors tends to be cutthroat and industry
profitability low under various conditions explained as follows:
(i) Industry Leader: A strong industry leader can discourage price wars by
disciplining initiators of such activity. Because of its greater financial
(iii) Fixed Costs: When rivals operate with high fixed costs, they feel strong
motivation to utilize their capacity and therefore are inclined to cut
prices when they have excess capacity. Price cutting causes profitability
to fall for all firms in the industry as firms seek to produce more to cover
costs that must be paid regardless of industry demand. For this reason,
profitability tends to be lower in industries characterized by high fixed
costs.
(iv) Exit Barriers: Rivalry among competitors declines if some competitors
leave an industry. Profitability therefore tends to be higher in industries
with few exit barriers. Exit barriers come in many forms. Assets of a firm
considering exit may be highly specialized and therefore of little value
to any other firm. Such a firm can thus find no buyer for its assets. This
discourages exit. When barriers to exit are powerful, competitors
desiring exit may refrain from leaving. Their continued presence in an
industry exerts downward pressure on the profitability of all
competitors.
(v) Product Differentiation: Firms can sometimes insulate themselves
from price wars by differentiating their products from those of rivals. As
a consequence, profitability tends to be higher in industries that offer
opportunity for differentiation. Profitability tends to be lower in
industries involving undifferentiated commodities such as, memory
chips, natural resources, processed metals and railroads.
(vi) Slow Growth: Industries whose growth is slowing down tend to face
more intense rivalry. As industry growth slows, rivals must often fight
harder to grow or even to keep their existing market share. The resulting
intensive rivalry tends to reduce profitability for all.
V. Threat of Substitutes
Substitute products are a latent source of competition in an industry. In many
cases they become a major constituent of competition. Substitute products
offering a price advantage and/or performance improvement to the consumer
can drastically alter the competitive character of an industry. And they can
bring it about all of a sudden. For example, coir suffered at the hands of
synthetic fibre. Wherever substantial investment in R&D is taking place,
threats from substitute products can be expected. Substitutes, too, usually
limit the prices and profits in an industry.
A final force that can influence industry profitability is the availability of
substitutes for an industry’s product. To predict profit pressure from this
source, firms must search for products that perform the same, or nearly the
same, function as their existing products. For example, Real estate, insurance,
bonds and bank deposits for example are clear substitutes for common stocks,
because they represent alternate ways to invest funds.
The five forces together determine industry attractiveness/ profitability. This
is so because these forces influence the causes that underlie industry
attractiveness/ profitability. For example, elements such as cost and
investment needed for being a player in the industry decide industry
profitability, and all such elements are governed by these forces. The collective
strength of these five competitive forces determines the scope to earn
attractive profits. The strength of the forces may vary from industry to industry.
consider merging with a rival to bolster market share and profitability or,
alternatively, begin looking outside the industry for attractive diversification
opportunities.
Value to Customer
Customer’s
Surplus
Price
Profitable
Pricing Band
Firm’s
Margin
Thus, we can say that the value creation is an activity or performance by the firm
to create value that increases the worth of goods, services, business processes or
even the whole business system. Many businesses now focus on value creation both
in the context of creating better value for customers purchasing its products and
services, as well as for stakeholders in the business who want to see their
investment in business appreciate in value. Ultimately, this concept gives business
a competitive advantage in the industry and helps them earn above average
profits/returns.
Competitive advantage leads to superior profitability. At the most basic level, how
profitable a company becomes depends on three factors:
(1) the value customers place on the company’s products;
(2) the price that a company charges for its products; and
and supporting activities, which can help to comprehend the potential sources for
differentiation and to understand an organisation’s costs behaviour.
It is basically the value consumer wants to pay, over and above the price that the
business wants to charge from the consumer. This excess amount is called value
creation, wherein the consumers value the product or service more than it actually
costs them.
While the market is a place, business strategist work on marketing to improve the
chances of success. The term "marketing" encompasses a wide range of operations,
including research, designing, pricing, promotion, transportation, and distribution.
Often market activities are categorised and explained in terms of four Ps of
marketing – product, place, pricing, and promotion. These four kinds of marketing
activities help marketers identify customer needs so they may meet their demands
and deliver satisfaction. Delivering the best customer experience and establishing,
maintaining, and growing relationships with customers are the main goals of
marketing.
2.6.1 Customer
A customer is a person or business that buys products or services from another
organisation. Customers are important because they provide revenue and
organisations cannot exist without them. All businesses vie for customers, either by
aggressively marketing their products or by lowering their pricing to boost their
customer bases. The terms customer and consumer are practically synonymous and
are frequently used interchangeably. There is, however, a thin distinction.
Individuals or businesses that consume or utilise products and services are referred
to as consumers. Customers are the purchasers of products and services in the
economy, and they might exist as consumers or only as customers. In homes
groceries are often bought by a parent and consume by all the members of family.
Businesses routinely research the characteristics of their consumers in order to fine-
tune their marketing strategies and adjust their inventory to attract the most
customers. Customers are frequently categorised based on demographics like as
age, race, gender, ethnicity, economic level, and geographic region, which may all
assist businesses in developing a profile of a perfect customer.
customer profiles, and the selection of the best market segmentation techniques.
Using the facts generated by customer analysis, an effective profiling of customers
may be established. Customer profiles can reveal demographic information about
customers. A number of parties, including buyers, sellers, distributors, salespeople,
managers, wholesalers, retailers, suppliers, and creditors, can assist in gathering
information to effectively assess the needs and desires of consumers. Successful
businesses constantly monitor the behaviour of existing and prospective
customers.
External Factors
Market Stimuli
Environmental Purchase and
Factors Decision
Post Purchase
Making
Actions
Internal Factors
Key success factors are the prerequisites for industry success or, to put it another
way, KSFs are the factors that shape whether a company will be financially and
competitively successful.
The answers to three questions help identify an industry’s key success factors:
♦ On what basis do customers choose between the competing brands of sellers?
What product attributes are crucial to sales?
♦ What resources and competitive capabilities does a seller need to have to be
competitively successful, better human capital, quality of product or quantity
of product, cost of service, etc.?
SUMMARY
In this chapter, we learnt about the concept of strategic analysis, which is an
important tool to appreciate and assess environment of business as it largely
defines how an organisation conducts its operations. We have also discussed in
detail the environmental influences on business functioning and competition.
Employees, customer demands and expectations, supply and demand,
management, clients, suppliers, owners, government actions, technological
innovation, social trends, market trends, economic changes, and so on are all part
of the business environment.
(a) Society
(b) Government
(c) Competitors
(d) Technology
8. The emphasis on product design is very high, the intensity of competition is low,
and the market growth rate is low in the ______ stage of the industry life cycle.
(a) Maturity
(b) Introduction
(c) Growth
(d) Decline
Descriptive Questions
1. Explain the concept of Experience Curve and highlight its relevance in strategic
management.
2. Write a short note on Product Life Cycle (PLC) and its significance in portfolio
diagnosis.
3. Explain Porter’s five forces model as to how businesses can deal with the
competition.
ANSWERS/SOLUTION
Answers to Multiple Choice Questions
1 (c) 2 (d) 3 (a) 4 (a) 5 (c) 6 (b)
7 (c) 8 (b)
An advantage that Baby Turtle has is even though the material required has
no substitutes, but it used to make many other products and thus there are
many other suppliers who can provide that material. It might affect operations
in short term but will help to fight off the pressure created by existing supplier.
The implication is that larger firms in an industry would tend to have lower
unit costs as compared to those of smaller organizations, thereby gaining a
competitive cost advantage. Experience curve results from a variety of factors
such as learning effects, economies of scale, product redesign and
technological improvements in production.
The concept of experience curve is relevant for a number of areas in strategic
management. For instance, experience curve is considered a barrier for new
firms contemplating entry in an industry. It is also used to build market share
and discourage competition.
The second stage of PLC is the growth stage, in which the demand expands
rapidly, prices fall, competition increases and market expands.
The third stage of PLC is the maturity stage, where in the competition gets
tough and market gets stabilized. Profit comes down because of stiff
competition.
The fourth stage is the declining stage of PLC, in which the sales and profits
fall down sharply due to some new product replaces the existing product.