Galvan vs. Segundo
Galvan vs. Segundo
Galvan vs. Segundo
Segundo
G.R. No. 238270, July 28, 2020
FACTS:
The case involves a dispute between sisters, Amelia Tilan Galvan and
Lolita Tilan Segundo, over the ownership and division of a house and lot in
Baguio City. The property was originally purchased by their uncle, Pedro Dor-
as, in 1972, and both Amelia and Lolita were named as buyers in the Deed of
Absolute Sale of Realty. The property was subsequently registered under their
names. Lolita claimed to be the sole owner of the property, stating that
Amelia's inclusion in the deed was only to ensure her education and nursing
degree. Lolita also claimed to have paid for the property's maintenance and
taxes since 1972. Amelia, on the other hand, asserted her co-ownership of the
property and sought its partition and accounting.
ISSUE:
RULING:
Yes, Amelia and Lolita are co-owners of the house and lot. The Court
found that the Deed of Absolute Sale of Realty and the TCT issued under both
Amelia and Lolita's names were sufficient evidence of co-ownership. The Court
then ordered the equal division of the property between Amelia and Lolita, and
the net rent earnings from the old building to be equally divided between them
after deducting necessary expenses and real property taxes.