Case Against Homework
Case Against Homework
reinforces learning and helps students develop important skills. However, there is a growing body of
evidence that suggests homework may actually be doing more harm than good.
Furthermore, research has shown that homework does not necessarily improve academic
performance. In fact, a study by the National Education Association found that high school students
who did more than 90 minutes of homework per night actually performed worse on standardized
tests.
Additionally, proponents of less homework argue that it can have a negative impact on students'
mental and physical health. With the increasing pressure to excel academically, students may
experience burnout and a lack of motivation, leading to a decrease in overall well-being.
By ordering your homework on ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔, you can save time and reduce stress, allowing
you to focus on other important aspects of your life. Our team of experienced writers will ensure that
your homework is completed accurately and on time, giving you the opportunity to excel in your
studies without sacrificing your well-being.
Join the movement against homework and take the first step towards a more balanced and fulfilling
academic experience. Order your homework on ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔ and see the difference it can
make in your life.
My understanding of homework and achievement is that you will get a better course grade. And
there are form letters, examples of conversations with teachers, counselors and administrators
regarding homework overload. Worksheets, busy work, and reading assignments continue to be a
mainstay of students’ evenings. There are three ethnic groups in Rwanda “ the purchasing clerk
assistant resume Hutu, the Tutsi and the Twa. She successfully challenged and changed homework
policies at her children’s schools. Many parents told us that their middle schoolers never had any
homework in kindergarten, yet now homework for kindergarteners is the national norm. Is
memorizing word lists the best way to increase vocabulary—especially when it takes away from
reading time. Not only do I now quote this book but I make copies of certain pages to give to my
teachers and I bought a second copy to give to the school as a gift. My homework experience as a
student was almost non- existent until I reached high school because, back then, homework was an
insignificant part of the learning experience. The Case Against Homework by Sara Bennett, Nancy
Kalish. Let me confess that I have no school age children, and I am reading this book as someone
who tutors children. It isn't as convincing as it could be and I would have approached the book in a
completely different way if I was the author. They also talk about the fact that parents often complete
the assignments for their students; that homework takes away too much time free time out of each
day; that homework leaves students mentally exhausted; and that students have to sacrifice family
time to complete homework as proof that something needs to be done to change this trend and move
toward a more balanced approach to work and play. But does this mean that all homework is a waste
of time. What I have found in my 7 year old, first grade daughter and touched on in the book is that
there are two types of homework: Rote work and life based skills. But a 2004 national survey of
more than 2,900 children done by the University of Michigan found that the time kids spend doing
homework has skyrocketed by 51 percent since 1981. Even many teachers are in the dark: Only one
of the hundreds the authors interviewed and surveyed had ever taken a course specifically on
homework during training. This makes the book a little less effective than it could have been.
Whether or not the elimination of a majority or even a fraction of homework assignments would
improve physical and mental health is open to wide debate. I had several arguments with my teachers
over my theories on homework effectiveness and after reading this book i can see that I'm not alone.
But a 2004 national survey of more than 2,900 children done by the University of Michigan found
that the time kids spend doing homework has skyrocketed by 51 percent since 1981. The rest is full
of useful role-played conversations and emails helping you challenge meaningless assignments,
homework overload, etc. Writing is about things, people and events for which you are thankful.
Students already spend 5-8 hours every day in school — adding homework on top of jobs or other
outside activities is too much for your average student. Your child may not need help in certain
subjects, but that is why you need to sit down with them and see what areas need improvement and
what they are learning. I was an advocate in my work life, so it comes naturally to me to speak up.
All in all homework does not improve your grades or your understanding. While affluent students are
treated to stimulating camps and Shakespeare in the Park, impoverished minority students spend a
good portion of those three long months losing everything they've acquired over the previous nine.
That is akin to me coming to your home, observing for 15 minutes, than lambasting and critiquing
your parenting, except we get to take your kids away if your parenting is not up to the standards we
set, much like people want to fire or cancel teachers if they give homework assignments. And don't
get me started on how every parent interviewed is white and school district analyzed is majority
white, with the chief parental complaint being if children have homework parents can't dictate what
they do with their free time.
On top of that, our kids are currently spending an average of two more hours in school each day than
we did. Finnish children and teenagers, not tied down by homework, have time to explore their
interests and indulge in learning as an experience to look forward to, rather than a duty. Additionally,
the second half of the book, no matter how well-intentioned, certainly could be considered
subversive, manipulative, insubordinate, disruptive, etc., if parents take the authors' advice about how
to deal with schools regarding homework. The time crunch gets even worse in middle school, when
our children start to get homework from many different teachers who don't coordinate assignments.
All in all homework does not improve your grades or your understanding. A helpful book with
research about the benefits of homework and useful recommendations for approaching teachers
when homework is not working for your child and your family. It gives examples of homework that
is truly productive and what is simply busy work that could be doing more harm than good. It spends
a lot of time attacking Teachers and Schools as institutions. Why should I deprive your student of a
memorable experience simply because a few high school teachers are lazy. Nancy Kalish is a former
senior editor at Child and columnist for Redbook, Working Mother, and Selecciones. If the boss
wants an hour long presentation in 2 days, that’s what you do. But I respect Bennett and Kalish for
their dogged determination to lessen the impact of homework on students' everyday lives. Bennett
and Kalish reveal that the homework emperor has no clothes; there is no good evidence to support
piling on homework, especially in the younger grades. I have got this far, I have opened the book and
read the preface. They're not handing out hours of homework to their middle schoolers, either,
according to researchers Baker and LeTendre. Of course students are going to complain that they
have too much homework. The third chapter looks at the relationship between (and within) families
and teachers. This makes the book a little less effective than it could have been. School should be
about exploration, not about how many grades one can cram into a semester. The kids had to write a
book report, and it had to be 12-point font and three pages, no more and no less. Full content visible,
double tap to read brief content. An article I came across today is about how parents feel that their
children are being assigned too much homework. But does this mean that all homework is a waste of
time. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. When you add it up, it makes you wonder,
Are there enough hours for everything. Like Comment Angela 313 reviews 3 followers February 22,
2019 I liked that it has a lot of references to studies and statistical data, it seems well documented.
How much homework should students have to complete each night. Like Comment Anastasia 1,241
reviews 1 follower December 13, 2010 This was such a great book. However, it does pose interesting
discussion points regarding homework today. A Discussion of Domain Name Trademark Protection
By Matt Poole.
I agree with almost everything the authors contend regarding homework for elementary students; the
research is pretty clear on this. He also gets very angry and vents his anger by yelling. The second
half of the book was how to become an activist and rally those around you and make everyone
change teachers and school policy. It may be true, but pointing it out is bound to lead to
defensiveness. 1 like Like Comment Suzanne 304 reviews January 25, 2008 This book gave me a
different perspective on homework. And if you'd like, visit my blog and share your comments. That
has given me a lot of leverage in conversations with my child's teachers and administration. In the
against homework, novel, we are initially presented with a photograph of Emma, the protagonist on
for computer tech sample, the front cover. This book deserves 1 star because it lacks a sturdy
argument other than what all three parties want, more time for themselves. And it is a hidden cause
of the childhood obesity epidemic, creating a nation of “homework potatoes.” In The Case Against
Homework, Bennett and Kalish draw on academic research, interviews with educators, parents, and
kids, and their own experience as parents and successful homework reformers to offer detailed
advice to frustrated parents. He didn’t know how to read or write, so my husband and I filled in his
log for him. If she has ninety-nine minutes of nightly assignments, as students in the Associated
Press-AOL Online poll report, her work week jumps to 43.25 hours. That means that many sixth-
graders are working longer hours than the average adult. Kids whining because they have homework
over winter break. How much homework should students have to complete each night. Full content
visible, double tap to read brief content. And there are form letters, examples of conversations with
teachers, counselors and administrators regarding homework overload. As a teacher, my experience
with homework is from the perspective of an adult level (college teaching) and homework has always
been a part of my classroom agenda. Common sense will dictate how much should be budgeted for
school supplies beynd the norm, and if it is beyond the family means the book gives a few lines on
how to communicate it. No better time for an all-out assault on that perennial threat to 11- and 12-
year-olds everywhere: homework. This book emphasizes the damage done by homework and its
authors point out that not only is homework (the proper way to administer, how much is enough; etc)
not part of the college curriculum, the assignments given are often irrelevant to learning and a serious
waste of valuable time. This makes the book a little less effective than it could have been. Overall,
The Case Against Homework is a decently- written book that tackles a tough subject that many
wouldn't dare to touch. Clerk Resume. Her strong and against can case child homework it our we
positive facial expression connotates her clever and clerk assistant resume assertive state of mind.
The Case Against Homework: How Homework Is Hurting Children and. I want kids to enjoy their
childhood, not resent it. 5. Extra homework does not mean challenging a student. Some other facts
about the against hurting it our local economy include: A. At a deeper level, it is also true to say that
the way in which both composers have generated meaning will slightly differ of course, due to the
different mediums which have been used to propose their narratives. After a long day at school,
young children are having to spend their evening hours on homework, which has no proven benefit,
instead of on socializing, creative play, hobbies or being physically active. The authors of this book
do not take it quite that far but they come close. I am not going to do something purely because some
crummy high school teacher ONLY assigns textbook reading and worksheets (as opposed to actually
teaching the kids or conducting hands-on activities). I used this book along with 'Doing School' as
references for a presentation.
A study by Adam Maltese and reported on by The Huffington Post (the IU School of Education
assistant professor) found that “There was no relationship whatsoever between time spent on
homework and course grade.”. Like Comment Nathan Author 24 books 19 followers April 25, 2011
I feel compelled to qualify my 3-star rating. Our payment security system encrypts your information
during transmission. Empowering, practical, and rigorously researched, The Case Against Homework
shows how too much work is having a negative effect on our children’s achievement and
development and gives us the tools and tactics we need to advocate for change. Although
homework-free weekends were semi-stress-relieving (what happened to those, by the way?), they
were not enforced, and homework would usually find its way in. Most of us in my milieu just choose
to ignore it or count it as a sacrifice on the altar of vigor. I want kids to enjoy their childhood, not
resent it. 5. Extra homework does not mean challenging a student. Reading includes parental visits
to the public library, writing a book report, etc. GreatSchools: Why did you start an anti-homework
campaign. I am only using high school as an example because that is the argument I receive from
parents being a middle school teacher. 4. Kids are kids and they need time to be kids. This one week
would consist of absolutely no assignments that went beyond the hours of class time, allowing
students to use this time to try something new and invest in something they care about. Full content
visible, double tap to read brief content. And don't get me started on how every parent interviewed is
white and school district analyzed is majority white, with the chief parental complaint being if
children have homework parents can't dictate what they do with their free time. No better time for an
all-out assault on that perennial threat to 11- and 12-year-olds everywhere: homework. Even I, who
teaches three AP courses, only assign one. Why do busy work? You get enough of that in college and
graduate school. Sales made via Amazon links on Playvolution HQ support the site. In essence, for
can case child homework homework hurting we good marks in courses, banks could lower interest
rates or offer some other form of payback. It robs students of social time with friends; family time
with parents and siblings; time for participation in sports and hobbies; etc. Yet the nightly burden is
taking a serious toll on America’s families. How much homework should students have to complete
each night. In fact, according to the hundreds of families we surveyed and interviewed, the majority
of their kids in all grades were doing amounts that far exceeded the recommended guidelines each
night. The stories however are primarily from people who support the argument against. Full content
visible, double tap to read brief content. Taking into account the average seven-hour school day, a
middle schooler who does just one hour of homework each night is putting in a forty-hour work
week. With equal access to educational resources among citizens, a high moral and economic respect
for teachers, and an emphasis on nurturing collaborative rather than competitive students, Finland’s
model of learning proves that a better option is both feasible and successful. How much homework
should students have to complete each night. I had several arguments with my teachers over my
theories on homework effectiveness and after reading this book i can see that I'm not alone. There is
no mention, for example, of the system of standardized tests and whether or not they are worthwhile
indicators of future success. How many people in the work force routinely bring their work home.
Captain Quentin Cox Warsash Maritime Academy Southampton Solent University UK. At that point,
my husband and I were pretty radical about it and felt she didn’t need to do all this homework.
Many parents told us that their middle schoolers never had any homework in kindergarten, yet now
homework for kindergarteners is the national norm. The authors of this book- Sara Bennett and
Nancy Kalish- are not professional educators and this, once again, could negatively impact the
credibility of this book. The book felt very repetitive to me though- I got the point without the
endless examples of what I've already experienced with my own child. But I feel like adults have
more downtime than kids. But why not make sure that they are the smartest 18 year old out there. Is
it the worst thing if your child gets a B or God forbid a C, and were merely average (when you are
average, you are literally better off than half the people in the world or who ever you are measuring
yourself against). More to the point, no one has ever studied whether something other than
homework--independent reading, for example--might improve test scores. To me, I'm thinking this is
a pretty good deal- homework protesting parent gets her kid off the hook, there is no impact on his
grade, and everyone is happy, right. Their basic argument is that a seven hour school day is plenty of
time to teach what needs to be taught and that forcing kids to continue working each evening at
home is detrimental to students on many levels. All of the anti-homework crusaders point out that the
connection between homework and achievement is tenuous at best and nonexistent at worst. Full
content visible, double tap to read brief content. A few days after Kennedy was shot the new
President, Lyndon Johnson set up an official inquiry into what happened. It robs children of the
sleep, play, and exercise time they need for proper physical, emotional, and neurological
development. The authors attempted to blame schools and teachers. Just for fun. Homework was
contentious between Kerri and I, less so now. You’ll find out which assignments advance learning
and which are time-wasters, how to set priorities when your child comes home with an overstuffed
backpack, how to talk and write to teachers and school administrators in persuasive,
nonconfrontational ways, and how to rally other parents to help restore balance in your children’s
lives. Homework Hurting ! The problem is that it will continue to be used to manipulate Order now.
Homework burns students out, tires them, and reduces their grades the next day due to the inability
to finish assignments. Let me set this straight: I do not disagree with homework. And it is a hidden
cause of the childhood obesity epidemic, creating a nation of “homework potatoes.” In The Case
Against Homework, Bennett and Kalish draw on academic research, interviews with educators,
parents, and kids, and their own experience as parents and successful homework reformers to offer
detailed advice to frustrated parents. In fact, the hours of homework many of our kids are doing far
exceed guidelines from the National Education Association, an organization of more than 2.7 million
teachers and other educators founded in 1857, and the National Parent Teacher Association. Indeed,
in-class study is shown to be more effective — a state of affairs that barely improves by middle
school. If they choose not to do homework, they should deal with the consequences at school. In
fact, according to the hundreds of families we surveyed and interviewed, the majority of their kids
in all grades were doing amounts that far exceeded the recommended guidelines each night. In short,
they're just too young to get much out of it on their own. Like Comment Gillian 51 reviews 2
followers November 5, 2012 I wholeheartedly agree with the general idea of this book, that children
have too much homework and that it doesn't improve the overall quality of their education. I truly do
think that we over burden kids with too much homework, and I certainly remember some pointless
homework that was basically a check mark. Assignments like word searches and certain projects are
nothing more than busy work.