A Mothers Fight Against Homework
A Mothers Fight Against Homework
As a single mother of three, Emily had her hands full with work, household chores, and taking care
of her kids. She barely had time to catch her breath, let alone help her children with their homework
every night. And yet, she saw the toll that homework was taking on her kids. They were constantly
stressed, exhausted, and had little time for anything else.
Emily knew that something had to change. She started doing some research and found out that she
was not alone in her struggle. Many parents and experts were speaking out against the increasing
amount of homework given to students, and the negative effects it had on their mental and physical
well-being.
With this newfound knowledge, Emily decided to take action. She started by speaking to her
children's teachers and explaining her concerns. She also reached out to other parents and formed a
support group to discuss the issue and come up with solutions.
But Emily didn't stop there. She also took her fight to the school board and local government,
advocating for a change in the homework policies. She shared studies and research that showed the
negative effects of excessive homework and proposed alternative solutions, such as project-based
learning and more meaningful assignments.
It wasn't an easy battle, and Emily faced a lot of pushback and criticism. But she persevered,
knowing that she was fighting for the well-being of her children and countless other students who
were struggling with homework overload.
Finally, after months of hard work and determination, Emily's efforts paid off. The school board
agreed to review and revise their homework policies, and the changes were implemented the
following school year. Students were given less homework and were encouraged to participate in
extracurricular activities and spend time with their families.
Emily's children, along with many others, saw a significant improvement in their overall well-being
and academic performance. And for Emily, it was a victory that she was proud of and a reminder
that one person can make a difference.
For those who are still struggling with the burden of homework, Emily's story serves as a reminder
that change is possible. And for those who are looking for a way out of the constant homework
struggle, there is a solution - ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔.
At ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔, students can find professional writers who can help them with their
assignments, essays, and projects. With their expertise and experience, students can save time and
reduce their stress levels, allowing them to focus on other important aspects of their lives.
So why continue to struggle with endless homework assignments when there is a better way? Join
the fight against homework overload and order your assignments on ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔ today.
Your mental and physical well-being will thank you.
From a literary perspective, the authors should understand. See solutiontalk.ie for details Erectile
dysfunction or performance anxiety. All in all homework does not improve your grades or your
understanding. It started in kindergarten, and year by year, it gets worse. Try to work with your child
to come up with a good time for the homework to get done. The husband says let them do it or not it
it, but the wife is terrified their kid will be left behind. In college, the professor can then
philosophize between Aristotle or Plato and how the Utopian world should be. It demonstrates the
students’ ability to comprehend the problem presented and his ability to research and solve it. I will
be well-prepared to advocate on their behalf, should the need arise. Many teachers are open to to a
more flexible child centred approach to homework. Accept that your child's intelligence may not be
evenly distributed in all subjects. I could see it was as much a problem of elitist striving parents as it
was school policy. For most kids, homework is an inconvenience that keeps them from doing what
they want to do. Like Comment Lisa 27 reviews May 31, 2009 Although written by parents for
parents, every teacher needs to read this. Log In Watch Live TV Watch the live stream of Fox News
and full episodes. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. One needs to attain a
license, and constantly maintain it, to continue the practice of teaching.) There is also the audacity to
dictate what a teacher should spend their work and home hours doing. It doesn't claim that all
homework is bad, but that homework needs to be limited and meaningful at all grade levels. Save
articles for later Add articles to your saved list and come back to them any time. Like Comment
Angela 313 reviews 3 followers February 22, 2019 I liked that it has a lot of references to studies
and statistical data, it seems well documented. Your child may not need help in certain subjects, but
that is why you need to sit down with them and see what areas need improvement and what they are
learning. The third chapter looks at the relationship between (and within) families and teachers.
Naturally, people who have vast amounts of unresolved stress are statistically more likely to develop
psychological problems and turn to substance abuse as a release. That’s true of elementary or
secondary students.” 2. DOES THE COUNTY OFFER HELP. Similar results have also been seen in
lower grades. The tone of the book is elitist and the authors could not conceive of just not doing the
homework. A parent as a math tutor can be a ruinous experience to their primary relationship,
whereas a trusted family friend the child likes might be more useful. I’m tired of relearning concepts
that I’ve forgotten or never learned myself. How many people in the work force routinely bring their
work home. The new math grouping is a lot different than how I learned addition, subtraction,
multiplication and division.
Sometimes, it is out of a desire for parents to get involved in their child’s learning. I've seen friends'
children struggling to complete silly assignments at an age when they should be playing games, free
reading, and exploring the world. The problem is that the battles around homework are counter-
productive and likely to be damaging if they happen often. Got it Normal text size Larger text size
Very large text size Advertisement. I took from it the importance to value the free time that students
have and to respect that by only assigning valuable assignments. My son is surprised on the days we
say, “You don’t have any homework tonight or at least you don’t have to do it until Sunday.”. If the
boss wants an hour long presentation in 2 days, that’s what you do. I found the arguments against
excessive busywork quite compelling. One argument is that homework sets up lifetime study habits
and helps with self-discipline. Drop out of the race, you don’t need to win everything. Back then,
physicians in the US worried that homework might damage children’s health. Answer:
Unfortunately, your question is a common one. Over the past few years, a movement has emerged
that is questioning homework. For example, 10 minutes for kindergarten, 20 minutes for first grade,
30 minutes for second grade, etc. It even made me change how I assigned homework; I did not
change the amount of homework, but I gave kids more time. I also think every parent should read
this book too. Overall, this book could have been a thoughtful, well researched assessment of
homework and its place in education- I've read some short essays that were just that, and they were
more enlightening than this wordy book. Loading interface. About the author Sara Bennett 10 books
1 follower Librarian Note: There is more than one author by this name in the Goodreads database. As
for parents, they should find it disconcerting to hear that their school administrators and teachers are
opting of this. Like Comment Amy 154 reviews October 31, 2012 This book left me feeling
distressed about the amount and quality of homework that schools in the US are assigning. Bennett
and Kalish give examples of the competition to sustain this is between parents more so than children.
You can’t choose only to have the good aspects of teaching. However, some kids were bringing
home in excess of five hours’ worth of homework. These students have Saturday and Sundays off for
the most part unless they are in sports, which by the way, is an extra-curricular program. Not
anymore. Across the country, standardized tests and fears of falling behind are causing kids in pre-
school and kindergarten to be assigned hours of homework a night, and this after long days in the
classroom (and much more than the 10 mins per grade level recommended). Like Comment Noble
Reader 38 reviews 2 followers March 26, 2017 So some in the education community actually believe
this new wave of thinking. Indeed, integrating a relaxing reading time into the daily routine such as
around bedtime is often a special way of spending time and connecting with your child. There's no
consensus that homework lifts academic performance in the primary years. I also find it humorous
that the authors say that homework should not be given until junior high. The truth, according to
Sara Bennett and Nancy Kalish, is that there is almost no evidence that homework helps elementary
school students achieve academic success and little evidence that it helps older students.
Many parents I work with, end up in homework battles with their young children every evening. One
needs to attain a license, and constantly maintain it, to continue the practice of teaching.) There is
also the audacity to dictate what a teacher should spend their work and home hours doing. The
teachers have always reported her as bright and well able in the class so I don’t think there are any
academic problems. I’ve tried changing the routine of when she does it and letting her try it after
dinner but that can be even worse as she is tired then. Not anymore. Across the country, standardized
tests and fears of falling behind are causing kids in pre-school and kindergarten to be assigned hours
of homework a night, and this after long days in the classroom (and much more than the 10 mins per
grade level recommended). The bottom line is that they are in school 7 hours a day, that is good
enough. I truly do think that we over burden kids with too much homework, and I certainly
remember some pointless homework that was basically a check mark. Focus on reading and fun
learning As mentioned above, reading at home has enormous benefits for children and this is
something to integrate into your day. He was so tired and stressed out from being in school all day
that he needed a break. Like Comment Cortney 65 reviews 22 followers September 10, 2011 I'm
pretty progressive when it comes to educational philosophy. They state Professors don't include the
teaching of homework in teacher degrees. He has published 14 books, including 'Positive Parenting:
Bringing up responsible, well-behaved and happy children'. Focus on playtime As a parent the
important priority is to have a daily fun time connecting with your child. Bennett and Kalish provide
several concrete examples of districts who have worked with parents to address the explosion of time
spent on homework, and address how teachers can work with parents to find a happy medium.
Didn't agree with everything, but there is still value in flipping through the book. Calculus, algebra
and chemistry are the most sought-after subjects. The authors generally steer clear of high school
homework. Students should understand that in the real world, this is how life operates. I thought
this book was a great book because it makes sense about homework not being necessary to get a
good education. Similar results have also been seen in lower grades. I also liked that the book gave a
lot of ideas for how to approach the topic with teachers, school administrators and other parents -
- while Kohn's book left me convinced, this book left me feeling more like I could actually do
something about that conviction. Many people seem to believe that working on assignments after
school is an essential part of a child’s success. Parents, who themselves grew with mountains of
homework, want their kids to do mountains of homework, too, without rationally thinking, how is it
helping their own kids become educated. It robs children of the sleep, play, and exercise time they
need for proper physical, emotional, and neurological development. The rest is full of useful role-
played conversations and emails helping you challenge meaningless assignments, homework
overload, etc. But if you actually do your homework on homework, evidence suggests its benefits
are negligible at best. It is certaily easier for teachers, parents and students not have too much
homework. These playtimes can involve just about anything, whether this is drawing, lego, playing
games, baking together and includes outdoor activities such as skipping, football, creating
adventures or doing a nature walk together. Sometimes, it is out of a desire for parents to get
involved in their child’s learning. I highly recommend this book. 2010 class-issues current-
events.more Like Comment Jana 67 reviews 4 followers December 15, 2010 The book had some
good points and useful insights.
I’m not sure how he got the answer that he did, but in the end it’s correct. Many parents I work with,
end up in homework battles with their young children every evening. It spends a lot of time attacking
Teachers and Schools as institutions. We consulted with a tutor and a therapist suggested we lighten
her workload. However, the authors make some assertions about the state of kids today that I believe
are misdirected and falsely attributed to homework and teachers. This is a must read (even just a
skim) for all parents not planning to homeschool. I have always made it explicit to the kids I’m not
the Homework Enforcement Officer. See solutiontalk.ie for details Erectile dysfunction or
performance anxiety. I have begun studying and researching similar ideas and believe that if we don't
change something soon, then we are destined for trouble in the future of our children. Not anymore.
Across the country, standardized tests and fears of falling behind are causing kids in pre-school and
kindergarten to be assigned hours of homework a night, and this after long days in the classroom
(and much more than the 10 mins per grade level recommended). These playtimes can involve just
about anything, whether this is drawing, lego, playing games, baking together and includes outdoor
activities such as skipping, football, creating adventures or doing a nature walk together. You
probably didn’t understand the long-term implications of getting it done (or not getting it done, for
that matter). We eventually get it done, but it is taking far too long and sometimes ruins the evening.
The authors go on to present the research (or lack of it) around home work, The research that has
been done is not known by the average teacher. It seems to me that it would be more effective to skip
the excuses and just say what you mean. What is supposed to be academic scholarship regarding the
conditions of the schools and the learning environment, for me, turned into a whiny expose about
how teachers are over-burdened with papers to grade, students with no free-time and parents actually
having to sit down with their children a few nights a week going over what their children are
learning. Maybe your child prefers music and activity around the house to focus. They nod in
sympathy at my nervously delivered spiel. I'm saying this all with a wink, because honestly it was
just so ridiculous it was funny. I am interested, you don't need to convince me homework is a
concern. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. The good news is that only half
the book is spent whipping you into a frenzy about homework. I am sooooo glad I read this before
my sons start school. However, some kids were bringing home in excess of five hours’ worth of
homework. Another argument from the pro-homework camp is that parents can track what their kids
are doing at school. Just because it is their work culture, does not mean it has to be yours. This book
deserves 1 star because it lacks a sturdy argument other than what all three parties want, more time
for themselves. Common sense will dictate how much should be budgeted for school supplies beynd
the norm, and if it is beyond the family means the book gives a few lines on how to communicate it.
If we had twenty vocab terms in social studies, I gave them four days to get it done, as well as ten
minutes of class time. In the long term not doing homework does not seem to have done me a lot of
harm.
Try to work with your child to come up with a good time for the homework to get done. In my
distant memories of my own school experience, I had little homework in elementary school and
almost no parental involvement in my process. How many people in the work force routinely bring
their work home. Like Comment Nathan Author 24 books 19 followers April 25, 2011 I feel
compelled to qualify my 3-star rating. Try fixing up a quiet corner for him or her to work, and respect
their privacy. What's surprising is how little I have to press my case with the teachers during my
annual homework meeting. Maybe you’re wondering whether to help, or wondering how much is too
much work. Teachers when asked have contradictory beliefs about what makes good homework. As
for parents, they should find it disconcerting to hear that their school administrators and teachers are
opting of this. This is another problem, that most teachers do simply not have the time to grade all of
these assignments. Big difference. Like Comment Alison 164 reviews 8 followers December 7, 2019
Judgmental me says: derivative and intellectually dubious. This book deserves 1 star because it lacks
a sturdy argument other than what all three parties want, more time for themselves. A parent as a
math tutor can be a ruinous experience to their primary relationship, whereas a trusted family friend
the child likes might be more useful. Bennett and Kalish provide several concrete examples of
districts who have worked with parents to address the explosion of time spent on homework, and
address how teachers can work with parents to find a happy medium. Is time spent just being a child
relaxing at home not important. I believe that every educator should be required to read this book.
My son is surprised on the days we say, “You don’t have any homework tonight or at least you don’t
have to do it until Sunday.”. As the authors point out (and I can attest to this with experience)
parents tend to do most of the work. In addition, the Literacy Coalition of Palm Beach County
offers homework-assistance programs, mostly for non-English speakers. Like Comment Tanya 156
reviews September 10, 2008 Really made me think about the value of homework (or lack thereof). It
teaches you because it is hands on, meaning it forces one to open a book to read, or to calculate or to
create a project. It seems to me that it would be more effective to skip the excuses and just say what
you mean. My thoughts on homework is similar, if u get the concept and they make you do more
assignments on it, then it's just busy work taking up our childhood. I am aware educators routinely
bring work home, but this is unusual. Tantrums are thrown, and sometimes homework doesn’t get
done. It is rough for those families where both parents work full time. The third chapter looks at the
relationship between (and within) families and teachers. Common sense will dictate how much
should be budgeted for school supplies beynd the norm, and if it is beyond the family means the
book gives a few lines on how to communicate it. A lot more research and several chapters less
emotion would have turned this into a great book that tackles a worthy debate. I was reading this
hoping to become more informed about homework (spoiler: it has little to no influence on academic
outcomes).
It was frustrating that I would end up disliking a book that, in many ways, aligned with my own
educational philosophy. Evidence is right in this article that parents are fighting the school that why
their kid is not getting homework. Calculus, algebra and chemistry are the most sought-after
subjects. Like Comment Tanya 156 reviews September 10, 2008 Really made me think about the
value of homework (or lack thereof). It spends a lot of time attacking Teachers and Schools as
institutions. Maker For Teams Exclusive features for businesses to get to market faster with brands,
templates, and shared projects. Like Comment Noble Reader 38 reviews 2 followers March 26, 2017
So some in the education community actually believe this new wave of thinking. This is a must read
(even just a skim) for all parents not planning to homeschool. Work and school (and after school
care) might take 10 hours out of the day. Teachers when asked have contradictory beliefs about what
makes good homework. Parents, who themselves grew with mountains of homework, want their kids
to do mountains of homework, too, without rationally thinking, how is it helping their own kids
become educated. I have an older son and he does his homework no bother, just gets it out of the
way when he comes in. Will you: A. Assign an essay asking the students to discern the differences in
domestic policy between Carter and Reagan B. Not anymore. Across the country, standardized tests
and fears of falling behind are causing kids in pre-school and kindergarten to be assigned hours of
homework a night, and this after long days in the classroom (and much more than the 10 mins per
grade level recommended). The first chapter is just an emotive bitch fest of quoting mothers about
how terrible homework is for kids from the perfectionists to those with intellectual disabilities. If the
ban in New York gets kids playing outdoors, other schools should follow suit. The study focused on
more than 4,000 children in both public and private schools. Answer: Unfortunately, your question is
a common one. Bennett and Kalish provide several concrete examples of districts who have worked
with parents to address the explosion of time spent on homework, and address how teachers can
work with parents to find a happy medium. Let me confess that I have no school age children, and I
am reading this book as someone who tutors children. A career women complains it is so much easier
for stay at home mums to have their children keep up with the mounting piles of homework(p 72).
By this point I was able to have a quiet setting, a snack and could purchase most of the things
required, without parental involvement. The problem is not that homework takes up the kids free
time, but that homework doesn't let the parents schedule that free time. Share to Twitter Share to
Facebook Share to Pinterest. That being said, parts of this book made me want to throw it against
the wall, while uttering however many prayers to as many deities as possible that would guarantee
that I, as a teacher, would never encounter the kinds of parents profiled in this book. The halls of
academia is for learning and expanding the mind, not socializing and getting some “down time”. If
you child has difficulty in a subject, communicate to the teacher, or find an outside party to help
your child. Over the past few years, a movement has emerged that is questioning homework.
Included are fact sheets, surveys (for other parents in your kid's class), meaningful homework
policies, and step-by-step instructions for organizing other families to help reclaim their evenings,
weekends, and holidays. Maybe you’re wondering whether to help, or wondering how much is too
much work.
That's not what teaching is about, and educators need to get Master's degrees and licenses to ply
their craft (like lawyers and doctor's. It can't be scheduled within neat half-hour blocks. Homework
teaches ownership, responsibility and provides a taste of both success and failure which are both
important. I thought the book seemed rather whiney in parts - especially the end, and it lacked hard
data. The book felt very repetitive to me though- I got the point without the endless examples of
what I've already experienced with my own child. After reading this book, I would suggest that
parents, wanting more family time, assess homework when it seems accessive or odious, and
prioritize the most valuable assignments. Like Comment Tanya 156 reviews September 10, 2008
Really made me think about the value of homework (or lack thereof). Forget eating with the family
(the authors are guilty of a pollyanna-ish view of family life) or having quality time with friends. It
robs children of the sleep, play, and exercise time they need for proper physical, emotional, and
neurological development. We found that waiting until after dinner was the perfect time for him.
Tady je dulezite zminit, ze situace v Americe je velmi odlisna od te nasi ceske - deti tam dosavaji
neuveritelne naloze a to uz ve skolce. Is it the worst thing if your child gets a B or God forbid a C,
and were merely average (when you are average, you are literally better off than half the people in
the world or who ever you are measuring yourself against). From a literary perspective, the authors
should understand. Their success in life is not dependent on how they did their homework in Grade
1. Here is what worked for us last year and, hopefully, they will help you. Many schools do adopt
more creative homework policies and recommend more creative and flexible learning at home.
Parents, who themselves grew with mountains of homework, want their kids to do mountains of
homework, too, without rationally thinking, how is it helping their own kids become educated. The
litany of complaints over testing and No Child Left Behind is FAR too long to get into here; suffice
it to say that the homework phenomenon of 2-3 hours per night for 8th graders is being fed by the
standardized test beast. The authors generally steer clear of high school homework. Those guidelines
set an embarrassingly low bar: at least one-hour of moderate to vigorous physical activity a day. How
AI is helping the search for extraterrestrial life 'Dad, please don't go out': The Gazans killed as Israel
freed hostages Sahil Omar: The real story behind a fake criminal Beef trade risks key Brazil
ecosystem - campaigners 'Premier League caught my online troll. Community Reviews 3.69 209
ratings 38 reviews 5 stars 55 (26%) 4 stars 73 (34%) 3 stars 53 (25%) 2 stars 18 (8%) 1 star 10 (4%)
Search review text Filters Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews Liz B 1,744 reviews 18 followers July 31,
2009 I put this on my professional shelf because I think it's important for me to know 1)how
homework can affect families; 2) what at least some parents in my area are reading and possibly
thinking. This shows that the kids are overwhelmed with homework and have no time to their self.
We eventually get it done, but it is taking far too long and sometimes ruins the evening. That is our
problem, and why most homework is mindless drudgery. Naturally, people who have vast amounts of
unresolved stress are statistically more likely to develop psychological problems and turn to
substance abuse as a release. I was really hoping that I could gather some stats to use while debating
or explaining topics, but this book is bit too old for that. She usually refuses point-blank to do it
when she comes in and I have to spend the rest of the evening cajoling and coaxing her to do it.
Advertisement And more importantly, every minute she spends scratching her head over a matrix
literacy task, is a minute less that she could be playing in the backyard. Set aside a space where your
child has some snacks, drinks, music (if it doesn’t distract), and a favorite chair (maybe buy a special
chair, like a beanbag chair, specifically for this purpose).