Combustion Flame Speed Oxygenate
Combustion Flame Speed Oxygenate
Combustion Flame Speed Oxygenate
(2014) 36:403–410
DOI 10.1007/s40430-013-0094-y
TECHNICAL PAPER
Received: 14 January 2011 / Accepted: 4 November 2011 / Published online: 27 October 2013
Ó The Author(s) 2013. This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com
Abstract Speed flame propagation in Otto cycle engines compression ratios measured as compared to the non-
is one of the principal characteristics of fuel and is fun- oxygenated (isooctane) and oxygenated fuels (MTBE and
damental in defining the ignition advance. The greater the TAEE).
propagation speed the less the negative work required to
compress the mixture before the piston reaches the top Keywords Fuels Speed flame propagation Otto
dead center and the higher the cycle’s efficiency. This cycle engine
paper presents experimental results of time measurements
of the fuel’s ignition and the maximum pressure rating in List of symbols
the combustion chamber of a Cooperative Fuel Research AKI Antiknock Index ([(MON ? RON)/2])
engine specially instrumented. The combustion duration Hz Hertz frequency unit is derived from the International
measurements of oxygenated and non-oxygenated fuels System (IS) for frequency, which is expressed in
were taken as a function of the compression ratio (8:1, 10:1 terms of cycles per second
and 12:1) and lambda (k). The speed flame propagation in Kpa 103 Pa (Pascal) unidade padrão Multiple of the
the combustion chamber is significantly changed with the standard unit of pressure and tension of the
change of the lambda different compression ratios. The International System (IS)
VNG has a maximum in the speed flame propagation in the k lambda expresses a relationship between the mass
stoichiometric region (k = 1.0) in all compression rates in of air and fuel admitted to in a given instant by the
this study. Similar behavior occurs with ethanol and gas- engine, compared to the masses of air and fuel
ohol, but only in compression ratio 12:1. Ethanol and chemically balanced
gasohol have the higher rate of flame propagation for all
1 Introduction
Technical Editor: Demetrio Neto.
In conventional spark-ignition engines, the fuel and air pass
P. Mello (&) F. Wildner G. S. de Andrade
through intake manifold into the cylinder’s, where they are
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Federal University of
Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS 90050170, Brazil mixed with the residual gas and then compressed. Under
e-mail: [email protected] normal operating conditions, combustion is triggered by an
F. Wildner electric discharge during compression. The flame front
e-mail: [email protected] propagates through the air–fuel mixture until it reaches the
walls of the combustion chamber, where it is extinguished.
R. Cataluña R. da Silva
At the onset of combustion caused by the spark from the
Department of Physical Chemistry, Federal University of Rio
Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS 90050170, Brazil spark-plug, the speed flame propagation is small and is
e-mail: [email protected] accompanied by a slight increase in pressure (delay time)
R. da Silva due to combustion. The flame front increases progressively
e-mail: [email protected] and propagates through the combustion chamber until the
123
404 J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410
pressure inside the cylinder reaches its maximum after the for an operating condition [4]. The engine’s geometric
top dead center (TDC). parameters affect the turbulence and surface area of the
The combustion process is divided into four distinct flame front. Aerodynamic details of the intake system
phases: ignition, development, propagation and end of contribute to the creation of an oriented gas flow, changing
flame. The maximum combustion pressure must occur at a the flame’s surface area and path. The shape of the com-
point (15° after TDC) that provides the maximum power or bustion chamber also affects other criteria such as volu-
maximum torque. Combustion starts immediately after metric efficiency, knocking trend and pollutant emissions.
spark ignition, but, because the initial stages are quite slow, Combustion speed measurements in a laminar system using
the ignition delay period is used to describe the first stage. pure hydrocarbons indicated that, for the same air–fuel
Second Ishii et al. [1] it is difficult precisely determine the ratio, the speed flame varies as a function of the fuel’s
end of combustion because of burning late phenomenon [2]. chemical structure [9, 18, 19].
For these reasons, ignition delay and end of combustion are Due to the constant increase in crude oil-derived liquid
usually defined arbitrarily. Ignition delay can, for example, fuel prices and the growing restrictions with respect to
be considered the time period in which the ratio of burned environmental contamination, interest has focused
gas reaches a value of 5 [3] or 10 % [4]; [5] and end of increasingly on alternative fuels [20–27]. These fuels can
combustion as the time period in which this ratio reaches the be classified as synthetic gasoline, gasoline with oxygen-
value of 85 [4, 6] or 90 % [3]. If the onset of combustion ated compound additives such as methyl tert-butyl ether
advances progressively before the TDC, the negative work (MTBE), tert-amyl-ethyl-ether (TAEE) [28, 29]. Studies of
of compression increases. If ignition is delayed, the pressure the speed flame propagation of new oxygenated fuels such
peak occurs later and its value is reduced. The appropriate as TAEE are important to determine the best ignition
time for the onset of the combustion process depends on the advance to reach the maximum brake torque. This paper
speed flame propagation and on the geometric configuration analyzes the variation in burning speed of a Brazilian
of the combustion chamber. These depend on the engine commercial gasoline (gasohol), isooctane, MTBE, TAEE,
design, the operating conditions and the properties of the ethanol and vehicular natural gas (VNG) at different
fuel–air mixture [7–9, 4]. compression ratios and air–fuel ratios. Compression ratios
Complete combustion is described as that in which the used in this study were 8:1, 10:1, and 12:1 for the liquid
flame front moves through the combustion chamber until fuels and 14:1 for VNG. The air–fuel ratios used for each
the air–fuel mixture is completely consumed and trans- compression ratio were 0.8 and 0.9 (rich mixture), 1.0
formed into carbon dioxide and water. During the com- (stoichiometric), and 1.1 and 1.2 (lean conditions).
bustion process, carbon monoxide, unburned hydrocarbons
and nitrogen oxide are present due to kinetic effects. Factors
such as the fuel’s composition, air–fuel ratio, geometric 2 Materials and methods
details, temperature, pressure, compression ratio and
deposits in the chamber determine the physical and chem- Six different fuels were used in this study: a Brazilian
ical characteristics of the combustion process [10–13]. The commercial gasoline (gasohol), isooctane 99 %, MTBE
reactions that occur during the combustion process are 99 %, TAEE 99 %, ethanol 99.3 % and VNG. The VNG
determined by serial and parallel mechanisms whose stages contained 89 % methane, 7 % ethane and 2 % propane.
initiate in response to the formation of radicals and reac- Table 1 lists the physicochemical characteristics of the
tions due to equilibrium displacement. In many cases, due liquid fuels used here.
to the high release of energy and the resulting increase in According to table, ethanol shows a higher antiknock
temperature, the speed of the reaction increases exponen- index (AKI) than the ramified ethers (TAEE and MTBE)
tially, leading to possible detonation or knocking [4]. and isooctane. The antiknocking strength is an extremely
Knocking depends on the temperature, the system’s pres- important property of fuel for Otto cycle engines, since it
sure, and the fuel’s physicochemical characteristics [9]. At should not auto ignition by compression, but by sparking.
very low pressures, the system is outside the knock region Combustibles having a high octane index produce a milder
and the mixture reacts mildly [4, 14–16]. and more effective combustion. The octane number is
In engines with optimal design, the turbulence inside the simply a numerical description of its resistance to auto
combustion chamber is proportional to the engine’s revo- ignition without entering into a knocking process (sponta-
lution and increases the speed flame propagation [4, 17]. neous burning of the mixture). The average of the Motor
High revolution requires a great advance in the ignition, Octane Number (MON) (ASTM D 2700-97) [30] and
because the spark time for a given mass of fuel and air Research Octane Number (RON) (ASTM D 2699-97) [31]
inside the cylinder is set to give the maximum brake torque is known as the Antiknock, AKI = [(MON ? RON)/2].
123
J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410 405
Table 1 Physicochemical characteristics of the liquid fuels used in this study {Fonte: [10, 29]}
Physicochemical characteristics Gasohol Isooctane Ethanol TAEE* MTBE
123
406 J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410
composition volumetric gasohol consisted of 13 % normal cylinder equipped with a pressure control valve and the
paraffins, 23 % isoparaffins, 13 % naphthenes, 11 % ole- dosing was done with a mixer mounted on the intake
fins, 9 % aromatics and ethanol 25 %. manifold of the CFR engine. The engine’s original system,
When considering the flow of the fuel through a car- which was used for the other fuels, consisted of a triple
buretor jet, the coefficient of discharge for normal hydro- barrel carburetor with adjustable height for adjustment of
carbon fuels is virtually constant above a critical value of the air–fuel ratio.
the Reynolds number. Under these conditions, the mass The speed flame was obtained using a D-1 knock sensor
flow is a function of the density of the fuel so that increases (a standard component of the CFR engine). The D-1 sensor
mass flow and lowers the air–fuel ratio of the mixture. This has a stainless steel diaphragm, which induces a voltage in
is partly offset by the lower level in the float chamber that the sensor through the action of pressure. The induced
occurs with heavier fuels. There is such compensating voltage signal is proportional to the pressure rate in the
factor with injection vehicles where the mass of fuel combustion chamber. In this work, speed flame propaga-
injected will depend directly on the density of the fuel. tion was defined as the angle between the spark ignition
Variations in density between commercial fuels will and the maximum pressure rate inside the combustion
therefore influence the air/fuel ratio unless there is an chamber divided by time. According Ishii et al. [1], the
engine management system to hold it at the optimum level. angle considered in flame propagation includes the ignition
Most gasolines have a density between about 0.72 and delay [4] and the maximum pressure rate. The ignition
0.78. The density will depend on the types of components advance was set at 10° to compare the speed flame prop-
used in blending the gasoline, aromatics compounds have agation of the fuels under study. The ignition was deter-
the highest density, with the olefins being intermediate and mined from the signal voltage of the electronic ignition
the paraffins having the lowest density, when compounds control system. The piston’s position was determined by a
having the same number of carbon atoms are compared. Of 600 mm diameter toothed wheel with 304 straight teeth
the pure compounds used in this study, ethanol has the and one slanted in the position relative to the top dead
highest density value. The tests to measure the speed flame center with the aid of an inductive sensor.
propagation were performed with a CFR engine (a Coop- The parameter (k) lambda expresses a relationship
erative Fuel Research engine (year 1951) manufactured by between the mass of air and fuel admitted to in a given
the Waukesha Engine Division) modified with an Otto instant by the engine, compared to the masses of air and
cycle cylinder head being specially instrumented with fuel chemically balanced. It is called ‘‘rich mixture’’
sensors and temperature indicators, D-1 Knock sensor, (k \ 1) when there is a lack of oxygen for the complete
Lambda probe, acquisition board, as shown in Fig. 2 a oxidation of all the reagent available in the combustion
schematic diagram of the system with the instrumentation chamber and is called ‘‘lean’’ (k [ 1) when there is excess
used in the tests. The VNG was stored in a high-pressure oxygen to the oxidation of all the available reagent into the
123
J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410 407
320 CR 8:1
240
200 Ethanol
VNG
160
Gasohol
MTBE
120 Isooctane
TAEE
CR 10:1
320
240 Ethanol
200 VNG
Isooctane
Gasohol
160 MTBE
TAEE
240 Gasohol
The burning time in the combustion chamber was
Isooctane
defined as the interval between ignition and the maximum VNG
pressure variation inside the combustion chamber. The 200 MTBE
123
408 J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410
antiknock index. The oxygenated compound TAEE pre- higher diffusion of mass and energy when density is high
sented the lowest vapor pressure. [38–39].
Figure 4 shows the results of the speed flame propaga- Note that among the rich mixtures (k = 0.8), fuels such
tion of fuels used in this study in function of the lambda in as ethers (MTBE and TAEE), gasohol and isooctane
different compression ratios (8:1, 10:1 and 12:1). present similar speed flame propagation. Among the oxy-
It is observed that the speed flame propagation in the genated compounds, ethanol presents the highest speed
combustion chamber is significantly changed with the flame propagation and among the hydrocarbons, VNG
change of the lambda to different compression rates. The shows the lowest flame speed with rich mixtures, which
VNG has a maximum in speed flame propagation in the increases with lean mixtures. Methane has high activation
region stoichiometric (k = 1.0) in all compression rates in energy in the oxidation process, which may explain the
this study. Similar behavior occurs with ethanol and gas- lower speed flame propagation observed at air–fuel ratios
ohol, but only in compression ratio 12:1. below the stoichiometric condition when the combustion
Evaluating rich region (k = 0.8 and 0.9) shows that the temperature is low. The best ignition advance for VNG
fuel reached the lowest flame propagation rate is VNG, should be higher than that of gasohol and oxygenated fuels
while the lean region (k = 1.1 and 1.2) the TAEE begins to to achieve maximum torque. Ethanol has higher speed
show a slower flame propagation in all compression ratios flame propagation, while the high flame speed of gasohol
studied. MTBE presents a behavior similar to TAEE to the can be attributed of the ethanol in its formulation. As
lean region can be explained of the oxygenated fuel TAEE, mentioned by Lawes et al. [40], the speed flame propaga-
whose molecular structure is similar to that of MTBE but tion of ethanol can be explained by the formation of
with a higher molecular weight. intermediate species such as acetaldehyde and formalde-
Ethanol and gasohol have the higher flame propagation hyde, whose high reactivity favors the oxidation process
rate for all compression ratios measured as compared to the [41–42].
non-oxygenated (Isooctane) and oxygenated fuels (MTBE The speed flame propagation of all the fuels analyzed,
and TAEE). Ethanol has a vapor pressure of about 16 kPa, except for VNG, here increases when the air–fuel ratio is
according to Table 1, however, when mixed with gasoline, rich and close to the stoichiometric ratio. This behavior can
form azeotropes with the hydrocarbons of minimum, which be explained by the fact that the combustion temperature
have a boiling point lower than that of two separate com- increases when it approaches the stoichiometric ratio.
ponents. This effect results in an increase of the vapor When the air–fuel ratio is above the stoichiometric ratio
pressure of the mixture. (lean mixture), the speed flame propagation diminishes in
Gasohol is a complex mixture of hydrocarbons and response to the decrease in combustion temperature caused
ethanol and it is impossible to attribute the increase or by excess air.
decrease to any specific compound. However, it is known
that linear chain compounds and olefins have a higher
combustion speed than branched and saturated compounds. 4 Conclusions
However, oxygenated compounds such as MTBE and
TAEE presented lower speed flame propagation than gas- The proper determination of the compression ratio and
oline, although ethanol showed values close to that of ignition advance for the optimal performance of engines is
Brazilian commercial fuel, whose composition contains directly related with the type of fuel employed. Fuels with
about 25 % v/v of ethanol. branched-chain and ether compounds show low speed
Higher burning speed requires smaller advancements. flame propagation. The speed flame propagation of ethanol
Fuels with low flame speed need a higher ignition advance is higher than that of branched-chain and ether compounds.
to maximize the torque. For VNG and gasohol, when used The use of compression ratio 12:1 increases the combus-
compression ratio 12, the highest combustion speed occurs tion speed of isooctane, VNG, TAEE, ethanol and gasohol
in the stoichiometric mixture condition, while the burning as compared with compression ratios 8:1 and 10:1. The
speed of oxygenated fuels is higher when the mixture is higher the compression ratio the greater is the speed flame
rich (k = 0.8–0.9) and diminishes when the mixture is lean propagation. To achieve high thermodynamic and
(k = 1.1–1.2), showing the profile for all compression ratio mechanical performance, internal combustion engines with
used in this study. For air–fuel ratios above the stoichi- spark ignition should operate with high compression rates,
ometric ratio (lean mixture), the combustion process and to minimize the negative work of compression, the
becomes unstable, leading to failures in the combustion ignition advance should be reduced to obtain the maximum
cycle. brake torque. The combustion speed diminishes at air–fuel
It should be noted that, as the compression ratio ratios above the stoichiometric ratio. The VNG has a
increases, so does the speed flame propagation, due to the maximum in the speed flame propagation in the
123
J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410 409
stoichiometric region (k = 1.0) in all compression rates in 18. Hurn RW, Marshall WF, Allsup JR (1991) SAE PT-91/38, ISBN
this study. Similar behavior occurs with ethanol and gas- 1–56091-141-7, 1991
19. Owen K, Coley T (1995) Automotive Fuels Reference Book,
ohol, but only in compression ratio 12:1. Ethanol and Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc, 2a Edition, USA
gasohol have the higher rate of flame propagation for all 20. MacLean HL, Lave LB (2003) Evaluating automobile fuel/pro-
compression ratios measured as compared to the non- pulsion system technologies. Prog Energy Combust Sci 29:1–69
oxygenated fuels (isooctane) and oxygenated (MTBE, and 21. Menezes EW, Silva R, Cataluña R, Ortega RJC (2006) Effect of
ethers and ether/ethanol additives on the physicochemicalpro-
TAEE)fuels with high octane ratings can be used in perties of diesel fuel and on engine tests. Fuel 85:815–822
engines with high compression ratios. 22. Pascoli SD, Femia A, Luzzati T (2001) Natural gas cars and the
environment. A (relatively) ‘Clean’ and cheap fuel looking for
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the users. Ecol Econ 38:179–189
Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, dis- 23. Poulopoulos SG, Sâmaras DP, Philippopoulos CJ (2001) Regu-
tribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original lated and unregulated emissions from an internal combustion
author(s) and the source are credited. engine operating on ethanol-containing fuels. Atm Environ
35:4399–4406
24. Poulopoulos SG, Philippopoulos CJ (2004) MTBE, methane,
ethylene and regulated exhaust emissions from vehicles with
References deactivated catalytic converters’’. Atm Environ 38:4495–4500
25. Rampe T, Heinzel A, Vogel B (2000) Hydrogen generation from
1. Ishii K, Sasaki T, Urata Y,Yoshida K, Ohno T (1997) ‘‘Investi- biogenic and fossil fuels by autothermal reforming. J Power
gation of Cyclic Variation of IMEP Under Lean Burn Operation Sources 86:536–541
in Spark-Ignition Engine’’, SAE Tech Paper 972830 26. Shelef M, McCabe RW (2000) Twenty-five years after intro-
2. Zervas E (2005) Comparative study of some experimental duction of automotive catalysts: what next? Catal Today
methods to characterize the combustion process in a SI engine. 62:35–50
Energy 30:1803–1816 27. Silva R, Veses RC, Menezes EW, Samios D, Piatnicki CMS
3. Varaprasada R, Nehru KVK, Ganesan V (1993) Evaluation of (2005) Effect of additives on the antiknock properties and Reid
S. I. Engine Combustion Parameters: a New Approach. Combust vapor pressure of gasoline. Fuel 84:951–959
Sci Tech 89:47–55 28. Ortega RJC (2006) TAEE (Terc-amil etil éter) como aditivo para
4. Heywood JB (1988) Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals. Gasolinas Automotivas, Sı́ntese, Purificação e Aplicação, Dis-
McGraw-Hill, USA sertação Mestrado. Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul,
5. Grupta M, Bell SR, Tilmlman STJ (1996) An investigation of Brasil
lean combustion in a natural gas-fueled spark ignited engine. 29. Piel WJ (1994) Diversify future fuel needs with ethers. Fuel
Energy Res Technol 118:145–168 Reformul 4:28–33
6. Bell SR, Grupta M (1996) Extension of the lean operating limit 30. American Society for Testing and Materials. D 2700-97. Standard
for natural gas fueling of a SI engine using hydrogen blending. test method for motor octane of spark-ignition engine fuel. West
Combust Sci Technol 123:23–48 Conshohocken, PA. USA; 1998
7. Chollet HM (1996) O Motor e seus acessórios. Hemus Editora 31. American Society for Testing and Materials. D 2699-97. Standard
Ltda, São Paulo test method for research octane of spark-ignition engine fuel.
8. Giacosa D (1986) Motores Endotérmicos. Editora Cientı́fico- West Conshohocken, PA. USA; 1998
Médico, Barcelona 32. Reuter RM, Benson JD, Burns VR, Gorse RA, Hochheauser AM,
9. Guibet J, Faure-Birchem E (1999) Fuels and Engines. Editions Koehl WJ, Painter LJ, Rippon BH, Rutherford JA (1992) SAE
Technip, Paris Technical Paper 92036, 391
10. Ceviz MA, Kaymaz I (2005) Temperature and air–fuel ratio 33. Rippon BH, Rutherford JA (1992) Effects of Oxygenated Fuels
dependent specific heat ratio functions for lean burned and and RVP on Automotive Emissions – The Auto/Oil Air Quality
unburned mixture. Energy Convers Manage 46:2387–2404 Improvement Research Program SAE Technical Paper 920326
11. Moses E, Yarin AL, Bar-Yoseph P (1995) On knocking predic- 34. Lappas AA, Iatridis DK, Vasalos IA (1999) Production of
tion in spark ignition engines. Combust Flame 101:239–261 reformulated gasoline in the FCC unit. Effect of feedstock type
12. Sayin C, Kilicaslan I, Canakci M, Ozsezen N (2005) An exper- on gasoline composition. Catal Today 50:73–85
imental study of the effect of octane number higher than engine 35. Leong ST, Muttamara S, Laortanakul P (2002) Applicability of
requirement on the engine performance and emissions. Appl gasoline containing ethanol as Thailand’s alternative fuel to curb
Therm Eng 25:1315–1324 toxic VOC pollutants from automobile emission. Atmos Environ
13. Zervas E, Montagne X, Lahaye J (2004) Influence of fuel and air/ 3495–3503
fuel equivalence ratio on the emission of hydrocarbons from a SI 36. American Society for Testing and Materials. D 86-1996. Standard
engine. 1. Experimental findings. Fuel 83:2301–2311 test method for distillation of petroleum products. West Cons-
14. Farrel JT, Johnston RJ, Androulakis P (2004) ‘‘Molecular struc- hohocken, PA, USA; 1998
ture effects on laminar burning velocities at elevated temperature 37. Cataluña R, Silva R (2006) Desenvolvimento de um equipamento
and pressure’’, SAE Paper 2004-01-2936 para avaliação do efeito do etanol na pressão de vapor e entalpia
15. Selamet EE, Selamet A, Novak JM (2004) Predicting chemical de vaporização em gasolinas automotivas. Quim Nova
species in spark-ignition engines. Energy 29:449–465 29:580–585
16. Wendeker M, Czarnigowski J, Litak G, Szabelski K (2003) 38. Bradley D, Hicks RA, Lawes M, Sheppard CGW, Woolley R
Chaotic combustion in spark ignition engines. Chaos Solitons (1998) The measurement of laminar burning velocities and
Fractals 18:803–806 Markstein numbers for Iso-octane–Air and Iso-octane–n-Hep-
17. Lee KH, Lee CS (2002) Analysis of combustion and flame tane–Air mixtures at elevated temperatures and pressures in an
propagation characteristics of LPG and gasoline fuels by Laser explosion bomb. Combust Flame 115:126–144
Deflection Method. KSME Intern J 16:935–941 39. Jessup PJ, Croudace MC (2000) Gasoline fuel. US Pat 6(030):521
123
410 J Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. (2014) 36:403–410
40. Lawes M, Ormsby MP, Sheppard CGW, Woolley R (2005) 42. Salooja KC (1965) The role of aldehydes in combustion: studies
Variation of turbulent burning rate of methane, methanol, and of the combustion characteristics of aldehydes and of their
iso-octane air mixtures with equivalence ratio at elevated pres- influence on hydrocarbon combustion processes. Combust Flame
sure. Combust Sci Tech 177:1273–1289 9:373–382
41. Gulder OI (1984) Burning velocities of ethanol-isooctane blends.
Combust Flame 56:261–268
123