2016, Development, Application and Direction of Development of Urea-SCR
2016, Development, Application and Direction of Development of Urea-SCR
Abstract
Nitrogen oxide (NOx) is one of main pollution sources of air pollution, so it need to be
more and more stringent emission regulations limiting pollution. Selective catalytic
reduction (SCR) technology is the mainstream technology to remove NOx at euro V and
euro VI stage. By analyzing chemical reaction mechanism of selective catalytic reduction
(Urea-SCR) of urea, research actuality of Urea-SCR from the urea storage device, urea
supply system, catalystic converter and control unit separately was pointed out. At last
development trend of SCR technology based on research that we have was analyzed.
1. Introduction
Recently, with the aggravation of global atmospheric pollution and increase of
awareness for environmental protection, the NOx after-treatment technology is paid more
and more attention. NOx after-treatment technology includes the direct catalytic
decomposition technology, selective non-catalytic reduction (SNCR) technology,
selective catalytic reduction (SCR) technology, NOx storage reduction (NSR) technology
and plasma-facilitated catalysis (PFC) system. The promotion of practical applications of
direct catalytic decomposition technique and SNCR are limited in the field of automobile
exhaust purification due to their own limitations. NSR that is also called NSC (NOx
Storage Catalyst) or LNT (Lean NOx Trap Catalyst) is a technology pathway developed
firstly by Toyota in 1996. It is the mainstream technology of light diesel engines to reduce
the NOx, and it is suitable for applications where space is not enough to install SCR
system especially. This technology has few applications in China. There are still some key
theoretical and technical difficulties of PFC technology to be resolved, so this technology
still in the process of theoretical research and experimental studies.
As the mainstream technology of heavy duty diesel engines to reduce the NOx, SCR
refers to the reaction of exhaust and NOx to N2 by inhibiting the nonselective combustion
of reductant under the action of catalyst. The absolute amount of unburned HC in the
exhaust is low, and diesel engines need adding a little more reductant to purify NOx since
they adopt oxygen-enriched combustion technology. According to the differences of
additional reductant, SCR can be divided into urea selective reduction of NOx (Urea-SCR)
and HC selective reduction of NOx (HC-SCR). HC-SCR technology uses hydrocarbon
fuel as reductant and zeolite or Ag substrate (Ag/Al2O3) as a catalyst generally, so the cost
is relatively low. Its advantage is that the catalyst has high initial activity, and the
disadvantages are that hydrothermal stability is poor, sulfur resistance is low, low-
temperature activity is not ideal, and practical application is limited.
Urea-SCR technology is developed based on the ammonia selective reduction of NOx
(NH3-SCR) technology. But as one kind of gas, ammonia is too difficult to move and
store. Ammonia is also highly corrosive, prone to leakage, while urea is characterized by
non-toxic, clean, odorless, non-flammable, no explosion danger and low corrosive. So we
use an aqueous solution of urea instead of ammonia generally in the current, and use the
ammonia from urea thermal decomposition to restore the NOx of diesel exhaust. Urea -
SCR has been used all over the world widely as the most mature post-processing
technology of NOx.
When SCR is working, the control unit performs the predefined control strategy. Then
the urea solution in the storage device is sucked by the supply pump and injected into the
exhaust pipe in front of the catalysts through the nozzle of urea supply system. The urea
reduces into reductant NH3 by heating, as shown in formula (1). On the surface of the
SCR catalyst, the NOX is reduced to N2 by NH3, its main formula of reaction as shown
in (2) and (3):
(NH3)2CO2+H2O→2NH3+CO2 (1)
4NH3+4NO+O2→4N2+CO2 (2)
4NH3+2NO+2NO2→4N2+6H2O (3)
In high-temperature environment (higher than 300 ℃), NOx in the exhaust gas can
quickly react with ammonia (NH3) to form N2 and H2O under the action of the catalyst.
The temperature of diesel engine exhaust is generally in the range of 300 ~ 500 ℃, it
meets the temperature conditions that NOX reduction needs.
Figure 3 shows a set of air-assisted urea supply system. The metering of urea solution
is accomplished by the diaphragm pump. Stepping motor through the belt drive eccentric
wheel, then the eccentric wheel drive the plunger reciprocating movement, and the
diaphragm is finished under the action of the plunger to the suction and extrusion process
of urea solution. Diaphragm working chamber volume is fixed, so the stepper motor each
push a diaphragm, quantitative 0.8ml urea solution is supplied. According to the
measurement and control unit of instruction, in different speed of motor work, the
corresponding demand for urea is provided. The urea solution from diaphragm reaches the
mixing chamber through a one-way valve, and is mixed with the high pressure air
supplied by the air compressor. The final urea solution in the compressed air blowing
reaches atomizer to achieve atomization. A sensor for monitoring the pressure of the
pipeline is arranged on the urea pipeline in the mixing chamber. Under normal operating
conditions, the pressure of compressed air so that the air valve urea return port blocked. If
the pressure sensors to monitor the urea solution pressure is too high, the control unit send
instructions to air solenoid valve to reduce the air pressure before executing valve, thereby
opening a reflux inlet, excessive urea goes back to the urea box by reflux inlet.
V 3
k In (1 )[ cm /( g.s )]
W (4)
In the formula, k is rate constant; V is gas flow velocity under the actual temperature
and pressure; W is the quality of catalyst. Figure 4 is the relationship between the reaction
rate constant and temperature of HNCO in 4 different catalysts. From the diagram, at low
temperatures, the reaction rate constants of HNCO under different catalysts are different,
but the gap is gradually decreased with the increase of temperature.
As shown in Figure 5, urea sediment can be divided into urea crystallization and urea
stone according to the process of formation. Urea crystallization is due to the loss of water
in urea solution which leads to over saturation and production of urea, which is the
The Ford Motor Co studied the urea by experiment, the results showed that the
sediment was produced by a period of time after a period of time under 300℃, and the
main component of sediment was cyanuric acid and urea. But the sediment was not
formed at 350℃ [11].
Navistar company of the United States also carried out the study, the results show that
in the low exhaust temperature, low ambient temperature, relatively large urea solution
injection volume and relatively small exhaust flow, the sediment is the most easy to
produce. Under these conditions, 25-65% injected urea solution is converted to the
sediment. When the temperature is raised to 350℃, the amount of the injected urea
solution converted is less than 1% [12].
Weichai Power Technology Center Yu Jiao’s research [13] shows that in SCR system,
urea decomposition deposition is an important factor that affects the efficiency of the
catalytic converter. And urea decomposition and injection quantity and exhaust
temperature have great relationship. The spray nozzle position of urea deposition is due to
the nozzle flange design is not reasonable. In the position urea deposition was produced
by the presence of a exhaust flow vortex. Urea deposition in the exhaust pipe is that urea
injection angle is not reasonable. Urea solution is injected into the wall, and the wall
temperature is reduced, so the result is deposition of urea in the wall. Urea deposition in
SCR catalyst inlet is caused by no completely evaporation of the injected particles or the
excessive amount of injection.
Some researchers [14] have studied and achieved some results by optimizing the
arrangement of SCR system to improve the conversion efficiency of NOx at low
temperature and reduce the sediment generation, but it also needs further research to be
able to effectively prevent the generation of sediment.
These deposits may clog the nozzle of urea and the catalyst carrier. It also may affect
the activity of catalyst and increase the consumption of urea. These repercussions bring
about the difficulty to control the SCR system. Thus the cryogenic sediment of urea is a
hot issue of SCR field in the current [15-16].
It is common practice to install mixer before the SCR catalyst for promoting the
evaporation, decomposition of the urea and the mixture of exhaust. Numerical simulation
and experiment show that mixer is helpful to reducing the generation of sediment and
improving conversion efficiency of SCR [17-19].
3.3. Catalysts
Catalyst has three basic parts: the coating, carrier and package [20]. The study of
catalyst focuses on the choice of chemical reaction coating, internal carriers of catalyst
and the design of muffler.
Coating what consists of water coating and activity components of catalytic is the core
of the catalyst [21]. Urea-SCR catalyst bases on vanadium-based catalyst (TOi2-V2O5)
and zeolite catalyst. The advantages of vanadium-based catalyst are high conversion
efficiency, high and wide temperature window, good resistance to sulfur and low cost.
But the volatilization of vanadium will lead to inactivate when the temperature is higher
than 600 ~ 800 ℃. The temperature from heavy engine to the surface of catalyst cannot
reach such a high level, so it is applied to the domestic heavy engine. By comparing
conversion efficiency of NOX with Fe, Cu zeolite catalyst and alumina-based catalyst, we
can know that Cu zeolite catalyst have a good low temperature performance. Fe zeolite
catalyst have a good high temperature performance, while the performance of alumina-
based catalysts is somewhere in between. However, the composite zeolite catalyst of
copper and iron can integrate the all advantages [22-24].
The conventional coating application of SCR catalyst also includes catalyst that is used
to remove ammonia. This catalyst is named AMOX (Amm on Oxidation catalyst). And it
is also be used to remove NH3 that is remained after the main reaction of SCR.
Alternative technology is that we installs the after-oxidation catalytic converter after the
SCR catalyst. But there are problems with these solutions. Not only may oxidise these
solutions from NH3 into NOX as to increase pollution and system cost, but also cause
waste of urea injection to a certain degree. So we place the before-oxidation catalysts
before the SCR catalyst as the pretreatment device of engine exhaust generally.
Carrier is the skeleton part of SCR system, AMOX and coating are coated on the
carrier. Most of carrier is a whole which has cylindrical cellular channel. Its basic material
can be divided into two categories: metal and ceramic based. Metal-based carrier is small,
and it can be made into various shapes to make the design of catalytic converters easy.
But the cost of it is higher. Ceramic carrier is mainly composes of silicon carbide and
cordierite. Cordierite is mainly used in heavy engine. The advantages of cordierite are
high temperature resistance and high mechanical strength. Its disadvantages are the poor
corrosion resistance and small thermal conductivity. In addition, there is a poisoning
effect on the noble metal catalyst because cordierite contains a large of SiO2 (55% or
more). SiC mainly is applied to small-displacement engines. It has better performance
than cordierite [19]. The advantages of SiC are high porosity and strong thermal diffusion
ability. The disadvantages are high cost of preparation and the need of adhesive for a
bigger volume. Its wall thickness and porosity of the carrier are affected by the accuracy
of machining, durability of catalysts and influence of packaging process.
Package for SCR catalyst that is used to connect the carrier with the exhaust pipe is the
outer packing of carrier. It can be divided into packages with silencer and without silencer
according to the different functions as the outer packing of carrier. It also can be divided
into boxes and barrels type package depending on the arrangement of whole vehicle. Box
package’s advantages are remarkable noise-reducing effectiveness, lower airspeed and
higher efficiency of catalytic reaction. But there is a certain degree of difficulty on vehicle
layout because of the large volume. It is suitable for large vehicles and trucks. Barrel type
package is convenient for layout because the volume of post-processor close to the
muffler of original vehicle. Its performance is slightly worse than the box-type post-
processor due to the lack of structural design of muffler and the high airspeed of catalytic.
So the barrel type package is mainly suitable for small space vehicles and city buses. The
most important parameters of diesel SCR catalytic converter package are the uniformity
of flow field and entire backpressure of catalytic converters.
4. Conclusions
Follow the author information by two blank lines before main text. For the present,
with the increasingly strict emission standards, the optimization of fuel economy and
system design costs will become an important constraint condition to the control of diesel
engine emission. In this condition, the main research of urea storage device focuses on
alternatives of urea and storage problem of urea solution under the low temperature. The
research direction of urea supply system is that we need improve the low temperature
properties of SCR technology and the efficiency of the decomposition of urea. Catalyst is
the core of SCR technology research, and it trends for reducing the installation dimension
and cost of the system under the premise of meeting emission standards. In addition, it
will develop a new type of catalyst and reductant. The main research direction of control
unit is that we need develop new sensors and more precise control strategies.
In recent years, China increases investment in science and technology for
environmental protection. It makes great progress in the overall level of science and
technology, and it reaches or approaches international advanced level in some areas.
Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Tsinghua University, the PLA
Academy of Military Transportation, China Environmental Science Research Institute and
many other domestic research institutes all study for purification technology of diesel
exhaust. Dalian University is studying the closed-loop control strategy of SCR based on
pulse spectrum. Experiments show that this strategy can improve the catalytic efficiency
of SCR, and it also can reduce the difficulty of the SCR system control. So it will achieve
more precise feed control. This SCR can open a new direction of diesel engine exhaust
gas purification.
Acknowledgements
This paper is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China
(51306025) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities
(2572015AB13), and Project supported by the Maor International Joint Research Program
of China (Grant No. 2013DFA71120).
References
[1] G. Fulks, G. B. Fishe, K. Rahmoeller, M. C. Wu and E. D’Herde, “A Review of Solid Materials as
Alternative Ammonia Source for Lean NOx Reduction with SCR”, SAE Paper, (2009).
[2] T. Johannessen, H. Schmidt, J. Svagin, J. Johansen and J. Oechsle, “Ammonia Storage and Delivery
Systems for Automotive NOx After treatment”, SAE Paper, (2008).
[3] M. Tatur, D. Tomazic, F. Lacin, H. Sullivan and A. Kotrba, “Directions in Engine-Efficiency and
Emissions Research Conference”, dearborn, (2009).
[4] “German MAN Commercial Vehicle Co., Ltd. Apparatus and method for producing ammonia by solid
urea pellets”, China, 200510098006.8[P], (2006).
[5] T. J. Tarabulski, N. Y. Brewster and J. D. Peter-Hoblyn, J. M. Valentin and F. Conn, “Reducing NOx
emissions from an engine by selective catalytic reduction utilizing solid reagents”, US 5809775 [P],
(1998).
[6] L. Hua, Y. Zhao, J. Hu, T. Tao and S. J. Shuai, “Comparison between Air-assisted and Airless Urea
Spray for Diesel SCR System by PDA and CFD”, SAE Paper, (2012).
[7] Y. Jiao, “Optimization for SCR system of Heavy Engine Layout Based on STARCD”, The Annual
Symposium of CDAJ in 2008, Xian,China, (2008).
[8] A. Lundström, B. Andersson and L. Olsson, “Urea Thermolysis Studied under Flow Reactor Conditions
Using DSC and FT-IR”, Chemical Engineering Journal, vol. 150, no.2, (2009), pp.544-550.
[9] V. O. Strots, S. Santhanam, B. J. Adelman, G. A. Griffin and E. M. Derybowski, “Deposit Formation in
Urea-SCR Systems”, SAE Paper, (2009).
[10] D. Hongyi, “The Experimental Research and Numerical Simulation about the Technology of NO x
Selective Catalytic Reduction of Diesel Engine”, Beijing: Tsinghua University, (2008).
[11] Z. Guanyu, A. Fila, A. Kolrba and R. Floyd, “Investigation of Urea Deposits in Urea SCR Systems for
Medium and Heavy Duty Trucks. SAE Paper, (2010).
[12] E. Roharl, O. Krocher, M. Casapu, M. Rui and D. Harris, “Acidic Zirconia Mixed Oxides for NH3-SCR
Catalysts for PC and HD Applications”, SAE Paper, (2011).
[13] M. Karlsson, U. Wallin, S. Fredholm, J. Jansson and G. O. Wahlström, “A Combined 3D/Lumped
Modeling Approach to Ammonia SCR After-treatment Systems: Application to Mixer Designs”, SAE
Paper, (2006).
[14] L. Xu, W. Watkins, R. Snow, G Graham and R. Mccabe, “Laboratory and Engine Study of Urea-related
Deposits in Diesel Urea-SCR After-treatment Systems”, SAE Paper, (2007).
[15] H. Dong, S. Shuai and J. Wang, “Effect of Urea Thermal Decomposition on Diesel NOx-SCR
Aftertreatment Systems”, SAE Paper, (2008).
[16] H. Lun, T. Tao and Z. Yanguang, “Experimental Study on Deposition and Decomposition of Urea SCR
System for Diesel Engine”, the Symposium about Technology of Internal Combustion Engine, (2012),
pp. 20-24.
[17] Z. Y. Guang, H. Jing and C. Zhen, “Design and Experiment of Mixer in NOX Urea-Selective Catalyst
Reduction System for Heavy Duty Diesel Engine”, Chinese Internal Combustion Engine Engineering,
no. 1, (2012), pp. 32-37.
[18] Z. Yanguang, H. Jing and C. Zhen, “Experimental Study on the Effect of Mixer on the Performance of
Urea-SCR System in Automotive Diesel Engine”, Automotive Engineering, vol. 33, no. 4, (2011), pp.
303-308.
[19] C. Zhen, Z. Yanguang and L. Guodong, “Design and Numerical Simulation Study of Diesel Engine
Urea-SCR System’s Mixer”, Small Internal Combustion Engine and Motorcycle, vol. 40, no. 1, (2011),
pp.57-60.
[20] M. Guosheng and T. Zhujian, “Application and Prospect of SCR in China”, Internal combustion
Engines, vol. 3, (2008).
[21] G. Yuchai, “Incorporated company, The instructions of SCR system in YC6L-40 rail diesel engine”, vol.
2, no. 1, (2008).
[22] J. R. Theis, “SCR Catalyst Systems Optimized for Light off and Steady-state Performance”, SAE Paper,
(2008).
[23] J. Girard, G. Cavataio, R. Snow and C. Lambert, “Combined Fe-Cu SCR Systems with Optimized
Ammonia to NOx Ratio for Diesel NOx Control”, SAE Paper, (2008).
[24] Z. Yi, Z. Zhenfeng and H. Ruihua, “Research Progress in Selective Catalytic Reduction of V2O5-WO3 /
TiO2 Based SCR Activator”, Materials Review, vol. 23, no. 1, (2009), pp. 28-31.
[25] W. Fenghu, G. Xiurong and M. Yan, “Present Status and Development Trend of the Exhaust Particulate
Filter for Diesel Vehicles”, Small Internal Combustion Engine and Motorcycle, vol. 39, no. 1, (2010),
pp. 92-96.
[26] F. Willems, R. Cloudt, E. V. D. Eijnden, M. V. Genderen and R. Verbeek, “Is Closed-loop SCR Control
Required to Meet Future Emission Targets”, SAE paper, (2007).
[27] C. James and P. Jones, “Smart Sensing and Decomposition of NOx and NH3 Components from
Production NOx Sensor Signals”, SAE paper, (2011).
[28] H. Jing, Z. Yanguang and C. Ting, “Study of Control Strategy for Urea-SCR After-Treatment System of
Heavy Duty Diesel Engine”, Chinese Internal Combustion Engine Engineering, vol. 32, no. 2, (2011),
pp. 1-5.
[29] M. Devarakonda, G. Parker and J. H. Johnson, “Model-Based Estimation and Control System
Development in a Urea-SCR Aftertreatment System”, SAE paper, (2008).