Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 12 views

    BBA LLB VIII Sem EVIROMENTAL LAW MOOT PROBLEM

    Uploaded by

    Aaa
    The Modern School of Environmental Studies and private schools in Delhi filed a writ petition against orders by the Delhi Green Tribunal and Delhi government that negatively impacted their school buses. They argued that: 1) Using school buses for commercial purposes violates the education act; 2) Insurance and road tax exemptions only allow student transportation; and 3) Vehicle age alone should not determine a ban, instead fitness. A separate public interest litigation also argued the odd-even vehicle restriction violated citizens' fundamental rights without proper discussion. The Supreme Court will hear both petitions.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    BBA LLB VIII Sem EVIROMENTAL LAW MOOT PROBLEM

    Uploaded by

    Aaa
    12 views2 pages
    The Modern School of Environmental Studies and private schools in Delhi filed a writ petition against orders by the Delhi Green Tribunal and Delhi government that negatively impacted their school buses. They argued that: 1) Using school buses for commercial purposes violates the education act; 2) Insurance and road tax exemptions only allow student transportation; and 3) Vehicle age alone should not determine a ban, instead fitness. A separate public interest litigation also argued the odd-even vehicle restriction violated citizens' fundamental rights without proper discussion. The Supreme Court will hear both petitions.

    Original Description:

    moot problem environmental law

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The Modern School of Environmental Studies and private schools in Delhi filed a writ petition against orders by the Delhi Green Tribunal and Delhi government that negatively impacted their school buses. They argued that: 1) Using school buses for commercial purposes violates the education act; 2) Insurance and road tax exemptions only allow student transportation; and 3) Vehicle age alone should not determine a ban, instead fitness. A separate public interest litigation also argued the odd-even vehicle restriction violated citizens' fundamental rights without proper discussion. The Supreme Court will hear both petitions.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    12 views2 pages

    BBA LLB VIII Sem EVIROMENTAL LAW MOOT PROBLEM

    Uploaded by

    Aaa
    The Modern School of Environmental Studies and private schools in Delhi filed a writ petition against orders by the Delhi Green Tribunal and Delhi government that negatively impacted their school buses. They argued that: 1) Using school buses for commercial purposes violates the education act; 2) Insurance and road tax exemptions only allow student transportation; and 3) Vehicle age alone should not determine a ban, instead fitness. A separate public interest litigation also argued the odd-even vehicle restriction violated citizens' fundamental rights without proper discussion. The Supreme Court will hear both petitions.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    MOOT COURT PROBLEM

    The present environmental problems in Delhi, India, are a threat to the well-being of the city's and area's
    inhabitants as well as the flora and fauna. Delhi, the sixth-most populated metropolis in the world, is one of the
    most heavily polluted cities in India, having for instance one of the country's highest volumes of particulate
    matter pollution. This was corroborated by an announcement by the World Health Organization, in May 2014,
    that New Delhi was the most polluted city in the world.

    Overpopulation and the ensuing overuse of scarce resources such as water have put pressure on the
    environment. The city suffers from air pollution caused by road dust and industry, with comparatively smaller
    contributions from unclean engines in transportation, especially diesel powered city buses and trucks, and two-
    wheelers and three-wheelers with two-stroke engines. Besides human and environmental damage, pollution has
    caused economic damage as well.

    On April 8, 2015, picking up several points brought out in the ‘Death by Breath’ series, an ongoing
    investigation on the quality of air in Delhi, the Delhi Green Tribunal (DGT) issued a fresh ban on all diesel
    buses and trucks more than 5 years old from plying in the National Capital Region. A day after that, the Delhi
    government came up with a unique order of the era whereby the vehicles with odd and even registration
    numbers will be allowed on alternate days from January 01, 2016. It also passed an order to requisition school
    buses to ply as commercial, public buses after school had ended in order to encourage the commuters of Delhi to
    take public transport rather than rely solely on their private vehicles.

    The Modern School of Environmental Studies, Delhi was plying school buses running on diesel purchased in
    2005 for school purposes, and coincidently, all the buses were of the odd number series. This order of the Delhi
    government proved to be the last nail in the coffin for the school.

    The Modern School of Environmental Studies was not the sole victim of the ban and thus got the support of all
    the private schools of Delhi. And so, aggrieved by the orders of DGT and the Delhi government, the Action
    Committee for Unaided Recognized Private Schools, Delhi has filed a Writ petition in the Supreme Court
    against the DGT ban and the Odd-Even formula order of Delhi government on the following grounds:

     That taking the schools' own buses is in violation of Education Act which stipulates that school's assets
    cannot be put to commercial use. The school buses are the assets of the schools and allowing them for
    use as commercial vehicles shall amount to violation of basic principles and provisions of DSEAR
    (Delhi School Education Act and Rules) 1973.
     That the insurance of school buses stipulates use of buses for students only. The school buses are not
    permitted to be used for general public nor should the school buses be used for hire.
     That the road tax exemption also stipulates the buses shall not be used for any commercial purposes.
     That the Motor Vehicles Act prescribed a fitness test, and not the vehicle’s age, to ascertain whether it
    should be allowed to ply or not. They also contended that the DGT could not substitute by its order
    what has been written in the Motor Vehicles Act, which did not put a ban on vehicles older than 5
    years.
     That it is further contended that such a ban is completely arbitrary, and raised the argument that it is not
    the College who is responsible for making Delhi a gas chamber.

    A group of public-spirited individuals also filed a Public Interest Litigation before the Supreme Court of India,
    Delhi. While the ban on diesel buses and trucks older than five years did not directly affect private individuals,
    the Odd-Even formula did, especially those who have to commute to work and also persons with disabilities and
    other vulnerable groups who rely on their personal means of transport to get by. The writ petition was based on
    allegations of the violation of the fundamental rights of the citizens – including Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the
    Constitution of India. They also averred that the decision was made without any informed public discussion or
    debate, and without paying attention to the particular circumstances of India which are different from those of
    other countries where this rule has previously been implemented. The individuals approached the court to issue
    a writ that would restrain the Delhi government from implementing the Odd-Even rule on private vehicles and
    cars in Delhi. The two petitions have been clubbed together to be heard by the Apex Court. Argue from the both
    side.

    You might also like