Oedema Guidelines
Oedema Guidelines
Authors: Elizabeth Bouch, Katie Burns, Elizabeth Geer, Matthew Fuller and Anna Rose
It has been developed from work originally completed as part of a Post graduate
certificate from Bradford University and has been endorsed by the British Association of
Chartered Physiotherapists in Amputee Rehabilitation (BACPAR) to support and enhance
the other evidence based guidance produced by this professional network (Appendix 3);
BACPAR is a professional network and a Chartered Society of Physiotherapy (CSP)
affiliated organisation. BACPAR aims to promote best practice in the field of amputee and
prosthetic rehabilitation, through evidence and education, for the benefit of patients and
the profession. It is committed to research and education, providing a network for the
dissemination of best practice in pursuit of excellence and equity whilst maintaining cost
effectiveness.
All decisions on the application of oedema control modalities should be made jointly by
the multidisciplinary team. The residuum should also be regularly reassessed and
measurements documented in order to ascertain the clinical effectiveness of the chosen
oedema control modality.
Within the current literature there are various methods of oedema control described,
with wide variation in their application and a lack of clarity on the timing of such
applications. The guidance presents current evidence and is intended as a resource to
guide application of best practice and to assist decision making. It should be used to
support clinical judgement. Further research is needed to substantiate the guideline with
regards to the timing and application of modalities.
Background
Oedema control methods should ideally be safe, easy to apply, remain secure, prevent
skin breakdown, provide limb shrinkage and shaping, be painless and cost effective. 6,7
Oedema occurs post operatively following lower limb amputation surgery due to the
trauma and handling of tissues during surgery.12,20,29 In normal tissues, volume is
controlled by the complex interplay of fluid transfer across capillary membranes and
lymphatic re-absorption. Usually equilibrium is maintained unless pathology or trauma 20,
Literature Review
Evidence was gathered from a thorough review of available literature in November 2010
using a search of multiple databases: AMED, BNI (British Nursing Index), CINAHL,
Cochrane, EMBASE, Medline, NHS EVIDENCE, OT Seeker, PEDro, Pubmed and hand
searches of relevant literature reference lists. Limits were applied to exclude minor
amputation, upper limb amputations, hip disarticulations and hemi pelvectomy, children
and non-human studies. The inclusion criteria included major lower limb amputations,
human adults and papers written in the English language.
A list of all methods of oedema control was compiled by the guidance development group
(GDG) all working in the field of vascular surgery and amputee rehabilitation.
Search terms generated from this list were; Elevat*, Swelling, Stump AND Board,
Shrinker, Sili* AND/OR Sleeve, Heal*, Femurett*, Exercise, Juzo, Tubi, Flowtron *,
Wound, Elastic AND/OR band*, Compres*, PPAM, EWA, Sock, Volume, POP, Plaster of
Paris, Rigid AND dressing.
117 articles were identified by the literature search, 73 were excluded by abstract. Of the
remaining 44 articles, 39 were appraised using the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines
Network (SIGN) methodology checklists28, by two GDG members, as recommended by the
National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)26 and assigned a level of
evidence (Appendix 1). This appraisal tool was selected as the GDG were familiar with its
use from previously published guidelines relating to lower limb amputees 21. The
remaining five articles could not be appraised as their methodological design did not have
an appropriate corresponding checklist; these include OrthoEurope 27 & manufacturers
guidance24. These articles were included in the guideline’s additional reference list, as
they provide a depth of explanation to the guideline recommendations. The evidence
base for each modality was assigned an overall grade of recommendation based on the
quality of research available. (Appendix 2)
Robust evidence was found to support the use of Rigid dressings, Pneumatic Post
Amputation Mobility Aid (PPAM aid), compression socks, wheelchair stump boards and to
discourage the use of elastic bandage wrapping.
Grade of
recommendation
B
Types available
Rigid removable (extending above the knee or remaining below knee, eg fibreglass
sock)
Vacuum formed manufactured by Ossur
Rigid non removable (eg Plaster of Paris)
Semi rigid (extending above the knee or remaining below knee).
These techniques require specialist skills and materials. Costs vary depending on design
and supplier.
Application
When
Immediate post-operative/theatre4,8,9,12,14,15,18,19
0-3 days post-operative5
Who
Duration
The literature is unclear on the duration of use of rigid dressings but the GDG
suggest use until fitting of a prosthesis or until stump volumes have stabilised.
Rigid Dressings
Kept on for 7 days, checked and reapplied for further 14 days19
Dressing changed every 7 days15
5-7 days then replaced with compression therapy9
Rigid Removable Dressings
Continuous (to be removed for wound inspection)7,8,11
5-7 days then swapped to standardised compression therapy8
Reduction in oedema1,7,8,11,12,14,15,18
Reduced healing time4,12,15,18
Reduced time to prosthetic casting3,7,8,9,12,15,19
Reduced incidence of fixed flexion deformities at the knee15
Physically protects the stump from external trauma4
Removable rigid dressings permits regular residuum inspection7,8
Able to apply earlier than other modalities such as stump shrinkers 7
Further Considerations
Grade of
recommendation
D
Types available
Ortho Europe - trans-tibial and trans-femoral bags available with 3 heights and 2
circumferences of frames available.
Application
When
Who
Duration
Frequency
Everyday25,27
The GDG suggest use of the PPAM aid until fitting of a prosthesis or until stump
volumes have stabilised.
Benefits
Reduction of oedema3,13,25
Improves limb shaping13
Can be used as an assessment tool for prosthetic limb potential2,25
Allows commencement of early walking preventing deterioration of postural
muscles13
Further Considerations
Grade of
recommendation
D
Types available
Manufactured by Juzo and Otto Bock. Available for trans-tibial and trans-femoral
amputations in a variety of lengths and circumferences.
Application
When
Who
Duration
Benefits
Reduction in oedema1,2,10
Reduced time to prosthetic casting3
Easy donning and doffing10
Helps to shape into cylindrical shape for casting10
Further Considerations
Grade of
recommendation
D
Types
Kings Mark II
Different types available from different wheelchair manufacturers
Application
When
Who
No literature documents who should provide the stump boards but it is suggested
by the GDG that this is done by the professional responsible for providing and
organising a loan/permanent wheelchair.
Duration
Literature does not state how long a stump board should be used for but the GDG
group suggest their use whenever the patient is in the wheelchair without a
prosthesis.
Benefits
Further Considerations
The evidence available6 is against the use of elastic bandages therefore information
regarding types available and their application is not included in this guideline.
Elastic bandage wrapping has been used as the control group in comparison with rigid
dressings and was demonstrated to be less effective in oedema reduction1,11,15,18
Conclusion
Based on the best current available evidence rigid/semi rigid dressings should be used
when expertise, time and resources allow; the benefits are well documented in the
literature. The PPAM aid, compression socks and stump boards have been shown to have
some evidence base for oedema control and may be used in addition or in the absence of
rigid dressings dependant on clinical judgement. However, these modalities are not
necessarily primarily intended for use for oedema control. Their advantages include
preparation for prosthetic rehabilitation, reduction in flexion deformities and
maintenance/improvement in muscle tone and are important components of amputee
rehabilitation. Compression socks and the PPAM aid are the only tools available for trans-
femoral amputees.
Although compression socks are widely used3 as a form of oedema control there is very
limited evidence on aspects such as timing of application, who should assess
appropriateness and the frequency it should be worn for. It is suggested that further
research is required in order to offer more clarity for clinicians in these areas.
20. Airaksinen, O., Kolari, P.J., Herve, R. and Holopainen, R. (1988) Treatment of post-
traumatic oedema in lower legs using intermittent pneumatic compression. Scandinavian
Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 20(1), pp.25-28.
21. Brett, F., Burton. C., Brown. M., Clark, K., Duguid, M., Randell. And Thomas. D. (2012) Risks
to the contra-lateral foot of unilateral lower limb amputees: A therapist’s guide to
identification and management. BACPAR. Available from:
http://www.csp.org.uk/sites/files/csp/secure/ka-final_contra_foot_guideline.pdf
[accessed on 20th April 2011].
22. Ham, R. and Whittaker, N. (1984) The kings amputee stump board: a new design.
Physiotherapy, 70(8), pp.300.
23. Hickok, R.J. and Zimmerman, J.P. (1972) What are the legal implications for a physical
therapist applying an immediate postoperative rigid dressing, a cast change, or a
preparatory plaster of Paris prosthesis to an amputee under the order and supervision of
a physician? Physical Therapy, 52(3), pp.330-331.
24. Juzo JUZO-Varin soft-in two-way stretch compression stump shrinkers.
25. Lien, S. (1992) How are Physiotherapists using the vessa pneumatic post-amputation
mobility aid? Physiotherapy, 78(5), pp.318-322.
26. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (2009) The Guideline Manual 2009
[online]. London: National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE). Available
from:
http://www.nice.org.uk/aboutnice/howwework/developingniceclinicalguidelines/clinicalg
uidelinedevelopmentmethods/GuidelinesManual2009.jsp [accessed 5th April 2011].
27. Ortho Europe. Introducing PPAM Aid the pneumatic post-amputation mobility aid.
Hampshire: Ortho Europe. Available from: http://www.ortho-
europe.com/products/PPAM/ppam-aid-brochure-2010.pdf [accessed 19th March 2011].
2++ High quality systematic reviews of case control or cohort or studies. High quality
case control or cohort studies with a very low risk of confounding or bias and a
high probability that the relationship is causal
2- Case control or cohort studies with a high risk of confounding or bias and a
significant risk that the relationship is not causal
4 Expert opinion
Appendix 2
Grades of Recommendations
A At least one meta-analysis, systematic review, or RCT rated as 1++, and directly
applicable to the target population; or A body of evidence consisting principally
of studies rated as 1+, directly applicable to the target population, and
demonstrating overall consistency of results.
C A body of evidence including studies rated as 2+, directly applicable to the target
population and demonstrating overall consistency of results; or Extrapolated
evidence from studies rated as 2++
Clinical guidelines for the pre and post operative physiotherapy management of
adults with lower limb amputation.
http://www.csp.org.uk/sites/files/csp/secure/BACPAR_guidelines_lower_limb_am
putation_2006.pdf
All BACPAR and jointly produced publications are available to download from the BACPAR
website http://bacpar.csp.org.uk/publications
Anna Rose is a senior physiotherapist leading vascular, amputee and renal therapy at The
Royal London Hospital within the North East London Vascular network. Anna graduated in
2001 from Oxford Brookes University. After completing Band 5 rotations and in-patient
Band 6 rotations at large teaching hospitals, Anna specialised in vascular and amputee
management in 2008. In 2011 Anna completed a post graduate certificate in amputee
rehabilitation at The University of Bradford.