James W. Rohlf - Guide To Modern Physics. Using Mathematica For Calculations and Visualizations-CRC Press (2024)
James W. Rohlf - Guide To Modern Physics. Using Mathematica For Calculations and Visualizations-CRC Press (2024)
This is a “how to guide” for making beginning calculations in modern physics. The academic
level is second year college physical science and engineering students. The calculations are
performed in Mathematica, and stress graphical visualization, units, and numerical answers.
The techniques show the student how to learn the physics without being hung up on the math.
There is a continuing movement to introduce more advanced computational methods into
lower-level physics courses. Mathematica is a unique tool in that code is written as “human
readable” much like one writes a traditional equation on the board.
Key Features:
• Concise summary of the physics concepts.
• Over 300 worked examples in Mathematica with available notebooks.
• Tutorial to allow a beginner to produce fast results.
James Rohlf is a Professor at Boston University. As a graduate student, he worked on the first
experiment to trigger on hadron jets with a calorimeter, Fermilab E260. His thesis (G. C. Fox,
advisor, C. Barnes, R. P. Feynman, R. Gomez) used the model of Field and Feynman to compare
observed jets from hadron collisions to that from electron-positron collisions and made detailed
acceptance corrections to arrive at first the measurement of quark-quark scattering cross sec-
tions. His thesis is published in Nuclear Physics B171 (1980) 1. At the Cornell Electron Storage
Rings, he worked on the discovery of the Upsilon (4S) resonance and using novel event shape
variables developed by Steven Wolfram and his thesis advisor, Geoffrey Fox. He performed par-
ticle identification of kaons and charmed mesons to establish the quark decay sequence, b –>
c. At CERN, he worked on the discovery of the W and Z bosons and measurement of their
properties. Presently, he is working on the Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) experiment at the
CERN Large Hadron Collider (LHC) which discovered the Higgs boson and is searching for new
phenomena beyond the standard model.
Guide to Modern Physics
Using Mathematica for Calculations
and Visualizations
James W. Rohlf
Designed cover image: James W. Rohlf
Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and
publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of
their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material
reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this
form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and
let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint.
Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced,
transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or
hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information
storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, access www.copyright.
com or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA
01923, 978-750-8400. For works that are not available on CCC please contact mpkbookspermissions@
tandf.co.uk
Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are
used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515
Publisher’s note: This book has been prepared from camera-ready copy provided by the authors.
Contents
Preface xiii
v
vi Contents
Index 201
Preface
Example 5.3 Calculate the numerical value of the Bohr radius (n = 1).
4n2 πh̄2 0
,
e2 m
xiii
xiv Preface
will not evaluate if its units are incompatible with the requested unit of
nanometers (nm). If the unit is not specified, the output will be in the in-
ternational system of units (SI), no matter what units were assigned to the
input. Thus, Mathematica is a powerful unit converter. This can be a huge
time saver.
The book contains a number of figures that are all drawn in Mathematica.
The chapters are largely independent of one another, except that the ma-
terial in Chap. 1 should be digested first, and Chap. 6 (Particle in a Box)
should come before Chaps. 7 (Quantum Harmonic Oscillator) or 8 (Hydro-
gen Atom).
CHAPTER 1
Basis of Modern
Physics
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-1 1
2 Guide to Modern Physics
One e per coulomb (C) is equal to 1 eV per joule (J). Thus, the elementary
charge of 1.602×10−19 C gives the eV to be 1.602×10−19 J.
Basis of Modern Physics 3
e eV
Example 1.5 Compare the units C to J and calculate the numerical value
of the ratio.
e2
The preferred unit of 4πε0 in modern physics is eV·nm.
e2
Example 1.7 Calculate the value of 4πε0 in units eV·nm.
The units are always output in the same order (mass, length, time, etc.)
no matter what order they are input.
The unit eV/nm is a unit of force that is practical to use at the atomic
scale. The attractive force between an electron and proton separated by a dis-
tance of 0.1 nm is
e2 1.44eV · nm 14.4 eV
F= 2
= = .
4πε0 r (0.1 nm)2 0.1 nm
The strength of the electric force in these units can be identified with the
atomic energy and distance scales.
4 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 1.12 Get the numerical value of the speed of light in vacuum.
For higher energies of the nuclear scale, one may note that
Example 1.15 Get the reduced Planck’s constant times the speed of light.
Again,
197 eV · nm = 197 MeV · fm.
The fine structure constant of Ex. 1.16 can be compared with e2 /4πε0 h̄c.
e2
Example 1.18 Compare the quantity α to 4πε0 h̄c .
Basis of Modern Physics 7
v = αc.
Example 1.19 Calculate the rms speed and kinetic energy of an electron in
hydrogen.
The strength of gravity between and electron and proton can be made di-
Gm m
mensionless with the expression h̄ce p which gives the gravitational equiva-
lent of α. The particle masses may be obtained with the natural language box
(A.5). They are discussed further in 1.3.1.
8 Guide to Modern Physics
1.3 ENERGY
1.3.1 Mass and Momentum Units
A convenient mass unit is MeV/c2 , where c is the speed of light in vacuum.
Masses may be obtained with either the function Quantity[ ] or the natural
language box.
Example 1.22 Get the electron mass with both the Quantity[ ] function and
the natural language box.
Example 1.24 Get the proton mass with both the Quantity[ ] function and
the natural language box.
The preferred momentum unit is eV/c (or keV/c, MeV/c, etc.) depending
on the scale. This is convenient whether or not the electron is relativistic. The
formula for relativistic momentum is given in 1.3.3.
Example 1.25 Calculate the momentum in eV/c for an electron with speed
v = 104 m/s.
E0 = mc2 .
10 Guide to Modern Physics
1.3.3 Momentum
If the particle is relativistic, the rule for momentum (as observed to be con-
served in the lab) is
mv
p= .
2
1 − vc2
and the total energy is
2 p2
E = (mc2 )2 + (pc)2 = mc 1+ 2 2.
m c
The second term inside the square root is a small number if v << c, and the
kinetic energy reduces to the familiar nonrelativistic form.
Example 1.27 Get the nonrelativistic kinetic energy from the relativistic en-
ergy equation.
# !()*"
!"%
!",
!"$
!"+
!"#
!"'
!" !()*"
!"# !"$ !"% !"& '"!
Figure 1.1 The plot shows the kinetic energy of an electron vs. momentum
times c. At low momentum the expression is quadratic but at high momentum
it is linear.
Example 1.29 Calculate the kinetic energy and speed of an electron with
momentum 1 MeV/c.
12 Guide to Modern Physics
K + U = −13.6 eV,
e2
U =− .
4πε0 r
(In the language of quantum mechanics, both the position r and the momen-
tum p are smeared out and the above energies become averages.) The neg-
ative sign means that the force is attractive and the electron is bound. An
energy of 13.6 eV must be added to free the electron.
mH = me + mp − 13.6 eV/c2
The mass of the hydrogen atom is smaller than the sum of the masses of its
parts. The value of U is negative.
U = mH c2 − (me c2 + mp c2 ) − K
In the lowest energy (most bound) state of the hydrogen atom, the (average)
electron kinetic energy is
K = 13.6 eV
and the (average) potential energy is
U = −27.2 eV
Basis of Modern Physics 13
In the describing atom, one doesn’t worry about the constant mass ener-
gies of the electron and proton and they are left out of the expression for total
energy,
E = U + K,
This is understood to mean
U = −27.2 eV + me c2 + mp c2 ,
and
E = U + K = m H c2 .
One has to know from the context (GeV vs. eV scale), if the shortcut of leav-
ing out the mass part has been made.
The neutron mass is larger than the proton mass (Ex. 1.24) by about 1.3
MeV/c2 .
The alpha particle is the nucleus of helium and is composed of 2 neutrons
and 2 protons. It is very stable.
Example 1.32 Calculate the binding energy of the alpha particle.
Notice that Mathematica reports the atomic mass of 238 U so the electrons
need to be subtracted from the atomic mass to get the nuclear mass.
A neutron is added to an oxygen-16 nucleus to make an oxygen-17 nu-
cleus,
n +16 O →17 O + energy.
1.3.6 Q Value
The energy released in a decay (Q) is the mass energy of the decaying paricle
minus the sum of the mass energies of the decay products. The neutron decays
n → p + e + ν̄e .
p → n + e+ + νe .
This process is called β+ decay. The positron (e+ ) has the same mass as the
electron. The β+ process cannot happen for a free proton because the proton
mass is smaller than the neutron mass. An example is the decay of boron-8,
8
B →8 Be + e+ + νe .
p + p → d + e+ + νe .
Note that Q of the process is subtly different from the binding energy of
the deuteron because the positron mass must be included. The positron will
annihilate with an electron and produce energy in the form of 2 photons.
The fusion process generally occurs for elements lighter than iron, but
does not occur for heavier elements.
Example 1.38 Show that the decay 230 U →229 Pa + p + e + ν̄e cannot occur.
Example 1.39 Show that the decay U230 → U229 + n + e+ + νe cannot occur.
E = hf
18 Guide to Modern Physics
For example, the energy of photons from a 100 MHz radio broadcast is
λ (nm)
10-6
10-7
10-8
10-9
10-10
10-11
p (eV/c)
10 100 1000 104 105 106
#&
#!
"&
02
"!
&
!
! "! #! $! %! &!
'()*+, -.*/01
Figure 1.3 The atomic ionization energy is shown vs. atomic number.
The de Broglie wavelength of a nucleon inside the nucleus gives the size of
the nucleus.
20 Guide to Modern Physics
The de Broglie wavelength of a quark inside a proton gives the size of the
proton.
gives
pc = K 2 + 2mc2 K,
and
hc hc
λ= = √
pc K + 2mc2 K
Example 1.46 Calculate the wavelength of an electron that has a kinetic en-
ergy of 2 MeV.
!+,"
#!%
#!!!
!"#
#!#*
#!#)
& !'("
!"!# #! #!$ #!% #!#!
Example 1.47 Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of the earth in its orbit
about the sun.
∆x∆p ∼ h.
Note that the calculation of momentum above does not depend on the parti-
cle mass or whether or not the particle was relativistic. Suppose the confined
particle is an electron.
∆E = mc2
Example 1.52 Use the uncertainty principle to estimate the mass energy of
the exchanged particle.
In beta decay, weak force is mediated by the W particle whose large mass
gives the force an extremely short range, even compared to that of the strong
force.
Example 1.54 Use the uncertainty principle to estimate the range of the
weak force.
CHAPTER 2
Thermal Radiation
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-2 25
26 Guide to Modern Physics
!!"
!('
'(*
'()
'($
'("
&
! " # $ %
Figure 2.1 The exponential distribution, e−x , has the remarkable property the
the integral, average, and rms deviation from the average are all unity.
In Ex. 2.3, the Greek letter E is used to avoid a reserved name (A.4),
and k is entered as a user-defined variable (not the unit of Ex. 2.2) to avoid
substitution of a number in the output.
An exponential distribution of oscillators gives an average energy of kT .
!
θ
Figure 2.2 Radiation at an angle θ from a cavity wall. The time for radiation to
cross the cavity is L/(c cos θ) and the effective area from which the radiation
originates is reduced by a factor cos θ (all the radiation makes it across when
θ = 0 and none makes it across when θ = π2 ).
The power per area per wavelength radiated from the surface is
c 2πckT
R(λ) = u(λ) = .
4 λ4
This is the famous Rayleigh-Jeans formula (Fig. 2.3). It only works in the
limit of long wavelengths, suffering from what is referred to as the “ultravio-
let catastrophe”, as it blows up when λ → 0. Solution of this problem was the
birth of modern physics at a time when it was once widely thought that that
all of fundamental physics was known!
The power per area due to photon wavelengths in an interval
λ1 < λ < λ2
may be obtained by direct integration (area under the curve of Fig. 2.3).
Example 2.6 Calculate the power per area radiated for 1 m < λ < 2 m at
300 K.
Thermal Radiation 29
*$!" +,- %
!&#)
!&#(
!&#'
!&#!&
!&#!!
!&#!"
!&#!#
!%"
! " # $
Figure 2.3Radiated power per area per wavelength vs. λ predicted by the
Rayleigh-Jeans formula at 300 K.
Example 2.7 Calculate the power per area radiated for 400 nm < λ < 700 nm
at 300 K.
This is clearly not correct: objects are not glowing from radiation in the vis-
ible spectrum at room temperature!
()*+,+-.-/0 1-2/)-+3/-*4
%'&
&'$
&'#
&'"
&'!
! !"#"!#
! " # $ %&
Example 2.8 Calculate the average energy per oscillator for a quantized dis-
tribution with kT
2 energy spacing.
Thermal Radiation 31
Example 2.9 Calculate the average energy per oscillator for a quantized dis-
tribution with 10kT energy spacing.
Example 2.10 Calculate the average energy per oscillator in terms of λ for
energy spacing hc/λ.
Note that Mathematica chooses the order of the symbols in the output.
The famous universal thermal (blackbody) radiation formula derived by
Planck is obtained by replacing kT in the Rayleigh-Jeans formula (2.1.3) with
the average energy per oscillator from Ex. 2.10, giving
2πh̄c2
R= hc
.
λ5 (e λkT − 1)
This is the correct answer for the observed power per area per wavelength
radiated by an object in thermal equilibrium at a temperature T .
Example 2.11 Calculate the leading term in the blackbody formula at large
λ.
32 Guide to Modern Physics
!"!$
!"!#
!"!'#
"&#
!"!# !"!$ "%"! !
The location of the peak of the distribution is found by setting the derivative
equal to zero. The calculation is done over the domain of real numbers.
Thermal Radiation 33
!""
!"!(
!"!!(
!"!)(
!"!'(
"&#
!"!# !"!$ "%""! "%!""
Figure 2.6 The blackbody distribution is shown vs. λ at 300 K and 5800 K.
)#!$ *+, #! (
%!!
$'!
$!!
#'!
#!!
'!
!("
!"!!!!# !"!!!!$ !"!!!!% !"!!!!& !"!!!!'
150
100
50
f (s-1 )
2 × 1013 4 × 1013 6 × 1013 8 × 1013
4 × 1065
3 × 1065
2 × 1065
1 × 1065
E (eV)
0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20
Example 2.17 Integrate the thermal radiation formula over all wavelengths
to get the total radiated power per area.
)#"#
!"'
!"""
! !("
!""" #""" $""" %""" &""" '"""
Figure 2.10 The total radiated power per area is shown vs. temperature.
Example 2.18 Find the temperature where the radiated power per area is
1 MW/m2 .
Example 2.19 Find the value of kT where the radiated power per area is
1 MW/m2 .
38 Guide to Modern Physics
The Stefan-Boltzmann law for the radiated power per area is written
P
= σT 4
A
where the constant
2π5 k4
σ=
15h3 c2
is called the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.
1
Example 2.24 Calculate the radiated power per area for kT = 40 eV.
Example 2.25 Find the total radiated power per area from an object at room
temperature.
Example 2.27 Calculate the power per area radiated from sun.
40 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 2.29 Find λ that gives the peak radiated power per area.
Example 2.30 Find the value of λT which gives the wavelength for maxi-
mum power.
λmax T = 0.002898 m · K.
Thermal Radiation 41
Example 2.31 Find the wavelength for maximum power from the sun.
The human eye has evolved to have sensitivity at the wavelength where
the sun puts out its peak power.
CHAPTER 3
Key Processes
Z−2 Y + α,
A A−2
ZX →
where the decaying nucleus has shed both 2 neutrons and 2 protons that are
bound into the α particle.
Beta decay has two types, where either a neutron turns into a proton in-
side the nucleus,
+
Z X → Z+1 Y + β + νe ,
A A
Z−1 Y + β + ν̄e ,
A A −
ZX →
ZX +β Z−1 Y + νe ,
A − A
→
where a nucleus has captured an inner atomic electron and turned a proton
into a neutron.
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-3 42
Key Processes 43
Gamma decay occurs when a nucleus has been left in an excited state
(X ∗ ),
A ∗ A
Z X →Z X + γ.
N(t) = N0 e−t/τ ,
where N(t) represents the size of the sample as a function of time, N0 is the
sample size at time t = 0, and τ is the average lifetime.
The exponential distribution has the special property that the rms deviation
from the mean is equal to the mean.
Example 3.2 Calculate the rms deviation from the mean lifetime.
1
= e−t1/2 /τ
2
which gives
t1/2 = τ ln 2.
Uranium-238 decays by α emission,
238
U →234 Th + α.
44 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 3.5 An old bone has a 14 C fraction that has dropped by 20% from
atmospheric equilibrium to 0.96 × 10−12 . How old is the bone?
Key Processes 45
which gives
mv = p = qrB.
If the electron is relativistic, the same equation, p = qrB, holds provided that
the relativistic expression for momentum (1.3.3) is used.
aL
vy = at = ,
vx
where (L) is the distance traveled between the plates, t is the travel time, and
v x is the initial electron velocity. Thus,
q v x vy
= .
m EL
Key Processes 47
When the magnetic field is also applied with a strength that balances the elec-
tric force,
qE = qv x B.
Thus, using
E
vx =
B
and vy
tan θ = ,
vx
the result may be written
q E tan θ
= .
m LB2
In the above expression, E is the electric field that causes a deflection θ and
B is the magnetic field that causes no deflection.
( )!'*+ $))
" " !!
#
!"#$%!"& ' ( )!'*+ $"
Figure 3.1 A region of space has an electric field in the downward direction
and a magnetic field into the page. When the electric and magnetic forces can-
cel, an incoming electron is undeflected. When the magnetic field is turned
off, the electron is deflected upward.
Example 3.8 Calculate the electron speed for a θ = 0.1 (radian) deflection
from an electric field of 104 V/m and L = 5 cm.
48 Guide to Modern Physics
This is an atomic speed (1.2.3); the electrons used for this measurement came
from atoms.
mg = bvT = 6πηRvT ,
where the constant b is proportional to both the viscosity of air (η) and the
droplet radius (R) through a relationship called Stokes’s Law. Using the for-
mula for density (ρ),
m
ρ= 4 ,
3 πR
3
qE = mg + bvE ,
where vE is the electron velocity with the field on. This can be used to elim-
inate b to get
mg(1 + vvET )
q= .
E
Note that a free electron cannot absorb a photon. The metal is needed in this
case to conserve momentum, but it is so heavy that it gets no energy.
!"#$%&'(
+&## ,%-%#,
#(#&)*
ϕ
!23%* 0'1(/ ,%-%#,
+.""#/ 0'1(/ ,%-%#,
Figure 3.2 The energy diagram for the photoelectric effect shows empty and
filled states.
Example 3.12 Calculate the threshold wavelength for the photoelectric ef-
fect in potassium.
nλ = 2d sin θ,
where d is the distance between layers of atoms (distance between the dashed
lines in Fig. 3.4).
incident e
scattered e
θ ϕ
Figure 3.4 Electron scattering geometry from a crystal array of atoms.
p2 3
K= = kT.
2m 2
This gives √
p= 3mkT ,
and
h
λ= √ .
3mkT
54 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 3.16 Estimate the speed of a charm quark inside the J/ψ particle.
+,$-$*
+,$-$* θ
.'"&-%$*
ϕ
.'"&-%$*
Figure 3.5 When a photon scatters off an electron at rest, the photojn and
electron emerge at different angles.
E1 = E2
Example 3.18 Find the scattered photon energy at small values (compared
to the electron rest energy) of incident energy.
hc
∆λ = λ1 − λ2 = (1 − cos θ)
mc2
Example 3.21 Solve for the photon wavelength difference.
The quantity,
hc
λC = ,
mc2
is known as the Compton wavelength.
λc = 2παa
58 Guide to Modern Physics
Δλ (m)
5. × 10-12
4. × 10-12
3. × 10-12
2. × 10-12
1. × 10-12
θ
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0
Figure 3.6 The change in photon wavelength depends on the scattering angle.
! !'()"
!"#
!"%
θ
!"! !"# $"! $"# %"! %"# &"!
Figure 3.7 The energy of the scattered photon is shown vs. scattering angle
for 1, 2, and 5 MeV incident photon energies.
Example 3.23 Calculate the Compton wavelength from the Bohr radius.
Key Processes 59
Example 3.24 Calculate the Compton wavelength from the Rydberg con-
stant.
e2
= mc2
4πε0 re
which is the radius where the potential energy of an electron charge distribu-
tion would equal to its mass energy. It turns out that there is nothing special
about this distance. The electron has no measurable structure (to date) and
experiments have been performed at distances 5 orders of magnitude smaller
than re . The Compton wavelength compared to the classical electron radius is
re
λc = 2π
a
Example 3.25 Calculate the Compton wavelength from the classical elec-
tron radius.
Thus, we have
α3
re ∼ αλc ∼ α2 a ∼
R∞
Example 3.26 Calculate the maximum speed of the electron after the colli-
sion with an energetic but still non-relativistic α particle.
This energy is much larger than the energy of outer electrons in atoms (eV
scale) but much smaller than the kinetic energy of the α particle. Collisions
with electrons are negligible in Rutherford scattering.
vα and passes approximately a distance b from the nucleus (charge Q). The
momentum transferred (∆p) to the α particle is
qα Q 2b
∆p = F∆t = ,
4πε0 b2 vα
where the time (∆t) for the α partiple to pass the nucleus (the time it spends
feeling the large part of the force) is estimated to be 2b/vα . The factor of 2
is not important in the estimate; the important part is that the time experienc-
ing the force is proportional to the distance scale divided by the speed. The
scattering angle (θ) is
∆p qα Q 2b 1 qα Q
θ= = 2
= ,
p 4πε0 b vα mα vα 4πε0 bKα
where mα is the α-particle mass and Kα is its kinetic energy.
Example 3.28 Calculate the scattering angle for a 6-MeV α particle that
passes a distance 100 fm from a gold nucleus.
The above answer is in the dimensionless unit, radians. Even for a rel-
atively large approach distance of 100 fm (the nuclear scale is 1 fm), the
scattering angle is quite large, about 22◦ .
Notice that a 6-MeV α particle cannot penetrate the gold nucleus, which
would require a kinetic energy exceeding that of the Coulomb repulsion at a
distance equal to the nuclear radius,
qα Q
Kα > .
4πε0 r
Example 3.29 Calculate the α particle kinetic energy needed to penetrate the
gold nucleus of radius 7 fm.
62 Guide to Modern Physics
Scattered α
ϕ
Incident α ϕ θ
b
Nucleus
Momentum is exchanged in the collision but very little energy (like a ball
bouncing off a brick wall) because the nucleus is so massive. Therefore, the
direction of the alpha particle changes but not its magnitude and
(∆p)2 = p2 + p2 − 2p2 cos θ,
because the initial and find vectors each of length p and ∆p make a triangle.
The momentum transfer in the collision is
∆p = mα vα 2(1 − cos θ.
p
p2 Δp
p1
Figure 3.9The momentum vector before scattering (p1 ), after scattering (p2 )
and the momentum transfer vector (∆p) form a triangle.
where the last step comes from the relationship between θ and φ,
π θ
φ= − .
2 2
64 Guide to Modern Physics
Equating the two expressions for momentum transfer gives the relation-
ship between impact parameter and scattering angle,
qα Q 1 + cos θ
b= .
4πε0 mα vα 1 − cos θ
2
Example 3.31 Calculate the angular dependance of the cross section, dσ/dx
where x = cos θ.
The number of target nuclei per area is dN/V where d is the target thick-
ness. If the rate of incoming particles is Ri , then the flux is
Ri dN Ri dN0 ρ
Φ= = .
V A(10−3 kg)
The cross section is
Rs Rs A(10−3 kg)
σ= = ,
Φ Ri dN0 ρ
where Rs is the scattering rate.
αw = GF E 2 .
At 1 GeV,
αw ≈ 10−5 .
Example 3.37 Estimate the interaction cross section per nucleon for the in-
teraction of a 1 GeV neutrino.
Example 3.38 Estimate the interaction rate for 1 GeV neutrinos incident on
a 104 kg target with a flux of 108 m−2 s−1 .
Example 3.39 Estimate the mean free path for a 1 GeV neutrino in the earth.
The 1 GeV neutrino mean free path is about 5000 times greater than the
earth’s diameter (1.3 × 107 m). A 1 GeV neutrino passing through the full
diameter of the earth will only have a probability of 1 in 5000 of interacting.
CHAPTER 4
Special Relativity
The first postulate of special relativity states that the laws of physics are iden-
tical in all inertial (non-accelerated) frames of reference. The second postu-
late states that the speed of light in vacuum (c) is the same for all observers.
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-4 69
70 Guide to Modern Physics
2.5
2.0
1.5
β
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
c-v (m/s)
108
106
104
100
0.01
γ
1 10 100 1000 104 105
Figure 4.2 The speed of light in vacuum minus particle speed is shown vs. γ.
Frame ℬ
c c2 - v 2
v
Light left
Figure 4.4 In frame S0 , in the time that light moves from A to B, points A
and B have both moved to the right. The speed of light and the speed v make
a right triangle as shown.
.
The muon is its own clock ticking away until its decay. The mean lifetime
for the muon in its rest frame is about 2.2 µs. In a frame in which it is moving,
the lifetime is a factor of γ longer.
Example 4.2 Calculate the lifetime of the muon in the frame where it moves
corresponding to γ = 10.
Example 4.3 Calculate the average distance the muon can travel before de-
caying.
The muons are observed to reach the surface of the earth because of time
dilation.
An atomic clock was flown on the space shuttle at a speed v for a time
∆T as measured on earth. The time interval measured on the space shuttle is
shorter by a factor of γ. The difference of the time intervals due to special
relativity is
1 v 2
∆T − ∆T = T 1 − 1 − .
γ c
Example 4.4 Calculate the time interval difference for v = 7710 m/s and T
= 7 days.
Special Relativity 73
The energy is
q q q
E = (mc2 )2 + (pc)2 = (mc2 )2 + (γβmc2 )2 = (mc2 )2 ((1 + γ2 β2 ).
Using
β2 1
1 + γ2 β2 = 1 + = = γ2 ,
1−β 2 1 − β2
gives
E = γmc2
and
pc
β= .
E
74 Guide to Modern Physics
In 2022, the CERN Large Hadron Collider (LHC) increased the energy
of the protons to 6.8 TeV per beam. One TeV is 1012 eV.
Example 4.7 Calculate how much the speed of LHC protons differ from the
speed of light.
4.4 4-VECTORS
A 4-vector is a 4-component vector with one scalar “time” part and an or-
dinary vector “space part whose length does not depend on the frame of
reference. The length-squared of a 4-vector is defined as the square of the
time part minus the square of the space part. The combination (ct, r) makes a
4-vector of length (L) squared:
L2 = (ct)2 − x2 + y2 + z2 ).
(mc2 )2 = E 2 − (pc)2 ,
s = (E1∗ + E2∗ )2 ,
where E1∗ and E2∗ are the energies in the CM frame. Thus, the total energy
squared in the CM frame is the invariant mass of the system. The collision
of two particles is simplest when viewed in the CM frame because the total
momentum is zero both before and after the collision. If the two particles have
the same mass, then the energies E ∗ are also equal in the CM frame, and
s = (E ∗ + E ∗ )2 = 4E ∗2 .
p + p → p + p + p + p̄
in order to conserve baryon number. The antiproton has the same mass as the
proton.
Example 4.10 Calculate the (total) energy that a proton needs to hit another
proton at rest and make an antiproton.
The Lorentz transformation preserves the length of any 4-vector. The un-
derlying physics states whether something transforms like a 4-vector or not.
Time-space makes a 4-vector because the speed of light does not depend on
the frame of reference.
The Lorentz transformation accounts for time dilation. and length con-
traction. Consider the example of the clock. In the frame where the clock
is at rest, a time interval (t2 − t1 ) is measured at the same location. Make a
Lorentz transformation to the frame where the clock is moving. In this frame
the time interval is longer by γ.
Example 4.13 Calculate the time interval c(t2 − t1 ) in the moving frame.
Example 4.14 Transform a mass m from rest and calculate its β-factor.
Example 4.16 Calculate the relative speeds of the particles in Fig. 4.5.
4.6.2 Redshift
Astrophysicists define redshift (z) to be a fractional change in frequency for
stars that are receding from us,
f − f 1+β
z=
= −1
f 1−β
Example 4.18 Find β corresponding to redshift z.
'(*
'()
'($
'("
&
! " # $ %
Example 4.19 Find cos θ for the boundary between redshift and blueshift as
a function of β.
()*θ
'"!
!"&
!"%
!"$
!"#
β
!"# !"$ !"% !"& '"!
Figure 4.7 Cosine of the boundary angle between redshift and blueshift is
plotted as a function of β. Note that at very large values of β there will be a
redshift unless the source is headed sharply toward the observer.
CHAPTER 5
Bohr Model
mvr = nh̄,
e2 mv2
= .
4πε0 r2 r
The possible values of the orbit radius as a function of the quantum number
n are
4n2 πh̄2 ε0
r= .
e2 m
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-5 82
Bohr Model 83
4πh̄2 ε0
Example 5.2 Compare a0 with e2 m
.
5.2.2 Energy
The kinetic energy is one-half the potential energy with the opposite sign.
1 1 e2 1
K = mv2 = = − U.
2 2 4πε0 r 2
The total energy (E) is
V 1 e2
E = K +U = =−
2 2 4πε0 r
with r given in 5.1 as
r = n 2 a0 .
84 Guide to Modern Physics
1 αc 2
E=− m .
2 n
5.3.1 Orbits
The size of the orbits in the Bohr model scale by the square of the quantum
number, n2 .
5.3.2 Speeds
The orbit speeds are inversely proportional to the quantum number n.
Bohr Model 85
5.3.3 Energies
The energies scale as −13.6 eV/n2 . Increasing values of the quantum number
n give larger energies.
Example 5.17 Calculate the energy of the first Lyman transition using the
Rydberg constant.
Example 5.18 Calculate the reduced mass divided by the electron mass.
The deuteron has a slightly bigger reduced mass than the proton. Con-
sider the Balmer series n = 3 to n = 2 transition. This photon from this tran-
sition was calculated to have a wavelength of 656 nm (5.4.2). The photon
energy is
1 2 1 1
E = µ(αc) − ,
2 4 9
and the wavelength is
hc
λ= .
E
Example 5.19 Calculate the wavelength difference between the n = 3 to
n = 2 transition in hydrogen vs. deuterium.
e2 a2
P= .
6πε0 c3
For an atom in a circular orbit, the acceleration is
v2
a= .
r
Bohr Model 89
Example 5.20 Calculate the power radiated for a classical electron in the
Bohr orbit.
The energy radiated per second is enormous compared to the kinetic energy
of the electron and the Bohr atom would collapse on a time scale of 10−11
s.
Example 5.22 Calculate the radiation frequency and take the limit as n → ∞.
0.005
0.002
% difference
0.001
5.× 10-4
2.× 10-4
Figure 5.1 The percentage difference between the radiation and orbit frequen-
cies drops vs. the quantum number n.
Particle in a Box
1.5
1.0
U
0.5
0.0
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
x/L
Figure 6.1 The potential for the one-dimensional particle in a box becomes
infinite at the boundaries.
DOI: 10.1201/9781003395515-6 92
Particle in a Box 93
d2 ψ 2mE
2
= − 2 ψ.
dx h̄
This is the most important differential equation that appears in physics. It
is of the same form that describes mechanical oscillations: two derivatives
of a function gives the same function back with a negative sign and a con-
stant multiplier. The only functions that satisfy this are the sine and cosine.
The sine and cosine have the same shape and differ only by placement of the
origin.
6.3 SOLUTION
There are multiple solutions (in this case, an infinite number) corresponding
to the number of oscillations that fit inside the box. The general solution that
satisfies the boundary conditions (ψ → 0. at at x = 0 and x = L) is
nπx
ψ = A sin ,
L
where A is a constant that is determined by normalization to unit
probability and n is a positive integer that tells us how many peaks
the sine function makes inside the box. It is a general feature in
the quantum world that the lowest energy cannot be zero because
that would require ψ = 0 which would correspond to no particle at
all.
The energy levels increase with n, but the percentage of increase de-
creases with n, in such a manner that we arrive at the classical limit at large n.
The interpretation of the wave function is that its square is the probability
per distance x (or per volume for 3 dimensions) of finding the particle at lo-
cation x. The integral of the wave function squared over all possible positions
94 Guide to Modern Physics
'()*+, !π # ℏ# "#-.# #
&"
%"
$"
#"
!"
π2 h̄2
Figure 6.2 The energy levels are indicated in units of 2mL2
.
is normalized to unity.
#"! # #
'"! ! !
ψ
ψ
$ $ $
( ( (
# # #
ψ#
ψ#
ψ#
' ! ' ! '
! ! !
!"! !"# !"$ !"% !"& '"! !"! !"# !"$ !"% !"& '"! !"! !"# !"$ !"% !"& '"!
)!* )!* )!*
Example 6.3 Calculate the ground state energy for an electron in a box of
width 0.2 nm.
We may make a comparison with the Bohr model (Chap. 5) which re-
quires
λ = 2πa0 .
This is the n = 2 state for a box of size L = 2πa0 .
Example 6.5 Calculate the energy for a proton in a box of width 3 fm.
π2 h̄2 h2
∆E > = .
2mL2 8mL2
In the de Broglie picture, this can be thought of as a standing wave where
1/2 wavelength fits inside the box,
λ
= L.
2
Thus gives
h h
∆p = = ,
λ 2L
corresponding to a minimum kinetic energy,
(∆p)2 h2
∆E > = .
2m 8mL2
The de Broglie wavelength interpretation gives the same minimum energy as
the Schrödinger equation.
To apply the uncertainty principle, the uncertainty ∆x must be evaluated.
This may be taken to be the rms of a flat distribution.
Particle in a Box 97
For
L
∆x = √ ,
2 3
the uncertainty principle gives
√
h̄ h 3
∆p = = .
2∆x 2πL
The minimum allowed kinetic energy
2
(∆p)2 3 h
∆E > = 2 .
2m π 8mL2
In this case, the minimum kinetic energy is greater than required by the un-
certainty principle by about a factor of 3. To meet the uncertainty principle
minimum, a Gaussian distribution is required.
6.5.2 Momentum
The momentum operator is given by
d
p = −ih̄ .
dx
Example 6.9 Calculate the average value of momentum for n = 1, 2, and 3.
(p2 )ave
E= .
2m
Example 6.11 Check that the product of the root-mean-square values of po-
sition and momentum satisfy the uncertainty principle.
0.025
0.020
0.015
ΔE/E
0.010
0.005
Figure 6.5 The fractional energy difference between adjacent levels is indi-
cated vs. n.
Example 6.12 Calculate the ground state energy of a mobile phone confined
to be in a room of width 15 feet.
Example 6.13 Calculate the quantum number n if the iPhone had a kinetic
energy of a thermal photon (1/40 eV).
L L L L
Example 6.14 Integrate ψ2 from 2 − 200 <x< 2 + 200 .
Particle in a Box 101
The n = 2 wave function has a node there and has nearly zero probability of
being found near there.
Example 6.15 Calculate the probability that the particle is found at the cen-
ter of the box within 1% for n = 1 and 2.
0.020
0.015
∫ ψ 2 dx
0.010
0.005
0.000
0 200 400 600 800 1000
n
The probability that the particle is found at the center of the box
Figure 6.6
within 1% is shown for n = 1 to 1000.
The over and undershoot gets progressively smaller with increasing n. From
symmetry of the wave function, we always get the exact answer when n
is a multiple of 100 and the worst case when n is 50 plus a multiple
of 100. How close is the solution to the classical result when n = 106 +
50?
102 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 6.16 Calculate the probability that the particle is found at the cen-
ter of the box within 1% for n = 106 + 50.
Example 6.17 Solve the Schrödinger equation for a particle in a box in 3D.
n1 = n2 = n3 = 1.
The ordering of the energies after that will depend on the relative sizes of
L1 , L2 , and L3 . The energy levels can be degenerate. The greatest degeneracy
will happen when L1 = L2 = L3 . In that case (n1 , n2 , n3 ) being (1,1,2), (1,2,1),
or (2,1,1) all have the same energy.
Particle in a Box 103
d2 ψ 2m(V − E)
= ψ,
dx2 h̄2
where V is the value of the potential outside the box. The principle difference
in the solution, compared to the infinite potential, is that now the wave func-
tion extends outside the box. It must go to 0 at ±∞ instead of at the boundary
of the box.
2.0
1.5
1.0
U
0.5
0.0
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
x/L
Figure 6.7 The potential for a finite square well is constant outside the bound-
ary.
ψ = Aeαx ,
Inside the box, the Schrödinger equation is identical to the infinite potential.
d2 ψ 2mE
2
= − 2 ψ.
dx h̄
Defining s
2mE
k= ,
h̄2
the solution may be written
ψ = Ceikx + De−ikx .
A = C + D,
and at x = L gives
Be−αL = CeikL + De−ikL .
The derivative dψdx must also be continuous in order for the second derivative
to exist. This gives at x = 0,
αA = ikC − ikD,
and at x = L
−αBe−αL = ikCeikL − ikDe−ikL .
The even states are obtained eliminating the constants making use of
ψ(x) = ψ(−x). The conditions at x = 0 give
−α − ik
C= D,
α − ik
Particle in a Box 105
and combining this with the condition at x = L gives the relationship between
α and k to be
−α − ik ikL −α − ik ikL
−α e − αe−ikL = ik e − ike−ikL .
α − ik α − ik
The even functions have kL < π and the wave function for 0 < x < L has the
form L
ψ ∼ cos k x − .
2
Example 6.18 Solve for the relationship between α and k for the even func-
tions.
'!
&
! ! ξ"
ξ
()*ξ )*+
!&
! " # $ %
ξ
√
W−ξ2
Figure 6.8 Plot of tan ξ and ξ . vs. ξ. The solution for the even energies
are the points where the curves meet. In this case there are 2 solutions for the
even energies, corresponding to the ground and 2nd excited states.
108 Guide to Modern Physics
Figure
√ 6.9 shows that there are two solutions for the energy where tan ξ
W−ξ2
and ξ are equal.
&
$
! ! ξ"
"
ξ
)
*+,ξ +,- !
!"
!$
!&
! " # $ % & ' (
ξ
ξ
Figure 6.9 Plot of tan ξ and - √ . vs. ξ. The solution for the odd energies
W−ξ2
are the points where the curves meet. In this case there are 2 solutions for the
odd energies, corresponding to the 1st and 3rd excited states.
80 000
50 000
60 000
ψ (m-12 )
ψ (m-12 )
0
40 000
0
-100 000
-1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10 -1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10
x (m) x (m)
50 000
50 000
ψ (m-12 )
ψ (m-12 )
0 0
-50 000
-50 000
-1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10 -1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10
x (m) x (m)
8 × 109 8 × 109
6 × 109 6 × 109
ψ2 (m-1 )
ψ2 (m-1 )
4 × 109 4 × 109
2 × 109 2 × 109
0 0
-1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10 -1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10
x (m) x (m)
8 × 109
5 × 109
6 × 109
4 × 109
ψ2 (m-1 )
ψ2 (m-1 )
4 × 109 3 × 109
2 × 109
2 × 109
1 × 109
0 0
-1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10 -1. × 10-10 0 1. × 10-10 2. × 10-10 3. × 10-10
x (m) x (m)
Example 6.22 Calculate the normalization constant for the ground state and
110 Guide to Modern Physics
evaluate the probability for the electron to be outside the box. The ground
state energy has been saved as Eg (see Ex. 6.20).
Particle in a Box 111
Since the wave function extends beyond the potential boundary with expo-
nential decay, the ground state energy may be approximated as that due to an
infinite potential of a box of size L + α2 .
Example 6.23 Estimate the ground state energy from the infinite potential
result,
Quantum Harmonic
Oscillator
d2 ψ 2mE 1
2
= − 2 ψ + mω2 x2 ψ.
dx h̄ 2
Many important problems in physics reduce to that of a quantum har-
monic oscillator because the leading term of a potential near its minimum
is quadratic.
where A and α are constants. This is a Gaussian distribution with the parame-
ter α giving the width of the wave function. It is the simplest function whose
second derivative gives the same function back again with a minus sign plus
2.0
1.5
1.0
U
0.5
-3 -2 -1
0.0
0 1 2 3
x ( m ω)
a term which has x2 times the function. The Schrödinger equation may be
written
1 d2 ψ 2mE 1
= − 2 + mω2 x2 .
ψ dx 2
h̄ 2
1 d2 ψ
Example 7.1 Calculate ψ dx2 .
7.1.2 Energy
Knowing the value of α, one can directly substitute ψ into the Schrödinger
equation, verifying the solution.
114 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 7.3 Solve the Schrödinger equation to get the ground state energy.
7.1.3 Normalization
The constant A is determined from the normalization condition,
∞
ψ2 dx = 1.
0
#$'
#$&
)ω # ! ℏ $
#$%
ψ! "
#$!
#$#
!! !" # " !
( " ! ℏ # )ω $
Figure 7.2Wave function squared for the ground state with the classical limits
indicated by vertical lines (left and right). The square of a Gaussian is also a
Gaussian.
Example 7.5 Calculate the probability that the quantum oscillator is found
beyond the classical limit (on either side).
Example 7.6 Calculate the probability that the quantum oscillator is found
within the center half of the classical range.
The absolute limit of the uncertainty ∆x∆p has been achieved because the
wave function squared is a Gaussian distribution.
2
The x2 term of ψ1 ddxψ2 is seen to be identical to that of the ground state, there-
fore, the solution for α is the same. The constant term is 3 times that in the
ground state, giving 3 times the energy.
7.2.2 Energy
Example 7.11 Solve the Schrödinger equation to get the energy of the first
excited state.
7.2.3 Normalization
Example 7.12 Find the normalization constant A.
#$(
#$'
#$&
*ω # ! ℏ $
#$%
ψ! "
#$!
#$"
#$#
!! !" # " !
) " ! ℏ # *ω $
Figure 7.3 The wave function squared for the 1st excited state is shown with
the classical limits indicated by vertical lines (left and right).
√
where Hn ( 2αx) is a Hermite polynomial.
1 d2 ψ
Example 7.18 Get the Hermite polynomial and calculate ψ dx2 for n = 1.
120 Guide to Modern Physics
1 d2 ψ
Example 7.19 Get the Hermite polynomial and calculate ψ dx2 for n = 2.
1 d2 ψ
Example 7.20 Get the Hermite polynomial and calculate ψ dx2 for n = 3.
1 d2 ψ
Example 7.21 Get the Hermite polynomial and calculate ψ dx2 for n = 4.
Quantum Harmonic Oscillator 121
7.3.2 Normalization
Example 7.22 Check the normalization of the first 20 states.
7.3.3 Energy
The oscillator energy is given by
1
E = n + h̄ω
2
for n = 0, 1, 2, etc.
Energy (ℏ ω)
Figure 7.4 The energy levels of the quantum harmonic oscillator are equally
spaced.
Figure 7.5 The wave functions for the first 9 states are shown.
Quantum Harmonic Oscillator 123
Figure 7.6 The wave functions squared for the first 9 states are shown.
E = mgH.
Using T = 2π/ω,
1
P= .
π 2 − x2
xmax
The classical maximum displacement corresponding to energy with quantum
number n is
(2n + 1)mω
xmax = .
h̄
Quantum Harmonic Oscillator 125
!$%!
!$#"
∫ψ% '(
!$#!
!$!"
!$!!
! " #! #"
&
Figure 7.7 The probability for a quantum oscillator to be found beyond the
classical limit is shown vs. n.
Example 7.25 Calculate the classical probability that the particle is in the
center half of the oscillation range.
0.20
0.15
mω / 2 ℏ )
0.10
ψ2 (
0.05
0.00
-10 -5 0 5 10
x ( 2 ℏ / mω )
Figure 7.8 The wave function squared for n=50 is shown together with the
classical probability distribution.
CHAPTER 8
Hydrogen Atom
The Bohr model (5) is highly successful in explaining many features of the
hydrogen atom. The next level of sophistication is to solve the Schrödinger
equation,
h̄2 e2
− ∇2 ψ − ψ = Eψ.
2m 4πε0 r
The solution may be obtained by the technique of separation of variables,
resulting in radial
1 d 2 dR 2m h̄2 `(` + 1)
(r ) + (E − V − )R = 0
r2 dr dr h̄2 2mr2
and angular
1 d dY m2`
(sin θ + [`(` + 1) − 2 ]Y = 0
sin θ dθ dθ sin θ
equations. The integers ` and m` appear as part of the separation process. The
radial solutions are of the form
r
R = f (r)e− na ,
L = h̄2 `(` + 1)
Lz = m` h̄
being its “z component”, the possible value of L along any given direction.
The integer n appears in the solution for allowed energies from the second
derivative in the radial equation.
E0
E= ,
n2
where E0 is the ground state energy.
8.1.1 Solution
The Schrödinger equation is
1 2 2me2 2mE
∇ ψ=− − 2 .
ψ 2
4πε0 h̄ r h̄
Example 8.1 Calculate ψ1 ∇2 ψ.
Comparing, separately, the terms containing r and the constant terms gives a
and E.
Example 8.3 Get the hydrogen atom ground state wave function in terms of
the Bohr radius a.
Example 8.4 Show that this function satisfies the Schrödinger equation and
calculate the energy.
dP 4r2
= 4πr2 |ψ|2 = 3 e−2r/a .
dr a
+(,-(. /'01(1-.-23
)*%
)*$
)*#
)*"
)*!
'!(
! " # $ % &
Figure 8.1 Radial probability for the ground state of hydrogen is plotted in
units of the Bohr radius.
Example 8.7 Calculate the most probable distance for the electron to be
from the proton.
It is seen that the most probable (rmp ), average (rave ), and rms (rrms ) dis-
tances are related by
rmp < rave < rrms .
Figure 8.1 shows that there is a substantial probability of finding the elec-
tron beyond the Bohr radius.
Example 8.10 Calculate probability that the electron is found beyond the
Bohr radius.
part of ψ2 is essentially unity, and it can either be expanded (or just set to
unity and pulled outside the integral).
Example 8.11 Estimate the probability that the electron may be found inside
the proton.
Example 8.12 Calculate the average kinetic energy and give the numerical
value.
Example 8.13 Check the uncertainty principle for the ground state of hydro-
gen.
8.2.1 Wavefunctions
Example 8.14 Get the n=2 wave functions.
134 Guide to Modern Physics
8.2.2 Energies
Example 8.15 Show that the 2s wave function satisfies the Schrödinger
equation and calculate the energy.
Example 8.16 Show that the 2p wave functions satisfy the Schrödinger
equation and calculate the energies.
All 4 states are seen to have the same energy which is the ground state
energy divided by n2 = 4.
+(,-(. /'01(1-.-23
&)!&
&)%*
&)%&
&)&*
'!(
! " # $ %& %! %"
ψ2 = ψ∗ ψ.
+(,-(. /'01(1-.-23
&)!&
&)%*
&)%&
&)&*
'!(
! " # $ %& %! %"
4s 4p 4d 4 f
3s 3p 3d
2s 2p
1s
+&,-&. /%01&1-.-23
#'"#
#'#*
#'#)
#'#(
#'#$
%!&
! "# "! $# $!
Example 8.23 Calculate the radial probability for the (100,99,0) state of hy-
drogen.
The integer in front of a201 is a very long number (2.45... × 10716 ) whose
output has been iconized.
Figure 8.5 shows the radial probability for n = 100 and = 99.
*&+,&- .%/0&0,-,12
"'"""!
"'""")
"'"""(
"'"""$
"'"""#
%!&
!""" #" """ #! """ $" """
Example 8.24 Calculate the expectation value of the dipole vector connect-
ing the 2p and 1s states.
Electric dipole transitions are forbidden when the dipole integral is zero
(corresponding to infinite lifetime). Transitions are also forbidden when the
quantum number l does not change by one unit. This is a result of angular
momentum conservation with the photon carrying one unit of angular mo-
mentum.
Example 8.26 Calculate the dipole factor for the 2s → 1s transition (∆ =
0).
J = L + S.
J = j( j + 1)h̄.
p
g = −2, 1/2 unit of intrinsic angular momentum gives the same magnetic con-
tribution as one unit of orbital angular momentum.
The Bohr magneton is the dipole strength of the electron’s permanent
magnet. It is the projection of the magnetic moment in some direction (S → s)
and defined with g = 2 so that the spin 12 factor exactly cancels, giving
eh̄
µB =
2m
Example 8.28 Get the Bohr magneton.
Example 8.30 Calculate the magnetic field need to make a fractional energy
shift of 10−4 on the 3d5/2 state of hydrogen.
field (B) may be estimated as that at the center of of a tiny current loop with
radius (r). From Ampère’s law,
µ0 (Idl) × r̂ µ0 2πr µ0 I
B= = = ,
4π r2 4π r2 2r
where µ0 is the magnetic constant and I is the current from a proton charge
v
with orbit frequency ( 2πr ),
ev
I= .
2πr
This gives
µ0 ev
B= .
4πr2
Example 8.31 Get the magnetic constant.
In solving for ∆E in Ex. 8.33, the input quantities are user-defined vari-
2
ables (not units) to allow the substitutions µ0 → c21ε and h̄ → 4πεe0 αc . The
0
energy levels are themselves proportional to α2 and the correction to them is
proportional to α4 . This is how α got its name as the fine structure constant.
Note that the correction to spin up (down) is positive (negative) so the energy
difference between the 2p3/2 and 2p1/2 states is 2∆E.
Example 8.34 Calculate the energy difference between the 2p3/2 and 2p1/2
states.
Despite using a simple Bohr orbit for getting the magnetic field, the en-
ergy splitting turns out to be correct. Such semi-classical classical calcula-
tions are often extremely physically intuitive compared to a full calculation
with wave functions.
e p p
Figure 8.6 Visualization of the spin-flip transition in hydrogen. The state with
spins aligned is higher energy than spins opposite.
1.0
0.5
0.0
z
-0.5
-1.0
where analogous to the electron case, gp is the proton g-factor to account for
the charge-to-mass ratio and mp is the proton mass.
The expression for the field can be calculated from
µ0 ẑ
A= µp ∇ × ,
4π r
and
B = ∇ × A.
146 Guide to Modern Physics
The magnetic field from the proton dipole at the location of the electron (Bohr
radius, a) is
µ0
B= µp .
4πa3
Notice that electron spin down is aligned with the magnetic field from the
proton (Fig. 8.7) and spin up is anti-aligned. Therefore, spin down is lower
energy than spin up. The energy difference is
µ0 eh̄
∆E = 2 gp ge
4πa3 mp
Example 8.36 Calculate the difference in energy levels for electron and pro-
ton spins aligned or anti-aligned.
Hydrogen Atom 147
This is the correct order of magnitude for the observed energy difference.
To get a more accurate answer, on needs to use the 1s hydrogen wave func-
tion (8.1.2) and evaluate its square over the magnetic field produced by the
proton. The only contribution is at the origin where the magnetic field is a
delta function. The magnetic field at the proton location is
2
B = µδ(r).
3
The delta function has the property that its value is zero everywhere except
at the origin where it is infinite, such that its integral gives unity. It can be
thought of as a Gaussian with unit area under the curve in the limit where its
width goes to zero.
Example 8.37 Calculate the energy difference using the wave function.
Example 8.38 Calculate the wavelength of the radiation emitted when the
electron flips its spin.
This is the famous 21-cm line from hydrogen that allowed the mapping
of the spiral nature of the Milky Way galaxy due to its ability to penetrate
interstellar dust.
The lifetime of the hyperfine transition can be calculated from the classi-
cal formula for radiated power,
µ2p ω4
P = µ0 .
12πc
The lifetime is
∆E
τ= .
P
148 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 8.40 Calculate the wave function squared at the origin for the 2s1/2
and 2p1/2 states.
There is no shift for the 2p1/2 state. The 2s1/2 state is shifted up by an
amount proportional to
1 (mc2 )3
ψ2s (0)2 = = .
8πa3 8π(4πh̄2 ε0 )3
The expression to leading order is,
2
5 mc 1
∆E = α ln .
6π 8.9α2
Example 8.41 Calculate the Lamb shift and transition frequency.
Example 8.42 Use the measured value of the 2s1/2 Lamb shift to estimate
the Lamb shift frequency for the 3s1/2 state.
The measurement of the Lamb shift and the calculation that followed ush-
ered in the development of quantum electrodynamics which is the foundation
on which the standard model of particle physics was constructed.
The g-factor of the electron has been calculated to 10 decimal places (or-
der α5 ) using the theory of quantum electrodynamics. The leading corrections
are
|g| − 2 α α 2 197 π2 2
= + + − 2π ln 2 + 3ζ(3) ,
2 2π 2π 36 3
where ∞
1 x2
ζ(3) = ≈ 1.20206.
2 0 ex − 1
Hydrogen Atom 151
|g|−2
Example 8.44 Calculate 2 to order α2 .
CHAPTER 9
Statistical Physics
n!p x (1 − p)n−x
fb (x) = .
x!(n − x)!
The normalization condition is
n
fb (x) = 1.
x=0
Example 9.2 Calculate the probability of getting a coin toss in your favor
exactly 5 times out of 10 tosses, assuming the probability of the coin landing
either way is 1/2.
&'!(
&'!&
&'%(
&'%&
&'&(
! " # $ %&
The average is
x = np,
and the rms is
xrms = np(1 − p).
In the limit where n → ∞, the variable x becomes continuous and the bi-
nomial distribution because a Gaussian, provided that the average np is not
too small. In the case where p << 1, one gets a Poisson distribution.
0.025
0.020
0.015
0.010
0.005
Figure 9.2 The binomial distribution is shown for n = 1000 and p = 1/2. The
distribution has become Gaussian.
0.3
0.2
0.1
2 4 6 8 10
Figure 9.3 The binomial distribution is shown for n = 1000 and p = 0.001.
The distribution has become Poisson.
Statistical Physics 155
and
n!
= (n)(n − 1)(n − 2)...(n − x) ≈ n x .
(n − x)!
With both p << 1 and x << n, the binomial distribution reduces to the Poisson
distribution
e−a a x
fP (x) = ,
x!
where a = np, the average.
A major-use case of the Poisson distribution comes about when one wants
to know an upper limit on the average value (a) when a small number of oc-
currences are observed. For example, suppose 0 events are observed. What is
the upper limit on a at 90% confidence level (CL)? The answer is given by
e−a a0
fP (0) = = e−a = 0.1.
0!
Solving for a,
a = − ln 0.05 = 2.3.
One says that a is less than 2.3 at 90% CL.
156 Guide to Modern Physics
$) )))
#) )))
") )))
!) )))
)
! " # $ % & ' (
Figure 9.4 For a histogram of the sum of 10 random numbers between 0 and
1, the average is 5.00 and the rms is 0.913.
Statistical Physics 157
πa2 l ≈ d3 ,
d3
l= .
πa2
Statistical Physics 159
"
Figure 9.5 Schematic to indicate the mean free path (l) and its qualitative
relationship to molecular size (a) and average distance between molecules
(d).
p2 3
= kT.
2m 2
160 Guide to Modern Physics
a << d << l.
"$""!&
"$""!%
"$""!"
")#*$!!
"$"""(
"$"""'
# "!" $
"$"""&
"$"""%
"$""""
!!""" !#"" " #"" !"""
!" ")#*$
It is seen that
1 1 1 1
m v2x = m v2y = m v2z = kT.
2 2 2 2
Each component of the velocity contributes 12 kT to the kinetic energy. This
result is known as the equipartition theorem. Together, the 3 translational
components contribute 32 kT to the kinetic energy in agreement with the def-
inition of temperature (9.2.1).
The most probable speed is found by setting the derivative of the distribution
equal to 0.
Example 9.21 Calculate fraction of particles that are within 10% of the most
probable speed.
!&(
!&'
"#"
# "#
!&%
!
$ !!"
!&#
!&!
! " # $ %
! "
# "#
!
!
Figure 9.7The Maxwell speed distribution is shown in units of the most prob-
able speed.
Example 9.24 Calculate the most probable, average, and rms speeds for ni-
trogen molecules at T = 300 K.
1.0
0.8
0.6
fFD
0.4
0.2
0.0
2.0
1.5
f
1.0
0.5
0.0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
E (kT)
For distributions of electrons or photons, one can get the density of states
using the concept of phase space, which is counting the number of waves that
can fit inside a given volume in the same way as done in 2.1 with λ replaced
by the de Broglie wavelength h/p. The number of states per volume is
3 πp
4 3
ns (p) = g 3 ,
h
where the factor g accounts for the degeneracy of the states due to spin. The
density of states is
p
dns dns d p 4πp2 d( E 2 − (mc2 )2 /c)
ρ(E) = = =g 3 .
dE d p dE h dE
168 Guide to Modern Physics
This is the correct order of magnitude. The Fermi energy for metals is a few
eV. To calculate the Fermi energy more accurately, one may use the known
density of the metal to get N/V.
170 Guide to Modern Physics
Example 9.29 Calculate the Fermi energy of copper which has one conduc-
tion electron per atom.
2π(2m)3/2 √ 1
n(E) = E E/kT .
h3 e −1
The number per volume is
∞ √
N 2π(2m)3/2 1
= E dE.
V h3 0 eE/kT −1
Making a change of variables, x = E/kT ,
√
N 2π(2mkT )3/2 ∞ x
= dx.
0 e −1
V h3 x
Statistical Physics 171
Solving for T,
2/3
h2 (N/V)
T= .
2mk 2π 2.315
which is the temperature at which liquid helium would obey BE statistics, i.e.,
become a superfluid. This process is called a Bose-Einstein condensation.
The answer above is very close to the true value of 2.17 K. To get a more
precise answer, one would need knowledge of a constant A which needs to be
added to the BE probability (compare to the FD case where the Fermi energy
was introduced),
1
fBE = E/kT .
Ae −1
which has been set to 1 as in the case of the thermal distribution where it gave
the correct answer.
The next candidate, after helium, to be a superfluid might be neon, but its
melting point is too high , i.e., it is a solid at the temperature it would need to
reach to condense to a superfluid.
172 Guide to Modern Physics
Astrophysics
p + p → d + e+ + νe .
The neutrino (νe ) is produced to conserve lepton number. The kinetic energy
released is the sum of the mass energies on the left minus that on the right.
the neutrino is essentially massless. This may be followed by
p + d → He3 + γ,
and
He3 + He3 → p + p + α,
The net reaction is
4p → α + 2e+ + 2νe + 3γ.
There are other variances that have the same net reaction. The positron anni-
hilates with an electron to give its mass energy back,
e+ + e− → γ + γ,
Example 10.1 Calculate the amount of energy released in the proton cycle.
The parsec (pc) is a length unit defined by the distance at which the mean
radius of the earth’s orbit subtends an angle of one second of arc.
Ls = 4π(1 au)2 f.
Example 10.6 Calculate the solar neutrino flux at the surface of the earth.
Example 10.9 Calculate the number of rotations the sun has made about the
Milky Way center.
Astrophysics 177
GMg ms ms v2
= .
R2 R
This gives the galactic mass (MG ) in terms of the solar mass (ms ) to be
MG Rv2
= .
ms Gms
Example 10.10 Calculate the galactic mass in terms of the solar mass.
There is a maximum mass to the white dwarf beyond which it will col-
lapse further to form a neutron star or black hole. This maximum mass is
called the Chandrasekhar limit, the order-of-magnitude of which is given by
3/2
1 h̄c
M∼ 2 .
mH G
178 Guide to Modern Physics
A more precise calculation gives about 1.4 solar masses for the maximum
white dwarf mass.
10.5.1 Density
Example 10.13 Estimate the neutron star density in kg/m3 and (short) tons
per tsp.
Assuming constant density which can be written in terms of the neutron star
mass M and radius R (ρ = 4 M 3 ), the binding energy is
3 πR
M
G 2/3 G 3 3GM 2
Eb = 1/3 m dm = 1/3 M 5/3 = .
3 0 3 5 5R
4πρ 4πρ
Example 10.15 Calculate the binding energy of a neutron star with 1.4 solar
masses and a radius of 10 km.
180 Guide to Modern Physics
h̄c3
T= .
8πkGM
Example 10.17 Find the blackbody temperature of a black hole of mass 3
times that of the sun
Astrophysics 181
The radiated power per area is given by the Stefan-Boltzmann law, where the
area comes from the Schwarzschild radius. The equation is
d(Mc2 ) h̄c3 4 c8 h̄4 σ
= −4πσrs2 ( ) =− ,
dt 8πkGM 256π3 k4G2 M 2
or 0 τ
2 c8 h̄4 σ
M dM = − dt,
M0 256π3 k4G2 0
where M0 is the initial mass. The solution for the blackhole lifetime is
256π3 k4G2 M03
τ= .
3c6 h̄4 σ
Example 10.18 Calculate the lifetime of a black hole having a mass of 3 so-
lar masses.
It would take 1031 s for light to travel from a star at distance d. The night
sky would be bright because in any direction out to far enough distance there
would be star in the line of sight. However, the universe is evolving on a time
scale that is much faster than 1031 s and the night sky is dark. In other words
there are no stars to be seen at such a distance.
In 2.2.5 the photon flux from blackbody radiation was calculated. The
photon number density (n) in a cavity (in this case the universe) is given by
dn 1 du
= ,
dE E dE
with
du 4 2πE 3
.
=
dE c h3 c2 (e kT − 1)
E
184 Guide to Modern Physics
E
One integrates over all energies to get n. With the change invariables, x = kT ,
3 ∞
kT x2
n = 8π .
hc 0 ex − 1
The result is
3H02
ρc = .
8πG
Example 10.26 Solve for the critical density.
The Planck time is the time it would take a photon of energy MP c2 to travel
a distance equal to the Planck length.
Mathematica Starter
A.1 CELLS
Mathematica notebooks have 2 types of cells: “text” cells that can only dis-
play what is written and “input” cells that are executable. Input cells are ex-
ecuted by typing (simultaneously)
SHIFT RETURN
which generates the label In[ ]:= with the output going to another input cell
with the label Out[ ]= (but it is still an input cell and can be executed).
A semicolon after a line of code means the code will still execute but the
output will be suppressed. This is a useful feature for debugging code.
When a variable is set, its value may be used in other cells until cleared.
A.2 PALETTES
The menu has several extensive palettes that are useful in formatting the in-
put. For example, there is a Writing Assistant that manages cells and fonts.
This is useful for quick access to Greek letters. There is a Math Assistant
that has templates for operations like division, raising to a power, summa-
tion, integration, etc. This makes it easy to enter something like a summation
of squares into an input cell in a very clean format.
A.3 FUNCTIONS
Mathematica functions always begin with a capital letter. When typing in
a cell, Mathematica will give autocomplete options for existing functions.
Mousing over a function gives extensive documentation for the function’s use
with examples. The function Clear [ ] clears a variable. It produces no output.
x2 −4x+4
Example A.7 Simplify x−2 .
Example A.9 Define the function f (x) = x2 and evaluate it for x = 2.5.
CTRL +
and then typing into the natural language box that appears, for example,
“speed of light”:
Figure A.1 Typing “speed of light” into the natural language box.
Clicking outside the box gives you (hopefully) what you were looking for,
displayed in standard physics notation.
The units to be displayed may be specified. There are 2 ways to get a unit 1)
typing into the natural language box, and 2) using the function Quantity[ ].
Example A.14 Get the numerical value of the speed of light in miles per
second.
The function N[ ] will calculate the numerical value to the specified num-
ber of significant figures. The value has been stored in the variable x and it
remains so until cleared.
Example A.15 Get the numerical value of the previous calculation of the
speed of light to 3 significant figures.
Other useful physical constants are similarly obtained by typing the fol-
lowing into the natural language box: elementary charge, epsilon 0, planck’s
constant, hbar, electron mass, proton mass, boltzmann constant, etc. Physical
constants and their names are given in App. B.
Mathematica is extremely useful as a calculator because it will automat-
ically check the units of a calculation and report errors.
Example A.17 Try to get the speed of light in kg.
A.6 INTEGRATION
Integration is performed with the function Integrate[ ].
Mathematica can convert your input cell into a “standard form” which
looks very much like you would see it typed in a book. This is equivalent code
that executes identically. The computer code has become human readable!
Example A.19 Calculate x3 e−x dx with the input in standard form.
∞
Example A.21 Calculate x3 e−x dx with the input in standard form.
0
∞ x2
Example A.22 Numerically integrate e x −1 dx.
0
A.6.4 Assumptions
Mathematica will not assume that a variable is real.
Example A.23 Calculate the average value of e−λx for 0 < x < ∞.
Assumptions about variables can be made with the global command $As-
sumption. The can also make the code run faster for involved calculations.
Example A.24 Calculate the average value of e−λx for 0 < x < ∞ with the
assumption that λ > 0.
Mathematica Starter 195
Example A.25 Get the 2p, m = 0 wave function of hydrogen with Bohr ra-
dius a.
Solve produces a list. It is useful sometimes to put the results from Solve
into a variable.
Example A.29 Extract the results from Solve above for the solution to x
stored in the variable y.
Physical Constants
Physical constants may be called in two ways. One way is to use the function
Quantity[ ] with the argument equal to the name of the constant. A second
way which makes a much cleaner look to the code is to use the defined sym-
bol obtained from the natural language box as described in A.5. Executing
Quantity[ ] produces the an output identical to that of the natural language
box.
Example B.1 Compare the elementary charge as obtained from the Quan-
tity[ ] function and the natural language box.
The names of the fundamental constants used in this book with their sym-
bols and values are shown in B.2 and derived combinations are shown in
B.1.
Example B.2 Get the numerical value of the electron mass using the natural
language box.
Table B.1 Mathematica names (symbol) and numerical values for physical
constants.
Table B.2 Mathematica names (symbol) and numerical values for derived
constants.
Physical Constants 199
Table B.3 Mathematica names (symbol) and numerical values for particle
masses.
Table B.4 Common names (symbol) and numerical values for sky objects.
Index
201
202 Index
temperature, 32 W boson, 23
thermal neutrons, 53 wave function, 94, 109, 116, 122
thermal radiation, 25 wave function, hydrogen atom, 133
threshold frequency, 51 wave speed, 17
time dilation, 72 wavelength, 17, 20
transitions, 85 weak force, range, 24
transitions in hydrogen, 138 weak interaction, 66
Wein’s law, 40
uncertainty principle, 22, 23, white dwarf, 177
96, 98, 115, 132 work function, 50
UnitConvert, Mathematica, 2
Zeeman effect, 142
velocity distribution, 160