Writing a thesis on code switching can be a daunting task for many students.

This term paper

requires extensive research, critical analysis, and a deep understanding of the concept of code
switching. For those who are not familiar with this term, code switching refers to the practice of
alternating between two or more languages or dialects in a single conversation or sentence.

The complexity of code switching lies in its cultural and linguistic implications. It is a phenomenon
that is prevalent in multilingual societies and is deeply ingrained in the way people communicate.
Therefore, writing a thesis on code switching requires not only a thorough understanding of the
linguistic aspect but also a deep understanding of the cultural context in which it occurs.

Moreover, conducting research on code switching can be challenging as it involves studying different
languages and their cultural backgrounds. This requires a significant amount of time and effort,
which can be overwhelming for students who have other academic and personal commitments.

Another difficulty in writing a thesis on code switching is the lack of available resources. As this is a
relatively new field of study, there is limited literature and research material available. Students may
have to spend hours searching for relevant sources and may still struggle to find enough information
to support their arguments.

Considering the challenges of writing a thesis on code switching, it is understandable why many
students struggle with this task. However, there is a solution to this problem – ⇒ HelpWriting.net
⇔. This website offers professional writing services that can assist students in completing their term
papers on code switching.

At ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔, we have a team of experienced writers who have a deep understanding

of code switching and its complexities. They can conduct thorough research and provide well-
written, original content that meets the academic standards. Our writers are also well-versed in
various formatting styles, ensuring that your thesis is properly structured and referenced.

Furthermore, by ordering your term paper on ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔, you can save yourself from
the stress and time-consuming process of writing a thesis. You can use this time to focus on other
academic or personal commitments, knowing that your thesis is in good hands.

In conclusion, writing a thesis on code switching is undoubtedly a challenging task, but with the help
of ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔, it doesn't have to be. Our professional writing services can provide you
with a well-researched, well-written, and properly formatted term paper that meets all academic
requirements. So why struggle with this task when you can order from ⇒ HelpWriting.net ⇔ and
get the best results?
Extensive code-switching experience did not seem to be necessary for bilingual speakers to know the
grammatical constraints of code switching. Using both codes together makes the conversations more
meaningful, and gives a sense of community to the people who switch codes in the same way.
Specifically, this paper explores the social malapropism and code-switching as trails of colonization
dented by the American and Spanish regimes in the Philippines. In linguistic programs, personal
observation has been stipulated as the main method of data collection. It was noted that some
participants were more than willing to provide not only full but also detailed information on
interview that on the questionnaires. There are several reasons why Saudi female students code-
switch, the main being that these students feel that the English language is easier than Arabic. In
some societies, some speakers of the L variety will even deny that they even speak it (Wardhaugh
1998: 88). Put a flag on it. A busy developer's guide to feature toggles. However, students believe
that code switching is used haphazardly and unconsciously without paying attention to the syntactic
rules that govern each language. However, those who grew in the United States and learned their,
also found themselves code switching but on a very minimal occurrences. For bilinguals, it is a great
way of communicating, as they can use both languages to convey the exact meaning of what they are
thinking. It can be, for example, ’family’, ’employment’, or ’education’ (Swann, in Mesthrie 2005).
Statistical analysis was conducted for the collected data. Personal observation, this was a good tool
because the accent can logical be observed. In the next part of this essay, I will explain the different
theories on code-switching, starting with Ferguson’s theory of diglossia. Expand 129 3 Excerpts
Save General Number and the Semantics and Pragmatics of Indefinite Bare Nouns in Mandarin
Chinese Linguistics Where Semantics meets Pragmatics 2006 90 PDF 1 Excerpt Save First language
attrition: Interdisciplinary perspectives on methodological issues M. Schmid B. Kopke Merel Keijzer
L. It can be concluded that code switching could be used to help gain mastery of subject contents. A
code is a neutral term that is used to talk about language varieties. Moreover, there is no policy
communicated to the teachers and students of Sindh University regarding the code switching.
Warner, E,( 2007), A Black Classroom Culture: Student Code-switching in an Inner City Secondary
School. ProQuest.3rd Ed. New York. Clevedon, Bristol, England: Multilingual Matters, Ltd. Code
Generation. Create linear representation of program Result can be machine code, assembly code,
code for an abstract machine (e.g. the JVM ) threaded code, or anything in between. As the eldest
child in a family of five, B has spent a considerable part of his life in the U.S., the parents portray
diverse ethnic backgrounds, with the mother depicting a Chinese origin and the father English
(Yamamoto 2001, p.37). This means that B comes up in a bilingual household (Nordquist 2014, np).
Put a flag on it. A busy developer's guide to feature toggles. This study illustrates the American
attitudes if wanting to know English-Arabic Code switching as perceived by several Arab Americans
who are currently residing in the United States. However, with the growing acceptance of a usage-
based approach as a basis for linguistic research, exclusively relying on this method has become a
serious limitation, as various questions and issues become important that cannot be studied well with
purely synchronic conversational data. Receiver audience 3 abstract these studies of art and cinema
and contains switched in to a jacobean theatre repertory. This small-scale research looks at code-
switching by students and teachers in an English as a foreign language lesson at Jordan University.
Download Free PDF View PDF JLE: Journal of Literate of English Education Study Program Code
Switching Used by the Students in Efl Classroom Interaction Heriyanti Tahang This research aims at
finding out the types of code-switching used by the students in the English as a foreign language
classroom interaction. The study concludes that CS might be one of the instructional methods that is
motivating and efficient to be used in the field of education.
Even though code-switching is widely accepted as a strategy for bilingual speakers, its application in
foreign language learning remains controversial. Within the world of languages use, code-switching
has often been. The speaker is usually unaware of the switch, until after the fact, and for example,
you have to find a kalo pedi (good guy) and marry him. (English-Greek). The environment of being a
way from their mother’s homeland made them adapt another culture, hence changing how they
talked. The most prominent topics were religion and emotional issues. It was noted that some
participants were more than willing to provide not only full but also detailed information on
interview that on the questionnaires. Other studies were more sociolinguistic in nature and
investigated the functions of code switching. What are the functions of code switching used by
secondary students in English classes at the Modern American School? 2. Cook 1991; 2001
emphasized that teachers have to consider the external and internal goals of language teaching. The
results have revealed that the mainstream of Arab female scholars at Brisbane do code-switch to
english in their everyday discussions and there is no connection linking acquaintance with
interlocutors and code-switching. The sociological perspective later goes on to attempt to use the
answer to those questions to illuminate how language operates as a social process. Students feel
comfortable and confident in using more than one language within the same discourse. In conclusion,
all this types of code switching need to be embraced all (Bassiouney, 2009). Code-switching can
take on several forms including alteration of sentences. First, what is the nature of the grammatical
rules that underlie code switching. However, for one to make good use of them should have a
general clue of them all. Shin, S.Y, Winter, 2010, The Functions of Code-Switching in a Korean
Sunday School. Literature review on the role of mother tongue in learning and teaching engli. The
teacher understood that she was mad at him, but did not know exactly what she was saying.
According to the findings of the study, the researcher recommended that the sample may be
expanded to cover different occupations and ages for the purpose of differentiating various speech
communities (i.e. a group of people sharing a common language or dialect). Weinreich’s book was
Hans Vogt, whose “Language Contacts” (1954) is. However, these said functions and triggering
words are not all being used by the students and not being observed in all classrooms instructions.
Unlocking the Cloud's True Potential: Why Multitenancy Is The Key. The questionnaire was
presented in English and on top of it a cover later that was speaking about the objectives of the
sturdy. In some instances, there are also factors that hinder the students to use code-switching during
classroom oral participation, and these are called as trigger words. What are the functions of code
switching used by secondary students in English classes at the Modern American School? 2. This
language switching might not be the whole sentence, but also can occur in brief phrases or words.
See Full PDF Download PDF See Full PDF Download PDF Related Papers Teacher's and students'
use of code switching in a bilingual context Jessica Dias A great part of research on bilingualism is
focused on code switching. In providing for a social context, code switching allows individuals to
explore their identities and ethnic backgrounds. Code switching refers to the application of two or
more languages between various speakers during a given speech or conversation (Lowi 2005, p. 1).
In this case, the concept stands to be essential in such practices involving bilingual or multilingual
speakers.
Sometimes I will start a sentence in English y termin? in espanol. (Poplack 1980). The samples of the
research consisted of 6 English teachers. Code-mixing is not to be confused with lexical borrowing,
where one does not know a word in one language and must use its equivalent in another language.
Due to bilingualism and multilingualism languages are getting mixture with each other hence
creative a variety of languages. The fluctuation between languages in the form of code -switching is
an extensively practical occurrence in foreign language classrooms. The purposes of this research
were to examine, whether Arab female scholars living in Brisbane code-switch to english in their day
by day discussions. The present study aims to investigate the patterns and functions of code
switching in English language classrooms. The context of the study was University of Sindh,
Jamshoro. Saturday in usa: northwestern polytechnical college thesis include: see a polygraph joint
2016 terminator scc wallpaper. In the non-switch condition in Experiments 1 and 2, Persian-English
bilinguals described pictures using an adjective-noun string from the same language requested.
Download Free PDF View PDF THE USE OF CODE-SWITCHING BY ENGLISH TEACHERS
IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE CLASSROOM (A DESCRIPTIVE STUDY AT SMAN 1 PANGSID)
Nur Maria Ulfah ABSTRACT NUR MARIA ULFAH. 2014. The Use of Code-Switching by English
Teachers in Foreign Language Classroom (A Descriptive Study at SMAN 1 PANGSID). The H
variety is the most prestigious one and is used in relatively formal situations, such as broadcasting
the news on television and radio, delivering sermons at church and speaking in parliament. During
the interview, A considers his native language as English, and a fluent speaker of Spanish. Expand
683 Highly Influential PDF 10 Excerpts Save The Syntax and Semantics of the Tagalog Plural
Marker Mga M. It was tabulated that, 13.9 percent of the Arab Americans illustrated that they
usually code switch with English always. The aims of this study are to find out the types and the
reasons of code-switching that used by Kaera speakers. From the results of the interview, participant
A exemplifies fluency in both languages of upbringing as pertains to English and Spanish. New
theoreticians working within a Critical Discourse Analysis framework are seeing Taglish as a
reaction to the hegemonizing tendencies of Philippine society and modern life. A language is a great
part of a people’s cultural identity: a Norwegian would be insulted if one told him that what he
spoke was merely a dialect of ’Scandinavian’. Based on Mattsson and Burenhult's (1999) functions
of code switching, and Heredia and Altarriba's (2001) discussion about the reasons why bilinguals
code switch, this article aims to find out what functions for code switching are being used in a
bilingual classroom. We need a bridge. linguists. psycho-linguists. Lingualism. Monolingualism even
monolinguals know about other languages Bilingualism Multilingualism. To sum up in this view, code
switching reflects the grammar of the two language because the speaker it shows the knowledge on
how to use two languages in speaking. Ultimately, Personification is the most dominant (43.3%
answered always) function of LCS. Statistical analysis was conducted for the collected data. Other
members of the team and the instructor will be given copies of the code to review at least 48 hours
ahead of time. As much as it is a frequent phenomenon in several parts of the globe, many assert that
code switching is a sign of illiteracy or the lameness of having the ability to control two languages
(Poplack, 1980). Defiance County can also be the identical chance employer. The percentages and
means were calculated for the questionnaires, and the lesson observations were described in words.
Put a flag on it. A busy developer's guide to feature toggles. Even though there seems to be no clear
clarification to emphasize this, an individual gets a difference after the fist type of code switching is
understood. By constance leroy frank guggenheim bonus- the hidden. In kindergarten and primary
school, teachers will use the L variety for storytelling, for example.
There are nearly 3.5 million Arab Americans in the United States that is as per the statistics revealed
by the Arabs American institution. The reality is, though, that all children learn the L variety at home.
The lack of textbooks in Haitian Creole force people in higher education to function in Standard
French. Kwan, HFSP 2010. What is the neural code?. M. Berry. What is the neural code. The number
of male respondents is more than of female respondents due to the imbalanced gender ratio in the
composition of the population. Among the many available instruments of study, the following were
more of appreciative than any other. Semantic Scholar is a free, AI-powered research tool for
scientific literature, based at the Allen Institute for AI. It follows therefore that the increased spread
of English language, the pace of globalization and the media progression has ease the potential of
“code-switching” each day (MacSwan, 2010). Text Register In Translation Text Register In
Translation Key issues in 2nd language acquisition Key issues in 2nd language acquisition Discourse
And Identity Discourse And Identity LANGUAGE CHOICE IN MULTILINGUAL
COMMUNITIES.pptx LANGUAGE CHOICE IN MULTILINGUAL COMMUNITIES.pptx
Language and Gender (Sociolinguistics) Language and Gender (Sociolinguistics) Social class and
language Social class and language Language maintenance and Shift. Just to emphasize more on this,
the difference occurs only in the spellings of the words but the meaning remains the same (Holes,
2009). During conversations, a mix of both languages, mainly Spanish arises as a common habit.
People seem to choose their codes purely out of habit, depending on the situation they are in and
their relationship to the people with which they are speaking. Download Free PDF View PDF See
Full PDF Download PDF Loading Preview Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. Literature review
on the role of mother tongue in learning and teaching engli. Conformity comes with many
advantages and disadvantages. No matter if it is Anzaldua switching between two different
languages or myself acting different around different groups of people; everyone code switches
whether it is subtle, or obvious. Various studies point to this issue, with extensive reviews on the
application and patterns of code switching (Muthusamy 2009, p. 2). The social implications caused
by code switching generate from various factors. Martin’s Press). Richard has offered because the
About.com Self-self-help guide to Grammar Composition since 2006. The population of this research
comprised of Arab American speakers who are American residents. The participants of this study
were 25 Saudi female students chosen randomly who are living in Brisbane. And another factors
gather from the classroom setting are: (a) the students. Despite the fact that they study at an
international school, they switch codes as it is hard to find proper equivalents especially to culturally
loaded terms. Also, students switch codes in order to avoid misunderstanding. It was tabulated that,
13.9 percent of the Arab Americans illustrated that they usually code switch with English always.
Moreover, there is no policy communicated to the teachers and students of Sindh University
regarding the code switching. The results will be interpreted in terms of Hartsuiker and Pickering’s
(2008) model of syntactic representation. LEXICAL BORROWING: Original choice to borrow is
conscious and deliberate Become lexicalized and is used consistently. Defiance County can also be
the identical chance employer. In this paper, results are reported from two pilot studies with a wider
range of research methods, including interviews, acceptability tasks and controlled elicitation. Put a
flag on it. A busy developer's guide to feature toggles. This paper looks at the social motivations for
code switching I terms of the various applications in social, discourse and identity expression
situations.
An Analysis Of Grammatical Errors In EFL College Students Quot Proposal The. Extensive code-
switching experience did not seem to be necessary for bilingual speakers to know the grammatical
constraints of code switching. The example of Polly abusing her teacher in Patois is a case of code-
switching as an marked choice. In simpler terms, is a part that brings about a sole clarification in a
given conversation or dialogue. Bilinguals: where bilingualism is, essay papers of code-switching.
Just in the same way as other communities, some of the communities that are Arabic usually
alternate between Arabic and English systematically. We need a bridge. linguists. psycho-linguists.
Lingualism. Monolingualism even monolinguals know about other languages Bilingualism
Multilingualism. Consequently, the present study aimed at the level of students practicing code-
switching in English teaching classroom at the tertiary level. They felt like they code-switch is more
in the UK comapred to Kuwait. 30 per cent said not while 10 per cent said they do not know. Based
on the analysis, it is argued that codeswitching should not be seen as detrimental to the learning
process, even in the learning of languages. The number of male respondents is more than of female
respondents due to the imbalanced gender ratio in the composition of the population. Those who
migrate in the United States at most usually establish their own communities, which they later
exhibit patterns of language behaviors, which depicts a different and unique resemblance from that
of the native English speakers. The analysis of the data reveals that most English language teachers in
the sample code-switch; students likewise codeswitch in their English language classes. Moreover,
through language and especially through code-switching many bilinguals. Supervised by Syamsiarna
Nappu and Nunung Anugrawati. It follows therefore that the increased spread of English language,
the pace of globalization and the media progression has ease the potential of “code-switching” each
day (MacSwan, 2010). Avoiding Bad Stats and the Benefits of Playing Trivia with Friends:
PancakesC. A clear example of identity expression occurs within particular groups. To browse
Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade
your browser. Upload Read for free FAQ and support Language (EN) Sign in Skip carousel Carousel
Previous Carousel Next What is Scribd. Research on linguistic attitude is difficult because speakers.
The availability of language resources including the knowledge of two or more languages enables
different individuals to depict instances of language alternations. The most prominent topics were
religion and emotional issues. The demographic background comprised of the data such as level of
education, gender, age, current occupation, their originality juts to mention but a few. This translates
to the utilization of code switching as a means for conversation, and as an approach towards the
establishment, maintenance and description of existing boundaries due to ethnicity (Fong 2011, p.
23). Additionally, the idea arises as an important tool for symbolizing relevant features of
background in speakers. The analysis of the data reveals that most English language teachers in the
sample code-switch; students likewise codeswitch in their English language classes. In light of these
findings, pedagogical implications especially in the Philippine language education contexts are given.
Maschler (1998) defines code mixing or a mixed code as “using two languages such that a third, new
code emerges, in which elements from the two languages are incorporated into a structurally
definable pattern” (p.125) In other words, the code mixing hypothesis states that when two code
switched languages constitute the appearance of a third code it has structural characteristics special
to that new code. The results i. Download Free PDF View PDF The Functions of Code Switching
Used by Secondary Students in English Classes shereen abu hait Abstract This study aimed at
investigating The Functions of Code Switching Used by Secondary Students in English Classes. He
believed that the relationship between the signifier and the signified was arbitrary.
In other words, I examined whether there are any cases in which an inherent syntactic feature a
lexical item is inhibited and the syntactic feature that belongs to the other language is used, instead.
Put a flag on it. A busy developer's guide to feature toggles. People who mix codes are usually very
competent, if not fluent, in both codes they are using. It is hypothesized that, for bilingual students,
alternating in foreign language systems, between two languages is considered a beneficial
communication technique and facilitates educators in communicating concepts to their students and
clarifying them. A represents a sequential bilingual due to the learning of the Spanish language in his
adult life. An Exploration Of Perceptions And Intentions Of Code-Switching Among Bilingua.
Introduction The language is the ability to gain and utilize multifaceted system of interaction. The
standardization of the world has been brought forth due to the immense communication as well as
escalating of the process of globalization (Rouchdy, 2004). A Norwegian that speaks the dialect used
in Oslo would find it easier to understand a Swede from Stockholm than a Norwegian who is from
Inner Telemark (South-Eastern Norway). Intermediate Code generator. Front end. output code must
be correct output code must be of high quality code generator should run efficiently. Yet Swedish
and Norwegian are different languages, and the dialects in Oslo and Inner Telemark are varieties of
Norwegian. Download Free PDF View PDF Code-Switching in Language: An Applied Study
Godwin Endurance Download Free PDF View PDF Code-switching in Sociolinguistic Studies:
Review and Analysis K h a l i l E l -S a g h i r asri siwon Download Free PDF View PDF See Full
PDF Download PDF Loading Preview Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. This view of code-
switching and bilingual talk in general is more. Primarily, young children are taught to respect their
elders, and most keep this principle with them throughout their lives. To some extent, the pollution is
found to be unified by a common culture, language, as well as, tradition. A convenient purposive
sampling was used for this study which involves both international and local students in a class.
Recently, various studies point to the discourse function played by the use if code switching in a
number of conversations or speeches. Dumanig, 2008 in his study about analyzing code switching
using conversation analysis, provides a wide-raging analysis on the occurrence of code switching
interactions. This involves the insertion of a tag in one language into an utterance that is otherwise
entirely in the other language. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
Emphasizing more on this, a hyphen has to be used in order to bring about the separation, even
though it may not be realized through utterance but through written form. For those reasons, the
word ’code’ is used instead of ’language’ or ’dialect’. Floor-holding is used when a student cannot
remember a word, and uses their. Myers-Scotton classified the choices people make when deciding
which code to use as either ’marked’ or ’unmarked’. There were two functions of codeswitching
found in this study, they ware translation and communicative function which included motivating,
giving feedback, checking comprehension, joking, and expressing state of mind. Download Free
PDF View PDF Bilingual constructions Reassessing the typology of code-switching Derya Demircay
Studies of language contact have largely been based on analyses of contact effects, such as
codeswitching or grammatical interference, in recordings of spontaneous in-group conversation
among bilinguals. We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Skiba, Richard. Code
Switching as a Countenance of Language Interference. The following research discusses the question
of whether code-switching is simply a sign of language incompetence or rather a functional and
useful component of the communicative process. New theoreticians working within a Critical
Discourse Analysis framework are seeing Taglish as a reaction to the hegemonizing tendencies of
Philippine society and modern life.
In his teenage years, at sixteen, the family moved to Mexico, where he has lived for over forty years.
Download Free PDF View PDF Psycho-Linguistic Code-Switching in Philippine English Classroom
Ariel Ramos Switching of codes has been a practice for many students in classroom context in which
the speakers can easily express their feelings and emotions towards their classmates. He also argues:
”Diglossia reinforces differences, whereas code-switching tends to reduce them.” (Wardhaugh 1998:
103) People switch codes depending on the conversation’s setting and participants. Language has a
social feature, which means that it is used by the members of society. You can download the paper by
clicking the button above. This has instilled fear into many students during lessons, of the fear of
being punished, hence creating a participation gap when it comes to class work. People who mix
codes are usually very competent, if not fluent, in both codes they are using. Second, code-switching
enables you to mark switching from informal situations (using native languages ) to formal situations
(using second language ). The number of male respondents is more than of female respondents due to
the imbalanced gender ratio in the composition of the population. Since the study involved human
beings in a different geographical location, it was better to get and instrument of the study that could
give out a clear illustration of the above reaction. It is not only used in the market but, homes,
courtrooms, hospitals and educational institutes of Pakistan are also under the influence of English
language. Mardijono M.P 64250 This study is aimed to analyze the types of code-switching used by
the teacher and under what circumstances the switching occur to identify its function. Upload Read
for free FAQ and support Language (EN) Sign in Skip carousel Carousel Previous Carousel Next
What is Scribd. As Wardhaugh states: ”the H variety is ’taught’, whereas the L variety is learned”
(Wardhaugh 1998: 89). In some societies, some speakers of the L variety will even deny that they
even speak it (Wardhaugh 1998: 88). In Holmes (2001: 38), there is one example of metaphorical
code-switching that illustrates this very well. Code-switching can be used in a variety of degrees,
whether it be used at. Year two semester two for students pursuing Bachelor of Arts with Education
in Kibogora Polytechnic took part in this study. An Analysis Of Grammatical Errors In EFL College
Students Quot Proposal The. Introduction The language is the ability to gain and utilize multifaceted
system of interaction. On the other hand, the conversation that follows takes another new dimension
of communication (Duszak, 2002). The following table gives out a clear demographic characteristic.
It is used to provide an option where the speaker can be able to express in his best way of saying
something. Download Free PDF View PDF THE USE OF CODE-SWITCHING BY ENGLISH
TEACHERS IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE CLASSROOM (A DESCRIPTIVE STUDY AT SMAN
1 PANGSID) Nur Maria Ulfah ABSTRACT NUR MARIA ULFAH. 2014. The Use of Code-
Switching by English Teachers in Foreign Language Classroom (A Descriptive Study at SMAN 1
PANGSID). In the non-switch condition in Experiments 1 and 2, Persian-English bilinguals
described pictures using an adjective-noun string from the same language requested. Code: BETA.
Code: MINI BETA. Code: BETALITE. Code: MIRO 1. Code: MIRO 3. Code: FLEXICAT. Code:
OPEN DOT 12. Code: OPEN DOT 12RGB PIXEL. Ludmila Isurin, D. W. (2009). Multidisciplinary
Approaches to Code Switching. Problems in the Analysis of Some Commonly Occurring Forms in
Philippine Languages L. A. Reid Linguistics 2002 TLDR Analysis of common noun phrases in
Philippine languages shows that historical evidence showing that the forms in question were
originally demonstrative nouns supports their synchronic analysis as nouns. Dewi Rusliyani
Download Free PDF View PDF RELATED TOPICS Discourse Analysis Education Sociolinguistics
Critical Discourse Analysis Bilingualism Asia pacific education Socioeconomic Status See Full PDF
Download PDF About Press Blog People Papers Topics Job Board We're Hiring. Although there
were several limitations, the truth is that the goal was achieved, since the participants showed a clear.