Advancing Banana and Plantain R&D in Asia and The Pacific - Vol. 11
Advancing Banana and Plantain R&D in Asia and The Pacific - Vol. 11
Advancing Banana and Plantain R&D in Asia and The Pacific - Vol. 11
Citation: Molina A.B., J.E. Eusebio V.N. Roa, I. Van den Bergh and M.A.G. Maghuyop, editors.
2003. Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the Pacific - Vol. 11. Proceedings of the
1st BAPNET Steering Committee meeting held in Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines, 7-10 October
2002. International Network for the Improvement of Banana and Plantain - Asia Pacific, Los Baños,
Laguna, Philippines.
INIBAP ISSN 1729-0805
© International Plant Genetic Resources Institute 2003.
IPGRI Headquarters INIBAP INIBAP-AP
Via dei Tre Denari 472/a Parc Scientifique Agropolis II c/o IRRI, GS Khush Hall
00057 Maccarese 34397 Montpellier Cedex 5 Los Baños, Laguna 4031
Italy France Philippines
Advancing banana and
plantain R&D in Asia
and the Pacific - Vol. 11
Acknowledg
Acknowledgement
knowledgement
Editorial Note
Some references have been submitted without complete publishing data. They
may thus lack the full names of journals and/or the place of publication and
the publisher. Should readers have difficulty in identifying particular references,
staff at INIBAP-AP will be glad to assist.
iii
Contents
Workshop recommendations 3
Opening ceremonies
Welcome remarks
Dr Patricio S. Faylon 9
Sec Estrella F. Alabastro 11
Mr Nicomedes P. Eleazar 15
Dr Agustin B. Molina 17
Country Reports
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia
Mr Robert Williams 21
The banana industry status in Bangladesh
Dr Md. Shahidul Islam 63
An overview of the production and banana research in Cambodia
Dr Men Sarom 71
Production and banana R&D in China
Dr Xu Linbing 77
Status of banana industry in India
Dr M.M. Mustaffa 81
Current status of banana R&D in Indonesia
Dr Ika Djatnika 93
Banana industry and R&D in Malaysia
Dr Nik Mohd. Masdek Nik Hassan 99
The Philippine banana industry: Status and prospects
Dr Jocelyn E. Eusebio 107
Status of banana R&D, production and consumption in PNG
Mrs Rosa N. Kambuou 125
Present status of banana cultivation in Sri Lanka
Dr Chandrasiri Kudagamage 139
Banana in Thailand
Dr Prasert Anupunt 149
Update on banana R&D in Vietnam
Dr Ho Huu Nhi 155
Banana R&D in the Pacific
Mr Tom Osborn 165
Somaclonal variation approach to breeding Cavendish banana
for resistance to fusarium wilt race 4
Dr Shin-Chuan Hwang 173
iv
Workshop recommendations
After the presentations of country reports by each member
representatives, a workshop was conducted. This workshop provided
the venue to exchange opinions and formulate specific regional
programs and activities of BAPNET based on the needs and priorities
of the national agricultural research systems of each member country.
Extension
• Promote high-yielding banana varieties among smallholders.
• Disseminate postharvest technologies for banana.
• Disseminate technologies on processing of banana for various uses.
W
Opening Ceremonies
Opening session 9
Welcome remarks
Patricio S
S.. Faylon*
Fa
Our friends and colleagues from the Asia Pacific region, ladies and
gentlemen, good morning.
On behalf of PCARRD and the entire Philippine National Agriculture
and Resources Research and Development System (NARRDS), and as
current Chair of the Banana Asia Pacific Network (BAPNET), it is a
privilege for me to welcome all of you to the Philippines. I hope you all
had a pleasant travel coming to this country, and may your stay here
be both enjoyable and rewarding.
I am confident that our meeting today will be as memorable and
productive as last year’s meeting, although I hope that this time, we
will be able to come up with specific programs and activities, in
consideration of the needs and priorities of all the partner NARS, on
banana and plantain R&D.
At this point, allow me to extend to you the apologies of our Science
Secretary Estrella F. Alabastro, for her inability to join us in today’s
important gathering. While she had confirmed her attendance to this
meeting, she had to beg off due to a very crucial matter she has to
attend to, which is the budget deliberation called upon by our legislative
body, aimed at rationalizing government investment to all its agencies/
organizations. In fact, I was also required to attend the said budget
deliberation, but I had to decline and justify the need for me to be here
with you today, this being an equally important activity for us in the
R&D sector.
I would like to inform you, though, that Secretary Alabastro has
promised to join us all during the closing ceremonies – so that she will
have a chance to meet all the participants of this meeting. In view of
her absence, allow me then to read to you her welcome message.
Message
Nicomedes Eleazar*
Message
Agustin B
B.. Molina*
Country Repor
Re ts
ports
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 21
General pr
General oduction issues
production
Banana production in Australia over the past 18 months has been
through a period of very difficult times. In north Queensland, the major
production area for Cavendish, an outbreak of black sigatoka occurred
in April 2001. This is the first occurrence of black sigatoka in the
production area. An intense controlled management program of zero
disease tolerance was implemented, and no detections have been made
since August 2001. A detailed report on the outbreak and process and
progress is presented in Annex 1.
In Northern Territory, no further outbreaks of Fusarium oxysporum f.sp.
cubense (Foc) tropical race 4 have been detected, although there are
now only two major growers in the area. The fusarium-testing site is
operating very well in screening cultivars for tolerance.
Drought conditions in the southern production areas of Queensland
and northern New South Wales, together with the presence of Banana
Bunchy Top Virus and Foc race 1 and 4 is restricting the expansion of
Lady Finger in this area.
Current Australian production is just over 22 million cartons (297 000
tonnes) for approximately 14 000 hectares. Consumption has continued
to increase to just over 15 kilograms/head/year.
The majority of production is AAA Cavendish types (Williams, Mons
Mari and Grande Naine) grown in tropical areas north of the Tropic of
Capricorn, whilst AAB Pome – Lady Finger are grown in southern or
higher altitude regions. Small quantities of ABB Ducasse (Pisang Awak)
and AAAB Goldfinger are providing a demand in niche markets. Some
potential exists for the development of specialist markets for organically
grown or eco-labelled bananas together with new varieties for both
dessert and cooking types.
The major cultivars grown are: Cavendish (90%), Lady Finger (7%),
Goldfinger (2%) and other varieties (1%).
Annex 1
Background
− Identification confirmed;
• Extensive surveys in the April-June period defined the outbreak to the Tully
area.
26 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
• In the 12-week period, 2773 samples of diseased leaf tissue were sent to
the laboratory for identification.
• Sixteen were positive for BS (Mycosphaerella fijiensis); 11 samples were
from commercial farms and 5 from unmanaged plants (feral, residents,
regrowth areas).
• Of the samples, 2432 were positive for yellow sigatoka (YS) (Mycosphaerella
musicola).
• Other diseases were identified in 1835 samples.
Biology of Mycosphaerella fijiensis
• Survey data suggested the outbreak was relatively recent (16 positive BS
samples from 2773 examined, few with mature lesions)
• Program was based on deleafing/removal of all diseased tissue from the
plants in the TBPA, an intense spray program to prevent new infections and
the destruction of all unmanaged plants in the area.
• Under an inspectors’ approval, the following regulations were introduced:
o All properties had to achieve and maintain a zero visible disease level
o Where an inspector detected disease, a Direction Section 11 was issued
which prevented the movement of fruit until all visible disease was
removed.
o The program was divided into four stages:
Annex 2
Introduction
This document summarises most of the RD&E projects currently being conducted
within Australia.
Presented for each project is an overview of the project objectives and summary
of the progress to date.
Project title: Plant protection extension in the Queensland banana
industry
Project duration: 1 July 1999 - 30 June 2002
Continued productivity and maintenance of fruit quality are major issues for banana
producers in Queensland. Appropriate management of pests and diseases is a
major factor in meeting the market requirements for quality and the productivity
requirements for profitability. This project aims to facilitate the development of
better pest and disease management practices by Queensland banana growers
by providing better communication and information transfer. This can be achieved
with the following activities:
* Continued production and distribution of ‘Bananatopics’ newsletter for growers;
* Assistance for the production of the annual grower publication, ‘Banana
Protection’;
* An industry awareness program for exotic and endemic quarantine threats;
* Industry activities aimed at extending the results of pest and disease research;
* Industry extension of regulatory requirements for growers.
Production of the newsletter, ‘Bananatopics’, and industry extension for pest
and disease management have been identified as high priorities by the Banana
Sectional Group Committee of the QFVG.
This project aims to continue industry extension work started by the project
FR96022. This proposal will also link with the existing and proposed research
projects on banana pests and diseases affecting quality and productivity:
* Erwinia corm rot
* Burrowing nematode control
* Banana streak virus
* Banana rust thrips
* Yellow sigatoka (YS) resistance monitoring.
Summary of milestones
Integrated nematode management
• Significant progress has been made in the development and implementation
of IPM practices for burrowing nematode, especially the use of non-host
32 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
fallow crops – 200 hectares of specific non-host fallows planted in north
Queensland in 2001.
• The use of ‘Callide’ Rhodes grass in fallows has presented the opportunity
for commercial seed harvesting, and a seminar was held with a commercial
seed merchant for interested growers on the seed industry and its
requirements. This has led to technical staff from the seed merchant assisting
growers in the Tully and Innisfail district with production advice. Seed
harvesting is beginning in June 2002.
• Training workshops on IPM for burrowing nematode are being conducted in
the NQ production regions. From this workshop, publications are being
prepared for ‘Bananatopics’ and ‘Australian Bananas’.
IPM for banana bunch pests
• The project officer’s involvement with Crop Care Australia and IBS in Innisfail
have resulted in the development of a mechanical application device for the
SusCon® ribbon. Consequently, Crop Care has proceeded with registration
of the product, and it is expected to be available to producers by July 2002.
The project officer has been involved in field demonstrations for producers
with Crop Care.
• Results from research trials on biopesticides and ‘new chemistry’ insecticides
for bunch pest management have been published in ‘Bananatopics’.
Leaf disease management
• The project officer was involved in presenting information at 12 regional YS
management workshops in April and May in NQ production area.
• The project officer works with chemical companies and regional local
agribusiness outlets to update banana fungicide resistance strategy to include
new strobilurin fungicides.
Next steps
• Continue industry-wide extension training in integrated nematode
management as required for Queensland production regions. Articles for
industry publications are being published from this work.
• Continue to monitor performance of fallow crop trial sites to determine period
between replanting and nematode population reaching damaging levels.
• Actively collaborate with project leader FR99011 to update and produce grower
manual on integrated management of burrowing nematode.
• Assist in the communication and extension of results from research project
on IPM for bunch pests.
• Continue to conduct grower and agribusiness discussion groups in NQ
production region. It is intended to use these groups to help evaluate project
actions and outcomes.
Communication/Extension activities
• The full colour banana quarantine threats information sheets have been posted
to all registered banana producers in Queensland to complement previous
activities in Tully and Innisfail.
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 33
Progress to date
• Market throughput analyses completed
36 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
• Price/Quality analyses in markets completed
• Consumer survey completed
• Retailer survey completed
• Australian size grade standards for Lady Finger bananas developed
• Product description language for Lady Finger fruit developed
• Guidelines for Lady Finger carton packing developed
• Maturity and harvesting procedures for Lady Finger bananas developed
• Newsletters sent to all Queensland Lady Finger growers
• Subtropical Agrilink kit draft completed
• Sustainable best practices growing guide developed for Lady Finger
growers by NSW Agriculture in conjunction with QDPI
• Coff’s Harbour forum addressed on results of Lady Finger project to date
Project title: Diagnosis of banana pathogens
infected host tissue as well as in pure culture. It will also identify genetic variability
within a VCG. DNA fingerprint analysis of Australian isolates has already identified
seven different genotypes amongst the four races of the pathogen (33 genotypes
of Foc have been identified worldwide). The identification of Foc in Australian
plantations will be continued with VCG analysis and the development of a PCR-
based detection system. To improve regulation of quarantine restrictions in
Australia and to prevent the introduction of more strains from overseas, we will
develop a DNA-based identification system to accurately characterise all strains
that occur in Australia and generate a DNA fingerprint database. We will also
develop a system to detect the pathogen directly from plant tissue.
Four nematodes are precluded from approved planting material and these are
detected in routine testing of root samples. Radopholus similis (burrowing
nematode) is a major pest of Queensland’s banana industry. Recent studies
have revealed the presence of an undescribed species of Radopholus in Northern
Territory. This and populations of R. similis from Queensland vary in their ability
to reproduce on a range of cultivars. If new ‘resistant’ cultivars are introduced to
manage burrowing nematode, variation between nematode populations is likely
to result in ‘failure’ of some cultivars. This project will collect and culture
populations from throughout Queensland and test them for their ability to reproduce
on representative range cultivars. This will determine the distribution of different
pathotypes and the reaction of cultivars.
This project will ensure implementation of practical and reliable quarantine
schemes.
Progress to date
Host range of BSV isolates determined
As reported in June 2001, mealybug inoculation was found to be an inefficient
technique for screening large numbers of banana genotypes for susceptibility to
BSV. A new approach was therefore adopted to determine the natural host
range of the different strains of BSV. The DPI plant virology group has collected
206 specimens of banana streak disease from more than 50 different banana
genotypes and 17 countries. This collection was screened using specific PCR
assays for six strains of BSV, namely BSV-OL, BSV-Mys, BSV-GF, BSV-Cav,
BSV-IM and BSV-Lac.
Positive PCR reactions were obtained with 106 of the diseased specimens. Failure
to detect BSV in the remaining specimens may reflect deterioration during storage,
the existence of other BSV strains in addition to those tested and/or
misidentification of symptoms. In Australia, all strains, except BSV-Lac, were
found. BSV-Lac is very uncommon, and only detected in a single specimen from
Africa. BSV-OL was the most common strain, being detected in exactly 50% of
the specimens and in many different banana genotypes, viz. Musa AA, AAA,
AAB, AAAB and ABB groups. BSV-OL is known to arise by activation of viral
sequences that are integrated into the B genome of banana. The fact that BSV-
OL was detected in a Cavendish banana (Musa AAA group) at Weipa, north
38 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
QLD, suggests that there is natural transmission of this virus by mealybugs.
After BSV-OL, BSV-GF was the next most commonly detected strain, being
detected in 25 specimens. All cv. Mysore plants were infected with BSV-Mys,
and this strain was very uncommon outside this cultivar. BSV-Mys was detected
in a cv. Lady Finger plant from Flaxton, NSW, and a Cavendish plant from Kiama,
QLD, but in both cases, links could be made with a cv. Mysore plant growing
nearby. BSV-Cav was found in Cavendish plants from Daradgee, Babinda and
Innisfail in north QLD. These plants had a common propagation history. Outside
this group of plants, BSV-Cav was very rare, only being found in one Dwarf
Cavendish plant from Bowen, QLD. BSV-IM was also extremely rare; in Australia,
this strain was detected in new IRFA hybrids (Musa AAB group) originating from
the CIRAD (France) breeding program, a Pisang Raja (Musa AAB group) plant
from north QLD and a single Pisang Awak (Musa ABB group) plant from a
germplasm collection at Alstonville, NSW.
Specificity and sensitivity of PCR diagnostic determined for detecting Foc in
planting material
The specificity of the PCR primers for each of the Australian races and VCGs of
Foc has been established by screening them against other VCGs and genotypes
of Foc in vitro. Diagnostic PCR primers have been designed that are specific for
the race 1 strains (VCGs 0124, 0125, 01220), race 2 strains (VCG 0124 and
0128), subtropical race 4 strains (VCGs 0120, 0129, 01211) and the tropical race
4 strain (VCG 01213) of Foc.
Procedures for DNA extraction and PCR amplification directly from infected plant
material and infested soil have been investigated and optimised. Several different
DNA extraction protocols (both published methods and commercially available
kits) were tested for plant material and soil, and a method was selected that
gives a good DNA yield and minimal inhibition of PCR amplification.
The protocols for DNA fingerprinting analysis and the PCR diagnostic test for the
tropical race 4 strain of Foc were collated into a training manual for a workshop
coordinated by the CRC for Tropical Plant Protection. The workshop was held at
the Northern Territory Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries (NT DPIF)
Plant Pathology Department in Darwin, during November 2001. Staff from the
NTDPI, WA Agriculture, AQIS and NAQS were trained in fusarium wilt diagnostics
and the DNA diagnostic test for tropical race 4 of Foc was implemented in the
Darwin laboratory, where several outbreaks caused by this strain of Foc have
already occurred.
Nematology section of project
The project has finished and the final report is being written. Eight isolates of
Radopholus spp. from banana crops from throughout the major banana areas of
Australia were collected (Darwin, Tully, Bartle Frere, Cudgen Tallebudgera,
Pimpama, Red Hill and Crossmaglen). The isolates have been established on
carrot cultures at Indooroopilly Research Centre. The isolates were tested on a
range of tissue cultured banana cultivars (Williams, Pisang Jari Buaya (PJB),
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 39
SH-3142, Goldfinger and Lady Finger) for their ability to reproduce and tolerate
nematodes.
The ability of the nematodes to reproduce on the banana cultivars was significantly
different between the different nematode isolates. The isolates of R. similis from
Tully and Pimpama were able to multiply equally well on all cultivars including
PJB. PJB is reported to have some resistance to R. similis and has been used in
international breeding projects to develop nematode resistant lines. All other
nematode isolates had lower reproduction on PJB relative to Williams. Williams
was used as the susceptible standard throughout the trial. The resistance to
multiplication on banana cultivars, relative Williams, depended on which isolate
of R. similis was used. While PJB was resistant to most nematode isolates, SH-
3142, Lady Finger and Goldfinger also demonstrated some resistance depending
on the isolates of R. similis. Similar results were obtained when the trial was
repeated.
The R. similis isolate from Tully was also found to be more pathogenic than all
other nematode isolates, except the isolate from Pimpama. The pathogenicity
was determined by the nematodes’ ability to reduce the root weight of banana
plants. Pathogenicity of the nematode isolate appears to be correlated with the
nematodes’ ability to multiply in the roots of the host plant. Again, similar results
were obtained when the trial was repeated.
The results suggest that resistance that is being developed in banana varieties
could be overcome by some isolates of R. similis. This is a strong indication of
the presence of pathotypes of R. similis in the Australian banana industry. The
presence of pathotypes would need to be confirmed by RAPD analysis of the
eight isolates of burrowing nematode. If banana cultivar resistance is to be used
to reduce the impact R. similis has on banana production, sources of resistance,
other than PJB need to be investigated.
Project title: Banana Fungicide Resistance
Project duration: 1 July 1999 - 30 June 2002
Synopsis of project
Loss of sensitivity to the demethylase inhibitor (DMI) and benzimidazole fungicide
groups in Mycosphaerella fijiensis (black sigatoka) is widespread in Central
America and has resulted in an increase in the number of fungicide applications
applied from about 20-25 to 40-45 per season. A loss in sensitivity was detected
in Mycosphaerella musicola in the Innisfail banana-growing area in 1996. An
eight-fold decrease in sensitivity was demonstrated using a technique developed
using conidia. The sensitivity appeared to return to normal over a 6- to 8-month
period in the absence of the DMI fungicides. In Central America, where a shift
was reported over many years, the sensitivity of the population did not increase
or return in the absence of the fungicides. Anti-resistance strategies were
developed for all fungicides in consultation with the banana industry and chemical
companies.
40 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
In this project the sensitivity of yellow sigatoka populations in north Queensland
will be determined for the DMI fungicides presently used in bananas to identify
any shift in sensitivity before major problems develop as has occurred in Central
America. The stability/persistence of any less sensitive populations detected
will be monitored over time to enable the anti-resistance strategies to be
implemented to reduce the effect of any loss in sensitivity. The validity of the
test developed using conidia will be compared to that used for M. fijiensis in
Central America which uses ascospores. Baseline sensitivity data will be
generated for all systemic fungicides presently registered and those in the pipeline
to be registered for use on bananas in Queensland.
Progress to date
Baseline sensitivity data were established for the compounds benomyl,
propiconazole and tebuconazole. This was achieved by collecting wild-type
isolates from unsprayed banana plants at least 25 kilometers away from known
commercial blocks of bananas to ensure isolates had not been in contact with
any spray drift or originated from ascospores from sprayed areas. Baseline data
on percent germination were gathered tor trifloxystrobin, however, further wild-
type isolates need to be assessed to determine germtube elongation, as recently
shown in Central America, to be an indicator of small shifts in sensitivity. Base
line EC50 (effective concentration required to reduce growth/germination by 50%)
figures for each of the fungicides are as follows: benomyl – 0.045 mg/ml,
propiconazole – 0.01 mg/ml and tebuconazole – 0.016 mg/ml.
Since 1999, the north Queensland banana industry has been monitored for
resistance or loss of sensitivity to the above-mentioned fungicides. In the 1999-
2000 season, approximately 70% of samples tested for “resistance” to benomyl
registered moderate to serious shifts (>8 fold increase compared to the baseline
EC50). As this high level of resistance was detected throughout the industry, no
further testing of samples against benomyl was conducted.
Loss of sensitivity to the fungicides propiconazole and tebuconazole was also
detected throughout the north Queensland banana industry. Between 1999-2002,
greater than 90% of samples registered wither a nil or minor shift in sensitivity to
propiconazole leaving <10% of samples in the moderate to serious category (> 8
fold increase in the baseline EC50). Results of samples assessed for loss of
sensitivity to tebuconazole were the reverse with approximately 78% of samples
registering a moderate to serious shift and the remaining 22% of samples in the
nil or minor shift category.
Data suggest “resistance” to propiconazole implies 100% cross-resistance to
tebuconazole. The reverse, however, is not as high.
A selection of farms that registered a moderate to serious shift in sensitivity to
either propiconazole or tebuconazole were monitored on a regular basis to observe
if the sensitivity of the M. musicola population returned to normal in the absence
of the fungicide. In the majority of cases where a decrease in sensitivity had
occurred to propiconazole, the population returned to a normal level of sensitivity.
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 41
However, where the sample population was tested against tebuconazole, results
were not as definitive and monthly data were erratic.
Spray history where possible was obtained for the previous 12- to 18-month
period to determine if any practices could have contributed to the loss of
sensitivity. In the majority of cases where a loss in sensitivity was detected, the
anti-resistance strategy was not followed. The following appeared to contribute
to a loss of sensitivity:
• Prolonged use of DMIs (>2 back to back);
• Overuse of DMI fungicides (>6 per season);
• Applications of DMIs made during the ‘DMI free period’ (July to October);
• Applications of DMI fungicides made to severely diseased tissue.
Project title: Strategies for management of fusarium wilt of banana
Project duration: 1 July 1999 - 30 June 2002
Summary
Disease pressures continue to limit banana production in Australia. Fusarium
wilt is a disease, which is widespread in many of the banana producing regions
of Australia. Fusarium wilt of banana (Panama disease) is caused by a soil-
inhabiting fungus, Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cubense (Foc), for which there is
no commercially viable means of chemical control. Throughout the world, long-
term control of this disease is largely dependent on genetic host resistance.
Through this project, banana varieties including dessert hybrids and breeding
diploids from the four largest international banana breeding programs will be
evaluated for their reaction to the two major strains of Foc present in Australia
(race 1 and sub-tropical race 4) at separate field evaluation sites. Agronomic
data will also be taken from surviving varieties, including the postharvest evaluation
of fruit. It should be noted that disease evaluation trials are different to commercial
variety evaluation trials, the latter not being within the scope of this project.
The incidence of fusarium wilt in tissue culture-derived plants has been shown by
DPI researchers to be higher than that in plants derived from traditional planting
material (bits or suckers). It is thought that the sterile environment in which
tissue-cultured plants are raised may preclude useful or beneficial microorganisms
from establishing in the young tissue culture plantlets, delaying the onset of
naturally occurring defenses to soil borne diseases. In a complementary research
approach to the field evaluation of banana germplasm, the role of non-pathogenic,
endophytic strains of Foc will be investigated for their ability to enhance resistance
to Foc in tissue-cultured banana plants. Studies commenced in FR96018 identified
some non-pathogenic strains of Foc that afforded levels of protection to tissue-
cultured banana plantlets against Foc in small-scale trials. These and new strains
were included in this investigation. This research also complements that of
FR98006, investigating the potential of mycorrhizal fungi and rhizobacteria for
developing healthier banana roots in relation to banana nutrition and resistance
to Foc and nematodes. This project also directly relates to FR99037 “Diagnosis
42 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
of Banana Pathogens”, in which the host range, geographical distribution and
diversity of the different strains or Vegetative Compatibility Groups (VCGs) of the
fusarium wilt pathogen is being monitored. Knowledge of the VCGs of Foc in
Australia is important for the selection of resistant cultivars for particular locations,
depending on the strains present. The known geographical distribution of these
VCGs has also enabled the implementation of meaningful quarantine zones to
limit the spread of this pathogen by the movement of rhizomes and infested soil.
The characterisation of all new outbreaks of Foc enabled the early detection of
exotic strains such as tropical race 4 in Darwin, NT.
In addition to the evaluation of microorganisms for improving resistance of banana
to Foc, other agents such as plant activators were investigated. For example,
BION® is a plant activator that is known to have a systemic acquired resistance
(SAR) effect, and has reduced the incidence of fusarium wilt in other crops.
Field-trial evaluation of Musa germplasm for resistance to Foc is time-consuming
and expensive. The development of a reliable small plant bioassay will be
investigated to enable a more rapid and economical evaluation for new varieties,
breeding lines and disease control measures under glasshouse conditions. This
test would not replace field-trial evaluation; however, it would be a tool by which
the most promising varieties could be selected for evaluation under field conditions.
Progress to date
Field evaluation of banana varieties for resistance to races 1 and 4 of Foc
Resistance evaluation at fusarium wilt-infested field sites is ascertaining the
reaction of new varieties to Australian strains of fusarium wilt caused by the
fungus Foc. Varieties produced by the world banana breeding programs (FHIA in
Honduras; EMBRAPA-CNPMF in Brazil, IITA in Nigeria and CIRAD-FHLOR in
Guadeloupe) have been imported by DPI for evaluation.
Evaluation against Foc race 1 (VCG 0125)
Varieties resistant to Foc race 1 were FHIA-01 (Goldfinger), FHIA-18 (Bananza),
FHIA-25, SH-3640-10 (known as Highnoon in South Africa) – conflicting results,
TMBx 5295-1 (a Laknau hybrid known internationally as Bita 3).
Varieties susceptible to Foc race 1 were FHIA -02 (known as Mona Lisa in
South America), SH-3641 and Lady Finger.
Full term internal ratings for the CIRAD-FHLOR varieties (IRFA -901, -910 and -
914) could not be conducted as the plants were removed and destroyed due to
development of banana streak virus (BSV) in these varieties after planting.
Evaluation against Foc race 4 (VCG 0120)
Varieties resistant to Foc race 4 were FHIA-01, FHIA-18, SH-3640-10, SH-3656,
IRFA -909, IRFA -914 and TMBx 5295.
Varieties susceptible to Foc race 4 were FHIA -02, FHIA-03, FHIA-17, FHIA-23,
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 43
natural botanicals for banana bunch pest control. Other control practices to reduce
the cost of pest management will also be investigated. This project has the
potential to manage insecticide resistance by reducing the dependence on
organophosphates for bunch pest management and identifying safer insecticides
with new modes of action that are better suited to the development of IPM in
bananas. This is in line with the industry’s aim to develop pest management
practices which are sustainable and safe to human health and the environment.
Progress to date
A new technique for the mass production of banana scab moth – The development
of a successful insect-culturing technique has been achieved for the first time for
banana scab moth and has been in operation now for 21 months. This new
technique will give us better capability to carry out research against this pest
and allow artificial infestation in field trials when natural populations are low and
a ready supply of larvae for lab bioassays. An artificial diet has also been
successfully developed for this system using soybeans and wheat germ as the
diet’s base. This is the first time a successful rearing system has ever been
developed to produce large numbers of banana scab moth for research purposes.
Lab assays for banana scab moth - A series of lab trials have now been
successfully completed for banana scab moth to examine pesticide efficacy on
insect mortality.
Tropical biopesticide assays - Droplet sizes of 1ml were placed on x 4, 1st, 3rd
and 5th instar larvae and replicated four times with a control (water and wetting
agent) and a standard (chlorpyrifos). The treatments included Metarhizium
anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana and spinosad. The chlorpyrifos standard and
spinosad treatments were clearly the best performers achieving 100% mortality
after 24 hours. Both Metarhizium anisopliae and Beauveria bassiana achieved
100% mortality after 72 hours. Although the fungal pathogens achieved slower
insect mortality, there was no significant difference between the levels of damage
when compared to each of the biopesticide treatments and the chlorpyrifos
standard. Some phototoxicity was observed in both the Metarhizium anisopliae
and Beauveria bassiana treatments, possibly due to the oil suspension in the
insecticide formulations. These biopesticide formulations may need to be modified
before field use but the level of efficacy achieved by these insecticides was quite
acceptable.
Residual and ingestion biopestcide assays - These trials looked at the residual
and ingestion efficacy of Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Spinosad,
Baccillus thuringiensis (Bt) and emmamectin. The most effective treatments
identified in this trial were emmamectin and spinosad which were equally as
effective as chlorpyrifos achieving 100% mortality after 24 hours. The Bt treatment
was the next best performer achieving 100% mortality after 4 days for all instars.
The Metarhizium anisopliae and Beauveria bassiana treatments were the least
effective in these assays and a lot slower acting compared to the other treatments
showing that residual efficacy is only partially effective when compared to direct
contact. Some phototoxicity was observed on banana fruit caused by both the
46 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Metarhizium anisopliae and Beauveria bassiana treatments possibly due to the
oil suspension in the insecticide formulations. These biopesticide formulations
may need to be modified before field use but the level of efficacy achieved by
these biopesticides was quite acceptable.
New insecticides residual and ingestion assays - Assays have just been
completed looking at new insecticides with different modes of action. Treatments
included thaimethoxam, tebufenozide, DPX-MP062 and noveluron. Tebufenozide
and DPX-MP062 performed equally effective when compared to the standard
chlorpyrifos at all instar stages of banana scab moth. All treatments were effective
in controlling banana scab moth in the first instar stage, which is the stage that
is most realistic in a field situation. As the banana scab moth larvae increased in
size, thiamethoxam and noveluron where the least effective treatments in achieving
mortality.
Field trials - Three field trials were completed investigating (1) insecticides with
different modes of action, (2) biopesticides and (3) insecticide impregnated plastics
as an alternative to bunch dusting with chlorpyrifos.
Experiment 1. Insecticides with new modes of action - in this trial three insecticides
were selected with different modes of action and compared to chlorpyrifos applied
as a bunch spray. Actara® (thiamethoxam, a Neonicitinoide compound) was
selected because of its good environmental profile and general all round control
for most insect pests. Confidor® (imidacloprid) was selected for its potential
efficacy against thrips. Mimic® (tebufenozide - IGR) was also selected for its
potential control against banana scab moth and sugarcane bud moth. Moderate
pest pressure was achieved throughout the duration of this trial. Actara®
(thiamethoxam) gave the best control against all insects compared to the standard
treatment of chlorpyrifos. The results indicate Actara® can be used as an
alternative to chlorpyrifos as a broad-spectrum insecticide against all bunch pests
although further trials need to verify this. Actara® also has a safer environmental
profile and because of the chemical group’s new mode of action may be well for
inclusion in insecticide resistance strategies. Confidor® (imidacloprid) had the
greatest efficacy against banana rust thrips and banana flower thrips. Mimic®
(tebufenozide) was the most effective against banana scab moth and sugarcane
bud moth. Further work will be carried out investigating combining various
treatments to achieve complete control against all bunch pests.
Experiment 2. Biopesticides - The next experiment was carried out to examine
the potential of using biological insecticides based on insect pathogens. This
initial trial looked at four biopesticides, which included; (1) Success® (spinosad,
spinosyns A and D natralytes produced by a Saccropolyspora spinosa bacteria),
(2) Beauveria bassiana and (3) Metarhizium anisopliea (insect fungal pathogen
supplied by CSIRO insect pathology in Canberra) and Dipel® (secondary
metabolite produced by Bacillus thuringiensis bacteria. Moderate pest pressure
was achieved throughout the duration of this trial for all insect pests. Success®
gave excellent control against all insect pests. In this trial, it was the only
insecticide that gave 100% control against banana scab moth and banana rust
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 47
paraffinic oils, vegetable oil formulations, mixtures of vegetable oils and tea tree
oil and the adjuvant Nufilm®. These treatments were compared with the industry
standards BP Misting Oil® and Fuchs Spray Oil®. Rates of application of the BP
Misting Oil® were also compared making a total of 15 treatments. The standard
rate of Dithane® (2.2 kg/ha) was added to all treatments except tea tree oil. This
was done at the request of the supplier of the tea tree oil.
An assessment of youngest leaf spotted (YLS), total number of leaves and DSI
was made on 16 May following the 6th spray application. Disease pressure in the
guard row plants was moderate to severe. Results showed that the paraffinic oils
were significantly more effective than the vegetable oils and tea tree oil. The
industry standard BP Misting Oil® + Dithane® was also more effective than Nufilm®
+ Dithane®. The higher rates of application of BP Misting Oil® (8.0 and 10.0 l/ha)
gave more effective control of leaf spot than the standard rate of 5l/ha.
Glasshouse techniques for yellow sigatoka and rust investigations developed
The mass production of spores (conidia) of yellow sigatoka on artificial media
was successfully achieved in the laboratory. Symptoms of yellow sigatoka were
reproduced in the glasshouse under conditions of high light intensity. Initial attempts
to develop rust symptoms on inoculated plants were unsuccessful. Research
did not proceed any further due to the outbreak of black sigatoka in the Tully
valley in April 2001.
Rust fungicide field trials
At the commencement of 2001, contact was made with a number of growers and
a suitable trial site (rust had been a problem at this site for a number of seasons,
and the site was separate from the rest of the farm so avoiding spray drift) was
found at Paul McAvoy’s property at Garradunga just north of Innisfail.
Arrangements were made with the grower regarding access to the property and
compensation for the loss of fruit sprayed with un-registered chemicals. A broad
range of systemic (strobilurins and triazoles) and protectant fungicides were
obtained from the chemical companies. Research did not proceed any further
due to the outbreak of black sigatoka in the Tully valley in April 2001.
Early in 2002, growers were again contacted regarding establishing the rust
control trial. The trial did not proceed due to a lack of leaf rust in the region. This
was due to the prolonged dry weather and the intensive de-leafing program in the
region.
Project title: Development of bananas with resistance to Fusarium
oxysporum f.sp. cubense (tropical race 4)
Project duration: 1 March 2001 -30 June 2005
Synopsis of project
The primary outcome from this program will be the effective management of the
devastating disease of bananas, fusarium wilt, caused by Fusarium oxysporum
f.sp. cubense (Foc) “tropical” race 4 through a program approach.
50 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Specific outcomes of this program will include the identification and commercial
adoption of a banana variety that is acceptable to domestic consumers and
profitable to produce in tropical areas of Australia infected with this strain of Foc.
Such varieties will be resistant, or at least tolerant, to this strain of the disease
whilst displaying acceptable agronomic requirements and marketability.
A condition of this program is that the conduct of the proposed R&D will not
increase the risk of Foc inoculum moving to the wider industry. That is, a further
outcome is the minimisation of risk associated with the research of Foc on a site
in the Darwin region.
Progress to date
A secure research facility with a capacity to test 20+ varieties of bananas has
been constructed and is operational with appropriate protocols in place. A 21
hectares site known as Coastal Plains Banana Quarantine Station (CPBQS)
has been fenced and a 2.7 hectares secure area known as Coastal Plains Banana
Quarantine Area (CPBQA) has been established within CPBQS.
Construction of the 2.7-meter high earth bund, 2-meter high security fence and
associated wash-down pads, internal earthworks and buildings was delayed about
6 months by prolonged wet weather and this has delayed the project overall. Site
works were completed on 6 June 2001 and the site was officially opened by the
NT Minister for Primary Industries on 9 June 2001.
Appropriate Quarantine Protocols have been developed and were implemented
on 22 August 2001. This is to test them for 2 months before inoculation takes
place.
All available test varieties have been established within CPBQA and are
approaching the size suitable for inoculation. Fourteen varieties have been
established and the remaining six are currently completing quarantine procedures
and will be established as soon as they become available.
The Management Committee has met regularly, has conducted site inspections
and has endorsed the facility suitability and the quarantine protocols.
Early identification of highly susceptible and possibly tolerant varieties in the
parent crop.
Six susceptible and highly susceptible types and six types, which, at this stage,
are resisting the disease under very high inoculum pressure, have been identified.
Criteria 1– Documentation of fusarium wilt rating and identification of susceptible
and potentially resistant varieties.
- Pisang Berangan is extremely susceptible and dies before reaching bunch
emergence stage in almost all cases. This confirms the Malaysian work.
This has been used to advantage as it was used as the sacrificial interplant
to build up inoculum in the site as well as a datum plant.
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 51
This variety began showing the first symptoms 6 weeks after being directly
inoculated in the field. A further 6 weeks later, some 547 of the 622 directly
inoculated plants were showing external symptoms of the disease and most
were severely affected.
- Cavendish [Williams 1017] and FHIA-17[944] are susceptible in the test site
with 20-25% of test plants at this stagehaving been rated as positive to Foc
tropical race 4 using the INIBAP guidelines and more plants developing
symptoms. It is to be reasonably expected that the remainder will develop
symptoms in time.
- Foc-susceptible malaccensis selections 845, 846, 848 are proving susceptible
in the test site with approximately 50% of test plants at this time being rated
as positive using the INIBAP guidelines. It can be reasonably expected that
the remainder will develop symptoms in time.
- Cavendish [GCTCV-119-ex Taiwan], FHIA -01[Goldfinger], FHIA-18, FHIA-25
and SH-3460.10 [High Noon] are not showing any symptoms at this stage
and could be considered potentially resistant at this stage.
In addition to the visual assessments being done on plants as per the INIBAP
guidelines, one sample has been taken from one plant assessed as positive to
Foc TR4 in each of the treatments where a susceptible plant has been identified.
This sample of pseudostem showing symptoms is being tested in the laboratory
for presence of Foc TR4. The laboratory procedures have not yet been completed
but preliminary results confirm the visual assessments as per the INIBAP
guidelines.
Criteria 2 – Strategy to protect IP and ensure the right to commercialize
development with each of the promising variety owners.
Strategy is to get written commercialization agreements with owners of non-
public varieties by direct negotiation.
Criteria 3 – Reports of Progress to HAL, Management Committee, National
Reference Group. The management committee meets at 6-9 week intervals or
as required and receives a full accounting of progress of the project at these
meetings.
Copies of this report are being sent to HAL, Management Committee and National
Reference Group. A separate report has been sent to QFVG.
Project title: Banana tissue culture for industry development
Project duration: 1 July 2001 - 30 June 2004
Summary
The Australian banana industry needs to address a range of issues in order to
maintain and expand its market share. They face a changing consumer focus,
more emphasis on environmental protection and sustainability issues as well as
increasing pressure from pests and diseases within Australia (e.g. subtropical
52 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
and tropical Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cubense (Foc) race 4, nematode, yellow
and black sigatoka, banana bunchy top virus) as well as from threats of exotic
pests and diseases. The Australian Banana Growers Council (ABGC), Banana
Industry Protection Board (BIPB, Queensland) and Banana Industry Committee
(BIC), New South Wales have identified national research and development
strategies to address these emerging problems. The strategies rely heavily on a
diverse range of banana varieties. Varieties sourced specifically for Australian
R&D need to enter Australia directly through our AQIS-registered tissue-culture
facility to safeguard against release of exotic pathogens. Industry requires
planting material to be pest- and disease-free and therefore able to be accessed
across the domestic quarantine zones and this can only be achieved using virus-
indexed tissue-cultured plants. Our laboratory is best able to deliver this outcome.
Current and future research into pest and disease, as well as industry development,
all rely on the use of banana germplasm (a diverse range of varieties)! The research
and support to be provided addresses the provision of banana material,
improvements in tissue culture and support of the Quality Banana Approved
Nursery (QBAN) Scheme to enable disease free plantlets to be distributed
anywhere in Australia. Maintenance of the large number of disease-free banana
varieties is managed by tissue culture storage. Plants stored in tissue culture
can be multiplied as needed in a short time frame and include varieties that are
not grown commercially and therefore not available elsewhere. In Australia, our
laboratory is the only laboratory that serves this vital function. There are over 20
current research projects (including black sigatoka exclusion strategies) utilizing
banana tissue culture plantlets from this banana germplasm collection. As well,
there is an increase in growers wanting to evaluate new varieties to explore their
potential in new markets.
Progress to date
This laboratory maintains an extensive collection of banana varieties used
specifically for industry development. The banana collection is maintained using
world’s best practice, at 16 oC to reduce subculture requirements. We currently
maintain approximately 400 accessions within our low temperature culture room.
To satisfy industry needs, we maintain these varieties “on call” ready to supply
plants in whatever quantity is required by researchers or growers. As part of this
project, we are looking at ways to improve efficiency of production and quality of
plants, with emphasis on germplasm storage and recalcitrant varieties. Since
the start of this project, we have been able to improve the condition and quality of
this material. We have developed improved methods of medium-term storage
conditions, including containment in plastic and increased light levels. We have
implemented improved procedures for routine initiation of cultures using dissected
meristems rather than shoot tips to eliminate detrimental bacterial contamination.
The result has been a significant improvement in the time of rotation of plants as
well as quality and multiplication! We are implementing new processes to improve
production of recalcitrant varieties. Reduction of apical dominance has been of
major importance to some varieties and requires damage to the apical dome
when plants stop multiplying.
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 53
• The field germplasm collection at Centre for Wet Tropics Agriculture has
been relocated on-station to rationalise and revitalise it. Approximately 200
varieties are maintained in this field collection. This year, 56 accessions
have been re-initiated into the tissue-culture collection using meristem culture.
These varieties will replace older, low-vigour accessions.
• Plants for variety evaluation have been produced and are in nursery
establishment in North Queensland prior to field establishment. Grower
evaluation sites for niche varieties are due for planting in September 2002 in
North Queensland. Basic agronomic/yield/fruit quality information will be
collected. Once the varieties are bunching, a field walk will be organised for
growers to attend. In association with QHI Marketing Officer, we have been
working with a group of NQ growers doing market R&D for a range of niche
banana varieties with particular emphasis on Señorita.
• QBAN industry support provided. QBAN continues to expand as an important
sector of the Australian Banana industry. All of last year’s facilities renewed
membership. This year, we have 30% more fully accredited QBAN facilities
than last year. There are currently 24 QBAN facilities, 5 commercial
laboratories in Queensland, 4 commercial laboratories in NSW, 6 commercial
nurseries in Queensland and 3 nurseries in NSW. There is one DPI Research
tissue-culture laboratory and 5 DPI- and 1 University-registered research
facilities.
QBAN connections newsletter was written and distributed July 2002.
54 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Summary
This programme addresses the issue of improving the performance of banana
growing operations by providing growers with the necessary information to assess
quickly and easily their farm’s performance based on Key Performance Indicators
(KPIs). By monitoring these KPIs over a period of time and comparing them
against a farm’s past performance, against others in the same region, against
other regions and against their own targets, growers can obtain a picture of how
their operations are performing in relation to the wider industry. As the system is
able to return information quickly, growers can see almost immediately where
changes they have made have had an impact on their operation, whether in
relation to production or labour management.
The project delivers against R&D Priority “Information for Good Management “
1.1.2 (a priority 1 issue identified in the National R&D Plan Revisions 26/4/2001)
and is further enforced in the draft and R&D plan delivered in July 2002 under the
following headings:
6.1 “Increase the quality of industry intelligence available to growers at the
grassroots level to enable them to make more informed business
decisions utilising the national Benchmarking Project.”
11.4 “Take a leadership role in financing and directing of R&D expenditure.”
Benchmarking will be an invaluable tool providing insight in to where
R&D funding is most needed.
Both 6.1 and 11.4 were identified as “High Priorities” in the Draft National Strategic
and R&D Plans.
Progress to date
No Milestones have been completed as yet.
Data entry forms have been developed.
Project title: Identification in banana of defence genes and
analysis of their induction by beneficial
microorganisms, to confer resistance to soil-borne
pathogens.
Project duration: 1 July 2002 - 30 June 2005
Certain non-pathogenic strains of the fungus, Fusarium oxysporum, and certain
bacterial isolates (identified at UQ and QDPI) provide protection to banana plants
from infection by the fusarium wilt fungus (Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cubense
[Foc]) and the burrowing nematode (Radopholus similis). The presence of such
beneficial microorganisms may be the underlying component in suppressive soils
where banana plants appear to be protected from these soil-borne pathogens.
This may also explain the problem of tissue-cultured banana plants being more
susceptible to fusarium wilt and to R. similis in the first year of planting cfr. non-
tissue cultured plants; tissue-cultured planting material may lack the beneficial
micro-organisms.
58 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
We intend to investigate how this protection is conferred by determining if plant
defence genes are triggered by the presence of these non-pathogenic
microorganisms. Initially, plant defence genes will be isolated in banana. Plants
will be challenged with pathogenic microorganisms (Foc and R. similis) and with
beneficial microorganisms to determine if the latter is triggering a systemic defence
response and if so, whether it is sustainable.
By identifying the mechanisms by which these non-pathogenic microorganisms
confer resistance to Foc and burrowing nematode, we will be able to manipulate
these beneficial microorganisms to confer an effective sustainable control against
Foc and the burrowing nematode, whether applied in the field and/or to tissue
culture material.
In addition, a wild line of banana (Musa acuminata subspecies malaccensis) will
be investigated further to determine if a putative specific defence gene already
identified in these lines is associated with resistance to Foc. Identification of a
defence gene unique to the resistant malaccensis plants would have implications
for the production of resistant transgenic banana lines.
Progress to date
One scientist has been awarded a DPI/UQ scholarship to work on this project.
Putative defence genes have been identified and work is in progress to verify their
involvement in a plant defence response.
M. acuminata ssp. malaccensis lines are currently growing at the University’s
farm and crosses will be undertaken in the coming summer months.
Project title: Soil and root health for eco-banana production
In each production area, triplicate soil samples will be taken down the soil profile
to determine the effects farm management has on biological, physical and
chemical soil properties. The samples will be taken from a conventional banana
growing soil, a low-input or organic banana production system and an undisturbed
system, either rainforest or pasture. This will measure the effects of farm
management on soil properties and determine which soil characteristics are
most susceptible to change due to farm management. The soil characteristics,
which are most sensitive to change due to farmer’s management and the most
practical for the banana industry to use, will be adopted as key soil indicators
throughout the project.
The key soil indicators developed from the initial survey will be used to develop a
soil health scorecard for use by banana growers. The soil health scorecard will
be tested for practicality and reliability to indicate soil health by a second survey
over three years. The survey will take place yearly on banana farms on a range of
soil types and management practices. This will indicate the current soil health
status of banana soils and what soil characteristics need to be improved. It will
also allow banana growers to incorporate a soil health recording system into an
environmental management system to validate their method of farming to
environmental agencies and allow continuous improvement in soil health.
To help banana growers determine what is the best method to improve the health
of their soil, trials are planned to test pre-plant organic amendments and the use
of interrow crops. The pre-plant amendments applied to bananas are intended to
provide growers with workable solutions to improve the soil health indicators and
allow a more sustainable method of soil management. Pre-plant amendments
and the soil health indicators will be linked to the sustainability of banana
production by measuring plant growth and yields over a 3-year period. The
amendments will also be tested for their addition of nutrients and ability to
suppress soil-borne diseases. The use of pre-plant amendments builds on
information gathered from previous projects on the use of compost and mill ash
to develop disease-suppressive soils.
The use of crops in the interrow of bananas is intended to improve the plant, soil
and water relationships within the banana paddock and to reduce the movement
of sediment from the banana paddock. A number of shade tolerant species will
be tested for their ability to persist within the banana interrow, withstand traffic,
their resistance to soil-borne diseases and their agronomic suitability for a banana
production system. The effects of interrow species will also be tested for their
effects on the key soil health indicators to determine if this allows growers to
improve their soil health and the sustainability of banana growing. The use of
interrow crops builds on information gathered on the resistance of banana fallow
crops to soil-borne diseases.
The project to develop soil indicators to determine the health of banana-growing
soil has evolved due to the observations made of poor plant growth, restricted
root growth and plant toppling observed on banana farms when there is no plant
pathogen involved. Often the only apparent cause of poor plant growth is poor
60 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
soil structure. The poor soil structure has been difficult to describe to banana
growers. The effect soil structural degradation has on banana growth has no
quantifiable or descriptive measures to indicate to banana growers how poor soil
health is impacting on plant growth. To increase the awareness of banana growers
of the effects of poor soil structure and soil degradation have on production and
sustainability of banana cultivation, pot trials have been included in the project.
The pot trials will also investigate the interaction of a pathogen, such as
nematodes and Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cubense (Foc), on bananas in poorly
structured soil. This trial will demonstrate if soil conditions can increase the
susceptibility soil-borne disease has on banana growth.
The project aims to develop practical science for banana growers to develop
useful and practical indicators of soil health. To help with the adoption and uptake
of the use of soil indicators, an extension component of the project comprising a
biannual newsletter, annual farmer field schools and the development of a banana
root and soil health manual and testing kit will be developed. The soil health
manual and testing kit will complement one another and allow growers to use a
soil health scorecard to assess and validate their management practices in relation
to soil health. This information can then be incorporated into an environmental
management system for growers to continually improve the health of soils under
banana cultivation.
For banana growers to improve their knowledge of soil health practices, they
need indicators that can quantify and describe their current soil health status as
well as management options that growers can implement to improve soil health.
This project will improve the knowledge of soil health, allow growers to monitor
and validate soil health and give options to improve soil health management. As
a result of improved soil health from this project banana growers will be able to
reduce losses due to poor soil structure, validate their farming practices and
continuously improve soil health management to sustainably produce bananas
in Queensland.
Progress to date
The project has not officially started due to the delay in finalising approval from
HAL and agreement contracts. Some preliminary work has commenced and
protocols have been established for conducting trials in north and southeast
Queensland. A soil health kit has been delivered from the USA, which will form
the basis of the kit that will be made available to banana growers. The logistics of
how this will be used in the field are currently being determined.
Some pre-plant amendments have been collected, such as cattle paunch (abattoir
by-product), mill ash and sludge. A small pot trial has been conducted on the
use of paunch material supplied from the Innisfail meat works. The use of paunch
material was able to increase the leaf area of banana plants relative to untreated
soil. Paunch was not able to suppress nematodes in the soil in the 8-week pot
trial.
A preliminary pot trial investigating the impact of soil compaction on the growth
Banana industry status and R&D update in Australia 61
of banana plants with and without nematodes has been completed. Plants growing
in a soil with a high bulk density (compacted soil) had less chord roots than
plants growing in a soil with low soil bulk density. The amount of chord root was
significantly correlated with the growth of the plants. Plants with lesser chord
roots weighed less and were smaller than plants with a larger mass of chord
roots. The weight of root hairs was not related to the growth of the plants in this
trial. Plants growing in a soil with a high bulk density tended to have the corm
sitting on the soil surface rather than in the soil. Nematodes were also related to
reduced plant growth. More nematodes were found on smaller plants with smaller
root systems. The bulk density of the soil appeared to be the major factor limiting
plant growth, with nematodes being a secondary factor.
Seeds from 12 interrow pasture species have been collected and are currently
being tested for their ability to host burrowing nematodes at the Indooroopilly
Research Centre.
Selection of strains of beneficial microbes has been made to inoculate tissue
culture bananas to plant in the field. A commercial growth promoting rhizobacteria
that is currently available will be included in the trial.
Project title: Market-based analysis of constraints to banana industry
development in Indonesia and Australia
Men Sarom*
Sarom*
Introduction
Introduction
Cambodia is a country in Southeast Asia in the southwestern corner
of Indochina. It occupies a compact territory covering 181 035 square
o
kilometers. The country is extended in latitude between 10-15 N and
o
in longitude between 102-108 E. To the north the country is bordered
by Thailand and Laos, to the east and south by Vietnam, and to the
west by Thailand and Gulf of Siam.
Cambodia has a tropical monsoonal climate with defined dry and wet
seasons. The dry season is from November to April, and the wet season
is from May to October. The annual rainfall ranges from 1250 to 4000
millimeters. It is low in the central plain and increasing towards the
Gulf of Siam. The mean temperature ranges from 21 to 35 OC, with the
highest temperature in April (30-35 0C) and the lowest in January
(21-25 0C). The central plain is the hottest spot in the country and it is
cooler in the east and southwest regions. Across the country,
photoperiod ranges from about 11 hours 14 minutes to 13 hours 01
minute with the shortest daylength occurring in late December and
the longest in June (List 1958).
Cambodia is a country of 12 million inhabitants with an annual
population growth rate of 2.4%. Cambodia is predominately a rural
economy with more than 84% of the active Cambodian population
rural or agrarian. Most are farmers. In 2000, agriculture contributes
approximately 34.1% to the gross domestic product (GDP) with a
further 25.5% coming from industry and 40.4% from services (MEF
2001). Agriculture contribution to the GDP has decreased from 44.7%
in 1994 to 34.1% in 2000, while industry increased from 15.0% in 1994
to 25.5% in 2000.
Within the agricultural sector, crops are the main contributors to the
GDP. Rice is the main crop followed by maize, beans, vegetables and
fruit crops. Within the last group, banana, or Chek in Khmer, plays a
very important role in the daily diet of the people.
Chek Teuk (water banana). By its name, this banana is more tolerant to
waterlogging, but its fruits have no commercial value. It is grown
mainly in the low-lying areas where water logging is a problem and
where no other types of banana can be grown.
Chek Snap Mouk (masked face banana). This banana can only be
found in some areas. The fruits are big and are eaten boiled when
they are ripe.
Chek Muoy Roy Snit (one hundred hands). This type of banana has no
commercial value but it can be a good genetic source for cultivar
improvement. Many hands rise from the stalk but fruits are not fully
developed.
Chek Chvea. It is a seeded banana. It is grown in farmers’ backyards
but normally far away from the house. It is believed that this banana
has the power to attract the spirit and so it is not advisable to grow it
next to the house.
Chek Tes (decorative type). This is a decorative banana and is grown
mainly for its nice flowers. The flower can be red or yellow.
Uses of banana
Banana is a very important crop for Cambodians. All parts of the crop
are used, but that depends on the type of banana grown. Table 1 presents
some of these uses.
Production constr
Production aints
constraints
Major pests and diseases
There are many problems associated with banana plantation, but as
no research has been conducted in this area, the causes of those are
still unclear. The only problem that has been widely reported is fusarium
wilt.
74 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Table 1. Uses of the different parts of commercially-grown banana cultivars
in Cambodia.
Banana
Stem Leaves Male bud Fruits
cultivars
Chek Namva Can be used Used as Used as fresh Used both green
as food (fresh wrapping salad or cooked and ripe. When
and cooked) materials green, it is used for
and feed (for cooking. Ripe
pig and cattle) banana can be
eaten fresh, fried,
boiled or in many
different forms of
preparations.
Chek Ambong Occasionally Mainly used as
used as cooked dessert because of
recipe their sweetness
and mild aroma.
Eaten as fresh ripe
fruits only.
Chek Pong The most delicious
Moan banana. The fruits
are small, but have
very tasty flavour
and texture. Eaten
as fresh ripe fruits
only.
Chek Nuon Mainly used as
dessert because of
their sweetness.
Eaten as fresh ripe
fruits only.
Chek Meas Similar to Chek
Sgnuon Nuon, but the ripe
fruits are more
acidic. Eaten as
fresh ripe fruits
only.
Chek Tuk Occasionally Good Occasionally Have strong aroma,
used as feed wrapping used as cooked but very soft
material recipe consistency. Not
very popular.
Chek Snap Ripe banana is
Muok boiled
Chek Muoy There are many
Roy Snit small hands on a
long bunch. The
fruits are not eaten
and have no
economic value.
Chek Chvea Occasionally Good Occasionally Because the ripe
used as feed wrapping used as fruits can be full of
material cooked seeds, only young
recipe green fruits are
used. It is
fermented.
Chek Meas Used mainly for
decoration
An overview of the production and banana research in Cambodia 75
Production practices
The use of suckers as seed stock is the main practice in Cambodia. To a
lesser extent, for planting a new crop, the use of rhizome is also
practised. Normally, for the new plantation, suckers separated from
the main stem are planted in a prepared pit. Commonly, suckers with
three to four leaves are used. Cow manure and/or compost is mixed
with the soil for filling the pit. Distance between pits is 2.5 x 4 meters
or 3 x 4 meters. Two to three cycles of generation are kept before a new
crop is established. Due to this practice, the spread of diseases such as
fusarium wilt is difficult to control and/or eliminate and the yield
becomes poorer from one cycle to the next. It is also possible that some
pest populations can build up over the years.
Environmental factors
• Water. Water is the major environmental constraint to the
production of banana. Rain in most cases provides the sole source
of water available to the crop. Rainfall is variable in its amount
and distribution, so much so, it can substantially affect the
productivity of the crop. Floods may occur with excessive rain,
and can cause massive decline in production, yield and quality.
• Wind. Damage to the stem and leaves caused by wind can also be
observed very frequently when there is a storm.
Others
• Research and development. Because of resources constraint, public
investment in agricultural research constitutes only a small portion
of the total government budget. Needed infrastructure is not present
and there is a big shortage of manpower in agricultural research.
Presently, the Cambodian Agricultural Research and Development
Institute (CARDI) is the first and only agricultural research institute
in the country where a significant mass of researchers are employed.
Current banana R&D activities
At present, there are no R&D activities in any of the areas below:
• Germplasm collection/conservation
• Nutrition
• Irrigation
• Plant protection
• Production systems
• Postharvest
76 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Opportunities and thrusts
As mentioned earlier, Cambodia is rich in genetic diversity of the Musa
species. The need for their collection and conservation therefore
requires special attention. The level of banana consumption in the
country is high, thus increasing the production level is regarded as a
major role in the policy guideline of the Royal Government of
Cambodia in alleviating poverty in the country. In this regard, varietal
improvement of banana and protection measures from major pests
and diseases are very urgent issues.
Areas for future collaboration
• Germplasm collection and conservation
• Germplasm improvement
• Research support on every area including nutrition and water,
plant protection, production systems, postharvest handling, etc.
• Human resource development program
References
List, R.J. 1958. Smithsonian Meteorological Tables. Smithsonian
Institution. Washington, DC, USA.
MEF. 2001. Report of the Ministry of Economics and Finance, Phnom
Penh, Cambodia.
Production and banana R&D in China 77
same. The results based on the molecular level could provide theoretical
basis for the classification of Musa AAA group Cavendish. At the same
time, some rare and excellent germplasm has been applied and
popularized in banana production, such as Fenjiao, Longyajiao,
Gongjiao and so on.
Nutrition and water
Based on the study of nutritional requirement and the fertility
investigation of different soil types, the research group headed by Soil
Fertilizer Research Institute of GAAS, has worked out banana specific
fertilizer through adjusting the ratio of N:P:K, and sometimes adding
Mg, S, Ca and B element. It was proven that the banana specific
fertilizer had larger application areas and better effects than ordinary
compound fertilizer. Through treatment of balanced nutrition and good
irrigation, the yield of banana per plant and per hectare has been
improved remarkably; the maximum reaches to 95.5 kilograms and
75 tonnes, respectively. At present, water management is still a problem
in the banana production, because water distribution is seasonal,
summer and autumn are rainy seasons, but winter and spring are dry
seasons. Modern irrigation system is little use in the banana plantations.
Some farmers usually dig some deep wells and use pump for irrigation.
The study of vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhiza (VAM) on banana was
done by Green Giant Environmental Biotechnology Limited by Dr
Huang Jinxian. The results indicate that VAM plantlets grow faster,
flowering and harvest earlier and have bigger fingers than the control.
Production systems
The current production systems are mainly in smallholders; sale is
separated from cultivation which leads to high cost and poor quality.
Thus, intensive and industrial production systems must be established,
such as banana production cooperative group with a famous
trademark.
Postharvest
Recently, our technology and equipments of postharvest lagged behind
80 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
banana production. The equipment for harvest and package handling
are rough, resulting to many scars and bruises on the fingers. Most of
bananas are below B class.
Opportunities and thrusts
China became a member of WTO last year which provides many
opportunities. Because we have wide places and appropriate climate
for banana production, the redundant banana will have more markets
than before. At the same time, the competence from overseas brings
us big thrusts. The key is how to use biotechnology to breed new
cultivars resistant to the diseases, extend the new technology, and
improve the quality and efficiency of the production.
Proposed ar
Proposed eas of colla
areas bor
collabor ation
bora
Rapid propagation
Tissue culture plant (TCP) is the most popular planting material in
China. 80-90% of TCP are used for new plantations. Generally
speaking, less than 3% off-type plants can be found in the field. More
than 100 million TCP are planted every year. With the low price, it
can be exported to other countries.
Excellent germplasm exchange
Germplasm exchange can screen some excellent cultivars and help
produce some disease-resistant cultivars. Improve the banana industry
in China through INIBAP collaboration.
Harvest and postharvest management, technology and equipments
Marketing management
These are the shortcomings of banana industry in China.
Status of banana industry in India 81
Introduction
Introduction
Banana and plantain is one of the popular fruits in the world in terms
of production and per capita consumption aside from being one of
the important fruits of commerce. Banana and plantain is the fourth
important global agricultural commodity after rice, wheat and maize
in terms of gross value of production. It is cultivated in over a hundred
countries throughout the tropical and subtropical regions of the world.
Banana in India
There has been a gradual increase in production of banana during the
last 30 years and in the last decade, a spectacular growth has been
witnessed due to the concerted efforts in banana research. The area
has doubled from 200 000 hectares in early 1970s to 490 000 hectares
in 2000 (Table 1). The banana production has made a giant leap by
five times from 3.0 million tonnes in 1970s to 16.8 million tonnes in
2000. Productivity has also increased from 11.5 tonnes per hectare to
34.3 tonnes per hectare (national average), while in some states it is
recorded as 60 tonnes per hectare. This significant increase in the
production and productivity of banana happened due to adoption of
improved cultivars, production technologies like optimum plant
density; nutrition and water management coupled with integrated
pest management strategies.
Table 1. Growth of banana industry in India.
Area % Production % Productivity
Year
(ha) Increase (t) Increase (t/ha)
1962 2.0 --- 2.6 --- 11.5
1977 2.4 48.0 5.9 153.4 15.54
1987 3.0 150.0 8.9 255.0 17.42
1993 4.3 215.0 11.9 457.0 27.57
1997 4.4 220.0 13.33 512.0 29.7
2000 4.9 245.0 16.81 696.0 34.3
Selection
Gandevi, a mutant of Giant Cavendish has exhibited its superiority
with an average yield of 45 kg bunch as compared to other Cavendish
selections namely, Shrimanti, Padarse, etc.
A promising selection was made from Karpuravalli at NRCB, which
is under multilocation trials. The selection is with 16 to 18 hands and
produces 35 to 45 kg bunch with uniform sized fingers having better
shelf life.
Promising hybrids
Promising
In India, earlier efforts have been made by Tamil Nadu Agricultural
University (TNAU), Coimbatore but were successful in a very limited
scale, in breeding AAB Prata dessert bananas (Pome type). Diploid
male parents breeding at TNAU as potential sources of resistance to
Mycosphaerella spp.; Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. cubense (Foc) and
nematodes has resulted in development of 25 useful lines. Later,
breeding work was also initiated at Banana Research Station, Kannara
and Kerala Agricultural University, Thrissur.
84 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Co-1
It is a promising Pome hybrid resulting from 3-way sequential crosses.
It produces the typical acid/apple flavour of Virupakshi even in plains,
contrary to Virupakshi, which develops aroma only when grown at
higher altitudes.
H 1 (Agniswar x Pisang Lilin)
A shorter cropping cycle hybrid with resistance to leaf spot, fusarium
wilt and burrowing nematode (Radopholus similis). It is a medium to
tall plant, with a bunch weight of 14-16 kg. Elongated fruits turn
attractive golden yellow upon ripening. It has a slightly acidic fruit
and on full ripening, it develops high sugar content. H 1 has a
remarkable early ratooning ability, completing 4 crop cycles in 3 years.
This hybrid is immune to sigatoka leaf spot diseases.
H 2 (Vannan x Pisang Lilin)
A hybrid developed at Kerala Agricultural University (KAU), Kannara,
is a medium-stature plant of 7-8 ft in height. Crop cycle is short with
bunch coming to harvest in 11-12 months. Average weight of the bunch
is 15-20 kg with short, stout, dark green Poovan - like fruits, which
are arranged very compactly. Fruits are slightly acidic with pleasant
sweet sour aroma. It is highly tolerant to leaf-spot disease and
nematodes, hence, suitable for subsistence cultivation.
Uses
Bananas and plantains have high carbohydrate and low fat contents,
making them useful particularly in low-fat diets. They are also good
sources of many vitamins and minerals particularly vitamin A
(carotene), vitamin B (thiamin, niacin and riboflavin), B6 and vitamin
C (ascorbic acid). Banana is low in sodium, making it a salt-free food.
Due to the low lipid and higher energy value, bananas are
recommended for obese and geriatric patients. Banana fruits, being
rich in vitamin A, act as an aid to digestion. Boiled, mashed fruits are
good for relieving constipation. The juice from the male bud provides
remedy for stomach problems. Bananas are often used as the first solid
food fed to infants in many parts of the globe, as they are readily
acceptable and easily digestible.
Dried banana leaves are used as fuel in the rural areas of India. The
dried sheaths are tightly twisted and made into two feet long sticks.
In addition, dried banana leaves are used for thatching the roofs and
also as a fence, which prevents the sun radiation and reduces the
Status of banana industry in India 85
• Nematodes
Table 5 shows the common banana nematodes in India, their
distribution and susceptible cultivars.
• Major diseases
The major diseases of banana and susceptible cultivars are shown
in Table 6.
Environmental factors
• Problem soils
Salt accumulation in root zone causes saline and alkaline soils. The
higher accumulation of sodium in alkaline soil causes reduced
cation, especially potassium, uptake and also causes injury to roots
causing leaf injury, thereby decreasing yield.
• Wind
With high velocity, wind causes blow-downs in tropical banana
plantations. At a wind velocity of more than 20 meters/second,
between 50-100% of the plants can be blown down. Apart from
this, regular strong winds cause leaf tearing which reduces
productivity significantly. Winds between 2.5 to 5 meters/second
can reduce fruit quality by enhancing leaf and dust abrasion.
• High temperature
The important problems encountered due to hot weather are
summer leaf stress mixed-ripe fruits and ripe fruit breakdown.
• Drought
Periodical occurrence of drought leads to yield reduction, caused
by a physiological reduction of assimilation. Prolonged drought
produces small, stunted plants, reduced leaf emergence, choked
bunches and small bunches with shrivelled, blackened fingers.
Others
• Postharvest technology
Handling damages in banana could occur during harvesting,
handling, collection, transport, loading onto trucks, off-loading,
handling by the wholesalers, retailers and finally by consumers.
The physiological loss in weight, finger drop, impact damage due
to rough handling and spoilages are the main reasons for the losses
Status of banana industry in India 89
Introduction
Introduction
Banana contributed 51% of 6 661 761 tonnes of Indonesian fruit
production (Anonym. 2000). The area of productions are scattered
throughout the country with various agro-ecosystem and cultivation
system. The major production areas are West Java, East Java, Central
Java, South Sulawesi, West Sumatera, and others, which produce 40%,
19%, 13%, 4% and 24%, respectively (Anonym 2000). The largest area
of banana production is in Java (61%) and followed by Sumatera (16%),
Sulawesi (8%), Kalimantan (4%) and other islands (Anonym. 2000).
Major commercial dessert cultivars are Pisang Ambon Kuning, P.
Ambon Hijau, P. Barangan, P. Raja Serai, P. Emas and P. Berlin, and
cooking bananas/plantains are P. Kepok, P. Raja Bulu, P. Oli/Jantan,
P. Tanduk and P. Candi.
Commonly, bananas are grown by smallholders with minimum
cultivation and production inputs. In some areas, smallholders
cultivate banana with monoculture system and mix-cropping system.
Their productions are generally for local market, banana chips and
dry banana industry (P. Sale). A few commercial growers at Lampung
(Sumatera), Halmahera (Maluku) and Mojokerto (East Java) have
established large plantation mainly for export and industry of banana
flour and puree.
Although banana production has increased over the years, the
production area of banana has declined from 1997 to 1999 (Table 1),
particularly in the central area of banana production such as Sumatera,
Sulawesi, Central and East Java. The declining areas were caused by
the outbreak of several pests and diseases such as panama disease,
blood disease, moko disease, sigatoka, BBTV, CMV, borer and
nematodes. The major diseases in the central area of banana
production are panama disease (fusarium wilt), blood disease and
moko disease (bacterial wilt disease). Export of banana was significantly
increased from 1992 to 1993 and from 1995 to 1996 (Table 1), because
private sectors have involved on banana agribusiness. Banana export
decreased from 1996 until 1999 due to the outbreak of some banana
diseases on the commercial banana plantations, insufficient supply of
Area (ha) 76 721 70 721 50 041 49 044 48 944 78 115 71 537 70 560
Production
2 650 814 2 643 812 3 086 557 3 805 431 3 023 431 3 057 081 3 176 749 3 376 661
(tonnes)
Export (tonnes) 11 24 917 33 092 55 318 101 495 71 028 76 982 76 726
Source: Central Bureau of Statistics and Directorate General Production of Horticulture and Various Plants.
Cur
Currrent Banana Resear
Resear ches a
esearc att Solok Resear
Research Institute of F
esearc Frruits
(RIF)
Musa germplasm collection and conservation
Solok RIF has done banana-collecting missions since 1994, but some
of the collections were affected by fusarium wilt and recollected again.
Currently, there are 200 accessions which are maintained in the field,
screenhouse and in vitro laboratory. Under the collaboration with
INIBAP, Musa collecting missions were carried out in Maluku Islands
in 1996 and Papua (Irian Jaya) in 2002 and obtained 28 and 70
accessions, respectively. A unique
accession obtained from Seram Island
(Central Maluku) was P. Sepatu Amora.
This variety is similar to Kepok (ABB/
BBB), but no male bud flower. In
appropriate condition, P. Sepatu Amora
produces up to 18 hands per bunch.
Due to the absence of male bud flower,
Plate 1. Bunch of Pisang Sepatu Amora
this variety has potential to escape from
vector of BDB. In Papua, many of accessions were AA-types, similar
to those from Papua New Guinea. There are two accessions found in
Papua as well as in Maluku; P. Dawaka and P. Jarum. P. Dawaka is
similar to P. Kepok, but the size of the fruit is bigger and fruit shape is
similar to Bluggoe. P. Jarum, with the hairy pedicel, is the most popular
dessert banana in Maluku Island. Musa schizocarpa, M. lolodensis and
M. acuminata banksii were found during the exploration in Papua.
Banana-collecting missions were also done in Java and Sumatera
Islands. Some wild types of M. acuminata were found in Sumatera,
designed by BKT-11, BSK-30, SLK-29, and SPN-21. The first two
accessions (BKT-11 and BSK-30) are potential for male parent, because
those are resistant to fusarium wilt and bearing long size of bunch (18
to 20 hands). For banana improvement, these accessions are used as
pollen sources and crossed with commercial varieties (research on
going).
Preparation of IMTP-III project
Under the Letter of Agreement (LOA) with INIBAP 2001/22, CRIH
received in vitro planting materials (21 accessions) from INIBAP Transit
Centre. These accessions have been multiplied in the tissue culture
laboratory of Research Institute for Ornamental Plants and Solok RIF.
Three locations are chosen as the sites of experiments, where the
presence of the pathogen is sufficient: RIF (West Sumatera), Berastagi
96 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Research Station (North Sumatera), and Bogor University of
Agriculture, West Java (tentative) or Nusantara Tropical Fruit,
Lampung.
Some of the planting materials are being maintained in pots and ready
for planting by the middle of October 2002.
IPM on banana pests and diseases control
Integrated pest management (IPM) can be defined as the use of multiple
tactics in a compatible manner to maintain pest populations at levels
below those causing economic injury while providing protection
against hazards to humans, animals, plants and the environment
(Frison 1998). IPM is thus ecologically based pest management that
makes full use of natural and cultural processes and methods, including
host resistance and biological control. There are some tactics that can
be employed into IPM strategies, either alone or in combinations which
include regulatory control, cultural control, genetic manipulation of
the pest population, host plant resistance, biological control and
chemical control.
Most of banana pests and diseases such as weevil borer, fusarium wilt,
BDB, Moko disease, sigatoka leaf spot and BBTV are difficult to be
controlled by pesticides. IPM tactics that used by RIF for controlling
such pests and diseases, particularly weevil borer, fusarium wilt and
bacterial wilt, are regulatory control, cultural control, host plant
resistance and biological control. Regulatory control by quarantine is
applied in order to restrict the movement of pests into areas where
they do not occur. Quarantine usually goes hand in hand with
eradication. Cultural control is integral of farming practice. In banana,
a practical disease management technology was developed successfully
and adopted by farmers in the Philippines to manage ‘bugtok’, the
same disease that also has been ravaging Saba (similar to Kepok). This
technology was adopted to manage BDB in Sumatera (Setyobudi and
Hermanto 1999). Some researches have been carried out in order to
induce banana plant resistance to fusarium wilt and BDB through
conventional hybridization between commercial variety and wild
Musa, off-type induction using mutagen (EMS) and gamma radiation,
and in vitro screening and selection of plantlets on pathogenic toxin
medium (Karsinah et al. 1999; Djatnika et al. 2000). One promising
variety named P. Sepatu Amora is not resistant to BDB, but avoidance
variety due to the absence of male bud flower. This variety is now
being multiplied to produce a sufficient amount of planting materials
for further evaluation and dissemination. The use of natural pests to
Current status of banana R&D in Indonesia 97
Total production over the past 10 years ranges between 510 000 to
560 00 metric tonnes per year. Thus, Malaysia is a very small producer
compared to the neighbouring countries such as Thailand (2 million
tonnes), Philippines (4 million tonnes) and India (8 million tonnes).
Malaysia exported a 10-year average of about 37 000 metric tonnes
per year or 7% of its total production with an average value of US$7
*Research Officer, Horticulture Research Centre, MARDI, Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia.
100 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
million. The traditional markets for Malaysian bananas are Singapore,
Hong Kong, Brunei and the Middle East.
The annual per capita consumption of banana is 5.5 kg for Malaysia
and is very much lower than some European countries at more than
10 kg. The popular varieties for dessert are P. Mas (2.7 kg per annual
capita consumption) followed by P. Rastali (0.70 kg) and P. Berangan
(0.48 kg). For the cooking variety, P. Nangka is the most consumed
followed by P. Abu and P. Raja perhaps due to ease of availability.
Major cultivars of banana in Malaysia
Malaysia is considered as one of the center of diversity of banana as
evidenced by the diploids AA (eg. Pisang Mas, P. Jari Buaya. P. Lilin,
etc.) and the natural hybrids of AAB (P. Nangka, P. Raja, P. Rastali,
etc.) and ABB ( P. Awak, P. Abu, P. Nipah, etc.). Thus, there exists a
variety of choice for the farmers and growers (Table 2).
Production constr
Production aints
constraints
The destruction due to pests and diseases, the production system, high
cost of production and transportation, low yield, competition from
neighbouring countries and from other fruit types within the country
are constraints and weaknesses in the production of banana.
Pests and diseases
The major pests are banana weevil (Cosmopolites sordidus), leaf roller
(Erionata thrax) and nematodes. Thrips, aphids, spider mites and scab
moth are minor pests, which do not cause serious damage. The banana
weevil is frequently associated with P. Tandok and other cultivars
damaging the corms and pseudostems. This results in stunted growth,
weak plant base, yellowing of leaves and rotting of the corms.
Leaf rollers cause seasonal damage and are normally controlled by
natural predators. Nematodes played an important roles in reducing
banana production. There are 14 nematode species associated with
banana but 8 species in 4 genera are considered as potentially of
Banana industry and R&D in Malaysia 103
Ilocos Region 9.1 8.9 9.2 9.0 8.9 8.2 7.8 7.4 7.5 7.5 7.5
Adv
Cagayan Valley 24.9 25.4 26.0 26.0 27.6 29.7 29.4 28.4 26.4 26.3 26.3
Central Luzon 3.3 3.4 3.6 3.7 3.9 4.0 4.4 4.6 4.4 4.3 4.3
Southern Tagalog 47.7 48.7 49.0 49.3 50.6 51.7 53.4 57.0 61.1 60.8 60.9
Bicol Region 18.0 19.0 19.4 19.3 17.1 13.6 16.0 17.6 19.1 19.4 19.3
W estern Visayas 33.7 34.0 34.5 33.7 33.4 33.4 33.5 33.7 34.3 34.3 34.6
Central Visayas 18.4 17.8 17.9 18.1 18.3 18.5 19.1 18.6 19.3 19.8 19.8
Eastern Visayas 26.7 26.9 27.4 28.2 25.4 25.5 25.7 24.8 25.4 27.2 27.8
W estern Mindanao 21.9 22.2 22.6 22.8 23.3 23.8 24.0 24.2 24.3 23.9 24.6
Northern Mindanao 14.3 15.0 15.0 15.9 17.0 18.2 18.0 19.2 23.4 26.1 26.0
Southern Mindanao 38.0 39.7 42.9 48.7 53.1 55.5 55.6 55.6 59.1 62.6 64.3
Central Mindanao 17.8 17.6 16.2 15.5 14.9 15.1 15.7 16.6 18.0 19.2 19.7
CARAG A 26.1 24.4 24.9 25.7 26.2 27.1 25.4 24.8 27.0 27.0 27.2
ARMM 13.8 14.6 14.8 15.6 16.2 16.6 17.0 17.7 19.3 20.4 20.5
Philippines 317.1 321.2 326.7 335.1 339.4 344.5 348.6 353.7 372.1 382.5 386.5
Source: BAS 2001.
W estern Visayas 244.3 242.2 239.6 239.7 240.6 236.6 243.6 201.0 243.5 254.5 256.1
Central Visayas 157.3 158.6 156.9 162.4 166.0 170.7 179.1 166.5 175.4 182.3 168.5
acif
Pacif
Eastern Visayas 205.3 213.2 214.1 228.7 217.3 206.2 216.3 201.5 207.2 224.2 227.0
acific
W estern Mindanao 201.4 203.5 202.1 209.1 206.5 183.5 200.5 163.8 173.7 181.8 184.5
Northern Mindanao 147.5 153.0 158.2 162.2 165.9 170.1 171.2 130.1 178.2 184.2 205.1
ic - V
Southern Mindanao 1 264.8 1 265.1 1 366.5 1 477.1 1 809.5 1 875.5 1 883.5 1 753.5 1 972.7 2 142.2 2 245.1
Vol
Central Mindanao 342.2 356.0 331.0 317.9 302.1 318.0 374.6 382.0 433.3 483.9 514.1
ol 11
CARAG A 261.7 259.1 262.0 248.5 247.5 244.1 207.5 188.1 192.1 197.3 197.8
ARMM 166.2 179.4 188.1 195.7 204.4 198.7 218.5 224.9 290.8 328.7 334.5
Philippines 3 662.3 3 723.9 3 809.4 3 916.4 4 236.2 4 229.1 4 407.7 4 106.7 4 570.6 4 929.6 5 060.8
Source: BAS 2001.
The Philippine banana industry: Status and prospects 109
Others
Bungulan
8%
6%
Latundan Saba
20% 44%
Lakatan
Cavendish
12%
10%
Bungulan Others
Latundan 3%
4%
10%
Saba
Lakatan 38%
13%
Cavendish
32%
The Philippines is the only Southeast Asian country that made it to the
top five major suppliers of banana in the world in 2000. The country
ranked 5th among the world’s banana producers with 3.56 million
tonnes or 6.1% of the world production (FAO 2000). India had the
biggest share (18.9%) followed by Brazil (9.3%), China (8.9%) and
Ecuador (8.6%). Indonesia occupied the 6th rank while Thailand ranked
9th(Table 4).
The major products being exported are fresh banana, chips/crackers
and catsup. In 2000, the fresh bananas constitute the main bulk of the
country’s export, or almost 98% of the total volume exported (1.62
million metric tons) valued at US$312M (Table 5).
The Philippine banana industry: Status and prospects 111
UAE Japan
6% 61%
Taiwan
6%
Singapore
17%
Japan
25%
Bacterial wilt or moko and bugtok are caused by one and the same
bacterium, Ralstonia solanacearum (EF Smith). Bugtok occurs
commonly in cooking bananas like Saba and Cardaba, while moko
occurs in dessert bananas like Giant Cavendish and Lakatan. Rice
hull-burning is one of the practices employed by commercial
plantations to control moko. Early detection and prompt
eradication of the infected mats have contributed to the decreasing
trend in moko incidence in commercial plantations but there are
still reports of sporadic cases of disease recurrence.
Sigatoka leaf spot diseases of banana are caused by Mycosphaerella
fijiensis Morlet (black sigatoka) and M. musicola Leach and Mulder
(yellow sigatoka). The leaf spot diseases destroy banana leaves
leading to decrease in yield and premature ripening of fruits. The
disease is a major limiting factor in the production of export-quality
banana in commercial plantations and smallholder banana farms.
Sigatoka is primarily controlled by regular aerial spray of fungicides
causing enormous expense to Cavendish corporate farms.
Smallholder farmers who do not have the capability and resources
are under the mercy of sigatoka recurring losses as much as 80%.
Viral diseases such as bunchy top and mosaic are widely spread
among local cultivars such as cooking bananas, Saba, Cardaba
and Morado. There is a growing concern on the behavior of mosaic
under Philippine conditions considering the favorable climate, the
cultivation of susceptible banana varieties, the presence of abaca
(Musa textilis Nee) plantations, and other factors (Valmayor 1990).
Banana bunchy top (BBTV) is considered as the most serious disease
present in practically all commercial plantations in the Philippines.
San Juan (1989) stated that the disease had reached epidemic
proportion since it was widespread in both the small and large
farms attacking different cultivars planted by the farmers such as
Lakatan, Latundan, Bungulan, Saba, Cardaba, Giant Cavendish,
Umalag, Señorita and others. Control measures of this disease
consist of: a) early disease recognition and prompt eradication of
infected plants; b) control of its insect vector, Pentalonia nigronervosa
coq.; c) use of virus-free planting materials; and d) quarantine for
areas that are free from the said disease.
In 1994, rehabilitation of BBT-affected areas was initiated in
114 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
southern Mindanao, southern Luzon and northern Luzon areas.
There were some problems encountered by the project, i.e. farmers’
attitude, insufficient source of clean planting materials and lack of
continuous support from the local government units (LGUs).
Based on the accomplishments of the project on rehabilitation of
BBTV-affected areas, success can be attained in small farms
provided the following conditions can be met: a) education of the
farmers and agricultural technicians in the disease symptomatology,
insect vector and control measures;
b) cooperation of the whole community in the prompt eradication
of infected plants; c) availability of virus-free planting materials;
d) availability of technologies to improve production; and e)
continuous support of concerned local government units.
For insect pests, the most destructive is the corm weevil or corm
borer (Cosmopolites sordidus Germar) whose larvae feed on the corm
by making tunnels in it. Control measures consist of trapping and
making the area around the mat/hill always clean. For heavy
infestation, the use of insecticides such as pirimphos-ethyl and
chloripyritos are recommended at manufacturer’s recommended
dosage. Thrips (Thrips florum Schmutz) and Chaetanaphotrips
signipennis Begnall) feed on the fruit peel resulting to corky scab or
reddish brown discoloration. Severely damaged fruits may split
open. Control measures consist of bud injection of insecticide
solution 3-5 days after shooting and by bagging the inflorescence
with chlorypyrifos-impregnated polyethylene bag. The insecticides
used for bud injection are chloropyrifos, methyl parathion
(encapsulated), methamidophus and phoshamidon.
b. Production systems/practices
Four (4) distinct production systems evolved after long years of
cultivating banana in the Philippines (Valmayor 1990). These are:
1. Backyard production system. This is characterized by the diversity
of cultivars in the different regions. Cultivars planted by farmer
is dictated by family needs (i.e. dessert or cooking), quality
preferences of the household members, prevalence of insect pests
and diseases, climatic conditions and ease of production. Very
minimal input goes into this system of production. Only compost
and animal manure are used as fertilizers. Labor is supplied
entirely by family members. Common problem arises in this
system as most of bananas planted receive minimal inputs and
attention; hence, prevalence of pests and their spread is hardly
The Philippine banana industry: Status and prospects 115
cultivars
2. Nutrition
• Establishment of critical nutrient levels for major cultivars
• Nutrient requirements of major cultivars during fruit growth
and development
3. Water relations
• Determination of water requirements based on crop
phenology
• Influence of water on fruit growth and development
4. Cultural management/cropping systems
• Environment-specific management options for major
cultivars
o Characterization of root/shoot growth and function of
major cultivars
• Establishment of sustainable banana-based cropping system
• Establishment of cropping system for typhoon-prone areas
5. Crop protection
• Determination of pest biology, behavior and ecology
• Determination of disease epidemiology
• Control strategies for moko, bugtok, and sigatoka
• Improved IPM programs for major cultivars against BBTV,
sigatoka and fusarium wilt
6. Postharvest system
• Determination of maturity indices, storage requirement,
ripening regulation and physiological disorders
• Improvement of packaging, grading and transport
• Development of postharvest treatment to reduce loss due
to insect pests and diseases
7. Processing, utilization and promotion
• Establishment of processing facilities in production sites
• Development of new high value and novel processed
products and utilization of by-products
• Development of standards for consistent quality of
processed products
• Development of innovative and appropriate packaging for
banana products
• Banana processor-assisted process standardization,
marketing and promotion to create new markets for banana
products
122 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
8. Socio-economics and marketing
• Ex-ante socio-economics evaluation of R&D project on
banana
• Analysis and advocacy of policy options to enhance the
development of small-hold banana sub-industry
• Assessment of factor conditions that affect the growth and
competitiveness of the banana industry
• Analysis and development of entrepreneurial skills among
the small-hold farmers in the country
• Analysis of marketing efficiency and development of
innovative marketing strategies for small-hold banana
growers
The Department of Agriculture program focuses on improved product
development, postharvest handling and enhancement of productivity
of banana farms through control and management of virus and other
diseases, validation of nutrient values and nutritional requirements of
banana plant, cultivar development for disease resistance, population
density studies and biotechnology (BBTV gene constructs).
Proposed ar
Proposed eas of colla
areas bor
collabor ation
bora
Regional cooperation is of utmost importance particularly among
countries of the Asia-Pacific Region where there is a common ecological
conditions, problems and thrusts. Their R&D activities are relevant to
each of their neighbors. Such conditions call for a unified effort among
the member countries to hasten development of the banana industry
in the region:
This meeting is very important for all the participating countries to
identify areas for collaborative R&D to further strengthen our efforts
in the development of the banana industry. As such, the following are
proposed areas of collaboration in banana and plantain research and
development for the region:
a. Research
1. Improved propagation techniques for efficient plantlet
production
2. Strain diversity of major viruses (BBTV, CMV, BBrMV and BSV)
and cross protection studies
3. Development of disease-resistant varieties
4. Vulnerability of disease-free planting materials in the field
The Philippine banana industry: Status and prospects 123
This paper will discuss the current status of banana R&D activities
undertaken in the country and highlight the constraints that the
banana production is facing. Some thoughts on possible areas of
collaboration and opportunities and thrusts to further strengthen the
network arrangements will also be discussed.
Banana industry status
Banana production in the country is still in the hands of the subsistence
farmers and the 85% of the people who live in rural areas. Well over
80% of the bananas produced are cooking types, grown mainly for
household consumption and surplus is sold in urban fresh food markets
for cash income. Less than 20% of the bananas produced in the country
are dessert types grown mostly by semi-commercial set-ups run by
institutions or private growers for the urban fresh fruit market.
Banana production and yield
There are no recent national level data on banana production for PNG.
However, the nationwide household consumption survey that was
carried out in 1996 as part of the World Bank Poverty Assessment
Project, gives some estimates of household production and
consumption. Gibson (2001) reported an estimate of 413 000 tonnes
of bananas produced in 1996 and each person was producing around
85 kg of bananas. The Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO)
estimates for banana production for PNG in 1996 was 665 000 tonnes
(Waterhouse et al 1999). These figures are only estimates and may not
reflect the true situation in the country. It is very difficult to accurately
assess the area under production and the quantity produced and
consumed under subsistence situation.
The bunch yield/hectare depends very much on the varieties, the
growing conditions and the cultural practices. A survey on the banana
production, marketing and consumption carried out in 1986 to 1988
revealed the mean bunch yield of 6.0 t/ha/household was obtained
from a single harvest of diploid bananas (Kambuou 2001). The mean
bunch weight of diploid bananas was 5.4 kg. The triploids have heavier
bunches and would give a higher mean weight of bunch per hectare
per household.
The acreage under dessert bananas is small. The subsistence farmers
grow their dessert bananas amongst the cooking bananas and other
food crops in a mixed cropping manner. There are few semi-commercial
establishments in PNG that grow dessert bananas. The Pacific
Adventist University (PAU) outside Port Moresby is currently growing
Status of banana R&D
Status R&D,, production and consumptionin PNG
production 127
six hectares of varieties Williams and Cavendish for the Port Moresby
fresh fruit market and the students’ mess. They are producing around
27-30 tonnes of banana per hectare. The students are consuming 10%
of what is produced and 90% is sold to the fresh fruit markets in Port
Moresby.
Consumption and trade
Gibson (2001) reported that each person in PNG was consuming
around 83 kg of bananas in 1996 with the rural areas consuming the
highest quantity of 90 kg per head. The FAO estimates imply an average
banana consumption in PNG of 84 kg per head in 1998 (Waterhouse
et al 1999). The FAO estimates closely related to the findings of the
PNG household survey conducted in 1996.
The importance of banana as a food crop is again apparent in
providing 6.9% of the national calories and 7.4% of the rural household
calories (Gibson 2001) (Table 1).
Table 1. Share of total calories (%) provided by bananas and other staple food
crops of PNG.
Food Crops PNG Rural Urban
The average prices of cooking and eating bananas sold in urban markets
throughout the major centres of PNG during January to December
2001 are given in Table 2. It is evident that bananas sold in Mt Hagen
and Port Moresby markets are more expensive than other centres.
This is also true for other food crops.
The data indicate a large spread of prices between markets such as
Popondetta where banana production is low due to few farmers
growing the crop, compared to Rabaul where every household is at
least growing banana. The price for a bunch (five hands) of diploid
128 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Table 2. Average price for bananas sold in seven major centres in PNG during
Jan - Dec 2001 (in PNG Kina*/kg).
Type of Port
Lae Madang Goroka Rabaul Popondetta Mt Hagen
banana Moresby
Dessert/
3.12 0.79 0.70 0.63 0.63 1.91 3.99
sweet
Cooking 1.45 3.57 3.65 1.24 0.50 3.86 2.96
Source: PNG Fresh Produce Development Company, Fresh Produce News, January-December 2001.
*PNG Kina 3.85 = US$ 1.
Production constr
Production aints
constraints
The decline in banana production in PNG is due to a number of factors.
The main factors are pests and diseases, climatic factors, poor farmer
management practices, declining soil fertility, lack of market
infrastructure, inadequate R&D technologies appropriate for adoption
by farmers, limited credit facilities for farmers, poor storage facilities
for fresh fruits, lack of know-how on downstream processing and poor
marketing strategy.
Climatic factors
The climatic pattern has changed so much in the last 5-15 years that it
has severely affected the subsistence way of farming. Rainfall patterns
have changed throughout the country. The dry areas are now
experiencing longer dry seasons and the wetter areas are experiencing
a lot of rain, causing severe landslides and floods. This has forced
farmers to grow landraces that are able to grow under adverse climatic
conditions, thus losing diversity on farm. Climate change has also
created a conducive environment for pest and disease build up and
outbreaks of pests such as locusts and armyworm.
Pests and diseases of bananas
The major insect pests of bananas that are of some concern to the
farmers are banana skippers (Erionota thrax), the fruit flies (Bactrocera
musae) and banana scab moth (Nacoleia octasema). The economic yield
reduction caused by these pests is not fully researched in PNG.
However, Waterhouse (1999) reported that banana skipper could cause
bunch weight loss up to 28% with 50% leaf defoliation.
The most noticeable diseases of bananas in PNG are the leaf spot
complex. These include black sigatoka (Mycosphaerella fijiensis),
cordana (Cordana musae), black cross (Phyllachora musicola) and freckle
(Ramichloridium musae). Sharrock and Jones (1989) reported no firm
evidence that yellow sigatoka, the disease that black sigatoka is known
to have replaced in other countries (Myscosphaerella musicola), ever
existed in PNG. The leaf spot complex mostly affects the diploid AA
and the AAA groups. The triploid ABB groups are resistant, particularly
to black sigatoka. Leaf spot diseases are not a threat to subsistence
banana production because of the resistance and tolerant materials
and the diversity in banana genomes present in PNG.
The two lethal diseases of bananas, the blood disease or bacterial wilt
and the fusarium wilt or panama disease have been reported to spread
to the Irian Jaya Province of Indonesia (Davis et al 2001). Blood disease
132 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
is not yet present in PNG, while the fusarium wilt is currently present
in three locations in PNG, along the Irian Jaya-PNG border. These
diseases would be a serious threat to the subsistence banana production
if and when they arrive and establish in PNG.
Inadequate practical research targeted at subsistence production and
limited understanding of the traditional farming systems
The current research agenda has not given much weight to banana
research, except for germplasm collections and maintenance. More
emphasis should be given to banana farming systems R&D. The new
technologies that are developed should take into account farmers’
knowledge, practices and attitudes and be appropriate for small
farmers’ use. Banana is a cultural crop in PNG, where tradition plays
a major role in determining the growing of certain types or landraces
for special events. Researchers need to be aware of farmers’ practices,
the kind of landraces they grow and how they relate these landraces
to the social events that are taking place.
Poor farmer management practices
In most areas of PNG, subsistence farmers are still practising ‘shifting
cultivation. Farmers are growing bananas with other food crops in a
mixed cropping manner, often at very high densities. Management
input is very low, in terms of labour for weeding, propping, removing
dried leaves and earthing soil around banana bases. No mulch is used
in the gardens, all weeds are gathered at the side and burnt. Farmers
do not desucker their bananas. Suckers are left to grow and produce
bunches or are removed as planting materials for new gardens.
Subsistence farmers aim mainly at producing bananas for the household
consumption and therefore are not too concerned about yield of
banana. The traditional technique of covering banana bunches only
applies to certain areas and for specific landraces that are selected for
customary purposes. Most areas in PNG do not cover banana bunches
and therefore are heavily subjected to damage by bats, birds or insects.
Declining soil fertility
It is evident in some parts of the country like the Gazelle Peninsula
and some areas of the Simbu Province in the highlands of PNG, that
farmers are experiencing shortage of arable land for farming. This is
due mainly to population pressures and the expansion of good arable
land under cash crops such as cocoa, coffee and oil palm. Farmers are
not able to shift their gardens to new sites and therefore are forced
into shortening the fallow period, which used to be 10-15 years, now
Status of banana R&D
Status R&D,, production and consumption in PNG
production 133
processing fresh food crops into other products are available elsewhere
and should be investigated for bananas.
Inadequate delivery of support services (extension) and limited technical
manpower
The delivery mechanism through government service providers is very
ineffective and needs to be properly developed and staff to better assist
the farmers in the rural areas of the country. Information and
technology providers should use other service providers like the Non-
Government Organisations (NGO) agencies. More technical and skilled
workers are required on banana research.
Lack of appropriate machinery for production
Lack of appropriate machinery for farming is a big problem throughout
the country. Subsistence farmers are unable to purchase basic farm
machinery and implements because of high prices and service back-
ups are either poor or very expensive.
Investigation into development and bulk production of appropriate
farm machinery, implements and tools would help farmers to boost
their banana production.
Current banana research and development activities and
institutes involved
R&D work on bananas in PNG is minimal at this stage. Banana has
been considered with other food crops in the farming systems research
agenda, but not as an entity on its own. Research on nutrition and
water, postharvest and integrated pest management on banana has
not been looked at in PNG. Production of banana in the country is
mainly focusing on cooking types as food crops and by subsistence
farmers.
NARI is perhaps the only institution in the country that is doing some
work on bananas. The Institute is currently maintaining the national
banana germplasm collection and the working collections at various
research locations throughout the country where suitable farmer
cultivars or landraces are selected, multiplied and distributed to
farmers for production. There are no service providers that are
specifically involved in banana work. The farmers themselves
effectively distribute planting materials of bananas and other crops.
PNG banana species
Simmonds (1956) and Argent (1976) pointed out that PNG is an
Status of banana R&D
Status R&D,, production and consumption in PNG
production 135
subsistence farmers along river basins outside Port Moresby are growing
diploid cultivars that originated from Morobe, Madang and other
provinces because of their good eating qualities.
NARI also maintains small working collections at the NARI Wet-
lowlands Island site, Keravat (<70 accessions), Wet-lowlands Mainland
site, Bubia (>20 accessions) and Highlands site, Aiyura (26 accessions).
Improved banana breeding lines
NARI, Laloki collaborated with QDPI Mareeba in a Banana Sigatoka
Resistant Variety study conducted in 1999. The 14 FHIA hybrids and
some common cultivars known to be resistant to sigatoka disease were
tested at Laloki during the 1999-2000 growing season. The study
showed that nine breeding lines/cultivars out of 14 were highly
resistant to sigatoka disease. The highly resistant hybrids that yielded
over 20 kg/bunch were FHIA-25, FHIA-03 and FHIA-17. The lines/
cultivars that produced around 16-19 kg/bunch and are also highly
resistant to sigatoka disease were FHIA-18, FHIA-02, FHIA-23, Pisang
Ceylan and SH-3436. Taste panel was carried out on all the lines/
cultivars as dessert bananas. Cultivars SH-3436 and Pisang Ceylan
were recorded as highly liked by the tasters. The lines that were
susceptible to sigatoka disease were SH-3640, Musa acuminata banksii
and Pisang Berlin. Materials for SH-3436 and Pisang Ceylan are being
multiplied for distribution to farmers.
Opportunities and thrusts
There is potential for PNG to develop its banana industry, especially
the cooking bananas for its domestic market. Prices for bananas in the
urban markets throughout the country are very high because of limited
production. General observation showed that the current subsistence
production does not meet the market demands in urban areas. Once
the industry is established, this would encourage more farmers to grow
Status of banana R&D
Status R&D,, production and consumption in PNG
production 137
and sell the crop thus reducing the price of bananas sold in the urban
markets.
The potential for dessert bananas for the domestic market is also high.
The quantity produced at the moment is minimal because of uncertain
markets and lack of information on the demand by urban consumers.
Lack of market infrastructure throughout the country has hindered
the supply of bananas from rural areas to the urban markets.
Opportunities exist for the government to develop feeder roads and
improve the existing road network throughout the country, to alleviate
the problem of accessibility. Proper cold storage depots for fresh produce
need to be established in main centres in the country to assist the
farmers with their produce.
Proposed ar
Proposed eas of colla
areas bor
collabor ations
bora
There may be many areas for collaboration under the Network. The
two areas where PNG as a subsistence producer of bananas would
like to see established is the postharvest and downstream processing
and the plant protection area.
Banana skipper, banana leaf scab and fruit fly may not pose serious
threat to banana production at the moment, but if production increases
through monocropping, economic yield losses will certainly be
experienced.
Banana diseases may not cause economic yield reduction at the
moment, but once the production acreage increases, diseases such as
the leaf spot complex would become a serious problem. Some concerns
have been raised by the Research and Quarantine authorities in PNG,
regarding the spread of the fusarium wilt from the border area of
Sandaun Province to the rest of the country and the introduction and
spread of banana bacterial wilt. Collaboration in research in the area
of banana diseases would be of great benefit to PNG.
The appropriate technology and skills in postharvest handling and
downstream processing of bananas into other food products may have
been researched but not developed in PNG. Collaborative research in
these areas would be of great benefit to the country.
References
Argent, G.C.G. 1976. The wild and cultivated bananas of Papua New
Guinea. Royal Botanical Garden Edinburgh, 35(1): 77-114.
Bourke, R.M. 1976. Know your bananas. Harvest 3(2): 48-54.
138 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Davis, R.I., N.Y. Moore and M. Fegan. 2001. Blood Disease and Panama
Disease: Two Newly Introduced and Grave Threats to Banana
Production on the Island of New Guinea. Food Security for
Papua New Guinea, ACIAR Proceedings No. 99. pp. 816-820.
Gibson J. 2001. The Economic and Nutritional Importance of Household
Food Production in PNG. Food Security for Papua New Guinea,
ACIAR Proceedings No. 99. pp 37-44.
Kambuou R.N. 2001. Review of Germplasm Collections and Agronomic
Research on Bananas in PNG. Food Security for Papua New
Guinea, ACIAR Proceedings No. 99, pp. 809-815.
King G.A. 1986. Review of research on bananas, cassava and yams in
Papua New Guinea. Technical Report 86/6. DPI, Port Moresby.
King, G.A. and P.B. Bull. 1984. The PNG Biological Foundation Banana
Collection. International Board for Plant Genetic Resources.
South East Asian Newsletter 8(2): 3-4.
Sharrock, S. 1989. Collecting Missions in PNG. Musa Conservation
and Documentations. Workshop Proceedings, Leuven, Belgium.
pp 57-58.
Sharrock S. 2000. Diversity in the genus Musa: Focus on Australimusa
in Networking Banana and Plantain. INIBAP Annual Rep.
2000. pp. 14-16.
Sharrock S.I & D.R. Jones. 1989. Report on Third IBPGR/QDPI Banana
Germplasm Collecting Mission to Papua New Guinea. 15 Feb.-
12 Mar. Section 1 - Summary.
Simmonds N.W. 1956. A banana collecting expedition to Southeast
Asia and the Pacific. Tropical Agriculture, Trinidad, 33(44): 251-
271.
Stover R.H. & N.W. Simmonds. 1987. Bananas. London. Longman.
468p.
Waterhouse D., B. Dillion & D. Vincent. 1999. Biological Control of
the Banana Skipper in Papua New Guinea. Cost-benefit analysis
of an ACIAR project. Report, CIE, Canberra & Sydney. pp. 14-
16.
Present status of banana cultivation in Sri Lanka 139
Introduction
Introduction
The total extent of land under fruit cultivation in Sri Lanka is about
90 000 ha and about 50 different fruit crops are found. Banana is the
main fruit crop grown year-round throughout the country. The total
fruit production of the country in 1999 was about 640 000 tonnes, in
which banana constituted 46%. Annual per capita fruit consumption
in Sri Lanka ranges between 21.8 kg to 28 kg and banana is the major
fruit crop consumed.
8
Ambul Kolikuttu Seeni Anamalu Ambun
7
6
5
Price (Rs)
4
3
2
1
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Month
Figure 1. Within year price fluctuation of banana varieties.
(mean for the last 5 years)
Production constr
Production aints
constraints
There are several factors contributing to the low productivity of banana
in Sri Lanka. Lack of high-yielding varieties, prevalence of pest and
diseases, rainfed cultivation, adoption of low plant density and high
postharvest losses are some of the production constraints of banana
cultivation.
Present status of banana cultivation in Sri Lanka 143
Postharvest losses
Banana industry in Sri Lanka is predominantly small farmer based,
catering mainly to domestic market. The postharvest losses of banana
account for about 20%. This is mainly due to the delicate nature of the
fruit when it ripens and lack of suitable infrastructures for transport
144 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
from production points to consumers. Very few processed products
are marketed in Sri Lanka, primarily due to the difficulty in retaining
the characteristic colour, flavour and the tenure during processing.
Research and development
R&D programme is focused on increasing productivity and solving
the field problems.
Varietal Improvement
Varieties obtained from International Musa Testing Programme (IMTP)
of INIBAP were evaluated for their yield and other agronomic
characters. Two varieties were identified as superior and recommended
for cultivation (DOA 2001). Yield data of these varieties and a local
selection is given in Table 6.
Kandula This Cavendish type banana variety can be used both
as a dessert type and cooking purpose. It is an early-
bearing variety with high yield.
Pulathesi A high-yielding Cavendish variety suitable as a cooking
(FHIA-03) banana. It has a robust and semi-dwarf pseudostem
and hence can resist wind damage. It showed resist-
ance to black sigatoka.
Prasad It is a cooking type of banana with high yield and
adaptability to both dry and wet zones.
Angunakolapelessa
Nadee 13.3 14.6 15.2 16.7 15 16.5
Kandula 25.5 28.0 21.5 23.7 25.8 28.4
Pulathesi 26.3 28.9 27.1 29.8 24.3 26.7
Prasad 13.5 14.9 14.2 15.6 15.0 16.5
Mahaiiluppallama
Prasad 13.2 14.5 14.5 15.9 15.3 16.8
* Each figure is mean of nine bunches
Present status of banana cultivation in Sri Lanka 145
2. Exchange of germplasm
• High quality, high-yielding varieties will be exchanged with
the objective of increasing quality and yield of local varieties
3. Exchange of information
• Information on new technological innovations will be
exchanged using print and electronic media
References
Anonymous 2001. Report of the Varietal Release Committee Meeting
of the Department of Agriculture, Sri Lanka.
Ariyarathne I. and T. Liyanage. 2002. Survey on incidences and
severity of virus diseases of banana in Sri Lanka. Pp. 245-254
in Annals of the Sri Lanka Department of Agriculture, Vol. 4.
Dassanayake E.M. and B.M. Rathnabarathi. 2002. Development of
virus free banana foundation stock. Pp. 255-265 in Annals of
the Sri Lanka Department of Agriculture, Vol. 4.
Ekanayake H.M.R.K. , W.W.M.S.N. Wekadapola and K.A.N.P.
Bandara. 2002. Studies on fruit fly infestation in banana
cultivars in Sri Lanka. Pp. 269-274 in Annals of the Sri Lanka.
Department of Agriculture, Vol. 4.
Ekanayake S. and I. Bandara. 2002. Development of banana fruit
leather. in Annals of the Sri Lanka Department of Agriculture,
Vol. 4. pp. 353-358.
Weerasinghe S.S. and K.H. Ruwanpathirana. 2002. Influence of
bagging material on bunch development of banana (Musa spp.)
under high density planting system. Pp. 47-53 in Annals of the
Sri Lanka Department of Agriculture, Vol. 4.
Weerasinghe S.S., P. Weerasinghe, K.H. Ruwanpathirana and H.R.
Premalal. 2001. Internal browning syndrome of banana fruits.
P. 401 in Annals of the Sri Lanka Department of Agriculture,
Vol. 3.
Weerasinghe S.S. 2000. Influence of high density planting on the
productivity of banana (Musa spp.) under irrigated conditions.
Pp. 319-324 in Proceedings of the Annual Symposium of the
Department of Agriculture.
Banana in Thailand 149
Banana in Thailand
Prasert Anupunt*
Introduction
Introduction
As it originated in Southeast Asia, bananas are capable of growing in
a wide range of environmental conditions favourable for the humid
and hot climates. As a non-seasonal crop, year round production is
possible if cultural management is appropriate. Hence, crop
productivity can be controlled to serve the market all throughout the
year.
Banana plays a major role in food security and income generation for
millions of the region’s rural poor. It is an important source of energy
and in addition, it is high in a number of important vitamins and
minerals, providing a nutritious staple food.Apart from fresh
consumption and various processing product uses, the other parts of
banana, including pseudostem and leaf, are also utilized in many Thai
cultural and traditional activities. Mostly, the fruit produce is served
for domestic consumption. A number of fresh fruits and processed
products are also exported to various countries with the value of
approximately 100 million Thai baht (US$2.3 million) each year.
Meanwhile, the crop has developed into a major Thai industry.
Industry status
Planting area and production volume
Bananas are cultivated widely by smallholders in many parts of
Thailand ranging from a small number of plants to orchards of ten
hectares.
Kluai Khai (AA group). It has delicious, good taste and flavour and
the fruits are famed for fresh consumption. The plants, however, are
quite susceptible to yellow sigatoka. The plant and the bunch are rather
small and short in size compared to other bananas. The crop-growing
areas are restricted in the lower northern and the upper-southern
regions, i.e. Kamphaengpet, Nakornsawan, Tak, Sukhothai, Petchburi
and Prachuabkhirikhan.
Kluai Namwa (ABB group). It is the most popular banana in Thailand.
This banana is easily grown and widely adapted to several areas in
the country. In addition, all parts of the plant can be utilised. The
fruits are consumed fresh as desserts or cooked. Pseudostems are used
in social and religious functions and for feeding pigs in the rural areas.
Leaves are also utilized as wrapping material and in art works. The
duration from planting to harvesting lasts about 14 months. The plant
height ranges from two to five meters. There are many clones, namely:
K. Namwa, K. Namwa Daeng, K. Namwa Luang, K. Namwa Khao,
K. Namwa Khom and K. Namwa Ngeon. The production provinces
of K. Namwa are spread from the upper southern region, the central
plain and the lower-northern region, i.e. Chumporn namely, Petchburi,
Rachburi, Nakornpathom, Prathumthani, Phitsanulok and Sukhothai.
Banana in Thailand 151
Table 2. Volume and value of fresh banana fruits exported from Thailand in 2001.
Volume Value
Variety
(t) THB (million) US$ 000
Kluai Hom 1 520 41.5 972.8
Kluai Khai 3 533 48.4 1 134.5
Others 470 5.9 138.3
Source: Department of Customs
Table 3. Volume and value of banana products exported from Thailand in 2001.
Volume Value
Product
(t) THB (million) US$ 000
1. Product in gas filled 198 6.7 157.1
package
2. Dehydrated banana 136 8.7 203.9
3. Banana product with sugar 237 32.4 759.5
Source: Department of Customs.
Production constr
Production aints
constraints
Production practice
In Thailand, banana is mainly grown under rainfed condition and
poor cultural practice management. In addition, most growers are
smallholder producers with limited knowledge on production
technology. Hence, the major problems affecting banana production
are:
- low yield;
- inconsistent quality either in fruit shape, size or characteristics;
- lack of high yielding varieties;
- narrow fruit bearing season leading to oversupply and low prices;
- unsuitable handling, packaging and transportation.
Environmental factors
As mentioned earlier, most orchards are established under rainfed
cultivation system. As such, plants have to be grown at the same period
resulting to overflowing of products into the market at nearly the same
time causing an oversupply. In contrast, in some periods there are no
products available. This circumstance causes disadvantage on export
promotion.
Cur
Currr ent banana R&D activities
activities,, pr og
ogrr ammes
prog
and institutions involved
Banana research is mostly undertaken by government agencies. There
are many institutes involved such as Department of Agriculture,
Department of Agriculture Extension, Kasetsart University,
Chulalongkorn University, Maejo University.
As banana is not the main export crop of the country, there are no
immense R&D plans. Moreover, the financial support on research,
production improvement and marketing system are very limited.
Nevertheless, over the past few years, banana R&D in Thailand are
still undertaken on some areas as follows:
Germplasm collection and conservation
About 175 accessions have been collected and conserved under care
of Department of Agriculture, Department of Agriculture Extension
and Kasetsart University. Most of these have been characterised on
morphology and taxonomy. Some have been used for breeding
programmes.
Banana in Thailand 153
Production system
R&D on production systems are aimed to improve yield and qualities.
Investigation so far, has been carried out on variety improvement and
cultural practices such as:
- Development of production technology for improving growth,
yield and qualities of Grande Naine;
- Effect of sucker size on growth of Grande Naine;
- Sucker-dividing effect on growth of K. Hom, K. Khai and K.
Namwa;
- Effect of media on Grande Naine seedling growth;
- Effect of some foliar fertilizers on growth of Grande Naine
seedling;
- Study on the growth of inflorescence and fruit of K. Hom Khom
- Selection of saline-tolerant varieties through tissue culture
techniques;
- Effect of number of genomes on propagation via tissue culture
methods;
- Increasing number of chromosomes of K. Leb Mu Nang using
colchicine under aseptic condition;
- Banana improvement through tissue culture and gamma
radiation;
- Conservation of abaca (Musa textilis Nee.) under aseptic
condition;
- Study on the possibility of conservation of banana germplasm
with liquid N.
Postharvest
As oversupply of production is a serious problem for growers every
year, most research on postharvest has been emphasized on processing
and utilising banana in various forms. The following are some areas
of research over the past few years:
- Study on appropriate technology for producing banana wine
and liqueur;
- The use of banana and its by-product in cosmetic industry
- Extraction of tannin from banana rind;
- Development of drying banana by using solar energy in
combination with electrical energy;
- Producing banana flour from fruit and other parts;
- Production and utilisation of banana puree;
- Comparison of drying methods for dried banana production;
- Study on banana catsup production and preservation;
154 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
- Investigation on the methods for delayed ripening of K. Namwa
- Shipment trial for sea transportation of K. Khai to Denmark
Integrated pest management (IPM)
There is no immense research on IPM of banana. Nevertheless, there
is a corporation between Japan and Thai cooperatives in producing
either organic or chemical residue-free banana. Meanwhile, the market
of this particular productivity is restricted to Japan and some European
markets.
Opportunities and thrust
Thailand is fortunate for not having serious natural disaster and disease
problems. Due to the localisation and climate, bananas can be grown
throughout the country. In addition, some Thai bananas, such as K.
Hom Thong and K. Khai have a unique flavor.
Proposed areas of collaboration
Although Thailand has no serious problems of viral, bacterial and
fungal infection, other fields of work and problem related to improve
banana production are still awaited for development and solution.
Following are the areas where research collaboration and training are
needed:
- Breeding and crop improvement via conventional, tissue-
culture and genetic-engineering techniques;
- Production technology;
- Germplasm conservation both in vivo and in vitro;
- Exchange of germplasm;
- Tissue-culture and disease-free planting-material propagation;
and
- Postharvest technology.
Update on banana R&D in Vietnam 155
General pr
General oduction sta
production tus
status
Ranging between 80 and 23023’N Vietnam has diverse geographical
features. In the south, it is tropical with two distinct seasons (wet and
dry) while in the north there is a subtropical climate with four seasons:
spring, summer, autumn and winter. As banana can widely adapt to
different climatic conditions, they have long been grown in all the eight
agro-ecological regions in the country. In 1998, Mekong River Delta
ranks first in terms of total banana growing area and fruit production,
followed by Red River Delta (Table 1).
Table 1. Banana production in different regions of Vietnam (1998).
Total growing Average yield Total production
Region
area (ha) (t/ha) (t)
Red River Delta 14 505 18.27 264 964
North East 9 292 15.59 144 891
North West 2 540 12.26 31 142
North Central Coast 13 567 4.63 62 844
South Central Coast 9 052 13.08 118 371
Central Highlands 2 592 8.24 21 360
South East 9 700 27.77 269 364
Mekong River Delta 34 884 11.53 402 253
Total 96 132 1 315 189
The results in Table 1 show that the total banana growing area in
Vietnam was 96 132 ha in 1998 giving total production of 1 315 189
tonnes. At present, farmers are using local varieties with different
genotypes (Table 2).
Table 2. Set of popular banana varieties in Vietnam.
Bunch Growth
Fruit quality,
Cultivars Genotype Location weight duration
utilities
(kg) (months)
Chuoi Ngu AA Red River 8-10 12 Sweet, aromatic,
Delta desert
Chuoi AA Red River 6-8 12 Worship, donation
Tien Delta
Chuoi AAA All regions 20-25 14-16 Dessert, local and
Tieu export
Chuoi AAB Central 8-10 9-10 Dessert, dried
Bom highlands
Chuoi Tay ABB All regions 18-20 12-14 Dessert, collapsed
IMTP III
Propagation
In the recent years, with valuable supports from the Ministry of Science
and Technology, different provincial departments of Science and
Technology have established in vitro laboratories for cell and tissue
culture with the purpose of recovery and multiplication of fruit tree
varieties of high economical values. Therefore application of cell and
tissue culture techniques for rapid propagation of banana has achieved
significant progress.
Update on banana R&D in Vietnam 159
Table 6. The most common banana pests and diseases found in Vietnam.
Occurrence
Scientific name Infection site Note
frequency
Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. whole plant +++ ABB
cubense
Mycosphaerella musicola leaf +++ AAA
(yellow sigatoka)
Mycosphaerella fijiensis (black leaf ++ AA
sigatoka)
Cordana musae leaf +++ ABB
Cladosporium musae leaf ++ both
Periconiella musae leaf + both
Capnodium spp leaf, fruit +++ both
Erwinia spp corm + AAA
Pseudomonas musae leaf ++ both
Macrophoma musae leaf ++ both
Leptophaerella musarium leaf +++ both, north
Banana Bunchy Top Virus whole plant ++ AA
(BBTV)
Cucumber Mosaic Virus (CMV) leaf + both
Banana Streak Virus (BSV) leaf + both
Banana scab moth (Basilepta) skin young fruit ++ AA
Banana weevil borer corm, ++ AAA, ABB,
pseudostem highland
Nematode root, corm + both, highland
160 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
The most important diseases found were:
Fusarium wilt: This disease occurs in all the ecological regions in the
whole country. However, it is more often observed in the south than
in the north, and mostly on C.Tay (Pisang Awak, ABB group). It attacks
banana plants at 4-6 month of age and at the flowering stage. Fusarium
wilt in Vietnam is caused by Foc that belongs to race 1.
Sigatoka: This disease spreads at a large scale in the Mekong River
Delta in the south. Yellow sigatoka (Mycosphaerella musicola) damages
banana at a higher rate than black sigatoka (Mycosphaerella fijiensis)
and is found mainly on Cavendish group (AAA).
Among viruses found on banana in Vietnam, BBTV is the most
important one, discovered in all ecological regions and causing heavy
damage on Cavendish group.
A joint project entitled “Identification of nematodes resistance and
tolerance in Vietnamese Musa germplasm for improvement of banana
production” between INIBAP and VASI was carried out under the
assistance of VVOB and ACIAR. The following activities have been
done during the process of the project:
1. Assessment of the occurrence and distribution of nematodes on
wild and cultivated bananas in north and central Vietnam
Surveys have been carried out in some northern provinces and in the
central part of Vietnam as well as in 3 natural habitats in north
Vietnam. Some wild banana species [C. Rung (VN1-026), C. Rung
Hoa Do (VN1-049) and C. Tay Rung (VN1- 051)] and some common
cultivars [C. Tieu (AAA), C. Tay (ABB) and C. Hot (BB)] were sampled.
With the exception of Radopholus similis, the most important Musa
nematodes, i.e. Pratylenchus coffeae, Meloidogyne spp. and
Helicotylenchus multicinctus, were found on both wild and cultivated
bananas. This means that the natural soils of Vietnam are infested
with these nematodes and we therefore infer that these species are
indigenous to Southeast Asia. Meloidogyne spp. seemed to have a
negative influence on the growth of banana plants while the effect of
P. coffeae on Musa plant growth was not very clear.
2. Establishment and maintenance of in vitro nematode cultures
Eleven P. coffeae populations collected from different areas in Vietnam
are being maintained in vitro on carrot discs to provide for
morphological and biological studies. A population of Meloidogyne spp.
collected from Habac province is being propagated in the roots of
Update on banana R&D in Vietnam 161
Dif
Diffficulties
During past years, banana production has not been developed due to
an extensive cultivation of (?) banana production, use of undeveloped
Update on banana R&D in Vietnam 163
References
Molina A.B., V.N. Roa and M.A.G. Maghuyop (eds.). 2000. Advancing
banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the Pacific, Vol. 10.
158p.
Nhi H.H., A.B. Molina, I. Van den Bergh and P.T. Sen. 2000. Highlights
of Musa research and development in Vietnam. Proceedings of
a meeting held in Hanoi, Vietnam, 7/8 June 2000. 195p.
164 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Valmayor R.V., S.H. Jamaluddin, B. Silayoi, L.D. Danh, O.C. Pascua
and R.R.C. Espino. Banana cultivar names and synonyms in
Southeast East Asia. 24p.
Van den Bergh I. 2002. Host-plant response of Vietnamese bananas
(Musa spp.) to plant-parasitic nematodes. Dissertationes de
Agricultura no. 547, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium.
161p.
Banana R&D in the Pacific 165
Tom Osborn*
• Poor soil fertility reduces yield, fruit size and quality. Fertilizer is
seldom used on banana, however the tradition is to use animal
manure and organic matter.
Markets
Bananas was a major export earner for the Pacific Islands until the
1970s with exports going to New Zealand and other developed country
markets. However, the large transnational banana producers then
captured these markets based on price and quality, so the Pacific
countries’ profitable export markets quickly disappeared. There are
still a few small banana exporters in the region, based on niche exports
such as organic banana. The major constraint to banana production
is thus a lack of an export market to absorb higher levels of production.
The result is that farmers are limited to the small local market or
producing from home consumption. They lack the incentive to invest
in increased production and improving the quality of bananas. This
also means that NARS do not target bananas as a priority crop for
research and extension.
Current banana research and development
SPC Regional Germplasm Centre
The SPC Regional Germplasm Centre distributes accessions of bananas,
taro, yams, sweet potatoes and other vegetatively propagated crops
to the 22 SPC member countries and territories. INIBAP has provided
FHIA lines and modest funding for the multiplication and distribution
of new banana lines in the region. FHIA-01, -02, -03, -17, -18, -23 and
-25 have been distributed to American Samoa, Cook Islands, Federated
States of Micronesia (FSM), Marshall Islands, New Caledonia, Palau,
Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, and Wallis and Futuna. Distribution
of thousands of accessions of the FHIA lines is continuing. Reports
indicate interest in the material, but in most cases the new lines have
not reached farmers’ fields yet.
• Recent results from New Caledonia indicate FHIA-17, -18 and -23
had excellent BLS resistance but grew very slowly during and after
the cool dry season. Earlier results of organoleptic testing indicate
that FHIA-01 is acceptable as a dessert banana and FHIA-02 is
acceptable as a cooking banana. These lines are being distributed
to farmers for testing.
• In the FSM, the FHIA trials conducted by the community college
indicate the resistance to BLS is excellent but organoleptic tests
have not been conducted yet.
168 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
• American Samoa reported that FHIA-25 produces well and is
resistant to BLS, but Samoans prefer a cooking banana with a
harder texture. Suckers are being distributed to farmers for further
testing.
• FHIA-01 has been distributed in Samoa for many years. An
INIBAP- funded survey in Samoa through the University of the
South Pacific indicates acceptance of FHIA-01.
• In Wallis and Futuna the FHIA lines are being distributed to
farmers.
There have been problems with confusion over the identification of
the 7 FHIA lines. What is needed is a guide to the identification and
characteristics of the lines. We hope that this will be available soon.
New Caledonia
Since 1990, the Pocquereux Fruit Research Station of the Institute of
New Caledonian Agriculture (with links to CIRAD) has had a banana
research programme to control BLS through chemical methods,
selection of BLS tolerant banana cultivars and epidemiological studies
to better understand the interaction between the pathogen, the plant
and the climate. These efforts are linked with extension efforts with
both subsistence and commercial banana producers. Pocquereux also
participates in the Musa Germplasm Information System (MGIS). The
station is one of the BLS evaluation sites for the Banana Improvement
Project (BIP), which evaluates 80 different cultivars with the aim of
selecting diploids as parents for breeding programmes. This is our
leading center of banana research in the region.
ACIAR/QDPI Banana Improvement Project
This project conducted important banana research in the Pacific during
the late 1980s and early 1990s, with collaborating Ministries of
Agriculture in the Cook Islands, Samoa and Tonga. Trials were
conducted to screen improved banana lines for pest and disease
resistance as well as to better understand these pests. Training and
technical assistance were also an important component of this project.
It is important to note that QDPI and other Australian banana
researchers are an important source of technical assistance for the
Pacific Islands on banana-related problems.
Banana R&D in the Pacific 169
Future Dir
Future ections ffor
Directions or Bananas in the Pacif
Pacif ic with INIB
acific AP
INIBAP
25000
Cook Islands
Fiji Islands
20000 French Polynesia
Guam
Kiribati
FSM
Production (Mt)
15000
New Caledonia
Niue
Samoa
10000
Solomon Islands
Tokelau
Tonga
5000 Tuvalu
Vanuatu
Wallis and Futuna Is
0
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001
Year
Annex 1
Fe’i banana research in the Federated States of Micronesia
Health research relating to banana has been conducted by the nutritionist, Lois
Englberger, in Kosrae and Pohnpei, two of the four states of the Federated States
of Micronesia (FSM). The overall aim of her research related to identification of
foods which might contribute to vitamin A status, as vitamin A deficiency has
been identified as a serious health problem in the country, both among children
and women, affecting not only eye health and vision but increased morbidity and
mortality. Her work on banana has included:
• A dietary study that showed banana fits into the present daily diet.
Provitamin A carotenoids, most importantly beta-carotene, contribute to vitamin
A status and protection against vitamin A deficiency. Epidemiological evidence
indicates that consumption of carotenoids (including those which have no vitamin
A activity) decreases risk to certain chronic diseases, such as cancer, heart
disease and diabetes, which have also become serious health problems in FSM.
Yellow and orange coloration of the edible flesh was used for selecting those
cultivars for analysis which might have the most potential for health benefits,
based on the fact that carotenoids often may be identified by those color traits.
Some common cultivars without yellow or orange coloration were analyzed for
purposes of comparison. Increased coloration was found to closely match with
increased carotenoid content, with five distinct colors identified in the cultivars,
white, creamy, yellow, yellow-orange and orange.
In all, 17 banana cultivars from Kosrae and Pohnpei were analyzed and
characterised. There was a great range of carotenoid content, from 30 to 6360
µg/100 g edible portion. The Karat banana cultivar was found to contain over 25
times the beta-carotene content of the common Cavendish, and the Uht En Yap
cultivar was found to contain 250 times the beta-carotene content of the common
Cavendish. Thirteen Micronesian cultivars were identified which would provide
the total or up to half of the estimated daily requirements for vitamin A, within
normal eating patterns.
It was concluded that certain cultivars of banana have particular potential in FSM
for providing important health benefits and decreasing risk to vitamin A deficiency
and chronic diseases. On that basis, it was concluded that these cultivars should
be promoted for family consumption and possible commercialization. Lack of
planting material is a major limitation at present. A study of Chuuk and Yap
cultivars has not yet been carried out. It is suggested that nutritional projects, in
conjunction with agricultural agencies, would have great benefit for both the health
and agriculture sectors in FSM. It is also suggested that certain banana cultivars
elsewhere may be identified for promotion and increased health and enjoyment.
Somaclonal variation approach to breeding Cavendish banana 173
Abstract
Fusarium wilt of banana, caused by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense
(Foc) race 4, is the major constraint for cultivation of banana in Taiwan.
For obtaining a resistant variety to replace the susceptible Cavendish,
Taiwan Banana Research Institute (TBRI) initiated an innovative
breeding program based on somaclonal variation approach. This
breeding program which began in 1984, already produced a total of
13 resistant/tolerant clones; all derived from the wilt-susceptible
variety Giant Cavendish. To solve the fusarium wilt problem, three of
them were released as the new varieties, Tai-Chiao No.1 in 1992, Tai-
Chiao No.3 in 2001 and Formosana in 2002, for commercial
production. The former two varieties are mediocre in resistance to
fusarium wilt and in productivity, and moderate success has been
obtained. Formosana not only showed a high level of resistance to
fusarium wilt but also produced a bunch about 40% heavier than that
of its progenitor Giant Cavendish, a breakthrough in banana breeding.
This new variety was released for commercial planting beginning
January 2002 to replace both Tai-Chiao No.1 and Tai-Chiao No.3. With
its superb agronomic and horticultural characteristics, it is believed
that Formosana will soon become the major banana variety grown in
Taiwan. The novel breeding strategy based on somaclonal variation
has proved to be a useful method for the improvement of banana.
Introduction
Introduction
In Asia, the oldest international banana trade exists in Taiwan where
banana production for exporting to the neighbouring Japanese market
began in the early 1900s. The banana industry, involving small
producers mostly, expanded rapidly and reached the peak production
on over 50 000 hectares in the mid-1960s, ranking Taiwan the second
largest banana-exporting country in the world. Under the subtropical
climate, bananas produced in Taiwan have top eating quality, and
they are highly esteemed in the Japanese market.
*Director, TBRI, Chiuju, Pingtung, Taiwan.
174 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Over the last 20 years, production of Cavendish banana in Taiwan,
however, has been seriously jeopardized by the intractable fusarium
wilt (Hwang 1985; Su et al. 1977). The fungus attacking Cavendish,
previously considered highly resistant to this disease, belongs to the
type of race 4 of Foc (Su et al. 1977). The disease, found in 1967, has
spread rapidly to epidemic proportions within few years and caused
considerable losses to the banana growers. At present, about 4000 of
the total 6000 hectares of banana growing in the central and southern
part of Taiwan is affected. Attempts in controlling the disease using
soil sanitation, soil fumigation and soil amendment, etc. were
unsuccessful (Hwang 1985; Su et al. 1986). A commercially acceptable
resistant variety is needed, urgently.
Banana breeding based on the traditional crossing (pollinating)
approach is extremely difficult, for Cavendish especially, because of
the female seed sterility inherent in Cavendish varieties. Over seventy
years of crossing a short Gros Michel with a resistant diploid to obtain
a resistant tetraploid competitive with the Cavendish cultivars has
been unsuccessful (Stover and Buddenhagen 1986). For this reason,
for obtaining a fusarium wilt resistant Cavendish, an innovative
breeding approach based on somaclonal variation was taken by the
TBRI in 1984 (Hwang and Ko 1988; 1991). This paper gives an account
of the progress this breeding program has made highlighting the recent
development of a superb high-yielding, fusarium-resistant variety,
Formosana, a breakthrough in banana breeding.
In vitro pr
vitro opa
propagation and somac
opag lonal v
somaclonal aria
varia tion
ariation
Although in vitro propagation of vegetatively propagated crops such
as banana has shown the potential for producing substantial genetic
variability, known as somaclonal variation (Snowcroft and Larkin
1982), it is generally believed that the probability of success in obtaining
an improved Cavendish clone that also corrects its susceptibility to
fusarium wilt race 4 based on somaclonal variation would be extremely
low, if not impossible. The key to the success is to produce a large
number of seedlings in vitro for screening.
The initiative of the development of tissue culture program at TBRI
came from the fusarium wilt. As a systemic disease, it spreads readily
through the movement of infested suckers, the conventional planting
material used by farmers (Hwang 1985; Su et al. 1986). The adoption
of disease-free plantlets by farmers has proved useful to check the
spread of the disease (Hwang et al. 1984; Su et al. 1986). Field surveys
revealed that these plants showed up to 3% somaclonal variation
Somaclonal variation approach to breeding Cavendish banana 175
Improvement of rresistant
Impro esistant clones
clones
With exception of the latest selected clone GCTCV-218 which is
horticulturally superior to its progenitor Giant Cavendish, all the rest
of resistant clones are inferior either in agronomic traits or in yield
(Hwang and Ko 1988; 1989). As indicated in Table 1, many resistant
clones possess undesirable agronomic characters such as excessive
height, weak petiole with drooping leaves, and produce under-sized
bunch, while others like GCTCV-216 and GCTCV-217 produce heavy
bunches but having too large hands of the former and too short fingers
of the latter, rendering them unacceptable to the market. Selection of
improved variants from these inferior resistant clones was attempted,
again based on somaclonal variation approach.
When large numbers of tissue-cultured plantlets of resistant clones
were planted in the field, a few plants with improved agronomic
characters were found in each clone (Hwang and Ko 1989). These
improved types had thicker pseudostems, grew faster, and produced
bigger bunches than their respective resistant progenitors. The clone
GCTCV-119 for instance, the bunch weight of the original resistant
parent was 17.2 kg. only, while that of the improved variant was
increased up to 26.5 kg. The growing cycle of the improved variant
was also shortened from 15 months of its progenitor to 13 months
only. The frequency of improved variants found in these resistant clones
varied from 0.2 to 10.1% (Hwang and Ko 1989). Of considerable interest
is that the gene(s) conferring resistance to Foc race 4 in most of the
resistant clones appears to be transmissible to their respective improved
variants. Among these four improved variants tested, GCTCV-44-1,
GCTCV-53-1 and GCTCV-119-1 remained to be resistant to Foc race
4, and GCTCV-40-1 only had lost wilt resistance (Hwang and Ko 1989)
as shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Fusarium wilt on improved variants compared to their resistant parents.
Conclusion
For decades, banana production in Taiwan has been greatly challenged
by the intractable fusarium wilt problem. For the control, the
susceptible variety Giant Cavendish must be replaced by the resistant
variety. For obtaining a resistant Cavendish whose breeding based on
180 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
crossing has been seriously handicapped by the female seed sterility,
an appropriate method for breeding must be developed. Because in
vitro propagation of banana has shown the potential for producing
substantial genetic variability, a novel approach based on somaclonal
variation was taken by TBRI in 1984 (Hwang and Ko 1984). Much
interest, support and effort have been devoted in this direction over
the past 16 years leading to the continued discovery of many
interesting, useful resistant clones and to the release of three
commercially acceptable resistant varieties, Tai-Chiao No.1, Tai-Chiao
No.3 and Formosana for commercial production in Taiwan. The most
ideal variety Formosana is now planted in about 1500 ha of infested
farms, saving the banana industry from destruction by fusarium wilt.
The most significant achievement made by this breeding program is
the successful development of the superb variety, Formosana. The plant
brings together many useful traits including fusarium wilt resistance,
high-yielding, improved agronomic characters and improved fruit
quality, a breakthrough in banana breeding. This is the most productive
Cavendish considered by TBRI. Commercialization of Formosana
would have great impact on Taiwan banana industry. First, it would
reduce the loss of production to fusarium wilt from the present 15%
level to less than 5% every year. Second, the yield per hectare would
be increased by over 50%, hence greatly reducing the production cost,
the key constraint for banana production in Taiwan. Third, for decades,
Taiwan banana has been suffering a seasonal uneven ripening problem
that greatly reduces its competitiveness in the Japanese market.
Planting Formosana to replace Giant Cavendish will solve this problem
for bananas produced by Formosana ripen evenly. Fourth, it is believed
that planting the most productive Cavendish variety Formosana has
great potential for Taiwan bananas to enter the new export markets
because of its lower production cost and better fruit quality, thus more
competitive on international market.
In comparison with the traditional banana breeding based on crossing
(pollinating) which has not produced any improved Cavendish variety
for commercial use over the past 70 years, the somaclonal variation
breeding has proved to be an efficient, useful approach for the
improvement of Cavendish cultivars. The innovative approach has
the following features that make the selection so efficient and thus the
goal of breeding attainable.
1. A wide range of genetic variability found among in vitro mass-
produced plants offers a higher probability of success in selecting
desirable mutated traits. As shown in this study, the chance of
Somaclonal variation approach to breeding Cavendish banana 181
References
Hwang S.C., C.L. Chen, J.C. Lin and H.L. Lin. 1984. Cultivation of
banana using plantlets from meristem culture. HortSci. 19:231-
233.
Hwang S.C. 1985. Ecology and control of fusarial wilt of banana. Plant
Prot. Bull. (Taiwan) 27:233-245.
Hwang S.C. 1986. Variation in banana plants propagated through
tissue culture. J. of the Chinese Soc. of Hort. Sci. 32:117-125.
Hwang S.C. and W.H. Ko. 1988. Mutants of Cavendish banana
resistant to race 4 of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense. Plant Prot.
Bull. (Taiwan) 30:386-392.
Hwang S.C. and W.H. Ko. 1989. Improvement of fruit quality of
Cavendish banana mutants resistant to race 4 of Fusarium
oxysporum f. sp. cubense. Plant Prot. Bull. (Taiwan) 31:131-138.
Hwang S.C. and W.H. Ko. 1991. Somaclonal resistance in Cavendish
banana to Fusarium wilt. Plant Prot. Bull. (Taiwan) 33:124-132.
Hwang S.C. and W.H. Ko. 1992. Breeding for resistance to fusarial
wilt of Cavendish banana by using tissue culture method. Pp. 229-
237 in Proceedings of the SABRAO International Symposium on
the Impact of Biological Research on Agricultural Productivity held
at Taichung, Taiwan.
Hwang S.C., W.H. Ko. and C.P. Chao. 1994. GCTCV-215-1: a
promising Cavendish clone resistant to race 4 of Fusarium oxysporum
f. sp. cubense. Plant Prot. Bull. (Taiwan) 36:281-191.
Hwang S.C. and H.J. Su. 1998. Production of virus-free banana
plantlets in Taiwan. FFTC Extension Bull. No.460, 7p.
Hwang S.C. and C.Y. Tang. 2000. Unconventional banana breeding
in Taiwan. Pp.449-464 in Disease of Banana, Abaca and Ensete.
CABI Publishing, CAB International, UK.
Stover R.H. and I.W. Buddenhagen. 1986. Banana breeding polyploidy:
disease resistance and productivity. Fruits 41:175-191.
Su H.J., T.Y. Chuang and W.S. Kong. 1977. Physiological race of fusarial
wilt fungus attacking Cavendish of Taiwan. Taiwan Banana Res.
Inst. Spec. Publ. 2. 21p.
Su H.J., S.C. Hwang and W.H. Ko. 1986. Fusarial wilt of Cavendish
banana in Taiwan. Plant Dis. 70:814-818.
Somaclonal variation approach to breeding Cavendish banana 183
Bananas and plantains are fruits most extensively grown in Asia. The
fruits are non-seasonal and therefore consumed the whole year round.
As the premier fruit of the region, bananas and plantains contribute
significantly to the diet and nutrition of the people, particularly the
poor. This important fruit commodity, which is grown primarily for
domestic consumption, is an important source of income to numerous
small farmers and entrepreneurs.
In November 1984, a group of countries and organizations established
the International Network for the Improvement of Banana and Plantain
(INIBAP) with headquarters in Montpellier, France. INIBAP’s mandate
includes coordination of research efforts, dissemination of research
information and generation of funds to support priority research and
development activities on bananas and plantains. Recognizing the
enormous complexity involved in world banana agriculture and to
ensure relevance and flexibility in its program thrusts, INIBAP decided
to set up regional networks in West Africa, East Africa, Latin America
and the Caribbean and finally Asia and the Pacific in 1991.
Asia is the recognized Center of Origin of the genus Musa and
possesses the greatest wealth of banana germplasm in the world. It is
also the source of practically all commercial cultivars of dessert bananas
and holds an enormous collection of hardy and high-yielding cooking
bananas with great potential for the other regions of the world. The
Asia-Pacific Network (ASPNET) in 1991 started with Australia, China,
India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand, and the Taiwan
Banana Research Institute (TBRI) as its initial members and later
expanded to also include Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Vietnam, Pakistan
and the Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC).
The relaunching of the regional network
While INIBAP is pleased with the progress made by the network, there
was a need to review the modus operandi of the network under the
framework of the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) of collaboration
signed between IPGRI International Plant Genetic Resources Institute
Introduction
Introduction
Southeast Asia and the Pacific is the centre of diversity of the genus
Musa. This diversity includes a wide range of wild species, which are
divided amongst the sections Australimusa, Callimusa, Rhodochlamys,
Eumusa and a large number of different types of cultivated banana
varieties which fall into various genome groups (AA, AAB, AAB etc).
This diversity provides the raw materials used by banana breeding
programmes to develop new, improved high yielding varieties with
enhanced capacity to withstand pest and disease attack. These
improved varieties are starting to be introduced and grown in many
countries in the Asia-Pacific region.
Due to the high levels of sterility in most cultivars, banana breeding is
a complicated, time consuming and expensive task. For this reason,
very few breeding programmes exist in the world, and most of the
major programmes are located outside Asia. For this reason, there is a
great interdependence between countries and regions for Musa
germplasm.
INIBAP’
INIBAP’
AP’s ole in Musa div
s rrole er
diver sity mana
ersity gement
manag
Conservation
INIBAP maintains the world collection of Musa germplasm. This
collection is held in vitro at the INIBAP Transit Centre (ITC), which is
located at the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (KUL), Belgium. This
collection of germplasm is held ‘in trust’ for the world community
and ownership of the accessions in the collection remains with the
country of origin. All material held in the world collection is provided
to INIBAP under the terms and conditions of a Germplasm Acquisition
Agreement (GAA) which confirms that the material will stay in the
public domain, and will be made freely available for distribution on
request. The world collection acts as a safety back-up, or duplicate
*Germplasm Conservation Scientist, INIBAP, Montpellier, France.
This paper is a shortened version of a paper prepared by Olivier Guinard, an intern with
the Quebec Ministry of International Relations as part of his internship with INIBAP. A
copy of the full version of the paper is available from INIBAP on request.
192 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
collection for NARS, and accessions are available for repatriation,
should they be lost from national collections.
Collecting
INIBAP supports germplasm collecting activities, with a particular
focus on filling gaps in germplasm collections. In recent years, collecting
missions have been held in China, Vietnam and Indonesia.
Distribution
All accessions in the world collection maintained by INIBAP are held
in vitro and are routinely indexed for the presence of virus infections.
In line with the Guidelines for the safe international movement of Musa
germplasm, only those accessions in which no virus particles are found
are made freely available for distribution. All germplasm is distributed
under the terms and conditions of a Material Transfer Agreement which
ensures that the germplasm stays in the public domain.
Characterisation
INIBAP carries out molecular and cytological analysis of all germplasm
it maintains. This information is made freely available to users of the
germplasm, as well as to germplasm curators and researchers in the
country of origin of the germplasm. Such information thus adds value
to the germplasm and supplements characterisation and evaluation
data collected by users of the germplasm.
Information management - the Musa Germplasm information System
(MGIS)
Following a request by Musa researchers and genebank curators,
INIBAP has developed an information system which allows genebank
curators to efficiently manage the information they generate about
the accessions in their collections. As well as being a tool for curators,
the MGIS also provides a mechanism by which information can be
exchanged between curators. All data entered in MGIS remains the
property of the country entering the data, but by sending updates to
INIBAP, national data can also be incorporated into the global
database. The global database is made available by INIBAP to
participating institutes on CD-ROM and will shortly be available for
free consultation on the internet.
MGIS presently contains passport data for 4810 accessions from 16
different institutes, and these include photographs for 763 accessions.
Characterization data is available for 1745 accessions and agronomic
evaluation data for 1643 accessions. MGIS is therefore a mine of
Musa diversity in Southeast Asia - An analysis of data 193
13% 9%
Wild
Cultivars
Unclassified
78%
AAA/AAB
AT/AAT
0.16% 0.79%
AAS
ABB 0.03% Fe'i
BBB AA
12.01% 0.74%
0.29% 26.13%
AB
3.44%
AS
AAB 0.16%
31.02%
AAA
25.23%
400
350
300
No of accessions
250
200
150
100
50
0
Australimusa Callimusa Rhodochlamys Eumusa
malaccensis
17.25%
unclassified burmanica
30.59% 1.96%
burmaniccoides
1.18%
truncata
0.39%
zebrina banksii
5.10% 32.94%
microcarpa siamea
7.45% 3.14%
Chuoi Xiem
Personal speculation
Malaysia
No records from Malaysia have been entered in MGIS and only a few
cultivars originating from Malaysia, which are present in other
collections around the world, are recorded in the database. These
include 6 accessions which are recorded by INIBAP as being present
in the international collection. None of the wide diversity of wild
species from Malaysia is recorded in MGIS.
Musa diversity in Southeast Asia - An analysis of data 197
Indonesia
Information on the germplasm collection maintained by the Research
Institute for Fruits (RIF) in Solok, Indonesia is available in MGIS. A
total of 197 accessions have been recorded in the database. Following
a literature search, 60 accessions known from Indonesia are not
recorded in any collection in MGIS. Only 7 accessions from the RIF
collection are duplicated in the international collection. An analysis of
the extent of diversity present in the collection revealed that a wide
range of cultivar genotypes and wild species are maintained in the
genebank.
One problem regarding data from Indonesia related to the
nomenclature used. For example, the accession Susu which is present
in several collections, recorded as originating in Indonesia in MGIS,
and is listed as an Indonesian accession by Valmayor (1990), is not
listed as Susu by RIF. Instead, the RIF collection lists: Susu olahan,
Susu ternate and Klutuk susu. It is not clear which Susu is being
referred to by the other collections. A similar problem exists with the
accession Kepok
Thailand
No data from Thailand has been recorded in MGIS. However, 37
accessions are present in the international collection originating from
Thailand and many accessions are present in the regional collection
in the Philippines. Many wild Musa species are known to exist in
Thailand but none of these are recorded in MGIS.
Papua New Guinea
The national Musa germplasm collection is maintained by the National
Agricultural Research Institute at Laloki. To date, only 39 out of a
collection of 309 accessions have been recorded in MGIS. This lack of
data relates to computer problems in PNG. However, more than 250
accessions from the collection are duplicated at both South Johnstone
Research Station in Australia and in the international collection.
Information about PNG accessions is therefore available from data
entered by South Johnstone and INIBAP. Such data includes
characterisation data as well as molecular and cytological data. An
analysis of the extent of diversity included in the collection shows that
both cultivars and wild species are well represented and the diversity
reflects that found in the country as a whole.
198 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
China
Information on Chinese accessions is available from the South China
Agricultural University (SCAU). Information on 98 accessions is
available and these consist mainly of AAA and ABB cultivars. No
accessions from China have been sent to the international collection.
Conclusions and recommendations
During this first analysis of data in MGIS, some immediate difficulties
were identified:
• Lack of data – especially related to origin of accessions.
• Searches by name were difficult due to the use of vernacular
prefixes, such as Chuoi, Pisang, Kluai
• The use of special characters (Vietnamese) which could not be
recognised by non-Vietnamese computers;
• Inconsistencies in the naming of wild species:
- Musa acuminata ssp. banksii
- M. acuminata ssp. banksii
- M. banksii
- Banksii
- Etc.
As a result of this work, a number of recommendations were made:
• Efforts should be made to add data from important missing
collections (Malaysia, Thailand)
• Existing data needs to be completed and corrected;
• NARS should make more effort to include wild species in
germplasm collection
• Vernacular names should be standardised, and the use of prefixes
should be avoided
• Full scientific names should be used for wild species. e.g. Musa
acuminata ssp. banksii;
• Data on the origin of accessions should be completed to assist
further analysis using GIS tools such as DIVA-GIS
Finally, it was recommended that, in recognition of the interdependence
of countries for germplasm, and following the agreement that has been
reached on the International Treaty for Plant Genetic Resources for
Food and Agriculture, countries should share germplasm and related
Musa diversity in Southeast Asia - An analysis of data 199
Introduction
Introduction
DIVA-GIS is a computer software developed by the International Potato
Centre (CIP) and the International Plant Genetics Resources Institute
(IPGRI) to map and analyse biological diversity. It was specifically
designed to help spatially analyse the distribution of germplasm as
well as their specific traits – morphological or genetic (Hijmans et al.
2001; Hijmans et al. 2002).
In 2002, INIBAP carried out a preliminary investigation into the
potential use of DIVA-GIS as a tool to analyse data recorded in the
Musa Germplasm Information System (MGIS). The benefits of carrying
out GIS-based analysis are considered to be as follows:
At the global level:
• The ability to build maps showing the location of germplasm
collections and provide access to environmental data at those
sites through a single click;
• The ability to build maps showing the spatial distribution of Musa
diversity, at the district, national, regional or even global scale;
• Providing assistance in decision-making regarding collecting
campaigns;
• Providing the capacity to analyse diversity distribution according
to environmental factors;
• Establishing correlations between the geographical distribution of
varieties and species and the distribution of the main pests and
diseases;
• Associating environmental factors with specific genetic traits;
• Improving MGIS data by checking the integrity of location
information in MGIS;
Results
Visualizing Musa distribution
A first map was generated to show the original location (collecting
site) of accessions used in the study (Figure 1). This map also highlights
the countries from which data was availability for use with DIVA.
Countries with valid MGIS data are coloured green, while other
countries with MGIS data but no collecting site coordinates were
coloured grey.
Wild Musa accessions were then categorized and displayed on a map
204 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
according to their respective taxonomic sections. The map (Figure 2)
showed that recent collecting missions in China have revealed the
presence of Musa laterita (Rhodochlamys) on the border of the Guangxi
province of China and northern Vietnam, much to the east of where
this species had been reported previously. An even more striking
example is a Musa coccinea (Callimusa) accession reported in the
Guangdong province of China, which if truly native, and not
introduced, could expand the traditional distribution of the Callimusa
section much to the northeast.
These first maps show the limited areas in which germplasm has so
far been collected and for which relevant data is available. However,
they also illustrate how DIVA-GIS can help in determining in which
regions to organize future collecting missions, as well as providing a
clear means to visualise the distribution of diversity in any given area.
A B
C D
Figure 3. Musa morphlogical trit distribution in Southeast Asia. All characteristics included
in the Musa accessions that contained data were displayed in DIVA-GIS and
maps were selected on the basis of highlighting regional differences.
(A) Sucker development. (B) Pseudostem aspect. (C) Fruit length. (D) Fruit
pulp colour at maturity.
most “high richness” grid cells simply reflect the regions targeted by
INBAP and their collaborators in collecting missions held in the past
two decades.
With regard to diversity conservation, DIVA-GIS also contains a
function that prioritizes areas of richness in order of decreasing
importance. Briefly, the grid cell with the greatest number of distinct
species is identified and ranked one, while the species it harbours are
removed from the “total” list of species identified; a second grid-cell
containing the largest number of distinct remaining species is ranked
“2”, and so on. This type of analysis can be used to identify, for example,
priority areas for in situ conservation.
206 Advancing banana and plantain R&D in Asia and the P
Adv acif
Pacif ic - V
acific ol 11
Vol
A
Associating accessions with geo-referenced climate data
With DIVA-GIS, it is possible to associate accession-coordinates with
geo-referenced climate data observed from 1961 to 1990 and available
from the DIVA-GIS website. Through this feature, one can examine
the specific growth environment of a particular accession with regards
to mean annual rainfall, lowest and highest temperatures, average
temperature, etc. It is also possible to visualize the climate spectrum
associated with Musa occurrence. Using data related to wild accessions
a map was created showing that wild Musa species mainly occur in
locations where there is an average annual temperature of between
20 and 27 degrees Celsius and where there is 1300 to 4000 mm of
precipitation. DIVA-GIS is also able to locate the areas of a defined
Gone by 2040-2060
Still present in 2040-2060
Appears by 2040-2060
A
geographic location where climatic factors fit this range. Most of the
regions that fit the climatic range are well known areas of Musa
occurrence, with the exception perhaps of the western coast of India,
where very few wild species of Musa have been reported.
References
Hijmans R.L., L. Guarino, M. Cruz and E. Rojas. 2001. Computer Tool
for Spatial Analysis of Plant Genetic Resources Data: 1. DIVA-
GIS. Plant Genetic Resources Newsletter 127: 15-19.
Appendixes
Programme 213
Monday, 7 October
Dr Eliseo Ponce
Director
Bureau of Agricultural Research (DA-BAR)
Department of Agriculture
List of participants 219
Dr Nestor Altoveros
Institute of Plant Breeding
U.P. Los Baños, College, Laguna 4031 Philippines
Tel: (63-49) 5362512
Fax: (63-49) 5363438
Dr Felipe de la Cruz
Institute of Plant Breeding
U.P. Los Baños, College, Laguna 4031 Philippines
Tel: (63-49) 5362512
Fax: (63-49) 5363438
Email: [email protected]
Secretariat
Appendix 3 : Awards
Presents this
Plaque of Appreciation
to
This Plaque of Appreciation is given this 7th day of October 2002 in PCARRD, Los
Baños, Laguna, Philippines.
Presents this
Plaque of Appreciation
to the
This Plaque of Appreciation is given this 7th day of October 2002 in PCARRD,
Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines.
Presents this
Plaque of Appreciation
to the
Department of Agriculture
Bureau of Agricultural Research
(DA-BAR)
In recognition of its strong commitment in banana R&D, for its cooperation and
annual financial contribution to IPGRI/INIBAP towards the conservation,
characterization and evaluation of Musa germplasm in the Philippines;
In appreciation for co-hosting this year the first Banana Asia Pacific Network
Steering Committee Meeting on 7-10 October 2002.
This Plaque of Appreciation is given this 7th day of October 2002 in PCARRD,
Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines.
Presents this
Suzanne Sharrock
PATRICIO S. FFA
PA AYLON AGUSTIN B. MOLINA
Chair, BAPNET Regional Coordinator, INIBAP-AP
EMILE A. FRISON
Director, INIBAP
List of acronyms and abbreviations 229