Trade Off Template
Trade Off Template
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE EXISTING DESIGN DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 2.2449 3.8125 4.0612 4.1633 4.7143
2. Usability 3.5918 3.8542 3.7551 3.9388 4.5306
3. Safety 3.5510 3.8750 3.6327 3.7755 4.3878
4. Functionality 3.6327 4.1458 3.8163 4.1020 4.7347
5. Quality 2.9592 3.9792 3.7551 3.8367 4.5918
AHP
1. Maintainability 5 2
2. Usability 2 8
3. Safety 3 6
4. Functionality 1 10
5. Quality 4 4
RANKING CRITERIA
Maintainability Usability Safety Functionality Quality
Maintainability 1 1/4 1/3 1/5 1/2
Usability 4 1 1 1/3 4/5 2
Safety 3 3/4 1 3/5 1 1/2
Functionality 5 1 1/4 1 2/3 1 2 1/2
Quality 2 1/2 2/3 2/5 1
SUM 15 3 3/4 5 3 7 1/2
Other way of getting Priority vector OTHER WAY OF GETTING PRIORITY MATRIX
0.38385 0.06667 STEP 1: MULTIPLY THE ROWS OF CRITERIA ON THE RAN
1.53541 0.26667 STEP 2: POWER UP THE PRODUCT WITH 1/M, M=NUM
1.15156 0.20000 STEP 3: SUM THE RESULT ON EACH CRITERIA
STEP 4: GET WEIGHTS BY DIVIDING THE RESULT/SUM O
1.91926 0.33333
0.76770 0.13333
5.75778
5
2
3
1
4
NORMALIZED
MaintainabilityUsability Safety FunctionalQuality PRIORITY VECTOR
Maintainabi 0.0667 0.0667 0.0667 0.0667 0.0667 0.0667
Usability 0.2667 0.2667 0.2667 0.2667 0.2667 0.2667
Safety 0.2000 0.2000 0.2000 0.2000 0.2000 0.2000
Functionali 0.3333 0.3333 0.3333 0.3333 0.3333 0.3333
Quality 0.1333 0.1333 0.1333 0.1333 0.1333 0.1333
SUM 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
PRIORITY MATRIX
OWS OF CRITERIA ON THE RANKING TABLE
PRODUCT WITH 1/M, M=NUMBER OF CRITERIA
ON EACH CRITERIA
DIVIDING THE RESULT/SUM OF RESULT
CHECKING FOR CONSISTENCY
0.333333 5.00
1.333333 5.00
1 5.00
1.666667 5.00
0.666667 5.00
5.00 0 0
Maintainability
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE
DESIGN 1 1.0000 0.9755 0.8615 1. Maintainability 2.2449
DESIGN 2 1.0251 1.0000 0.8831 2. Usability 3.5918
DESIGN 3 1.1608 1.1324 1.0000 3. Safety 3.5510
3.1859 3.1078 2.7446 4. Functionality 3.6327
5. Quality 2.9592
NORMALIZED
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 PRIORITY VECTOR
DESIGN 1 0.3139 0.3139 0.3139 0.3139
DESIGN 2 0.3218 0.3218 0.3218 0.3218
DESIGN 3 0.3644 0.3644 0.3644 0.3644
Usability NORMALIZED
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1 1.0000 0.9534 0.8288 0.3072 0.3072 0.3072
DESIGN 2 1.0489 1.0000 0.8694 0.3222 0.3222 0.3222
DESIGN 3 1.2065 1.1503 1.0000 0.3706 0.3706 0.3706
3.2554 3.1036 2.6982
Safety NORMALIZED
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 0.3080 0.3080 0.3080
DESIGN 1 1.0000 0.9622 0.8279 0.3201 0.3201 0.3201
DESIGN 2 1.0393 1.0000 0.8605 0.3720 0.3720 0.3720
DESIGN 3 1.2079 1.1622 1.0000
3.2472 3.1243 2.6884
Functionality NORMALIZED
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 0.3016 0.3016 0.3016
DESIGN 1 1.0000 0.9303 0.8060 0.3242 0.3242 0.3242
DESIGN 2 1.0749 1.0000 0.8664 0.3742 0.3742 0.3742
DESIGN 3 1.2406 1.1542 1.0000
3.3155 3.0846 2.6724
Quality NORMALIZED
DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 0.3082 0.3082 0.3082
DESIGN 1 1.0000 0.9787 0.8178 0.3149 0.3149 0.3149
DESIGN 2 1.0217 1.0000 0.8356 0.3769 0.3769 0.3769
DESIGN 3 1.2228 1.1968 1.0000
3.2446 3.1755 2.6533
PRIORITY VECTOR
0.3072
0.3222
0.3706
PRIORITY VECTOR
0.3080
0.3201
0.3720
PRIORITY VECTOR
0.3016
0.3242
0.3742
PRIORITY VECTOR
0.3082
0.3149
0.3769
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 BEST WORST
1. Maintainability 4.0612 4.1633 4.7143 4.7143 4.0612
2. Usability 3.7551 3.9388 4.5306 4.5306 3.7551
3. Safety 3.6327 3.7755 4.3878 4.3878 3.6327
4. Functionality 3.8163 4.1020 4.7347 4.7347 3.8163
5. Quality 3.7551 3.8367 4.5918 4.5918 3.7551
STD DEV
1. Maintainability - 0.1562 1.0000 0.5379
2. Usability - 0.2368 1.0000 0.5226
3. Safety - 0.1892 1.0000 0.5312
4. Functionality - 0.3111 1.0000 0.5118
5. Quality - 0.0976 1.0000 0.5513
SYMMETRIC
Maintainability Usability Safety Functionality Quality
Maintainability 1.0000 0.9966 0.9994 0.9867 0.9984
Usability 0.9966 1.0000 0.9988 0.9968 0.9902
Safety 0.9994 0.9988 1.0000 0.9916 0.9959
Functionality 0.9867 0.9968 0.9916 1.0000 0.9758
Quality 0.9984 0.9902 0.9959 0.9758 1.0000
SUM ENTROPY
Maintainability - 0.3637 - 0.3649 - 0.3679 - 1.0964 0.6813 0.3187 0.199514
Usability - 0.3626 - 0.3649 - 0.3679 - 1.0954 0.6806 0.3194 0.19993
Safety - 0.3627 - 0.3646 - 0.3679 - 1.0952 0.6805 0.3195 0.199993
Functionality - 0.3615 - 0.3652 - 0.3678 - 1.0945 0.6801 0.3199 0.200257
Quality - 0.3628 - 0.3639 - 0.3678 - 1.0944 0.6800 0.3200 0.200306
1.5976
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 MAX VALUE
1. Maintainability 0.0663 4.0612 4.1633 4.7143 4.7143
2. Usability 0.2509 3.7551 3.9388 4.5306 4.5306
3. Safety 0.1989 3.6327 3.7755 4.3878 4.3878
4. Functionality 0.3514 3.8163 4.1020 4.7347 4.7347
5. Quality 0.1326 3.7551 3.8367 4.5918 4.5918
WSM
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0663 0.0571 0.0585 0.0663
2. Usability 0.2509 0.2079 0.2181 0.2509
3. Safety 0.1989 0.1646 0.1711 0.1989
4. Functionality 0.3514 0.2833 0.3045 0.3514
5. Quality 0.1326 0.1084 0.1108 0.1326
0.8213 0.8630 1.0000
WPM
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0663 0.9902 0.9918 1.0000
2. Usability 0.2509 0.9540 0.9655 1.0000
3. Safety 0.1989 0.9631 0.9706 1.0000
4. Functionality 0.3514 0.9270 0.9508 1.0000
5. Quality 0.1326 0.9737 0.9765 1.0000
4.8080 4.8552 5.0000
WASPAS
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0663 0.5236 0.5252 0.5331
2. Usability 0.2509 0.5810 0.5918 0.6254
3. Safety 0.1989 0.5639 0.5708 0.5994
4. Functionality 0.3514 0.6051 0.6277 0.6757
5. Quality 0.1326 0.5410 0.5436 0.5663
2.8147 2.8591 3.0000
NORMALIZED ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0663 0.8615 0.8831 1.0000
2. Usability 0.2509 0.8288 0.8694 1.0000
3. Safety 0.1989 0.8279 0.8605 1.0000
4. Functionality 0.3514 0.8060 0.8664 1.0000
5. Quality 0.1326 0.8178 0.8356 1.0000
Maximin (Best of Worst)
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE EXISTING DESIGN DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2
1. Maintainability 2.2449 3.8125 4.0612 4.1633
2. Usability 3.5918 3.8542 3.7551 3.9388
3. Safety 3.5510 3.8750 3.6327 3.7755
4. Functionality 3.6327 4.1458 3.8163 4.1020
5. Quality 2.9592 3.9792 3.7551 3.8367
IMPRECISE
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2
1. Maintainability 2.2449 0.1405 1.8091 1.8545
2. Usability 3.5918 0.2248 1.0455 1.0966
3. Safety 3.5510 0.2222 1.0230 1.0632
4. Functionality 3.6327 0.2273 1.0506 1.1292
5. Quality 2.9592 0.1852 1.2690 1.2966
4.3878
DESIGN 3
2.1000
1.2614
1.2356
1.3034
1.5517
1.4904
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0667 4.0612 4.1633 4.7143
2. Usability 0.2667 3.7551 3.9388 4.5306
3. Safety 0.2000 3.6327 3.7755 4.3878
4. Functionality 0.3333 3.8163 4.1020 4.7347
5. Quality 0.1333 3.7551 3.8367 4.5918
ALTERNATIVE
DESIGN CRITERIA IMPORTANCE DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
1. Maintainability 0.0667 - 0.1562 1.0000
2. Usability 0.2667 - 0.2368 1.0000
3. Safety 0.2000 - 0.1892 1.0000
4. Functionality 0.3333 - 0.3111 1.0000
5. Quality 0.1333 - 0.0976 1.0000
PROMETHEE II
D1 D2 D3 Leaving Flow
D1 - - - -
D2 0.2281 - - 0.1141
D3 1.0000 0.7719 - 0.8859
Entering Flow 0.6141 0.3859 -
5. Quality SUM
- -
- -
0.0130 0.2281
- -
0.1333 1.0000
0.1203 0.7719