Slo-Mo Mojo - The Economist

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

Menu My Economist

Science & technology | How animals perceive time

Slo-mo mojo
Small creatures with fast metabolisms see the world like an action
replay

Sep 21st 2013 Save Share Give

FLIES live shorter lives than elephants. Of that there is no doubt. But
from a !y’s point of view, does its life actually seem that much shorter?
This, in essence, was the question
Download asked
The by Kevin Healy
Economist app of Trinity
College, Dublin, in a paperfor
just published
the in Animal
best reading Behaviour. His
experience

answer is, possibly not.


Subjective experience of time is just that—subjective. Even individual
people, who can compare notes by talking to one another, cannot know
for certain that their own experience coincides with that of others. But
an objective measure which probably correlates with subjective
experience does exist. It is called the critical !icker-fusion frequency,
or CFF, and it is the lowest frequency at which a !ickering light appears
to be a constant source of illumination. It measures, in other words,
how fast an animal’s eyes can refresh an image and thus process
information.

ADVERTISEMENT

For people, the average CFF is 60 hertz (ie, 60 times a second). This is
why the refresh-rate on a television screen is usually set at that value.
Dogs have a CFF of 80Hz, which is probably why they do not seem to
like watching television. To a dog a TV programme looks like a series of
rapidly changing stills.

Having the highest possible CFF would carry biological advantages,


because it would allow faster reaction to threats and opportunities.

Flies, which have a CFF of 250Hz, are notoriously di"cult to swat. A


rolled up newspaper that seems to a human to be moving rapidly
rolled up newspaper that seems to a human to be moving rapidly
appears to them to be travelling through treacle.
Mr Healy reasoned that the main constraints on an animal’s CFF are its
size and its metabolic rate. Being small means signals have less far to
travel in the brain. A high metabolic rate means more energy is
available to process them. A literature search, however, showed that no
one had previously looked into the question.

Fortunately for Mr Healy, this search also showed that plenty of people
had looked at CFF in lots of species for other reasons. Similarly, many
other people had looked at the metabolic rates of many of the same
species. And size data for species are ubiquitous. All he had to do,
therefore, was correlate and repurpose these results. Which he did.

To simplify matters he looked only at vertebrates—34 species of them.


At the bottom end of the scale was the European eel, with a CFF of
14Hz. It was closely followed by the leatherback turtle, at 15Hz.
Tuataras clocked in at 46Hz. Hammerhead sharks tied with humans, at
60Hz, and yellow#n tuna tied with dogs at 80Hz. The top spot was
occupied by the golden-mantled ground squirrel, at 120Hz. And when
Mr Healy plotted his accumulated CFF data against both size and
metabolic rate (which are not, it must be admitted, independent
variables, as small animals tend to have higher metabolic rates than
large ones), he found exactly the correlations he had predicted.

The upshot is that his hypothesis—that evolution pushes animals to


see the world in the slowest motion possible—looks correct. Flies may
seem short-lived to people, but from a dipteran point of view they can
thus live to a ripe old age. Remember that next time you try (and fail) to
swat one.

This article appeared in the Science & technology section of the print edition under the headline "Slo-
mo mojo"

Science & technology


Science & technology
September 21st 2013

→ The devil and the details

→ Slo-mo mojo

→ It’s not rocket science

→ Life in the labyrinth

From the September 21st


2013 edition
Discover stories from this section
and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Save Share Give Reuse this content

SUBSCRIBER ONLY | SIMPLY SCIENCE


SUBSCRIBER ONLY | SIMPLY SCIENCE

Curious about the world? Enjoy a


weekly !x of our mind-
expanding science coverage
Delivered to you every week

Sign up

More from Science & technology

DARPA, lasers and an internet in orbit


America hopes to create a new intelligence network in space

How to predict record-shattering


weather events
Meteorologists are trying to work out just how
Meteorologists are trying to work out just how
common they will become

People of di!erent opinions process


political data di!erently
Brain scanning suggests activity patterns cluster
with ideology

Subscribe

Group subscriptions

Reuse our content

The Trust Project

Help and contact us

Keep updated

Published since September 1843 to take part in “a severe contest


between intelligence, which presses forward, and an unworthy, timid
ignorance obstructing our progress.”

The Economist The Economist Group

About The Economist Group


Economist Intelligence
Economist Intelligence
Advertise
Economist Impact
Press centre
Economist Events
Working Here
Economist Education Courses
Which MBA?
Executive Jobs
Executive Education Navigator

Terms of Use Privacy Cookie Policy Manage Cookies Accessibility

Modern Slavery Statement Sitemap Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Copyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2023. All rights reserved.

You might also like