Module 4 21st Century Lit
Module 4 21st Century Lit
Module 4 21st Century Lit
LECTURE NOTE 1: “Biographical, Feminist, Historical, Marxist and other Approaches”. Weeks 1-2 (Fourth Quarter)
I. LEARNING COMPETENCIES Teacher’s Note: Ang approach na ito ay mas nagagamit sa mga akdang may
At the end of this module, the learners are expected to: kinalaman sa buhay ng author, katulad ng kina Alexander Pope, John Dryden, and
1. Identify representative texts and authors from Milton.
Asia, North America,
Europe, Latin America, and Disadvantages: New Critics refer to the historical / biographical critic’s belief that the
Africa (MELCS) meaning or value of a work may be determined by the author’s intention as “the
intentional fallacy.” Thus, art is reduced to the level of biography rather than universal.
Teacher’s Note: Hindi lahat ng akda ay angkop o may kinalaman sa buhay ng
II. CONTENT
author o sa kasaysayan. Ibig sabihin lang nito na Limitado lamang ang mga
In this module, you will learn and understand about
akda na ginagamitan ng approach na ito.
1. In this module, you will learn and understand about
“Elements of a Short Story and Literary Criticism”.
A Checklist of Historical Critical Questions:
-When was the work written?
Lecture Proper -When was it published?
-How was it received by the critics and public and why?
1. Knowledge Test -What does the work’s reception reveal about the standards of taste and value during
INSTRUCTION/DELIVERY the time it was published and reviewed?
-What social attitudes and cultural practices related to the action of the word were
The three-fold Purpose of Criticism: prevalent during the time the work was written and published?
1. To help us solve a problem in the reading. -What kinds of power relationships does the word describe, reflect, or embody?
2. To help us sift between and resolve conflicting readings. -How the power relationships do reflected in the literary work manifest themselves in
3. To enable us craft interpretative, yet scholarly judgments about literature. the cultural practices and social institutions prevalent during the time the work was
written and published?
Historical / Biographical Approach: -To what extent can we understand the past as it is reflected in the literary work?
-Historical / Biographical critics see works as the reflection of an author’s life and -To what extent does the work reflect differences from the ideas and values of its
times (or of the characters’ life and times). H/B approach deems it necessary to know time?
about the author and the political, economic, and sociological context of his times in Checklist of Biographical Critical Questions:
order to truly understand the work(s).
Teacher’s Note: Tinitignan ng approach na ito ang koneksiyon ng isang akda sa -What influences—people, ideas, movements, events—evident in the writer’s life does
buhay o talambuhay ng isang manunulat o author. Kailangang alamin na ito the work reflect?
ang politikal, ekonomikal at sosyological na konteksto o status ng isang may -To what extent are the events described in the word a direct transfer of what
akda. happened in the writer’s actual life?
-What modifications of the actual events has the writer made in the literary work? For
Advantages: This approach works well for some works -like those of Alexander Pope, what possible purposes?
John Dryden, and Milton – which are obviously political in nature. It also is necessary -What are the effects of the differences between actual events and their literary
to take a historical approach in order to place allusions in their proper classical, transformation in the poem, story, play, or essay?
political, or biblical background. -What has the author revealed in the work about his/her characteristic modes of
thought, perception, or emotion?
Advantages: This approach is useful for such works as Alexander Pope’s “An Essay on A Checklist of Formalism Critical Questions:
Man,” which presents an obvious moral philosophy. It is also useful when considering
the themes of works (for example, man’s inhumanity to man in Mark Twain’s -How is the work structured or organized? How does it begin? Where does it go next?
Huckleberry Finn). Finally, it does not view literature merely as “art” isolated from all How does it end?
moral implications; it recognizes that literature can affect readers, whether subtly or -What is the work’s plot? How is its plot related to its structure?
directly, and that the message of a work -and not just the decorous vehicle for that -What is the relationship of each part of the work to the work as a whole? How are the
message -is important. parts related to one another?
-Who is narrating or telling what happens in the work? How is the narrator, speaker,
Disadvantages: Detractors argue that such an approach can be too “judgmental.” or character revealed to readers? How do we come to know and understand this
Some believe literature should be judged primarily (if not solely) on its artistic merits, figure?
not its moral or philosophical content. -Who are the major and minor characters, what do they represent, and how do they
relate to one another? What are the time and place of the work—it’s setting? How is
Checklist of Moral/Didactic Critical Questions: the setting related to what we know of the characters and their actions? To what
-What enduring truth is revealed in the theme of this work? extent is the setting symbolic?
-How are the actions of the protagonist rewarded and the actions of the antagonist -What kind of language does the author use to describe, narrate, explain, or otherwise
punished? create the world of the literary work? More specifically, what images, similes,
metaphors, symbols appear in the work? What is their function? What meanings do
Formalism / New Criticism they convey?
-A formalism approach to literature, once called New Criticism, involves a close
reading of the text. Formalism critics believe that all information essential to the Psychological Approach
interpretation of a work must be found within the work itself; there is no need to -Psychological critics view works through the lens of psychology. They look either at
bring in outside information about the history, politics, or society of the time, or about the psychological motivations of the characters or of the authors themselves,
the author’s life. Formalism critics spend much time analyzing irony, paradox, imagery, although the former is generally considered a more respectable approach. Most
A Freudian approach often includes pinpointing the influences of a character’s psyche Checklist of Psychological Critical Questions
(Greek for “soul”), which consists of the:
-What connections can you make between your knowledge of an author’s life and the
Id (reservoir of libido or pleasure principle in the unconscious) o Libog in tagalog behaviour and motivations of characters in his or her work?
Superego (the moral censoring agency and repository of conscience/pride that -How does your understanding of the characters, their relationships, their actions, and
protects society)- Ito ang ahensiya ng konsensya o pride upang protektahan ang their motivations in a literary work help you better understand the mental world and
ibang tao o ang lipunan. imaginative life, or the actions and motivations of the author?
Ego (the rational governing agent of the unconscious that protects the individual)- -How does a particular literary work—its images, metaphors, and other linguistic
Ang sarili o ang ahensiya sa iyong sikolohikal na aspeto na promoprotekta sayong elements—reveal the psychological motivations of its characters or the psychological
sarili. mind-set of its author?
-Freudian critics steer toward the sexual implications of symbols and imagery, since -To what extent can you employ the concepts of Freudian psychoanalysis to
Freud theorized that all human behaviour (drives) derives from libido/sexual energy. understand the motivations of literary characters?
Teacher’s Note: Ayon sa teorya ni Freud lahat raw ng pag-uugali ng tao ay may -What kinds of literary works and what types of literary characters seem best suited to
kinalaman sa kanilang libido o sexual energy. a critical approach that employs a psychological or psychoanalytical perspective?
Why?
Concave Images, such as ponds, flowers, cups, and caves = female symbols. -How can a psychological or psychoanalytical approach to a particular work be
Convex Images, such as skyscrapers, submarines, obelisks, etc. = male symbols combined with an approach from another critical perspective—for example,
Actions, such as dancing, riding, and flying = sexual pleasure. biographical, formalist, or feminist criticism?
Water = birth, the female principle, the maternal, the womb, and the death wish.
Oedipus complex = a boy’s unconscious rivalry with his father for the love of his (b) Jungian Approach
mother -Jung is also an influential force in myth (archetypal) criticism. Psychological critics are
The Electra complex = a girl’s unconscious rivalry with her mother for the love of her generally concerned with his concept of the process of individuation (the process of
father discovering what makes one different form everyone else). Jung labeled three parts of
Critics may also refer to Freud’s psychology of child development, which includes the the self:
oral stage (eating), the anal stage (elimination), and the genital (reproduction).
Shadow – the darker, unconscious self; rarely surfaces, yet must be faced for totality of
Advantages: A useful tool for understanding some works, in which characters Self
manifest clear psychological issues. Like the biographical approach, knowing Persona – the public personality/mask (particularly masculine)
something about a writer’s psychological makeup can give us insight into his work. Anima/Animus – a man’s/woman’s “soul image” (the negative that makes a composite
whole)
Disadvantages: Psychological criticism can turn a work into little more than a
psychological case study, neglecting to view it as a piece of art. Critics sometimes
Checklist of Mythological Critical Questions Disadvantages: Feminists turn literary criticism into a political battlefield and
overlook the merits of works they consider “patriarchal.” When arguing for a distinct
-What incidents in the work seem common or familiar enough as actions that they feminine writing style, they tend to relegate women’s literature to a ghetto status; this
might be considered symbolic or archetypal? Are there any journeys, battles, falls, in turn prevents female literature from being naturally included in the literary cannon.
reversals of fortune, etc.? The feminist approach is often too theoretical.
-What kinds of character types appear in the work? How might they be classified?
-What creatures, elements of nature, or man-made objects playing a role in the work Checklist of Feminist Critical Questions
might be considered symbolic?
-What changes do the characters undergo? How can those changes be characterized To what extent does the representation of women (and men) in the work reflect the
or named? To what might they be related or compared? place and time in which the work was written?
-What religious or quasi-religious traditions might the work’s story, characters, How are the relationships between men and women or those between members of
elements, or objects be compared to or affiliated with? Why? the same sex presented in the work? What roles do men and women assume and
perform and with what consequences?
Feminist Approach Does the author present the work from within a predominantly male or female
sensibility? Why might this have been done, and with what effects?
-Feminist criticism is concerned with the impact of gender on writing and reading. It How do the facts of the author’s life relate to the presentation of men and women in
usually begins with a critique of patriarchal culture. It is concerned with the place of the work? To their relative degrees of power?
female writers in the cannon. Finally, it includes a search for a feminine theory or
Dialectical Materialism
Objectives:
● identify the different ways one may evaluate a literary text, specifically by
Marx believed that communism was a historical inevitability. Society had progressed examining its biographical context, sociocultural context, and linguistic context;
from one economic system to another—from feudalism to capitalism, for example. ● distinguish various critical reading strategies; and
The contradictions of each system led to its collapse. As history advanced, the failures
When reading a text or writing a critique through the sociocultural context, set aside ● Analyse the diction or choice of words in the text.
your personal political ideologies. Say for example, if you greatly believe that boys ● Examine the texts’ syntax or use of sentences, clauses, phrases, line cuts, etc.
should only like girls and vice versa, it should not hinder you from analysing a text ● Observe the use of figurative language.
using the queer theory in an objective way. Your personal ideologies may lead you ● Analyse the mood and tone of the text. ● Observe the text’s overall structure.
to over read the text according to what you believe in even if the text is not related ● Analyse the content of the text.
to your political inclinations. Do your best to be unbiased in reading.
Here are guide questions that may help you when you read literature through the
linguistic context:
● What were the striking words in the text? What words were unfamiliar to you?
Lesson 3: Literary Reading through a Linguistic Context Which words attracted your attention? What words were dramatic?
● What nouns are the most prominent? Are these concrete or abstract nouns? What
-According to David Richter, “Practically everything we do that is specifically human about verbs? Does the author use common words or lofty diction? Are the words
is expressed in language.” This is why literary texts can be read through the context short or long? Is there any word that has two or more meanings?
of the language used to write the text as well as the way language is used in the ● Are the sentences in the usual order of subject-predicate? What are the
text. This literary reading adheres to Roland Barthes’s famous maxim, “The author is dependent clauses? What are the independent clauses? If you restructure a sentence
dead.” Reading through a linguistic context focuses on the language used in the or a phrase, would it make a difference? Is the voice active or passive? Is there a
literary work and how it is used to convey meaning. rhythm in the sentence structure in relation to the length of the sentences or lines?
Essential Question: What is the importance of understanding the way language is ● What literary devices are used? Are there images? Do those images stand for
used in a literary text? anything aside from their literal meaning?
Vocabulary ● What is the tone? Is the speaker happy about the subject? Is the tone negative or
Linguistic: of or relating to language or the study of language. positive?
Syntax: the study of how linguistic elements form phrases, clauses, or sentences.
●Even if literature uses language, it does not mean that the structure of literature ● What a text says is the restatement . At first, you simply talk about the same
and the language are the same. Some writers may not follow grammatical rules, and topic as what is written in the original text.
this kind of deviation may be used in your analysis. You may ask, “Why is the text ● What a text does is the description. Next, you discuss and examine the
not following standard grammar?” and other similar questions. aspects of the discussion or the contentof the text.
●The characteristics of the language in which the text was written may help in -What a text means is the interpretation. As you read critically, you should analyse
analysing the text. You may also ask, “Why is the text written in this language?”, “Is the text and assert a meaning for the text as a whole.
this considered a weak language or a strong language?” and other similar questions. Vocabulary
●You may consult literary approaches that focus on language. Structuralism, post Critique-a detailed analysis or evaluation of something.
structuralism, and formalism have linguistic aspects. These approaches may lead you Arguments- a set of reasons given to prove a statement or stand.
in your view of reading through the linguistic context.
Structuralism -relays the texts being examined to a larger structure. The structure Here are the three main goals of critical reading that require inference from reading
may be a particular genre, a range of intertextuality connections, a model of a within the text (Kurland 2000):
universal narrative structure, or a system of recurrent patterns or motifs.
Formalism (or New Criticism) - Formalism is a school of literary criticism and
● First is to recognize the author’s purpose, which involves inferring a basis
literary theory that focuses on the structure of a particular text. It examines a text
for choices of content and language.
without taking into account any outside influence.
● Second is to understand the tone and persuasive elements of the text,
Post structuralism is the reaction to structuralism. In the linguistic context, there
which involves classifying the nature of language choices used by the author.
may be underlying structures that may have different interpretations based on how
the words or phrases were used in the text.
● Third is to recognize bias, which involves classifying the nature of patterns
of choice and language used in the text.
Structuralism relays the texts being examined to a larger structure. The structure
may be a particular genre, a range of intertextuality connections, a model of a
The following critical reading strategies will help you cope with different
universal narrative structure, or a system of recurrent patterns or motifs.
reading texts:
● Annotating. Annotating involves highlighting or making notes of important ● Rereading. Rereading requires a repeated examination of the text to enable
ideas in the text. This can be done by doing the following: you to improve your comprehension of the text and to identify ideas that you may not
❏ With a pencil or a pen in hand, underline important ideas such as the thesis, topic have noticed in initial reading. Critical readers read the text more than once to fully
sentences, and key concepts. Also, highlight unfamiliar words so you can look them grasp the meaning of the text and what the author is conveying.
up later.
❏ Make notes such as questions and comments or responses on the margins as you Responding. After you have developed a clear understanding of the text, you are
read. now ready to respond to the text. Responding to the text means drawing meaning
❏ Develop a symbol system. You may draw symbols to mark important words or from what you have read and presenting it in writing or talking about it to others.
When you respond to a text, you express your thoughts, feelings, and questions about
sentences so that the text will not appear cluttered.
the text. You can write why you agree or disagree with the text or the author’s
arguments, or you can interpret the text. You can also respond to a text by discussing
● Contextualizing. When you contextualize, you consider the historical, it with others. Sharing the information that you gained from a text with others who
cultural, or biographical context of the text. Identify the context(s) in which the text have read the same text is a good way to check your understanding.6. English as a
medium of instruction was introduced in the schools as the intellectual language of
was written and determine how this context differs from your own. Keep in mind that
education in this period.
your understanding of a particular concept is influenced by these contexts, in the
a. New Society Period
same way that they influence an author’s. b. American Period
c. 21st Century Period
● Outlining and Summarizing. Outlining and summarizing the text help you d. Period of 3rd Republic
7. This is the period wherein the youth became vocal with their sentiments and
identify the main ideas in the text and express them again in your own words. In
demanded change in the government.
outlining the text, you identify the basic structure of the text (i.e., the main ideas and a. Spanish Period
the supporting ideas) and make connections between those ideas. Outlining helps b. Period of Activism
you understand how the author developed the text through the ideas presented. After c. Pre-Spanish Period
making an outline, you can now summarize the text. Summarizing the text allows you d. Period of 3rd Republic
8. Filipinos during this period were hooked on reading magazines and comics.
to present your understanding of the text by reviewing and synthesizing important
a. New Society Period
ideas, and then restating them in your own words. b. American Period
c. Period of 3rd Republic
d. 21st Century Period