Introduction To The Comprehensive Plan
Introduction To The Comprehensive Plan
a Comprehensive Plan. Comprehensive Plans are the backbone of any community planning effort. They
outline challenges facing the community, identify solutions, and provide guidance to appointed and elected
officials on planning-related decisions. The best Comprehensive Plans are those that have the support of the
broader community. They are a living document that grows and changes with the community. The purpose
of this handout is to provide course participants with supplemental information on Comprehensive Plans and
detailed information on the Centre Region’s most recent planning endeavors.
Community planning, according to the American Planning Association, is “a process that seeks to engage all
members of the community to create a more prosperous, convenient, equitable, healthy, and attractive
place for present and future generations.” One of the fundamental responsibilities of local government is to
plan for future growth and development of the community. The guidance document that results from this
planning process is the comprehensive plan.
In Pennsylvania, municipalities are enabled by the Municipalities Planning Code (MPC) to create
comprehensive plans to guide growth and development for their jurisdictions. The term “comprehensive
plan” is not defined in the MPC. Comprehensive plans are defined by their contents, which are intended to
proactively and comprehensively address future growth and development. Proactive planning is important
for local governments because without it, the ability to plan is given to others who may not have the best
interests of the municipality in mind. A comprehensive plan provides a vision for the future of the
community along with the steps that are needed to make that vision a reality. It is the basis for land use
regulations and provides a nexus between the community’s future vision and the regulation of private
property. This framework helps guide growth and change but without it, the development process would be
reactive, resulting in development that is uncoordinated and costly.
The comprehensive plan is a recommendatory document, providing guidance and is often written abstractly
so that appointed and elected officials can utilize a variety of means to implement it. While only
recommendatory in nature, the value of a comprehensive plan is indicated by the community’s desire to see
to its implementation.
It is important to remember that a comprehensive plan and a zoning ordinance are two separate tools that
are used in conjunction with one another. A comprehensive plan acts in a guiding role and provides
recommendations on how land should be utilized to meet the needs and desires of the community,
whereas a zoning ordinance regulates land uses as recommended by the plan.
1
Enabling Legislation
Article III of the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code outlines the requirements for preparing,
adopting, and implementing a municipal, multi-municipal, or county comprehensive plan. Although the
MPC does not provide an actual definition for what a comprehensive plan is, this section of the MPC
clearly outlines what a plan should contain and its legal status. The MPC also includes references to
comprehensive plans throughout its other articles. In recent decades, the MPC was modified to permit
greater collaboration amongst municipalities that are contiguous or located within the same school
district boundaries. These improvements have encouraged and allowed for greater cooperation in multi-
municipal planning.
2
Components of a Comprehensive Plan
Article III, Section 301 (a) of the MPC defines minimum requirements for what a municipal, multi-municipal,
or county comprehensive plan must contain. These minimum requirements can be exceeded based upon the
desire of the community for which it is being prepared. The following requirements are listed in Section 301
(a) of the MPC:
(a) The municipal, multi-municipal, or county comprehensive plan, consisting of maps, charts, and textual
matter, shall include, but need not be limited to the following related basic elements:
(1) A statement of objectives of the municipality concerning its future development, including but not
limited to, the location, character, and timing of future development that may also serve as a
statement of community development objectives as provided in section 606.
(2) A plan for land use, which may include provisions for the amount, intensity, character, and timing
of land use proposed for residence, industry, business, agriculture, major traffic and transit facilities,
utilities, community facilities, public grounds, parks and recreation, preservation of prime agricultural
lands, flood plains, and other areas of special hazards and other similar uses.
(2.1) A plan to meet the housing needs of present residents and of those individuals and families
anticipated to reside in the municipality, which may include conservation of presently sound housing,
rehabilitation of housing in declining neighborhoods, and the accommodation of expected new
housing in different dwelling types and at appropriate densities for households of all income levels.
(3) A plan for movement of people and goods, which may include expressways, highways, local street
systems, parking facilities, pedestrian and bikeway systems, public transit routes, terminals, airfields,
port facilities, railroad facilities, and other similar facilities or uses.
(4) A plan for community facilities and utilities, which may include public and private education,
recreation, municipal buildings, fire and police stations, libraries, hospitals, water supply and
distribution, sewage and waste treatment, solid waste management, storm drainage, flood plain
management, utility corridors and associated facilities, and other similar facilities or uses.
(4.1) A statement of the interrelationships among the various plan components, which may include an
estimate of the environmental, energy conservation, fiscal, economic development, and social
consequences of the municipality.
3
(4.2) A discussion of short and long-range plan implementation strategies, which may include
implications for capital improvements programming, new or updated development regulations, and
identification of public funds potentially available.
(5) A statement indicating that the existing and proposed development of the municipality is
compatible with the existing and proposed development and plans in contiguous portions of
neighboring municipalities, or a statement indicating measures which have been taken to provide
buffers or other transitional devices between disparate uses, and a statement indicating that the
existing and proposed development of the municipality is generally consistent with the objectives and
plans of the county comprehensive plan.
(6) A plan for the protection of natural and historic resources to the extent not preempted by federal
or state law. This clause includes, but is not limited to, wetlands and aquifer recharge zones,
woodlands, steep slopes, prime agricultural land, flood plains, unique natural areas, and historic sites.
The plan shall be consistent with and may not exceed those requirements imposed under the
following:
(i) Act of June 22, 1937 (P.L.1987, No.394), known as “The Clean Streams Law”
(ii) Act of May 31, 1945 (P.L.1198, No.418), known as the “Surface Mining Conservation and
Reclamation Act”
(iii) Act of April 27, 1966 (1st SP.SESS., P.L.31, No.1), known as “The Bituminous Mine Subsidence
and Land Conservation Act”
(iv) Act of September 24, 1968 (P.L.1040, No.318), known as the “Coal Refuse Disposal Control
Act”
(v) Act of December 19, 1984 (P.L.1140, No.223), known as the “Oil and Gas Act”
(vi) Act of December 19, 1984 (P.L.1093, No.219), known as the “Noncoal Surface Mining
Conservation and Reclamation Act”
(vii) Act of June 30, 1981 (P.L.128, No.43), known as the “Agricultural Area Security Law”
(viii) Act of June 10, 1982 (P.L.454, No.133), entitled “An Act Protecting Agricultural Operations
from Nuisance Suits and Ordinances Under Certain Circumstances”
(ix) Act of May 20, 1993 (P.L.12, No.6), known as the “Nutrient Management Act,” regardless of
whether any agricultural operation within the area to be affected by the plan is a concentrated
animal operation as defined under the act.
The 2013 Centre Region Comprehensive Plan includes policies that relate
to the protection of the region’s natural and environmental resources.
One such policy encourages the ongoing implementation of riparian buffer
ordinances that seek to protect surface and groundwater resources from
pollutants and also provide wildlife habitat.
4
(b) The comprehensive plan shall include a plan for a reliable supply of water, considering current and future
water resources availability, uses and limitations, including provisions adequate to protect water supply
sources. Any such plan shall be generally consistent with the State Water Plan and any applicable water
resources plan adopted by a river basin commission. It shall also contain a statement recognizing that:
(1) Lawful activities such as extraction of minerals impact water supply sources and such activities are
governed by statutes regulating mineral extraction that specify replacement and restoration of water
supplies affected by such activities.
The 2013 Centre Region Comprehensive Plan includes a chapter that specifically
addresses sustainability throughout the Region. While not listed specifically within
the MPC, comprehensive plans can include additional elements that are necessary to
address the specific needs of the planning area.
Growth Areas
The MPC also permits municipal, multi-municipal, and county comprehensive plans to identify areas where
growth and development will occur. These growth areas can be used to identify where public infrastructure
and services such as water, sewer, fire and police protection, schools, parks, and open space can be planned
for and provided. The Centre Region Comprehensive Plan utilizes a Regional Growth Boundary (RGB) to
identify when the majority of future growth should be directed.
Energy Conservation Plan
A comprehensive plan may include an energy conservation plan to promote energy conservation and
effective utilization of renewable energy sources. This element should analyze the impact of each
component and element of the comprehensive plan on the present and future use of energy in the
municipality. It should also detail measures designed to reduce energy consumption.
Designate Future Growth Areas: In addition to growth areas, multi-municipal plans are also
permitted to designate future growth areas. These areas are where future development is
planned for at densities that will accompany the orderly extension of services.
Designate Rural Resource Areas: Rural resource areas are where rural resource uses are
planned for. Development within rural resource areas would be limited to densities that support
rural resource uses. Infrastructure extensions or improvements are not intended for these areas
with the exception of villages or in areas where participating municipalities agree that extension
of such services is vital for health or safety reasons.
Plan for Developments of Area Wide Significance and Impact. The Centre Region
Comprehensive Plan does not have a specific plan for developments that are considered of “area-
wide significance and impact”. The Centre Region municipalities did enter into an
implementation agreement in 2006 (updated in 2013) which identifies how developments that
propose the expansion of the Regional Growth Boundary and Sewer Service Area are to be
evaluated and acted upon.
Plan for the Conservation and Enhancement of the Natural, Scenic, Historical and Aesthetic
Resources within the Plan Area. The Centre Region Comprehensive Plan provides goals and
policies related to the preservation and protection of natural, environmental, and historic
resources.
7
Plan for All Categories of Uses: Municipalities are required by
the MPC to provide for all land uses within their corporate
boundaries. This includes all housing, commercial, and
industrial uses. Municipalities cannot exclude particular land
uses from their community. All land uses must be
accommodated somewhere in a municipality (e.g. industrial,
Municipalities that participate in a multi-
landfills, cell phone towers, adult uses, and correctional municipal comprehensive plan can share
institutions). Not providing for a particular land use can result in a land uses across municipal boundaries.
Less desirable uses can be
zoning validity challenge, such as a claim that the zoning ordinance accommodated within the larger
planning area rather than in each
is exclusionary. Municipalities are not required to provide for all individual municipality.
land uses within their corporate boundaries if they participate in a
multi-municipal plan. This exemption is provided in Section 1103
(4) of the PaMPC, which reads as follows:
Plan for the accommodation of all categories of uses within the area of the plan provided, however, that
all uses need not be provided in every municipality, but shall be planned and provided for within a
reasonable geographic area of the plan.
Based upon this section of the MPC, municipalities that participate in a multi-municipal comprehensive plan
can rely upon land uses being provided within other municipalities that also participate in the same plan.
How it is Implemented
Creating a comprehensive plan is a monumental undertaking that is both costly and time consuming. To
create a comprehensive plan that provides value to the municipality, the planning commission and technical
staff must spend countless hours studying the issues, formulating solutions, vetting proposals with the public,
and meeting with elected officials. A common criticism of comprehensive planning efforts is that once
adopted, these documents are placed on the bookshelves of municipalities only to be dusted off when it’s
time to complete the next ten year update.
In order for a Comprehensive Plan to provide value, it must be implemented. The MPC requires that all
Comprehensive Plans discuss short and long-term implementation strategies to emphasize that the planning
process does not end with adoption of the comprehensive plan. However, the MPC doesn’t provide any
explicit direction on how to best utilize a comprehensive plan. Implementation is, much like the plan’s
development, an incremental process that can involve elected and appointed officials, municipal or regional
authorities, and community stakeholders.
Land Use Regulations
The primary tools used by most municipalities to implement the comprehensive plan are the
subdivision and land development ordinance and zoning ordinance. While comprehensive plans
rarely provide specific requirements that should be included within these two documents, the
guidance provided by the plan should result in ordinances that meet the intent of the plan. In some
cases, the comprehensive plan may specifically identify issues that should be addressed within land
8 use regulations, such as encouraging more of a particular type of use or regulating land uses which
may have long-term impacts on the community. Relying on the comprehensive plan while creating or
modifying land use regulations is essential to ensuring that such regulations are consistent with the
plan.
The Official Map
Municipalities are able to utilize an official map, as permitted in Article IV of the MPC, to identify areas
of the community that will be needed for public purposes at some time in the future. These public
purposes can include, but are not limited to, transportation improvements such as roads and trails,
public services infrastructure such as utility stations, and parks and recreation areas. Since the
comprehensive plan will often identify future needs of the community, utilizing an official map to
declare where these needs will be addressed is a method of comprehensive plan implementation.
Several Centre Region municipalities have adopted official maps for their jurisdictions.
An Official Map can be utilized to implement portions of a comprehensive plan. Official maps can be
utilized to identify future improvements including but not limited to roadways, bicycle facilities,
pedestrian facilities, and parklands.
13
Protection of Natural Resources
Air, water, wildlife habitats, soil, forests, and mineral resources are important natural elements that
the comprehensive plan seeks to protect. The plans includes various policies that seek to protect
vulnerable environmental resources that provide natural habitats such as wetlands, forests, and
waterways. Numerous policies seek to balance development patterns with the protection of prime
agricultural and other important soil types. The plan recommends the responsible management and
preservation of natural resources that play a key role in the health, safety, and welfare of Centre
Region residents.
Transportation
The 2013 Centre Region Comprehensive Plan includes a variety of goals, objectives, and policies that
focus on transportation-related issues including traffic congestion, bike and pedestrian pathways,
and access to other communities throughout the state. The plan provides recommendations such as
balancing transportation projects and programs with the Centre Region’s future land use plans and
adopting a complete streets policy that would encourage use of all modes of travel.
Protection of Established Neighborhoods
The region contains many mature, diverse, and unique neighborhoods that vary in size, character,
and composition. The plan promotes the preservation of existing neighborhoods and provides
policies that focus on buffering them from negative impacts
from incompatible uses.
Housing
The 2013 Centre Region Comprehensive Plan provides a number
of goals, objectives, and policies related to housing variety,
supply, and affordability. The plan encourages a variety of The 2013 Centre Region Comprehensive
plan includes several policies that emphasize
housing types that will meet the changing demographics within the need to provide more affordable
the region and also stresses the need for affordable housing housing in the region.
15