PMC Unit 2 Exercise 2
PMC Unit 2 Exercise 2
Exercise 2
Making effective decisions is a critical leadership quality. However, settling on the best
course of action is often easier said than done. When instinct and reasoning alone
aren't enough to pinpoint the best decision out of your available options, it can often
be helpful to utilize a decision-making model.
A decision-making model works by walking you through the decision-making process
— and there are several such models available for you to choose from.
To help you improve your problem-solving abilities and make better decisions, let's
take a look at five proven decision-making models and when you should use them.
There are five main decision-making models designed to help leaders analyse relevant
information and make optimal decisions.
The rational decision-making model involves identifying the criteria that will have the
biggest impact on your decision's outcome and then evaluating possible alternatives
against those criteria. The steps of the rational decision-making model are:
Step #1) Define the problem: You'll want to start by identifying the issue you are
trying to solve or the goal you are trying to achieve with your decision.
Step #2) Define criteria: The next step is to define the criteria you are looking for
in your decision. For instance, if you are deciding on a new car, you might be
looking for criteria such as space, fuel efficiency, and safety.
Step #3) Weight your criteria: If all of the criteria you define are equally important
to you, then you can skip this step. If some factors are more important, you will
want to assign a numerical value to your criteria based on how important each
factor is.
Step #4) Generate alternatives: Having defined and weighted the criteria you are
looking for, it's time to brainstorm ideas and develop a few alternatives that meet
your criteria.
Step #5) Evaluate your alternatives: For each possible solution you come up with,
you should evaluate it against your criteria, giving extra consideration to the
criteria you weighted more heavily.
Step #6) Choose the best alternative: After evaluating all possible alternatives,
select the option that best matches your weighted criteria.
Step #7) Implement the decision: The next to last step in the rational decision-
making model is simply putting your decision into practice.
Step #8) Evaluate your results: It's essential to evaluate your results anytime you
make a decision. Looking at your decision from a retrospective point of view can
help you decide if you should use the same decision-making process in the future.
The Vroom-Yetton decision-making model presents seven "yes or no" questions for a
decision-maker to answer followed by five decision-making styles for them to choose
from. It's the most complex decision-making model on our list, requiring decision-
makers to utilize a decision tree to arrive at the right decision-making style based on
their answers to the model's questions.
Check out this helpful resource for a complete breakdown of the Vroom-Yetton
decision-making model and a copy of the decision tree template you will need to use.
For example, if you don't have much information to consider, instinct may be the only
tool for finding the best solution that you have available. Likewise, trusting your
instinct can often yield the best results in cases where you are already deeply
experienced with the matter at hand since nothing hones instinct better than
experience.
The intuitive decision-making model probably shouldn't be the first model you turn to
when you need to make a decision, but there are instances where it can be useful.
We've mentioned a couple already, including cases where there isn't enough
information for you to make a more informed decision and instances where your own
experience is more reliable than the available information.
The intuitive decision-making model can also be useful in cases where you don't have a
lot of time and need to make a decision quickly.
Biasing in decision-making:
Anytime you are faced with an important decision, it is essential not to let biases get in
your way. Biases might be rooted in prior experiences, but that doesn't inherently
mean that they are grounded in facts. In many cases, avoiding biases is also key to
making an ethical decision since biases can sometimes cause you to mistreat certain
people and their ideas.
1. Confirmation bias
2. Availability bias
3. Survivorship bias
4. Anchoring bias
5. Halo effect
1. Confirmation bias:
Confirmation bias entails favouring or focusing on information that confirms your
pre-existing beliefs and ignoring information that runs counter to those beliefs.
While it's important to trust your own experience and beliefs, you don't want to
subconsciously favour information just because it aligns with what you already
believe to be true.
2. Availability bias:
Information that is easily accessible in your memory often gets undue weight, and
this is known as availability bias. One example of availability bias is overestimating
the likelihood of an event just because you can remember a similar event
happening to you in the past.
3. Survivorship bias:
Survivorship bias entails focusing only on the solutions that have generated
success in the past. While it's important to consider past results, ignoring possible
solutions just because they are unproven will place unnecessary constraints on
your decision-making process.
4. Anchoring bias:
Anchoring bias is the tendency to "anchor" yourself to the first piece of
information you learn. Information should not get extra weight just because you
have known about it for longer, and new information can be equally important to
consider.
5. Halo effect:
The halo effect occurs when positive experiences with or impressions of one
aspect of a possible solution cause you to view the entire solution positively.
Rather than being blinded by the positives, seek out and consider the negatives as
well.
Importance of Organizing
Organizations are systems created to achieve common goals through people-to-people
and people-to-work relationships. They are essentially social entities that are goal-
directed, deliberately structured for coordinated activity systems, and is linked to the
external environment. Organizations are made up of people and their relationships
with one another. Managers deliberately structure and coordinate organizational
resources to achieve the organization’s purpose.
Each organization has its own external and internal environments that define the
nature of the relationships according to its specific needs. Organizing is the function
that managers undertake to design, structure, and arrange the components of an
organization’s internal environment to facilitate attainment of organizational goals.
Organizing creates the framework needed to reach a company's objectives and goals.
Organizing is the process of defining and grouping activities, and establishing authority
relationships among them to attain organizational objectives.
Need and Importance of Organizing
1. Efficient Administration
2. Resource Optimization
3. Benefits of Specialization
4. Promotes Effective Communication
5. Creates Transparency
6. Expansion and Growth
1. Efficient Administration
It brings together various departments by grouping similar and related jobs under a
single specialization. This establishes coordination between different departments,
which leads to unification of effort and harmony in work.
It governs the working of the various departments by defining activities and their
authority relationships in the organizational structure. It creates the mechanism for
management to direct and control the various activities in the enterprise.
2. Resource Optimization
Organizing ensures effective role-job-fit for every employee in the organization. It
helps in avoiding confusion and delays, as well as duplication of work and overlapping
of effort.
3. Benefits of Specialization
It is the process of organizing groups and sub-divide the various activities and jobs
based on the concept of division of labour. This helps in the completion of maximum
work in minimum time ensuring the benefit of specialization.
5. Creates Transparency
The jobs and activities performed by the employees are clearly defined on the written
document called job description which details out what exactly has to be done in
every job. Organizing fixes the authority-responsibility among employees. This brings
in clarity and transparency in the organization.
6. Expansion and Growth
When resources are optimally utilized and there exists a proper division of work
among departments and employees, management can multiply its strength and
undertake more activities. Organizations can easily meet the challenges and can
expand their activities in a planned manner.
Organizational Structures
Organizational structure defines the manner in which the roles, power, authority, and
responsibilities are assigned and governed, and depicts how information flows between
the different levels of hierarchy in an organization.
The structure an organization designs depends greatly on its objectives and the
strategy it adopts in achieving those objectives.
Managements need to seriously consider how they wish to structure the organization.
Some of the critical factors that need to be considered are –
The organization’s top management team consists of several functional heads, such as
the VP Operations, VP Sales/Marketing etc. communication generally occurs within
each functional department and is communicated across departments through the
department heads.
In spite of the above benefits there are some issues that arise with this structure.
When different functional areas turn into silos (get isolated from other departments)
they focus only on their area of responsibility and do not support other functional
departments. Also expertise is limited to a single functional area allowing limited scope
for learning and growth.
As with every model, this model also has a few downsides like requirement of strong
skills specializing in the particular product. It could lead to functional duplication and
potential loss of control; each product group becomes a diverse unit in itself.
Geographic Organizational Structure
Organizations that cover a span of geographic regions structure the company
according to the geographic regions they operate in. This is typically found in
organizations that go beyond a city or state limit and may have customers all across
the country or across the world.
Organizations suffer a great loss when talented employees quit and join their
competitors. When an individual who has been trained for six months by an
organization leaves all of a sudden, it is both waste of time and energy. Make sure
employees who know their job and responsibilities well stick to the organization for a
long time at least for two to three years.
Every leader has a unique style of handling the employees (Juniors/Team). The
various ways of dealing with the subordinates at the workplace is called as
management style.
The superiors must decide on the future course of action as per the existing culture
and conditions at the workplace. The nature of employees and their mindsets also
affect the management style of working.
Delegation:
A manager alone cannot perform all the tasks assigned to him. In order to meet the
targets, the manager should delegate authority.
Elements of Delegation
1. Authority
2. Responsibility
3. Accountability
Authority must be well-defined. All people who have the authority should know what
is the scope of their authority is and they shouldn’t misutilize it. Authority is the right
to give commands, orders and get the things done. The top level management has
greatest authority.
Authority always flows from top to bottom. It explains how a superior gets work done
from his subordinate by clearly explaining what is expected of him and how he should
go about it.
2. Responsibility - is the duty of the person to complete the task assigned to him.
A person who is given the responsibility should ensure that he accomplishes the tasks
assigned to him. If the tasks for which he was held responsible are not completed, then
he should not give explanations or excuses. Responsibility without adequate authority
leads to discontent and dissatisfaction among the person.
Responsibility flows from bottom to top. The middle level and lower level
management holds more responsibility. The person held responsible for a job is
answerable for it. If he performs the tasks assigned as expected, he is bound for
praises. While if he doesn’t accomplish tasks assigned as expected, then also he is
answerable for that.
Accountability cannot be delegated. For example, if ’A’ is given a task with sufficient
authority, and ’A’ delegates this task to B and asks him to ensure that task is done well,
responsibility rest with ’B’, but accountability still rest with ’A’.
The top level management is most accountable. Being accountable means being
innovative as the person will think beyond his scope of job. Accountability, in short,
means being answerable for the end result.
For achieving delegation, a manager has to work in a system and has to perform
following steps: -
The managers at all levels delegate authority and power which is attached to their job
positions. The subdivision of powers is very important to get effective results.
3. Creating Responsibility and Accountability - The delegation process does not end
once powers are granted to the subordinates. They at the same time have to be
obligatory towards the duties assigned to them.
Accountability, on the others hand, is the obligation of the individual to carry out his
duties as per the standards of performance. Therefore, it is said that authority is
delegated, responsibility is created and accountability is imposed.
Principles of Delegation
There are a few guidelines in the form of principles which can be a help to manager in
the process of delegation. The principles of delegation are as follows:
This principle suggests that every manager before delegating the powers to the
subordinate should be able to clearly define the goals as well as results expected from
them. The goals and targets should be completely and clearly defined and the
standards of performance should also be notified clearly.
For example, a marketing manager explains the salesmen regarding the units of sale to
take place in a particular day, say ten units a day have to be the target sales. While a
marketing manager provides these guidelines of sales, mentioning the target sales is
very important so that the salesman can perform his duty efficiently with a clear set of
mind.
According to this principle, the manager should keep a balance between authority
and responsibility. Both of them should go hand in hand.
This says that the authority can be delegated but responsibility cannot be delegated by
managers to his subordinates which means responsibility is fixed. The manager at
every level, no matter what is his authority, is always responsible to his superior for
carrying out his task by delegating the powers. It does not means that he can escape
from his responsibility. He will always remain responsible till the completion of task.
Every superior is responsible for the acts of their subordinates and are accountable to
their superior therefore the superiors cannot pass the blame to the subordinates even
if he has delegated certain powers to subordinates example if the production manager
has been given a work and the machine breaks down. If repairmen is not able to get
repair work done, production manager will be responsible to CEO if their production is
not completed.
This principle suggests that a manager should exercise his authority within the
jurisdiction/framework given.
The manager should be forced to consult their superiors with those matters of which
the authority is not given that means before a manager takes any important decision,
he should make sure that he has the authority to do that on the other hand,
subordinate should also not frequently go with regards to their complaints as well as
suggestions to their superior if they are not asked to do.
This principle emphasizes on the degree of authority and the level up to which it has to
be maintained.
Importance of Delegation
Delegation of authority is a process in which the authority and powers are divided and
shared amongst the subordinates. When the work of a manager gets beyond his
capacity, there should be some system of sharing the work. This is how delegation of
authority becomes an important tool in organization function.
1. Through delegation, a manager is able to divide the work and allocate it to the
subordinates. This helps in reducing his work load so that he can work on
important areas such as - planning, business analysis etc.
2. With the reduction of load on superior, he can concentrate his energy on
important and critical issues of concern. This way he is able to bring
effectiveness in his work as well in the work unit. This effectivity helps a
manager to prove his ability and skills in the best manner.
3. Delegation of authority is the ground on which the superior-subordinate
relationship stands.
An organization functions as the authority flows from top level to bottom. This
in fact shows that through delegation, the superior-subordinate relationship
become meaningful. The flow of authority is from top to bottom which is a way
of achieving results.
5. Delegation of authority is not only helpful to the subordinates but it also helps
the managers to develop their talents and skills. Since the manager get enough
time through delegation to concentrate on important issues, their decision-
making gets strong and in a way they can flourish the talents which are required
in a manager.
Through granting powers and getting the work done, helps the manager to
attain communication skills, supervision and guidance, effective motivation and
the leadership traits are flourished. Therefore it is only through delegation, a
manager can be tested on his traits.
With effective results, a concern can think of creating more departments and
divisions flow working. This will require creation of more managers which can be
fulfilled by shifting the experienced, skilled managers to these positions. This
helps in both virtual as well as horizontal growth which is very important for a
concern’s stability.
Therefore, from the above points, we can justify that delegation is not just a process
but it is a way by which manager multiplies himself/herself and is able to bring
stability, ability and soundness to a concern.
What is Centralization?
Centralization refers to the concentration of authority at the top level of the
organisation. It is the systematic and consistent reservation of authority at the
central points within an organisation. In a centralized organisation, managers at the
lower level have a limited role in decision-making. They just have to execute the
orders and decisions of the top level.
What is Decentralization?
Conflict in There are least chances of any There are chances of conflict
Basis Centralization Decentralization