Sensitivity Analysis of WTIV Leg Design
Sensitivity Analysis of WTIV Leg Design
SUMMARY
In this study, sensitivity analysis of WTIV (Wind Turbine Installation Vessel) leg for the Korean west-south offshore wind
zone is performed considering soil characteristics. Firstly, environmental conditions and seabed characteristics of the
Korean west-south offshore wind zone is collected and investigated. Based on these data, design specifications are
established and the overall basic design is performed. The sensitivity analysis of WTIV leg design for the Korean west-
south offshore wind zone due to changes of soil characteristics is performed. It is observed that the WTIV leg design is
very sensitive to soil characteristics. The structural integrity of the WTIV leg is verified through the code check and the
adequate safety margin is observed. The results of this study can be expected as practical and useful data for the design of
the WTIV for the Korean west-south offshore wind zone.
Table 2: Statistical results of wave measurement surveys. Tables 3 and 4 show the cumulative probability
of occurrence for sea states and design conditions based
on a 50-year return period, respectively. These data are
obtained from the Korea Institute of Ocean Science &
Technology (KIOST) report [1]. The design conditions for
each return period for the Korean west-south offshore
wind zone, which were studied by Jeong et al. [2], are
summarized in Table 5. The design conditions for the wind
velocity are determined to be 41 m/sec based on the
literature surveys [3].
Table 7 shows the design specifications of the transit and 4. SEABED CHARACTERISTICS
DP (dynamic positioning), reloading, crane operation, and
survival conditions. Among all the conditions, the survival 4.1 POSSIBILITY OF PUNCH-THROUGH
condition is generally the most severe case for the majority
of the structures. The maximum wave height and wind The seabed characteristics of the Korean west-south
velocity are determined to be 13.76 m and 41 m/sec for the offshore wind zone are investigated through direct
survival condition, respectively. measurements and literature surveys. Figure 6 shows the
measurement points for the seabed characteristics. In Fig.
Table 6: Total leg length 6, 8 points (NO.1-NO.8) have been measured by the Korea
Electric Power Research Institute [4]. Other points
Parameter Data (OW.1-OW.8 and OWW.1-OWW.8) have been measured
Leg reserve 2.5 m by the authors through the national project acknowledged
Jack case height 12.5 m at the end of this paper.
WTIV depth 11.0 m
Air gap 9.0 m
Max. water depth 55.0 m
Penetration depth 15.0 m
Total Approximately 105.0 m
Depth (m) γ’
cu
Position Layer Soil φ (°) (kN/m2)
Top Base (kPa)
(assumed)
of unit of unit
1 Sand 0.0 32.0 35 - 10
2 Clay 32.0 42.0 - 20 10
NO.1 3 Sand 42.0 63.0 30 - 10
Weathered
4 63.0 67.0 25 - 10
soil
1 Sand 0.0 6.0 41 - 10
2 Clay 6.0 27.0 - 13 10
NO.8 3 Sand 27.0 39.0 36 - 10
Weathered
4 39.0 41.0 43 - 10
rock
In the design of the jack-up or WTIV, the estimation of the 4.2 SOIL STIFFNESS OF KOREAN WEST-
spudcan penetration force is an important step. So far, SOUTH OFFSHORE WIND ZONE
many studies have been performed on the design of the
spudcan and the spudcan penetration force [5~6]. In this Figure 9 shows effect of spudcan-soil fixity [8]. Figure 10
study, the spudcan penetration force for the Korean west- shows bending moment diagram for pinned and fixed
south offshore wind zone is estimated based on the conditions. If soil fixity effect is considered, the bending
SNAME rule [7]. The SNAME rule is widely accepted in moment at the lower guide can be reduced. Therefore
offshore engineering, and the conservative results are lighter scantlings are possible in the upper portion of leg
obtained through the SNAME rule. and hull-leg interface region. Even though pinned
constraint is regarded as the more conservative method,
The spudcan penetration force has already been studied by partially-fixed constraint can be also useful for the
Cho et al [5]. The spudcan is assumed to be a flat, circular, strength estimation of the WTIV leg.
cross-sectional area of 100 m2 with height of 2 m. At the
measured point NO.1, the seabed can resist about 14,000
tons without the punch-through phenomenon occurring.
However, at the measured point NO.8, the seabed can
resist only 1,500 tons and then the punch-through
phenomenon occurs. The estimated spudcan penetration
force can be useful and practical data for the design of the
spudcan.
(c) OWW.1~OWW.8
Figure 7: N value vs penetration depth curve Figure 9: Effect of spudcan-soil fixity [8]
Figure 10: Bending moment for pinned and fixed Table 9: Parameters for strength analysis of WTIV leg
conditions
In order to perform sensitivity analysis of the WTIV leg Parameter Data
for the Korean west-south offshore wind zone, the soil Hull main dimension (L×B×D) 124.8 m×40 m×11 m
stiffness needs to be obtained. In this study DNV CN 30.4 Lightweight (MT) 12,000
[9] is used. Most of the parameters are obtained through Payload (MT) 6,000
the actual soil investigation for the Korean west-south Crane load Not operating
offshore wind zone and some parameters are obtained LCG, TCG, VCG (m)* 73.79, 0.0, 20.0
from the references [7, 9]. In DNV CN 30.4 [9], the initial Design leg length (m) 105
stiffness can be calculated through Equations (1)~(3). Water depth (m) 55
These parameters can be possible to represent as actual Air gap (m) 9.0
overturning behavior against environmental loads such as
Leg chord distance (m) 8.0
wind, current and wind.
Leg bay height (m) 4.2
Vertical (Z) : Wave height (m) 13.7
Wave period (s) 12.0
4GR 1D Surface current (m/s) 1.029 (1/7 power law)
KZ 1 (1) Wind speed (m/s) 41.0
1 2R
Wave reduction factor 0.86
Current blockage factor 1.0
Horizontal (X)
Spudcan penetration (m) 3.0-15.0
Marine growth No marine growth
8GR 2D (2)
KX 1 CD/CM for rack and chord** 1.0, 1.8/2.0
2 3R CD/CM for braces 0.65/2.0
Wave theory Stream function 5th order
Rocking (θ) *LCG (longitudinal center of gravity), TCG (transverse
center of gravity), VCG (vertical center of gravity)
8GR D **CD (drag coefficient), CM (inertia coefficient)
K 1 2 (3)
3 1 R Table 10: Material property of WTIV leg
The leg property data are indicated in Table 12. Figure 11 The flow chart of the global in-place analysis of the WTIV
shows actual 3D view of one bay of the WTIV leg leg is shown in Figure 12. During the first step of the
structure. In case of the strength analysis model of the leg calculation, the static results, such as of both the base shear
structure, the equivalent section properties as rectangular and Overturning Moment (OTM) at the end of the spudcan,
shape are used in the SACS software. are estimated. Then the natural frequency based on the
SDOF (Single Degree Of Freedom) model is estimated
Table 12: Leg property data during the second step of the calculation. The Dynamic
Amplification Factor (DAF) is defined by the use of the
Type of leg 3-chorded truss type classical method based on the previous results depending
Chord distance Approximately 8.0 m on the wave heading angles. After these procedures, a
reanalysis is performed to consider the newly updated
Type of chords Split pipe with opposed teeth rack
inertia loads.
Thickness of rack in chord 177 mm thick and 995 mm wide
Bracing type Fully-crossed X-type bracing The strength analysis of the WTIV leg is performed with
the use of Structural Analysis Computer System (SACS)
Chord steel min. yielding stress 690 MPa software and code checks. The SACS model of the WTIV
Penetration depth Min. 3 m/Max. 15 m leg for the strength analysis is shown in Figure 13. The
considered loading conditions in the global in-place
analysis of the WTIV leg are shown in Table 13. A total
of four cases of loading directions are considered, as
shown in Figure 14.
Table 13: Loading conditions in global in-place analysis Table 14: Overturning stability calculation [5]
of the WTIV leg
Overturning Stabilizing
Angle Mx My dx dy e SMRF* Mso Factor Remark
moment moment
[deg.] [kN-m] [kN-m] [cm] [cm] [m] (kN-m) [kN-m] of safety (1)
Loading combination [kN-m] [kN-m]
Load 0 -2.06E+04 1.34E+06 1.34E+06 69.98 1.43 0.700 2.40E+05 8.17E+06 7.93E+06 5.93 OK
Subcase Self- Pay Con- Wind Inertia Wave
case 30 -8.10E+05 1.28E+06 1.52E+06 67.4 60.39 0.905 2.88E+05 9.68E+06 9.39E+06 6.19 OK
weight load sumable load load load 60 -1.72E+06 8.22E+05 1.91E+06 50.55 116.92 1.274 3.74E+05 8.18E+06 7.81E+06 4.09 OK
1 1 O O O - - - 90 -2.00E+06 -1.27E+05 2.01E+06 0.97 137.32 1.373 3.97E+05 4.35E+06 3.95E+06 1.97 OK
120 -1.66E+06 -7.68E+05 1.83E+06 -48.57 111.63 1.217 3.61E+05 8.26E+06 7.90E+06 4.33 OK
2 - - - - - O(1) 150 -7.66E+05 -1.27E+06 1.49E+06 -67.02 54.42 0.863 2.78E+05 9.56E+06 9.28E+06 6.25 OK
3 O O O O - - 180 -1.51E+04 -1.39E+06 1.39E+06 -71.62 1.08 0.716 2.44E+05 8.33E+06 8.08E+06 5.83 OK
4 4 cases of O O O - O -
210 8.31E+05 -1.30E+06 1.54E+06 -66.61 -59.69 0.894 2.86E+05 9.18E+06 8.90E+06 5.78 OK
loading 240 1.69E+06 -7.75E+05 1.86E+06 -47.18 -113.84 1.232 3.65E+05 7.59E+06 7.23E+06 3.89 OK
5 directions O O O - O O(1) 270 1.98E+06 -1.34E+05 1.98E+06 2.04 -135.77 1.358 3.94E+05 4.35E+06 3.96E+06 2.00 OK
300 1.68E+06 7.75E+05 1.85E+06 48.19 -114.06 1.238 3.66E+05 7.52E+06 7.15E+06 3.87 OK
6 O O O - - - 330 7.43E+05 1.23E+06 1.44E+06 64.92 -55.56 0.854 2.76E+05 9.05E+06 8.77E+06 6.10 OK
Member result:
Combined UC
Figure 14: Four cases of loading directions
7. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
9. AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY