COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

FOR

Supply, Carriage and delivery at site of SWMS Pipe

Including Overhead
Including Contractors
SL. NO. Name of Agency Size in mm Thk. in mm Offered Rate (Rs.) Charge (5% of offered Position Remarks
Profit (10%)
rate)

1 PUJA ENTERPRISE 200 8 RS. 2749.00 / RM 2886.45 3175.10 1st Lowest Out of Three (3) Quotation
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
2 U.S . Pipe Udyog 200 8 RS. 2990.00 / RM 3rd Lowest @ RS. 2749.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
3 Mahuashree Enterprise 200 8 RS. 2900.00 / RM 2nd Lowest
accept.

Out of Three (3) Quotation

4 PUJA ENTERPRISE 250 8 RS. 3451.00 / RM 3623.55 3985.91 1st Lowest Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
@ RS. 3451.00/ RM The rate
5 U.S . Pipe Udyog 250 8 RS. 3600.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
6 Mahuashree Enterprise 250 8 RS. 3580.00 / RM 2nd Lowest accept.
Out of Three (3) Quotation
7 PUJA ENTERPRISE 300 8 RS. 4113.00 / RM 4318.65 4750.52 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
8 U.S . Pipe Udyog 300 8 RS. 4400.00 / RM 3rd Lowest @ RS. 4113.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
9 Mahuashree Enterprise 300 8 RS. 4300.00 / RM 2nd Lowest Hence recommended to
accept.
Out of Three (3) Quotation
10 PUJA ENTERPRISE 350 8 RS. 4526.00 / RM 4752.3 5227.53 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
11 U.S . Pipe Udyog 350 8 RS. 4600.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 4526.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
12 Mahuashree Enterprise 350 8 RS. 4526.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
accept
Out of Three (3) Quotation
13 PUJA ENTERPRISE 400 8 RS. 5344.00 / RM 5611.2 6172.32 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
14 U.S . Pipe Udyog 400 10 RS. 5700.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 5344.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
15 Mahuashree Enterprise 400 10 RS. 5850.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
accept
Out of Three (3) Quotation
16 PUJA ENTERPRISE 450 10 RS. 7499.00 / RM 7873.95 8661.35 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
17 U.S . Pipe Udyog 450 10 RS. 7600.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 7499.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
18 Mahuashree Enterprise 450 10 RS. 7690.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
accept
Out of Three (3) Quotation
19 PUJA ENTERPRISE 500 10 RS. 8596.00 / RM 9025.8 9928.38 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
20 U.S . Pipe Udyog 500 10 RS. 8870.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 8596.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
21 Mahuashree Enterprise 500 10 RS. 8800.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
accept

Out of Three (3) Quotation

22 PUJA ENTERPRISE 600 10 RS. 10646.00 / RM 11178.3 12296.13 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
23 U.S . Pipe Udyog 600 10 RS. 10900.00 / RM 3rd Lowest @ RS. 10646.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
24 Mahuashree Enterprise 600 10 RS. 10646.00 / RM 2nd Lowest accept

25 PUJA ENTERPRISE 700 10 RS. 12449.00 / RM 13071.45 14378.60 1st Lowest Out of Three (3) Quotation
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
26 U.S . Pipe Udyog 700 10 RS. 13000.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 12449.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
27 Mahuashree Enterprise 700 10 RS. 13100.00 / RM 3rd Lowest accept
28 PUJA ENTERPRISE 750 10 RS. 13351.00 / RM 14018.55 15420.41 1st Lowest Out of Three (3) Quotation
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
@ RS. 13451.00/ RM The rate
29 U.S . Pipe Udyog 750 10 RS. 14000.00 / RM 2nd Lowest
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
accept
30 Mahuashree Enterprise 750 10 RS. 14300.00 / RM 3rd Lowest

Out of Three (3) Quotation

31 PUJA ENTERPRISE 800 10 RS. 14451.00 / RM 15173.55 16690.91 1st Lowest Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
@ RS. 14451.00/ RM The rate
32 U.S . Pipe Udyog 800 10 RS. 15501.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
33 Mahuashree Enterprise 800 10 RS. 15480.00 / RM 2nd Lowest accept

Out of Three (3) Quotation

34 PUJA ENTERPRISE 900 12 RS. 19494.00 / RM 20468.7 22515.57 1st Lowest
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
35 U.S . Pipe Udyog 900 12 RS. 19800.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 19494.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
36 Mahuashree Enterprise 900 12 RS. 19890.00 / RM 3rd Lowest
accept

37 PUJA ENTERPRISE 1000 12 RS. 21688.00 / RM 22772.4 25049.64 1st Lowest Out of Three (3) Quotation
Received , the lowest rate
offered by PUJA ENTERPRISE
38 U.S . Pipe Udyog 1000 12 RS. 22000.00 / RM 2nd Lowest @ RS. 21688.00/ RM The rate
is Competitive and workable.
Hence recommended to
39 Mahuashree Enterprise 1000 12 RS. 23000.00 / RM 3rd Lowest accept
 PUJA ENTERPRISE
HO- 1/B SAHID PRALAY DAS MAZUMDAR ROAD KOLKATA-
SPECIALISED IN LARGE DIAMETERS P.E/PIPE/MARKT/001
700065
PIPES 8" TO 120" P.E [email protected] FORMATE NO
MARKETING DIVISION,KOLKATA, INDIA REV. NO 0
QUOTATION FOR SUPPLY OF GI,ERW,SEAMLESS, SPIRAL PIPES DATE 01.04.2021
Quotatio Dateof
n No. 21-22 -34 Name of the client Nabcons,KOLKATA
quotation
04-11-2023
Basic rate Total Price per Mtrs Ex works
SL. NO. SIZE OD in mm WT in mm Qty in Mtrs GST @18% MAKE
per Mtrs (including GST) IN INR
1 48'' 1219.2 11.2 400 26,424.37 EXTRA - 11 TO 11.2 SAIL
1 8'' 219.1 8 3000 2,749.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
2 10'' 273.1 8 3000 3,451.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
3 12'' 323.9 8 3000 4,113.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
4 14'' 355.6 8 3000 4,526.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
5 16'' 406.4 8 3000 5,344.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
6 18'' 457.2 10 3000 7,499.00 EXTRA ERW PIPE
7 20'' 508 10 3000 8,596.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
8 24'' 609.6 10 3000 10,646.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
9 28'' 711.2 10 3000 12,449.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
10 30'' 762 10 3000 13,351.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
11 32'' 812.8 10 3000 14,451.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
12 36'' 914.4 10 3000 16,280.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
13 40'' 1625.6
1016 10 3000 18,109.00 EXTRA SWPIPE SW MS PIPE
14 64'' 20 1000 70,027.40 EXTRA JINDAL/JCO
Note : BEAR PIPE
SL NO Commercial Terms & Conditions
1 Delivery :- Dispatches will be 4 TO 6 week from the date of PO, approved QAP, Advance whichever is later.
2 Pipe Length :- 10 TO 12 MTRS OR 6 MTRS
3 Bevelled Ends :- yes /AS PER IS 3589 FE 410
4 Inspection :- At works before despatch.
5 Payment Term :- 20% Advance With PO Balance 80% before Deapatch
6 The offer is valid till :- 30-11-2023
7 Make;- SAIL/ UTKARS
9 Freight :- EX KOLKATA AT YOUR SITE
Extra Quoted prices are on the basis of present Steel / Raw materials prices of steel plants etc. and Taxes/ Duties are at prevailing rates. In case of any increase till dispatch of materials
Point will be applicable.
As per government law/policy w.e.f. 1st October 2020 TCS @ 0.075% of the total invoice value will be charged extra on the above quotation/ amount. This
A Tax Collection at Source (TCS)
amount is not included in the quotation at this moment. Also w.e.f. 1st April 2021 the TCS will be charged @ 0.1%
B Interest on Delayed Payment Interest will be charged @ 24% P.A. if the payment is not received within 7 days from the date of Invoice.
C Third Party Inspection and its charges All TPI Expenses including Boarding/ Lodging & Fooding in Buyer's account.
D Manufacturing of the Pipe As per be manufactured as per approved QAP only at our plant
2 Technical Terms & Conditions
A The pipes to be supplied as per IS 3589 - Fe410 from material Grade of IS 2062 Grade E 250 BR or Equivalent
B Tolerances on Wall Thickness Wall Thickness, weight and Outer Diameter Tolerance as per IS:3589:2001
C Internal Coating NO
D External Coating NO
E Qty. Tolerance One pipe +/-
CORRESPONDENCE OFFICE-8/1,PRINCE STREET 1 ST FLOOR KOLKATA-700072
Prepared By : - SUDIP MITRA
Email;-id [email protected] Date 04-11-2023
9830204870
+91-9830204870/8583995985/9330169322/9433215730
(This is a computer generated quotation & do not require signature)
 PUJA ENTERPRISE
HO- 1/B SAHID PRALAY DAS MAZUMDAR ROAD KOLKATA-
SPECIALISED IN LARGE DIAMETERS P.E/PIPE/MARKT/001
700065
PIPES 8" TO 120" P.E [email protected] FORMATE NO
MARKETING DIVISION,KOLKATA, INDIA REV. NO 0
QUOTATION FOR SUPPLY OF GI,ERW,SEAMLESS, SPIRAL PIPES DATE 01.04.2021
Quotatio Dateof
n No. 21-22 -35 Name of the client Nabcons,KOLKATA
quotation
04-11-2023
Basic rate Total Price per Mtrs Ex works
SL. NO. SIZE OD in mm WT in mm Qty in Mtrs GST @18% MAKE
per Mtrs (including GST) IN INR
1 36'' 914.4 12 3000 19,494.00 EXTRA SWPIPE
2 40'' 1625.6
1016 12 3000 21,688.00 EXTRA SWPIPE SW MS PIPE
14 64'' 20 1000 70,027.40 EXTRA JINDAL/JCO
Note : BEAR PIPE
SL NO Commercial Terms & Conditions
1 Delivery :- Dispatches will be 4 TO 6 week from the date of PO, approved QAP, Advance whichever is later.
2 Pipe Length :- 10 TO 12 MTRS OR 6 MTRS
3 Bevelled Ends :- yes /AS PER IS 3589 FE 410
4 Inspection :- At works before despatch.
5 Payment Term :- 20% Advance With PO Balance 80% before Deapatch
6 The offer is valid till :- 30-11-2023
7 Make;- SAIL
9 Freight :- EX KOLKATA AT YOUR SITE
Extra Quoted prices are on the basis of present Steel / Raw materials prices of steel plants etc. and Taxes/ Duties are at prevailing rates. In case of any increase till dispatch of materials
Point will be applicable.
As per government law/policy w.e.f. 1st October 2020 TCS @ 0.075% of the total invoice value will be charged extra on the above quotation/ amount. This
A Tax Collection at Source (TCS)
amount is not included in the quotation at this moment. Also w.e.f. 1st April 2021 the TCS will be charged @ 0.1%
B Interest on Delayed Payment Interest will be charged @ 24% P.A. if the payment is not received within 7 days from the date of Invoice.
C Third Party Inspection and its charges All TPI Expenses including Boarding/ Lodging & Fooding in Buyer's account.
D Manufacturing of the Pipe As per be manufactured as per approved QAP only at our plant
2 Technical Terms & Conditions
A The pipes to be supplied as per IS 3589 - Fe410 from material Grade of IS 2062 Grade E 250 BR or Equivalent
B Tolerances on Wall Thickness Wall Thickness, weight and Outer Diameter Tolerance as per IS:3589:2001
C Internal Coating NO
D External Coating NO
E Qty. Tolerance One pipe +/-
CORRESPONDENCE OFFICE-8/1,PRINCE STREET 1 ST FLOOR KOLKATA-700072
Prepared By : - SUDIP MITRA
Email;-id [email protected] Date 04-11-2023
9830204870
+91-9830204870/8583995985/9330169322/9433215730
(This is a computer generated quotation & do not require signature)
 U.S. PIPE UDYOG
88, SHOVA BAZAR STREET, KOLKATA-700005
[email protected], PH. NO. 6290149221/03325540930
==========================================================================
To
Pramod Ghosh Dt-10/11/2023
Contact No- +918159806577
M/S Nabcons ,Kolkata

Sub. : Offer for MS PIPE MS Pipe.

Dear Sir, with ref to your Enquiry we are submitting our best offer as follows:-
8 (RATE PE
1( SLNO) 8''(SIZE) 219.1 (OD) 3000 (MTRS) 2,990.00
(THICKNESS) MTRS) ERW PIPE
2 10'' 273.1 8 3000 3,600.00 ERW PIPE
3 12'' 323.9 8 3000 4,400.00 ERW PIPE
4 14'' 355.6 8 3000 4,600.00 ERW PIPE
5 16'' 406.4 8 3000 5,700.00 ERW PIPE
6 18'' 457.2 10 3000 7,600.00 ERW PIPE
7 20'' 508 10 3000 8,870.00 SWPIPE
8 24'' 609.6 10 3000 10,900.00 SWPIPE
9 28'' 711.2 10 3000 13,000.00 SWPIPE
10 30'' 762.0 10 3000 14,000.00 SWPIPE
11 32'' 812.8 10 3000 15,501.00 SWPIPE
12 36'' 914.4 10 3000 17,300.00 SWPIPE
13 40'' 1016 10 3000 18,500.00 SWPIPE
14 36'' 914.4 12 3000 19,800.00 SWPIPE
15 40'' 1016 12 3000 22,000.00 SWPIPE
1. Price - Ex KOLKATA. Final Rate
2. Delivery within 12 weeks from the date of P.O.
3. GST will be charged extra @18%
4. Payment – 100 % Advance against Performa Invoice.
6. Validity: 30Days
7 .MAKE -SAIL
Thanking you,
Regards,

For U. S. PIPE UDYOG

Authorized Signatory

DEALER OF MS & GI ERW, SW PIPES

 MAHUASHREE ENTERPRISE
Address : 42/72/1D/1, Bediadanga 2 nd Lane, Kolkata 700039
Mob. : 9330530638 / 9433492756, E-mail : [email protected]
GST NO.: 19AUIPS7609F1Z6, PAN NO.: AUIPS7609F
Supplier of: Pipes, Pipe Fittings, Flanges, Fasteners, Valves (Gate, Globe, Check, Butterfly, Ball, Plug),
Expansion Joint, Instruments (Pr. Gauge, Temp. Gauge, Pr. Swh, Temp. Swh, Level Indicator)

Date : 09.11.2023
M/S Nabcons
Pramod Ghosh
Kolkata -
Sub. : Offer for MS pipe
Dear Sir,
With ref to your Enquiry Dt 4/11/2023 we are submitting our best offer as follows:-

SL NO / SIZE / THICKNES / MTRS / RATE PER MTRS

1 8'' 8 3000 2,900.00 ERW MSPIPE
2 10'' 8 3000 3,580.00 ERW MSPIPE
3 12'' 8 3000 4,300.00 ERW MS PIPE
4 14'' 8 3000 4,640.00 ERW MS PIPE
5 16'' 8 3000 5,850.00 ERW MS PIPE
6 18'' 10 3000 7,690.00 ERW MS PIPE
7 20'' 10 3000 8,800.00 SW MS PIPE
8 24'' 10 3000 10,999.00 SW MS PIPE
9 28'' 10 3000 13,100.00 SW MS PIPE
10 30'' 10 3000 14,300.00 SW MSPIPE
11 32'' 10 3000 15,480.00 SW MSPIPE
12 36'' 10 3000 17,380.00 SW MS PIPE
13 40'' 10 3000 18,580.00 SW MS PIPE
14 36'' 12 3000 19,890.00 SW MSPIPE
15 40'' 12 3000 23.00000 SW MS PIPE
Terms & Condition.

1. Price - Ex our godown kolkata

2. Delivery Charges: As Applicable
3. Delivery within 6 weeks from the date of P.O.
4. GST will be charged extra @18%

5. Payment – 100 % Advance against Proforma Invoice.

6. Validity: 10 Days

For MAHUASHREE ENTERPRISE

Authorized Signatory

BEST QUALITY, COMPETITIVE PRICE & PROMPT DELIVERY IS OUR PRIME COMMITMENT