DBB2104 Unit-08
DBB2104 Unit-08
DBB2104 Unit-08
BACHELOR OF BUSINESS
ADMINISTRATION
SEMESTER 3
DBB2104
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Unit 8
Capital Structure Theories
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION
Capital structure planning is considered very crucial in financial
STUDY NOTE
decision making since its components are related to each other
Capital structure is
and it also has a relationship with risk, return and value of the
important both for
firm. Basically, there are two forms of capital: equity capital and Fortune 500
companies and for
debt capital small business owners
trying to determine
In order to have sustainable business growth, a balance has to be how much of their
start-up money should
maintained between various funding sources, weighing the pros
come from a bank loan
and cons of each type of capital. The purpose of a finance manager without endangering
the business.
in every organization is to create a capital structure that strives to
attain a balance between risk and reward for the shareholders.
Working capital, or the cash in hand, a company has is the part of capital structure only.
Working capital is the difference between a business’s assets and liabilities.
More debt than equity means a business has more liability than assets and it will be seen by
the investor as a riskier investment although it may vary from industry to industry. In any
organization capital structure decision is considered to be the most important decision taken
by the management as it has an effect on the risk profile and the profitability of the firm.
The capital structure helps firms to decide how to finance the assets and operations of the
business. A firm can have a combination of debt, equity, and hybrid securities as its source
of finance.
By looking at capital structure one can find out how a firm finance itself. It can choose from
a number of securities: shares, bonds, preferred shares, convertible bonds, etc. Basically,
there are two types of securities, debt and equity, each has its own benefits and drawbacks.
This chapter will give you further insights into important capital structure theories.
Thus, capital structure refers to the proportions or combinations of equity share capital,
preference share capital, debentures, long-term loans, retained earnings, and other long-
term sources of funding in the total amount of capital that a firm should raise to run its
business.
Source: https://caknowledge.com/capital-structure-meaning-types/
Fig 1: Capital Structure
Definition
“Capital structure of a company refers to the make-up of its capitalization and it includes all
long-term capital resources viz., loans, reserves, shares and bonds.”—Gerstenberg.
“Capital structure is the combination of debt and equity securities that comprise a firm’s
financing of its assets.”—John J. Hampton.
“Capital structure refers to the mix of long-term sources of funds, such as debentures, long-
term debts, preference share capital and equity share capital including reserves and sur-
plus.”—I. M. Pandey.
People often get confused between the term capital structure and financial structure.
Financial structure includes shareholder’s funds, long term and short-term debt. But capital
structure includes only long-term debt and shareholder’s funds. So, we can say that capital
structure is only one segment in the financial structure of the firm. But some experts in
financial management consider capital structure the same as financial structure.
Capital structure is a part of the financial structure. Capital structure includes only long-term
debt and equity in the total capital. While financial structure includes owner’s equity as well
as long term and short-term liabilities.
The difference between capital structure and financial structure is that the former does not
include short term liabilities.
As far as the term asset structure is concerned, it means a firm’s total assets. In other words,
it will be shown in the assets side of the balance sheet of a company which implies that that
fund has been applied in procuring fixed and current assets.
Calculation
Example 2: Calculating capital structure when financial leverage ratio is given - the financial
=2.5
A = 2.5 × (A − L) A = 2.5
A − 2.5 L 2.5
L = 2.5 A − A
2.5 L = 1.5 A
L/A% = 1.5/2.5 = 60%
1. The capital structure is defined as the mix of ___________and __________ that the firm
uses in its operation.
2. Capital structure does not include short term liabilities but financial structure
includes short-term liabilities or current liabilities. (True/False)
3. Capital structure of a firm is a part of its financial structure.
4. Capital structure consists of long-term debt and ________ fund.
Many firms consider debt structuring as it is a cheaper source of finance because interest
payable on a debt is tax deductible. But at the same time, it also has some drawbacks, like the
risk of bankruptcy or increased fixed interest obligations. Different theories have evolved to
find the optimum capital structure so as to maximize the value of a firm. In the following
sections these will be explained.
where:
E = Market value of the firm’s equity
D = Market value of the firm’s debt V=E + D
Re = Cost of equity
Rd = Cost of debt
Tc = Corporate tax rate
Suppose a firm has equity-debt ratio of 50:50. If it changes this ratio to 20:80, it will bring a
positive change in the business as the value per share of the firm will increase.
Calculation procedure
# Particulars Amount
A EBIT XXX
B Less: Interest cost (Debt X Interest rate) (XX)
C EAT (Tax is assumed to be absent) XXX
D Shareholders earnings (C = D) XXX
E Market value of equity shares (D/Cost of Equity) XX
F Market value of debt XX
G Total market value of firm (E + F) XXX
H Overall cost of capital in percentage (A/G*100) XX%
Example: Consider a fictitious company with the figures (all figures in Rupees).
EBIT = 1,00,000
Less: Interest cost (10% of 300,000) = 30,000
Earnings (since tax is assumed to be = 70,000
absent)
Shareholders’ earnings = 70,000
Market value of equity (70,000/14%) = 5,00,000
Now, assume that the proportion of debt increases from 3,00,000 to 4,00,000, and everything
EBIT = 1,00,000
Less: Interest cost (10% of 4,00,000) = 40,000
Earnings (since tax is assumed to be = 60,000
absent)
Shareholders’ earnings = 60,000
Market value of equity (60,000/14%) = 4,28,570 (approx.)
The market value of debt = 4,00,000
Total market value = 8,28,570
EBIT/(Total value of firm)
The overall cost of capital = 1,00,000/8,28,570
12.% (approx.)
It is clear from the above illustration that in net income approach, as the debt proportion
increases, the overall market value of the company will also increase resulting in decreased
cost of capital. As debt is a cheaper source of finance than equity, increase in debt finance
will reduce WACC and the value of firm will increase.
5. According to the net income approach, the value of a firm can be increased by
decreasing the ________ through higher debt proportion.
6. Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is the weighted average cost of _______
and debts where the weights are the amount of capital raised from each source.
While financing their businesses, companies choose to have a mix ratio of debt and equity in
their capital structure. The other name of debt ratio in capital structure is financial leverage.
Companies have a choice here; they can choose to have more debt or more equity while
financing their assets. The paramount aim of a company is to maximize profits and its market
value. At last, only the relationship between the capital structure and value of a firm matters
to a company.
There is a difference of opinion in this matter, some believe that an increase in the debt
component will increase the value of a firm, while the others are of the opinion that it will
also increase risk at the same time. Various theories have been given to establish the
relationship between financial leverage, weighted average cost of capital and the total value
of the firm. One among them is the net operating income approach.
This theory was given by Durand and is also known as the traditional approach and it is
completely different from the net income approach. As per this theory, change in debt of the
firm will not bring about any change in the total value of the firm. Moreover, it says that no
relationship exists between capital structure decision, WACC, and the total value of a
company. In other words, we can say that they are independent of each other.
It further says that the market value of a firm depends on its operating income and the
related business risk of the firm. Financial leverage does not affect any of the above
mentioned fac- tors; it can only affect the income of debt holders and equity holders but does
not have any impact on the operating income of the firm. For this reason, it can be concluded
that any change in the debt-to-equity ratio does not impact the value of the firm.
As a company increases its debt component, the related risk also simultaneously increases
which causes the equity shareholders to expect a higher return. So, when a company
increases its financial leverage, the cost of equity also increases with it.
A.
C. Example
D. Consider a fictitious company with the following figures (all figures are in Rupees).
EBIT = 1,00,000
WACC = 12.5%
Market value of the company = EBIT/WACC
= 1,00,000/12.5%
= 8,00,000
Total debt = 3,00,000
Total equity = Total market value – total debt
= 8,00,000 – 3,00,000
= 5,00,000
Shareholders’ earnings = EBIT – interest on debt
= 1,00,000 – 10% of 3,00,000
= 70,000
Cost of equity = 70,000/5,00,000
= 14 %
Now assume that the proportion of debt increases from 3,00,000 to 4,00,000 and everything
else remains the same.
(EBIT) = 1,00,000
WACC = 12.5%
The market value of the company = EBIT/WACC
= 1,00,000/12.5%
= 8,00,000
Total debt = 4,00,000
Total equity = Total market value –
total debt
= 8,00,000 – 4,00,000
= 4,00,000
= EBIT – Interest on
debt
= 1,00,000 – 10% of
4,00,000
= 60,000
= 60,000/4,00,000
= 15%
So, on the basis of above illustration, we can say that, in the net operating income approach,
with the increase in debt proportion, market value of the company remains unaffected, but
the cost of equity increases.
According to the traditional theory of capital structure, the optimal capital structure will
increase to a certain level before it remains constant and eventually begins to decrease. An
increase or a decline on the optimal structure of capital affects the value of a firm. Hence,
when the overall cost of capital is reduced down to a specific level of debt, the optimal capital
structure exists to increase the value of a company.
c) The average cost of capital Kw, decreases up to a certain level, remains unchanged more
or less, and thereafter rises after attaining a certain level.
Example
It is clear from the above example that with the increase in financial leverage of the
company, the debt increases from 10% to 50% and there is a decrease in equity from 90%
to 50% (case 1 to 3). As can be seen from the table, there is also an increase in cost of debt
and equity because of the company’s higher exposure to risk. The WACC decreased from
16.3% to 15.5%.
It can also be observed from the table, that as the financial leverage of the company increases,
the overall cost of capital decreases simultaneously. The reason behind this is that debt is a
cheaper source of finance as interest on debt is tax deductible.
When a company increases its financial leverage further, there is an increase in debt from
50% to 90% and a reduction in equity from 50% to 10% (Case 3 to 5). There is also a
further increase in cost of debt and equity. The new WACC is increased from 15.5% to
16.7%. So, it can be revealed that as the financial leverage of the company increases, the
overall cost of capital also increases.
The above exercise shows that initially increasing the debt reduces WACC but only to a
certain level. After that level is crossed, a further increase in the debt level increases WACC
and reduces the market value of the company.
2. VL = VU
Where:
VU = Value of unleveraged firm (Equity financed)
VL = Value of leveraged firm (Debt and equity financed)
3. Proposition 2 (M &M I)
Where:
rE = Cost of levered equity
ra = Cost of unlevered equity
rD =Cost of debt
D/E = Debt-to-equity ratio
As per the second preposition, a company’s cost of equity and a company’s leverage level are
directly proportional to each other. There will be an increase in related risk and therefore
investors may demand a higher return due to the additional risk.
Where:
Tc = Tax rate
D = Debt
It states that the cost of equity and leverage level directly proportional to each other.
Example
Company A and B are two similar businesses with similar business risks. Company A is
unleveraged whereas Company B is leveraged with Rs. 2,00,000 debenture @ 5% interest
rates. Both companies earn Rs. 50,000 before-tax income. The after-tax capitalization rate is
10% and the corporate tax rate is 40%. Calculate the market value of the two firms.
Solution
Firm A Firm B
Net operating income 50,000 50,000
Interest on debenture - 10,000
Profit before taxes 50,000 40,000
Taxes (40%) 20,000 16,000
Profit after taxes 30,000 24,000
After-tax capitalization rate 10% 10%
Total market value of the equity (S) 3,00,000 2,40,000
Market value of debt (B) - 2,00,000
Total value (V) 3,00,000 4,40,000
4. SUMMARY
• Theories of capital structure argue about the use of debt in the capital mix and its
resulting impact on the value of a firm; dividend theories argue about the policy of
dividend payment and retention and its resulting impact on the value of the firm.
• These theories have been divided into two categories: theories of relevance and
theories of irrelevance.
• All the theories are bound by certain assumptions which are subject to criticism.
• Application of these theories would be possible if all the assumptions are realized.
• Practically, at the time of formulation of investment and financing policies in the
industry, these capital structures and dividend theories provide guidance.
5. GLOSSARY
Capital Structure: Capital Structure is the proportion of all types of long-term capital.
Financial structure is the proportion of all types of long-term and short-term capital.
EBIT: Earnings before Interest and taxes.
EPS: Earning per share.
NI approach: Net income approach says more usage of debt will enhance the value of the
firm.
NOI approach: Net operating income approach.
WACC: Weighted average cost of capital.
Cost of equity: The cost of equity is the return a company requires to decide if an investment
meets capital return requirements.
Debt: Debt is something, usually money, borrowed by one party from another. Debt is used
by many corporations and individuals to make large purchases that they could not afford
under normal circumstances. A debt arrangement gives the borrowing party permission to
borrow money under the condition that it is to be paid back at a later date, usually with
interest.
Cost of capital: Cost of capital is the required return necessary to make a capital budgeting
project, such as building a new factory, worthwhile.
Cost of debt: The cost of debt is the effective interest rate a company pays on its debts
5. CASE STUDY
“A business that doesn’t grow dies”, says Mr. Shah, the owner of Shah Marble Ltd. with a
grand success having a capital base of Rs. 80 crores in just 36 months. Within a short span of
time, the company could generate a cash flow which not only covered
fixed cash payment obligations but also create a sufficient buffer. The company is on the
growth path and a new breed of consumers are eager to buy the Italian marble sold by Shah
Marble Ltd. To meet the increasing demand, Mr. Shah decided to expand his business by
acquiring a mine. This required an investment of Rs. 120 crores. To seek advice in this
matter, he called his financial advisor, Mr. Seth who advised him a judicious mix of equity
(40%) and debt (60%). Mr. Seth also suggested to him to take a loan from a financial
institution as the cost of raising funds from financial institutions is low. Though this will
increase financial risk, it will also increase the return to equity shareholders. He also
apprised him that the issue of debt will not dilute the control of equity shareholders. At the
same time, the interest on a loan is a tax-deductible expense for computation of tax liability.
After due deliberations with Mr. Seth, Mr. Shah decided to raise funds from a financial
institution.
1. Identify and explain the concept of financial management as advised by Mr. Seth in the
above situation.
7. TERMINAL QUESTIONS
SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS
Q1. What is a firm’s capital structure? How is it different from financial structure?
Q2. Under the traditional approach to capital structure, what happens to the cost of debt and
cost of equity as the firm’s financial leverage increases?
7.1 ANSWERS
SELF ASSESSMENT QUESTIONS
1. Debt and Equity
2. True
3. True
4. Shareholder’s fund
5. The overall cost of capital (WACC)
6. Equity
7. Traditional
8. Debt and equity
TERMINAL QUESTIONS
SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS
Answer 1: Capital structure refers to the proportions or combinations of equity share
capital, preference share capital, debentures, long-term loans, retained earnings, and other
long-term sources of funds in the total amount of capital which a firm should raise to run its
business. Capital structure is different from the financial structure. It is a part of the financial
structure. Capital structure refers to the proportion of long-term debt and equity in the total
capital of a company. On the other hand, financial structure refers to the net worth or owners’
equity and all liabilities (long-term as well as short-term).
Answer 2: In the traditional approach to capital structure, the cost of debt capital Kd,
remains constant more or less up to a certain level and thereafter rises. The cost of equity
capital, Ke, remains constant more or less, or rises gradually up to a certain level and
thereafter increases rapidly.
REFERENCES
• A., & Olokoyo, F. O. (2015). An empirical analysis of capital structure on performance
of firms in the petroleum industry in Nigeria. Journal of Accounting and Auditing:
Research & Practice, 1-9
• Alves, P. F. P., & Ferreira, M. A. (2011). Capital structure and law around the world.
Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 21(3), 119-150.