Assignment
Assignment
Lack of Employee Involvement: The new system was implemented without consulting or
involving the employees in its development.
Resistance to Change: Employees, particularly miners, resisted the change, viewing it as a
threat to their occupational identity and community.
Managerial Perspective vs. Employee Perspective: Management perceived the change as
rational and necessary, while employees saw it as an imposition and a threat.
Political and Cultural Dynamics: The case highlights the role of power, politics, identity, and
culture in organizational change.
In the context of the Glenrothes Colliery case, applying the Conversational Framework could have
potentially mitigated resistance by involving employees in meaningful dialogue about the change,
addressing their concerns, and aligning the new appraisal system with their identity and cultural
values. This approach underscores the importance of communication in effectively managing and
facilitating organizational change (Nielsen et al., 2009).
Background of Glenrothes Colliery
Historical Overview Before the 1980s
Glenrothes Colliery, located in Fife, Scotland, has a rich history that dates to the early 20th century.
The colliery was one of many in the Fife coalfield, an area with a long-standing association with coal
mining. The development of Glenrothes Colliery was part of the broader industrialization of
Scotland, which saw a rapid expansion of coal mining to fuel the growing demands of the industrial
revolution and the subsequent wars (SLEEMAN, 1987).
During its early years, Glenrothes Colliery played a pivotal role in the local economy, providing
employment to a significant portion of the population in Fife (McCollum et al., 2021). The colliery,
like many others in the region, was not just a workplace but a central part of community life,
influencing the social and cultural fabric of the surrounding area. Mining communities were tightly
knit, with generations of families often working in the mines.
Overview of the Coal Industry in the UK During the 1980s (The miners' strike of
1984-5: An oral history)
By the 1980s, the coal industry in the UK, including Glenrothes Colliery, faced significant challenges.
The decade marked a period of substantial change and turmoil for the industry. The government,
under Margaret Thatcher, was moving towards energy diversification and reducing reliance on coal.
This shift led to the closure of many mines and significant job losses, sparking widespread industrial
action and strikes, most notably the miners' strike of 1984-85.
Economically, the coal industry was grappling with increasing costs, competition from cheaper
imported coal, and the need to invest in newer, more efficient mining technologies.
Environmentally, there was a growing awareness of the impact of coal mining and burning on air
quality and climate change, leading to stricter regulations.
The 1980s were a pivotal decade for the coal industry in the UK, marking the end of an era for many
traditional mining communities and heralding a period of significant economic and social transition,
particularly in areas like Fife, where mining had been a cornerstone of community life for
generations.
Restraining Forces
1. Worker Resistance: The most palpable restraining force was the resistance from workers.
The threat of unemployment and the erosion of their skills and identity led to significant
resistance from the workforce. This resistance was not just about job security but also about
preserving a way of life deeply ingrained in mining communities (Feu, 2020).
2. Union Influence: Unions played a crucial role in organizing worker resistance. They mobilized
strikes and protests, negotiating with governments and industry leaders to protect jobs and
workers' rights. The unions' influence was significant, often slowing down or complicating
the process of industry restructuring and closure.
3. Cultural Attachment to Traditional Practices: There was a strong cultural attachment to
traditional mining practices within these communities. Coal mining was not only an
occupation but also a significant part of the community's identity and heritage. This cultural
attachment acted as a restraining force against the decline of the industry, as communities
fought to preserve their heritage and way of life.
Interaction of Forces
The interaction between the driving and restraining forces created a complex and often contentious
dynamic in the coal industry, particularly evident in decision-making processes.
Economic Pressures vs. Worker Resistance: As economic pressures mounted due to market
competition and technological advancements, industry leaders and governments pushed for
restructuring and downsizing. However, worker resistance, often led by powerful unions,
challenged these moves. Strikes and protests not only disrupted coal production but also
brought the plight of the workers to public attention, influencing political decisions (Hodson,
1995).
Technological Change vs. Cultural Attachment: Technological advancements aimed at
improving efficiency and environmental compliance conflicted with the cultural attachment
to traditional mining practices. Many workers viewed these changes as a threat to their skills
and identity, leading to resistance against adopting new technologies and practices
(Goldstone, 2012).
Environmental Regulations vs. Economic and Social Stability: The need to comply with
environmental regulations and move towards cleaner energy sources clashed with the
economic and social stability of mining communities. Governments and industry leaders had
to balance environmental priorities with the socioeconomic impact of declining coal mining
on communities (S. Cohen et al., 2020).
Negotiation and Compromise: The interaction of these forces often led to negotiations and
compromises. For instance, governments and industry leaders had to provide retraining
programs, economic aid, and other forms of support to ease the transition for workers and
communities (Overvest, 2023).
Union Resistance
Unions played a pivotal role in organizing and amplifying worker resistance. They led strikes,
negotiated with employers, and sought public support. A notable instance was during the UK miners'
strike, where Arthur Scargill, the National Union of Mineworkers leader, passionately argued, "We
are defending our jobs, our communities, and our very dignity." His words echoed the sentiment of
many workers, emphasizing the resistance was not just about economic survival but also about
dignity and community integrity.
Effective Communication
In contrast, instances of effective communication were characterized by dialogue, empathy, and
transparency. For instance, some leaders used open forums to discuss the challenges facing the
industry, acknowledging the workers' fears and seeking their input on possible solutions. This
approach, albeit less common, helped in easing tensions and fostering a sense of shared
responsibility for the future of the industry.
Leadership Communication
Leaders who succeeded in managing resistance effectively often employed a conversational
approach, recognizing the importance of two-way communication. They listened to the workers'
concerns, acknowledged their fears, and provided clear, honest information about the industry's
realities. This approach not only reduced resistance but also helped in building trust between
management and workers.
1. Equity and Fairness: Ethical change management requires an equitable approach where the
impact of change is considered and mitigated for all stakeholders. For instance, in the case
of industries like coal mining, where changes can lead to job losses, it's crucial to ensure that
the process is transparent and fair. This includes providing adequate notice, fair severance
packages, and support for transitioning to new employment. Equity also involves giving a
voice to all affected parties, including those who may not hold power within the
organization, such as junior employees or part-time workers (Exploring Ethics in Business &
Finance Today, The importance of ethics in change management).
2. Impact on Local Communities: Organizational changes in industries like mining can have a
profound impact on local communities that depend on these industries for employment and
economic stability. Ethical considerations include assessing the broader social and economic
repercussions of organizational decisions and finding ways to mitigate negative impacts. For
example, when closing a mine, a company might invest in community development
programs or assist in creating alternative employment opportunities (Rami Al Rawashdeh a
et al., 2016).
3. Responsibility Towards Workers: Ethical change management must consider the welfare of
employees. This encompasses not just the legal obligations, but also the moral duty to
support workers through transitions. It includes providing training and development
opportunities for employees to adapt to new roles or technologies, ensuring mental health
support during periods of uncertainty, and maintaining open and honest communication to
reduce anxiety and fear (Payne et al., 2022).
4. Long-Term vs. Short-Term Gains: Ethically, organizations should weigh the long-term societal
impact against short-term financial gains. Decision-makers should consider whether the
benefits of change justify the potential harm to employees and communities, and whether
there are ways to achieve organizational goals while also upholding social responsibility
(McGrath, 2023).
Reflective Analysis: Case Study, Conversational Framework, and
Personal Experiences
Connecting Case Study and Personal Experiences
Reflecting on the Glenrothes Colliery case and the conversational framework, I find parallels with my
own experiences in organizational settings. In previous roles, I've witnessed how top-down decisions
can lead to resistance, especially when change is imposed without sufficient communication or
consideration for employees' perspectives. For instance, in one of my past organizations, the
introduction of a new technology platform was met with significant resistance because the decision
was made without consulting the employees who would be using it daily. The frustration and
reluctance to adapt were palpable, like the resistance faced by the management in the case study.
1. Prioritize Open Communication: Ensuring that all changes are communicated transparently,
and that employee feedback is actively sought and valued.
2. Foster Inclusivity: Involving diverse voices in the decision-making process, recognizing that
different perspectives can lead to more robust and sustainable change strategies.
3. Embrace Empathy: Understanding the emotional and psychological impact of change on
employees and addressing these human aspects with sensitivity.
4. Build Trust: Developing trust through consistent, honest, and open dialogue, which is crucial
for any change initiative to succeed.
5. Continuous Learning and Adaptation: Recognizing that organizational change is an ongoing
process and being open to adapting strategies based on feedback and evolving
circumstances.
The conversational framework emerges as a crucial tool in navigating such change. It highlights the
importance of dialogue in understanding and addressing the concerns of all stakeholders. This
approach contrasts with more traditional, top-down methods, as seen in the case study, where the
lack of effective communication exacerbated resistance and conflict.
Further, the comparative analysis of the conversational framework with Kotter’s 8-Step Change
Model and Lewin's Change Management Model enriches our understanding of change management.
Each model offers unique perspectives and strategies, yet all emphasize the need for thoughtful,
inclusive, and empathetic approaches to change.
The broader implications for understanding organizational change are profound. The case study
serves as a reminder that change is not just a business process but a deeply human experience. It
requires balancing economic objectives with empathy and ethical considerations. The need for
inclusive dialogue, understanding diverse perspectives, and addressing the emotional and cultural
dimensions of change is paramount.
Final Thoughts
In conclusion, the Glenrothes Colliery case and the conversational framework offer valuable lessons
for managing organizational change. They emphasize the importance of communication, empathy,
and inclusivity in navigating the complex interplay of economic, technological, and social forces that
characterize modern organizational environments. This holistic approach is essential for successfully
implementing change that is not only effective but also respectful of the diverse needs and values of
all stakeholders involved.
References
27, S. Cohen |January, Cohen, S., Wolf, M., McGowan, A., Seema, Hernlund, J., 10111, Elfelt, S., Dalby, T., Billie,
McCarthy, W. F., Sutton, P., Purnell, M. J., Jerry, F., Kibalirwandi, M. M., Allie, Metaphor, E. and Rob (2020)
Economic Growth and Environmental Sustainability, State of the Planet. Available at:
https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2020/01/27/economic-growth-environmental-sustainability/ (Accessed: 9 January
2024).
AusIMM (no date) Leadership in mining sector, AusIMM. Available at:
https://www.ausimm.com/insights-and-resources/insights/leadership-in-mining-sector/ (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Author links open overlay panelRami Al Rawashdeh a, a, b, AbstractThis paper compares selected socioeconomic indicators
(e.g. unemployment, Rawashdeh, R. A., Badera, J., Campbell, G., Davis, G., Dupuy, K., Garvin, T., Gifford, B.,
Hajkowicz, S., Hilson, G., Kim, J., Pegg, S., Vanclay, F., Warhurst, A., Bin, P. and Brohman, J. (2016) The socio-
economic impacts of mining on local communities: The case of jordan, The Extractive Industries and Society.
Elsevier. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2214790X16300119 (Accessed: 9
January 2024).
Author links open overlay panelRobert B. Finkelman a, a, b, c, Highlights•Impact of coal mining and coal use on Future
Environmental and Health Impacts.•Positive and negative impacts and of the dynamic changes in coal mining and
use.•Dramatically different approaches of coal mining and use in different parts of the g and States, A. the U. (2020)
The future environmental and health impacts of coal, Energy Geoscience. Elsevier. Available at:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666759220300706 (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Author links open overlay panelSekhar Bhattacharyya 1, 1, 2 and AbstractThe technology of coal mining has gone through
continual evolutions and several revolutionary changes which transformed the methods (2023) Advances in coal
mining technology and sustainable mining techniques, The Coal Handbook (Second edition). Woodhead Publishing.
Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978012824328200011X (Accessed: 9 January
2024).
Bedard, A. (2023) The 8-step process for leading change: Dr. John Kotter, Kotter International Inc. Available at:
https://www.kotterinc.com/methodology/8-steps/ (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
The conversational framework (2022) FutureLearn. Available at: https://www.futurelearn.com/info/courses/blended-and-
online-learning-design/0/steps/191671 (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Cooper, C. (2000) Gender differences in conversational style : An experiment in interpersonal communication. doi:
10.15760/etd.6096.
Cornescu, V. and Adam, R. (2016) ‘Organizational change — managing employees resistance’, Challenges, Performances
and Tendencies in Organisation Management, pp. 381–389. doi: 10.1142/9789814656023_0042.
Exploring Ethics in Business & Finance Today (no date) The importance of ethics in change management, ILLINOIS CPA
SOCIETY. Available at: https://www.icpas.org/information/copy-desk/insight/article/summer-2019/the-importance-
of-ethics-in-change-management (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Feu, M. (2020) ‘Damned cartoons! workers’ identity and resistance’, Fighting Fascist Spain, pp. 159–170. doi:
10.5622/illinois/9780252043246.003.0010.
Goldstone, J. A. (2012) ‘Cultural Foundations of technological change in Europe vs. Asia’, SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:
10.2139/ssrn.3462586.
Hodson, R. (1995) ‘Worker resistance: An underdeveloped concept in the sociology of work’, Economic and Industrial
Democracy, 16(1), pp. 79–110. doi: 10.1177/0143831x9501600104.
Kirby, M. W. (1973) ‘The control of competition in the British coal-mining industry in the Thirties’, The Economic History
Review, 26(2), p. 273. doi: 10.2307/2594253.
Malik, P. (2023) Lewin’s 3-stage model of change theory: Overview, The Whatfix Blog | Drive Digital Adoption. Available
at: https://whatfix.com/blog/lewins-change-model/ (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
McCollum, D., Nicholson, H. and Duffy, P. (2021) ‘A place-based approach to population sustainability: Demographic and
Economic Change at the local level in Fife, Scotland’, Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy
Unit, 36(6), pp. 505–523. doi: 10.1177/02690942211057439.
McGrath, R. (2023) Council post: The role of ethical leadership in long-term organizational success, Forbes. Forbes
Magazine. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbusinesscouncil/2023/09/08/the-role-of-ethical-
leadership-in-long-term-organizational-success/ (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
The miners’ strike of 1984-5: An oral history (no date) Faculty of History. Available at:
https://www.history.ox.ac.uk/miners-strike-1984-5-oral-history (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Nielsen, K., Randall, R., Brenner, S.-O. and Albertsen, K. (2009) ‘Developing a framework for the “why” in change
outcomes: The importance of employees’ appraisal of changes’, Prerequisites for Healthy Organizational Change,
pp. 76–86. doi: 10.2174/978160805011610901010076.
Overvest, M. (2023) Compromising negotiation - 3 powerful strategies + examples -, Procurement Tactics. Available at:
https://procurementtactics.com/compromising-negotiation/ (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
Pallett, K. (2022) ‘Is UK agriculture going the same way as the coal and steel industry in the 1980s?’, Outlooks on Pest
Management, 33(3), pp. 86–88. doi: 10.1564/v33_jun_01.
Payne, D., Trumbach, C. and Soharu, R. (2022) The Values Change Management Cycle: Ethical Change Management -
Journal of Business Ethics, SpringerLink. Springer Netherlands. Available at:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10551-022-05306-8 (Accessed: 9 January 2024).
SLEEMAN, W. (1987) ‘Colliery spoil in urban development’, Advances in Mining Science and Technology, pp. 163–177.
doi: 10.1016/b978-0-444-42876-9.50018-x.
Tian, L., Li, M., Jiao, S., Yang, D. and Kang, X. (2016) ‘Research on stability of coal pillars in Wongawilli Mining area of
Ganhe Colliery’, Proceedings of the 2016 4th International Conference on Management Science, Education
Technology, Arts, Social Science and Economics (msetasse-16). doi: 10.2991/msetasse-16.2016.113.