BFP Smoke Control System
BFP Smoke Control System
CATALAN, PME
DISCLAIMER
CODES
Extinguishing Equipment
❑ Means of Egress/Evacuation
❑Smoke Control
❑ Structural Safety - LEVEL of SAFET
❑ Firefighting
DIVISION 8 TO 20
Building Occupancy
STANDARDS
SYSTEM PRODUCT
STANDARDS STANDARDS
- LEVEL of EFFECTIVENESS - LEVEL of RELIABILITY
Success in producing the desired result. Production of consistent and
replicable outcomes.
SYSTEM STANDARDS
INTERNATIONAL
LOCAL STANDARDS STANDARDS
➢ Details the application, installation, location,
performance, and maintenance of what is
required by the Codes.
PRODUCT STANDARDS
RA 9514 RIRR
NFPA 13-2019
NFPA 72-2019
Product standards
Process standards
PRODUCT-LISTING STANDARDS
➢ Listing agency standard ensuring product safety,
reliability and certain performance levels.
EN = Product-based
standards
ISO = Process-based
Standards
VENTILATION/SMOKE CONTROL REQUIREMENT IN THE CODES
International Building
NFPA 101 and 5000 Fire Code of the Philippines (RA 9514)
Code (IBC)
Smokeproof enclosures (stairs, Smokeproof enclosures (high rise
High rise buildings
elevators) buildings)
Atrium over certain height Detention and correctional Smoke refuge areas
Smoke Protected Assembly Atrium of covered malls >2 levels
Covered malls (over 2 levels)
Seating Atrium of other occupancies >3 levels
Underground or windowless
Atrium (>2 levels) Underground structures
buildings
Proscenium openings Smoke Protected Assembly Seating Windowless facilities
Fire Service elevators >120 ft Underground or windowless Means of egress serving smoke-
(36.3 m) buildings protected assembly seating
Stages (≥93 m²) All movie houses
CODE –Rule or law used to enforce requirements for fire protection, life
safety, or building construction.
CEILING JET - A flow of smoke under the ceiling, extending radially from
the point of fire plume impingement on the ceiling. (3.3.2*., NFPA 92)
A.3.3.2 CEILING JET - Normally, the temperature of the ceiling jet is
greater than the adjacent smoke layer.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
HEAT RELEASE RATE (HRR) – Is the rate at which fire release energy - this
is also known as power. HRR is measured in units of Watt (W), which is an
International System unit equal to one Joule per second.
q = at²
where :
q = rate of heat release (normally in Btu/sec)
a = constant governing the speed of growth
t = time (normally in sec)
DEFINITION OF TERMS
T-Square (t2) FIRE – A fire that has a heat release rated that grows
proportionally to the square of time from ignition.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
UNSTEADY FIRE – A fire that has a heat release rate that varies with respect
to time. (3.3.5.4., NFPA 92)
Unsteady Fire
DEFINITION OF TERMS
TENABLE ENVIRONMENT - An environment in which smoke and heat are limited or
otherwise restricted to maintain the impact on occupants to a level that is not life
threatening. (3.3.24*., NFPA 92, & PMEC, 2012, Chapter 9)
SMOKE CONTROL ZONE - A space within a building enclosed by smoke barriers, including
the top and bottom, that is part of a zoned smoke control system. (3.3.25.1., NFPA 92)
SMOKE ZONE - The smoke control zone in which the fire is located. (3.3.25.2., NFPA 92)
ZONED SMOKE CONTROL – A smoke control system that includes smoke exhaust for the
smoke zone and pressurization for all contiguous smoke control zones. The remaining
smoke control zones in the building also may be pressurized. (PMEC, 2012, Chapter 9)
DEFINITION OF TERMS
VENT - A device or construction that, when activated, is an opening
directly to the exterior at or near the roof level of a building that relies on
the buoyant forces created by a fire to exhaust smoke and heat. (3.3.20.,
NFPA 204)
VENT SYSTEM - A system used for the removal of smoke and heat from a
fire that utilizes manually or automatically operated heat and smoke vents
at roof level and that exhausts smoke from a reservoir bounded by exterior
walls, interior walls, or draft curtains to achieve the design rate of smoke
mass flow through the vents, and that includes a provision for makeup air.
(3.3.21., NFPA 204)
SMOKE REFUGE AREA - An area of the building separated from other spaces
by fire resistance–rated smoke barriers in which a tenable environment is
DEFINITION OF TERMS
INTRODUCTION
FIRE INCIDENT
FIRE INCIDENT
FIRE INCIDENT
Flames broke out in the hotel at around
9:30 am on Saturday, March 18, 2018,
generating clouds of thick smoke at the
Ermita District in Manila. After 25 hours
of facing flames and smoke at the
Waterfront Manila Pavilion Hotel &
Casino. The blaze erupted from the
ground floor and spread to the rest of the
22-storey hotel. A heavy thick smoke
inside the building was preventing the
firefighter from immediately entering and
killed 5 persons and injured 24.
FIRE INCIDENT
FIRE INCIDENT
On 2 June 2017, 40 people at the
Resort World Manila entertainment
complex in Pasay, Metro Manila were
killed when a gunman caused a
stampede and set fire to casino tables
and slot machine chairs around
midnight. All of the attack’s deaths
and injuries resulted from the initial
stampede and smoke inhalation from
the fire.
The main hazard from a
fire is
SMOKE
INTRODUCTION
SMOKE - The airborne solid and liquid particulates and gases evolved when a
material undergoes pyrolysis or combustion, together with the quantity of air
that is entrained or otherwise mixed into the mass. (3.3.12., NFPA 92, & PMEC, 2012,
Chapter 9)
PRODUCTION
OF SMOKE IN A
FIRE
HAZARDS OF SMOKE
FACTS!!!! INTRODUCTION
• Smoke is a serious hazard to the building occupants.
• Smoke contains toxic and irritant gases
• Smoke is commonly recognized as the major killer in
building fires.
• ¾ of all fire deaths are caused by smoke inhalation
• Approximately 57% of fire deaths occur outside the room
of the origin
• 48% of fire survivors could not see more than 12 feet.
(visually impaired)
• Smoke travels 120 to 240 ft/min
• Extreme Heat Convection and Radiation affects
evacuation response.
SMOKE MOVEMENT FACTORS
1. Differences in temperature
between outdoor and indoor air
(stack effect)
2. Natural convection
3. Thermal expansion
4. Wind forces
5. Buoyancy of combustion gases
6. HVAC operation
7. Elevator Piston Effect
STACK EFFECT
NFPA 90A - Standard for the Installation of Airconditioning and Ventilating Systems
ELEVATOR PISTON EFFECT SMOKE MOVEMENT FACTORS
The motion of an elevator car causes transient
pressures that are called elevator piston effect.
SMOKE CONTROL SYSTEM
FUNDAMENTAL
Smoke Control System.
An engineered system that includes all SMOKE CONTROL SYSTEMS
methods that can be used singly or in
combination to modify smoke movement.
(3.3.23.5., NFPA 92)
Flexibility – applying design features that allow for easy adjustment of a smoke control
system in order to achieve acceptable performance (e.g. use of fans with sheaves to
allow several flow rates, a variable flow fan for the same purpose, dampers that can
be manually adjusted to obtain desired pressure differences).
Resiliency – applying design features that could resists serious adverse effects due to
pressure fluctuations (e.g. automatic control in supply fan by-pass system to reduce
the effect of opening and closing of stairwell doors).
Smoke Control System Interaction
Design must consider interaction of smoke control system
with other systems (e.g. HVAC, multiple or other smoke
control systems )
Duration of Operation
Smoke control systems shall be capable of operating for 20
minutes OR 1.5 times calculated/required safe egress time
(RSET), whichever is greater (IBC 2015, 909.4.7, FCP ).
FUNDAMENTAL
SMOKE CONTROL SYSTEMS: APPROACHES
METHODS STAIRWELL PRESSUIRZATION
SMOKE ZONED PRESSURIZATION
ELEVATOR PRESSURIZATION
CONTAINMENT VESTIBULEPRESSURIZATION
GOAL SYSTEM SMOKE REFUGE AREA
PRESSURIZATION
SMOKE CONTROL
SYSTEMS ▪ MAINTAIN A TENABLE
ENVIRONMENT IN THE MEANS OF
EGRESS
SMOKE ▪ CONTROL & MAINTAIN MIGRATION
MANAGEMENT OF SMOKE BETWEEN FIRE AREA &
SYSTEM COMMUNICATING SPACES (SMOKE
FILLING, SHEVS, OPPOSED
AIRFLOW)
SMOKE CONTAINMENT SYSTEM
➢Zoned Pressurization
➢Elevator Pressurization
➢Vestibule Pressurization
➢ Work best in buildings where doors are not opened very often or for very long.
➢Two Options
1. Barometric dampers
2. Motor operated dampers
3. Automatic opening door or vent
to exterior
4. Exhaust fan
DESIGN APPROACHES
STAIRWELL PRESSURIZATION –COMPENSATED SYSTEMS (F4., NFPA 92)
OVERPRESSURE RELIEF – BAROMETRIC DAMPERS
➢ Simplest, least expensive method
➢ Prone to “chatter”
BAROMETRIC DAMPERS
Barometric dampers use
adjustable counterweights which
are adjusted so that the damper
opens when a particular
(excessive) pressure is reached.
The location of dampers needs to
be carefully chosen since
dampers located too close to the
supply openings can operate too
quickly
DESIGN APPROACHES
STAIRWELL PRESSURIZATION –COMPENSATED
SYSTEMS (F4., NFPA 92)
OVERPRESSURE RELIEF – MOTOR OPERATED
DAMPER
➢ More complicated and expensive
than barometric dampers
➢ Controlled by differential
pressure sensors
DESIGN APPROACHES
STAIRWELL PRESSURIZATION –COMPENSATED SYSTEMS (F4., NFPA 92)
OVERPRESSURE RELIEF – OPEN DOOR OR VENT
Vent
DESIGN APPROACHES
STAIRWELL PRESSURIZATION –COMPENSATED SYSTEMS (F4., NFPA 92)
OVERPRESSURE RELIEF – EXHAUST FAN
➢ Can be used when all doors closed
➢ Controlled by differential
pressure sensors
➢ Should be set to shut off when
pressure drops below a certain
point so smoke is not sucked into
stair through open doors when
pressure drops due to doors being
open.
➢ Multi-speed (variable frequency
drive) fan recommended
➢ Windshields recommended
DESIGN APPROACHES
VARIABLE FREQUENCY DRIVE FAN
The variable frequency drive
(VFD) is becoming increasingly
popular in modern pressurization
systems. VFD allows the fan
speed (RPM) to be altered
thereby modulating the airflow.
The control signal is obtained
from a pressure sensor controller
that senses the static differential
pressure between the stairwell
and the occupied zone and gives
feedback for corrective action
DESIGN APPROACHES
SMOKE PROOF ENCLOSURES
Life Safety Code (NFPA 101) enforced by the
Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ),
recognizes three specific means for
providing smoke proof enclosures:
Exhaust
2-hr. wall
Supply
* Vestibule shall be provided with not less than 1 air change per minute, & exhaust shall be 150%
of the supply.
* Stair shall be provided with a dampered relief opening with sufficient air to discharge at least
70.8 m3/min (2500 ft³/min) while maintaining a positive pressure of not less than 25 N/m2 (0.10
in. water column) in the stair.
DESIGN APPROACHES
SMOKEPROOF ENCLOSURES: STAIR PRESSURIZATION
• Design pressure difference across the barrier ≤ 12.5 N/m² (0.05 in. water
column) in sprinklered buildings, or ≤ 25 N/m² (0.10 in. water colunm) in
nonsprinklered buildings. The smokeproof door force to open ≥ 133 N (30
lbf). (NFPA 101)
DESIGN APPROACHES
Zone Smoke Control using HVAC System Normal Operation (a) and Smoke
Control Operation (b)
SMOKE CONTAINMENT SYSTEMS
ELEVATOR PRESSURIZATION SYSTEMS
Where elevator pressurization is provided, elevator
hoistways shall be pressurized to maintain a
minimum positive pressure in accordance with
4.4.2. The minimum pressure shall be maintained
with the elevator car at the recall floor and
elevator doors and the hoistway vents open. (4.7.*,
NFPA 92)
A.4.7 If elevators are intended to be used for
evacuation during a fire, the elevator
pressurization system should be protected against
heat, flame, smoke, loss of electrical power, loss
of elevator machine room cooling, water intrusion,
and inadvertent activation of controls.
ELEVATOR
PRESSURIZATION SYSTEMS CODE REQUIREMENT
SMOKE CONTAINMENT: VESTIBULE
• Vestibules shall not be required but shall be permitted as part of the building smoke
control system. (4.10.1.*, NFPA 92)
• Where vestibules are provided, either pressurized or nonpressurized vestibules shall
be permitted. (4.10.2.*, NFPA 92)
• Doors located in smoke barriers shall be self-closing or shall be arranged to close
automatically upon activation of the smoke control system. (4.11.*, NFPA 92)
Methods (A 4.10.2) Vestibule Stair Pressurization
Pressurization
Nonpressurized Vestibules Indirectly Directly
Pressurized Vestibules Directly Indirectly
Pressurized Vestibules and Directly Directly
Stairwells
Purged or Vented None None or Directly
SMOKE CONTAINMENT SYSTEMS
AREA OF
REFUGE
VENTILATION DUCT LAYOUT: SMOKE CONTAINMENT SYSTEMS
PROVISION OF FIRE DAMPERS
5.3.1., NFPA 90A,-Standard
for the Installation of Air-
Conditioning and Ventilating - fire rated walls and
- air transfer openings in
Systems. partitions required to have
partitions required to have
fire resistance rating of 2-hr
• Penetrations – Protection of fire resistance rating
Openings
or more
Objectives:
2. Mechanical smoke exhaust capacity to remove smoke from a space to maintain the smoke layer
interface at a predefined height in the space for an indefinite period of time
3. Mechanical smoke exhaust capacity to remove smoke from a space to slow the rate of smoke
layer descent for a period that allows occupants to safely egress from the space
4. Natural smoke venting to maintain the smoke layer interface at a predetermined height in the
space for an indefinite period of time
5. Natural smoke venting to slow the rate of smoke layer descent for a period that allows
occupants to egress from the space
DESIGN APPROACHES
smoke layer
interface
Z
d = depth of smoke layer Z = distance above the base of the fire to the smoke layer interface
Zl = limiting elevation (also called as flame height) H = ceiling height
Managing Smoke Spread to Communicating Space
2. Providing a barrier to transform a communicating space into a separated
space
Managing Smoke Spread to Communicating Space
3. Providing an opposed airflow through the opening to prohibit smoke spread into the
communicating space.
4. Opposed Airflow
▪ quantity of fuel
▪ arrangement of fuel
▪ quantity of oxygen
▪ effect of manual and automatic suppression
DESIGN FIRE & FIRE GROWTH
Research have shown that most fires grow exponentially; i.e. the rate of
heat release increases exponentially with time.
UNSTEADY FIRE – A fire that has a heat release rate that varies with respect
to time. (3.3.5.4., NFPA 92)
Unsteady Fire
DEFINITION OF TERMS
T-Square (t2) FIRE – A fire that has a heat release rated that grows
proportionally to the square of time from ignition.
SMOKE MANAGEMENT IN LARGE AREA
Points of Interests
❑ Height of First Indication of Smoke with No Smoke Exhaust Operating.
❑ The smoke temperature at any layer interface.
❑ The total mass consumption required to sustain the steady heat release rate
for steady fires.
❑ The total mass consumed over the time period of interest for unsteady fires.
❑ Rate of Smoke Mass Production according to the smoke plume type.
❑ Plume Width.
❑ Average Plume Temperature.
❑ Centerline Plume Temperature.
❑ Number of Exhaust Inlets.
❑ Minimum edge-to-edge separation between inlets.
❑ Maximum Air Supply Velocity.
❑ Opposed Airflow Requirements.
SMOKE MANAGEMENT IN LARGE AREA
SMOKE MANAGEMENT IN LARGE AREA
6. Smoke Containment. A smoke control method that uses mechanical equipment to produce pressure
differences across smoke barriers. (3.3.14*., NFPA 92)
Opposed Airflow
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION
8. Finally, the study of Smoke Control System and its methods (Smoke
Containment & Management) have the following main objectives:
Maintain tenability in exit stairs long enough to allow occupants to exit the
building.