How To Save Money Ebook
How To Save Money Ebook
Following the process described in this book will help you to:
In a nutshell:
• It’s not how much you earn that is important; it’s how much you save.
• A simple way to wealth is to save small amounts over long periods of time. This book explains, in
detail, how to do that.
• Beyond a certain point money does not buy happiness. That point is lower than most people
expect. Using the process described in this book should help you find it for yourself. Once you
know the point and reach it, you can choose when and how to work.
The practical parts of this book aren’t original; they are tried and tested methods. The main source has
been “Your Money or Your Life” by Joe Dominguez and Vicki Robin. The exercises in this book are a
personal interpretation of their techniques.
Contents
Contents................................................................................................................................... 2
Pictorial Overview of the Book .............................................................................................. 3
Chapter 1: Overview of the book ........................................................................................... 4
What the book is about .............................................................................................................................. 4
A snapshot of this book.............................................................................................................................. 5
An important question to ask yourself ........................................................................................................ 6
How to decide if this process is worth following ......................................................................................... 6
Chapter 2: The Structure of this Book .................................................................................. 9
The structure of this book and how to use it…........................................................................................... 9
The 4MAT learning system ........................................................................................................................ 9
Chapter 3: Background – why How to Save Money works ............................................... 12
Where this book came from: modelling successful savers ...................................................................... 12
How successful savers behave................................................................................................................ 13
Know how much is enough ...................................................................................................................... 16
Conscious control of behaviour may be an illusion .................................................................................. 17
Chapter 4: Getting motivated ............................................................................................... 20
Chapter 5: Recording............................................................................................................ 21
Why is Recording important? ................................................................................................................... 21
The What of Recording ............................................................................................................................ 22
How to do Recording................................................................................................................................ 23
What if? questions for Recording ............................................................................................................. 24
Chapter 6: Sorting your Spending....................................................................................... 27
Why Sorting your Spending is important?................................................................................................ 27
The what of Sorting your Spending.......................................................................................................... 27
How to develop your own set of General and Detailed Spending Areas ................................................. 31
What if? questions for Sorting your Spending.......................................................................................... 33
Chapters 7 to 9: The Monthly Review.................................................................................. 35
Chapter 7: Working out your monthly income and expenditure ...................................... 36
Why is Working out your Monthly Spend/Income Important? .................................................................. 36
The What of Working out your Monthly Totals ......................................................................................... 36
How to work out your Monthly Income and Expenditure.......................................................................... 38
What if? Questions for Working out Monthly Income and Expenditure.................................................... 39
Chapter 8: Reviewing your Expenditure ............................................................................. 41
Why Reviewing your Expenditure is important?....................................................................................... 41
What you need to know about Reviewing your Expenditure.................................................................... 42
How to Review your Expenditure ............................................................................................................. 44
What if questions for Reviewing your Expenditure................................................................................... 44
Chapter 9: Making Changes ................................................................................................. 46
Why Making Changes is important .......................................................................................................... 46
What you need to know about Making Changes...................................................................................... 46
How to Make Changes............................................................................................................................. 49
What if questions about Making Changes................................................................................................ 49
Chapter 10: Final Words ....................................................................................................... 52
Appendix 1: Sample Monthly Review Worksheet .............................................................. 54
Appendix 2: Sample Change Sheet ..................................................................................... 55
Appendix 3: Bibliography..................................................................................................... 56
2
How to Save Money
(Chapter 1)
the book How
What?
(Chapter 2) to?
Background to
the book
(Chapter 3) $
Set a goal
(Chapter 4)
Setting the scene
Food
Luxuries
$ Income
Spend
? x2
Monthly
Review 2
Two questions
(Chapter 8)
Monthly
Review 3
Make changes
Recording (Chapter 9)
(Chapter 5)
Monthly Review 1
Income and spend
(Chapter 7)
3
How to Save Money
• A snapshot of the “How to save money” process: each of the four activities is
introduced.
It’s intended as a workbook, not a reading book. You need to do the exercises to get results.
What can you expect to gain by investing your time and energy in this process?
• Live within your means – you’ll find out if you are making or losing money each
month and how to make the adjustments required to spend less than you earn.
• Reduce your debts and increase your savings – one result of living within your
means is that you can reduce debts, assuming you have some, and once your debts
are paid off, you can build savings.
• Be happier – I know, it’s a bold claim. However, consider this – when asked, “do you
1 2
earn enough to meet your needs?” 62% of Australian’s answered “No”; and, of the
top 20% of earners 46% answered “No”. It is inconceivable that half of Australia’s
richest people are deprived; and yet, that is how they feel. This suggests that money
does not buy happiness. So how do you find happiness? Read the book, practice the
techniques and find out.
4
How to Save Money
This “snapshot” is the map that will help you on a journey to financial freedom.
5
How to Save Money
together, they catch all of your expenditure. The Detailed Spending Areas are smaller buckets
under the Spending Areas. They increase the resolution for noticing spending patterns.
Monthly
activity
The Monthly Review activity (Chapters 7-9) – once a month, usually at the end of the
month, you carry out a Monthly Review. The review takes a few hours; the first time you ever
do it will take the longest and as you get used to it the process gets quicker. The Monthly
Review helps you to:
• Find out whether you are spending more or less than you earn.
• Identify spending habits that aren’t serving you well.
• Develop ways to change those habits.
• Did I get full value for this expenditure (i.e. was it worth the money)?
• Does this expenditure meet my Values (i.e. does the expenditure support what I
consider important in life)?
Your answers to these questions highlight areas of expenditure that may not be serving you
well and where you might want to make changes.
6
How to Save Money
month, it’s the same as being paid and extra $200 per month, tax-free. If you save $1000 per
month, it’s the same as a $1000, tax-free, pay rise. So, how much will you earn and how
much time will it take…
1. Work out roughly how much you currently spend per month. You could work this out
by taking how much you earned last month and subtracting how much your bank
balance went up by over the same period. Or, you may want to work it out in another
way. The aim is to get a rough (e.g. to the nearest hundred) figure.
2. Work out what 20% of your approximate monthly expenditure is (i.e. divide the figure
from step one by five). 20% is the minimum amount most people can expect to save
3
each month by using this process over the long-term.
3. The process will take a few minutes each day and a few hours at the end of the
4
month. Let’s say that will amount to 10 hours of your time each month.
4. To get your hourly pay rate for using the process, divide the savings per month from
step 2 by the time it will take to get the saving from step 3, i.e. 10 hours. This is the
hourly rate, tax free, that you’ll be paying yourself if you do the exercises. Is it worth
making the commitment?
Fictitious
example
Kim takes home $4000 per month after tax and saves about $500 per month; Kim’s monthly
expenditure is $3500 per month ($4000 - $500 = $3500). 20% of $3500 is $700 ($3500 ÷ 5 =
$700). Assuming it will take 10 hours a month to do the exercises, Kim realises that’s $70 per
hour, tax-free: roughly twice what he/she is earning at work. Kim decides to do the exercises
for 6 months and see what happens.
A questionnaire
If you don’t currently enjoy maths, then another way to decide if the process is for you, is to
answer this (biased) questionnaire:
If you answered “Yes” to any of the questions, you will benefit from doing the process (I did
warn you it was a biased questionnaire.). The more Yes answers you gave, the more you
7
How to Save Money
have to gain. (If you didn’t answer “Yes” to any of the questions, then I have one further
question for you: why did you read this far?)
So, have you decided? Are you ready to commit some time and energy to making over $700
per month, tax-free? Are you ready to change your life? Yes, yes, yes! Read the next chapter.
Key
points
Throughout this book the key points of each chapter are summarised at the end, like this. All
the Key Points are also gathered together at the end of the book.
• The “How to save money” process consists of one daily, a single one-off and one
monthly activity.
• The Daily activity is to write down everything you spend and earn. This takes a few
minutes each day.
• The one-off activity involves setting up a two-level hierarchy (Spending Areas and
Detailed Sending Areas) to draw together similar expenditures during the Monthly
Review.
• The Monthly Review is, unsurprisingly, the Monthly activity. It involves analysing your
expenditure and income, and planning for changes you want to make. It takes a few
hours once a month, and the more you do it the quicker it gets.
• If you practise these activities consistently over several months you can expect to
spend less than you earn; reduce debts and/or start saving; and, probably, become
happier.
• An average person, who is currently spending around $3500 per month, can expect
to save $700 per month by doing the process over the long-term. That works out at
around $70 per hour for the time spent working the process. All figures are tax-free.
1
Affluenza: when too much is never enough, Clive Hamilton and Richard Denniss,
2
It’s not just Australian’s, Hamlton and Denniss (above) supply comparisons for other “developed” nations.
3
If 20% sounds unlikely, then let me supply some context. We’ve cut our own expenditure by about 90%. That’s
taken some substantial lifestyle changes though. From our experience and from other sources (e.g. see the Your
Money or Your Life book) 20% is highly achievable for most people, without feeling deprived, simply by eliminating
those expenditures you don’t actually get good value from.
4
10 minutes per day times by 30 days = 300 minutes, which is 5 hours; plus 5 hours for the Monthly Review equals
ten hours. This is probably an over-estimate for most people.
8
How to Save Money
• The chapters on skills follow a specific “optimal learning” structure called 4MAT.
Chapter 3 is background research and ideas that put the process in context and explain why
the skills work. Chapter 4 is a simple goal setting exercise to help with motivation.
• Why?
• What?
• How to?
• What if?
Each question is answered in a specific way. The way 4MAT is used in this book is explained
in the table on the next page.
How to Save Money
4MAT question What the question means for a learner. How the question is answered in this book
Why? Why is this subject important and why Anecdotes, research and/or examples that
should I spend time learning it? demonstrate why the skill is useful.
What? What are the main facts, key points and Information about the skill, including a list of the
other information I need to use the skill? key points at the end of each chapter.
How
to? How do I use the skill into practise? A specific, detailed procedure for applying the
skill at its simplest level.
What
if…?
“What if...?” questions explore how the skill A series of “What if...?” questions with answers.
works in different environments and The questions are drawn from our own
situations; they explore the complexities experience of using the skills and from questions
that arise when a skill is applied in the asked by participants at workshops we’ve run on
“real world”. these skills.
Bernice McCarthy, the developer of 4MAT, recommends working through the questions in the
order in the table. Answering the Why question creates interest, motivation and context for the
facts that are presented in the What section. Once a learner knows the facts, it makes sense
to apply them in a simple exercise (the How to section.) Finally, once you have had the
experience of using the skills, you will probably have questions about that experience. This
includes exploring exceptions and unusual situations. These are addressed in the What If
section.
Each chapter of this book that presents a specific skill (Chapters 5 to 9) is structured using
the 4MAT system and answers the four questions in the order above.
1. Skim through the entire book, this should just take a few minutes and will give you an
idea of the overall layout and contents.
3. If you need help with motivation read and do the exercise in Chapter 4.
4. Work through Chapters 5 to 9 in order. The skills you are learning follow on from one
another in a logical sequence. You will learn quickly and easily if you follow the
sequence as it is laid out in the book. (Some of the exercises are best done at certain
times; for example, The Monthly Review is done once a month, usually at the start of
the month after the one you are reviewing. This timing is made clear in the “What”
section of each chapter.) For each chapter:
c. DO THE EXERCISE in the “How to” section. This process only works if you
DO THE EXERCISES. Refer back to the “What” sections to resolve any
questions you have.
d. Once you have done the exercise skim through the “What if?” section to find
out if any of the questions are relevant to your experience. Some may be,
some won’t. If you have a question that hasn’t been answered: contact me by
email, I’m really happy to answer your questions.
10
How to Save Money
5. It’s best to work with the exercises in Chapters 5, 7, 8 and 9 for at least six months
(the exercise in Chapter 6 is done just once). Six months is really the minimum time
required to get results; better still, get into the habit of doing the exercises for the rest
of your life.
What if I prefer to learn in my own way and jump from topic to topic as it suits me?
Well, that’s OK as well. To help you, keep in mind that the chapters are presented in the
sequence it seems best to do them in the first time round. Also keep in mind that the
exercises follow on from one to the next. If you do take this approach of hopping from place to
place, please, once you’ve hopped all you want, go back and DO THE EXERCISES in the
order presented.
Key
points
• This book has a structure. Chapter 3 is Background information. Chapter 4 is a
motivational exercise. Chapters 5 to 9 are a series of practical skills arranged in a
logical, step-by-step way.
• Chapters 5 to 9 (the practical skills) are structured in a specific way. Each section
aims to answer four questions:
1
4MAT was developed by Bernice McCarthy. For more information see www.aboutlearning.com. I learned it from
NLP trainer Richard Bolstad, www.transformations.net.nz
11
How to Save Money
• The techniques in this book are a road map to an alternative way of life.
If you’ve ever visited a new country you may have used a travel guide. The guide is usually
laid out with a background section, describing the history, culture and geography of the
country; and in a separate section you find out about specific places you can visit and the
things to see and do. The background information is useful because it gives you a context for
understanding and appreciating the places you visit and the things you do.
This chapter is like the background to a travel guide; it sets the scene and creates a context
for the tools in the remaining chapters.
A similar process can be used for modelling human behaviour: find people who are
successful at something you want to do; gather information about how they think and act to
get the success they do; and then build a model of that behaviour so that you can use it to
1
teach yourself and others how to get the same results . This book describes a model for
saving money.
Over the last few years my wife, Carole, and I have talked to and read about people who are
successful with money in a particular way: they are prodigious savers. We have worked out
the specific ways that they think and behave to get the results they do. From that we have
built a model of how to get similar results for ourselves. This book lays out that model for you
and describes a series of steps for you to take to get the same results. And just to remind
you, we’ve found that this model is useful for:
In this chapter you’ll discover some of the sources we’ve used to develop the How to Save
Money model and the key behaviours that those sources have lead us to adopt.
Understanding these behaviours should help you with the specific, practical steps described
in the following chapters.
How to Save Money
So how did these ordinary people become millionaires? By saving small amounts regularly
over a long period of time. How do they manage that? By consistently spending less than they
earn. This is the crux of the entire How to Save Money system.
Take a look at figure 1. The arrows pointing up show income, the ones pointing down show
expenditure. The picture on the left shows the balance of income and expenditure for a
person who may look wealthy, but is actually getting poorer every day – a person who spends
more than they earn; while the right hand picture shows someone on the path to real wealth –
a person who spends less than they earn.
Spend
Income
Income
Spend
Profit =
savings
Loss =
debt
The point is: it’s not how much you earn that is important; it’s how much you save. If you earn
$150,000 per year and spend $155,000 per year you are steadily becoming poorer; if you
earn $50,000 per year and spend $45,000 per year you are steadily becoming wealthier. The
question is: if it’s so obvious, why isn’t everyone becoming wealthier?
One of the reasons is that quite often people simply don’t know, on a month-by-month basis,
whether they are spending more or less than they earn. Stop a moment and think: do you
know precisely how much you earned and how much you spent last month? How about the
month before or the one before that? By following the How to Save Money program you will
always be able to answer that question. And once you know that you are in a position to make
the changes that will lead to wealth.
13
How to Save Money
1. It’s high return. If you save a dollar you are a dollar better off, immediately and
forever. There is no tax, no expense and little or no on-going effort associated with
2
not spending .
2. There is a lot of scope for making savings without any major changes in lifestyle.
There are many studies that show most people throw away a lot of money. For
3
example , Australians spend an estimated AU$10.5 bilion every year on goods they
never even use; in the USA people throw away 20% of all the food they buy at a cost
4
of US$43 billion; and a Canadian study found that spending on necessities like food,
shelter, water, electricity, fuel, household operation and health care increases with
income. People earning $65,000 per year spent $9000 per year more on these items
than those on a salary $30,000 per year. The point being: did they get full value for
that extra expenditure, or was it largely wasted on unnecessary luxury?
3. Reducing spending is easy. To earn more you have to do more and you have to work
at it day-in-day-out; to reduce spending all you have to do is less.
The question is how do you go about reducing your expenditure? That’s what this book is
about.
The way compounding works is this: each time you receive an interest payment, the bank
adds it to your original amount deposited (the capital or principal). The next time your interest
is worked out it is on the initial sum you deposited plus all the interest you’ve earned. For
example:
14
How to Save Money
This may not look that important at first, but over years, the compounding of interest can have
quite dramatic results. Here’s an illustration:
Imagine you have $1,000 to save. You put it in a savings account with the bank that pays
5
interest at 5% after tax has been deducted. Here’s how your money will grow:
40 $ 7,040
50 $ 11,467
Now that you can appreciate the effect of compounding on a single sum, imagine what
happens if you save on a regular basis. For example, if you saved $5,000 every year and the
interest rate was consistently 5%, then your savings would grow as follows:
20 $ 173,596
30 $ 348,803
40 $ 634,198
50 $ 1,099,076
15
How to Save Money
Given there is a simple way for people on even modest incomes to build wealth, the question
then becomes: do you really need to be a millionaire to be happy?
You may recall from the overview section that when asked, “do you earn enough to meet your
needs?” nearly half of Australia’s wealthiest people answered “No”. As the author of the
study, Clive Hamilton, points out, in reality around only 4 or 5% of people in developed
nations don’t have enough to meet their needs. And yet, the people in the survey have a
genuine feeling of being deprived. The point being that sometimes we get caught up in
desires and keep pursuing material wealth even when it isn’t making us any happier.
9
This point has been explored in numerous studies that have shown that beyond a certain
level of income there is no link between money and happiness. For example, respected
10
psychologists Martin Seligman and Ed Diener state :
“…we want to emphasize here the divergence of economic indicators from indices of well-
being. For example, over the past 50 years, income has climbed steadily in the United States,
with the gross domestic product (GDP) per capita tripling, and yet life satisfaction has been
virtually flat. As can be seen in [the] Figure..., since World War II there has been a dramatic
divergence between real income (after taxes and inflation) and life satisfaction in the United
States.”
Figure 2 Reproduced from Ed Diener and Martin Seligman, Beyond Money: Towards and economy of well-being,
Psychological Science in the Public Interest 5, no. 1, July 2004, 10
11
In another study researchers asked people from several distinct groups to rate their life
satisfaction on a 7-point scale, with 7 being the most satisfied. As we’ve generally been lead
to believe, the super-wealthy (those on the Forbes list of richest Americans) were amongst
16
How to Save Money
the most satisfied (they scored 5.8). Unfortunately, these billionaires only number 400 and the
chances of joining them are very remote.
Not exactly people associated with excessive material wealth. In fact as the author, David C.
Korten, points out the characteristics that define these three groups are:
• Strong communities.
• The equitable sharing of resources.
• Minimal economic distinctions between individuals.
• A simple life lived close to nature.
All of which seem much more attainable than joining the Forbes “elite”.
What seems clear is that increasing the wealth of extremely poor people does increase the
quality of their lives and happiness. However, it is equally clear that once a certain level of
material wealth has been achieved, more money does not buy more happiness. In fact
making money beyond that point could make people less happy if it distracts them from more
important things in life. Many people know this empirically, a sense that is backed up by
research. For example, psychologist Tim Kasser has conducted extensive studies into the link
between values, well-being and psychological health. His conclusions are:
“What stands out across the studies is a simple fact: people who strongly value the pursuit of
wealth and possessions report lower psychological well-being than those who are less
12
concerned with such aims.”
The question then is how much is enough to be happy? The studies quoted above point to an
annual income of around US$12,000 per person as being the amount beyond which more
money does not buy more happiness. This is, of course, an average over many studies, so it
will vary from person-to-person.
Wouldn’t it be useful to be able to know for yourself “how much is enough?” That is ultimately
what practising the techniques in this book will help you do. It won’t necessarily happen
immediately, but if you keep working with the techniques, you will become increasingly aware
of what “enoughness” means for you. By achieving that you could also become increasingly
aware of the things that are more important to you than material wealth.
Finally, given that material wealth, beyond a certain point, doesn’t appear to make us any
happier, it’s interesting to wonder: why do we keep pursuing materialistic goals?
• People eat up to 50% more food when they use a large plate rather than a small one.
This occurs even when they are educated about the effect. When asked if the amount
14
they’ve eaten has been influenced by their plate size: they deny it.
17
How to Save Money
• Children exposed to TV adverts for snacks foods eat about 50% more snacks than a
control group exposed to non-food advertising. A similar affect is noted in adults.
Participants showed “no awareness or appreciation that the amount of food eaten
15
was influenced by the ads”.
• In a wine store, classical music played in the background primed customers to select
wines that were three times more expensive than if rock music was played.
16
Customers were unaware of the influence.
• The amount of money people put into an “honesty box” for tea and coffee in a
staffroom was influenced by the picture hanging on the wall near the box. Pictures of
staring eyes resulted in people putting in three times as much as when the picture
17
was of flowers.
There are many more examples. Of course, not all our behaviour is unconsciously driven. We
do have freewill and the ability to choose the course of our life. But, our conscious mind can
only process a limited amount of information and is easily distracted. This creates the
possibility that things going on around us will influence our behaviour. These influences may
be very subtle and hard to consciously notice, and yet they still have a significant influence on
our behaviour. It is, however, important to point out that even when our behaviour is
unconsciously driven, it will still lie within the bounds of what’s normal. For example, in one
18
study people were primed to think about old age (without knowing they’d been primed); as a
result they walked more slowly down a corridor than an un-primed control group. In other
words, their physical behaviour became “older”. However, as John Bargh, the researcher,
pointed out: none of them went out and bought a condo in Miami.
It’s also important to point out that this tendency to automatically respond in a particular way
is generally a very useful thing: if we had to re-learn everything we do each day and make a
decision about what to do every second of the day, we wouldn’t get much done. What’s
relevant is how easily can our behaviour be influenced and how they are being influenced.
In the context of How to Save Money, this unconscious influencing of our behaviour is
relevant because we are living in a culture that seems to value materialism and over-
19
consumption. By it’s very nature, living in this culture will influence us to adopt behaviours
aligned with materialism and consumption. For example, it has become “normal” to live in a
large house, own two or three cars, drive short distances, throw away increasingly large
amounts of non-renewable resources, eat food that has travelled thousands (or tens of
thousands) of kilometres and then throw away what doesn’t get eaten.
The good news is that it is possible to consciously influence our unconscious behaviour by
controlling aspects of our environment. For example, people eat up to 50% more when they
use a large plate, but this can be counteracted by consciously choosing to eat from a small
plate. By developing the habit of using a small plate (it’s not hard: give all the large ones
away), a person will unconsciously take and eat smaller portions (and, bizarrely, still feel as
full!)
In a similar vein the “How to save money” system described in this book is a way to influence
our patterns of consumption by tracking how we spend money. The tracking and questioning
of expenditure will bring into consciousness wasteful spending habits. Once these habits
become conscious, it becomes possible to design changes in our behaviour so as to live in a
different way. This “How to Save Money” process is, I believe, a way to install an alternative
set of values to “materialism”; a set of values based around frugality and the conservation of
resources.
Key
points
• The “media” stereotype that wealth = materialism is false. Genuinely wealthy people
are often frugal.
18
How to Save Money
• Beyond a certain level, more material wealth does not bring more happiness. Used
over the long-term the techniques in this book can help you find that level and live
there. This is liberating.
• Our society favours materialistic values. There are many influences that push us
towards adopting these values.
• We can consciously choose to adopt a set of values that take us away from
materialism and towards a way of life that will make us happier. The simplest way to
adopt these values is to make them unconscious habits. The “How to save money”
system described in this book seems to be a way of doing that.
• Cultures with high levels of life satisfaction are characterised by the equitable sharing
of resources, strong community ties, simple living and connection to nature.
1
Many of the techniques used for modelling others’ success have been drawn from Neuro Linguistic Programming
(NLP).
2
In comparison when you earn a dollar, you actually take home less than a dollar (things like advertising for
business, tax, cost of materials, travel time and expense all eat into your income). This isn’t to say you shouldn’t look
for ways to earn more, just that reducing expenditure is more efficient.
3
Affluenza: when too much is never enough, Clive Hamilton and Richard Denniss
4
http://www.nelson.com/business/0176201408/pdf/WOB3.pdf
5
Depending on when and where you live an annual interest rate of 5% may look conservative or generous.
Personally I think 5% is on the good side, after taking into account tax, inflation and costs. Be dubious of financial
planners who promise 7 to 8% and actively avoid the one’s promising more than that – they are legalised “con men”.
See the bibliography for some recommended books on investing. You might also like to consider that the whole
concept of “economic growth” may well become meaningless if we are approaching natural limits to growth (see
bibliography). However, in these circumstances it makes even more sense to live well within your means and save
continuously and consistently.
6 t
To calculate compound interest on a single sum on an annual basis, use A=P(1+r) where A = value after t years; t =
years; P = present value; r = interest rate. From John A. Paulos A Mathematician Plays the Stock Market. Basic
Books. 2003
7
To calculate compound interest on regular savings, I use a spreadsheet. Email me if you’d like a copy.
8
The story comes from Hamilton and Denniss (ref 3 above)
9
See Happiness – Lessons from a new science by Richard Layard for a good overview of the studies on happiness
and it’s (dis)connection to wealth.
10
Ed Diener and Martin Seligman, Beyond Money: Towards and economy of well-being, Psychological Science in the
Public Interest 5, no. 1, July 2004, 10. Available on-line at www.psychologicalscience.org/pdf/pspi/pspi5_1.pdf
11
Found in David C. Korten, Agenda for a New Economy, page 98-99. Korten takes his data from the Seligman and
Diener publication mentioned above, but the cultural distinctions are his.
12
Tim Kasser “The High Price of Materialism”, p 5.
13
For many other examples and details Daniel Kahneman’s “Thinking, Fast and Slow” is recommended.
14
See Brian Wansink’s research at http://www.smallplatemovement.org/
15
”Priming Effects of Television Food Advertising on Eating Behavior”, Jennifer L. Harris, John A. Bargh, and Kelly D.
Brownell, Health Psychology (2009), Vol. 28, No. 4, 404 – 413.
Freely available at: http://www.yale.edu/acmelab/articles/Harris_Bargh_Brownell_Health_Psych.pdf
16
Charles Areni and David Kim, Advances in Consumer Research, (1993), 20, 333.
17
“Cues of being watched enhance cooperation in a real-world setting”, Melissa Bateson, Daniel Nettle and Gilbert
Roberts, Biol. Lett. 22 September 2006 vol. 2 no. 3 412-414 Abstract at: http://171.66.127.192/content/2/3/412.short
18
John A. Bargh, Mark Chen, Lara Burrows, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996, 71(2), 230-244.
19
How to Save Money
This short chapter is an exercise to help you set a goal for using the How to Save Money
system. A goal is useful for getting off on the right foot and keeping motivated over the
coming weeks and months.
1. Why you want to change Write down the things you don’t like about your present
financial position? What are you dissatisfied about?
2. How you want things to be Imagine that you’ve learned the How to Save Money
tools and worked with them for 6 months. Think about how you would like your life to
be at this time. Try and visualise how your life will look. You can also imagine sounds
and feelings too, if you like. It’s like daydreaming. Then write down a sentence or two
that describes how you want things to be. This is your Goal.
3. First practical steps. Now think about some things you can do today to get started.
Where can you begin? What will be the first thing you will do? “Brainstorm” as many
“first steps” as you can. Then pick one of the steps and do it.
Now that you have set a goal you have begun this How to Save Money journey. You can use
the Goal you created at step 2 to keep yourself motivated over the coming months; and if at
any time you feel stuck, simply repeat step 3 to find your next practical step to keep you
moving.
Key
points
• Setting a Goal is a good way to start your How to Save Money journey.
• You can use the Goal to remind yourself why this is important to you and to keep
yourself motivated over the coming months.
• If you find yourself stuck at some point you can generate more “practical steps” to
help you keep going.
How to Save Money
Recording
Chapter
Summary
(Chapter 5)
In this chapter:
• There is some advice on how to apply the process if you have a partner and/or family
that aren’t as committed to the process as you (in the “What if” section)
This chapter explains the first step in the How to Save Money process: recording all your
income and expenditure. By doing this step you gather information on how money flows in
your life. Once a month, you use this information in the Monthly Review (Chapter 7 - 9).
Of these four factors only one was influenced by the background music: the average price per
bottle bought. When classical music was playing the average price per bottle was three times
as much as when Top 40 hits were playing.
The researchers suggest that this happens because classical music is associated with being
wealthy and refined; and people usually believe that wealthy, refined people drink more
expensive wine. Hearing classical music, even though it’s in the background, seems to make
people think of themselves as being wealthy and refined, so they buy more expensive wine.
Two things stand out from this study; first of all, the people were not conscious of being
influenced. It seems most unlikely that anyone would consciously think to themselves: “oh,
classical music, I must buy some expensive wine.”
Secondly, although “three times as much” may sound a lot, in real terms it’s a relatively small
amount of money. On current prices the difference between, for example, an $8 and a $24
bottle of wine is just $16. That’s not exactly going to break the bank. However, it’s the
accumulation of small amounts like this, over long periods of time that make the difference. I
like this quote by Benjamin Franklin: “Beware of small expenses, a small leak will sink a great
ship.” Or to put a positive spin on it: plugging the small leaks can lead to a long and happy
voyage.
Understanding the importance of many small gains is at the heart of the How to Save Money
system. Certainly there may be areas of your life where you can make a large saving in one
hit; but these tend to be few and far between. The real savings come by finding the many
21
How to Save Money
small leaks of your wealth and stopping them. The challenge is: given that at least some of
them may be out of your conscious awareness, how do you go about finding them? That’s
where Recording everything you spend and earn comes in.
Keep a written record of all your income and expenditure, right down to the last cent.
1. Regular payments for things such as power, phone, rates, mortgage/rent etc. These
expenditures tend to be large, regular and entered into in a relatively conscious way.
They are often paid through direct debits, standing orders or cheques. In general, so
long as you are good at filling out your cheque stubs and/or have access to on-line or
paper bank statements, these items do not need to be recorded as soon as you make
them. It is enough to write them down at the end of each month when you are
bringing all your income and expenditure together for the Monthly Review.
Use a notebook
A small paper notebook is the simplest way to keep your day-to-day record of expenditure
and income. At first, it’s a good idea to get into the habit of carrying this with you at all times.
Then it is immediately to hand whenever you spend or make money. If you like electronic
gadgets, you could do your recording electronically. However, the advantage of a paper
notebook is that it doesn’t have a battery, won’t crash and doesn’t take any time to start up.
22
How to Save Money
How to do Recording
Follow these steps to get started on recording.
2. On the first page of your notebook write the month at the top of the page. Draw
vertical lines so you have three columns down the page. Label them: Date, Item and
Amount (see figure 1 below).
3. Keep your notebook with you and every time you spend or earn money: write down
the date, what you spent money on or when the income came from and the amount.
To help you distinguish spend from income, put income in brackets, e.g. If you made
$56.60 from gardening, write: 21/12 Gardening ($56.60).
4. Keep doing this for the rest of the calendar month (you’ll probably use several pages
of the book).
5. At the end of the month, you will use the information you’ve recorded in your Monthly
Review (see Chapters 7 - 9).
That’s all there is to it. Here are the answers to some common questions that come up as
people practise Recording.
23
How to Save Money
For example, imagine you’ve been to the supermarket and spent $45.60. In that are some
things you want to pay special attention to (chocolate and wine) and other groceries you are
less interested in at the moment.
This does require a bit of arithmetic to subtract the “separated out” items from the total
amount spent.
In the next chapter you are going to develop a list of your “Spending Areas” that will help you
identify the things you want to track separately from the things you can just lump together.
I’ve started recording and I’m feeling a bit overwhelmed by the amount of information,
what should I do?
Keep going. In the next two steps (Sorting your Spending and the Monthly Review) you learn
a way to filter the information you’re recording and make it manageable. And, it’s useful to
24
How to Save Money
notice that this may be the first time you’ve become conscious of all the expenditures you
make. If this feels uncomfortable, then that could be a sign that you’re changing.
I forgot to take my notebook with me the other day and realise now I’ve missed several
expenditures. What should I do?
Relax. If you’ve kept receipts you should be able to work out what you spent. If you haven’t,
then it’s fine. This is just one month. In the long run it’s important to get into the habit of
recording everything, and the occasional missed item as you master the process is OK. Learn
from the experience and keep going.
I started recording, did a couple of weeks and then it got too much, I forgot to do it and
stopped. I feel like I’ve failed.
The thing to do in this case is to answer this question: How many times in your life have you
tried this before?
The answer is probably “never”. This is your first time. Like anything worth having in life, you
don’t always succeed first time and mistakes are OK if you treat them as an opportunity to
learn.
Think about how a movie is made. How many “takes” does it require to get each scene just
right? A lot more than one. Would it make sense, if every time there was a miss-take, for
every one on the set to assume they had failed, throw up their hands and walk off feeling
miserable. No! They do the only sensible thing: set everything back up and try again; a
mistake is an opportunity to improve.
I’ve already seen several areas where I can reduce my expenditure and start making
money by saving. Should I go ahead and do this?
No. I recommended that for the first month you just keep recording and don’t make any
changes. Why? I have a friend who lives in an old house that’s in need of repair. One day he
noticed that the bedroom windowsill was rotting away. He spent many hours carefully
removing the old sill; cutting and fitting a new one; sanding and painting it until it looked
perfect. In the meantime, because he was so busy on the windowsill, he failed to notice that
the roof was leaking and one day the ceiling fell in. It’s much more useful to first of all have an
overview of everything that you could change and then focus your energies on the places that
will have the greatest impact.
I like to take my grandchildren out for ice cream and treats. I’m concerned that they will
think I’m mean if I get out my notebook and write down the money I’ve just spent on
them…
There are a couple of things to consider here. First of all, maybe it’s meaner to deny them the
opportunity to learn how to look after money. People do what they see others doing, not what
they’re told to do. By writing down the expenditure you’re giving your grandchildren a very
valuable gift: you’re modelling financial intelligence for them.
Secondly, the question presupposes that just because I write something down, I will stop
making that expenditure in the future. This is not true. If I get value and pleasure from an
expenditure then I keep doing it. The point of the How to Save Money process is not to give
up the things you love; it’s to find the expenditures where you don’t get full value and change
those. Which means you have more resources to do the things you love, like treat your
grandchildren.
I’m really taken with this process and want to make it work in my life. However, other
people in my family, that I share money with, don’t think it’s worth doing. How can I
convince them it’s worth doing?
You have a great opportunity. First of all, stop trying to convince them of anything. Simply
focus only learning and using the process on the income and expenditure that applies directly
to you. That way you give yourself time and space to learn the processes involved and to
prove that you can increase your wealth by comfortably making changes. Other members of
your family will notice this and their interest will increase. After all, by working the How to
25
How to Save Money
Save Money system you are likely to enjoy the equivalent of a 20% tax free pay rise for a few
hours effort each month. Who could ignore that once they’ve seen it work for you?
Then, once you have mastered the process and demonstrated what’s possible, you should
find that those around you either naturally follow your lead, or at least are much more open to
your suggestions about how to make the process work for you as a family.
I have some expenditure that I’m a little embarrassed about and I don’t want to show to
my partner, what should I do?
The chances are that if you’re embarrassed about admitting to a spend, then it’s a habit that
may not be serving you well. So, this is exactly the sort of thing you should be recording.
Ideally, in a relationship all expenditure should be “in the open”, but if you really can’t bring
yourself to do that yet, then by all means keep your own private record. Record, analyse and
change your “private” expenditures in exactly the same way as usual.
Key
points
• Many small savings are more useful than a few large ones.
• Regular expenditures (e.g. power and phone bills, rates, rent or mortgage) can
usually be recorded at the end of the month from your bank and credit card
statements.
• Immediately write down all other expenditures in a note book that you carry with you
at all times.
• Be nice to yourself and others; just write down everything you spend and earn. Leave
the analysis for later.
• Don’t try and coerce other people in your life into following the process. Just get on
with it for yourself and lead by example.
1
This is the same study described in Chapter 3. Charles Areni and David Kim, Advances in Consumer Research,
(1993), 20, 33
26
How to Save Money
Travel
Chapter
Summary
Sorting your
House
In this chapter: Spending
Holiday (Chapter 6)
• How to organise your income and expenditure so
you can spot trends and find areas to make Luxuries
changes in the Monthly Review.
The previous section was about keeping a written record of all your income and expenditure.
This section is about how to sort and organise the information you gather. This is an essential
precursor to the Monthly Review. This step is done once, when you first set up the How to
Save Money system. The exercise takes about an hour.
This is what this section is about. Grouping similar things together and thinking of them as a
single thing simplifies the information you gather. It’s a bit like the way a library is organised. If
the books were put on the shelves in the order they came in, then it would be very hard to find
anything. But libraries aren’t organised that way. They have separate sections for fiction, non-
fiction, reference and periodicals. Within each
section the books are arranged in a specific way Definitions
(e.g. alphabetically or grouped into subjects). For
Sorting your Spending – a process for
example, all the books on gardening are in one grouping and sorting your income and
place. This makes it easy to find what you want. expenditure so as to help you get to grips with
the flow of money in your life.
You can do a similar thing for money and hence Business money – the income and expenses
make it simple to get an overview of everything associated with self-employment/business.
you spend and earn in a month. This makes it Includes everything that goes on your tax return.
easier to focus in on particular spending patterns Personal money – the income and expenditure
and make changes that will save you money. associated with your day-to-day life. Personal
money is everything that doesn’t go on your tax
return.
The what of Sorting your Income – money that comes into your life, for
Spending example wages, dividends, gifts, rent, loose
change you find in the street etc.
Think back to the way the collection of materials
in a library is organised. There are different levels Expenditure – all the money you spend.
of organisation. At the broadest level materials General Spending Area – a broad area of
may be organised into Fiction, Non-fiction, expenditure, for example “Food and drink” or
“Transportation”.
Reference and Periodicals (see figure 1 below).
Then within each section there are sub-divisions. Detailed Spending Area – a smaller grouping
For example, Fiction is usually divided into Adult, under a General Spending Area that catches the
detail of expenditure.
Large Print and Children’s sections; and then the
books are organised alphabetically in each. Every
27
How to Save Money
The same principal is used to organise your money. You can create a series of divisions that
will ensure you have a place for all of your income and expenditure. At the broadest level
most people will use the same divisions; and as you get into the detail, you can personalise
the divisions to reflect your lifestyle and interests.
For example, say you run a café. Money you spend on stock, rent and power for your
premises, the cost of travel to buy stock and your work clothes would all fall into Business
Expenditure. Your lunch and the cost of travel to your premises at the start and finish of each
day fall into Personal Expenditure.
28
How to Save Money
expenditure as well. However, for the purposes of this book all examples and discussion will
focus on the Personal realm. This is for two reasons: firstly most of our own experience with
the system is in the area of making changes to personal expenditure; and secondly: everyone
has personal expenditure, but not everyone has business expenditure.
To achieve this, we’ll use two levels for organising expenditure. A top level, which we’ll call
General Spending Areas; and below that, a second level that we’ll call Detailed Spending
Areas. The Detailed Spending Areas are the most important part: each month you will assign
each expenditure you make to a Detailed Spending Area and it is the total expenditure in
each Detailed Spending Area that you will use to identify spending patterns. In this way,
related expenditures are grouped together and considered as one thing. For example: if you
eat well, then you probably buy a wide variety of fruit and vegetables each month. It makes
sense to group all these expenditures together and think about them as a whole. It’s quick
and easy to consider the value of, say, “$134.60 for fruit and veg”, rather than going through
each individual fruit and veg purchase.
So as to work in harmony with your brain, and to keep things manageable, you should have
between five and nine General Spending Areas. Then for each General Spending Area you
should have between five and nine Detailed Spending Areas. This gives you somewhere
between twenty-five (five times five) and eighty-one (nine times nine) Detailed Spending
Areas in total. This should be more than enough to cover all of your expenditure.
The beauty of this system is that you can tailor it to meet your needs. If you like detail and
have a busy life with lots of different expenditures, then you can have lots of Detailed
Spending Areas. If on the other hand your life is simple and/or you prefer to work at a more
general level, then you can have fewer Detailed Spending Areas.
Figure 4 shows how the General and Detailed Spending Areas fit together.
29
How to Save Money
Business/Self-employed Personal
Expenditure Income
General Spending
Areas
Food Housing Travel Communicatio Personal Hobbies Health
n (clothes etc.)
Staples
Meat
Meals out
Alcohol
Dinner parties
Miscellaneous
Figure 4 Sorting your income and expenditure – showing possible General Spending Areas
and possible Detailed Spending Areas for “Food” (examples are for illustration only, your own
labels will be different and personal to you)
The examples are for illustration only. It is important to develop the list for yourself: it is at this
stage that you personalise the How to Save Money tools. In selecting your own General and
Detailed Spending Areas, you define which areas of expenditure you want to focus on. There
are few pointers to doing this that are important to keep in mind:
• Your list of Detailed Spending Areas should cover all of your expenditure. The How to
Save Money system works by including absolutely everything you spend and earn.
• Your General and Detailed Spending Areas are not written in stone; they can be
modified as you gain experience with the system.
• It is sometimes useful to have a Detailed Spending Area (or maybe even a General
Spending Area) labelled something like “Miscellaneous” or “Other”. This can be used
to catch expenditures that don’t fit elsewhere.
• Rigorously stick to using only five to nine General Spending Areas and five to nine
Detailed Spending Areas for each General Spending Areas.
• At first glance setting up Spending Areas can look like a lot of work. In practise it’s
much simpler to do than it is to explain!
30
How to Save Money
1. Find a quiet place. Have some paper and a pen handy. Some coloured pens (such as
felt tip pens) or pencils are also useful but are not essential. Start by thinking about
your personal expenditure. Cast your mind back over the last month and think about
all the ways you may have spent money. To help do this try recalling the things you
have been doing and then notice where you spent money to do them. Let your mind
wander, at this stage you’re priming your brain.
2. Then, when you feel ready, start writing down all the ways you’ve spent money. Any
level of detail will do, just write down everything that comes to mind, you’ll sort it all
out in the next step. Sometimes this sort of process is referred to as “brainstorming”.
3. Once the flow of ideas begins to slow down, stop writing and review what you’ve
written. You are aiming to identify between five and nine General Spending Areas.
Remember these General Spending Areas need to cover all of your expenditure. To
do this they will need to be broad in scope. For example, “Food and drink” is more
useful than “Bread”. Coloured pens can be very useful at this stage. Pick a colour and
use it to mark all items that are similar. One way to come up with labels that have a
broad scope is to pick and item and ask yourself “what is this an example of?” and/or
“what larger thing is this a part of?”
4. Once you have a list of General Spending Areas: take them one at a time and
develop between five and nine Detailed Spending Areas. Go back to the original
(brainstormed) page of expenditure and review all the spending that might fall into a
General Spending Area. Look for Detailed Spending Areas that will encompass
everything you spend. Remember, it’s OK to have a “miscellaneous” or “Other”
Detailed Spending Area to catch bits and pieces that don’t fit elsewhere. Also,
develop Detailed Spending Areas that help you focus on the areas where you
intuitively think you might want to save money. For example, if you know you
regularly buy takeaway coffee from a café, and would like to know how much that is
costing you, then have a Detailed Spending Area called “Takeaway coffee”.
5. Once you have a set of General and Detailed Spending Areas, put them into the
Monthly Review Worksheet (see the example below). A blank, template table is
included in the book of this book and is also available on-line.
There is an example of General and Detailed pending Areas recorded in the Monthly Review
Worksheet on the next page.
31
How to Save Money
32
How to Save Money
Why would I want to change the General and Detailed Spending Areas at a later date?
Once you gain some experience of using the How to Save Money tools you may find there
are several reasons for modifying your Spending Areas. For example:
• You may have missed a particular expenditure when you first did the exercise above.
• You might find the expenditure in a particular Detailed Spending Areas is very large
and want to get a more detailed breakdown of that spend. In this case you might
divide the spend over two new Detailed Spending Areas.
• You might make significant changes in a particular Detailed Spending Area (or even a
General Spending Area) and find that it is no longer as important.
I’ve got several “miscellaneous” Detailed Spending Areas for capturing “other”
expenditures. Is that OK?
Yes, miscellaneous Detailed Spending Areas can be very helpful for capturing all of your
expenditure. This is especially true when you have one-off or occasional expenditures. If
during your Monthly Reviews, you regularly find that the total expenditure in a miscellaneous
Detailed Spending Areas is large then you might want to review how you’re dividing up your
expenditure in that area.
I’m trying to do the exercise and it’s getting a bit overwhelming. There just seem to be
too many Spending Areas to think about. What should I do?
First of all: relax. The How to Save Money tools work over months; you have plenty of time to
think about this and work out how to do it. For now, the best thing to do is work at a more
generalised level. For example, you could just work out your General Spending Areas and
use only those for a month or two until you get used to the process. Or you could do the
General Spending Areas and just a few Detailed Spending Areas. One of the beauties of this
system is that you can choose to work at a level of detail that is comfortable for you.
Can I have fewer than five Detailed Spending Areas in a General Spending Areas?
Of course. From our own experience: as we worked with these tools our lifestyle got simpler
and simpler. Eventually certain Detailed and the General Spending Areas became irrelevant.
(e.g. the Detailed Spending Areas: “Coffee out” and “Meals out” both disappeared very
quickly; after a longer time, the General Spending areas “House”, “Holidays” and
“Entertainment” were moved on.) If you find you no longer spend anything in a certain
Detailed Spending Area (or General Spending Area) then it’s OK to let it go (and give yourself
a pat on the back!)
Would you recommend using the same system to organise personal income as well?
Yes, if you have a lot of different sources of income and you want some way of finding out
how much each source gives you. You might decide on only having General Income Areas,
and you can add Detailed Income Areas as well, if that helps you.
33
How to Save Money
accounts and tax returns much simpler to do; and, going on and applying the remainder of the
How to Save Money tools will probably make your business more profitable too.
Key
points
• Sorting your Spending involves grouping similar things together and thinking of them
as a single thing. The system you create here is used in the Monthly Review step.
• The first two levels of organisation are to separate business and personal money; and
then separate income and expenditure for each.
• Personal Expenditure is further divided into between five and nine General Spending
Areas.
• Each General Spending Area is further divided into between five to nine Detailed
Spending Areas.
• The General and Detailed Spending Areas should cover all of your personal
expenditure.
• The General and Detailed Spending Areas can be changed as you learn how to use
the system.
1
George Miller coined the phrase in the 1960’s. Wikipedia has a good article on his work and a link to
the original paper:
ttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Magical_Number_Seven,_Plus_or_Minus_Two
34
How to Save Money
The Monthly Review draws these two elements together. As the name suggests, this is a
monthly process consisting of three steps. Each of the steps has it’s own chapter:
Chapter
Summary
In this chapter:
In this first step of the Monthly Review you gather together all your income and expenditure;
sort the expenditure into your General and Detailed Spending Areas and calculate the totals
for each Detailed Spending Area. You will also calculate your total income and total
expenditure for the month.
All the information you have been gathering over the month is like the pieces of the jigsaw. At
first they seem jumbled and unconnected; it’s hard to put everything together and get the big
picture. This first step of the Monthly Review is like sorting out the pieces of the jigsaw. By
ordering and grouping your income and expenditure it becomes manageable; this helps you
get a grip on how money flows in your life, tunes out the noise and highlights your spending
patterns. Which puts you in a position to take action and make changes that will build your
wealth.
The first part of working out your monthly income and expenditures is to gather all your
financial information together. At the risk of repetition: it is important to gather information on
everything you spent or earned in the month.
For your personal income and expenditure there are likely to be two main sources of
information:
• The notebook in which you’ve been writing down your income and expenditure. This
should cover most of the money in your life including all the day-to-day expenditure.
36
How to Save Money
Once you have all your information together you can begin the process of organising it. There
are detailed instructions on this in the “how to” section below. The overall process is to use
the set of Spending Areas you developed in the Sorting your Spending section (chapter 6).
The money splits up as follows:
1. if you are self-employed or have a business, you will separate out business and
personal money.
• This process takes some time and effort, especially if you spend a lot of money or
generate income from several different sources.
• Your first Monthly Review will probably take the most time and be the most
challenging of any you’ll do.
• Approach the Monthly Review with an attitude of acceptance and don’t rush into any
changes. The Review is designed to reveal where your money goes (and where it
comes from) and in particular to highlight spending habits that may not be serving you
so well. These are what they are; accept them, follow the process and make changes
when you’re ready.
37
How to Save Money
• Expenditure
• Income
• Got value?
• Meets Values?
• Changes
A blank Monthly Review Worksheet is included in Appendix 1 and a Word version is available
on-line. The first part of the Monthly Review process makes use of the income and
expenditure columns of the Worksheet. In subsequent parts of the Monthly Review you will
use the remaining three columns.
It can also be useful to have some scrap paper, a highlighter or felt tip pen and a calculator
handy.
Gather your records of everything you spent and earned in the month. Use the notebook
you’ve recorded everything in and bank statements for direct credits. It is useful to have any
other financial records (such as receipts, credit card statements, income statements from
things like rental property and dividends) to hand as well; these are useful for cross-checking
your records of income and expenditure.
The process
1. Start with your expenditure. Begin with the first Detailed Spending Area on your
Monthly Review Worksheet. Go through your notebook and find all the expenditures
that fall into this first Detailed Spending Area and add them up. In your notebook,
cross off each expenditure as you add it up. (Crossing off is important; it can save a
lot of frustration.) Then go through your bank statement and any other records you
might have; add any further expenditures that fall into the first Detailed Spending
Area. Cross items off as you add them in. Once you have a total for the first Detailed
Spending Area, write it into the corresponding “Expenditure” box on the Worksheet.
2. Repeat step one for the next Detailed Spending Area and so on until you’ve been
through every Detailed Spending Area (This may take some time!).
3. Repeat step one for all of your income, except you obviously add the totals to Income
Areas.
4. Now total up all your expenditure and all your income; write the total at the bottom of
each column.
That’s it. It’s interesting at this stage to compare your Total Income and Total Expenditure to
see if you are spending more or less than you earn (more on what to do about it is in the
“What if?” section below.)
38
How to Save Money
• Making sure you have all your records (your notebook, all your bank statements etc)
handy and tidy at the start can save time.
This will mean more time during your monthly review because you’ll need to find the
receipt and check for what belongs in which Detailed Spending Area. Or you can
write it into your notebook like this:
This requires a bit of arithmetic in the supermarket (never hurt anyone) and is much
quicker when you come to the Monthly Review.
• If you have a calculator with an “add to memory” function (often written as “M+”) you
can use it to keep your running total for a Detailed Spending Area. This is the most
efficient way of adding up a long list of items on a calculator. Remember to clear the
memory when you move to the next Detailed Spending Area. (Yes, I know this is
obvious, but I’ve been there and it’s a little annoying if you don’t remember to do it.)
• It may be useful to think about how you use your time during this part of the Monthly
Review. It’s better to plan how long you will work for and give yourself regular breaks.
For example you might decide to do 40 minutes of work with a 10 minute break. This
will help maintain your energy levels and concentration.
Now I have my income and expenditure for the month what can I do with it?
39
How to Save Money
If spending is more than income (i.e. you lost money in the month) then obviously you might
want to take immediate action to either reduce your spending or increase your income.
Reducing spending is, in my opinion, by far the quickest and easiest way of doing that. In the
remaining How to Save Money steps you will analyse your spending and find the places you
can easily make changes to reduce spending and start building wealth.
If income is more than expenditure then this is good news. One of the aims of the How to
Save Money system is to do this consistently month after month. You should still proceed with
the next step in the Monthly Review. This will help you identify places you may be spending
but not getting good value for your money. Finding and changing these areas will help you
save even more. In the long run this will increase your wealth and create opportunities for
changing your lifestyle if you wish.
Key
points
• It’s best to do the Monthly Review for a calendar month.
• Do the Monthly Review a few days into the next month (e.g. January’s review in the
first week of February.).
• Gather all your records and a blank Monthly Review Worksheet before you start.
• Put aside at least half a day for your first Monthly Review. Find a quiet place where
you won’t be interrupted. Take regular breaks.
• Work out your total expenditure for each Detailed Spending Area on your Monthly
Review Worksheet.
• Once an expenditure has been assigned to a Detailed Spending Area: put a cross
through it in your records.
40
How to Save Money
In the first part of the Monthly Review (Chapter 7) you gathered together all your income and
expenditure and grouped similar expenditures together in the Detailed Spending Areas. The
next stage is to consider your expenditures to check you got value for money and that they
are aligned with how you want to live. Your answers will lead naturally to the final stage of the
Monthly Review: Making Changes.
“The motive of change is always some uneasiness: nothing sets us upon the
change of a state or upon any new action but some uneasiness. This is the
1
great motive that works upon the mind to put it upon action.”
D x V x F must exceed R
The equation suggests that if D, V or F are zero, then the change won’t happen; and that the
bigger they are, the more likely it is that a change will be successful.
Obviously, The Change Equation is not completely true; real life is never going to be that
simple. However, it seems to be a good enough approximation of real life to be useful when
thinking about change.
The Change Equation is explored in more detail in the next chapter. For now it is useful to
appreciate that dissatisfaction with how things are is a key element in change; and that
reviewing your expenditure is a way of identifying areas of your spending that bring you little
or no satisfaction.
How to Save Money
• How durable (long lasting) the thing you paid for is.
• A sense of enjoyment and satisfaction that is in keeping with the amount spent.
Other ways of thinking about the question are to ask: “would I spend the money in the same
way again?” or “was what I got worth the money I spent on it?”
As mentioned above, at this stage, just answer Yes or No; deciding what changes to make, if
any, comes later.
• I spent $85 on a shirt I haven’t worn yet and that I’m not even sure I like now I’ve got
it home. Did I get full value for the expenditure?
• I spent $150 on petrol for my car over the month. When I think about it only one
journey in this time was long distance. All the others were driving around town.
Meanwhile I have a push bike in the garage that hasn’t been ridden since I bought it.
Did I get full value for the expenditure on the petrol?
• I spent $72.50 on take out coffees over the month. Did I get full value for the
expenditure?
42
How to Save Money
There are no black and white answers to these questions. The answer depends on how
someone wants to live. It’s also worth noticing that the answers may change from month-to-
month, so even if I answer “yes” one month, later on I may change my mind.
Our Values influence the way we behave; if we believe something is important we try and live
our life in way that meets that belief. It’s not usual to explicitly think or talk about our Values in
everyday life, and sometimes our Values can be outside conscious awareness. More often
we’re aware of a person’s behaviour rather than the underlying Value that lead to that
behaviour. Values are like the roots of a tree: they are essential for the wellbeing of the tree,
but are hidden below the surface. Here are some examples:
Value that person has Things you might notice about them
Sustainability Recycle all their waste
Cycle to work
Grow their own veges
Donate to Greenpeace
Being wealthy Read the business section the paper
Work hard
Regularly check their bank balance
Knowledgeable about investing
Having fun Spends time reading about their interests
Invites friends round
Laughs a lot
Often have ideas for things to do
In general people know what is important to them in life; and, as explained above, sometimes
our Value are outside of our conscious awareness. In this case, a short cut to identifying your
Values is to ask yourself “Does this expenditure feel right to me?” In asking this you are
calling on your intuition to help you decide if the expenditure fits with the way you want your
3
life to be. People sometimes talk about this as their “gut feeling”.
Here are some examples to play with; imagine the expenditure applies to you and check how
well it is aligned with your Values. For each example, ask yourself “Would this expenditure
meet my values? Would it feel right to me?”
• Someone donated $100 to a community group to help put on a social morning for
local people.
• A person took three short-haul flights in the month to catch up with friends. The total
cost was $1350.
For the purposes of the Monthly Review, all you want is a simple “Yes” or “No” answer;
however, you might begin to notice that asking this question can also lead you to deeper
thinking about your life and what is important about it.
43
How to Save Money
1. Starting with the first Detailed Spending Area, ask yourself “Did I get full value for the
expenditure?” If the answer is “Yes” put a tick in the column headed “Value?” If the
answer is “No” put a cross in the column headed “Value?”
2. For the same Detailed Spending Area” ask yourself “Does the expenditure meet my
Values?” If the answer is “Yes” put a tick in the column headed “Values?” If the
answer is “No” put a cross in the column headed “Values?”
3. Repeat steps 1 and 2 for the next Detailed Spending Area and so on until all Detailed
Spending Areas have been done.
Another thing to do if you can’t decide is to take a guess; try asking yourself “if I were to know,
what would it be?” and then going with whatever comes to mind. Trust your intuition.
Rather than asking each question for a Detailed Spending Area, could I first ask the
“Did I get full value?” question for all expenditures and then come back to the start and
ask the “Did it meet my Values?” question?
Yes, either way works fine. You can try different ways and find out what works best for you.
The main thing is to ask both questions for all expenditures. The order they get done in
seems relatively unimportant.
I’ve answered the two questions but didn’t really come up with many “No” answers.
However, I still feel I’m spending too much money each month, what do you suggest?
To help you find places for savings you can try analysing certain expenditures more deeply.
One way of doing this is to compare the cost of the way you do things now against the costs
of possible alternatives. This can highlight areas where your expenditure is high compared to
more thrifty alternatives. For example, many people go out to buy a coffee and then take it
back to work or home. Let’s compare the real cost of buying coffee from a coffee shop with
making your own coffee.
In Australia a standard coffee bought from a café costs around $3.00. A typical cup of coffee
is made with about 7 grams of coffee. That means that the coffee from a café costs about
4
$430 per kg ($3 divided by 7g and multiplied by 1000g).
Compare this with making coffee at home. A packet of coffee from the supermarket costs
5
around $8.00 for a 200g bag. That works out at $40 per Kg.
So, when you buy coffee from a café you are paying around ten times as much as if you
made it yourself. Obviously people must have reasons other than just value for buying coffee
6
from a café. The question is: are those reasons strong enough for you to be sure you are
getting full value for your money?
As I’m working through the questions I get lots of ideas about how I can change things
and start thinking about them, is that OK?
The key at this stage is to go through all of your expenditure and answer the two questions. If
you get ideas for changes along the way then by all means jot them down, but for the time
being just focus on answering the two questions. This is important because although it’s
44
How to Save Money
exciting to think about making changes, you want to be sure that you are focusing on the
most productive areas.
I asked the questions and found an area where I think I could spend more is that OK?
Sometimes you will find areas where more expenditure would improve the quality of your life
or lead to you living more aligned with your Values. That’s great. Spend more and then review
those expenditures in coming months. If it genuinely makes you happier: spend more.
Key
points
• Change often starts from a sense of dissatisfaction with something.
• Reviewing your expenditure reveals areas of dissatisfaction with how you spend
money.
• You review your expenditure by asking questions about your Detailed Spending
Areas.
• Answer “Yes” or “No” to each question for every Detailed Sending Area.
• If you can’t decide take a guess, put a question mark or put “No”.
1
John Locke, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, (1690)
2
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formula_for_Change
3
There are exercises that can help people work out their Values. There is one here.
4
This assumes that most of the cost of a cup of coffee is the coffee itself. For you making coffee at home this is true;
for a café obviously it is not: they have many other expenses. When you buy coffee from a café you are paying to
keep them in business.
5
That’s fancy coffee. It’s often possible to get 1kg of beans for as little $10 or $12 when there are offers on.
6
One reason I’ve heard at workshops is about the quality of café coffee compared to homemade. It’s true, cafes do
make good coffee. From my own experience I would say you can get as good, or better, results at home by using
what is often called an “Italian coffee machine” (they look a bit like a Dalek) and heating the milk up.
45
How to Save Money
Having done this you might have identified some areas of expenditure where you’d like to
make changes. This section describes how to do that.
All the previous steps lead to this point: making changes to your spending is the whole point
of this book.
D x V x F must exceed R
In the previous chapter (Chapter 8: Reviewing your Expenditure) you will have identified some
areas of spending that are ripe for change: the Detailed Spending Areas where you answered
“No” to one or both of the two questions (“Did I get full value?” and “Does this meet my
Values?”) are likely to be areas of high Dissatisfaction with how things are; areas where
change is likely to be easiest. This section describes ways to take an area of dissatisfaction
and to complete the Change Equation by developing a Vision of the future and then
identifying the First practical steps.
Imagine that I’ve just finished a Monthly Review and I’ve realised my car is an
expensive way of making short journeys. Alongside that I’ve become so unfit
that I get breathless climbing a flight of stairs (Dissatisfactions with how things
are). My idea is to buy a pushbike to cycle journeys less than 10 km (Vision of
the future). This will take a bit of time and effort to research and buy a bike, plus
it’s going to cost me some money and I have to make the effort to get on the
thing and use it (Resistance to change). To get things started I decide to visit a
bike shop to do some research about bikes; look on the internet and in the
paper for second-hand bikes and talk to a friend who’s been cycling for years
(First practical steps).
47
How to Save Money
there. The first thing you do is visit the library web site to find out how to join and then
go and do it.
• You spent a lot on petrol in the month and have decided to cycle to work at least four
days a week (weather allowing), as you already own a bike and hard hat, and work is
only 5 km away this should be easy to do. The first thing you do is go and check over
the bike, pump up the tyres and put some oil on the chain.
Complex
changes
Complex changes are those that require some thinking through and planning, particularly if
they might affect your income, have an impact on other people, may require a lot of effort or
involve major changes to your way of life. Some examples might include:
• You are a smoker and have had enough of ruining you health and wasting money on
cigarettes; you decide to quit once and for all. Of course, everyone knows smoking is
bad for your health and is expensive, but if it were as easy as just deciding to stop
you’d have done that a long time ago. Changing an addictive habit, like smoking,
1
requires a little more effort and planning.
• You have realised that your job is costing you a lot of money in clothing, travel and
food; and isn’t really very satisfying. You’ve been thinking of changing jobs and
working closer to home for a while now, so you decide it’s time to take action and
make the shift. However, your family is at least partly dependent on your income, so
the change will need some careful planning.
• Your mortgage is your biggest outgoing and your house is twice the size you need to
live comfortably. You would like to “downsize” to a smaller home and a more sensible
mortgage. Even if you live alone and are free to make this change, such a shift needs
some planning. If you have a family, then, obviously, there is more to making this
change than just moving house!
The Change Equation seems to apply well to both simple and complex changes and the
process described below can be applied to both. However, complex changes may require
more time and effort to plan. Some additional tools for making complex changes are available
on-line.
I recommended that you take on Complex changes one at a time. There is a risk in trying to
make too many changes at once: you may get overloaded and this can deter you from
continuing with the system. It is VERY IMPORTANT for the changes you take on to feel
manageable. If you’re feeling overwhelmed, you are trying to do too much. Remember, this
system is NOT a quick fix; it works over years. You’ve got plenty of time.
“What benefit is there in making this change and how easy is it?”
Based on this question, you assign each possible change a priority rating of High (H), Medium
(M) or Low (L).
• Financial benefits – the more money you will save, the higher the priority rating, or,
• Lifestyle benefits – the more a change helps you live the way you want, the higher the
priority rating.
Obviously, the highest priority ratings got to changes that are both easy and that have lots of
benefit to you.
48
How to Save Money
1. For every Detailed Spending Area with one or more “No” answers ask yourself: “What
benefit is there in making this change and how easy is it?” Assign a priority rating of
High (H), Medium (M) or Low (L). Write the priority rating in the “Change” column of
the Monthly Review Worksheet.
2. Starting with highest priority Detailed Spending Areas, pick the ones you will actually
make changes to this coming month. Pick a number that feels manageable, probably
somewhere around three is good. Pick a mixture of smaller, easy to make changes
and, at most, one complex one. Make a note of which changes you are going to make
in the “Change” column of the Monthly Review Worksheet.
3. For each Detailed Spending Area where you have decided to make a change this
month, fill out the Change Sheet: write down the name of the Detailed Spending
Area, why you are unhappy with the expenditure (your Dissatisfaction with how things
are), how you want it to be (your Vision of the future) and the first two or three things
you are going to do to change it (your First Practical steps).
4. Keep the Change Sheet in a visible place and refer to it over the coming months.
When it comes to prioritising possible changes, can I rank benefit and ease
separately?
Yes. For example, you could record them like this: H/H which would be High benefit and High
ease (i.e. it’s easy to do); or M/H Medium benefit and easy to do. If you do this, tackle the H/H
ones first. After that, I’d go for M/H (Medium benefit, High ease) before H/M (High benefit but
not so easy), but that’s just me.
I’ve got something I want to change, but I’m having problems coming up with a Vision
of the future...what should I do?
Sometimes when we’re stuck in a rut it isn’t always easy to imagine how we’d like things to be
instead; the present seems to obscure the future. There are many ways to create a vision of
the future. Try working through this exercise. At each step jot down any and all ideas that
come to mind; don’t judge the ideas in any way, just write down everything, you can sort them
for practicality later (sometimes called “Brainstorming”).
49
How to Save Money
1. Think about what you’re dissatisfied with. Then ask yourself “If I didn’t have that
anymore, what would I have instead?” Keep asking the question until you arrive at
something positive.
2. Try and think of someone else who is living the way you want to. What is about their
lifestyle you admire? How would they describe their lifestyle to you?
3. Ask yourself this question “If I could wave a magic wand and have everything just the
way I want it, what would that be like?”
Once you have some ideas, go through them and find the one(s) that seem achievable. Use
those to create a Vision of the future. If you’re still stuck, feel free to get in touch with the
author ([email protected]).
• If you lose interest in one, there are always other things to turn to.
• Small changes spread risk: if you muck up a small change or change your mind half
way through, then not much is lost.
• The long-term accumulation of many small gains is the way that the majority of very
wealthy people become very wealthy (see the bit about the Millionaire’s Next Door in
chapter 3).
• If you enjoy drama in your life, then you’ll have to find other ways to get that.
It’s all very well knowing I want to change a habit like smoking, but I’ve tried before and
I don’t think it’s as easy as just seeing how much it’s costing me: I’m an addict!
That may be true. This book is about money; there are other excellent sources of help and
information about changing things like addictions. Use this How to Save Money system to
point out those places you may need to seek further help.
And, for smoking: Alan Carr’s “Easy Way to Stop Smoking” worked for me. Important point:
you have to read the book thoroughly and do what it says, seems obvious but it’s surprising
how many people own it, but fluff it.
I want to make a big change in my lifestyle, but this process seems a bit “light”, what
should I do?
Good question. Making big changes can include a lot of different factors. I foyu’d like more
ideas or some help please feel free to contact me ([email protected]), I’m happy to
share what I know.
50
How to Save Money
Key
points
• Making changes to how you spend money is the whole point of the book.
• The Change Equation is a simple model for thinking about change (The Equation:
Change is most likely to occur when you are dissatisfied with how things are, have a
clear vision of how you want things to be and have identified the first practical steps
to take.)
• Possible areas for change are those Detailed Spending Areas where you didn’t get
value for money, that didn’t meet your Values, or both.
• Priority ratings (High, Medium or Low) are assigned to each possible area of change.
Priority ratings are based how easy a change is likely to be and how much benefit it
could bring.
• Broadly speaking, changes can be split into ones that are simple and those that are
complex; only ever take on one complex change and a small number of simple ones
at any one time.
• Keep the Change Sheet in a visible place and use it to review your progress.
1
There is a lot of very good information on quitting smoking. From my own experience: Alan Carr’s “Easy way to stop
smoking” works. You can get this book from any library. So long as you read the book carefully and do what he says,
the method seems to work.
51
How to Save Money
2. Once a month assign each expenditure to a Detailed Spending Area (Chapter 6 to set
up General and Detailed Spending Areas, Chapter 7 to assign expenditure).
3. For each Detailed spending Area ask yourself if you got full value for expenditure and
if it is aligned with your Values (Chapter 8).
4. For Detailed Spending Areas where you answered no to either question: make
changes to the way you spend money in that area (Chapter 9).
• This process only works if you do the exercises; in particular it works best when you
do it over the long term.
• This process takes time and effort, especially if you spend a lot of money or generate
income from several different sources. Sometimes it can seem a bigger job than it
actually is. It’s a bit like being in the situation of wanting to say something difficult to
someone and not having the nerve to broach the subject. In my own experience, the
longer I put these things off the worse they get. When I do eventually pluck up the
courage to do something, it’s invariably easier than I expected and it’s a real relief to
get it done. When it comes to the Monthly Review, you may want to remind yourself
of how much you stand to save by doing this process (see the end of Chapter 1) and
therefore how much you are effectively paying yourself per hour by doing the Monthly
Review.
• Please keep in mind that your first Monthly Review will probably take the most time
and be the most challenging of any you’ll ever do. It’s the same whenever you
undertake something worthwhile: it takes time to learn the process. The good thing is
that practise makes perfect. The more Monthly Reviews you do, the easier they will
th
become. At the time of writing (January 2013), we have just completed our 70
Monthly Review (nearly six years!). They have become extremely easy and routine.
And in those six years we have made some amazing lifestyle changes.
• By doing the Monthly Review you will become aware of how money flows in your life,
including some ways that you’re not happy about; it is designed to reveal unhelpful
spending habits. Sometimes this is a less than comfortable experience. It is helpful to
approach the Monthly Review with an attitude of acceptance. It’s a bit like receiving
some honest, well-intentioned and fair feedback. It’s not always a comfortable
experience and our tendency can be to react with strong emotions, like resentment or
anger. However, once these feelings pass, it’s usually possible to consider and
evaluate the feedback. Then we can choose whether to make changes to our
behaviour. The Monthly Review is the same: by systematically reviewing the flow of
money in your life you are giving yourself feedback about how you spend and earn.
How to Save Money
By accepting and considering this feedback, you are in a position to either take life as
it comes or change the way you use money.
Chris Lampard
[email protected], @ChrisLampard, sustainablemoney.wordpress.com
53
How to Save Money
The Millionaire Next Door, Thomas J. Stanley and William D. Danko – wide ranging
research on how millionaires become millionaires and how they live. In summary: they’re
frugal and save money over the long term.
Affluenza: when too much is never enough, Clive Hamilton and Richard Denniss – the
book about consumerism in all its guises.
Prosperity without Growth, Tim Jackson – he’s an economist. The book lays out an
economic model for life after growth. First half of the book explains why this is important:
we’re approaching limits to growth. Gives capitalism a good solid kick in the teeth.
Happiness – Lessons from a new science, Richard Layard – a good overview of the
studies on happiness and its non-connection to wealth and materialism.
The High Price of Materialism, Tim Kasser – research on the effect of holding material
values on psychological health and well-being: it’s not good for them. Describes alternative
ways of thinking that are more conducive to happiness.
Status Anxiety, Alain de Botton – one of the causes of consumerism is that we constantly
seek to increase our status. Deep and thoughtful book, great examples exploring the link
between needs, desires and consumption.
Climate Wars, Gwyn Dyer – a geopolitical analyst’s take on climate change and the future.
Often grim reading, but he does try to look for possible futures as well and ends surprisingly
optimistic.
Requiem for a species, Clive Hamilton – if you’re ever feeling too cheerful and need a nice
dose of reality about the next thirty years or so: read this book. Hard-hitting, uncompromising
and a call to action. Doesn’t waste time on optimism.
Thinking, Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman – major overview of unconscious patterns of
behaviour and how easy they are to influence.
Investing
If you’re interested in investing then my advice is: avoid financial advisors of all kinds until you
have educated yourself (see below). Then, if you are sure you need professional advice:
approach with extreme caution and cynicism and...you’ll probably still get burned (after all,
they’re professionals at it).
These books are, on the whole, not trying to sell a service and seem to offer solid, impartial
advice.
Investing for Dummies, Eric Tyson. Good solid investment advice without any agenda.
Strongly recommended. His premise is that you can learn enough to make most investment
decisions yourself, and if you do need advice, it’s much better to be well educated before
seeking it. That way you can ask the right questions and assess the answers you get. This
book is written for a US audience, so some of the advice, for example on tax, applies
56
How to Save Money
differently elsewhere. However, the principles are sounds, the layout clear and the advice is
good.
A Random Walk Down Wall Street, Burton G. Malkiel – a thorough, researched and
referenced demolition of financial advisors, brokers and all the other charlatans who claim
they can predict the market and make you a fortune fast. In summary: it can’t be done and
anyone who looks like they can do it is just getting lucky (or massaging their data). If only they
taught this at school!
The Wall Street Defense Manual, Henry Blodget. Humourous and vigorous look at the
investing world from someone who used to be part of it. His advice is sensible and likely to
work. Covers pretty much the same ground as the Random Walk book above. Again, written
for a US audience, and the principles apply here.
After the panic: surviving bad investments and bad advice, Gareth Morgan with John
McCrystal. Gareth Morgan has a no-nonsense style and very clear view of how the
“investment industry” works and makes money. In summary: by charging investors for advice
they probably don’t need and that may not actually help them much. Written for NZ audience.
Beware: he’s a financial advisor and has written the book to sell himself and his advice. It’s
still a good book just don’t buy anything from him.
Twenty good summers : work less, live more and make the most of your money, Martin
Hawes. Practical, down to earth and clear. His other books are excellent too. Written for a NZ
audience. Beware: he’s a financial advisor and has written the book to sell himself and his
advice. It’s still a good book just don’t buy anything from him.
57