ON

SERPENT-WORSHIP
AND ON

THE VENOMOUS SNAKES

OF

INDIA.

Sir JOSEPH FAYREE, K.C.S.I., LL.D., M.D., F.R.S.

BEING A BABER READ BEFORE THE VICTORIA INSTITUTE.

AUTHOR’S COPY.
ON SERPENT-WORSmP AND ON THE VENOMOUS
SNAKES OF INDIA AND THE MORTALITY
CAUSED BY THEM. By Sir Joseph Fayrer,
K.C.SJ., LL.D., M.D., F.R.S.
he serpent is the ancient enemy of the human race, and
T it is stillheld in antipathy, not only by man, but by the
lower animals. In man, this is probably due as much or more
to the lethal properties of some forms, as to the repulsiveness of
their aspect generally while animals seem to be instinctively
;

imbued with the dread of them. The destructive qualities,

albeit the property of but few members of this large order,
have come to be attributed so universally to all, that the
innocent are classed with the guilty, and the harmless creature
which undulates so gracefully through the grass, is popularly
associated with the deadly cobra or rattlesnake.
But although dread of their baneful properties may lie at the
root of the repugnance in which they are held, yet Avith this
feeling, no doubt, has been mingled a sentiment of veneration
for their supposed A\dsdom and supernatural poAver, which,
combined with fear, originated one of the earliest forms of
Avorship,in which superstition and religious feeling have found
expression, for coeval Avith the Avorship of trees, the heavenly
bodies, and other natural objects, Ave find that ophiolatry has
been general throughout the Avorld from the remotest
antiquity.
VICTORIA INSTITUTE TRANSACTIONS. A
2 SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, K.C.S.T., ETC.,

Serpent-worship, according to Fergnsson,* is cliaracteristic

of the Turanian races, and is rarely to be found among Aiyan
or Semitic peoples. There is no mention of it in the Old Testa-
ment from the formation of the Jewish nation, unless the
raising of the Brazen Serpent be so considered, but six cen-
turies later, Hezekiah “brake in pieces the brazen serpent that
Moses had made for unto those days the children of Israel
;

did burn incense to it; and he called it Nehushtan,” 2 Kings

xviii, 4 and 5. Between these periods there is no other
mention of it in the Old Testament, but in the book of the
Wisdom of Solomon, xi, 15, we read, “ They worshipped
serpents void of reason ” nevertheless its revival among
;

the Gnostic sect of the Ophites points to the fact that the
notion was not extinct. “ A wondrous blending of the
ancient rites of Ophiolatry with mystic conceptions of
Gnosticism appears in the cultus which tradition (in truth or
slander) declares the semi-Christian sect of Ophites to have
rendered to their tame snake, enticing it out of its- chest, to
coil round the sacramental bread, and worshipping it as repre-
senting the great king from heaven, who in the beginning
gave to the man and woman the knowledge of the mysteries ”
(“ Primitive Culture,” Tylor).
Serpent-worship, according to Fergusson, has prevailed to
a greater or less extent nearly all over the world.
In America it was known in Peru, Mexico, and among the Red
Indians, according to ancient records of the United States.
Its prevalence in Western Asia seems doubtful, except in
Judaea, to a slight extent in Phoenicia, and in the Troad,
among the so-called Ophiogones.
As regards Europe, there are next to no traces of its
prevalence among the Germans, though Tylor refers to the
“ Prussian serpent-v/orship and offering of food to the house-
hold snakes,” nor among the Gauls nor Britons. Ophiolatry
is said to have been practised by the Druids according to
;

Fergusson there is not much evidence of this, but other

authorities state that the serpent’s egg was the Druids’ crest,
and that the serpent Avas entwined at tlie foot of their altars.
At Avebury in Wiltshire, there existed the figure of a serpent
in stones extending for tAvo and a half miles, of AA'hich the
head and tail are still obAdous. There are traces of it in

* To Fergusson’s “
Tree and Serpent- Worelii}),” and Tylor’s “ Primitive
Culture,” I am indebted for much information.
 —
ON SERPENT-WORSHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 3

Scandinavia and on the east coast of Scotland, north of the

Forth, w'-here sculptured stone monuments have been found
on which the serpent appears frequently, and as a prominent
figure.
In Greece the temple of .dUsculapius was a centre of serpent-
worship, whilst the iEsculapian rod svmbolises wdsdom. In
this, as in other cases, the serpent was the symbol of the god,
ratlier tlian itself the god.*
In Italy the serpent was often represented as the genius loci,
but there is no direct evidence that beyond this the Romans
ever worshipped it. Dante, in his “ Inferno,” ascribes to
the serpent supernatural power, his bite causing a man to be
reduced to ashes :

“ Ed ecco ad un, cli’era da nostra proda,

S’avventd un serpente, che’l trafisse
L^, dove’l collo alle spalle s’annoda.
Ne O si tosto mai, nd I si scrisse.
Com’ ei s’accese, ed arse, e cener tutto
Convenne die cascando divenisse.”
(Inferno, xxiv, 97.)

Itprobably prevailed in Eastern Europe during the Middle

Ages, and in Esthonia and Finland up to a comparatively
recent period.
In Africa, Fergusson says that Sheikh Haredi in Upper
Egypt is one of the best known sites of modern serpent-wor-
ship, but there are very slight traces of its prevalence in ancient
Egypt. The Egyptians worshipped many animals, but there is
nothing to shoAv that the serpent was honoured above the rest.
In Abyssinia it was worshipped before the introduction of
Christianity in the fourth century, and on the Guinea coast
serpent-worship flourishes at the present day, and possibly
has done so for the last 4,000 years.
In Eastern Asia, Persia affords but slight traces of it. The
Iranians were Aiyans, and brought with them fire-worship.
It may have existed among their predecessors.
Cashmere was one of the principal centres of it. There is
no direct testimony of its existence there till a century before
the Christian era, and the latest authoritative notice of its
practice was in the reign of Akbar (fourteenth century).
In Cambodia and the adjacent countries, serpent-Avorship
reached its fullest development. The country was conquered
* For instance, when a pestilence was raging in Rome in
291 b.c., the
god was brought in the form of a serpent from Epidaurus. A sanctuary
was built for him on the Tiber Island.
A 2
4 SIE JOSEPH KAYRER, K.C.S.I., ETC.,

by the Sia.mese in the middle of the fouideenth century, and

since then has given place, to a great extent, to Buddhism.
it
It prevailed also in Ceylon till the island was converted to
Buddhism, in the third or perhaps the sixth century, and there
are traces of it there still.
In China there are only slight traces, but the repetition of
the dragon-like forms in connection with temples, pagodas,
tvc., in China and Burma, is suggestive of something akin
to the ophidian worship.
In India it was not noticed before the Mahabhrata, but in
that is mention of the Nagas, the great sei’pent-worshipping
race, who, taking the serpent as their emblem or cognizance,
came to consider themselves the descendants of serpents.
Ihere are tribes in India called Nagas at the present day.
Ophiolatry in a modified torm still prevails in many parts
of India.^ It is met with in Manipur, Cashmere, Sumbulpore,
Nepaul, in many parts of the Deccan and Southern India.
On the festival of Nag-Panchmee, snakes are worshipped by
most of the lower tribes of the Deccan.
Serpent-Avorship has no place in Brahminism, but the Hindus
of the present day, if they do not directly Avorship the snake,
will^ neither injure nor kill, but rather propitiate it. This
feeling may be as much due to fear of any bodily harm it may
do them, as to the idea of its possessing supernatural poAvers.
Tylor says the serpent has been taken as the symbol of the
world, of the Taunt, or heaven-god of the Phoenicians, and
as^ the emblem of eternity ;
in the latter case it is depicted
mouth. It may have been the personifica-
Avith its tail in its
tion of evil in the Apophis serpent of the Egyptian Hades,
and it was so in the wicked serpent of the Zoroastrians. Aji
Dahaka Ajdaha is still applied to the larger constricting
;

snakes. Sir George Birdwood tells me that besides abstract

evil, Aji Dahaka symbolised death, destruction, the storm
cloud, &c. “ There Ingromaniyus (Ahriman) the deadly
created a mighty serpent, and snow, the Avork of DeA’^a.”
Cyclopaedia of India (Balfour). He also reminds me that the
deadl}’ serpent is the symbol of oauI in all Eastern countries,
though there, as in Greece and Rome, it may have had also a
creative symbolism.
But time does not permit thatI should dAA^ell longer on
this exceedingly interesting subject I must rather describe
;

to you those forms of the serpent in Avhich the lethal

attributes exist in their most marked conditions, producing
fear and repugnance, if not the Avorship of olden times.
 ON SEllPENT-WOIiSHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 5

The cobra, as I have said, is an object of veneration and

superstitious awe to the nativ^es of Hindustan, for in a
religion that deprecates the wratli of a cruel and relentless
power which it desires to propitiate, the symbol of evil
represented by this reptile is naturally regarded with
peculiar deference. The rapidity and deadliness of its
poison, and the large death-rate due to its bite, explain these
feelings, which need cause no surprise Avhen it is remembered
that upwards of 20,000 people die yearly of snake-bite alone.
I shall give you a brief account of the most interesting
forms of venomous snakes, confining myself to those that are
found in our Indian Empire. It would be barely possible
even to enumerate in the time at my disposal, the deadly
snakes of other countries, or the innumerable innocent forms.
AVherever climate and other conditions are favourable,
snakes are likely to be found, the most venomous as well as
the greatest numbers in hot and tropical regions. In our
own island, as Avell as'iu most parts of Europe, the common
adder is the only venomous snake, and its poAver is feeble
compared Avith that of the snakes of India, the AVest Indies,
Tropical America, Africa, and Australia.
The order Ophidia is divided into Colubriform and Viperi-
form the fi.ist are both Amnomous and innocuous, the second
;

are all Amnomous. Both are numerously represented in

India the colubiiform has five genera of Elapidae^ and four
;

of Hydrophidae, the viperiform has tAvo genera of Viperidae,

and four of Crotalidae, making fifteen poisonous genera, Avhich
comprise a large number of species, but this is small com-
pared Avith the number of innoceut colubrine snakes.
dhe most widely distributed venonrous snakes are the
Auperiform America and Africa aborrnd in them
; the
;

Crotalidae are most nunrerous in America, the Viperidae in

Africa, Avhilst poisonous colubrine snakes are most numerous
in Asia.
I he Ophidia are cold-blooded vertebrata, destitute of
external skeleton, pectoral arch, sternum, or limbs. In a few
there a rudimentary pelvis and hinder extremities.
is
The body is covered by a deciduous epidermis and scales.
These, Avith some exceptions, assume on the head and
_

abdomen the condition of scutm or plates. The bones of

the mouth are connected by ligaments, which alloAv of great
distension, thus enabling the creature to SAvalloAV prey larger
in diameter than itself.
In snakes, one lung is much larger than the other. Their
 —
6 SIE JOSEPH FAY REE, K.C.S.L, ETC.,

cil’culation of mixed arterial and venous blood is regulated

by a heart, consisting of one ventricle, and two amides.
Locomotion is eflected in the terrestrial forms by the motion
of the numerous ribs, which are connected indirectly with
the abdominal scutae. These act as feet, and aided by the
undulations of the body, grasp the surface, thus effecting
the rapid movements of which a snake is capable. The
pelagic sei'pents swim like fish, motion being effected by the
undulations of the body and of the fin-like tail.
Snakes have neither external ears nor eyelids the eye is ;

protected by a transparent capsule, which is shed with the

epidermis. The approach of moulting is indicated by
diminution in the brilliancy of the colouration, and a pearly
opacity of the eye the creature itself becoming more or
;

less apathetic until the process is completed.

The scales and scutse form the basis of classification.
Those on the head are named as follows ;

Eostral. Prse
1- Orbitals.
Anterior "I „ , , Post
Posterior Upper
Labials.
Vertical. Lower
Supra-ciliary. Temponils.
Occipital. Mental.
Nasals. Chin-sliields,
Loreal.

The form and arrangement of the scales vary. In some

snakes they are plain and lie side by side, more or less
lanceolate in form. In others they are imbricated, that is
they overlap each other. On the head, in some snakes, they
are arranged as large plates or shields. On the abdomen in
the land snakes, they are in transverse plates for the purpose
of locomotion. In the Ilydrophidae and burrowing land
snakes these are absent.
Snakes are oviparous and viviparous; the colubrine, except
the pelagic forms, for the most part belong to the first class,
the viperine to the second. The cobra lays twenty to thirty
white, leathery eggs, which are hatched in some warm place
by natural heat. Some are said to incubate the python is ;

said to coil itself round the eggs until they are hatched.
The female of all snakes is said to be larger than the male ;

there are slight differences in colour and form, but no other

external distinction.
Snakes hybernate inthe cold, but returning warmth rouses
them into activity. They generally eat living creatures, but
 ;

ON SERPENT-WOE8HIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 7

—
some -will eat eggs the cobra robs the ben roosts, or devours
insects, molluscs, and even, it is said, vegetable matter; and
—
some are cannibals the opbiophagus and callopbis live on
snakes. In captivity they will, it is said, drink milk.
Snakes differ in their habits and modes of life, and are
grouped accordingly. Tree and grass snakes live in the
trees, bushes, and grass, and are often coloured like the
vegetation they frequent their tails are prehensile. AVhen
;

slender, they are called whip snakes innocent and poisonous

;

forms are found among these. Ground snakes are found in

all three sub-orders; the great proportion belong to this group.
Bur rowing snakes live nnrch under ground, have a rigid,
cyhndrical body, short tail, narrow mouth, small teeth, and
are all innocent.
There are fresh-and salt-water snakes. The salt-water
snakes are adapted for an aquatic life, and are venomous
the fresh-water snakes have not the same characters as the
—
Hydrophidae, and are innocent a curious fact The Hydro-
!

phidae are viviparous.

I.

ViPERiroBM {Dahoia Russellii).

A Maxillary bone.
B Intermaxillary bone.
E Maxillary teeth.
E' Ecto-ptcrygoid bone.
E Poison fang.
Q- Palatine bone.
H Pterygoid bone.
L Frontal bone.
M Mastoid bone.
N Mandible.
T Tympanic.
O Palatine teeth.
P Parietal bone.
R Pterygoid teeth.
 .

6 SIR JOSEPH PAYRER, K.C.S.I., ETC.,

Deglutition effected in a peculiar way ; the jjrey being

is
seized, the mouth gapeslaterally and vertically, each side of
the jaws is called separately into action the sharp and
;

recurved teeth hold the prey firmly, as each side of the jaw
alternately advances or relaxes its gi’asp, aiid it is thus
gradually but inevitably engulfed.
Ihe maxillary bones in the venomous snakes are much
shorter, and provided with fewer teeth than in the innocent.
In the latter, they are elongated slips of bone set with small
recurved teeth. In the poisonous colubrine snakes they are
less elongated and have a fixed, large poison fang, several
loose, reserve fangs, and one, two, or more fixed smaller
teeth,^not_ directly connected with the poison apparatus. In
the Viperidae the maxillary bone is a short, triangular,
movable wedge, furnished with a poison fang lying hidden
in the mucous sheath. The movements of the fang are due
to the rotation of the maxillary bone. This mobility is great
in vipers, whilst it is slight in the colubrines.
When the fang is reclined or erected, the maxillary bone
into which it is inserted is jjushed by the external pterygoid
bone, a movement which is effected by muscular action.
The muscular arrangement for opening and closing the mouth
at the same time compresses the poison gland, thereby inject-
ing the venom through the tubular fang. The fangs are shed
at intervals, and to supply the loss, the reserves are pro-
vided. These lie in the capsule of mucous membrane which
ensheathes the fang. The fang is, during development
II.

Cobra di Capello (Naja Tripudians)

A Poison gland.
B Duct.
C I'nng.
 .

ON SERPENT- WORSHI I’ AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 9

folded on itself so as to form a tube. It is along this ehamiel

that the poison passes; when the fang is deeply imbedded
the quantity of virus injected is considerable, and its effects
are rapidly manifested.
The poison glands are situated between the orbit and the
tympanic bone they are composed of lobes and lobules,
;

which having' secreted the virus, transmit it under muscular

pressure through a duct which communicates with a tri-
angular opening at the base of the fang. They are of
various forms and sizes in callophis they are much elon-
;

gated ; in the cobra they are of the size and something of

the shape of a small almond.
The virus is a transparent, slightly viscid fluid, faintly acid
in reaction, of a straw colour —
in the ophiophagus, of a
yellow colour when ch’ied it forms a semi-crystalline sub-
;

stance, like gum arabic. It is secreted in considerable

quantities, and if a fresh, vigorous cobra be made to bite a
leaf stretched across a tea-spoon —
or as the natives do it,
a mussel-shell, several drops may be obtained. The poison
III.

A D.

A Maxillarj bone and fangs of Daboia Eussellii (yiperiform)

B „ „ ,, Naja tripudians (colubriform).
C ,, ,,
teeth of Ptyas mucosus (innocent).
D Fang of Hydrophis.
E ,,
Baboia.
F „ Naja tripudians.
 10 SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, K.C.S.I., ETC.,

is exhausted when the snake has

bitten frequently, but is
lapidly reformed ; in the interval the reptile is comparatively
haimless, but soon becomes dangerous again. A vigorous
cobra can kill several creatures before its bite becomes
impotent. Removal of the fangs renders the snake tempo-
rarily harmless.
Some animals, especially the pig and the mongoose, are
supposed to have immunity from snake-bite fat sometimes
;
protects the former, the latter is so wiry and active that it
frequently escapes with only a scratch but, if either of them
;
be fairly bitten in a vascular part, it succumbs like any other
animal.
The chemistry of snake-poison has been studied by F ontana,
by Prince L. Bonaparte, Armstrong, Gautier, and others, and
recently by Drs. Weir, Mitchell, and Reichert, of the United
States. a most vnulent poison, and may neither be sucked
It is
li om a bite
nor swallowed with impunity. It acts most rapidly
on warm-blooded, but is also deadly to cold-blooded creatures,
and to the lowest forms of invertebrate life. Strange to say,
a snake cannot poison itself, or one of its own species,
scarcely its own congeners, and only slightly any other genus
of venonious snake but it kills innocent snakes quickly.
;

Snake-poison kills by extinguishing the source of nerve

energy. It is also a blood poison and irritant, and causes
great local disturbance as well as blood change. If it enter
by a large vein, life may be destroyed in a few seconds.
The chief effect is on the respiratory apparatus, and death
occurs by asphyxia; but general paralysis is also a result.
The phenomena of poisoning vary according to the nature of
the snake and the individual peculiarities of the ci-eature
injured, the chief difference being observed in viperine, as
contrasted with colubrine poison. The latter is a nerve-
poison of great deadliness as a blood poison its results are
;

less marked. Viperine poison, on the other hand, is a more

potent blood-poison.
Adder poison is of the viperine character, and though its
immediate effects as a nerve-poison are feeble, yet those on
the blood and locally on the tissues may be productive of
serious symptoms.
It is impossible to enumerate all the antidotes that have
been reported beneficial but amongst those that have the
;

greatest repute may be mentioned arsenic, ammonia, alcohol,

<iuinine, strychnine, acids, snake poison itself, snake-bile, and
the snake -stone, so much relied on in India.
 ON SEIiPENT-WORSHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 11

These stones are said to attach themselves closely to the

bitten part, the blood that oozes out being rapidly absorbed,
and when it drops off the bitten person is thought to be out
of danger. Faraday said that these are pieces of charred
bone. There may be a fragment of trutli in the supposition
that they are of use, because in absorbing the blood, they
must also absorb some of the poison, though so little that
their efficacy must be a mere delusion.
Experience shows that so far no physiological antidote to
snake-virus is known, and that, when the full effect is pro-
duced, remedies are of little avail but when the poison has
;

entered in smaller quantities, medical treatment may be of

service.
The entry of the poison into the system should be aiTested,
if possible,by a ligature above the injured part next the ;

poison in the wound should be destroyed or removed by

excision or by burning, and the application of potassium
permanganate. The'subsequent treatment is conducted on
ordinai’y medical principles, of which further details would
be out of place here.
I must now describe the principal venomous snakes of India.
The Elapidae are subdivided into Najadce or hooded snakes,
and Elapidae proper, which are not hooded. Najadai has two
genera, Naja and Ophiophagus; Elapidae has three, Bungarits,
Xeniirelaps, Callophis.
Naja includes the several varieties of cobra, which are all
of one species,, though differing considerably in external
appearance.
The cobra di capello {Naja triptudians) has numerous
synonyms in different parts of India. A common general
native term kala nag or kala samp. There are many
is
varieties, and they are considered by natives to be of different
degrees of activity or deadliness but the probability is that
;

any difference is due to temporary or individual causes.

The cobras are all hooded, bearing on the hood a spectacle
mark, or a single ocellus, or no mark at all this hood is
;

caused by the expansion of a certain number of elongated

ribs. The body and tail are relatively of moderate length,
seldom together exceedina: five or six feet, more frequently
three or four feet. The scales are smooth and imbricated ;

there is no loreal shield, the nostrils are lateral and the pupil
is round. The colour generally is from a light chocolate,
speckled, to a dark brown or even black. The head is short,
and not very distinctly separated from the neck the fangs
;
 12 SIR JOSEPH EAYRER, K.C.S.I., ETC.,

aie of moderate size and but slightly movable;

there are
one 01 two small teeth behind them in the maxillary
bone.
Cobias are most active in the night, though often seen in
the day. They wall live weeks, even months
in captivity.
Without touching food or water. They go into water readily,
but are essentially terrestrial snakes. They occasionally
ascend trees in search of food, and are not infrequently found
in holes in walls, old ruins, fowl-houses, and
among stacks of
wood, cellars, old brick-kilns, old masonry of brick, or stone,
oi mud, among the grass or low jungle
such are the common
:

lesorts, and during the rains and inundations they

collect in
such places of refuge, where men. stepping on, or unintention-
ally disturbing them, mostly in the dark, are bitten.
The cobra sheds the epidermis wdth the outer layer of the
coinea frequently, the fangs also are shed. The entire slough
often marked by a single rent, through which the creature
^
has emerged, brightly coloured and glistening in its new
epidermis. It aids the process of exfoliation by friction
against some hard substance, such as the branches of a tree,
a stone, or the like, the cast off epidermis being often found
in fragments. It is oviparous, the eggs are about the size of
those of a pigeon, and the shell is w^hice, tough, and leathery.
The cobra is found all over Hindustan, up to a height of
8,000 feet. It is equally dreaded and fatal wdierever met
with; fortunately it is not naturally aggressive unless pro-
voked, then raising the anterior third or more of its body,
and expanding its hood, with a loud hissing it draws back its
head prepared to strike, darts forward and scratches, or
imbeds its fangs in the object of attack. In the latter case,
the results are often dangerous and fatal, but if the fangs
only inflict a scratch, or if the snake be exhausted, the same
danger is not incurred. If the poison enter a large vein and
be quickly carried into the circulation, death is very rapid.
Men have been known to perish from a cobra bite within half
an hour. I he largest and strongest, as well as the smallest
and weakest creatures succumb. Fortunately all who are
bitten do not die. In the first place some human beings as
well as lower animals have greater tolerance than others or
;

a wound may have been inflicted and yet but little of the
poison inoculated or in the third place, the snake may be
;

weak or sickly, or it may have been exhausted by recent

biting, and thus have become temporarily incapable of in-
flicting a fatal wmund, though it may still poison. But when a
cobra in the full possession of its power bites and injects the
 ON SERI’ENT-WOUSniP AND VENOMOES SNAKES. 13

poisou into man or beast, it is almost surely fatal, and all the
vaunted antidotes are futile.
Cobras are frequently exliibited by the so-called snake
charmers. Their g-raceful attitudes, with raised heads and
distended necks, as they sway from side to side Avatching the
movements of their keeper, and frequently striking at him,
and the ease with which they are handled, make them general
favourites. I may here remark that the cobra depicted in
Hindoo legends or old j^aintings is the gokiuTah, or spectacled
snake. They are generally depiaved of tlieir fangs (which
is done by cutting them out Avith a coarse knife), but the
snake charmers knoAv the habits of the creature so AA-ell that
they handle them without fear, even Avhen armed, though
Avith great caution, ahvays grasping them tightly beloAV the
head AAutli one hand and holding the tail Avith the other.
They knoAV that a neAv fang is soon produced, and to prevent
this they sometimes reraoAm the capsule and reserve fangs,
thus makijig the snake permanently harmless. The sole
secret of th'^se men lies in their dexterity and fearlessness.
Their mantras, their antidotes, and the pipes Avith Avhich they
pretend to charm are as devoid of real poAver over the snake
as are the snake-stones, roots, and other nostrums OAmr its
poison. They knoAv that dexterity is their real security.
The snake-charmers occasionally exhibit tlie ophiophagus,
— which, like the cobra, dilates the hood Avhen excited also —
the bungarus, daboia, and some of the innocent snakes, such
as Chrysopelia, Passerita, Ptyas, and Erix. AAdiich ai'e remark-
able for the beauty of their colours, their activity, or their
peculiarity of form. These exhibitions are ahvays accom-
panied by the music of the pipes.
The cobra is an object of superstitious aAve to the Hindus.
Should fear or the death of some inmate of the house in
Avhich the cobi-a has taken up its abode prove stronger than
superstition, it may be caught and deported in an earthen
jar to some field, where it is alloAved to escape, but not
destroyed. Still the cobra has many enemies. Besides by
its natural foes, such as the mongoose (^Iierpestes\ pigs,
rapacious birds, and other creatures, numbers are destroyed
by loAv caste people for the sake of reAAarrd. But still the loss
of human life is great.
The Ophiophayas daps (Hamadryad, Sunkerchor) is one of
the largest venomous snakes. It attains a length of ten or
tAvelve feet, is very poAverful and active, and is said to be
aggressive it is hooded like the cobra, and resembles it in
;
14 SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, K.C.S.I., ETC.,

general configuration. The adult is some shade of olive

green or brown the shields of the head, the scales of the
;

neck, hinder part of the body and tail are edged with black ;

the body and hood are marked with black obhque bands.
There are several varieties with modifications of colouration,
but the general characters are essentially the same. The
young differ considerably from the old, and might be mis-
taken for another genus ;
they are black, with numerous
white, equidistant, narrow cross bands. The shields surround-
ing the occipital are large, and give a distinctive character
to the adult snake. This snake, though widely distributed
throughout India and in the Andaman Islands, is not common
and probably does not destroy many human lives but it is
;

very deadly, and its virus seems to have similar effects to

that of the cobra. It is found in the forest and grass jungle,
and is said to live in hollow trees, and to climb them, being
frequently found resting in the branches; it also takes to the
water very readily. As its name implies it feeds on snakes,
though probably when they are not forthcoming, it is con-
tented with other small creatures. Its hood is smaller than
the cobra’s; it is even more graceful in its movements and
turns more rapidly. The snake-charmers, who prize it highly,
say it is very difficult to catch and handle. A fine specimen
of the ophiophagus, about nine or ten feet in length, lived
for some ten years in the Zoological Society’s gardens, and
died two or three years ago; it consumed numbers of the
common English snake, and, I believe, would eat nothing else.
It seemed a quiet, unaggressive creature until roused, when it
would raise its head, dilate its hood, and strike at any object
brought near it.
Bungarus has two Indian species. The Bungarus cceruleus
or krait, is probably next to the cobra, the most destructive
snake to human life. The other species, B. fasciatns, sankni,
or raj-samp, is probably equally poisonous but it is not much
;

brought in contact with men, and therefore is less destructive

to human life than cceruleus. The krait is of a dark, almost
steel-blue black to a chocolate brown, with narrow white
cross- streaks, rings, or bars of white the ventral surface is
;

of a dark, livid colojir, or wliite or yellow tinge; but there

are varieties in the form of colouration. 'I'his species is

common all over India. The fangs are smaller than those
of the cobra, and the poison is not so rapid in its action, but
it is very dangerous and destructive. It is found in the fields,
in grassy plains, rice fields, low, scrubby jungle, and among
 ON SERl'ENT-VVORSHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 15

debris of wood and buildings. It insinuates itself into houses,

into the bath-rooms, verandahs, on the ledges of doors, in
book-cases ajid cupboards: in such situations it not in-
frequently causes fatal accidents. Jjycodon aidicus is some-
times mistaken for it, but the least examination detects the
difference. The scales along the dorsal region are hexagonal
and very characteristic. The krait rarely attains the lena-th
of four feet.
Bunguriis fasciatus, is larger than coeruleus, and is beautifully
marked with rings of yellow on a dark steel-blue ground.
The metallic lustre of the skin is very beautiful ; its body is
of a triangular shape, and it has hexagonal scales along the
dorsal ridge. It is tolerably common in Bengal, Burmah, and
Southern India, and is known in the north-west. It is found
in the open country, in grass, in low jungle, and in the fields
in holes in the ground, sometimes deep down among the roots
of trees ; sometimes finds its way into a native hut.
it It
feeds, like the krait, on small animals, mice, birds, frogs,
lizards, probably on small snakes, and even insects. It is
not_ very aggressive, but when attacked, retaliates fiercely.
It lies coiled up, and when disturbed, jerks itself out like
a
spring, but does not extend its whole length of body.
Xenurelaps has only one species, which is closely allied to
Bungarus. It is very rare, and consequently not destructive
_

to human life.
The_ genus has several species in different parts
of India, which are all more or less brilliantly coloured.
They
are not aggressive, and bite reluctantly, so it is sufficient
to
enumerate some of the species Callophis intestinalis, C. Mae-
:

(d* Q.lX'ldciVtS ^ (d• tVlinCiGXllcitUS y (d, 'tXXgVGSGGXlS^ Cd* GGVOSXTtllS

and probably others.
Theviperiform sub-order has two families, Viperidw, or
and Crotalidae, or pit-vipers. The former is represented
yipers._
in India by two genera, Daboia and EgMs, each
of which has
one Indian species, viz., Daboia RusselKi and EgMs
Garinata
or kuppur. Crotalidae has several genei-a Trimeresurus,
^ with ;

seven species; Peltopelor, one species; Halys, two

species;
I'lypnale, one species. These snakes are all venomous but ’
cause few deaths.
The Daboia Russellii, sometimes called cobra-monil and
chain viper, is a very beautiful snake; it
is of a light
chocolate colour, with large, black, white-edged
rings; a
yellow line is on each side of the upper surface
of the head
converging on the snout rostral and labial shields
; yellow’
IG SIR, JOSEPH FAYREE, K.C.S.l.j ETC.,

witli brown margin, a triangular, brown, black- edged spot

behind the eye ventral surface yellowish, or marbled with
;

more or less numerous semi-circular brown spots, on^ the

hinder margin of the ventral shields. It attains a consider-
able length, forty to fifty inches. It is common in Bengal,
the south of India, Ceylon and Bnrmah, and probably may be
found all over the plains and on the hills, up to G,000 feet, in
Cashmir, but its usual habitat is lowei’.
Fowls bitten by it sometimes die in less than a minute. It
is nocturnal, is sluggish, and does not readily strike
unless
irritated, when it bites with great fury it hisses fiercely
;
and
strikes with great vigour. Its long movable fangs are very
prominent ohjects, and with them it is capable ot inflicting
deep, as well as poisoned wounds. It does not appear to cause
many human deaths, but its misdeeds may be sometimes
asci’ibed to the cobra, ddie daboia is said to kill cattle when
grazing, by biting them about the nose or mouth. In proof
of its sluggish nature, there is a well authenticated story of a
voung person having picked one np, and mistaking it tor an
innocent snake, carried it home. Its true nature as
y
discovered when it bit a dog. It had not attempted to injure
the ]jerson who carried it.

There only one Indian species of

is cavinata
(kuppur, afae). " This snake is much smaller than the daboia,
but grows to the length of 20 inches or more it is terrestrial.;

It is found in the North-West Provinces, Punjab,

Central
Provinces, Scinde, and generally in the south ot India, in the
Anamally Hills, in the Carnatic, and in the vicinity of Madras.
It is of a brownish-grey colour, with a series of quadrangular
or sub-ovate whitish spots, edged with dark brown a semi- ;

circular band on each side of the dorsal spots enclosing a

round, dark-brown, lateral spot; a pair of oblong, brown,
black-edged spots on the centre of the head, converging
anteriorly a brownish spot beloAv and a broad streak behind
;

the eye ventral surface, whitish, with brown species. The

; ^

scales are keeled those on the lateral series have their tips
;

directed downwards obliquely the friction of these against

;

each other causes a peculiar rustling sound.

The Echis is a very fierce viper it throws itselt into an
;

attitude of defence and ofience, coiled up like a s}U’ing. rust-

ling its carinated scales as it moves one fold ot the body
against another. It does not wait to be attacked before
darting its head and body at its enemy, the mouth vide open,
and the long fangs vibrating, presenting a most menacing
 — ;

ON BEEPENT-WORSHU’ AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 17

appearance. It is very poisonous ; the vu-us is of the same

character as that of daboia. There can be little doubt that
it destroys many human lives, as men are much more exposed
to contact with it than with the daboia. It is said to live
largely on the scolopendridae, but probably it preys also on
small mammals, frogs, and small birds. In some parts of India
it is probably chargeable with a considerable number of
deaths.
Pit vipers (Crotalidae) have several genera in India. They
are less dangerous than their American congeners, but are all
poisonous. They are remarkable for the pit or depression
between the eye and nostril in the loreal region, the triangular
broad head, and short, thiek body.
Hypnale is the only Indian genus or species with any
vestige of the caudal appendage, which has given the name
of rattlesnake to certain American Crotalidae, and in this
species it is reduced to a horny spine at the end of the tail.
Many of the Indian Crotalidae are arboreal snakes, and in
colour resemble the foliage and branches of the trees in which
they live. The Indian genera are: Trimeresurus 7. grami-
neus, T. erytlirurus, T. carinatus, 1. anamallensis, T. monticola,
T. strigatus, T. macrosquamatus ; Peltopelor P. macrolepis
^
; ;
Haigs, B. himalaganus, H. Elliottii ; Hypnale, H. Nepa (or
carawilla). The bites of most of these do not seem to differ
much in their effects from those of the English adder, except
the Hypnale nepa, or carawilla of South India, which is more
dangerous.
There remains only to notice briefly the pelagic colubrine
snakes, or Hydropliidae. They may be recognised at once by
their peculiarities. With one or two exceptions they are all
\ enomous, and inhabit the sea, the salt-water
estuaries, and the
tidal streams. They have a very wide range of distribution
in
the Indian and Pacific Oceans. They have a great variety of
form, but the transitions are very gradual some attain
; a
consideiable lengtJi; I have not seen one of more than five
feet, but no doubt they often exceed this.
They are very
poisonous, and though accidents are rare, yet fatal cases
are
on record. The fishermen and sailors on the coasts know
their dangerous properties, and avoid them.
^ydropMdae have smaller heads, jaws and fangs than
E land snakes
the the fangs have open grooves in some, but
;

not all. The virus is very active, and appears to

operate as
speedily and certainly as that of the land snakes.
They have
an elongated body like the 'latter; in some instances
it is
B
 ; ;:

18 SIR JOSEPH PAYRERj K.C.S.I., ETC.,

short and thick in others it is very thick towards the tail,

;

and most disproportionately elongated and attenuated in the

neck, whilst the head is very minute. The colouration is
varied, often brilliant and beautiful. The hinder part of the
body and tail is flattened and compressed vertically, almost
like the fin or tail of a fish, and they swim with ease and
rapidity. When thrown on the land by the surf, as they fre-
quently are, they are helpless. Their food is fish and small
aquatic creatures. There are certain parts of the Bay of
Bengal where they may be seen in great numbers, and their
movements in the blue water are agile and beautiful. There
are four genera in the Indian seas Platurus, Enliydrina,
;

Pelamis, Hydo'opliis. Platurus has two species, P. scutatus and

P. Fischeri (Bay of Bengal, tidal streams near Calcutta). This
genus has several characters of the land snakes, e.g., well-
marked ventral shields body sub-cylindrical, and not com-
;

pressed like HydropMs the colour is black, tinged with

yellow.
Enliydrina has only one species, Enliydrina bengalensis
(valakadyen) ; it is very poisonous ;
body and tail com-
pressed, belly carinate ; colour, bluish-grey, with dark bands
of same, though deeper colour ; no ventral shields. Pelamis
has only one species, P. bicolor. This is one of the most
remarkable sea-snakes in the Bay of Bengal ; no ventral
shields, body flattened, yellow sides and belly, back black
it iscalled kullundur, and is very poisonous.
Of HydropMs the species are numerous ; in the Indian seas
about thirty have been described, and there are probably
others. They present a considerable variety of form and
colouration ; some have elongated necks and small heads, the
posterior part of the body being larger than the anterior
others have not this characteristic, but they all have a strong
family likeness, and may be recognised at once by their com-
pressed bodies, fin-like tails, and the general absence of
well marked ventral scutse. Their colouring is also remark-
able, green, yellow, black, in bands or rings being a common
pattern. They are pelagic, though they enter the tidal
rivers ;
they seldom live long in captivity.
mortality from snake-bite in India is very great. The
The
average loss of life during the eight years ending 1887 has
been 19,880 human beings, and 2,100 head of cattle yearly.
Mr. V. Richards said the cobra causes nine-tenths of the
human deaths. The snakes Avhich are most destructive to
life are so probably in the following order the cobra,
:
—
 ; ; ;

ON SEltPENT-WOESHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 19

N^ar/a trijmdians the krait, Bungarus cceruleus the kupper,

Bc/iis carinata; Kussell’s viper, JJaboia Russellii the hama-
chyas, Ophiophagus daps ; the raj-samp, Bungarus fas ciatus.
Deaths from Snake-Bite in India in 1889 and 1890.
lu Madras in 1889, 1,587 human beings, and 2,037 cattle
Avere killed 340 snakes were destroyed at a cost of Rs, 49.
;

In 1890, 1,424 human beings, and 1,852 cattle were killed; no

snakes were destroyed.
In Bombay in 1889, 1,080 human beings, and 74 cattle
Avere killed; 433,795 snakes were destroyed at a cost of
Rs. 7,848. In 1890, 1,075 human beings, and 100 cattle
were killed 406,092 snakes were destroyed at a cost of
;

Rs. 7,136.
In Bengal in 1889, 10,681 human beings, and 480 cattle
were killed; 41,189 snakes were destroyed at a cost of
Rs. 3,439. In 1890, 10,534 human beings, and 538 cattle
Avere killed; 41,115 snakes were destroyed at a cost of
Rs. 3,742,
In the North-West ProA^inces and Oudh, in 1889, 6,445
human beings, and 221 cattle were killed; 25,663 snakes
were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 3,137. In 1890, 5,798
human beings, and 247 cattle were killed; 24,083 snakes
Avere destroyed at a cost of Rs. 2,902.
In the Punjab, in 1889, 915 human beings, and 87 cattle
Avere killed 68,501 snakes Avere destroyed at a cost of Rs.
;

8,232. In 1890, 834 human beings, and 32 cattle were

killed; 29,941 snakes v/ere destroyed at a cost of Rs.
4,313.
In the Central Provinces in 1889, 1,063 human beings, and
14 cattle Avere killed 1,395 snakes were destroyed at a cost
;

of Rs. 558. In 1890, 1,041 human beings, and 54 cattle

Avere killed; 1,554 snakes were destroved at a cost of Rs.
565.
In Lower Burma 1889, 208 human beings, and 689
in
cattle Avere killed; 6,178 snakes were destroyed, but no
rewards given. In 1890, 223 human beings, and 731 cattle
Avere killed; 6,319 snakes were destroyed, but no rewards
given.
In Assam, in 1889, 230 human beings, and 71 cattle Avere
_

killed 395 snakes were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 23. In

;

1890, 214 human beings, and 257 cattle were killed; 478
snakes were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 14.
In Coorg in 1889, 1 person Avas killed; 14 snakes were
B 2
20 SIK JOSEPH PAYRER, K.C.S.I.j ETC.,

destroyed at a cost of Rs. 3. In 1890, 2 cattle were killed;

20 snakes Avere destroyed at a cost of Rs. 6.
In the Hyderabad Assigned Districts in 1889, 216 human
beings, and 120 cattle Avere killed; 76 snakes Avere destroyed
at a cost of Rs. 26. In 1890, 191 human beings, and 132
cattle Avere killed
;
113 snakes Avere destroyed at a cost of
Rs. 29.
In Ajmere and MerAvara in 1889, 53 human beings Avere
killed 224 snakes Avere destroyed at a cost of Rs. 10. In
;

1890, 78 human beings and 3 cattle Avere killed 192 snakes

;

were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 20.

In Bangalore, in 1889, 1 human being was killed 645 ;

snakes were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 231. In 1890, no

human beings nor cattle AAmre killed; 746 snakes Avere
destroyed at a cost of Rs. 277.
Throughout India, in 1889 there were 22,480 human beings
and 3,793 cattle killed by snakes, while 578,415 snakes were
destroyed at a cost of Rs. 23,556. In 1890, there Avere 2 1,412
human beings and 3,948 cattle killed; while 510,659 snakes
were destroyed at a cost of Rs. 19,004.
“ The average result for all the ProAunces, shows a mor-
tality of one to every 10,155 of population in 1890,
as
compared Avith one to every 9,673 in 1889. The Provinces
Avliich shoAved the greatest loss of life from snake-bite in
proportion of population (excluding Ajmere and Menvara)
are Bengal (1 to 6,731), the North-West Provinces and Oudh
(1 to 8,094), and the Central Provinces (1 to 10,350).
The
loAvest mortality (about 1 to 25,000 of population) occurred
in Madras, the Punjab, and Assam —
.” Report of Indian Govern-
ment^ 1891.
As regards the measures to be adopted for reducing the
annual loss of life by snake-bite, the chief points are to make
known the appearance and habits of the poisonous snakes,
and to institute proper reAvards for their destruction. With
a plain description, and a faithful representation in colour of
each .species, .such as the Government of India have been put
in possession of, the people can easily be made acquainted
Avith the characters that distinguish the venomous from the
harmless snakes, and thus learn to aAmid or to destroy
them.
Until some measures are more uniformly resorted to, there
Avill be no material diminution in the loss of human
life fi’om

snake-bite, Avhich cannot noAV be rated at less than 20,000

annually.
 ON SERPENT-WORSHIP AND VENOMOUS SNAKES. 21

It is satisfactory to find that the Government of India are

insisting upon the institution of measures having for their
object the destruction of snakes. It is, however, to be feared
that the last measure proposed, ^.e., the cutting down and
clearing away of jungle in the vicinity of villages, can hardly
be expected to have the desired effect, for the reason that
the poisonous snakes do not frequent the sort of jungles that
surround villages so much as they do other localities, such as
ruins, holes in walls and in the ground, grass and cultivated
fields, &c., and that also the probability is that a great pro-
portion of bites are inflicted far from the villages, where such
clearances as those proposed by Government could not be
effected, even were they useful. I would suggest that a
reivard should be given for each poisonous snake and for
no other; there can be no difficulty in identifying them.
This could only be effected by an organised system carried
out generally in every district in w'hich poisonous snakes
exist. If it were decided to try this plan as universally as it
is proposed to cut down the jungle, it is probable that a
diminution of the evil might be expected; but whatever
efforts are made they should be universally sustained and
continuous. It is quite admitted that the problem is a diffi-
cult one to solve, but no effort should be spared to mitigate
what must be regarded as a preventible cause of death.

IIAEEI80K & Sons, Printers in Ordinary to Her Majesty, St. Martin’s lane.
 Brief Address, delivered on the occasion of the

Tercentenary of Galileo, celebrated at Padua in 1892, by

Sir J. Fayrer, representing the College of Physicians of
London and the University of Edinburgh.

AW Universitd di Padova ed ai Delegati.

Centenaio di Galileo.

Illustrissimi e Dotissimi Signori.

Profondamente commosso all’onore accordatomi dal Reale

Collegio del Medici di Londra, ed anche dall Universita di
Edinburgo, nel nominarmi il loro delegato, io mi presento
davanti a questa insegne adunanza, per far onore alia memoria
di uno dei piu grandi uomini e dei piu illustri sapienti del
mondo, e per render omaggio da parte del detto Collegio, cosi
bene come dell’ illustre centro di scienza e di filosofia in Scozia,
air inclito 'fecienzato, nonche a feiicitare di cuore colla massima
riverenza, questo antico seggio di scienza e di filosofia in cosi
beta e fausta occasione, nella quale commemorano le scoperte
si

gloriose del celebre e rinomato filosofo, col nome del quale e

intimamente collegata la sua storia passata ed anche la sua
rinomanza attuale.

La scienza di tutto il mondo e senza dubbio in questo

luogo ora rappresentata. Da ogni parte sono venuti messaggi
di simpatia, ma da nessuno forse, con maggiore premura e zelo
che dai compatrioti di Harvey e Newton. Questi, impugnando
la facciola caduta dalla mano morta di Galileo, la innalzo e la
sostenne per illuminare le tenebre e rischiarare di vera luce i

luoghi finallora oscuri anche al gran filosofo stesso ;

I’altro
avendo terminato i suoi studii ed essendo laureato in questa
universita, divenne dipoi, come socio del Collegio di Londra,
farnoso per le sue scoperte sulla circolazione del sangue. I

suoi studii anatornici che fece a Padova svilupparono in lui

quel genio al quale il mondo intero e debitore.

 :

Signori miei, non e solo alio scopritore del terrnometro, e,

come si piio dire, all’ inventore del telescopio ;

non e neppure
air astronomo famoso che ha stabilito il sistema eliocentrico, ed
ha quasi anticipato le scoperte di Kepler, e che ha dimostrato
i satelliti di Giove, le fasi del pianeta Venere, i rnovimenti
diurni e mensili della luna e le macchie solari ;
non e infine all’
autore del “ Saggiatore,” del “ Sidereus Nuncius” e del
“ Dialogo dei due Massimi sistemi del Mondo,” — ma e piuttosto
al fondatore e fautore della filosofia sperimentale che noi
rendiamo adesso omaggio ed onore.

Egli, osando pensare ed investigare da se stesso, rigettando

gli assiomi degli antichi sistemi di filosofia, anche quello di
Aristotile stesso, e rifiutando gl’ insegnamenti della teologia
dogmatica, stabili il sistema del libero esame, affermando che
la scoperta della verita dev’ essere il primo motive, e che s
deve cercarla per via di sperimenti e non sull’ altrui auterita
e che la verita, tanto in respetto alle scienze divine come
alle umane, e unica.

Ardisco dire che nessun migliore tribute si pub fare al gran

maestro adesso commemorate, che questa riconoscenza festiva
dopo trecento anni, dell’ assiduo e instancabile lavoro che ha
non soltanto rovesciato il sistema Tolomaico, ma ha date un
nuovo impulse vitale ad ogni ricerca scientifica e filosofica.

Signori, con queste poche parole ho tentato d’esprimere i

sentiment! dell’ illustre Collegio e dell’ inclita Universita, dei

quali io sono il modesto interprete, e ho I’onore di sommettere
queste indirizze e con esse, i voti piu sinceri dei miei colleghi
per la prosperity futura di questa venerabile Universita, la
quale, molto avanti a Galileo, e stata un primo centre della
vita intellettuale in Europa, e che anche adesso e famosa per
Ja sua propria eccellenza e pei suoi rapporti col gran savio di
cui si pud dire, come ha detto Dante di Aristotile

“ Tntti Vammirun, tiitti onor gli funno”

V
7 December, 1892. j. faykek.
 A LECTURE
DELIVERED AT

itatfjavine’s Kogal Hospital,

TO THE

QUEEN’S JUBILEE NURSES,

At the request of the Council of the Institute,

ON

NURSING IN CHOLERA, AND HOW TO DEAL

WITH IT AS FIRST AID,
BY

SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, K.C.S.L, M.D., F.R.S.,

ON

MAY 4TH, 1893.

J. ON DON ;

I’msted dv Lowe liKOTHERs, 157, High IIoi-born, W.C.

FIRST AID & NURSING IN CHOLERA.

IN an interesting lecture given recently by the Rev. the Pre-

sident of your Institute, I find the following appropriate words:
“I believe the influence for good of this great nursing work
“throughout the land to be incalculable. . . . A
regenera-
“ting influence will follow the steps of the tender-hearted, skil-
“ ful, sympathising nurse, which will tarry in the house when
“she has gone elsewhere on her mission of love and mercy. . .

“She will be the pioneer for good in more directions than one.
“ The sanitary authorities will find that their hands are strength-
“ened by the practical dealing of the nurse, who will teach the
“ poor how to find out what is wrong about the place, and how
“ to set it right . . the ministers of religion will find that
.
;

“their work is often less difficult because the kindness of the

“nurse . . has somehow or other touched a chord in the
.

“heart which they have long wanted to get at, but could not,
“and, if the hearts of Englishmen and Englishwomen will allow
“themselves to catch warmth from the gracious act of the So-
“vereign, and will endeavour to see how they can best help to
“give an impulse to her beneficent intentions, they will find that
“their effort is not unrequited, for .... there are none
“who more value the work, and are more grateful for what is
“done lor them, than the sick poor themselves.”
f uch are some of the concluding words of the lecture referred
to, and I could hardly find a better introduction to the
remarks
which I am about to offer you at the President’s request, on the
 4

application of your knowledge of nursing to those among whom

it is your mission to minister, should the emergency against
which it is our duty at least to make preparation, ever arise.

Having spent many years of my life in a part of the world

where cholera prevails, and having consequently had some ex-
perience of its movements, modes of action, and effects upon the
human race, as also of the methods of dealing with it, 1 am, per-
haps, in a position to ofter you advice which may he of practical
use should we he visited by the epidemic which, having appeared
in France, Germany, Holland, and Belgium, now menaces us
also, and certainly renders it expedient that preparation should
be made in anticipation of its possible arrival here.
To be forewarned is to be forearmed, and there is no more
effective way of ensuring peace than being prepared for war.
Whilst, however, all exaggeration or sensational statements
should be avoided ;
whilst any action or public demonstration
which may tend to e.xcite e.xpectancy and anxiety in respect of
an impending invasion of cholera, is to be deprecated, it is ex-
pedient that whatever forethought can do, under the guidance
of science and experience, should be done quietly and unosten-
tatiously now, ere yet the enemy has assailed us, that, — should
it come — it may not take us by surprise or find us unprepared.

Our mental attitude may then well be as tranquil as the con-

fidence derived from the assurance that all possible precautions
have been taken, can make it.
Now, as respects the sanitary arrangements of tlie country
generally, of the seaports, and the influx of foreigners by sea, it
is satisfactory to know that nothing is omitted by Goverment
and the Sanitary Department of the Local Board, whether by
action or by counsel, which can preserve the country from the
evil, or mitigate it should it gain a footing in our islands.
There is good reason for believing that the precautions taken
in recent years have had the salutary effect of preserving us
from cholera, for whilst our neighbours on the continent have
suffered grievously, we have been almost entirely exempt; and
from this we may derive confidence for the future, for we know
that the same vigilant observation of the progress of the epidemic
i|i Europe is maintained, with the intent that no precaution
which can guard our country from invasion or render it antago-
nistic to epidemic activity should be omitted.
This vigilance is by no means confined to London or the sea-
ports. Tliroughout tlie United Kingdom there exists a well-
organised sanitary service, administered by medical officers of
health, all alive to the danger, and prepared with the means of
dealing with it; and notwithstanding differences of opinion that
may exist as to the etiology of cholera, there is much unanimity
as to the measures necessary to control and mitigate it, with a
full appreciation of the vital importance of. pure air, pure water
 5

and cleanliness, as well as a conviction that immunity from cho-

lera depends on local sanitation rather than on quarantine, cor-
dons or coercion, which are not only useless in themselves, but
hurtful, by diverting attention from the only measures which can
be relied on.
Choleia has been moving and active in our vicinity. We
are
alive to the danger, and are prepared to deal with it should it
come among us.
But it must be remembered that notwithstanding all the
efforts of Government and the health officers, there is still much
to be done. The powers of these authorities are not plenary ;

insanitary conditions still exist in places which public authorities

cannot reach, and people do not always observe all prophylatic
measures. Insanitary dwellings and localities abound; imper-
fect drainage, impure water, unwholesome food, and insanitary
habits and occupations still render people obnoxious to disease.
Now it is in the crowded resorts of the poor that your influence
may be exercised for good, and that your knowledge may be
brought to bear, by advice and persuasion, to effect results which
sanitary coercion would hardly achieve.
It is not my intention to discuss at any length the natural
history or theories of causation and diffusion of cholera. To do
so would be Out of place on this occasion. Nor do I intend to
encroach upon that part of the subject which belongs especially
—
to the pathologist and physician -I mean the nature and treat-
ment of the developed disease. It is rather to the part you, as
nurses, may have to play in your intimate intercourse with the
—
people in rendering first aid and it is impossible to over-
estimate the importance of the influence you may exert in con-
trolling the earliest approaches of cholera— that I would direct
my observations.
—
In no other circumstances in whatever sphere of social life
—
your work may lie is the trained nurse likely to be of more
value than in this for as your very raison d'etre is to minister to
;

the poorer classes, among whom so much is wanting which is

possessed by those more blessed with worldly means, it is in that
sphere that your services will be most valuable and best appre-
ciated by the sufferers and their friends, as well as by the phy-
sician to whom you will be able to render such valuable aid.
Under these circumstances it is most probable that you may
be called upon to act promptly and on your own responsibilit}^
especially should the outbreak be severe. Medical men, how-
ev'er active, energetic, and devoted, cannot be everywhere, and
sudden emergencies are likely to occur in which your experience
and action may be of the utmost importance in the inchoate
stages of the disease. But let me impress on you that in all
—
cases however trifling they may seem
— you should never de-
pend on yourself alone if you can obtain the aid of a medical
s.
 6

man. If this, however, be not always immediately available, it

will behove you to do your best, exercising the judgment and
discretion which your training in the practical work of adminis-
tering first aid may have given you.
Here let me refer briefly to the subject of nursing in the present
day, and I cannot do so without offering my tribute of sincere ad-
miration and respect for a work which, though it has existed
since woman first solaced and assisted those suffering from pain
and disease, has of late years attained to so remarkable a pitch
of perfection, and has become so essential an adjuvant to medical
treatment that one marvels how disease was ever satisfactorily
dealt with, or the well-being of the sick provided for without it.
No social movement of recent days has been more beneficent, in
nothing has your sex contributed more to the common weal.
On my return to England some years ago, after long residence
in the East, nothing impressed me more favourably than the
splendid system of nursing which had come into existence in my
absence. I have watched with infinite pleasure and interest its
steady onward progress up to the present, and I am glad of this
opportunity of addressing you on a subject in which you are so
well-fitted to justify the high esteem in which your vocation
is held.
In laying down practical rules to be observed either in antici-
pation of an invasion of epidemic disease, or as touching the
measures of first aid ancillary to medical treatment, I am sensi-
ble of the great advantage I have in communicating my views
to those so well qualified as you are to carry them out.
The project of making preparation in anticipation of an out-
break of cholera is, under present circumstances, a most ju-
dicious one, and it is a source of extreme satisfaction to know
that a large body of devoted women is ready to under lake the
work of nursing.
There is scarcely any emergency in which such service could
be more valuable, for in the treatment of cholera much of the
prospect of success depends on early measures and on the nurs-
ing. It will not only be a boon of inconceivable value to the
public, should the calamity overtake us, but it must be a source
of extreme satisfaction to the gracious Lady to whom this asso-
ciation of nurses owes its existence, to know that among the
many provisions against the possible danger to her subjects, there
are so many competent persons ready, willing ami able to un-
dertake this important duty. This will also be the case as re-
gards another great nursing association which has made similar
provisions under the auspices of one of Her Majesty’s royal
daughters.
I must now proceed to the special subject which was repre-
sented to me in the following plain and practical words: —
“The
“Council of the Jubilee Institute are making arrangements to
 7

“place the Queen’s Nurses in as good a position as possible to

“meet any outbreak of cholera that may occur where their work
“of nursing the sick poor in their own homes lies. The Council
“think that it would be a great advantage to the nurses who are
“being trained in the Metropolis or are working near to it, that
“they should attend a lecture given by some one who has had
“experience in dealing with it, upon matters in which it is ne-
“cessary that the nurse should be well instructed.”
—
further it is said, “It is important that the nurses should
“learn how to judge of cases in the incipient stage, and how best
“to deal with them as cases requiring first aid, till the services
“of the medical man can be obtained.”
To this proposition I had great pleasure in acceding, for I
regard it as a most judicious and reasonable one. It in no way
implies encroachment on the province of the physician, whilst
such services will lessen his labour and tend to save many lives.
The knowledge one would wish to impart to you is needed
not only by every nurse, but would be of great advantage to
each member of the community, were cholera to come among us.
I shall presently say a few words on the general
characters
and symptoms of cholera, sufficient to enable you, as nurses, to
detect the earlier manifestations in which you can render the
first aid, which may do so much good, and I shall also
describe
the influence exerted by hygienic measures, sufficiently to enable
you not only to detect and arrest the early indications of the
disease, but to point out and urge the removal of insanitary con-
ditions which are a source of danger.
This will support you in your efforts to encourage those among
whom you labour in realizing how much depends on their own
exertions in repelling the assaults of the disease, and in assuring
those on whom it may devolve to watch and attend on the
stricken, that the danger to themselves is small, for however
cholera be communicated, it is not by contagion, in the sense
that that term is applied to some other diseases.
I can safely assure you that in all
m}^ experience of cholera, I
have seen nothing to support the belief that the attendants on
cholera patients are more liable to suffer than other members
of the community.
The records kept in the military and jail hospitals through-
out India show that only I'g per cent, of the attendants
were at-
tacked— probably a smaller per-centage than that among the
community generally. Similar results, I believe, were shown by
the statistics of London hospitals for iS66; whilst in the
great
hospitals of Calcutta, where cholera cases are admitted
indis-
criminately witli others, the disease has never spread.
Such, indeed, has been the experience of India generally,
and
that too, before the antiseptic precautions and
purifications now
recommended were insisted on or practised.
 —
8

The subject of cholera is always one of great interest, but it

is especially so now that the mysterious pestilence is again cast-
ing its dark shadow over Europe, and threatening our islands.
During the recent epidemics on the continent, we have es-
caped, or nearly so; but who shall say that this immunity will
continue ? The means already adopted by the state are about as
good as they can be, but it is impossible to say that the condi-
tions which foster the diffusion of cholera are altogether extinct.
It would be wrong therefore to neglect the warning by omitting
to take precautions.
Cholera exhibits characteristics in common with other pesti-
—
lences for example, the plagues of the middle ages. It traverses
the earth in all directions, spreading in tropical, temperate, and
even northern regions; is often capricious in its incidence, and
terrible from the rapidity and intensity with which it strikes, as
well as from its obstinate resistance to treatment. Yet it is obe-
dient to certain laws which regulate its origin, diffusion and
decline.
Of thetrue nature of its cause, I fear we must still be regarded
as, to a great extent, ignorant but experience and observation
;

have thrown so much light on its habits and modes of action, as

to enable us to mitigate, if not avert, its evil effects. Nor need
we be without hope that in time to come, it may have become
like the sweating sickness, black death, and other pests a thing —
of the past.
That time, however, has not yet come, and we find it illus-
trating all the peculiarities of an epidemic, diffused far and wide
—
over extensive countries, leaping as it were from one to —
another by bounds, or spreading rapidly among more limited
communities, following a definite track, modified by climatic,
meteorological, or local conditions, dying out gradually or ra-
pidly, remaining in abeyance till revivified by new influences, or
occurring sporadically or endemically in certain regions, where,
as in Bengal, it is never altogether absent, and whence it may
at any time appear to spread as an epidemic to countries beyond.
Parkes says — “We
have no certain clue to the origin of cho-
“ lera, and in some respects the propagation of the disease is
“very enigmatical. The way, for example, in which the disease
“has spread over vast regions, and has then entirely disap-
“peared, and the mode in which it seems to develop and de-
“ dine in a locality in a sort of regular order and at certain
“ seasons, are facts which we can (as yet) only imperfectly
“explain.”"*'
Among the many apparent caprices of this disease, it seems to

have an affinity for certain districts — even streets and houses.

The same house has been known to be twice the 'site of the first

fiarke’s ‘-Manual of Practical Hygiene.’' —De Chaimiont.

 ;

outbreak of an epidemic. There were such houses in Calcutta

when I was there. It is worthy of notice also that certain trades,
such as the tanner’s, seem to confer a prophylactic influence
but everything points to locality as the most important factor in
the development of the disease, and to its being the most serious
subject for consideration in dealing with an outbreak.
During epidemic prevalence cholera never attacks all the places
in the area over which it is diffused, but breaks out in but few of
the inhabited towns and villages, sometimes leaping over places
in the direct line of its course, and returning to them later during
the same epidemic. It is a remarkable fact also, that in Bengal
an epidemic moves, not necessarily along the great lines of traffic
or with the rivers, but rather against them. Places attacked at
the same time are often widely distant, and this is constantly
observed in Indian epidemics, only a comparatively small pro-
portion of villages and towns being attacked in any large area
where an epidemic, however intense, prevails.
Much of the earth’s surface has felt its malign influence,
but there an geographical regions where it has not yet appeared.
It has visited our own islands on several occasions — the last
severe outbreak being in 1866 when — it caused great mortality.
But we were not then so well prepared to contend with it as
we are now, and it found a more congenial nidus in which to
effect its ravages.
It is far different at and we may await its appearance,
present,
should it come, with much confidence that measures dictated by
sanitary science and experience will render it comparatively
harmless.
If we have learnt anything by experience of late years, it is
that the invasion and diffusion of cholera are to be prevented or
mitigated by careful application of the principles and rules of
hygiene ;
—
on the other hand, experience in Europe during the
recent epidemic shows how futile coercive measures have been,
while the examples of Marseilles, Toulon, Valencia, Palermo,
Naples and Hamburg, whose notoriously insanitary conditions
have paid their natural penalty, should be a salutary warning as
to how cholera may be intensified by local causes, and give a
lesson which should not be disregarded.
As I have already told you, the broader sanitary questions are
carefully dealt witii by Government and our officers of health,
but you, who know by your experience in tlie houses of the
lower classes how much Lliere is still to be done towards im-
proving the sanitary conJilions of their dwellings and localities,
will understand how much good you may do in your intercourse
wiui them to amend wiiat is defective and gradually accustom
them to realize chat tlie laws of healthy, living-cauriut be broken
or neglected with impunity, especially during the prevalence of
epidemic disease.
 To

Cholera, though happily rare in this country, is no new dis-

ease. It has been known since the days of Hippocrates: its
familiar name in India up to this day is “ haiza,” the Arabic
term by which it was known to Rhazes and Avicenna in the

loth and iith centuries.

Were this a fitting occasion, I might tell you the story of its
wanderings and its ravages in past years, but I must restrict my-
self to practical points in its natural history and modes of proce-
dure which are germane to the aspects in which you are especially
interested.
For similar reasons I must omit disputed questions of causa-
tion and modes of transmission and diffusion for our action
:

must be based on experience and not on theories. I consider it

sufficient to quote a paragraph from a paper on cholera written
five years ago, which seems as applicable now as it was then.
“ The belief in transmission by human intercourse is still firmly
“held by the highest authorities few consider that there is dan-
;

“ ger from mere contact or personal communication, but that

“the danger lies in the transmission of a germ through water or
“other channel from the bowel of one person to that of another.
—
“Hence they insist on what all recognize the importance of
“the purity of the drinking water, because any organic impurity
“during cholera prevalence tends to give rise to the pathological
“conditions which result in the disease.
“For my part, I am unable to accept the water theory as the
“sole and sufficient explanation of all cholera outbreaks, especi-
“ally those which occur where the water is beyond suspicion
“of cholera contamination.”
It would be difficult to overestimate the importance of recent
researches into micro-organisms in connection with cholera, but
their true relation to the disease has not yet been fully established.
“ I rather seek the solution in causes of a more general nature,
“but I would speak as one who awaits further information, and
“who, though impressed with the belief in the non-communica-
“bility of cholera by the ordinary mode of contagion, is not pre-
“ pared dogmatically to assert that under certain conditions it
“may not become communicable, in localities such as quarantine
“lazarettes, or other insanitary and crowded quarters.
“I hold, moreover, that until contagion is disproved, autho-
“rities are justified in adopting measures which avoid undue
“interference with personal liberty, yet take reasonable precau-
“ tions against possible sources of infection, and give efipct to all
“ known practical measures against the propagation and diffusion
“of disease.”
Some simple and practical measures you may be called on to
put in force at any time in the early stage of the disease, and
wiratever views on the etiology of cholera may be held by those
to whom you are responsible, you will have the satisfaction of
 —
II

knowing that you are doing that which experience has proved to
be the best.
the case that British and Indian authorities, basing their
It is
measures for protection on ascertained facts, and not on theories
of causation oir on coercive measures, have come to rely on in-
spection and sanitation as the real and sufficient means of safety.
It is satisfactory to know that this view is becoming more gene-
rally accepted by other nations, and that the tendency to combat
the inroads and diffusion of disease by sanitary measures alone is
becoming general.
The panic produced by the dread of contagion was well ex-
emplified by the state of the South of Europe, which, during the
cholera of 1887 was pitiable, and the measures of fumigation,
isolation, and general interference with personal liberty which
would have been ridiculous had they not been so pernicious.
The same feeling still prevails in other parts of the world, and I
quote an example (from the of January 22, 1886) “Two
“Japanese sailors died from cholera during the short journey
“ trom Kobe to Nagasaki. Their dead bodies were thrown over-
“ board. The Japanese authorities immediately forbade fishing
—
“along the coast .’’ Sanitavy Review. It would not be difficult to
adduce others almost, equally absurd.
Up to the present date the belief is maintained by foreign
powers that epidemic diseases, and especially cholera, can be
arrested in their progress and debarred from entering a country
by quarantine. This, as you are probably aware, originally
meant seclusion and isolation for a period of forty days, of per-
sons either affected by a disease or coming from a locality where
it prevailed. Quarantine is based on the assumption that the
disease is communicable from person to person, either by means
of the individual himself or of his effects. This view, however,
has been modified considerably in its application of late years,
and the period of isolation has been much diminished, even by
those who, holding the doctrine of contagion, should therefore
logically concede the theoretical efficacy of quarantine, but say
with De Chaumont;
“Whatever may be the final opinion respecting the portability
“ of the disease, we are bound to act as if it was perfectly ascer-
“tained. It is usually impossible to have rigid quarantine, for
“nothing short of absolute non-communication would be useful,
“and this is impossible, except in exceptional cases
“Then as the incubative stage can certainly last for ten
or twelve
“days, and there are cases on record where it has lasted for
“more than twenty, it is clear that quarantine, unless enforced
“for at least the last period of time, may be useless. The con-
“ stant evasions, also,
of the most strict cordon, renders such
“plans always useless.”

*larkes “ ffaiiual of Practical Hygiene,” — De Chaumont.

 —
12

Withreference to the period of incubation, it has been stated

to be from a few hours up to twenty days.
The approach of an epidemic of cholera has not unfrequently
been heralded by some peculiarly depressed or altered condition
of the general health, or even by some other epidemic, such as
the influenza, which has lately prevailed in this country.
Outbreaks of cholera, though they generally commence by
dropping cases, are sometimes very sudden and violent. A pro-
vince or a body of men may be struck, the whole community
being affected. The outbreak starts from a definite time, and
the greatest mortality is conipressed into a few days, generally
at the very beginning.
Let me give a few examples :

“While proceeding up the China Sea in one of the late East

“India Company's ships we were” says the writer, “ suddenly
“attacked by cholera, men falling on deck as if struck by
“lightning. This continued for three days, when the visitation
“as suddenly ceased. As we were then drinking the same water
“ that we had been using for three months previously, and from
“the time of leaving England, there could have been no con-
“tamination of the water in this instance independently of the
;

“fact that it was contained in tanks into which extraneous mat-

“ter could not possibly have entered, A precisely similar out-
“ break occurred on board H.M.S, Undaunted,’ while proceed-
‘

“ing down the China Sea, As the cases continued to increase,

“the surgeon, at the end of three days, recommended the captain
“to change the course of the vessel. This was no sooner done
“than the attack ceased. Not a case occurred afterwards.”
“ In 1854, in London, in the district of the Savoy, there were
“in a few days 537 deaths from cholera; the suddenness of the
“ outbreak was very remarkable. The greatest local diffusion
“seems to have been reached on the second day, if not on tlie
“first. During two days it prevailed with the greatest intensity,
“and in the two following days it showed a diminution of 50
“percent.”!
The suddenness of an outbreak may be followed by an equally
rapid declme, and the remarkable alternations, whether for better
depression
or worse, caused by changes of weather, fall of rain,
temperature, thunderstorms and gales of wind, are very sug-
of
gestive of the influence exerted by meteorology on its progress.
Sudden outbreak followed by rapid decline was well illustrated
when cholera attacked our troops and ships in the Crimea.
After its arrival in the Levant, the French army had suffered
a great deal from sickness, but the British
army had been com-
paratively free up to the 19th of July, when cholera appealed

* farUiii, "Are Eiiideniics eoiitagiuus?”

Nov. 3rd and 17tli, 1887.
f ‘‘Journal d’Hygieiie,”
 t f

13

among our regiments in Bulgaria, and by August igth had killed

532 men. Before appearing in our army it had attacked
French
ships of war in the Mediterranean and their army in Bulgaria,
making great ravages among the three divisions marching into
the Dobrudja and in the ships. In a day's march, sometimes
within the space of a few hours, hundreds of men dropped down
in the sudden agonies of cholera. Out of these three divisions
no less than 10,000 lay dead or struck down by sickness.
The disease appeared in the British Heet, and on the iith and
1 2th of August the admirals put out from their anchorage,
hoping thus to arrest its progress. It nevertheless raged wiih a
violence rare in Burope the “Britannia” alone lost 105 men,
;

and the number of sick was so great as to render the usual duties
impracticable.
“The waywardness on board the British ships
of the disease
“was extraordinary; it spared the officers, who, partly by kind-
“ ness and sympathy, partly by remedies, seemed often able to
“fight the disease, or make the men think they did so.”
“ Almost suddenly the cholera ceased on board ship, the sur-
“vivors returned to their duties, all mention of the terrible tra-
“ gedy was dropped, and in a few days from the time when
“cholera had been at its height, the crews were ready to embark
“the troops and land them in the Crimea.”*
The great epidemic which broke out among the troops of the
army of Lord Hastings in India began on November the 7th,
1817, was in all parts of the camp on the gth, and reached its
height on the 17th. During the week in which it raged most
violently, 764 soldiers and 8000 camp followers died; the epide-
mic had ceased by the 22nd or 23rd of November.
An outbreak occurred in May, 1818, among the Nagpore subsi-
diary force. Between 70 and 80 cases were admitted the first
day, and many were found dead and dying about the camp.f
Another instance is the great outbreak at Kurrachee in 1846.
On Sunday evening, June 14th, there was a sudden change in
the atmosphere, the wind veered from south-west to north-east,
and a thick, lurid cloud darkened the air. Later on in the even-
ing cholera appeared in thirteen corps of the troops stationed
there; it increased in violence till the i6th, when 227 cases were
admitted, of which 186 died; after that date it gradually de-
clined, 814 cases and 442 deaths having occurred between the
15th and i8th (inclusive).
Without any premonitary symptoms, cholera appeared at
Peshawur, at five o'clock in the morning of May 17th, 1867;
from that day till the 23rd, the number of cases increased daily,

and after that date decreased gradually, the last case being ad-
mitted to hospital on the 3ist.f
*Kiiiglake ‘-Invasion of tlio Crimea.'’ N’ol. viii.

t <Juoted from Bryden. Cholera in the Bengal Presidency from 1817 to 1872.
 14

A remarkably sudden outbreak occurred in an orphanage at

Secundra, near Agra, on May 29th, 1867. The girls were caught
in a sudden shower of rain, the elder ones being the most ex-
posed to it. One of them was found dying at four o’clock the
next morning, and subsequently 40 of them and 6 of the younger
girls were attacked. On May 30th, 16 cases were admitted; on
the 31st, 15; between the ist and 6th of June, 15; the disease
then died out.
In an establishment for pauper children at Tooting, in 1849,
there were crowded 1395 children, little more than 100 cubic feet
breathing space being allowed for each child. One night cholera
attacked 64 of these children; 300 were attacked in all, and
within a week 180 died.*
The epidemic of 1832, in Paris, commenced on the 26th of
March, and increased so rapidly, that in eighteen days it had
reached its climax, and had already extended to all the quarters
of the city, and had been fatal to 7000 people.!
It would be easy to adduce other examples, but these are
sufficient to illustrate the point.
Let me now say a few words on the disease itself.
The premonitary symptoms of cholera are malaise and diarr-
hoea, generally painless and often not violent at the outset. This
may continue in some cases for days before it assumes the spe-
cific character of the disease, that of profuse watery discharges
from stomach and bowels.
There is good reason to believe that if diarrhoea be checked
early by simple measures, cholera may often be averted. For
this reason the slightest indication of it should be enquired into
and at once arrested. It is at this early stage that you can
render that first aid which is of such importance.
It is quite true that cases may occur in which a dose of castor
oil might be more appropriate, but as you would hardly be able
to discriminate between these, and bearing in mind the import-
ance of immediately checking all diarrhcea in cholera seasons,
it is better you should do so, for in the cases in which it might

not have been really necessary, no harm will be done that

cannot easily be remedied, whilst you may have averted an
attack of cholera.
The medical men under whom you work will give you the for-
mula they approve of for the purpose, probably an astringent,
combined with aromatics and laudanum.
In India it used to be, perhaps still is, the custom to supply
the people in cholera seasons with pills consisting of asafcetida,
black pepper, and half a grain of opium in each, to be taken on
the appearance of diarrhcea.
Should it progress to cholera, the diarrha'a will become fre-

*Soiitliwood Sinitli. The Common Mature of l'4)idemies.

I Baly and Gull. Itcports on Epidemic Cliolcra.

 15

quent and; like rice-water, whilst incessant vomiting of rice-

watery looking fluid, cramps, great exhaustion, lividity of skin,
and husky voice will soon be followed by collapse, suppression
of urine, and too frequently death.
There are certain erroneous notions about cholera; one is
e.g.,

to give that name to the disease only when developed

in its fully
condition. But the fact is that it presents many phases, varying
in gravity from simple malaise to collapse. Sporadic cholera, or
“ cholera nostras,” as it is called when it occurs in this country,

is regarded by some as a different disease from Asiatic cholera,

or “ cholera maligna,” but the cholera of our country is indis-
tinguishable at certain stages from that of India.
I believe that the difference in intensity or epidemic preva-

lence depends on climate, locality, and certain conditions not yet

definitely known.
Whilst the disease is in its incipient stages you may frequently
have the opportunity of acting on your own responsibility, but in
all cases, I repeat, obtain medical aid if possible, and remember
that it is not only in the administration of simple remedies at the
outset, but in the carrying out of your instructions generally that
you will be able to give the most effective aid, whether in the
early or later stages of the disease; in the latter especially, your
action must be guided by the medical officers.
I will briefly summarise the methods of procedure before I

conclude this lecture.

When the symptoms of cholera have established themselves,
the patient’s condition rapidly becomes one of great gravity.
The vomiting and purging are frequent and profuse, the strength
rapidly fails; the patient is tortured by cramps and thirst the ;

temperature is depressed, the voice becomes husky, the coun-

tenance and surface livid, the renal secretion is suspended, the
skin of the fingers becomes shrunken and corrugated; and if
reaction do not take place, death soon closes the scene.
During these stages of the disease, the services of the nurse
are of the utmost importance, and her unremitting attention is
required in the administration of medicine, nourishment, stimu-
lants, and ice to relieve the intense thirst; the application of
sinapisms or other counter-irritants friction of the limbs and
;

body, and other measures that may tend to alleviate the suffer-
ings, moderate the symptoms, sustain the rapidly failing vital
energy, and give intelligent effect to the physician’s directions
generally.
I cannot here pretend to indicate the remedies or nutriment
that should be administered, or the local applications that should
be made. In all this you must be guided by the medical officer
under whose direction you work; but I can assure you that on
your watchful, skilful care and intelligent interpretation and ful-
lilment of his behests, the life of the patient may depend.
 — ;

i6

As I have already said, the disease assumes many phases and

degrees of intensity, and though very fatal in the most severe
forms, happily in those of less intensity recovery often occurs
and let me repeat that in no form of disease does the issue de-
pend on good nursing and intelligent interpretation of the
physician’s orders more than in cholera.
The mortality is high when cholera has reached the condition
of collapse or consecutive fever. At the outset of an epidemic
probably half or more than half of those affected die. The
fatality decreases as time goes on, and this has sometimes led
the inexperienced to think that they have found some more
effective treatment than any hitherto known.
The diminution in intensity and fatality as an epidemic pro-
gresses is not confined to cholera. It was observed by Defoe in
the plague of London during the 17th centui'V. In an outbreak
of cholera at Kurrachee, of the first too admitted, 79 died; of
the second, 66; of the third, 50; of the fourth 40; at a later
period the mortality diminished and the cases were less severe.
The following conclusions may be deduced from experience;
1. —
That in cholera epidemics, though the disease is generally
heralded by premonitary attacks of diarrhoea, often trivial and
painless, yet the cases of fully developed cholera are more fre-
quent and more severe at the commencement than in the con-
tinuance of an outbreak.
2. —
That hygienic measures afford the greatest security, but
still are not an absolute safeguard against cholera. Local in-
sanitary conditions and impure water, especially if contaminated
with cholera dejecta, impure atmosphere from overcrowding and
from emanations from drains and cesspools, decomposition of
organic matter, imperfect ventilation, absence of cleanliness
generally, favour its incidence and increase its intensity.
—That cordons and quarantine have utterly failed to pre-
vent the spread of cholera, but on the contrary, have done harm.
—That it is important to clieck all diarrhoea in times of
cholera prevalence.
—Tliat to enter an area in which cholera is present or to
travel within that area is dangerous to a new-comer, while
residents whose circumstances of living are favourabje have a

5.
—
better chance of escape.
'I o change the localit\ is the bt.st o au se to pursue when
cholera attacks a body of men, such. lor example, as a regiment.
y.
—
That attendants on the sick do not sulier more than others.
g. —
I'hat irritating articles of diet, imripe fruit, tainted animal
footl, fish, fiesh or fowl, and saline aperients are liable, during
cholera prevalence, to liring on diarrhtea which may rapidly
pass into cholera.
g. — That fatigue, exhaustion, inteinpci. nee in alcoholic drinks,

fear, anxiety begotten of dread of contagion and sensational

 —
17

descriptions of the horrors of the disease, and sudden vicissitudes

and alternations of temperature are powerful predisposing and
exciting causes.
10. —
Having suffered from cholera gives no immunity from re-
currence of the disease.
The question then arises, what does it behove each individual
of the community, and especially what is it incumbent on you,
the Queen's Nurses, to do, as regards your household, district,
village, town, or the country generally i.e., as far as your influ-

—
ence extends when cholera threatens or has actually made its
appearance ?

In the first place, bear in mind that coercive measures are

futile they divert attention from the true and only source of
:

safety, which lies in the removal of all insanitary conditions

which may give fatal activity to the disease.
Use every secure good ventilation, pure air and pure
effort to
drinking water, well-trapped sinks and good drainage, with the
removal of all cesspools, foul dust-bins, ash-pits, decaying vege-
table or other organic matter.
Avoid as much as possible damp, ill-ventilated rooms, over-
crowding, and every impediment to the free circulation of air.
—
Careful living by which I mean regularity and avoidance of
all errors in diet, all depressing and exhausting habits or occu-
—
pations is essential. Let the food be plain, the water and milk
be boiled before drinking, and avoid all excess of alcoholic sti-
mulants, indigestible or imperfectly cooked food, and especially
animal food, whether of mammal, bird, fish, crustacean or shell-
fish, unripe and partially decayed fruit or vegetables.
Professor Notter, of Netley, a high authority on hygiene,
points this out in some remarks which are of great practical
value.
Be most careful to avoid chills or exposure to sudden alter-
nations of temperature, aperient medicines, especially saline
aperients. Wear woollen next the skin a flannel belt is often
:

worn in India.
Do all you can to secure personal cleanliness of body and
clothing. Avoid fatigue or exhaustion.
Be careful that all excreta are freely disinfected and re-
moved; the drain or sink into which they are thrown should be
well flushed with carbolic acid water. Use disinfectants freely
for clothing, rooms, and houses.
Whenever you detect any breach of these directions, do your
best by persuasion and advice, or by the intervention of sanitary
executive authority, to rectify them.
Endeavour to keep a good heart and a cool head be hopeful
;

and cheerful yourselves, and encourage that feeling in others,

for panic, fear and anxiety are very apt to favour, if not to
provoke, the onset of the disease.
 i8

Donot be afraid to attend on the sick, and encourage others

to same purpose, for no danger is incurred thereby, whilst,
the
as I have said, a mental attitude of despondency or dread of
contagion is full of danger, as has been proved by frequent
experience.
i would impress on you that it is on such measures only you
may repose confidence, and that, if carefully carried out, expe-
rience shows that reliance may be placed on them.
Do not for a moment suppose that I regard cholera merely as
a result of dirt and insanitation. It is something more than
this, but so much is certain, that to prevent the onset, or con-
trol the evil effects of cholera, sanitary measures, strictly carried
out, are of all things, most effective.
With reference to the part you, as Queen’s Nurses, will be
called on to play, I find that excellent recommendations have
been already made by your Council. They are to a great ex-
tent based on those of the Royal College of Physicians and of
the Government Local Board, and I can do little more than
endorse and emphasize them.
In the first place I notice that the superintendents of your
Nursing Homes are recommended to acquaint themselves with-
out loss of time with whatever special arrangements may have
been made by the local or other authorities for giving medical
assistance within the district, and to ascertain what steps the
nurses are to take with reference to cases of diarrhoea or cholera.
That, having obtained this information, each Superintendent
should inform the Nurses how to communicate, with the least
possible delay, with the proper medical authority for notification
of any such case; also the nearest centre for obtaining medical
aid, medicine and disinfectants.
It is very important that centres where medicine and medical
comforts and disinfectants can be got at any moment, should be
well known and accessible.
I would suggest that as, in crowded neighbourhoods especially,
there will probably be hospitals for the reception of cases, the
Nurse should know where these are, and the best means of
effecting removal to them when necessary.
I would further suggest that each Nurse be supplied with
some simple remedy to be given at once to any case of diarrhoea
of which she may become cognizant.
The Nurses should be made acquainted with the regulations
of the Local Government Board, or district sanitary authority,
with regard to the disinfection of houses, clothing, furniture, etc.,
so that they may at once take the requisite steps.
They should be made acquainted with any arrangements for af-
fording relief to the very poor, so th.at there may be no lo.-^ of time
in communicating with the relieving officer or other person ap-
pointed to dispense such relief in any case of want pr destitution
 ——
19

since privation, as a predisposing cause, may require special aid.

If extra local centres could be established in poor, overcrowded
neighbourhoods, where the Nurses could procure nourishment
and comforts for the sick, it would be an excellent prophylactic
measure.
It is further recommended that the Superintendents of all
Nurses’ Homes should enjoin the following precautions on the
Nurses :

In the first place that they should preserve an equable frame

of mind, and endeavour to maintain it in others. They should
avoid, as I have said before, excitement or exaggeration they ;

should not dwell on the dangers of exposure to contagion, and

on the terrors of the disease; or, in short, do or say anything
that may discourage or depress.
Let me repeat that to do so can cause nothing but harm.
Panic, depression, and anxious expectancy are the worst frame
of mind in which to meet cholera, whilst the converse has
exactly
^
the opposite effect.
As an illustration of this, let me tell you the following Oriental
story :

A Dervish travelling over the desert met the Genius of Cho-

lera, to whom he said, “ Where are you going ? ” The Genius
replied, “I am going to Baghdad to kill 20,000 men.”
Some
time afterwards the Dervish met the same Genius returning,
and accused him of having killed go,ooo. “No, no,” said the
Genius of Cholera, “I killed only 20,000, fear killed the rest.”
The advice I have just given is probably unnecessary for the
majority of the highly trained women I have the
pleasure
of addressing, but as there are timid natures to whom en-
couragement may be helpful, it is right that they should know
that the danger exists chiefly in the imagination, as
far as nurs-
ing cholera is concerned, and that, as to other
sources of danger
of incurring the disease, they but share alike with
the rest of the
community, whilst risk to all is vastly diminished by conformiiu^
to the rules of hygiene.
The Superintendents are enjoined to impress on the Nurses
that they should not go on duty, if they can avoid
it, when feel-
iiig fatigued or unvyell, especially if
affected with any relaxation
of the bowels; that it is necessary for them to take
a good, plain
nourishing diet ev^en an extra allowance and at
not too long intervals.
— regular and
The depression caused by fatigue, hun-
pr, and an empty stomach predisposes to the disease.
’Such
food should be available by night as well as by
day.
As to stimulants— it is not necessary that they should
be taken
m increased proportion, though occasions ma'y
arise when an
extra allowance will be expedient.
It is only too probable that in
your ministrations among the
poor, especially should cholera appear in
crowded neighbour-
 20

hoods, it may not be possible for you to observe to the letter all
these directions; but at any rate remember and observe them as
nearly as you can. You must, under such circumstances, neces-
sarily be exposed to many hardships and risks, but it is a noble
Avork, worthy of your highest aspirations, and twice blessed, fur
it will, like mercy, bless those who give as well as those Avho

receive.
The Superintendents are emphatically to caution the Nurses
as to any neglect on their own part or on that of others of perfect
cleanliness of person and clothing, which should be carefully dis-
infected. This again, under the circumstances, will often be
very difficult, but do your best to ensure it, as far as possible.
You will, no doubt, see much that to your instructed eye is
suggestive of danger from insanitary conditions, which, alas, you
are unable to prevent. But jou may do a good deal, and what-
ever warning, advice and remonstrance can effect, you should
insist on. Do not wait for the actual advent of cholera, but try
and accomplish this before it comes.
I have already referred to the need for personal cleanliness,
and on this the Nurses should strenuously insist. The houses
should also be kept as clean and well-ventilated as possible; dust-
bins emptied frequently no decaying matter or dirt of any kind
;

to be allowed to accumulate in or near the house or premises.

No cesspools to be tolerated if it is possible to remove them. All
latrines and closets should be kept in good order, and flushed
frequently with disinfecting fluids. The best are solutions of
corrosive sublimate | oz., hydrochloric acid loz., dissolved in
three gallons of water and coloured Avith five grains of aniline
blue. This is a disinfectant in the truest sense; the only objec-
tion to it is its poisonous nature.
Professor Notter says that a five per cent, solution of carbolic
acid is quite effective, and this would be safest for the Nurse to
use for general disinfecting purposes, and a good supply of it
should be available. He strongly recommends that all dejecta
should be disinfected Avith it or by chloride of lime, Avhilst all
linen or bedding soiled by cholera discharges should be destroyed
by burning, or soaked in the corrosive sublimate solution, or heated
in a disinfecting chamber.
Fumigation by burning sulphur or chlorine gas is effective in
rooms, but these must be used in large quantities to be of any
avail.
Much stress — —
and rightly so is laid on the purity of drinking
Avater. Itshould be obtained from as pure a source as possible,
and should be Avell filtered and boiled shortly before using. All
tainted Avells should be closed. Milk also should be boiled shortly
before it is used.
Provisions of all kinds should be as fresh as possible. As I
have before said, all stale food, especially flesh or fish, should be
 — :

21

avoided. much importance to this as reejards

Notter attaches
fish, which unhappilyoften sold to the poor in a stale condition.
is
It is the conviction of most medical men who have had to deal
wnth cholera epidemics that it is right to check diarrhcea at the
outset in cholera seasons. Of this I have already spoken.
I again repeat, seek medical advice as early as possible, and it

is most desirable that all persons should know where to find it;
but in anticipation, the Nurse will do well to administer a dose of
some astringent such as the following, whenever diarrhoea appears
Pulv. aromat three drachms.
Sat volatile three drachms.
Tr. Catechu ten drachms.
Tr. Card. Co sixdrachms.
Tr. Opii one drachm.
Mist. Cret twent}'^ ounces.
Dose, —
loz. for an adult, ^oz. for a child 12 years, ^oz. for a
child 7 years, less for a younger child in proportion to age, after
each liquid motion.
Professor Notter says: —
“For the diarrhoea which precedes
“cholera, and for the early stages, to check it, I found nothing
“better than:
“Acid Sulp. dil fifteen minims.
“Tr. Opii.. five minims.
“Aq. menth. pip one ounce.
“and this might be safely left with a nursing sister.
“ If the comma bacillus is the cause, we know that it will not
“live in acid media. So there is good reason for prescribing that
“form of astringent.
“For like reason, acid drinks should be given, ad lib., to make
“up for the water passed off in the discharge from the bowels,
“and to relieve the kidneys, which become early involved.
“ found this the best treatment in the early stages myself.
I

“Of after, the first two doses, I omitted the opium.”

course,
1 he College of Physicians has formulated some excellent rules
for the early treatment of cholera. You will find them in the
leaflet of recommendations issued by your Council. Those which
apply to first aid I have already mentioned. The others are
rather such as w'ould appertain to the medical man, so I need not
repeat them here.
I have now told you enough to show you how you
hope I
should act, and I can hardly sufficiently insist on the importance
of the services you may render in relieving suffering, assuaging
pain, and giving confidence to the healthy as well as to the sick.
You will have full opportunity of doing all this, and of justifying
the encomium passed on your order by your reverend and re-
spected President. You will establish a claim to the gratitude of
your countrymen and countrywomen, but far better than this,
you will have the satisfaction arising from the consciousness of
 —
22

duty well :ind thoroughly performed; the solace of knowing you

have rendered valuable aid in a great emergency, relieved suffer-
ing, and, it may be, have saved life.
You will have done more too, for you will have contributed
your share towards that great end to which sanitary efforts
aspire, the diminution, if not the extinction of the pestilence.
You will have furthered in some degree, however small it may
be, the object to which we all hope to attain, as was well ex-
pressed by Dr. Southwood Smith, a sanitarian and epidemiolo-
gist, whose loss we continue to deplore, when he said :

“Epidemics are under our own control; we may promote their

“spread, we may prevent it. We
may secure ourselves from
“them. We have done so. We
have banished the most for-
“midable. Those that remain are not so difficult to be con-
“quered as those that have been vanquished We
“see that epidemics are not made by a divine law the necessary
“condition of a man’s existence upon earth. The boon of life is
“not marred with this penalty. The great laws of nature, which
“are God’s ordinances in their regular course and appointed
“operations, do form and give off around us, products which are
“injurious to us; but He has given us senses to perceive them,
“and reason to devise the means of avoiding them, and epidemics
“arise and spread because we will not regard the one nor use
“ the other,”
“Let us,” says Dr. Dallinger, in a recent address, “do our
“duty and act up to our knowledge, and as surely as disease
“comes among a people by physical laws broken, so it will de-
“part from them if they see to it that physical laws are obeyed.”

Lowe, Bkos., Printers, 157, High Uolborn, Loudon, W.C.

VV
V
 J

V,

.•'T A

•
>*k »•?

t %w
>-

,
<^ : y

'•> -'•^ \4 I
IfJ.

s#

-
A /'.

"I

•''>. .•-V{;i.: ’"/' •-

..

"
-
vw^ ^ ' ^ ’

^ •

t:>-
 aX. tcJixA^^a^ ^'o£jli
‘s.

CARLSBAD
AND

ITS THERMAL WATERS FOR ANGLO-INDIANS.

By Sir J. FAYRER, m.d., p.r.s.

y old friend,
M Surgeon-Colonel Harvey,
President of the Calcutta Congress, having re-
quested me to contribute a paper on the advantages of
a visit to Carlsbad by Anglo-Indians who are suffering
from the effects of climate and tropical disease, 1 have
much pleasure in complying with his request, know-
ing from personal experience and observation of the
results to many who have gone there on my recom-
mendation that great benefit is often conferred, not
only on those who have had to leave India on sick
furlough, but on others who have retired from the service
and still suffer from the consequences of prolonged
sojourn in a hot and malarial climate.
It has always appeared to me that this most valu-
able of health resorts is neither sufficiently known nor
appreciated, and that erroneous impressions as to the
depressing and debilitating effects of the waters and
diet exist which better knowledge would probably
remove.
Carlsbad, like other health resorts, is not suitable to
all complaints, but for a large number of chronic
functional disorders, to which old Indians especially
are liable, it is often of great and enduring value. I
2 CABLSBAD AND ITS THERMAL WATERS

should be glad, if I could induce those to whom I

believe it is so well adapted to try it either on their
way to England or later and I believe that if many
;

who have retired from the services would spend a

month or three weeks there every year for two or
three years they would probably derive lasting
benefit,

Carlsbad, which is easily approached by those re-

turning from India via Venice or Trieste, is situated
in the north-west of Bohemia, not far from the Saxon
and Bavarian frontiers. It is in 50° 13' N. latitude
and 12* 53' E. longitude. The town itself, which is
1,200 feet above the sea, lies in a valley through which
the Tepel, a bright trout stream, flows to join the
river Eger, their confluence being in close proximity
to the town, which is built on the banks of the river
and on the hills which rise in terraces on either side
in most picturesque forms, one, the Ewigleben, being
800 feet above the town. They are densely wooded
with magnificent pine, spruce, beech, birch and other
trees. Through these woods innumerable well-kept
paths and roads lead to fine points of view of the town
and neighbouring hills, the Erzgebirge and other
mountains, and of the ranges of forest country which
stretch away to the Bohmerwald. The Tepel and the
Eger are beautiful streams, with picturesque and in
some places rocky banks. In the woods the odour
of the pines is often very perceptible ; they afford
pleasant shade during the summer and enable visitors
to spend much of their time in the open air.

The weather is variable, the temperature at night

and the morning being subject to marked changes.
The mean temperature of the year is 43° F. of sum- ;

mer 66’5° F.; but in July and August there are days
of great heat as there are in many other places. In
the spring and autumn it is 47° F. in the winter
27° F. The prevailing winds are from the west
and north, the latter being cool and bracing in
summer.
 FOR ANGLO-INDIANS. 3

Tbe annual rainfall, according to a return kindly

supplied to me be Dr. Schuman Leclercq, a resident
physician at Carlsbad, is as follow^: —
January • • • 1’46 in. July 2-77 in.

February • • • 1-99 „ August 0*91 „

March * « • 1-26 „ September 2-05 „
April • • • 0-01 „ October 1-89 „
May • • • 3-89 „ November 2-51 „
June • • • 1 03 „ December 0-78 „

Total ... 20-55

The source of the mineral springs is in a vast reservoir

at a considerable depth below the surface. Great part
of the town is built upon the Sprudelstein, a hard
calcareous crust deposited by the water.
Carlsbad has always been remarkable for the purity
and salubrity of its atmosphere. No contagious epi-
demic has ever visited the town. In the Austro-
German war, when cholera prevailed in the surrounding
districts, Carlsbad was exempt.

The population of a very mixed character, espe-

is

cially in the season which extends from May to Septem-

ber, when it is visited by people from almost all parts
of the world. The waters are accessible at all times
of the year, but few people resort to them during the
winter months, when it is cold and dreary and the
ground covered with snow. A
considerable number
remain till November, but after that there are very few
visitors. The resident population is about 12,000,
the visitors about 30,000 annually.
The warm springs of Carlsbad, though apparently
unknown to the Romans, have long been famous for
their medicinal virtues. A legend says they were dis-
covered in the 14th century by the Emperor Charles
IV. during a hunting expedition. Whatever may be
the truth of this story, there is no doubt that the town
owes its name, and probably its existence, to that Sover-
eign, but it is only within the last century that they
4 CARLSBAD AND ITS THERMAL WATERS

have attained their present widespread reputation.

It would appear from the records of the place that at
one time they were drunk in inordinate quantities an —
abuse which probably laid the foundation of prejudices
which still exists, but are gradually disappearing as
more judicious use of the waters and the baths has
shown their efl&cacy in the treatment of numerous
forms of disease and functional disorder.
The hygienic condition of the town, on the whole,
are good, but a more complete system of drainage is on
the point of completion, which will leave little to be
desired from a sanitary point of view. Engineering
difficulties connected with the springs have hitherto
impeded the progress of this work, but these appear
to have been overcome and the desired object attained.
Meanwhile the low death-rate and absence of epidemic
disease points to a high state of salubrity.
The Carlsbad springs yield warm alkaline, saline
waters. They are clear and sparkling, free from any
disagreeable taste or smell and vary in temperature and
amount of free carbonic acid, and they all contain the
same solid constituents, the proportion varying in only
a very slight degree, and all come from one common
source emerging at no great distance from each other,
the differences in temperature and amount of car-
bonic, and depending on the depth from which they
come and the nature of the channel by which they reach
the surface. — —
They all the iSprudel especially deposit
a yellowish or dark brown crust consisting of calcare-
ous, siliciousearth with traces of iron. These are
kept in solution by the carbonic acid, which, being
parted with on coming to the surface, occasions the
deposit which has formed the crust before referred to
on which part of the town is built and which
colours the ground and rocks wherever surplus Sprudel
water flows.
There are numerous springs
in Carlsbad. Those
Sprudel, Muhlbrunu, Schloss-
chiefly in use are the
brunn, Marktbrunn and Felsenquelle. Around these
 —
FOR ANGLO INDIAXS. 5

numbers of patients congregate, the others are less

in request. To the differences which exist between
the springs, such as they are, the experienced
physicians of Carlsbad attach considerable importance,
as may be seen by the greater attendance at some than
at others.

The active constituents in these waters are sulphate

and carbonate of soda and chloride of sodium no ;

doubt the other salts contribute some share in deter-

mining their efl&cacy.
The following table, according to Dr. Kraus, gives
the temperature and chemical composition of the
springs :

Names and temperatures of the thermal springs now in

use at Carlsbad.
Sprudel ... • • • • 4 • 162° F.
Hygieaquelle • • • • • • 162°
Marktbrunn • • • 111°
Kaiser Karlsquelle * • « • • • 119°
Russische Krone • • • * • • 95°
Schlossbrunu • •• 129°
Muhlbrunn • • c 129°
Keubrunn • •• 141°
Theresienbrunn • • • 139°
Bernhardsbrunu • • • 150°
Elisabethquelle • • • • • • 109°
Felsenquelle • • • 140’
Kurhausquelle • • • * • • 149°
Kaiserbrunn • • • • 4 • 120°
Parkquelle • • • .*• 99°

Many analyses of the Carlsbad waters have been

made. They give an average of 41 to 42 grains of
solids in each pound of water. The differences in the
various analyses are so trifling as not tc require notice.
6 CARLSBAD AND ITS THERMAL WATERS

Solid constituents of three principal springs.

1- 1-
Sprudel. Muhl. Schloss.

2- 2-
Sulphate of Potash 2564 7172 1-4645
Sulphate of Soda 18 216 17-961 17 2453
Chloride of Sodium 7-9156 7-869 7-5282
Carbonate of Soda 10-4593 10-868 9-6620
Carbonate of Lime 2870 0236 3-0668
Carbonate of Magnesia 0-9532 0-2641 0-3870
Carbonate of Prntoxyd. Iron ... 0-0215 0-0230 0-0176
Carbonate of Protoxyd. Mangan, 0-0046 0-0053 0 0053
Carbonate of Strontia 0-0061 0-0069 0-0046
Phosphate of Aluminium 0 0030 0-0025 0-0023
Phosphate of Lime 0-0015 0-0016 0-0030
Fluoride of Potassium ... 0-0276 0-0268 0-0291
Silicious Earth ... 0-5590 0-6190 0-7365

Total of solid constituents 41-7090 41-3870 40-1523

f in grains 5-876 7-3260 10-2940

Free Carbonic Acid s
( in cub. in. 1-8820 14-8370 20 6260

Traces of lithia, boracic acid, iodide of sodium'

bromide of sodium.
One spring called the Eisenquelle differs entirely
in its constituents from the others, and
probably is
from a different source. It contains a small quantity
of iron, and is used as a chalybeate. Its temperature
is only 48’ all the year round. There are one or two
others, such as the Saverbrunn, which contain few
mineral constituents, but are largely impregnated with
carbonic acid gas they form pleasant drinking water.
;

Afavourite drinking water, which contains a quan-

tity of carbonic acid, and is much used in cases of
nric acid and gout, is brought from the Gieshubler-
Puchstein springs, a few miles distant from Carlsbad.
All the other springs lie within a radius of half a mile
from the centre of the town.
Bathing is an essential part of the treatment for
some complaints. The mineral baths consist chiefly
ol the Sprudel water, the temperature varying from
 FOR ANGLO-INDIANS. 7

90^ to 100°, to which the pine needle extract is some-

times added. The peat or mud bath is also frequently
used ; it is a thin, pulpy mass, made of peat which
comes from Franzensbad, mixed with Pprudel water,
and is used at a temperature of 90’ to 104°. Vapour
baths and douche baths are also much in use. I’he
iron water baths are supplied by the chalybeate
springs before mentioned. Acidulous batbsare supplied
by the Saverbrunn springs. The peat baths are much
in use in gouty and rheumatic swelling and exudations.
The therapeutic value of the Carlsbad waters depends
chiefly on the sulphate of soda, which has a gentle
purgative action. The carbonate of soda neutralises
acid, the chloride of sodium and other constituents
combined with carbonic acid, and in conferring on the
water its solvent powers and materially contribute to
the solution of various exudations and concretions
which may be forming or have formed. The general
effects are promotion of defaecation and diuresis, absorp-
tion of fat and modification of metabolism promoting a
favourable influence on the blood formation, improving
digestion and nutrition and the integrity of the func-
tions generally.
The waters, which are usually taken early in the
morning, sometimes also in the evening, in quantities
varying from 2 to 6 tumblers in the 24 hours, accord-
ing to circumstances, are agreeable to the taste. They
produce gentle action of the bowels with flatus strong-
ly tainted with sulphuretted hydrogen. The stools are
at first of a dark green or blackish appearance and con-
tain increased secretion of thick bile ;the dark colour
is partly due to the result of decomposition of the sul-
phate of soda and consequent formation, with the traces
of iron in the water, of sulphide of iron.
After a few days’ use of the water, the quantity of
urine is considerably increased and the acidity is di-
minished, but an alkaline reaction, Kraus says, is never
induced. Seegen shewed decrease in uric acid and
urea with a corresponding increase in phosphoric acid.
8 CAELSBAD AND ITS THERMAL WATERS

The mucous membrane soon shews more vitality,and

increased secretion consequently follows. The nervous
system is energetically influenced.
The good effects, though often manifested early, are
not so always, and the patient may leave Carlsbad ap-
parently no better than when he went there but im- ;

provement so frequently occurs later as a result of the

treatment that it would be unwise to pronounce un-
favourably on leaving the place.
It is not necessary in this brief notice to say more on
the general action of the waters. It is obvious from
the above how peculiarly they are indicated in many
functional disorders of tropical residents. Their salu-
tary effects are, of course, greatly enhanced by the
circumstances under which they are taken, such being
the change of air and surroundings, the perfect rest,
open air life, moderate exercise, the well-ordered dietary
mental relaxation, the absence of work and worry, the
mental attitude of a society whose chief aim and object
is to do all that is conducive to restoration of health.

1 do not venture to indicate the respective merits of

the different springs all
;
—
as before shewn — contain the
same constituents, yet they have difl’erent actions, and
therefore are respectively applicable to different cases.
Their special indication as well as the amount of exercise,
the nature of the diet, quantity of stimulant and dura-
tion of the stay at Carlsbad, can only be authoritatively
laid down by one or other of the able physicians on the
spot. The question of bathing, in addition to the inter-
nal use of the waters, must equally be determined by
local medical authority, and the nature of the baths,
whether simple Sprudel water, peat, vapour or douche,
will depend on the special symptoms in each case. The
same may be said of massage.
1 feel convinced that, rightly used, with due atten-
tion to diet, habits and mode of living, the Carlsbad
waters are capable of conferring great benefit, without
the depressing effects so often attributed to them,
but the cases for which they are appropriate must be
 FOR ANGLO-INDIANS. 9

carefully selected. Organic diseases of all kinds,

especially if in an advanced condition, should not as a
rule be sent there, though in the*earlier stages of some
so much improvement in the general health may re-
sult as to retard their development and ameliorate the
condition of the sufferer. But when the cases which
are not appropriate are excluded, a number still re-
mains for which the benefit will be great indeed.
The nature of the ailments for which the waters are
applicable has been clearly out by many
pointed
authorities, whilst the necessity for care in respect of
mode of life, diet and occupation, the importance of
travelling slowly, the need for repose and sojourn in
some bracing locality after the treatment, and delay
in return to work and to those causes by which the
original trouble was' induced, have been equally insist-
ed on, and I can only say that they apply as much
to invalids from India as from elsewhere. It remains
only briefly to notice the conditions for which Carlsbad
is likely to be useful to Anglo-Indians.

The waters are indicated in the following disorders :

In congestion and functional derangement of the liver,

in catarrhal jaundice, in gall stones or inspissated
bile and in chronic hepatic enlargement in which
serious structural change of the amyloid or other
degenerative process have not taken place. In chronic
engorgement of the portal system, in catarrhal con-
ditions of the mucous membrane of the intestines and
congestion of the hfemorrhoidal vessels also in habi- ;

tual constipation, incipient hfcmorrhoids and even

in the earlier stages of tropical diarrhcna. In diseases
of the spleen, such as chronic hypersemia and enlarge-
ment, resulting from malarial poisoning. In chronic
gastric catarrh in cardialgia or gastralgia, dyspepsia,
;

dilatation the
of stomach. In those forms of
albuminuria which take place as the result of abdominal
plethora and changes in the blood due to malarial
poisoning. In renal and vesical gravel in lithiasis ; ;

also in chronic catarrh of the bladder and in hypersemia

10 CABLSBAD AND ITS TH"ERMAL WATERS

condi-
of the prostate gland, and in some hypersemic
In gouty condi-
tions of the womb and its appendages.
tions, whether expressed in affections of the
abdominal
or other viscera ; in arthritic effusions and in thickening
of the tissues and sheaths of the tendons
surrounding
in excema, and in fact, in any of the other
the joints ;

in which the gouty diathesis manifests itself,

modes
also ingeneral abdominal plethora and in obesity,
whether of the abdomen or of the body generally.
In the earlier forms of diabetes there seems
little

authorities, that
doubt, from the testimony of eminent
benefit may be derived.
But Carlsbad is to be especially^ recommended to
India or other
those who, after protracted residence in
recurrences
malarial climate, suffer frcm occasional
derangement ot
of malarial fever, with consequent
function and even alteration in the
normal condition
of liver, spleen and other
abdominal viscera ; who?
are tailing
without suffering from any positive disease,
distended condition
in health, have impaired digestion,
fatty deposit in the
of the abdomen, increasing
degeneration ot the
turn and a tendency to fatty
themselves 1 an-
muscular system generally, who find
much physical or meiffal
guid and depressed, unequal to
anaemia, suffer
exertion, shew indications of incipient
or gouty pains,
from dyspnoea, from rheumatic
congestion of the portal
irregular action of the bowels,
vessels— a state
system and distended hsemorrhoidal
aggravated by excesses
of thino-s, perhaps in some cases
of diet, or the neglect of
due precau-
or irregularities
of alcoholic stimulants.
tions as to the quantity or kind
early recourse
Such are the conditions in which an
selection of some inter-
to Carlsbad and a judicious
to the ordinary
mediate health resort before returning
benefit. Indeed,
mode of life are likely to confer organic
almost every European not the subject of
years in Bidia would do
disease, who has spent many
resources of Carlsbad before
well to avail himself of the
life which lies before
he enters upon the new course of
 FOR ANGLO-INDIANS. 11

him, whether he be returning to India from furlough

or retiring to spend the remainder of his life at home.

It is almost needless, after what has been said, to add

that diseases of the brain or spinal cord, severe forma
of fever and suppurative processes, intestinal or pul-
monary growths and syphilis,
tuberculosis, malignant
diseases of the heart and blood vessels, haemorrhagic
diathesis, excessive menstruation, profuse hsemorrhoi-
dal flux and well-developed haemorrhoids, severe anae-
mia or cachexia and atrophy, cirrhosis or malignant
disease of the liver and ascites, Bright’s disease or
albuminuria depending upon renal disease, the ad-
vanced forms of diabetes and neurasthenia, will derive
no benefit.
I have not attempted in this brief sketch to point
out all the conditions that might be benefited by Carls-
bad, but have selected those in which it may be profit-
able to my countrymen in India. My object is simply
to call attention to it as a health resort which appears
to me to be very suitable for many of them, and to dis-
courage notions, which I fear still prevail, that risk of
excessive spoliation by the waters and depletion by
starvation is incurred, for neither of these results need
be apprehended, whilst the local advantages of climate,
scenery and healthful recreation are such as contribute
greatly to the therapeutic value of the mineral waters
and consequent restoration to health.
[From the Obituary Notices of the Proceedings op the Royal Society,
Vol. 55.] JSv-

Sir William Aitken was born at Dundee on April 23, 1825, and
received bis early education in the Higb School of that town. He
commenced the study of medicine under his father, a medical man
inDundee, and by attendance in the wards of the Dundee Royal
Infirmary. In November, 1842, he matriculated in the University of
Edinburgh, where, after attending lectures in the faculty of arts,
and having complied with the requirements of the medical curriculum,
he took the degree of Doctor of Medicine in 1848, his thesis on a
pathological subject on that occasion gaining for him a gold medal.
He also became a Licentiate of the Royal College of Surgeons of
Edinburgh in the same year. Thence he appears to have proceeded
to the University of Glasgow as Demonstrator of Anatomy under
Dr. Allen Thomson. This office he continued to fill in conjunction
with that of Pathologist to the Royal Infirmary of Glasgow up to
1855. Here he laid the foundation of that knowledge of disease
which procured for him the appointment as Pathologist to the
Hospitals of the Bosphorus, which were then filled by sufEerers
from the army in the Crimea. In association with the late Dr.
Lyon he published a report on the diseases of the Crimea, which
appeared in a Blue-book in 1856, and it is, and always will be, a
valuable work of reference in regard to the maladies which were
so fatal to the troops in that campaign.
On the foundation of the Army Medical School, which commenced
its existence in 1860 at Chatham (afterwards transferred to Netley),
and was an outcome of the experience of the Crimean War, Dr.
Aitken was made Professor of Pathology, an appointment for which
his early training and matured experience in the military hospitals
in the East peculiarly fitted him, and which his subsequent career at
Netley has abundantly justified. This duty he continued to perform
until April, 1892, when failing health compelled him to rest from
work. His final resignation of the chair had been fixed for the close
of the session in July, 1892 but renal disease, from which he had
;

for some time suffered, to the profound regret of his colleagues and
numerous friends, terminated his valuable life on June 25, 1892.
Of the value of Aitken’s work at the ikrmy Medical School, as well
as to medicine generally, it would be difficult to speak too highly. As
a teacher he was pre-eminently successful in his method of imparting
 —
XV

knowledge ;
was scientific and practical, his demonstra-
his reasoning
tions lucid and convincing, and he must be gratefully remembered by
hundreds of medical oflBcers who owe much of their knowledge of
disease, its causes and results, to his teaching.
—
A friend and colleague of Dr. .Aitken writes “In the post-mortem,
:

room he was facile princeps. I never saw any one to compare with
him at work of this kind. It was a lesson none could forget to see
him conduct a post-mortem and hear his exposition of what he saw.
He had great powers of work, and was a student in his own way all
his life. His book held the field for many years as a student’s text-
book.” And, again, “ He was scrupulously honest as a writer strove ;

always to give every man his due.”

Aitken’s services to medicine were not restricted to his work as a
teacher and examiner. He made many contributions of importance
to the literature of medicine, and to that branch
which he had of it
made peculiarly his own — pathology. Uphe continued
to the last
his labours, and at the time of his last illness was engaged in the
publication of a descriptive catalogue of the Museum of Pathology
now located at Netley. It is to be hoped that some competent
successor will undertake to carry on and complete the work thus
unfortunately interrupted.
It is sufficient to name the chief of his writings to indicate the
debt due to this great pathologist, and to show how earnestly he
laboured to contribute his share of knowledge to the common stock.
The following are the best known :

“ On Inflammatory Effusions into the Substance of the Lungs as

“
modified by Contagious Fevers,” 1849. (2) Contributions to
Pathology.” (3) “ On the Pathology of the Diseases of the Troops in
the East during the Russian War, 1855-56,” in conjunction with
Dr. R. D. Lyons. (4) “ On the Diseases of the Troops in the East
during the Russian War, and on the Climate of Scutari, on the
Bosphorus,” 1857. (5) “Medical History of War with Russia,”
1857. (6)
“ On
the Persistent and Pernicious Influence of the
Residence in Bulgaria on the Subsequent Health of the British
Troops in the Crimea.” (7) “ On conducting Post-mortem Examina-
tions at Coroners’ Inquests,” 1857. 10) “ On the Pathological
(8, 9,
Connexions and Relations of Epidemic Diseases in Man and the
Lower Animals, with special reference to the relationship between
the health of man and the condition of his food,” 1857. (11) “ Ana-
lytical Review of the Transactions of the Medico-Chirurgical Society
of London, vol. xii,” 1859. (12) “ Critical and Analytical Review of
Recent Works on the Pathology of Vaccination, and its Protective
Influence from Small-pox,” 1857. (13) “Analytical and Critical
Review of Decenniura
the First of the Pathological Society of
London,” 1858. (14) “ Handbook of the Science and Practice of
 !

x\n

“
Medicine,” 1858 [this has reached its seventh edition], (15) On
the Growth of the Recruit and the Young Soldier ” [now in its
second edition]. (16) “ On the Doctrine of Evolution in its Applica-
tion to Pathology,” 1885-86. (17) “ On the Animal Alkaloids.”
Aitken was a man of somewhat reserved and reticent speech, but
what he said was pregnant with science and common-sense. He was
of a most kindly, genial nature, loyal to his profession, devoted to
his friends, and just to all. His pei’sonal character endeared him to
every one. His frank, straightforward mode of expressing his
opinions, tempered as they were by sound judgment and discretion,
made him respected and esteemed, and contributed, in no s ma ll
measure, to the formation of the reputation of one of that small but
remarkable group of men to whom the great Army Medical School
owes its rise, development, and success. Regretted universally by
friends and colleagues, it is in the great School of Military Medicine,
which owes him so much, that his loss will be most keenly felt.
His merits have not escaped some recognition. He was made a
Fellow of the Royal Society in 1873. In 1887 he received the honour
of knighthood. The Universities of Edinburgh and Glasgow, in
1888, conferred on him the degree of LL.D., whilst on the walls of
the ante-room at Netley is an excellent portrait presented by his
numerous friends, admirers, and pupils.
May his memory long continue to influence coming generations of
medical officers in the School he loved so well
J. F.

UAEEISON AND SONS, PEINTBBS IN OEDINAET TO HEE MAJESTY, ST. MAETIN’s LANE.
 AVe are indebted to Sir Joseph Fayrer, a life-Iohg friend
of
Professor Huxley, for the following note on his life
character:
and
“It was with profound grief that I heard of the death
of
my old and much respected friend, T. H. Huxley. The loss
of the foremost biologist of this or any other country
will be
universally deplored, for he has for many years had a
pre-
dominant influence on the progress of biological science and
the expansion of scientific teaching which was not
surpassed
by even that of his friends, Darwin and Tyndall, and has con-
tributed beyond all others to the advancement of
natural
knowledge and the promotion of the scientific methods
of
investigation of the problems of life. To this end, indeed,
the whole strength of his surpassing intellect was
stead-
fastly, through good and evil report, devoted, and
the results
have been recorded in language so incisive and convincing
as to leave on all who have followed his teaching the
impres-
sion of incontrovertible truth, and the conviction that
in this
department of knowledge he was maestro di color die sanno. I
have always felt it to be a great privilege to have known him
so well during early life. The friendship and affection
in
which I held him never diminished, though after his de-
parture m 1846 I had no opportunity of seeing him again
until my return from India in 1872, when I had the gratlfica-
tion of finding that on his part the feeling was unchanged,
whilst on mine it was enhanced by the admiration with which
I regarded his great natural powers and the
unwearying
labour in scientific research which had raised him to the
pre-
eminent position he has since occupied.
“We were fellow students from 1844 until he joined the
fiiavy in 1846, and it was during that time
that I learnt to
recognise his great intellectual power and the keen interest
be took m the physiological lessons of Wharton Jones and
other teachers. It was not surprising that he took honours
at the London University, and it was with a feeling of
confi-
dence that I looked forward to a distinguished career for him
when he departed with Captain Owen Stanley in the Rattle-
snake on his scientific mission.
entered the naval service I have always felt proud
to think was due to my persuasion, for after
consultation one
day I urged him to apply to the Director-General of the Navy.
He did so, and the result was an appointment to Haslar, and
subsequently to the Rattlesnake. Doubtless had he selected
any oth^_ career the result would have been the same, but as
some of his earliest contributions to science arose out of the
expedition to the South Seas, one cannot but regard that as
haying in some degree determined the course and direction
of his future work.
,
inculcate veracity of thought and action, to subordi-
nate to It reasonable or unreasonable ambition for
scientific
fame, to develop and organise true scientific
education, and
to combat whatever might oppose it, were
his aspirations,
and that by which he hoped to be remembered by posterity,
io quote his own words : I should not count these things as
‘

marks of success if I could not hope that I had somewhat

„
movement of opinion which [has been called
the New Reformation.’
But he will be remembered not only as a great original
thinker, investigator, and promoter of biological science,
but
as a man of the highest principle and unswerving
devotion to
truth, a genial and charming friend, a keen
but courteous
controycrsialist, and one who illuminated all he
said or did
with the brightness of a remarkable personality, and
a good-
ness of heart that endeared him to all who knew
him and
now lament his loss.”
 ^Mtiisq %'lkxm,
Delivered at the termination of the Seventieth Session of the
Army Medical School, Netley,

By SuRGEON-GmERAL SIR yOSEPH PAYRER,

K.C.S.I., M.D., F.R.S., Q.H.P.,
HONORARY PHY’SICIAN TO THE PRINCE OF WALES LATE PRESIDENT OF
;

THE MEDICAL BOARD, INDIA OFFICE.

It is rather more than twenty years since my official

relations with the Army Medical School at Netley began, and
this is not the first time I have had the honour of addressing
the surgeons on probation on an occasion similar to that for
which we are now assembled, for I find that on April 1st,
1875, I addressed them at the opening of the school, and on
Feb, 3rd, 1879, I had the privilege of presiding at the dis-
tribution of prizes. During the intervening period of twenty
years I have had the opportunity of watching the progress
of the school, have done so with great interest, and
have noted with much satisfaction the gradually increasing
good influence it has exerted on the medical department
and through them the medical services generally. It is
a subject for congratulation that the school continues
to prosper, despite the vicissitudes and changes it has under-
gone its very existence even has been menaced, but happily
;

it has survived these dangers and has so well maintained its

prestige and asserted its utility that we may hope that (the
need for its existence being so well established) any future
changes will be only such as tend to the expansion of the
teaching of those subjects especially relating to the duties of
the military medical officer which were originally contemplated
when it was founded, and which can nowhere be so well
taught as they are here. Deeply interested in the service
in which my life has been passed, and knowing by experience
how valuable is the character of the education and training
imparted here, I have always wished to see the teaching of
 2

this school extended over a longer period of time and its

sphere of utility enlarged, and have hoped that in process of
time its benefits might be made available for other medical
men destined for a public career in the sanitary and civil
medical services of the country, including the colonial, as
well as for the officers of the Army and Indian Medical
Department. I am much impressed with the belief that such
a modification in tlie present system would be of gi-eat benefit
alike to the Service and the individual medical officers, for,
however perfect may be the scheme of education in the
great civil medical schools and universities, however highly
specialised may be the teaching of certain subjects in any
one of them, that combination of special subjects peculiarly
needed in the public medical services, especially in the Army
and India together with instruction in military and adminis-
—
trative questions to say nothing of the advantages of esprit
de corps acquired by association in a great school before
—
entering the actual service can never be imparted or acquired
as thoroughly elsewhere as it can here. In my humble
opinion, the time now allotted for residence at Netley, con-
sidering the varied and special nature of the cmriculum, is
hardly sufficient, and I do not hesitate, therefore, to say that
I trust the period of study for probationers may ultimately
be extended. Officers having this longer training and
special education would be even better qualified than they
are at present to meet all emergencies and to caiTy out
the scientific investigations so imperatively demanded in
these days, when great problems of etiology as well as of
preventive medicine are exciting so much interest and are
straining to the utmost the resources of practical scientific
research for their elucidation. In this respect this great
school is peculiarly well endowed and admirably equipped for
the means of such teaching, and the teachers are alike forth-
coming more time only is required to do full justice to both.
;

And here I would, through you, urge on your successors the

supreme importance of diligent use of the period of probation
here. The time is so short, the subjects are so important,
that without close and unremitting work and attention the
necessary standard may not be attained and disastrous failure
result. This in my experience of Netley is rare, but it does
occasionally happen, and I would urge you to impress on
your friends and successors the importance of bearing it in
mind.
When I last addressed the young officers (1879) wlio had
just gained their commissions, 1 exf>ressed my hope and
 3

belief that better prospects were foreshadowed and might be

anticipated for the Medical Services Times had been, and
indeed still were, unfavourable, a feeling of disquietude and
unrest prevailed, and there was a sense of general dissatis-
faction with the existing condition of things. That there
was reason for this I think cannot be doubted, nor can I say
it is altogether extinct now but I ventured then to suggest
;

that possibly the difficulties did not all arise from outside,
and that to a certain extent, perhaps, the obstacles might be
found within the Service itself, and that, if it were so, it
behoved the medical officers to see to it that such internal
causes should be removed. I reminded the young officers that
the social and educational influences of a great institution like
Netley are calculated to foster and develop (amongst other
things) that esprit de corps which so greatly conduces to
real stability in any department of the public services.
I pointed out also that the position of the military and
Indian medical officer offers such advantages as ought to
command a supply of the elite of our Universities and medical
schools. All this I repeat to-day ; and I am glad to think
that as time advances there has been, on the whole, a favour-
able change. Many men of high culture are competing for
the appointments, but indications are even now not wanting
of a doubting confidence, for I am told that the competition
is less keen than it has been still, the general tone and
;

feeling in regard to the Services have improved. Unfavour-

able conditions have been mitigated if not removed the
;

importance of the medical officer’s work is more appreciated

and his true place in the great military organisation better
understood, and, as a consequence, more authority is attached
to his opinion and more weight to the importance of his
duties, which are concerned with not merely sickness and
wounds,^ but the well-being and .sanitary condition of those
under his care. Until a few years ago the military status of
the medical officer was insufficiently defined. It is true he
held what was called “relative” or “comparative” rank,
but this, however, served but imperfectly to endue him with
that authority which is essential to his position as an
important and indispen.sable officer of the Ai-my. It had long
been felt that liis status required more exact definition, but
there were always certain obstacles to this which stood in the
way. It was argued, I believe, that however necessary the
medical officer might be— and that he is so was not disputed
—
or denied, at all events by reasonable persons yet that
substantive military rank could not appropriately be conferred
 4

upon him. This view, it would seem, could only have arisen
from a misconception of the true nature of a commission.
The idea that the title of Lieutenant, Captain, Major, or
Colonel could only he held by that particular branch of the
Service whose duty it is to direct the combative energies of
the soldier was surely a mistaken one, for it is in the power
of the Sovereign to confer such distinction on anyone, and it
is conferred on officers of the military service who have no
immediate connexion with mere combatant action, as is
amply demonstrated by the fact that the officers who control
the Commissariat, the Army Service Corps, nay, even the
band master, now can and do, hold substantive commissions
in one or other of those ranks. If it be considered necessary
and possible that these officers should be so commissioned, it
is difficult to understand why the same advantages should
have been withheld from the medical officers, who, being so
closely connected with all that concerns the health, disci-
pline, the well-being and effective condition generally of the
Army, need such warrant for their authority as much as do
those of any other department. The concessions that have
been made doubtless conduce to the interests of the Service by
placing the medical officer in a more assm’ed position and by
defining more clearly the substantive rank and authority which
he holds, though I must confess one has difficulty in appreciat-
ing the advantage of such a cumbrous title as that of
“Brigade-Surgeon-Lieutenant-Colonel.” Time, however,
will probably modify such complex designations. Invidious
distinctions implied in the terms “combatant” and “ non-
combatant ” can have but little real significance in these
days, when the records of almost every action fought or
position defended show how equally risks are shared by the
medical and the other officers, whilst the number of Victoria
Crosses worn by them is a curious comment on the use of the
term “ non-combatant ” (with its present meaning) as applied
to the medical officer. But let me repeat what I said on a
former occasion, which is that your military rank gives you
no title, nor does it call upon you in ordinary cases to assume
the place or duties of the combatant officer, and I hope I
need not even hint at the impropriety and bad taste of
assuming any position to which your own, as members of a
learned profession, should make you indifferent, for, what-
ever your military rank 7uay be, you are first of all meilical
men. Still, withal, you are soldiers, and it may happen, as it
often has done, that you have in an emergency to take the
place of your combatant brethren. Should it fall to your lot
 —

to do so you will be prepared to show that you are as ready

for this as for any other duty. Two brilliant examples are
even now before you in the cases of Surgeon-Major Robertson,
who as a political officer contributed to the defence of
Chitral, and of Surgeon-Captain Whitchurch, who risked his
own life and fought his way through the enemy, carrying and
protecting his mortally wounded comrade. Both these
officers have recently received recognition of their services.
If you confine yourselves, therefore, to your own distinct
sphere of duty, which is ample and sufficient, the benefit of
your influence will be appreciated ;
if you overstep it you
will be in a false position ;
your efforts for good will be
minimised and your counsels neglected if not ignored.
Remember also that though your status in the Service is
— —
now as it should be assured by your military rank, so
much of your influence for good depends upon personal
character that you should endeavour to maintain that at the
highest standard.
Gentlemen, let me now congratulate you upon the success-
ful termination of your career at Netley, and upon having
—
achieved the great object of your ambition your commissions
and especially I would congratulate those of
in the Service;

you who have obtained prizes bearing the names of Sidney

Herbert, Edmund Parkes, Ronald Martin, and De Chaumont
names that will be honoured and respected wherever they are
mentioned and medical science is appreciated. They have
conferred lustre on the Service generally and upon this
school in particular. They deserve well of their country,
and they may rightly be held up to you and other
young men as models for imitation. Let these prizes
be an inducement to you to endeavour to follow in the steps
— —
long and laborious they may have been which led to their
great distinction, and which will lead you too, perhaps, if
you follow in them, to a similar pre-eminence. These prizes
should also be an incentive to you to endeavour to maintain
and increase the prestige which they now reflect upon
you, whilst at the same time they should serve to remind you
of the efforts by which that success was obtained and the
obligation imposed upon you of continuing to merit it. To
— —
those of you and it is of necessity the majority who have
not been equally successful I would say that you have won
one great prize in securing your commission there are still
;

others to be won in the career before you, and many advan-

tages to be gained, if you will only work perseveringly and
seize the opportunities when they present themselves. Both
 6

India and the army offer many paths to eminence India —

—
especially does so and to one or other of these goals you
will surely attain, if having determined to do so at the outset
you earnestly persevere. It has been said that the public
services offer little inducement to exertion;
that they present,
after all, but a somewhat dull level of monotonous equality ;

and that talent, energy, zeal, and special devotion to one or

other of the branches of science are but of litttle avail and
—
lead to nothing. This is not the case least of all is it so in
India, where many and varied appointments are attainable
and await the earnest worker. They are, at least, filled
at the present moment by medical officers, and though
in this respect, perhaps, India is not so fertile as it may
have been in past times, it still offers opportunities of pro-
fessional and scientific advancement which are excelled by
those of no Service in the world. I am afraid I may not hold
out to you such prospects of honours and distinctions as fall
to the lot of some other departments of the public service, but
even in this respect there are signs of improvement, and it is
possible that in the future such recognitions as are accorded to
military, political, and civil officers of long and distinguished
service may fall to your lot likewise. But, after all, when
you adopted the profession of medicine as a career you did
not contemplate such rewards as the chief object of your
ambition. It was rather, I take it, the exercise of a noble
profession, the advance of knowledge, the welfare of your
fellow-creatures, and the satisfaction of feeling that you aim
at the almost god-like power of relieving suffering, saving
life, and promoting the sanitary, moral, and material welfare
of your fellow subjects that influenced you, and to this you
may in a measure certainly attain. Great wealth you will
perhaps not acquire, but a competency you may certainly
rely on — sufficient, at any rate to relieve you from those
carking cares and pecuniary anxieties which so often retard
the pursuit of knowledge and the progress of the individual.
In most cases you may rightly look forward to being able to
provide for your families and, under favourable circumstances,
even to acquire a certain amount of wealth. You will, at all
events, be able to lead useful and honoured lives, whilst
you will acquire “ troops of friends,” and it may well be that
from among you shall arise another Parkes, Falconer, Waring,
Hooker, Longmore, Maclean, Aitkin, De Chaumout, or David
Smith, or perhaps even a worthy successor to the great
biologist and philosopher who has so recently gone to his
—
rest for Huxley and the men I have mentioned, to whom
 7

might be added many others, at least began their lives and

laid the foundations of future eminence in one or other of the
medical services.
On the last occasion upon which I had the privilege of
presiding at a meeting of this kind I had but recently become
officially connected with this scliool as a member of the
Senate. The duties were most congenial to me, for I had
always taken much interest in the education and training of
medical officers. The anticipations that I then formed in
reference to the objects and results of this great school have
been fully justified ; and I now, having ceased to occupy
that official position, look back with great pleasure upon the
years that have passed in connexion with it, and the regret that
I feel on the closing of my official connexion with the school is
tempered by the knowledge that my successor, Surgeon-Colonel
Hooper, will strive to guard and promote your interests with
all the zeal, earnestness, and ability which characterised him
in India, and have led him to the position he now occupies.
1 have watched with keen interest the career of your prede-
cessors on these benches, .and have been gratified to learn
how thoroughly many of them have done credit to the
teaching they have received here whilst I deeply regret that
;

this almost general rule has not been without exception. The
severance of my official relation with the school in no way
diminishes the interest I take in it and I look forward with
;

pleasure to the privilege of being present on such occasions

as these, and of still watching its progress and the influence
that it will, I hope, continue to exert in elevating the Medical
Department and maintaining it in the position it should take
amongst the other great public services of this country.
It only remains for me now to impress briefly upon you the
importance of the duties that you will be called upon to
perform. To those of you who are destined for the military
service of this country will be entrusted the care of the
health of our soldiers at home and abroad. Upon you it will
devolve to advise the authorities upon all sanitary questions
and whatever concerns the physical well-being of the army
under your care. In the event of war—and who can say how
long we may remain at peace ? — the treatment of the sick
and wounded will be your special care. To you, also, it will
fall to investigatethe laws that govern the origin and diffu-
sion of epidemic and other forms of disease, and all that
concerns the soldier’s health. Already, through the influence
of your predecessors, the death-rate of our soldiers in India
lias been reduced within the last fifty years from something
 8

like sixty to thirteen per mille, and no doubt this mortality

issusceptible of further diminution, whilst side by side with
the reduced death-rate will continue an amelioration of the
conditions of life generally. Nor will your duties be limited
to those of a purely military medical character, for there are
some special spheres of action and appointments open to
those who may aspire to them. To those of you who are
destined for the Indian Medical Service similar but even
wider prospects are open, for there your duties will be
of a still more varied character. Problems concerning
disease, the laws regulating the rise and spread of
—
cholera, fever, and other epidemics their pathology, etio-
—
logy, and therapeutics still need and claim further investi-
gation and research. Or, apart from medicine and
hygiene, the whole range of natural science, involving
zoology, botany, meteorology, and ethnology, afford matter
for investigation and fields for research which are yet com-
paratively unexplored. Your education and scientific train-
ing fit you to take up and deal with these subjects, and I
would suggest to you the advantage of doing so i.e., of —
having some other occupation than that which is concerned
with medicine alone. You have thus before you, to whatever
Service you belong, the prospect of an interesting, useful, and
profitable career. The measure of your success will be that of
your own exertions. If you exercise the ordinary precautions
for preserving health you may have every reason to hope
—
that you will pass through it successfully and, I trust,
—
satisfactorily and may return to this countiy in health and
vigour and with large experience with the prospect of doing
—
useful work at home it may be in this great school. I will
not detain you longer than to say that in bidding you fare-
well I wish you every prosperity and success, and trust that
your highest aspirations may be realised.

PKINTED AT THE LANCET OFFICE, 423, STRAND. W.C.

. 1
 Reprinted for the Author from the Beitish Medical Journal,
August 29th, 1896.

ON FALMOUTH AS A WINTER RESORT.

Presented to
THE SECTION OF MEDICINE.
At the Annual Meeting of of the British Medical Association in
Carlisle, July, 1896.

By Sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I., M.D., F.R.S.,

Honorary Physician to Her Majesty the Queen and to H.R.H.
the Prince of Wales.

A SEVERE and prolonged attack of bronchitis having, in the

opinion of my medical advisers, rendered it necessary that I
should leave London during the winter months of 1895-96,
and being anxious to avoid foreign travel and residence, I
decided to try whether what I wanted could not be found
nearer home, and accordingly, on the recommendation of Sir
E. Sieyeking, selected Falmouth as a winter residence where
one might hope to escape the raw damp cold and fogs of
London, and at the same time perhaps find immunity from
the sudden and violent alternations of temperature which are
so dangerous and trying to those who have suffered from, or
become liable to, bronchitic affections. The result has been
so satisfactory, that I feel it is a duty to record my experience
and call attention to a health resort which is perhaps too
little known, but which, if appreciated as it deserves to be,
might prove of great benefit to many who would gladly avail
themselves of the opportunity of obtaining the required
change, and of avoiding ajourney for which they are physically
unfitted, and residence in a foreign country for which they
have no inclination.
The chief desideratum in a climate, for those who find it
expedient to seek change in the winter, is that it should be
equable, sheltered from prevailing winds, and sunshiny, a
combination not always to be obtained, at all events within a
reasonable distance by land or sea. The south of France and
the Riviera are much sought after, but though the climate
IS genial and bright with sunshine, and the scenery
charm-
ing, the daily range of temperature is often considerable,
and the risks of chill are great, whilst the mistral and bise
are very tiying.
It seems hardly to be known that the conditions so
essen-
tial to the invalid exist in our islands and yet it is so, for the
;

cpast of Cornwall presents them in

Why this ignorance should prevail is harda marked degree.
to understand,
seeing that since 1816, when Dr. Paris called attention to it.
 2

the peculiar advantages of this part of England have been

most clearly pointed out by Clarke, Sieveking, and latterly
by Dickinson,^ who, in a most able and interesting paper, has
described the climatic conditions of Cornwall. But, as in the
case of many other health resorts, the very fact of being so
near home would seem to be an objection like the
;

prophets, they have no honour in their own country, and

waters and climate are sought for in Germany, the Riviera,
etc., at the cost of much trouble and considerable incon-
venience, which could be found equally well in the neglected
health resorts of our own islands.
It is especially to one of these that I now wish to draw
attention, and, as I speak from personal experience, others, I
hope, may be induced to seek and to find similar advantages
to those I derived from a winter spent in Falmouth though ;

my remarks are limited at present to Falmouth, I believe

they apply almost equally to other parts of the southern as-
pect of Cornwall.
I am glad to find that the claims and advantages of our
own health resorts are now engaging the attention of the
medical profession, and if a result be to direct public
opinion in their favour it would be a great benefit alike to
invalids and health resorts.
The county of Cornwall is a promontory, including the
most westerly as also the most southerly portion of the main-
land the northern shore is washed by the Atlantic Ocean,
;

the southern by the English Channel. It is about 8i miles

in length, about 40 miles wide at the base, diminishing to
about 20, the average breadth, and again towards the Land’s
End becoming much less. The south coast is about 100 miles
from France, the north coast about 2,000 miles from ISTorth
America. It has thus the advantage of an insular climate,
which is further modified by the influence of the Gulf Stream,
which raises the temperature of the water on both sides to a
higher degree than that of the eastern shores of England. A
range of hills and high ground runs through its entire length,
forming a ridge or plateau of an average height of 600 feet,
descending sometimes to 300 feet towards the Land’s End.
This shelters the southern coast line.
The mildness of the climate of Cornwall is due not onl,y to
its southerly but also to its westerly situation, owing to the
course of the isothermal lines. The presence of the Gulf
Stream tends also to increase the rainfall, which is undoubt-
edly high compared with that of other parts of England, these
physical conditions tending, as in the case of insular
climates, to produce mildness and equability not found in
other parts of England.
Falmouth is in lat. 50° 9' N., long. 5° 4' W., and is situated
on an arm of the sea which indents the south coast, forming
one of the finest harbours in the world, which, with St.
Mawes, Truro, and other creeks occupies an area of about
10 square miles, with a coast line of 71 miles, 58 of which are
occupied by cliffs. Many portions of this great harbour are
protected by elevations rising several hundred feet. The
town of Falmouth lies on the north-western shores of this
harbour in a crescentic form, rising in tei’races on the hill
behind, whilst that portion which is known as Gillingvase,
extending on to the headland of Pendennis, has a southern
1 Climates and Baths oj Great Britain, being Uie Report of a (Committee of
the Royal Medical and Cliirurgical Society of Loudon.
 3

aspect. The whole coast line is exceedingly beautiful, espe-

cially the headland upon which Pendennis Castle is built,
and which forms a most charming drive, returning through
the town to Penryn at one extremity of the harbour on the
;

opposite side, round the point of Trefusis, the so-called Fal

river extends to the town of Truro, affording most picturesque
scenery. On the other side of the harbour are St. Just and
the town and castle of St. Mawes, with its creek, terminating
ultimately at St. Anthony’s Point and lighthouse, which with
Pendennis Point facing it forms an entrance of about a mile
in width to this magnificent and well-sheltered harbour.
The neighbourhood of Falmouth offers most varied and
interesting scenery, undulating and elevated ground, with
lovely country seats and richly cultivated gardens. In all of
these sheltered places, especially on the southern slopes of
the peninsula, trees grow luxuriantly in the valleys, but on
the higher, more exposed, and wind-swept portions the trees
are stunted and gnarled, their growth evidently being re-
pressed by the prevailing south-westerly winds. Along the
—
south coast sandy beaches alternate with cliffs beaches
upon which an infinite variety of shells are washed up by
the sea, and which are composed almost entirely of the
detritus of shells.
The equability and mildness of the climate are remark-
ably illustrated by the numbers of exotic, and even sub-
tropical plants which thrive many of them fio wering even in the
, ,

winter. The myrtle, fuchsia, hydrangea, escalonea, dracaena

chamaerops, citron, azalia, agave, bamboo flourish, whilst
the rhododendrons andcamellias flower throughout the whole
winter in the open air. Many other plants also which would
only thrive under shelter in other parts of England live in
the open throughout the whole year, whilst the gardens
supply vegetables such as broccoli, peas, asparagus, etc., much
earlier than any of those of other parts of the United
Kingdom.
With all these attributes of climate and scenery, it seems
remarkable that greater advantage should not have been
taken of Falmouth and other parts of Cornwall, but it is to
be hoped that the testimony borne by those who have bene-
fited by them will gradually induce others to avail
themselves of them as winter resorts, especially when it is
an object to avoid a long and weary journey, and foreign resi-
dence far from home and friends. But it may be well to say
here that with all its natural advantages, Falmouth has done
but little yet to encourage visitors to winter there, for
although it possesses some most excellent accommodation in
a few hotels and boarding houses, this is sufficient to pro-
vide only for a limited number. It has scope for much accom-
modation, especially along the southern coast, whilst the
addition of certain attractions such as are found in other
watering places, and certain alterations and improvements of
the town facing the harbour would offer further inducements
to visitors. There can be little doubt were public opinion but
given an impetus in this direction, and were Falmouth pre-
pared to accommodate more visitors, its merits would soon
receive general recognition.
The advantages of Falmouth are not merely those of a
winter resort, for whilst it is more equable in winter than any
other place in England, or even than the south of France, so
in summer the mean temperature is lower than it is in many
4
5
 6

Winter

the

for

Observatory

Falmouth

at
 other health resorts in England, the range in all these places
being much greater than it is in Falmouth. The mean aver-
age differenee of day and night temperature for the last three
winters was 8.6°, and, as Sir E. Sieveking has pointed out in
the British Medical Journal of December 14th, 1889, “To
those who wish to escape from the summer heat of other
localities, and to those who wish for an equable temperature
during the winter months, Falmouth offers attractions not
readily found elsewhere.” It is often urged that, admitting
its mildness and equability, the climate of Falmouth is
necessarily relaxing and enervating, but from my personal ex-
perience, which extends through the winter months, this is not
the case as compared with other places on the south coast.
With regard to moisture generally, the very conditions that
induce the mildness, that is, the proximity of the Gulf Stream
and the condensation resulting from the raised backbone of the
peninsula, naturally produce a greater rainfall, but the rain
when it does fall rarely continues for long, and the greater
part of most days is fine, while the water runs off or is
quickly absorbed by the porous and gravelly soil. As to
mists, those that occurred during my stay there were rare
and were sea mists. On no occasion did snow fall during
that winter, only twice was there hoar frost on the ground in
the early morning, whilst on only four occasions did the
thermometer fall below the freezing point. I am well aware
that this winter was a peculiarly mild one all over Great
Britain, but the relative equability claimed for the climate
of Falmouth will be shown by reference to the statistics of
other years of which two are given on the preceding page.
As an illustration of this continuous mildness of the
climate throughout the winter, I may say that with few
exceptions I was able to spend the greater part of the day out
at sea in an open sailing boat. Strong breezes, even
amounting to gales of wind, were not infrequent, but they
were rarely ever so severe as to prevent my going out, whilst
three or four miles from the shore it was quite perceptible
that not only was the sea water warmer than the air, but that
the air itself was warmer than that on shore. Throughout
the whole of this time, notwithstanding frequent exposure to
strong winds and to wetting by sea water, my health steadily
— —
improved, and by the time I left early in April traces of
bronchitis had almost entirely disappeared.
Walking down to the boat in the morning, passing
gardens in which rhododendrons and camellias were bloom-
ing in the depth of winter, one forgot that one was still in
England, and it was a subject of congratulation to find that
such conditions existed in our own islands.
Amidst all these advantages it must be admitted that the
east wind, when it did blow, was not exempt from the evils
which generally characterise it, but even these seemed to be
somewhat tempered, and, though unpleasant enough, making
it sometimes desirable that an invalid should remain in
the
house, it was by no means the prevalent wind, as will be seen
from the preceding tables, which I owe to the kindness of Mr.
Kitto, the director of the Observatory, and which also indi-
cate the chief climatic conditions which prove the fitness of
lalmouth for a winter residence.
he noted that in the winter of 1894-95, cold year,
uie lowest point attained by the thermometer was 21.8° in
J? ebruary and the mean minimum in February, the coldest
,
 8
month, was 30.8°, and the mean maximum 38.6°; while
in
1895-96, a mild winter, the lowest temperature reached
was
30.2 in January, and the mean minimum in January,
the
coldest month, was 41.1°, and the mean maximum 48.5°.
th® winter of 1894-95 the east wind blew for five
days in
November, 3 in December, 6 in January, 13 in February, and
3 in March while in 1895-96 it blew i day in November, in
;

December, 2 in January, 5 in February, and not at all3 in

March, the prevalent wind being south-west.
On the basis of 10 years’ records, Falmouth is found to be
considerably favoured in the matter of sunshine, standing
second only to Jersey of all stations of the British Islands
where records are kept.
A comparison of the mean temperature of the winter months
with Cannes, Mentone, Montpelier, Nice, Pau,
j
and Madeira, shows that it compares not unfavourably with
those Continental resorts.

November. December. January. February. March.

Falmouth 47 8 -
°
44 3
°
44 1
° °
4 S'i°
' -

Penzance ° 44 7
-

47.26° 45 17 45.21° 45.20° 45- 32°

-

Soilly “
49 8 - 46.7° 46-3° 46.9° 46.4°
Cannes S2.6° 46.3° 48.0° 48.8° °
Montpellier ° ° 57 0
-

... SO' 7 45 7
- 42.1° 44.8° 48-9°
Mentone 54 - 0° 49.1° 48.7° 49.1° 52-8°
Nice 53 8
°
- 48.5° 47.1° 46.2° °
Pau 51 8
-

47.0° 42.8° 41.2° °

Madeira 43 6
- 48.8°
64.96° 62.58° 61.89° 64.0°
62.70°
1

On the whole, I think it will be found that Falmouth

merits the preference assigned by all who know it, whilst
the
many advantages arising from proximity to the sea, the
beautiful and interesting surroundings, the mild and
genial
atmosphere, bright sunshine, lovely flowers and vegetation,
which suggest the geniality of spring in the midst of winter,
all combine to confer on it qualites such
as are rarely met
with, and are not the less valuable that they are
easy of ac-
cess and near home.
I- heaitily commend Falmouth to
those who seek a winter
residence, and only hope it may prove as satisfactory
to them
as it did to me and mine. If the contribution of my
personal experience to that of others who have realised its
benefits could induce its kindly, hospitable, and genial in-
nabitants to add to what they have already done for this
charming place, by making certain alterations and improve-
ments and by adding to the accommodation, which, however
excellent, is all too limited, I feel sure that not only would
the interesting old town and suburbs be benefited, but a last-
ing boon would be conferred on numbers of invalids and
delicate persons who_ would gratefully avail themselves of
a health resort which in all respects equals, if it does not sur-
pass, many of those now frequented abroad.
 We are indebted to Sir Joseph Fayrer, Bart., for the follow-
ing tribute to Mr. Pollock’s memory :

“It was with most profound I'egret that I heard of the death
of my dear and much valued friend and colleague, George D.
Pollock. I had seen him a few days previously, when, though
he made no complaint about his health, I was struck with
the marked change in his appearance still I little thought I
;

was not to see him again.

“The medical profession has recently sustained severe
losses by death, but none will produce a greater blank in the
roll of distinguished men than that of the great surgeon and
thorough English gentleman now so much deplored.
“ Mr. Pollock’s life will no doubt be written in detail by
someone who has known even better than I the great merits
which throughout a long career have placed him in the front
rank of his profession, and gained for him the confidence,
esteem, and affectionate regard in which he has been so uni-
versally and deservedly held.
“ But I, who have known him intimately for the last twenty-
four years, have been closely associated with him in public
duties, and have received many kindnesses at his hands, had
learned to regard him as the best and truest of friends and
the wisest of counsellors, and to know that every action of
his life was influenced by the highest and noblest principles.
I cannot, therefore, refrain from a brief expression of the
esteem in which I held his noble personal character, his pre-
eminence as a surgeon, his high sense of the importance of
his duties, the unremitting zeal, ability, and care with which
he performed them, and, above all, the loyal and affectionate
nature which endeared him to the friends who will ever hold
him in loving remembrance.
“ In offering this last tribute of respect I know I'shall have
the sympathy of many of my brother offieers in the Services
with which he was intimately associated, and in whicn he was
much interested, not only as an examiner, but by family con-
nection.
“The name of Pollock has been borne by many distin-
guished men, including the great Field Marshal, his father,
but by none has it been more usefully and honourably repre-
sented than by him who, though now taken from us in the
fulness of age, we had hoped might have continued his useful
•career for some years to come.”
“Jfwtos tile bonis flebitis occidit."
 ADDRESS
TO

Prize Winners of Municipal Schools of

Science and Technology, and Art,

DELIVERlil) BY

SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, BaRT.,

K.C.S.I., M.D., F.R.S.,

IN

THE DOME, BRIGHTON

On the 14th April, 1898.

^riglxtoii
THE SOUTHERN PUBLISHING COMPANY, LIMITED.
130, North Street.—85,809
 ADDRE55
TO PRIZE WINNERS OF MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS OF
SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, AND ART,
IIEUVEUEP IIV

Sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.l. and F.R.S.

IN

THE IDOIVCE, E R,XC3-HT03Sr.

On the I4th April, 1898.

For several reasons it was witli veiy great pleasure that

I accepted the invitation of the Chief Magistrate and Coi-
poration of Brighton —conveyed to me through my old
friend; Aldennan Sir Ewart —
J. to be present on the in-
teresting occasion of this Meeting of the Municipal Schof^l
of Science and Technology and School of Art for the purpose
of j)resenting prizes to the students who were successful
during the year 1897.

(1), My first reason is that I liave had old associations with

Brighton, which I have always liked ; (2), two olf my sops
commenced their education in one of those excellent schools

for which Brighton ha.s always been so remarkable; (.‘1), I

was closely associated with Sir Joseph Ewart in India,, where

1 had the opportunity of seeing liow thoioughly well lie
 4

carried out the important duties entrusted to him,, and was

giad to see that the same activity, enei’gy, and intellectual
power had been devoted to the good of Brighton since he
Wisely made that chai-ming health resort his home.

My first duty is to make my cordial aclaiowledgments for

the honour conferred on me, to offer at the same time my
warm congratulations on the successful inauguration of this
important centre of intellectual activity and education and to
express a sincere hope that the objects contemplated may
in the future be fulfilled in the realization of the far-reaching
benefits which it is calculated to confer, and of which it.s

present condition justifies hopeful anticipation.

So far as I have been able to learn from public report, as

well as from personal observation, the Brighton Municip.il
School of Science and Technology is entitled to take a hick
place among numerous other Institutions of the same kind
which have been established in different parts of England,
as the outcome of the Technical Instruction Acts of
1889
and 1891, which contemplate not only scientific, teclmical,
«ind commercial, but also the higher education of the youth
of our country ;
and it is no small satisfaction to note that
whilst technical instruction is mainly contemplated, the
preliminary culture implied in general education is
also to
a certain extent required as a condition of admission
to tlie
technical classes, which classes studeaits cannot
attend imtil
after the age of 14 to 16 years, and also tliat
opportunilv
is given— nay encouraged— of pursuing general culture and
education to the highest point, even to that of obtaining
a
L'niversity degree.
 I observe with further satisfaction that the curriculum of
tills important School includes in its extensive programme
four main departments., namely (1 ), Mechanical Engineering
and Applied Mathematics ; (2), Physics and Electrical
Engineering ; (3), Chemistry, General, Technical, and Com-
mercial ;
(i). Natural Science, and in addition lectures on
such subjects as Modern and Classical Languages, Domestic
Science (for women), and Commercial Subjects.

Besides this extensive curriculum there are University

courses by means of which the student may pursue his
studies until he attain the standard which fits liim for matri-

culation, the intermediate examination in Science, and the

Preliminary Scientific (M.B.), or for degrees in Arts or
Science in the London Univer.sity. In any case it is enacted
that the advanced technical subjects shall not be undertaken
until the student gives evidence that he has been prepared,
by preliminary culture, to study them with advantage. In
short, till he shall have learnt how to learn. To this end
there is a Preparatory Division in which junior students
may be grounded in Arithmeticy Algebra, Geometry,
Trigonometry, ilensuration. Drawing, English Composition,
etc., to cnatde rhem to ])roceed in those subjects for which
they seem intellectually most fitted.

Further 1 note that with the object of extending the

utility of this Institution evening classes are provided during
the winter for those who may be debarred by circumstances
from availing themselves of the more systematic regular in-

struction of tire day classes, in which the' curriculum is much

the same as that of the day classes, but with a larger
 c.

deveiupmeiit of :ipplied scionce, ai’t, and trade .subjects, to

meet the wants of tliose wlin wish tf» supplement the prac-
tical side of their daily occupation by a scientific knowledge
of the theory on wliich it is based. The programme, how-
ever, is so wide and varied, that to all over 14 years of a^e,
Avhose time, means, and opportunities are limited, the oc-
casion is offered of improving' their general education and
of acquiring knowledge of such subjects as n ay be specially

useful in their particular walk of life. I am glad to find

that already about 600 of both sexes evince their apprecia-
tion of the opportunities thus offered In’' availing them-

selves of these most comprehensive evening classes.

All this had, up to September, 1897, to a certain extent

been carried on by means of (1), The Art and Science
School, now constituted a School of Art alone : (2), by
Technical Classes held in temporaiy premises ;
(3), by
S cience and xCrt Clas.ses in the Grammar School : but you
owe it to the munificence and wisdom of the Municipality

that the subjects thus formerly taught in a scattered form

are now' gathered together in one centre and constitute part
of the general curriculum of the new Municipal School of

Science and Technology of llrighton, and it is to tliis that I

would pariicularly call attention as a new departure in the

treneral scheme of national education which offers so much

jjromise. 'fhe teaching must of necessity be better con-
ducted in this large building specially adaiited and fitted for
the purpose, w’ith its numerous clas.s-room.s and laboratories,

an efiicient staff of teachers, and all the special apparatus

required for the various subjects taught than it could have

l)oen under the former regime. In its new capacity, and

 fresh .adaptation to the purposes for
which it is in-
with its

tended, it is to be hoped that it will obt.ain the support and

svmpathy it so eminently deserv^es.

L.adies .and gentlemen,an Institution so constituted, it

conducted according to the sound principles advocated
and
—
the promises held out as there is good reason to believe
is

the case in these Technical Colleges founded under the

Acts quoted —must confer an indescribable boon on the

rising generation, and there is reason to feel assmed that

the diffusion of education resulting from them is

gradually

manifesting itself in the general elevation of the social con-

dition and life of the nation to a higher plane.

Competition is keen among the nations of Europe, and if

Great Britain is to maintain the predominant position to

V hich we fondly think she is entitled, we cannot afford to

lether drop behind in the race for knowledge. Therefore

these Technical .and Scientific Schools with their concomitant

means of general education may be hailed not as rivals

or opponents of our ancient and historical Schools and

Uni-

versities, but .as - natural and welcome complements and

coadjutors, and we think that they are calculated to aid,

not impede, each other in the great national work of educa-

tion., whilst it may well be that the stimulus
of friendly

rivalry will contribute to the progress and welf.are of all.

NiOthing is more remarkable in the present ,age^ than the

progress made in general educ.ation, .and nothing is more

calcul.ated to increase the happiness and prosperity of the
nation. Among many subjects for the congratulation
 8

offered to our beloved

Queen on the completion of the 60th
year of her happy and auspicious reign, few could have
been more gratifying to her than the assurance of the
general spread of education among her people, which was
such as to give stability to her rule, and increase the
happi-
ness and prosperity of her subjects and let it be remem-
j

bered that the general diffusion of knowledge not

only
tends to advance the moral and intellectual status,
but
that it is impj-oving the physical health and the
value and
duration of life of the population, for
teaching the im-
it is

portance of observing those rules of living on which

physical
and consequently moral health depend.

My own professional instincts move me to note with in-

teiest that H}’giene forms a part of the curriculum, and
(hat from this as from many other centres will go forth the
teaching of the simple but iuqTOrtant rules on
which public
health depends.

The Rev. J. Hocking remarks, “ Three-fom-ths

of the sick-
ness and ailments and Aveaknesses of the world are
wastes
and burdens—wastes and burdens to the sufferers,
wastes
and burdens to society, and Avastes and burdens that need
not be.”* myself said some years ago, and the words hold
I

good noAv as they did then, “ If the people eould be

taught
to believe in the efficacy of pure air, pure
water, cleanly
dwellings, temperate habits, proper food and clothing,
and
could be induced to make efforts to secure them ; and if
they could be taught to regard infective diseases as
the
scourge of uncleanliness and of their own disregard of
the
simple laws of health ....
the result would be, not
• .Alodern ri'oltleins and Christian Ethics.
 9

only greater usefulness and happiness, but better health

nnd the saving of money. Preventible diseases, the result

of insanitary conditions, still kill many thousands yearly —

at least one hundred and foity thousand ;
and, considering

the large number of cases of illness for each death, it has

been calculated that seventy-eight million five hundred

thousand days of labour are lost in this country annually,
which represents a loss in money of seven million seven

himdred and seventy-five thousand pounds per year.”

It is to be hoped that the knowledge which will be diffused

among the people by such Institutions as this will gradually
tend to mitigate such conditions as I have just described,
and to obviate this wasteful e'xpenditure of health and life,

Sind that in so doing it will promote not only the moral,, but
the physical welfare of the people.

Let me now congratulate you, the prize winners, on your

success, but let me advise you to regard your prizes not so
much as proofs that you are better than your less successful

competitors, but .rather as incentives to further diligent

pursuit of the \\ ork you have begun so well, ittmember

that many (jualities go to make up a really good man, and
that, after all,, most of those are not susceptible of being
tested by a school examination. Prizes, however, as in-

dications of successful work, perseverance, and greater

capacity tliau that of others for assimilating knowledge are
most valuable and honourable distinctions, and will be

specially so if thej^ increase your interest in your studies

and stimulate your energy in future work.
 10

To those who have tried for but not won prizes^ I wonh'l
pay, be not discouraged ;
your next efforts will probably be
more successful, and, at any rate, the real prize is the know-
ledge you are attaining and will continue to attain, if you
persevere. The possibilities at your age are gi*eat. Study,
perseverance, and determination are sure in the end to pro-
duce their natural result, success.

Let me congratulate you all on having such a complete

store-house of knowledge to You cannot now,
resort to.
perhaps,, realize the advantages you possess, but I and many
others far younger than I am, are very sensible of them, and
can remember the time when no .such opportunities as you
have were available. Yet even in those times, by per-
severance and diligent pursuit, considerable knowledge
could be acquired, and it is well to remember that some of
our greatest men of science and men of action Avere mainlv
self-taught.

Michael Faraday, for example, a bookseller’s apprentice

at the age of 13, at the the age of 21 was Professor

Humphiy Da.Ay’s assistant in the Eoyal Institution, and at

the age of 32 was Fullerian Piofessor at the Iloyal Institu-
tion. lie had no Technical School to train him for this Im-
portant scientific post. His published memoirs on experi-
mental researches in Electricity and Magnetism, on Chemis-
try .and Physics, on Forces of Matter, on Metals, and on
many other Scientific Subjects, placed him in the foremost
r.ank of men of Science. It is probable that he would, could
he speak now, be the first to advocate the importance of
such an Institution as you possess. One might mention
 11

men who by their ener-y and perseverance

many other creat
hardly less
in self-cultivation have attained to positions

important.

me refer to some
But in further illustration of this let
in 1858, when he was
remarks made by Charles Dickeais
Association of Lanca-
o-ivinp:the prizes at the Institutional
Manchester. After certain depre-
sliire^and Cheshire, in
comments upon Literaiy Societies and Mechanics
ciatory
he led to express his admiration and
Institutes in general, is

which he was then con-

approval of the Institution with
over
cenied. He says, for example, that having looked
which comprise all the
some of the examination papers,
of knowledge,, he felt devoutly
].eys that open all the locks
to him to
that they had not been submitted
gr.atefiil
“ And yet it
answer as he certainly could not have done
it.

is to be observed and seriously

remembered that those ex-
lives had been
aminations were undergone by people whose
passed in a continual fight for bread and
whose whole exis-

tence had been a constant wrestle with

‘
Those' twin gaolers of the daring heart.
Low birth and iron fortune.’

not by
‘•That the questions, in fact, had been replied to,
life was -with
persons like himself, the business of whose
of whose life
writing and with liooks, but men the business
was vdth tools and machinery.” He then goes on to illus-

“ There
trate this by describing some of the prize-winners.
not read at eighteen,
isa piecer at mule-frames, who could
in which
who is now Arithmetic teacher in the Institution
 12

he himself was taught, who writes of himself that he made

the resolution never to take up a subject without keeping
to it, and who has kept to it with such an astounding will
that he is now well-versed in Euclid and Algebra, and is

the best French, scholar at Stockport.” Among the dele-

gates from the local Societies there was a man “ who worked
vhen he was a. mere l)aby at a haed-loom ;
who began to
teach himself as soon as he could earn 5s. a week; who is

now a botanist acquainted with every production of the

Lancashire valley ;
who is a naturahst, and has made and
preserved a collectio>n of the eggs of British birds and
stuffed the birds ;
who is now a conchologist. with a veiy
curious and in some respects an original collection of fresh-
water shells, and has also preseiwed and collected the mosses
of fresh water and of the sea ; who is worthily the Presi-
dent of his own local Literary Institution, and who was at
work this time last night as foreman in a mill.”

With what 1 have quoted to j'ou from this great writer

I am sure you will all agree, and you will feel what grati-

fication it would afford him and others of his way of think-

ing had they had the opportunity of witnessing the forma-

tion of such Institutions as your own, Institutions which are

the outcome ol the necessities of the age and the demand for

knowledge that is inherent in the people. You will see the

bearing of it upon yourselves, but of course the illustrations

of the struggling labourer or the jDOor mechanic developing

into a teacher and a man of Science are of partial applica-

tion only to .an Institution of this kind, but they emphasize

the principle that success will depend rather upon your own
personal exertions than ujion your environment, though
 13

these personal exei’tions, when aided by such

means as are here placed at the disposal

of the student, must render the accomplishment

of his purpose more certain and complete. To a large

number of you probably the course of education in this

school will be like that in other public schools,, and your

special attributes and fitnasses will be directed in the line
of the least resistance, whilst at the same time it 'will be
satisfactory to all to feel that its benefits are not limited

to any one class, but that it extends the advantages of its

culture to all who are ready and willing to receive them.

There is, however,, some danger — let us hope you may avoid
it —that the veiy ease with which you can attain this know-

ledge, thus, as it were,, brought to your feet, may prove an

obstacle by diminishing your efforts. Accept what I and
so many othei-s of a former generation can tell you are your
great advantages thankfully, and avail yourselves of them
fully. So train yourselves —^whatever walk in life you may
adopt and for which you may be prepared here —that you
may inspire all with whom you come in contact with confi-

dence in your own capability and respect for these great

Technical In.stitutions.

I think I ought not to detain you longer. It only re-

mains for me to wi.sh you much success in your future

studies and in the walk of life to which they may lead you,
and to hope that you will in the future look back with
gratitude and pride to the Alma Mater which did — as will
assuredly be the case if you avail yourselves of her teaching

-—so much for you and equipped you with means of main-
taining — I trust with success— ^the struggle for existence,
 14

which is daily becoming harder in this great, ever-increas-

ing population, whether at home or in our Colonies, to whose

greatness and development it may fall to the lot of some of
you to contribute.
 / y*

', f

Js'.. -

] A - .V ^ "•^y
'-'J!^^^'-

?> ,1.' j -' •- <i •. -.v^^'- v. • <>

. ? ^ '

-
•
••'
W' -
^
*1 \'
''

!^Co: ; .
>
.-
' • 1

ww*-
/
 .

Dbputy-Surgeon-Gehekal S. B. partridge,
C.I.E., Q.H.S.
Bengal Medical Service (retired).
On May nth, In the presence of relatives, brother officers,
and friends, the mortal remains of Samuel Bowen Partridge
were laid to rest in the cemetery at Norwood.
This distinguished medical officer was born at Cardiff in
1828 and was educated at King’s College, London, where he
had a most brilliant career, during which he gained many
prizes. After passing the Royal College of Surgeons he
entered the East India Company’s service on the Bengal es-
tablishment as an assistant surgeon in the year 1852. Shortly
after his arrival in India he was ordered to Burmah to join
the Bengal Field Force, and after performing excellent service
in a variety of ways, on his return to Bengal he served as
civil surgeon and also with a cavalry regiment. On the out-
break of the mutiny in 1857 he served with a cavalry regiment
in Oude, and when the siege of the Residency of Lucknow
commenced he served throughout the whole of that eventful
period in Dr. Fayrer’s house in the garrison, where his energy,
activity, and professional knowledge were of the greatest
benefit. He was present with the expedition under Colonel
Burmester, in which several officers were killed, and he also
accompanied the ill-fated expedition to Chinhut, where he
had a narrow escape of losing his life. Subsequently he dis-
tinguished himself as field-surgeon in the operations under
the Commander-in-Chief at the recapture of Lucknow. For
these services he received the brevet promotion of surgeon,
was allowed to count a year’s service, and received the thanks
of Government In general orders.
The state of his health after all these exceptional services
rendered it necessary for him to return to England. After a
short stay, during which he became a Fellow of the Royal
College of Surgeons, he resumed his duties :n India, and was
then appointed to the Medical College of Calcutta, in which
he had on a former occasion officiated for a short time, as
Professor of Anatomy and Surgeon of the Medical College
Hospital. He was also an Examiner in the University of
Calcutta, a member of the Senate, and for a short time
President of the Medical Faculty of the University. Subse-
quently, on the retirement of Dr. Fayrer, he succeeded to his
appointment as First Surgeon and Professor of Surgery in
the Medici College Hospital, which appointment he con-
tinued to hold with the greatest distinction. In addition he
had an extensive practice in Calcutta until 1880, when he
retired from the service.
After his return to England Deputy Surgeon-General Part-
ridge was appointed member of the India Medical Board at
the India Office, where he rendered most valuable service,
until loss of sight made his resignation of that appointment
necessary, to the deep regret of his colleagues and friends.
The news of his death will be received in India, as it has
been in this country, with the greatest sorrow. He was held
in the highest esteem by everyone who knew him ; no
man was ever more deservedly loved and respected than he
was. His intellectual powers were great, and he was as much
characterised by the breadth as by tlie accuracy of his know-
ledge most laborious in his studies, most persevering in
;

pursuing to the end any object which he had undertaken;

with the profoundest mathematical problem as with the
simplest piece of mechanics he was equally at home. As an
anatomist he was unrivalled in the clearness of his
demonstrations as a surgeon he was remarkable not only
;
for his skill as an operator but for his great powers of
diagnosis'
nor was he less remarkable for his capacity for dealing
with
disease in its tropical and other forms, whilst his firm,
gentle
and patient method of treatment inspired all who came under
his care with confidence and affection. Notwithstanding
his
great attainments and his remarkable intellectual
power, he
was as humble as a child. The simplicity of his character
was not less marked than its strength. He
was naturally
beloved by all his brother officers, associates, and pupils, and
in fact by everyone who knew him. Whilst so
gentle and
tender in every way, a rock was not firmer than he where
firmness was required. Not even Bayard himself, or Outram
(with whom he was justly compared) better deserved the
title
of “Chevalier sans peur et sans reproche.”
On Deputy Surgeon-General Partridge’s retirement from
the India Ofiice the Government signified their approval
of
his services by creating him a Companion of the
Indian
Bmpir^ He had previously been made an Honorary Surgeon
to the Queen, and had also received a medal and
clasp for
Burmah, and a medal and clasp for the siege and for the
recapture of Lucknow.
_______ J- F.

British Medical Joiarnal.

f l4- f
[FroHi the Obituary Notices of the Proceedings of the Royal Society,
Vol. 63.]

Richard Quain, wlio died on March 13, 1898, at the age of 81, was
born on October 30, 1816, at Mallow-on-the-Blackwater, co. Cork, in
which county his family was one of the best known and most
respected. His father, John Quain, was a younger brother of
Richard Quain, of Ratheahy, whose sons, Jones and Richard, were
distinguished for their knowledge of anatomy and surgery, and John
Richard as a lawyer and judge in the Court of Queen’s Bench. The
father of the subject of this notice married, in 1815, Mary, daughter
of Michael Burke, of Mallow, a member of an ancient and honoured
Irish family.
After early education at Cloyne, Richard Quain was apprenticed to
a medical practitioner in Limerick, where he acquired a knowledge of
many of the essentials of medical practice. In 1837 he entered the
University College of London, where his two cousins were, the one
Demonstrator, the other Professor of Descriptive and Practical
Anatomy, from whom he seems to have received much sympathy and
valuable instruction. In this School of Medicine he studied with
much diligence, and his perseverance and keen powers of observation
obtained for him many distinctions.
In 1840 he graduated as M.B. of the University of London, obtain-
ing high honours in physiology, surgery, and midwifery. He con-
tinued to gain much experience in the appointments of Resident
Surgeon or Physician at the hospital, and in 1842 he obtained the
degree of M.D. at the Loudon University, receiving a gold medal and
certificate of special proficiency. He was soon afterwards elected a
Fellow of University College.
 ^U

1848 be became Assistant Physician to tbe Hospital for Disenses

111

of tlie Cbest, at Brompton, wbere he was associated with Drs. Walsh,

Theophilus Thompson, and Cotton. In 1855 he was elected
Physician to this hospital, and his connection with it as a Consulting
Physician continued till the time of his death. He was also Con-
sulting Physician to the Seaman’s Hospital at Greenwich, and to the
Consumption Hospital at Ventnor.
In 1851 Quain was elected a Fellow of the Koyal College of
Physicians, and was identified with it till the time of his death for
;

he was a member of the Council, Censor, Lumleian Lecturer, Senior

Censor in 1877, Harveian Orator in 1886, and Vice-President in
1889. In 1888, on Sir William Tenner’s retirement, he contested
the Presidency with Sir Andrew Clark, who, however, was elected,
though only by eight votes, in a large meeting.
In 1863 Quain was elected as Crown nominee of the Medical
Council, and continued in that post till his death. He was a moving
spbit in all the work of that body he was a member of many com-
;

mittees, serving with great distinction on the Pharmacopoeia Com-

mittee, which he seemed to make his special care, though most active
on several others. The services he rendered to this Council in the
various offices he held were most valuable, and the result was his
appointment, on the death of Mr. John Marshall in 1891, to the post
of President, to which he was unanimously re-elected on the expiry
of his first term of office in 1896, when he gave a valuable address,
clearly setting forth the questions in which the Council wmre in-
terested and his own practical and statesman-like view of the
methods of dealing with them. His predecessors in this important
office were Sir Benjamin Brodie, Joseph Henry Green, Sir George

Burrows, Sir George Edward Paget, Sir Henry Acland, and John
Marshall, none of them more devoted to the duties or more efficient
as President of the Council than himself.
Sir Richard Quain’s literary work and his researches into various
departments of medical science were, if not numerotis, very important.
As a member of the Royal Commission appointed in 1865 to con-
sider the question of rinderpest or cattle plague, in which he was
associated with Lord Spencer, Lord Cranborne (now Marquess of
Salisbury), Lord Sherbrook, Dr. Lyon (now Lord) Playfair, Dr.
Edmund Parkes, and Dr. Bence Jones, he took a prominent part,
and was an earnest advocate of the stamping-out measures recom-
mended by the Commission, which, though strongly opposed at the
time, subsequent events have proved to have had the result of saving
large sums of money to the nation. He w'as a frequent contributor
to the ‘
Saturday Review,’ to the ‘
Lancet,’ and other medical
”
journals ;
whilst his treatise on “ Fatty Degeneration of the Heart
in the ‘
Transactions of the Medical and Chirurgical Society ’
for
 vm
1850, expanded into a more elaborate article in bis Dictionary of ‘

Medicine some years later.

’
His reports in conjunction with the
staff of the Brompton Hospital, compiled for several years, of the
cases treated ther-e some valuable contributions to the Lancet of
;
‘ ’

1845 on Bright’s disease, and to the Edinburgh Monthly Journal of

‘

Medicine on “ Injuries of the Valves of the Heart,” together with

’

his Lumleian Lectures given before the College of Physicians in 1872

on “Diseases of the Muscular Walls of the Heart” were, and are
still, regai’ded as authoritative writings.
But the great work with which Quain’s name will ever be asso-
ciated is that of the ‘ on which the years
Dictionary of Medicine,’
between 1875 and 1882 were spent, and which reappeared in a second
edition in 1894, enlarged and brought up to the knowledge of the
present time. For this cyclopaedia of medical science he had care-
fully selected the contributors from the most eminent members of
the medical profession, whose communications were all revised and,
in some cases, modified by himself. His own contributions, espe-
cially those on “ Patty Degeneration of the Heart,” “ Angina
Pectoris,” “ Aneurism of the Heart,” “ Diseases of the Bronchial
Glands and General Remarks on Disease ” are not the least valuable.
The work, in short, having filled a want long felt by the profession,
gained their entire confidence. To his able coadjutors. Dr. Frederick
Roberts, Dr. Mitchell Bruce, and Mr. John Harold he gave due
credit, and to their untiring devotion to the work its success is in

great part — as he himself would have acknowledged — to be attri-

buted.
Not the least interesting of Quain’s contributions to medical litei’a-
ture was his Harveian Oration, delivered before the Royal College of
Physicians in 1885, in which he dealt eloquently with the healing art
in its historic and prophetic aspects.
In 1871 Dr. Quain was, for his eminence as a physician, and for
scientific researchinto subjects connected with medicine, elected a
Fellow of the Royal Society. He was also a member of the Senate
of London University elected by the Queen, LL.D. of Edinburgh,
M.D. (Hon.) of Dublin and of the Royal University of Ireland, and
also a Fellow (Hon.) of the Royal College of Physicians of Ireland.
He was Fellow and President of both the Medical and Chirurgical
and the Pathological Societies, to the Transactions of which he
‘ ’

made several valuable contributions, and member and President of

the Harveian Society of London.
In 1890 he was appointed Physician Extraordinary to the Queen;
and on New Year’s Day, 1891, received the well-merited honour of a
baronetcy of the United Kingdom. This becomes extinct with his
death, as Sir Richard Quain leaves no son. Isabella Agnes, Lady
Quain, to whom he was married in 1854, was the only daughter of
 IX

Mr. George Wray, of Cleasby, Yorkshire; she died, to his profound

grief, a few months after the baronetcy had been conferred upon
him. Four daughters survive him.
Sir Richard Quain was much and justly esteemed by his profession
and by the public. The kind-heartedness and geniality of his nature,
his amusing and epigrammatic conversation, his wide knowledge of
men, and his unwearying sympathy and kindness, made him popular
not only with the younger as well as the older members of his pro-
fession, but with society generally, and in the Athenseum and Garrick
Clubs, of which he was a well known member, whilst the bright and
cheering effect of his presence in the sick room was always beneficial.
Few men have been more endowed with the faculty of endearing
themselves to their acquaintances, friends, and patients and few ;

will be more regretted than the warm-hearted, genial Irishman and

physician who has been taken from us, though not until advanced
age had afforded the world full opportunity of appreciating his merits.
J. F.

IIaubison and Sons, Printers in Ordinary to Her Majesty, St. Martin’s lane.
 ;

[Excerpt from Vol. XIX., Part III., of The .louriial of

Tlie Sanitary Institute.]

ox:

INAUGURAL ADDRESS,
By Sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I., LL.D.Edin.
& St. And., M.D.Edin., F.R.C.P.Eng., Q.H.P., F.R.S.

(Fellow.)

Delivered September ^7th, 1898.

My first duty on taking the chair is to acknowledge the honour

conferred on me in selecting me as President of this Congress
and my next to offer a cordial welcome to all who propose
to take part in its proceedings, and to express a hope that
they may not only derive pleasure and profit from them, but
at the same time confer benefit upon the cause they advocate.
It is also my duty to convey the thanks of the Congress
to the Right Honble. the Lord Mayor and Corporation for
the hospitality and courtesy which has been extended to it in
the important city of Birmingham, a great and populous centre
of activity, to which the problems to be considered in the forth-
coming conferences must be of deep and abiding interest.
It is not without misgiving that I have asAnned the office
entrusted to me, for when I think of those who have been my
predecessors, I Ael painfully conscious of my inaptitude for
the post that they have filled so well. I must confess, more-
over, that I found some difficulty in selecting a topic suitable
for an inaugural address, but can only hope that my short-
comings may be redeemed by the proceedings of the various
sections into which the Congress is divided.
I shall not attempt to deal with any special branch of
338 INAUGUKAL ADDRESS.

preventive medicine or hygiene, but sliall endeavour to take

a brief general survey of progress during recent times. It
should be a retrospect full of interest, offering scope for
many addresses on special brandies of sanitary science such,—
indeed, as I hope will characterise the coming Conference.
We live in an age of progress and discovery. Intellectual
activity has never been greater, scientific reseai'ch never more
profound or far-reaching, whilst the practical applications of
the discoveries of science are not less remai’kable. Among
many subjects of interest which were laid before our gracious
Queen on the completion of the sixtieth year of her glorious
reign, few perhaps if any afford better ground for con-
gratulation than the improvement in the vital statistics of her
people, as shewn by reduced death-rate, enhanced expectation
of life, decline in some of the most potential death-causes, and
the almost total disappearance of others.
In effecting this improvement, the Institute which I have the
honour to represent and which holds its 17th Annual Congress
this year has taken an important part. It Avas the outcome of
the impulse given to sanitary science by the Public Health Act
of 1875, which itself was a result of the growing conviction
that public health was a subject which demanded more con-
sideration than it had hitherto received.
At a public meeting held in London in July, 1876, presided
over by His Grace the Duke of Northumberland, it was resolved
that the sanitary condition of the country is still very unsatis-
factory, that further legislation is necessary with a view to its
improvement, and that for the purpose of collecting and im-
parting information upon all matters connected with the subject
of ‘‘Public Health,” a society be formed to be styled “The
Sanitary Institute of Great Britain,” and a committee was
a[)pointed to give effect to the terms of the resolution. Since
then the progress of the Institute thus founded has been un-
interrupted, and its influence for good has steadily increased.
In the same year, 1876, the Parkes Museum wais founded at
University College as a memorial to Dr. E. A. Parkes, first
Professor of Hygiene at Netley, and in its galleries were ex-
hibited various hygienic appliances for the purpose of affording
information by the objective method of teaching. Its Council
originated and managed the International and Sanitary Exhi-
bition at South Kensington in 1881, Avhich Avas presided over
by the Duke of Edinburgh. It Avas in 1882 incorporated as a.
society', its treasures Avere transferred to the present premises in
Margaret Street, Avhcre it Avas joined by the Sanitary Institute,
and the tAvo institutions having a common object ivorked har-
moniously together and practically became one. In August,
 —
sill JOSEPH PAYEEIl. 339

1888, they were formally amalgamated and re-incorporated

under the title of The Sanitary Institute. In 1887, just before
the amalgamation took place, the Institute, in conjunction with
the Society of Medical Officers of Health, invited the Inter-
national Congress of Hygiene and Demography to meet in
London, which it did in 1891 with great success.
The object which the Institute has kept steadily before it
from the outset has been the advancement of sanitary science
by the promulgation of sound scientific and practical teaching
of those principles on which health depends, by which life is
prolonged, and the physical and thereby the moral welfare of
the people promoted.
One of its earliest steps, taken in 1877, was to establish
examinations for Local Surveyors and Inspectors of Nuisances,
in order that the officers who had to carry out the provisions of
the Public Health Act should be competent for their duties.
The Council also arranged to hold an Annual Congress in
some provincial town, in order that papers should be read and
discussions take place, whilst, at the same time exhibitions of
sanitary appliances were arranged as object lessons, and judges
appointed to examine the exhibits and award prizes. Since
the amalgamation with the Parkes Museum the same work has
been continued, with the addition of periodical meetings, at
which papers are read and discussed, the publication of trans-
actions, and advanced examinations while to aid the important
;

teaching work it was canying on, it collected and published

the works of Farr and of Simon, which deal exclusively with
the problems of sanitary science. It has gradually accumulated
an excellent library, and instituted lectures and practical sani-
tary demonstrations for the benefit of medical men and of
sanitary inspectors, which subsequently were considerably ex-
tended and more elaborately organized. Under the patronage
of the Duchess of Albany and the Presidency of the Dukes of
Northumberland and Westminster, and latterly of the Duke of
—
Cambridge who had already been connected with the Institute
for fourteen years, and had not only displayed great interest
in its work, but had rendered it valuable assistance, and under
the guidance of such men as Sir Douglas Galton, Earl Fortescue,
Sir Francis Powell, Mr. Rogers Field, Prof. Corfield, and
others who had been its early supporters and founders, it
steadily developed its purpose of diffusing practical sanitary
knowledge throughout the country and attained its present
influential position.
An idea may be gained of the scope of the operations of the
Institute by reference to the epitome of the work done in 1897,
which was as follows ;
340 INAUGUItAI; ADDRESS.

London Lectures and Examinations. Total

Attendance.
4 Sessional Meetings for discussion of Sanitary Subjects 285
36 Lectures to Sanitary Officers ... ... ... 2,251
2 Special Demonstrations, Inspection of Meat ... 140
34 Practical Demonstrations for Sanitary Officers ... 925
2 Examinations in Practical Sanitary Science ... 34
2 Examinations Sanitary Inspectors ... ... ... 213
38 Classes brought to the Museum ... ... ... 1,674
Other persons visiting the Museum (estimated) ... 17,500

Provincial Examinations.
8 Examinations Sanitary Inspectors and Practical
Sanitary Science ... ... ... ... ... 316
Congress and Exhibition at Leeds.
6 Sectional Meetings ... ... ... ... ... 706
8 Conferences ... ... ... ... ... ... 850
3 Addresses and Lectures ... ... ... ... 956
Exhibition open for 23 days, at which a number of
Lectures and Demonstrations were given ... 75,790

All this is effected entirely by private enterprise, unaided

oy any subsidy either from Government or other pubhc
authority, by which it is from time to time consulted, and
to which its services are most willingly rendered. As an
illustration of the progress made it may be stated that when
the first Congress took place in 1877, there were 150 members
and the income was £240. In 1897 the members Avere 2,100
and the income £6,000. In 1877 five candidates were ex-
amined for certificates, in 1897 521 were examined, of whom
300 obtained certificates.
Such is a brief outline of the history of The Sanitary
Institute. But it is by no means the only source of instruction
in matters relating to Hygiene and Preventive or State
Medicine, for all our Medical Schools and Universities, the
Army and Navy Medical Schools at Netley and Haslar, and
many technical schools now give instruction in those subjects,
and the Universities and Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons
attest the fitness of candidates for the Diploma of Public
Health. One great national reproach, moreover, has lately
been removed by the foundation, by private enterprise of the
Institute of Preventive Medicine, under the presidency of Lord
Lister, with which is amalgamated the College of State
Medicine. The object of this Institution is to search out the
causes of disease, a knowledge without Avhich we cannot hope
to deal effectively with modes of prevention. The Medical
 ;

SIR JOSEPH EAVEER, 341

Departments of Navy, the Army, and the Local Govern-

tlie
ment Board, the Army Sanitary Committee, the Koyal Institute
of Public Health, many municipal and rural Health Societies,
and Societies of Medical Officers of Health, are actively em-
ployed in extending the jn’actical application of the knowledge
imparted by the various educational institutions as well as by
individual research.
The time at my
disposal does not permit of tracing in detail
the history ofthe growth of Sanitary Science from times
of ignorance and superstition to its present well-established
foundation on a scientific basis, but I may at once say that it is
indeed only comparatively recently that preventive as distin-
guished from curative medicine has assumed the position of a
science at all ; it is now from a liygienic point of view, the
more important of the two, though the difficulties attending
its application are still considerable and largely such as arise
from ignorance and incredulity.
Half a century ago the great mass of the population lived
and died under conditions which violated all the now well
known principles on which health depends prejudice, ignor-
;

ance, and vested interests stood in the way of progress, and but
little effort was made to correct the one or remove the others
government looked on with indifference the people knew little
;

and thought less of the efficacy of pure air, pure water, cleanly
and uncrowded dwellings, temperance, and other conditions
which are now well known to be essential to health. They had
no idea that infective disease is but too frequently the scourge
of uncleanliness, overcrowding, and disregard of simple laws of
health.
Under the influence of such reformers as Chadwick, Parkes,
Richardson, Sitnon, Southwood Smith, Sutherland, Bristow,
Buchanan, Netten Radcliff, De Chaumont, Corfield, Thorne,
Notter, Seaton, L. Parkes, Ballard, Power, A. Hill, Armstrong,
Russell, Littlejohn, Cameron, Smith, Ransom, and others, to
say nothing of Sanitary Engineers such as Rawlinson, Galton,
Rogers Field, Hawkesley, Mansergh, etc., measures which were
regarded as mere theories or fads of no practical value, are now
accepted as of cardinal importance. Statesmen have learnt
to realise that Sanitary Science comes well within the sphere
of practical politics, and that it is an important part of
the duty of executive governments, whether general or local,
to protect the people fx’om disease which may be prevented or
controlled.
Numerous Acts of Parliament have been passed, such as
the Public Health Act of 1875, Rivers Pollution Prevention
Act 1876, Public Health (Water) Act 1878, Acts for Housing
342 INAUGUEAL ADDRESS.

the Working Classes 1885 and 1890, Infections Diseases Noti-

fication Act 1889, Infectious Diseases Prevention Act 1890,
Isolation Hospitals Act 1893, Public Health Act for London
1891, and many others. Officers of Health, Sanitary Engineers
and Sanitary Inspectors have produced a better state of things;
the poor are no longer left to be a law unto themselves on such
matters. Public health is cared for in a sense which was
utterly unknown in the past houses are better built, sewerage,
;

drainage and ventilation are provided for, the land is better

cultivated, the subsoil better drained the absolute importance
;

of pure drinking-water is recognised, food is more varied and

more nutritious in its character, clothing is better adapted to
climate and were all the e.xisting official provisions enforced,
;

little would remain to be desired on the part of the Executive

government; but as some of these Acts are permissive, not
compulsory, and as others are utterly neglected, much of the
benefit they might confer is lost.
Though education has done much as far as the better classes
are concerned, and upwards of 200 millions have been spent
on sanitary work, with great benefit to the public health,
popular teaching and example, and the general diffusion of
education, are still necessary in order to convince the pro-
letariat of what so intimately concerns their vital interests.
The death-rate is susceptible of further diminution, expectancy
of life may be enhanced, and the general conditions of living
and exemption from certain forms of disease are by no means
as perfect as they might be ; tainted water is still drunk, as was
illustrated by the condition of Maidstone and King’s Lynn last
year, where an extraordinary visitation of typhoid fever was
traced to impure water, shewing either that legislation was
imperfect or that its provisions had not been duly observed.
Chimneys still vomit forth their smoke and chemical fumes,
rivers are still polluted, cesspools and imperfect drains, badly
constructed, ill-ventilated houses, and so on, still defy alike
sanitary law and common sense and it will perhaps not be
;

until the more complete organisation of the public health ad-

ministration under a Minister of Public Health be effected,
that the full benefits of sanitary legislation will be realised and
the people attain to that standard of health and duration of life
for which they have a right to hope.
Even our great cities with all their improvements leave much
to be desired. Notwithstanding Acts of Parliament, all the
efforts of sanitaiy authorities, all the advice that may have
issued from this and other similar sources, serious defects
remain. Even your own great city, according to the journals,
notwithstanding the splendid municipal arrangements for which
 SIB JOSEPH rAlREH. 343

it is remarkable, has still a higher death-rate than some other

great cities. Since lt?82 up to 1897 it has stood at from 219)
"2 and the same authority points out sanitary defects
to 20 ,

which one may venture to think might be ameliorated.

In the first week of July in thirty-three of the largest English
towns the rate of mortality, which had been 15*1 and 14‘9 per
thousand in the two preceding weeks, declined to 14’7. It was
14*3 in Lontlon, whilst it averaged 14'9 in the thirty-two provin-
cial towns. The lowest death-rates were 9*4 in Cardiff, 9*7 in
Huddersfield, 10*3 in Brighton. The highest rates were 17*9
in Plymouth, 20*3 in Newcastle, 21*4 in Sunderland. When
the last quinquennium is compared with the preceding decen-
nium it is found that Blackburn and Huddersfield have reduced
their death-rate 4, Halifax and Cardiff 3*8, Oldham 3*7, Preston
3*4, Manchester 3*3 per thousand, while Birmingham has been
practically at a stand-still.* If I am not mistaken, your own
eminent health officer thinks that if the death-rate is to be
reduced, it is essential that the improvements should be con-
tinued which had such a good effect some years ago. I merely
venture to suggest it as a hint that may be worthy of the con-
sideration of the municipal authorities.
Apropos of London, Sir Henry Burdett said in a speech
made last year “ London, unfortunately, in regard to certain
:

*
health matters is still under the control of the Vestries. * *
In the district of for example, in this year of the
Diamond Jubilee (wherein the greatness and majesty of the
British Empire has been so convincingly exhibited,) the streets
of one of the wealthiest portions of London are left unswept
and uncared for from Saturday to Monday in each week. No
matter how high the temperature, or how filthy the streets may
be, the streets- of probably the wealthiest disti’ict in the Metro-
* * * *
polis of the Empire are made dangerous to health.
Some of the most influential of the residents have entreated
and protested in vain. The intelligent foreigner, to his sur-
prise and disgust, may see in the streets of on any
Sunday when the principal residents are at home all day,
fermenting filth and even dead cats, dirty papers and various
kinds of offal, which offend the senses and infect the atmosphere
to the danger of the inhabitants. Such a state of affairs is as
shameful as it is unaccountable.’'
He might have added a paragraph upon the abominable
and insanitary practice of sending out the vestry dust-carts
to take away the house refuse at all times of the day. This

* “ Lancet,” July 16th, 1898.

344 INArOUllAL ADDRESS.

proceeding is not only offensive to the eye and nose, but

prejudicial to health. It ought to be pi’omptly discontinued,
and on no ])retext ought dust-carts to be allowed in the streets
after an early hour in the morning. Recent discussions in the
House of Commons shew that the question of pure water
supply also has not yet been satisfactorily settled or brought
under the control of the sanitary authorities. It is to be hoped
that disputes upon a question of such vital importance will not
long remain unsettled.
Nevertheless, when we contrast the present state of our
country with its millions of inhabitants, with that of the
Elizabethan era with its 4 millions, we have ample proof of the
ignorance of science in those days and of the great improve-
ments which have taken place in these. When we think of
the ill-ventilated dwellings, the ill-built towns and villages,
the narrow, unpaved, unlighted streets, uncultivated, marshy
country, unreclaimed land, the wretched houses, often of wood
or earth, without drainage or ventilation, with floors covered
with straw or rushes saturated with filth and reeking with
noxious miasmata, the stagnant gullies and open cesspools,
to which must be added the wretched diet, often of salted
meat, with little or no vegetable food, the intemperate habits,
and frequently the most impure water, we can understand how
under such conditions disease found a congenial nidus, and
frequently assumed the epidemic proportions in which it proved
so destructive to life, manifesting itself in the forms of the
black death, sweating sickness, typhus, plague, eruptive fevers,
small-pox, leprosy, scurvy, malarial fevers, and dysentery. Many
of these have disappeared —
never, we hope, to return —
and
others have been mitigated.
But can we feel confident that the immunity will continue'^
I am afraid not !Sudden invasions of cholera and other epi-
demics, and, as now, of plague in India, are warnings that our
vigilance must never be relaxed. But the experience of our
country under the greatly improved sanitary administration of
the present time has shewn how much we inay rely on pre-
ventive measures wisely enforced, especially when these are
based on experience ami enlightened obsen'ation, and not upon
mere theoi-ies of causation.
A brief enquiry into the statistics of some well known
diseases will show that they have become less severe in their
incidence if not less frequent in their recurrence, and how far
they are thus subject to the influence of hygienic measures. ^

In Small-pox, for example, there has been great I’eduction,

more so than in any other disease. Since the passing of the first
Vaccination Act in 1841, the death-rate has fallen from 57(5 per
 SIE JOSEPH FAYREK. 345

million to 20 per million in 1891-95. Vaccination, isolation,

attention to rational treatment, whether therapeutic or hygienic,
have preceded or accompanied, and as most people believe,
induced these results aud theories which ignore vaccination as
;

a preventive must, it appears to me, necessarily be rejected

until a better explanation of the cause of the diminished inci-
dence and mortality from the disease can be offered.
As to the value of vaccination, all the evidence that is forth-
coming seems to shew that there can be no doubt of it. As to
the methods by which every individual is to be vaccinated or
re-vaccinated, that is a subject for the State to determine.
That the Acts in existence up to the present time are inade-
quate to this end is plainly shewn by the fact that large and
increasing numbers of the population are known to be uuvacci-
nated, despite their compulsory character. Lord Lister said in
his speech in the House of Lords last August that one- third of
the children born are unvaccinated, and that one-fourth of the
Boards of Guardians do not put the law in force.
The most recent Vaccination Act, whatever may be its

advantages, iscertainly defective in this that it : makes no

provision for re-vaccination, the necessity for which is univer-
sally admitted by the medical profession, whilst it is very
doubtful whether the modification of the compulsory clauses
will have the effect, as it is hoped, of extending vaccination.
This remains to be seen during the five years for which the new
Act is to be operative. Whatever the Government may have
thought proper to enact, though there seems good reason to
believe that as far as it is concerned faith in vaccination is
unshaken, it must be borne in mind that the Royal College of
Physicians have recently expressed their unaltered conviction,
and it is endorsed by the whole profession, that vaccination
“ properly performed ” and “ fluly repeated ” is the only known
preventive of small-pox, a view “ which is confirmed by the
experience of every epidemic, and is endorsed by those whose
office it is to combat such outbreaks by all the resources of
science. The characters of small-pox, its high degree of con-
tagiousness, the rapidity of its spread on congenial soil, defy
the efforts to suppress it by isolation alone or to arrest it in its
earlier days of invasion, and if vaccination were not at hand to
render its remarkable aid, the disease would become as common
and as widespread in this country as it was in times when sani-
tary science was unknown.” *
In 1838 the death-rate from fever at all ages was 1,053 per
million ;
in 1891-95 it was 185 per million. It was not until

“ Lancet,” August (itli, 1898.

346 INAUGUEAL ADDRESS.

1869 that enteric fever was separated from typhus, so tliat it

is not possible to say how much of the reduction should be
assigned to each, but the death-rate from enteric fever has
been reduced by about 53 per cent, since the diseases have been
differentiated, whilst typhus has almost ceased to exist. Now
these fevers notably flourish where sanitation is defective, and
as dirt, overcrowding and destitution have been diminished
so has typhus disappeared, whilst with improved drainage, the
removal of excretal filth, and the supply of pure water, enteric
fever has become less.
There is reason to think that Cholera is similarly influenced,
for though it has appeared in England several times since its
first invasion in 1831, as in 1845-49, ’53-54, ’65-66, and even
since as at Grimsby in 1893, yet its virulence and activity have
been gradually diminishing. I believe we do not know all the
conditions on which the origin and diffusion of cholera depend,
but it has been shewn here, as in India, that whatever may be
its ultimate cause it is amenable to sanitary laws ;
and that
though we may not be able to prevent it altogether, we can so
mitigate its incidence and severity as to deprive it of much of
its terrors. Happily the antiquated system of prevention by
coercion has in our country been replaced by, that of sanitary
measures and isolation, and it is to the wise and judicious
exercise of these by the medical authorities of our Local
Government Board and County Councils, and by Municipal
authorities and Health Officers throughout the kingdom, that
whilst neighbouring countries in the full practice of coercion
and quarantine were decimated, England has lately remained
almost exempt. It seems to me that few better examples of
the beneht arising from vigorous action by Government, under
the guidance of scientific authority, could be adduced.
Scarlet fever and diphtheria were formerly tabulated to-
gether; since 1859 they have been separately returned, and I
learn from Dr. Louis Parkes (a most worthy successor of his
distinguished relative and namesake) that “in 1838-42 the
joint mortality was 797 per million living; in 1891-95 it was
435 per million, a reduction of 45 per cent. Since 1861-65
the scarlet fever death-rate has been reduced 81 per cent.,
but the diphtheria death-rate is now very much the same as it
was over thirty years ago (1861-65), and about double the rate
prevailing in the fifteen years 1866-80. Whilst there can be
little doubt that improved sanitary and social conditions have
played some jiart in the reduction of the scarlet fever death-
rate, still the larger propox'tion of the diminished mortality is
probably attributable to a change in the type of the disease.”
With regard to diphtheria, it wonld seem “that sanitaxy
 SIR JOSEPH FAYRER. 347

ai’ranc^eiHcnts as such have liad or no effect upon the

little

behaviour of the disease. The excitin^r cause is now known to

—
be a bacillus, hut we know little of the conditions the pre-
disposing causes —
which favour the growth or virulence of this
micro-organism, either inside or outside the human body, or
which fiicilitate transference from the sick to the healthy
its

— conditions which must be studied if we are to ascertain why

of popu-
it is that diphtheria has made certain large centres
lation its abiding place, and in its endemic homes assumes at
times epidemic proportions. There is evidently some connection
between elementary school attendance as now carried out and
diphtheria prevalence, but the relation is not a very simple one,
and is incapable of explaining all the facts of increased diph-
theria incidence in rural populations.”
Dr. Louis Parkes’ remark suggests the necessity for studying
all collateral conditions of other diseases as well as diphtheria,
as being of equal importance with the microbe, which is
believed to be the causa causans, and of more practical value as
far as preventive measures are concerned.
In 1835-42 the death-rate from tuberculous disease was
3,959 per million, in 1891-95 it was 2,124, not so remarkable
a diminution as in other diseases but it serves to shew that
;

sanitation has done good by helping to improve the ill-ventilated

crowded dwellings, damp, waterlogged soil, impure water, and
protection against noxious trades. Better drainage and drying
of the subsoil have been shown by Sir G. Buchanan in this
country, and Dr. Bowditch in America, to have been attended
bv diminution in the death-rate from this cause.
"
Dr. James Pollock, in a recent Report on the Hospital Treat-
ment of Consumption, makes the following pertinent remarks :

“In seeking for the cause of this vast improvement in the

health of the country, we must attribute it mainly to improved
drainage of the subsoil, more cleanly habits, removal of insani-
tary surroundings, better dwellings, and a higher standard of
comfort in the lower classes. Bacteriology is the study of the
hour, but it is plain that the presence of bacilli alone is not
sufficient to account for all the phenomena of tubercular affec-
tions, and we are perhaps in danger of substituting the work
of the laboratory and the microscope for clinical observation.
However this may be, we have witnessed an enormous decrease
of deaths from phthisis, and a decided lengthening of its dura-
tion. Fewer die of it, and are slower to die when affected.
As vet we know of no agents which we can apply locally to the
interior of the body for the destruction of bacilli or sejitic
material. The energies of medical men are to-day devoted to
preventive medicine, ami in this consists our hope that the more
348 INAUGURAL AUDRESS.

fatal diseases of our time may be extinguished.” It is satis-

factory to know that an Association has already been formed
which has for its object the Prevention of Consumption and
other forms of Tuberculosis, and as this is supported by the
heads of the medical profession and other influential authorities,
it is to be hoped that effective war will be waged against what
is now considered to be a preventible disease.

As to malarial diseases, we may include them, in England at

least, among those that have become all but extinct. The
improved state of land drainage, the reclamation of marshy and
swampy ground and more extensive cultivation have almost,
though not altogether, eradicated a prolific source of disease
aud death which, though much diminished even in the eai’ly
part of this century, had in past times caused the loss of many
lives and great deterioration of health.
This disease is still the prominent cause of death in our
Eastern Empire, as will be shown later; but the results of
improved sanitation and the extension of cultivation and subsoil
drainage, under the direction of the admirably conducted sani-
tary department of the Government of India, are there too
producing good results.
It is not to be supposed that zymotic disease can be al-
together exterminated, but we can modify and diminish its
incidence, and as our knowledge of the real causes and the
concomitant conditions which foster its evolution extend, we
may hope, at least, if not to extinguish, so to attenuate as to
render it comparatively harmless, as, indeed, has been the case
with more than one scourge of our race.
The scope and aim of Sanitary Science in its preventive
aspects should not be limited to the consideration of zymotic
and other acute diseases, but should extend to the results of
abnormal social conditions arising out of the strain and
struggle for existence, involving over-competition in various
occupations by which life is supported, or wealth and dis-
tinction acquired, and under the pressure of which so many
lose their health or even succumb. For example, it frequently
suggests itself that the over-pressure now exerted on the
younger of the rising generation may not only involve the
risk of miscarriafre of true education, but dancrers ajjainst
which it is as much the duty of preventive medicine to guard
young people as it is to protect them from scarlatina, small-ix)x,
measles, cholera, or any other disease.
Again, as regards the food of the people, how necessary it is
to exercise control and supervision ;
and it is satisfactory to
know that not only does science teach the recognition of im-
proper food, but executive sanitary regulations eiulcavour to
 SIE JOSEPH FA.XRBU. 349

protect them from the consumption of tuberculous or other-

—
wise contaminated flesh or milk which, nnhappily, arc far too
—
common oysters and shell-fish grown up under the influence
of water polluted with sewage, etc., as effectively as it does or
should do from impm’e water.
The influence exerted on vital statistics by sanitary science may
be seen by reference to the returns of the Registrar-General.
In the birth-rate, however, we find a diminution, especially
since 1871-80, when it fell 3 per thousand. It has fluctu-
ated from time to time, but since 1876 —when it was 36-3 per
—
thousand, the highest recorded it has steadily declined, and
for the quinquennium 1891-95 was 30*5 per thousand. This
must be due to a variety of social conditions, which need not
be discussed here.
The great increase in the population is an indication of the
increasing prosperity of the countiy. This, of course, is at-
tributable to many causes apart from sanitation, though, no
doubt, improved hygienic conditions have some share in it,
as is shewn by the diminished death-rate. The census of 1841
returned the population of England and Wales as 16,049,554,
that of 1891 as 29,002,525, and it is still progressing at a
similar rate,* and not likely to be restricted whilst the present
state of prosperity continues, and the Empire is ever enlarging
its boundaries.
One indication of the effect of sanitary work is observed in
the death-rate of the country. In 1841-50 it stood at 22 '4
per thousand ; in 1891-95 at 18'7 per thousand; but for the
four years 1890-1893, it had risen owing to epidemic influenza,
the lowest rate, 1884, having been 16‘6 per thousand. It varies
considerably according to locality. In some parts of England
where health is the main object considered, it has been as low
as 9 per thousand ; in others where the chief objects are manu-
facture, trade, or money-making, it has been 30 per thousand.
The death-rate is susceptible of considerable modification, and
we know how it may be increased or diminished ; it behoves
the nation to exert its power and stand credited with the lowest
figure. In fact, it is, within certain limits, at our own control,
and whether the people shall die at the rate of 13 or 23 per
thousand depends on how we recognise our responsibility and
put in force sanitary regulations. It is mainly a question of
finance. Our sanitarians can say how it is to be done and are
perpetually saying it, biit more money, more faith, more energy
are needed to deal with this question satisfactorily.

In the Eegistrar- General’s quarterly return for the second quarter of

1898 it estimated at 31,397,078.
350 INAUGURAL ADDRESS.

The death-rate has fallen proportionately more in the towns

than among the rural population. In 1861-70 the town death-
rate was 24‘8 per thousand whilst the country was 19 '7, but in
1891-95 the town rate was 19*5 and the country 17'3 in —
both cases a diminution but more marked in the urban, pro-
bably because sanitation was better in the towns than in the
country.
There is a leading article in the Standard of June 23rd
stating that the death-rate for London, one of the healthiest
cities in the world, for the previous week had been 13*8 per
thousand, the lowest for five years with the exception of one
week in July last year, when it was 13‘5. This shows that
improvement has taken place of late years, for in 1855 it was
24’3 per thousand, in 1887 it was 19*3, and two years later
it was 17 ’3.
The tendency to migrate to towns no doubt helps to reduce
the general health, and it would be well to discourage this as
much as social and economic requirements will permit for a ;

strong and healthy peasantry is more conducive to the national

welfare than a weakly urban population.
The registration system came into force the year of the
Queen’s accession under the auspices of Dr. Farr, and it is
since then that we have been able to get accurate vital sta-
tistics, upon which depends our knowledge of the state of
public health, and from which also we can estimate the mean
expectation of life. Statistics show that in 1838 to 1854 the
mean expectation of life was for males 39‘81, for females 4L85
years. From 1871-80 it had increased to 41'35 for males,
44*66 for females. “When Dr. Farr conunenced his labours
the mean duration of life in Surrey was 45 years. It was not
more than 37 years in the Metropolis and 26 years in Liver-
pool. Now, the mean duration of life throughout the whole
of England and Wales is higher than the first named figiu’es.”*
Dr. Tatham, in the Registrar-General’s report for the last
ten years, gives the mean expectation of life for males as 43*7,
females 47*2 years. From a comparison of the tables of 1841
and 1881-90, it will be seen that this has increased both for
males and females up to the age of 30, but diminished after
that age.
Age. 1841. 1881—90. 1841. 1881—90.
20 39*88 40*27 40*81 42*44
30 33*13 32*52 34*25 34*76
40 26*56 25*42 27*72 27*60
50 20*02 18*52 21*07 20*56

* “ rractitiouer,” Juue, 1897,

p. 704.
 SIR JOSEPH EATRER. 351

shewing that though improved sanitation saves more children’s

lives, the conditions of life being harder as time progresses, the
expectation of adult life has become rather less for the very:

causes wliich enabled the weak and sickly to survive have

perhaps in the end thus tended to diminish the value of the
adult life of such survivors.
It has been suggested that whilst our improved sanitation,
our amended condition of living, and our more extended charity
have done all this ffood, and have generallv bettered the human
race, on the other hand they have prolonged the existence
of those who formerly would have succumbed rather than
promoted the survival of the fittest. To a certain extent it
may be so, but the moral sense insists that the benefit of our
knowledge must continue to be exerted in the direction of
ameliorating the sufferings, and prolonging the life of the indi-
vidual as well as of the race.
As to the registration of sickness, to quote Dr. Farr —
“ It is
:

true that notification of the chief infective diseases has been

secured in the majority of districts but the wider returns of
;

all sickness treated at the public expense, whether in rate-

supported or State-supported institutions, or in hospitals sup-
ported by charity, are still left almost completely un-utilised.
As Farr said, ‘the thing to aim at ultimately is a return of
cases of sickness in the civil population as complete as is now
procured for the army in England.’ By means of such returns
‘ illusion will
be dispelled, quackery as completely as astrology sup-
]u’essed, a science of therapeutics created, suffering diminished,
life shielded from many dangers. The national returns of
cases and of causes of death will be an arsenal which the genius
of English healers cannot fail to turn to account.’”*
I have already alluded to the benefits that have accrued to
the vast population, over 280 millions, of our great Indian
Empire, and I trust that a few remarks on the subject may not
be considered inopportune. My former connection with India,
and the experience derived from observation of its diseases and
their effects, in addition to the interest that attaches to what-
ever concerns the health and well-being of our own as well
as the indigenous races, will I trust be accepted as justifica-
tion for introducing this into an address to a Congress that
deals with public health as its chief topic of interest.
The beneficial results of sanitary work have nowhere been
better illustrated during the last half-century than in India.
Up to that time little or nothing had been done to control
disease, or to organise measures upon which public health and

* “British Medical Journal,” June 19th, 1897.

 —
352 INAUGXJHAL ADGEESS.

the preservation of life depend. The disastrous effects of the

want of such precautionary measures on our Army in the
Crimea led to the appointment of a Royal Commission to
enquire into the sanitary condition of the British Army, and
to devise measures for remedying such defects as might be
revealed. And here I may say that the result of that Cornmis-
sion was that the mortality of the British Army has fallen
from 16 or 18 to 6 or less per thousand. In 1859 this enquiry
was extended to India first to the European and subsequently
;

to the Native Army and jail and civil population. The enquiry
having to deal with a large body of men the conditions of
whose lives were Avell known, a vast amount of reliable infor-
mation was obtained and it Avas ascertained as one result of
;

the investigation that the ordinary death-rate of the British

soldier had stood for a long period of time at the appalling
figure of
84'6 per 1000 from 1800 1830 —
56-70 „ „ 1830—1856.
It resulted in certain sanitary changes and improvements in
the housing, clothing, food, occupation and discipline of the
soldiers, which were followed by a signal decline in the death-
rate, though marked by fluctuations :

1886 ... 15-8 per 1000 1891 ... 15-89 per 1000
1887 ... 14-20 1892 ... 17-07 99

1888 ... 14-84 59 1893 ... 12-61 99

1889 ..: 16-60 99

1894 ... 16-07 99

1890 . 13-54 99
1895 ... 15-26 99

It has been even lower, down to 10 per thousand. Epidemics

such as fever, cholera, &c., disturb the regularity of the death-
rate, but it is certain that on the whole there has been great
'
reduction of this.
If we roughly estimate the value of a British soldier as
£160, a simple calculation will show the amount of gain in the
value of lives saved, to say nothing of the suffering and in-
validing avoided.
I confine myself here to a simple reference to one form of
preventible disease which has recently attracted much public
notice, as it seriously menaced the efficiency of the army in
India. Its rapid increase was attributed, erroneously, I believe,
to the suppression of a Contagious Diseases Act which could
only from the nature of things have been of very limited
application in that country. But even granting that it may
have been to a certain extent concerned, the main causes are
to be sought far more probably in the absence of other pre-
ventive measures rather within the sphere of military discij)line
 Sn? JOSEPH FATRER. 353

As attention has been directed to tins, as well as to other

possible canses,it is to be hoped that the evil may be controlled.

The death-rate of the Native Army does not shew so great

a diminution, but here too there is impi’ovement.
In 1889 the death-rate was 12’94 per thousand.
„ 1890 53 51
15*91 53

„ 1891 35 35
15*44 55

„ 1892 33 33
14*97 35

,, 1893 53 35
10*29 53

„ 1894 35 35
10*76 35

„ 1895 33 33
11*60 53

Another about which we have reliable statistics is the

class
jail population. and here the mortality is higher, despite sani-
tary measures. For example-
In 1889 it was 36’56 per thousand.
„ 1890 31*49 55

„ 1891 31*89 53

„ 1892 36*83 55

„ 1893 25*01 55

„ 1894 31*87 55

„ 1895 91
27*61 55

The high rate of sickness and mortality in the Indian jails

has been a subject of anxious consideration to the Government
of India and the sanitary authorities. No pains I may say —
no expense —are spared in dealing with it. The abnormal con-
ditions of prison life, and perhaps occasional defects in archi-
tectural construction, may in some measure account for it,
and the probability is that were not every sanitaiy precaution
rigidly enforced the moi’tality would be higher than it is.
As regards the vast civil population we have not only got to
deal with epidemics, famine and long established modes of living,
which obstruct improvement, but also with ignorance, prejudice
and religious scruples, which tend to make the natives doggedly
resist all measures taken for the amelioration of their condition.
They persist in their ancestral modes of social life, resist all
changes, and, as we have lately seen, have risen in revolt against
the well-meant measures devised by authority for saving them
from plague, cholera, and other pestilence. Their indolent habits,
prejudiced minds and fatalistic creed all stand in the way, but
even the natives of India are being gradually educated into a
better comprehension of the value of sanitary measures, and, as
time progresses, it is to be hoped that under the firm and
judicious administration of the authorities, sanitation may prove
as beneficial to them as it has been to others. Though we
Iviiow that improvement is in progress it is not so easy to shew
 —
364 INAUGUUAL ADDKESS.

by the actual rates of mortality of the vast civil

statistics
population, because so many disturbing causes exist and though
;

registration is greatly improved there is not the accuracy and

reliability that belong to the returns of the army and jail
population, which are all under supervision and control.
Referring to the published mortality returns during the
period between 1882 and 1895, they have oscillated between
23 and 33 per thousand. This is after all not a very high
death-rate considering the circumstances, but is susceptible of
diminution, and this I trust will take place.
Since 1866 a well-organised sanitary department has existed
and every effort is made to give effect to its teaching, whilst
the ample and carefully constructed reports by the Chief Com-
missioner, as well as those of subordinate local governments
and municipalities, afford ample data upon which to construct
preventive measures, and at the same time shew that public
health forms one of the most important considerations of the
Government.
The annual Report of the Sanitary Commissioner with the
Government of India for 1892 shews that out of a registered
population of 217,255,655, 4,621,583 died of fevers. Compare
this with the year 1895, when out of a registered population
of 226,010,428 (note the increase) there was a death-rate from
fevers of 4,266,293. These returns fluctuate, but at any rate
the figures shew a tendency towards improvement. How much
more fatal, fever is than any other disease is shewn by the
following figures for 1892 :

Fevers caused 4,621,583 deaths.

... ...

Cliolera „ ... 727,493

... „
Dysentery and diarrhcea caused 234,370 „
Small-pox „ 101,121 „
The plague which has appeared in India within the last two
years, and has so largely added to the death-rate in certain
localities, its modes of invasion, diffusion, and recrudescence,
are all being carefully studied, and already it has been shewn
to be amenable to sanitary laws like other epidemics we may,
;

therefore, hope to ultimately control and get rid of it altogether,

though there is reason to fear that this will not take place for
some time to come.
It is satisfactory to know
that the etiology of cholera,
plague, and fevers is being carefully investigated by competent
observers, and we are warranted in believing that we are
approaching the solution of important problems of ultimate
causation of disease which have hitherto remained without
satisfactory explanation, and the knowledge of which will enable
 ;

SIR JOSEPU EAYEER. 355

IIS to cousti'uct our measures for prevention upon an even more

assured basis tliau they occupy at present.
In connection with the subject of sanitation and preventive
medicine in India, one may not omit to refer to the names of
its great pioneers, such as Ainsley, who wrote as early as 1788
upon measures for the protection of the health of soldiers
llanald Martin, who was one of the foremost pioneers in India
as he was in this country, and to whose initiation many of the
sanitary measures now in force in both countries are due later
;

on J. M. Cuningham, Byyden, Cornish, Hewlett, EwaPt,

D. Cunningham, Vandyke Carter, Simpson, Manson (China),
whose investigations into the causation of malarial fevers have
justly excited so much attention and to these, did time permit,
;

I might add a number of names of younger men to whose

admirable work I gladly bear testimony.
I have already noticed the gi’eat progress that has been made
of late years in the knowledge, of the etiology of disease. This
is not the time or place in which to describe or dilate on the
various steps by which it has been or is being acquired but ;

one must not omit to acknowledge thut its importance in relu-

tion to hygiene and as a scientific basis on which to found any
rational system of proceeding with regard to prevention as Well
as cure of disease is incalculable, for without it, although em-
pirical methods may be of some value, no real progress can be
maintained.
It is impossible to exaggerate the value of these researches,
wliich have already led to the antiseptic methods of preventing
the noxious action of micro-organisms and their products, and
to the knowledge of the immunising or curative effects produced
by inoculation of the attenuated virus, toxins or antitoxins
(blood serum therapeutics), as well as to the aid that has been
afforded to diagnosis. Already, indeed, important practical
results have been obtained.
I am indebted to Dr. A. Macfadyen, the able Director of the
Institute of Preventive Medicine, himself one of the most
distinguished workers in bacteriology, for the following lucid
account of the progress already made in the application of
bacteriological science to the prevention and treatment of
disease, and which holds out promise of further advance in this
most important branch of science. The successful establisliT
ment of the Bacteriological Department of the Institute as
well as of that of the Royal Colleges, is an earnest of further
development in our own country of a branch of scientific enquiry
which is obviously of such vital importance to public health
and to those interests with which this Congvess is so closely
concerned.
356 INAUGURAL ADDRESS.

“ There can be no better memorial to Jenner than to carry on his

work in his spirit. The fresh impulse to this was derived from the
labours of Pasteur and Koch, who not only demonstrated the part
that living agents play in the causation of disease, but also gave us
the methods whereby these might be investigated. In this way the
foundations of bacteriology were laid.
The main problems connected with the causation and prevention
of disease and many sarutary questions are bacteriological in their
nature, whilst some of the most pressing questions connected with
water and sewage are of a biological character. The soil, air, and
water, as well as our food, have to be considered as possible media for
harbouring and conveying the living germs of disease.
The question of questions has been that of immunity to disease.
We know that animals are insusceptible to certain diseases that affect
man, and that the converse holds good. We also know that certain
individuals remain unaffected in times of epidemic, though equally
exposed to the infection. Further, that recovery from certain
diseases protects the individual against a subsequent attack of the
same disease.
The attempt has been made to follow nature’s methods in the
hope of protecting the system from the attack of a disease or of
alleviating its symptoms. The discovery of the principle of vaccina-
tion for small-pox remained a unique achievement until the success-
ful isolation of the living agents in many infectious diseases rendered
it work with greater certainty of success in this field.
possible to
The attempt was made to use the modified living virus to produce a
mild attack of a disease with a view of protecting the system against
infection with the fully virulent virus, e.g., Pasteur’s attenuated
anthrax vaccine for cattle.
The endeavour was also made to use as a vaccine, substances
which no longer contained the living organisms, but their products.
Bacterial toxins of varying origin have been experimented with for
the purpose, e.g., products obtained from the cultures or the bodies of
pathogenic bacteria ; as in the case of the cholera and typhoid fever
organisms, and more recently the disintegrated bodies of tubercle
bacUli.
The results are not yet of a final character, though much hopeful
work is being done in connection with cholera asiatica, enteric fever
and tuberculosis.
The greatest modern advance in the treatment of disease has been
the introduction of serum therapeutics through Behring’s labours,
which have found their special application in connection with
diphtheria and tetanus.
Diphtheria and tetanus may be described as toxic diseases, inas-
much as the general intoxication of the system due to the poisonous
products of the diphtheria bacillus or the tetanus bacillus outweighs
in gravity the local action of these organisms at the seat of infection.
These bacilli when cultivated in suitable media produce the same
toxins that they elaborate in the body, and it is these toxins which
 am JOSEl’II FAYKER. 357

are utilized for immunizing purposes. The animal used is usually

the horse, which after treatment witli progressively increasing doses
of the toxin becomes ultimately insusceptible to otherwise fatal doses
of these poisonous products. The animal is then said to be im- ‘

mune,’ in virtue of antitoxic bodies produced in its system through

the introduction of the toxins. The blood serum of the immunized
animal contains the antitoxic bodies in large quantity, and can, when
transferred to other susceptible animals, confer a like protection
in virtue of the iramuniziug substances it contains. The method
adopted is appropriately termed ‘blood serum therapeutics.’ This
procedure is technically known as passive
‘ immunity, i.e., the
’

animal has not to go through an attack of the specific disease in

order to acquire protection.
The bodies that are produced in the course of immunizing a horse,
say to diphtheria, are called antitoxins, because they act not so much
on the specific microbe as on its products. In the course of an
attack of such a disease the human body elaborates similar substances,
which are in a certain sense antidotes. If formed in a sufficient
quantity a neutralization of the toxins that are being formed by the
microbe in the system occurs and recovery takes place. At the
‘ ’
crisis nature effects a process of self-immunization. In the
older methods it was sought to produce immunity by inducing a mild
attack of the disease. In the case of blood serum therapeutics, im-
munity is brought about by introducing into the system ready formed
‘
antitoxins ’ from a previously immunized animal, and the result, if
successful, is an immediate one. The immunity is transient however,
lasting only a few weeks.
The preparation of such antitoxic serums has only a prospect of
success, when the poison to which the fatal effects of the ilhiess are
due is known, and can be obtained of an adequate strength for
immunizing purposes. This has been the case in diphtheria, tetanus,
and snake poisoning, and hence the most encouraging I’esults that
have been obtained are in connection with these complaints.
Experiment has shown that an antitoxin can act both as a pre-
ventive and curative agent. Thus, in the case of experimental
tetanus, the serum from a previously immunized animal when injected
into a guinea-pig is not only able to prevent the disease but also to
cure it, even when tetanus symptoms have supervened.
It is in connection with diphtheria that the most successful results
have been obtained in man. The Imperial Board of Health, Berlin,
has published statistics in relation to diphtheria, which deal with
9,581 cases treated in hospitals with diphtheria serum from April,
1895, to March, 1896, and shew that for every 16 cases that
recovered 3 died. In previous years before the sermn was used
there were on an average 6 deaths for every 16 recoveries. The
mortality was accordingly reduced by one half.
The diphtheria serum has also preventive properties, and can be
used for immunizing healthy persons exposed to infection.
In the case of tetanus in man the results have hitherto not been
so satisfactory. This umy be due to the fact that the serum has
358 IKAUaUHAL ABDliESS.

not been of sufTioient antitoxic strength, or because the disease was

too far advanced previous to its employment.
In all cases the best results are obtained by the earliest possible
use of the antitoxic serum.
The facts that seem proved are, that in human diseases characterised
by an intoxication of the system, immunity occurs at the moment of
recoveryj and that by the artificial introduction of the substances to
which this immunity is due it is possible to prevent or cure such
infections.
If this be so the present endeavours of bacteriologists are based
on Nature’s methods, and we can confidently look forward to still

greater achievements in the field of serum therapeutics.

Bacteriology has also supplied agents which are of proved value in
the diagnosis of certain diseases. Thus Mallein, a preparation from
the glanders bacillus, is successfully used for the early diagnosis of
this disease. Tuberculin, a similar preparation from the tubercle
bacillus, allows of an early diagnosis of the disease in cattle. An
early diagnosis enables one to adopt timely preventive measures, and
therein is the great value of tuberculin, inasmuch as we are here
dealing with a pommunicable disease between man and animals.
Bacteriology has also rendered valuable help in the diagnosis of
diphtheria and typhoid fever, and medical men and sanitary authori-
ties are now largely availing themselves of this help.
The yearly increase in the work the British Institute of Preventive
Medicine is asked to undertake on behalf of sanitary authorities
demonstrates how keenly alive they are becoming to the importance
of adopting the latest methods calculated to safeguard the health of
the community.”

Evidently, a great future is before preventive medicine, and

we may confidently look to the eminent men of science Avho are
now pursuing with such indefatigable zeal their researches into
the mysteries of bacteriology for its fulfilment. But those wdio
admire and appreciate their work the most, and look forward
hopefully to its results are anxious that progress should not he
retarded by hasty deduction and premature generalisation,
which may only end in disappointment.
I venture to suggest that however great may be the import-
ance of the study of bacteriology and the various conclusions
resulting from it with regard to the origin, diffusion, and
prevention of disease, there are other factors of no less im-
portance to be considei'ed, and it can only be by the study of
all these that we can hope to arrive at the complete knowledge
which will enable us to fulfil the requirements of sanitary
science. Whilst on the one hand it is of the utmost signifi-
cance that we should be able to demonstrate the actual cause,
whether a micro-organism or not, on the other hand it is not
of less— nay, from a practical sanitary ])oint of view it is of
 SIR .TOSEIMI FAYIIEU. 359

—
more importance that we should know the conditions
all
under which this cause becomes effective. It is not enough
that we know the seed, but it is necessary that we should also
know the nature of the soil, the meteorological and other con-
ditions which determine whether it is to grow and multiply or
to x’emain inert and harmless. If one can learn how to destroy
the seed or sterilize the soil in which it attains its full develop-
ment, or if we can neutralise the favouring conditions and so
prevent or impede its growth, then we shall have solved a great
problem, and conferred a lasting benefit on mankind.
Much of this has already been done, and the splendid work
of Pasteur, Davaine, Koch, Lister, B. Saunderson, Sims Wood-
head, and their followers, has added and is almost daily adding
to the knowledge which confirms the hope that the consumma-
tion so devoutly to be desired will be achieved, that zymotic
disease will be minimised, that life will be prolonged nearer to
the natural term of human existence, and that man, in short,
will no longer be subject to the curse of dying before he has
reached the prime of life.
It cannot be doubted that The Sanitary Institute has already
done excellent work, and has contributed its share to the
advance^ which public health has made since its foundation.
Tlie Spii’it of Hygeia is abroad, and measures for preserving
health and preventing disease, which at no very distant period
in the past were looked on as mere hypotheses, are now, thanks
to the teaching of this Institute and others of a similar
character, and notwithstanding the obstacles to research arising
out of ill-considered sentimental opposition, regai'ded as of vital
importance,^ and an integral part of the basis of the system of
administration on which the public health depends.
I cannot conclude this address without expressing a hope
that the proceedings of this Congress now assembled may add
largely to the influence of the work of The Sanitary Institute,
and widely diffuse the opinions and teaching of the numerous
men of science who are associated here and elsewhere in the
crusade against insanitation, and in the great humanitarian
project of furthering not only the health, bnt the moral and
material welfare of our own country and of all the world.

Kenny & Co., Printers, 26, Camden Bead, London, N.W.

 Leamington College Prize Distribution.

SPEECH BY SIR JOSEPH FAYRER.

Reprinted from Leamington Advertiser, November 24th, i8g8.

S[R Joseph FayRer said: Having com- £ would postpone it until the boy’s
pitted the most intere.sting and important mental culture has been so far advanced by
part ot the duty conlided to me, that of other well-known and accepted means, such
ilistributing the prizes, I will now, with your Classics and Mathematics, as to fit him to
jiermission, make a few remarks which seem assimilate and make proper use of them and
to me appropriate to the occasion which has other technical branches of knowledge. Let
brought us together to-day, I desire to oie now say a few words to the younger
—
thank the governing body for the distinction portion of my audience a very few, but, as
—
conferred on me by inviting me to preside £ think, important words which I trust they
over this meeting, to assure them that it has -^vill lay to heart and ponder over, not only
given me great pleasm’e to do so, and that it now or when their thoughts revert to their
is a source of sincere gratihcation to offer my schooldays, but always, as they make their
hearty congratulations on the marked pro- way in life, whatever conditions that life
gress and success of the School, results may assume. I especi.ally congratulate those
which, it is well known, are due not only to to whom I have had the pleasure of handing
t'.ie judicious administratiou of the govern- prizes. I syni£3athise with the feelings
ing body, but also to the earnest, zealous, naturally aroused by success, but I trust that
and able tuition and m.anagement of the these will not beget over-confidence or an
Head Master and his colleagues. No one undue sense of superiority, or involve relasa-
can have watched the progress of the College tion of effort, but rather prove an incentive
for the last few years, during which it has to further exertion. A clever writer has
made such rapid strides, without feeling a quite recently said, “strength is shewn by
deep sense of obligation to them for their self-suppression rather than by self-glorifica-
.admirable work, which has not only re-' tion,” and let me add that the winning of
established the ancient prestige of the School, prizes, though most commendable, is not an
l)ut justifies the feeling of confidence with infallible proof of possession of the qualities
which its future is. anticipated. This must, which lead to success in after life. You all
be a subject of gratification not only to; know the fable of the hare and the tortoise,
Leamington and to the parents of the boys! and can appreciate the moral ! I do not in
who are educated in the College, but to all the least undervalue the efforts of those who
— —
M ho are interested and who is not ? in the £iave distinguished themselves on the con-
;

welfare of that most important of our trary, I applaud them, and regard the win-
national institutions, a public school. W e ning of a prize in open competition as a
have heard with great interest and satisfac- subject for legitimate pride. Bat I would
tion the report of the Head Master, and the remind you, in the words of the writer
•

results of the Oxford and Cambridge Exam- already referred to, “that the man who tries
ination, which prove that the boys have and succeeds is one degree less of a hero
attained not only a high standard of know- than the man who fails and yet goes on try-
ledge, but that they have been well taught, ing ” — words of consolation and encourage-
and that the moral and intellectual training ment for those who, though doing their best,
has been of a high order. The curriculum, have for the present failed to win prizes,
moreover, shews that education in the truest The unsuccessful competitors have no reason
sense is the object aimed at, rather than the to be discouraged. The prizes missed this
accumulation of facts which, however useful year may be won the next, and failure may
t rey may be in other ways, are of little value do good by inciting to increased effort and
as a means of general culture, of disciplining to the recognition and correction of defects
the mind, of preparing it for higher objects, which are remediable by introspection and
or of making that most desirable of all self-discipline. The m.ain object of your
things, a gentleman, and of fitting the young life here is education. This does not mean
for the emergencies of life, and, above all, cr imming or the winning of prizes, but that
of teaching them how to learn. I, for one, training whicli cultivates alike mind and
confess that in these days of competition, body, and fits you for the duties and respon-
Avhen subjects are apt to be selected and sibilitios of life. And this, though a£jjjlicable
tauglit rather with reference to their com- generally, is so specially in the formation of
mercial value than their fitness as a means of the .attributes, character and qualification
mental discipline, I sympathise with those which make an Englisli gentleman, a title
who stearlily oppose and resist the growing which I trust you all not only claim now,
tendency to disregard or depreciate the tried but will maintain .and do justice to in the
and aj)proved system of education which is future. Lord Salisbury recently made the
well known to have been so elfectual and fallowing remarks when doing honour to the
successful in times past in our public schools, ac'.iievements of one who has greatly distin-
Such,. I ,am glad to see, is the spirit of this gushed himself — “The Egyptian Army,”
school, and such I trust it m.ay continue to s ai 1 the Prime Minister, “as it has issued
be. No one, I hope, will for a moment think from the hands of Sir Evelyn Wood, Sir
that I undervalue the teaching of Natural fi'rancis Hrenfell and the Sirdar, is a magni-
Science and other kindred subjects. On thedi3ent specimen of the creative power of the
contrary 1 value it highly, in its right ])lace,l English leader. We do not reflect on it.
 —

yet, if we have any insight into the adminis-

trative processes that go on in various parts '

of the Empire, we cannot help being impress-,

od by the fact that numbers of educated
young men, who, at home in this country
would probably attract no special attention
and who would show no very conspicuous
qualities, except those we are accustomed to
look for in an English gentleman, yet if
thrown upon their own resources and bidden
to govern and control and guide large bodies
of men of another race have never, or hardly
ever fallen short of the task that has
been given them, but will make of
that very unpromising material splen-
did regiments by which the Empire
of England is extended and sustained.”
T.he officer here referred to is the dis-
tinguished victor of Omdurman, but there
have been hundreds of similar examples, and
it is from the public schools that these have
generally emerged, and will continue to
emerge while the methods of education which
have been hitherto so successful shall remain
in force. What has been done by one edu-
cated young Englishman can be done by
others, and who can say what embryo states-
man, general, lawyer, divine, or man of
science I may now be addressing. The
object of your life here, then, is not the
accumulation of a number of details of this
or that branch of knowledge, but that
culture of all your faculties which may fit
you to respond to any call that may be made
on you. By all means cultivate any taste
you may have for science, art, or music, but
let your primary object be those subjects
your masters here will tell you what they
are— that shall best develop your intel-
lectual, moral, and religious life and charac-
ter. As to your physical training that, too,
is of great moment, and should go side by
side with, but second in importance to the
other. “Mens sana in corpore sano” can
only thus be assured. When the Duke of
Wellington said that Waterloo had been won
in the playing fields of Eton, I cannot believe
that he meant to ignore the share taken by
the school room, but rather that, important
as the latter might be, it was made more
effective by the former. The character of
the young Englishman is greatly influenced
for good by the national athletic games, and
they should be freely pursued, but not to the
postponement of intellectual culture, and it
would seem from occasional public corres-
pondence that there is some danger of this,
as there is a tendency to give more heel in
these days to ])hysical than to mental training.
Avoid this mistake. Stick to your games,
but let them, as they will if rightly followed,
be ancillary, not prejudicial, to your school
work indoors. But, whatever your objects
in life, your tastes and ])iirsuits may be, let
me advise you, in your aspirations for the
future, to contemplate .and aim at <a high
ideal .an 1 work for it with all your energies
and ability. Though you m ly not att.aiiiall
you aspire to, you will surely m lint.aiu the
national prestige, jelay a iisetul .and honour-
able i>art in life, an I so doing prove .a ci'edit
to yourself, to your country, and to the Aim i
Mater that has nourished you.
 FALMOUTH GRAI.m'IAR SCHOOL
Distribution of prizes

Speech by Sir Joseph Fayrer

awards,
Sir Joseph Fayrer having distributed the
in
remarked that the school commenced its career
o
and
1824 under the designation of the Classical

Mathematical School. It was evident that its

Founders, including Lords Wodehouse and Dunster-

ville, and other gentlemen of position and impor-

tance, especially those connected with the Fox

family, to whom Falmouth owed other debts of

gratitude, contemplated a school where boys

should receive culture and training and a liberal

and religious education. In 1894 the present

Head Master assumed control of the school, and

the number of boys rapidly rose from 23 to 60.

At present the number was 65. The trustees,

knowing the advantages of the climate, were

impressed with the idea that the school was well

adapted for the training of delicate lads, and he

was much inclined to agree with them. He was,

however, of opinion that its advantages would be

equally beneficial to the youth generally of a

county which had often been regarded as the

 ,

birthplace of* athletes, whether of physical or

intellectual type. — The resultr of the recent

exarriination shewed that steady progress had been

made, and that the p“upils had'hacquitt ed themselves

r

most creditably. He assured them of the pleasure

it afforded him to be present on that occasion.

r> • '

He was also glad of having an opportunity of ^

saying how much interest he took "in their charm-

ing winter health resort, which, from the mild-

ness and^'^equability of its climate , "seemed so

well adapted for the site of a school where ' '

young persons of doubtful or delicate constitu-^’"'

tion might, 'along with the robust, reside and

pursue their studies under favourable ^climatic

conditions during the winter months.

•
(

He thought the inhabitants of Falmouth

and Cornwall generally were fortunat^e in possess-

irig a public school with such advantages. All

^
who had watched its recent "progress "must be

gratified at the rapid onward strides it had

taken. The plan of education adapted was based

on sound principles and tended to develop intel-

lectual growth and culture. The disposition

to specialise at an early age was not encouraged
The main object aimed at was education in its

truest sense, not a mere accumulation of facts,

which, however useful in other respects, were

valueless as a means of mental culture and disci-

pline. He did not undervalue the study of

physical or natural science, but regarded it as

of supreme importance in its proper place when

mental culture had been so far advanced by

other well-known and tried means. Experience

proved that early mental culture was of the

greatest importance. lie congratulated the boys

who had won the prizes, and fullv sympathised ,

with the pleasure naturally resulting from the

success. If, howeven, it excited any undue

feeling of superiority, and suggested the notion

that they might relax-their efforts, it would

have been .better if they had not won the prizes

at all. ’
On the other hand, they should not

undervalue the efforts of those who had distin-

guished themselves, but applaud them for the f.

winning of a prize in open competition, which

was a legitimate object for pride and congratu-

lation. The object of their life was education,

which did not mean cramming for the winning

of phizes, but the training which cultivated

 blnon;; J'loqH , li 0 'u; o r. 3
-
0 < ^ i) L x o rl
1

I I
-, .:»* 1 1 .-r •
'

uj .t 0 e X 1 0 it lix y'o in X fr e 'ro liJivi eie'x'Tf) j;;! ^'pjvo

60 yXriMbu\ta dr-J* !qd axvbx? oali; •

oH . e'u.' J-Itfo

tX J X xj di.fiw Jl 'lo'T :Xnow X<^t«bX rl^irl xs Sc

,y^Stltdc bnfi '/q*xeno

''
'£f3X^i£?vb'v ’J iiiwanoO Jjuoxilfi'i

X3 (?r 5
I- . ObCi
 Falmouth High School.
SIR JOSEPH FAYRER ON EDUCATION.
FKIZK DISTlilBUTION.
Sir Joseph Fayrer, who received a cordial
welcome, said It has given Lady Fayrer and
myself much pleasure to be present on this
occasion, and to assist at the interesting ceremony,
which, whilst it marks the conclusion of a year's
work, commemorates the progress made in this
school during that period. It has also afforded us
an opportunity of becoming acquainted with the
methods of teaching, and also of estirhating by the
results the satisfactory character of the adminis-
tration of the school. It is very gratifying to hear
so encouraging a report of its success, to know
that the school is steadily increasing in public
confidence, and that within the last three or four
yearsits numbers have nearly doubled. — (Applause.)
This is a subject for congratulation, not only to
the teachers and the taught, but to the community
of 'Falmouth generally, and especially to the
parents and friends, who must naturally feel a
deep sense of obligation to the accomplished lady
and her colleagues, whose earnest, increasing, and
skilful labours have contributed so largely to
develop its present high state of eflSoiency to infuse
confidence into all who are interested in its welfare
and to justify the anticipation of still further
success. I observe that, notwithstanding its com-
paratively recent establishment, the school has
given marked evidence of its capabilities, Students
are prepared for the Cambridge local examinations,
and some have already passed the higher local with
honours. Till now, outside examiners have not
examined except in drawing, when the results were
most creditable but it is to be hoped that as the
;

school continues to prosper, and as time goes on,

similar tests will be applied in other subjects with
—
equally satisfactory results. (Hear, hear ) Respect-
ing what may be anticipated from the teaching
here as regards higher education, it is interesting
to note that one student has already gone on to
Newnham. and others to training colleges. The
school is still in its infancy, but this is sufficient
to show that it promises, under favouring auspices
such as those now existing, to develop a vigorous
maturity. Indeed, in all respects, I think it may
be regarded most hopefully, for whilst it is well
equipped in all that should ensure success
in moral and intellectual training to possess
remarkable advantages in its healthy and
picturesque position and surroundings, well
planned architectural and sanitary arrangements
and mild and singularly equable climate, which
seems to render it specially well-suited for children
or young persons who, from one or other cause of
delicacy or weakness, may dread and seek to avoid
the rigour of the usual winter of other parts of our
island. The curriculum shows that education in
its truest sense is aimed at rather than the
accumulation of specific facts in various depart-
ments of knowledge, which, however useful they
may be in themselves, are of little value as means
of disciplining the mind, or of giving general
culture and preparing the recipient for the duties
and emergencies of life. The training indeed con-
templates not only the cultivation of the mental
faculties and the higher education which in these
days is rightly conceived to be necessary to put
the girls to perform the duties incidental to any
of the walks of life which are now open to women
and in which the sexgs alike are concerned, but
also those more homely and domestic subjects, such
 —
as needlework and cookery and the various accoin-
plishmente.aB music and drawing, which give charm
and interest to life and social existeuce.-( Applause).
Let me now say a few words to the junior portion
of my audience, who indeed are chiefly concerned
in the proceedings of this afternoon. Lady Fayrer
bids lie to say to you how heartily she congratulates
you on the result of your last year's work and on
the prieea which several of you have won.
(Applause.) To those who have not been successful
in prize-winning I would say, do not be in the
least discouraged, renew your efforts you may and
;

probably will win next time, and the want of success

on this occasion may do good by inciting to renewed
efforts, to seif-examination and the recognition
and correction of defects which may have stood^ in
your way. I hope it is not necessary to remind
you vvho have won prizes that they should not
render you over confident, or impress you with an
undue notion of superiority, or induce any
relaxation in efforts to advance but rather, on the
;

other hand, to act as incentives to continued

exertion. Do not suppose for a moment that I
undervalue your efforts. On the contrary, I
entirely sympathise with and approve of them, and
regard the winner of a prize in open competition
as a subject for legitimate pride and congratulation.
But remember the growth and development of your
intellectual, moral, and religious life is far more
important than the anxious struggle to be first.
The chief aim of education is not simply winning
prizes or gaining a high place in one or other
special subject, but the cultivation of all the
faculties that make for a high moral and
intellectual standard. This can only be attained
by striving to do your best always and in all
things, not only in your work here at school, but
at home, and in time to come, when you have to
enter on the duties of later life, whatever
conditions that life may assume. In any case let
the ideal yon aim at be a high one keep your ;

thoughts steadily on that object, and though you

may not attain all to which you may aspire, you
will in so doing surely fulfil the purpose which
should be the aim of all English women of
refineipent and culture.— (Applause.)
On the motion of the chairman, Sjr Joseph
Fayrer, and Lady Fayrer were thanked, and in
reply Sir Joseph congratulated the pupils on their
performance, which reflected the highest credit
alike .on students and teachers. During the
afterngon Lady Fayrer and Miss Todd were the
recipients of choice bouquets from the teachers
and students.
 —

The following appreciation of Dr. Macnamara is from the

pen of his old friend and colleague, Sir Joseph Fayrer ;

“In The Lancet of March llth I read with great

regret a short paragraph announcing the death of Dr. F. N.
Macnamara of the Bengal Medical Service. I little thought
when quite recently I stood by his side at the grave of our
mutual friend and colleague, Samuel Bowen Partridge, that
we should so soon have to deplore the loss of this eminent
medical oflScer, one whose whole life claimed the admiration
of his numerous friends and brother officers and who through
a long and distinguished career had rendered services of
the greatest importance to the country and people in and
among whom his useful life had for so many years been
spent. The value of these services, though as unostentatiously
as earnestly rendered, was thoroughly appreciated though
they never that I am aware of received the public recognition
they merited, yet they will long be gratefully remembered
by the students and Dr. Macnamara’s colleagues in the
Medical College of Calcutta of which he was so brilliant an
ornament, as by all to whom his noble personal character
and courteous bearing endeared him. These services, of
the greatest scientific importance, were not limited to
India, for on his retirement some years ago he was appointed '

a member of a committee to inquire into and regulate

the supply of drugs and medical stores to India and as
a result of that inquiry he was appointed by the Secretary
of State to supervise the administration of a new department
which has worked most satisfactorily and beneficially both
to the Government and India and well merits recognition
of its importance and value. As an old friend and
colleague as well as an admirer of his valuable services I
desire to pay this brief tribute to his memory.”

Q 9
 <

k ;
is

i
Speech at the Adult school at Falmouth March 27 1899

It was with much pleasure that I accepted

«

an invitaion to preside at this meeting of the Adult

School, for being much interested in all that concerns

the welfare of Falmouth, I am naturally so in matters

relating to education here.

f f

My good friends and boatmen, William Hodge

j K.‘

and G-eorge Sheaf f, to whom I an indebted for much good

service and interest ing:,-informat ion of a local and

. i7‘.:
'
’ d - ‘
S
technical nature, and whose sterling qualities entitle

them to general confidence and respect, made me ac-

i . 0: W I .

quainted with the existence of this excellent school

'
d A '
1 ,
^
i

in which I ’an glad to know that George Sheaf f, who

%

has been decorated for his gallantry in saving life

j. •
j dt
at sea, holds a post of trust. He it was who sugges-

ted that I should visit the school and see for myself
what it is doing.

To this I had great pleasure in assenting,

and being favoured by an invitation from Mr. G.H.

Fox to preside at this meeting, I was glad thus to

have an opportunity of shewing my appreciation of the
-on
Institution and of the honour conferred on me. I

can well imagine that its prosperity is assured when

it is under the aegis of so earnest and so true a

'j'
<r
to
friend to Falmouth, especially when he is suppor-

ted by such colleagues and benefactors as Mr. Rogers

:..l- p 1
Mr Downing and other influential friends. A visit

to the school entirely confirmed the high opinion

I had been led to form of it.

’
I learn from your excellent^ secretary, Mr.
....

Downing, that the school, established in 1884, has

now 115 Members with an average attendance of 50 ,

-
'
. 1 "•'X .lij
‘
no;
I wish the latter figure were a little largerl At
^ :o . X 9 Jn:
i '
;

a meeting held last November, the Chairman in an

•

'il J‘* dr f-- r , 'nu - .-

interesting speech, stated that in addition to the
-or .j. * ce r nne;,,. -1;

above, everything possible was done to make the

or oiiO lr#r)A‘ el v -rl ..iv 1 ; . . .
.

meeting pleasant on Sundays as well as on weekdays, t

that the social meetings on Tuesdays were well

J. :;.f ‘Ol '

attended and that the library was a great help, es-

^
Ji “'T .I'k; 1 ;

pecially to the young men who were never too old to

8 .> : :>Oii0 8 Oiiw tied •
pli.' • i T
learn, and that the reading of good books kept alive

in them the grand thoughts of great men. He allu-

ded also to a sick benefit fund, a Savings bank and

other advantages which are of much value to the In-

stitution. Encouraging remarks were made hy other

u V 0 i
i.

influential members, giving a verj'- satisfactory ac-

count of the state of the school.

Mr Downing has been so kind, moreover, as to

*
it' ; -'t
'
'
i •
‘ i

explain to me the nature, plan and objects of

the
school, as well as the prograinine of work and the '
•

1. -n ‘

-’t

methods adopted for extending its utility and for

fulfilling its purpose, which appears to be that of

improving the general and religious education, and

imparting sueh knowledge as may be useful in various

ways especially to those who may have been debarred

by circumstances from availing themselves in early

life of an ordinary education; and it.. is satisfac-

tory to learn thai this is appreciated arid taken

advantage of, though one would be glad to know that

the number of those who avail themselves of that

'

j.

privilege were increasing.

tr dSuch an Institution conducted on sound

principles and carried on under such favourable

auspices must confer an inestimable boon on many,

and there- is reason to believe that these measures,

here and elsewhere, for enabling those who have

lacked opportunity of education in early life, of

making, up for lost time, are valued and utilised,

and are gradually telling on the social condition

and life of the people, and it is pleasant to have

reason to believe that it is so, for in the compe-

tit ion which now obtains everywhere our nation

cannot afford to fall behind others.

 .

Nothing is more remarkable in the present

age that the progress made in the general education,

or more calculated to increase the happiness and

prosperity of the nation. /jnong other subjects

for congratulation offered to our beloved Q^ueen on

the completion of the 60th year of her auspicious

reign, fe'J7 could have been more gratifying than

the general spread of education among her people,

which is such as to give stability to her rule, and

increase the happiness and prosperity of her sub-

jects; and let it be remembered that the general

diffusion of knowledge not only tends to advance

the moral and^ intellectual status, but that it is

improving the physical health and the value and

duration of life of the popualtion, by teaching the

^

importance of observing those rules of living on

which physical, and consequently, moral health

depend

The Rev. J. Hocking remarks "Three-

fourths of the sickness and ailments and weaknesses

of the world are wastes and burdens - to the suffer-

ers and to society, that need not be'.' I myself said

some years ago, and the words hold good now, "If

the people could be taught to believe in the effi-

cacy of pure air, pure water, cleanly dwellings

 could
temperate habits, proper food and clathing, and
and if
be induced to make efforts to secure them;
as
they could be taught to regard infective diseases
disre-
the scourge of uncleanliness and of their own

gard of the simple lav/s of health . . . the result

would be, not only greater usefulness and happiness

but better health and the saving of money. Preven-

table diseases, the result of insanitary conditions^-

still kill 140,000 yearly; '

and, considering the large

number of cases of illness for each death, it has

been calculated that 78 million f iv’eshundred thcru-

sand d<ays of labour are lost in this country annually,

. which represents a loss in money o‘f seven millions

seven hundred and seventy-five thousand pounds per

year.

Le^t me congratulate you 'on having such a

school and urge yo'i - especially the young men of

defective education -'strongly, to avail yourselves

of the advantages it holds out. You may not now

appreciate, perhaps, its value, but depend on it,

you will do sooner or later. Think of what it

might have done for many who never had such oppor-
I

tunities, and yet did well by their own efforts.

T can remember well when they hardly existed.

flow much has been done and can be done

life was with writing and with books, but men the bus

business of whose life was with tools and inachinery ,

”

He then goes on to illustrate this by describing some

of the prize-winners. "There is a pieper at mule-

frames, who could not read at IB, who is now arith-

metic teacher in the Institution in which he himself

was taught, who writes of himself that he made the re

solution never to take up a subject without keeping

to it, and who has kept to it with such an astound-

ing will that he is nov^ well versed in Euclid and

Algebra, and is the best French scholar at Stock-

port." Among the delegates from the local socie-

ties there was a man "who >worked when he,^was a mere

baby at a hand-loom; who began to teach himself

as soon as he could earn 5s a week; who is now a
botanist acquainted with every production of the Lan-

cashire valley; who is a Naturalist, and has made

and preserved a collection of the eggs of British

birds and stuffed the birds; who is also a conchol-

ogist , *and with a vei^y curious and in some respects
an original collection of fresh-water shells, and

has also preserved and collected the mosses of fresh

water and the sea; who is worthily the President of

his own local Literary* Institution, and who was at

work this time last night as foreman in a mill."

 With this great writer I am sure you will

all agree, and you will feel what gratification it

7/ould afford him and others of his way of thinking

had they had the opportunity of witnessing such Insti-

tutions as this, Institutions which are the outcome

of the necessities of the age and the demand for know-

ledge that is inherent in the people. •

You will see

the bearing of it upon yourselves; it emphasizes the

principle that success will depend rather upon your

>

own personal exertions, than upbh' tour environmentt.5

though these 'persona:! exertions, when aided by such

means as are now placed at the disposal of the stu-

dehty must render the accomplishment of his purpose

more certain and complete, whilst at the same time

it will be satisfactory to feel that its benefits are

not limited to any one class, but that it extends to

ail who are ready and willing to receive theiri. Accept

I

your great advantages thankfully and avail yourselves^

of them fully. So train yourselves that yon may

inspire all with whom you come in contact with con-

fidence in your capability and respect for such

Institutions as this.

I think I ought not to detain you longer fro

from your entertainment . It only remains for me to

wish you much success in your future studies and in

tha walk of life to which they may lead you, and to

hope that you will in the future look back with gra-

lilude to the school which helped to equip *you with

means of maintaining - I trust with success - the

struggle for existence which is daily becoming harder

in this great ever-increasing population, whether at

homo or in our colonies , to whose development it may

fall to the lot of some of you toi contribute.

’ I must- now conclude these brief remarks by
remindingoyou - and you can never be -.told it too em-
phatically or too often - „that- whatever else you may
learn, you should oremember the words of r the Patriarch

of Uz, "Behold the fear of the Lord that is wisdom,

II

and to depart from evil is understanding.

^ '.-Kix tj: -
t-,. .
V. ^
.

9v tco *
'-s k-. •••*
;

.u 'vr bfio / vfv':. : c ._=

107 . V i O ^ 00 V- M ‘
.. "o
*' oo : •
... j .1 -j .i; Oi. ,y:: , q-; , ; ^
hjf .‘^r

''7 j v'/
.
-j ; j £{• j ,
•
.
’
_
 i

4.
 CASTLE-DOUGLAS
COTTAGE HOSPITAL.
THE OPENING CEREMONY.
SPEECH BY SIR JOSEPH FAYRER.
Sir Joseph Fajrer, who was accorded a very like the quality of mercy, it is twice
hearty reception, said it gave him great pleasure ‘it blesseth lum that gives, and him that
takes,
giving to
to be permitted to take part in the proceedings of They might q^uestion the e.vpedieiicy ot
that meeting, and assist on, that interesting occa^some of the objects good enough in themselves — but he
sion of the inauguration of an institution which submitted to them as worthy of support,
was calculated to be of so much benefit to the thought he was not wrong in saying that no mis-
people of this district. (Applause.) He had to giving need either stint or limit nieir generosity
congratulate the founders and supporters of the i'^re. Let thein hope that the patriotic and
p^hil-

^ TT anthropic spirit which had so often e.xpressed it-

Cottage Hospital— especially Mr Graham Hutchi-ggjj.
ii. j. 1 • 11
public eharity in the Stewartry,
son—on the success which had. so far, attended dispose the well-to-do to give of their
thei^r philanthropic efforts, and most cordially towards the permanent endowment of
wished them a continuance of it in the tuture. It^^^ institution which beyond question would merit
was a most signifi^nt step in the social develop-
gu „rt. (Applause.) The first cottage hos-
ment of this neighbourhood, one which demanded established by Mr Napper, surgeon, at
and deserved alike admiration approval and sup- {:;ranleigh, in 1855. It began in a cottage adapted
port for It must have beneficial results of the for the purpose, had 6 beds, and each patient paid
most important character to the cornmunity of After a beginning was once
the neigh bournooQ, whilst the reiiei
neighbourhood, relief it w'ouldwoiim j L „ weekly.
„ areneral. and a further
became general,
f -Lpcaine
certainly afford to suffering humanity would g^bniilus was given it by the Queen's Jubilee, until
amply recompense its originaiors tor the labour fbe year 1892 there were 215 in England, 15 in
and expenditure it had entailed. Hospitals,
Scotland. 14 in Wales, and 3 in Irelancl. He could
whether large or small, now so numerous in our
bow many had been founded since, but
islands, were standing proofs of the vitality of bo bugV there had 'been seven, and he knew there
that spirit of philanthropy which was the ^sis bo^j been one added that day. Apparently none
on which Christianity itself was founded, had less than 4 beds, while some had as many as
this spirit perrneated society generally was shown ^ 2 in which case the term cottage hospital seemed
^

by the progressive increase of such institutions as j^gg jfg significance. (Laughter.) Most cottage
hospitals were for severe surgical and medical
w juld have to rencrt to Egypf 4000 y^rs a^, gJ^ggg^ though there were a few for infectious
7 I

later to Greece, Rc me, and so downwards to the diseases, and a few were special and for children,
crusades and through the iniddle ages, when they bnf children might well be admitted to all. As
associated with religious in- finance, Mr vacher, an English surgeon, in a
stitutions; but this would be impossible on the p^pcj. read at the Chicago Congress in 1893, said
present occasion. If they took up the thread of
^bat whilst most were dependent on voluntary
their history about the period of the Reformation contributions or endowments, a few were wholly
it would bring them to the time when hospitals supported by local rates, and nearly all
began to exist ^separate fro™, independent charged for the maintenance of the patients, gen-
of, though quite in sympathy with, the Church, gj.gUy from 2s 6d to lOs weekly. It was well, he
and it was then they would find the great en- gJ^icb that half the income should be derived from
dowed hospitals beginiung to perform their irn- jQcal subscriptions, in order to keep up interest
portant services to suffering humanRy. Jo^t R ^bg hospital, and a well-managed one should
was not till a much later period that they saw h Lf w get about two-thirds of its X- 4- 4-
i4-ei
income from
T YiirxTVi
r\ 4"
thisa
T

institution of the greater number of the existing

church collections, and the like might
hospitals in Great Britain, which, whether as
bg looked to to supply about one-third of the
receptacles of the sick, or as medical schools, had remainder, leaving the balance to be obtained
played a part of ever mcreasing national imporL otherwise, by patients' fees, or by interest from
ance. It was within the Victorian age that they capital. It had been found that cottage hos-
had attained fheir present ^eat development, large or small, could be maintained at a
and had become the seat of scientific med ca p^^. b^j provided, or ,£66 per bed
education in connection with their coll ..^es and Qccupied. He merely mentioned this as an indica-
universities, as well as of the treatment ot a vast what they cost elsewhere; it might be a
amount of disease, thus confernng benem on aU, gyjfie fo them here. Whether the hospital was
by educating the physici^, curing the sick. It was
adapted building or a new one, there were
characteristic of the public spint and mdepend- ngceggary conditions to be provided for. The
ence of our nation that, with the ® site should be in a raised, well-drained locality;
hospitals, such J there should be a free and full supply of pure
water, fresh air, and sunlight. The wards should
military hospitals, and those in which ® have a surface space of not less than. 90 square
infectious disease was treated-— which were s g^^^b patient, and a minimum cubic space
what like the Lazar houses of earner days a ggg (which should be doubled for infectious
which were supported by local rates, that t e g^^ggg ^ben admitted), with a free ingress and
vast mass of hospitals and d^pensaries egress of air.
.
A certain part of the buildings of
to private charity, owing nothing for their ‘
every hospital should be devoted to administra-
^,® ™^^®?
f ronviin tivo' purposes in addition to the wards there
;

differed from i
p „j should be .a reception room, bath room, operating
this period also lhE>t, ®°^*^®°®,.^®®P
g t room, dispensary, matron's sitting-room, two bed-
.

arisen, and since the ^®®®sniation ot i

j.QQjjjg^ ^ mortuary outside the building, kitchen,
^

store room. and proper conveniences detached

till they had now come to be '
from, though connected with, the main buildings,
pensable institutions, provinn -pr„ whilst no drains should pass under the house.
i It
unmitigated blessings •
might not be possible to obtain all this at once,
could ^rdly conceive of any form but such was the. ideal which should be aimed at
deserving ot the sympathy a s pi
,v _ as means iiermitted. and this they had here, for
community among \vdiich it P,, .
, this hospital had the advantage of having been
hospital; disease aiul i , constructed on modern principles for the pnr-
ditions of its ministry, it ^
Vmnpstv of Poses for which it was intended, and the arrange-
ff

misgivings ®0"®®i‘:”''S,|^®® about administration, patients' nursing,

its clients cause, ^ 1 '

V'
L- medical attendance, seemed to be all that
fats, without stmt or scrap e, to |men ot every „„gj.v
.

be desired. (Applause.) It was to be

country, and party, b
‘
religion, and to ineu or no religion at^ all. Ami, hojied, a.s time advanced, that means would in-
’a,,,i »
crpase, that those who contributed now
would
continuo <o do so, that others might follow their
example, and contribute toivards its endowment
as they believed indeed they would, for everyone
must tool that he had a personal interest in such
an institution, and thus enable them not only to
obviate the possibility of failure, but to enlarge
their sphere of operations. It was very satisfac-
tory to know that they were making such a good
hospital could be extended, and
thati the basis upon which their future action
was
proceed was of so sound a nature. (Applause.)
^
He thought it would be their wish that he should
h®t® publicly express their acknowledgments to
1.
Hutchison for the important part
tiiat lie had taken in the foundation
and com-
pletion of the hospital. No nne could read
its
history without feelinpf that to his influence, liber-
ahty, and unwearying labours, the initiation and
success of this most public-spirited and excellent
design was mainly due. (Applause.) It remained
only tor him to express the hope that this cottage
hospital, which commenced its operations that
day under such favourable auspices, would, like
its cnngeners elsewhere, prove as great
a boon
and blessing to the population as they had done,
tby it would fulfill the purpose for which it was
instituted, viz., the commemoration of the Dia-
mond .Jubilee of their beloved Queen, and the
wed-being of the people of this beautiful county
so full of historic interest, in which it was placed
He had now formalllv to declare the Castle-
Douglas Cottage Hospital open. (Applause.)
 :

iOtiituarp

ALEXANDER GRANT, F.R.O.S.Edin.,

SurKeon-Maior Bengal Army (retired), Honorary Surgeon to Her Majesty
the Queen.
Surgeon-Majob Alexander Grant died in London on Jan-
uary 3rd at the age of 82. He entered the Indian
Mediow
Service in 1840, landed in India in April, 1841, was appointed
to join th*
to Her Majesty’s 55th Foot, and went with them
expeditionary force in China, when his ship was exposed to
severe hurricanes oflf Hong Kong he was present at the cap-
;

ture of Amoy, the capture of Tinghai, Chusan, and

accom-
panied the regiment in pursuit of the enemy to Sm-kea-mun.
In 1842 he joined headquarters at Ohinhae, was present at
the attempt to take the city by surprise, and at the capture
of Chapoo. He was present at the storming of
the batteries
of Woosung, at the capture of Shanghai and
Chin-mang-fo<L
He was placed in charge of cholera cases of the 49th Foot, and
then served with Lord Saltoun’s brigade at Nankin, both
duties involving heavy work as sickness was very prevalent.
At the conclusion of peace, he returned to Chusan, and
mained therewith the 55th Foot during 1843. In 1844 be
^
proceeded to Hong Kong, where he took leave m the 5^b
regiment which was returning to England, when Dr. Shanks,
the
the surgeon to the regiment, paid the following tribute to
value of his services. ^
I cannot allow Mr. Grant to depart without
expressing to him the deep
sense of obligsition I am under to him for the very valuable profM^Ml
assistance he has rendered me on all occasions, and I
cannot
record the high opinion I entertain of Mr. Grant s merits
than by amm-
service in vanous quarters of the
ing that during a long course of active
officers I have ever met
globe, I consider him one of the very best medical

^He was then placed in charge of a wing of the 98th Foot at

Victoria, Hong Kmg, and subsequently ordered to MadrM
with the 41st Madras Native Infantry. He returned to
Calcutta and was sent on special duty to Madras and Bombay.
In 1845 he was appointed Civil Surgeon of Bhagulpore,
ordered thence in 1846 to join the army of the Sutlej on the
outbreak of the ist Sikh war, and encountered great hard^ipa
on the march. He was attached to the Field Hospital, Fero-
zepore, until the conclusion of the war, when he
returned to
Bhagulpore, where he remained till his appointment in 184S
as Civil Surgeon of Chapprah. He was
ordered thence on
special duty to the North-West Provinces by the
Governor-
General, Lord Dalhousie, who wrote to him as follows :

recommended
No medical officer in the service has been more strongly benefit of your
than yourself, and I am truly desirous of obtaining the
services and your skill. . . . y-t i

In 1849 he was appointed Surgeon to the Governor- General,

Lord Dalhousie, which office he held for seven years, accom-
panying him in his various tours through different parts
to the
India, Ceylon, andBurmah. He was appointed Secretary
Medical Board, Calcutta, in 1852, and promoted to Surgeon m
In 1856 he prepared for the Governor-General a digest
of all
of the Indiw
that had been written about the reorgani^tion
Medical Services, and sketched a plan which was adopted by
Lord Dalhousie and formed the basis of that memorable de-
liber^
spatch to the Court of Directors, which was the first
enlightened acknowledgment of the claims of medical
and
officers by any English statesman. The
same y^r he wa«
gazetted Presidency Surgeon and Surgeon to the
Presidency
General Hospital, the most coveted of Calcutta apjraintments.
The following is an extract from the minute of Council on
the occasion of that appointment
founded on service
The claims of Mr. Grant to this coveted appointment,
Department, on his personal
in the field, on his standing in the Medical
character and professional reputation, will be questioned by
none. I re-
joice, before departure, to have an opportunity by the nomination of
my
Mr 6rant to thisoffice, of placing the future charge of the (General Hos-
pital in most capable hands, and at the same
time of evincing my own
deep sense of the ability and skill and sedulous care which have
characterised his attendance for more than seven years on my family and
myself.
In the meantime he accompanied Lord Dalhousie, who was
in failing health, to England, and when there was examined
respecting the Indian Medical Service by the Parliamentary
Committee. On taking leave of Lord Dalhousie he received
from him a touching letter. He then, era route to India,
 visited the chief hospitals in Europe. In 1857 Grant was ap-
pointed by the Governor- General to be Apothecary-General
and Opium Examiner to the Government of India also :

Member of the Senate of the University of Ca'cutta, and

Government Examiner in the Medical College, In 1858 he
was elected President of the Faculty of Medicine, and its
representative on the Syndicate of the University. In 1859
he was thanked by the Governor- General in Council for hia
valuable services during the period of the Mutiny in making
provision of medical stores for the army in the Held, and by
the Secretary of State in the following year for the same
services. As Apothecary- General he compiled a code of rules
for the Medical Store Department which was adopted by
Government. In i86i he proceeded to England on medical
leave, was offered a dinner by his boother officers which he
was compelled by failing health to decline, and subsequently
was presented by them with a service of plate. He retired as
Surgeon-Major.
Mr. Grant made many valuable contributions to Indian
medical literatur*^ among which may be mentioned. Medical
Sketches of the Expedition to China (^Medical and Physical
Journal 0/ Bengal, 1845); Diary of Chinese Agriculture, with
illustrations (^Transactions of the Agri-horticultural Society of
Bengal, 1845). He founded in 1853 the Indian Annals of Medi-
cal Science, and was, till he left India, its joint editor with Dr.
Chevers. He contributed to it the following papers On Hill :

Dia^hoea and Dysentery, with some account of Himalayan

Sanitaria, 1853; Note on the Preparation of the Bael Fruit,
1854; The Hill Stations, Murree, its Topography and Medical
History, 1861 Fragments of the Medical Practice in Calcutta
;

at the close of the last Century, ist Fever, 2nd Dysentery.

These papers owe their value to the fact that they were not
only lucid in style and sound in theory, but eminently prac-
tical, thus reflecting the mind and character of the author.
The foregoing brief epitome gives but an imperfect idea of
the Indian career and services of one of the most distinguished
members of the Bengal Medical Service, whose name will long
be remembered in India, especially by his brother officers of
the Medical Service, for whose benefit he laboured so
strenuously. His professional and personal character inspired
respect and affection in all who knew him, whilst his unselfish
nature, his unquestioned ability, and his calm and dis-
passionate judgment impressed all, whether in official or
private life, with a strong sense of his value as a public
servant. To his friends he endeared himself by the genuine
truth of his friendship, his modest appreciation of his own
meritSj and his generous recognition of all that was good and
deserving of praise in others.
Mr. Grant was educated at Glasgow and Edinburgh, and
became a Licentiate and subsequently a Fellow of the College
of Surgeons of Edinburgh. He held many important posi-
tions in India, and distinguished himself alike in the military,
administrative, and civil branches of the service. He occu-
pied for about seven years the post of Surgeon to the Governor-
General, Lord Dalhousie, perhaps one of the greatest Governor-
Generals that ever ruled over India and it is well known how
;

wisely the large influence he exercised over that nobleman

was exerted on behalf, not only of his own service, but of all
that was deserving of support or commendation. It cannot be
doubted that to his influence and advice are mainly due the
recognition of and improvements in the Indian Medical Ser-
vice which resulted from the memorable despatch of Lord
Dalhousie in 1856.
Mr. Grant’s life was a long and useful one, and its utility by
no means came to an end when he left India for after his;

return to England he still continued to serve the public in

many ways, and especially in connection with the distribu-
tion of the Indian Mutiny Fund, whilst his interest in the
Service he himself had adorned never slackened.
The only public honour he received, except war medals, was
that of being made Honorary Surgeon to the Queen. Had
his career in India been prolonged, it is certain that he must
have received other honorary distinctions.
Mr. Grant did not marry, but lived always with his sister,
whose devotion to the end was unfailing, and for whom his
many friends feel the profoundest sympathy.
His life was one of honour and distinction, and it terminated
mourned by “ troops of friends.”
J. Fayrkr.

Reprinted from the British Medical Journal, January 13th, 1900.

 ' ,

<2 , I i*~cy

SCIENCE AND ART AT

FALMOUTH.
t»RlZE distribution by sir JOSEPH
FAYRhiR.
After distributing the prizes and certificates
system of drainage, which should be equally practicable in
Sir Joseph Fayrer, speaking of the virtues of Falmouth
» place with such natural advantages as Falmouth had,
as a winter resort, said :AVhether they regarded that but the main sewage outfall should bo removed to a
charming and genial port of the South of England from greater distance, thus preventing tlie accumulation of
the point of view of a seaport, with a magnificent harbour deposits offensive alike to sight and smell, and so often
— now, alas comparatively neglected or of a valuable
!
— perceptible, jjaiticulavly at low tides, on the foreshore. Of
course, such improvements could not be carrie<l out
place of residence, with great latent jwssibilities only
immediately, nor without considerable e:;pense, but their
needing development, it was to the results of the training realisation must inevitably tend to the future prosperity of
afforded by science, art, and technical schools that they might that picturesque and beautiful seaport. Eet him urge the
’

look, in one direction at least, for impulses which should absolute necessity of giving practical effect to these reforms,
give impetus and continuity to further advance in working
for without them, whatever they cost, and whatever efforts
might be made in other directions, no ultim.ite success
out that which would enable Falmoutfa to fulfil purposes
would accrue. Difficulties might stand in the way,'but they
for which by nature it was so admirably designed. were only such as had existed and been dealt with satis-
Although one might not feci justified in anticipating iactorily in places less favoured by nature than Falmouth,
bet it be hoped that the spirit of jirogrcss and
iny great revival of the shipping and commercial pros- enterprise
would be no less potent here than it had been elsewhere
perity, everything jointed the direction of The inhabitants might rest assured that the money ex-
that for which nature had so admirably designed Fal- pended on it would be a sound investment and certain of
mouth, a health resort of undoubted m.erit, which might
;
Its reward. (Hear, hear.) He went on to express his
oe favourably contrasted with places abroad, now so latistaction at the fact that the State, while recognising
^

;he necessity of technical instiucticn, did not intend to

popular. Projecting thought into a
not very distant neglect preliminary training, and realised that technical
future, one liked to picture Falmouth as a beautiful health
I sducation was best assimilated by those who had had a good
resort, with all the natural advantages of its situation slementary education of the ordinary character ; that, in
developed to their utmost extent by a wise exercise of that ihort, it was only desirable that the individual should’ be
artistic spirit for which it was well known, and which had '
sompetent in the mechanical jirocedure of his
already received so powerful an impetus from the genius ndustry, but that he should be sufficiently taught before-
of such masters as Hemy, Tuke, and Ingram, whose hand to enable him to understand the scientific principles
impulses were doubtless quickened by the natural beauties upon which it was based. Our country now abounded in
that surrounded them.but whose feelings, one feared,must technical and science schools of various grades and condi-
be more or less jarred at, times by the marring of tions, which were tending necessarily to elevate the
those beauties by the hand of inartistic man. people and to place and keep them upon an equality with
Houses ather nations by whom the importance of such training
should be built with some regard for symmetry and
architectural beauty, so piaoed as to add to the natural bad been hitherto more fully recognised. Competition
advantages rather than detract from them, as they did in was keen among the nations of Europe, and if Great
many cases now, dotted about, as they were, promiscu- Britain wa.s to maintain the position to which she was
ously here and there, rega rdless of proportion and the sonsidered to be entitled her people could not afford to let
future aesthetic development, comfort, and well-being of
\
her drop behind in the race for knowledge ; especially
the place That school was practically limited to science 4hould the British be careful leat they be overpassed by
and art. The technical aide needed development if it was those whom they should least have expected to excel.
to take part, as it should do, in aiding the town to assume His own professional instincts reminded him that some
ihat position for whion aiature had designed it. part of the teaching in this school bore upon the simple
As surely , „
and ,
elementary
i ,
rules upon which public health depended
i s
IS he anticipated a great future for Falmouth so surelv • dependei
did be feel convinced that if men required to carry out the ’
“Such subjects, for example, as house building, chemistry
work on the best lines were not forthcoming locally! |'ke to add plumbing,
ihey would bo procured *he people could be taught to believe in the elficacy ol
elsewhere, to the!
detriment ol inhabitants. In urging the c airns of I
' o'eanly habits, proper food and cloth
*^® ™*'^ke efforts to secure
the technical side. Jet them not sujjpose that h^p 1
these
andervalued the scientific teaching. That was most im taught to regard infective diseases as the scourge ol
im-
uncleaidiiiess and of their own disiegaid of the .simple law;
portant, not only from a general point of view, but
tspecially so with regard to sanitation— a subject of great of health, the result would be not only greater usefulness
lignificance to Falmouth at the present time— with wl ich
and happiness, but better health, prolonged life, and the
ihe technique of plumbing, architecture, and house biiild-
saving of money. Preventible diseases killed many
ng was so much concerned, and which was the fumla- thousands yearly, and considering the laige number of
nental basis of the prosperity of every place, whatever oases of illness for each death, it had been calculated that
ts natuial advantages might be. AVitli reference to
some millions of days of labour were lost in this country
water supply and drainage, the most important elements annually, which, of caurse, represented a corresponding
loss in money. Knowledge diffused among the people bv
In sanitation, Falmouth possessed great advantages, only
this class of school must gradually tend to mitigate
seeding recognition and development. Fot only’ must sue!
conditions, to obviate the wasteful expenditure of healtt
there be sufficiency of the water supjfiy, about
which there should he no difficulty, and life, and to promote not only the moral and social, bul
and of the
purity of which there could be no suspicion, and a perfect the physical welfare of the people. (Applause.)
THE HILL STATIONS OF INDIA
AS

HEALTH RESORTS.

An Address delivered to the Balneological and Climatological Society.

May 80th, 1900.

BY

Sir .JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I.,

M.D., P.E.S.

Reprinted from the British Medical Journal, June 9th, 1900.

LONDON
Printed at the Office of the British Medical Journal,
429, Strand, W.C.

I goo.
 a r -
’
...•'. T
! .

,
- - .'v -'rf .:,./;
’ ^ - /V' V
.

... .
V ,
-i'-

'
•‘- - J.. : -'
-•- ’’- ' *.. ' • : - •

^ - .
. .
-<v . i.
..
'

, •.• ...
•

r V,. -'“T,
'
i. ' .v':.. ",:.v

•
'fe'‘ -vT \ '•''’’v- g- -
;
.C'--',' '/V'

-' '.<'••."
V -'7^- i\‘ y^>": '-'.i-,:- .> :
.* '
.
,-g*< '.-• ... V 1 .
.
• •.- r . V "•
V •'- •••- .
- >’ •- ---i.
,

.V-: :, :•
,
. ..- .:

'•- '''V " V - *»’ '•'. 'V

•..' ' ' '

.
'
''
; v’ y ,:T
-
:
g’ t-' :' -
' '

,
; „i
.’
-'.y-'
.yj.' r\
r'
X--’..."
71 -. ^.,, -.‘-V'.
-, - ,r. ->
-Vt rr .,,
. ,
-
,
.

-'v' ,

\ s- .'g . .;
' g
-.--S',./'
•-
-
-;-
“ g
-
. -
• ' ''^
‘'T .'-v'--

; •-.- ...vy.g. 'r . -

-

g
'
g^ 5 '-

- .y
"
'
'1--

’
'

-gVgg.y-'--;'vgyvyr>A ,,y / -’
"
/ f ‘y-y-'^gy-i yy.:

:-yyy
••
V - V
, ,. , ...rJ -.• •• . r.
•• * V, > -v'-- --g.-. ..

.'

e':'iy^yyr'y;?^-^ >

.'V' -'g^ '

y-’ r’' -
K \
':'-
1
•’ ^ i^--' J,

r
c ," '
:‘-y
••'
'V.
r^'r - •• ' . ,
- .X —• ^ , .
.• -'- r-
W .
'

-
. , . ^.' 3
; .
X >
^ y -'g* g-,
-v .- j'.. . ' C-
J. g.' yv yyy-g.-g-.:- •>,- -. xc-y.g- / ,
g- r- ^ ^\ -
'y.yg''' - g'
g; : -‘gyv' :.- .

..,yg:yegg,gyy"vg.;:y'y-yg. ••y-.-cy yyy- y. •‘'i.y’Kvy:

yyyg^:^.yy y,-‘ V. \ y: ':y.'-,yyy;.y
'yy- -’y.-y'-y y-y-'v,; y
",
y-"- -y
-t-g-'y-
-y gyy.' /> y^y'yyyyy/- v:;,y'yyy.

“ y- " 'y
a" y« 'yy-yy:
.''y;yi;.--y:H :g v 'yg'^gy "av v yy:- ,:
;y'-^

AA
,

;-g ,y y^ A yy y y„ ^ g.
'

.;
y .: /y^rV;.; gy ';:>y ^"y . y y„ t-.

'y-yy-^y^yy'-y- .' -
-v >~.yy-'; :y:y^^y-yy^y' ::m
'yygi^.g,' '.g ‘ '
.v g.'yy.v.'Ag -sysvr'.'-'.ry-
'>'-.;A.,; ••
;
V*/ X '
/..y'- •
’.
• y • •
•-
'
^ '.A T. h* v •. ..
•
'.’•v.)^'y- ’

' :
-=. >* .

y- y-'y -/xy i“'-=g---y'.., a .g'-y'.-'' y- .-v

.

'..> “
_y :
-
;•-'
- .yy ;• -.

yy^iyy ^y-y'r y .>."',yA.yiy yyyy^-r^i^yy'-T'y-yy . a a^." :

y'y .yy- y'y^: gi^A-A'AAy' 'g

. vC'^^g'
'y "''y y'-'y -

. ^ 'y^y' y' yy‘ "yg y .- y " a '’

>,,

y-''-y^\y:"yy:K':'^'' y:^- "'y .y; y’y y

-
' V
'-
A A* ••.'.-
y - » ' v
yy :yV’ ..
- • : s. .• '

. .

x-"As^(;y' ,'. . , - . I ..

.A
'

.yyiygyV-:-
’•••
. x»
'.‘-
'AAgy
ggg>.g
y'V." y
AA,.;'a' y.y.' y
-c
'^
..
';A' V'-A-yy y; A-,
,

:'
^yy.-y A -o,-
•

a'" --.A,’ '".A

^
• .»

. y- A-A:.yg- ..A*.'-'. > • .

y.y'^
v''-

:
g-

'•'
X .-• '. -
.

K
.

g y
J.; .. A ' y'
THE HILL STATIONS OF INDIA AS
HEALTH RESORTS.
I TH,TNK I can hardly better fulfil the mandate of your
esteemed President, Dr. Ivor Murray, to give an address to
this Society than by inviting your attention to those moun-
tain regions which play so important a part in the social and
physical economy and well-being of our countrymen in India,
and which, under the designation of hill stations, are familiar,
by name at least, to all who have any knowledge of the con-
ditions of life in that country.

Possibilities of Acclimatisation.

I propose to consider them, not merely in reference to the

treatment of disease and convalescence, but also as resorts in
which the European may preserve his health and avoid the
physical deterioration which inevitably results from pro-
tracted residence in the plains, and where, indeed, it seems
even possible that he may take root, thrive and propagate his
race, a subject of ever-widening interest to our rapidly-
increasing population, and for which there are grounds for
belief that the prospects of success are not altogether unfavour-
able, though so far no conclusive proof is forthcoming. Past
history shows, however, that colonisation by the unmixed
European race in the plains of India is impracticable. In the
very rare instances in which the third generation has been
reached it had evidently attained its utmost desirable limits,
whilst of the Portuguese who preceded us, no descendant
unalloyed by native blood can be said to exist.

Physiography op the Indian Peninsula.

Before describing the hill stations let me recall to you
briefly some of the physiographical characters of the great
peninsula in which they are situated, and the climatic and
physical attributes which so largely influence the conditions
of European India.
life in
The geographical position of British India, part within the
torrid, part within, the temperate zone, with the Bay of Bengal
 :

on the east and the Arabian Sea on the west, its physical
characters, comprising lofty mountain ranges rising in the
north to the abodes of eternal snow, elevated plateaux and
deserts, noble rivers and estuaries, vast plains formed by their
basins and deltas, extensive forest tracts, jungles, and swamps
invest it with peculiar interest from climatic and hygienic
points of view, especially as regards the alien race who now
control its destinies and to whom its future development and
welfare seem to be committed.
India proper is a vast triangle with its apex at Cape Comorin
and its base in the Himalayas. Its extreme length is 1,900
miles, its breadth at the base about 2,000 miles. It is situated
between the 66th and 104th meridian of East longitude and
the 8th and 35th parallel of North latitude. It is over 1,250,000
square miles in extent, contained within a coast line of about
4,000 miles and a land boundary of over 5,000 miles. The
natural divisions are
1. The Himalayan and Sub- Himalayan
region.
2. The Indo-Gangetic basin and deltas.
3. The peninsula pi’oper formed by the elevated'plateau of the
Deccan
bounded on each side by the Ghauts and the littorals between them and
the ocean.
The Himalayan range extends for about 1,750 miles, cres-
centially,N.W. and S.E., with a breadth of from >50 to 250
miles. The mean height is from 16,000 to 20,000 feet, and
there are several high points, amongst them Kinchinjunga
28,176 feet, and Everest 29,002 feet, the highest measured
peak in the world. The Sub-Himalayan region consists of
ranges separated by broad valleys, bounded in part on the
south by the Siwalik range and the Terai. It is in the lower
ridges of this range of hills, at elevations up to 7,000 feet, that
many of the hill stations lie.
The Inio Gangetie plain or Hindostan proper which
separates the Himalayas from Southern India, forms the
richest and most populous parts of the empire.
The great
rivers Indus, Ganges, and Brahmaputra water this
region and
contribute to its formation.
Tropical or Peninsular India is bounded on the north
by the
Vindhyan system of hills, consisting of various ranges from
1,500 to 4,000 feet, which extend for nearly 800
miles from east
to west, and indude also the Aravalli,
Kaimoor, Satpura, and
other ranges. The Eastern Ghauts form
rather a descent
littoral than a distinct mountain
range. They extend along part of the
east coast with an
average elevation of 1,500 feet and occasional
high peaks, with
ground between them and the ocean,
ihe Western Ghauts extend from near the Tapti
river on the
^8 own tlie coast to Cape Comorin, with an average height
<-0 between 4,000 and 5,000 feetfas
fit Mahableshwar.
at Between these three ranges the peninsula
IS raised into the plateau of
the Deccan. It has an
3.000 feet, a region of open valleys
isolated peaks here and there, and
raimes^of ’ the most important are the Nilgiris,
whose
wboflP highestf point is
Dodabetta, 8,760 feet.
great slopes of drainage, into the Bay of
Benpn^i^ n^n®+b'^®
®“® Arabian Sea on the other.
TW® B f
receives the Ganges, Brahmaputra,
MahaJartdi
^^“'''‘'ry, and others, whilst
the Arabian ^ "^«c«*ves the Indus, Nerbudda, Tapti, and
some Sheri
 3

Climate and Seasons.

These geographical and physical characters involve many
varieties of climate, and between Northern and Tropical
India, according to latitude, elevation, and other physical
attributes, every degree of difference in temperature,
humidity, or dryness is found.
There are three distinct seasons in India— the hot, the
—
rainy, and the cold which vary in time of setting in and in
duration according to latitude, elevation, and other physical
conditions. Approximately the cold season extends from
November to March, the hot from March to June or July, and
the rainy from that to October, these seasons being greatly
influenced by the monsoons.
The monsoons, which do so much to determine the condi-
tions of climate and health as well as the production of food,
are the result of the northern flow of currents of air bearing
moisture from the ocean, as the S.W. monsoon, and again
their reflux, as the N.W. monsoon, which also brings rain to
Southern India. In both cases they are more or less deflected
or modifled by the physical conditions of the country over
which they pass. The S W. monsoon is the great carrier of
rain to the whole of India. Saturated with moisture, it de-
posits it in the form of heavy rain upon the Western Ghauts,
where it first impinges and where the greatest amount falls ;
but passing over extensive tracts of desert land, it deposits
very little rain until further north, when, on impact with the
Himalayas a large fall takes place. For example, at
Mahableshwar in the Western Ghauts 300 inches of rain fall
in the few months of the rainy season and again, on the
;

N.E, frontier, in that prolongation of the Himalayas into the

Aracan Yomas, on the plateau of the Khasia and Jyntea hills,
at an elevation of 4,500 to 6,000 feet at Cherra Poonji, 4,200
;

feet, the large amount of 600 inches falls, the largest rainfall
known in the world whilst at the corresponding latitude on
;

the west, in the desert of Sind and Rajputana, there is almost

no rain, not that the air is not charged with moisture, but
that the conditions of condensation do not there exist.

Hill Colonies.
In such a variety and different elevations, with
of climates
great swamps and deltas on the one hand, and arid, dry,
sandy plains on the other, with an almost universal presence
of malaria and great solar heat, all those conditions exist
which give rise to the well-known forms of tropical disease,
render the plains of India unsuitable to be the permanent
home of the European, and emphasise the expediency of seek-
ing sites in the more elevated regions where Europeans may
find immunity from them. Many such stations have now
become health resorts, of which the advantages are very
great, not only in preserving the health of those yet unaffected
by the climate of the plains, but for invalids who, without
being the subjects of organic disease, have suffered from the
wearing effects of climate and work, and in some cases for
those convalescent from certain tropical diseases, thus ob-
viating the necessity for long and extensive voyages and pro-
longed absence from duties.
In considering the question of hill stations, it is to be re-
membered that the welfare of upwards of 100,000 Europeans
 4
l8 concerned. A ve^ large number of these are destined
to
spend a great part but not the whole of their lives in
India,
the utmost importance for the preservation
fu of
their health and vigour to utilise those localities in
this object may be to so great an extent attained.
which
for and adoption of others and the
The search
endeavour to improve bv
sanitation or by any other means the condition
of those now
existing, have always seemed to me worthy
of the
and consideration of all interested in the welfare of attention
the com-
munity.
In some of the hill stations, more especially those
to the
south, at e^vations between 4,000 and 7,000
feet, a certain
number of Europeans have settled but sufficient time has
;
not elapsed to show how far this commencement of
colonisa-
tion may develop and ultimately succeed. For those who
have assured means of living and who are not solely dependent
professions or labours it seems probable enough
that the results may be satisfactory. It also seems
possible
that the various industries connected with tea, coffee
and
cinchona planting and minerals may afford the means of
sub-
sistence, notwithstanding the competition of native
labour,
and so in time European communities of considerable extent
may arise and flourish, producing men fltted to carry on work
in the plains, returning at intervals to their
homes in the
more elevated regions. But this remains to be proved.
The great proportion, however, of Europeans who live in
India conduct the commerce, government, and other
arffi
would still have to be imported from Europe,
^d I do not say that the necessity for occasional
return to
ever be entirely obviated, for cases must occur in
which this will be necessary, not only for recovery from
disease or for the re-establishment of perfect health, but for
moral and social reasons. Still, I am under the impression
that full advantage has never been taken of these hill stations,
and it is satisfactory to know that they are capable of consider-
able extension. I may here express a hope that those who are
in a position to do so will endeavour to bring about the reali-
sation of that which would certainly be of beneflt to our race
m Iiidia. I can hardly, indeed, imagine a more profltable
subject for the consideration of a Society such as this, whose
opinion would carry so much weight.
_
One obstacle to the progress and success of such colonisa-
tion would be found in the limited area of the elevated table-
lands and their intersection by deep valleys, but this is not
universal. There are regions more promising in this respect
example, the Khasia and Jyntea Hills, between Bengal
andj
Assam, where_ the elevated plateaux are broader and
more extensive, with undulating ground, at a height that
would be favourable to the European constitution. The late
Inspector-General Maclelland, an observer of great scientifle
acumen, in discussing this subject, writes of these hills :

The elevations,more about the centre of the tablelands, are broad and
extensive downs, with favourable soil and plentiful supplies of water, with
coal and other resources at hand suitable to the enterprise of Europeans,
which seem to leave nothing to be wished for in regard to this locality,
but greater facilities of communication in order to render it all to be
desired.
In this I thoroughly concur, having known this part of the
country, and being much struck with the general character of
that between Cherra and Shillong, and its aptitude for this
purpose. The greater facilities for communication in these
days by rail and steam are gradually diminishing the objec-
tions at that time considered to be inseparable from its re-
mote position. He says of another region :

Proceeding from Hazaribagh further to the west, we have a range of

high country parallel to the Ganges, presenting fine tablelands at Sohag-
pore, the elevation of which has been variously stated at from ^,000 to
5,000 feet. Again, in the district of Ramghur, in theSaugor and Nerbudda
territories, are high tablelands, which had then been imperfectly
explored, but the elevations were known to be from 3,000 to 5,000 feet.
Here during the month of May the climate is truly delightful. Everything
around is fresh and green, the air is elastic and buoyant, with dew falling
every night. Fifteen or twenty days seldom pass, even in the dry season,
without showers. Again, in the Maliadeo hills is the tableland of Pach-
mahri, in theNagpore district, elevated 3,500 feet. The soil is light and
sandy.
Of this it was written in 1839 ;
In the month of May the climate has been known to be such as to suit
the most delicate European constitution, while the cold season is
intensely cold and invigorating.
This place has now become a station. The same writer
remarks :

A bracing climate, mineral treasures of unexplored value, rich and un-

appropriated lands, abundance of moisture for all agricultural purposes,
beautiful scenery, and a vast variety of products of almost every descrip-
tion, are to be found in these tablelands, to which Providence has been
so lavish in its gifts, but which man has not yet been taught to
appreciate.
Although much has been done since Dr. Maclelland wrote,
there is good reason to believe that in the vast mountain
ranges and tablelands of India the physical and climatic con-
ditions necessary for the preservation of health and perhaps
even for the permanent colonisation of the European will be
found to exist to a much greater extent than has hitherto
been supposed.
For example, the late Colonel Warburton, who was Super-
intendent of the Khyber, has recently pointed out Tor Sapper,
in the Khyber district, north of Landi Kotal, and 32 miles
west Peshawar, at an altitude of from 5,300 or 5,600 feet,
of
which capable of accommodating 1,500 soldiers, and also
is
other elevated regions in the same district with equal advan-
tages, which have all the conditions favourable to European
health, and which he strongly recommends.

Hill Stations.
Considering, however, how little was known of the hill
climates of India half a century ago, it is interesting to note
the number of instances in which they are now resorted to, and
to learn what service they have rendered both to the civil
and military population. Since the late Sir Eanald Martin
urged the attention of Government to the matter, and pointed
out the importance of locating the European troops as much
as possible at elevated regions, the number of hill sites at
which the British army is stationed has greatly increased, and
their vital statistics contrast favourably with those of India
generally, the death-rates being respectively about 14 and 23
per 1,000 in 1897, an unusually sickly year, the latest
officially reported. According to the last report of the Sani-
tary Commissioner with the Government of India, of the
68,000 European soldiers now in India, there are 3,000 in con-
valescent dep6ts and hill sanatoria, and 7,000 are stationed in
the hills. I am inclined to think this number might be in-
creased. The facilities of communication are now so much
 R

greater than they were, say, at the time of the Mutiny, that
there would be little difficulty in getting at them in any
sudden emergency.
Time does not permit me to do more than a brief descrip-
tion of a few of the typical hill stations of the Himalayas, of
the Ghauts and Vindhyan range, and of those more, southern
regions where the two systems of the Ghauts unite, forming
the great mass of the Nilgiri hills. The chief hill stations of
—
popular resort are in the extra-tropical districts that is, the
Himalayas, Dalhousie, Dharmsala, Marri, Abbottabad,
Thandiana, Simla, Missouri, Landour, Rainkhet, Naini Tal,
Almorah, Darjeeling, CherraPunh, Shillong, at heights of from
4,000 to 7,000 feet ;
in the Nilgiris, Utacamand, Conoor,
Wellington, Kotagherri ;
Pachmarhi, in the Central Pro-
vinces Mount Abu in Southern Rajputana, in the Aravallis ;
;

Mahableshwar, Matheran, and Khandalla, in the Western

Ghauts, near Bombay. There are several others, but even of
those mentioned I can only describe a few, and shall take as
sufficiently illustrative of the extra-tropical Darjeeling, Naini
Tal, Simla, and Mount Abu of the tropical, Mahableshwar,
;

Matheran, and the Nilgiris, for what is said of those applies tO’
a great extent to the others.
2 he Tableland of MahablesMoar, latitude 17° 58' N., longi-
tude 73° 42' E., in the Western Ghauts, about 290 miles via
Poona from Bombay, is of considerable extent. Its mean
elevation is 4,500 feet above the sea ;
it is rugged and un-
dulating. It varies from eight to fifteen miles in breadth,
and is seventeen miles from N.E. to S.W. The station
occupies the north-westerly region of this tableland, having
a south-west aspect, and is densely wooded there are excel-
;

lent rides and drives. It is composed of basalt, trap, and

laterite. The mean annual temperature is 66°, daily range 8°,
maximum of summer 89°, ordinary limit of winter cold 40°.
The rainfall here, as I have already pointed out, is very great,
the average being 229 inches, though frequently more ; but
the natural drainage rapidly carries oflf this surplus water.
The drinking water is good, the vegetation luxuriant. The
headquarters of the Government of Bombay are established in
this station, which is naturally the great hill resort from
Bombay, as well as from many other parts of India. The
elevation and position of this station afford a delightful
climate. Malarial fevers do not occur, and cholera is said
never to have originated here. The season extends from
March to June, and the greatest heat is in March and April,
when the thermometer may rise to nearly 90°, but the nights
are almost always cool and refreshing. Winds are variable,
sometimes from the east, but there is a daily sea breeze,
which goes on blowing till the monsoon sets in. Thunder-
storms are frequent after April, and in May the atmosphere
becomes moister by day, while mist and cloud envelop the
hill by night and in the early morning. Early in June the
monsoon bursts and the rain falls in deluges, during which
time the mean temperature is about 63°. In September the
monsoon ceases, and by October jhe weather has become
settled. The change from the heat of the plains now affords
great relief in November the air becomes cooler and drier,
;

weather fine, mean temperature 62°; the greatest cold only

produces slight hoar frost. The days are mild and genial, the
atmosphere bracing and elastic, and the nights are cool. The
periods both before and after the monsoon are those at which
the place is —
desirable as a residence. The scenery mountain,
sea, and waterfall— is magnificent. Recovery from most
maladies, except hepatic, dysenteric, or rheumatic, is
accelerated, and to those jaded and exhausted by some
forms of disease, long exposure, or hard work, the transition
to the greater altitude and more elastic air is often very
beneficial.
Mount Abu is in the native State of Rajputana, and is
separated from the Aravallis, to which it really belongs, by
the valley of the Western Banass River. It is situated in
latitude 24° 35' N., longitude 72° 53' E., and is about 420 miles
from Bombay. Its base is about 50 miles in circumference,
and its average height 4,000 feet above sea level. It is very
irregular on the surface, and the highest peak is over 5,600
feet above sea level. It is composed of granite, with a
mixture of blue slate and quartz. The inhabited part is a
basin perforated by ravines, studded with hills, and sur-
rounded by higher eminences, from which gorges descend to
the plains. The distant views are very picturesque vegeta-
;

tion is luxuriant and semi-tropical a lake about two miles in

;

circumference is found on the western side of the station.

The hill sides are well wooded, and at the beginning and ter-
mination of the monsoon it has its most charming aspect,
green with vegetation and brilliant with flowers, and all the
little valleys are filled with clear streams. The mean annual
temperature is 70°, the average maximum in summer is 92°,
the extreme 98° in the winter the temperature is about 50°,
;

but occasionally it freezes at night, and hoar frost covers the

ground. The daily temperature is, on the whole, equable,
and the station is sheltered from the winter east winds. The
rainfall averaged during 10 years 64 inches, August being the
most rainy month. It is often enveloped in clouds during the
monsoon. Though the summer is warm it is a great contrast
to the heat of the burning sandy plains below, and is generally
tempered by refi’eshing breezes, the atmosphere is light and
elastic, and the nights cool. It is raised above the hot winds,
but is not altogether free from malaria, especially from
October to the end of the year. The water is somewhat
uncertain in quantity though good in quality. The advantages
of this station as a. dry, tonic climate, without great vicissi-
tudes of temperature, are considerable, and are much appre-
ciated. It is susceptible of further development, which
doubtless will take place as time goes on. It is now the head-
quarters of the Rajputana Political Agency, one of the
Lawrence asylums for European children, and a sanatorium
for British troops. It is a great place of resort for those who
are exhausted by climatic causes and hard work, and for con-
valescents after any ordinary maladies, except hepatic and
confirmed forms of bowel complaint, or those who have
suffered from severe malarial fever, and are liable to recur-
rences of it.
Matheran (latitude i8°s8'N., longitude 73° 18' E.). which
rises abruptly from the plain, consists of trap rock and
laterite, is very irregular in form, its central ridge is about
a mile and a half long and half a mile in breadth, with spurs
which are known by various names. Its proximity to Bombay
(only about twenty miles as the crow flies) makes it of great
value to that city. It can hardly be dignified by the name of
a hill station, but as it illustrates remarkably the advantages
of even 2,460 feet of elevation, in its cooler atmosphere, its
 8

pleasant breezes and proximity to the sea, it is worthy of

mention. The rainfall is heavy, amounting sometimes to 250
inches in the season, when Matheran is not desirable as a
residence, but it runs off quickly. In the cold weather, from
the middle of October to the beginning of March, the tempera-
ture rarely reaches higher than 78° by day and 70° by night,
but in March and April it may reach as high as 90° with a
mean of 80°. The place appears to be free from malaria.
Persons who have suffered from overwork and heat and who
are convalescent after illness, other than malarial fevers or
hepatic disease, will find it beneficial, and by resorting to it
may sometimes avoid the necessity for more prolonged absence
and change.
The Nilghiris
. —
In the south of India, in the Madras Presi-
dency, a tract of mountain country lies between 11° 12' N.
latitude, and 76° 18' and 77° 15' E. longitude. These are the
Nilgiris, the total area of which is 957 miles, the surface
undulating, in some parts not much wooded, and the fall to
the plains sudden and abrupt. In other parts of these elevated
lands there are extensive forests. The general elevation of
the tablelands varies from 6,000 feet to about 7,600 feet. There
are several high peaks Dodabetta, the principal, measures
;

8,761 feet. In the high lands some European settlers have

already established themselves, and there are lour European
stations: Utacamand, 7,361 feet; Wellington or Jackatalla,
almost exclusively military, 6,ioo feet; Conoor, 5,886 feet;
Kotagherri, 6,571 feet. These hill stations are justly in great
request, and much frequented. Their elevation in that lati-
tude, their relative proximity to the sea, and the influence
exercised over them by the monsoon, produces a climate well
suited to the European constitution, in which our race may
maintain its healthful vigour, and where there is good reason
to believe that, other accessories being favourable, a permanent
home for the European race might be, and indeed is, estab-
lished, though of course time alone can determine in what this
attempt at colonisation will result. When compared with the
elevated stations of the Himalayas, the distinctions arising
out of differences of latitude, proximity to the sea in the one
case and to the snowy range in the other, are expressed in the
Nilgiris in the greater equability of the climate, neither the
heat nor the cold being excessive whilst the configuration of
;

the country itself, with it long, undulating plains, renders it

more suitable to the habits and constitution of the European.
Time does not permit of my dwelling upon the physical
aspects, and on the magnificent scenery presented by these
mountain peaks, undulating plains, and rushing rivers but ;

let me say a few words about Utacamand, the chief station,

and Conoor and Kotagherri, which seem to be so intimately
associated with each other. Invalids or others frequently
finding a sojourn at one of these places a wise preliminary to
that at Utacamand whilst Wellington holds a high place in
;

the medical annals of the British army, upwards of 1,000 men

being in the convalescent depot there.
Utacamand is situated in an elevated valley or basin sur-
rounded by hills, and has a lake in the centre there are few
;

trees in its immediate vicinity. From its peculiar geograph-

ical position, it feels the influence both of the S.W. and the
—
N.E. monsoon; the rainfall is heavy according to Hunter
—
45 inches annually though it varies in different parts of the
Nilghiris, the highest fall being in June and July brought by
 9

the S.W. monsoon this is the most unpleasant season. The

;

N.E. monsoon sets in in October, and is also accompanied by

rain the months of November and December are showery,
;

and the latter cold the atmosphere after that becomes dry.
;

January, February, March, and April are clear, with

dry north and east winds. The mean annual tem-
perature is 58°; in the hottest season it seldom ex-
ceeds 75°—it may drop at night to 54°—but the mean
range seldom exceeds 9°. The hottest month is May,
the coldest are December and January, when the freezing
point is sometimes but very seldom reached at night. At
this time the range between the hottest part of the day and
the coldest part of the night is about 16°. In the cold season,
in the rarefied air, the sun’s rays have great force, and even in
this comparatively equable climate it is necessary to guard
against sudden changes of temperature. From diflerence in
altitude, locality, and physical characters generally, varieties
of climate are within easy access.
Conoor is milder and less subject to these sudden changes
of temperature, and therefore more suitable to delicate per-
sons on first going to these hills. The climate generally of
the Nilgiris is suitable for all conditions of depressed health,
or after disease contracted in the plains, except, as in most
other hill climates, those of hepatic or dysenteric nature.
Conocr is not so high as Utacamand, but is much more beau-
tiful, as the sides of the hill are wooded. The mean average
temperature is 64°, of the summer 70°. It is more relaxing
than Utacamand, and in the winter is more sheltered from
the north-west, to which the latter is exposed. The water-
falls that occur during the monsoon are most picturesque, one
at no great distance being 400 feet. At this elevation the
tropical character of the vegetation ceases. Most of these
remarks apply to Kotagherri, which is only a little higher
than Conoor.
Darjeeling, latitude 27° 2' N., longitude 88° 18' E., about
400 miles from Calcutta, and easily and rapidly accessible by
rail, is situated in a district of the Sikkim Himalayas, 138
square miles in extent, which was acquired from the Eajah as
a sanatorium in 1835. The height of the ridge varies from
6,500 feet to 7,500 feet above sea level. Most of the houses
are perched upon this ridge, others are on the side, with a
S.W. aspect. Rather more than half-way up is the station of
Kurseong at an elevation of about 4,500 feet, where it is some-
times better for Europeans to sojourn for a time before going
to the greater elevation of Darjeeling. The geological forma-
tion is chiefiy micacious shale and gneiss, with granite, sand-
stone, and slate. The S.W. monsoon produces a heavy rain-
fall averaging from 120 to 150 inches in the year. The
humidity of the atmosphere is consequently considerable,
especially during the fogs and rains of the monsoons. The
climate, however, is very equable, in which it differs from
other Himalayan stations. Snow falls in the winter to a much
less extent than it does at Simla, and the winter is milder.
The mean annual temperature is 56°, the maximum in July
is 70°, in May 65°, in December 52°, the minima being re-
spectively 59°, 51°, and 36°. The views from the station and
the surrounding localities are very fine the loiv valleys on
;

the one hand, some with rivers flowing through them, and on
the other hand range upon range of snow-clad mountains from
15,000 feet up to 28,000 are exceedingly picturesque and mag-
 10

nificent. The roads are numerous and well kept, sanitation

is good, and the water supply fine and sufficient. The fiora
is very varied— fine trees, such as saul, magnolia, oak, chest-
nut, toon, coniferse of all kinds, and rhododendrons, whilst
ferns, creepers, and numerous fiowers, such as orchids,
abound, and the cinchona plantations—a recent but rapidly-
—
increasing and important industry not far distant, are most
interesting. The climate in March and in May is like
that of Europe. During the monsoon the rain is disagree-
able, but there are frequent intervals in which the climate is
pleasant enough. From October to March the weather is
sunny, bright, and cheerful, the nights cold, clear, and some-
times frosty. Darjeeling is the summer residence of the
Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal, and is resorted to by num-
bers, many of whom are planters in the Terai and neighbour-
ing districts.
Though the Terai itself and the valleys are malarious, yet
the fever never originates in the station, it being raised above
malarious infiuences, and people from the Terai suffering from
fever recover speedily at this station. Whilst diarrhoea is
not infrequently found at other Himalayan stations, it is
comparatively uncommon at Darjeeling, nor does there seem
to be any special tendency to bronchial troubles. As a change,
which is so necessary after long residence in the plains, where
exhaustion and hard work have deteriorated the general
health, and where there is no definite organic disease, and no
complications, such as asthma, cardiac or cerebral disease,
thought not to do well here, it is of the greatest value as a
health resort. Delicate people and young children especially
thrive almost as well as they would in Europe.
Naini Tal in Kamaon, in the N.W. Provinces, latitude 29°
22' N., longitude 79° 29' E., may be described as an amphi-
theatre surrounded by hills which are 2,000 feet higher except
on the S.E., where it is open to the plains. Between the main
range and a spur called the Ayapata is a valley with a pic-
tureque lake or tal, probably an ancient crater, from which
the place takes its name, about one mile long and a quarter of
a mile broad. On the slope above this lake the present
station is built, and at various elevations. The height of the
lake above the sea is 6,400 feet, and the hills surrounding it
rise to 8,500 feet, the ascent from the station being rather
precipitous. From some ridges near the station magnificent
views of the snowy ranges, including some of the higher
peaks, are to be seen, with the intervening valleys and lower
ranges gradually leading up to them. The scenery of the
station itself and the views of the lake are most picturesque,
while the fiora is varied, consisting of rhododendrons, cypress,
ash, and a variety of flowers and ferns. English vegetables
and fruits are also produced in the cold season. The geological
formation is clay, slate, and limestone, with light friable soil.
In 1881 it was the scene of two serious landslips which
destroyed many buildings and several lives. This station is
the summer resort of the Government of the N.W. Provinces,
and consequently is much frequented. The climate is bracing
and invigorating except in the rains. The average rainfall is
70 inches, but in some years it is double that amount, and it
rains more days in the year than at other places. During a
period of seven years it was recorded that some rain fell in
every month except October, but August is usually the wettest
month. The temperature in summer rarely exceeds 8o“, and
 11

in winter it may sink to the freezinR point. The maximum

and minimum are: in May 78° and 48°, in June 69° and 59“, in
July 78° and 61°, in August 76° and 62°. Water is derived
from springs and is good, and the sanitation of the place is
carefully provided for. In the cold weather invalids and
children may be out most of the day, though occasionally
snow falls. February and September are said to be most dis-
agreeable months.
This picturesque and beautiful station is very easily acces-
sible by the railway to the foot of the hill and thence by good
road, and there seems to be ample accommodation for any
number of visitors. Those are most benefited who have been
debilitated by long residence in the plains or who have suf-
fered from frequent attacks of intermittent fever, or other
diseases unattended with organic complications. As is the
case with the hill stations generally, it is not so beneficial for
hepatic or dysenteric troubles, and it is not free from occa-
sional occurrences of so-called “hill diarrhcea,” and indeed
from rheumatism and neuralgia, due to its exposure to occa-
sional cold northerly winds. Cases of bronchitis and croupy
affections in children are also of occasional occurrence. Persons
who suffer from any organic disease, '.cardiac or other, should
not go there without medical authority, and as the transition
from the plains to this greater elevation is sudden, delicate
perspns should not undertake it without the sanction of their
medical adviser. There is here a convalescent dep6t for
European soldiers in which in 1897 there were 123 inmates.
<Sim/a (latitude 31® 6' N., longitude 77°ii'E.), in the dis-
trict of Simla, in the north-east corner of the Punjab, the
largest and most important of the Himalayan stations, is on
a ridge of the sub-Himalayan system, of a crescentic form,
culminating in the east in the peak of Jakko, and in the west
in another peak. Prospect Hill. From Jakko the ridge gives
off another spur to the north called Elysium, and another to
the east called Mahasu it is, in fact, a series of ridges and
;

spurs upon which the numerous houses are most picturesquely

situated, on the north aspect of which is the snowy range, and
on the west the plains at a distance of about 40 miles. The
area of the whole district, obtained from the Patiala Rajah in
the first quarter of the century, is about 18 square miles. It
is approached by good roads, but the rail, which already
reaches to the foot of the hills will no doubt, as in the case
of Darjeeling, be extended nearer to the station. The scenery
is very picturesque to the north the mountain ranges on the
;

other side of the Sutlej valley are covered with dense vegeta-
tion, whilst in the distance is the magnificent panorama of
the snowy range. The valleys to the north and south are
also beautifully wooded, whilst the Kussouli and Sabathu
hills, at a lower level, which are military sanatoria, are seen,
with the plains of Umbala, extending far in the distance.
The hills generally about Simla are well wooded by oak,
deodar, and rhododendrons, which are very beautiful. These
mountain ridges are composed chiefly of metamorphic rocks,
shale and conglomerate, limestone and mica. The average
height of the station is 7,100 feet, the fir-clad peak of Jakko
rising to 8,000 feet. The average rainfall is 76 inches, but it
varies, ranging from 50 to 100 inches, and during the rainy
season there is much mist. The mean annual temperature is
60° in the hot season it frequently attains to 85° or 90°,
;

whilst in the cold it may fall to 22° at night. From the

 12

middle of March and in April the mornings and evenings are

fresh and cool, the day bright and pleasant. In May it
is warm and dry with a temperature from 70° to 80°. In June,
the hottest month, the temperature may rise to 90° in the
;

middle of June there is a certain amount of rain, but in July

the regular rains begin, which continue with intervals till the
middle of September. During this period the atmosphere is
damp and the station is often enveloped in clouds. Bright
and bracing weather follows the rainy season, and in October
the air is peculiarly bright and clear and the scenery is then
very beautiful. Snow begins to fall in December, increases
during January, and sometimes lies deep on the ground. The
air is then dry, calm, and bracing, and very agreeable to per-
sons in good health, Chini, another ridge, is well known for
its dry elastic atmosphere and moderate rainfall, the climate
being bracing [and healthy like that of Switzerland, Com-
plaints have been made from time to time about the sanita-
tion of Simla and of overcrowding. The water supply is good,
having been lately improved. Simla is the summer resort of
the Viceregal Court, and is naturally a most popular station,
and much frequented, not only during the season but also
throughout the winter. The climate is beneficial in ordinary
malarial diseases, if unaccompanied by structural changes,
but, as in the case of other hill stations, it is specially useful
after prolonged residence and hard work in the plains. Like
the other, also, it is unsuitable in dysenteric, hepatic, cardiac,
or lung complaints. Hill diarrhoea is not infrequently seen
and requires special precautions, especially in those who have
any tendency to bowel complaints or have just come up from
the plains and are more than usually susceptible to alterna-
tions of temperature. Children thrive well here, but the
question of their remaining during the winter may require
consideration. At Sanower, close by, is the Lawrence
Asylum for European children. Here also, as at Sabathu
and Kussouli, a few Europeans resort. The climate of Simla,
in 31° N. latitude, as compared with that of Utacamand in
latitude 11° N., at about the same elevation, shows a consider-
able contrast in its extremes of temperature, both of heat
and cold, and the greater equability of the climate is very
frequently the reason why the more southern hill stations
are preferable to the northern, especially in the case of
certain diseases or constitutional peculiarities in which these
are important considerations. Such questions can be best
determined by medical authority on the spot, but it may be
safely said of all, from 4,000 to 8,000 feet, in whatever latitude,
that they are of exceeding benefit to Europeans, for here they
are placed above those morbific influences which determine
the forms of tropical disease and in an atmosphere not too
rarified to be prejudicial.

Hill Stations as Health Eesorts.

It is also worthy of consideration (and nowhere could this
consideration be more appropriately given than by this Society)
whether the hill stations of India might not be more resorted
to by people from our own islands, when prolonged absence
from this country is necessary and residence in a milder and
more genial climate sought for. The evils of the winter In
England might be avoided by residence in the plains of India
or on the plateau of the Deccan, and if necessary that absence
 /

13

should be prolonged, the hot weather in India might be bene-

ficiallyspent in one of the hill stations.
There are many other hill stations in India, and amongst
them might be included the lofty valley of Cashmere, in which
all the advantages resulting from altitude, pureness, and
rarefaction of air, and removal from the various conditions
which give rise to tropical diseases are found. But it is im-
possible for me in the short time at my disposal to enter into
any description of these or other cognate subjects of the
greatest interest.
I have endeavoured briefiy to indicate certain points with
regard to the hill stations of India which I thought might
form the subject of profitable consideration in a Society such
as this, so eminently qualified to estimate their value and im-
portance, and it 'only remains for me to apologise for having
treated the subject so cursorily.
[The address was illustrated by paintings of the Himalayas
by the Sight Hon. Sir E. Temple, Bart., late Governor of
Bombay by photographs lent by Mr. Birdwood, C.S.I., Bombay
;

Civil Service and by photographs and sketches lent by the

;

India Office, and by the Eoyal Geographical Society.]

 ^ " 7 ' ,

'
\' -
-- .-:,
77 :;
-'
'v'-’
V 7 -•..; r-'-,;; ^t •.'A'-f--'
>^'^777 ?^-' 7 y;;-,^y-

-- ^
- V ,S- 7 >Hrv.7 ~ .y-T -7 ^ '- 7 : 7
77
'
^ ^
.:'
^

^'77'tSia: S’ .|i "v}, 7 'v V r C,;;v

->
' '. *
•
-'
;
,-, ;.,

•' *'**^ 'C

'"
-y 7 r:r::-’.9-ii.-^HvP^i
:' ^
; --
.- . •
- >•/•, •'

'‘^^'; i-/,
'
- . -

7 ;;'.•
'
T- 7 ••
'

1
/-: . 7 ^\r'S .^.y.: r->r',. 7
" -;'-
;y, v-:- 7^ - '-.sy- •/,-^7
• ,.
^
A;‘
7;7
-f
'
- -'
'
;
/- ,., •..' >7
..v '
,' '.
^

ii-, .
.: '\
7 .‘ „ , „’-, "*i^*‘ .,•• ,"7
'
^
77 7.^ 77 -77 :y, 777 -
r7'-^7:v7-'^;y;7^ '
'
. - .

.t •. .-» ^ ,
'
v.'i*
.
v^,

7:-^ 7
77- 7.-777 -?.-- ^>-^ 7
;./^y- 7>7
7 ;
•
-
„.v,
,-.^'' yvv:' 7yyy
7
r,_ •
-

7 v>y-- 7 ^-
t-, v..^ ,V.
:^ 7.:'-7 y 7 7y 7;7
7 :.v-,. -,;. >. ;' '*'

'
'7 '7
7- y>'*
^ ^v' 7 -- .
^>x
-7
7 ‘--, ...
.••''
7
'^'.-^-“''
'-;j
-•"?-. -.7
,
};
•-
7 ,^' '.;'>^ ,•
;'
'»r
7
.
.
.,",
.A "...7

7 *
,. •. 'i'.; - - V ,

7
''
' -
'7 .• '.' - 7 ':>

77 .
:v.i;,-. . ,-

v 7 \ ^
'

-7
y '
;. , ' V' -><.-. •*7 r-<^--.. •
* -
,

’
•• •
.'V -•'
‘ .'• -^- -; -.. . .
.' .' '
f,- .: ', (
'
.’< -.
' ' ' =’'''>'
'
'
-7 > v/:i .;_ '{-

v-y:^7>-'^7 777 .^ 7 ^^ 777:-7 7

vCr'- 'v _i:- .-; 7.7
v/ r *^7 , .
< ' kL.W, - ^
•
" .
'-'
'
-7
,
-
: .>
''7
,., ..* y
rr."- 1^:=; n’" : .- jv'"'" 7 / ’

->
7,.vr 7 7 ^-i7
'.
>.: y--. 777 'yv, y 7 ^:^xL 7 :-'-'
- :^.,
y
,
", 7 -...^ y .-y. y ,.„^.
.'^•. 7
'” .•'-<,••.• .’
-
*'V '

7 T 7 >^rV4?r;!.;
V- ''
7 .— ^ 7
--v .

-, ^ 77 :-:,.
7y>k;r 7 7
y- ^
,.. 'Y-yyvy . - :
-

"
y^.•' 77777 i:y>y 7 y 7l ^.•«7 7 =‘' 777 ^ 7 ;; 7 >
: . ;^: - .. 777 7 , ..^,
7- ^ " ,

'/'yy -y.yy- — 7 ; 7 ut^^

'-
7 -•j. -<
7y ''‘y-v
.-,-
'

. ..
.

7 7 7^ '.vr;' -' 7y 7- 7 7
> ' . , -
.--'-'^ >- • • - '^
7 7,7 yy ., :;.-
'
.

;
7 7y 77 7 7 7 ,.^:^ 7 y7 r,iy. 7;'yt -^7
:

'
: y 7 77 7 7 y 777 ,;,. ,. ,^^ .. •.. ;.>’'-
'.i
'-
'

» 7- 7y777 y"*^';7 7 V 7 7 y..;-y'. ,yTi^’-': 7 7 7y>‘,-'>

'"'
I- >77’ 7'-v; ‘^ -.'
•;
,'•'
.-
, ;.x.
*:-
-

. .
-y;

7%y ?7777 .-7

"^
“' >'
.y ,%;
i-; yvy77 > 77 . y -
C-- -,.> 7-7 777
.> 7-’7 7 -*7 7 7 y 7 7 y-^y -
'-
, , ':v.,
''
\ ]i.‘ ; v,:' .
'.y

7 , :
.

>"‘7 '; 7 !77 -Uy->v

77 7
7 777 :^y
777^7 7 777 -y 7
-^-.vy C-y^^^ 77 77 > x/:>^' 7 ;^ 7 777777
-'
77 :^' :
-

:77
*r 777
^ 7
7 7
yv;,:
;,: ;7 -^y 7 7 7 V
> ;:^'
7777 my^; 77 7 >y
yy 7777 > 7:
7
:^ y >>:
''

m^, '
'

77,yyy y. 77
C ::.:yy;.;r: 77 7 77 y >"77 yis'' 7-.>.:7
777'yy-y^r^y ;V.-y yij-y 7 ,. - •
;
,

.v aK ,
.,.7
•
-v;---. > ...77 - - '

_ >7
. ^

,
."-
7-7 .
/"•
7777 7 y ‘-.
7 7 ';.. :
7'‘"'77 '
-
'
' 77 ;;y'y7 .

7 7 ‘^''."‘ 's:
.
’ "’^> 7'>> 7’-."y-.y
7 ? '
7-> i'
'"yy- j.,...

’7

"7.-
7
>y
7 7
- ^y-yy^yy'-y^nw's:.
>:y;. 7 y^yi r^;,y:-:
->v.
:7 '-

7 , .-''.vi,#" .y ,-
7 y, :':=^

> 7 ""7 -
^ ’ -
7 v- yy- y ;>. y; 7 7 - .". 7 77 > 777 7 ;ryy'. :^yy'f_;yy: 7 7 *.y

. '
.
'- 7 ’.
7 > . .y..y'.; :
’.
7 "»7r '77 7-‘.- '•
^
.

'.t-yy ,y-'>'.y: 7 'T'

j v .-, .

• ‘•.- ’-•. ^
'• •
7 >,T v- 7 7 .- 7 v,-.-

7 7 y 7 7'r.-.w 7 77
-

77 ". y-
.

'--y
:7 •U:>-. -
-
,.... : >777 77"y 7 Ay .'
'7

"
7 7 '- :V -.-7 7 7..:7 v," 7 yy': 7 "^>S...-y
'

: y V y" .. -
.
>i"
- v^.'-
.-•.

;
.y""7y,7:7777y777
7 y yy 7
- v,,y. 7-7 «y 7 ^' • 7
..

,..
'
.;

'''^'
7 7 ":
„.r c:'-y. 77 7 :' '^'
577 .y/:^->:,
7 .

/i-

7 •>: .•. 7
7.-74-^7 X yv' 777^
7 ^y."
-
•
-,v
-

;- '.
- -
-
yyr'..y:y _ 7
7 .y.y:';,v-' -
- 'y-'"]

:.
"'-.
l’ .•;.; > >,y, y.
-. ’.
,

> ‘-''-J-
-- ~ -.
.

7 ,.
" ," ,. .'-*.r ;••

7 -
,
'

7. ,.v,!.7;_;-''--7.
7,..,
’
7 -

,
' 7V ....
‘y

>

x y yy'
[

'

' '= '~''7

77 y 7 ; '
7
>.-

‘
‘
' ' '-' " '" yi <.
• '

‘'.'v „v'
•'.V*

;..vvr-' 7 y.y
/

' 7. 7,.
.'• V/. —
.

7 --V- " / '7 • .- -Vi;*-'

•

"M 7 .i;7 ;„>y ...> 7 vy - ."> 7 :-- y-

•

p7 7 ^ 7 y;,. ..
.7
7
'-
.;;7 .- >y '7 • 7;
- ^'v "
7 . ,,,. .y
'y, ...
' 7 --'
,:,
'• , .-‘'> 7 4
'
''.',

. ' .>-. 7 7 .
>'' " ..- 7 ’y ., •'.-,, 7 •,.
THE SANITARY INSTITUTE.

IDictovia

DEI GRATIA BRITT. REG. FID. DEF. IND. IMP.

BY

Sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart.

SECBETAllY:
E. WHITE WALLIS, F.S.S.

OFFICES:

PARKES MUSEUM, MARGARET STREET,

London, W.
 IDictoina

S)ei Gratia :©ritt. IReg. jfib. 2)ef. 3n^. 3mp.

Obiit d. XL ante Kal. Feb., A.D. MCMI.

 [Excerpt from Vol. XXII, Part L, of the Journal of
The Sanitary Institute.]

IDictoina Gratia Britt. IRco. 3fit). 2)ef. 3nt). 3mp.

Obiit. d. XL ante Kal. Feb., A.D. MCMI.

By sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Baut., K.C.S.I., LL.D., M.D., F.R.S.,

Physician Kxiruordinary to the King.

(Vice-Pkesident.)

INCE the issue of the last number of this Journal, not only the
British Empire but the world generally, has been plunged into
mourning by the death of the great and good Queen under whose bene-
ficent sway a vast population has advanced beyond previous record in the
evolution of those material, moral and intellectual qualities on which the
welfare and happiness of mankind depend. The Victorian age has passed
into the domain of history, and we gratefully acknowledge the benefits it
has conferred; at the same time we hail the inauguration of a new era in
which the promise and potency of continuity and further progress of the
work of its predecessor are clearly foreshadowed.
It seems fitting that on such an occasion some brief retros])ect of the

progress of Sanitary science during the past sixty-three years should

appear in the Journal of a Society which is devoted to the exposition of
that branch of knowledge and which has owed much of its wide-spread
influence to Royal sympathy and encouragement. This has shewn no
sign of abatement under th.e aegis of the Royal Duke who has presided
over its destinies for so long, and who, after a period of seventeen years,
still manifests undiminished interest in its work, and, with the help of
other members of the Royal Family and of the leading representatives of
Sanitary science, continues to render it valuable support.
This has been an age of progress and discovery ;
intellectual activity
4 Victoria Dei Gratia Britt. Reg. Fid. Def. Ind. Imp.

has never been greater, scientific research never more profound or far-
reaching, nor the practical application of the discoveries of science more
remarkable. Among many subjects of import which have characterised
the reign of the late gracious Sovei’eign, few afford greater cause for
congratulation than the improvement in vital statistics, as evidenced by
reduced death-rate, enhanced expectation of life, decline of some potential
causes of death and the almost total extinction of others. The Sanitary
Institute,which has now existed for twenty-five years, has taken no
unimportant part in effecting these changes. It was the outcome of an
impulse given to Sanitary Science by the Public Health Act of 1875,
which was itself one of many beneficial enactments of the late Queen’s reign.
Up to the time of Queen Victoria’s accession the great mass of the
population of our islands lived and died under conditions which violated
the now well-known principles upon which health depends. Prejudice
and ignorance obstructed progress. Government looked on with indifference,
the people knew little and thought less of the importance of pure air, pure
water, cleanly and uncrowded dwellings, temperance, and other conditions
which are now known to be essential to health. But under the influence
of such Chadwick, Parkes, Simon, Buchanan, Corfield,
reformers as
Kawlinson, Galton, Rogers Field, and many others, measures formerly
regarded as mere theories of no practical value, are now accepted and
acted upon. Statesmen have learnt to realise that Sanitary Science is an
important element in practical politics, and that it is the duty of executive
governments to protect the people from disease which may and can be
prevented or controlled, and the ministrations of officers of health, sanitary
engineers and inspectors, consequently provide that the poor shall no
longer be a law to themselves. Public health, in short, is cared for to a
degree utterly unknown in the past, as evidenced by the reduction of the
general death-rate from 22-4 in 1841 to 18'7 in 1895 ;
houses are better
built, sewerage, drainage and ventilation, are insisted on, the land is better
cultivated, the subsoil better drained, the importance of pure drinking
water is fully recognised, food is better, clothing more adapted to the
climate, and, were Acts which are in existence compulsory and not per-
missive, little would remain to be desired.
If we turn to the public services, i.e., to those who live under the
control of the State, we find that, not only in respect of the duration of
life,but also the prevention and cure of disease, the influence of sanitary
science has been remarkable. For example, for some time after the Queen’s
accession, the death-rate of the British Soldier in India stood at about
56 per 1,000, but has now declined to 15 per 1,000, and has been as low
 Sir Joseph Fayrer. 5

as 10. Epidemic disease, no doubt, disturbs the regularity of the death-

rate, but it is certain tliat there has been great improvement. In the
British Army generally the results of the Royal Commission, which was
appointed to enquii’e into these subjects after the Crimean War, show
that the death-rate has fallen from 16 or 18 to less than 6 per 1,000.
Great advance has been made of late year’s in the knowledge of the
etiology and prevention of disease. The various steps by which it has
been acquired cannot be related here, but its importance in respect to
Hygiene must be acknowledged to be incalculable, for without it, al-
though empirical methods may be of some value, no real progress can be
maintained.
Nothing in the history of the
development of Hygiene is more remark-
able than the influence it has had upon the methods of prevention as well
as of treatment of epidemic diseases. However much or little we may
have accurately determined as to their real causation, we have at least
learnt the conditions under which they thrive, become diffused, and in-
crease in intensity. The rigors and terrors of quarantine have con-
sequently been abolished, and reliance isnow placed upon isolation and
sanitation. The beneficial results of this mode of treatment are illustrated,
for example, by the control that has been exercised over cholera, from
which our country w’as comparatively free when it was prevalent all round
us on the Continent.
That general progress is likely to continue can safely be predicted
from the fact that the spirit of scientific research is so active in all
directions and so genuine. It has led to much and must inevitably lead
to more, to generalisations of increasing importance and value. There-
fore,Sanitary Science looks forward with peculiar hopefulness to the new
regime, feeling assured that the Sovereign who, as Prince of Whales,
always gave evidence of deep interest in science, especially sanitary
science, and in the maintenance and improvement of great hospitals,
will, in his more exalted position, still continue to extend the benefits of

his influence to its further development, and that the efforts of the British
Congress on Tuberculosis, which His Majesty has graciously consented
to patronise, will afford another signal example of the beneficial results
of the alliance of power with science.
 : '

.-

t ..V-
.lua-

M.*

\
V ,

f •
V,

'<-

*
\-

.'*
">
-’ t.

‘
f .oys-
 '
^
. * V

V'

'

' V ^

's .

j \

%
s

»
‘

I V

'T;

i
)
 A A ' \ 1 A .

-•
X >.. -V . i‘, 't

•)
'

'' ;-
'
>f

y- y \
'
i.'
’
.
. ; ,'i • ' ,
'
'
'v '
-i
'

,
•
*
j,' ^

'

'
' ‘•‘'y 'y.' ;'•
v'’ ’-Vr y-.'f V^'f'
'
'

’--A - A A?
'
I - -
.A-, -/' •
->> ,

r-

f,'
'4 4 -
! .;( / aa
r %:AAiA:AA'AA aA'sA^A ;
i SA'J; :<&
;'
'A', '-
• r';,

‘MKv;:

,:
;
v:-':;'
?-:': vAv:- «i

-.TOk - 'S: vyr-^ s:^-.Kks-s

-v«> A- . V:
•;• •• -. -- •
’.
'- '
.'/' -
'v.SA' >--, •
* •

i;

.:a.n .
‘

A'-
• Avk
:
. r-k ,
A;',,,kA' '
;kA A,.a 'A/ y .kkk
A '"Ca

.' .,:
'. '^‘
V''
' •••^ •
k -r '•'-"'..‘J
'' '’ '•-^
> •
'i > •,...-/ .-
‘
•''
'• -X'*
' '
. ,• - — T’f- ',''*
i Ak a
* '-
' ‘'**' *
'-"r ~ '
f? *s ,
'
:
-
'

'k '
\'^T s'"

A :,.k> kk-.',AA-- -^A:v AkA'AA'

kk.Ai.
>f'AkA,A, :

,-A AA>k V A' A- k

i.' v-AA::A - A'kkAA-;kkA':;kA

o^,.AA;AA;,. Aa^AA ,AA;vkkAkk.AaAAkA.,'^

V?’- yxS'-<- A
k :k A”, -k.’* >, . k ''•'^y j,-
'
’’
^ "A
"
.'Vk
Jv, a: Avj A^ '• _• k
'

^ •'
•''•» ' *'
A. >f' --' .
., •; . ',-.kA''J '
./« ,.- .A--, r'.

,.f^' •*•
A’-'a
' •^'k;
A^'^r ,:

k-..' v'a^'
'.‘
k '
.r;A,‘ -V.! ‘'iV'’yV'- ,A^';-:

^
;"i\A' Ak'"AA-'A.^W
k kAAA-^k AA^•AAA^ '"AA
- Ak k<kk>:-'. -kA-'A; ::>
;:,:.A:-: ,
„' ' ;,.A ",-k''A,:-A,A' ^AaA Ak
'A
A'AA: "AAA' k
:-;k: ;,k
"V*.,.:
a-

•A'-^'.' 'A-V.-A:,^ Akk,Ak k- k k.AA;

''

'A- .
' /A ; 'A’k', V'''k/‘' Ak- ;
V'
A;;>A-\. 'Ak AA'.kA' aA'A”' A V

AAiAAkA A A^' V :k“ik A- :k ;;;:

A." ‘k'-A kAA A':k Av.^kAAAk :iA.Astf A-AAAAkt

•k, -.AkkAk-kkA -
A" k A.-A A- AA.-Ak'-'A kA-Akvtk' -k- k'kk Aj,

A^ A, .

-,;A ;
A ...;
AAA xk^Ak r -kA^A‘''-AAA',Ak A"A' '•,'V*A

'J\
:>
k-A^^AA/,s;;A
A/ k'k'A-k- - A-
3k ^k.A:;^A^^^^
-A.- , k -A A- .A 'A.A.. AA'"-
.

C\ .

--'-k
,

A -^k ,' kkAk ^k k-' k-v- k.

A.' .AA-k k "'vA kk -.^A^k-.v-kAA^k- Ak AA- A--^ A':k,k'v,.k '

A -kk
k A- i'i; A^
A
kv. 'k' '
-

k '

-k k--. k.,; k i,,,k ,

'.
A> kk: ()-' AA H A k„- k
V*

kA>; A'k kA'^'k. .Ak',': A 'k^A;'; ^kAHvAAk,

kk-k';
A k; k '. • A<
'

k ,
:k; k’
;->v. k;,,;,- ,k '
V :A^^,,-^k.v,,k-',
A -'kAkAk^.; ; k A^k'^AAVAkA? k'okk' - kAk ;.-"k .

A V;k k; AA, -AA,k,^^k kk,k,,^,v v, Ak,_ .A;/-,.-,

-
.

AA - A A-' ,

-Av. k iA'-kkk- kAkk;k.-kk-k,A:k 'AAAAaA^''A,

’'
.
k'A'k. ,,'• k' -
i...
jj k- k.'kk (TA .-
; A', AA,'
k-
,
;
' '
k -
,-. , .
', -
,. ;
•. ,. , ,
;

k
•.'
-. '.
'
*' A-k- ;-. : <r
,
1
.-A'. AA '
iv,
k-l- V '
-...;
‘
, , :k
.- - ' . ,,
jVi 'i . : '
r,'
' -
,
,'" ,

i ',? -A •_
\ V-
,' -kk:
-' ' '
" /:' t< ."
V-.
': kAVv k
'

.
'SfA'
-
Akk- 'k -k
kAAk'^k-v^.A^A::k.^^
';
,, -,, /-V' ''"tA>A.,A a>-A:a
":A^-
A;kA^kkk ;kA, kk ik; v;. k;,;k kk- ,

'
i A'-kr..*'
^a'.
.. M
.

'•
AAA^^
// >. ' .V A =*N-
;
A.' . *.•, V .•.•‘-IV- t^k aAA'v'^AA.
¥
THE SANITARY INSTITUTE.

jftel5*mai-0bal Ibis 1Ro?al Ibigbncss

©corge MiUiam ffreberid? (tbaclcs, ®ufte of ©ambribge,

lEarl of tlipperar?, anb ffiaron Culloben.

BY

Sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I., LL.D.,

M.D., F.R.S.
(vice-president.)

SECBETABT:
E. WHITE WALLTS, F.S.S.

OFFICES:
PARKES MUSEUM, MARGARET STREET,
LONDON, W.
 H.K.H. TIIK DUKE OF CAMBRIDGE, K.G.

FROM A PHOTOORAPH TAKEN AT THE CONGRESS OF THE INSTITUTE HELD AT N EWCASTLE -O N - TV N E

IN 1896.
 [Excerpt from Vol. XXV., Part I., 1904, of the Journal of
The Sanitary Institute.]

OBITL^AEY.

Ifielb^flDarsbal Me IRo^al Ibiobnese

(Bcoi'oc TOilliam Jfrebciicb Cbavlc6 2)ube of (Tambiibge,

]£arl of ^lipperar^, anb Baron CuUoben.

By sir JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I., LL.D., M.D., F.R.S.

(V ice-President.)

ri'^IIE announcement of the Duke of Cambridge’s death on the 17th of

X March, 1904, was received with the greatest regret by the com-
munity generally, as well as by the public institutions over which he
presided or with which he was connected, and which had benefited by his
great experience and practical common sense, his cordial sympathy and
his valuable co-operation. By none, probably, was the sad event more
by The Sanitary Institute, of which, at the time of his
deplox’ed than
death. His Royal Highness was the venerated and greatly respected
President. It is in association with the affairs of this Institute that we
now refer to the late lamented Royal Duke, the catholicity of whose
sympathy with the Army of which for forty years he was the head (as
well as with numerous charitable, beneficent, and other public bodies in
which he took the greatest interest, and on whose behalf he exercised the
influence of his generous, kindly, and philanthropic nature as well as that
arising out of his exalted position) has been fullyand gratefully acknow-
ledged in the various obituary notices which have already appeared. It
is, however, becoming that The Sanitary Institute, for which the Duke

did so much, should place on record a separate notice of His Royal High-
ness’s services on its behalf.
The Duke Cambridge became a member of the Parkes Museum
of
in July, 1883, when the Duke of Albany was President. On the incor-
poration of the Museum with The Sanitary Institute in 1888 he joined
147 Obituary.

the amalgamated society, in 1895 was elected President, and from that
time onwards his efforts had been strenuously devoted to its development.
He was present at the Congress of The Sanitary Institute at Newcastle-
on-Tyne where he evinced the greatest interest in the proceed-
in 1896,
ings, spoke at several of the meetings, and opened the Exhibition held in
connection with the Congress. He presided at the twenty-first com-
memorative dinner of the Institute in July, 1897, which occurred during
the busy period of the Jubilee celebrations, and on several occasions since
then has taken the chair at the annual dinners.
Especially to be remembered, however, are the signal services that
His Royal Highness rendered during the early history of the Institute.
In 1885 the Museum was in serious difficulties for want of funds, and
Sir Douglas Galton wrote a letter to the Times calling attention to its
need of support. On seeing this letter the Duke of Cambridge wrote to
Sir Douglas Galton, asking he could help in any way to reinstate the
if

Museum, and forthwith took an active part in furthering the success of a

public meeting at the Mansion House, which he not only attended, but
where he personally m’ged the importance of the undertaking, with the
result of an accretion of funds which rescued the Museum and enabled it
to be continued as the present successful and valuable public institution
which is contributing to the sanitary welfare of the country.
The Sanitary Institute, whilst, like many other public institutions,
deploring the loss of the Royal President, feels that its long period of active
work in the past and its anticipation for the futui’e has been materially
influenced by the guidance and direction of the great man who, full of
years (nearly eighty-five) and of honour, has passed away. The office
vacated will not be an easy one to fill, but the memory of his predecessor’s
valuable work will be a stimulating incitement to the next incumbent to
endeavour to follow in the footsteps of the great Prince, who made his
exalted position ancillary to furthering the progress and welfare of an
institution which, under his guidance, has become of great importance to
tlie well-being of mankind.
The memory of the late Duke will long be preserved among scientific

men, and bis name will be associated with those of other great leaders in
hygiene-work, which has resulted in the prolongation of life, the enhance-
ment of the physical and, with it, the moral well-being of the human
race. The Duke conferred great benefits on the nation, not only in his
military capacity, but as a supporter of all those departments of science
and art which contribute to human progress.
It was well said in Westminster Abbey by Canon Henson, “It is a
 Obituary. 148

gi’eat thing to say in summary of a careei’, lived thi’oughout its whole

course in the widest publicity and protracted to the extreme verge of
human life, that it was the life and as such
of a typical Englishman,
commanded the affectionate respect of a nation which, beyond other
nations, venerated sincerity, duty, and religion”; and by the leader in the
Times of March 18th, “What public life will miss in him is the spectacle
of a bluff, loyal, hearty, English gentleman, who carried a soldier’s sense of
duty into much more than his military occupations.”
Such, indeed, was the character of the Koyal Prince whose loss as its
President The Sanitary Institute has to mourn, and whose memory will
be cherished by the Institute in the growth and evolution of which he
took so great a part.
THE SANITARY INSTITUTE.
FOUNDED 1876-INCORPORATED 1888.

PARKES MUSEUM, MARGARET STREET, W.

OFFICERS OF THE INSTITUTE FOR 1903-1904.

){3attonr8s.
H.R.Il. THE DUCHESS OF ALBANY.
^resitirnt.

llaat preaititnta.
THE DUKE OP CAMBRIDGE, K.G.
H.R.H.
HIS GRACE THE DUKE OF NORTHUMBERLAND, K.G.
D.C.L., LL.D. '
{Decemfiil.
HIS GRACE THE DUKE OP WESTMINSTER, K.G.
ITicr= 13 rtsiljmts.

HIS GRACE THE DUKE OP NORTHUMBERLAND, K.G., P.C.

RIGHT HON. EARL EGERTON OP TATTON.
RIGHT HON. EARL FORTESCUE.
RIGHT HON. EARL STAMFORD.
SIR JOSEPH FAYRER, Bart., K.C.S.I., LL.D., M.D., P.R.S.
SIR FRANCIS SHARP POWELL, Bart., M.P.
SIR WILLIAM HENRY PREECE, K.C.B., F.R.S., M.Inst.C.E.
ROBERT FARQUIIARSON, M.D., M.P., LL.D.
A. WYNTER BLYTH, Barrister-at-Law, M.R.C.S., F.I.C., P.C.S.
A. WATERHOUSE, R.A., LL.D., P.R.I.B.A.
Eegistrat.
A. Wtnter Blyth, Barrister-at-Law, m.r.c.s., f.i.c., f.c.s.

CTreasurer.
T. W. Cutler, f.r.i.b.a.

Council.
Wm. Whitaker, b.a., f.r.s., f.g.s Chairman.
Prof. Henry Adams, m.inst.c.e. Prof. H. R. Kenwood, m.b., d.p.h.
T. W. ALDWINCKLE, F.R.I.B.A. Henry Herbert Law, m.inst.c.e.
Bcjshell Anningbon, m.a.,m.d, Arthur Nkwsholmk, m.d., f.r.c.p.,
Philip Boobbybr, m.b. m.r.c.s. D.P.H.
H. Percy Boulnois, m.inst.c.e. Col. J. Lane Notter, m.a., m.d.
Christopher Childs, m.a., m.d., Louis Parkes.
C. m.d., d.p.h.
M.R.C.S., D.P.H., F.c.s. W. Kaye Parry, m.a., m.inst.c.e.
W. COLLINGRIDGE, m.a., M.D., LL.M., F.R.I.B.A.
H. H. Collins, F.R.I.B.A. [d.p.h. George Reid, m.d., d.p.h.
Liedt.-Col. R. H. Firth, r.a.m.c ,
Samuel Ride a l, d.sc., f.i.c.
F.R.C.8., D.P.H. Prof. II. Robinson, m.inst.c.e.
J. Glaister, m.d., d.p.h. H. D. Searles-Wood, f.r.i.b.a.
Edwin T. Hall, f.r.i.b.a. J. O.sBORNE Smith, f.r.i.b.a.
A.Wellesley Harris, m.r.c.s., l.s. a., A. Saxon Snell, f.r.i.b.a.
D.P.H. W. C. Tyndale, m.inst.c.e.
Prof. A. Bostock Hill, m.d., m.sc., J. B. WiLLCOX. A880C.M.INST.C.K.
C DP m
T* I H. Williams, m.d., d.p.h., m.r.c.s.,
Lieut.-Col. a. S. Jones, P.C., assoc, L.R.C.P.
m.inst.c.e. John Edward Worth, m.inst.c.e.

auliitars.
W. COLI.INGRIDGK, M.A. , M.D., LL.M., D.P.H. |
WOOD, DrEW, & CO.

J^on. Solicitor.— Basil Field, b.a.

Stcretaro.
K. White Wallis, f.s.s.

ISanhtrs.
The Union of London & Smiths Bank, Regent St. Branch.
OPPICES-PARKES museum, MARGARET STREET, LONDON, W.
Ku.nny a (JO., PrlutoTS, 2S Camdon Road, London, N. W,