GROUP 6 Stats Report With Syopsis
GROUP 6 Stats Report With Syopsis
UNIVERSITY
PROJECT REPORT
“EVALUATING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SOCIAL
MEDIA USAGE AND MENTAL HEALTH OUTCOME”
SUBMITTED TO
DR. ANSHUL SRIVASTAV
Acknowledgments
Thank you to my advisor, Dr. Anshul Srivastava , who has
been the best guide throughout this journey. Dr. Anshul
Srivastava provided me with advice, feedback, and honesty at all
times.
Introduction
Social media can serve multiple purposes, for example providing
a need in several areas such as communication, entertainment, and/or
occupation (Clemmitt, 2013). However, with the increase in social
media use, individuals have been impacted in various ways, including
financial, behavioral, and personal mental health (Lenhart, 2018).
Further research on the impact of social media use on an individual’s
overall mental health is only going to become more relevant due
amount of use and the number of areas social media can have
influence on an individual’s life (Clemmitt, 2013).
With increasing amounts of research being conducted for social
media impact on personal mental health, there have been several
identified limitations when it comes to the populations studied. It is
more common to look at younger populations, Generation Z, regarding
this topic (Cipolletta, Malighetti, Cenedese, & Spoto, 2020; Frison &
Eggermont, 2017; Hanna, Ward, Seabrook, Jerald, Reed, Giaccardi, &
Lippman, 2017; Primack, Shensa, et al., 2017). There have not been
studies specifically that have considered age cohort comparisons for
social media impact, which laid the foundation for the current study.
The current study aimed to look at the broad impact of social
media and to compare reported levels of depression, anxiety, stress,
and self-esteem on the Millennial generation, which are individuals
born between the years of 1981 and 1995, and Generation Z, which are
individuals born between the years of 1996 and 2012. Based on prior
literature, it is believed that Generation Z will report more negative
mental health scores because they grew up in the prime
of social media and the internet (Golbeck, 2017); however, this may
also be the case with Millennials that were born toward the end of the
generation. This study targeted four areas of mental health:
depression, anxiety, stress, and self-esteem, which will be the focus of
the current study.
LITREATURE REVIEW
One of the primary features of social media is chatting. As a social
network, chats are a powerful method of communication among social
media users. They may take the form of group or private chats.
According to , young people with psychological issues tend to worsen
their conditions by participating in social media chatrooms. Private
chats are not exempted, found that constant chatting with other
people without feeling their physical presence is one reason for the
increase in mental health issues among social media users. The
outcome is more loneliness, a common factor in psychological
deterioration. While chatting may not directly cause depression and
other mental health problems, it can exacerbate an individual’s
symptoms if one engages in long chats . The studies further caution
that young people must be careful when chatting with their peers on
social media.
Mental Health
Depression is a mental health disorder characterized by
persistently depressed mood or loss of interest in activities, causing
significant impairment in life (Mayo Clinic, 2018). Depression is a
condition that can occur once, or through multiple episodes. During
depressive periods various symptoms occur. The symptoms of
depression include tiredness, loss of interest, angry outbursts, reduced
appetite, and in some cases, suicidal thoughts (Mayo Clinic, 2018).
Depression is a condition that can affect individuals in different ways,
the effects ranging from mild to severe.
Anxiety disorder is a mental health disorder characterized by
feelings of worry, anxiety, or fear that are strong enough to interfere
with one’s daily activities (Mayo Clinic, 2018). Experiencing anxiety is
considered a normal part of life; however, individuals with anxiety
disorder frequently have episodes that severely impact one’s daily
activities, making it difficult to function. The symptoms of anxiety
disorder include increased heart rate, hyperventilation, sense of
impending danger, difficulty controlling worry, and even having the
urge to end things that cause anxiety (Mayo Clinic, 2018). Anxiety
episodes can peak within minutes and can be extremely difficult to
control.
Conclusion
When it comes to the relationship between social media and
mental health, it has been more common to conclude social media
negatively impacts mental health. However, there are studies that
suggest exceptions to these conclusions for a negative impact .
There is a range of findings on the relationship between social media
and mental health. Impacts on mental health differ based on the
reasons as to why it is used and even how individuals are using it .
There simply is not enough research on the topic to know what impact
social media has on user mental health.
Looking at studies that have already been conducted, there has
been a variety of reported limitations. Most studies reported problems
with participants enacting social desirability when filling out surveys,
which limited the findings of the studies because participants could
have altered responses based on perceived notions of desirability. It is
also common for studies to be conducted with only young adults,
specifically from Generation Z, and no individuals from the Millennial
generation. This limits findings because they become less generalizable
to the entire population. It was recommended that future studies focus
on multiple age groups to make conclusions more generalizable.
Due to the recommendations, this study investigated the impact
of social media on mental health across two age groups, comparing the
Millennial generation and Generation Z. This study fills the gaps of
knowledge to existing research with specific regard to the ages
considered and cohort differences on the impact social media has on
personal mental health.
Methodology
In order to gather the necessary data, this study utilized a self-
report survey method. The survey collected quantitative data and
was constructed to specifically target the amount of time individuals
spend using social media, which social media platforms used, and to
identify any issues of mental health, including self-reported mental
health issues and prior mental health treatment that occur due to
social media use.
Participants
The survey was given to individuals born within the years 1996-
2012 (Z Generation) and 1981-1995 (Millennials). The study gathered a
total of 126 participants; 100 of which identified as part of Generation
Z and 26 of which identified as part of the Millennial Generation. With
the ability to gather 126 participants, this study contains a power score
of 0.96.
Data Collection Procedures
After an IRB was submitted and approved, a consent form
(Appendix A) was provided to participants before data collection
began. Data was collected by utilizing two sources. First, in order to
target the younger age pool (Z Generation participants) and in hopes of
obtaining Millennial respondents as well, the survey was provided to
students taking Principles of Psychology courses. Students completed
the survey as part of a course requirement. A second way used to
obtain Millennials; the survey was presented on the social media
platform,
Facebook, and was also distributed to alumni of the University of
Northern Colorado Honors Program through their newsletter. Qualtrics
was used to collect data on the one specific social media platform (i.e.,
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter) as a way to reach individuals from both
age groups.
Instrumentation
Various surveys were utilized to collect data. A demographic
survey was used to gather background information from participants
on gender, age, birth year, race, highest education level completed,
marital status, number of days per week social media is used and the
average number of hours per week the three social media platform(s)
are used.
The Bergen Social Media Addiction Scale (BSMAS) was used to
measure the amount of time and frequency on Facebook, Twitter,
and Instagram. The BSMAS is a six-item self-report scale on a 5-
point Likert scale and was adapted from the Bergen Facebook
Addiction Scale (Golbeck, 2017). The BSMAS is widely accepted and
has a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.88 (Duradoni, Innocenti, & Guazzini,
2020).
Levels of anxiety were measured using The Generalized Anxiety
Disorder 7-item Scale (GAD-7). The scale asks participants to rate
the severity of symptoms from four options including “not at all,”
and “nearly every day” (Child Outcomes Research Consortium, n.d.).
The widely accepted GAD-7 Scale has been validated to assess the
general population (CORC, n.d.).
The GAD-7 scale has been shown to be reliable with a Cronbach’s alpha
of 0.88 (Johnson, Ulvenes, Oktedalen, & Hoffart, 2019). Johnson et al.
(2019) reports the scale to have high validity through consistent
findings.
The Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) was used to measure
depression. Created by
participants?
Results
Demographics
As previously mentioned, this study included a total of 126
participants. Of these participants, 100 were identified to be part of
Generation Z and 26 to be part of the Millennial Generation. Majority
of participants identified as single (n=100), female (n=104), white
(n=53), and reported a High School Diploma (n=95) as their highest
level of education (see Table 1).
Table 1. Demographics
The Bergen Social Media Addiction Scale was utilized in this survey
to measure the level of addiction, feelings, and thoughts towards the
usage of social media. This scale was also used to measure the stress
that can come with the use of social media. In this study, the scale had
a Cronbach Alpha of 0.840.
Of the six questions in the scale, only 4 questions were found
to show a significant different between participants in the two
cohorts. Participants of Generation Z reported higher levels of
addiction regarding: feeling an urge to use social media more and
more, using social media to forget about personal problems, trying
to cut down on the use of social media without success, and
becoming resltess/troubled when being prohibited from using social
media (see Table 3).
Table 3. Bergen Social Media Addiction Scale
The GAD 7 – Item Scale was used to measure the level of anxiety
participants through the behaviors in which anxiety may present itself.
In this study, the scale had a Cronbach Alpha of
0.943. All questions in the scale were found to have a significant
higher levels of: feeling nervous, anxious or on edge, not being able to
Overview
This study looked to further knowledge and identify gaps with
research created when looking at the impact social media has had on
mental health across generations. The findings suggest Generation Z
participants displayed predicted impacts of social media on mental
health. Based on the hypotheses, this study was able to support that
participants in Generation Z report higher levels of depression, anxiety,
stress, and negative perceptions of self-esteem in relation to social
media use compared to participants self-identified as part of the
Millennial Generation.
Limitations
The main limitation in this study was the self-report survey
format. The survey format led to two possible issues: social desirability
and introspective ability. Social desirability is a phenomenon where
individuals who are taking a self-report survey may choose the answer
that is most socially desirable, as opposed to choosing the answer that
is most true. Introspective ability is a phenomenon where individuals
are not truly able to reflect on themselves, which makes it hard for
individuals to accurately answer a self-report survey.
Two other limitations in this study went hand in hand. Not being able
to reach the goal of
100 participants that are part of the Millennial Generation was a
limitation. Without being able to reach this goal of 100 Millennial
participants prohibited the findings from being generalizable to the
larger population. This also lead to resorting to social media to spread
the word about the survey. The survey was shared to the Facebook
social media platforms in hopes of attracting more particpants.
However, the goal was still not reached and this also created the
potential presence of bias in the results.
Although participants from Generation Z were found to show
higher levels of depression, anxiety, stress, and having negative self-
esteem, participants in the Millennial Generation also reported similar
levels. However, from the lack of Millennial participants, there was not
enough data gathered for there to be a significant connection. The
findings in this study are supported by previous research studies
(Brailovskaia et.al., 2020; Cramer et.al., 2016; Frison et.al., 2017), but
the variables of interest should receive further investigation using a
greater number of Millenial participants. Future research should also
consider recent changes in social media ownership (Twitter) along with
potential changes in use and specific perceptions of the various social
media formats.
REFRENCE
SYNOPSIS