Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology - September 1954 - Ekeblad - Non Aqueous Acid Base Titrations in Pharmaceutical

REVIEW ARTICLE
NON-AQUEOUS ACID-BASE TITRATIONS IN

PHARMACEUTICAL ANALYSIS
BY PER EKEBLAD
AND KURTERNE
Apotekens Kontrollaboratoriurn, Stockholm K, Sweden
IN recent years a great number of papers have appeared, dealing with
different types of non-aqueous titrations and complete bibliographies on
the subject have been published by Riddick1p2. This review will treat of
the non-aqueous titration of Bronsted acids and bases, a subject which has
become of great importance in the analysis of pharmaceutical preparations.
The BrSnsted acids and bases are protolytes, proton donors and proton
acceptors respectively. An acid A and its corresponding base B are
related by the formula :-
A+B$-H+
The strength of an acid or a base is indicated by the K, value of the
dissociation constant of the acid in aqueous solution.
In the titration of an acid A, with a base B, or vice versa a solvent should
be used, where the equilibrium
+ *
A, B2 Bi -t A2
lies so far to the right, that a large change in the hydrogen ion potential
takes place at the end point. The equilibrium constant in a given solution
depends on the K, values and the electrical charge of the protolytes, the
ionic strength and the dielectric properties of the solution. The proto-
lytic properties of the solvent have a levelling effect on the strength of
dissolved protolytes. Thus perchloric acid and the weaker hydrochloric
acid have the same acid strength in aqueous solution because both react
completely with the solvent, giving rise to the weaker acid H,Of . In the
same way diethylaniline and the stronger base guanidine in acetic acid
solution are of the same strength, both being protolysed to give the base
CH,COO-. From a practical point of view, the choice of solvent is
influenced by the requirements that it should not be too dangerous or too
disagreeable to handle, that the solubility of the titrated samples should
not be too low, that suitable electrodes or colour indicators should be
available for indicating the end-point and that stable titrant solutions can
be prepared.
TITRATION OF BASES
The non-aqueous titration of weak bases with perchloric acid is the part
of non-aqueous titrimetry that has been until now, most thoroughly dealt
with. The method permits a rapid determination of different types of
compounds common in the pharmacy of today: amines and heterocyclic
nitrogen compounds, amino-acids, alkali and organic salts of weak acids
and of hydrogen halides.
Acetic acid is the solvent most commonly used in the non-aqueous
titration of bases. The fundamental work on the method was carried out
43 3
20427158, 1954, 1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.2042-7158.1954.tb10969.x, Wiley Online Library on [31/01/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
PER EKEBLAD AND KURT ERNE
by Conant, Hall and Werner394y5$6,7 in the years 1927 to 1930. Some
years later Kolthoff and Willmans~9published important results from
studies of the acid strength of different cations in acetic acid.
Titration with acetous perchloric acid in different organic solvents was
studied by FritzlO. In recent years Pifer and W o l l i ~ h ~have
~ J recommen-
~,~~
ded a solution of perchloric acid in p-dioxane as being more generally
useful than the solution in acetic acid. The levelling effect of acetic acid
on the strength of bases can be overcome by titration in aprotic solvents.
Fritz14 performed differential titration of bases of different strength in
acetonitrile solution with perchloric acid in dioxane as the titrant.
Spengler and Kaelin15 applied the acetous perchloric acid titration to
many pharmaceutical problems, and gave titration curves for many
pharmaceutical compounds. The preparation of the reagents and the
role of acetic anhydride were discussed. The application of the method to
pharmaceutical preparations has also been discussed by Auerbachleand in
this journal by Beckett, Camp and Martin17.
The method is inserted in the Collection of monographs of this labora-
tory18. Details of the technique used have been p ~ b l i s h e d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
REAGENTS
The acetic acid used as solvent in the titration should have a water
content not exceeding 0.1 to 0.2 per cent. The perchloric acid solution
(usually 0.1 N) is prepared from 70 per cent. aqueous solution, which is
diluted with acetic acid. Acetic anhydride is added after the dilution to
eliminate the water. Excess of acetic anhydride should be avoided if
easily acetylated bases are to be titrated.
For back titration Spengler and Kaelin15 used a 0.1 N sodium acetate
solution prepared by dissolving standard sodium carbonate in acetic acid.
This solution was also used for the standardisation of the perchloric acid
solution. Due to the acidic property of the sodium ion in acetic acid,
sodium acetate is a weaker base than the strong organic bases in this
solvent. A strong, organic base, not sensitive to acetic anhydride, is
recommended for the standard base solution. Guanidine22and triethyl-
aminel9 have been used. The former is more easy to handle. It can be
used in the form of carbonate or acetate.
Seaman and Allen23introduced potassium hydrogen phthalate for stan-
dardisation of the acetous perchloric acid. The low ionic strength
during the titration, due to the precipitation of potassium perchlorate,
gives an extremely sharp end-point.
The standard base solution is best standardised against the perchloric
acid. The standard solutions in acetic acid are stable for a long time.
Though many acid-base indicators give colour changes in acetic acid,
crystal violet, introduced by the pioneers of the methode, is still the most
commonly used. a-Naphthol-benzein and benzoylauramin were found
to have no advantage over this indicatorz2. Crystal violet gives a series of
colour changes around the “neutral point” of the acetic acid system and
some practice is required if good results are to be obtained with this
indicator. In the titration of potassium salts, the end-point is indicated by
434
NON-AQUEOUS ACID-BASE TITRATIONS
the first change from violet to blue, in the titration of strong organic bases
the change is from blue to green and in the titration of weaker bases the
change is from bluish green to greenish yellow.
A Ciba-dye, Blue BZL, which has a colour change from blue to red at
the “neutral point” has been successfully used in our laboratory in the
titration of nikethamide and stronger bases. For weaker bases neutral
redl9 (colour change red- blue) is recommended. For potentiometric
indication of the end-point chloraniP or hydroquinonez4electrodes can be
used in cases where the solutions do not contain acetic anhydride or other
compounds, which react with the electrode. The glass electrode is
most suitable. A calomel electrode or a silver-silver chloride electrodelo
can be used as reference electrode. Reproducible and stable potentials
are best obtained with a calomel electrode, connected to the solution by
the lithium chloride bridge used by Hall and Conant3.
APPLICATIONS
Organic bases: As shown by Hall‘, the basic strength of amines and
heterocyclic nitrogen compounds in acetic acid is, in most cases, linear
to their strength in aqueous solution. Organic bases with K, = 10-6 or
less are strong bases, that is, they give completely ionised acetates in
acetic acid solution. Bases with K, values up to often are strong
enough to be titrated visually. Among the weak bases titratable in
acetic acid can be mentioned phenazone and isopropylphenazone,
nikethamide, nicotinamide and phenylcinchonic acid. Many bases,
monovalent by titration in aqueous solution are divalent in acetic acid, for
example quinine and procaine.
For the titration of tertiary amines in mixtures with primary and
secondary amines, Blumrich and Bandd5 used acetic anhydride. By
boiling with acetic anhydride the primary and secondary amines are
acetylated and lose their basic character, and the tertiary amines can be
titrated. The method can be used on compounds containing a tertiary
and a primary or secondary nitrogen. Examples of this are procaine
and tetracaine. On account of the weaker basic properties of the
aromatic amino groups in these compounds and the precipitation of
diperchlorate during the titration, visual indication of the end-point is not
sharp. After boiling with acetic anhydride, giving an acetylated aromatic
amine, the strongly basic tertiary aliphatic nitrogen can be titrated in
acetic acid. The same procedure has been used for titration of the pyri-
dine nitrogen in isoniazid.
Amino-acids: The potentiometric and visual titration of amino-acids in
acetic acid was described by Nadeau and Branchen22. The amino-acids
are usually very slowly soluble in acetic acid. Heating can cause acetyla-
tion and decompositionz0. Toennis and Callanz6showed that the amino-
acids could be dissolved in a small amount of formic acid and the solution
diluted with acetic acid before titration. The final solutions should
contain less than 2 per cent. of formic acid. The same procedure can be
used for electrolytes, which are difficult to dissolve in acetic acid and sensi-
tive to heat, for example thiamine hydrochloride.
435
Salts : The low dielectric constant for acetic acid favours the titration
of anion bases. Whereas the weakly basic caffeine can hardly be titrated,
anion bases of approximately the same strength, e.g., the picrate and the
dihydrogen phosphate ion, are titrated as strong bases. Higuchi and
Concha27titrated salts of such strong acids as nitric acid. Sulphates can be
titrated to acid sulphates, but not to sulphuric acid. The halogen ions are
too weakly basic to be titrated directly. As a great deal of the pharma-
ceutically useful organic bases are used as chlorides or bromides, a great
widening of the field of non-aqueous acidimetry was made when Pifer,
Wollish and SchmalP2introduced mercuric acetate as a means of removing
halogen ions inacetic acid solution. The mercuricacetate reacts with haloid
ions giving mercuric halide and an equivalent amount of acetate ions. The
mercuric acetate and halide have no basic properties in acetic acid.
In a recently published review article28,the same authors mention that
they have succeeded in titrating sulphates in acetic acid after removing the
sulphate ions by heating with mercurous acetate. No details have yet
been given.
Today, it is possible to titrate acidimetrically the salts of most of the
commonly used acids, except perchloric and sulphonic acids, provided
that the acid strength of the cation in acetic acid is not too great. The
salts of organic bases, themselves not too weak to be titrated, can be
assayed in this way. As to the inorganic cations, it is of special impor-
tance to have a rapid method for the assay of the alkali salts.
TITRATION OF ACIDS
The pioneer in this field was Folin who as early as 1910 estimated
fatty acids in non-aqueous solvents by titrating with sodium ethoxide20.
La Mer and Downs seem to be the first to apply potentiometry to the
determination of acids in aprotic systems30. In 1948 Moss, Elliot and
Hal131 published an important account of the determination of phenolic
compounds in resins. They used sodium aminoethoxide in ethylene-
diamine as titrant and antimony-antimony electrodes as indicating system.
Of fundamental importance to the further analytical development of the
method has been the work of Fritz and co-workers who since 1950 have
issued a series of papers concerning the non-aqueous titration of both
weak a ~ i d ~and~bases. ~ ~As titrant
~ ~ Fritz~ used
~ ~alkali~ methoxide
~ ~ * ~ ~
in benzene-methanol, while the solvent was varied according to the acid
strength of the compound to be titrated.
Solvents
Selection of a proper solvent is essential in non-aqueous titrations.
Especially important factors are the basicity and the dielectric properties
of the solvent. Increased basicity of the solvent enhances the acidic
properties of a dissolved acid and a low dielectric constant of the solvent
depresses the ionisation and thereby augments the acid strength or base
strength of dissolved p r ~ t o l y t e s ~ ~ .
The solvent power of such a solvent may, however, be poor and the
addition of a more polar medium is required. There is evidence that such
436
mixed solvents (e.g., benzene-methanol) are superior to pure solvents in
solubilising effect and sharpness of the indicator change or the potential
break at the equivalence point. No solvent with such general applicability
for weak acids as glacial acetic acid has for weak bases, has yet appeared.
A widely used mixed type solvent is benzene-methanol introduced by
Fritz3z. Dimethylformamide has shown itself to be a very useful sol-
vent3z~34~36,
among its advantages is the freedom from odour, and it does
not absorb carbon dioxide as eagerly as the more basic solvents. A draw-
back however is the risk of hydrolysis of the amide linkage, especially in
the presence of water, with subsequent liberation of acid. For the most
weakly acidic compounds butylamine, pyridine and ethylenediamine
seem to be the most suitable solvents.
Titrants
Several alkaline titrants have been used in non-aqueous solvents : alkali
hydroxides, a l k o x i d e ~ ~aminoalk~xides~~
~~~, and amides38; as well as
quaternary ammonium bases and-for extremely weak acids-triphenyl-
methyl sodium39. Although none has gained absolute dominance
like acetous perchloric acid, sodium methoxide in benzene-methanol has
found a rather wide application. There are some interferences however.
Water behaves like a weak acid and should be absent. Likewise the need
for protection against carbon dioxide is obvious. There is also some risk
of atmospheric oxidation of alcoholic alkoxide solutions to acidic com-
p o u n d ~ ~An
~ . inert atmosphere in the storage bottle and in the titration
vessel tends to minimise the influence of these last mentioned factors. In
some instances lithium methoxide may be preferable because of its greater
solubility in organic solvents and in other cases the more strongly basic
potassium analogue may offer some advantagesz8.
Indicator systems
Some acid-base indicators known from aqueous titrimetry have been
used with success in non-aqueous media. Here may be mentioned thy-
mol blue, thymolphthalein and phenolphthalein and also azo violet
(p-nitrobenzene azoresorcinol) and o-nitroaniline. Among these thymol
blue especially has found a wide acceptance. The colour change is from
yellow through green to blue. By comparison with potentiometric
determinations the exact colour shade at the equivalence point may be
established.
For that purpose several electrode couples have been used, e.g., glass-
calomeP5, antimony-antimony31antimony-glass, antirn~ny-calomel~~. In
some instances such systems operate successfully but often the electrode
response is slow and unstable. Electrode systerus in non-aqueous
media have been investigated at the National Bureau of S t a n d a r d s * l ~ ~ ~ ? ~ ~ ,
but much work remains to be done in this field. Until now there has
appeared no electrode system that functions satisfactorily in solvents of
low dielectric constant.
Most of the methods published have employed an alkali methoxide
titrant. The procedure used in this laboratory (which follows Fritz
437
closely) for the determination of barbiturates and other weak acids may
serve as a guide to the technique.
REAGENTS
0.1 M Sodium methoxide
Dissolve 3 g. of freshly cut sodium metal in 50 ml. of dry methanol
protecting the vessel from carbon dioxide, add 100 ml. of methanol and
then 750 ml. of benzene. The solution is stored in alkali resistant glass
and is protected from carbon dioxide.
Thymol blue
0.3 per cent. solution in methanol.
Procedure
To 10 to 20 ml. of a suitable solvent add 2 drops of thymol blue and
bubble nitrogen gas through for 10 minutes. Then titrate to a blue colour
with the methoxide. Add the sample corresponding to about 1 m-equiv.
and titrate to the same colour change. During the titration nitrogen gas
is led into the solution whereby the latter is both stirred and protected
from carbon dioxide and moisture. The titrant is standardised in the
same manner against benzoic acid. The titre is rather sensitive to temper-
ature on account of the high thermal expansion of benzene-methanol and,
therefore, frequent restandardisation is advisable.
With this technique it is possible to determine a great many substances
of importance in pharmacy. Carboxylic acids and other moderately
acidic compounds may be titrated in neutral or basic solvents but the
sharpest end-points are obtained in mixed solvents such as benzene-
methanol. Thymol blue is a good indicator31.
. In “sulpha” drugs the amide hydrogen is sufficiently acidic to permit of
ready titration in dimethylformamide with thymol blue as the indica-
tor34136. The same technique applies to the barbiturate^^^ but butylamine
and ~ y r i d i n eare
~ ~also good solvents.
The acidic moiety of ammonium salts and salts of aliphatic amines is
amenable to titration in dimethylformamide or ethylenediamine (thymol
blue or azo violet)33. Likewise negatively substituted phenols possess
sufficient acidic character to be titrated in dimethylformamide, azo violet
being a suitable indicator. Phenol and alkyl phenols are weaker acids and
require a more basic solvent such as ethylenediamine ( o - n i t r ~ a n i l i n e ) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .
Numerous other compounds of very slight acidity such as enols,
mercaptans and imides may be titratcd in bulylarniiie or eth~lenediamine~~.
In all these cases the water content of the system should be kept at a
minimum because of the acidic properties of water. Besides, as the
solvents often contain acidic contaminants, it is a good rule always to
neutralise the solvent prior to the titration of the sample.
Our thanks are due to Dr. T. Canback, head of this Laboratory, for
valuable discussions during the preparation of this review.
438
REFERENCES
1. Riddick, Analyt. Chem., 1952, 24, 41.
2. Riddick, ibid, 1954, 26, 77.
3. Hall and Conant, J. Amer. chem. SOC.,1927, 49, 3047.
4. Conant and Hall, ibid., 1927, 49, 3062.
5. Hall and Werner, ibid., 1928, 50, 2367.
6. Conant and Werner, ibid., 1930, 52, 4436.
7. Hall, ibid., 1930, 52, 5115.
8. Kolthoff and Willman, ibid., 1934, 56, 1007.
9. Kolthoff and Willman, ibid., 1934, 56, 1014.
10. Fritz, Analyt. Chem., 1950, 22, 1028.
11. Pifer and Wollish, J. Amer. pharm. Ass., Sci. Ed., 1951, 40, 609.
12. Pifer and Wollish, Analyt. Chem., 1952, 24, 300.
13. Pifer and Wollish, ibid., 1952, 24, 519.
14. Fritz, ibid., 1953, 25, 407.
15. Spengler and Kaelin, Pharm. Acta Helvet., 1943, 18, 542.
16. Auerbach, Drug Standards, 1951, 19, 127.
17. Beckett, Camp and Martin, J. Pharm. Pharmacol., 1952, 4, 399.
18. Apotekens Kontrollaboratoriums Monografsamling, 1953.
19. Ekeblad, Svensk. Farm. Tidskr., 1952, 56, 191.
20. Ekeblad, ibid., 1953, 57, 185.
21. Ekeblad, J. Pharm. Pharmacol., 1952, 4, 636.
22. Nadeau and Branchen, J. Amer. chem. SOC.,1935, 57, 1363.
23. Seaman and Allen, Analyt. Chem., 1951, 23, 592.
24. Tomicek, Coll. Czech. Chem. Comm., 1948, 13, 116.
25. Blumrich and Bandel, Angew. Chem., 1941, 54, 374.
26. Toennis and Callan, J . biol. Chem., 1935, 125, 259.
27. Higuchi and Concha, J. Amer. pharm. Ass., Sci. Ed., 1951, 40, 173.
28. Pifer, Wollish and Schmall, ibid., 1953, 42, 509.
29. Folin and Wentworth, J. biol. Chem., 1909-10, 7, 421.
30. La Mer and Downs, J. Amer. chem. SOC.,1931, 53, 888.
31. Moss, Elliot and Hall, Analyt. Chem., 1948, 20, 784.
32. Fritz and Lisicki, ibid., 1951, 23, 589.
33. Fritz, ibid., 1952, 24, 306.
34. Fritz and Keen, ibid., 1952, 24, 308.
35. Fritz and Keen, ibid., 1953, 25, 179.
36. Vespe and Fritz, J . Amer. pharm. Ass., Sci. Ed., 1952, 41, 197.
37. Hammett, J. Amer. chem. SOC.,1928, 50, 2666.
38. Higuchi, Concha and Kuramoto, Analyt. Chem., 1952, 24, 685.
39. Corwin and Ellingson, J. Amer. chem. SOC.,1942, 64, 2098.
40. Wooten and Ruehle, Zndustr. Engng Chem. (Anal.), 1934, 6, 449.
41. Davis and Hetzer, J . Research Nut. Bur. Stand., 1952, 48, 381.
42. Davis and McDonald, ibid., 1949, 42, 595.
43. Davis and Schumann, ibid., 1947, 39, 221.
44. Heiz, Dansk Tidsskr. Farm., 1952, 26, 69.
439

Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology - September 1954 - Ekeblad - Non Aqueous Acid Base Titrations in Pharmaceutical

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology - September 1954 - Ekeblad - Non Aqueous Acid Base Titrations in Pharmaceutical

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology - September 1954 - Ekeblad - Non Aqueous Acid Base Titrations in Pharmaceutical

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

REVIEW ARTICLE

NON-AQUEOUS ACID-BASE TITRATIONS IN

You might also like