Articles 1038012 PDF
Articles 1038012 PDF
Introduction
Companies have exchanged jobs and roles usually developed by people for animals,
devices and/or machines in order to maximize profits. Along centuries, new technologies
have been gradually incorporated to amortize jobs and create more efficient ones. The
final effect, with ups and downs during the process, has been a constant improvement
in productivity and the generation of economic wealth.
Animals, water and steams suppressed humans crushing cereals, mills eliminated
them, and automation chains eliminated mills. This has facilitated the creation of an
exponentially growing food industry whose products became potentially cheaper.
No one has protested for the disappearance of bread kneaders in the same way that
106
J. Bayón Pérez, A.J. Arenas Falótico - Various perspectives of labor and human resources challenges and changes due to automation and artificial intelligence 107
no one has complained about not having to plough the land as a consequence of
tractors´ invention (Moriya, H., Fernández, M.C., Fernandini, M. & Méndez, J.C., 2018).
Analysis
Forecasts for the year 2025
Most people think their jobs are special and irreplaceable. They are considered
essential and personal skills and creativity are key elements to their development and
implementation, but the advent of constant technological innovation, for instance
artificial intelligence (AI) systems has a greater presence in our global business
workplace. How can this affect our labor relations systems? This will inevitably lead
to the destruction of jobs that do not require specific, multidisciplinary training,
more related to jobs that consist of physical or repetitive tasks. This circumstance is
going to trigger a violation of the rights of basic training for employees who develop
monotonous jobs. This job destruction by robots is closely related to Daniel Pink
theory of motivation (2009), those jobs that are not suitable for cash bonuses are those
which will easily be replaced by robots using Artificial Intelligence (AI), hence those
with more lateral thinking (Bono, 1970) will be harder to be replaced.
However, the World Economic Forum Report (2018) states that new jobs will also be
created. Will there be a pyramidal balance between destruction and creation? The
answer is no. The report also confirms that 75 million jobs will be destroyed due to
robots or software using AI, with the subsequent creation of 133 million jobs. This
has considerable consequences in our global labor relations system. The jobs of the
future will require more specific training, more preparation, new skills, competences,
aptitudes and distinctive attitudes that generate added value so robots cannot be
seen as a danger to job stability. The question is, which profiles will be needed?
Martín-Artiles, J. A., Godino, A. & Molina, O. (2018) assert that, among other profiles,
the most demanded ones will be: Data analysts, designers, critical thinkers, social
intelligence, digital marketing specialists, online leaders, multitasking personnel,
as well as programmers and software developers, cybersecurity experts, artificial
intelligence engineers, digitization lawyers, data scientists / Deep Learning, Digital
Content Manager, Web/CRO analyst, Social Media Strategist, and Transformation &
Innovation Auditor.
This abrupt transformation process in a short period of time must be managed with
great caution, as this could be projected into a new era of excellent jobs and a better
quality of life for all. The cutting-edge consequences of a disastrous direction and
management could lead to widening gaps skill, greater disparity and more prolonged
polarization. Can artificial intelligence, advanced robotics, autonomous automobiles
and other new technologies spread and expand progress, success and well-being to
108 A cademicus - I nternational S cientific J ournal www . academicus . edu . al 108
the world’s population? The main idea is that new technologies integration into the
business sector has led to the loss of many jobs. It is true than between the number
of creation and destruction there is a considerable number of people who will be
impacted negatively by new needs and different demands. Some of those profiles will
become obsolete. On the other hand, it is clear the comfort increase and the good
acceptance level of e-services by users even before the services are provided.
Recent experiments published by Science Robotics magazine (F. Suárez-Ruiz, X. Zhou, Q.-C.
Pham, 2018) show that a robots can easily assemble an IKEA chair. A new trend may begin
if customers perceive that a chair assembled by a robot is fashionable and stylish.
But there are still things to be improved, we increasingly order online products that
arrive late due to shipping bottlenecks, also there are long waiting times or backorders
for some specific products. On the other hand, Wi-Fi often fails or is below our digital
needs such as TV on Demand and high resolution online games.
Moving the focus to human resources, the search for a new employee involves
the recruitment and selection processes. It can take a recruiter a long time to read
approximate 100 CVs that are received online. Using this manual approach, the first
selection by the recruiter takes considerable time. Actually the online method just
creates a virtual rush-hour that lands in the eyes and hands of an employee who ends
up reading them on a screen instead of using a printed piece of paper. A second round
of finalists is then implemented, and the candidates are finally scheduled for individual
or group testing. These tasks are always the same with few changes. Things evolve
when the process is automated using artificial intelligence because they are now
used as support in the Human Resources (HR) department of large companies (Human
Resources Observatory, 2018). Companies that use AI in their HR processes have increased
up to 300% the hiring processing time with higher quality compared to traditional
recruitment methods mentioned before. The main applications of AI are oriented to
market research, human resources automation, customer service, big data analysis
and digital marketing. Companies must implement AI in these key areas if they want
to obtain the highest return on their technological investment (Big Data Social, 2018).
Artificial intelligence applied to Human Resource Management can encompass many
activities, not just scanning curriculums. Therefore, AI is able to categorize candidates
according to certain parameters, evaluate their aptitudes and calculate the probability
of success. Some of the solutions available on the market use artificial intelligence
technology to reduce the number of candidates according to experience and relevance,
then give the same personalized skills assessments to measure aptitude, personality
qualities and even the probability of success in the available positions. With access
to this critical data, recruiters can make contractual decisions, supported by the high
security and reliability of a department that has automated the selection process.
J. Bayón Pérez, A.J. Arenas Falótico - Various perspectives of labor and human resources challenges and changes due to automation and artificial intelligence 109
Work in the digital age a paradigm shift in the object of labor law?
It is undeniable that the progressive automation of economic activities eliminate the
relations between labor supply and demand. New technologies, e-commerce, Big Data
and AI have created great business successful stories that represent the revolution
from which the economy of the future has been born. It is interesting that we are
initiating a flexible educational model, in which training in new digital skills, abilities
and the demand for continuous learning throughout life are extended as much as
possible.
It is important to highlight the focus shift from content to competencies. Learning
is no longer just a question of knowledge access or theoretical content assimilation;
indeed, it is about being able to acquire applicable skills in the digital world. An integral,
transdisciplinary, multiskilling and very practical training.
Given that neither the training of these generations, nor experience nor adequate
effective employment policies are currently adapted, it is necessary to request our
labor legal system for a new legal instrument that could adapt to all the idiosyncrasies
that occur in the labor sphere. This is what we can call the “viability of labor law in a
digitized environment”.
Labor relations and digitalization
The constant changes that have taken place in our labor market have been supported
by negotiation and social dialogue. In recent years there have been many changes in
most countries through different labor law reforms. Organizations in general exploit
technological platforms and, through these, great changes are transforming traditional
labor relations. What are the workers like in these companies? There is a predominance
of employees who carry out activities alone, with less social contact, either from
home or another comfortable place. This form of employment has spread mainly in
the service sector. The advancement of this new labor framework is leading to weak
collective bargaining, if any. A good example of this is the Amazon`s mechanical Turk
platform. The presence of new technologies has led to a transformation of production
processes due to all the innovations incorporated. This is a clear attempt to reduce
labor costs. In addition, companies look to outsource independent workers and
freelancers that can provide greater flexibility. It also reduces the size of companies
through the decrease of jobs and causes fragmentation of the units or departments
involved. This complex process generates a series of setbacks and weaknesses in the
collective bargaining capacity that under normal conditions would make possible to
improve people’s working conditions and guarantee safe and quality employment
(Álvarez, D., 2018).
114 A cademicus - I nternational S cientific J ournal www . academicus . edu . al 114
We must also consider the high level of self-employed workers that prevent collective
bargaining agreements. In the same way, the considerable and constant increase in
self-employment leads to worse working conditions, greater lack of protection and,
generally, a job quality decrease. Likewise, the development of crowdsourcing entails a
qualitative improvement in terms of the outsourcing of self-employed workers, either
one or the other observe independent workers without a real contractual relationship
between the parties.
So far there has been no response from the sphere of collective autonomy to the
situation of platform workers. This contrasts with the experience of other European
countries, including the Nordic countries, where collective agreements have been
developed at sectoral level through which attempts have been made to resolve the
problem of non-coverage in this type of workers.
The European trade union has persevered in the need to develop legal mechanisms to
regulate this situations at community level, given its extension in all member countries.
The transnational dimension in the regulation of collective rights is a particularly
important element in this regard. By definition, digital platforms can operate in several
countries without the need for physical presence in any of them. It is, therefore, a
business model that overcomes national barriers and requires treatment at the same
level.
Conclusions
More and more workers are entering the world of android/robots creation, innovation
and AI. It has been proven that being an expert in robotics and artificial intelligence
applied to automation gadgets is one of the most sought-after professions for the
technology industry and in the near future may be one of the professions with the
greatest demand in different work environments of the world. According to all the
information presented, we can consider that new technologies, their evolution, the
impulse and development of artificial intelligence, etc. have a dominant influence on
the relations between employers and workers, giving rise to much more flexible labor
relations.
Entrepreneurs, freelancers, interested personnel, and large and SMEs can affirm
that AI and the exponential development of robotics is needed to improve business
productivity, organizational results, and competitiveness in a market of constant
changes, transdisciplinary issues and worldwide asymmetric competition. Also, that it
allows the optimization work teams and the enhancement of human talent, achieving
organizational and productive improvements. In addition, automation, robotics and
AI, present an opportunity for people who are part of it to grow professionally, that is
J. Bayón Pérez, A.J. Arenas Falótico - Various perspectives of labor and human resources challenges and changes due to automation and artificial intelligence 115
to say, that they dedicate most of their time to make important decisions and eliminate
repetitive tasks or bureaucratic processes.
In contrast, we have found that all of these improvements have major disadvantages.
The appearance and transformation of new technologies have caused and will cause
alterations in the ways organizations work. This allows people to perform multiple
tasks, to work outside the office and not regular working hours. In addition, they
generate the need to rely on more flexible working relationships. Furthermore, there
are 24-hour contracts, weak working interactions, search for collaborations with
freelance personnel, and the uberization of workers.
To be able to continue supporting us in all these mechanisms in a gradual way, a great
cultural change must take place. The progressive establishment of new technologies
and artificial intelligence in companies represents a qualitative techno-organizational
impulse with an unlimited range of consequences for human resources policies and
new law regulations that affect the work environment.
Artificial Intelligence is the most disruptive of all new technologies and entails a
series of far-reaching organizational and legal consequences for those companies
that choose to use them as the operational epicenter for most of their production
processes, functions and tasks developed by workers.
The robotization of the world’s jobs using AI is coming in due time. Throughout the
years, robots have developed tasks in factories, however, the difference between the
new robots using AI and the old ones lies in the fact that those that are coming will
affect our lives in a much more direct and palpable way, when these are implanted in
the majority of the workplaces.
Are we going to lose our jobs because of robots? There is no doubt that robotics
development raise questions, from jobs sustainability to social welfare system
maintenance.
This is the opinion of an Israeli mathematician and university professor Moshe Vardi
(2016) “By 2045 machines will be able to do a very significant fraction of the work that
humans can do. (…) If machines are capable of doing almost any work humans can
do, what will humans do?” It is clear that humankind, to be sustainable, must reach
an equilibrium between the use of robots with AI and the tasks to be performed by
workers in the near future.
According to Fernandez, C. (2018) in 2027 most of the workforce is expected to be self-
employed. Being ‘small’ will no longer be a synonymous of having fewer options. Today
we see how many small companies are operating internationally and large companies,
rethinking how to make the leap.
116 A cademicus - I nternational S cientific J ournal www . academicus . edu . al 116
In addition, the “war for talent” will be between Cities around the world. The majority
of workers will be freelancers, they will want to be able to carry out their work with
freedom of schedule and without having to go daily to a demarcated work center, and
such scenarios will allow people to choose where to work with total freedom. And
this freedom to decide which city to live in will become vital for both of them. Faced
with this prediction hundreds of cities are preparing, not to receive the technological
giants and their legion of workers, but rather, moving away from this, to receive the
employees that will work remotely and only want a place where they can be happy,
pay less taxes, have good internet connection and work independently to different
companies.
Finally, it is clear that humans will prevail since the only reason for robot with AI to
exist is profit maximization, increase comfort and expedite procedures in all business
areas. However, employees must start to give more value to their current jobs and
develop more their emotional and personal skills, such as: positive thinking, criticism
in all senses, assertiveness, creativity, communicative and social skills, giving rise to a
new and different series of products and services that people will demand, to increase,
together with AI and robots, the economy and the well-being of our future world. It is
clear that this paradigm will shift the current concept we have of the information and
the knowledgeable society to a new redefined concept that is still to be known. Also,
this innovative approach will also trigger new labor legislation and human resources
policies and procedures that can fit better with it.
Bibliography
1. Álvarez, R. (2018). Webedia. Automatización eliminará 75 millones de
empleos para 2025. Retrieved from https://www.xataka.com/robotica-e-
ia/automatizacion-eliminara-75-millones-empleos-para-2025-creara-133-
millones-nuevas-funciones-wef
2. Big Data Marketer. (2018). Inteligencia artificial aplicada a la automatización de
recursos humanos. Retrieved from http://www.bigdata-social.com/inteligencia-
artificial-aplicada-automatizacion-recursos-humanos/. Big Data Social.
3. Bria, F. (2019). Ingreso básico y precariedad laboral en la economía de los robots.
Nueva Sociedad, 114-121.
4. Carrozza, M.C. (2019) Are We Going Through a Real Revolution? In: The Robot
and Us. Biosystems & Biorobotics, vol 20. Springer, Cham
5. De, B. E. (1970). Lateral thinking: A textbook of creativity. London: Ward Lock
Educational.
J. Bayón Pérez, A.J. Arenas Falótico - Various perspectives of labor and human resources challenges and changes due to automation and artificial intelligence 117