Vaidam Health
Vaidam Health
selection of [a] health care solution and to provide a seamless experience through[out] their
patient journey.
Ever since Pankaj Chandna, the co-founder of online medical-value travel (MVT) facilitator Vaidam
Health
Private Limited (Vaidam),1 had returned from his trip to Fiji, there had been a lot on his mind. The
trip had
been aimed at business expansion. Now, Pankaj and his old classmate and co-founder, Manish
Chandra,
were flipping through the market data he had collected during meetings with health care
professionals,
corporations, insurers, and representatives of ministries of health during this month-long tour in May
2018.
Their intention was to create a presence in the offline market and to identify alternate business
channels to
attract more patients from some of the key source countries for MVT to India.
Since its inception in January 2016, Vaidam had hosted overseas patients who travelled to India for
medical
treatment. It had partnered with over 100 world-class health care facilities across the major cities in
the
country. In addition to hospitals, the company worked closely with over 1,000 medical practitioners
(surgeons and specialists) who were renowned for highly advanced allopathic treatments such as
organ
transplant, cardiology, and oncology. To efficiently address medical travellers’ needs during their
stays, the
company had also created an ecosystem of service providers offering accommodation, ground
transportation, language translation, and domestic services. So far, patients from more than 50
countries
(primarily Australia, countries in Africa and the Middle East, and in neighbouring Asian nations) had
received satisfactory treatment using Vaidam’s network. It had generated business worth over
US$275,0002
for the associated hospitals and medical practitioners during the first half of financial year 2017–18.
As one of the pioneers in setting up web-based MVT services in India, Vaidam was able to gain the
trust
of overseas patients by offering personalized and customized care with complete transparency. From
a
business environment perspective, the Indian health care industry, backed by the supportive policies
of the
government of India (GOI), was emerging as a global destination for medical tourism. Given the
improved
1 MVT facilitators were companies that worked as intermediaries between medical travellers and
health care service providers,
attractiveness of MVT, the founders of Vaidam realized that they would face tough competition in
attempting to further leverage this massive unaddressed business opportunity. Although they had
successfully built the company using personal finances and had come this far, they now faced a
tougher
challenge. As an MVT facilitator, Vaidam needed to determine how it could continuously offer value
to
medical travellers so that they would continue to choose Vaidam to plan their treatment and travel
to India.
With globalization, travelling abroad for medical interventions (known as MVT, medical tourism, or
health
travel) had become a widespread phenomenon. These medical interventions ranged from advanced
medical
treatments and surgeries (e.g., curative treatments such as cardiac surgery or knee replacement) to
wellness
or rejuvenation treatments (e.g., cosmetic surgery and spa services) and alternative medicine (e.g.,
Ayurveda and naturopathy).3 The last two decades had witnessed a shift in the MVT destinations
preferred
by travellers from the developed markets of the United States and Western Europe, who now
travelled to
Asian countries such as Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore, South Korea, and India.4 Rising health care
costs
and long waiting times for treatment in developed countries combined with the availability of heavily
subsidized, world-class medical care in Asian countries were the key reasons for this shift.
India was one of the key destinations for MVT and witnessed a 22–25 per cent growth in the arrival
of
medical tourists in 2017.5 The MVT industry was expected to reach $9 billion by 2020. This was
evident
from the steep rise in the number of medical visas the country had issued for both initial medical
treatments
and follow-up visits.6 The majority of these tourists were from South Asian Association for Regional
States countries such as Russia, Kazakhstan, and Moldova; African countries such as South Africa,
Kenya,
and Nigeria; and Middle Eastern countries such as Iran, Turkey, and Egypt. Patients from these
regions
were primarily travelling for advanced curative care for cardiac and orthopaedic treatments.
However,
despite large numbers of foreign tourists arriving from the United States, Europe, and other
developed
regions, the share of medical tourists from these regions had been limited so far. There were
numerous
environmental considerations that made India a preferred choice for medical tourists.
Brand India
India was one of the oldest civilizations in the world, with a rich cultural heritage. Historically, the
country
had been the centre of alternative healing therapies such as Ayurveda, yoga, and meditation,
attracting
travellers globally and offering health and spiritual benefits. Economically, the country was the
seventh largest
economy, with a gross domestic product (GDP) growth of 5.4 per cent in 2017. With vast cultural and
natural
resources and price competitiveness, India was ranked 40th (gaining 12 places from 2016) among
136
countries in the Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report for the year 2017.7 Further, despite the
phenomenal language diversity in the country, English was the official language and was spoken
widely by
the people. The country’s diversity also contributed to the extensive variety of international and
national
cuisines offered in the country. Supportive visa policies, such as visa on arrival and e-visas, were
indicative
of the country’s openness for international travellers. India’s booming information and
communication
technology industry had contributed to increased Internet and mobile penetration, which facilitated
distribution of information for foreign travellers. Nevertheless, security risks in some border regions
and cases
of crime against women in the past had affected the country’s global image as a tourist destination.
Having
said that, the GOI had been taking concrete steps to make India stand out in the field of medical
tourism.
Health care delivery was one of the largest sectors in India; it was growing at a compound annual
growth
rate of 16.5 per cent and was expected to reach $280 billion by 2020 (up from $160 billion in 2017).8
This
sector comprised public and private health care delivery systems. The public health care system was
limited
to primary health centres staffed by medical officers and some paramedical staff in rural areas,
secondary
district hospitals and community health centres, and tertiary care centres and advanced medical
research
institutes in cities. Total health care spending represented 5 per cent of the country’s GDP; out of
this, the
amount spent on the public health care system was still low (1.2 per cent in 2017) compared to that
in many
emerging economies. However, the GOI’s National Health Policy had set a target to increase this
share to
Private health care players, who accounted for 75 percent of the country’s total health care
expenditure,
were the vibrant force behind the growth of the Indian health care industry. These players had made
huge
investments in setting up chains of world-class hospitals and diagnostic centres in metros and Tier 1
cities
including New Delhi, Chennai, Mumbai, and Hyderabad. Some of the private hospital chains in India,
which were renowned for tertiary and quaternary care facilities, were Apollo Hospitals Enterprise
Limited
(with a capacity of 9,215 beds), Fortis Health Care Limited (10,000 beds), Max Health Care (2,016
beds),
Manipal Hospitals Group (4,900 beds), and Narayana Health (7,452 beds).10 The vision of these
hospitals
was to offer high standards of medical care along with clinical research and training. According to a
recent
PWC report, in addition to an influx of private investors, this sector had been witnessing a significant
increase in foreign direct investment over the past few years.11 “Access to capital had been the
major
roadblock for the growth of [the] Indian health care sector. Both the public and private sectors need
to join
hands to build the health care infrastructure in the country,” Manish said.
Curative care treatments involving advanced medical procedures for cardiology, orthopaedics,
transplants,
and ophthalmology were available in India at significant cost differentials and without any waiting
time.
According to statistics released by the American Marketing Association, the cost of a knee
replacement
surgery was $40,000 in the United States, $10,000 in Thailand, $13,000 in Singapore, and $8,500 in
India
(see Exhibit 1). The total cost of treatment, including health services, accommodation, and food
services,
was estimated to be 70–75 per cent less in India compared to in many Western and South Asian
countries
According to a 2013 Harvard Business Review study, keys to making the global standards of Indian
health
care available at a competitive price were coordinated medical planning, economizing the use of
expensive
equipment and expertise, and minimizing operational costs.13 “The Indian surgeons operate far
more cases
than their counterparts in the United Kingdom or the United States and thus are more experienced.
They
give excellent outcomes with less resources, and that is their USP [unique selling point],” Manish
noted.
Beyond allopathic medicine, the Indian health care sector enjoyed credibility in a host of traditional
healing
methods or alternative medicines based on Ayurveda, yoga and naturopathy, and homoeopathy
(AYUSH).
With the establishment of the Ministry of AYUSH in 2014, the GOI was working to develop and
promote
these traditional medical and health care systems to attract foreign patients.
The focus on accreditation of Indian health care facilities played a key role in building patients’
confidence
in the quality of health care outcomes. “The patient’s trust towards a certain hospital is automatically
enhanced when they see that it is well accredited,” Manish explained. Established in 2006, the
National
Accreditation Board for Hospitals and Health Care Providers (NABH), a constituent body of the
Quality
Council of India, established comprehensive health care standards for all hospital activities—right
from a
patient’s registration to their discharge. These standards were equivalent to international standards
(ACHS),
Society for Quality in Health care (ISQua), an independent not-for-profit organization promoting the
quality
and safety of health care systems worldwide. As of March 2017, 520 hospitals in India were NABH
accredited, and another 661 were undergoing the accreditation process.17 Further, to achieve global
acceptance of their medical procedures, Indian health care service providers were aggressively
working to
meet the requirements of JCI accreditation standards. As of March 2018, 37 Indian medical and
health care
Policy Support
To promote India as a medical-tourist-friendly destination across the globe, the GOI had initiated
many
policies and schemes over the past few years. One such initiative was the liberalization of the visa
regime
through the introduction of a new subcategory of electronic visa—an e-medical visa—for 161
countries. Other
rules relating to visa fees, duration of stay, frequency of visits, and police reporting of patients were
also
liberalized to ease the experience of medical travellers.19 The Ministry of Tourism had set up the
National
Medical and Wellness Tourism Board to address all issues related to medical tourism.20 The Ministry
of
Tourism, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, and the Ministry of Commerce carried out
promotional
initiatives to endorse the Indian health care industry on international platforms such as global-travel
trade
: shows. “Realizing the potential of [the] MVT industry to generate foreign exchange (Forex) earnings,
the
government has been working to reduce the challenges faced by medical travellers in treatment cost
estimation, visa documentation, hospital admission, and recovery assistance,” Pankaj explained.
VAIDAM HEALTH
Based out of Gurgaon, India, Vaidam Health was certified according to ISO 9001 and 27001 standards
(international standards for assuring customer satisfaction and information risk reduction)21 as a
web-based
MVT facilitator. It offered treatment and travel assistance services to international patients travelling
to
India for treatment. The venture was officially launched in January 2016 after receiving funds from a
Singapore-based venture capital firm. The brainchild of Pankaj and Manish, both alumni of the Indian
Institute of Management in Lucknow, Vaidam was the outcome of in-depth market research of the
health
The term Vaidam is derived from the Sanskrit word vaidya, which means “doctor.” It is usual that,
when it comes to travelling abroad for advanced treatments, people always have apprehensions
around the selection of host country, hospitals, surgeons, and estimated cost of treatment. They do
consult their relatives, friends, [and] family doctors to retrieve such information. They use [the]
Internet to find and validate information about the suitability of medical and health procedures.
However, people could not find any credible source of answer [to] all their queries. No one in the
field of health care was providing an easy solution for this problem. We decided to establish a
business to fill this unmet customer need in the health care sector.
Before establishing Vaidam, both founders had worked in the development of health-technology
platforms.
Pankaj had closely worked with public and private health institutions such as Lybrate Inc., an online
doctor-
consultation platform (as vice-president of Sales), and Manish had 15 years’ experience in managing
and the Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation’s massive railway booking platform
IRCTC.co.in. The duo was careful to form a team by hiring people with diverse skills, such as medical
consultants, operations managers, logistics experts, language translators, and digital marketing
professionals. “We are a team of 20. All the members are highly efficient and carry experience in
their
respective domain. Having the right people at the right place has enabled us to improve the patient
For patients, Vaidam played several roles: it was an educator, providing verified information on
treatment
options, accreditations, affiliations of hospitals and specialists, and on other travel considerations
such as
security and culture; it was an organizer, facilitating medical history compilation, scheduling
appointments,
and managing travel logistics; it acted as a bridge, providing a 24/7 point of contact in the host
country to
deal with local issues such as language barriers; and it functioned as an advocate, acting as the
representative
of the patient in the host country. For the health care industry in host nations, facilitators worked to
boost
In India, NABH was responsible for evaluating the reliability and accountability of MVT facilitators
using
defined empanelment criteria.23 Enticed by the GOI’s supportive policies and the growing number of
foreign tourists entering the country, many players had entered the space of web-based MVT
facilitation
service. Some of the discovery platforms were MediConnect India, Tour2india4health Consultants
Pvt.
Ltd., Indicure Health Tours, and Zoylo Digihealth Pvt. Ltd. Manish said,
What makes us distinct from the other health care discovery platforms is we go beyond the norm
in assisting the travellers with consultations, travel plans, and everything amid, till the time they
fly back, post check-ups or surgeries. We carefully select the hospitals, doctors, accommodation,
In addition to MVT facilitators, independent hotel groups and travel agencies such as Travelite India,
which
offered travel packages for Ayurveda and yoga, had also ventured into this service, seeing it as an
alternate
business opportunity. For hotel groups, MVT was an additional service line for connecting
international
patients with the health care institutions they were associated with. Travel agencies utilized their
logistics
Business Model
Individual Patients
The largest segment of medical travellers to India was uninsured individual patients, who paid for
their
treatments with their own cash and thus looked for low-cost destinations to make significant savings.
“At
this point, 80 per cent of our business is generated through inquires coming directly from the
patients on
our website or through referrals from our past clients,” Pankaj explained. The lack of public or
insurance
funding for advanced medical procedures in their home countries (e.g., African nations such as Kenya
and
Nigeria and neighbouring Asian countries such as Bangladesh, Afghanistan, and the Maldives) was
driving
these patients to travel to destinations like India for quality health care at affordable prices. These
patients
generally made a trade-off between perceived health care quality and cost of treatment, proximity,
and
culture while selecting the health care destination. These patients primarily sought medical
treatment for
dentistry, cosmetic surgery, and in-vitro fertilization.
Insured Patients
Insurance companies that offered self-funded health care benefits collaborated with Vaidam to add
world-
class hospitals in India to their network and worked out packages for various medical procedures.
Vaidam’s
team offered to conduct site visits to hospitals, hotels, and other facilities on behalf of the insurance
companies to understand the true conditions of each destination. Having established strong
relationships
with over 100 hospital affiliates, the team facilitated preferential treatment for patients and resolved
issues
that required immediate attention during their patients’ stay in the country. “At present, we are
working
with three insurance companies abroad and [are] in discussion with many others for the
empanelment of
Indian medical centres and hospitals into their network,” Pankaj explained.
Government-Funded Patients
This segment included international patients travelling from countries where their government
funded
treatments abroad for its citizens, due either to lack of domestic expertise and facilities to handle
advanced
medical treatments or to lengthy waiting times. The Vaidam team had collaborated with ministries
of health
in two countries to assist the patients referred by the ministries. Manish explained:
Currently we are receiving patients referred through ministries of small-population countries such
as Fiji, which have well-developed health care systems, but the range of health care facilities is
limited. On the other hand, ministries of countries like Ireland are funding treatment abroad due to
These patients sought complicated treatments for hip or knee replacement, cataract surgery, or
other
surgeries.
Among the first few to enter the niche of online MVT facilitation, the Vaidam team had focused on
building
a reputation of trust, care, and expertise during its initial years. “We have adopted a ‘patient-centric’
business model, not just in facilitating the medical consultation and care but also in every process
associated
with their medical travel, including air travel, ground transportation, and accommodation,” Pankaj
said.
Vaidam had created a strong network of accredited hospitals and boutique clinics. The company
monetized
the marketing of services offered by these health care institutions on its website, and these
institutions paid
referral fees for each patient coming through the Vaidam route. This fee was mostly a commission
percentage based on the package price of the medical procedure. However, this fee was sometimes
charged
from the hospitals on a per-patient basis regardless of the cost of the procedure. “Our business
model is
such that we don’t charge from our patients. Only in special cases, when a patient requires a second
opinion
or needs additional services such as a full-time attendant, we charge a concierge fee,” Pankaj
explained.
Apart from charging referral fees from medical service providers, the company also received
commissions
from the partners offering lodging, ground transportation, and tour services. One of these was OYO
Rooms,
a budget hotel network in India. “Our partnership with OYO Rooms, one of the largest hospitality
companies in the country, has allowed us to extend standardized and affordable accommodation to
our
travellers. In lieu, we earn commission whenever a user makes an OYO hotel booking through
Vaidam’s
Vaidam’s value chain was divided into three stages that corresponded to the series of activities
involved in
Pre-procedure Stage
At this stage, individual patient queries received through different business channels (online,
referrals, and
insurance companies) were attended by the patient relation team at Vaidam, who facilitated the
patient’s
choice of hospital, doctor, and medical procedure. This team, composed of health care professionals,
helped
in compiling patients’ medical reports, which were shared with the empanelled hospitals and
doctors. The
team offered at least three personalized treatment plan options for each query, based on each
patient’s
The cost of treatment varies widely across hospitals and cities. The average quote for a single knee
replacement surgery is $5,000. However, the budget of one of our patients from Nigeria was
$3,500. Our case manager researched and negotiated the price with the empanelled hospitals and
Live consultations with doctors and sharing the experiences of previous patients was also facilitated
by the team.
The team also assisted the patients in processing their visas and planning their air travel. As Pankaj
explained,
The anxiety of a patient travelling abroad for treatment is usually beyond finding a good hospital
and doctor. Our team actively helps the patients in case assessment, treatment cost estimation,
travel
planning, and hospitality. The prices quoted by the hospitals are discounted for patients coming
Procedure Stage
This stage began as soon as the patient landed at the destination. The company assigned a dedicated
patient
case manager, who acted as a point of contact while the patient stayed in the country. Besides the
case
management system, the team also created customer relationship management (CRM) software to
facilitate
individual patient interactions and create personalized relationships. Upon each patient’s arrival to
the
destination, the concierge team managed the patient pickup, discounted accommodation, currency
exchange, language interpretation, food options, and other local issues. Priority appointments with
the
doctor and admission to the chosen hospital were also arranged. “Our concierge team ensures that
the
patient is taken care of from the moment of arrival to departure after checkup or surgery,” Manish
said.
Post-procedure Stage
This stage included post-operative care and follow-ups. Once the procedure was over, the patient
was
assisted with post-treatment rehabilitation or physiotherapy and follow-ups with the surgeon. An
internal
team of doctors also helped resolve patients’ post-operative concerns. In case of any billing issues
with the
hospital, the Vaidam team escalated the problem on the patient’s behalf for quick resolution. After
post-
operative care, once the patient had recovered, the concierge team assisted with shopping and
planning
leisure tours. The team cautiously worked on improving their services based on patients’ feedback
received
after they had returned to their home countries. “It’s the customer experience–focused mindset of
[the]
Vaidam team that has made it popular among the international medical travellers,” Pankaj explained.
SERVICE FEATURES
Cost Estimator
Along with curated profiles of hospitals, doctors, and patient testimonials to facilitate informed
choices
regarding health care destinations, the technology team had also created a self-help tool—a cost
estimator
for medical travellers. This tool enabled patients to get a total cost estimate that included treatment
cost,
airfare, accommodation, visa processing, food, ground transportation, and other miscellaneous
costs, based
on the specific hospital, doctor, duration of stay, number of attendants, and other preferences of the
patient.
“We understand that [patients do] not want to experience an information overload by browsing
hundreds
of medical procedures available. With the cost estimator, we provide answers to patients’ queries
related to
Managing patient interactions before and after the medical procedure was the key to a successful
relationship between facilitators and their patients. Realizing this, the technology team at Vaidam
developed
: a CRM solution. Not only did this solution allow the team to consolidate the patient leads generated
through
different business channels, it also helped it to manage real-time interactions with patients and to
secure
patient information. “Our CRM tool is designed to bridge the inherent physical distance between the
team
As a leading web-based MVT facilitator, Vaidam was committed to maintaining the highest standards
of
service quality and information security. The patient management protocols for treatment, travel,
and post-
operative care were compliant with ISO 9001:2008 quality-management requirements for ensuring
patient
satisfaction. Stringent data security practices were in place to ensure the protection of patients’
personal
and health information, in line with the ISO 27001 specification. According to Pankaj, “The
requirement
Since its official launch in January 2016, Vaidam had grown to become a trusted name in the Indian
MVT
industry. In the last two years, the team had successfully built a strong ecosystem to take care of
every need
We have a network of over 100 hospitals, and we are looking forward to entering into more
partnerships with health care institutions, insurance providers, and health ministries of countries
from where the patients travel to India. This will allow us to penetrate deeper into the industry and
The team had developed an online platform fed by effectively curated content available in multiple
languages for international travellers, an efficient on-ground team to aid the patients during their
stay, and
So far, the team had worked on promoting and facilitating MVT services in its own country. Now,
building
its recognized brand in the MVT market, the company wanted to set up a network of medical
providers in
countries that were popular for their health care infrastructure. Pankaj mentioned:
We want to refer patients to global destinations in the future, especially to countries like Thailand,
Turkey, Dubai, Malaysia, and Singapore, which are ranked very highly in the [hierarchy] of
countries receiving medical travellers. Our alliance team is working for opening offices at these
overseas locations.
The company invested in marketing its services through the local newspapers and radio channels to
create
brand awareness in these overseas destinations. Apart from investing in diverse marketing channels,
the
content team at Vaidam had worked to translate content into seven different languages, to increase
access
Vaidam aims to help patients from any country travelling to any country for treatment as per their
preference for health care cost, quality, and social alignment. We are working towards achieving our
aim. Now it is to be seen whether we are able [to] continuously create value for the medical
travellers.
Summary:
Analysis:
1. Analyze the external environment for India's MVT facilitation services sector. Based on the
analysis, could you make recommendations for Vaidam to invest in alternate business
channels for attracting international medical travelers? The following frameworks could be
used.
a. PEST analysis of the host country
b. Five Force Analysis of Indian Health Care Sector.
2. What are facilitation services? What is the role of MVT facilitation services in the health care
sector?
3. Diagnose the strategic capability of Vaidam based on the value offered to MVT patients.
Based on the evaluation, could you recommend improvements?
Social: India's rich cultural heritage, diversity, and alternative healing methods like
Ayurveda attract travelers seeking holistic treatments. Language diversity and the
widespread use of English benefit international patients.
Threat of New Entrants: The healthcare sector in India has seen a surge in private
players, signifying increased competition. However, establishing trust and credibility
as an MVT facilitator demands expertise and relationships, posing a barrier to new
entrants.
Threat of Substitutes: While India offers quality healthcare at competitive prices, other
countries like Thailand, Malaysia, and Singapore also compete for medical tourists.
The threat of these countries as substitutes is moderate.
Supplier Power: Hospitals and medical practitioners hold significant power due to
their expertise. However, MVT facilitators' ability to bring in a stream of international
patients could balance this power.
Buyer Power: International patients have varied preferences and choices. MVT
facilitators that offer comprehensive services and choice options can wield more
power.
Competitive Rivalry: The healthcare sector in India is competitive, with several players
offering similar services. Differentiation, quality of service, and partnerships become
critical for standing out.
Recommendations for Vaidam: Based on this analysis, Vaidam could invest in:
The role of MVT facilitation services is pivotal. They act as intermediaries, bridging
the gap between international patients and healthcare providers. They offer
convenience, guidance, and support to patients navigating a foreign healthcare
system. Facilitators like Vaidam enhance patient experience, increase accessibility to
quality healthcare, and address the unique needs of medical travelers.