Field Trips in Learning
Field Trips in Learning
Rugaiyah
[email protected]
Islamic University of Riau, Pekanbaru, Indonesia
Abstract
This reseach studied about the beneficial of educational Field Trips at secondary and
high school level in Pekanbaru, Riau Province Indonesia. The respondents of this study were
the students and Pre-service teachers of English program of both government and private
schools. The ideas and views of students and Pre-service teachers were sought out regarding
the benefit of educational field trips at secondary and high schools level. To achieve the
purpose of study two questionnaires was design as research tool separately for teachers and
students. sixty respondents including 10 Pre-service teacher of English program and 50
students were randomly selected. The questionnaire was used as a research instrument which
was consisted of 25 items, collected data was analyzed by using simple percentage method.
The findings for each statement were made. On the basis of findings, the conclusion was
drawn. Majority of the respondents had a view that educational field trip is helpful to explore
students’s learning experience. Therefore, a large number of respondents opinioned that
educational field trip positively affect students’ creative thinking and practices in learning.
122
The 65th TEFLIN International Conference, Universitas Negeri
Makassar, Indonesia, 12-14 July 2018
123
The questionnaire used in this them closed-ended questionnaire, and
study was divided into three categories, asked them to complete it. The researcher
which were labeled as Part-1, part-2, part- distributed the questionnaire in English
3 part 4 with and part 5 in closed-ended and they have to respond all questions
questions. The item format for type in using likert scale. Then, analyzed the
questionnaire was developed on a three- information, and proceed to the data for
point scale which asked individuals to purpose of the research. Creswell (2012)
respond in series of statements by asserts that using a narrative passage to
indicating whether the incidents in state the findings of the analysis is the
question take place ‘Strongly most frequent approach in this step.
Agree’,agree’, ‘slightly agree’, ‘disagree’, Therefore, the researcher described every
and ‘strongly disagree.’ The Part-1 type theme, supported it with excerpts of the
questionnaire for students consisted of 10 students’ responses from the questionnaire
statements, which aimed to determine how and interpreted the data
much field trip are helpful in effective
learning. The Part-2 type questionnaire for Finding and Discussion
the teachers, on the other hand, consisted In finding, the researcher
of 9 statements, which likewise aimed to described the process of calculating and
determine how much field trip promotes presenting result of the data. It was
the required qualities among students. The intended to answer the questions of the
Part-3 type of questionnaire for the study. In finding, the researcher described
students consisted of 6 statements the process of calculating and presenting
respectively. These questionnaires were result of the data.
aimed at determining how much fieldtrips The data from the quistionnaire in
are beneficial for society and individuals. this study has been analyzed with the
Before collecting the data, the results as shown in the following table:
researchers met the respondents who have
been chosen as the sample. Then, gave
124
The 65th TEFLIN International Conference, Universitas Negeri
Makassar, Indonesia, 12-14 July 2018
Based on the results presented in attitude about the subject. The students
table above, it shows that field trip are also demeed that Field trips also can help
helpful in effective learning. However, them to explore their learning experience
majority of students (93.2%) think that (85.5%). Besides, (84%) agreed that field
Field Trips can give them opportunity to trips provide self experience and
relate their own experiences to the topics observation in increasing their knowledge,
covered in the course. From students’ this finding supported by Nabors et al.,
responses above were in line with several (2009) claims that students on field trips
researchers findings. Oreon (1993) found sharpen their skills of observation and
that field trips can facilitate the perception by utilizing all their senses.
construction of abstract concepts by Likewise, (82.8%) believe that Field trips
providing the setting for long term contribute to their learning experience
memorized episodes. It means that field positively, beside, it also can help them to
trips contribute o students’ learning solve many problems in the classroom and
experience and help them to relate the enhances their ability to think critically
concept of what they have learnt in the and creatively. On the other hand, there
classroom. Behrendt Marc and Franklin were (70%) of them consider that Field
(2014) also point out that students who Trips make students understand the
directly participate during a field importance of learning from sharing real-
experience generate a more positive world experiences.
125
agree that Field Trips allow them to backgrounds, it gives students a chance to
comment and discuss ideas with their get to know each other and interact in a
group more efficiently and make them more relaxed environment. However, it
convidence in sharing idea to others in was only (80,9%) of them believed that
discussion. Morever, Shakil and Hafeez Field Trips make them feel more involved
(2011) again asserted that Educational with the class as well as allow them to
field trips provide an opportunity for social comment and discuss ideas with m group
training of the students because field trips more efficiently as compared to traditional
are taken in large group and students are classes.
included from different social
Table 3 represents the ideas of vital for seeing and understanding the
students that how much field trips are things. Students to have a chance to view
beneficial for society and and explore historical places and different
individuals.according to the data shown in social institutions. They provide an
the table, (93.6%) of students reveal that opportunity for the students to visiting a
This field trips are relevant to their study at new place, meeting new people and Field
writing descriptive text. Likewise, (87%) Trips help them appreciate the relevance
of them Field Trips ancourage them to and importance of what they have learnt in
participate efectively during the trip. the classroom (84%). Then (83.2%) of the
Further, (86%) from the respondance students fostering better perfomance in
believe that Field trips help them to know studies. Nevertheless, Nevertheless, it was
the importence of histrical places and only (70.8%) of the students reported that
cultural heritage this point related to Eric Field Trips allow them to meet the need of
Powell who describes that field trips are higher education.
126
3 Field Trips allow students to express their 1 9 98%
thoughts more clearly and openly
4 Fieald Trips contribute to students’ learning 3 7 94%
experience positively
5 Field Trips help students to solve many 1 9 96%
problems in the classroom
6 Field Trips help students to explore their 0 10 100%
learning experience
7 Field Trips make students understand the 2 8 96%
importance of learning from sharing real-world
experiences.
8 Field Trips enhance students’ ability to think 2 8 96%
critically and creatively
9 Field Trips enhance students’ ability to think 3 7 94%
logically
10 Field Trips give students the opportunity to 1 9 96%
relate their own experiences to the topics
covered in the course
The analysis revealed that teachers (100%) opportunity for students to create
held the strong view that Field Trips help connections, which will help them gain
students to explore their learning understanding and develop an enjoyment
experience, the same is the case with of learning. On the othr hand, teachers’
Scarce (1997) claimed that field trips are (96%) believed that Field Trips enhance
experiential, authentic social events that students’ ability to think critically and
create a new way of knowing an object, creatively and allow students to express
concept, or operation. In terms of Field their thoughts more clearly and openly.
Trips provide self experience & Thus, supported by Catherine E. Boyle,
observation to increase Knowledge and (1995) that Students are encouraged to
allow students to express their thoughts think critically an creatively beyond the
more clearly and openly This finding also parameters of the classroom environment
coincided Hutson, T., at all. (2011) who engage with the theoretical knowledge that
stated that Field trips offer a unique they have mastered.
127
discuss ideas with their group more efficiently
as compared to traditional face-to-face classes.
9 Field Trips make students convidence in 3 7 94%
sharing idea to others in discussion
The table above shows that the field trip not only could help students to
mayority of teachers (98%) believe that promote sense of discipline and develop
Field Trip allows students to comment leadership qualities but also could make
and discuss ideas with their group more students convidence in sharing idea to
efficiently as compared to traditional face- others in discussion. This findings also
to-face classes. This finding is in keeping related to the outcomes reserach by Shakill
with the outcomes of the study by NRC and Hafeez (2011) demonstrate that the
(2009) illustrated that students who positive benefits derive from field trips are
acquire hands-on, authentic experience hands-on, real-world experiences, quality
may develop curiosity and interest, leading of education, positive attitudes to science
to a desire to learn more, observation skills and motivation towards the subjects,
improve. Social skills develop as the improvement of the socialization between
students share perceptions and knowledge students, which would impinge on the
with others. However, it is indicated that classroom, and development of rapport
(96%) of teachers considered out that field between teachers and students. Likewise,
trip allows students to sharpen their (92%) of teachers’ perceptions that it
discussion and interaction. Therefore, it allows students to communicate more
anables students to increase self effectively than traditional face-to-face
confidance. This finding is similar to the meetings. Therefore, it anables students to
outcomes of recent study by Shakil and increase self confidance as (Kisiel, 2003;
Hafeez (2011) pointed out that Educational Rennie, 2007) found that students are
field trips are very important because they better observers, interact more frequently,
are a way to bring the students closer discuss the concepts, and ultimately
together develop more connections between the
However, from the results of concepts and the experience.
teachers’ resposes (94%) claimed that
The above table shows that it is belief that Field trips are relevant to
found related to the dominant of teachers’ students’ study at writing descriptive text.
128
For the reason that, during the field trips Conclusion
the students have concrete learning The results of this study showed
experiences in a real situation which can that Field Trip is an effective strategy in
improve their writing on the descriptive enhancing students’ knowledge in Social
text. Therefore, It is crucial that educators Studies. Interestingly, after the field trip,
make connections between what students students were much more confident in
are being taught in their classrooms and dealing with exploring their idea and
the real world. The respondents also sharing idea to others in discussion in the
deemed that Field trips help students to classroom. It is indicated that Field Trip
know the importence of histrical places could increase students’ motivation.
and cultural heritage (96%), In line with Likewise, in terms of promoting students’
this, Eric Powell quality, it seems that students can interact
(https://www.slideshare.net/aneeshashokan to each others. However, Field Trips allow
545/online-assignment-39405965 students to comment and discuss ideas
describes that field trips are vital for with their group more efficiently as well as
students to have a chance to view and they are involved in the class.The other
explore historical places and different most significant is The field trip acted as
social institutions. Inspide of (92%) of the an empowering tool for students and
teachers agrred on Field Trips could help assisted them in gaining ownership over
students to show better perfomance in future learning experiences. Therefore, the
studies. However, teachers on the whole mayority of teachers and students believe
believed that Field Trips benefits for that Field Trips are not only helpful in
sociaety and individual. effective learning, but also promotes the
required qualities among students and
beneficial for society and individuals.
129
Glenn, J. L. (2000). Environment-based Mackenzie, A.A. & White, R.T. (1982).
education: Creating high performance Fieldwork in geography and long-term
schools and memory
students, Washington, DC: The National structures, American Educational
Environmental Education & Training Research Journal, 19(4).
Foundation)
Michie M. (1998). Factors influencing
Haw-Jan “John” Wu (2009). Using field secondary school teachers to organize
trips to enhance student learning in and
operations management: Literature conduct field trips. Australian Science
Review and Field Observations. Teachers Journal, 44(4).
California State University San
Bernardino, CA. California Journal of Nabors, M.L., Edwards, L.C., & Murray,
Operations Management © 2009 CSU- R.K. (2009). Making the case for field
POM ) trips:What
research tells us and what site
Hutson, T., Cooper, S., & Talbert, T. coordinators have to say. Education
(2011). Describing connections between 129(4), 661-667.
science content
and future careers: Implementing Texas National Research Council (2009).
curriculum for rural at-risk high school Learning science in informal
students using purposefully-designed environments: People,
field trips. Rural Educator,31,37-47. places, and pursuits. Washington, DC:
The National Academies Press.
Jamilu, Ja’far and Salihu (2012) “Effects
of Educational Field Trips on Academic Online Journal of Distance Education-
Perfomance of Junior Secondary School TOJDE October 2014 ISSN 1302-6488
Social Studies Students in Kaduna Volume: 15 Number: 4 Article 2
Statenigeria https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ10928
06.pdf
Kisiel, J. (2003). Teachers, museums, and
worksheets: A closer look at learning Orion, N., “A Model for the Development
experience. and Implementation of Field Trips as an
Journal of Science Teacher Education, Integral
14, 3–21. Part of the Science Curriculum,” School
Krepel, W. J., & Duvall, C. R. (1981). Science and Mathematics, Vol. 93(6),
“Field trips: A guide for planning and 1993,
conducting educational experiences”, 325-331.
Washington, DC: National Education
Association. Price, S. & Hein, G.E. (1991). More than a
field trip: Science programmes for
Lisowski, M. and Disinger, J.F. elementary school groups at museums.
(1991).The effect of field-based International Journal of Science
instruction on student Education, 13(5),
understanding of ecological concepts.
Journal of Environmental Education, Price, S. & Hein, G.E. (1991). More than a
23(11). field trip: Science programmes for
elementary school groups at museums.
International Journal of Science
Education, 13(5),
130
empirically determined values of
Raiszadeh, F. M. E. and L. P. Ettkin, secondary school science field trips.
“POM in Academia: Some Causes For Science
Concern,” Education,
Production and Inventory Management
Journal, Vol. 30(2), 1989 37-40. Tal, T., & Morag, O. (2009). Reflective
Practice as a Means for Preparing to
Rennie, L.J. (2007). Learning outside of Teach Outdoors
school. In S.K. Abell and N.G. in an Ecological Garden. Journal of
Lederman (eds.), Science Teacher Education, 20(3), 245-
Handbook of Research on Science 262.
Education. Mahwah, New Jersey:
Erlbaum. Victor, E. (1965). Science for the
Elementary School. New York:
Scarce, R. (1997). field trips as short-term Macmillan.)
experiential education, Teaching
Sociology, 25: 219-226. Wendling, R.C. &Wuensch, K.L. (1985).
A fifth-grade outdoor education
Sinatra, G. (2005). The ―Warming Trend‖ program: expectations and effects.
in conceptual change research: The Journal of Interpretation, 10(1}.
legacy of Paul
R. Pintrich. Educational Psychologist. Wright, T.S.A. (2000), No more
40: 107-115. pencils…no more books? Arguing for
the use of experiential
Stake, R. 1995. The Art of Case Study learning in post secondary
Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. environmental studies classroom.
Electronic Green \ Journal, 1: 1-8.
Sorrentino, A. V., & Bell, P. E. (1970).
A comparison of attributed values
with
131