Procurement
Procurement
Procurement
Procurement Management
Course Outline
2.Conduct procurements
3.Administer procurements
4.Close procurements
Course Outline
• seminars,
• case studies,
• TOTAL 100%
Required References
• Burrows, R. P. (2012). The Market-Driven Supply Chain: A Revolutionary Model for Sales and
Operations Planning in the New On-Demand Economy. New York:AMACOM.
• Gattorna, J. (2016). Gower Handbook of Supply Chain Management. New York: Gower Publishing.
• Kildow, B.A. (2011). A Supply Chain Management Guide to Business Continuity. New York:
AMACOM.
• Mitchell, J.S. (2014). Operational Excellence: Journey to Creating Sustainable Value. New Jersey:
Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Required References
• Musiolik, T. (2012). The Global Player: How to Become the Logistics Company for the World.
Hamburg: Diplomica Verlag GmbH.
• O’Brien, J. (2015). Supplier Relationship Management: Unlocking the Hidden Value in Your Supply
Base. Great Britain and United Sates of America: Kogan Page Limited.
• Presutti, W.D., & Mawhinney, J. (2013). Understanding the Dynamics of the Value Chain. New York:
Business Expert Press, LLC.
• Temesgen, B., & Dargie, A. (2016). Project Logistics and Contract Administration. Addis Ababa:
Addis Ababa University School of Commerce.
• USAID. (2011). The Logistics Handbook: A Practical Guide for the Supply Chain Management of
Health Commodities.Arlington: USAID.
Chapter One: Introduction to Project Logistics
• Logistic is the function that enables the flow of materials from suppliers
into an organization through different operations
• It is derived from the Greek word “logistikos’ which means ‘to reason
logically’ .
H. Ch. Pohl define that logistics management comprises all the steps leading to
planning, supervision, execution and control of the time-and-space transformation of goods
and the related transformation in quantity and range of assortment, the manipulation
properties and the degree of logistics determination of goods.
Logistics Activities
• Logistics is responsible for the movement and storage of material as they
move through the supply chain.
• When the material moving through an organization one can see the following
activities are normally included in logistics.
Activities
• Transportation
• Inventory Management
• Information flows and order processing
• Warehousing
• Material Handling 17
Project Logistics
• A project logistics can be defined as a complex, special and unique sets
of activities which can be described by technical and economic
parameters and is determined by cost, time, and scope .
• Packaging;
• Material handling ;
• Inventory ;
Elements of logistics
22
Logistics Strategic Decisions
• Depending on the type of business, logistics decision groupings are
diverse.
1. Customer service
• These decisions are critical because the largest part of invested capital
belongs to them
3.Outsourcing versus vertical integration
Fundamental Concepts
A supply chain is a dynamic concept that involves the constant flow of
resources (products, information, funds) amongst all the participants
along the chain
All these entities are linked by the flow of goods, information and cash
Supply chain ‒ a process ‒ a sequence of events in the relocation of
goods that increases their value.
Supply Chain …
Supply chain is a network of connected and interdependent
organizations that cooperate and mutually control, manage and improve
the flow of goods and information from suppliers to the end users.
Supply chain is a physical network, which starts with the supplier and
ends with the final customer.
It involves aspects associated with product development, purchasing,
production, real distribution and after-sales services, as well as, deliveries
carried out by external bidders.
Supply Chain …
3. Funds Flows:
• The flows of funds, mainly upstream (payments for goods & services
received) but also in some cases downstream.
4. Distribution decision
Higher productivity
Lost or delayed goods. Goods that go missing at any point in the chain
ultimately delay the whole process and can impact customers negatively.
Supply chain challenges …
Increasing customer expectations. New technology and businesses
raise customer expectations, which can be difficult to manage, and
impossible to meet if not properly managed.
progress tracking, regular status meetings, dispute resolution and “day to day”
management.
Contents of a contract
1
Introduction
Project Procurement Process [Project Procurement Management Process] is
;
The process aims to ensure timely delivery of the purchased items which are
selected and acquired according to the specifications and requirements set
up by the purchasing department and approved by the project manager.
2
Project Procurement Management Processes
Project procurement management: Acquiring goods
and services for a project from outside the performing
organization
Processes include:
Planning procurement management
Conducting procurements
Contract administration
Closing procurements
3
Purchasing/procurement
the next step in material planning and management system is
the process of procurement of the planned materials.
Should be done economically and on time to maintain material
supplies and increase final profits by lowering expenses.
Most of the states and other organization have laid down
detailed set of rules and regulations regarding the procedure of
ordering materials.
Organization like “directorate general of supplies and disposals
“( DGSD) play a crucial role in purchase which involves in
4
5
What Is Project Procurement Management?
•Project procurement includes the processes required to
acquire goods and services to attain project scope from out
side the performing organization.
•It is the act of obtaining goods, supplies, and/or services.
•Project procurement management includes three primary
processes. These are:
1. Plan procurements
2. Conduct procurements
3. Administer (or control) procurements
6
PROCUREMENT CYCLE
Review
selection
Receipt and Determine needed
inspection quantities
7
OBJECTIVES OF PROCUREMENT SYSTEM:
9
Project procurement categories
Not all project procurements are created equal.
Different project procurement needs different management based on their
generic categories
Managing project procurements differently according to their complexity,
their risks, their unique characteristics.
In order to properly manage the procurements items some firms have
found it beneficial to categorize their project procurement into different.
This helps management better focus their attention on the unique
problems and issue peculiar to each categories of procurement.
Project procurements would create three generic categories and two
special relationships as follows:
10
1. Major (high -risks ) complexity procurements
the purchase of something which does not exist, and unique specification.
Their nature always represent high risk to any project technical, quality, costs
and schedule.
Such purchases are for newly developed items, something that doesn’t already
exist.
Such procurements will often result in long term relationships being created
between buyer and suppliers
Examples
The development of an new software package, new computer
The architectural design of a new commercial center
Information technology service ,
A development of new airplane
11
2. Minor (low-risks) complexity procurement
Some examples
Purchase of existing automobiles / radar system / high value
software / computers
large electrical generators
12
3. Routine buy of commercial off the self (COTS) commodities or
purchased services.
Consider as routine but nevertheless must arrive in the time to
support the project schedule
It involves the purchase of substantial amounts of materials that are
often commercially available as “off-the-shelf” articles, or routine
services.
The early identification of these procurement is typically not vital to
the success of the project.
Some examples are:
Office supplies and equipment: existing computers, printers, scanners
Outsourced services, such as cafeteria, security, and accounting
13
Special procurements:
I. done under corporate teaming arrangements.
Team agreement between the top management of the
companies.
II. to other segments of the project’s company, typically called
interdivisional work
• Inter divisional works are the procurements made within
single company by one operating unit with another operating
unity
This type of procurement sometimes result from having a unique capacity.
These both special categories have been found to represent unique
management challenges in the successful competition of any project
14
Project Procurement Management Processes
15
1. Procurement planning ;
I keep six Honest serving men (they taught me all I knew) Their names are What , Why ,
When, How, Where and Who (Rudyard Kipling, 1902)
Plans are worthless, but planning is every thing (D.Eisenhower, 1957
Without an adequate plan…. Success will be a matter of luck (Russel D. Archibald, 1992)
Project procurements planning are too critical to the success of the project
It is a simple single page Bill of materials, describing:
the items to be bought,
the quantities, required and the need dates to support the project master
schedule.
There are three dimensions of the critical to successful project management;
these three dimensions are;
The scope,
the schedule and
the budget.
16
a. The definition of scope: deciding the “what” the project
will be procure
The definition of ‘what ‘will be procured by the project, and then
preparing plan of execution for these items can be one of the most
important of management a project.
17
The project fully defined typically with use of a work Breakdown Structure (WBS)
a determination must then be made as to who will perform the work.
Under this phase what types of project procurement categories should buy
will be decided (major complexity, minor complexity and routine
procurement, two special procurement (Corporate teaming and
interdivisional purchasing) .
18
.
WBS will identified who are the potential sellers of these products or
services,
What type of contractual arrangement would best for the project and
minimizing its risk?
19
b. Scheduling; deciding “when” each procurement must happe
The other critical issue for any procurement plan is to decide “when” each
procurement must happen
A project master schedule should list the delivery date of each procurement.
(like A,B,C )
The identification of contract award dates is critical to start the management
of the procurements.
Each procurement should be award at a time, should clearly define the award
process on the master schedule
Determine the late delivery and it impact on the success of the project
The sellers required performance lead time for each procurement and the
contract award dates.
Legal terms and conditions
20
Scheduling: deciding when each buy must be Awarded
21
c. Budgeting :estimating how much each procurement
will cost
22
Budgeting :estimating how much each procurement will cost
23
2. Conducting Procurements (Excuting)
24
Revised the procurement negotiations that will the final
contracts to meet the project needs
a purchase order to document the price, quantity,
delivery window and terms of payment of the
goods/services you order.
Selecting bidders based on d/t criteria:
project can advertise to procure goods and
services in several ways:
Approaching the preferred vendor
Approaching several potential vendors
Advertising to anyone interested
25
Selecting bidders
26
3. Controlling procurement (Monitoring and
controlling)
Once contracts become active,
procurement control and management are important parts of
maintaining partnerships with vendors and ensuring the services.
27
Suggestions for Change Control in Contracts
28
4. Closing procurement
Closing procurement involves all necessary steps in
ending a partnership or contract.
The procurement team:
determine if all work was completed correctly and
satisfactorily
Update records to reflect final results
Confirms vendor has fulfilled the terms of the original
contract
Archive information for future use
29
Procurement audits identify lessons learned in the
procurement process
30
E-procurement of Project types and their procurement needs
What is e-procurement?
Electronic procurement, also known as e-procurement or supplier
exchange,
It is the process of requisitioning, ordering and purchasing goods and
services online.
e-procurement utilizes a supplier's closed system and is only available
to registered users.
It facilitates interactions between preferred suppliers and customers
through bids, purchase orders and invoices.
Today, e-procurement involves everything from supplier evaluation and
selection to contract management, electronic orders and payments.
E-procurement uses a web interface or some other kind of networked
system that connects suppliers and customers.
31
E-procurement software
E-procurement software facilitates the e-procurement process.
It also enables procurement staff to automate various activities,
functions and procedures, including policies, contracts and vendor
relationships.
Although available functions and features vary among vendors, the
software's biggest advantage is that it streamlines the procurement
process and eliminates manual or paper-based activities.
32
E-procurement software
systems provide tools that allow procurement managers to customize
the procurement experience.
They can also:
determine which items will be available to which users;
control who can view the budget information;
control who can approve purchase requisitions; and
control who can view and pay invoices.
Many e-procurement platforms can be accessed over mobile devices
like smartphones and tablets.
33
What are the benefits of e-procurement?
E-procurement helps automate the procurement process.
Centralized transaction tracking, simplified reporting and contract compliance ,
reduce delivery times and shorten procurement cycles.
Reduce the overhead cost for procurement teams, optimize performance,
increase process efficiency and achieve cost savings.
Access to a larger selection of products and services to meet their specific
needs.
Increases process transparency and accountability and enables better control
over the procurement function.
34
35
Chapter Three
Identifying and
evaluating suppliers
Sourcing strategies for goods and services
Procurement policy
The term policy includes all the directives, both explicit and
implied, that designate the aims and ends of an organization and
the appropriate means used in their accomplishment.
Policy refers to the set of purposes, principles, and rules of action
that guide an organization.
Rules of action refer to standard operating procedures along with
any rules and regulations.
Although, policies are usually documented in writing, unwritten
or informal policies can also exist.
Informal policies are understood over time and eventually
become part of an organization’s culture.
23-Oct-23 2
Cont.…
23-Oct-23 6
Strategic Sourcing
• Sourcing decisions and purchasing activities serve to link
a company with its supply chain partners.
• Sourcing decisions- High level, often strategic decisions
regarding which products or services will be provided
internally and which will be provided by external supply-
chain partners.
• It determine what will be provided by supply chain
partners.
– In-sourcing: the use of resources within the firm to provide
products or services.
– Outsourcing: The use of supply chain partners to provide
products or services.
23-Oct-23 7
Con….
• The definition of sourcing strategy (Weele, 2009:
10):
“Identifies for a certain category from how many
suppliers to buy, what type of relationship to follow,
contract duration, type of contract to negotiate for, and
whether to source locally, regionally or globally.”
23-Oct-23 8
Con….
• According to (Baily and Farmer, 1982 in Hines, 1995:19):
“If a buyer gives all his business to one supplier,
Does he get a better and more economic service than when he
splits the order between two or more?
Does he lose his competitive position by, in effect, creating a
monopolistic source?
If, on the other hand, he uses more than one supplier is he
dissipating his purchasing power, or is he protecting himself against
shortage, fire, and strike?”
23-Oct-23 9
Con…
Strategic Sourcing Primary Objectives
• Reduce the costs of goods and services / Capture
resulting savings
• Create contractual alliances with suppliers to
support the long-term goals of the organization.
• Maintain and improve product quality
• Improve business functions
• Optimize the total purchasing process
23-Oct-23 11
Key project Sourcing structure
• There are four primary sourcing structures that can
be used (with some amount of variation): single,
multiple, delegated and parallel.
1.Single sourcing: This structure characterizes a buyer
with only one source of supply for a particular good or
service.
23-Oct-23 12
Con..
23-Oct-23 13
Con..
3. Delegated sourcing strategy: This sourcing configuration
involves making one supplier responsible for the delivery of an entire
sub-assembly as opposed to an individual part.
The customer delegates authority to a key supplier who becomes
known as a first-tier supplier.
The customer’s objective is to work with one supplier and the
supplier in turn works with all other suppliers that provide parts to
complete the product.
23-Oct-23 14
The Strategic Sourcing Plan
• Strategic souring plan consists of how to:
–discover,
–evaluate,
–select,
–develop and
–manage a viable supplier base.
23-Oct-23 15
A. Discover :
• Finding Information sources that are
helpful to a supply manager in
establishing potential suppliers.
Supplier Web Sites
Supplier Catalogs:
Trade Journals:
Professional Organizations
23-Oct-23 16
B. Evaluating Potential Suppliers
Approach to Evaluate Suppliers:
Supplier Surveys: A survey should provide sufficient
knowledge of the supplier to make a decision to include
or exclude the firm from further considerations.
Financial condition Analysis: preliminary investigation
of a potential supplier’s financial condition often can
avoid the expense of further study. A qualified supply
manager or professional from the finance department
conduct these investigation.
Third Party Evaluators: Independent third-party firms
can be hired to conduct many of the analyses given in
this section.
23-Oct-23 17
Con…
Evaluation Conference: For an extremely critical purchase, a
supplier evaluation conference is frequently held at the supply
manager’s plant to discuss the purchase.
Facility Visits: By visiting a supplier’s facility, the sourcing
team can obtain first-hand information concerning the
adequacy of the firm’s technological capabilities,
manufacturing or distribution capabilities, and its
management’s technical know-how and orientation.
Quality Capability Analysis: The firm’s quality capability is a
critical factor to examine. If the prospective supplier’s process
capability is less than the buying firm’s incoming quality
requirements, the supplier typically is not worthy of further
investigation
23-Oct-23 18
C. Selecting Suppliers
After one or more potential suppliers have passed the
evaluation process, the selection process must begin. The
supply manager or the souring team will now invite
potential suppliers to submit bids or proposals.
A decision must be made as to whether to use competitive
bidding or negotiation (or combination of the two) as the
basis for source selection.
Strategic supplier selection involves four main stages:
1. Initial supplier qualification;
2. Agree measurement criteria;
3. Obtain relevant information;
4. Make selection
23-Oct-23 19
4.Developing Suppliers
Not all suppliers need development, but to reach the
lofty (proud) status of a world-class collaborative
relationship, development is needed.
Even suppliers recognized as the “best of the best”
require investment on the part of the buying firm to
realize the full benefit of the collaborative
relationship.
23-Oct-23 20
4.Developing Suppliers
Process map for deploying a supplier development
initiative.
• Identify Critical Commodities for Development
• Identify Critical Suppliers for Development
• Form Cross-Functional Development Team
• Meet with Supplier’s Top Management Team
• Identify Opportunities and Probability for Improvement
• Define Key Metrics and Cost-Sharing Mechanisms
• Reach Agreement on Key Projects and Joint Resource
Requirements
• Monitor Status of Projects and Modify Strategies as
Appropriate
23-Oct-23 21
Con..
• Exercise
Discuss the similarity and differences of the
concepts of Procurement , Purchasing and
sourcing
23-Oct-23 22
CHAPTER FOUR
– Cost Reimbursable
– Unit Price
• Sellers charge the buyers for the actual cost of any materials,
equipment, labor, and overhead involved in running the
project.
23-Oct-23 2
Transport Principle
23-Oct-23 3
Con…
23-Oct-23 4
Transport Function
23-Oct-23 5
Con…
• Transportation management is a subset of supply
management chain concerning transportation
operations.
• Transportation Management reduces transportation
cost and increases delivery reliability through
collaboration across all modes and providers.
• An effective transportation management helps
companies move freight from origin to destination
efficiently, reliably, and cost effectively
23-Oct-23 6
Modes of Transportation
• Transport modes are the means by which people and
freight achieve mobility.
• They fall into one of three basic types, depending on
over what surface they travel as:
• land (road, rail and pipelines),
• water (shipping/Maritime), and
• air.
23-Oct-23 7
Road/Truck transportation
• Road infrastructures are large consumers of space
• Road transportation has an average operational
flexibility as vehicles can serve several purposes but
are rarely able to move outside roads.
• Road transport systems have high maintenance costs,
both for the vehicles and infrastructures.
• They are mainly linked to light industries where rapid
movements of freight in small batches are the norm.
23-Oct-23 8
Rail transportation
• Railways are composed of a traced path on which wheeled vehicles are
bound.
Pipelines
• Pipeline routes are practically unlimited as they can be laid on land or
under water.
23-Oct-23 9
Maritime transportation
• Because of the physical properties of water and limited friction,
maritime transportation is the most effective mode to move large
quantities of cargo over long distances.
23-Oct-23 10
Air transportation
Air routes are practically unlimited, but they are denser over
the North Atlantic, inside North America and Europe and over
the North Pacific.
23-Oct-23 11
Advantage and disadvantage of five modes
of transportation
12
Project Transportation Modal
choices
• The choice of transport mode is probably one of the most important
classic models in transport management.
23-Oct-23 14
1. External factors
Encompassing the many operational factors that may need to
be considered are those that are external to direct
distribution related factors.
These are particularly relevant when contemplating the
international context of modal choice, because from country
to country these factors can vary significantly.
External factors includes:
• The basic infrastructure in the country: Trade barriers:
these might include, for example, customs duty, import
tariffs or quota payments which can have a big impact on
the overall cost of a product.
• Export controls and licenses: with these, there may be
implications for the quantity of product that can be shipped
in given periods of time. Law and taxation, Financial
institutions and services, and economic conditions,
Communications systems, Culture, Climate.
23-Oct-23 15
2. Customer characteristics:
The main characteristics to take into account are:
• Service level requirements: This may occur when there is a need for delivery to be
at a certain time or on a certain date, or when a specific time delivery window is
stipulated.
• Delivery point constraints: refers particularly to the physical aspects of delivery,
including the location of the delivery point. any access constraints concerning the
size of vehicle that can make the delivery and any equipment requirements for
unloading.
• Credit rating: The credit rating of a customer may help to impose a limit on route
selection and modal choice. New customers and existing customers with a poor
credit rating mean that a company will want to be sure that payment is confirmed
before delivery is made
• Terms of sale preference: There are a number of different terms of sale that can be
used, ranging from ex works (at the supplier factory) to delivered duty paid (at the
customer’s delivery point).
• Order size preference:
• Customer importance: Most suppliers have ‘A’ rated customers who are deemed to
be their most important and who really must be given a delivery service that does
not fail.
• Product knowledge: Some products or orders may necessitate some knowledge
transfer to the customer at the time of delivery. l
23-Oct-23 16
3. Physical nature of the
product
The main factors that need to be considered include:
• Volume to weight ratio
• Substitutability (product alternatives, etc)
• Special characteristics (hazard, fragility,
perishability, time constraints, security).
23-Oct-23 17
Other logistic issues
Supply points: The location of raw material or component
suppliers will clearly impact on route and modal choice.
23-Oct-23 18
Section II: Warehouse and Inventory Management
Inventory Management
• Inventory: is the raw materials, work-in-process goods and
completely finished goods that are considered to be the portion of
a business's assets that are ready or will be ready for sale/use.
• Anything that goes into producing the items sold by your business
is part of its inventory.
• Inventory management is primarily about specifying the size and
placement of stocked goods.
• Inventory management is required at different locations within a
facility or within multiple locations of a supply network to protect
the regular and planned course of production against the random
disturbance of running out of materials or goods.
23-Oct-23 19
Types of Inventory
Raw material inventories: are the basic inputs to the
manufacturing process.
Work-in-process inventories: consists of partially
finished goods
Finished – goods inventory: are the outputs of the
manufacturing process.
Spare parts inventory
23-Oct-23 20
Major reasons for holding
inventories
To satisfy expected demand: Companies use anticipation stock (buffer stock) to
satisfy expected demand
To protect against stock outs: Manufacturers use safety stock to protect against
uncertainties in either the demand or supply of an item.
To take advantage of economic order cycles: Companies use cycle stock to produce
(or buy) in quantities larger than their immediate needs. Because of the cost
involved in setting up a machine, companies usually find producing in large
quantities economical and to minimize purchasing costs companies often buy in
quantities that exceed their immediate requirements. (periodic orders, or order
cycles produce more economical overall production costs.) The quantity produced
is called the economic lot size. The quantity ordered is called the economic order
quantity (EOQ).
23-Oct-23 21
Stock control Methods
• Minimum stock level - first identifying a minimum stock level,
and reorder when stock reaches that level. This is known as the
Re-order Level.
23-Oct-23 22
Con…
• Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) minimize the balance of costs
between inventory holding cost and re-order cost.
Assumptions In calculating EOQ
• Demand for the product is known and constant
• Lead time (time from ordering to receipt) is constant
• Price per unit of product is constant
• Ordering or setup costs are constant
• All demands for the product will be satisfied (No shortages are
allowed)
• The order quantity is received all at once
23-Oct-23 23
con….
• EOQ formula
23-Oct-23 24
Con..
23-Oct-23 25
Con…
• Example: A computer company has annual demand of 10,000. They
want to determine EOQ for circuit boards which have an annual
holding cost (H) of $ 6/unit, and an ordering cost (S) of $ 75. They
want to calculate TC and the reorder point (R) if the purchasing lead
time is 5 days
23-Oct-23 26
Inventory Management
Summary
• Inventory quantities must be organized
and measured carefully.
• Minimum stocks must be assured to
prevent stock-outs or the lack of
product.
• At the same time, they must be
balanced against excessive inventory
because of carrying costs.
23-Oct-23 27
Con..
• Careful attention and constant review must be built
into the management system in order to avoid getting
caught short by unexpected changes in the larger
business environment.
23-Oct-23 28
Warehouse management and material
handling
• Warehouse management is a key supply chain activity and involves
complex tasks.
23-Oct-23 29
Activities of warehouses
23-Oct-23 30
layout in warehousing
23-Oct-23 31
23-Oct-23 32
23-Oct-23 33
Con..
• layout
23-Oct-23 34
23-Oct-23 35
Con…
• Materials handling is the provision of the right amount of the right
material, in the right condition, at the right place, at the right time, in
the right position, in the right sequence, and for the right cost, by using
the right method(s).
23-Oct-23 36
23-Oct-23 37
23-Oct-23 38
23-Oct-23 39
Con..
23-Oct-23 40
Warehousing productivity
• Warehouse productivity can be significantly improved using
information technology.
23-Oct-23 41