Unit 11
Unit 11
1' Ihtrnduation,
llli.2 The. MBtHematias of Carn~~undIht&x!st'
We are introducing the models of stoch~sticinterest rate and some simple uses in
actuarial applications. I
11.2.1 EffectivecInterestRates
. An interest rate is always related with a basic time unit like an annual interest rate
I
of 5%. With the interest rate, the time interval at the end of which interest rate is
credited or "Compounded" has to be stated, which is known as conversion period.
An interest rate is called effective if the basic time unit; and the conversion period
are identical. 1n this case interest.is credited at the end df basic time unit.
Let i be the effective interest rate and let Fobe the ilitial capital. Let rk be the
additional amount invested at the end of year k , k = 1,2,. . .,n.
We want to find out the balance at the end of n years.
Suppose Fkis the balance at the end of year k includin rk, interest credited to the
previous year's balance is i Fk-,.
So,.
,
Fk = Fk-,+iFk-, +rk,k= 1,2,..., n (1 22.1)
which implies ;
One of the t~chniquesis give* by the equation (1 1.2.4) where the interest is
credited at the endi of ea& oanwsrsian period; in arrears. The ather technique. is
given below, where the interest1 is credited at the beginning of the conversion
period. Interest credited in this way is also referr~dto as discount and. the
correspondingrate is called discount rate or rate of intarest in advance. Let d be
an annual effective discount rate. A person investing an amount of C will' be
credited interest equal to dG 4mmediately and the invested aqital C will be
returned1at the end of the peiiod, Ihvesting the interest dC at the same conditions,
the investor will receive additional intemst of d ( d ~=) d 2 C , and. the additional
invested amount wills be retumedlat the end opthe year; reinvesting, the intemst
yields additional interest~ofd ( d 2 c ) =d 3 C and sa on.
Repeating this prooms infinitely we. find tha investor will receive the total sum of
at the end of'the year in wiu.m,fbrinvesting the initial aapital C. The equiwdant
effective intbms4 rate i is given by. tHe equation.
which im~lies.
Thus the iritmeit: pystttlh- a t t the1 end of the year is the accumdhted valhe of
interest payable; atithe h@nnihg:ofi the yean
Actuaria'Techniques-ll which is the net single premium calculated at twice the origins1 force of interest.
Thus calcullating the variance 'is no more difficult than calculating the net single
premium.
An insurance which provides for payment only if death occurs within n years is
known as term insurance of duration n. For example: 1 unit is payable only if
death occurs during the first n years, the actual time of payment still being the end
of the year of death. So
vK+'for K = 0 , 1 , 2 , ..., n-1
0 for K = n , n + 1, n + 2 , ...
The net single premium is denoted by
and
E ( Z ~ ) = E [ 2L6 ( K + I ) ]
11.5.2 Pure Endowments
A pure endowment of duration n provides for payment of the sum insured.only if
the insured is alive at the end of n years,
0 for K = 0 , 1 , ...,n-1
( 1 1.5.9)
vn for K =n; n + l , n + 2 , ...
A I =vnn~x (1 1.5.10)
+,
;;i
The formula for the varianck of a Bernoulli random variable gives . >
11.5.3 Endowments
Assume that the sum insured is payable at the end of the year of death, if this
,,ccurs within the first n years, otherwise at the end of the nth year
VK +I
for K = O,l,2,...,n-1
vn for K = n , n + 1, n + 2 , .,.
The net single premium is denoted by A I J . Denoting the present value of ( 1 1 S.6)
by ZI and (1 1.5.9) by Z2, we have
. ,
and'
v(z)=v(z,)+v(z2)+2cov(z,,z,) ,
The net single premium is denoted bym,Ax.Alternative formula for its net single
premium are
rn1A.r = n, ~ x ~ ~ ' A x + r n
and
m,AI= A x -
The second moment E(z,)again equals the net single premium at twice the
original force of interest.
11.5.4 Insurance Payable at the Moment of Death
In previous sections we have discussed that the sum insured was payable at the
en'd of the year of death; This assumption does not reflect insurance practice in a
realistic way, but has the advantage that the formulae may be evaluated directly
from a life table.
Let us now assume that the sum insured is payable at the instant of death. i.e. at
time T. The present value of a payment of payable at the instant of death is at time
T. .'The present value of a payment of 1.payable immediately on death is
The net single premium is denoted by A,. Using the :formula from force of
mortality
where K is the number of complete future years lived by (x) and S is the fraction
of a year during which ( x ) is alive in the year of death.
Making use of assumed independence of K and S, as well as the uniform
distribution of S, so that
we find
Let us finally assume that the sum insured is payable at the end of the mth part of
the year in which death occurs i.e, time K + $m). The present value of a whole life
insurance of 1 unit then becomes
and we obtain
Cash Flow Pro.jection
Example: 2,is the present value random variable for an n-year continuous
endowment insurance of 1 issued to (x).2, is the present value random variable
for an n year continuous term insurance of I issued to (x).Given
Var (2,)= 0.01, v n = 0.3, p, = 0.8,E (2,)= 0.04 ,calculate Var (2,).
Solution: Let Z3be the present value random variable for the pure endowment
Z,= Z, + Z,
we want to find out ~ar(2,).
Hut var(2,)= V U ~ ( Z+~ 2,)
= Var (2,)+ 2 c o v ( ~ , 2,)
, + ~ar(&).
v n . 1 with probability 1
0 otherwise
Now
E(&) = v n ,,P,=(0.3)(0-8)=(0-24)
...........................................................................................
-)
?
For m = 1,2.3,4,6,12,and oo calculate i(") for i = 6%.
Actuarial Techniques-]]
3) Z1 is the present value random variable for an n-year continuous
endowment insurance of 1 issued to (x). Z2 is the present value random
variable for an n-year continuous term insurance of 1 issued to (xj. Given
values Var(Z2) , px,E(Z2) obtain a formula to find out Var(Z1).
If the first payment is made at the end of yea? 1, we call the perpetuity an
immediate perpetuity. Its present value is denoted by a4 and is given by
el
1
i
1
Let us now consider perpetuity where paymedts of - are made rn times each
rn
1
year. If the payments are made in advance (first payment of - at time O), the
rn
present value is denoted by ii$) and is
1
If the payments ire made in arrears (first payment of - at time O), the present
m 1
J
j L
\
The results in (1 1.6.3) and (1 1.6.4) lead to an interpretation of the identity
(1 1.4.7). Since a perpetuity-due and an immediate perpetuity differ only by a
1 1
payment of - at time 0, their present value differ by - .
m m
Let us now consider a continuous perpetuity with constant rate of payment r = 1
and starting at time 0. Its present value is denoted by a4 and given by
Time Payment
and so on
m k
In particular, the last - payments of year k are - each.
4 m
z ) ~. We can
(m)
Let us denote the present value of such a perpetuity by ( I ( ° )
calculate it by representing the' sequence of increasing payments as sum of
1
perpetuities ~ t constants
h payments of - payable m times per year and
(mq)
1 2
beginning at times 0,-, -, .... Thus we obtain the follawing formula:
4 4
( 1
( I y ) = ,6;) '
, L
l + v Y+ v 4 + . . .
The corresponding immediate annuity differs only in that each payment is made
one mth year'later, thus giving
( I )( I )a =
(,)(I)
-1
d2
. (11.6.8)
ro 0
5 - ro 1
r2 - 'i 2
and so an
provided r < S .
Annuities
In practice annuities are more frequently used than perpetuities. An annuity is
defined as a sequence of payments of a limited duration, which we denote by n.
Here we consider some standard type of annuities or annuities-certain.
The present value of an annuity due with n-annual payments of 1 starting at time
0, is denoted by a d . It is given by
'This result can be verified by evaluating the geometric sum ( 1 1.6.15). Similarly
from ( 1 1.6.2), (1 1.6.3) and (1 1.6.4) the following formulae can be obtained
Note that only the denominator varies, depending on the payment made
(immediate 1 due) and frequency. Note that n must be an integer in (1 1.6.16) and
1
(1 1.6.17). and a multiple of - in (1 1.6.18) and (1 1.6.19).
m
Another simple relation between the initial value and final value of a constant
annuity may be verified.
Time Payment
Substituting (1 1.6.6) and (1 1.6.3) and using (1 1.6.19) we obtain the equation
we get
Let S k be the principal outstanding i.e., the remaining debt immediately after r k
has been paid. It consists of the previous years debt, accumulated for one year
minus Q.
It consists of two components, one is interest on the running debt and reduction of
principal. Substituting -Skfor Fk(1 1.6.32) is equivalent to (1 1.2.2). From (1 1.2.3)
From this one can get S,, = 0 and Sk= v rk+,+ v2rk+,+ ...+ ~ ~ - ~ (1 1.6.35)
r ~
Formula (1 1.6.34) is the retrospective formula and (1 1.6.35) is the prospective
formula for the outstanding principal.
The payments rl, r2, . .., r k may be chosen arbitrarily, subject to the constraint
(1 1.6.3 1). By proper choice of payment steam the following formula of annuities
can be obtained. For example, S = 1 can be repaid by the payments,
I Actuarial Techniques-I1
The payments rl, r*, ..., rk may be chosen arbitrarily, subject to the constraint
(1 1.6.31). By proper choice of payment steam the following formula of annuities
can be obtained. For example, S = 1 can be repaid by the payments,
In this case only interest is paid for the first (n - 1) years and the entire 'debt
together with the last year's interest, is paid of the end of the nth year. From
(1 1.6.31) l=iaJ +vn (1 1.6.37)
The debt S = 1 may also be repaid by constant payments of
.
As an alternative to repaying the creditor at times 1,2,.. ..n-1, one could pay only
the interest on S as in (1 1.6.36). In order to cover the final repayment one can
make equal deposits to a fund that is to accumulate to 1 of the end of n years.
1
from this it is obvious that the annual deposit must be -. Since the total annual
sn
outgo must be the same in both the cases and we arrive at
For security, suppose an investor pays a price p which entitles him to n future
payments. The payments are denoted by rl, r2, . .,, r,, and payment rk is due at time
Tk, for k = 1,2,.. .,n. What is the resulting rate of return?
The present value of the payment stream to be received by the investor is a
function of the force of interest 6 . Define
Let I be the solution of the equation Cash Flow Proiection
P (1 1.6.44)
The internal rate of return or investment yield is defined as i = e' - 1 .
Equation (1 1.6.44) can be solved by standard numerical methods such as interval
bisection or the Newton-Raphson method. We shall present a more efficient and
simpler method than other methods.
Consider
ln (" ) s <l<-
ln (P;) U
(1 1.6.49)
a[+r ' ) I(. " ( r u )~
The process may be iterated yielding the following algorithm. Starting with do,
calculate
recursively.
21
Actuarial Techniques-11
For 6, < t , the resulting sequence will be monotonically increasing and will
converge to t. For 6, > t , the sequence will decrease monotonically to t. Thus any
arbitrary positive value may be chosen for 6,.
Example: 'Security = Rs.50001- (Face amount) yearly coupons = Rs.3001-.
Assume that the security has been bought for Rs.5250 for a remaking running
time of 9 years. Thus we have
r = 7700.
Assuming we know that the current yield of similar securities lies between 5%
and 5.5% we have s = In 1.05, u = In 1- 055. The bounds for the investment
yield is
and
~ ( ut ), = 100e-~("-') (1 1.7.1)
where BC) denotes the present value of 100 discounted at a rate r. A pure
discount bond does not make any coupon payment, does not contain any implicit
option and has a par value of 100. The function e-r(u-I) at time t plays the role of a
discount factor. At time
the bond matures and the exponential function equals 1. At all t < u, it is less
than 1.
The bond price formula depends on the whole spectrum of future short rates.
Hence the yield curve at time t contains all the available information concerning
future short rates and the bond prices depend on the whole yield curve or on the
term structure of interest rates, which we define below.
Cash Flow Projection
Definition: Assume that at time t there exists zero coupon bonds with a spectrum of
. their price be ~ ( u , t )and their yield be given by P;'. Then
maturitiesu E [ t , ~ ] Let
the spectrum of yields (R,",u E [t, T]} is called the term structure of interest rates.
Here the yield R," is defined as the number that satisfies the equality
B ( ~ ,=~1)OOe-4"(~t-t)
,t <U (1 1.7.3) ,
t-u
Examples of yield curves
In practice, there are two ways of proceedings. Often a market participant
assumes a functional form for the yield curve and from there obtains the implied
forward rates. A second method is to go the opposite direction. One can assume a
dynamic behavior for the forward rates and from there obtain a yield curve. In
most common case one assumes that the yields R(-) depends on one variable rt
which represents the short rate observed now, and they are given by the functional
form.
Functions ~ ( u , t and
) c(u,t) can be constructed in various ways, so that the yield
curve can be upword, downward sloping or hump shaped.
we write
Thus the value at time 0 of a payment to be made at time t (i.e., its present value)
-I
I
6(s) d.s
is obtained by multiplication with the factor e "
From (1 1.8.4) we obtain
F ( h ) = eo
I
Thus the value at time h of a payment made at time t < h (its accumulated value),
is obtained by multiplication with the factor
Is
h
(s) dr
eO
In the case of a constant force of interest i.e., ~ ( t= )6 , the factors e " and
h
IS(.^) dr
where rl is the current short rate, r2 is the unknown short rate during year 2 and r3
is the (unknown) short rate during year 3. According to equation (1 1.8.7) the
bonds price is equal to the expectation under risk neutral probabilities of the
discounted value-of the par value. The discount factor is obtained by multiplying
the one period discounts during the present and the two future years. Since future
discounts are unknown, an expectation operator needs to be used.
This example may be more useful in interpreting the cbntinuous-time bond price
given in (1 1.8.6). As time becomes continuous, discrete-time discount factors
need to be replaced by the exponential function. But because interest rates are
continuously changing an integral has to be used in the exponent.
,
Check Your Progress 2
1) Define annuity. Represent annuity as the difference of two perpetuities
one at time 0 and the other at time n. Show that
Conversion Period: The time interval at the end of which interest is credited or
compounded. .
Curtate Future Life Time: The average number of completed future years lived
by the group attaining age x.
Discount Rate: When interest is credited of the beginning of conversion period. '
Effective Interest Rate: When the conversion period and basic time unit are
~dcnricalinterest rate is credited at the end of basic time unit.
. I".
I[.ife Table: A conventional method of expressing the most essential facts about
the age distribution of mortality in a tabular form and it gives the life history of a
hypothetical population which is gradually diminished by deaths. It is a powerful
tool for measuring the probability of life and death at various age sectors.
Net Single Premium: The expected value of present value of the payment.
Nominal Interear Qgte: When the conversion period does not coincide with basic
time unit.
Perpetuity: A sequence of payments of an unlimited duration.
11.13 EXERCISES
2) A deposit of 100,000 is made into a newly established fund. The fund pays
nominal interst of 12% convertible quarterly. At the end of each six
months a withdrawal is made from the fund. The first withdrawal is X, the
second is 2X, the 3rd is 3X and so on. The last is sixth withdrawal, which
exactly exhausts the fund, Calculate X.
3) Given: (i) A a = 4 , (ii) A : : ~= y ; (iii) A,,. = z . Determine the value of
Ax in terms of u, y and x.
4) Z I is the present value random variable for an n year continuous
endowment insurance of 1 issued to x. Zz is the present value random
variable for an n year continuous term insurance of 1 issued to x. Given
(i) ~ar(~,)=0.01, (ii) v n = 0 - 30 .
Calculate var(Z,).
5) A loan of 1000 at a nominal rate of 12% convertible monthly is to be
repaid by six monthly payments with the first payment due at the end of
one month. The first three payments are x each, and the final three
payments are 3x each, calculate x.