PM Unit2
PM Unit2
2 Explain & describe a well planned and executed project. Describe a failed
project. What elements of project integration might have contributed to the
success or failure of each?
Well-Planned and Executed Project:
- Clear project objectives aligned with organizational goals.
- Comprehensive project planning with detailed tasks and timelines.
- Effective project communication among stakeholders.
- Efficient resource management and allocation.
- Proactive risk management and contingency planning.
Failed Project:
- Undefined or shifting project objectives.
- Inadequate planning and scope management.
- Poor communication and stakeholder engagement.
- Inadequate resource allocation and management.
- Ineffective risk management and lack of contingency plans.
Project Integration in Success:
- Alignment of project objectives with organizational strategy.
- Collaboration and effective communication among stakeholders.
- Coordinated planning and execution of project activities.
- Integration of stakeholder inputs and feedback.
- Proactive monitoring, control, and quality assurance.
Project Integration in Failure:
- Lack of alignment with organizational strategy.
- Insufficient collaboration and communication.
- Inconsistent planning and execution.
- Inadequate stakeholder engagement and support.
- Neglected monitoring, control, and quality assurance.
1. Definition: ROI measures the financial gain or loss relative to the investment
cost.
2. Formula: ROI = (Total Benefits - Investment Cost) / Investment Cost
3. Percentage Value: ROI is expressed as a percentage, representing the return
on the investment.
4. Positive vs. Negative ROI: A positive ROI indicates that the returns exceed
the investment cost, while a negative ROI means the investment incurred a loss.
5. Decision-making: ROI helps in comparing and prioritizing investment
options based on their potential returns.
6. Example: Suppose a company invests $100,000 in a marketing campaign and
generates $120,000 in revenue. The ROI is ($120,000 - $100,000) / $100,000 =
20%.
7. Importance of ROI: It enables organizations to evaluate the effectiveness and
efficiency of their investments.
8. Considerations: ROI should be analyzed alongside other factors such as
investment duration, associated risks, and industry benchmarks to make
informed decisions.
1. Definition: Payback analysis calculates the time taken to recoup the initial
investment in terms of net cash inflows.
2. Payback Period: It represents the time when the cumulative benefits equal or
surpass the cumulative costs.
3. Calculation: The payback period is determined by comparing the cumulative
discounted benefits and costs each year until the point where the cumulative
benefits minus costs equals zero.
4. Chart Representation: Creating a chart of cumulative discounted costs and
benefits helps visualize the payback period, which is indicated by the point
where the lines intersect.
5. Example: In Figure 4-6, the payback period occurs in Year 1 as the
cumulative discounted benefits minus costs turns positive.
Years 2, 3, and 4:
Cost: $30,000 per year
Benefit: $100,000 per year
Discount Rate: 9%
To calculate the Net Present Value (NPV), Return on Investment (ROI), and
payback period, we need to discount the projected costs and benefits to their
present values.
Discount Factors (rounded to two decimal places):
Year 1: 1.00
Year 2: 0.92
Year 3: 0.85
Year 4: 0.78
Years 2, 3, and 4:
Cost PV: $30,000 * 0.92 + $30,000 * 0.85 + $30,000 * 0.78 = $80,400
Benefit PV: $100,000 * 0.92 + $100,000 * 0.85 + $100,000 * 0.78 = $346,800
Calculating the Net Present Value (NPV):
NPV = Total Benefit PV - Total Cost PV
NPV = $346,800 - ($200,000 + $80,400)
NPV = $66,400
Based on the financial analysis, the project has a positive NPV of $66,400 and
an ROI of approximately 23.68%. Additionally, the payback period occurs in
Year 3. These results suggest that the project is financially viable. Therefore, I
would recommend investing in this project based on the positive NPV, favorable
ROI, and relatively quick payback period.