Unit 4
Unit 4
Measurement of Resistances
CLASSIFICATION OF RESISTANCES
For the purposes of measurements, the resistances are classified into three major groups based
on their numerical range of values as under:
• Low resistance (0 to 1 ohm)
• Medium resistance (1 to 100 kilo-ohm) and
• High resistance (>100 kilo-ohm)
Accordingly, the resistances can be measured by various ways, depending on their range of
values, as under:
1. Low resistance (0 to 1 ohm): AV Method, Kelvin Double Bridge, potentiometer, doctor
ohmmeter, etc.
2. Medium resistance (1 to 100 kilo-ohm): AV method, wheat stone’s bridge, substitution
method, etc.
3. High resistance (>100 kilo-ohm): AV method, Fall of potential method, Megger, loss of
charge method, substitution method, bridge method, etc.
4.1 Measurement of medium resistances
In this section, we will discuss the method of measurement of Medium Resistance. The
different methods used for Medium resistance are as follows:
· Ammeter Voltmeter method
· Substitution Method
· Wheatstone Bridge Method
· Ohmmeter Method
4.1.1 Ammeter Voltmeter Method:
There are two possible connections for the measurement of Medium Resistance using Ammeter
Voltmeter Method as shown in figure below:
In both the cases, the reading of Voltmeter and Ammeter is taken. If the Voltmeter reading is
V and Ammeter reading is I then the measured Resistance will be
Rm = V/I
This measured Resistance Rm will be the true value of the Resistance if and only if the
Resistance of Ammeter is zero and that of Voltmeter is infinite. But actually this is not possible
to achieve zero resistance Ammeter and infinite Resistance Voltmeter. Therefore measured
value of resistance Rm will deviate from the true value R (Say).
So we will discuss both the circuit individually and will calculate the percentage error in the
measurement.
Case1:
We consider first kind of connection as shown in figure 1 above. It is clear from the figure that
Voltmeter is measuring the Voltage drop across the Ammeter as well as resistor.
So V = Va + Vr
Let current measured by Ammeter = I
Therefore, measured Resistance Rm = V/I
So, Rm = (Va+Vr) / I =(IRa+IR) / I = Ra+R
Therefore, the measured Resistance is the sum of Resistance of Ammeter and true Resistance.
Therefore measured value will only represent true value if Ammeter Resistance Ra is Zero.
True value of Resistance R = Rm –Ra
= Rm(1-Ra/Rm)
Relative Error = (Rm-R)/R = Ra/R
Therefore, Relative Error will be less if the true value of Resistance to be measured is high as
compared to the internal Resistance of Ammeter. That’s why this method should be adopted
when measuring high Resistance but it should be under Medium Resistance category.
Case2:
We will consider second connection in which Voltmeter is connected in which Voltmeter is
connected toward Resistance R whose value is to be measured.
It is obvious from figure that Ammeter will read the current flowing through the Voltmeter and
Resistance R. Therefore current measured by Ammeter Ia = Iv+Ir
So, Ia = Iv+Ir
= V/Rv+V/R where Rv is Resistance of Voltmeter and V is Voltmeter reading.
Measured Resistance Rm = V/Ia
= V/(V/Rv+V/R)
= RvR/(R+Rv)
= R/(1+R/Rv) ….Dividing Numerator and Denominator by Rv
Therefore, true value of Resistance R = RmRv/(Rv-Rm)
= Rm(1-Rm/Rv)
Therefore, true value of Resistance will only be equal to measured value if the value
of Voltmeter Resistance Rv is infinite.
If we assume that the value of Voltmeter Resistance Rv is large as compared to the Resistance
to be measured R, then Rv>>>Rm
So, True value R = Rm(1+Rm/Rv)
Thus from the above equation it is clear that the measured value of Resistance is smaller than
the true value.
Relative Error = (Rm-R)/R
= -R/Rv
Therefore, it is clear from the expression of Relative Error that, error in measurement will be
low if the value of Resistance under measurement is very less as compared to the internal
Resistance of Voltmeter.
This is the reason; this method is used for the Contact Resistance Measurement. As the value
of Contact Resistance is of the order of 20 micro Ohm which is very less as compared to the
internal Resistance of Voltmeter.
The Voltmeter Ammeter Method for Cases1 and Case2 are simple method but it is not accurate
method. The error in the value of Resistance depends on the accuracy of Ammeter as well as
Voltmeter. If the accuracy of both the instrument are supposed 0.5% then when both the
instrument read near full scale, the error in measurement of Resistance may vary from 0 to 1%
while if both the instrument read near half scale then error may double and so on.
However this method is very useful where high accuracy is not required. The suitability of
Case1 or Case2 depends on the value of Resistance to be measured. The division point between
the two methods is at the Resistance for which both the method give same Relative Error.
So, Ra/R = R/Rv
R=
4.1.2 Measurement of Medium Resistance by Substitution Method
In Substitution Method, the Resistance whose value is to be measured is compared with the
Standard Resistance by some technique which is described in this section. The connection
diagram for Substitution Method is given below.
Here, R is the unknown Resistance, S the Standard variable Resistance, A is Ammeter and r is
Regulating Resistance.
When we put the Switch at position 1 then R is connected in the circuit. The Regulating
Resistance r is adjusted till the reading of Ammeter is at a chosen scale mark. Now the Switch
is thrown to position 2 putting the Standard variable Resistance S in the circuit. Now the
variable Resistor S is adjusted till the reading of Ammeter is same as when R was in the circuit.
The setting of dial of S is read. Since the substitution of one resistance for another has left
current unaltered, and provided that EMF of battery and position of Regulating Resistance r
remain unaltered, the two Resistance R and S must be equal. Thus the value of unknown
Resistance R is equal to the dial setting of Standard Resistance S.
This method of measurement is more accurate as compared to the Ammeter Voltmeter Method
as in this method measurement is not affected by the accuracy of Ammeter. However, the
accuracy of this method is greatly affected if there is any change in the Battery EMF during
the time when the reading in two settings is taken. Therefore to avoid the error because of
change of EMF of Battery, a Battery of enough capacity is used so that it remains constant
during the entire period of testing.
The accuracy of this method also depend on resistance of circuit excluding R and S, upon the
sensitivity of instrument and upon the accuracy with which the Standard Resistance S is known.
This method is not widely used for simple Resistance measurement and is used in modified
form for the measurement of High Resistance. The Substitution Method is however very
important as it finds its use in application of bridge method and in high accuracy A.C
measurement.
4.1.3 WHEATSTONE BRIDGE
For measuring accurately any electrical resistance Wheatstone bridge is widely used. There are
two known resistors, one variable resistor and one unknown resistor connected in bridge form
as shown below. By adjusting the variable resistor the current through the Galvanometer is
made zero. When the current through the galvanometer becomes zero, the ratio of two known
resistors is exactly equal to the ratio of adjusted value of variable resistance and the value of
unknown resistance. In this way the value of unknown electrical resistance can easily be
measured by using a Wheatstone Bridge. THEORY The general arrangement of Wheatstone
bridge circuit is shown in the figure below. It is a four arms bridge circuit where arm AB, BC,
CD and AD are consisting of electrical resistances P, Q, S and R respectively. Among these
resistances P and Q are known fixed electrical resistances and these two arms are referred as
ratio arms. An accurate and sensitive Galvanometer is connected between the terminals B and
D through a switch S2. The voltage source of this Wheatstone bridge is connected to the
terminals A and C via a switch S1 as shown. A variable resistor S is connected between point
C and D.
The potential at point D can be varied by adjusting the value of variable resistor. Suppose
current I1 and current I2 are flowing through the paths ABC and ADC respectively. If we vary
the electrical resistance value of arm CD the value of current I2 will also be varied as the
voltage across A and C is fixed. If we continue to adjust the variable resistance one situation
may comes when voltage drop across the resistor S that is I2.S is becomes exactly equal to
voltage drop across resistor Q that is I1.Q. Thus the potential at point B becomes equal to the
potential at point D hence potential difference between these two points is zero hence current
through galvanometer is nil. Then the deflection in the galvanometer is nil when the switch S2
is closed.
Now, from Wheatstone bridge circuit
And
Now potential of point B in respect of point C is nothing but the voltage drop across the resistor
Q and this is
Again potential of point D in respect of point C is nothing but the voltage drop across the
resistor S and this is
A Wheatstone bridge is a fairly convenient and accurate method for measuring resistance.
1. Discrepancies between the true and marked values of resistances of the three known arms
can introduce errors in measurement.
2. Inaccuracy of the balance point due to insufficient sensitivity of the galvanometer may result
in false null points.
3. Bridge resistances may change due to self-heating (I 2R) resulting in error in measurement
calculations.
4. Thermal emfs generated in the bridge circuit or in the galvanometer in the connection points
may lead to error in measurement.
5. Errors may creep into measurement due to resistances of leads and contacts. This effect is
however, negligible unless the unknown resistance is of very low value.
6. There may also be personal errors in finding the proper null point, taking readings, or during
calculations.
Thermal emfs in the bridge arms may cause serious trouble, particularly while measuring low
resistances. Thermal emf in galvanometer circuit may be serious in some cases, so care must
be taken to minimize those effects for precision measurements. Some sensitive galvanometers
employ all-copper systems (i.e., copper coils as well as copper suspensions), so that there is no
junction of dissimilar metals to produce thermal emf. The effect of thermal emf can be balanced
out in practice by adding a reversing switch in the circuit between the battery and the bridge,
then making the bridge balance for each polarity and averaging the two results.
Figure Guard circuit for measurement of high resistance: (a) Circuit without guard (b) Circuit
with guard
3. Due to electrostatic effects, stray charges may be induced in the measuring circuit.
Flow of these stray charges can constitute a current that can be comparable in magnitude with
the low value current under measurement in high resistance circuits.
This may thus, cause errors in measurement. External alternating electromagnetic fields can
also affect the measurement considerably. Therefore, the measuring circuit needs to be
carefully screened to protect it against such external electrostatic or electromagnetic effects.
4. While measuring insulation resistance, the test object often has considerable amount of
capacitance as well. On switching on the dc power supply, a large charging current may flow
initially through the circuit, which gradually decays down. This initial transient current may
introduce errors in measurement unless considerable time is provided between application of
the voltage supply and reading the measurement, so that the charging current gets sufficient
time to die down.
5. High resistance measurement results are also affected by changes in temperature, humidity
and applied voltage inaccuracies.
6. Reasonably high voltages are used for measurement of high resistances in order to raise the
current to substantial values in order to be measured, which are otherwise extremely low. So,
the associated sensitive galvanometers and micro-ammeters need to be adequately protected
against such high voltages.
Taking these factors into account, the most well-known methods of high resistance
measurements are (i) direct deflection method, (ii) loss of charge method, and (iii)
megohmmeter or meggar.
4.3.2 Direct Deflection Method for High Resistance Measurement
The direct deflection method for measuring high resistances is based on the circuit described
in Figure, which in effect is the voltmeter-ammeter method. For measurement of high
resistances, a sensitive galvanometer is used instead of a micro ammeter as shown in Figure.
A schematic diagram for describing the direct deflection method for measurement of insulation
resistance of a metal sheathed cable is given in Figure.
Figure.
Figure: Loss of charge method for measurement of high resistance
In Above Figure, the unknown resistance R to be measured is connected across the capacitor
C and their parallel combination is connected to the dc voltage source.
Let the capacitor is initially charged up to a voltage of V while the switch is kept ON.
Once the switch is turned OFF, the capacitor starts to discharge through the resistance R.
During the discharge process, the voltage v across the capacitor at any instant of time t is given
by Thus, the insulation resistance can be calculated as With known value of C and recorded
values of t, V and v, the unknown resistance R can be estimated using (24).
The pattern of variation of voltage v with time is shown in Figure.
Capacitor discharge pattern Great care must be taken to record the voltages V and v and also
the time t very precisely, otherwise large errors may creep in to the calculation results.
This method, though simple in principle, require careful choice of the capacitor. The capacitor
C itself must have sufficiently high value of its own leakage resistance, at least in the same
range as the unknown resistance under measurement. The resistance of the voltmeter also needs
to be very high to have more accurate results.
4.3.4 Megohmmeter, or Meggar, for High Resistance Measurement
One of the most popular portable type insulation resistance measuring instruments is the
megohmmeter or in short, meggar. The meggar is used very commonly for measurement of
insulation resistance of electrical machines, insulators, bushings, etc. Internal diagram of a
meggar is shown in Figure.
The traditional analog deflecting-type meggar is essentially a permanent magnet crossed-coil
shunt type ohmmeter.
The instrument has a small permanent magnet dc generator developing 500 V dc (some other
models also have 100 V, 250 V, 1000 or 2500 V generators). The generator is hand driven,
through gear arrangements, and through a centrifugally controlled clutch switch which slips at
a predefined speed so that a constant voltage can be developed. Some meggars also have
rectified ac as power supply.