Psychology and Marketing - 2016 - Alves - Social Media Marketing A Literature Review and Implications
Psychology and Marketing - 2016 - Alves - Social Media Marketing A Literature Review and Implications
Psychology and Marketing - 2016 - Alves - Social Media Marketing A Literature Review and Implications
See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Social Media Marketing: A Literature
Review and Implications
Helena Alves
University of Beira Interior and NECE
Cristina Fernandes
Polytechnic Institute of Castelo Branco and NECE
Mário Raposo
University of Beira Interior and NECE
ABSTRACT
This study carries out content analysis and systemizes articles on social media marketing in the Web
of Science database. Forty-four studies were analyzed in accordance with a variation on the
systematic review approach, involving synthesis- and interpretation-based assessment. The results
demonstrate how most of the studies analyzed focus on the consumer perspective in terms of usage,
share, and influence of social media on consumer decisions, and perceptions. The studies focusing on
the firm’s perspective centered not only on the usage of social media, but also on their
implementation, optimization, and measurement of results. The majority of studies are quantitative
and published in recent years. This study not only reached certain conclusions for both theory and
practice, but also defined future lines of research according to the gaps detected by the study’s
results. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
The emergence of new information and communication According to Mangold and Faulds (2009), social me-
technologies, particularly the Internet and social net- dia enables firms to communicate with their customers
works, has changed market dynamics, threatening the and also allows customers to communicate with each
competitive positions of firms (Porter, 2001) and in- other. Communications between firms and their cus-
creasing the power of consumers (Urban, 2005). tomers help build brand loyalty beyond traditional
The Internet- and online-based social media have methods (Jackson, 2011; Kaplan & Haenlein, 2010),
changed consumer consumption habits by providing which concede to the promotion of products and ser-
consumers with new ways of looking for, assess- vices as well as the setting up of online communi-
ing, choosing, and buying goods and services (Albors, ties of brand followers (Kaplan & Haenlein, 2010).
Ramos, & Hervas, 2008). These developments influ- Furthermore, conversations between customers pro-
ence how marketers operate and affect marketing prac- vide firms with new means of increasing brand aware-
tices in terms of both strategy and tactics by present- ness, brand recognition, and brand recall (Gunelius,
ing marketers with new challenges and difficult choices 2011).
(Thomas, 2007). Researchers such as Castronovo and Huang (2012)
We understand social media as including all maintain that marketing strategies involving market-
Internet-based technological applications, in accor- ing intelligence, promotions, public relations, product
dance with the principles of Web 2.0 and providing and customer management, and marketing communi-
the creation and exchange of user-generated content, cations should begin exploring and leveraging social
while also facilitating interaction and collaboration be- media, not only because there is a growing interest
tween participants (Kaplan & Haenlein, 2010). Such among consumers in Internet usage, but also due to
applications also include blogs and microblogs (such as the fact that consumers consider information shared on
Twitter), social networking sites (such as MySpace and social media as more reliable than information issued
Facebook), virtual worlds (such as Second Life), collab- directly by firms (Constantinides et al., 2010).
orative projects (such as Wikipedia), content commu- According to eMarketer (2013), firms have increas-
nity sites (e.g., YouTube, Flickr), and sites dedicated ingly adopted social media for various marketing ac-
to feedback (e.g. online forums; Chan & Guillet, 2011; tivities such as branding, market research, customer
Mangold & Faulds, 2009). relationship management, service provision, and sales
and that their influence on other consumers depends predominance of quantitative techniques in the study
on their characteristics and overwhelmingly conveyed of social media marketing. In the quantitative studies,
by their communication networks rather than through the majority apply quantitative statistical and econo-
their contact networks; the messages and content of metric techniques such as linear regressions, structural
social media cannot be the same for utility and he- equations, and stochastic analysis, while in qualita-
donic products; these are perceived differently by in- tive studies content analysis predominates. Analysis of
dividuals with different levels of trait reactance; the Table 2 confirms that qualitative methodologies still
more personalized applications are, the greater their remain scarce in this field even if these open up un-
success; and social media marketing actions and cam- derstandings of the meanings to the phenomena under
paigns contribute to improving consumer attitudes to- study (Patton, 2002).
ward brands similar to that proposed by Kaplan and
Haenlein (2010), Gunelius (2011), and Jackson (2011).
IMPLICATIONS AND FUTURE LINES OF
RESEARCH
Type of Study
Finally, the typology of studies was analyzed regard- From the results presented by the various different
ing the type of analysis carried out. As Table 2 sets studies, we may identify various implications both for
out, four studies are purely theoretical, 39 are empiri- theory and for practice. One of the conclusions reached
cal and, of those, 29 are quantitative, 5 are qualitative, by the studies refers to how microblogs and social net-
and 5 apply mixed methodologies and demonstrate a works, such as Facebook and Twitter, constitute the
Firm/organization Degree of use and facility - Microblogs and social networks are the Ashley and Tuten (2015), Chan
of using social media most commonly used means and Guillet (2011), Enli and
- Sites managed by the firm itself have Skogerbø (2013), Hays, Page,
better results and Buhalis (2012), Keinänen
- The use of social media is still and Kuivalainen (2015),
restricted in some Koumpouros, Toulias, and
sectors/organizations, such as health, Koumpouros (2015), Mackey
tourist destination management and Liang (2013),
organizations, and in B2B, where this Michaelidou et al. (2011), and
often depends on the individual and Ubeda et al. (2013)
private use of social media by
professionals in these
sectors/organizations
- It is very easy to begin using social
media
Optimization, - Social media sentiment has a stronger Kozinets et al. (2010), Kumar
measurement, and impact on firm stock performance than and Mirchandani (2012),
impact of social media conventional media Kumar et al. (2013), Luo and
marketing strategies - Word-of-mouth messages are adapted Zhang (2013), and Yu et al.
by the senders according to the (2013)
receiver
- Consumer buzz and online traffic
explain part of the company’s value
- Social media can be used to generate
increased sales, return on investment,
word of mouth, and spread
information about brands
Use, search, and share of - Opinion leaders search for and share Bilgihan et al. (2014), Chang
information more information in social media et al. (2015), Lorenzo-Romero
- Participation and sharing of et al. (2012), Özgüven and
information varies according to the Mucan (2013), Schulze et al.
demographic and behavioral (2014), La Torre, Miccoli, and
characteristics of social media users Ricciardi (2014), and
- Strategies of social media marketing Workman and Gupta (2013)
for utility products cannot be based on
the same mechanisms as hedonic
products
- The most popular smartphone
applications are those that allow the
uploading of photos and their
personalization
- The popularity of a post influences its
sharing
(Continued)
social media, so far, most commonly deployed by com- Kumar et al., 2013) and companies should therefore en-
panies (Chan & Guillet, 2011; Enli & Skorgerbo, 2013). sure their presence in these channels but, on the other
Furthermore, these are the means that prove able to hand, leaving open the scope for company recourse to
return the best results in terms of attitudes toward the other social media platforms. According to Mangold and
brand (Kim & Ko, 2012; Kumar & Mirchandani, 2012; Faulds (2009) and Chan and Guillet (2011), there are
Attitude toward the - Messages on social media contribute to Cambria, Grassi, Hussain, and
brand improved attitudes toward the brand, Havasi (2012), Chen et al.
increased word of mouth and customer (2015), De Vries et al. (2012),
equity Kim and Ko (2012), Lee et al.
- Positioning the brand post on top of (2015), Lee, Xiong, and Hu
the brand fan page enhances brand (2012), Leung, Bai, and
post popularity Stahura (2015), Rishika et al.
- Vivid and interactive brand post (2013), Smith, Fischer, and
characteristics enhance the number of Yongjian (2012), and Zadeh
likes and Sharda (2014)
- The share of positive comments on a
brand post is positively related to the
number of likes
- People with different levels of trait
reactance respond differently toward
the same marketing attempt
- Twitter and Facebook seem to be the
best means to improve consumer
attitudes toward the brand
- - The time and the number of followers
of a brand post are determinant in
measuring the post’s popularity
Influence among - It is more reliable to forecast the Guo et al. (2015), Liu and Park
consumers influence on individuals through their (2015), Qazi et al. (2014), and
network of effective communications in Tang et al. (2015)
social media than through their list of
friends
- The usefulness of an assessment
depends on the characteristics of the
message but also on the characteristics
of the individual making the
assessment
- The SVM ranking model can help to
determine which users recommend to
other users
various means of social media, among them, in addi- light how this extends beyond simply maintaining the
tion to the aforementioned social network sites, virtual presence in social media. Obtaining success from com-
worlds, content community sites, and sites dedicated pany social media marketing strategies requires elic-
to feedback. This points to the need to analyze the be- iting strong feelings among users (Chen, Kim, & Lin,
haviors of consumers in these different channels, the 2015; Lee, Gallagher, Liebman, Miller, & Marlenga,
differences in consumer behaviors across the various 2012). This may result not only from vivid and inter-
channels, and the contribution of these other means active brand posts, by positioning the brand post at
that have not been studied yet, the similarities that the top of the Web page (Chang, Yu, & Lu, 2015; De
occur between Facebook and Twitter, moving toward Vries, Gensler, & Leeflang, 2012), among other mar-
increased sales, word of mouth, and profits. keting techniques, but also from the involvement of
Another conclusion with major implications for com- consumers in social media initiatives and campaigns
panies derives from how social media marketing strate- (Rishika, Kumar, Janakiraman, & Bezawada, 2013).
gies hold the capacity to impact the market value of Our results also stress how opinion leaders channel
firms and businesses. Social media enable and empower and share the greatest amount of information on so-
word of mouth (Luo & Zhang, 2013; Yu et al., 2013) as cial media (Bilgihan, Peng, & Kandampully, 2014) and
well as the capacity to generate added sales (Kumar should correspondingly constitute the preferential tar-
& Mirchandani, 2012). However, these findings high- gets of any social media marketing strategy. Through
these opinion leaders, such strategies prove to gener- The results also convey how the majority of studies
ate buzz words about the company and its products. focus on understanding the aspects related to consumer
However, in terms of future lines of research, there is behaviors in social media, and so more studies, focus-
still a need to better understand just how online shar- ing on firms, their various facets, especially barriers to
ing of information takes place, which in turn shapes social media usage, measuring returns on investment,
the co-creation of value by consumers and to this end ways to optimize strategies, among others, may prove
making recourse to social network theories, for exam- future paths for research.
ple, to better grasp the relationships and the spread of In addition, firms need models to analyze the returns
information across human online networks. on investment in social media. Some studies already
The results also demonstrate how companies are not take this approach, for example, we would highlight
able to deploy but a single strategy for social media those by Hoffman and Fodor (2010) and Kumar and
marketing because, on the one hand, individual charac- Mirchandani (2012). Nevertheless, more studies are
teristics such as different levels of trait reactance end necessary both to confirm the results found by these
up influencing the ways in which consumers react to authors and also to analyze the models developed by
these strategies (Lee, Kim, Lim, & Kim, 2015; Özgüven other, less studied, social media.
& Mucan, 2013) and, on the other hand, because the Regarding recourse to the usage of social me-
characteristics of products, for example, with hedonistic dia in the B2B context, this proves still limited in
versus functional appeals, also condition the respective scope (Keinanen & Kuivalainen, 2015; Michaelidou,
social media marketing strategies (Schulze, Schöler, & Siamagka, & Christodoulides, 2011; Ubeda et al., 2013)
Skiera, 2014) and require different approaches to en- and hence more studies in this area are necessary,
sure the deployment of effective and efficient strategies. particularly targeting possible utilizations of some