Academic Audience Final Draft
Academic Audience Final Draft
Academic Audience Final Draft
To: Professor Kimberly Freeman, COLWRIT 161 class, College Writing Program
My Literature review discusses the present research that has been done on the effects of changing
hormone levels in women and their effects on neurodegeneration progression. Specifically, I will
be focusing on the effects of a particular hormone, estrogen, and its changing levels experienced
during the time of pregnancies. The specific neurodegenerative disease that will be reviewed in
this context is Alzheimer’s Disease (AD). With women in the United States suffering from a
disproportionately higher rate of AD, the effects of female hormones on this associated
the actual effects of estrogen exposure on neurodegeneration as well as reviewing the differing
This literature review is composed of multiple sections which are presented in a thematic order
based on study type and result findings. The primary section gives background information on
the main role of estrogen in a woman’s body and the ways in which the levels of estrogen change
during pregnancy. An understanding of the basic roles of estrogen in the body is used to lead into
the subsequent sections on how current studies on these changes are involved in the
neurodegeneration process. The second section reviews the main study types that have been
2
utilized by researchers while the third and fourth section looks at these studies as either an
If I were able to submit this literature review to a journal, it would be the Frontiers in Aging
Neuroscience. This journal specifically publishes papers that focus on the advancements in
knowledge regarding central nervous system aging as well as age-related neuronal diseases. This
closely aligns with the subject I am choosing to focus on for my review. In addition, most of the
papers which have been used for this literature review have also been published in this journal.
While reading this literature review, an understanding of these terms may aid in the
2. Endogenous- having an internal origin within the body (definition taken from Oxford
Dictionary)
3. Exogenous- having an external origin (not originating from the body) (definition taken
5. Myometrium- middle layer of the uterine wall (definition taken from Wikipedia)
6. BMP4- Acronym for Bone Morphogenetic Protein 4, which is a gene encoding protein
Disease
Abstract
Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) affects millions of people in the United States, but it is more
prevalent in women than men. One of the main differences between males and females is the
presence of the menstrual cycle, pregnancy, and menopause, which are all time periods of high
17β-estradiol (estradiol), is an important variant during these times. The significant physiological
difference is enough to prompt research regarding whether or not the fluctuation in estrogen
levels during pregnancy have an effect on the rate of AD progression. This review looks at the
various methods of testing estrogen levels, including specific tissues, hormone replacement
therapy (HRT), genetic risk factors, alternative life events, and parity events. Due to the mixed
results that the studies have produced, a discussion of data supporting both disadvantageous and
advantageous effects of increased estrogen exposure will be supplied. While most of the research
reviewed ultimately supports the notion that estrogen has protective effects within a “critical
window”, further research needs to be conducted. One topic for future research includes how the
Introduction
population (1). With over 5 million individuals suffering from this disease in the United States,
more than half of these individuals are women (2). Thus, the reasons why women are more
4
susceptible to this disease needs to be a focus for research. Due to the large number of hormonal
changes the female body undergoes within a lifetime, studies regarding the effects of these
hormonal changes on neurodegeneration have been difficult to execute. This might explain the
Although there have not been a significant number of studies done on the effects of
female hormones and neurodegeneration, the current research has identified estrogen as an
important contributor to many of the major hormonal fluctuations in a female’s life (3). While
the increased levels of estrogen during puberty are considered helpful to a woman as their
reproductive system starts to mature (4) , the effects of increased estrogen exposure during later
life are still being studied. The current research studies reveal conflicting results regarding
In this review, I will be discussing the current, but limited, studies that have been
conducted in their attempts to understand the effects of estrogen exposure on women’s rate and
risk of neurodegeneration. I will begin by outlining the role of estrogen in a woman's health,
including its role during the time of pregnancy. We will then look at the study types that have
been utilized by researchers in an attempt to isolate the effects of this hormone and, later, how
their results might be applicable to the overall question of estrogen exposure on AD progression.
Lastly, in order to consolidate and organize the current research, the studies analyzed will be
separated into two sections based on their findings: one concluding increased estrogen exposure
has protective effects against neurodegeneration, and the other concluding increased estrogen
exposure has detrimental effects regarding neurodegeneration. The purpose of this review is to
highlight the overall inconclusive results regarding the effects of estrogen exposure on
5
neurodegeneration in women across current studies, and ultimately reveal the need for further
research. Overall, this review provides an structured overview of current studies regarding the
background information regarding the hormone itself and the study types that are utilized.
Estrogen is a hormone well known to the female body. The hormone itself is classified as
a steroid hormone and is produced following a cascade of signaling hormones called follicle
stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH) in the ovaries (4). Before puberty, the
secretion of estrogen in the female is minimal but as puberty progresses, levels of estrogen rise
which aid in the development of sexual organs. Later in life when women experience menopause
(an end in the menstruation cycle), the number of gonadotropins drops and so does the level of
estrogen. In addition to the ‘typical’ effects of estrogen, there are specific effects seen within the
The main form of estrogen that is considered in this context is called 17β-estradiol
(estradiol). This isoform acts on the receptor E2 which is located throughout the body and
notably in the hippocampus. This isoform and receptor type is crucial in understanding the role
of estrogen in neurodegeneration precisely because of the effects it has on different brain regions.
Males and females have different forms of this E2 receptor and the signaling pathway subsequent
to binding also shows different effects between genders. Given that estrogen is present in both
males and females, the changes in signaling pathways and levels of 17β-estradiol can be useful in
understanding why more females experience this disease compared to men. While the difference
6
in amount of estradiol receptors are known between males and females, it is still unknown how
the rise and fall of estrogen in the body during pregnancy alters the progression of the disease.
Estrogen levels increase dramatically during pregnancy. One longitudinal study reported
an almost 7-fold increase in the amount of estradiol in women’s bodies by the time of their third
trimesters (6). At the biological level, estrogen plays a number of roles in preparation for the
development of a fetus. This includes thinning the cervical fluid which allows sperm to reach an
egg located in the ovaries, as well as providing lubrication, making penetration easier. These are
a result of the previously mentioned LH and FSH, which help to regulate the menstruation cycle,
as well as the rise and fall of estrogen levels. Before an egg is fertilized by a sperm, estrogen
levels rise rapidly during what is considered an LH surge (7). If the egg is not fertilized, the
estrogen levels return back to normal. When the egg is fertilized, the placenta maintains estrogen
levels (7). Thus, the increased level of estrogen experienced by a woman during pregnancy is
why they are ideal for studying the effects of estrogen on female neurodegeneration.
Estrogen is difficult to completely isolate in the body, which is why there are a variety of
methods that have been used to study the effects of estrogen on neurodegeneration. These
methods include specific tissue studies, hormonal replacement therapy studies, genetic risk
studies, as well as other alternative life-events for women studies (ex. Menopause, time of
puberty onset, etc.) and parity studies. It is vital to first understand the types of studies used to
Tissue Studies
7
Tissues studies are used to focus on the effects of neurodegeneration within a specific
region of the body. The tissue studies included in this review focused on determining the levels
of neurodegeneration that occur within specific areas, including the uterus and axons with their
sympathetic terminals in the myometrium (8). The goal in separating out different bodily tissues
in a woman and analyzing the changes in estrogen levels and neurodegeneration progression is to
localize the main regions of the female reproductive system that seem to be suffering from high
extents of axon degeneration and decreased neuroplasticity. The direct cause of this decreased
neuroplasticity was a result of the effect that estrogen has on sympathetic neuron neurotrophin
receptor expression. The underlying mechanisms of neuroplasticity effects varied among the
different tissues studied but included BMP4 synthesis suppression by estrogen in the vagina (8).
The tissue studies indicate which estrogen producing and utilizing regions may be contributing to
(9). This type of study is useful in the context of this review because the researcher can directly
The most well known HRT study was the Women’s Health Initiative Memory Study (10) which
followed over 4,000 women in a randomized control study receiving either the hormone
treatment or a placebo in addition to the same study settings following over 2,000 women who
recently had a hysterectomy. Cognitive decline and estrogen was monitored during the trials to
evaluate disease progression and estrogen levels. The results of the study reported mixed effects
of estrogen exposure on neurodegeneration among both groups of women (10). Further studies
have been trying to identify the time period in which women may be the most vulnerable to
8
changing estrogen levels, as well as how the type of menopause (ie. naturally, early, or externally
induced), which inherently affects the levels of estrogen, influences the progression of AD (11).
The topic of hormone replacement in conjunction with time period and menopause types are still
being studied.
While studying the effects of estrogen is essential, understanding the origin of estrogen in
the body is also vital. Estrogen, like all other hormones in the body, is translated from a specific
portion of mRNA that results from the transcription of an individual’s DNA. Identifying the
genes encoding estrogen biosynthesis and the receptors within DNA, provide insight into risk
factors for neurodegeneration and may help identify which genes are specific to
neurodegeneration diseases such as AD (12). Due to the variations in DNA between individuals,
identifying and targeting specific genes has implications for disease treatments. Additional
genetic studies identified important genes, CYP17 and CYP19, as influential risk factors for
encoding estrogen and related hormones to those encoding tau phosphorylation which is a
commonly regarded biomarker for AD (14). These genes may provide a basis for trial screenings
While the main focus of this literature review is the effects of changing estrogen levels
experienced during the time of pregnancies on AD, most studies have focused on reviewing
these changes in the context of alternative life events, such as onset of puberty and menopause.
The time in a woman's life in which puberty begins, including the subsequent hormonal
fluctuations each month, have been used to quantify the amount of endogenous estrogen
9
exposure and the potential link it has with neurodegeneration (8). In addition, clinical studies on
natural or surgically induced menopause have been used in measuring the differing levels of
estrogen as well as cognitive decline (11). The time periods of major hormonal changes during a
female’s life, outside of pregnancy, can provide valuable background information on the topic of
Parity Studies
The number of pregnancies, and the amount of time a woman spends pregnant during her
lifetime, closely reflects major changes in estrogen. The fluctuations can be measured and
correlated with the rate in AD progression, but whether the correlation is positive or negative is
being evaluated. Researchers are attempting to uncover the connection, if there is any, between
how the number and type of pregnancies affects neurodegeneration. The type of pregnancy
(parous vs nulliparous) heavily influences the levels of 17β- estradiol which may influence
neurodegeneration (15). Studies have attempted to find correlations with disease progression and
parity by utilizing a clinical dementia rating in conjunction with previous health history of the
individual (number of menstrual cycles, amount of estrogen exposure, age at first pregnancy, age
at onset of Alzheimer’s Disease symptoms) (16). These ratings and mental cognition tests to
The main study type that concluded disadvantages with regard to neurodegeneration from
increased estrogen were HRT studies. Interestingly, the main question being asked in this context
was how the timing of this increased estrogen exposure, known as the “Critical Window”, affects
neurodegeneration (17). This “Critical Window” is a brief amount of time in a woman’s life in
10
which increased estrogen exposure can result in protective effects. HRT studies reviewed the
effects of increased estrogen exposure outside of this window, and concluded that increased
Another study showed that while some individuals who underwent HRT experienced
decreased neurodegeneration, almost 50% of the participants showed increased risk (18). Within
this study, the age in which the therapy was administered was recorded. The researchers
concluded that increased estrogen from these therapies has varied effects depending on the time
exposed (18). There may be advantageous results in early to mid-life females with potentially
deleterious effects in later-life (many years after menopause). While the “critical window” has
been used to identify the time in which the effect of estrogen changes, HRT studies have been
used on individuals who are already experiencing AD symptoms to see whether they are reduced
or enhanced (10). The results of the study concluded that hormone therapy does not offer
protective effects against AD progression after the age of menopause and the hormone therapy
shows adverse influence on this process in women over the age of 65. The final hormone
replacement therapy study analyzed for this literature review showed similar results in the
temporal importance of this increased estrogen exposure (11). Although it is unclear whether or
neurodegeneration, most studies revealed that outside of this “critical window”, increased levels
In addition to HRT studies, grand multiparity studies have also revealed similar
disadvantageous results. A specific longitudinal study sought to discover the effects of multiple
pregnancies on cognitive decline in women (19). Using a Cox proportional hazards model, using
a variety of risk factors and dementia, parity was found to be the most significant risk factor.
11
These studies concluding disadvantageous effects from estrogen confer that the time of
HRT is affecting the progression of AD (10, 11, 17, 18, 19). While it is understood that estrogen
levels rise during time of pregnancy, whether or not the significance of this study’s conclusion
was due to increased estrogen exposure or not would require further analysis.
It has already been identified that there are many different ways in which hormonal
changes in women may influence their rate of AD progression. While there is most widely a
consensus that estrogen has a role in neurodegeneration, whether the effects are protective or
detrimental are highly debated. Studies that concluded protective effects by estrogen are stated
here.
A particular study noted the densities of different estrogen receptors in specific regions of
the brain (eg. hippocampus, hypothalamus and amygdala) are involved in memory formation and
retention (15). Multimodal imaging revealed that the ERα and ERβ receptors found in these
associated areas were shown to be involved in the biochemical pathway resulting in protective
effects on neurons when acted on by estradiol (20). The ERα receptors showed to contribute
more in neuroprotection and ERβ receptors being closely associated with learning and memory
as well as survival factor for both sympathetic and sensory neurons (21). Estrogen receptors
playing a role in both memory and neuroprotection may provide insight into estrogen's role in
neurodegeneration.
When taking these findings and applying them to parity, researchers found that women
who were pregnant later in life showed better cognitive performance on brain-aging-related tests
(22), as well as lower risk for AD (23). A cumulative number of pregnancy durations was
12
recorded for each woman involved in the study as well as the duration of each trimester for each
pregnancy (23). These measurements were utilized in a Cox proportional hazards modeling
assessment to determine the associated level of neurodegeneration. The results concluded that a
lower risk of neurodegeneration correlated with a longer duration of the first trimester of
pregnancy (23).
Figure 1: Plot reports the probability of being Alzheimer’s Disease-free for women with the total number of months
the individual was pregnant. “Cox regression of the reliance of AD risk on median-split dichotomous
characterization of cumulative months pregnant demonstrates that women above the cohort median exhibit 37.01%
lower AD risk compared with women below the cohort median.” (23)
13
In a similar study using a Cox model, a longer reproductive span and longer duration of
life spent being pregnant, was associated with proactive effects against AD progression and risk
(24). This particular study revealed that estrogen may be involved in the disruption of the
precursor of amyloid protein plaques which would confer protective effects. Further evidence for
which they found estradiol to prevent a specific type of hyperphosphorylation of tau (12). Using
rat models, researchers were able to identify that okadaic acid, which is involved in
hyperphosphorylation of tau in specific genetic sites, was negatively affected by the presence of
increased estradiol levels. These studies all conferred protective effects from estrogen against
The main findings of the studies concluding advantageous effects of increased estrogen
exposure against AD progression reveal that, on a biochemical and molecular basis, estrogen
receptors might have neuroprotective abilities (20 ,21) and estradiol is able to disrupt the
formation of a common AD biomarker (12). The studies utilizing a Cox model found
correlations with increased time during pregnancy and reduced risk of AD (23, 24).
The main focus of this literature review is to determine how the recent academic
literature reveals the effects of changing estrogen levels during pregnancy on the progression of
AD. While only a few of these papers have been directly focused on time during pregnancy, it is
possible to make inferences from the alternate study focuses which may lend itself into better
The genetic studies can be utilized as a starting point to separate cohorts of individuals
for further analysis. In addition, the potential protective effects of decreased estrogen exposure
during menopause may prompt research regarding whether the increased levels of estrogen
during pregnancy might have the opposite effect. One might assume that if decreases in estrogen
during menopause and increased estrogen during puberty cycles and pregnancy may confer
opposite results, the “critical window” may help define the boundaries of these effects (since it
relates to the time of estrogen exposure). Furthermore, it might explain how experiencing a
pregnancy later in life and possibly closer to the time of menopause may result in a higher risk of
neurodegeneration. Alternatively, this hypothesis may also reveal that changes in estrogen levels,
because they are occurring during a time before this significant temporal window, may be
unrelated to the contributions of estrogen in detrimental effects and instead may offer protective
effects.
Concluding Remarks
Estrogen plays one of the most important roles in many stages of a woman’s life. This
literature review sought to analyze the current research that has been done in an attempt to link
estrogen changes and neurodegeneration. Although there is not a clear cohesive conclusion for
the effects of estrogen on neurodegeneration in women across the study types, the papers
reviewed here reveal more papers concluding advantageous effects. The only study type that
revealed disadvantageous results was regarding HRT. With the majority of current studies
showing estrogen having protective effects, it might be predicted that estrogen is not the primary
contributor of more females than men experiencing this disease. In addition, it has been seen that
the effect of estrogen may be related to the time of exposure. This needs to be further looked into
15
to determine if estrogen has any effect on neurodegeneration at all, and if so, is it dependent on
when the individual is exposed to it. Specifically, the effects of estrogen on neurodegeneration
during the time of pregnancy has not been fully studied and, I believe, that understanding how
the number of pregnancies affects this process is an area that needs to be further researched. It is
understood that females undergo vast hormonal changes throughout their lives, it is now vital
that researchers get to the bottom of whether or not these changes are causing the
References
1. Ho JY, Franco Y. The rising burden of Alzheimer’s disease mortality in rural America.
SSM - Population Health. 2022 Mar;17:101052.
2. Alzheimer’s Association. 2015 Alzheimer’s disease facts and figures. Alzheimers
Dement. 2015 Mar;11(3):332–84.
3. Yu Z, Jiao Y, Zhao Y, Gu W. Level of Estrogen in Females-The Different Impacts at
Different Life Stages. J Pers Med. 2022 Dec 2;12(12):1995.
4. Findlay JK, Liew SH, Simpson ER, Korach KS. Estrogen Signaling in the Regulation of
Female Reproductive Functions. Handb Exp Pharmacol. 2010;(198):29–35.
5. Ceccarelli I, Bioletti L, Peparini S, Solomita E, Ricci C, Casini I, et al. Estrogens and
phytoestrogens in body functions. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews. 2022 Jan
1;132:648–63.
6. O’Leary P, Boyne P, Flett P, Beilby J, James I. Longitudinal assessment of changes in
reproductive hormones during normal pregnancy. Clinical Chemistry. 1991 May
1;37(5):667–72.
7. The Menstrual Cycle – MCAT Biology | MedSchoolCoach [Internet]. 2023 [cited 2023
Oct 3]. Available from:
https://www.medschoolcoach.com/the-menstrual-cycle-mcat-biology/
8. Mónica Brauer M, Smith PG. Estrogen and female reproductive tract innervation:
Cellular and molecular mechanisms of autonomic neuroplasticity. Autonomic
Neuroscience. 2015 Jan 1;187:1–17.
9. Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) [Internet]. WordPress on Azure. [cited 2023 Oct
12]. Available from:
https://www.nhsinform.scot/tests-and-treatments/medicines-and-medical-aids/types-of-m
edicine/hormone-replacement-therapy-hrt/
10. Mills ZB, Faull RLM, Kwakowsky A. Is Hormone Replacement Therapy a Risk Factor
or a Therapeutic Option for Alzheimer’s Disease? Int J Mol Sci. 2023 Feb 6;24(4):3205.
11. Henderson VW. Action of estrogens in the aging brain: dementia and cognitive aging.
Biochim Biophys Acta. 2010 Oct;1800(10):1077–83.
12. Janicki SC, Schupf N. Hormonal influences on cognition and risk for Alzheimer’s
disease. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep. 2010 Sep;10(5):359–66.
17
13. de Lange AMG, Barth C, Kaufmann T, Maximov II, van der Meer D, Agartz I, et al.
Women’s brain aging: Effects of sex-hormone exposure, pregnancies, and genetic risk for
Alzheimer’s disease. Hum Brain Mapp. 2020 Dec 15;41(18):5141–50.
14. Alvarez-De-La-Rosa M, Silva I, Nilsen J, Pérez MM, García-Segura LM, Ávila J, et al.
Estradiol Prevents Neural Tau Hyperphosphorylation Characteristic of Alzheimer’s
Disease. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 2005 Jun;1052(1):210–24.
15. Jett S, Malviya N, Schelbaum E, Jang G, Jahan E, Clancy K, et al. Endogenous and
Exogenous Estrogen Exposures: How Women’s Reproductive Health Can Drive Brain
Aging and Inform Alzheimer’s Prevention. Front Aging Neurosci. 2022 Mar
9;14:831807.
16. Fox M, Berzuini C, Knapp LA. Cumulative estrogen exposure, number of menstrual
cycles, and Alzheimer’s risk in a cohort of British women. Psychoneuroendocrinology.
2013 Dec;38(12):2973–82.
17. Hormone therapy and cognitive function: Is there a critical period for benefit? -
ScienceDirect [Internet]. [cited 2023 Oct 9]. Available from:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030645220600042X
18. Whitmer RA, Quesenberry CP, Zhou J, Yaffe K. Timing of hormone therapy and
dementia: The critical window theory revisited. Annals of Neurology. 2011;69(1):163–9.
19. Bae JB, Lipnicki DM, Han JW, Sachdev PS, Kim TH, Kwak KP, et al. Parity and the risk
of incident dementia: a COSMIC study. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences. 2020
Jan;29:e176.
20. Dubol M, Epperson CN, Sacher J, Pletzer B, Derntl B, Lanzenberger R, et al.
Neuroimaging the menstrual cycle: A multimodal systematic review. Front
Neuroendocrinol. 2021 Jan;60:100878.
21. Zhou G, Liu J, Sun F, Duan L, Yan B, Peng Q. Cognitive functioning in elderly women
who underwent unilateral oophorectomy before menopause. Int J Neurosci. 2011
Apr;121(4):196–200.
22. Ning K, Zhao L, Franklin M, Matloff W, Batta I, Arzouni N, et al. Parity is associated
with cognitive function and brain age in both females and males. Sci Rep. 2020 Apr
8;10(1):6100.
23. Fox M, Berzuini C, Knapp LA, Glynn LM. Women’s Pregnancy Life History and
Alzheimer’s Risk: Can Immunoregulation Explain the Link? Am J Alzheimers Dis Other
Demen. 2018 Dec;33(8):516–26.
18